High Court · Decided 4 June 2019
Wilmar Trading Pte Ltd v Heroic Warrior Inc.
Feedback & support[2019] SGHC 143 · Case no. Admiralty in Personam No 33 of 2015
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The plaintiff, Wilmar Trading Pte Ltd, is a commodities trader. Pursuant to three sale contracts for various palm oil products, the plaintiff, as buyer on Free on Board (“FOB”) terms, nominated the Bum Chin as the carrying vessel for the shipment of a consignment of palm oil products to be loaded at Kuala Tanjung terminal in Indonesia for carriage to and delivery at Jeddah and Adabiyah. The defendant, Heroic Warrior Inc., is the registered owner of the Bum Chin, a Hong Kong flag oil/chemical tanker built in 2005. Her overall length is 145.35m, and there are 22 independent and segregated cargo tanks on board. She is classed with the Korean Register of Shipping.
- [2]
[2] The dispute in this action arises out of the loss and damage to part of the consignment of palm oil products due to an incident on board the Bum Chin on 17 April 2013. As the Bum Chin sustained physical damage in the incident, the plaintiff arranged another substitute vessel to transport the consignment of palm oil purchased under three aforementioned sale contracts that were made between PT Multimas Nabati Asahan (“MNA”) and the plaintiff.
- [3]
[3] The plaintiff’s pleaded claims are founded in contract and negligence. The averment in the statement of claim is that the defendant, as contracting carrier, failed in its duty to ensure that the Bum Chin was seaworthy and thus acted contrary to the Hague-Visby Rules (“Visby Rules”). The plaintiff also argues that the defendant, through its servants or agents, amongst other things, failed to take reasonable care of the cargo of RBD Palm Olein IV 64 (“ROL IV 64”) stowed in tank 4S. The plaintiff’s key contention is that tank 4S was not cargoworthy in that there were structural weaknesses present, and/or was over-pressurised due to insufficient venting of tank 4S or lack of control of the manifold valve. As a result, the longitudinal bulkhead of tank 4S buckled and the tank top fractured, thereby causing loss and damage to the cargo of ROL IV 64 stowed in tank 4S and the loss of use of the Bum Chin as the nominated carrying vessel to perform the voyage to the intended discharge ports, amongst other things. The proceedings also contain an assertion of ownership of the consignment of palm oil products.
- [5]
[5] As stated earlier, the Bum Chin was the nominated carrying vessel for the shipment of a consignment of palm oil products. There were three charterparties involved in the carriage of the aforementioned consignment of palm oil: a head time charter, a sub-time charter and a voyage charter. None of the three charterparties were between the plaintiff and the defendant, and no bills of lading were ever issued for the parcel of ROL IV 64 in tank 4S or other palm oil products loaded in other tanks on board the Bum Chin. This judgment will first deal with the plaintiff’s claim founded on an express or implied contract derived from an intention in the charterparties to issue original bills of lading that incorporated the Visby Rules for the consignment in question. If it is adjudged that there is no contractual relationship between the plaintiff and the defendant as alleged, the plaintiff’s alternative cause of action is in negligence. In this regard, the plaintiff did not sue in common law bailment and the precise question to a claim in negligence is whether it is legally necessary for the plaintiff to have a proprietary interest in the cargo at the time of the incident before it is entitled to sue for substantial damages; or can a duty of care in negligence arise despite the absence of a proprietary interest in the consignment in question at the material time. As for the defendant, its counterclaim is premised on the existence of a contractual relationship between the parties and an agency relationship between the plaintiff and the terminal. If it is adjudged that there is no agency relationship as described, a related issue that arises is whether the plaintiff is entitled to hold the defendant wholly liable for the damages claimed even if the terminal is partly to blame for the incident. This issue would not arise if the terminal is not to be blamed for the incident at all. After addressing each parties’ title to sue under the respective claims and counterclaim, this judgment will then examine the merits of the parties’ respective cases on the cause of the incident and who is to be blamed for the incident.
- [6]
[6] The plaintiff is represented by Mr Prem Gurbani (“Mr Gurbani”) and assisted by Ms Tan Hui Tsing. The defendant is represented by Mr Philip Tay (“Mr Tay”) and assisted by Ms Yip Li Ming.
Background facts
- [7]
[7] The plaintiff brings this action as the owner and/or the party entitled to sue in respect of the following palm oil products:
(a) 9,650mt of RBD Palm Olein (“ROL”);
(b) 1,200mt of ROL IV 64;
(c) 5,780mt of RBD Palm Oil (“RPO”); and
(d) 2,240mt of RBD Palm Stearin (“RPS”).
These were the quantities and quality of palm oil products stipulated for loading at the terminal in Kuala Tanjung for carriage to and delivery at Jeddah and Adabiyah under the voyage charterparty between the disponent owner of the Bum Chin, NHL-Development Ltd (“NHL”), and Raffles Shipping International Pte Ltd (“Raffles Shipping International) (nominating the plaintiff as charterer) (see [10] below).
- [8]
[8] Further or alternatively, the plaintiff brings this action as the owner and/or the party entitled to sue in respect of:
(a) 1,200.055mt of ROL IV 64;
(b) 2,327.944mt of ROL; and
(c) 1,146.451mt of RPO.
According to the plaintiff, these were the actual volumes of the palm oil products already loaded on board the Bum Chin at the time of the incident. There appears to be a discrepancy in the loaded volume of ROL IV 64 stated in the pleadings, the affidavits of evidence-in-chief (referred to as “AEICs” in the plural and “AEIC” in the singular) and in parts of the closing submissions. “1,200.055” and “1,200.55” are both used. As the plaintiff’s damages are based on calculations that use the figure of 1,200.055mt, and the surveyor report adduced by the plaintiff uses the same figure, this judgment will take 1,200.055mt as the volume of ROL IV 64 that was loaded.
- [9]
[9] The plaintiff had purchased these palm oil products from an Indonesian seller, MNA, under three sale contracts. These contracts expressly state that the palm oil products were purchased FOB Indonesian Ports. Under the sale contracts, MNA as FOB seller was responsible for loading the palm oil products on board the Bum Chin and the plaintiff was responsible for procuring the Bum Chin. MNA owned the Kuala Tanjung terminal. At the terminal, palm oil products in storage tanks are pumped through the terminal’s product pipelines terminating at flanges which are fitted with flexible hose lengths for connection to the loading vessel’s manifold system.
- [10]
[10] As stated earlier, the carriage involved three charterparties. The head charterparty was a time charterparty between the defendant as the registered owner and STX Pan Ocean as the head charterer. The sub-time charterparty was between STX Pan Ocean and NHL. The voyage charterparty was between NHL and Raffles Shipping International (nominating the plaintiff as charterer). There are ongoing arbitration proceedings between the various parties under the three charterparties.
- [11]
[11] For completeness, MNA, Raffles Shipping International and the plaintiff are related companies under Wilmar International Limited. Nothing turns on this relationship in this action.
Plaintiff’s causes of action against the defendant
Plaintiff’s cause of action in contract
- [12]
[12] The essence of the plaintiff’s pleaded claim in contract against the defendant is that the defendant failed to render the Bum Chin seaworthy and/or make the holds and all parts of the vessel in which cargo is carried, fit and safe for the reception of goods, and that its servants or agents failed to take reasonable care in the loading, handling, storage, keeping and care of the cargo. The plaintiff asserts that there exists an express and/or implied contract of carriage between the parties. The issue for determination is whether the plaintiff and defendant are contracting parties.
- [13]
[13] The plaintiff’s contention that there exists an express contract of carriage between the plaintiff and defendant is ambiguous. As alluded to earlier, it is not controversial that the three charterparties involved in the carriage of the consignment of palm oil products are not between the plaintiff and the defendant. The head time charter is between the defendant and STX Pan Ocean, the sub-time charter is between STX Pan Ocean and NHL, and the voyage charter is between NHL and the plaintiff, as nominee of Raffles Shipping International (“NHL charter”). Hence, it is unclear how an express contract of carriage could arise between the parties.
- [14]
[14] As for the alleged implied contract, the plaintiff submits in its closing submissions that the implied contract of carriage between the plaintiff and the defendant is evidenced by original bills of lading that would have been issued to the plaintiff in Singapore by the defendant had tank 4S not been damaged and loading of the entire consignment of palm oil products on board been accomplished. The NHL Charter contemplates the issuance of bills of lading for shipments under the charter. The bills of lading as contemplated would incorporate the Visby Rules, thereby giving rise to contractual obligations on the defendant’s part to exercise due diligence to make the Bum Chin seaworthy, among other things. The obvious difficulty in the plaintiff’s case is that no bills of lading were ever issued as the voyage was never carried out. Thus, the plaintiff bases its argument on an intention in the NHL Charter to issue original bills of lading that incorporated the Visby Rules for the consignment in question and cites Pyrene Co Ld v Scindia Navigation Co Ld [1954] QB 402 (“Pyrene”) for the proposition that there is no need for bills of lading to be actually issued for there to be a contract of carriage since the bill of lading is only evidence of an antecedent contract, and that where bills of lading were contemplated to be issued, the Visby Rules would be incorporated if the terms of the bill of lading so provide.
- [15]
[15] That a bill of lading evidences the antecedent contract of carriage is not controversial. The question is whether there exists such a contract of carriage in the first place. In this connection, the existence of a contract of carriage is to be decided on contractual principles. The following paragraph is instructive (Guenter Treitel & F.M.B. Reynolds, Carver on Bills of Lading (Sweet & Maxwell, 4th Ed, 2017) at para 3-002):
It is only if a contract of carriage has come into being between the relevant parties that the court considers the next question of whether the antecedent contract incorporated the Hague Rules or the Visby Rules as terms of the contract of carriage.
- [16]
[16] Pyrene is of no assistance to the plaintiff. Let me begin by summarising the case. The plaintiffs in that case sold a fire tender to the Government of India for delivery FOB London. One of the defendants’ vessels was nominated as the ship under the contract of sale and arrangements were made for the carriage of the goods. While the tender was being lifted onto the vessel and before it was across the rail, it was dropped and damaged. The fire tender was not the only machinery supplied by the plaintiffs for shipment, although it was the only machinery damaged before shipment. A bill of lading had been prepared to cover the whole shipment but because of the incident, the fire tender was deleted from it. The defendants admitted liability and contended that the plaintiffs’ claim was limited under the Hague Rules. According to Devlin J, for the defendants to succeed, the defendants had to show privity of contract between themselves and the plaintiffs, that the contract incorporated the Hague Rules, and that the Hague Rules were effective to limit their liability (at 413).
- [17]
[17] In Pyrene, it was “not disputed that … the contract of carriage was actually created before the issue of the bill of lading” (at 414) and more importantly, the existing contract was between the shipowner and the cargo interest. In the present case, there is no such contract between the plaintiff and the defendant. Hence, it is not apparent how Pyrene would be applicable to the facts in this case.
- [18]
[18] The entire basis of the plaintiff’s position on an implied contract of carriage is the allegation that the original bills of lading contemplated by the parties would be owner’s bills of lading (ie, issued by the defendant); thereby evidencing a direct contractual relationship between the plaintiff and defendant. This premise is seriously misplaced since the evidence shows, and I find, that the intention was to issue charterer’s bills of lading (ie, issued by NHL). This finding means that the defendant is not the contractual carrier and so the defendant is not liable in contract.
- [19]
[19] I start by addressing the matter of the bill of lading format that was intended to have been used. At the trial, the plaintiff disclosed an email dated 8 March 2013 from Inge Steensland Singapore Pte Ltd (the brokers who had arranged the fixture) to Raffles Ship Chartering Pte Ltd (the operational arm of Raffles Shipping International). This email sets out the details of the bills of lading arrangement relating to the shipment of palm oil cargo from Kuala Tanjung terminal. The plaintiff claims that the defendant had agreed to a bill of lading format purportedly attached to the 8 March 2013 email and that this was an “Owner’s Bill of Lading format”. There appears to be no such attachment to the 8 March 2013 email. As counsel for the defendant, Mr Tay, suggested to the plaintiff’s witness, Chen Kit Peng (“Ms Chen”), the bill of lading attachment tendered to the court was sent much later in a subsequent email in 2015. And Ms Chen accepted that the 8 March 2013 email had no attachment. To this end, the only reference to a pro forma bill of lading is the sample contained in the NHL Charter.
- [20]
[20] The standard printed pro forma bill of lading to the NHL Charter is drafted to express and evidence a contract between the shipper (and any transferee of the bill) and the registered owner of the vessel (ie, the defendant) as the provision for signature by the master or his agent so indicated. This standard printed pro forma bill of lading at first blush supports the plaintiff’s position that owner’s bills of lading would be issued. However, reading the NHL Charter and the 8 March 2013 email as a whole, as well as taking into account the bills of lading arrangement regarding the shipment, it is clear that charterer’s bills of lading were intended to be issued by Sea Ocean Shipping Agency Pte Ltd (Singapore) (“Sea Ocean”) as agent for and on behalf of NHL.
- [21]
[21] The NHL Charter included two addendums: a set of Special Terms and Wilmar Trading Rider Terms (Revision 5 dated 18 April 2001). Clause 2 of the Special Terms of the NHL Charter is titled “NON NEGOTIABLE BS/L CLAUSE”, and cl 2 of the Wilmar Trading Rider Terms (Revision 5) dated 18 April 2001 is titled “BILL OF LADING CLAUSE”. Under these clauses it would appear that upon completion of loading in Indonesia, non-negotiable bills of lading will first be issued for the purposes of clearing customs. It is only upon confirmation that freight has been irrevocably remitted and that the non-negotiable bills of lading have been cancelled that Sea Ocean would release the original bills of lading.
- [22]
[22] The 8 March 2013 email states: “OWNER’S NAME TO BE ON B/L: NHL DEVELOPMENT CO., LTD”. The email also confirms that the agent for signing and releasing original bills of lading would be Sea Ocean. At trial, Ms Chen, who was at the material time the senior executive of operations, clarified that that the plaintiff was expecting bills of lading to be issued by the disponent owner, NHL, and not the defendant as registered owner. Her evidence is consistent with the testimony of the defendant’s representative, Mr Uchiyama Yasuhiro (“Mr Yasuhiro”). Essentially, Mr Yasuhiro’s evidence is that the defendant was not asked to issue any original bills of lading for the consignment. As Mr Yasuhiro’s AEIC explains, “[n]o blank bill of lading format or draft bill of lading was ever given to the [d]efendant for approval or comment.” In other words, the defendant was not the intended contractual carrier.
- [23]
[23] Going back to the language of the standard printed pro forma bill of lading sample, the preamble of the NHL Charter provides that the terms of the NHL Charter in relation to receipt, delivery and discharge are incorporated in the bills of lading covering the cargo described in Part I of the NHL Charter. This suggests that any bills of lading would not be with the defendant as there is no provision for the terms of head charter to be incorporated into the bill of lading.
- [24]
[24] Accordingly, this court finds that the arrangement was for NHL to issue bills of lading for the consignment of palm oil products shipped on board the Bum Chin. It is sufficient on this holding to dispose of the plaintiff’s submission on an implied contract of carriage. For completeness, I should mention that the defendant’s plea that the plaintiff’s claims are time-barred under the Visby Rules does not arise having regard to the holding that there is no contract of carriage between the plaintiff and defendant.
Plaintiff’s cause of action in negligence
- [25]
[25] I turn now to the plaintiff’s cause of action in negligence. The plaintiff brings this action as cargo owner and FOB buyer of the cargo. The endorsement of claim included the plaintiff’s plea of common law bailment. However, bailment was dropped in the plaintiff’s statement of claim and in the plaintiff’s closing submissions. Thus, it is proprietary and not possessory interest that is the relevant issue to the claim in negligence.
- [26]
[26] As stated above at [7] to [8], the plaintiff claims that it is entitled to sue in respect of the whole consignment of palm oil products that was to be shipped on board the Bum Chin, or in the alternative, the plaintiff is at least entitled to sue in respect of cargo that were already loaded. On either view, the plaintiff asserts that at the time of the incident, property in the cargo had passed to it.
- [27]
[27] The three sale contracts between MNA and the plaintiff specified that the palm oil products were sold on FOB Indonesian Ports terms. The plaintiff has not referred to any contractual clause that deviates from the classic FOB arrangement. Under a classic FOB contract, unless expressly contracted otherwise, property passes upon payment. The payment term in the sale contracts stipulates either cash against documents or advance payment.
- [28]
[28] The plaintiff called two witnesses to testify on payment. The first witness is a manager employed by the plaintiff, Mr Foo Chee Tong (“Mr Foo”). He confirmed the two forms of payment under the sale contracts and testified that the plaintiff normally makes payment upon the presentation of an invoice. The second witness, Mr Thomas Lim Kim Guan (“Mr Lim”) is the plaintiff’s Group Head for Edible Oils who signed the three sale contracts on behalf of the plaintiff. He testified that the plaintiff had made advanced payment for the cargo and that the plaintiff would have received an invoice to make the payment. However, no evidence of an invoice, or evidence detailing amount paid, mode of payment and date of payment were before this court.
- [29]
[29] As for the cash against documents payment option, it is highly unlikely that the plaintiff had used this mode of payment as the relevant documents could not have been ready for exchange at the material time. In the three sale contracts, the word “documents” referred to in the payment term is expressed in plural and this indicates that more than one document is envisaged to be exchanged for cash. The presentation of invoice is not to be regarded as sufficient. Other than an invoice, Mr Foo did not mention the requisite documents to be tendered for payment. However, it is likely that the documents to be presented would be similar to those listed in an email between MNA and the plaintiff dated 12 April 2013 regarding the revised shipping instructions. This is because in international sale of goods, these are the documents normally required to be presented in exchange for cash. Now the email stated that three copies of commercial invoices along with a list of other documents were required before the original bill of lading would be issued in Singapore after confirmation that freight had been received. This list of other documents included the non-negotiable bill of lading where the plaintiff was to be named as the notify party with MNA as the named shipper (as was testified by Ms Chen), certificates of origin, the relevant survey report, and other certificates required at the discharge ports. It is unlikely that the plaintiff would have been presented with these documents for cash payment as these documents would normally be available only after completion of loading of cargo. At the time of the incident, the documents would not be ready to be exchanged for payment.
- [30]
[30] On the two alternative modes of payment, there is no evidence of the option used in this case and this court holds that the plaintiff has not proved that it had paid for the consignment of palm oil products at the time of the incident.
- [31]
[31] The plaintiff further contends that the property in the palm oil passed from MNA as seller to itself as buyer when the goods were loaded on board the Bum Chin, and quotes the following passage from M G Bridge, The International Sale of Goods (4th Ed, Oxford University Press, 2018) at para 7.08 in its closing submissions:
- [32]
[32] The plaintiff is effectively referring to s 19 of the Sale of Goods Act (Cap 393, 1999 Rev Ed) on the right of disposal, which states:
- [34]
[34] For the reasons stated, the plaintiff has not established that property passed when the goods were put on board. The plaintiff has not shown evidence of payment nor shown that there was no intention on the part of the seller to reserve its right of disposal.
- [35]
[35] The next question that arises is whether the plaintiff can sue the defendant in negligence as an FOB buyer of the palm oil products. On this basis, the defendant contends that the plaintiff has no title to sue in negligence. The defendant’s argument is that the plaintiff has no proprietary interest in the cargo and relies on the English case of Leigh and Sillavan Ltd v Aliakmon Shipping Co Ltd [1986] AC 785 (“Aliakmon”) in support of the proposition that the buyer has no title to sue the shipowner in negligence if title to the property remained with the seller at the time the goods were damaged. I note parenthetically that the English position continues to prevail even though risk in the cargo passes to the buyer: see Obestain Inc v National Mineral Development Corporation Ltd (The “Sanix Ace”) [1987] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 465.
- [37]
[37] As pure economic loss is claimable under Singapore law, the plaintiff need not prove a proprietary interest in the cargo to have title to sue in respect of the loss it has suffered. The question therefore turns on whether the defendant owes the plaintiff a duty of care; and if no such duty is owed, the plaintiff’s claim can be dismissed in its entirety.
Existence of duty of care
- [38]
[38] The test for the establishment a duty of care in tort is settled and well-established. A duty of care will arise in tort if: (a) it is factually foreseeable that the defendant’s negligence might cause the plaintiff to suffer harm; (b) there is sufficient legal proximity between the parties; and (c) policy considerations do not militate against a duty of care (see Spandeck Engineering (S) Pte Ltd v Defence Science & Technology Agency [2007] 4 SLR(R) 100 (“Spandeck”) at [73], [77] and [83]).
- [39]
[39] The first requirement of factual foreseeability is satisfied in this case. In Spandeck at [75]–[76], the Court of Appeal referred to factual foreseeability as a low threshold requirement. The focus of this enquiry is on the foreseeability of harm and the class of persons who may be affected by the negligent act of the omission: Gary Chan Kok Yew, The Law of Torts in Singapore (Academic Publishing, 2nd Ed, 2016) (“The Law of Torts in Singapore”) at p 9. In my judgment, the defendant as performing carrier would have reasonably foreseen that its negligence would cause economic loss to a buyer of cargo who bore the risk of damage to or loss of the cargo, which in this case, was the plaintiff. Indeed, it was the plaintiff who nominated the Bum Chin as the carrying vessel for the shipment of a consignment of palm oil products to be loaded at Kuala Tanjung terminal, and part of the consignment was actually on board before the incident occurred on 17 April 2013.
- [40]
[40] The second requirement of legal proximity is also satisfied. Legal proximity focuses on “the closeness of the relationship between the parties” and includes “physical, circumstantial as well as causal proximity” (Spandeck at [77] and [81]). The crux of the inquiry is whether the plaintiff was so closely and directly affected by the defendant’s actions that the latter ought to have had the former in contemplation in its acting.
- [41]
[41] While the defendant has no contractual relationship with the plaintiff, the relationship between the plaintiff and defendant was sufficiently proximate. Under a classic FOB contract, it is the buyer’s duty to nominate the carrying vessel and the FOB seller’s duty to put the goods on board the nominated vessel. Risk in the goods passes from the seller to the buyer when the goods are put on board the vessel. The significance of risk passing to the buyer before payment is that even if the goods were lost or damaged, the buyer would have to pay the seller the price under the sale contract. More so under Singapore law where the claimant need not show a proprietary interest in the goods to mount a claim for pure economic loss. Here, the plaintiff, as FOB buyer, was responsible for nominating the Bum Chin and took on the risk of damage to the palm oil products on board the Bum Chin. The defendant as the registered owner in a chain of charterparties, was in possession of the Bum Chin and the employer of the Bum Chin’s crew at all material times. As a result of the damage to tank 4S, the cargo of ROL IV 64 in tank 4S was contaminated by seawater and some of the cargo of ROL IV 64 on board was lost during discharge from the Bum Chin, amongst other things. Further, the Bum Chin could no longer continue to perform the carriage given the physical damage she sustained. The plaintiff was also the party who saw to the transhipment of the palm oil products to a substitute vessel, Ping An, as testified by Ms Chen. In the circumstances, I am satisfied that on the evidence before the court, there was physical, circumstantial and causal proximity.
- [42]
[42] Finally, as regards countervailing policy considerations, the common concern that arises is indeterminacy – would a defendant be exposed to liability to an indeterminate class of persons if a duty of care is found. In my view, indeterminacy would not arise as the limitation here is on the party who is at risk. That is to say the plaintiff, as FOB buyer, is the only party who bore the risk of loss or damage to the cargo and is within an identifiable class of persons who would suffer loss as a result of the defendant’s negligence, if any.
- [43]
[43] It is worth repeating that there is no contract of carriage evidenced by a bill of lading between the plaintiff and the defendant. As such, the Visby Rules do not apply. As a matter of principle, the defendant owes the plaintiff a duty to take reasonable care of the cargo loaded on board the Bum Chin for carriage to and delivery at named discharge ports. The care of the cargo would be based on the common law standard applicable to a performing carrier using reasonable care and skill to ensure that the Bum Chin was cargoworthy for the purpose of undertaking the carriage to and delivery of the cargo at the discharged ports. The issues of breach of duty and causation will be examined later in the judgment.
Defendant’s counterclaim
- [44]
[44] The defendant counterclaims against the plaintiff for the damage on board the Bum Chin. The defendant’s counterclaim is pleaded and predicated upon the plaintiff’s averment of a contract of carriage between the plaintiff and the defendant:
The defendant’s closing submissions confirms that the counterclaim takes its course from the plaintiff’s allegation of a contract of carriage between the parties. To the extent that there is no contract of carriage between plaintiff and defendant, the counterclaim is readily dismissed.
- [45]
[45] The defendant, separately, alleges that MNA and its personnel involved in the cargo operations are agents, servants, sub-contractors or stevedores of the plaintiff. Hence, the fault of any of these individuals gives rise to liability on the part of the plaintiff as regards the defendant’s loss arising from damage to the Bum Chin (“the agency argument”). In my judgment, the defendant has not shown any basis (legal or factual) for this contention and hence, the agency argument must fail.
- [46]
[46] The terminal (who for all intents and purposes is interchangeable with MNA), as FOB seller, was deploying its personnel to deliver the palm oil products to the plaintiff’s nominated vessel pursuant to the FOB sale contracts. From this perspective, the terminal’s personnel cannot be the servants, agents, sub-contractors or stevedores of the plaintiff as claimed by the defendant. In the light of the risk allocation under the FOB sale contracts, the relationship between the terminal’s personnel (through MNA) and the plaintiff is not one of agency.
- [47]
[47] Separately, under cl 7(a) of the NHL Charter, the charterer (ie, the plaintiff) agreed that the cargo be pumped into the vessel “at the expense, risk and peril” of the charterer. The risk allocation in cl 7(a) is between the plaintiff and NHL and the effect of this risk allocation is that the plaintiff cannot sue NHL. Clause 7(a) cannot change the relationship of the terminal’s personnel and the plaintiff to fit the defendant’s agency argument. In any case, the defendant cannot rely on this clause for want of privity.
- [48]
[48] The defendant further submits that at common law, the shipper is responsible for (ie, bears the risk and expense of) pumping the cargo into the ship and cites a passage from Sir Bernard Eder et al, Scrutton on Charterparties and Bills of Lading (Sweet and Maxwell, 23rd Ed, 2015) at para 9–143 to suggest that the plaintiff, as shipper, is jointly responsible for loading operations:
- [49]
[49] The passage quoted above does not improve the defendant’s agency argument. The defendant’s characterisation of the plaintiff as shipper is inaccurate. The shipper in this case is MNA, the FOB seller. And as stated above, at the material time, MNA was to be the named shipper to be inserted into the non-negotiable bills of lading. Equally, it was the terminal acting in its own capacity when it pumped the cargo through its product lines to the ship’s manifold.
- [50]
[50] Although the plaintiff did raise the term “joint operations” at trial and in the closing submissions, it did not go so far as to accept responsibility over the acts of the terminal. For the plaintiff, the term was merely used to describe the interface between the terminal and the vessel for cargo operations to take place. Whereas the terminal delivered compressed air to the ship’s manifold valve for pigging and line blowing, and was responsible for controlling the main valve at the jetty, it was the responsibility of the Bum Chin to handle and control the amount of pressure received at the ship’s manifold, assuming that the pressure was no more than 7 bar. On the specific responsibility of the Bum Chin, it had to ensure that the ship’s manifold valve opened to a maximum of 50% during pigging, and during line blowing, it had to ensure that the manifold valve was opened to a maximum of 10% and throttled to control the amount of air entering tank 4S. Suffice to say for now, the plaintiff’s case is that the defendant’s failure to throttle the manifold valve during line blowing led to a continued increase in pressure within tank 4S that contributed to the incident. The plaintiff’s point is that it was not involved at all in the cargo operations, and as between the terminal and defendant, the fault is on the defendant for not controlling pressure at the ship manifold valve during line blowing.
- [51]
[51] I should add that on the finding that the plaintiff is not responsible for the acts of the terminal and its personnel, any suggestion of a duty of care between the plaintiff and defendant for the purposes of the counterclaim (ie, that the plaintiff owed the defendant a duty of care to load the cargo) cannot stand. All in all, the conclusion reached in this judgment is that the defendant’s entire counterclaim against the plaintiff is without merit and is dismissed.
The substantive dispute in the main action
- [52]
[52] I now turn to the plaintiff’s claim in negligence and the defendant’s defence. To succeed in its claim, the plaintiff has to establish breach of duty on the part of the defendant, and that the breach caused or contributed to the incident that in turn led to the plaintiff’s loss. It is sensible to start the inquiry with what caused the damage to tank 4S as it would lead to the determination of the real question -– what caused the plaintiff’s loss (ie, for ROL IV 64 to leak out of tank 4S to the water ballast tank, and vice versa for ingress of seawater into tank 4S, and the loss of use of the vessel). As the plaintiff is suing in negligence, the legal burden lies with the plaintiff to establish the effective cause of the incident on 17 April 2013.
- [54]
[54] For a better understanding of the events leading to the incident on 17 April 2013, I start with a brief description of the terminal’s storage and loading facilities, tank 4S, cargo operations (namely, cargo loading, pigging and line blowing in the context of pipelines) and the venting facilities on board the Bum Chin.
The Kuala Tanjung terminal
- [55]
[55] In general terms, the terminal comprises storage tanks, pump houses, various pipelines and a jetty that has flexible hoses connecting to the receiving vessel’s permanent manifold system. Typically, palm oil is first received at the terminal’s reception areas, and would be transferred into storage tanks or storage areas on site for processing into various palm oil products before export. The storage tanks are inter-connected via pipelines or pump systems at one of the terminal’s two pump houses (referred to as the NKB and KB pump house).
- [56]
[56] The NKB pump house is the smaller of the two pump houses. It is equipped with export lines that connect to the main product lines in the KB pump house. There are two air compressors, two associated air dryers and two air reservoirs. The compressors, dryers and reservoirs form a compressed air facility that serves the entire terminal.
- [57]
[57] Compressed air from the NKB pump house would be channelled to and received by the air reservoirs in the KB pump house. Compressed air is necessary to clean the lines after cargo loading, through a process of pigging and line blowing. The KB pump house is located approximately 450m away from the NKB pump house and is the larger of the two. It is equipped with the following facilities:
(a) Three air reservoirs that receive compressed air sourced from the NKB pump house compressors.
(b) Six product lines (labelled as “A” to “F”) that serve the jetties.
(c) Six pig sender units that are fitted to the ends of every export line.
I add that while pressure of 7 bar is released at the KB pump house during pigging, as the compressed air travels down the pipeline system, the pressure decreases to 3 to 4 bar by the time it reaches the main jetty valve at the jetty.
- [58]
[58] From the KB pump house to the jetties is a road causeway that stretches approximately 2.65km. The six product lines from the KB pump house also runs to the jetties. The causeway terminates at the main jetty, Jetty A, which was the jetty that the Bum Chin was berthed at the time of the incident.
- [59]
[59] Jetty A is set up with the six product lines and their associated pig receivers. At the end of each product line, before the pig receivers, is a gate valve (ie, the main jetty valve). This main jetty valve is used during loading, pigging and line blowing. The product lines terminate at flanges which are fitted with flexible hoses for connection to the receiving vessel’s manifold system. Cargo is pumped from a storage tank along a product line to the manifold at the jetty and through the manifold of the receiving vessel. The reception of cargo into the receiving vessel’s manifold system is controlled by a manifold valve on board. In this case, the Bum Chin’s manifold is able to handle a maximum pressure of 7 bar. Each of the tanks on board the Bum Chin has its own manifold system. The distance between the main jetty valve and the vessel’s manifold is about 20 to 25m apart.
Tank 4S
- [60]
[60] The Bum Chin is fitted with 22 cargo tanks, 11 on port side and starboard side. Each tank is completely segregated and independent from all the other tanks and is comprised of longitudinal and transverse corrugated bulkheads. The following tanks were slated for loading:
(a) ROL IV 64 was to be loaded into tank 4S.
(b) RPO into tanks 2P, 2S, 8S, 9P, 9S, and 10P; and
(c) ROL into tanks 3P, 3S, 4P, 5P, 5S, 6P, 6S, 7P, 7S, and 8P.
- [61]
[61] Diagram 1: the plaintiff’s layout of tank 4S
- [62]
[62] Cargo is received from the bottom of the tank (referred to as the “tank top”). The topmost of the tank is referred to as the “deck”. The tanks are held in place by welds and stiffeners located at the underside of the tank top.
- [63]
[63] Every individual cargo tank is fitted with a level sensor that is connected to the system monitor panel in the Cargo Control Room (“CCR”). This panel indicates the level of cargo in a tank at any one point in time. The Bum Chin is also fitted with a level alarm system that consists of both automatic and manual alarms. The first automatic alarm, the high level alarm, will activate when the level in any tank reaches 95% of the tank capacity. The second automatic alarm, the overfill alarm, will activate when the level in any tank reaches 98% of the tank capacity. There is also a manual level alarm that cn be set within the CCR.
- [64]
[64] There is a pressure sensor fitted in every tank. This pressure sensor is located at the deck. The sensor is connected to the system monitor in the CCR and it indicates, in digital format, the pressure of the atmosphere in the ullage space of the cargo tank at any particular time. The ullage space refers to the space between the top level of the cargo and the deck.
- [65]
[65] The tank monitoring system is also equipped with a high pressure system. This is a manual system and the setting must be set by the chief officer in the CCR. The setting for the Hi Pressure Alarm System varies according to whether loading, pigging or line blowing operation is underway.
Venting system of the Bum Chin
- [66]
[66] Each cargo tank of the Bum Chin could be vented through the following means:
(a) the pressure vacuum valve (“P/V valve”) system;
(b) the gas free vent;
(c) the tank access hatch and ullage port; and
(d) the Butterworth tank cleaning hatch (“Butterworth hatch”).
These various components serve to allow pressure to escape from the respective tanks during cargo operations.
- [67]
[67] As regards the P/V valve system, the P/V valve has a pressure side and a vacuum side, and is connected directly to the tank access hatch via a 100mm line. There is an operational pressure for the P/V valve to be activated. On the pressure side, 20 kPA. On the vacuum side, -3.5 kPA. When the pressure within the tank reaches 20 kPA, the P/V valve will lift and release pressure. When the pressure falls below 17 kPA, the valve will close and the cycle will begin again. The P/V valve produces a sound when pressure is released. When the P/V valve reaches the operating pressure, the P/V valve will lift and a “sss” sound will be produced. After the pressure is released, the P/V valve sits back down and a “metal sound” is heard.
- [68]
[68] Open venting or closed venting can be adopted during cargo operations. The International Bulk Chemical Code (the “IBC Code”) describes an open venting system to be a system which offers no restriction except for friction losses to the free flow of cargo vapours to and from the cargo tank during normal operations. According to the Chief Officer of the Bum Chin, Mr Judes Anto Kavin, Joseph Ponniah (“Mr Joseph”), there is open venting if the cover of the gas free vent is in open position. There is closed venting if only the P/V valve is used.
Cargo operations
- [69]
[69] Cargo operations in the context of pipelines involve three phases: loading, pigging and line blowing. Both the terminal’s personnel and the crew on board the vessel would be engaged at each phase of cargo operations in respect of their own operational requirements.
- [70]
[70] Prior to loading, the terminal’s loading master, surveyors and the chief officer will meet to discuss and agree on specific matters pertaining to the cargo operations (such as the quantity of cargo to be loaded, the sequence of loading, loading rates and pressure). This discussion would be recorded in the Ship/Shore Safety Checklist.
- [72]
[72] Pigging in the context of pipelines refers to the practice of using a solid device called a “pig” to clear residual cargo from the pipeline. The pig is sent down a pipeline (also known as the product line) and propelled by compressed air to clear the pipeline of residual cargo remaining in the pipeline after loading. Towards the end of the pigging process, the loading master will remain on standby at the pig receiver. This is because the loading master has to control the valves at the jetty and to issue instructions to the pump house. Pigging is completed when the pig arrives at the pig receiver, at which point the pump house will stop the air supply. Upon completion of pigging, the loading master will inform the vessel that the pigging operation has completed.
- [73]
[73] Line blowing is also a process by which the product lines are cleared of residual cargo. Line blowing involves throttling the main jetty valve to allow small amounts of compressed air to clear the residual cargo down the pipeline, through the flexible hose, into the Bum Chin’s tank. The main jetty valve will be opened slightly for about 30 to 35 seconds using three turns of the valve wheel, and closed for about 10 to 15 seconds. This is done three times. The compressed air used for line blowing is the air leftover from pigging and the pump house will not supply fresh air. After line blowing is completed, the surveyors will once again draw cargo samples and take the ullage to ascertain the complete quantity of cargo loaded.
- [74]
[74] On the side of the Bum Chin, the manifold valve has to be adjusted at every stage of cargo operations. During loading, the manifold valve is opened to 100%. During pigging, the manifold valve is opened to 50%. During line blowing, the manifold valve is opened to a maximum of 10% and the manifold valve is throttled to control the air entering the tank (see [144] below).
Witnesses
- [75]
[75] The plaintiff called several witnesses. The terminal’s personnel included the loading master, Suprianto, and the assistant loading master, Mariston Sitinjak (“Mariston”). While Suprianto (“Duty Loading Master”) was the loading master who oversaw cargo operations, Joyo Suharno (“Joyo”) was the loading master on duty at the time the Bum Chin berthed at the terminal. In charge of the KB pump house (where the pig senders are located) was one Suganda Muhammad Amri (“Suganda”). Other terminal personnel who testified at the trial were Syahrul and Edy Yusri. The three cargo surveyors who testified at the trial were Eddy Gunawan, Zulchaidir and Awaluddin. Witnesses from the plaintiff’s company were Ms Chen, Mr Foo and Mr Lim.
- [76]
[76] On the side of the Bum Chin, Mr Joseph and the Third Officer were monitoring the cargo operations in the CCR at various points in time. At the manifold was the manifold watchman, able-bodied seaman Manendra Pandey (“Manifold Watchman”). The Third Officer and the Manifold Watchman were not called to testify at the trial. Only Mr Joseph testified at the trial on behalf of the defendant as to the events on board the Bum Chin. The defendant also called Mr Yasuhiro and Debdeepto Chattopadhyay, the superintendent of the Bum Chin. Nichola Philip Treen who investigated the casualty on behalf of the defendant testified as witness of fact.
- [77]
[77] The experts for the plaintiff are Captain Nigel John Snowden (“Captain Snowden”), Dr Jonathan Sykes (“Dr Sykes”) and Dr Chee Chin Yi (“Dr Chee”). The defendant’s experts are: (a) Mr Michael Gene Sachs (“Mr Sachs”), a technical consultant specialising in oil storage issues; (b) Mr Keir Stuart Alexander Gravil (“Mr Gravil”), a naval architect; (c) Dr Ong Lin Seng (“Dr Ong”), an associate professor at the Nanyang Technological University (“NTU”), School of Mechanical & Aerospace Engineering; and (d) Dr Chua Leok Poh (“Dr Chua”) of the NTU, School of Mechanical & Aerospace Engineering. The other defendant experts are Ms Lim Huei Ling Jennifer (“Ms Lim”), Mr Lim Kie Yong and Captain Sanjay Varma (“Captain Sanjay”).
- [78]
[78] The parties’ positions on the cause of the incident underwent some refinement as the proceedings unfolded. While the experts advanced several alternative theories on the cause of the incident, some of the theories advanced in the reports fell away and were no longer seriously pursued as the evidence developed. It is therefore unnecessary to address every single allegation or theory that had been made throughout the course of the proceedings. Similarly, submissions that do not directly resolve the central issues will not be addressed. In this vein, although many witnesses testified (factual and expert witnesses) and their respective evidence considered, this judgment will address only the testimonies that are relevant to the determination of this action. Unfortunately, this judgment remains lengthy given the approach taken by both sides in the conduct of the litigation.
The events on 16 and 17 April 2013
- [79]
[79] On 16 April 2013, the Bum Chin berthed at Kuala Tanjung, Indonesia. The first loading master on duty, Joyo, boarded the Bum Chin with two surveyors to discuss loading operation with Mr Joseph. The discussions were recorded in the Ship/Shore Safety Checklist. In this regard, the agreed primary mode of communication between the terminal and the Bum Chin was verbal: those at the jetty would call out to the ship’s crew at the manifold to maintain communication and vice versa. Internal communication between the terminal personnel was through walkie-talkies in respect of personnel stationed at a distance from the jetty. Similarly, the Bum Chin’s crew used walkie-talkies to maintain communication between the crew at the manifold and the CCR.
- [80]
[80] Loading commenced on 17 April 2013, at or about 0036 hours. By then, Joyo had ended his shift and the Duty Loading Master had taken over. Loading carried on smoothly in the various tanks. It was after the loading of tank 4S had completed that the incident occurred. When the incident precisely occurred is a matter of debate between the parties: did the incident occur during pigging or line blowing of pipelines for the cargo loaded in tank 4S. According to the plaintiff, it was during line blowing that a loud “bang” was heard and the deck in way of the centre line of the Bum Chin at no. 4 wing tanks was found to be deformed. The defendant, in its reply submissions, took the position that the incident occurred during pigging and not line blowing.
- [81]
[81] The time at which loading completed and pigging commenced, and when pigging completed and line blowing commenced, is also a matter of some dispute. Further, the parties were in disagreement as to whether the terminal had communicated the commencement and completion of each stage of the cargo operations to the Bum Chin, and sought and obtained permission to commence the next stage of cargo operations. Suffice to say for now that the plaintiff’s position is that permission was sought and obtained, and that ultimately, the surveyor’s assistance in seeking and obtaining permission from the Bum Chin to commence line blowing is consistent with what was agreed in the Ship/Shore Safety Checklist. The surveyor’s assistance was required as the terminal’s personnel could not communicate in English with the Bum Chin’s officers and crew.
- [82]
[82] A related dispute was whether Mr Joseph was indeed present in the CCR at the time of the incident. According to Mr Joseph, around the time when he was informed by the able-bodied seaman stationed at the manifold that “pigging operations had been completed and the [t]erminal was about to start line-blowing operations”, he observed a sudden surge in the pressure of tank 4S (reaching 0.993 bar) in the CCR and the high pressure alarm was activated. This increase in pressure was described to have been “instantaneous”, happening in mere “seconds”. What Mr Joseph observed was later advanced in defence as the “sudden surge theory” to pin fault exclusively on the terminal. The lead surveyor, Eddy Gunawan (“Lead Surveyor”), on the other hand, testified that Mr Joseph was not in the CCR when permission to commence line blowing was sought. Instead, only the Third Officer was on duty and present in the CCR and that permission to commence line blowing was sought and obtained from the Third Officer.
Aftermath of the Incident
- [83]
[83] As a result of the incident, the following damage to the Bum Chin was observed:
(a) cracks on the upper deck plate;
(b) buckling of the centre longitudinal bulkhead of tank 4S; and
(c) fracture and lifting of the 4S tank top.
- [84]
[84] The Bum Chin stopped cargo operations after the incident. According to the plaintiff, the following quantities of palm oil products had been loaded at the point in time:
(a) 1,200.055mt of ROL IV 64;
(b) 2,327.944mt of ROL; and
(c) 1,146.451mt of RPO.
- [85]
[85] The Bum Chin did not perform the voyage. Palm oil products loaded on board the Bum Chin had to be discharged and loaded onto the substitute vessel. Cargo of ROL IV 64 also leaked from tank 4S to the water ballast tank and vice versa (ie, ingress of seawater into tank 4S) as a result of the incident. There was also loss of cargo during discharge. Against this backdrop, the plaintiff’s claims relate either to the loss of and damage to the various parcels of palm oil products, and loss of use of the Bum Chin.
Plaintiff’s case on liability
- [86]
[86] To the plaintiff, the incident occurred during line blowing and it was the defendant’s fault that the incident occurred. The terminal had obtained permission before commencing each stage of cargo operations and had delivered the correct pressure to the Bum Chin’s manifold. Against this backdrop, the plaintiff submitted that:
(a) There were pre-existing weld defects and fatigue cracks in the tank top of tank 4S which adversely affected the strength of the structure such that the buckling of the bulkhead and the fracture of the tank top happened at a lower pressure than it otherwise would.
(c) The Bum Chin failed to control the air pressure entering the Bum Chin by failing to throttle the manifold valve during line blowing. Hence, “excess” air entered tank 4S during line blowing, leading to continued increase in pressure (over-pressurisation) within tank 4S that contributed to the incident.
(d) The Bum Chin failed to set the pressure alarm to 70% of the P/V valve setting for line blowing.
- [87]
[87] In support of its position, the plaintiff called its expert witness, Captain Snowden of Petrotech Marine Consultants (Pte) Ltd to opine on the cause of the incident. He opined that the nature of damage to tank 4S was indicative of structural weaknesses in the tank rather than a classic over-pressurisation incident. Further and in the alternative, tank 4S had not been venting through its P/V valve during line blowing, and this prevented air pressure entering tank 4S from being fully vented. Rejecting the sudden surge of air pressure observed by Mr Joseph, Captain Snowden opined that even assuming that the P/V valve was working, the Butterworth hatch was unsecured, the cover of the gas free vent was in open position, and the main jetty valve was opened at 100% with maximum air supplied by the pump house at 7 bar, it would have taken a total of 22 seconds for the air pressure within tank 4S to have risen to 0.993 bar. There was therefore no “instantaneous” rise in pressure. It was also suggested that the Bum Chin could have taken emergency procedures in the 22 seconds of grace.
- [88]
[88] Dr Sykes testified as the plaintiff’s metallurgy expert. Dr Sykes opined that there were pre-existing fatigue cracks and substantial weld defects which reduced the strength of the welds, all of which adversely affected the structural strength of tank 4S.
- [89]
[89] On the allegation that the Bum Chin failed to control the air pressure entering tank 4S by failing to throttle the manifold valve during pigging and line blowing, the allegation is directed at the Manifold Watchman. Mr Gurbani for the plaintiff, invites the court to draw adverse inferences from the Manifold Watchman’s absence at the trial and relies on s 116 illustration (g) of the Evidence Act (Cap 97, 1997 Rev Ed) (“EA”).
- [90]
[90] Mr Gurbani further points out that according to Mr Joseph, the manifold valve was in open position during pigging and line blowing. The natural inference is that the manifold valve was not properly throttled and “excess” air was allowed into tank 4S during line blowing. Consequently, it was over-pressurisation from insufficient venting or failure to control the ship’s manifold valve that caused the incident if it was not the structural weaknesses. It follows, on the plaintiff’s argument, that the plaintiff has proved that the failure of tank 4S was due to:
(a) over-pressurisation arising from the P/V valve not working or failure to control the ship’s manifold valve;
(b) failure of tank 4S from structural weaknesses; or
(c) a combination of reasons, such as structural weaknesses and insufficient venting, or structural weakness and failure to control ship’s manifold.
- [91]
[91] Finally, on the defendant’s failure to set the pressure alarm to 70% of the P/V valve setting, the plaintiff’s argues that the failure contravened the Bum Chin’s manual.
Defendant’s case on liability
- [92]
[92] The defendant on its part seeks to either deny the factual allegations of the plaintiff or suggest that the causal factors for the failure of tank 4S as identified by the plaintiff are irrelevant. The defence in brief is as follows. There are pre-existing defects in tank 4S but the effect of the defects on structural weaknesses of tank 4S is inconclusive. The experts could not definitively conclude on the extent of weaknesses. In any event, structural weaknesses in tank 4S is irrelevant because on the defendant’s view and understanding of over-pressurisation, it is a sudden surge of air pressure from the tank top that is the primary cause of the incident. The venting capacity of the vessel is also rendered irrelevant because the sudden surge of air pressure resulted in an almost immediate buckling of the bulkhead (about 3.04 seconds). The effects of venting would therefore not have manifested at the material time. That said, regardless of whether venting is a relevant factor, the vessel had been open venting at all material times.
- [94]
[94] On venting, the defendant denies the plaintiff’s factual allegations that the venting on board was closed and the P/V valve of tank 4S was not working. The defendant’s case is that open venting was used on board and the P/V valve of tank 4S was working. Primarily, the defendant seeks to shift the blame for the incident to the terminal. The allegation advanced is that the genesis of the sudden surge of air pressure that entered tank 4S was the terminal through the negligence of its personnel or the poor use of the terminal facilities. The two explanations given for the sudden surge of air pressure are canvassed at [100] to [102] below.
- [95]
[95] To elaborate on the defendant’s position on the over-pressurisation of tank 4S, the defendant’s case is that as the high velocity air penetrated through the liquid cargo, the force exerted against the liquid cargo would be transmitted instantaneously to the boundaries of the tank and thus resulting in the buckling of the bulkhead. As the buckling was instantaneous, the structural integrity and venting capacity of the tank are irrelevant to the cause of the buckling. In the closing submissions, the defendant clarified that the incident occurred at the end of pigging, before the commencement of line blowing. The defendant treats this interim period as still under the pigging phase (see [111] below).
- [96]
[96] In support of this position, the defendant primarily relies on the expert testimonies of Mr Sachs, Mr Gravil, Dr Ong and Dr Chua.
- [97]
[97] Dr Ong was asked to provide an opinion on whether the buckling was due to over-pressurisation or structural weaknesses of the tank. He was also asked to calculate the pressure required to buckle the bulkhead, which he concluded to be 1.2 bar. He arrived at this figure by modelling the bulkhead that was buckled and conducting a Finite Element Analysis (“FEA”) on the model. He further concluded that the primary cause of the buckling was due to over-pressurisation. The pre-existing structural defects at best brought about a “secondary failure”. Dr Ong further clarified that he was only concerned with the net pressure required to buckle the bulkhead. Hence, the inflow and outflow of air from the tank were irrelevant to him.
- [98]
[98] Dr Chua was asked to investigate whether the buckling would have occurred even if tank 4S had been ventilated. Relying on Dr Ong’s report, Dr Chua calculated the time in which the buckling would have occurred and concluded that it took about 3.04 seconds. He thus stated that the buckling process could be treated as immediate. Given the dynamics of air penetrating through the liquid cargo at a high velocity, buckling due to over-pressurisation would have occurred even though the tank was ventilated. In its closing submissions, the defendant sought to use Dr Chua’s evidence to counter Captain Snowden’s 22 seconds theory (see above at [87]) and to make the point that the buckling was due to a sudden surge of air into tank 4S.
- [99]
[99] More to the point, Mr Gravil mentioned that it was “possible” that during the incident, the P/V valve maximum flow rate value was exceeded. This would mean that the P/V valve would not have been able to prevent a build-up of pressure as the flow rate of the air entering the tank was higher than the P/V valve’s capacity. In its reply submissions, the defendant explained that based on Mr Gravil and Dr Chua’s evidence, the P/V valve was not designed for a sudden surge of high velocity air.
- [100]
[100] As to how the sudden surge of air was able to enter tank 4S, two explanations have been advanced.
- [101]
[101] According to Mr Joseph, the terminal failed to inform the Bum Chin that pigging had completed and failed to obtain permission before commencing line blowing. The Bum Chin was therefore unprepared for incoming air pressure delivered from the jetty. This was also the position adopted by the Master of the Bum Chin in the Letter of Protest dated 17 April 2013 written to the “Terminal Operators” and the plaintiff. It was also pleaded that the terminal had failed to give sufficient notice of the completion and commencement of pigging and line blowing and that the terminal failed to carry out separate operations for pigging and line blowing.
- [102]
[102] According to Mr Sachs, the over-pressurisation was likely to be due to an air breakthrough at the end of pigging. Based on the terminal’s own procedure, at the end of pigging, the two valves at the pig receiver that sit along return lines that eventually lead to the Bum Chin’s manifold would be left momentarily open. There is therefore an inherent risk of air breaking past the pig receiver down the lines into tank 4S. This all depends on “how long the operators delay after [the pig reaches the end of the receiver] before closing the valves to the ship”. Having considered the Duty Loading Master’s AEIC, Mr Sachs concluded that “[a]ir breakthrough must have occurred and it does not make any significant difference if this was at the end of pigging or during blowing as an extension of pigging”, and that the over-pressurisation was “due to the actions, omissions or delays by the [t]erminal operators”.
- [103]
[103] Finally, the defendant does not dispute that the pressure alarm was not set at 70% of the P/V valve setting for pigging and line blowing. Its defence is that even if the pressure alarm was set, the incident would still have occurred because of the instantaneous rise in pressure in tank 4S. Putting aside the defendant’s instantaneous rise in pressure argument, the plaintiff has alluded to a breach of the ship’s procedures in [91] above, but the plaintiff does not go on to explain what would have happened if the pressure alarm was set. The necessary causal link between the breach and damage is not explained. In the circumstances, I do not propose to dwell on this complaint and I say no more.
Burden of proof
- [104]
[104] It is for the plaintiff to establish that the defendant was negligent in the care of the ROL IV 64 cargo on board the Bum Chin and in executing its end of cargo operations, amongst other things. This means that the plaintiff has to show a breach of duty to take reasonable care of the ROL IV 64 cargo loaded and stowed in tank 4S, and that the breach caused the plaintiff to suffer loss and damage, amongst other things. The general test of causation applies here. The cause or causes must be sufficiently connected or related to the loss in question as to be legally causative (in other words the effective cause). The plaintiff has attributed the cause of the failure of tank 4S to the matters set out above at [90]. On the other hand, the defendant puts forward the positive cause of the failure of tank 4S to be a sudden surge of high velocity air pressure in tank 4S. Even if the defendant’s assertion of a sudden surge of air pressure is not made out, the plaintiff has not discharged its burden. The plaintiff only succeeds if it is able to establish that the cause of the failure to tank 4S was as it had contended. This is because the legal burden remains with the plaintiff and does not shift to the defendant.
- [105]
[105] The plaintiff’s claim for damages will be dealt with later. Suffice to say for now that the burden of proof is on the plaintiff to make out its claim for damages.
Key factual findings
- [106]
[106] It is not surprising that there is heavy reliance on the opinions of experts at the trial and in submissions. However, the theories and opinions advanced as to how the incident happened must ultimately be based on the facts, not postulations and beliefs: see Khoo Bee Keng v Ang Chun Hong & another [2005] SGHC 128 at [68]. As such, findings on the following factual issues must first be made:
(a) the time at which loading, pigging and line blowing commenced and ended, and relatedly, the phase of cargo operations during which the incident occurred;
(b) the procedures and matters agreed between the terminal and the Bum Chin regarding cargo operations, with reference to the Ship/Share Safety Checklist (such matters include the rate of flow of cargo, maximum pressure at the ship/shore cargo connection, agreed tank venting system being use, and agreed communications during cargo operations, including signal for emergency stop);
(c) whether the chief officer, Mr Joseph, was in the CCR from 0524h until the incident happened;
(d) whether the terminal sought and obtained permission to commence line blowing; and
(e) whether the Bum Chin adopted open or controlled venting.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.