High Court · Decided 4 July 2019
Viking Engineering Pte Ltd v Feen, Bjornar and others
Feedback & support[2019] SGHC 158 · Case no. Suit No 294 of 2017 · 11 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Background
- [2]
[2] Viking Engineering and Mr Feen are joint venture partners in the third defendant, Viking Inert Gas Pte Ltd (“Viking Inert Gas”). This action arose out of a sale and purchase agreement dated 10 September 2013 between parties in relation to Viking Inert Gas. By this agreement, Viking Engineering, at that time a 51% shareholder, sold 21% of its shareholding to Mr Feen, thereby giving Mr Feen a 70% shareholding in Viking Inert Gas. Mr Feen was obliged with various undertakings in return, including a change of the corporate name of Viking Inert Gas to Feen Marine Pte Ltd, the name of the second defendant (“Feen Marine”). Mr Feen is the sole director of Feen Marine, the fourth defendant, Scanjet Feen IGS Pte Ltd (“Scanjet Feen”), and the fifth defendant, Feen Marine Scrubbers Pte Ltd. All the companies in question are Singapore-incorporated companies.
- [3]
[3] On 4 April 2017, Viking Engineering commenced High Court Suit No 294 of 2017, as minority shareholders of Viking Inert Gas, for minority oppression. Its claim included contentions that in breach of the sale and purchase agreement, Mr Feen transferred his shareholding in Viking Inert Gas to Feen Marine. Further, not only did Mr Feen fail to change the name of Viking Inert Gas to Feen Marine as the sale and purchase agreement required, he instead incorporated a company of the same name. Thereafter the business and corporate opportunities of Viking Inert Gas were said to have been diverted to Feen Marine and Scanjet Feen IGS.
- [8]
[8] In accordance with FTI’s letter of engagement, this sum was due within 14 days of the invoice date, being 26 November 2018, and its valuation report would only be released to the parties upon payment in full of its outstanding fees, disbursements and expenses.
- [9]
[9] Following FTI’s invoice, Viking Engineering sent an email and a letter to Mr Feen’s solicitors, XA, on 23 November 2018 and 4 December 2018 to seek confirmation that the invoice would be paid. No response was received nor was the invoice paid. FTI has not released its valuation report to parties.
Parties’ positions
- [12]
[12] Mr Feen took the position that none of the specified provisions were applicable. His view was that the correct procedure to move things forward was not the present summons, but a suit to be brought by FTI against him on its invoice. Regarding the sum specified, his stance was that FTI had failed to provide an adequate explanation for claiming a final invoice sum that was “almost triple the initial fee estimate”, contending that there was no justification for having 12 employees carrying out work for 690.8 billable hours, and that there was no breakdown of actual disbursements in the invoice or the cover letter. As for his delays in providing the relevant documents to FTI, Mr Feen explained that he was a marine engineer who was overseas frequently and rarely in his office.
Decision
- [13]
[13] There were two essential issues in this case: first, the applicable provision in the rules of court and its scope; and secondly, whether Viking Engineering was entitled to relief under the applicable provision.
- [14]
[14] For reasons that I explain below, I decided that it was appropriate to use O 45 r 6 of the ROC. I set a timeframe of 7 days for Mr Feen to pay FTI’s invoice.
The applicable process
- [15]
[15] Viking Engineering relied on O 45 r 6, O 45 r 8 and O 92 r 4 of the Rules of Court. These read as follows:
Whether the FTI must commence a separate action
Scope of O 45 r 6
Mr Feen’s liability to pay
- [20]
[20] Mr Feen argued that FTI’s final invoice was not in accordance with their estimate and that there was no justification for their final fee. This final fee, he submitted, was excessive.
Whether FTI’s fees were reasonable
(a) Detailed investigative and review work on the documents provided, including the financial data, in view of the concerns over the veracity of those data;
(b) Research work on publicly available information to fill gaps in the information that were requested but not provided by the parties, including information on the business of the defendants (and stakeholders associated with them) and on the industry/markets;
(c) Additional efforts spent in attempting to obtain third party documents on the financial situation of the defendants, including numerous communications with the banks and tax authorities to obtain financial records of the defendants, and multiple attempts with solicitors to arrange for site visits to the offices of the defendants;
(d) Manual recreation of unaudited financial statements of three defendants provided in PDF format (despite being requested in spreadsheet format) into spreadsheet format for analysis purposes, and subsequent checking of the data;
(e) Change of approach and analysis to adapt to the lack of reliable information on the defendants;
(f) Detailed documentation of the events following the appointment of Mr Hayler, including issues faced in relation to the information request, in the Determination Report, to explain the lack of disclosures and impact on the valuation approach and analysis; and
(g) Additional time spent on work arising from utilisation of different non-core team staff members to adapt to the disruption in resources planning in view of the extended timeline (extended by almost three months) and uncertainty as to when the requested documents would be received.
- [22]
[22] FTI further explained, in view of Mr Feen’s criticism that 12 employees were used, that seven of the 12 employees involved were non-core team members who only billed for 57.5 hours out of the total of 690.1 hours. This was approximately 8.33% of the total amount of hours spent. These non-core members were mainly involved in the re-creation of information provided by the defendants in PDF format to spreadsheet format, certain investigative work of the financial accounts of the defendants, and quality assurance work; much of this work could be avoided if the first defendant had adequately cooperated in providing the necessary documents to FTI.
Mr Feen’s lack of good faith
- [24]
[24] Having failed to cooperate with the valuation process, Mr Feen thereafter omitted to deal with FTI’s invoice. What followed FTI’s invoice was not protest but inaction. While Mr Hayler’s final paragraph of his letter of 12 November left it open to counsel to email him as permitted by the letter of engagement, no queries were posed. Reminders from counsel for Viking Engineering met with the same response. Mr Feen first expressed dissatisfaction with FTI’s invoice through his lawyers in a pre-trial conference after this summons was filed, on 18 December 2018. His first substantive comments were made in his reply affidavit in this summons, dated 3 January 2019. He explained that his inaction arose from his being heavily engaged in working in Japan and Korea between June and December 2018. As a result he did not check for email regularly. In their affidavit in response, Viking Engineering showed that Mr Feen chaired an AGM in Singapore on 15 November 2018 and sent emails to Viking Engineering between 6-9 December 2019. Mr Feen’s belated complaints about FTI and attempts to explain his tardiness therefore wholly lacked conviction.
Sufficient basis for the use of O45 r 6
Conclusion