High Court · Decided 15 July 2019
Ahmad Ebrahim s/o S M E Mohamed Sadik v Ilangchizian Manogaran
Feedback & support[2019] SGHC 167 · Case no. Suit No 268 of 2018
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The Plaintiff in the present suit is a licensed money-changer who has been in the money-changing business for more than 30 years. The Defendant has, for a number of years, provided the Plaintiff with book-keeping services for his money-changing business as well as income tax filing services. The Plaintiff’s position was that the Defendant had provided such services since 2008 but the Defendant’s position was that he had done so since 2005. The two men became friends over the years, until their relationship broke down as a result of the present dispute.
- [2]
[2] In gist, between 1 October 2014 and 19 March 2015, the Plaintiff made a number of payments to the Defendant amounting to a total of US$1 million. The Plaintiff’s case was that he had paid these moneys to the Defendant pursuant to an oral contract whereby he would invest in the Defendant’s investment scheme. According to the Plaintiff, each sum he invested “in the Defendant” was to be locked in for a period of 18 months. The Defendant was to invest the moneys “in the foreign exchange market” and to pay him a “monthly guaranteed return of 8% per month”, with the return of the principal sum also being guaranteed. The Plaintiff claimed that after paying him a total of US$216,800 in “monthly returns”, the Defendant ceased paying any of the remaining “guaranteed” returns and also failed to return the principal sum paid. The Plaintiff sought various reliefs against the Defendant, including a declaration that the Defendant had breached or wrongfully repudiated the alleged oral contract; the return of the US$1 million; the payment of allegedly outstanding “guaranteed returns” totalling US$1,320,000; an “account and inquiry” of “secret commissions” allegedly received by the Defendant; and damages for breach of fiduciary duty and/or breach of trust.
- [3]
[3] The Defendant’s case, in contrast, was that the Plaintiff had asked him for a recommendation of “contacts” who might be able to lend him money, as he needed to settle loans taken from unlicensed moneylenders and to finance his money-changing operations. The Defendant did not know anyone who could lend the Plaintiff money. However, he did tell the Plaintiff about his investment in a company called “Maxim Trader” which was promising investors fixed monthly returns on the amounts invested. These investment sums had to be locked in for 18-month periods. The Plaintiff expressed interest in investing in Maxim Trader himself. As the Plaintiff had difficulty leaving his money-changing counter, he asked the Defendant to let him use the latter’s investment account with Maxim Trader for his first two investments; subsequently, to help him open his own investment account; and also to help collect and transfer his monthly returns from Maxim Trader. The Plaintiff invested a total of US$1 million with Maxim Trader of his own volition. The Defendant invested a total of US$230,000. In June 2015, Maxim Trader stopped paying returns to its investors. In January 2018, the press reported that three representatives of Maxim Trader had been charged for offences including that of promoting an illegal multi-level marketing scheme.
- [4]
[4] At the conclusion of the trial, I dismissed the Plaintiff’s claims. As the Plaintiff has filed an appeal, I now set out the reasons for my decision.
The parties’ cases
The Plaintiff’s claims
- [5]
[5] I start by setting out the various causes of action pleaded in the Plaintiff’s statement of claim as they provide context to the evidence given by the parties. Firstly, as mentioned above, the Plaintiff claimed that he had an investment contract with the Defendant which was made orally on the following terms:
(a) that the Plaintiff be entitled to a “guaranteed return” of 8% per month on the sums invested with the Defendant;
(b) that each sum invested would be locked in for 18 months from the date of payment;
(c) that the guaranteed return of 8% per month would be paid to the Plaintiff by the Defendant for every calendar month until the expiry of the 18-month period;
(d) that this monthly guaranteed return would be paid within two calendar months from each investment; and
(e) that the sums paid to the Defendant were guaranteed and immediately due and payable on the expiry of the 18-month period.
- [6]
[6] The Plaintiff also pleaded the following further contractual terms which he said were implied terms:
(a) that the Defendant would invest the Plaintiff’s moneys in the foreign exchange market;
(b) that the Defendant would use all reasonable endeavours and/or due care and skill in investing the Plaintiff’s moneys;
(c) that the Defendant owed the Plaintiff a fiduciary duty whereby he would serve the Plaintiff honestly and in good faith;
(d) that the Defendant would not receive and/or retain a secret profit and/or commission; and
(e) that the Defendant would not invest in any illegal investments to the Plaintiff’s detriment.
- [7]
[7] The Plaintiff contended that the Defendant had breached “the express and/or implied terms” of the oral contract by failing to pay outstanding guaranteed returns totalling US$1,320,000 and failing to return the total investment sum of US$1 million.
- [8]
[8] Secondly, the Plaintiff claimed in the alternative that the Defendant had made the following oral representations to him which he had relied on in entering into the alleged oral investment contract:
(b) that the Defendant, being a successful investor and foreign exchange trader, possessed the necessary knowledge, skills and ability to undertake the investment contract and to achieve the guaranteed returns; and
(c) that the Defendant would not undertake any commitments he was unable to fulfil.
- [9]
[9] The Plaintiff contended that the above representations were made “fraudulently and/or negligently” by the Defendant “knowing that they were false, untrue and misleading, or recklessly not caring whether they were true or false”.
- [10]
[10] Further and/or in the alternative, the Plaintiff also claimed that the Defendant had exercised “undue influence” over him in procuring his payment of US$1 million under the alleged oral investment contract. According to the Plaintiff, the Defendant had “placed himself in a position of trust and confidence vis-à-vis the Plaintiff” through the book-keeping services he had provided, by portraying himself as “an honest book-keeper and a trusted friend”, and by doing various favours for the Plaintiff such as “[r]ecommending a physiotherapist for the Plaintiff’s wife” and [v]isiting the Plaintiff at his business premises to either collect documents, to chat, to change money or to have lunch”. The Plaintiff contended that it was “only due to the Defendant’s longstanding relationship [with him] and position of trust and confidence” that the Plaintiff was “induced by the Defendant’s said representations” to invest in his foreign exchange investment scheme.
- [11]
[11] Thirdly, the Plaintiff claimed in the alternative that he had paid the total amount of US$1 million to the Defendant “on trust for the sole purpose of the Defendant investing in the foreign exchange market”. The Defendant was alleged to have breached this trust by “misapplying” this investment sum. From the Plaintiff’s pleadings, it would appear that the “misapplication” lay in the Defendant allegedly putting all of the Plaintiff’s moneys in Maxim Trader, which – according to the Plaintiff – was not in compliance with the purpose of “investing in the foreign exchange market”. It should be highlighted that in the earlier iterations of the statement of claim, the Plaintiff had pleaded that he had never heard of Maxim Trader until September 2016 – but this position underwent a change in February 2019 when his pleadings were amended to state instead that he heard from the Defendant for the first time in September 2016 that he had “directly invested in… ‘Maxim Trader’ instead of in the Defendant as agreed”. I highlight this change in position as the issue of the Plaintiff’s awareness of Maxim Trader and his dealings with them formed an important aspect of his case and of the Defendant’s defence.
- [12]
[12] Fourthly, the Plaintiff pleaded in the alternative that he had appointed the Defendant as his agent and given the Defendant instructions to invest his moneys “in the foreign exchange market”. According to the Plaintiff, the Defendant had breached his fiduciary duties as agent by failing to comply with these instructions. In addition, according to the Plaintiff, the Defendant had admitted to making “a secret profit and/or commission in the sum of $50,000” while acting as his agent, and was liable to account for such secret profit.
- [13]
[13] Finally, the Plaintiff claimed in the alternative the return of the sum of US$1 million as “money had and received by the Defendant to the use of the Plaintiff under the [alleged] oral investment contract”.
The Defendant’s defence
- [14]
[14] The Defendant’s defence has largely been set out at [3] above. The bottomline to his version of events may be summed up in [3] and [4] of the Defence, which asserted that the Plaintiff knew that the Defendant was not a trader in foreign currencies or commodities; that he was not doing such trading for himself or on behalf of anyone else; that the Plaintiff had been aware all along that he was investing in Maxim Trader for his sole benefit and not in any investment scheme of the Defendant’s; and that he had also been aware all along that the Defendant was helping him with his investment-related matters gratuitously, at his request, only because they were good friends and he (the Plaintiff) was unable to leave his money-changing counter to attend to such matters.
- [15]
[15] The Defendant also asserted that it was only in late January 2018 – after the media reported the prosecution of the Maxim Trader representatives – that the Plaintiff started claiming that the Defendant was the party with whom he had entered into an investment agreement.
The evidence
- [16]
[16] I next summarise the evidence given at trial by the parties and their witnesses.
The Plaintiff’s evidence
The Plaintiff’s relationship with the Defendant
- [17]
[17] The Plaintiff testified that he first became acquainted with the Defendant in 2008 when the latter started providing audit-related services to his money-changing business. The Plaintiff subsequently recommended the Defendant’s services to his daughter, Shakila binte Mohd Sham (“Shakila”), who ran a restaurant business, and to several fellow money-changers. At the same time, the Defendant also became a customer of the Plaintiff’s money-changing business. The two of them grew to be close friends over the years and the Plaintiff claimed that he came to rely “heavily” on the Defendant’s “advice” for his “business and also [his] personal matters”.
The Defendant’s “investment scheme”
- [18]
[18] The Plaintiff alleged that the Defendant first approached him in mid-August 2014 about investing in his (the Defendant’s) investment scheme. Up until that point in time, the Defendant had never mentioned trading in shares or in foreign exchange – but in August 2014, he allegedly represented to the Plaintiff that he was making “heaps of monthly returns” from trading in foreign exchange and in the stock market, thanks to his experience as a trader and his “investments research”. He also declared that he was “seeking funds from his own investors” so as to “increase the return on his investments” and that he wanted to “extend” the “opportunity” to his family and close friends to “participate in his scheme of investment”, Indeed, he assured the Plaintiff that his (the Defendant’s) wife and close friends had already invested in his investment scheme and were “reaping good monthly income”. This scheme, which he proposed the Plaintiff invest in, was based on the following terms:
(a) that the Plaintiff pay the Defendant cash which he would convert into US dollars at a rate dictated by him, and which he would “add on to his investments”;
(b) that in return for the Plaintiff’s investment “into his investment scheme”, the Defendant would “guarantee” a sum of 8% per month in cash on the invested sums, and such invested sums were to be locked in for 18 months but would be returned in full to the Plaintiff at the end of the 18-month period; and
(c) that the monthly return of 8% would be paid to the Plaintiff within two months of making the investment.
- [19]
[19] The Plaintiff claimed that he was initially “unwilling” to take up the Defendant’s investment proposal because he had no experience in investing in stocks or shares and did not wish to part with his “life savings”. He questioned the Defendant on how he was able to generate 8% monthly returns and even expressed his fear of getting involved in “money laundering activities”. The Defendant allegedly represented that the investment scheme was “lawful” and further claimed that the investments he had undertaken were “all well known, run by billionaires”. The Plaintiff did not ask the Defendant any questions about the platforms he traded on because he “trusted [the Defendant] wholeheartedly so [he] didn’t wanted [sic] to find out”.
- [20]
[20] Despite the Plaintiff’s avowed reluctance, the Defendant persisted in trying to “convince” him over the next few months to invest in his investment scheme by repeating the same representations (at [18] above). The Plaintiff claimed that he was “induced” by these representations to invest in the Defendant’s scheme. He believed that the Defendant must be “doing well from his investments” since he was a “partner” in an accounting firm (Alan Morgan Partners LLP ), his wife was a lawyer, and his daughter was pursuing further studies in London. Moreover, he “trusted” the Defendant not to “cheat” him because of their close friendship.
The oral investment agreement
- [21]
[21] On 29 September 2014, the Plaintiff informed the Defendant that he wished to invest in the latter’s investment scheme. He asked the Defendant why his investment had to be in US dollars and whether the lock-in period could be reduced to 12 months. The Defendant then informed the Plaintiff that his investment would be “tied to the terms of [the Defendant’s] own investment which had to be in USD and that the ‘lock-in’ period had to be 18 months because [the Defendant’s] investment was also locked in for 18 months”. The Plaintiff was also cautioned not to tell his family about the investment. At the same time, the Defendant made the following further representations:
(b) that as a “successful investor and foreign exchange trader”, he possessed “the necessary knowledge, skill and ability” to guarantee the Plaintiff’s capital and to achieve the guaranteed returns; and
(c) that he “was able to undertake his commitment and to fulfil his agreement with [the Plaintiff]”.
- [22]
[22] The Plaintiff claimed that in addition to the terms previously proposed by the Defendant (at [18(a)] to [18(c)] above), the oral investment agreement he entered into with the Defendant also contained the following implied terms:
(a) that the Defendant would invest his money “in foreign exchange market [sic]”;
(b) that the Defendant would “use all reasonable endeavours and/or due care and skill in so doing”;
(c) that the Defendant owed him a “fiduciary duty” of honesty and good faith;
(d) that the Defendant would not make any “secret profit and/or commissions” under their oral agreement; and
(e) that the Defendant would not invest in any “illegal investments” to his detriment.
The investments made by the Plaintiff and the profit payments he received
- [23]
[23] The Plaintiff decided to invest an initial sum of US$150,000 but was only able to raise the sum of US$50,000. This sum was collected from him by the Defendant in its Singapore currency equivalent in cash on 29 September 2014 (the Plaintiff’s evidence was that he would simply accept the exchange rate conveyed to him by the Defendant for the conversion of USD to SGD ). The Defendant assured the Plaintiff that in respect of this first investment sum of US$50,000, he would receive his first guaranteed monthly return – US$4,000 – in mid-November 2014.
- [24]
[24] On 20 October 2014, the Plaintiff invested a further sum of US$100,000 which he said he had raised from his own savings. He was told by the Defendant that the guaranteed return of US$8,000 on this investment sum would be paid to him in mid-December 2014. At the same time, the Defendant continued to repeat his representations about how he was “making a lot of money” in “his investment scheme” not just for himself but also for “his own investors, his wife and friends”.
- [25]
[25] The Plaintiff did in fact receive the “guaranteed return” of US$4,000 (S$5,097.44) on 14 November 2014. A few days later, the Defendant visited the Plaintiff at his office and “boasted” about “his investment abilities and his ability to promptly pay the 8% profit”. The Plaintiff claimed that he asked the Defendant how he was able to reap such good profits that he was able to pay his investors 8% monthly returns and guarantee their capital – to which the Defendant responded by revealing that his “main investment” was “in a foreign exchange company called Maxim and their returns were very attractive and reaped profits of more than 8% per month”. The Defendant then suggested that the Plaintiff invest more funds in his scheme, which suggestion the Plaintiff agreed to think over. On 25 November 2014, he received news from the Defendant that his “second monthly profit” on his total investment of US$150,000 – amounting to US$12,000 – would be paid on 25 December 2014. The Defendant followed up by again trying to persuade the Plaintiff to make another larger investment on the same terms as before. This time, he suggested that the Plaintiff invest another US$450,000 to bring his total investments up to US$600,000 and repeated the same representations about guaranteeing 8% monthly returns and return of capital. The Plaintiff was so impressed by the Defendant’s boasts and the prompt payment of the monthly profits on his first two investments that he agreed to – and did – increase his total investments to US$600,000.
- [26]
[26] On 29 December 2014, the Plaintiff received the promised returns of US$12,000 (S$15,200) from the Defendant. Once again, he asked the Defendant how he was able to reap such good profits that he was able to pay his investors 8% monthly returns and guarantee their capital. Once again, the Defendant boasted of his investment abilities, and also repeated his story about “his Maxim investment… reaping good profits”. Once again, the Defendant also attempted to “lure” the Plaintiff into making yet another, larger investment, emphasizing that his monthly returns would “double or triple” if he increased his total investments. The Plaintiff was reluctant to do so, however, as he had “depleted [his] personal savings and moneys [he] had borrowed from [his] business”. He decided to wait for the payment of the next set of monthly returns – US$48,000 – due in January 2015.
- [27]
[27] In January 2015, the Plaintiff received his investment profit of US$48,000 (S$60,245). On this occasion, the Defendant once again touted his own investment abilities and also once again suggested that the Plaintiff increase his investment. The Plaintiff was still reluctant to do so and decided to wait for the next monthly payment of the US$48,000 returns on his total investments of US$600,000. This payment was made to him by the Defendant on 26 February 2015. On this occasion, the Defendant once again boasted of his investment abilities and also once again attempted to “lure” the Plaintiff into investing more money with him. According to the Plaintiff, the Defendant stated that he wished to increase his own investment in Maxim Trader – “his biggest and most lucrative investment”. This was presented to the Plaintiff as a “good opportunity” for him to increase his investment in the Defendant’s investment scheme; and the Defendant allegedly also repeated the same representations about guaranteeing 8% monthly returns and return of capital. The Plaintiff was also told that he “should not take too long to decide” because the Defendant’s “own investment in Maxim Trader had a deadline for further investments”.
- [28]
[28] On 1 March 2015, the Plaintiff informed the Defendant that he would be investing another US$160,000 “into the Defendant’s investment scheme”, thereby bringing his total investments to US$760,000. This further investment sum (in its SGD equivalent) was collected from him in cash by the Defendant on 4 March 2015.
- [29]
[29] Following this, according to the Plaintiff, the Defendant urged him to invest another US$240,000 so as to bring his total investments to US$1 million. Besides repeating his boasts about his investment skills and his success in delivering the promised profits, the Defendant proposed that the original investment agreement should be varied as follows:
(a) All sums already paid to the Defendant thus far (ie, US$760,000 in total) would be locked in for an 18-month period starting from the date when the Plaintiff made his next investment of US$240,000.
(b) The guaranteed 8% monthly returns would be paid to the Plaintiff until the expiry of this 18-month period. These monthly returns would still be paid within two calendar months from his investment, with the final such payment being made in October 2016.
(c) The principal sum of US$1 million would be repaid to the Plaintiff at the end of the 18 months from his next investment of US$240,000.
- [30]
[30] The Plaintiff claimed that he did not ask the Defendant why a variation of their oral agreement was necessary. It did not occur to him to ask. Instead, he stressed that in proposing these variations to their oral investment agreement, the Defendant once again repeated his representations about guaranteeing the monthly profit payments and return of capital. Once again induced by these representations, the Plaintiff agreed to the Defendant’s proposal but stressed that he would only be able to confirm the next investment amount after sourcing for more funds.
- [31]
[31] On 10 March 2015, the Defendant informed the Plaintiff that he would be receiving the next payment of monthly profit (totalling US$48,000) on or before 18 March 2015. At the same time, the Defendant continued trying to “lure” the Plaintiff into investing another US$240,000. He also cautioned the Plaintiff not to take too long to decide as he (the Defendant) would be meeting with his investment manager at Maxim Trader, one Goh Seow Mooi (also known as “Sammi”).
- [32]
[32] On 18 March 2015, the Plaintiff received from the Defendant payment of the monthly returns of US$48,000 (S$65,400) on his previous total investment of US$600,000. The Plaintiff was “overjoyed” at the time – but claimed that on hindsight, this payment from the Defendant appeared to have been a “calculated arrangement” to “deceive [him] and induce [him] into making the additional substantial investment of US$240,000”, as the Defendant took the opportunity on this occasion to urge him again to round up his investments to US$1 million and to emphasise the “deadline” of 19 March 2015 imposed by Maxim Trader. The Plaintiff claimed that he was “induced” by the Defendant’s “deception” and the “alleged urgency” to agree to investing a further US$240,000. The following day, he handed the money (S$333,600) in cash to the Defendant.
- [33]
[33] On 22 April 2015, the Plaintiff received from the Defendant payment of the monthly returns of US60,800 (S$80,000) on his previous total investment of US$760,000. Once again he claimed that he was “overjoyed” at the time but that on hindsight, he believed this payment to have been a ploy “calculated to deceive [him] that the Defendant’s [investment] scheme was bona fide and in accordance with [their] agreement”.
- [34]
[34] As at 25 May 2015, the Plaintiff had invested sums totalling US$1 million, in return for which he had received monthly returns totalling US$300,800 (the Plaintiff initially erroneously claimed he was paid US$48,000 in April 2015, but this was later corrected and confirmed by the Defendant). According to the Plaintiff, up until this point, he believed that he had been investing in the Defendant’s investment scheme; and he was completely unaware of any investment agreement with Maxim Trader. As far as he was concerned, it was the Defendant who had guaranteed 8% monthly returns on the investment and who had been paying him these returns.
The Plaintiff’s allegations regarding the “deception” practised by the Defendant
- [35]
[35] On 2 June 2015, an article appeared on a Singapore social media site – “All Singapore Stuff” – in which the writer asserted, inter alia, that Maxim Trader was a Ponzi scheme whose founders had already been arrested in Taiwan. The Plaintiff claimed that he did not see this article at the time of its publication on 2 June 2015. However, he contended that the Defendant must have seen the article on 2 June 2015; that the Defendant deliberately concealed the information from him and that having realised on that date that “his investment in Maxim Trader was lost because it was a Ponzi scheme”, the Defendant “set out to hatch a false defence that he was only [the Plaintiff’s] agent” and that the Plaintiff had invested his US$1 million into Maxim Trader. The Plaintiff based his contention on the following. Firstly, the Defendant allegedly told him on 2 June 2015 that he had recommended to Maxim Trader that on the expiry of the Plaintiff’s contract with the Defendant in September 2016, the Plaintiff should “benefit directly” from investing in Maxim Trader “under the same terms agreed with the Defendant”. Secondly, according to the Plaintiff, the Defendant also started “frantically and deceptively chasing [him] to urgently” open “an I-account directly with Maxim Trader”.
- [36]
[36] In respect of the first allegation, the Plaintiff claimed that he was not agreeable to investing “directly in Maxim Trader for another 18 months” after the expiry of his investment agreement with the Defendant. He claimed that this refusal to take up the direct investment with Maxim Trader was communicated to the Defendant in a Whatsapp message on 7 June 2015, in which he had stated:
- [37]
[37] In respect of the second allegation, the Defendant explained during the trial that the “I-account” was an online fund transfer platform which was operated by another company unrelated to Maxim Trader, and which he and other investors used to transfer their investment profits from Maxim Trader to their personal bank accounts. The Defendant’s evidence about the “I-account” was not disputed. In any event, according to the Plaintiff, whilst he initially agreed to the Defendant’s suggestion that he open his own I-account, no I-account was opened for him because he decided not to proceed with the arrangement.
The cessation of monthly profit payments
- [38]
[38] June 2015 was in fact the month in which things started going wrong for the Plaintiff’s investments. On 21 June 2015, he discovered that the monthly profit of US$80,000 had not been credited into his bank account as promised; and on checking with the Defendant, he was told that the latter too had not received his June returns from Maxim Trader. The Defendant subsequently reported having been told by Sammi that there was a delay in the payment of investment profits for all investors in Maxim Trader. He suggested that the Plaintiff attend a meeting which he was planning to arrange with Sammi, adding that he had informed Sammi of the Plaintiff’s “monthly financial commitment”.
- [39]
[39] On 25 June 2015, the Plaintiff and the Defendant attended a meeting with Sammi at PUB Auditorium. Many other people were also there “raising issues with Maxim Trader”. At this meeting, the Plaintiff was told by Sammi that Maxim Trader was “having some investment problems in Taiwan” which apparently necessitated the conversion of investors’ shares and consequent delay in the payment of the Defendant’s investment profits. According to the Plaintiff, it was also at this meeting that the Defendant revealed to him “for the first time” that his US$1 million had all been invested “into Maxim Trader” together with the funds from the Defendant’s “other investors” – and that the payment of his investment returns would therefore “depend on Maxim Trader’s dealings and recovery of their own options”. The Plaintiff was “shocked” by this revelation. The Defendant later reported on 30 June 2015 that the share conversion alluded to by Sammy was going on “worldwide”. At this point, the Plaintiff received yet another shock when the Defendant informed him that he was “unable to confirm and comply with his contractual obligations” to the Plaintiff because he was “unsure when his investment in Maxim Trader [would] materialise”.
- [41]
[41] The month of July 2015 passed without the Plaintiff receiving payment of his monthly profit of US$80,000 for that month, or of the balance of his June profit. The Defendant’s “excuse” was that “he and Maxim Trader were not able to convert or sell their shares”. At the end of July 2015, the Defendant informed the Plaintiff that Maxim Trader was implementing a new trading platform through which he hoped to sell off his shares and pay the Plaintiff the contracted investment returns. By early September 2015, however, the Plaintiff had yet to receive any payment. He decided to contact Sammi directly for news, and was informed by her that the Defendant’s investment was to be “converted to shares”, that the share conversion was “still in progress”, and that these shares would be sold sometime in February 2016.
- [42]
[42] The Plaintiff did not receive any update from the Defendant throughout September 2015. Indeed, according to the Plaintiff, the Defendant delayed the provision of any updates whilst trying to “invoke [the Plaintiff’s] sympathy” by disclosing personal and family problems such as the death of an aunt, the ill health of his daughter and defaults in his mortgage repayments. The Defendant subsequently assured the Plaintiff in late October 2015 that he would be “speaking to some friends” to ask that they purchase his Maxim Trader shares and that he would use such sale proceeds to pay the Plaintiff his US$1 million capital and the guaranteed profits. However, by December 2015, no such sales had materialised. When the Plaintiff chased him again for an update in January 2016 on whether anyone was buying his shares, the Defendant replied that “everyone is quiet” and that there was no interested buyer. The Defendant also informed the Plaintiff that he had been told the Maxim Trader shares would be “in [the] market” in February 2016.
- [43]
[43] On 29 February 2016, the Defendant forwarded the Plaintiff a message from the Maxim Trader investors’ chat group which purported to inform all investors that the trading of their shares would commence “by the end of April 2016”. This deadline was subsequently pushed back once again to May 2016 via a company announcement shared within the same chat group. According to this announcement (which was forwarded to the Plaintiff by the Defendant via Whatsapp), investors were expected to have their shares traded on the New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”) by an “appointed Fund Manager” from May 2016; and in anticipation of the trading activity, investors were urged to “operate a trust account with [the] appointed official trustee” before 30 April 2016. On the Plaintiff chasing him for an update in early May 2016, the Defendant confirmed that he had successfully applied to open the necessary trust account. By June, however, this deadline had been pushed back by Maxim Trader yet again, this time to “July/August 2016”; and investors were being told to open a “brokerage account” with the “appointed share brokerage firm”.
- [44]
[44] By end-August 2016, the Plaintiff had still not received any further payment of monthly profits or of his principal investment sum. The Defendant informed him that the only update received from the purported “Trustee of Maxim Trader” was a text message which the Defendant forwarded – and which spoke in vague and general terms of the “next 2-3 months” being a “critical period of vulnerability” while “the Sponsor” worked towards “completing the NYSE project” As the Plaintiff himself observed in a Whatsapp message to the Defendant, there was “nothing solid [and] firm” about the “trading of shares” in the Trustee’s update.
The “confrontation” of 19 September 2016
- [45]
[45] The Plaintiff claimed that by this stage, it was already “clear” to him that the Defendant was in breach of their oral investment agreement and was unable to return him the principal investment amount of US$1 million, let alone pay him the guaranteed monthly profits. According to the Plaintiff, he was “very depressed”, “sick” and “felt cheated” by the Defendant, so much so that he finally confided the truth about his predicament to his daughter, Shakila. It was then that he learnt from Shakila that the Defendant had approached her in July 2014 to invite her to invest in his investment scheme; and it was only then that he realised the Defendant had “surreptitiously deceived” him into entering into the latter’s investment scheme and thereby “defrauded” him of his “whole life savings and borrowings”.
- [46]
[46] On 19 September, both of the Plaintiff’s daughters, Shakila and Haseena binte Mohd Sham (“Haseena”), confronted the Defendant at the Plaintiff’s office. The Defendant came alone while the Plaintiff and his wife were present with their two daughters (and apparently with Haseena’s husband as well). The Plaintiff’s and the Defendant’s accounts of the “confrontation” differed substantially. According to the Plaintiff, his daughters had berated the Defendant for “surreptitiously” inducing the Plaintiff to invest substantial amounts in his (the Defendant’s) investment scheme; and they had also questioned him as to how he could “guarantee” the 8% monthly profit and return of capital. In the Plaintiff’s version of events, the Defendant responded by falsely alleging that it was the Plaintiff who had not wanted to tell his children about his investment. It was also at this “confrontation” that the Defendant allegedly revealed that Maxim Trader was “not on the Stock Exchange”; and that he was “not able to pay… the monthly profit and guaranteed amount because Maxim Trader were having financial problems in Taiwan where their funds were frozen”. The Defendant also allegedly asserted – “for the first time” – that the Plaintiff had entered directly into an investment agreement with Maxim Trader with the Defendant acting purely as his “gratuitous agent” and that the Defendant had kept all the investment contracts between the Plaintiff and Maxim Trader. On top of all this, the Defendant even admitted that he had received “commission” of US$30,000 for “introducing” the Plaintiff to Maxim Trader, which commission – according to the Plaintiff – was “unlawful” and amounted to “secret profits”.
- [47]
[47] In the course of the “confrontation”, according to the Plaintiff, the Defendant did not say anything about Maxim Trader being a Ponzi scheme or about their being “subject to international criminal prosecution”. This led the Plaintiff to continue to believe that “Maxim Trader were in fact a genuine investment” and “they were doing everything to get their returns to be able to pay… the guaranteed returns”. The “confrontation” ended with the Defendant agreeing to produce the investment contracts between the Plaintiff and Maxim Trader.
The events following the “confrontation”
- [48]
[48] On 10 October 2016, the Defendant forwarded a file containing documents which he said were the investment contracts between the Plaintiff and Maxim Trader. Copies of these contracts and a table setting out the list of contracts are found in the Plaintiff’s AEIC. At trial, the Plaintiff insisted that he had never seen these contracts before, that the dates and amounts stated in the alleged contracts “did not correspond” with his investment agreement with the Defendant; and that these contracts must therefore have been “falsely fabricated” by the Defendant as a means of evading his own liability.
- [49]
[49] Despite the Defendant’s alleged “deception”, “fabrication” and shocking revelations, the Plaintiff decided not to make any police report or to seek legal advice – because, according to him, he still viewed the Defendant as a “close friend” and moreover, still continued to “trust” that the Defendant would “come back with the money”. Indeed, the only Whatsapp message from the Plaintiff in which he alluded to the 19 September 2016 “confrontation” between his daughters and the Defendant – which was sent on the same date – simply stated:
- [50]
[50] The Whatsapp exchanges between the two men for the rest of September 2016 and October 2016 do not contain any references to the “confrontation” or to the allegedly “false” contracts furnished by the Defendant. The Whatsapp messages exhibited by the Plaintiff in his AEIC end at 5 October 2016 and then resume on 9 January 2018. It should be noted that the Whatsapp messages exhibited in the Plaintiff’s AEIC appear to be exactly those disclosed by the Defendant during discovery. The Defendant has explained that he was unable to produce the Whatsapp exchanges for the period November 2016 to December 2017 because he lost all Whatsapp messages for the said period when he switched to a new iPhone.
- [51]
[51] On 9 January 2018, according to the Plaintiff, he found out for the first time from news reports that Maxim Trader was a Ponzi scheme and that they were being prosecuted in Singapore. He felt “shocked” and immediately suggested to the Defendant that he should contact Sammi and “see how he could recover his own investments from Maxim Trader” so as to pay off the guaranteed profits and capital sum pursuant to their own oral investment agreement. On 18 January 2018, the Defendant forwarded a text message from Sammi which simply stated:
- [52]
[52] The Plaintiff claimed that it was only then that he “finally accepted” that the Defendant would not be paying him the outstanding monthly profits or the principal investment sum. On 22 January 2018, he sent the Defendant Whatsapp messages announcing that he would commence legal action unless the latter paid him “the capital sum of [US$1 million] and agreed interest in the total [US$360,000]” within 7 days. He followed up by engaging his present solicitors and causing a letter of demand to be issued to the Defendant on 9 February 2018 for the total sum of US$2,360,000.
The evidence given by the Plaintiff’s daughters
- [53]
[53] Both the Plaintiff’s daughters, Shakila and Haseena, were called by him as witnesses; and both gave evidence about the “confrontation” on 19 September 2016 which matched his version of events. In gist, both claimed that when confronted, the Defendant had told them “his investment was in Maxim Trader” which “was guaranteeing 8% per month profits and guaranteed return of the capital investment”. Although he initially described Maxim Trader as “a listed Company on the Stock Exchange”, he caved in when pressed by them and admitted that the company was “not on the Stock Exchange”. He also told them he was unable to pay the Plaintiff his guaranteed profits and capital sum because “Maxim Trader was a failed investment and their funds were frozen”. Asked what relevance this had to the Plaintiff’s investment, the Defendant replied that the Plaintiff had invested directly in Maxim Trader and not in his (the Defendant’s) investment scheme: he had merely acted as an intermediary to assist the Plaintiff when the latter was unable to leave his business premises. He also informed Shakila and Haseena that he had received “commission” of US$30,000 for introducing the Plaintiff to Maxim Trader and had invested money in Maxim Trader himself, together with the Plaintiff.
- [54]
[54] According to Shakila and Haseena, the “confrontation” lasted for more than an hour, during which the Plaintiff “denied [the Defendant’s] false allegations”, and Haseena even threatened to lodge a police report against him for “cheating” the Plaintiff. The Defendant allegedly asked Haseena not to do so and promised to produce the investment contracts between the Plaintiff and Maxim Trader which were in his possession. A file containing the contract documents was subsequently forwarded by the Defendant. Both Shakila and Haseena claimed that they had examined these documents. Both opined that the documents had been “fabricated as an afterthought” by the Defendant, since the Plaintiff insisted that he had never seen these contracts, that he had never appointed the Defendant, and that it was “the Defendant’s investment scheme” which he had invested in.
- [55]
[55] Both Shakila and Haseena also claimed that the Plaintiff had refused to take any action against the Defendant even after his lies because the Plaintiff “still trusted the Defendant” and hoped that he would be able to pay the outstanding profits and capital sum. It is not disputed that no police report has to date been lodged by the Plaintiff against the Defendant. It was only after finding out on 9 January 2018 that Maxim Trader was a Ponzi scheme that the Plaintiff decided to take legal action against the Defendant.
- [56]
[56] In addition to the above account, Shakila claimed that the Defendant – who had been the book-keeper for her restaurant business since 2009 – had in July 2014 invited her to “invest into his investment scheme”. Under this scheme, she was promised “as much as 8% guaranteed returns per month” and “guaranteed” return of her capital after an 18-month lock-in period. . Shakila claimed that the Defendant had been “persistent” in contacting her several times about the suggested investment, but that she had been “sceptical” about his ability to pay the promised 8% monthly profit and had refused to invest in his scheme.
The Defendant’s evidence
The Defendant’s relationship with the Plaintiff
- [57]
[57] The Defendant runs his own book-keeping and tax advisory business, in the course of which he has developed a base of some 40 money-changer clients including the Plaintiff. He provides them with services such as the keeping of business books, the completion of tax returns, and the submission of audits to the Monetary Authority of Singapore.
- [58]
[58] The Defendant testified that he has known the Plaintiff since 2005 and agreed that they had over the years become good friends who would do favours for each other and discuss personal as well as family matters. It was during such chats that the Plaintiff talked about his financial problems: how he was often short of money to run his business, especially when it came to stocking up on fast-moving foreign currencies, and how he had taken short-term loans from some “regular customers” at high interest rates.
- [59]
[59] In mid-2014, the Plaintiff disclosed to the Defendant that he had resorted to borrowing from unlicensed moneylenders who charged high monthly interest rates. He asked the Defendant if he knew anyone who could lend money at a lower interest rate, but the latter did not know any moneylenders.
The Defandant’s first contact with Maxim Trader and his initial investment
- [60]
[60] It was around this time that the Defendant first heard about Maxim Trader from one James Thomas (“Thomas”), who was the manager of the condominium where the Defendant stayed. Thomas told the Defendant in May 2014 that he had invested in a company called Maxim Trader from which he was getting “good guaranteed monthly returns”; and he encouraged the Defendant to invest as well. In July 2014, Thomas broached the subject of investing in Maxim Trader again; and this time the Defendant agreed to attend an “investment presentation” by Maxim Trader. It was at this presentation that the Defendant learnt that Maxim Trader “was actually Maxim Capital Limited, a forex international company” whose core area of expertise was forex trading and who provided a platform for individual clients to “invest and trade” in forex directly for “high guaranteed monthly returns”. Such clients had to open investment accounts with Maxim Trader and enter into investment contracts which required them to “lock in” their investment sums in US dollars for 18-month periods. In return, they would be paid a “guaranteed monthly performance return” from 3% per month for a minimum investment of US$1,000 to 8% per month for investments of US$30,000 or more. These guaranteed monthly returns would be deposited in an investor’s Maxim Trader investment account after one month from the date of the investment, following which investors would be able to transfer the money to their personal bank accounts. Investors were also encouraged to open individual I-accounts as this online fund transfer platform allowed for faster transfers of their monthly profits from Maxim Trader to their bank accounts. Additionally, an investor who introduced a new investor to Maxim Trader would receive an “introduction fee of 10% of the first investment” of that new investor.
- [61]
[61] At this presentation, the Defendant spoke to some investors who told him that they were receiving the guaranteed returns on their investments regularly. After hearing from these investors, the Defendant was persuaded that Maxim Trader was genuinely trading in forex. Thomas then introduced him to one Chin Ming Kam (“Chin”), a representative of Maxim Trader. With Chin’s assistance, the Defendant opened an online investment account with Maxim Trader on 8 August 2014 and invested a sum of US$10,000, which he was told would yield a guaranteed monthly performance return of 6%. Subsequently, he also opened an I-account with an online fund transfer platform – I-Account Services (HK) Ltd – to allow for faster transfers of the monthly returns from his Maxim Trader investment account.
- [62]
[62] In cross-examination, the Defendant testified that as he had been told at the presentation that Maxim Trader was an online trading platform with a New Zealand licence to trade in forex “worldwide”, he did not check whether the company had a registered address in Singapore, nor did he conduct his own enquiries to verify the existence of the New Zealand licence. He had, however, limited the potential risks of his initial investment in Maxim Trader by investing only US$10,000, which was a sum he felt he “can risk with”.
- [63]
[63] According to the Defendant, apart from his investment in Maxim Trader, he had invested in stocks on only four occasions between 2012 and 2018. Those investments had been in Ausigroup (an Australian oil and gas company) and Olam (a company registered on the Singapore stock exchange); and he had made losses on those investments. He denied that he had represented himself to the Plaintiff as an experienced trader or that the latter had relied on him for advice in personal financial matters.
The Plaintiff’s initial investments into Maxim Trader
- [64]
[64] Around the same time, the Plaintiff again asked the Defendant if he could recommend any moneylenders. The Defendant did not know anyone he could recommend, but decided to share with the Plaintiff the information about his investment in Maxim Trader as he thought that the Plaintiff too might benefit from it. The Plaintiff became “very interested” in investing in Maxim Trader when he learnt of the “guaranteed 6% to 8% monthly returns” being offered by them. At this point, the Defendant also told the Plaintiff about the one-time 10% introduction fee and explained that he would receive this fee if he introduced another investor, just as the Defendant would receive this fee for introducing him. The Plaintiff replied that he “just wanted to invest on his own” and had no time to source for referrals. Seeing the Plaintiff’s eagerness, the Defendant advised him to wait until the Defendant had been paid his first monthly return. The Plaintiff agreed to wait, but declined the suggestion that he attend Maxim Trader’s presentations, claiming that he could not afford to leave his money-changing counter during operating hours. For the same reason, the Plaintiff was also unable to meet up with Maxim Trader’s representatives for the opening of an investment account in his name and instead requested that the Defendant assist to make the investment under his (the Defendant’s) name and to facilitate the withdrawal of the monthly returns. The Defendant agreed to assist him.
- [65]
[65] On 1 October 2014, the Plaintiff passed the Defendant the Singapore currency equivalent of US$50,000 for his first investment with Maxim Trader. It was around the same time that the Defendant received from Maxim Trader the first monthly return on his first investment, which spurred him on to make a second investment of US$40,000. He did not tell Chin that of the two tranches of US$50,000 and US$40,000 he wished to invest on this occasion, the former sum was the Plaintiff’s investment. Chin proposed that the Defendant break up the investments into three investment contracts of US$30,000, each of which would yield an 8% monthly return; and the Defendant accepted the proposal after obtaining the Plaintiff’s consent. He suggested to the Plaintiff that he create a file of the latter’s investments for him to keep at his business premises, but the Plaintiff said he did not wish his family members to know about his investments and asked that the Defendant keep the file for him instead.
- [66]
[66] On 20 October 2014, the Plaintiff decided to make a second investment with Maxim Trader, this time of a sum of US$100,000. Surprised, the Defendant advised him to wait until after the receipt of his first guaranteed monthly return – but the Plaintiff proceeded with the investment as he felt confident. This second investment was also made under the Defendant’s name, in the form of three investment contracts of US$30,000, US$30,000 and US$40,000 respectively.
- [67]
[67] In November 2014, the Plaintiff received two sets of monthly returns: US$4,000 (being the first monthly return on his investment of US$50,000) and US$8,000 (being the first guaranteed monthly return on his investment of US$100,000). He decided to invest a further US$450,000 with Maxim Trader. Concerned about the size of his intended investment, the Defendant advised him to think carefully about it – but the Plaintiff remained confident of making good returns on his investment in light of the monthly returns he had already received. When the Defendant informed Sammi that it was the Plaintiff who was proposing to invest US$450,000, she asked him to tell the Plaintiff to open an investment account in his own name. At first, the Plaintiff maintained that he still wanted to make his investments under the Defendant’s name and that he was not free to leave his money-changing business. He eventually agreed to open his own investment account but requested that the Defendant assist him to open the account and to pass his money to Maxim Traders. As he felt “very stressed” dealing with computers, the Plaintiff also did not wish to learn how to access his investment online and instead requested that the Defendant continue to facilitate the payout of his monthly profits by transferring the moneys to the Defendant’s I-account and bank account before paying it over. The Defendant agreed to assist. The Plaintiff’s US$450,000 was eventually invested under his own name in two tranches of US$300,000 (on 27 November 2014) and US$150,000 (on 28 November 2014) respectively. As the Plaintiff was considered a new investor with Maxim Trader, the Defendant received on this occasion the “introducer’s fee” of US$30,000 which was credited to his investment account.
The Plaintiff’s and the Defendant’s further investments into Maxim Trader
- [68]
[68] Between December 2014 and May 2015, the Plaintiff and the Defendant continued to receive their monthly profit payments from Maxim Trader. Both also continued to make further investments with Maxim Trader. The Plaintiff invested a further US$160,000 on 4 March 2015 and another US$240,000 on 19 March 2015, thereby bringing his investments with Maxim Trader to a total sum of US$1 million. The Defendant too made a further five investments with Maxim Trader between December 2014 and April 2015, which brought his own investments with Maxim Trader to a total of US$230,000. In cross-examination, the Defendant testified that he had not found Maxim Trader’s promises of 6% to 8% “guaranteed” monthly profits suspicious because not only had various investors spoken positively at the Maxim Trader presentation of their investment experience, the receipt of the first monthly return on his initial US$10,000 investment had led him to believe that the company was able to deliver on its promises. By end-May 2015, the Plaintiff had received a total of US$300,800 in monthly profits while the Defendant had received a total of US$56,600.
The cessation of monthly profit payments
- [69]
[69] Sometime in June 2015, the Defendant suggested to the Plaintiff that he open his own I-account, as it would allow him to withdraw his monthly profits directly from his investment account instead of waiting for the moneys to be transferred first to the Defendant’s I-Account and from there to the Defendant’s OCBC account before the Defendant then issued him a cheque. At trial, the Defendant could not recall whether an I-Account was successfully opened for the Plaintiff in the end. In any case, the issue of the I-Account opening was overtaken by other events: both men did not receive their guaranteed monthly returns for the month of June 2015; and at a meeting of Maxim Traders investors on 23 June 2015, Sammi informed the investors that the delay in payment “was because the authorities in Taiwan, Korea and Japan had frozen Maxim Trader’s funds and had begun investigations following some complaints”. Sammi also informed them that the matter had been reported in Taiwanese papers.
- [70]
[70] At the same meeting, investors were told that Maxim Trader would be converting their investments into Royal Group Holdings Inc (“ROGP”) shares under a programme called the “Super Swap Share” (“SSS”). The Defendant updated the Plaintiff, who requested that he assist with the online arrangements for the SSS programme. The Plaintiff also disclosed that he was worried about the delay in Maxim Trader’s payment of the monthly returns as he had to repay loans taken from moneylenders. The Defendant therefore asked him to attend a meeting with Sammi on 25 June 2015 so that they could discuss with her options on moving forward and overcoming the delay. The Defendant also conveyed to him information received from Sammi that, inter alia, “[m]aybe due to Taiwan case thus funds from Maxim being monitored”.
- [71]
[71] The meeting with Sammi on 25 June 2015 turned out to be “very unsatisfactory”, as she was unable to provide any certainty as to when Maxim Traders would be paying the investment returns. On 30 June 2015, the Defendant shared with the Plaintiff an update from Sammi to the effect that the conversion to ROGP shares had been extended to 15 July 2015 and that these shares were expected to be traded on the NYSE by the first quarter of 2016. The Plaintiff expressed fear that he was “totally stuck”. He subsequently asked the Defendant to arrange for another meeting with Sammi in early July 2015, but Sammi did not respond.
- [72]
[72] Around 15 July 2015, the Defendant managed – with Sammi’s help – to sell 200,000 of his converted shares at US$0.20 per share, for a total sum of US$40,000 (S$52,000). The Plaintiff then sought the Defendant’s help to sell his shares, but he wanted to sell at no less than US$0.50 per share, and no buyers could be found at that price. By then, the Plaintiff was desperate to settle his loan repayments, and he asked the Defendant to help him out. This led to the Defendant agreeing that the Plaintiff could use the former’s US$40,000 sale proceeds first.
- [73]
[73] Things did not get better in the following months. On 30 July 2015, the Defendant shared with the Plaintiff another update received from Sammi, in which it was announced that Maxim Trader investors would have a new platform by August 2015 to buy and sell their ROGP shares. On 13 September 2015, however, the Plaintiff spoke to Sammi and was informed that the new trading platform would only be operational in February 2016. In the ensuing months, confusing and at times contradictory updates were given by Maxim Traders. In October 2015, investors were told to open trust accounts with a Malaysian company called Perpectual Trustees Berhad, but after having done so, they were told in February 2016 to open trust accounts instead with a Hong Kong company called Legacy Fiduciary Services Limited (HK) because of “disagreements between Perpectual Trust Berhad and the management of Maxim Trader”. After opening a trust account with the Hong Kong company, however, the Defendant received yet another update from Sammi in May 2016 that the ROGP shares had been “suspended” from the NYSE and that Maxim Trader would instead be injecting investors’ moneys into another company called India Globalisation Capital Inc. Investors were further instructed in late June 2016 to open a brokerage account with the “appointed share brokerage firm”.
- [74]
[74] According to the Defendant, despite following the various instructions received from Maxim Trader, there was still no sign of the company paying them. The Plaintiff was “very very stressed” as he was finding it hard to maintain sufficient stock at his money-changing counter and to keep up with his financial commitments, and he repeatedly urged the Defendant to “talk to Sammi” and “chek [sic] with Sammi” about what was happening to their investments. The Defendant himself was very worried about his own financial commitments such as the school fees for his daughter’s university studies abroad.
The “confrontation” of 19 September 2016
- [75]
[75] On 12 September 2016, the Defendant received a request from the Plaintiff’s daughter Shakila to meet her. The meeting was arranged for 19 September 2016 at the Plaintiff’s money-changing counter. The Defendant’s account of the “confrontation” differed substantially from the Plaintiff’s and his daughters’. According to the Defendant, Shakila did not tell him what the meeting was about. He assumed it was to discuss her company’s accounts, but upon arriving, he found the Plaintiff, his wife, his two daughters (Shakila and Haseena), and Haseena’s husband all present. The Plaintiff told the Defendant he had told his family members about his investments in Maxim Trader and they wanted to speak to the Defendant about it. The Plaintiff’s wife and daughters then asked the Defendant how much the Plaintiff had invested in Maxim Trader. When the Defendant told them the Plaintiff had invested a total of US$1 million, he saw that they were very shocked; and although he could not understand much of what they said to each other in Malay, he sensed that the Plaintiff had not been frank with his family about his investments.
- [76]
[76] According to the Defendant, the Plaintiff’s family – and particularly his daughters – then scolded him for having agreed to help the Plaintiff invest with Maxim Trader and for not having told them about what the Plaintiff was doing. Haseena lamented that the Plaintiff had previously “put himself and his family in a similar situation” by borrowing money from unlicensed moneylenders, while Shakila – fretting that the Plaintiff would not have enough capital to run his money-changing business during upcoming festive periods – demanded that the Defendant make a written declaration stating that the Plaintiff’s US$1 million had been given to him and that he also provide the Plaintiff funds to run his business. When Shakila heard that the Defendant had received an introduction fee of US$30,000 for introducing the Plaintiff to Maxim Trader, she demanded that this amount should be given to the Plaintiff. The Defendant refused these demands. He felt that the Plaintiff’s family members were trying to make him the scapegoat when the Plaintiff himself had knowingly made an independent decision to invest with Maxim Trader. Shakila also demanded to have the Plaintiff’s investment contracts, which the Defendant explained had been left in his keeping at the Plaintiff’s request; and the Defendant agreed to give them the contracts.
- [77]
[77] Throughout this “confrontation”, the Plaintiff did not say anything apart from asking his daughters to have the discussion at a nearby coffee shop instead – which request they ignored. The Defendant left the meeting feeling very harassed and traumatised. It was only when he left that the Plaintiff came up to him and apologised, claiming that he had not been in a position to speak up against his family. The Defendant retorted that he should let his family know he had invested in Maxim Trader of his own free will.
The events following the “confrontation”
- [78]
[78] In December 2016, the Defendant received a phone call from the Plaintiff’s daughters in which Shakila again demanded that he help the Plaintiff out with funds for his money-changing business and Haseena verbally abused him. After this, the Defendant called the Plaintiff to express his disappointment at such treatment. He told the Plaintiff that he was in no position to help him financially, and that while he would convey any updates from Maxim Trader, he did not wish to be contacted by the Plaintiff’s family again.
- [79]
[79] On 9 January 2018, the Plaintiff texted the Defendant to highlight the news about the arrest and prosecution of Maxim Trader representatives. According to the Defendant, it was around this time that the Plaintiff began alleging that it was the Defendant to whom he had entrusted his money. In a Whatsapp message on 15 January 2018, the Plaintiff alleged for the first time that it was the Defendant who had been entrusted “with so mch [sic] mony [sic]” and who should be doing something “for that trust…to collect bk [sic] that money”.
- [80]
[80] On 18 January 2018, the Defendant received the following text from Sammi, which he understood to mean that all the moneys he had invested in Maxim Trader were lost:
- [81]
[81] The Defendant forwarded Sammi’s text to the Plaintiff. A few days later, he was shocked to receive from the Plaintiff a Whatsapp message which alleged that the Plaintiff had paid him US$1 million in return for his promise to pay monthly interest of 8% and to return the capital within 18 months. The Defendant did not respond to this message as he knew the Plaintiff was aware these accusations were all lies. On 9 February 2018, he received a letter of demand from the Plaintiff’s lawyers repeating similar allegations and demanding payment of US$2,360,000. It was then that he responded with his letter of 19 February 2018 to point out that it was the Plaintiff who had been “keen” to “grab the opportunity” to invest in Maxim Trader; that there was no investment agreement between him and the Plaintiff; and that the latter had invested directly in Maxim Trader all along.
- [82]
[82] Asked why he had not called Sammi, Chin or Andrew Lim (the CEO of Maxim Trader) to testify on his behalf, the Defendant said he had never spoken to Andrew Lim; and whilst he had initially dealt with Chin in the opening of his investment account, he had communicated much more with Sammi subsequently. He had not called Sammi as a witness because when he called her in the aftermath of the media story about her arrest, she had told him there was “a proceeding going on” and asked him not to call her again.
The evidence given by James Thomas
- [83]
[83] The Defendant did, however, call his former condominium manager James Thomas who confirmed that he had introduced the Defendant to Maxim Trader in mid-2014. Thomas testified that he had suggested the Defendant invest in Maxim Trader because he himself had invested US$20,000 in Maxim Trader at that point and – having received his 6% returns – was convinced that it was a genuine and good investment. He received a 10% “commission” from Maxim Trader for introducing the Defendant as a new investor.
- [84]
[84] Like the Defendant, Thomas too stopped receiving his promised monthly returns from Maxim Trader after May 2015, and had only found out later that “Maxim Trader had broken the law and its representative had been charged in Court for a variety of offences”.
The key issues in contention
- [85]
[85] From the evidence adduced by both parties, they were agreed that moneys totalling US$1 million were passed by the Plaintiff to the Defendant; that the moneys were in fact invested in Maxim Trader; that the promised interest rate was 8% per month; and that the moneys invested were to be locked in for 18 months, with the return of the capital sum at the end of the 18 months being guaranteed. What was in dispute was whether the Plaintiff had contracted directly with and invested directly in Maxim Trader, such that Maxim Trader was the entity contractually obliged to pay him the “guaranteed” profits and capital sum – or whether the Plaintiff had entered into an investment agreement with the Defendant, who was then contractually obliged to pay him the promised profits and the “guaranteed” capital.
Assessment of the evidence
Inconsistent and illogical evidence by the Plaintiff
- [87]
[87] I set out below my reasons for rejecting the Plaintiff’s version of events.
Material shifts in position in critical aspect of the Plaintiff’s case
- [88]
[88] It must be remembered that the Plaintiff’s entire case hinged on the assertion that he had contracted directly with the Defendant and invested his money in the Defendant’s investment scheme; that Maxim Trader had nothing to do with him; and that he had always looked to the Defendant to fulfil his contractual obligations vis-à-vis the payment of the guaranteed monthly profits and return of capital. In this connection, a fundamental – indeed, critical – aspect of the Plaintiff’s case related to the issue of when he first came to know that the Defendant was investing his money in Maxim Trader. This was because a key plank of the Plaintiff’s case rested on the contention that he could not have contracted directly with Maxim Trader when he had been ignorant even of the existence of Maxim Trader from the start, and remained ignorant of it until after sinking US$1 million into the Defendant’s “investment scheme”.
- [89]
[89] The original Statement of Claim filed on 13 March 2018 made no mention of Maxim Trader. Following the filing of the Defence, in which the Defendant asserted that the Plaintiff had contracted directly with Maxim Trader, the Plaintiff alleged in his Reply of 18 April 2018 that it was “not until the Plaintiff confronted the Defendant with his two daughters sometime in September 2016 at the premises of the Plaintiff’s money changing business that the Defendant first mentioned Maxim Trader to the Plaintiff”; that he had never been told about Maxim Trader prior to this meeting in September 2016; and that he “was… not aware of any alleged investment by the Defendant in Maxim Trader until” this meeting in September 2016. On 22 June 2018, the Plaintiff amended his Reply – but his pleaded position as to when he first heard of Maxim Trader and when he became aware of the Defendant investing his (the Plaintiff’s) money in it remained unchanged.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.