High Court · Decided 11 October 2019
Ding Auto Pte Ltd v Yip K in Lung and others
Feedback & support[2019] SGHC 243 · Case no. Suit No 1040 of 2017
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The plaintiff in this case is Ding Auto Pte Ltd (“Ding Auto”), a company in the motor workshop business engaged inter alia in accident repairs and panel beating. According to the business profile maintained by the Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority (“ACRA”), its sole director is Ding Tang Ling (“Ding”), who is also the sole owner of the 80,000 shares in the said company. Ding Auto brought the present suit against three parties. The first Defendant is Yip Kin Lung, who is also known as Jason, and whom all parties referred to as “Jason” during the trial. I will refer to him as “Jason” in these written grounds of decision. The second Defendant is Mega Auto Pte Ltd (“Mega Auto”), a company of which Jason is the sole director. According to Mega Auto’s ACRA business profile, Jason holds 340,000 (or 97.14%) of the 350,000 shares in the company whilst one Rohaiyu binte Sharif (“Rohaiyu”) holds the remaining 10,000 shares (2.86%). The third Defendant is Andy Chiun Tser Peng (“Andy”), who is described by both himself and Jason as a former “partner” of Mega Auto until his departure from that company in June 2016.
- [2]
[2] Ding Auto’s suit against the three defendants sought to make them liable to account for various payments and withdrawals from the former’s bank accounts which were alleged to be unauthorised and unlawful. At the conclusion of the trial, the total quantum of the allegedly unlawful payments and withdrawals was amended to $350,372.80 after Ding Auto elected to withdraw a number of claim items. As against Jason, Ding Auto claimed inter alia the recovery of this amount from Jason and an account of all properties and/or benefits obtained from the use of these monies. The same reliefs were claimed against Andy. As against Mega Auto, Ding Auto claimed the recovery of the amount of $212,277.38, being the sum total of the unlawful payments received directly by Mega Auto. Ding Auto pleaded a number of different bases for its claim, including breaches of fiduciary duties by Jason and Andy vis-à-vis Ding Auto; conspiracy by all three defendants (or any two of them) to injure Ding Auto by unlawful means; and the imposition of constructive trusts on each of the three defendants vis-à-vis the monies paid out of Ding Auto’s bank accounts.
- [3]
[3] The defendants denied Ding Auto’s claim. They also brought a counterclaim in which they alleged, firstly, that Ding Auto owed Mega Auto a total of $166,463.08 (taking into account the withdrawal during the trial of two counterclaim items) for “work done and/or services rendered at the request of [Ding Auto], rental, salaries paid for and on behalf of [Ding Auto]”. Mega Auto also counterclaimed for the alleged wrongful retention and conversion of several items of workshop equipment.
- [5]
[5] At the conclusion of the trial, I gave judgement for Ding Auto against Jason and Mega Auto for the amounts of $350,372.80 and $212,277.38 respectively, while dismissing its claim against Andy. I also dismissed Mega Auto’s counterclaim as well as the claims brought by Jason and Mega Auto in the third party proceedings. As Jason and Mega Auto have appealed, I am setting out the grounds for my decision.
- [6]
[6] I will first summarise each side’s version of events and the key evidence presented by the parties.
The plaintiff’s version of events
- [7]
[7] Ding Auto was incorporated on 2 May 2013. Its case was that Ding had set up the company after leaving the employment of ST Kinetics. Having started with ST Kinetics as a panel beater and worked his way up to managing two of its STAR accident repair workshops, Ding had acquired substantial experience in the motor workshop business. When he left ST Kinetics after 23 years, in the wake of its decision to close down its STAR workshops at the end of December 2012, he was keen to open his own panel beating and accident repair business. His plan was to get onto the insurance companies’ panel of authorised workshops, which would ensure regular referral by these insurers of accident repair claims. He felt quite confident of being able to get his workshop on the insurers’ panel as he had built up good contacts with the insurance companies – and also core suppliers – within the industry.
- [8]
[8] During Ding’s period of employment with ST Kinetics, he had befriended Jason, whose company Mega Auto was one of the sub-contractors that STAR assigned or sub-contracted repairs, spray-painting and other jobs to. When Jason learnt of Ding’s business plans, he expressed interest in coming on board as an investor and shareholder in the new company. However, Ding refused his offer to do so after receiving negative feedback from insurance company representatives and motor parts suppliers on the possibility of Jason being a shareholder in his proposed new company.
- [9]
[9] Subsequently, Jason offered to allow Ding Auto to operate from a unit leased by Mega Auto from the Housing Development Board (“HDB”) at Blk 10 #01-20 Sin Min Industrial Estate Sector C, in return for Ding Auto paying the rent payable to HDB. This unit had previously been occupied by one of Mega Auto’s workshops. Jason also offered Ding and Ding Auto help in the following ways. He told Ding that given Mega Auto’s existing operations and its many staff, he could help Ding with back-end operations such as accounts, payroll, tax returns, human resource (HR), and other financial and administrative operations. He also offered to extend loans to Ding Auto to enable it to set up its corporate bank accounts and to pay for initial expenses. He further offered to help Ding with his family expenses by suggesting that, for the short period before Ding Auto started receiving revenue from its jobs, Ding could be registered first as a Mega Auto employee and he (Jason) would help advance him some money in the form of his salary. This arrangement would cease once Ding Auto’s business was up and running: Ding Auto would then repay all these loans from Jason once it started earning money. Jason even arranged for Ding Auto to be provided with two second-hand computers which were then lying unused in Mega Auto’s back-end office.
- [11]
[11] As Ding was unfamiliar with the process of incorporating a company, Jason arranged for him to meet Lee Sye Choo (“Lee”). Lee ran a corporate secretarial firm that Jason was already a client of. At their meeting, Lee and Jason gave Ding a number of documents in English to sign. Ding could not understand these documents but he signed them as he was told by Lee that he “needed to sign a lot of documents to register the company” with ACRA. Ding was unable to read the documents as they were in English, and they were not explained to him.
- [12]
[12] In cross-examination, Ding was referred to two undated documents which the defendants alleged he had signed during the meeting with Lee. One of the documents purported to announce Ding’s resignation as a director from Ding Auto; the other purported to be a “share transfer form” transferring his shares in Ding Auto to one Hisham bin Suaidi (“Hisham”). It should be noted that in the latter document, Hisham’s particulars, the number of shares being transferred (80,000) and the date stated (20 June 2016) appeared to have been inserted separately at a different time from the rest of the contents of the document, as they appeared to have been typewritten and were in a different font. Ding agreed that the signatures on these two documents were his. He could not remember signing these documents during the meeting with Lee, as there had been a lot of documents placed before him then, and his grasp of written English was extremely limited. He also could not remember if the typewritten particulars in the “share transfer form” were present when he signed the document. His understanding was that he was incorporating Ding Auto with himself as the sole director and shareholder; and Jason did not tell him anything contrary to this understanding. Pursuant to the incorporation of Ding Auto, Ding was provided with a certificate certifying him to be the holder of one share in Ding Auto.
- [13]
[13] As to the reference in the “share transfer form” to the purported transfer of 80,000 shares in Ding Auto, it should be added that sometime in December 2014, Ding Auto’s issued share capital recorded an increase by an amount of $79,999, to a total amount of $80,000. Ding’s evidence was that Jason had mentioned this increase in issued share capital to him and had told him that this was to “make the company look better” so that “people in the market would know that this was not a $1 company”. Jason gave him some documents to sign but did not tell him to put up any money for the increase in issued share capital. In any event, Ding subsequently found out from his counsel that no deposit of $79,999 per se was ever made into Ding Auto’s bank accounts. This was not denied by the defendants, their case (or more precisely, Jason’s case) being that the figure of $79,999 was “paid for” by Mega Auto via its set-off of various “debts” which Ding Auto was alleged to owe it. Ding disputed the defendants’ case and denied in particular that Ding Auto had owed debts which could properly be set off by Mega Auto in this manner.
- [14]
[14] Jason also helped to arrange for the opening of corporate bank accounts by Ding Auto. It was at Jason’s suggestion that two bank accounts were opened: one at Oversea-Chinese Banking Corporation (“OCBC Bank”) which was “used for customers’ NETS and Credit Card payment facilities”, and one at Standard Chartered Bank (“SCB”) which was used for the “payment out of business expenses”. It was also at Jason’s suggestion that Andy, another Mega Auto staff named Wong Seng Kee (“Wong”), and Jason himself were added as signatories – along with Ding – for both bank accounts. Each of the four men was authorised to sign cheques solely. Jason explained to Ding that this was to “facilitate the company operations” since Ding Auto’s “back-end office” would in effect be located at Mega Auto’s premises. As to why Andy and Wong were added as signatories, Jason told Ding that this was because he (Jason) would be travelling out of Singapore from time to time, and having these two additional signatories “would make things easier”. Ding trusted Jason whom he regarded as “a good friend”. Ding was already familiar with Wong from his time in STAR, and he also knew Andy to be Mega Auto’s HR manager. Accordingly, he agreed to Jason’s suggestion that Andy and Wong be added as signatories. As Ding’s English was poor, it was Jason who completed the account opening forms for both bank accounts.
- [15]
[15] Jason also suggested that the bank statements for Ding Auto’s accounts be sent to his (Jason’s) residential address at 2J Still Road. This set of premises, apart from being Jason’s residence, was also used by him to house Mega Auto’s accounts personnel. Ding agreed to his suggestion as he needed Jason’s help to “read any documents in English” and he still fully trusted Jason at this point.
- [16]
[16] It was not disputed that following Ding Auto’s incorporation, Jason arranged for loans totalling $50,000 to be made to it. These loans consisted of a sum of $20,000 paid via a cheque from Mega Auto into Ding Auto’s OCBC account on 31 May 2013; a sum of $20,000 paid via a Mega Auto cheque into Ding Auto’s SCB account on 28 June 2013; and a further sum of $10,000 paid via another Mega Auto cheque into Ding Auto’s SCB account on 10 July 2013. It was also not disputed that the loans totalling $50,000 were repaid to Mega Auto by Ding Auto not long afterwards, via a cheque for $30,000 drawn on Ding Auto’s SCB account on 1 October 2013 and another cheque for $20,000 drawn on the same SCB account on 11 October 2013. Ding testified that at the time these repayments to Mega Auto were made from Ding Auto’s account, he was not aware of them because from 2013 to the start of 2016, Jason had been handling Ding Auto’s accounts and he did not show these accounts to Ding. Bank statements and other correspondence were sent to the address at 2J Still Road. Ding himself did not see the bank statements. He only managed to obtain the bank statements for Ding Auto’s accounts in the wake of his dispute with Jason in mid-2016, and it was only then that he found out about (inter alia) the withdrawal of the $30,000 and the $20,000. In Ding’s words, Jason “took the monies from [Ding Auto’s] accounts himself”.
- [17]
[17] In addition, shortly after the incorporation of Ding Auto, Ding was – as per Jason’s suggestion – registered on Mega Auto’s payroll for the months between June 2013 to March 2014; and during this period, Mega Auto paid him every month a salary of $4,000 plus CPF contributions. According to Ding, however, he was not an employee of Mega Auto’s: these advances were loans from Jason to help him temporarily and were to be repaid once Ding Auto started making money. Ding did not know why Jason had chosen to put him on Mega Auto’s payroll and to pay monthly advances including CPF contributions, instead of simply advancing him a lump-sum loan. Jason told him that “the accounts [had] to be done this way”, and he did not question Jason. In any event, Ding reiterated that Jason was not helping him for free: apart from Ding Auto having to repay the loans, the understanding between the two men was that Ding Auto would also refer business such as spray-painting works and car rentals to Jason’s companies.
- [19]
[19] As for the actual panel beating and repair work, Ding denied that in the initial period following the incorporation of Ding Auto, Mega Auto had “seconded” its own workers to Ding Auto and continued to pay for their salaries while they carried out Ding Auto’s work. Ding testified that in the initial period after Ding Auto was set up, he sub-contracted such work out to part-timers such as a “Mr Goh”, an “Ah Hin”, and a Mega Auto worker named Qing Dong who did “overtime work” at Ding Auto to earn more money.
- [20]
[20] Ding worked very hard trying to get sales and business for Ding Auto, and in particular, in convincing the insurance companies to put the company on their panel of authorised workshops. In December 2013, he succeeded in getting a contract for Ding Auto to be an authorised workshop for Liberty Insurance. This was followed by a contract with NTUC Income to be an authorised workshop for some 200 Corporate Travel Management corporate vehicles. By 2015, Ding Auto had also been added to the panel of authorised workshops for MSIG, Aviva and AIG. As Ding Auto’s business picked up, it embarked in April 2014 on hiring its own workers. By May 2014, it had hired a total of 6 workers, including panel beaters as well as fulltime office staff who processed insurance claim matters (Anna Chua, (“Anna”)) and took care of procurement matters (Ching). Andy helped Ding with Ding Auto’s payroll and human resource matters by handling paperwork such as work permit applications, computing the pay due to the employees, and disbursing these payments to the employees.
- [21]
[21] While 5 of the 6 workers listed in Ding Auto’s CPF statement for May 2014 were formerly from Mega Auto, Ding denied defence counsel’s suggestion that it was a case of their having been “transferred” to Ding Auto:
- [22]
[22] As per Jason’s offer, Ding Auto started operating from Mega Auto’s former premises at #01-20. Ding denied defence counsel’s suggestion that Mega Auto workers who had previously worked for Mega Auto at #01-20 remained at the unit to do work for Ding Auto after the latter’s formation.
- [23]
[23] On 28 September 2015, Ding Auto formally took over the HDB lease for #01-20. Ding agreed that Ding Auto should pay rent in respect of #01-20 for the period it had occupied that unit prior to 28 September 2015: this was, after all, the basis on which Jason had initially offered him the use of #01-20. He believed that the rent had already been paid because Jason had been handling Ding Auto’s accounts all along and would normally have ensured that whatever he had paid on Ding Auto’s behalf would be repaid from Ding Auto’s accounts.
- [24]
[24] As for #01-22, it was not disputed that the lease for this unit remained in Mega Auto’s name, even until today. Ding denied the defendants’ allegation that Ding Auto had occupied and operated the spray-painting booth at this unit from the time of its incorporation in 2013 until 2016. His evidence was that if a Ding Auto job involved spray-painting, such spray-painting work would be directed to the spray-painting booth at #01-22, which was owned and operated by Mega Auto; and the spray-painting work would be done by Mega Auto staff. Even after Ding Auto finally hired its own spray-painters from April 2014 onwards, #01-22 continued to be in Mega Auto’s possession. Ding Auto would send its spray-painters over to #01-22 to carry out spray-painting work there, paying Mega Auto a commission in return.
- [25]
[25] Insofar as the utilities bills for #01-20 and #01-22 were concerned, Ding acknowledged that there was only one PUB meter for both units, which was located within #01-20. He agreed that the utilities, which had been billed under Mega Auto’s name prior to Ding Auto moving into #01-20, had continued to be billed to and paid by Mega Auto up until the present day. According to Ding, he was “prepared to separate the meters”, but by July 2016 he was not on speaking terms with Jason and/or Mega Auto; and although he had asked Mega Auto staff Ling Kok Wong (“Ling”) about separating the meters, there was no response from Mega Auto. In respect of Mega Auto’s counter-claim for reimbursement of utilities payments for both #01-20 and #01-22, Ding agreed that Ding Auto should pay for the utilities in respect of #01-20. He disputed liability for the utilities in respect of #01-22 because (as mentioned earlier) he denied the defendants’ allegation that Ding Auto had occupied #01-22 between 2013 and 2016. He noted that the electricity bill for #01-22 would be higher than that for #01-20. Nevertheless, he was willing to pay half of the amounts counter-claimed for reimbursement of utilities in respect of #01-20 and #01-22.
- [27]
[27] Sometime in April 2014, therefore, Ding had a chat with Jason about the issues of paint and staff shortages. Both verbally agreed the following. Ding Auto would pay for whatever spray-paint it used for its spray-painting jobs. It would also hire and pay for its own spray-painters to undertake its spray-painting work. To this end, Ding Auto hired – in April 2014 – two spray-painters (one of whom had hitherto worked as a spray-painter at Mega Auto). It also continued to sub-contract spray-painting work out to “stand-in” spray-painters. In addition, as Ding Auto’s spray-painting work continued to be done at #01-22, albeit by its own spray-painting workers, Ding Auto would pay Mega Auto “commission” for the use of its spray-painting booth. According to Ding:
- [29]
[29] Ding acknowledged with chagrin that this ignorance on his part was symptomatic of how he had handled the running of Ding Auto until his dispute with Jason in mid-2016. As he put it:
- [30]
[30] Insofar as the day-to-day running of Ding Auto was concerned, Ding’s evidence was that he himself took charge of the operational aspects of the work and also of handling customers and getting in more business. Jason, as per his offer of help to Ding, took care of Ding Auto’s accounting and other back-end matters:
- [31]
[31] Ding testified that until his dispute with Jason in mid-2016, he had been submitting the payments received by Ding Auto – as well as incoming mail and financial documents - to the Mega Auto back-end office, but he had not seen any receipts. Insofar as payments from “petty cash” of the company’s ad hoc expenses were concerned, Ding accepted the validity of payments where he had signed off on the petty cash vouchers. Whilst “in the past” Anna had helped him handle some of the petty cash claims, she was required to let him see the supporting documents for the payments so that he would know what they were paying for. He was not aware, however, that the petty cash float held in the office was actually $2,500, as he had believed that it was $1,000.
- [32]
[32] Insofar as cheque payments were concerned, Ding saw the Ding Auto cheque-books only on the occasions when he was asked to issue cheques, but he was not shown any of Ding Auto’s accounts. He had no idea what the true financial situation of Ding Auto was in the period of 2013 to early 2016. When he tried asking Andy and Yvonne about Ding Auto’s finances, they would simply refer him to Jason. When he did ask Jason about Ding Auto’s finances, Jason would tell him that the company was not running profitably. The only time Ding was briefly shown some accounts was at the end of 2013, when he asked Jason how the company was doing as they needed to issue salaries and bonuses to the staff: that was when Jason showed him some accounts in electronic form on his (Jason’s) laptop. He was not given a hard copy of the document and in any event did not understand what was shown to him on Jason’s laptop, as he did not know how to read financial documents such as audited accounts and balance sheets.
- [33]
[33] On 11 September 2014, Ding was asked by Jason to sign documents titled “Report of the Directors” and “Statement by the Directors”, which eventually became the 2013 year-end financials filed with ACRA. At the time Ding was asked to sign the documents, he was told by Jason that they were “for compliance submission purposes”. He was only shown a total of four pages without being given the full set of the company’s financials; and Jason told him that Ding Auto had “made a small profit just over $1,000 in year 2013”.
- [34]
[34] Ding had started out putting his trust in Jason, but as time went on and the latter failed to show him Ding Auto’s accounts, he “started paying attention” and having reservations. He did not immediately “appoint someone else” to take over the handling of the accounts from Jason since he had after all accepted Jason’s help so that he could “save [the] money” he would otherwise have had to spend getting someone to “do [the company’s] tax returns, the GST and so on”. However, things did not get better. If anything, they got worse. The following year, on 9 September 2015, he was again asked by Jason to sign similar documents – this time a total of three pages – for “compliance submission purposes”. These documents were apparently subsequently filed with ACRA as the 2014 year-end financials. On this occasion, Jason informed him that Ding Auto had “made a loss of over $70,000 for 2014. This did not make any sense to Ding, as he knew Ding Auto had been making claims and bringing in business. Ding started to worry that the problem “seemed to stem from the quantum and nature [of] expenses incurred for [Ding Auto]”. He asked Andy and Jason for clarification on issues such as whom they had authorised payments to and what Ding Auto’s outgoing expenses were, but Andy simply directed his queries to Jason – who was “vague and elusive”.
- [36]
[36] As he was not getting any clear answers from Jason about how Ding Auto’s monies were being spent, Ding decided to stop forwarding documents and cheque payments to the Mega Auto back-end office from early June 2016 onwards. He had no access to Ding Auto’s bank statements, however, and did not know how much money was in the company’s bank accounts. He was shocked when a Ding Auto OCBC cheque issued to a customer for “loss of use payment” of $300 was dishonoured in late July 2016. This was the last straw for Ding: he now realised that Jason must not have managed Ding Auto’s finances properly. He decided to tell Jason that he “wished to take back all the finances and accounts matters”.
- [37]
[37] Jason did a number of things as soon as Ding told him he wanted to “take back” Ding Auto’s “finances and accounts matters”. The very next day (4 August 2016), he told Ding that he would be removing the furniture from #01-20 because it belonged to him. He also arranged for the removal of the two old computers which he had previously brought from the Mega Auto back-end office. In addition, whereas Jason had previously helped Ding to file Ding Auto’s GST returns with the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (“IRAS”), it was around this time in August 2016 that Ding Auto began receiving letters from IRAS stating that the company had failed to file its GST returns and to pay outstanding GST. It was also around this time that Jason arranged for Anna and Foo Wung Toon (“Foo”) – who had been employed by Ding Auto since 2014 – to be re-hired as Mega Auto employees. In Ding’s view, Jason “(b)asically…wanted to cripple [Ding Auto’s] operations”.
- [38]
[38] Sometime in August 2016, Jason also abruptly handed a document to Ding for his signature. A copy of this document is exhibited at pages 500 to 502 of Ding’s AEIC. In gist, it is entitled “Joint Venture Agreement” (“draft JVA”) and contained inter alia the following clauses:
- [39]
[39] As Ding did not understand the document, he brought it to his daughter Kelly and asked her what it was about. He did not sign the draft JVA in the end because Kelly warned him against signing it after she had gone through its terms.
- [40]
[40] Following Jason’s unilateral removal of the computers from #01-20, Ding Auto lost all access to records relating to its clients, car repair information, claim records, and other related documentation. Worst of all, Ding did not have any of Ding Auto’s accounting and other financial records. As Goh Boon Kok (“Goh”), the Certified Public Accountant engaged by Ding at his counsel’s suggestion noted, Ding “did not even have a general ledger or the company’s bank statements”: Ding told Goh that Jason had “simply refused to return the originals or to extend copies to him” and that even the computers containing the electronic data on Ding Auto’s claim cases had been unilaterally removed from the company’s premises. It was Goh who advised Ding to close Ding Auto’s existing bank accounts at OCBC and SCB and to open a new bank account; and Goh even accompanied Ding to the banks to carry out these arrangements. By the time the OCBC and the SCB accounts were closed on 27 July 2016, there was only a sum of $39.88 in the former account and $1,011.36 in the latter. Ding deposited these sums – along with the cheques he had held back from Mega Auto’s back-end office since June 2016 – into the new United Overseas Bank (“UOB”) account which Goh helped him to open for Ding Auto.
- [41]
[41] Jason continued to ignore Ding Auto’s requests for him to return its accounting and other financial records, even when the request was made to his lawyers by Ding Auto’s counsel. Ding had to get Goh’s help to apply to the banks for copies of cheque images and bank statements. Up until the commencement of these proceedings by Ding Auto in November 2017, Jason had continued to ignore the requests for him to return the company’s accounting and other financial records.
- [42]
[42] Ding testified that for months after his dispute with Jason in August 2016, Ding Auto was “in big trouble with no money, no accounting or financial documents”. In October 2016 and November 2016, it received demand notes from IRAS for over GST payments. Creditors too were chasing for payment; and some suppliers – such as Chow Enterprises Pte Ltd – even sued Ding Auto for unpaid invoices dating back to January 2016. Ding was obliged to go, cap in hand, to each creditor to explain the situation and to ask for more time to pay. He also had to tell his wife and children of the dire situation and to confess that he could not pay for the household expenses as he had not received any salary for months. Eventually, it was due to the support of his family members and friends that Ding Auto managed to pull through the crisis. His family members chipped in to raise money to pay off Ding Auto’s debts, and he also managed to obtain loans from some friends. His wife and daughter subsequently agreed to leave their own jobs to come and assist him in Ding Auto.
Summary of the plaintiff’s case against the defendants
- [43]
[43] The statement of claim filed on behalf of Ding Auto was lengthy and unfortunately at times rather confusing, but its case against the defendants may be summarised as follows.
- [45]
[45] Vis-à-vis Andy, Ding Auto’s case was that besides attending to payroll and human resource matters on its behalf, he would also sign cheques on its behalf for payment of business expenses, and generally assist Jason in managing Ding Auto’s “finance and office back-end work”; further, that he too acted as a manager and an agent of Ding Auto in carrying out these various functions.
- [46]
[46] Ding Auto’s case against Jason and Andy was based on a number of alternative causes of action. Firstly, it was Ding Auto’s case that in their capacities as managers and agents, Jason and Andy each owed Ding Auto a number of duties, including (inter alia) a “duty to be honest and to act in good faith with proper care, skill and diligence when dealing with the affairs of [Ding Auto]”, a “duty to keep accurate accounts of all transactions undertaken on behalf of [Ding Auto]” and [to] be prepared at all times to produce these accounts” to Ding Auto or its director; and a “duty to account for all money and property received and to indemnify [Ding Auto]” for any monies he or Mega Auto had “wrongfully retained”.
- [47]
[47] Further or alternatively, Ding Auto asserted that both Jason and Andy were trustees of its assets and accordingly owed it fiduciary duties which included (inter alia) a “duty to act always bona fide in the interests of [Ding Auto]”, and a “duty to ensure that the affairs of [Ding Auto] [were] properly administered and that its assets, property and resources [were] not exploited or relocated or dissipated to the detriment of [Ding Auto’s] interests”.
- [48]
[48] It was asserted that Jason and Andy had both breached the above duties and acted “mala fides against the interest of [Ding Auto]” by (inter alia) making unauthorised withdrawals from Ding Auto’s bank accounts, authorising payment out of [its] funds to various parties (including Mega Auto) “without any proper basis or documentation or apparent benefit to [Ding Auto]”, and improperly “diverting [Ding Auto’s] assets” to various parties including Mega Auto.
- [49]
[49] Generally, it was also Ding Auto’s case that Jason had removed all its accounting and financial records after his dispute with Ding in July 2016; that he had persisted in ignoring requests from Ding Auto and its lawyers for the return of these records; and that he had also failed to provide any details of the alleged reasons or basis for the impugned withdrawals and payments until the present suit was well underway.
- [50]
[50] As against Mega Auto, it was Ding Auto’s case that Jason was its “directing mind and will”; that it (Mega Auto) had acted “within knowledge that [Jason] was acting in breach of his duties to” Ding Auto; and that it was accordingly liable, “on the ground of knowing receipt”, to account as a constructive trustee for the cash cheques and payments made to it from Ding Auto’s account.
- [51]
[51] It was also asserted against Andy that he had “intentionally” or “with wilful recklessness” failed to query the unauthorised withdrawals and payments and “deliberately turned a blind eye to the nature of such irregular payments that an ordinary or honest person would so query [sic]”; and that he was accordingly liable for “dishonest assistance” of Jason’s breach of duties.
- [52]
[52] Further or alternatively, Ding Auto contended that all three defendants (or any two of them) had conspired to injure Ding Auto by unlawful means; namely, by making “various unlawful cash and cheque withdrawals” from Ding Auto’s bank accounts while keeping its accounting and financial records “away from sight” of Ding to “conceal such fraud and the proceeds of such fraud”.
- [53]
[53] The “unlawful cash and cheque withdrawals” which formed the subject of Ding Auto’s claims against the defendants are listed in the table set out in [13] of the statement of claim (Amendment No. 2). That the listed withdrawals and payments were made from Ding Auto’s bank accounts was not disputed by the defendants. It was also not disputed by the defendants that the cash cheques and other cheques relating to these withdrawals and payments were signed either by Jason or by Andy. The defendants alleged, however, that all these withdrawals and payments were properly made for legitimate reasons.
- [54]
[54] It was also not disputed by Jason that he had removed Ding Auto’s accounting and financial records following the dispute with Ding; that he had ignored the requests for the return of these records; and that he had disclosed documents to justify or support the impugned withdrawals and payments only after being sued by Ding Auto. Jason took the position that Ding Auto was truly owned by Mega Auto, and that in any event he had eventually provided documents in the discovery stage of these proceedings.
- [55]
[55] As a general observation at this juncture, it should be noted that in light of the removal of its accounting and financial records as well as the late stage at which documents were eventually disclosed by Jason, Ding Auto took the broad position that it was wholly unable to uncover any legitimate reason for these transactions. It should also be noted that although Jason and the other two defendants alleged that these withdrawals and payments were all properly made for legitimate reasons), neither Jason’s AEIC nor Andy’s AEIC elaborated on what these reasons were. What Jason did instead was to exhibit a large number of invoices, payment vouchers and other documents in Vols 1 to 4 of his AEIC, but beyond stating that “each withdrawal is justified” and that he had “sought to obtain documents supporting each withdrawal”, he did not explain the documents exhibited. It was left to counsel for Ding Auto and Ding to attempt to draw out – through cross-examination – Jason’s explanations as to these various documents. In the course of the trial, after Jason’s explanations for these various documents emerged, Ding and his counsel informed that they accepted the validity of some of the payments which had been included in the table at pp 208 to 214 of the statement of claim. Towards the end of the trial, this table was amended via the deletion of a number of claim items, which reduced the total value of the impugned transactions to $350,372.80. For ease of reference, a copy of the amended table is appended as Annex A to these written grounds.
- [56]
[56] In respect of Mega Auto’s counter-claim for certain items of equipment which had allegedly been wrongfully retained and/or converted by Ding Auto, Ding denied that the said items had been installed on Ding Auto’s premises. It will be seen from Jason’s AEIC that the most expensive of these items was a “Bench Rack 500 System Filter”. This was said by Jason to have been purchased at a price of $10,000 from ST Kinetics; and he exhibited an invoice from ST Kinetics dated 23 August 2013 and addressed to Mega Auto at its 355 East Coast Road office. Jason alleged that of the two units of “Bench Rack 500 System Filter” listed in the said invoice, one unit had been left at Ding Auto’s workshop at #01-20. Ding gave evidence, however, that the “Bench Rack 500 System Filter” found on Ding Auto’s premises was an item which Ding Auto had purchased from ST Kinetics – along with some other equipment – at a price of $4,280. In his AEIC, he had stated that these various items of equipment had been purchased in April 2015. In cross-examination, he clarified that he recalled that the “Bench Rack 500 System Filter” and other equipment had been purchased from ST Kinetics in 2013, a few months after the incorporation of Ding Auto; and that ST Kinetics had only collected the payment sometime later. The payment for these various pieces of equipment was made via a cheque drawn on Ding Auto’s SCB account. Ding added that ST Kinetics had sold him the “Bench Rack 500 System Filter” and other equipment at a steep discount because they had no more use for the equipment after closing down their STAR business; that in the end they had charged him a price far less than what the equipment was worth; and that they had provided an invoice sometime later when he asked for one.
- [57]
[57] As to Mega Auto’s counter-claim for outstanding payments allegedly due for “work done and/or services rendered…, rental, salaries paid for and on behalf of [Ding Auto]”, this was also disputed by Ding Auto, save for the following matters. Ding acknowledged that Ding Auto should reimburse Mega Auto for payment of charges relating to his (Ding’s) mobile phone, as well as the mobile phones of Anna and Ching for the periods that these two staff were employed by Ding Auto. He also agreed that Mega Auto should be reimbursed for payments it had made on Ding Auto’s behalf in relation to purchase of stationery supplies, broadband and fax charges, and photocopier leasing charges.
- [58]
[58] I will next summarise the Defendant’s version of events.
The defendants’ version of events
- [59]
[59] The defendants’ main witness was Jason. Although the ACRA business profile showed him to be the owner of 97.14% of the shares in Mega Auto (with Rohaiyu holding the remaining 2.86%), Jason said that he had a “verbal partnership agreement” with Andy and three other individuals – Hisham, Wong and Ling – whereby he was to own 50% of Mega Auto while the other four men owned the remaining 50% in equal proportions. It was not disputed that the other four men were all employees of Mega Auto, and that they did not pay Jason any money for their alleged 50% shareholding. According to Jason, he had provided all the financing for Mega Auto but had entered into the “verbal partnership agreement” with the four men because he wanted to “reward” them for working hard. It was “mutually agreed” amongst them that the shares of those who left Mega Auto would “pass back” to him. As Andy and Wong had left Mega Auto by the time of the trial, their shares had reverted to him, such that he now owned 75% of the shares in the company, while Hisham and Ling (who had remained with Mega Auto) continued to hold 12.5% each. As for Rohaiyu, she was said to be Hisham’s wife and to be holding her 2.86% shareholding on behalf of Hisham as part of his 12.5% shareholding due to his status as a bankrupt.
- [60]
[60] Jason claimed that when ST Kinetics closed its STAR business in December 2012, it was Ding who first approached him with a request to join Mega Auto. According to Jason, Ding had assured him that he had “contacts with motor insurers” and “would be able to convince them to place Mega Auto on the motor insurers panel” of authorised workshops. Jason was interested in this “new business opportunity” and held several discussions with Ding. According to Jason, it was Ding who subsequently proposed that “a new company be incorporated and that no one with any connection with Mega Auto should be involved”:
- [61]
[61] Jason claimed that over “various meetings” held between April to May 2013, he (representing Mega Auto) and Ding came to a verbal agreement whereby Ding was to be “appointed as Mega Auto’s nominee director” in the new company (which was eventually incorporated as Ding Auto). According to Jason, Ding also promised to hold the shares in the new company “as a trustee for and on behalf of Mega Auto”. In return, Ding was to be employed by Mega Auto, who would pay him a monthly salary of $4,000 and CPF contributions “until such time as when Ding Auto was financially able to pay Ding’s salary”. He was also to be entitled to “a 15% share of the net profits of Ding Auto over and above his salary”. However, he was required to “relinquish his share in Ding Auto to Mega Auto or anyone as may be directed by Mega Auto, and also to resign his appointment as Director”, as and when required by Mega Auto. This was why Ding was asked to pre-sign an undated letter of resignation as director and a share transfer form which had the transferee and the amount of consideration for the transfer left blank.
- [62]
[62] Jason also claimed that it was verbally agreed with Ding that Ding Auto would “be treated as a wholly owned subsidiary of Mega Auto and its assets and businesses would be the property of Mega Auto”, with the latter “[assisting] in the financial obligations and management of Ding Auto”. Mega Auto would manage, inter alia, Ding Auto’s bank accounts. Ding, Andy, Wong and Jason himself were all signatories to Ding Auto’s bank accounts, with any one signatory being able to operate the accounts. Ding Auto was supposed to pay Mega Auto a monthly management fee of $5,000 (although Jason also claimed that Mega Auto never billed for its management fees because “Ding Auto was not able to make ends meet”).
- [63]
[63] In cross-examination, Jason admitted that he did not have any text messages or other documentation recording the verbal agreement outlined above. Jason’s evidence was that the parties had engaged in “verbal discussions” because Ding did not read English and he himself did not write Chinese. Mega Auto had tried to reduce the verbal agreement with Ding into writing by getting a lawyer (one Ismail bin Atan, (“Ismail”)) to draft the JVA. Jason claimed that he had handed Ding a copy of this draft agreement sometime in 2013, and that Ding had said he needed “to go back and check with the lawyers” but had kept on “delaying” such that the agreement was never signed.
- [65]
[65] In addition to this initial loan, Jason alleged that Mega Auto helped to get Ding Auto’s business started in the following ways. Firstly, insofar as Ding Auto’s workshop premises were concerned, both sides were agreed that Ding Auto had operated from the unit at #01-20 after it was incorporated and that the HDB lease for this unit was assigned to Ding Auto on 28 September 2015. It will also be recalled that Ding had in his testimony asserted that Jason was the one who had suggested that Ding Auto could use these premises in return for its paying the rent payable to HDB; and that Ding had accepted that Ding Auto should pay Mega Auto rent for the period it occupied the unit prior to taking over the lease. Where the two sides differed was in respect of the unit #01-22 which housed Mega Auto’s spray-painting booth: the defendants’ position was that Ding Auto had also occupied this unit and operated the spray-painting booth since its incorporation until the breakdown of the relationship between Ding and Jason. Jason’s AEIC gave no details of this alleged occupation of #01-22 by Ding Auto, although in cross-examination, he continued to maintain the same position while conceding that unlike #01-20, the lease for #01-22 had never been assigned to Ding Auto. He stated that this was “[j]ust precaution”.
- [66]
[66] It was not disputed that unit #01-22 housed the only spray-painting facility which Mega Auto possessed (leaving aside its workshop at Corporation Road which in any event could only be used for CityCab taxis ). Following from the allegation that Ding Auto had occupied and operated the spray-painting booth at #01-22, Jason also alleged that after its incorporation in May 2013, Ding Auto received from Mega Auto the “first priority” referral of all of the latter’s spray-painting jobs. It was only if Ding Auto was unable to carry out spray-painting jobs that such jobs would be referred to others.
- [68]
[68] Insofar as manpower was concerned, Jason disputed Ding’s evidence that Ding Auto had largely relied on freelance sub-contractors in the early stages of its operations. Jason alleged that the Mega Auto employees who had previously been stationed at unit #01-20 were all “seconded” to Ding Auto once it was set up, to do all its work. It was Jason’s evidence that the Mega Auto employees so “seconded” included Ding himself; and that it was only from April 2014 that some Mega Auto employees – including Ding and (later) two Malaysian employees – were “formally transferred to become employees of Ding Auto”.
- [69]
[69] As noted earlier, the defendants’ case was that it had been verbally agreed between Jason and Ding that Mega Auto would pay for Ding Auto’s expenses and outgoings before reimbursing itself from Ding Auto’s funds. According to Jason, the employees “seconded” to Ding Auto continued to be paid during the period of secondment by Mega Auto, who would in turn invoice Ding Auto for reimbursement of the employees’ salaries, CPF and workers’ levy. Reimbursement was done whenever Ding Auto had enough cash to do so; and it was “fully up to” Jason to decide “how or when the reimbursements were made”.
- [71]
[71] According to Jason, Ding Auto’s staff salaries were paid in cash because Ding Auto suffered from cash flow problems. Andy was the one who would notify Mega Auto’s accounts staff Yvonne to issue cash cheques for the payment of Ding Auto’s staff salaries after computing the amounts payable. Andy’s evidence was that the cash cheques would be drawn on Ding Auto’s SCB account; and that if Ding Auto had insufficient funds, Mega Auto would pay first before getting reimbursed by Ding Auto. Andy also asserted that it was Jason who would decide when these cash cheques for salary payments would be “available” and also when Mega Auto would be reimbursed any salaries it had paid on Ding Auto’s behalf. Andy himself would hand out the cash payments – in Ding’s presence – to the workers at Ding Auto.
- [72]
[72] Jason admitted that as one of the signatories who could issue cheques drawn on Ding Auto’s accounts, he owed a responsibility to Ding Auto to give an account of the cheques issued and the monies paid out from the accounts. However, he denied that he was either the manager or an agent of Ding Auto. Instead he described himself as “the owner” of the company. Whilst conceding that he had identified himself as “manager” of Ding Auto in the bank account opening forms and in the tax returns submitted to IRAS on Ding Auto’s behalf, he insisted he had done so solely out of “convenience” and because he had “never come across job title called owner”. He also insisted that in relation to Ding Auto, he was really only “helping out at the backend office”.
- [73]
[73] Jason said that he showed Ding the annual financial reports for Ding Auto and explained them to him every year. Indeed, according to Jason, apart from the annual financial reports, he also showed Ding the profit and loss statements (“P&L statements”). Ding was not given copies of these P&L statements to take away, and none of these statements were adduced as evidence in the trial. Nevertheless, Jason insisted that he did discuss these statements with Ding when he showed them to him.
- [74]
[74] As to how the dispute between the parties came about, Jason had a different version of events. Jason claimed that he realised in early 2016 that “Mega Auto could no longer continue to support Ding Auto as it was consistently not profitable”; and that it was while various options were being considered that Ding made an offer in mid-2016 to buy Ding Auto from May Auto. According to Jason, he accepted this offer, and even agreed with Ding on the price of $220,000.
- [75]
[75] According to Jason, this proposed sale of Ding Auto to Ding did not come about because the latter changed his mind and proceeded to open a new company, Ding Automative Pte Ltd, on 13 July 2016 and also to close Ding Auto’s bank accounts on 27 July 2016 after withdrawing the monies in these accounts. At first, Jason thought of using the share transfer form that was pre-signed by Ding to effect a transfer of Ding’s shares in Ding Auto to Hisham. It was at this point, however, that he realised it would not be possible to do so, “as Ding Auto’s Memorandum and Articles of Association required any share transfer to be approved by the board of directors and Ding was the only director of Ding Auto”.
- [76]
[76] Jason claimed that despite feeling disappointed with Ding, he had been prepared to do nothing and simply to “write-off Ding and Ding Auto as a bad investment experience”. He did not expect that Ding would decide to take legal action against him and Mega Auto. He did not deny having removed Ding Auto’s accounting and financial records; and in cross-examination, he agreed that he had ignored the requests from Ding Auto’s counsel for these accounting and financial records. His explanation for having ignored these requests was that he had felt “very angry” and “cheated” by Ding at the time, and also because he “did not deign [sic] fit to respond being aware that at all material times, [Ding Auto] is and/or was financially weak”.
Summary of the defence, the counterclaim, and the claims made in the third party proceedings
- [77]
[77] The crux of the defence filed on behalf of all three defendants was the verbal agreement which Jason claimed he had entered into with Ding sometime in May 2013 – which the defendants referred to as “a Profit-Sharing Agreement between Ding and [Mega Auto]”. To recap: according to Jason’s version of events, this agreement made Ding Auto a “wholly owned subsidiary” of Mega Auto’s, with Ding holding the shares in Ding Auto on trust for Mega Auto and also being appointed as the latter’s “nominee director” in Ding Auto. According to Jason, it was pursuant to this agreement that Mega Auto paid for various operating expenses on Ding Auto’s behalf. The withdrawals made from Ding Auto’s bank accounts were therefore, in the main, reimbursements to Mega Auto; and any other withdrawals which were not reimbursements to Mega Auto were payments made for goods and services supplied to Ding Auto.
- [78]
[78] Unlike the statement of claim which was rather lengthy and dense, the defence was short on particulars which I would have thought relevant and necessary to elucidate the defendants’ case. The defence pleaded a general denial of Ding Auto’s claims of agency, trusteeship, breaches of fiduciary duties, and conspiracy to injure. The defendants also pleaded that “[a]ll withdrawals from [Ding Auto’s] Standard Chartered Account were for the proper and legitimate payments made on behalf of [Ding Auto]” and that “all transactions were legitimate and properly made in the course of the business of [Ding Auto] and are or were within the knowledge of Ding”. However, scarcely any particulars were provided in the defence of the actual reasons or purposes of the various withdrawals alleged by Ding to be unauthorised; and Jason’s AEIC also provided no real particulars beyond those already appearing in the defence. Much of the defendants’ explanation for the impugned withdrawals emerged in Jason’s testimony in cross-examination.
- [79]
[79] In respect of the impugned withdrawals from Ding Auto’s bank accounts, Jason acknowledged that he had personally signed some of the cheques in question, and that he had also approved the issuance of all the other cheques which were signed by Andy. As alluded to earlier, he and the other two defendants alleged that these withdrawals and payments were all properly made for legitimate reasons – but neither he nor Andy furnished any explanation in their AEICs as to what these reasons were. Jason’s explanations for the documents which he said supported the various payments (exhibited in Vols 1 to 4 of his AEIC ) emerged only in cross-examination.
- [80]
[80] I will briefly summarise below Jason’s evidence about the impugned withdrawals and payments, according to the four categories in which Ding Auto’s counsel grouped the alleged reasons for withdrawal or payment.
- [81]
[81] The first category was what Ding Auto’s counsel referred to as “labour charges”. In brief, this category covered payments made in purported reimbursement of staff salaries paid by Mega Auto, both in respect of Mega Auto employees allegedly “seconded” to Ding Auto from July 2013 to April 2014 and Ding Auto employees from April 2014 to June 2016. A table listing the amounts of staff salary payments which Mega Auto claimed to have made – and for which it claimed to have reimbursed itself from Ding Auto’s accounts – is found at p 2212 of Jason’s AEIC. The claim item number in the table at [13] of the statement of claim which each alleged reimbursement corresponds to is stated in the last row of this table. In perusing this table, it should be noted that the payments said to constitute reimbursements of staff salary payments were typically made to Mega Auto several months after the alleged salary payments. It should also be noted that these reimbursements to Mega Auto of staff salary payments were not always done on a monthly basis. There were at least two instances when a sum of money paid out of Ding Auto’s bank account was alleged by the defendants to have been a lump-sum reimbursement of several months’ worth of staff salary payments: namely, the cheque payment to Mega Auto of $76,152.24 issued by Andy on 6 December 2013 (which was alleged to be in reimbursement of staff salaries paid by Mega Auto for the months of July and August 2013), and the cheque payment to Mega Auto of $91,598.71 issued by Andy on 15 August 2014 (alleged to be in reimbursement of staff salaries paid by Mega Auto for the months of October to December 2013).
- [82]
[82] In respect of the category of “labour charges”, the documents which Jason produced in respect of each purported reimbursement would typically consist of a remittance advice on Ding Auto’s letterhead, an invoice issued by Mega Auto to Ding Auto, and an unsigned document listing the names of the staff for whom Mega Auto claimed reimbursement of salary payments and the amount of salary claimed per staff.
- [83]
[83] The second of the four categories of disputed payments related to petty cash vouchers presented by Wong for reimbursement. Wong was one of the Mega Auto employees who – according to the defendants – was “seconded” to Ding Auto from July 2013 until the beginning of 2014. The petty cash vouchers in question related to the following claim item numbers in the table at para 30 of the statement of claim: 3, 4, 6, 7, 10 and 23. For these petty cash vouchers, again there was no explanation provided in Jason’s AEIC – or for that matter, in Andy’s and Wong’s AEIC – as to the items making up the total amounts claimed in reimbursement. What Jason typically did for each of the payments alleged to be reimbursement of petty cash claims was to exhibit a Ding Auto petty cash payment voucher, another document on Ding Auto letterhead said to be a “petty cash record form”, and a number of receipts and invoices from different sources. Typically, these petty cash claims would include what appeared to ad hoc purchases of small items such as cushion seats and an antenna. Apart from ad hoc small purchases, two items which appeared in Wong’s petty cash claims were an item of $300 for “petrol” and an item of $70 for “cash card” .
- [84]
[84] The third of the four categories related to purchases of spray-paint in the period prior to April 2014 (Ding Auto being prepared to accept payments made for spray-paint after April 2014 ). This concerned the following claim item numbers in the table at para 30 of the statement of claim: 13, 20 and 22. In cross-examination, Jason alluded again to the defendants’ allegations about Ding Auto having taken over the spray-painting booth at #01-22 after its incorporation. His position was that these spray-paint purchases were charged to Ding Auto because:
- [85]
[85] The last of the four categories of disputed withdrawals or payments related to reimbursements made to Mega Auto, purportedly of rental for both units at #01-20 and #01-22 as well as miscellaneous items such as the utilities for both units, renovations, stationery supplies, broadband and fax charges, and various phone charges. I have set out earlier Ding’s position in relation to rental charges and utilities. In respect of the renovations for which Mega Auto was reimbursed, these were allegedly carried out at #01-20 in May 2013. Ding’s position was that Ding Auto should not have had to pay for these renovations because it was already being charged rental by Mega Auto for #01-20 from the point it moved into the unit to the point it took over the lease; and any renovations carried out at the unit prior to its moving in were “necessitated by the fact that [Mega Auto] had to prepare the premises for a tenant to move in”. Jason disagreed as he maintained that:
- [86]
[86] It should be added that Ding Auto’s counsel had originally mentioned a fifth category which did not concern any specific reasons given by the defendants for payment but instead concerned payments for which it was said no supporting documents had been produced. This category was said to concern claim item numbers 37 and 62 in the table at para 30 of the statement of claim. Item 37 related to a petty cash item for $500. This item was accepted as a valid payment by Ding after the explanations given by Jason in cross-examination. As for item 62, this related to a cheque payment for $23,513.91 issued by Jason to Mega Auto on 12 September 2014. In cross-examination, Jason said that claim item 62 at page 209 of the statement of claim was the same item as claim item 74, and that he had exhibited the supporting documents for claim item 74 at pages 745 to 767 of his AEIC. In brief, this payment of $23,513.91 to Mega Auto was said to be reimbursement of a number of items such as staff salaries and utilities.
- [87]
[87] Mega Auto’s counter-claim for monies allegedly due from Ding Auto concerned similar items relating to reimbursement of rental for both #01-20 and #01-22, utilities, and miscellaneous items such as stationery supplies and phone charges. In his AEIC, Jason clarified that the first two items originally included in this counter-claim were to be removed. The total amount of this counter-claim would accordingly be reduced to $166,463.08.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.