High Court · Decided 29 November 2019
Neo Aik Soo v Neo Geek Kuan and another
Feedback & support[2019] SGHC 278 · Case no. Suit No 850 of 2017
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The Plaintiff and the two Defendants in this case are siblings. The 2nd Defendant (Neo Aik Siong) and the Plaintiff (Neo Aik Soo) are, respectively, the eldest and second eldest of the twelve siblings in their family. Both are septuagenarians. The 1st Defendant (Neo Geek Kuan) is the fourth eldest sibling in the family. The dispute in this case centred on the beneficial ownership of a shophouse at 34 / 34A / 34B Keong Saik Road (“the Property”). It was not disputed that the Property had been registered in the 1st Defendant’s name since its purchase in June 1991. It was also common ground that the 1st Defendant was only the legal owner and that she did not have beneficial ownership of the Property. The Plaintiff’s case was that he was the beneficial owner of the Property and that the 1st Defendant held it on trust for him, whereas the Defendants alleged that it was the 2nd Defendant who was the beneficial owner of the Property and that the 1st Defendant held it on trust for him.
- [2]
[2] At the end of the trial, I found in favour of the Plaintiff. As the Defendants have appealed, I set out below the reasons for my decision. I start by summarising the key aspects of the Plaintiff’s and the Defendants’ cases and the evidence adduced in support of each side’s case.
The Plaintiff’s case
- [3]
[3] The Plaintiff’s case was that he was the beneficial owner of the Property as he had paid for the full purchase price with his own funds. He had asked the 1st Defendant to hold it in her name, on trust for him, because at the point of purchasing the Property, he was working as a broker engaged in “high value trades for high net worth individuals” and had concerns about shielding his assets from creditors in the event any of these trades “went badly” and exposed him to personal liability. The Plaintiff has enjoyed considerable financial success over the years; and the purchase of the Property was one of a number of property investments he has made.
The Plaintiff’s personal background
- [4]
[4] The Plaintiff’s financial success was derived largely from the “very high fees” he had generated as a broker servicing high net-worth individuals and companies “over many years” since the 1960s, as well as substantial lottery winnings ($400,000) in 1973 and his own investments. In 1972, the Plaintiff decided to start investing in real estate as a means of “beat[ing] inflation and… multiply[ing] [his] yield”. He started with the purchase of a property at 64 Medway Drive, Singapore in 1972. This became his matrimonial home after he and his wife (“Lai Wah”) moved out of the home at 446 Upper Paya Lebar Road which he had previously shared with his parents and siblings.
- [5]
[5] As his parents were unhappy with his moving out of the family home, the Plaintiff made a promise to them that he would continue to take care of his siblings even after moving out. According to the Plaintiff’s younger brother Neo Aik Kheng (“Aik Kheng”), although the 2nd Defendant was the eldest sibling, it was the Plaintiff who had always been regarded as the head of the family since the death of their father in 1974. Inter alia, it was the Plaintiff who provided his siblings with money whenever they needed it. This included, for example, paying for renovations to Aik Keng’s flat and financing his (Aik Kheng’s) daughter’s university education overseas.
- [6]
[6] In 1980, the Plaintiff purchased another property at 20 Lorong K, Telok Kurau, Singapore (“20 Lorong K”). He purchased this property for the use of his mother and siblings, as the family home at 446 Upper Paya Lebar Road had been compulsorily acquired by the Government by then. The Plaintiff paid for the purchase price of $320,000 with his own monies. The conveyance of the property was effected on 29 March 1980; and it was registered jointly in his and Aik Kheng’s name. The Plaintiff stated that he had included Aik Kheng’s name so as to help him in his business by ensuring that he had a property in his name to “prove [his] credit”. Aik Kheng too confirmed that he himself did not contribute any funds and that the purchase was made entirely with the Plaintiff’s monies. The Plaintiff subsequently sold 20 Lorong K in December 1983 for $2,120,470.
- [7]
[7] It was also in 1983 that the Plaintiff acquired a “’clean shelf’ company” which he renamed Medway Investments Pte Ltd (“Medway Investments”). This was done with a view to using the company as a vehicle for acquiring and holding properties for his own benefit and that of his wife and children. His wife Lai Wah was the majority shareholder of Medway Investments, with 55% of the shares, while he himself held 20% of the shares. He also gave 20% of the shares to Aik Kheng and 5% to the 2nd Defendant as a token of his thanks to them for “the various things that both of them had done for [him] in the past”. Although the 2nd Defendant was formally appointed as Chairman and as a director alongside their youngest brother Neo Chin Chai (“Chin Chai”) and Lai Wah, all investment decisions in Medway Investments were made by the Plaintiff and Lai Wah: at most, the 2nd Defendant might make recommendations to them on potential investments.
- [8]
[8] Over the years, the Plaintiff continued to trade in shares and to invest in properties. He sold some of the properties purchased within a relatively short time-span; some were redeveloped before being sold; and he also retained some as residences for family members and for himself.
The Plaintiff’s relationship with the 2nd Defendant
- [9]
[9] In the course of his investment activities, the Plaintiff got the 2nd Defendant to assist him with various administrative matters such as liaising with tenants, sellers and/or buyers of properties; managing repairs and renovation works at these properties; and collecting rent from tenants. The Plaintiff paid the 2nd Defendant pocket money for helping with these tasks. He also let the 2nd Defendant act as his agent in various property transactions so that the latter would be able to earn commissions.
- [10]
[10] The Plaintiff explained that he got the 2nd Defendant to assist with such tasks as he felt he could trust the 2nd Defendant, who was his older brother, and who was also able to communicate easily with tenants and property owners because of his proficiency in Hokkien and Teochew. In addition, he wanted a way of helping the 2nd Defendant who had not been successful in the businesses he had tried his hand at and who frequently racked up debts.
- [11]
[11] Typically, according to the Plaintiff, the 2nd Defendant would render “statements of account” to him showing the amounts of cash he had taken or drawn from the bank; the amounts expended on various expenses related to his errands for the Plaintiff (for example, stamp fees and postage); and the deductions he had made for personal expenses such as food and transport. The two of them met up almost daily to go through this “accounting” process and to discuss other issues.
The purchase of the Property
- [12]
[12] Sometime in 1991, the 2nd Defendant informed the Plaintiff of the shophouse located at 34 / 34A / 34B Keong Saik Road and suggested that he consider buying the Property. Although the Property was in a dingy area known as a red-light district, it was close to the central business district and had potential to grow in value. The Plaintiff decided to purchase the Property and to hold it for some time.
- [13]
[13] The Plaintiff left it to the 2nd Defendant to negotiate with the vendors of the Property. The purchase price for the Property was agreed at $370,000. At this point, the Plaintiff had “more than enough funds” to purchase the Property as he was then enjoying “a fair amount of liquidity”. He paid the purchase price of $370,000 from his own funds as follows:
(a) First, he paid the initial 10% deposit of $37,000 on 25 March 1991 with funds from an OCBC account (account number 503-031-494-001). This was an account in the joint names of the Plaintiff, Aik Kheng and the 1st Defendant, which parties referred to as “OCBC Account 1” in the course of the trial. Although it was held jointly in the three names, the Plaintiff’s evidence was that the monies in the account came from him; and Aik Kheng confirmed that this was so.
- [14]
[14] It should be noted that while the 2nd Defendant conceded that the funds for the purchase price of $370,000 had come from OCBC Account 1 (the bank account held in the joint names of the Plaintiff, the 1st Defendant and Aik Kheng), he denied that the funds in OCBC Account 1 came from the Plaintiff. Instead, the 2nd Defendant advanced at trial a narrative which depicted their entire family – the Neo family – as having been engaged in making substantial investments in properties and other assets; and he claimed that the monies in OCBC Account 1 came from monies made by the Neo family in one of these property transactions. I will elaborate on the 2nd Defendant’s narrative when I deal with the Defendants’ evidence in the next section of these written grounds.
- [15]
[15] Although the Plaintiff was paying for the purchase of the Property and intended to hold it as his own investment, he decided to put the Property in the 1st Defendant’s name and to ask her to hold it on his behalf. He decided on this course of action because he was concerned that should any of the high-value trades he was carrying out as a broker go badly and expose him to personal liability, he should be able to “shield” some of his assets from creditors. Being able to “shield” some of his assets from creditors was important because at that point in time, he was financially responsible for supporting not just his wife and children but also his mother and siblings. He asked the 1st Defendant to hold the Property on trust for him because he trusted her, was close to her, and believed that her unmarried status would preclude the possibility of a spouse or children trying to lay claim to the Property.
- [16]
[16] Once the sale was agreed, the Plaintiff left it to the 2nd Defendant to arrange for all the documentation. The Plaintiff trusted the 2nd Defendant and did not check up on what he was doing. He did not even ask to see the sale and purchase agreement (“SPA”). It was only in the course of these proceedings that he discovered that the 2nd Defendant had named himself as the purchaser of the Property in the Sale and Purchase agreement (“SPA”). In cross-examination, the Plaintiff agreed that the SPA was an important conveyancing document, but asserted that to him, the name in which a property was registered would be more important than the SPA. Since he had arranged for the Property to be registered in the 1st Defendant’s name, and since he was also collecting rent from the Property, he had not found it necessary to ask for a copy of the SPA in the 27 years following the purchase.
OCBC Account 2
- [19]
[19] In giving evidence of having paid for the renovations to the Property, the Plaintiff stated that the funds for these renovations came from a bank account referred to as “OCBC Account 2”, and that it was he who had given the 2nd Defendant approval to draw the funds from this account for this purpose. According to the Plaintiff, the background to the setting-up of OCBC Account 2 and his use of the funds in it was as follows.
- [20]
[20] Sometime in September or October 1993, the Plaintiff discovered that the 2nd Defendant had obtained overdraft facilities from OCBC by using the Property as security and getting the 1st Defendant to sign the necessary papers. This was OCBC account number 503-052730-001, which parties referred to during the trial as OCBC Account 2. The overdraft limit was $530,000. The 2nd Defendant had obtained the overdraft facilities in March 1993 and had been making use of them without the Plaintiff’s knowledge and consent. Indeed, as at 31 August 1993, the overdraft limit had nearly been reached, with the account showing a negative balance of -$$528,013-35.
- [21]
[21] The Plaintiff testified that when he found out the Property had been used to secure these overdraft facilities, he confronted the 1st Defendant and warned her not to do it again without his consent. He was not that angry with her, though, because she was his younger sister after all. The Plaintiff also confronted the 2nd Defendant who apologised, claiming that he had needed the money to buy art pieces and to invest in properties in China. Although the Plaintiff was upset, he also forgave the 2nd Defendant. In any event, the Plaintiff himself realised it would be useful having these overdraft facilities available. By way of “a compromise”, therefore, he asked the 2nd Defendant to “give” the overdraft account to him. The 2nd Defendant agreed; and from that point on (September or October 1993), OCBC Account 2 was treated as the Plaintiff’s.
- [22]
[22] The Plaintiff explained that he did not bother to get the overdraft facility transferred to his name because it would have taken time to re-apply for the bank’s approval, and he would also have had to incur lawyers’ fees. As far as he was concerned, as OCBC Account 2 belonged to him from sometime in late 1993 onwards, the 2nd Defendant would typically hand over to him the bank statements for this account, as well as the cheque-books containing pre-signed blank cheques and pre-signed blank “transfer forms”. Although the account remained in the 2nd Defendant’s name, all monies deposited into and withdrawn from this account were treated as the Plaintiff’s. According to the Plaintiff, this could be seen from the fact – for example – that between October 1993 and January 1994, he was the one making all the major deposits into OCBC Account 2, amounting to a total sum of $3,231,243-22. By 11 January 1994, the overdraft balance had been reduced to -$25,631-42.
- [23]
[23] The Plaintiff’s assertion that he was given pre-signed blank cheques and blank “transfer forms” was not refuted by the 2nd Defendant. Indeed, in his evidence, the 2nd Defendant stated that the Plaintiff had been using OCBC Account 2 since sometime in 1993 and that he himself had pre-signed blank OCBC debit slips at the Plaintiff’s request, for use in transferring funds out of OCBC Account 2. It was also not disputed that the 2nd Defendant signed mandates which provided for the Plaintiff to operate the account directly. However, the 2nd Defendant insisted that OCBC Account 2 was his “personal bank account” and remained as such throughout. As stated earlier, it was the 2nd Defendant’s position that the monies in OCBC Account 1 were “Neo family monies” and not the Plaintiff’s monies. According to the 2nd Defendant, he had taken a loan from these “Neo family monies” to pay for the purchase of the Property. According to the 2nd Defendant, he had repaid this loan on 12 January 1994 by transferring a sum of $400,000 from OCBC Account 2 (which he claimed was his “personal” account) to OCBC Account 1.
- [24]
[24] It will be seen that the 2nd Defendant’s narrative was diametrically opposed to the Plaintiff’s evidence. Firstly, the Plaintiff rejected entirely the existence of any “Neo family monies” or “Neo family assets”; he was adamant that he had paid for the purchase of the Property with his own funds from OCBC Account 1. The transfer of $400,000 from OCBC Account 2 to OCBC Account 1 on 12 January was a transfer which he had effected and which did not represent any repayment of loan by the 2nd Defendant. He could not recall exactly what he had used the $400,000 for but was sure that it had been “100 per cent… for own use, nothing to do with [the 2nd Defendant]”. As he put it in his AEIC:
- [25]
[25] Secondly as noted earlier, the Plaintiff’s evidence was that he had authorised the 2nd Defendant to use the funds in OCBC Account 2 to pay for the renovations to the Property. The 2nd Defendant, on the other hand, claimed that the overdraft facilities in OCBC Account 2 were obtained by him to pay for these renovations.
- [26]
[26] Thirdly, as noted earlier, the rental for the Property was collected by the Plaintiff and the 2nd Defendant. It was not disputed that most – if not all - of the rental collected from the tenant was deposited into OCBC Account 2. Naturally, the Plaintiff asserted that this was because OCBC Account 2 was really his account, whereas the 2nd Defendant claimed that it was because OCBC Account 2 was his.
- [27]
[27] Finally, while the Plaintiff and the 2nd Defendant were agreed that property tax on the Property had been paid via GIRO from OCBC Account 2 at least since 1996 (after the Property was tenanted out), they disagreed on whether these GIRO payments represented payments by the Plaintiff or by the 2nd Defendant. Each claimed that the OCBC Account 2 was his and that he was the one who had paid for property tax.
The extension of the lease in 2015
- [28]
[28] Sometime in 2015, the Plaintiff began thinking of selling the Property. He told both the 1st and the 2nd Defendants about his intention to sell. Pursuant to that intention, he began negotiations in 2015 with the then tenant (one Ong Geok Hoo, “Ong”) for a short 8-month extension to the lease and prepared two versions of a draft lease agreements. When he presented the second draft to Ong, however, he was shocked to discover that around July / August 2015, the 2nd Defendant had already gone behind his back to arrange for the 1st Defendant to extend Ong’s lease for another two years from 1 August 2015 to 31 July 2017, and at a rental amount of $10,000 per month.
- [29]
[29] The Plaintiff confronted the 1st Defendant about this lease extension. She claimed that she had simply signed whatever the 2nd Defendant put before her. The Plaintiff confronted the 2nd Defendant – who insisted it was a favourable deal, despite the Plaintiff’s view that the rent was too low. As their conversation went nowhere, the Plaintiff decided to drop the matter. However, as he did not want to risk the 2nd Defendant giving Ong further, unauthorised extensions of the lease, he decided to revoke the 2nd Defendant’s authority to act in matters concerning the Property. To that end, on 2 August 2016, the Plaintiff wrote a letter for the 1st Defendant to sign and to send to Ong. In gist, this letter told Ong that “with immediate effect”, the 2nd Defendant would cease to be the 1st Defendant’s legal representative and would have no authority to act on her behalf in respect of the Property: instead, the Plaintiff would be the 1st Defendant’s “only authorised legal representative”, with “full power of attorney” to act on her behalf in all matters relating to the Property. The letter also informed Ong that all future rentals were to be paid to or collected by the Plaintiff.
The meeting of 10 December 2016
- [30]
[30] In light of the 2nd Defendant’s conduct in granting Ong an unauthorised two-year extension of his lease, the Plaintiff decided around end-2016 to take steps to ensure he would be able to sell the Property with vacant possession once Ong’s lease expired. He consulted a lawyer – one Mr Lim Hin Chye of M/s Lim Hin Chye & Co (“Mr Lim”); and having explained that he was the beneficial owner of the Property whereas the 1st Defendant was its legal owner, he sought Mr Lim’s assistance in preparing “whatever documents…necessary to facilitate [his] marketing and sale of the Property”. An appointment was made for 10 December 2016 (a Saturday) at Mr Lim’s office.
- [32]
[32] Mr Lim explained both documents to the 1st Defendant, who confirmed that she understood what they were about. The 1st Defendant actively participated in the discussions with Mr Lim. Indeed, according to Aik Kheng who was also present at the discussions:
- [33]
[33] The Plaintiff did in fact issue the 1st Defendant a cheque for $30,000 at the meeting in Mr Lim’s office; and the payment of this sum in reimbursement of the 1st Defendant’s payment of income tax on rental income on the Property was duly recorded in clause 6 of the Statutory Declaration signed by the 1st Defendant. It was also recorded in clause 5 of the Power of Attorney that the Plaintiff “shall make a cheque of $100,000 in [the 1st Defendant’s] sole name from the net sale proceeds as consideration for [her] taking care of the said Property since the date of transfer of the said Property to [her]”.
- [35]
[35] This was not, however, the end of the matter, as the 1st Defendant then queried the Plaintiff about “what would happen if [he] mismanaged the sale of the Property and somehow exposed her to any kind of liability”. The Plaintiff replied that he “would indemnify her for any claims or losses”. This led to Mr Lim being asked to prepare a Deed of Indemnity.
- [36]
[36] Upon both the 1st Defendant and the Plaintiff confirming that they were satisfied with this draft Deed, Mr Lim brought then to the nearby office of one Mr Raymond Ng (“Mr Ng”), who was a Commissioner for Oaths. Mr Ng read and explained each document to the 1st Defendant, who confirmed that she understood them and also understood the nature of a statutory declaration. Both she and the Plaintiff then proceeded to sign the various documents, with Mr Lim and Mr Ng also signing as witnesses for them on the Deed of Indemnity.
Events post 10 December 2016
- [37]
[37] Some two to three days after the Plaintiff and the 1st Defendant had signed the documents, the 2nd Defendant visited Mr Lim’s office with “a bundle of documents” and “claimed that he was the owner of the Property”. Mr Lim did not know the 2nd Defendant at that time. As the 2nd Defendant was not his client and as he had been told on 10 December 2016 that the Plaintiff was the beneficial owner of the Property, he declined to entertain the 2nd Defendant. The 2nd Defendant subsequently sent Mr Lim a letter on 13 December 2016, titled “LETTER OF PEOTEST” (sic) in which he put forward what Mr Lim described as “wild allegations” – in particular, that the “wicked” Plaintiff had “threaten violently wanted to hit [the 1st Defendant] and broken her two legs”, that the Plaintiff had also threatened to break his (the 2nd Defendant’s) legs and “wanted to set fire on [his] HDB flat”, that the 1st Defendant had signed the documents in the lawyers’ office “under heavy pressure”, and that he (the 2nd Defendant) was “the actual owner of the said Property”. Mr Lim did not respond to the letter but instead forwarded a copy to the Plaintiff.
- [38]
[38] On 16 December 2016, the 1st Defendant went alone to Mr Lim’s office to collect the original Power of Attorney. Mr Lim did not attend to her on that day but he heard later the 1st Defendant had remarked to his secretary that “her brother had threatened to break her legs”. However, when the secretary asked if she had made a police report, the 1st Defendant did not reply. The Plaintiff was unaware of this incident. As far as he was concerned, the 1st Defendant had been cheery and happy throughout the meeting at the lawyers’ offices. She did not raise any complaints about the documents signed. After collecting the documents from Mr Lim’s office, she had handed them to the Plaintiff and collected reimbursement from him of the fees paid for these documents, without mentioning any disagreement with their contents.
- [39]
[39] On 23 December 2016, the 2nd Defendant lodged a caveat over the Property. This was done without the knowledge of the Plaintiff, who had been marketing the Property as per his stated intention to sell it. The Plaintiff only found out about the caveat months later when a buyer he had found for the Property in February 2017 brought the caveat to his attention before pulling out of the deal. When the Plaintiff confronted the 2nd Defendant and asked him to remove the caveat, however, the latter did so – and even went back to helping the Plaintiff with marketing the Property for sale. The Plaintiff thus believed the issue to be closed. He knew that both Defendants were aware not only of the newspaper advertisements he had taken out regarding the sale of the Property, but also of the fact that he had listed his mobile number as the phone number of the owner of the Property. He had even placed a large signboard on the shopfront of the Property listing his contact details as the owner of the Property. Neither Defendant had raised any objections.
- [40]
[40] In May 2017, the Plaintiff found a buyer for the Property – He Yi Investments Pte Ltd (“He Yi”) – to whom he granted an option to purchase on 13 May 2017. This option was exercised by He Yi on 25 May 2017. It came as a shock to the Plaintiff when – in June 2017 – the two Defendants suddenly made a claim to the Property, and when the 1st Defendant purported to disavow the Statutory Declaration and the Power of Attorney on the ground of “duress”.
- [41]
[41] It is not disputed that following the exercise by He Yi of the option, completion of the sale of the Property at the price of $8,128,000 has since taken place; and a net amount of $8,029,142-57 has been paid into court pending the resolution of the present dispute.
The Defendants’ case
- [42]
[42] The Defendants, for their part, denied that it was the Plaintiff who had purchased the Property using his own funds. Their case, as noted earlier, was that the 2nd Defendant had paid for the Property using a loan taken from “Neo family monies” maintained in OCBC Account 1. The 2nd Defendant was said to have repaid this loan on 12 January 1994 by means by a sum of $400,000 transferred from OCBC Account 2 (which he claimed as his “personal” account) to OCBC Account 1.
The “Neo Family Assets”
- [43]
[43] To explain how there could have been “Neo family monies” sufficient to fund the “loan” to the 2nd Defendant, the Defendants put forward in their AEICs a narrative which depicted their entire family (the Neo family) as having been heavily - and profitably - involved in investing in properties and other assets for many years. In their AEICs, the Defendants alluded to these investments as “the Neo Family Assets”.
- [44]
[44] In gist, according to the Defendants, the “growth” of “the Neo Family’s Assets” began when sometime in the 1970s, their parents allegedly “struck the 4-D lottery and obtained winnings of about S$200,000”. Subsequently, in the late 1970s or early 1980s, the property in which their entire family lived (446 Upper Paya Lebar) was compulsorily acquired by the then Telecommunications Authority of Singapore (“TAS”): in return, the Neo family received compensation totalling $95,000 which was made up of an initial award $62,200, a supplemental award of $27,800 issued after their appeal, and the refund of their $5,000 deposit for the appeal.
- [45]
[45] Pursuant to the compulsory acquisition of 446 Upper Paya Lebar, the Neo family was also given permission by the Government to purchase two 5-room HDB flats. One such HDB flat (at Block 21 St George’s Road #20-172) was purchased for one of the younger Neo sisters, Poo Chu; and this was paid for by the parents and by Poo Chu’s CPF funds. The other such flat (at Block 23 Eunos Crescent #06-3019) was purchased in the 2nd Defendant’s name on 9 July 1979. The 2nd Defendant claimed that the purchase price was paid using “money from [his] own pocket, permitted CPF withdrawals from [his] CPF account and a housing loan from the HDB”. The 2nd Defendant continues to reside in this HDB flat up until today; and throughout these proceedings, he has claimed that his ownership of this HDB flat is the reason why the Keong Saik Property – and indeed, all the various properties allegedly forming part of “the Neo Family Assets” – were not registered in his name.
- [46]
[46] According to the Defendants’ narrative, in the years which followed the compulsory acquisition of 446 Upper Paya Lebar, the Neo family embarked on a series of property acquisitions and investments. According to the 2nd Defendant, leaving aside the two HDB flats purchased in the 2nd Defendant’s and Poo Chu’s names, the first property acquired by the Neo family after their departure from 446 Upper Paya Lebar was a property at 20 Lorong K, Telok Kurau (“20 Lorong K”). This was purchased for $320,000 in March 1980. The Defendants claimed that the Neo family paid this purchase price using funds from the following sources:
(a) The compensation of $95,000 received from TAS for the compulsory acquisition of 446 Upper Paya Lebar;
(b) The parents’ lottery winnings of $200,000 from the 1970s;
(c) A balance sum of $40,000 said to be made up of “(s)avings and investments in listed shares from the Neo Family”.
- [47]
[47] 20 Lorong K was actually registered in the Plaintiff’s and Aik Kheng’s names. However, the Defendants claimed that it was “understood at all material times that the said property belonged to the Neo Family and not any sibling”. It was not disputed that 20 Lorong K was used by the Plaintiff in 1980 and in 1983 as collateral for mortgage loans for his “personal use”. It was also not disputed that when 20 Lorong K was sold for a sum of $2,120,470 in December 1983, part of the sale proceeds - $1,000,000 - went towards paying off the mortgage loans taken out by the Plaintiff. In his AEIC, the 2nd Defendant claimed that “(s)trictly speaking”, he and the other Neo siblings “should not have allowed [the Plaintiff’s] Mortgages to be redeemed using funds from the said sale proceeds as these funds also belonged to the Neo Family… However, being family members, [they] did not quibble over such matters then”.
- [48]
[48] According to the Defendants, the sale of 20 Lorong K was followed by the Neo family’s acquisition of a substantial property on freehold land of 14,000 square feet, at No. 61 Lorong K, Telok Kurau (“61 Lorong K”). The 2nd Defendant alleged that the purchase price of $875,000 was funded by the sale proceeds from 20 Lorong K. Again, it was asserted that although this property was registered in the names of the Plaintiff and the youngest Neo brother Chin Chai, “it is common knowledge and understanding between all members of the Neo family that 61 Lorong K belonged to the Neo Family as it was purchased from funds belonging to the Neo Family”.
- [49]
[49] In giving his version of events, the 2nd Defendant portrayed himself as the Neo sibling responsible for strategizing and managing the alleged growth of the “Neo Family Assets”. It was the 2nd Defendant’s evidence that following the purchase of 61 Lorong K, he “consulted” with the other Neo family members; and it was agreed that they should “form a company to look after all the properties and investments belonging to the Neo Family”. This company – according to the Defendants – was Medway Investments. They denied that Medway Investments was the Plaintiff’s company and asserted instead that:
- [50]
[50] According to the 2nd Defendant, as Chairman of Medway Investments, he was “overall in charge of making sound investments on behalf of the Neo Family”. The properties allegedly acquired as “Neo Family Assets” by Medway Investments included No. 25 Lorong M, Telok Kurau (“25 Lorong M”), which was purchased in 1984 for $1,651,550. The purchase price was said by the 2nd Defendant to have been funded with the balance of the sale proceeds from 20 Lorong K as well as an overdraft of $1,000,000. The latter was secured by the lodgement of shares registered in the names of the Plaintiff and other Neo siblings (the 1st Defendant, Aik Kheng, Ah Hoe and Choon Poo).
- [51]
[51] 25 Lorong M was sold in April 1989 for $2,019,979. Other properties allegedly acquired by Medway Investment as “Neo Family Assets” included No. 35 and No. 41 Oxley Road, which the 2nd Defendant claimed were purchased in 1989 using the sale proceeds from 25 Lorong M as well as various overdraft facilities. No. 35 and No. 41 Oxley Road were later redeveloped into six detached dwelling houses and two semi-detached dwelling houses. All eight houses continue to be held under Medway Investments. It is not disputed that two of these houses are occupied by the Plaintiff and his family: the Plaintiff and his wife live in No. 39 Oxley Road while the Plaintiff’s son lives in No. 41A Oxley Road. Notwithstanding this, the Defendants insisted at trial that all eight houses continued to be “Neo Family Assets”.
The Plaintiff’s own purchase of properties
- [52]
[52] The 2nd Defendant sought to draw a distinction between property acquisitions made by Medway Investments which he claimed were “Neo Family Assets”, and acquisitions made in the Plaintiff’s name or that of another company, Medway Realty Pte Ltd (“Medway Realty”) which he claimed were personal acquisitions by the Plaintiff). Medway Realty was a company set up in 1989 in which Aik Kheng and the Plaintiff’s wife Lai Wah were the shareholders and directors. The 2nd Defendant asserted that Medway Realty was different from Medway Investments because it was a vehicle “set up to allow [the Plaintiff] to hold his personal investments”.
- [53]
[53] Property acquisitions which the 2nd Defendant acknowledged as falling into the category of the Plaintiff’s personal investments included 5F Tanglin Hill, which was bought in the Plaintiff’s name. The 2nd Defendant insisted, though, that it was Medway Investments which had bought and subsequently sold the neighbouring property at 5E Tanglin Hill; and that it was he (the 2nd Defendant) who had “allowed” the Plaintiff to use some of the profits from this transaction to fund his purchase of 5F Tanglin Hill.
- [54]
[54] Other properties which the 2nd Defendant accepted as the Plaintiff’s personal investments included a number of shophouses in Smith Street and Tras Street which were purchased in Medway Realty’s name. The 2nd Defendant sought to distinguish these shophouse acquisitions from the purchase of the Keong Saik Property. According to the 2nd Defendant, the Plaintiff had sold these shophouses within a relatively short time after purchasing them, and for relatively modest profits: this showed that he had “no interest in long term investments” and was “happy to cash out his investments quickly and collect short term gains”.
OCBC Account 1
- [55]
[55] It should be noted that apart from claiming that the sale proceeds from 20 Lorong K were used to purchase 61 Lorong K, the 2nd Defendant also alleged that these sale proceeds were deposited into OCBC Account 1 (the account held in the joint names of the Plaintiff, the 1st Defendant and Aik Kheng). This formed the basis of his claims as to having purchased the Property with a loan from “Neo family monies” taken from OCBC Account 1.
The purchase of the Property
- [56]
[56] Insofar as the purchase of the Property was concerned, the 2nd Defendant claimed that he actually had the financial means to pay the purchase price of $370,000 because he had made a considerable amount of money over the years from his “various businesses and trading activities”. These included a sole proprietorship called First Vantage Properties which was involved in the retail of artworks and handicrafts, and which continues to operate as of today. Other sources of income were said to include commissions from acting as property agent in the sale and purchase of properties. The 2nd Defendant also exhibited his Income Tax Notices of Assessment for the years 1990 to 1994 which showed annual assessable incomes ranging from $40,556 (in 1992) to $107,716 (in 1991).
- [57]
[57] Despite enjoying what he described as “a substantial income”, the 2nd Defendant was reluctant to apply for a mortgage when it came to the purchase of the Property. Instead, he decided to take a loan from the monies held in OCBC Account 1 (the account held in the joint names of the Plaintiff, the 1st Defendant and Aik Kheng). Although he admitted that the Plaintiff was the one who operated and controlled OCBC Account 1, the 2nd Defendant claimed that the monies in this account “belonged to the Neo family” because they came from the sale proceeds of 20 Lorong K. In his version of events, therefore, his purchase of the Property was funded by a loan from “Neo family monies” – which he said he later repaid on 12 January 1994 by transferring $400,000 from OCBC Account 2 (which he insisted was his account) to OCBC Account 1.
- [58]
[58] Following completion of the purchase, the 2nd Defendant said he asked the 1st Defendant to be the legal owner of the Property and to hold it on trust for him. This was because as the registered owner of an HDB flat, he was not allowed to own the Property concurrently.
OCBC Account 2
- [59]
[59] As to how OCBC Account 2 came to be set up and what it was used for, the 2nd Defendant said that it was opened on 8 February 1993. In 1995 and in 1997, he got the 1st Defendant to pledge the Property as security for overdraft facilities obtained from OCBC, using OCBC Account 2. These overdraft facilities were allegedly for “various improvements and construction works carried out at the Property”. However, at the Plaintiff’s request, the 2nd Defendant agreed to allow him access to these overdraft facilities “to use the excess funds for trading purposes i.e. for the buying and selling of shares listed in the Singapore and Malaysia stock markets”. At the Plaintiff’s further request, the 2nd Defendant even supplied him with pre-signed blank debit slips for use in transferring funds out of the account. He felt that as the Plaintiff’s older brother, he could not reject his request.
- [60]
[60] The 2nd Defendant said that it was after he had obtained further overdraft facilities and when the construction works at the Property were halfway completed that he told the Plaintiff he was “in a position” to return the loan taken from OCBC Account 1. It was the Plaintiff who arranged for the sum of $400,000 to be transferred from OCBC Account 2 to OCBC Account 1. It was also the Plaintiff who informed the 2nd Defendant that the difference of $30,000 (between the $370,000 loan and the $400,000 repayment) was “for interests (sic) for the past 2 to 3 years”. The Plaintiff did not provide any calculations to explain the “interest” amount, and the 2nd Defendant did not argue. Nor did he ask the Plaintiff thereafter what happened to the $400,000 transferred.
A&A works on the Property
- [61]
[61] As noted above, the 2nd Defendant said he obtained the overdraft facilities in 1995, as well as the further overdraft facilities in 1997, for the purpose of funding improvement and construction works on the Property. In fact, according to the 2nd Defendant, the work of arranging for these improvements began even earlier in 1992 and was all undertaken by him. He was the one who liaised with the architect, the lawyers and the authorities to obtain official approval for the redevelopment of the Property, to recover possession of the Property from sitting tenants, and to compensate these tenants. Later, he was also the one who engaged various parties to carry out the Addition and Alteration (“A&A”) works; and he also supervised the execution of these works. He had such close interaction with the architect – Lim Han Leng (“Mr Lim HL”) – that the latter became a good friend.
- [62]
[62] Mr Lim HL gave evidence at the trial as the Defendants’ witness. Inter alia, he said that when he was working on the A&A works at the Property, the 2nd Defendant had told him that he owned the Property but had chosen to register it in the 1st Defendant’s name because of the issues created by his ownership of the HDB flat. Mr Lim HL also said that he only dealt with the two Defendants in relation to the A&A works at the Property; and that he thought it “odd that the owner of the Property would not want to be involved or have a say in the A&A works to be carried out”.
Tenancy of the Property
- [63]
[63] Insofar as the tenancy of the Property was concerned, the 2nd Defendant claimed that he was the one who arranged for tenants once the A&A works were completed and the Certificate of Statutory Completion (“CSC”) issued. The 2nd Defendant was also the one who collected the rent from these tenants and deposited the monies in OCBC Account 2. On the “rare” occasions when the Plaintiff collected the rent, it was only because the 2nd Defendant consented to his doing so.
- [64]
[64] It was also the 2nd Defendant’s evidence that prior to the Property being tenanted, he paid the property tax in cash. After the Property was tenanted out, he arranged to have the property tax paid via GIRO from OCBC Account 2. This, he said, showed that he was really the beneficial owner of the Property.
Sale of the Property
- [65]
[65] The 2nd Defendant claimed that despite not being the owner of the Property, the Plaintiff had “decided to market [it] for sale on his own account” because he was in “desperate need for funds” after suffering losses from “poor investment decisions”. According to the 2nd Defendant, it was the Plaintiff’s desperation for funds that led to his preparing the letter dated 31 July 2016. The 2nd Defendant was very concerned when he saw the letter, because it purported to revoke his authority to represent the 1st Defendant in all matters relating to the Property. However, as the 1st Defendant informed him that she had been “forced” to sign the letter of 31 July 2016 and that it did not reflect her true intention, he decided to treat the letter as being “invalid” and took no steps to respond to it.
The meeting of 10 December 2016
- [66]
[66] The letter of 31 July 2016 was not the only document the 1st Defendant claimed she had been “forced” to sign. She claimed that the Statutory Declaration and the Power of Attorney signed on 10 December 2016 were also “invalid” because she had signed them under duress. The particulars of duress pleaded in the Defence and Counterclaim may be summarised as follows:
(a) In November 2016, the Plaintiff had “scolded” the 1st Defendant for signing a tenancy agreement to lease out the Property. In the same incident, he had also “physically abused” her by throwing a metal measuring tape at her and pulling her hair. The reason for this abuse was “because the Plaintiff wanted the 1st Defendant to transfer the Property to the Plaintiff with a view to sell the Property and for the Plaintiff to collect the proceeds”.
(c) The 1st Defendant was taken to Mr Lim’s office on 10 December 2018 without being told that she was going to a law firm.
(d) At Mr Lim’s office, the 1st Defendant “felt compelled to remain quiet” as she “was in the company of the Plaintiff, Neo Geok Huwe and Neo Aik Kheng”.
- [67]
[67] In her AEIC, the 1st Defendant also stated that during the meeting on 10 December 2016, she did not ask the Plaintiff to reimburse her for the income tax she had paid on the rental income from the Property: she merely remarked to him at the meeting that she had paid nearly $30,000 in income tax on the rental from the Property. Nor did she ask for the payment of $100,000 from the sale proceeds: it was the Plaintiff himself who instructed Mr Lim Hin Chye to provide for a sum of $100,000 to be paid to her out of the sale proceeds. Indeed, according to the 1st Defendant, she did not even ask for the Deed of Immunity; it was “all prepared by the lawyer”.
Events post 10 December 2016
- [68]
[68] As to the events post 10 December 2016, the 1st Defendant stated that she had told the 2nd Defendant about the events at the lawyers’ offices. The 2nd Defendant was “furious”; and she was aware that he had written to Mr Lim on 12 December 2016 to “set the record straight”. The 1st Defendant insisted that when she herself went to Mr Lim’s office to collect the documents a few days later, she did speak with Mr Lim and she did inform him that she had been “forced to sign” the Statutory Declaration and the Power of Attorney “as the Plaintiff was a gambler and required funds urgently”. Mr Lim allegedly “did not respond” when she told him these things. She left his office with the documents, which she handed over to the Plaintiff.
- [69]
[69] The Plaintiff did not inform the 1st Defendant prior to executing the Option to Purchase in respect of the Property in May 2017, but she became aware of it when the 2nd Defendant – “as the rightful owner of the Property” - brought her to “see lawyers to seek advice on [their] legal rights”. It was the 2nd Defendant who told her that “the purchase price was too low and he was not willing to accept that price for the Property”. Following this, she filed a Deed of Revocation of the Power of Attorney on 20 June 2017.
Summary of the key issues in contention
- [70]
[70] As I noted at the start of these written grounds, it was common ground that whilst legal title to the Property vested in the 1st Defendant, she was not and had never been the beneficial owner.
- [71]
[71] Having regard to the parties’ respective cases as stated in their pleadings and as presented in the evidence adduced at trial, it was clear that the chief bone of contention between the two sides centred on the payment of the purchase price of the Property: whether the Property was paid for by the Plaintiff, or whether it was paid for by the 2nd Defendant. Given that it was agreed the money for the purchase of the Property came from OCBC Account 1, it followed that the key questions to be answered were these:
(a) Were the monies in OCBC Account 1 the Plaintiff’s monies as he claimed, or were these monies “Neo Family monies” as the 2nd Defendant claimed?
(b) If the monies in OCBC Account 1 were “Neo Family monies”, was the 2nd Defendant given a loan of these monies as he claimed, with which he paid the purchase price of the Property?
(c) In addition to the issue of payment of the purchase price, it was also relevant to consider whether there was other, objective evidence pointing to one or the other party’s beneficial ownership of the Property.
- [72]
[72] Having considered the evidence adduced, I was satisfied that the monies in OCBC Account 1 were the Plaintiff’s monies and not “Neo Family monies”; and that it was the Plaintiff who had paid for the Property using his own monies from OCBC Account 1. I was also satisfied that there was no such thing as “Neo Family monies” or, for that matter, “Neo Family Assets”. There was no loan of “Neo Family monies” made from OCBC Account 1 to the 2nd Defendant; and the 2nd Defendant did not pay for the Property.
- [73]
[73] I set out below my reasons for these findings.
On whether the monies in OCBC Account 1 were the Plaintiff’s monies or “Neo Family monies”
- [74]
[74] At the outset, I noted that the Defendants argued in their closing submissions that “(n)othing turns on whether the monies in OCBC Account 1 belong to the Neo Family or [the Plaintiff] or some other party. If [the 1st Defendant] could demonstrate that the monies from OCBC Account 1 which was used to fund the purchase of the Property was eventually repaid via the Transfer on 12 Jan 1994 (from OCBC Account 2), then his claim that he was the beneficial owner is made out”.
- [75]
[75] With respect, I found this argument both illogical and contrived. Firstly, to postulate that the 2nd Defendant needed only to demonstrate that the monies from OCBC Account 1 which were used to pay for the Property were “repaid” via the $400,000 transfer from OCBC Account 2 on 12 January 1994 was really to put the cart before the horse. The issue of “repayment” could only arise if one rejected the Plaintiff’s case that he had paid for the Property with his own monies from OCBC Account 1 – and accepted instead that the 2nd Defendant had taken a loan from that account.
- [76]
[76] Secondly, the argument ignored the case which the Defendants themselves had presented at trial, which was that the monies from OCBC Account 1 were “Neo Family monies” and not the Plaintiff’s monies. Indeed, under cross-examination, the 2nd Defendant firmly and repeatedly stated that the loan he took from OCBC Account 1 to purchase the Property was not a loan from the Plaintiff, because the Plaintiff “didn’t have that amount of money” and in any event would never have agreed to lend the 2nd Defendant money because he was “stingy” and “calculative”.
- [77]
[77] Having reviewed the evidence before me, it was clear that the evidence supported the Plaintiff’s claim that the monies in OCBC Account 1 were his. It was not disputed that this account was held in the joint names of the Plaintiff, the 1st Defendant and Aik Kheng: the 2nd Defendant was not and had never been an account-holder.
- [78]
[78] It was also not disputed that the Plaintiff operated and controlled OCBC Account 1. Aik Kheng was clear about this. The 1st Defendant confirmed in cross-examination that when she spoke in her AEIC of the Plaintiff having “control” of the bank accounts he held jointly with his siblings, these included OCBC Account 1. Even the 2nd Defendant himself admitted in his AEIC that OCBC Account 1 “was operated and controlled by [the Plaintiff] and the bank statements were sent to his residence at Oxley Road”. In cross-examination, the 2nd Defendant confirmed that although OCBC Account 1 was “held by three account holders”, “the person ultimately controlling the account was [the Plaintiff]”.
- [79]
[79] Critically, Aik Kheng and even the 1st Defendant gave evidence that the monies in OCBC Account 1 belonged to the Plaintiff. Aik Kheng stated clearly in his AEIC that
- [80]
[80] The 1st Defendant too agreed in cross-examination that OCBC Account 1 was opened with the intention that the Plaintiff “could use it for his sole beneficial purposes without reference to [her]”, and that she did not question him about it because she knew the monies in the account “belonged to him and not to [her]”.
- [81]
[81] It should be noted that although in her AEIC the 1st Defendant had stated that the balance of the proceeds from the sale of 20 Lorong K was deposited into OCBC Account 1, she admitted in cross-examination that she actually had no personal knowledge of any such deposit being made. When questioned about how she had come to include such a statement in her AEIC, she said that the statement had been “drafted by [her] lawyer” and she had signed off on it because she thought it was “logical”. It was then pointed out to her that in signing an affidavit, her responsibility was to ensure the truth of statements of fact made in it rather than to assess their logic – whereupon she agreed that had she been aware of this when making her AEIC, she would have asked that the statement about the deposit of the balance sale proceeds in OCBC Account 1 be deleted.
- [82]
[82] Ranged against the above evidence was the 2nd Defendant’s assertion that “the monies in [OCBC Account 1] were from the sale of 20 Lorong K” and that “the monies in [OCBC Account 1] belonged to the Neo Family”. The crux of the 2nd Defendant’s entire narrative came down to this: firstly, that 20 Lorong K had been purchased with monies from the Neo Family; and secondly, that when this property was sold in December 1983, an amount representing the balance of its sale proceeds was deposited into OCBC Account 1, thereby making the monies in OCBC Account 1 “Neo Family monies”. Both parts of the 2nd Defendant’s narrative were proven patently false.
- [83]
[83] It will be remembered that in his AEIC, the 2nd Defendant described the funds for the purchase of 20 Lorong K as having come from the following sources:
(a) The compensation monies received from TAS upon the compulsory acquisition of the Neo family’s original residence at 446 Upper Paya Lebar (totalling $95,000);
(b) The $200,000 allegedly won by the parents in a 4-D lottery sometime “in the 1970s”;
(c) $40,000 of savings and investments in listed shares from the Neo Family.
- [84]
[84] In respect of (a), objective documentary evidence showed that the compensation monies from TAS were received months after the purchase of 20 Lorong K. The records of the Land Registry showed that 20 Lorong K was conveyed to the Plaintiff and Aik Kheng on 29 March 1980. The initial award of $62,200, on the other hand, was received by the Plaintiff and the 2nd Defendant on 5 May 1980. The supplemental award of $29,367-46 (issued after their appeal), as well as the refund of their $5,000 appeal deposit, were received on 8 May 1981. In short, it was simply not possible for the TAS compensation monies to have been used for the purchase of 20 Lorong K. The 2nd Defendant was obliged to concede this – albeit with much reluctance - after being confronted in cross-examination with the documentary evidence.
- [85]
[85] The 1st Defendant – whose AEIC provided the same description as the 2nd Defendant’s of the sources of funds for the purchase of 20 Lorong K – also conceded in cross-examination that it was wrong to say the TAS compensation monies had been used for the said purchase.
- [86]
[86] In respect of (b), neither Defendant could produce any documentary evidence of the alleged lottery winnings of $200,000. That such evidence was not impossible to obtain was demonstrated by the fact that the Plaintiff was able, in contrast, to produce documentary evidence of his own lottery winnings of $400,000 in 1973 . $200,000 would have been a very substantial sum in the 1970s: the 2nd Defendant himself agreed that such a sum would have formed “the great majority” of his parents’ savings. I found it surprising that no documentary records existed of this allegedly huge win. The Plaintiff denied that their parents had won such a sum in the lottery. Aik Kheng gave evidence that although their parents had won at the lottery in the 1970s, they did not win such a large sum as $200,000: the sum which they won “was at most, a few thousand dollars and definitely less than 10 thousand dollars”. As for the 1st Defendant, although she insisted in cross-examination that the amount won was “definitely much more than the 10,000”, she admitted that she did not know the exact amount. Indeed, she even appeared to waver over whether the lottery had been won by the parents or by the mother. In the circumstances, I did not find it believable that there were lottery winnings of $200,000 from the 1970s which went towards making up the purchase price of 20 Lorong K.
- [87]
[87] In respect of (c), the Defendants were also unable to produce any documentary evidence of the “savings and investments in listed shares” which purportedly went towards $40,000 of the purchase price of 20 Lorong K. Neither Defendant was able to pin down exactly what these “savings and investments in listed shares” were. The 1st Defendant said she believed some of the shares in question were registered in her name, but no evidence was produced of any such shares; and as for which other siblings might have had shares registered in their names, she admitted she did not know. Indeed, when asked to confirm if she knew for a fact that there was $40,000 from such “listed shares” which were used for the purchase of 20 Lorong K, she confessed that she had “no idea”. She admitted that she actually had no personal knowledge of the statements made in her AEIC about the purchase having been funded by compensation monies of $95,000, lottery winnings of $200,000 and savings and share investments of $40,000. Even in making this admission, she vacillated rather confusingly between saying she had simply repeated what she heard from the 2nd Defendant and claiming she had included the statements in her AEIC because she “found it logical”.
- [88]
[88] As for the 2nd Defendant, he too was unable to identify what “savings and investments in listed shares” made up the sum of $40,000. When it was pointed out that this figure of $40,000 – when added to the $95,000 compensation figure and the $200,000 lottery winnings figure – would yield a total figure of $335,000 instead of the purchase price of $320,000, the 2nd Defendant was unable to explain the discrepancy. He resorted instead to claiming that “the $40,000 was just a rough calculation” and that the “actual sum could be higher or lower”. That he could so glibly shift positions in the blink of an eye, without any apparent basis, clearly showed that he was given to invention, and that his story about the funding for the purchase of 20 Lorong K was really just that – a story concocted from bare allegations and suppositions, for which no objective evidence could be produced.
- [90]
[90] Having considered the evidence before me, I rejected the Defendants’ story about 20 Lorong K having been purchased with the three sources of “Neo Family monies” as described in their AEICs. I found instead that 20 Lorong K was purchased with the Plaintiff’s own monies and that this property belonged to him – not to “the Neo Family” as the Defendants claimed. From this, it followed that the proceeds from any sale of 20 Lorong K belonged to the Plaintiff. This would explain why the Plaintiff was able to take out two mortgages on 20 Lorong K totalling $1 million. When 20 Lorong K was subsequently sold for $2,120,470, a sizeable portion of the sale proceeds were applied towards redeeming the two mortgages. It was not disputed that none of the other Neo siblings raised any objections. The 1st Defendant sought to downplay the absence of objections to the Plaintiff’s actions as a matter of “family members” not waiting to “quibble over such matters”. This explanation struck me as being quite unbelievable, considering that the mortgage loans which were redeemed came to nearly half of the sale price of 20 Lorong K. In my view, rather than it being a case of the other siblings choosing not to “quibble”, this was a case of their having no say in the mortgages or in the subsequent redemption of the mortgages because 20 Lorong K belonged to the Plaintiff; and he could deal with it – and with any proceeds from its sale - as he saw fit.
- [91]
[91] I should highlight that even leaving aside the issue of the sources of funding for the purchase of 20 Lorong K, it was plain that on the Defendants’ own case, there would not have been any balance amount left from the proceeds of its sale in December 1983 which could have been deposited in OCBC Account 1. First of all, it should be noted that neither Defendant was able to point to any documentary record of such balance amount having been deposited in OCBC Account 1. As noted earlier, the 1st Defendant also conceded during cross-examination that she had no personal knowledge of any such deposit having been made. The 2nd Defendant insisted that he knew there had been a balance amount deposited in OCBC Account 1 because he was involved in the sale and purchase of 20 Lorong K – but in cross-examination, he was obliged to concede that he did not deposit the money himself and did not really know about “the details”.
- [92]
[92] More fundamentally, however, the 2nd Defendant could not get his own figures to add up. It was not disputed that 20 Lorong K was sold for $2,120,470 and that $1 million of these sale proceeds went towards redeeming the mortgages taken out by the Plaintiff. The 2nd Defendant’s evidence was that out of the remaining sale proceeds, another $875,000 was used for the purchase of 61 Lorong K. That would have left a sum of $245,470. According to the 2nd Defendant’s case, this remaining balance of $245,470 would have been entirely used up in the purchase of 25 Lorong M by Medway Investments. This was because his evidence was that 25 Lorong M was purchased for $1,651,550 using bank overdraft facilities totalling $1 million and the “(b)alance of the sales proceeds from 20 Lorong K”. Based on the 2nd Defendant’s own evidence, therefore, there would not have been any balance amount left from the sale proceeds of 20 Lorong K which could have been deposited into OCBC Account 1. Indeed, when confronted with these figures in cross-examination, the 2nd Defendant ended up admitting that any balance sum from the sale of 20 Lorong K would – per his own case – have been fully used up in the purchase of 61 Lorong K and 25 Lorong M.
- [93]
[93] The 2nd Defendant was obviously discomfited at having to make this concession. First, he refused to admit that given the concessions he had made regarding the expenditure of the sale proceeds of 20 Lorong K, there could have been nothing left from those proceeds to go towards the purchase of the Property in 1991. His response plainly made no sense - and the realisation of his own vexed position appeared to prompt his next astonishing invention in the witness stand: namely, the claim that the monies in OCBC Account 1 which were used for the purchase of the Property came from Neo Family monies transferred from Medway Investments. This was something which he had never pleaded nor even mentioned in his AEIC. Tellingly, he was unable to put forward any documentary or other objective evidence of any such “internal transfers of money”; and when pressed further in cross-examination, he attempted yet again to prevaricate and backpedal. I reproduce below the relevant extract from the trial transcript, as it demonstrates clearly the shifty quality of the 2nd Defendant’s testimony:
- [94]
[94] Insofar as the 2nd Defendant appeared to suggest that funding for the purchase of the Property could have come from “internal transfers” from Medway Investments’ account to OCBC Account 1, I rejected this suggestion as an obvious fabrication.
Summary of my findings in relation to the source and the utilisation of the monies in OCBC Account 1
On the alleged existence of the “Neo Family Assets”
- [96]
[96] Given that the 2nd Defendant’s claim to beneficial ownership was premised on the alleged existence of “Neo Family Assets” which (according to him) yielded the funds for his purchase of the Property, I should make it clear at this juncture that I did not accept that there was such a thing as “Neo Family Assets”. In the first place, as pointed out in the Plaintiff’s closing submissions, insofar as the Defendants appeared to be claiming that certain properties and other assets were owned by an entity known as “the Neo Family”, such a claim was legally unsustainable: there is no concept in Singapore law of “family ownership” of a property. In this connection, I agreed with the Plaintiff’s submission that the Defendants’ reliance on Chia Kok Weng v Chia Kwok Yeo and another [2017] 2 SLR 964 was misplaced. The expression “family compact” as employed in that case clearly referred to the trial judge’s finding that there was an intention on the part of the Chia family members to secure the home at 37 Jalan Kechubong for the parents and the family members who lived there; and that it was this intention which actuated a series of transfers of ownership interests in the Jalan Kechubong property (at [28] and [33]). The trial judge’s finding was one of fact which the Court of Appeal agreed with on appeal (at [34]). Nothing in the judgement could be construed as establishing a legal concept of “family ownership” of assets in the manner advocated by the Defendants in this case.
- [97]
[97] Alternatively, if the Defendants were claiming that each Neo sibling was a beneficial owner of various properties and assets such as 20 Lorong K, 61 Lorong K, the company Medway Investments and the properties registered in Medway Investments’ name, then there was simply no objective evidence to support such a claim. According to the narrative advanced by the Defendants, 20 Lorong K was the first property acquired as a “Neo Family’s Asset”, and it was from this initial property acquisition that the New Family then built up a portfolio of assets. However, as I explained in the preceding paragraphs, my findings – after a review of the evidence – were that 20 Lorong K was purchased with the Plaintiff’s monies and belonged to the Plaintiff.
- [98]
[98] I also found the claim that Medway Investments was incorporated as the vehicle for “the Neo Family’s” investments frankly incredible. It was not disputed that the majority shareholders of the company - with a total of 75% shareholding – were the Plaintiff’s wife Lai Wah and the Plaintiff himself. Lai Wah is not a member of “the Neo Family”. As for the Plaintiff, the Defendants have sought throughout these proceedings to paint him as a selfish, covetous individual with a well-known “tendency to use his siblings for his own objectives and purposes”. If indeed Medway Investments had been set up as the vehicle for acquiring and holding valuable assets on behalf of “the Neo Family”, it was anomalous that the majority ownership of this vehicle should have been vested in the Plaintiff and his wife - of all people.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.