Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 5 Mar 2019

High Court

Ng Kian Huan Edmund v Suying Metropolitan Studio Pte Ltd and others

Feedback & support

[2019] SGHC 56Case no. Suit No 867 of 2015

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] In 2012, the plaintiff, Mr Ng Kian Huan, Edmund (“Edmund”), the 3rd defendant, Ms Tan Teow Feng Patty (“Patty”), and two others agreed to join forces and formed a new company, Suying Metropolitan Studio Pte Ltd (“SMSPL”). Edmund and Patty were the major shareholders. Edmund was then running an architectural firm, Metropolitan Office Experimental (“MOX”), while Patty ran an interior design company, Suying Design Pte Ltd (“SDPL”). Patty was planning to retire by 2012 or 2013 and the plan was for Edmund to continue to run the business. Unfortunately, the joint enterprise did not last long. The disputes that arose became intense and personal and resulted in the present proceedings in which both Edmund and Patty have made numerous allegations against each other.

  3. [2] On 24 August 2015, Edmund commenced this action against SMSPL (the 1st defendant), SDPL (the 2nd defendant) and Patty. Edmund’s main claim was that of minority oppression against Patty, pursuant to s 216 of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed) (“the Act”). As against SMSPL, Edmund sought certain orders in relation to, among other things, the director’s fees and dividends that he had received as well as those that were outstanding. Edmund also sought orders requiring SDPL and Patty to, among other things, pay certain sums of money back to SMSPL.

  4. [3] SMSPL counterclaimed against Edmund for, among other things, repayment of director’s fees and dividends received by Edmund, breach of director’s duties, and breach of duties of good faith and fidelity. SMSPL’s counterclaim also included conspiracy claims against Edmund and MOX (the 2nd defendant in the counterclaim), and against Edmund and Ms Chong Chin Fong (“Jazz”) (the 3rd defendant in the counterclaim). Jazz is Edmund’s wife and was, until the disputes started, a close friend of Patty.

  5. [5] After the witnesses had given their evidence, parties exchanged written closing submissions on 11 May 2018 and reply closing submission on 25 May 2018. On 4 July 2018, SDPL filed a response to three points in Edmund’s reply submissions and Edmund filed his response on 13 July 2018.

  6. Background

  7. [6] Jazz first introduced Edmund to Patty on 10 November 2011. A second meeting followed sometime in December 2011. A third meeting was held later, also in December 2011, in the presence of Mr Lim Chai Boon (“Chai Boon”), an architect and partner in another architectural company, Swan & Maclaren Pte Ltd (“Swan & Maclaren”). A fourth meeting was held in early January 2012 between Edmund, Patty, Chai Boon, and Ms Anita Chui (“Anita”), who owned an interior design firm, Chiu Design Associates Pte Ltd (“Chiu Design”). Anita and Chai Boon were long-time friends of Patty, and were invited to invest in SMSPL.

  8. [7] These four meetings culminated in an oral agreement among Edmund, Patty, Anita and Chai Boon (“the Oral Agreement”). SMSPL was subsequently incorporated on 20 February 2012 (“the Incorporation Date”). Patty held 40% of SMSPL’s shares. Edmund held 35%, Anita held 20% and Chai Boon held 5%. Chai Boon did not pay for his shares and eventually decided to withdraw from SMSPL. On 7 July 2014, Chai Boon’s shares (which had been paid for by Patty by then) were transferred to one Mr Shawn Lim (“Shawn”) who was then a director and an employee of SMSPL. Shawn resigned as an employee on 4 August 2014 and ceased to be a director of SMSPL on 13 August 2014. His 5% shareholding was transferred to Patty on 21 August 2014 and on 24 March 2015, Patty transferred 5% of her shareholding in SMSPL to Ms Martinez Gejane Siman (“Ane”), a former employee of SDPL.

  9. [8] It was common ground that the Oral Agreement was for a merger of MOX and SDPL to form SMSPL, and that all new businesses would be undertaken by SMSPL. Following the incorporation of SMSPL, all the employees of MOX and SDPL were transferred to SMSPL. Foreign staff nominally continued to be employed by MOX and SDPL as their employment passes were not transferrable. Chiu Design had ceased operations before SMSPL was incorporated.

  10. [9] What was in dispute was the treatment of amounts received by MOX and SDPL from projects that were in existence on the Incorporation Date (“pre-incorporation projects”). Edmund alleged that the agreement was that the amounts received by MOX and SDPL, pursuant to invoices dated after the Incorporation Date, were to be transferred to SMSPL, after deducting the expenses incurred. Patty’s version was that MOX and SDPL would continue to own the revenue from their respective pre-incorporation projects (even if invoiced after the Incorporation Date), but MOX and SDPL had to reimburse SMSPL for the use of its resources (primarily manpower).

  11. [10] From 2012 to 2015, MOX and SDPL effected various transfers of monies to SMSPL. The reasons for these transfers are in dispute. Edmund and Patty each argued that these transfers supported their respective versions of the Oral Agreement.

  12. [11] Edmund received $200,000 as director’s fee and $48,700.05 as dividends for 2012. As for 2013, Edmund’s director’s fee was $315,000 (of which he has received $50,000) and his share of dividends was $280,000 (of which he has received $150,000). In these proceedings, SMSPL and Patty alleged that the director’s fee paid to Edmund for 2012 was a loan and that it was agreed on 22 June 2015 that with respect to Edmund’s director’s fee for 2013, the outstanding amount of $265,000 would be loaned to SMSPL as working capital. SMSPL and Patty further alleged that the declarations of dividends for 2012 and 2013 were made under a mistake of fact as to what SMSPL’s profits were.

  13. [12] Patty had indicated to Edmund by March 2015 that she intended to go on a “sabbatical leave” and would retire in June 2015. SMSPL would then be left to Edmund to run, with the assistance of Ane. Ane was the new design director (though not appointed to SMSPL’s board), and, as stated earlier, had been given a 5% shareholding in SMSPL.

  14. [13] However, various disagreements arose between Edmund and Patty. On 13 July 2015, Edmund informed Patty and Ane that he intended to leave SMSPL and that he was prepared to give three months’ notice. The three of them agreed to meet again in October 2015 “to put in place the closure of the company”.

  15. [14] On 15 July 2015, Patty withdrew a total amount of $1,164,580 from SMSPL’s bank account with UOB for herself. This amount was withdrawn by way of 23 cheques for $50,000 each and one cheque for $14,580. All 24 cheques were signed by Patty. The reason for the multiple cheques was that cheques for sums above $50,000 required Edmund’s signature. Patty claimed that these payments were meant to be her gratuity and adjusted pay for the period from January to June 2015. Patty further claimed that she subsequently realised she had been overpaid by mistake. Patty returned the alleged excess amount of $492,580 to SMSPL’s account on 27 July 2015. Edmund disputed Patty’s claims to her gratuity and pay adjustment.

  16. [15] Edmund discovered that Patty was withdrawing monies from SMSPL’s bank account and on 21 July 2015, Edmund learnt from UOB that $1.15m (comprising the 23 cheques for $50,000 each) had been paid out to Patty on 15 July 2015. Edmund subsequently made various requests (including requests through his lawyers) for SMSPL’s financial documents. One of the issues in dispute is whether Edmund was denied access to SMSPL’s financial documents.

  17. [16] Subsequently, sometime between 13 July to 25 July 2015, Edmund was removed as a joint signatory and account holder of SMSPL’s bank account.

  18. [17] On 29 July 2015, Patty signed off on nine debit notes from SDPL to SMSPL amounting to $1,765,057 (“the Debit Notes”). Patty deducted a total amount of $230,000 allegedly for drafting services performed by SMSPL. The total amount payable to SDPL was therefore $1,535,057 before GST. After adding GST, the total amount became $1,642,510.99. Patty signed nine cheques in favour of SDPL for the total amount of $1,642,510.99. This amount was paid out to SDPL on 30 July 2015. SMSPL and Patty alleged that these were returns of various loans from SDPL to SMSPL. Edmund disputed this.

  19. [19] Meanwhile, on 25 August 2015, Edmund, Patty, Anita and Ane met and agreed that the directors would work towards the cessation of SMSPL’s operations by October 2015. A list of projects was drawn up, with various courses of actions to be undertaken by the respective directors-in-charge. Edmund’s last day of work at SMSPL was 12 October 2015. He was not paid his salary for the period from 1 to 12 October 2015, which amounted to $4,063.35.

  20. [20] On 9 October 2015, Edmund filed an application in Originating Summons 921 of 2015 (“OS 921/2015”) to inspect the documents of SMSPL in his capacity as a director of SMSPL. On 9 November 2015, Patty filed an affidavit affirming that SMSPL was not resisting the application. However, on 20 November 2015, SMSPL’s solicitors informed Edmund’s solicitors that SMSPL had taken the position that Edmund was not entitled to inspect its documents.

  21. [21] Before OS 921/2015 could be dealt with, on 15 December 2015, Edmund received a notice of a directors’ meeting to be held on 17 December 2015 to consider, among other things, convening an EGM to remove Edmund as a director. Edmund’s request to adjourn the directors’ meeting was not acceded to and the meeting proceeded in his absence on 17 December 2015. Edmund’s subsequent request to adjourn the EGM (fixed for 8 January 2016) till after the hearing of OS 921/2015 was also refused.

  22. [22] On 6 January 2016, Edmund filed an application for an injunction to restrain SMSPL and Patty from removing him as a director of SMSPL. On 7 January 2016, an interim injunction was granted to preserve Edmund’s capacity as director to proceed with the application in OS 921/2015 and to inspect SMSPL’s accounts and papers if the application in OS 921/2015 was granted. On 25 January 2016, I granted Edmund’s application in OS 921/2015.

  23. [23] SMSPL ceased operations in April 2016.

  24. Edmund’s claim

  25. [24] Edmund’s pleaded case is that

  26. (a) Patty has

  27. (i) conducted the affairs of SMSPL and/or exercised her power in a manner oppressive to him, in disregard of his interest as a member and shareholder of SMSPL;

  28. (ii) caused acts to be done or threatened by SMSPL and/or proposed to pass a resolution which unfairly discriminates against, or is otherwise prejudicial to Edmund;

  29. (b) he is entitled to retain the director’s fees and dividends that he received for 2012 and 2013 and that SMSPL has failed to pay him his outstanding director’s fees and dividends for 2013;

  30. (c) SDPL has to pay SMSPL certain sums of money that were wrongfully paid by SMSPL to or for the benefit of SDPL;

  31. (d) Patty has to pay SMSPL certain sums of money that were (i) wrongfully paid by SMSPL to Patty and (ii) losses that Patty wrongfully caused SMSPL to incur;

  32. (e) SMSPL and SDPL have to give an account of all projects / clients engaged, and all monies received, by each of them respectively since the Incorporation Date; and

  33. What were the terms of the Oral Agreement?

  34. [25] It would be useful to start with the dispute over the terms of the Oral Agreement. As stated earlier, the Oral Agreement was for a merger between MOX and SDPL to form SMSPL with all new businesses being undertaken by SMSPL. The dispute was over the treatment of amounts received by MOX and SDPL from pre-incorporation projects. Edmund alleged that all such amounts received by MOX and SDPL, pursuant to invoices dated after the Incorporation Date, were to be transferred to SMSPL (after deducting expenses incurred). Patty’s version was that MOX and SDPL would continue to own the revenue from all their respective pre-incorporation projects, but they had to reimburse SMSPL for any use of its resources (primarily manpower).

  35. [26] During his oral testimony, Edmund clarified that there was no discussion on whether work that had been completed before the Incorporation Date but invoiced only after the Incorporation Date, should be treated differently. Edmund then confirmed that he was agreeable to such cases being excluded from the Oral Agreement.

  36. No records of the use of SMSPL’s resources were kept

  37. [28] Patty asserted that the exact mechanics of how to account for the use of SMSPL’s resources was left to the discretion of Patty (for SDPL), Edmund (for MOX) and Anita (for Chiu Design) and that it was understood that this would primarily be by way of accounting for the use of SMSPL’s manpower. I do not accept Patty’s assertion. Without any records of the use of SMSPL’s manpower, how could anyone account for such use? Patty had had many years of experience managing SDPL. It is unbelievable that she would not have put in place a system to keep such records if indeed the use of SMSPL’s manpower had to be accounted for.

  38. [29] It was only after Edmund’s resignation from SMSPL that Patty worked with Ms Chua Choon Geok (“Choon Geok”), a part-time employee of SMSPL, to try to calculate the amounts that SDPL and MOX had to pay as reimbursement for the use of SMSPL’s manpower. There were no timesheets. Choon Geok testified that she would look at emails from and drawings by SMSPL employees, as well as the jobs they were working on, and estimate the amount of time spent on each job. Patty would make final adjustments based on her own estimates. Choon Geok accepted that not all emails were sent to her and that she did not have access to all the employees’ computers and emails.

  39. [30] In my view, Choon Geok’s estimates bordered on being arbitrary and were at best unreliable. The difficulty in trying to compute the reimbursement amounts only testifies to the importance of keeping proper records of the use of SMSPL’s manpower if Patty’s version were true. The absence of such records testifies to the improbability of Patty’s version of the Oral Agreement.

  40. [31] In fact, not only were there no records kept of the use of SMSPL’s resources, Patty’s evidence showed that her version of the Oral Agreement was unlikely to be true. Patty testified that what SDPL and MOX had to reimburse SMSPL for were just the CPF contributions, salaries and bonuses of SMSPL’s employees who worked on MOX’s and SDPL’s pre-incorporation projects. This does not make commercial sense because then, SMSPL would be bearing SDPL’s and MOX’s shares of overheads, operational expenses and general office expenses, all of which Patty conceded were paid for by SMSPL.

  41. Payments by MOX to SMSPL

  42. [32] Edmund referred to the following payments by MOX to SMSPL and submitted that they were transfers of amounts received by MOX in respect of pre-incorporation projects:

  43. (a) $100,000 in October 2012; and

  44. (b) two payments in 2013 and another two in 2014, amounting to $148,500.

  45. Payment of $100,000 in October 2012

  46. [33] This payment is described in SMSPL’s general ledger as payment by MOX in respect of “Design Consultancy” without any reference to any project. The relevant invoice from SMSPL (SM 2012-031) describes the invoiced amount as “Design Consultancy Fee” but does not refer to any project either. However, SMSPL’s list of incoming funds links this payment to “10 Aljunied & Maldives” which were pre-incorporation projects of MOX.

  47. [34] Patty claimed that the payment of $100,000 was a reimbursement for the use of SMSPL’s manpower which she alleged amounted to $104,535.11. Patty relied on (a) MOX’s accounts for 2012 which showed a sum of $104,535 owing to a “related party” as a result of expenses paid on behalf” of MOX, (b) MOX’s accounts for 2013 which no longer reflected this sum, and (c) MOX’s general ledgers which showed payment of $100,000 to SMSPL for salary and payment of $4,535.11 to Edmund’s director’s account.

  48. [35] I agree with Patty that the evidence does not support Edmund’s claim that the $100,000 was payment of receivables. However, I also do not think the evidence supports Patty’s claim that the payment of $100,000 was a reimbursement for the use of SMSPL’s resources either. Payment of salaries by SMSPL on behalf of MOX is very different from reimbursement by MOX for use of SMSPL’s resources. There is also no evidence showing what were the resources used that gave rise to the amount of $104,535.11. In addition, this payment is also separately described as a “loan” in SMSPL’s general ledger. SMSPL’s expert witness, Mr Abuthahir Abdul Gafoor (“Gafoor”), from RSM Corporate Advisory Pte Ltd, relied on instructions given to him that the payment was for the use of SMSPL’s drafting services. He was not able to explain the exact purpose of the various classifications in MOX’s general ledger. Neither was he able to conclude that the $100,000 was reimbursement for the use of resources.

  49. [36] In my view, the evidence with respect to the payment of the $100,000 in October 2012 is simply too unreliable to support either Edmund’s or Patty’s version of the Oral Agreement.

  50. Payments in 2013 and 2014 amounting to $148,000

  51. [37] MOX paid a total amount of $148,000 to SMSPL in 2013 and 2014, comprising $16,250 and $81,250 paid in 2013, and $21,000 and $30,000 in 2014. SMSPL’s general ledger describes the first three payments as payments by MOX in respect of “Chiltern Drive”, “Chennai”, and “MK 19 Wak Hassan Drive”. Each of the invoices for these three payments describes the invoiced amount as “Design Consultancy Fee” and also references the specific project. As for the fourth payment of $30,000, SMSPL’s general ledger refers to its invoice SM 2014-007 which in turn refers to a project at “Kasara, Sentosa”. All these projects were pre-incorporation projects of MOX. Edmund claimed that these four payments were transfers of amounts received by MOX in respect of pre-incorporation projects.

  52. [39] Edmund acknowledged that MOX had also received further payments from its pre-incorporation projects, which should have been but were not, transferred to SMSPL. Edmund explained that he had left it to Nisha who handled the maintenance of files and preparation of invoices. Nisha had failed to effect the transfers. I accept Edmund’s explanation. The evidence showed clearly that Edmund generally did not handle the accounts and the transfer of payments. In an email to Edmund dated 8 August 2015, Patty herself pointed out that Edmund never managed the accounts.

  53. [40] Patty alleged that the second payment of $81,250 (made in 2013) included a sum of $50,111.99 which was reimbursement of salaries paid by SMSPL ($21,000 paid to Shawn and $29,111.99 paid to Mr Ong Eng Meng). According to Patty, the balance of $31,138.01, together with the first, third and fourth payments, were “lump sum” reimbursements for MOX’s use of SMSPL’s resources. Patty also alleged that the reason for the fourth payment of $30,000 was that SMSPL had taken over the project at Edmund’s request. In my view, the evidence does not support Patty’s allegations of lump sum reimbursements.

  54. (a) First, Patty’s explanation, that these were lump sum reimbursements for the use of SMSPL’s resources, is too convenient and unbelievable. Even going by Patty’s own evidence, two of the amounts involved ($16,200 and $31,138.01 ) are hardly what one would describe as “lump sums”. It is also unbelievable that the parties would have been content to rely on a “lump sum” estimate without any records being kept of the use of resources; and

  55. (b) Second, Patty’s two explanations for the fourth payment of $30,000 are inconsistent with each other. There can be no question of reimbursement for use of only SMSPL’s resources if SMSPL took over the project, since in the latter case, the whole fee would be earned by SMSPL.

  56. [41] In my view, the payments which Patty described as lump sum reimbursements, were in fact transfers of amounts received by MOX from its pre-incorporation projects.

  57. Payments by SDPL to SMSPL

  58. [42] Edmund argued that payments by SDPL to SMSPL amounting to $600,000 in 2012 and $719,652.02 in 2013–2014, were transfers of amounts received by SDPL from its pre-incorporation projects pursuant to his version of the Oral Agreement.

  59. Payment of $600,000

  60. [43] The amount of $600,000 comprised payments of $176,000 made in August 2012 and $424,000 in September 2012. The payment of $176,000 included GST of $11,514.02 whilst the payment of $424,000 included GST of $27,738.33. Patty claimed that these two payments were advances by SDPL to SMSPL.

  61. [44] Patty testified that SMSPL was short of funds with a bank balance of only $248,875.93 in August 2012 and $276,008.13 in September 2012. In comparison, SMSPL’s outgoing payments from April to August 2012 amounted to $785.738.90 and SMSPL’s total expenditure for 2012 was $1,421,633.00 whereas the revenue was only $471,517.50.

  62. [45] However, the payments of $176,000 and $424,000 were recorded in SMSPL’s general ledgers as profit and loss items which included goods and services tax (“GST”). Edmund’s expert witness, Mr Owen Malcolm Hawkes (“Hawkes”), from KPMG Services Pte Ltd, testified that these records are inconsistent with the payments being loans because loans are balance sheet items and no GST would be payable in the case of loans.

  63. [46] As mentioned earlier, SMSPL’s employee, Nisha, was responsible for the maintenance of files and preparation of invoices. She testified that in December 2012, SMSPL’s then book-keeper, Mr Shin Say Hock (“Shin”), asked her for documentation supporting SMSPL’s receipt of the $176,000 and $424,000, and that he instructed her to prepare invoices issued by SMSPL. Nisha prepared six invoices, backdated to dates between March 2012 and August 2012. The six invoices described each of the amounts invoiced as an “administrative billing”. According to Nisha, Patty instructed her to use the same description that was used previously for invoices in respect of two payments by SDPL in February and March 2012 amounting to $203,430.71. The invoices for those two payments had similarly described each of the amounts invoiced as an “administrative fee”. It is not disputed that these two payments were payments by SDPL on behalf of SMSPL and that SMSPL repaid SDPL in April 2012.

  64. [47] Nisha explained that she had used the description “administrative fee” for the previous invoices, on the advice of Shin. In turn, Shin explained that he did not know then that the payments were advances extended by SDPL.

  65. [48] Nisha testified that when she told Patty that the description in the earlier invoices was “administrative fee”, Patty told her to use the description “administrative billing” for the six invoices.

  66. [49] Nisha had also prepared SDPL’s payment vouchers for the payments of $176,000 and $424,000. She subsequently wrote the word “loan” on her copy of the payment vouchers. Nisha could not remember when she did this but suggested it was likely to have been sometime in December 2012/January 2013 after Shin asked her for the supporting documents for the $600,000.

  67. [50] I accept Nisha’s explanations as to why she issued the six invoices with the description “administrative billing”. The invoices explain the treatment given to the two payments of $176,000 and $424,000 in SMSPL’s general ledgers. Loans should not be treated this way, but as Hawkes observed, the accounts were in a state of mess.

  68. [51] In my view, the evidence supports the defendants’ claim that the payments of $176,000 and $424,000 were in fact loans from SDPL to SMSPL. First, contemporaneous documents support the defendants’ claim. SDPL’s lists of expenses for August 2012 and September 2012 recorded the payments of $176,000 and $424,000 as “payout to Suying Metropolitan to cover expenses”. In addition, a contemporaneous post-it note from Nisha referred to the sum “$601,000” (including the $1,000 to open SMSPL’s bank account) and stated the following: “this one which was took out from Suy-D [SDPL] to Suy-M [SMSPL] to balance the new company Suy-M” (sic).

  69. [52] Second, Edmund admitted that he could not link the payments of $176,000 and $424,000 to amounts received by SDPL from any specific pre-incorporation project.

  70. [53] Third, Patty testified that at a meeting on 8 June 2015, Patty had informed Edmund and Ane that there was an $800,000 loan owing from SMSPL to SDPL. On 1 July 2015, Patty sent Edmund and Ane the following message:

  71. “Good news, the amount to be return to [SDPL] is much smaller..Nisa (sic) is checking and will give me the list to check.. The amount is about $600,000 and not S$800,000”

  72. Edmund replied “Thank you so much”.

  73. [54] Edmund admitted that he was told during a discussion in August 2012 that SMSPL’s bank account balance was low, although he claimed that Patty had then told him there was no cause for concern as there would be incoming receivables.

  74. [55] Edmund explained that his reply to Patty’s message was not an acknowledgement that there was a loan from SDPL to SMSPL and that it was merely to thank her for taking the time to check the amounts. I do not accept Edmund’s explanation. It is not a reasonable interpretation of his reply. More importantly, it is telling that in his reply, Edmund did not question the fact that there was $600,000 that had to be repaid to SDPL. The fact that it had to be repaid was clearly inconsistent with the amount being a transfer of receivables.

  75. Payment of $719,652.02

  76. [56] The amount of $719,652.02 reflected payments made by way of seven cheques from SDPL to SMSPL from April 2013 to November 2014. The payments were made in respect of the following ten invoices issued by SMSPL:

  77. [57] The amounts in the invoices represented fees from SDPL’s pre-incorporation projects. The invoices described the amounts invoiced as “consultancy fee”. Patty claimed that she instructed Nisha to use the description “consultancy fee” because this was the description used in the invoices for the payments by MOX to SMSPL (see [33] and [37] above).

  78. [58] Patty described these payments as “project-linked loans” by SDPL to SMSPL. According to her, these payments were from “fees earned from whichever project SDPL happened to have money payable to it”. Patty claimed that

  79. (a) SMSPL required further loans as working capital. According to Patty, as a “rough rule of thumb”, SMSPL would need a cash buffer of three times the monthly operational expenses. This excluded any additional cash that SMSPL may need to purchase furniture, fitting and equipment (“FF&E”) to fit out the project under its design and build contracts. ; and

  80. (b) she decided to transfer the whole amounts received by SDPL under “specific invoices” rendered for specific projects because the repayment of the loans could subsequently be set off against any reimbursement owed by SDPL to SMSPL. The “overpayment” to SMSPL arising from the loans would provide SMSPL a cash buffer for its projects.

  81. [59] In his expert report dated 9 November 2017, Hawkes pointed out that SMSPL’s cash balances prior to each of the payments by SDPL do not suggest that SMSPL was short of funds. SMSPL’s cash balance prior to the payment of $288,900 (under the first invoice) was $741,174.10. SMSPL’s cash balance prior to payment of each of the remaining nine invoices ranged from just over $1m to more than $1.7m.

  82. [60] In her oral testimony, Patty’s response was that she did not look at SMSPL’s bank statements or general ledgers. Instead, she assessed SMSPL’s need for funds by reviewing the monthly incoming funds (which she referred to as the incoming cheque listing) and the expenses list, and she tried to “balance, make sure that [she] receive[d] enough money to pay out”.

  83. [61] In my view, Patty’s explanation lacks credibility. I find it unbelievable that Patty, with all her experience, would have tried to assess whether SMSPL needed funds by merely looking at the incoming funds and expenses list, without considering what SMSPL’s cash balances were. In any event, assuming her evidence to be true, Patty was merely trying to balance the expenses against the incoming funds. Clearly, the question of whether SMSPL was short of funds or whether its cash buffer needed topping up, could not have been in her mind since she did not even look at SMSPL’s cash balances.

  84. [62] Further, if Patty’s evidence about maintaining a cash buffer is to be believed, one would expect the timing of the loans to correspond to times when the cash buffer was insufficient. However, as Hawkes pointed out, the timing of the alleged loans from SDPL does not appear to be correlated with the movements of the alleged cash buffer. Instead, the timing of the alleged loans appeared to be more correlated to SDPL’s receipt of payments from its own clients. This is also consistent with SDPL’s instructions to its own expert, Mr Andrew Grimmett (“Grimmett”) from Deloitte & Touche Financial Advisory Services Pte Ltd, that the flow of funds from SDPL to SMSPL was on a “back-to-back” basis, ie, SDPL would transfer the monies it received from its projects to SMSPL. Further, Hawkes’ analysis shows that with respect to nine of the ten alleged loans referred to in [56] above, SMSPL’s cash balance prior to the payment exceeded the cash buffer by between 22% to 65%. Clearly, the cash buffer could not have been the reason for those nine alleged loans.

  85. [64] The evidence also shows that

  86. (a) between August 2013 and November 2015, SDPL had collected a total sum of $1,066,087.13 in respect of SMSPL’s projects for which SDPL allegedly acted as contract administrator; and

  87. (b) by December 2013, SDPL’s company in Shanghai, Suying Design (“SD (Shanghai)”) had received payment of RMB2.16m for SMSPL’s projects in China, and in August 2014, SD (Shanghai) received payment of another RMB278,875.

  88. [65] The monies were due from SDPL to SMSPL. Patty could not give any credible explanation for not transferring these monies to SMSPL to meet SMSPL’s funding needs, instead of taking loans from SDPL. Interestingly, Gafoor testified that Patty instructed him to disregard the monies from SD (Shanghai) because they were used for the running expenses in China, to purchase FF&E and were “not a significant amount”. Clearly, these should have been considered for inclusion in Gafoor’s comparisons of SMSPL’s cash balances against the cash buffer since Patty did not dispute that they were SMSPL’s monies. Further, the amounts received by SD (Shanghai) were clearly significant amounts when compared to the amount of alleged “project-linked loans” taken by SMSPL in 2013 ($563,580) and 2014 ($156,072.02) (see [56] above).

  89. [66] Finally, SMSPL paid $70,433.55 towards Patty’s Bedok property in May 2013 (which Patty claimed was a temporary loan) and SMSPL’s funds were used to pay SDPL’s income tax of $154,707.65 on 20 November 2013 and SDPL’s GST liabilities of $14,800.02 on 28 January 2014. These payments are clearly inconsistent with Patty’s allegation that SMSPL was short of funds such that a loan of $288,900 was needed in April 2013, and loans amounting to $156,072.02 were needed in November 2014 (see [56] above).

  90. [67] In my judgment, Patty’s allegation that the payments by SDPL to SMSPL amounting to $719,652.02 were loans taken from SDPL, was an afterthought. Her description of these payments as “project-linked loans” was itself clearly an afterthought. The evidence shows that it is far more probable that these payments were transfers by SDPL to SMSPL of fees collected from SDPL’s pre-incorporation projects.

  91. Ode to Art’s transfer of $162,193.93 to SMSPL

  92. [68] Jazz owns Ode to Art, an art gallery and shop in Singapore. At Jazz’s request, SD (Shanghai) paid RMB817,133 on behalf of Ode to Art, to various artists in China. Ode to Art was to reimburse SDPL in Singapore dollars ($162,193.93).

  93. [69] However, the sum of $162,193.93 was paid to SMSPL instead of SDPL. Patty claims that she told Nisha to transfer the amount to SMSPL because SMSPL was in need of funds. The payment was made to SMSPL and recorded in SMSPL’s general ledger on 8 February 2013 as cash receipts. The amount was also credited to Patty as an amount “owing to director”.

  94. [70] Leaving aside the question whether the amount was correctly credited to Patty in SMSPL’s general ledger, in my view, this payment to SMSPL by SDPL was a loan and not a payment of fees collected by SDPL for pre-incorporation projects. Edmund himself admitted that he had no knowledge whether this was a payment of fees collected.

  95. Other evidence

  96. SDPL’s unbilled fees vs MOX’s unbilled fees; no due diligence

  97. [71] Patty argued that she would not have agreed to Edmund’s version of the Oral Agreement because SDPL’s unbilled fees from its pre-incorporation projects then were much greater than MOX’s unbilled fees from its pre-incorporation projects. However, I agree with Edmund that it was not unreasonable for Patty and him to agree that fees from pre-incorporation projects that were invoiced after the Incorporation Date to be paid to SMSPL. After all, MOX’s and SDPL’s employees were all transferred to SMSPL (save for those who were foreigners). Further, Patty was planning her retirement and intended that Edmund would take over the running of SMSPL and preserve the “Suying” name.

  98. [72] Patty also argued that the fact that no due diligence was done on SDPL’s and MOX’s unbilled fees supported her version of the Oral Agreement. I do not think that this is a strong argument since Patty appeared to already know that SDPL’s unbilled fees exceeded MOX’s. Further, this has to be look at in the context of Patty’s plans for her retirement and for Edmund to take over and preserve the “Suying” name.

  99. Patty’s email dated 8 August 2015

  100. [73] Next, after Edmund’s resignation, Patty sent a confrontational email to him on 8 August 2015. Despite Patty having set out at length various aspects of the Oral Agreement, she made no mention of her assertion that MOX and SDPL had to reimburse SMSPL for the use of SMSPL’s resources. When she was queried about this, Patty replied that this was because her email was simply an “outline of the event” and was “a general response” to Edmund’s email requesting to handover his projects and for access to SMSPL’s financial accounts. Patty further alleged during re-examination that she had not mentioned reimbursement as it “was already done by 8 August”.

  101. [74] I do not accept Patty’s explanation. Her email was not merely a “very quick response” to Edmund’s email as she had alleged, but went into great detail about SMSPL’s incorporation, including the fact that Edmund had represented to the other shareholders that he “shared the “Suying” vision and that [he] would continue the legacy, built upon the “Suying” brand…” Further, Patty’s explanation that she did not mention reimbursement in her email because it “was already done”, is suspect. The loans from SDPL had been repaid but this did not stop from Patty mentioning the loans in her email.

  102. Parties’ witnesses

  103. [75] Anita and Chai Boon testified in support of Patty’s version of the Oral Agreement. Both were present at the fourth meeting (with Patty and Edmund) in January 2012 (see [6] above). Mr Seah Chin Kwang (“Seah”) testified in support of Edmund’s version of the Oral Agreement. Seah was an Associate Partner in MOX and subsequently moved over to SMSPL. His testimony was based on his discussions with Patty as well as briefings by Patty. Obviously, the conflicting evidence of these witnesses, as with the conflicting evidence of Patty and Edmund, has to be considered against the totality of the evidence.

  104. Conclusion on the terms of the Oral Agreement

  105. [76] There are some aspects of the evidence that, looked at on their own, support Patty’s case. However, in my judgment, the totality of the evidence discussed above points to Edmund’s version of the Oral Agreement being more probable than Patty’s. I find therefore that pursuant to the Oral Agreement, all fees (less expenses incurred) for pre-incorporation projects, collected by MOX and SDPL based on invoices issued after the Incorporation Date, are to be paid over to SMSPL. However, as conceded by Edmund, this would not apply where the work had been completed before the Incorporation Date.

  106. Edmund’s claim under s 216

  107. [77] In his closing submissions, Edmund relied on the following allegations:

  108. (a) The payment of $1,164,580 to Patty on 15 July 2015.

  109. (b) The payment of $1,642,510.99 to SDPL on 30 July 2015.

  110. (c) The denial and/or obstruction of his access to SMSPL’s financial documents.

  111. (d) The claw-back of director’s fees and dividends.

  112. (e) The failure to pay Edmund’s salary for October 2015.

  113. (f) Excluding Edmund from decision-making in relation to SMSPL’s affairs while he remained a director of SMSPL.

  114. (g) Various claims set out in the Annexes to the statement of claim.

  115. (h) SMSPL’s payment of $50,048 for salaries of SDPL’s employees.

  116. (i) Writing off the sum of $194,290.08 owed by SDPL to SMSPL.

  117. (j) Other wrongful reductions of SMSPL’s revenue.

  118. (k) SMSPL’s continued payment of rent, overheads and salaries after it had ceased operations in April 2016.

  119. (l) SMSPL’s payment towards Patty’s Bedok property.

  120. Payment of $1,164,580 to Patty on 15 July 2015

  121. [78] As stated earlier, on 13 July 2015, Edmund informed Patty of his resignation from SMSPL and on 15 July 2105, Patty paid herself $1,164,580 by way of 23 cheques for $50,000 each and one cheque for $14,580. Patty claimed that Nisha made a mistake as to the amount and after she (Patty) realised the mistake, she returned $492,580 to SMSPL on 27 July 2015.

  122. [79] Patty claimed that the balance amount of $672,000 was payment of her gratuity ($600,000) and pay adjustment for the period from January to June 2015 ($72,000).

  123. [80] Patty claimed that during a meeting with Ane and Edmund on 8 June 2015, she reiterated that her last day of employment with SMSPL would be 30 June 2015. According to Patty, it was agreed at this meeting that she be paid a gratuity of $600,000 and a pay adjustment amounting to $72,000 for the period from January to June 2015. Patty claimed that the gratuity amount was based on 4% of the value of projects that she had brought to SMSPL and the pay adjustment was to reflect what she had been entitled to in SDPL. Patty also claimed that her gratuity was again discussed at another meeting with Anita and Edmund on 22 June 2015.

  124. [81] Anita testified that Patty told her about the $600,000 gratuity sometime after the 8 June 2015 meeting and that Patty’s gratuity was also discussed at the meeting on 22 June 2015 although the amount was not mentioned.

  125. [82] In his affidavit evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”), Edmund denied any discussion of either a gratuity or a pay adjustment. However, in his oral testimony, Edmund admitted that there was a discussion about paying Patty a gratuity and the figure of $600,000 was raised; however, Edmund would have to look at the accounts, and it would depend on whether the SMSPL’s accounts show that it was able to pay her that amount. Edmund also conceded that the relative billings and contributions were also discussed.

  126. [84] Second, Patty and Anita signed a resolution dated 30 December 2014, authorising the payment of $600,000 to Patty. Under cross-examination, Patty admitted that the resolution was signed in late July 2015 (ie, after Edmund had resigned but before he had left SMSPL) and backdated. Clearly, if there had been an agreement to pay Patty $600,000 as gratuity or bonus, there would have been no need for the resolution to be backdated and neither would there have been any reason not to have asked Edmund to sign the same. Even if Patty wanted to backdate the resolution because the gratuity had already been paid, there was no reason to backdate it to 30 December 2014 which is some six months earlier than the alleged agreement to pay her the gratuity. Patty alleged that the resolution was suggested in late July by Ms Karen Ng (“Karen”) from M/s Karen Ng and Associates which provided book-keeping services to SMSPL. However, Patty did not call Karen as a witness.

  127. [85] Third, Nisha testified that the reason for the initial payment of $1,164,580 (with the alleged overpayment of $492,580) was because she had misunderstood Patty’s instructions and had thought Patty was asking her to prepare repayment of loans from SDPL. I do not accept Nisha’s testimony for the following reasons:

  128. (a) Patty alleged in her AEIC that she “reminded Nisha to prepare the payments for her gratuity and adjusted pay”. Nisha’s claim that she misunderstood this to mean Patty was asking her to prepare repayment of loans from SDPL is simply too far-fetched.

  129. (b) Nisha alleged that the amount of $1,164,580 included $563,580 which was supposed to comprise the loans extended by SDPL in 2013 and 2014, but she made a mistake in that she failed to include loans extended in 2014. I do not accept Nisha’s explanation. According to Nisha, she was tabulating the loans for 2013 and 2014. I find it hard to believe that she would not have noticed that the supporting documents that she allegedly relied on, were only for 2013. In any event, the amount of $563,580 was part of the $719,652.02 which I have concluded (at [67] above) were not loans but transfers by SDPL to SMSPL of fees collected from SDPL’s pre-incorporation projects.

  130. (c) If the cheques were for the repayment of loans from SDPL, then they should have been made payable to SDPL instead of Patty. Nisha claimed that Patty instructed her to seek Shin’s views and when she spoke to Shin, he told her to make payment to Patty. In my view, Nisha’s evidence was not credible. Why would Patty ask her to seek Shin’s views if the payments were for her gratuity and pay adjustments, which according to Patty, had been agreed? Yet, if the payments were repayments of loans from SDPL, why would Nisha need to ask Shin who to make payment to, and why would Shin tell Nisha to make payment to Patty? Shin gave evidence for the defendants and, as Edmund submitted, Shin’s AEIC is conspicuously silent on this matter.

  131. [86] Fourth, Patty claimed that she subsequently discovered that she had been overpaid and she then returned $492,580 to SMSPL on 27 July 2015. Nisha testified that on a date after 24 July 2015, on the instructions of either Patty or Shin, she prepared a payment voucher for a loan of $492,580 from SMSPL to Patty and backdated it to 15 July 2015. Clearly, the payment voucher was a false document. There was no loan of $492,580 by SMSPL to Patty. There was no need for Patty to go through the rigmarole of preparing a payment voucher falsely showing a loan to her, if indeed there was an overpayment by mistake.

  132. [87] Fifth, by Patty’s own account, it took her almost one week to realise that she been overpaid, and a week thereafter to effect the repayment of $492,580. Patty was clear in her mind that her alleged entitlement was only for $672,000. In her AEIC, she claimed she was “pleasantly surprised” and at trial she claimed it was a “shock” that the amount paid to her was $1,164,580. However, she could offer no explanation for why she nevertheless went on to accept the $1,164,580 (rather than $672,000) other than it was her fault.

  133. [88] In my judgment, Patty’s gratuity may have been discussed but there was no agreement reached. Neither was there any agreement to pay her any pay adjustment. I agree with Edmund’s submission that after Edmund gave notice of his resignation, Patty moved quickly to withdraw $1,164,580 from SMSPL without Edmund’s knowledge. Patty achieved this by instructing Nisha to break the amount into 24 cheques each specifically drawn for an amount not exceeding her single cheque signing authority. Patty’s explanations about her gratuity and pay adjustments, as well as her reason for repaying $$492,580 to SMSPL, were all nothing more than afterthoughts. Patty had to repay the sum of $492,580 to SMSPL because she could not come up with any other reason to justify the payment of that amount to her. Patty is not entitled to retain the balance of $672,000.

  134. Payment of $1,642,510.99 to SDPL

  135. [89] By 25 July 2015, Patty had removed Edmund as a joint signatory for SMSPL’s bank account with UOB. On 29 July 2015, Patty signed the Debit Notes to be issued by SDPL to SMSPL for payment of “consultancy fees”. The Debit Notes were all backdated to various dates from 12 June 2014 to 28 June 2015. As stated in [17] above, the total amount on the Debit Notes was $1,765,057. Patty deducted a total amount of $230,000 allegedly for drafting services performed by SMSPL. The total amount payable to SDPL was therefore $1,535,057 before GST. After adding GST, the total amount became $1,642,510.99. Payment to SDPL was by way of nine cheques (all dated 29 July 2015) which Patty signed.

  136. [90] Patty alleged that around 24 July 2015, she had worked out the inter-company debts between SDPL and SMSPL and she asked Nisha to send the draft invoices for Karen’s review. It appears from email correspondence that it was Karen who suggested issuing debit notes instead. It is not clear what was told to Karen; Nisha’s email to Karen merely referred to “incoming fund[s]” for SMSPL from 2012 to 2015.

  137. [91] Each of the Debit Notes was for “Consultancy Fee[s]” for a certain period. According to Patty, the consultancy fee reflected the loan from SDPL. Eight of the Debit Notes each showed a deduction for “drafting services”. Patty claimed that these deductions reflected the reimbursement by SDPL for use of SMSPL’s resources. GST was then added to the net amount on each debit note.

  138. [92] The relevant particulars of the nine debit notes were as follows:

  139. [93] The amounts in DN-001 ($176,000), DN-002 ($424,000) and DN-004 ($162,193) have been dealt with earlier and I have found that these were loans from SDPL to SMSPL – see [51] and [68]–[70] above. There was therefore nothing wrong with the repayment of these loans to SDPL.

  140. [94] The following amounts have also been dealt with earlier and I have found that these were not loans but payments by SDPL of fees collected from its post-incorporation projects (see [56] and [67] above):

  141. (a) $288,900 under DN-005;

  142. (b) $3,210, $51,360, $9,630 and $160,500 (out of the total amount of $244,700) under DN-006;

  143. (c) $49,980 (out of the total amount of $99,200) under DN-007; and

  144. (d) $56,101.01, $56,101,01, $21,400 and $22,470 (out of the total amount of $230,022) under DN-009.

  145. The above add up to $719,652.02.

  146. [95] The remaining two items are DN-003 and an amount of $20,000 under DN-006. With respect to DN-003, Patty admitted that the correct amount should have been $20,000 and that the additional amount of $20,532 was a mistake by Nisha. The amount of $20,000 under DN-003 and the amount of $20,000 under DN-006, both described by Patty as “cash from SDPL’s Chennai Villa project”, have been paid to SMSPL under similar circumstances as the payment of the amounts referred to in [94] above. In her AEIC on behalf of SDPL, Patty also asserted that Nisha neglected to include an additional $10,000 into the debit notes, which were also cash deposits from the Chennai Villa project and that this was also a loan from SDPL to SMSPL. I reject Patty’s explanations. Accordingly, I find that these payments were also payments by SDPL of fees collected from its post-incorporation projects.

  147. [96] Clearly therefore, not all of the debit notes were in respect of loans from SDPL to SMSPL.

  148. [97] The amounts which Patty alleged to have been included by Nisha by mistake, add up to $243,212.

  149. [98] In my view, the Debit Notes were just excuses for Patty to withdraw moneys from SMSPL’s account following Edmund’s resignation. As discussed above, only three of the Debit Notes related to loans from SDPL. Payment on the remaining six of the Debit Notes was therefore wrongful.

  150. [99] As for the deductions for “drafting services” in the debit notes, I have found in favour of Edmund’s version of the Oral Agreement. There was therefore no basis for these deductions. In my view, the deductions for drafting services were just attempts by Patty made after the fact to support her allegation that under the Oral Agreement, SDPL and MOX were to reimburse SMSPL for use of SMSPL’s resources.

  151. Denial / obstruction of access to SMSPL’s financial documents

  152. [100] I accept Edmund’s evidence that he was denied and/or obstructed from having access to SMSPL’s financial documents. First, it is clear that Patty did not welcome Edmund’s requests for SMSPL’s accounts. In her email dated 8 August 2015 to Edmund, she said “we do not understand why you are requesting to see [SMSPL’s] accounts. In the last three (3) years, you never manage[d] the accounts at all”.

  153. [101] Second, on 23 or 24 July 2015, Patty showed Edmund three documents – a notice of an annual general meeting (“AGM”), directors’ resolution, and minutes of the AGM supposedly held on 30 June 2015. The minutes sought to adopt SMSPL’s accounts for 2014. Patty wanted Edmund to sign the documents but Edmund refused. Edmund claimed that he refused to sign because he asked for a copy of the 2014 accounts but was refused. I reject Patty’s denial that Edmund did not ask for the accounts. There is no reason why Edmund would have refused to sign the minutes otherwise. On 28 July 2015, Edmund sent an email to Patty, stating that he would not be able to sign the minutes as he had not received the 2014 accounts. Edmund also repeated his request for the 2014 accounts. On 5 August 2015, Edmund’s lawyers wrote to Patty seeking, among other things, copies of the company’s accounts for 2012 to date. In her oral testimony, Patty first claimed that SMSPL’s accounts were on the shelves and Edmund could help himself to them, only to subsequently admit that the 2014 accounts were not on the shelves and that she did not have them.

  154. [102] Third, Edmund also asked Nisha for certain documents. On 31 August 2015, Nisha emailed Edmund to get his lawyers to make a comprehensive list of what he wanted and send the list to Patty’s lawyers. Nisha admitted that her email was sent to Edmund on Patty’s instructions.

  155. [103] Fourth, on 5 October 2015, Edmund contacted Karen who refused to release any of SMSPL’s documents to him and instead referred him to Patty’s lawyers.

  156. [104] Fifth, on 9 October 2015, Edmund applied to the Court for inspection of SMSPL’s accounts in his capacity as director. SMSPL objected to the application on the ground that Edmund had an ulterior motive in seeking access to SMSPL’s accounts. Before the application could be heard, Edmund received notice of a directors’ meeting to be held on 17 December 2015 to consider, among other things, convening an EGM to remove Edmund as director. Edmund’s requests to adjourn the directors’ meeting and the EGM were not acceded to. Edmund then sought and obtained an injunction to restrain SMSPL and Patty from removing him as a director. On 25 January 2016, I granted Edmund’s application to inspect the company’s accounts. Patty’s conduct is clear evidence that Edmund was denied and/or obstructed from having access to SMSPL’s accounts.

  157. [105] Sixth, SMSPL’s finalised 2014 accounts were never produced, not even during the trial. I do not accept Patty’s assertion that she did not have the 2014 accounts for the following reasons:

  158. (a) Patty had asked Edmund to sign the minutes of AGM adopting these accounts.

  159. (b) Patty informed Jazz on 17 June 2015 that SMSPL had a profit of approximately $890,000 for 2014 after tax. Patty said that this figure was based on information from Shin and agreed that it must have been based on the finalised 2014 accounts.

  160. (c) Karen had filed SMSPL’s Annual Return on the basis that the 2014 accounts had been finalized and approved. Patty claimed that she was shocked. I find it quite unbelievable that SMSPL’s book-keeper would have filed the Annual Return without getting Patty’s confirmation on the accounts. SMSPL and Patty did not call Karen as a witness and I draw an adverse inference against them in this regard.

  161. (d) SMSPL’s notice of assessment dated 12 May 2015 disclosed an income of $948,368 for 2014. Patty agreed that the assessment could only have been prepared from an income statement given by SMSPL.

  162. (e) During the course of the trial, SMSPL produced a copy of SMSPL’s unaudited financial statement for 2014 and a set of several of SMSPL’s accounting documents for 2014. These were still not the finalised 2014 accounts. Even so, they were not given to Edmund earlier.

  163. [106] The 2014 accounts are relevant to several issues in this case. I find it most disturbing that SMSPL and Patty did not disclose the 2014 accounts and that even the unaudited financial statements for 2014 and several accounting documents for 2014 were only produced during the course of this trial.

  164. Claw-back of director’s fees and dividends

  165. [107] Edmund’s director’s fees and dividends for 2012 and 2013 were as follows:

  166. [108] Edmund thus received a total amount of $448,700.05. In this action, he is also claiming for the balance unpaid amounts of $265,000 (unpaid director’s fees for 2013) and $130,000 (unpaid dividends for 2013). SMSPL has counterclaimed the amount of $398,700.05 (comprising the director’s fee for 2012 and dividends for 2012 and 2013) that Edmund has received.

  167. [109] When Edmund notified Patty of his resignation on 13 July 2015, Patty wanted Edmund to return to SMSPL all the advances from SMSPL to him. Patty admitted to requiring Edmund to repay the total sum of the director’s fees and dividends that had been paid to him, amounting to $448,700.05.

  168. [110] SMSPL and Patty claimed that

  169. (a) the director’s fee paid to Edmund for 2012 was in fact a loan;

  170. (b) it was agreed on 22 June 2015 that with respect to Edmund’s director’s fee for 2013, the outstanding amount of $265,000 would be loaned to SMSPL; and

  171. (c) the declarations of dividends for 2012 and 2013 were made under a mistake of fact as to SMSPL’s profits.

  172. Edmund’s director’s fee for 2012

  173. [111] I reject SMSPL’s and Patty’s assertions that Edmund’s director’s fee for 2012 was in fact a loan to him.

  174. [112] First, Patty relied on the fact that the sum of $200,000 was described in SMSPL’s payment voucher as “Advanced Director Fee”. Patty argued that the word “advanced” meant it was a loan. In my view, this argument was contrived and unmeritorious. The payment voucher referred to a “director fee”. There was simply no reason why it could not have been described as a loan if it was intended to be a loan. Further, under cross-examination, Anita explained that this was not a loan but a director’s fee, paid to Edmund earlier than Patty or herself. Anita’s evidence is consistent with the fact that Patty and Anita received their respective payments of $50,000 each only in February 2014 and the payment vouchers clearly described the same as “director fees”. Edmund’s director’s fee had been paid to him earlier, in August 2013.

  175. [113] Second, even by Patty’s own account, around June 2013 when SMSPL’s 2012 accounts were closed, she was told by Karen that SMSPL could “take out” $300,000 as “director fees” if required. Subsequently, at an AGM held on 30 June 2013, the shareholders of SMSPL approved payment of $300,000 as directors’ fee for 2012, to Edmund ($200,000), Anita ($50,000) and Patty ($50,000). Even if Edmund had asked at the end of 2012 if he could have an advance (as Patty claimed), the fact remains that the $200,000 was approved as director’s fee for Edmund in June 2013 and paid to Edmund in August 2013 as director’s fee.

  176. [114] Third, the sum of $300,000 was charged as directors’ fee in SMSPL’s financial statements for 2012 which were signed by Patty.

  177. [115] Fourth, Edmund declared his receipt of $200,000 as director’s fees and paid tax on it. There was no reason for Edmund to do so if it was just a loan.

  178. [116] Fifth, Patty claimed that she met with Edmund and Anita on 3 November 2014 and they agreed that, among other things, Edmund would receive $150,000 which, together with his director’s fee of $200,000 for 2012, would allow him to recover his capital investment of $350,000 in SMSPL. In his email to Jazz dated the same day, Edmund informed Jazz that SMSPL would pay all the directors their “seeding money” and that he would receive $150,000 to add to the “$200,000 previous[ly] paid”. In my view, Patty treatment of the $200,000 as part of Edmund’s recovery of his capital investment confirmed that it could not have been a loan. It is completely illogical to treat the payment of $200,000 as part of Edmund’s return of his capital investment if that payment was a loan.

  179. [117] Sixth, in a message dated 17 June 2015 to Jazz, Patty stated the following:

  180. … for the record, Edmund got from the company so far for the director’s fee and company’s dividends for the last 2 years accounts (accounts for year ending 2012 & 2013) is quite a lot up [to] today (it is in excess of $400,000.00 to date.) Hope it goes to helping you guys pay the house mortgage or the rebuilding construction loan so that [you] guys do not have to shoulder the heavy weight [of] these loans…(sic)

  181. Clearly, in her message, Patty did not treat Edmund’s director’s fee for 2012 as a loan.

  182. [118] Seventh, in an email dated 8 August 2015 to Edmund, Patty referred to the $300,000 paid as directors’ fees for 2012 and took the position that since Edmund was paid $200,000 and Anita and she were only paid $50,000 each, therefore Edmund had taken an advance of $150,000. This statement is inconsistent with Patty’s present claim that the $200,000 was a loan. If the $200,000 paid to Edmund had been a loan (as Patty now claims), Patty would have simply taken that position in her email. In my view, Patty’s assertion of a loan (whether it was $150,000 or $200,000) was an afterthought.

  183. [119] In my judgment, the amount of $200,000 was paid to Edmund as director’s fee for 2012. Patty had no reason to ask Edmund to repay the amount to SMSPL.

  184. Edmund’s director’s fee for 2013

  185. [120] A total amount of $900,000 was approved as directors’ fees for 2013. This amount was also reflected in SMSPL’s Schedule of Expenses for 2013. The director’s fee for Patty was $405,000, Anita $180,000 and Edmund $315,000. Edmund received payment of $50,000 in January 2015 and Patty received payment of $100,000 in February 2015.

  186. [121] It is clear that a sum of $265,000 is due to Edmund in respect of his director’s fee for 2013. SMSPL and Patty pleaded that Edmund is not entitled to the balance as it had been agreed that the monies would be kept in SMSPL as working capital. I see no basis for SMSPL’s and Patty’s defences. Both have pleaded that the balance amount was to be loaned to SMSPL. Since no specific agreement as to its repayment has been pleaded, the loan must be repayable on demand.

  187. [122] SMSPL further pleaded that this sum should be set off against the alleged advance of $200,000 paid as director’s fee for 2012, and the dividends paid to Edmund for 2012 and 2013. I have held that the payment of $200,000 was not an advance but Edmund’s director’s fee for 2012. As for the dividends these are dealt with below.

  188. Payment of dividends for 2012

  189. [123] SMSPL’s financial statements for 2012, signed by Patty on 3 June 2013, showed a net profit of $139,967. A sum of $139,143 was declared as dividends for 2012 and paid in June 2015 to Patty ($62,614.35), Anita ($27,828.60) and Edmund ($48,700.05).

  190. [124] SMSPL and Patty now claim that the accounts have been reviewed after the commencement of this action, and after making adjustments and deducting tax, SMSPL in fact suffered a loss of $18,713.13 for 2012. SMSPL and Patty therefore say that the dividends for 2012 were wrongly declared and paid.

  191. [125] SMSPL and Patty pleaded the following adjustments to SMSPL’s accounts for 2012:

  192. (a) The revenue was reduced by $125,837.43. SMSPL pleaded that this amount was wrongly classified as revenue. However, it is not clear from the pleadings, AEICs or closing submissions, what this amount related to or why it was wrongly classified. Accordingly, I find that SMSPL and Patty have failed to prove that this adjustment was proper.

  193. (b) A sum of $315,118.54 was added to the revenue. This comprised charges to SDPL and MOX for use of SMSPL’s resources. As I have found in favour of Edmund’s version of the Oral Agreement, this adjustment was not justified.

  194. (c) A sum of $560,747.65, originally recorded as income, was recorded as a liability instead. The sum of $560,747.65 refers to the $600,000 (comprising $176,000 and $424,000) paid by SDPL to SMSPL, after removing the GST. SMSPL and Patty claimed that these were loans from SDPL. I have found (at [51] above) that these were indeed loans from SDPL. The adjustment was therefore justified.

  195. (d) A sum of $203,430.71, originally recorded as income, was recorded as expenses instead. These were expenses (including salaries for SMSPL’s employees) which SDPL paid on behalf of SMSPL before SMSPL opened a bank account. Edmund did not dispute this. This adjustment was justified.

  196. (e) The sum of $300,000 originally recorded as an expense, was recorded as advances instead. This was based on the allegation that this amount was not paid as directors’ fees but as advances to the directors. I have found that the amount was not paid as advances but as directors’ fees. The adjustment was therefore not justified.

  197. Patty pleaded additional adjustments for freight and handling charges ($8,021.28) and sub-contractors’ fees ($34,937.80). As no evidence was adduced to substantiate these, I find that Patty has not proved that these additional adjustments were justified.

  198. [126] Patty’s reliance on the pleaded grounds for the adjustments to SMSPL’s accounts for 2012 was not justified save for two adjustments involving $560,747.65 and $203,430.71 in (c) and (d) above. In the circumstances, Patty did not act in good faith when she insisted that Edmund returned the dividends received by him for 2012.

  199. [127] The adjustments involving $560,747.65 and $203,430.71 in (c) and (d) above are to be made to the original accounts of SMSPL for 2012. In addition, as I have found in favour of Edmund’s version of the Oral Agreement, all fees in respect of MOX’s and SDPL’s pre-incorporation projects which were collected based on invoices in 2012 (after the Incorporation Date) have to be included as part of SMSPL’s revenue for 2012. Fees from SDPL’s pre-incorporation projects that are set out in Annex A of the statement of claim, are dealt with in [148] and [149] below. Further, fees collected by SDPL in 2012 in respect of post-incorporation projects (see Annex B of the statement of claim and [157] below) will also have to be added to SMSPL’s revenue for 2012.

  200. [128] Whether there were sufficient profits in 2012 to support the dividends declared will only be known after adjustments have been made to SMSPL’s accounts for 2012 to give effect to the findings in this case. All fees in respect of MOX’s and SDPL’s pre-incorporation projects which have been paid pursuant to invoices issued in 2012 after the Incorporation Date have to be included as part of SMSPL’s revenue for 2012. To the extent that the profits are insufficient to support the dividends declared, the respective shareholders will have to return either all or part (proportionally) of the dividends received by each of them.

  201. Payment of dividends for 2013

  202. [129] SMSPL’s financial statements for 2013, signed by Patty on 3 June 2013, showed a net profit of $898,989. Patty’s case is that in February 2014, Shin advised her that SMSPL could “take out” a sum of about $1.7m – $1.8m for 2013. She then met with Edmund and Anita and they agreed that $900,000 would be paid as directors’ fees and $800,000 would be declared as dividends. In November 2014, Anita was paid dividends of $200,000, Edmund $150,000 and Patty $450,000. Edmund claimed that his 35% share of the dividends amounted to $280,000 and there is therefore a sum of $130,000 still owing to him as dividends for 2013.

  203. [130] Patty claimed that she met with Edmund and Anita on 3 November 2014 and they agreed that the sum of $800,000 would be distributed as follows:

  204. (a) $150,000 to Edmund. Together with his director’s fee of $200,000 for 2012, this would allow Edmund to recover his capital investment of $350,000 in SMSPL;

  205. (b) $450,000 to Patty to allow her to recover her capital investment of $450,000 in SMSPL; and

  206. (c) $200,000 to Anita to allow her to recover her capital investment of $200,000 in SMSPL.

  207. This meeting was referred to earlier in [116] above.

  208. [131] Patty’s claim is supported by an email dated 3 November 2014 from Edmund to Jazz in which Edmund said:

  209. [132] Edmund’s email referred to the directors’ fee of $900,000. I do not think that the reference to directors’ fees instead of dividends, is material. It is not disputed that Edmund received $150,000 as dividends in November 2014 and $50,000 in January 2015 as payment of part of his director’s fee for 2013. Patty received $450,000 in dividends for 2013 and Anita received $200,000. I agree with Patty that the three shareholders of SMSPL had agreed to the distribution of dividends as set out in [130] above. In the circumstances, Edmund is not entitled to any further dividends for 2013.

  210. [133] Next, as with the dividends for 2012, SMSPL and Patty now claim that after making adjustments to its accounts, SMSPL’s profits were $575,952 and thus the dividends amounting to $800,000 for 2013 were wrongly declared and paid.

  211. [134] SMSPL and Patty pleaded the following adjustments to SMSPL’s accounts for 2013:

  212. (a) A sum of $259,980, originally classified as revenue, was recorded as a liability instead. The sum of $259,980 is the total of five invoices (SM-2013-038 to 041 and SM-2013-066) which form part of the $719,652.02 referred to in [56] above, after removing the GST. SMSPL and Patty claimed that these were loans from SDPL. I have found (at [67] above) that these were payment of fees collected from SDPL’s pre-incorporation projects and not loans. This adjustment is therefore not justified.

  213. (b) A sum of $237,537.15, originally classified as revenue, was wrongly classified. However, it is not clear from the pleadings, AEICs or closing submissions, what this amount related to or why it was wrongly classified. Accordingly, I find that SMSPL has failed to prove that this adjustment was proper.

  214. (c) A sum of $307,067.18 was added to the revenue. This comprised charges to SDPL and MOX for use of SMSPL’s resources. As I have found in favour of Edmund’s version of the Oral Agreement, this adjustment was not justified.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.