Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 19 Mar 2019
Contents

High Court

Re CNA Group Ltd

Feedback & support

[2019] SGHC 78Case no. Originating Summons No 658 of 2015(Summons No 655 of 2019)4 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [2] The Company was incorporated in Singapore on 26 January 1990 as a private limited company. It was subsequently listed on the Singapore Exchange (SESDAQ) in March 2005, and thereafter on the Singapore Stock Exchange (Mainboard) in September 2007. The Company’s business was in the provision, design and implementation of integrated control and automation systems, information technology solutions for buildings and facilities as well as mechanical engineering solutions.

  2. [3] On 13 July 2015, the Company filed the application in this Originating Summons for the Company to be placed under judicial management to achieve one or more of the following purposes:

  3. (a) the survival of the Company, or the whole or part of its undertaking as a going concern;

  4. (b) the approval under section 210 of a compromise or arrangement between the Company and any such persons as are mentioned in that section; and

  5. (c) a more advantageous realization of the Company’s assets than would be effected on a winding up.

  6. [4] On 21 July 2015, the Court appointed interim judicial managers pursuant to an application by the Company in Summons No 3380 of 2015.

  7. (a) to sell the Company’s shares in an Australian listed company known as Urbanise.com;

  8. (b) to liquidate the Company’s dormant subsidiaries, and to sell/liquidate the Company’s operating subsidiaries;

  9. (c) to deal with arbitration proceedings against the Company in Dubai (“the Dubai Proceedings”);

  10. (d) to deal with arbitration proceedings commenced by the judicial managers in Qatar (“the Qatar Proceedings”); and

  11. (e) to negotiate with potential investors who were interested in effecting a reverse take-over of the Company.

  12. (a) The sale of the shares in Urbanise.com was not yet completed.

  13. (b) The Company’s former subsidiary in Vietnam (“CNAV”) was sold in November 2015. As part of the terms of the sale, CNAV was to repay an intercompany loan due to the Company. An SGD bank account was being opened in Vietnam to enable remittance of the balance amount that was outstanding.

  14. (c) The Dubai Proceedings and Qatar Proceedings were not yet resolved.

  15. (a) The shares in Urbanise.com had not been sold because of the low price and low trading volume of the shares.

  16. (b) The repayment by CNAV of the intercompany loan was pending approval from the State Bank of Vietnam for remittance to the Company.

  17. (c) The Dubai Proceedings were still pending.

  18. (d) The Company had reached a settlement in relation to the Qatar Proceedings but the benefits of the settlement had not been received.

  19. (e) The Implementation Agreement with SCR had been terminated by mutual agreement because it was unlikely that SCR could satisfy the conditions precedent within the intended timeline. However, the judicial managers had entered a memorandum of understanding (“MOU”) with Munsang Media and Printing Group Ltd (“the Munsang Group”) and OSC Group Pte Ltd on 3 March 2017 for the possible transfer of the Company’s listing status or the transfer of ownership of the Company to the investors. The judicial managers had also obtained an extension of time until 15 July 2017 from SGX-ST for the submission of the Resumption Proposal.

  20. (a) The judicial managers were in negotiations with potential buyers for the shares in Urbanise.com.

  21. (b) CNAV failed to pay the balance of the intercompany loan and the judicial managers were in negotiations with the purchasers of CNAV.

  22. (c) The Dubai Proceedings were resolved but receipt of the balance payment pursuant to the settlement of the Qatar Proceedings was pending clearance of withholding tax.

  23. (d) The judicial managers had terminated the MOU with the Munsang Group because due diligence suggested that the Munsang Group may not be suitable. However, in April and May 2017, the judicial managers had received expressions of interest in the Company’s listing status, from De Run International Resources (“De Run”) and Treasure Capital Group (“Treasure”). Treasure represented a group of Malaysian investors. In early July 2017, De Run withdrew as it was unable to meet the judicial manager’s deadline of 15 July 2017 (which was the deadline for the Company to submit the Resumption Proposal). On 13 July 2017, the Company entered into an Implementation Agreement with the Malaysian investors. On 14 July 2017, the judicial managers submitted an application to SGX-ST to further extend the deadline for submission of the Resumption Proposal, to 15 July 2018.

  24. [14] On 5 March 2019, I heard the Company’s application. The Company’s solicitor informed me that on 22 February 2019, Berlitz had also withdrawn from proceeding further. According to the Company’s solicitor, the judicial manager was now following up with two other potential investors.

  25. (a) it is satisfied that the company is or will be unable to pay its debts; and