Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 22 Dec 2020
Contents

High Court

New Ping Ping Pauline v Eng’s Noodles House Pte Ltd and others

Feedback & support

[2020] SGHC 271Case no. Suit No 20 of 2019

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] Mr Ng Ba Eng (“Mr Ng”) ran a successful wanton mee hawker stall at Dunman Street that had a strong following and from 2002, won many awards. In 2009, his son (the second defendant, hereinafter called “Desmond”) joined him at the stall. Around 2012, they were approached by a businessman customer, Jason, who proposed a collaboration. After successful negotiations, the first defendant (“the Company”) was incorporated on 27 February 2012 and father and son commenced operations from the Company’s new premises at Tanjong Katong Road. Pauline, Jason’s wife and the plaintiff in this action, and Desmond were the sole shareholders and directors of the Company.

  3. [2] Mr Ng passed away in 2013. The Company continued to prosper but the relationships between the partners started to deteriorate. In 2018, following a fall-out between the business partners, the Company failed to secure the renewal of the lease of its operating premises, and the business of the Company came to a standstill. These premises were eventually taken over by a new business called “Eng’s Wantan Noodle Pte. Ltd.” (“Eng’s Wantan Noodle”). In this common law derivative action and counterclaim, the Ng family and Pauline lock horns over Mr Ng’s legacy.

  4. Facts

  5. The parties and their claims

  6. [3] Mr Ng’s father first sold wanton mee from a pushcart in the Duku Road vicinity. Mr Ng helped his father from a very young age and learned the skills of the trade under his father’s tutelage. Mr Ng carried on the business after his father retired in 1976. Later, when street hawkers were reorganized into hawker centres, he moved to a hawker stall in Dunman Food Centre and continued his business there (“the Hawker Business”). Desmond assisted Mr Ng at the stall from 2009.

  7. [4] In early 2012, Jason approached Mr Ng with a business proposal to expand the Hawker Business. The Company was incorporated on 27 February 2012 with a share capital of $2, with the plaintiff (“Pauline”) and Desmond each initially holding 50% of the shares in the Company. Pauline and Desmond were also the directors of the company at the point of incorporation. Desmond employed the third defendant (“Bill”), an employee at one of Jason’s companies, to assist with managing the Company’s finances. Following the issuance of additional shares on 12 August 2015, Pauline and Desmond each had their shareholdings reduced to 47.5% and Bill was given 5% of the shareholding.

  8. [5] The Company ceased business operations on 28 February 2018. Pauline was removed as a director on 8 June 2018 . Desmond resigned as a director on 9 July 2018. Bill is presently the only director of the Company, having assumed directorship on 8 June 2018.

  9. [6] In this action, Pauline contends Bill and Desmond have breached their fiduciary duties to the Company. Desmond concedes he has such duties but denies any breach of them. Bill denies having any fiduciary duties prior to his becoming a director. Pauline’s case is that Bill was vested with such duties as a “senior employee”. Bill and Desmond, together with the other defendants, are also accused of conspiring to injure the Company by setting up a competing business. This competing business is the sixth defendant, Eng’s Char Siew Wantan Mee Pte Ltd (“Eng’s Char Siew”), which was incorporated on 5 March 2018 by Desmond’s sisters, the fourth and fifth defendants (“Mui Hong” and “Mei Ling” respectively). Mui Hong and Mei Ling each hold 50% of the shares in Eng’s Char Siew and have been the sole directors of Eng’s Char Siew since its incorporation. Pauline contends that Eng’s Char Siew was set up as part of a conspiracy to injure the first defendant.

  10. [7] In this context, Pauline brings a common law derivative action, claiming that

  11. (a) the defendants (save for the Company) have conspired to injure the Company by setting up Eng’s Char Siew;

  12. (b) Desmond and/or Bill has/have breached his/their fiduciary duties to the Company;

  13. (c) Desmond and/or Bill has/have breached his/their duties under s 157 of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed) (“the Companies Act”); and that

  14. (d) Bill had misappropriated monies from the Company (“the Misappropriation claim”).

  15. The Misappropriation claim was eventually withdrawn on the tenth day of trial.

  16. [8] Mui Hong, Mei Ling and Eng’s Char Siew, in turn, counterclaim that Pauline has committed the tort of passing off (“the Counterclaim”). They contend that Pauline and Jason are associated with Eng’s Wantan Noodle, and helped set up its first outlet at the former premises of the Company. In doing so, Pauline and Jason, whom Bill regards as the “shadow plaintiff” and whom Desmond, Mui Hong and Mei Ling regard as the “real plaintiff” of this suit, have both allegedly , “stolen the family business”. Neither Jason nor Eng’s Wantan Noodle have been joined in the Counterclaim.

  17. Background to the dispute

  18. [9] Broadly speaking, the history of this dispute may be divided into four time periods:

  19. (a) First, the period prior to the incorporation of the Company. This period was crucial to the development of the goodwill associated with the Company that forms the basis for the Counterclaim.

  20. (b) Second, the period spanning the incorporation of the company and the years of good, dispute-free business which the Company enjoyed. This period is crucial to understanding the initial agreement between the parties at the time of incorporation, their respective roles and remuneration within the Company, and in particular, the role that Bill played in the company (ie, whether he had been vested with fiduciary duties or not).

  21. (c) Third, the period which saw the relationship between the business partners (ie, Pauline and Desmond) deteriorate. Pauline claims that the conspiracy to injure the Company was incepted and executed during this period. This conspiracy is, in turn, the lynchpin of Pauline’s common law derivative action as she complains that the conspiracy amounts to a fraud on the minority.

  22. (d) Fourth, the period directly preceding and immediately after the Company ceased business. This period offers further insight into the conspiracy complained of, and also whether Pauline and Jason had themselves, attempted to appropriate the Company’s business for their own purposes.

  23. [10] With this in mind, I turn to the facts.

  24. Pre-incorporation

  25. [11] The Hawker Business began its operations on the first floor of the Dunman Food Centre before subsequently moving to the basement. The stall in the basement (“the Dunman Stall”) bore a white signboard with the English words “Eng’s Char Siew Wan Ton Mee” in blue and the Chinese characters “榮高叉燒雲吞麵” in red. These trade names (together, “the Original Tradenames”) were at all times prominently displayed on the signboard at the Dunman Stall:

  26. Figure 1: The Original Tradenames

  27. [12] Business was brisk and the stall’s wanton mee gained many admirers. The Hawker Business won many accolades, including the South East District Food Awards in 2002 and an “Excellent” rating from Makansutra (a local food reviewing website) in 2003. Mr Ng himself was later anointed a “hawker master” in 2011 by the Straits Times and Lianhe Zaobao (the local English and Chinese broadsheets respectively).

  28. [13] The cooking was shouldered primarily by Mr Ng. Mr Ng was “the walking brand” , “the one who [won] all the award[s]” and the “main thing that people will come to the shop [for]”. From 2009, Desmond assisted him at the stall daily by helping to cook, collecting takings and tending to customers. The rest of the family played various supporting roles: Mui Hong, assisting with publicity; Mei Kuen (Mr Ng’s eldest daughter), “simple bookkeeping” and helping Mr Ng file tax returns; Mei Ling, Desmond’s wife (“Ah Keat”) and Desmond’s mother (“Mdm Loh”), wrapping the wantons and cutting chillis.

  29. Incorporation of the Company and employment of Bill

  30. [14] In or around early 2012, Jason approached Mr Ng with a business proposal to expand the Hawker Business. No written records document the eventual agreement between the parties. It is common ground between the parties that (a) Jason advanced a sum of $150,000 as part of the agreement, (b) there had been substantial goodwill built up by the Hawker Business prior to the incorporation of the Company, (c) the subject of trademarks, goodwill or tradenames was not discussed when the Company was being incorporated, and (d) there was no written licensing agreement for any trademarks or tradenames.

  31. [15] Pursuant to this agreement, the Company was incorporated on 27 February 2012 with Pauline and Desmond each initially holding 50% of the shares in the Company. Bill, then an employee in Jason Parquet Specialist Pte Ltd (“JPS”), joined the Company to assist with its accounts and finances. There is no dispute that Bill was paid approximately $1,500 per month as an employee of the company and received 5% of the profits at year-end. It is however disputed whether this was as part of a profit-sharing agreement or from his 5% shareholding in the Company.

  32. [16] The Company began business at its new premises at 287 Tanjong Katong Road Singapore 437070 (“the 287 Premises”) around May 2012. Desmond was the formal tenant under the tenancy agreement for these premises (“the 287 Tenancy Agreement), but there was an express clause in the lease that stated that the premises were for the business of the Company (ie. Eng’s Noodles House Pte Ltd). There was also a renewal clause that entitled the tenant (Desmond) to write to the landlord three months before the expiry date of the tenancy (15 March 2018), to seek a renewal of the lease at a “rent to be agreed, or based on the prevailing market rent but otherwise containing the like conditions, covenants and stipulations as [we]re [t]herein contained with the exception of th[at] option for renewal” (“the Option to Renew”).

  33. [17] The 287 Premises used two signboards (respectively, “the Top 287 Signboard” and “the Bottom 287 Signboard”; and collectively, “the 287 Signboards”):

  34. Figure 2: The Top 287 Signboard

  35. Figure 3: The Bottom 287 Signboard

  36. [18] The Top 287 Signboard stated “Eng’s Char Siew Wantan Mee”, accompanied by the Chinese characters “榮高叉燒雲吞麵”. The look and get-up of this signboard, however, was different from the Original Tradenames and signboard used at the Dunman Stall in at least three regards.

  37. [19] First, the colour scheme was different. The “Eng’s” used in the Original Tradenames was blue against a white background. It was accompanied by the Chinese characters (“榮高叉燒雲吞麵”) in red and the English words “Char Siew Wan Ton Mee” in black. In contrast, the Top 287 Signboard had the English words “Eng’s Char Siew Wantan Mee” in green, inscribed against a background with a yellow-white gradient. Second, the words were different too. The Top 287 Signboard used the words “Char Siew Wantan Mee” (different from “Char Siew Wan Ton Mee” [see Figure 1]) and these words were in bold on the new signboard as well. There were also, at first glance, some difference in the kerning of the words, although the visual evidence made these distinctions difficult to discern. The same, red Chinese characters (“榮高叉燒雲吞麵”) were used too. But the font used in the Original Tradenames was different, evoking a more calligraphic style as opposed to that used in the Top 287 Signboard. Third, the Top 287 Signboard had a picture of the noodles (on the left side of the board) and a small graphical representation of two chillies at the bottom right corner of the board. These were not present on the signboard at the Dunman Stall.

  38. [20] The Bottom 287 Signboard was materially similar to the Top 287 Signboard save for two differences. First, it did not have the chilli designs and second, the English words used were “Eng’s Noodles House Char Siew Wantan Mee” instead.

  39. [21] When business at the Company began, Desmond and Mr Ng did most of the cooking. It took between seven and nine months to train the staff and put the operational systems in place for the business to run on “autopilot”. After training the staff to cook, Desmond and Mr Ng stepped back from the kitchen work, transferring to the more customer facing “frontline”. Mr Ng however, continued the “supervising of all those [sic] kitchen backend”, even as most of the “hands-on” work was done by the staff. As for the others, Mei Ling worked the till while Ah Keat and Mdm Loh wrapped the wantons. Bill only worked at the Company on a part-time basis handling the accounts, and some administrative matters (such as liaising with the property agent). Their jobs scopes and responsibilities did not change over the years.

  40. [22] Regarding salaries, Mr Ng was initially paid $5,000/month; Desmond, $5,000/month; Mei Ling, $2,000/month; Ah Keat, $1,200/month; Pauline, $1,500/month; Bill, $1,500/month and Mdm Loh, $500/month.

  41. [23] Mr Ng drew his last paycheck in June 2013. He passed away on 17 June 2013, from a sudden heart attack. Following this, Mdm Loh’s monthly pay, which was $1,050 in June 2013, was increased to $3,500 in July and August, and from September, $3,600. Desmond’s monthly pay was increased from $5,000 to $5,500. The reason for these increments is a matter of dispute and relevant to the Counterclaim (see below at [135]). The Company’s profitability increased steadily after Mr Ng passed away, but the relationships between parties started to decline.

  42. Deterioration of relationship between Pauline, Jason and Bill

  43. [25] On 1 September 2015, the Company’s registered address was changed through a directors’ resolution to 30 Simon Lane Singapore 546048. This was Bill’s residential address. Prior to the change in address, the Company’s registered address was 16 Tampines Street 92 JP Building Singapore 528873 (“the JPS Address”). This was the corporate address of JPS, the company where Bill used to work. The reasons for this change in registered address are disputed as well (see below at [79]).

  44. [26] Jason and Pauline contend that sometime in 2016 they discovered that they had been duped into helping Bill acquire a 5% share in the Company. They asked for the shares to be returned. Matters continued to escalate. According to Bill, Jason and Pauline took the Company’s documents on 20 January 2017, preventing the Company from filing its annual returns for 2016 and 2017, and incurring approximately $900 worth of filing/penalty fees imposed by the Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority. Pauline filed a police report against Bill alleging financial misappropriation on 12 February 2018. The Company meanwhile filed a suit for the return of its documents, which were then retrieved on 2 November 2018, after a settlement was reached between the parties.

  45. Deterioration of relationship between Pauline, Jason and Desmond

  46. [27] In 2015, Jason fell into financial trouble arising from problems with Jason Holdings, the parent company of JPS. Desmond claimed that around August 2015, Jason had asked him to purchase $120,000 of shares in Jason Holdings, saying this was to be treated as a loan and repaid within two to three days. According to Desmond, Jason did not repay the amount and the shares are only worth around $750 today. Desmond also contends that Pauline and Jason began picking fights with him about the Company. Matters were so heated that at one point, in a WhatsApp message dated 14 November 2016, Desmond expressed his wish to “clos[e] down the shop” and requested that Bill inform Pauline and Jason.

  47. [28] Mui Hong, aware of the deteriorating relationship between the Company’s directors, registered a sole proprietorship on 8 February 2017 “in anticipation of having [an] avenue to carry on the business” (“the Sole Proprietorship”). Later, she also registered a composite mark (“the Chilli Mark”) comprising the words “Eng’s”, the Chinese characters “荣高” and the chilli logo that was mentioned above at [20]. This was registered on 3 October 2017 under the Sole Proprietorship:

  48. Figure 4: The Chilli Mark

  49. [29] In a bid to “settle all the outstanding dispute [sic] and unhappiness and also to avoid causing any inconvenience to the shop in future”, Desmond, in a WhatsApp message dated 31 May 2017, offered to buy out Pauline’s shares for $350,000. Jason did not take up this offer.

  50. [30] Mei Ling and Desmond said that by 2018, Jason and Pauline were “pushing [the Ng family] to franchise the Family Wantan Mee Business, which was never [the Ng family’s] intention”. They contended that the pressure to franchise the business had been part of Jason’s attempt to raise money to pay off his debts.

  51. Cessation of the Company’s business and aftermath

  52. [31] The lease for the 287 Premises was due to expire on 15 March 2018. Pursuant to the renewal clause in the 287 Tenancy Agreement, negotiations had commenced with the landlord for the renewal of the lease. In fact, the lease was still available for renewal as late as 1 January 2018. Eventually, Desmond and the landlord reached an agreement on a rental price for the subsequent lease term.

  53. [32] Notwithstanding this, on 8 January 2018, Bill conveyed to the real estate agent, Jane, that Desmond wanted Pauline to sign the lease and that Jane should arrange with Pauline to sign the lease. Pauline, when informed of this, professed surprise and confusion (“I have no idea abt the lease term and the files are all with [Bill]”).

  54. [33] Bill and Desmond did not hear from Pauline or Jane after 8 January and became suspicious that they had “lost the shop”. Mei Ling, on her part, observed that Jason had been speaking to the head chef at the Company, coming to take measurements of the kitchen specifications after working hours and scrutinising the company accounts. Mui Hong’s suspicions were aroused as well. Desmond shared his sisters’ trepidation and became convinced that the lease for the 287 Premises “was being stolen”.

  55. [34] On 24 January 2018, Desmond’s lawyers wrote to Pauline seeking her cooperation in winding up the Company, citing a “collapse of trust and confidence in the partnership”. On the same day, Bill sent an email to Jane (“the 24 January 2018 Email”) informing her that “Eng’s Noodles House Pte Ltd will not be renew [sic] the tenancy agreement after the expired [sic] of the lease term (ie. 15 March 2018)”. It was also stated in that email that they would be making “arrangement to find a new tenant to lease the same place with the agreement rental of $8,800 per month for the next 3 years periods [sic]”. There was no reply from Jane. On 31 January 2018, Bill followed up with another email instructing Jane to “prepare a tenancy agreement and put the new tenant” as one Mr Chew Chye Sin Richard (“Richard”). Jane replied on 1 February 2018 that a new tenant had already been secured for the 287 Premises.

  56. [35] The Company’s business ceased on 28 February 2018.

  57. [36] Eng’s Wantan Noodle (the new tenant of the 287 Premises) was incorporated on the same day. It then applied to register three marks (collectively, “the Franchise Marks”):

  58. (a) the 1st Franchise Mark, identified by Trade Mark No. 40201815221W, was registered on 3 August 2018;

  59. (b) the 2nd Franchise Mark, identified by Trade Mark No. 40201815222U, was registered on 3 August 2018 as well; and

  60. (c) the 3rd Franchise Mark, identified by Trade Mark No. 40201920188T, was registered on 17 September 2019.

  61. (1st Franchise Mark)

  62. (2nd Franchise Mark)

  63. (3rd Franchise Mark)

  64. Figure 5: The Franchise Marks

  65. [37] The Ng family contended that Pauline and Jason were assisting Eng’s Wantan Noodle, which set up its first franchise outlet at the Company’s former address. The following facts are undisputed. First, Jason owes one Thomas Hong (“Thomas”) some $1.46 million. In fact, Thomas successfully sued Jason for the said sum and default judgment was entered against Jason on 30 September 2016. Second, The same lawyers who represented Thomas in Suit 986 of 2016, represent Pauline in the present suit. Third, Thomas Hong is involved with the Lao Huo Tang Group, although his precise level of involvement is uncertain. Fourth, sometime around early 2018, Jason introduced Thomas to the real estate agent who was securing a new tenant for the 287 Premises and was later “heavily involved in the renovation of the [first outlet of Eng’s Wantan Noodle]” (which took over the 287 Premises).

  66. [38] By the time of trial, Eng’s Wantan Noodle had expanded to multiple franchise outlets across the island.

  67. [39] As for the Company, Pauline was removed from directorship on 8 June 2018 while Desmond resigned on 9 July 2018. Bill became a director on 8 June 2018. Desmond eventually brought proceedings attempting to wind up the Company on 20 March 2018. Desmond’s attempt to wind up the company was resisted by Pauline and he later withdrew his application on 7 May 2018. The Company continues to subsist, but has no business whatsoever.

  68. [40] In the meantime, Mui Hong incorporated a new company, Eng’s Char Siew, on 5 March 2018. This was owned in equal parts by Mei Ling and Mui Hong. The sisters have been the sole directors of Eng’s Char Siew since its incorporation. She assigned the Chilli Mark to Eng’s Char Siew on 5 March 2018, and applied for it to be formally transferred to Eng’s Char Siew on 6 August 2018.

  69. [41] Following this, Mui Hong registered three marks (collectively, “the Name Marks”) under Eng’s Char Siew:

  70. (a) the 1st Name Mark, identified by Trade Mark No. 40201811254U, was registered on 19 October 2018;

  71. (b) the 2nd Name Mark, identified by Trade Mark No. 40201814979U, was registered on 30 November 2018; and

  72. (c) the 3rd Name Mark, identified by Trade Mark No. 40201814978P, was registered on 14 December 2018.

  73. (1st Name Mark)

  74. (2nd Name Mark)

  75. (3rd Name Mark)

  76. Figure 6: The Name Marks

  77. [42] Pauline brought her claim on 14 January 2019, followed by notices of opposition to the three Name Marks registered by Eng’s Char Siew on 19 February 2019, 28 March 2019 and 11 April 2019. She also applied to invalidate the Chilli Mark on 4 October 2019.

  78. Issues to be determined

  79. [43] Arising out of these facts, Pauline contends that Desmond, Bill, Mui Hong, Mei Ling and Eng’s Char Siew were in a conspiracy to injure the Company and that Desmond and Bill had breached their fiduciary duties to the Company in the process. She therefore brought a common law derivative action on behalf of the Company. The defendants deny her narrative, and contend, in their defence, that it was Pauline who failed to renew the lease for the Company’s benefit, and Pauline who acted to the Company’s detriment. Moreover, Pauline did not seek any leave to bring a common law derivative action. The defendants attempted to strike out the action and failed; they nonetheless submit that this action could be dismissed at trial for lack of leave. The claim therefore brings the following issues to the fore:

  80. (a) whether leave is required for the continuance of a common law derivative action, and if so, whether the action should be dismissed for lack of leave at this stage of proceedings;

  81. (b) whether there was a conspiracy between the defendants to injure the company;

  82. (c) whether Desmond and Bill had breached their fiduciary duties to the Company; and

  83. (d) related to findings on (b) and (c), whether a common law derivative action is made out on behalf of the Company.

  84. [44] The Counterclaim brought by Mui Hong, Mei Ling and Eng’s Char Siew arises out of the various defendants’ defence that it was Pauline who was collaborating with Eng’s Wantan Noodle. The main issue is whether Pauline, through these acts of collusion with Eng’s Wantan Noodle, has committed the tort of passing off against Mui Hong, Mei Ling and Eng’s Char Siew.

  85. [45] I deal with these five issues in turn.

  86. Is leave required for the continuance of a common law derivative action?

  87. [46] Pauline’s claim is premised on a common law derivative action that was commenced and continued without any leave being sought from the court. A distinction should be drawn between the common law derivative action and its statutory counterpart under s 216A of the Companies Act, where statute requires the obtaining of leave prior to the commencement of any suit. There is no applicable statutory rule in the case of a common law derivative action. Pauline’s position is that leave was not necessary. The defendants, on their part, contend that such leave is necessary but in the present case, trial is necessary to decide the issue. They saw the issue as one to be decided at the end of trial. The issues, therefore, are: (a) whether leave was necessary; and (b) if so, what stage is its consideration appropriate?

  88. Is leave required?

  89. [47] In Oates v Consolidated Capital Services Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 183 (“Oates”), the issue of whether leave was required for the commencement of a common law derivative action was considered by the Court of Appeal of New South Wales (see [71] – [107]). After a survey of the cases and the historical development of the derivative action, the court concluded that there was no requirement to seek leave prior to the commencement of a common law derivative action (see [105]). Campbell JA appeared to assume, however, that leave was required for the continuance of such actions. At [99] and [100], he highlighted O 15 r 12A of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1965 (UK) (added pursuant to the Rules of the Supreme Court (Amendment) 1994) which required a plaintiff to apply for leave to continue an action.

  90. [48] In Sinwa SS (HK) Co Ltd v Nordic International Ltd and another [2016] SGHC 111 (“Sinwa Nordic”) Steven Chong J (as he then was) referred to Oates, observing at [37]:

  91. This recognised that there is no procedural requirement for leave before a plaintiff commences a common law derivative action. The same paragraph explains that the court would thereafter decide the issue of locus standi. Referencing Oates, there can be no doubt that such decision as to locus standi was to be upon an application for leave. This explains Chong J’s view at [38] that “nonetheless leave of court was required to proceed with the common law derivative action in Nordic International’s name via arbitration” [italics in original; emphasis added in bold]. The Court of Appeal also considered the issue of leave sought in a preliminary trial of issues in Ting Sing Ning v Ting Chek Swee [2008] SLR(R) 197, although no argument and therefore discussion was made of its necessity. No doubt parties there, as did Chong J in Sinwa Nordic at [37], considered the matter “well-established”.

  92. [49] The same position was adopted by Margaret Chew, Minority Shareholders’ Rights and Remedies (LexisNexis, 3rd Ed, 2017), at para 3.012 (“Minority Shareholders”):

  93. [50] The above text reminds us that a common law derivative action is a departure from the proper plaintiff rule. It further points us to the rationale behind the necessity for the plaintiff to obtain a grant of leave from the court. In Foss v Harbottle (1843) 2 Hare 461; 67 ER 189, the Court mandated that injury to the company be pursued by the company. The plaintiff acting in her representative capacity must establish the locus standi that justifies such a departure. Therefore, while leave is not necessary for the commencement of an action, it is necessary for the continued pursuance of the action.

  94. When should leave be sought?

  95. [51] Leave being necessary, how and when should it be sought? Minority Shareholders at para 3.013 suggested the use of two provisions of the Rules of Court (Cap 322, R 5, 2014 Rev Ed) (“the Rules of Court”): (a) O 33 r 2 for plaintiff; and (b) O 18 r 19 for the defendant:

  96. [52] Pauline did not file, at any stage, any application under O 33 r 2 of the Rules of Court, or otherwise to seek leave to continue the action. Despite Pauline’s primary position that that such leave was not necessary, Pauline’s counsel suggested orally – and in my view too casually – if leave was indeed necessary as a legal requirement, that I grant leave on the first day of trial. No formal application had been made, nor was this issue mentioned in his written opening statement.

  97. [53] As for Bill and the Company, they made an application to strike out or stay the action on account of the lack of leave (“the O 18 r 19 application”). This was heard by an Assistant Registrar (“the AR”) and dismissed, on 24 April 2019. Bill and the Company did not appeal from the decision of the AR. Notwithstanding the AR’s dismissal of the O 18 r 19 application, their counsel (“Mr Ong”) took the view that a plaintiff continued to be under an obligation to obtain leave – “a request […] that must be made and pleaded even at the end of the matter.” This, he argued, was the plaintiff’s (continuing) burden, and to be undertaken through O 33 r 2 of the Rules of Court. In that regard, he drew a distinction between a plaintiff’s application for leave under O 33 r 2, and a defendant’s application to strike out, under O 18 r 19. The former, it was argued, would result in a final declaration that the plaintiff had leave, whereas the latter was adjudicated on the basis of the pleadings and thus could not be determinative of the matter. He therefore drew the conclusion that, at the end of trial, if no reasons for leave were disclosed on the facts on a balance of probabilities, the action could then be dismissed on that basis. Leave, in other words, could be addressed at the end of trial.

  98. [56] I turn, then, to the main claim.

  99. Conspiracy to injure by unlawful means

  100. [57] In EFT Holdings, Inc and another v Marinteknik Shipbuilders (S) Pte Ltd and another [2014] 1 SLR 860 at [112] (“EFT Holdings”), the Court of Appeal set out the legal elements necessary for establishing the tort of unlawful means conspiracy:

  101. (a) there must be a combination of two or more persons to do certain acts (“the Combination requirement”);

  102. (b) the acts must have been performed in furtherance of the agreement (“the Furtherance requirement”);

  103. (c) the acts must be unlawful (“the Unlawfulness requirement”);

  104. (d) the alleged conspirators must have had the intention to cause damage or injury to the plaintiff by those acts (“the Intention requirement”); and

  105. (e) the plaintiff must have suffered loss as a result of the conspiracy (“the Loss requirement”).

  106. [58] To establish her case, Pauline asserts that the defendants “combined together to set up a competing business to usurp [the Company’s] assets and ride on the goodwill and reputation of [the Company]”. She relies on the following facts to support her allegations:

  107. (a) the issuance of shares on 12 August 2015;

  108. (b) the change of the Company’s address on 1 September 2015;

  109. (c) the registration of the Sole Proprietorship on 8 February 2017;

  110. (d) the registration of the Chilli Mark on 3 October 2017;

  111. (e) the alleged attempt to appropriate the lease for the 287 Premises;

  112. (f) the cessation of the Company’s business on 28 February 2018;

  113. (g) the attempted winding up of the Company on 13 April 2018, pursuant to his application on 20 March 2018 for the same;

  114. (h) the incorporation of Eng’s Char Siew as a private limited company on 5 March 2018; and

  115. (i) the registration of the Name Marks.

  116. [59] On the facts, I find that there was no “combination” of the defendants as alleged. Further, the acts (a) to (i) complained of were not carried out in furtherance of any agreement between the defendants, nor unlawful. I also find that Pauline has not proved the defendants’ intent to injure the Company. I conclude therefore, that there is no conspiracy to injure the Company by unlawful means, for reasons explained below.

  117. The Combination requirement

  118. [60] The essence of conspiracy lies in the fact of agreement between the defendants: Halsbury’s Laws of Singapore vol 18 (LexisNexis Advance, 2020) at para 240.611. The agreement need not be in the nature of an express agreement (see Raiffeisen Zentralbank Osterreich AG v Archer Daniels Midland Co and others [2007] 1 SLR(R) 196 at [95] – [96]), and the conspirators need not all have joined in the scheme at the same time, nor need each know what the other conspirators have agreed to do so long as they were sufficiently aware of the surrounding circumstances and shared the same object: OCM Opportunities Fund II, LP and others v Burhan Uray (alias Wong Ming Kiong) and others [2004] SGHC 115 at [49]. The question was how far each of the parties to the conspiracy was aware of the plan (if any) and “joined in the execution thereof”: The “Dolphina” [2012] 1 SLR 992 at [265].

  119. [61] Pauline contends that there was an agreement between Bill, Desmond, Mui Hong, Mei Ling to set up Eng’s Char Siew and thereby injure the Company.

  120. Bill

  121. [62] Bill’s defence is that he was not involved in any plan. Pauline’s contentions that Bill was a conspirator are bound up with her suggestions that he was in fact a fiduciary of the Company. It is, according to Pauline, Bill’s financial role in the Company that allowed him to assist to injure the company. Bill’s defence, in contrast, is that he was a mere bookkeeper who could not have helped in the substantial way alleged. I thus first ascertain Bill’s level of involvement with the company.

  122. (1) Bill’s authority as a fiduciary

  123. [63] The “essence of an employment relationship is not typically fiduciary at all”: Nottingham University v Fishel [2000] IRLR 471, as cited in Nagase Singapore Pte Ltd v Ching Kai Huat and others [2007] 3 SLR(R) 265 at [26]. An employee is only a fiduciary if he/she is placed in a position where he/she must act solely in the interests of his employer. There must be particular functions of the employee which require him/her to pursue the interests of his employer to the exclusion of other interests, including his/her own: Clearlab SG Pte Ltd v Ting Chong Chai and others [2015] 1 SLR 163 (“Clearlab”) at [272].

  124. [64] As a rough and ready guide to when the imposition of a fiduciary obligation would be appropriate, Clearlab at [275] adopted the three factors identified by Wilson J (dissenting) in Richard Hugh Frame v Eleanor Margaret Smith [1987] 2 SCR 99 at [60], which were cited with approval by the Court of Appeal in Susilawati v American Express Bank Ltd [2009] 2 SLR(R) 737 at [41]:

  125. (a) The fiduciary has scope for the exercise of some discretion or power.

  126. (b) The fiduciary can unilaterally exercise that power or discretion so as to affect the beneficiary’s legal or practical interests.

  127. (c) The beneficiary is peculiarly vulnerable to, or at the mercy of the fiduciary holding the discretion or power.

  128. [65] Practically speaking, this means that employees subject to a high degree of supervision and review by a more senior employee would typically not be regarded as fiduciaries: OUE Lippo Healthcare Ltd (formerly known as International Healthway Corp Ltd) and another v Crest Capital Asia Pte Ltd and others [2020] SGHC 142 (“OUE Lippo”) at [111]. Moreover, the employee’s portfolio of responsibilities would be a crucial factor in determining whether he/she is subject to fiduciary duties as well. For example, in ABB Holdings Pte Ltd and others v Sher Hock Guan Charles [2009] 4 SLR(R) 111 (“ABB Holdings”), the employee-defendant was in charge of all aspects of the third plaintiff’s business, being responsible for its general management as well as business development, marketing and sales. He “remained part of the top management and attended meetings of the Country Management Team […] He was able to hire and fire for the third plaintiff”: ABB Holdings at [39]. As such, Judith Prakash J (as she then was) held that the defendant was “a very senior employee indeed”, owing fiduciary duties to the third plaintiff: ABB Holdings at [39]. As Hoo Sheau Peng J put it in OUE Lippo at [112], “[f]iduciary duties akin to those owed by a director would likely be imposed on senior employees whose domain extended to all or substantially all of the business of the company” [emphasis added].

  129. [66] Unlike the employee-fiduciaries in the case law, Bill was hardly the “ruler in his own domain”. Bill only worked at the Company on a part-time basis handling the accounts, and some administrative matters (such as liaising with the property agent). Pauline contends that Bill had “played a major role in the structuring of payments to the shareholders and [overseeing] the operations of [the Company] in many aspects including the financial affairs and CPF account of [the Company]”. However, in reality, Bill took instructions from Jason, clearing matters with Jason before preparing the documents. Bill’s evidence, which was not challenged, was that he gave Jason monthly briefings to update him on the accounts and to ensure that “[Jason] know[s] what is happening”.

  130. [68] Finally, I address an oral “employment agreement” which, as pleaded, charged Bill with (a) exclusive management of the operations of the Company together with Desmond, and (b) responsibility for the finances and accounts of the Company as the person “in-charge”. This allegation was neither proven at trial nor pursued in closing submissions. I thus find that Bill was not in a fiduciary position vis-à-vis the Company prior to taking on the role as director of the Company on 8 June 2018.

  131. (2) Bill’s relationship with the Ng family

  132. [69] Moreover, it was clear by the end of trial that Mei Ling and Mui Hong would not have involved Bill in any family plan. Mei Ling and Mui Hong made their distrust of “outsiders” clear. Everything was to be “a family business” following Desmond’s debacle with Jason and Pauline. As such, Bill has no shares in Eng’s Char Siew and is not entitled to any profits of the company. He is only paid $500 for some freelance accounting work that he does for Eng’s Char Siew. On Bill’s part, he would have no motivation to be, as Pauline alleges, a supposed “mastermind” of the plot. He is a retiree with a steady income from the Company. I accept Bill’s evidence on his lack of participation with the family’s plans of any kind.

  133. Desmond

  134. [70] It is implicit in Pauline’s accusations that Desmond was at the centre of the plan. However, at multiple points during trial, Mui Hong expressed her deep dissatisfaction with Desmond. He was not involved in securing the 248 Premises; the sisters viewed the property and procured the lease themselves. He was not allowed to go anywhere near the 248 Premises when it was being renovated for Eng’s Char Siew; Mui Hong took care of all the renovations. He was not involved in procuring the supplies and ingredients for Eng’s Char Siew ; Mei Ling was able to do “everything” from her six years’ experience at the Company. He was not asked about the recipes or the cooking – the sisters had “the consultant of [their] mother”. He could not have contributed any start-up capital either; he was “totally broke at that time”. Currently, Desmond “[helps] out in [his] sister’s shop” and greets the customers. But he is not entitled to any of the profits and draws no salary from Eng’s Char Siew. While some aspects of the family’s evidence may be exaggerated, the manner in which the events unfolded (see [73]-[106] below) suggests that Desmond was not the chief strategist behind a conspiracy as Pauline alleges.

  135. Mui Hong, Mei Ling and Eng’s Char Siew

  136. [71] Mui Hong and Mei Ling set up Eng’s Char Siew. This, however, was not pursuant to any conspiracy spearheaded by Desmond. I turn then, to the Furtherance and Intention requirements to explain their intentions and their plan.

  137. The Furtherance and Intention requirements

  138. [72] Conspiracy is usually established by inference from objective facts (see Asian Corporate Services (SEA) Pte Ltd v Eastwest Management Ltd (Singapore Branch) [2006] 1 SLR(R) 901 at [19]). I therefore first deal with the nine acts alleged by Pauline (see [58] above) that were purportedly carried out in furtherance of the conspiracy and with intention to injure the Company. Given that the Furtherance and Intention requirements involve overlapping facts and findings, I address them together. While the Furtherance requirement is fairly straightforward, the Intention requirement deserves explanation. The Court of Appeal in EFT Holdings ([57] supra) put it as such (at [101]):

  139. [73] In my judgment, none of the nine acts were carried out in furtherance of any conspiracy.

  140. Allotment of shares to Bill

  141. [74] I first consider the allegedly wrongful allotment of 5% of the Company’s shares to Bill on 12 August 2015. According to Pauline, the issuance of shares to Bill “paved the way for the Plaintiff’s removal as a director in June 2018”. This was allegedly part of a calculated and pre-meditated plan to “wrest control of the [Company]”.

  142. [75] Bill’s version is that Jason promised this 5% shareholding to him from the outset. It was only when Bill planned to leave Jason Parquet, that he decided he ought, for the sake of caution, to complete the paperwork and formalise the arrangement. Desmond supported Bill’s evidence on this point, explaining that while he was not happy with an arrangement that left him with less than 50% of the shares, this had been agreed with Jason from the start. On Desmond’s part, he signed the resolutions in 2015 because he felt he ought to honour the agreement.

  143. [76] Pauline signed the resolutions too, but claims that she had been misled and induced by Bill (and Desmond) into signing these documents. I reject her evidence. Her assertions, as she admitted on the stand, are wholly unsubstantiated, bereft of any proof. On 22 September 2015, she queried Bill on the specific allocation of shares on 22 September, and Bill explained that his 5% was derived by issuing extra shares to adjust the shareholding as follows:

  144. Shareholder

  145. Shares (#)

  146. Shareholding (%)

  147. Pauline

  148. 95

  149. 47.5%

  150. Desmond

  151. 95

  152. 47.5%

  153. Bill

  154. 10

  155. 5%

  156. Total

  157. 200

  158. 100%

  159. Subsequently, she signed documents for dividends to be paid out to “shareholders who [were] in the Register of Members”. Bill was paid dividends for his shares in 2015, 2016, and 2017.

  160. [77] Pauline’s evidence varied over the course of trial. At some points, she referred to a telephone conversation (“Bill told me there’s a stack of document for me to sign, accounting document […] He told me Desmond has signed. I just have to sign below Desmond’s signature will do.”). At other points, she characterised the misrepresentation as having been made through Bill’s conduct (“[Bill] would leave the documents at the counter of the [Company’s] premises for [Pauline] to sign as per the usual practice”). Whatever form these supposed representations took, there was simply no reference to, much less any misrepresentation of the contents of these documents. There was no suggestion that Bill and/or Desmond had sought to cover up or mask the nature of these share allotment documents. Pauline was simply told to sign the documents. Objectively speaking, there is nothing misleading about such an instruction. If Pauline’s argument is that Bill had taken advantage of the “usual practice” and capitalised on her complacency to execute this share allotment, such an allegation was neither pleaded nor borne out by any evidence. If anything, the evidence suggested the precise opposite. Pauline is experienced in corporate documents, having held multiple directorships in the past. The share allotment document was also, on its face, clear, with little room for confusion. The words “ALLOTMENT OF SHARES” were inscribed in bold at the top of the page, and the allotment of shares was the only matter printed on that page.

  161. [78] The facts are plain. Pauline did not “discover” Bill’s shareholding in 2016. Pauline signed the papers in 2015 because she was aware of the earlier agreement between Bill and Jason. The shares, in other words, were not issued pursuant to any conspiracy to injure the Company.

  162. Change of Company’s registered address

  163. [79] I turn now to consider the change of the Company’s address. Pauline’s contention is that Desmond and Bill attempted to prevent any official correspondence from reaching her and/or the Company by changing its registered address to Bill’s residential address.

  164. [80] Bill, on the other hand, furnishes a reasonable explanation for changing the Company’s registered address. Prior to the change in address, the Company’s registered address was the JPS Address, where Bill worked. With Bill’s departure from JPS around August 2015, he no longer had access to the JPS mailbox. It therefore did not make sense for the Company’s documents to be delivered to the JPS Address. As far as the choice of new address was concerned, Bill’s explanation was simple, clear and convincing:

  165. [81] On her part, Pauline did not report any issues with access to any Company documents. She was able to sign off on dividend distributions with no issues in the years following the change in address. Further, the address was changed through a directors’ resolution on in September 2015. Pauline was one of the directors that authorised the Company to change its registered office to Bill’s residential address. This means that she had explicitly agreed to the change in address. When confronted with this during cross-examination, she ultimately conceded that she had signed the directors’ resolution and that this resolution reflected an agreement between Jason, Desmond, Bill and herself, namely “that it would be more convenient if the Company’s official correspondence were mailed straight to [Bill’s home].”

  166. [82] It follows that the change of address was not intended to harm the Company.

  167. Registration of the Sole Proprietorship

  168. [83] Mui Hong registered the Sole Proprietorship on 8 February 2017. Pauline suggests that this had been done pursuant to the conspiracy between the defendants. Pauline’s arguments are threefold. First, she contends that Mui Hong’s stated reasons for registering the Sole Proprietorship are unbelievable and inconsistent with her affidavit of evidence-in-chief. Second, she argues that Mui Hong could not have done this without prior discussion with Desmond. Third, Pauline argues that even if this registration had been carried out without Desmond’s approval or knowledge, Desmond did nothing about it after he found out about the registration. He had effectively acquiesced to a conspiracy.

  169. [84] I deal with Mui Hong’s reasons first. These are believable and consistent with the narrative that unfolded over trial. Part of the motive was sentimental in nature (“no one has made an effort to register this name which I personally embrace it very, very much in commemoration to my father”), such sentiment being entirely consistent with the Ng family’s strong attachment to the “Eng’s brand”. Part of the motive is strategic (“in anticipation of having an avenue to carry on the Family Wantan Mee Business in the event [it] could not be able to operate through [the Company]”), such a plan being consistent with the family’s desire to protect and preserve the authenticity of their “Eng’s brand”. Crucially, none of these motives involve injuring the Company. If anything, this registration was a back-up plan in the event that the Company ceased business operations.

  170. [85] Pauline’s last two arguments concern Desmond. She contends that Mui Hong could not have registered the Sole Proprietorship without prior discussion with Desmond, and that Desmond must have condoned the registration when he found out about it and did nothing afterwards. Desmond and Mui Hong’s evidence was that Desmond was told after Mui Hong had registered the Sole Proprietorship, and Desmond was of the view that Mui Hong, being a member of the Ng family, was entitled to register such a sole proprietorship anyway.

  171. [86] The Sole Proprietorship was not used to operate any business. Mui Hong only took action to set up any wanton mee business after the Company was unable to secure the lease for its business. Therefore, Desmond’s tacit acceptance of Mui Hong’s action cannot be taken as a step in a conspiracy. In fact, Desmond’s actions reveal that he was hoping to continue with the Company. After the registration of the Sole Proprietorship, Desmond offered to buy Jason’s share of the Company. Desmond’s evidence was also that he would have continued with the Company if Pauline had signed the lease.

  172. [87] The evidence of Desmond, Mui Hong , Mei Ling and Mdm Loh show, rather, that the Ng family regarded the “Eng’s” name as family property. They regarded it as something to be protected from unauthorised use, especially by Pauline, Jason and any of their associates. Mui Hong’s, and the Ng famly’s (if any at all) intent in registering the Sole Proprietorship was directed towards protecting “this Eng’s brand” and towards devising a contingency should the Company’s business cease, not injuring the Company,

  173. [88] I therefore find that the registration of the Sole Proprietorship was not intended to injure the Company, much less made in furtherance of any agreement to do the same.

  174. Registration of the Chilli Mark

  175. [89] Mui Hong registered the Chilli Mark on 3 October 2017. Pauline’s allegation was that the registrations of the Chilli Mark and the Sole Proprietorship, were “to lay the groundwork” for the eventual incorporation of Eng’s Char Siew. In particular, Pauline pointed to the fact that Mui Hong had registered the Chilli Mark under the Sole Proprietorship (rather than under her own name) and had registered the Chilli Mark under Class 30 (for the manufacture of noodles). This, according to Pauline, was incontrovertible proof that the registration was a preparatory step towards usurping the Company’s business.

  176. [90] Mui Hong’s explanation is that she had registered the Chilli Mark because she had designed the “logo, the motif and everything”. She simply wanted to keep it. Jason challenges her account. He claims that the Chilli Mark had been designed by him and his personal assistant (“Cindy”), who was not called as a witness. According to Jason, Mui Hong had only fabricated the signage.

  177. [91] Nothing turns on who had actually designed the mark. The only relevant issue is whether the registration was part of a plan to injure the Company. In my judgement, Mui Hong registered the Chilli Mark for the same reasons that she registered the Sole Proprietorship. Mui Hong was taking pre-emptive steps to protect the “Eng’s brand”. The Chilli Mark, being “linked to the Eng’s Char Siew Wantan Mee name”, was registered to achieve those ends. This was why the Chilli Mark was registered under the Sole Proprietorship rather than under Mui Hong personally. This was also why the fact of this registration was kept from Pauline.

  178. [92] In that regard, my earlier findings regarding the registration of the Sole Proprietorship (see [87] above) apply with equal force here. As explained earlier, the Intention requirement is only fulfilled by acts that target or are directed at the claimant. It is not sufficient that harm to a claimant is a likely or probable or even inevitable consequence of a defendant’s conduct: EFT Holdings ([57] supra) at [101]. Here, Mui Hong’s efforts were directed at protecting the “Eng’s brand”, not injuring the Company. As such, I find that there was no intention to injure the Company through the registration(s) of the Chilli Mark (and the Sole Proprietorship).

  179. Alleged appropriation of the lease

  180. [93] The tenancy agreement for the 287 Premises expired on 15 March 2018. After no news was received on Desmond’s request for Pauline to renew the lease, Bill informed Jane on 24 January 2018 that “Eng’s Noodles House Pte Ltd will not be renew [sic] the tenancy agreement after the expired [sic] of the lease term (ie. 15 March 2018)”, promising to “make arrangement to find a new tenant to lease the same place with the agreement rental of $8,800 per months [sic] for the next 3 years periods [sic].” This was on the same date that Desmond’s solicitors sent Pauline a letter that they had instructions to wind up the Company. Bill then emailed Jane on 31 January 2018, asking for Richard’s name to be put on the tenancy agreement. Jane’s response was that a new tenant had already taken up the lease by then. Pauline alleges that the attempt to assign the lease to Richard had been an effort by the defendants “to appropriate the lease for themselves”. This, according to Pauline, was part of the conspiracy to injure the Company as it would have allowed Eng’s Char Siew to take over the 287 Premises.

  181. [94] Desmond and Bill’s explanation is somewhat convoluted but gels with the facts. Desmond perceived the lease to be a source of personal liability when it was under his name. He was willing to take on such “personal liability” when the “relationship [was] still very good” but did not want to do so after “trouble started”. That said, Desmond was keen on continuing the Company’s business. Frustrated as he was with the issues amongst the partners, Desmond testified that he would have carried on the Company’s business if the lease had not been taken over by somebody else. In my view, by asking Pauline to take up the lease, Desmond was signalling his dissatisfaction with the way Pauline was treating him, and attempting to have her take responsibility, rather than to stand on the side-lines complaining about the manner in which he managed the operations. By also previously expressing his intentions to retire, he was reminding her that he was the party responsible for the cooking and the joint venture’s success. The sequence of events indicates that he did not anticipate that she would assist another to acquire the lease and secure the employment of the cook that he and his father had trained.

  182. [95] In this context, the 24 January 2018 Email was entirely explicable. Pauline had not responded to the request for her to sign the lease. There was no word from Jane either. By this time, Desmond had decided that he ought to wind up the company, and was suspicious that the lease had been taken up by another. The 24 January Email, therefore, was a ‘test’ devised by Desmond and Bill to ascertain if the lease had already been promised to anyone else. Their thinking was that if Jane did not come back to Bill asking “why you all Eng Noodle House want to give up”, it would be confirmation that she had promised the lease to another interested party. In much the same vein, the attempt to assign the lease to Richard on 31 January 2018 was a way for Bill and Desmond to ascertain, in the face of Jane’s silence, whether the lease had already been assigned to someone else. Jane was thereby forced to respond that the lease had been taken up by someone else. In that regard, Desmond’s suspicions were well-founded.

  183. [96] For these reasons, I find that the 24 and 31 January emails were not advancing any sort of conspiracy or plot to take over the 287 Premises on behalf of Eng’s Char Siew. The lease had been secured by another by this juncture. If Desmond had wanted to secure the lease for his own benefit, he would have acted earlier and more decisively. He was certainly in a position to do so since he was the named tenant for the 287 Premises (see above at [16]) and the landlord had agreed to his price. For them to have asked Pauline to sign the lease in January and to have allowed matters to unfold in the manner that they did suggests a lack of a strategic plan on the alleged conspirators’ part.

  184. Cessation of business, winding-up application and incorporation of Eng’s Char Siew

  185. [97] I turn now to address the last three events that Pauline relies on to establish her (representative) action in unlawful means conspiracy. These are:

  186. (a) the cessation of the Company’s business on 28 February 2018;

  187. (b) the application to wind-up the Company; and

  188. (c) the incorporation of the Sole Proprietorship as Eng’s Char Siew.

  189. [98] These events will be addressed together because they are all, in substance, a reaction to Eng’s Wantan Noodle taking over the lease for the 287 Premises. I base my finding on two observations.

  190. [99] Firstly, the whole process of setting up and establishing Eng’s Char Siew was hasty and improvised. Desmond, Mui Hong and Mei Ling’s testimony aligned. They testified that this was a “very last minute rush decision”, that was “urgently” made and “very last minute”. Mui Hong and Mei Ling were scrambling to find a location for Eng’s Char Siew. They viewed the 248 Premises in mid-February, signed the lease on 21 February 2018, took over the premises in April, and opened Eng’s Char Siew for business on 13 May 2018. They were desperate and settled for the 248 Premises even though it was actually a lease for two units and the rental fees were significantly higher than the 287 Premises. They did not have a business plan and do not have any concrete profit-sharing arrangement till this day. The Ng family does not “even talk about profits” and “[n]obody expects to take in any profit”. In fact, Eng’s Char Siew is not a profitable business. This would seem to be the result of haphazard reactions to events as they unfolded, rather than (as Pauline alleges) a premeditated plan dating back to 2015.

  191. [100] Second, I am satisfied that the Ng family was genuinely concerned about the use of the name “Eng’s” by Eng’s Wantan Noodle. The family members who testified at trial presented a unified and convincing narrative – The “Eng’s brand” was threatened when a new tenant took over the 287 Premises looking to set up a similar business. The Ng family then rallied together to protect the “Eng’s brand”. In fact, Mei Ling had been suspicious of Jason and Pauline from as early as January 2018. Her testimony was that Jason had been speaking to the head chef at the Company, coming to take measurements of the furniture after working hours and scrutinizing the company accounts. The implication here, of course, was that Jason had been taking preparatory steps to divert the Company’s custom to another business. I make no findings as to whether Jason actually did these things, but I do accept that Mei Ling was suspicious of Jason and Pauline at that time. I also accept that Mei Ling’s observations were communicated to Mui Hong, whose suspicions were, in turn, aroused as well. Desmond, on his part, was fully convinced that the lease had already been ‘stolen’ and confirmed that he shared Mei Ling’s views.

  192. [101] It was in this context that Mei Ling and Mui Hong banded together to set up Eng’s Char Siew. Eng’s Char Siew was their way of asserting the original and authentic “Eng’s brand” - a way for them to “stand up and tell the public that, hey, we are here”. As for the Company, it was clear by 1 February 2018 at the latest, that it had no more future. The lease had been taken up by another tenant and relations between the directors had deteriorated irreparably due to the bitter infighting (“damage has been done”). The decision to cease the business is a natural and entirely reasonable one. It follows that the decision to wind-up the company was a sensible one as well. These decisions are entirely explicable in the light of the circumstances that the Company found itself in, and not by any supposed conspiracy between the defendants to injure it.

  193. [102] In that regard, the agreement that was being furthered (if any) was a family effort to root out mimicry, not misappropriate the Company’s custom. In fact, there was no Company to injure anymore. In any case, injury of the Company was neither the intent nor the means towards achieving their true goal – “to fight, to get back our “Eng’s” and rong gao”.

  194. Registration of the Name Marks

  195. [103] As for the Name Marks (see above at [41]) , Pauline alleges that their registration (together with the Chilli Mark’s registration) is further proof of the conspiracy to “usurp the Company’s [intellectual property] assets”.

  196. [104] To this, the defendants contend that all the “IP assets” which Pauline claimed on behalf of the Company were part of a licensing arrangement between the “Ng family” and the Company. They aver that the Ng family owned the tradenames “Eng’s Noodles House Char Siew Wantan Mee”, “Eng’s Char Siew Wantan Mee” and “榮高雲吞麵”. They could not have “usurped” things which were theirs all along. This licence also grounds the counterclaim, and I deal with it in that context (see [129] below). In respect of Pauline’s allegations on the Name Marks, it suffices to note that these registrations were well after the Company’s cessation of business. Eng’s Wantan Noodle had registered the 1st and 2nd Franchise Marks much earlier on 3 August 2018. Eng’s Char Siew’s solicitors wrote to Eng’s Wantan Noodle and the Intellectual Property Office of Singapore, objecting to the mark on 20 September 2018. Eng’s Char Siew then made a string of trademark applications on 19 October 2018 , 30 November 2018, and 14 December 2018, registering the Name Marks. The chronology of events suggests to me that the registration of the Name Marks was retaliatory in nature. It was not part of a plot to injure the Company. In any event, the Company was defunct by this stage. Without premises, it could not operate. The Ng family’s real adversary was Eng’s Wantan Noodles. That was the true target of their actions.

  197. [105] For this reason, I do not find that the registration of the Name Marks was done in furtherance of a conspiracy to injure the Company.

  198. The Unlawfulness and Loss requirements

  199. [106] Having found that the Combination, Furtherance and Intention requirements are not satisfied on the facts, it is no longer necessary for me to address the remaining requirements. There is no loss to speak of since a conspiracy has not been established, and the only unlawful actions are Bill and Desmond’s potential breaches of their fiduciary duties to the Companies. I deal with these actions (and any evaluation of their lawfulness) in the section below.

  200. Breach of fiduciary duties owed to the Company

  201. [107] It is undisputed that Desmond and Bill owed fiduciary duties to the Company during the terms of their directorships. These are respectively:

  202. (a) for Desmond, from 27 February 2012 up till 9 July 2018; and

  203. (b) for Bill, from 8 June 2018 till present day.

  204. Pauline avers that these duties had been breached.

  205. Bill

  206. [108] Up to the point of trial, two of Pauline’s contentions relied upon Bill being a fiduciary. The first was a claim of financial misappropriation. This was dropped midway through trial. The second relates to the conspiracy allegations, which I have dismissed. I have also held in that context that Bill was not a fiduciary prior to his becoming a director on 8 June 2018 (see above at [68]). Bill’s participation as a director was after the Company had ceased operations. There are no further allegations made by Pauline about any potential breaches of fiduciary duty on Bill’s part after he assumed directorship in the Company.

  207. Desmond

  208. [109] Pauline has pleaded that Desmond breached three fiduciary duties:

  209. (a) A duty to act in good faith in the best interests of the Company.

  210. (b) A duty to act for the proper purposes of the Company in relation to its affairs.

  211. (c) A duty not to place or allow himself to be placed in a situation or position whereby any of his duties and obligations to the Company conflict or may conflict with his own personal interests.

  212. [110] The first two duties pleaded are in essence, a reference to the alleged conspiracy between the defendants to injure the company. Having found that such a conspiracy does not arise on the facts, I find that those duties have not been breached. By the same token, the alleged breaches of the Companies Act which related to the allegations of conspiracy were therefore not made out either. The statement of claim, without listing which of the limbs in s 157 of the Companies Act were being relied on, simply stated that the “duty to act honestly and use reasonable diligence in the discharge of the duties” had been breached as well. I took Pauline’s allegations of such breaches to be merely the statutory equivalents of the same breaches (of fiduciary duties) that she complained of at general law. As such, where her claims of breach (of fiduciary duties) in general law failed, I dismissed their Companies Act equivalents as well. The analysis, in other words, was one and the same. Indeed, I am fortified in my approach by the lucid observations in Hans Tjio, Pearlie Koh & Lee Pey Woan, Corporate Law (Academy Publishing, 2015) at para 09.025:

  213. [111] I turn then, to whether there has been any breach of a duty to avoid conflicts of interest. At issue is Desmond’s omission to disclose the registration of the Sole Proprietorship and the Chilli Mark to the Company when he found out about them.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.