High Court · Decided 26 March 2020
CDV v C DW
Feedback & support[2020] SGHC 61 · Case no. Divorce Petition No 65 of 1993 (Summons No 600205 of 2019) · 24 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Facts
- [3]
[3] The decree absolute was granted on 21 June 1994.
- [4]
[4] After the divorce, the Husband remarried another woman (“the present Wife”). For a time, the Husband and the present Wife rented a property in Johor Bahru.
- [5]
[5] In 1998, they bought a HDB flat (“the HDB flat”), which they co-own. Both the Husband and the present Wife have a son together (“the Son”).
- [6]
[6] At the time of the divorce in 1994, the Husband was earning a salary of $2,000.00. In 1997, he earned an annual salary of $72,000.00. In 2013, his annual salary reached $98,933.00. In 2015, the Husband was offered around $7,000.00 per month as a director in a company. He, however, claimed to have received only $3,000.00 per month from his directorship. Thereafter, he left his position as a director and joined another company where he earned between $2,000.00 to $3,000.00 a month. Since then, the Husband has fallen on tough times. The company in question did not pay him on time. The Husband sent several WhatsApp messages to his employer asking for transfers of various sums of money, some of which include:
(a) “please tt urgently 150 to me” (dated 15 December 2018);
(b) “please tt $2000 to me for my son’s trip tomorrow” (dated 28 December 2018);
(c) “is there any way you can tt 200 to me urgently. appreciate…” (dated 21 January 2019); and
(d) “I have only $3 left in my wallet. please SMS after you have tt many thanks” (dated 5 April 2019).
- [7]
[7] The Wife did not challenge the veracity of these WhatsApp messages.
- [8]
[8] Given his financial difficulties, the Husband was unable to pay his monthly mortgage instalments on the HDB flat for three years. He resorted to using credit cards, including from OCBC, to pay his monthly mortgage instalments on the HDB flat.
- [9]
[9] The Husband also used a credit card to pay his household expenses. In addition, he faced difficulties in paying the Son’s university fees. In his own words, he was not “able to discharge [his] duty as a father to [the Son] since he entered [u]niversity”. The Son’s university fees amounted to $5,000.00 per semester and were payable upfront. As the Husband was unable to pay the fees, the Son’s aunt paid some of the fees.
- [10]
[10] As it turned out, the Husband was unable to pay the outstanding credit card debts. On 13 March 2019, OCBC served a statutory demand under s 62 of the Bankruptcy Act (Cap 20, 2009 Rev Ed) (“the Bankruptcy Act”) for outstanding debts of $58,352.85 on various credit card accounts. As at the date of my decision, this figure had risen to $69,314.44.
- [13]
[13] Notably, the Husband had highlighted in his letter to the Wife his fear that there would be a forced sale of the Matrimonial home given the extent of his debts. The Husband claimed that this letter was delivered to the Wife through the Son on 13 July 2019. The Wife did not deny that this letter was delivered to the Matrimonial home. In an attempt to discuss the letter’s contents with the Wife, the Husband and the Son visited the Matrimonial home at least three times in July 2019. During their visits, they found the Matrimonial home to be deserted.
- [14]
[14] Subsequent attempts to effect personal service of Summons No 600205 of 2019, ie, the present summons, on the Wife through the court clerk proved unsuccessful. The court clerk visited the Matrimonial home on 14 August 2019 and 18 August 2019. On both occasions, all the doors and windows were shut. The gate was padlocked. Thereafter, the Husband successfully applied for substituted service and served the papers by posting them on the gate of the Matrimonial home.
- [15]
[15] Eventually, the Wife filed an affidavit on 29 October 2019 claiming that she was still living in the Matrimonial home.
- [17]
[17] On 2 December 2019, I informed the Wife’s counsel, Mr Liaw Jin Poh (“Mr Liaw”), that there appeared to be insufficient evidence that the Wife was still living in the Matrimonial home. The Husband and the Son had not been able to speak to the Wife during their visits. The court clerk’s attempts to effect personal service also proved unsuccessful. The Wife’s only explanation was that her relatives had been suffering from a “slew of medical emergencies” which required her assistance and diverted her attention away from the Matrimonial home.
- [18]
[18] Concurrently, I impressed on Mr Liaw that it might be in the Wife’s own interests to consider the Husband’s offer to sell his half-share especially since there was evidence that the Husband was facing probable bankruptcy. Furthermore, the Husband had stated that he was willing to pay the Wife $192,000.00 in maintenance arrears from the sale proceeds of the Matrimonial home. I granted an adjournment for Mr Liaw to take further instructions and fixed the matter for hearing on 10 December 2019.
- [19]
[19] Prior to the hearing on 10 December 2019, both parties filed one additional affidavit without leave of court. I allowed the admission of both affidavits, but cautioned against the filing of further affidavits without leave of court. In her second affidavit, the Wife attempted to supplement her assertion that she was living in the property by exhibiting, inter alia, utility and property tax bills. The Husband’s response was that the Wife’s rates of usage of water and electricity fell below the average. The Husband further claimed that it appeared that the Wife would only go the Matrimonial home to water the plants and perform some minimal cleaning. At the hearing, I directed the Husband to file another affidavit to update the court on his present financial state, especially in relation to his outstanding debt with OCBC.
- [20]
[20] On 11 December 2019, the Husband’s solicitors wrote to OCBC’s solicitors, informing them that the Husband would settle the outstanding debt owed to OCBC if he was able to sell his half-share in the Matrimonial home. The solicitors also asked whether OCBC would commence bankruptcy proceedings against the Husband and if OCBC would be prepared to stay the bankruptcy proceedings pending the hearing of the present summons. OCBC’s response was as follows:
- [21]
[21] In his latest affidavit, the Husband provided details on whether he would be able to discharge his existing debts by selling the HDB flat. In the event that the HDB flat was compulsorily acquired, he would receive $585,992.00 from the HDB. After paying the outstanding mortgage of $197,052.62 on the flat, and assuming an equal split of the remainder (with the other half going to the present Wife), the Husband would have to refund $192,489.34 to his CPF retirement account. He would then be left with $1,980.35 in cash. The Husband pointed out that this cash balance would be wiped out by the time HDB actually acquired the HDB flat.
- [22]
[22] Apart from OCBC, Standard Chartered Bank (Singapore) Limited (“SCB”) was also pursuing the Husband for an outstanding debt. In this regard, SCB had obtained a writ of seizure and sale against certain items in the HDB flat. Pursuant to the writ of seizure and sale, on 30 October 2019, the bailiff seized various items, including a two-door fridge and a television. Collectively, all of these items were valued at a paltry sum of $660.00.
- [23]
[23] As a result of his financial troubles, the Husband also claimed that he was estranged from the present Wife for 10 years and that he was the sole breadwinner taking care of the Son and mother-in-law, who resided with him in the HDB flat. The present Wife was a bankrupt and had not made significant payments towards the outstanding mortgage on the HDB flat.
Parties’ arguments
My decision
- [27]
[27] My decision was based on the Husband’s probable bankruptcy and its implications on the Matrimonial home. Accordingly, I did not make any finding on whether the Wife was living in the Matrimonial home.
General principles
- [30]
[30] The court laid down several important principles to guide the exercise of discretion under s 112(4) of the WC. These include the following:
(a) Although the language utilised in s 112(4) of the WC is broad, the provision has a limited operation (AYM at [22]), especially because of the consideration of finality underpinning s 112 of the WC (AYM at [22]).
Analysis
- [39]
[39] Examining the language of sub-orders 4 and 5, I found that their basis was to provide the Wife with a place to live in by giving her exclusive occupation and control of the Matrimonial home. Hence, the question arising in this case is whether the circumstances raised by the Husband invalidated this basis. In my judgment, there was sufficient evidence of the Husband’s probable bankruptcy which would result in the forced sale of the Matrimonial home. This would undermine the basis of sub-orders 4 and 5 and thereby constitute a radical change in circumstances amounting to unworkability as required under AYM.
- [41]
[41] I now detail my reasons for finding that the Husband would probably face bankruptcy proceedings. First and foremost, OCBC knew of his half-share interest in the Matrimonial home. Even if it did not already know, it would inevitably have found out. The “legal action” that OCBC appeared to contemplate in its letter to the Husband is, in my view, wide enough to cover bankruptcy proceedings. This must be so given that he appeared not to have other substantial assets which could be used to discharge his mounting debts. I also did not regard the Husband as exaggerating the poor state of his finances. Given his advanced age, the fact that the HDB Flat was potentially the subject of compulsory acquisition and SCB’s execution of a writ of seizure and sale against items of minor value in the HDB Flat, the Husband was clearly facing extreme financial difficulty.
- [42]
[42] Although the Husband did not provide payslips from his employer (as pointed out by the Wife), this was not entirely unreasonable given that he was not being paid regularly by his employer (see above at [6]). All things considered, I found that there was sufficient evidence to show that the Husband did not have any substantial assets. Having regard to the circumstances set out above at [4]–[13], I was also of the view that the Husband’s application was made in good faith. Given the Husband’s lack of funds, it was clear to me that he would probably be made a bankrupt by OCBC.
Conclusion
- [48]
[48] For the above reasons, I allowed the Husband’s application for variation.