Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 30 Apr 2020
Contents

High Court

Tan Bee Hong Blossom and another v Tan Seng Keow Doreen and others

Feedback & support

[2020] SGHC 89Case no. Suit No 925 of 2018

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. The undisputed facts

  3. The key persons involved in the trial

  4. [2] I will start by setting out the undisputed facts in this case. The Plaintiffs and the 1st and the 2nd Defendants are sisters. The 1st Defendant (“Doreen”) is the oldest sister, followed by the 2nd Plaintiff (“Ivy”), then by the 1st Plaintiff (“Blossom”), and finally by the 2nd Defendant (“Julie”). I refer to them collectively as “the Sisters” in these written grounds. Among themselves, the Sisters are accustomed to calling each other by their childhood nicknames: Doreen is usually referred to as “Sis”; Ivy as “V”, Blossom as “Pi”, and Julie as “Nan”. Of the Sisters, Blossom and Julie are married, but only Julie’s husband, Tang Siew Kwong (“Alan”), featured as a witness in the trial.

  5. [3] The parents were Mr Tan Hock Chong (“Father”) and Mdm Poh Kim Lian (“Mother”). Father passed away on 18 April 2003 and Mother passed away on 27 June 2016.

  6. [4] The Sisters also had three other siblings: Charlie Tan Seng Hup (“Charlie”), Victor Tan Seng Lee (“Victor”), and Lena Tan Kiat Kee (“Lena”). These other siblings did not give evidence at the trial, although some reference was made to them by the Sisters during their testimonies.

  7. The companies

  8. [5] The companies which form the subject of the Plaintiffs’ winding-up application in this case (the 3rd to the 6th Defendants) are as follows:

  9. (a) Chiap Chuan Management Pte Ltd (“CCM”);

  10. (b) Yong Peng Realty (Pte) Limited (“YP”);

  11. (c) Tan Boon Liat And Company (Singapore) Private Limited (“TBL”); and

  12. (d) Chiap Chuan Holdings Pte Ltd (“CCH”).

  13. [6] In these written grounds, when all of these four companies are referred to collectively, I will refer to them as “the Companies”.

  14. [7] The number of shares in each company, as well as the amount of issued and paid-up capital, are as follows:

  15. Name of Company

  16. Issued and paid up capital amount (S$)

  17. Number of shares

  18. YP

  19. Paid-up – 170,122.00

  20. 170,122

  21. CCM

  22. Paid-up – 100,000.00

  23. 100,000

  24. TBL

  25. Paid-up – 426,100.00

  26. 4,261

  27. CCH

  28. Paid-up – 1,000,000.00

  29. 100,000

  30. The properties owned by CCH, YP and TBL

  31. [8] CCH, YP and TBL are all property holding companies, while CCM provides management services to these three. CCH, YP and TBL derive their main source of revenue from rental collected from the tenants of units in their buildings, while CCM’s main source of revenue comes from service management payments which it receives from the other three companies. Only CCM employs staff.

  32. [9] It is not disputed that the various properties owned by the Companies were acquired by Father during his lifetime as investment properties.

  33. [10] Within Singapore, CCH, YP and TBL own freehold strata titles in the following properties:

  34. (a) The RV Building.

  35. This is a mixed residential and commercial development located at 460/A/B/C to 484/A/B/C (even numbers) River Valley Road, Singapore 248345 to 248369 (“RV Building”). The building comprises 56 units, of which CCH owns 44 units (11 stacks of 4 units per stack) and YP owns 12 units (3 stacks of 4 units per stack).

  36. The RV Building is managed by Management Corporation Strata Title 325 (“MCST 325”). Blossom and Ivy are the Council members of the MCST 325 Council. The MCST 325 Council has a physical office at the RV Building. CCM served as the Managing Agent for MCST 325 until on or about 30 April 2017. The Plaintiffs and the Defendants presented opposing explanations as to how and why CCM ceased to be the Managing Agent, with Blossom and Ivy pointing the finger of blame at Doreen and Julie, and vice versa. Suntec Real Estate Consultants Pte Ltd was appointed as interim Managing Agent after 30 April 2017 and as Managing Agent with effect from 1 June 2017. CCM also managed the accounts in respect of the RV Building until on or about 1 June 2017, following which Suntec Real Estate Consultants Pte Ltd took on the management of the accounts.

  37. It is not disputed that the Companies share the same principal place of business and physical office at a unit in the RV Building (though Blossom and Ivy have asserted that Doreen and Julie later “unilaterally” moved “TBL or part of TBL” out to another unit in the RV Building).

  38. [11] At the time of Father’s death in June 2003, CCH also owned properties in Johor Bahru (”JB”) (“JB Properties”), Kuala Lumpur (“KL”) (“KL Properties”), Melaka (“Melaka Properties”) and Ipoh. The JB Properties and the KL Properties were subsequently sold. Indeed, the sale of the JB Properties – as well as the abortive sale of the Melaka Properties – became contentious issues which were canvassed by Blossom and Ivy on the one hand and Doreen and Julie on the other, in their respective bids to demonstrate the other side’s unreasonable or even underhanded behaviour.

  39. The Sisters’ shareholdings

  40. [12] The respective shareholding of each of the Sisters in the Companies is as follows:

  41. [13] The Sisters acquired the bulk of their shareholding in the Companies via inheritance. Prior to Father’s death, he was the majority shareholder in each of the Companies, and Mother was the minority shareholder, but none of the children held any shares. In his will, Father gave cash gifts to Mother, the Sisters, and their three other siblings (Charlie, Victor, and Lena). The residue of his estate – including shares in the Companies – was given to the Sisters “in equal shares absolutely”. Mother and the three other siblings did not receive any shares of the Companies under Father’s will. The Sisters were appointed as the trustees and executors of Father’s will.

  42. [14] It will be seen that after Father’s death, the Sisters each hold 25% of the shares in each company, subject to the following minor differences. In TBL, Doreen holds one more share than the other Sisters; and in YP, Doreen and Blossom each hold one share more than Ivy and July. These differences in the TBL and YP shareholdings came about through the following events.

  43. [15] In the case of TBL, the company has an odd number of shares in TBL (4,261 shares). After 1,065 shares were apportioned to each sister, the extra share ended up with Doreen. It is Blossom’s and Ivy’s case that Doreen had represented to them that ownership in the extra TBL share could not be divided between shareholders; and that on the basis that each sister would have an equal one-quarter share in the extra TBL share, they had “entrusted” Doreen with their respective one-quarter shares for her to hold on their behalf. It is Doreen’s and Julie’s case that Blossom, Ivy and Julie had unanimously and unconditionally agreed to let Doreen have the extra TBL share because she was the eldest sibling. According to Doreen and Julie, there was never any understanding or agreement that each sister would own a one-quarter interest in this extra TBL share: Doreen has at all material times been (and continues to be) the sole legal and beneficial owner of the extra TBL share.

  44. [16] In the case of YP, Doreen and Blossom had each purchased one of Mother’s YP Shares. Prior to her death, Mother held 3,000 shares in CCH; 2,000 shares in CCM; 100 shares in TBL; and 2 shares in YP. Sometime in late 2013 or early 2014, Mother sold her shares to the Sisters in equal proportions - save for her YP shares. Ivy and Julie had declined to purchase Mother’s YP shares; and eventually, it was Doreen and Blossom who each purchased one of Mother’s YP Shares.

  45. The directorships of the Companies

  46. [17] Prior to his death, Father was a director of all four Companies. Up to the point of her death on 27 June 2016, Mother too was a director of each of the Companies; and specific to CCH, Father had appointed her as “Life Director” pursuant to Article 77 of CCH’s articles of association. Prior to his death, Father had also appointed Blossom and Ivy as directors of CCH; Doreen as a director of TBL; and Julie as a director of YP. Chua – who is a relative of the Sisters’ – was also appointed as a director of CCM and YP.

  47. [18] Father’s will expressly stipulated that “no son of [his] shall be … appointed as officer or employee or agent” of any of the Companies. Apart from this express stipulation, Father’s will did not say anything either specifically about the directorships of the Companies or more generally about the management of the Companies’ affairs.

  48. [19] It will be recalled that pursuant to the terms of Father’s will, the shares in the Companies were bequeathed to the Sisters in equal shares; and that all four Sisters were appointed as the trustees and executors of the will. Following Father’s death and on or around 17 June 2003, the Sisters appointed themselves as directors of all the four Companies (insofar as they were not already directors). As to why they became directors of the Companies, Blossom and Ivy had a different version of events from that put forward by Doreen and Julie.

  49. [20] While there were varying accounts among the Sisters as to how the Companies’ affairs were managed post 17 June 2003, broadly speaking it was not disputed that in the immediate aftermath of Father’s death in April 2003, Julie was the only one of the four Sisters who worked fulltime in CCM (the company providing management services to the three property-owning companies). At that point, Doreen was an academic who split her time between Singapore and Australia; Ivy resided primarily in Malaysia and also Australia; and Blossom, whilst based in Singapore, was then in fulltime employment with Hewlett-Packard (although at trial she alleged that even whilst employed by Hewlett-Packard, she had spent a portion of her time working in the CCM office).

  50. [22] Throughout these proceedings, Doreen and Julie have used the term “working directors” to describe their positions in CCM. Whilst Blossom and Ivy expressed reservations about the use of this term and/or professed at times not to understand what it meant, I was prepared to accept the term as a form of convenient shorthand for referring to those directors who worked fulltime in CCM. This would cover not only Doreen and Julie but also Blossom during the period between 2010 and July 2016 when – post her resignation from Hewlett-Packard – she was working fulltime in CCM.

  51. [23] As for Ivy, it was not disputed that during the period she was living in Malaysia and Australia, she assisted to look after the Malaysian properties. It was also not disputed that she continued to do so after her return from Australia to Singapore in 2012. Ivy herself has alleged that she was “generally prepared to leave the day to day handling of Singapore business operations to the other Sisters (which concerned Singapore properties), but … expected to be kept abreast on all matters pertaining to the Companies”. On 28 July 2016 (the date of Blossom’s resignation), however, she wrote to the other Sisters stating that she was retiring “from involvement in the Singapore operations”.

  52. [24] I will next summarise the versions of events put forward by Blossom and Ivy on the one hand, and by Doreen and Julie on the other.

  53. Blossom’s and Ivy’s version of events

  54. The Companies were a “Family Business” and a “quasi-partnership”

  55. [25] The central tenet of Blossom’s and Ivy’s case was that the affairs of the four Companies were “closely intertwined” and that the Companies were managed on a “collective basis” as the vehicles through which the “Family Business” of “property leasing and/or property management” was conducted. The Statement of Claim pleaded that the Companies “were in effect a quasi-partnership between the Sisters”, or that it was “in any case managed as such by the Sisters since 17 June 2003 together with the Mother until recent events”.

  56. [26] Blossom and Ivy sought to assert that each Sister had a legitimate expectation to participate in the management of the Companies. According to them:

  57. [27] According to Blossom and Ivy, each of the Sisters had a defined role in the management of the Companies’ affairs. They claimed that Doreen’s focus was on “generating revenues from the TBL Building”; Julie’s focus was on “generating revenues from the RV Building”; Ivy’s focus was on the management of the Malaysian properties; and as for Blossom, she claimed to have been “involved in managing all the Companies, especially in CCM” from February 2010 until her resignation.

  58. The beginning of the end: Blossom’s and Ivy’s version of the “strained” relationship between 2010 and 2014

  59. [28] Blossom and Ivy claimed that the relationship of mutual trust and confidence which the Sisters enjoyed began to show signs of strain from 2010 onwards. They pinned the blame largely on Julie – though Doreen too came in for her fair share of blame in relation to events in later years.

  60. [29] The main source of friction was apparently the relationship between Blossom and Julie. While these two sisters had never been close, according to Blossom, their relationship became increasingly fractious from 2010 onwards; and she attributed the cause to “increasing acrimony from Julie”. Thus, for example, Blossom exhibited email correspondence from Julie in which the latter had responded to her announcement of a new IT system in the CCM office with comments about her “stirring” (apparently a reference to her stirring up trouble); and she also exhibited email correspondence from Doreen in which the latter described Julie at one point as “a law unto herself”. There were also other emails in which Julie continued to make scathing comments about “a ‘stirrer’ in management” and a “renown [sic] stirrer” which were understood to be references to Blossom. Tension even erupted over the use of the meeting room in the CCM office, with Blossom claiming that Julie had appropriated the room for her “exclusive use” in end-2011 or early 2012. Eventually, since Julie refused to surrender the keys to the meeting-room, a section of the main office had to be partitioned off to create a new meeting-room.

  61. [31] As the relationship between the Sisters continued to fray, Doreen emailed the other Sisters in February 2012 suggesting that as they were all “aware of the tensions in managing the companies that [they had] inherited from Dad”, it might be “timely to look into share ownership in these companies with distribution in mind”, and that there might be a need for “professional advice in pursuing this path”. Both Ivy and Julie replied to say that they agreed with Doreen’s suggestion. On 18 February 2012, Blossom emailed Doreen and Ivy to share information gleaned from her checks on options such as the en bloc sale of properties. (Julie was not copied in Blossom’s email but a hard copy of the email was later given to her at Doreen’s request.) On 29 February 2012, Doreen emailed the other Sisters again, stating somewhat vaguely that “[t]he consensus is to proceed”. In the same email, she also asked the other Sisters to consider the following:

  62. [32] At this stage, however, nothing concrete came out of the email exchange.

  63. The sale of the JB Properties

  64. [33] In 2013, unhappiness over the sale of the JB Properties caused further friction in the relationship between the Sisters. In gist, Julie had in August 2013 made an offer to purchase the JB Properties at the valuation price of RM 2.4 million. Julie asserted that the other three Sisters had agreed to the properties being sold to her at this price, but Ivy – who was responsible for the sale arrangements – had then changed her mind and asked Julie to “match the price of RM 2.7 million”. Ivy’s explanation for her change in position was that she had “a third party offer for RM 2.7 million” for the JB Properties; that Doreen and Julie had pressured her to sell the properties to Julie at RM 2.3 million; and that following discussion with Mother, she had concluded that it would not be “fair to CCH and by extension, to the other shareholders” if she were to sell the properties at RM 2.3 million.

  65. [34] After some to-ing and fro-ing, Julie agreed to pay RM 2.7 million, but there followed more unhappiness over the proposed terms of the letter of offer. The chief source of contention related to the inclusion – in the letter of offer – of Alan as one of the persons to whom an option to purchase the JB Properties might be given. This prospect of Alan being a co-purchaser of the JB Properties “disturbed” Blossom; and although in the end Ivy signed the letter of offer which named both Julie and Alan as co-purchasers, Blossom refused to co-sign the sale and purchase agreement together with Ivy on behalf of CCH. Since Julie herself was a party to the agreement and could not sign the agreement as CCH’s representative, Blossom’s refusal to co-sign meant that Doreen had to fly back from Australia to co-sign together with Ivy; and this also had to be done in a rush by 31 December 2013, before a new capital gains tax came into effect on 1 Jan 2014. Blossom, for her part, maintained that Julie had “concealed” her intention to make Alan a co-purchaser when she first made an offer for the JB Properties; and that by including Alan, Julie had contradicted her own avowed intention to purchase the JB Properties “to preserve … Father’s legacy”.

  66. The abortive sale of the Melaka Properties

  67. [35] The attempted sale of another set of CCH’s Malaysian properties created a further rift between the Sisters. In early October 2013, Ivy informed the other Sisters that she had received the figure of RM 750,000 as the valuation price of the Melaka Properties. Doreen expressed an interest in purchasing the Melaka Properties at the valuation price and requested time to consider the matter after getting information on the relevant regulations. However, after she confirmed her interest with Ivy in November 2013, she was informed by Ivy that the sale price would be RM 1.025 million. Ivy explained that this was the average of two valuation prices which she had obtained subsequent to October 2013.

  68. [36] Doreen responded by telling Ivy that she would only consider paying “10% higher than RM 750,000”. Around the same time, Blossom informed the other Sisters that she would co-sign the sale and purchase agreement for the Melaka Properties only if certain conditions were met – including a condition that there be “more than 1 set of valuation reports on which the sale price is based”. Eventually, Doreen decided not to proceed with the purchase of the Melaka Properties. Blossom and Ivy contended, however, that when they later agreed to allow CCH to sell the Melaka Properties to one Pastor Francis and his brother for RM 1 million, Doreen and Julie “obstructed the process” by “suddenly withdraw[ing] their support of the sale without clearly stating their reasons”. As a result, the sale to Pastor Francis and his brother was “thwarted”; and the Melaka Properties remain unsold today.

  69. The “severe deterioration” of the Sisters’ relationships from 2015 onwards

  70. [37] According to Blossom and Ivy, whilst the Sisters’ relationship had already started to show signs of “strain” from 2010 onwards, it was from 2015 onwards that things went severely downhill and the Sisters became clearly polarised on two opposing sides: Doreen and Julie on one side, Blossom and Ivy on the other.

  71. [38] One of the key triggers for the “severe deterioration” in their relationship was apparently Doreen’s announcement – at a meeting of the directors of the Companies on 25 May 2015 – that she intended to sell her shares to Julie. To Blossom and Ivy, this came as a shock. It meant that only Doreen would be able to “exit, and retire from business”. Indeed, Ivy described herself as feeling “betrayed” as it seemed to her that Julie had been “preferred”. The possibility of Julie buying over Doreen’s shares in the Companies was also highly disconcerting to Blossom and Ivy because they felt that it would “centralise power with just one person i.e. Julie” (Blossom’s words) and “tilt the control of the Companies in Julie’s favour” (Ivy’s words). Inter alia, as Ivy pointed out, it would “give Julie a majority in TBL”.

  72. [39] On 29 May 2015 (four days after Doreen’s announcement), Blossom sent an email to the other Sister to follow up on Ivy’s notes of the meeting on 25 May 2015. In it, she asked, inter alia:

  73. [40] Again, however, nothing concrete came out of Doreen’s announcement on 25 May 2015: Doreen did not proceed to sell her shares to Julie at this stage; and she also continued to hold the extra TBL share. It was to be nearly a year later, on 4 May 2016, that Blossom and Ivy wrote to Doreen to ask for “the return” of their one-quarter interests in the extra TBL share.

  74. [41] In the meantime, Blossom and Ivy became suspicious that behind their backs, Doreen and Julie were making their own “private plans” for the Companies. According to Blossom and Ivy, by mid-2015, the Sisters were “not working as a team”, “not communicating and no co-operating”. At a Directors’ meeting on 13 August 2015, Ivy proposed an en bloc sale of the Companies’ properties or a share swap (swapping TBL’s shares with CCH’s and YP’s). According to Blossom and Ivy, Doreen and Julie objected to the former. All four Sisters agreed to “explore share-swapping or any other options to avoid further disputes”. Some email correspondence ensued between them, and there was discussion of various options, including the possible sale of the RV Building – but no decision was reached. Tension continued to brew over a range of matters such as the signing of cheques, the condition of the RV Building and the potentially extensive repairs required, as well as Doreen’s and Julie’s decision to reduce the length of tenancies in the RV Building.

  75. [42] On 2 October 2015, Doreen sent the other Sisters a note stating that Mother had “authorised [her] to take the lead in all business-related matters, and to delegate work that needs to be carried out if need be, in [her] capacity as the eldest of the siblings”; and that accordingly she intended to “proceed with investigating different options regarding the proposed sale of [the RV Building]” and to arrange for TBL to “be managed by the company itself” instead of by CCM. Blossom claimed that Mother “denied authorising Doreen”; and a note dated 9 October 2015 was subsequently produced, purportedly written by Mother and declaring that she had not authorised Doreen “to make decisions on behalf of the (her) [sic] younger sisters and the company matters”.

  76. [43] For their part, Blossom and Ivy claimed that they were the ones encouraging the other Sisters to meet to discuss their options. Blossom described the options being put forward for consideration as that of “an en bloc sale of the Properties (to unlock their value) as well as the Share Swap”. These were also discussed at a meeting of the directors in January 2016, at which other options such as voluntary liquidation of the Companies – or having one pair of sisters take over the TBL Building and the other pair take over the RV Building - were also mentioned. It was agreed that the Sisters would find out more about the liquidation process. Blossom and Ivy alleged, however, that whilst a decision had yet to be made on “the issue of parting ways”, Doreen and Julie had already set in place machinations to remove Mother as a director of the Companies. Although Doreen and Julie explained that their suggestion to re-designate Mother as a consultant was due to concern over her age (82 years) and her poor health (cancer and other conditions), Blossom and Ivy alleged that they were really seeking to remove the obstruction which Mother posed to their plans and that Mother had “complained” about their “badgering” her over this issue.

  77. [44] Despite Doreen’s and Julie’s suggestion to re-designate Mother as a consultant, this did not happen; and Mother remained a director up to the time of her death on 27 June 2016. The Annual General Meetings (“AGMs”) of the Companies had actually been scheduled for 30 June 2016, but they did not proceed on that day as Mother’s sea burial took place on that day. Doreen and Julie also did not agree to Blossom’s proposal that the AGMs be held the following day (1 July 2016). Their explanation – that they were not in a state of mind to have the AGMs so soon after Mother’s death – was disbelieved by Blossom and Ivy. The latter charged that Doreen and Julie had certainly been well enough to visit the office on 1 July 2016. Indeed, it was alleged that that Doreen and Julie had told the staff that they were the “directors managing the business”, that Doreen had given Alan a Power of Attorney (“POA”), and that the staff should report to Alan on “business matters”.

  78. [45] Whilst Blossom and Ivy castigated Alan for his involvement in the Companies’ affairs, they did meet up with him on 7 July 2016 and 23 July 2016 to discuss how the Sisters “could go about parting ways”. Nothing came out of these meetings. For one, although Alan allegedly “pressed the idea of an en bloc sale of the Properties” (which Ivy had previously proposed), both Blossom and Ivy took the position that he “could not represent Doreen and Julie”. Further, although they had been told that Doreen had given a POA to Alan, they wanted either Doreen or Julie to produce the POA to them; and they lamented that they only obtained a copy of the POA after proceedings had commenced, despite the fact that the POA dated from 8 July 2016. They also complained that Doreen and Julie were abetting Alan’s “intrusion into the Companies” and giving him access to “the Companies’ confidential information”.

  79. The events of 28 July 2016 and thereafter

  80. [46] The AGMs of the Companies had been postponed to 29 July 2016, but on 28 July 2016, a series of events took place which prevented the AGMs from being held. First, the company secretary – one Jenny Tang – tendered her resignation via email.

  81. [47] On the same day (28 July 2016), Blossom tendered her resignation as “an employee” of CCM via a letter forwarded by email to the other Sisters. In her letter, she blamed “some directors” for her resignation, claiming that her “communications on the business matters and repeated requests for face-to-face meetings” had been persistently “ignored”. She also warned that Jenny Tang’s resignation as company secretary was “likely to have further consequences” but that she “will not be held liable” as she had “completed [her] due diligence”.

  82. [48] Blossom’s letter was plainly intended to make clear that she would no longer be working in the CCM office, even though she retained her directorship. Although Ivy – unlike Blossom – was not employed fulltime in the CCM office, she too did something fairly similarly on the same day (28 July 2016). On that day, Ivy too sent a letter to the other Sisters titled “Retirement from Singapore Operations”, in which she told them not to contact her “[w]ith immediate effect” on “the matters relating to the daily running of the Singapore operations of the four companies”. She also stated that her “status as a Director and Shareholder remain [sic]” and that she expected to “continue to be fully apprised of all matters relating to the four companies on a regular basis”.

  83. [49] As the AGMs could not be held until 27 September 2016, the Companies were penalised by ACRA. In the meantime, according to Blossom and Ivy, the staff had already been told by Doreen and Julie not to take instructions from them. At TBL’s AGM on 27 September 2016, Blossom – who was then the retiring director in TBL – was not re-elected due to Doreen and Julie voting against her re-election. Blossom claimed that Doreen and Julie refused to give her any reason for the move, and that it was a rejection of “Father’s intention to have the 4 [Sisters] working as a team”. In the course of the trial, the Plaintiffs’ counsel sought to put it to Doreen and Julie that Blossom’s non-re-election was in breach of Article 87 of TBL’s articles of association. I will deal with this argument in the later portion of these written grounds.

  84. [50] Despite these developments, a meeting of the directors still went ahead on 3 October 2016, with a number of decisions being taken. Inter alia, according to Blossom, the Sisters discussed the options of a share swap and an en bloc sale, and came to an agreement that the Companies’ auditors – Ng, Lee & Associates-DFK (“NLA”) – should be requested to “look into the share swap proposed with emphasis on equalising the share value to allow for a fair exchange”.

  85. [51] It will be remembered that in respect of the RV Building, CCH and YP own all 56 units in the building; and Blossom and Ivy make up the council members of MCST 325. Doreen and Julie do not sit on the council of MCST 325 but were – in their own words – the only two working directors left in CCM after Blossom’s resignation and Ivy’s “retirement from Singapore operations”. CCM had been serving as the managing agent for the RV Building, but in the period following 28 July 2016, CCM’s service agreement with MCST 325 was terminated. A new managing agent was subsequently appointed. The two sides blamed each other for the termination. Blossom and Ivy also claimed that Doreen and Ivy made other allegedly nefarious moves such as writing to question Blossom’s engagement of an unlicensed contractor to address serious spalling concrete issues at the RV Building; relocating TBL’s office to another unit in the RV Building despite Ivy’s protestations; attempting to evict MCTS 325 from the office in the RV Building and attempting to remove Blossom from the council of MCST 325. It should be noted that MCST 325 apparently remains at the same physical office, and Blossom remains on the MCST council, but the unhappiness created by the perceived nefariousness on Doreen’s and Julie’s part continued to rankle.

  86. [52] Other major issues which rankled during this period included Doreen’s and Julie’s alleged attempts to “entrench Alan in the management of the Companies”. At the directors’ meeting in January 2017, for example, Doreen had requested that Alan be appointed as her alternate director when she was unable to attend due to an urgent medical appointment. The request was not acceded to by Blossom and Ivy. On 15 February 2017, Doreen informed them that Alan had been appointed as a “Management Consultant / Advisor” to the Companies. This too met with protestations from Blossom and Ivy, both of whom objected vehemently to the perceived “entrenchment” of Alan.

  87. [53] Yet another matter which Blossom and Ivy objected to was the increase in the salary paid by CCM to Julie. Prior to September 2016, Julie’s monthly gross salary had remained at $2,020 for years, but from September 2016 onwards, it was increased to $6,000 . Blossom and Ivy charged that their approval was required for any salary increase, and that this particular increase was “unauthorised” because Doreen and Julie had effected it without their prior approval. Although Doreen explained that the increase in Julie’s salary was “to be expected” in view of her having to step in to “helm the business” after Blossom’s sudden resignation, both Blossom and Ivy refused to accept the explanation; and the issue of Julie’s salary increase remained a point of contention between the two sides.

  88. [54] The sense of grievance which Blossom and Ivy professed to feel about the “unauthorised” payments to Julie was aggravated by their discovery that Alan’s company Goodstar Developments (S) Pte Ltd (“Goodstar”) was being paid $4,280 for Alan’s management consultancy services, as well as by the Sisters’ disagreement over the issue of dividends. In respect of this latter issue, Doreen and Julie had taken the view that CCH and TP – which owned all the units in the RV Building – needed to conserve cash for all the repairs needed to the building. As such, CCH and YP had not paid out dividends from 2016 and 2014 respectively (It is not disputed that TBL continued to pay dividends throughout the same period, though Blossom and Ivy have complained that the amount of dividends paid has decreased.). Blossom and Ivy were upset about this, particularly since Julie’s salary increase in CCM was effected after the halt to dividend payments by CCH and YP.

  89. [55] As a result of their unhappiness over Julie’s “unauthorised” salary increase, Blossom and Ivy refused to approve CCM’s 2016 accounts at the CCM AGM on 4 July 2017. They continued to refuse to approve CCM’s 2016 accounts even after the abortive AGM on 4 July 2017. In addition, it was alleged that Doreen and Julie had failed to respond to requests by Blossom and Ivy for a “full inspection” of various records such as the CCM cashbooks and “the cheque books and documentation supporting the accounts”. On 25 August 2017, Doreen proposed to Blossom that in view of her continued objections to Julie’s increased salary, she should return to work in CCM, and that Julie’s salary would be re-adjusted once she returned. This offer was not taken up by Blossom: a reply sent by Ivy on behalf of Blossom and Ivy herself raised objections to a number of things, from Doreen’s use of to a “common email address” (ccm2012@singnet.com.sg) to send her 25 August 2017 email, to the perceived “insinuation” that Blossom had “not been performing her responsibilities as a director”. Another attempt was made by Doreen on 7 September 2017 to invite Blossom back to CCM to “helm” the company as a working director; and Doreen also proposed that she and Julie leave their positions as working directors to “pave the way” for Blossom. The invitation was not taken up by Blossom; and at trial, it was alleged that it was impossible for Blossom to return to CCM when they had already set the staff against her (This was disputed by Doreen and Julie.).

  90. [56] In September 2017, with Blossom and Ivy still refusing to approve CCM’s 2016 accounts, Doreen and Julie proposed the voluntary liquidation of CCM. This was opposed by Blossom and Ivy who claimed that it was simply a “blatant attempt to sweep the issue [of Julie’s salary increase] under the carpet”.

  91. The repairs to the RV Building

  92. [57] In 2017, the state of the RV Building also became a focal point of the two sides’ unhappiness with each other. In April 2017, the Building and Construction Authority (“BCA”) directed MCST 325 to appoint a structural engineer to conduct a periodic structural inspection of the RV Building and to submit a report to the BCA. On 29 August 2017, the BCA notified MCST 325 that as the structural engineer had in his report identified certain defects in the building (mainly related to concrete spalling), the MCST was required to carry out remedial works – namely, “[r]epair of all the columns, beams, slabs with concrete spalling” – as well as to carry out “the other minor remedial measures recommended by [the] Structural Engineer to prevent further deterioration”.

  93. [60] The wrangling between the two sides continued through 2018, with Blossom and Ivy claiming that MCST 325 was being denied the access it required to carry out the BCA-directed remedial works. It should be noted that while Blossom and Doreen insisted that these remedial works were completed by December 2018, Doreen and Julie disputed this.

  94. [61] For their part, Blossom and Ivy accused Doreen and Julie of carrying out large scale repairs of the RV Building from early 2019, allegedly “without Ivy’s and [Blossom’s] consent”. These repairs – which included waterproofing of the various units in the building and replacement of popped or damaged floor tiles - were said to be scheduled for completion sometime in September 2019.

  95. Blossom’s and Ivy’s case on being “trapped” in the Companies

  96. [62] It will be remembered that Blossom and Ivy took the position that the Companies constituted a “family business” and a “quasi- partnership”. It was Blossom’s and Ivy’s case that “[a]s a result of the irreconcilable difference between the Sisters, the relationship between the Sisters [had] completely broken down” and that “the Companies’ boards [were] effectively deadlocked”. According to them, the “trust and confidence that formed the basis on which the Sisters managed the Companies when they came together to do so after June 2003, [had] been completely eroded”. According to them, “[a]s a result, the Companies [were] unable to properly function and had been “badly hindered in making business decisions”, with CCH, YP and CCM experiencing a decline in their revenue (and indeed, CCM “operating at a loss”).

  97. [63] Further, it was Blossom’s and Ivy’s case that Doreen and Julie had “blocked [their] exit as shareholders” and that they were “trapped” in the Companies. It was alleged that Doreen and Julie had blocked various exit options. For one, it was alleged that they had “reneged” on the share swap proposed by Blossom (which would have involved the Sisters swapping the shares of CCH and YP with TBL shares or vice versa). It was also alleged that they had “resisted the sale of the freehold RV building and the land jointly owned by CCH and YP”, which “prevented a distribution of all the assets of the Companies between” the Sisters.

  98. [64] Over and above these allegations, Blossom and Ivy claimed that despite their offering to sell their shares in the Companies to Doreen and Julie, the latter two had refused to buy these shares. In fact, Blossom and Ivy claimed that they had offered to sell their shares as early as 10 February 2017, and castigated Doreen and Julie for “not responding clearly”. One of the key sticking points appeared to be the disagreement between the two sides as to whether Blossom and Ivy should indicate the price they were seeking as the would-be sellers, or whether Doreen and Julie should come up with a proposed purchase price. It should be noted that in December 2016, the Sisters had procured Valuation Reports from the Companies’ auditors, NLA, on the Net Asset Value (“NAV”) of the shares (“the 2016 Valuation Reports”). The valuation had factored in a discount which according to Blossom and Ivy came to “about 44%” in “some cases”. According to Blossom and Doreen, on “several occasions” including 10 February 2017, they had “indicated [their] willingness to consider a sale of all [their] shares in all the Companies (on a collective basis) to Doreen and Julie, at the value assessed by the Valuers (after including the deep discounts) for each of the Companies” (“the Valuation Price”). However, by 30 June 2017, while Blossom was allegedly still willing “in principle” to “sell all [her] shares at the discounted valuation price”, Ivy “informed that she was no longer prepared to sell her shares at that particular price”. Doreen had then invited Blossom and Ivy to write to her and Julie accordingly, but when Blossom and Ivy did write, it was to insist that Doreen and Julie should name “the price at which they would be prepared to buy out [their] entire shareholding”. As Doreen and Julie took the position that it was Blossom and Ivy who should (as the would-be sellers) be indicating their price, discussions regarding the sale of the shares did not make any headway.

  99. [65] In November 2017, Doreen asked Blossom and Ivy whether – to “break the impasse” – they would at least “reconsider selling [their] shares in CCM”. The latter two replied on 4 December 2017 to reject Doreen’s suggestion.

  100. The commencement of proceedings by Blossom and Ivy

  101. [66] On 7 December 2017, Blossom and Ivy filed proceedings for the winding-up of all four Companies (which proceedings were later consolidated into and converted to the present writ action). Following their commencement of proceedings, there were discussions between the two sides’ lawyers, mainly on the possibility of a sale of all of Blossom’s and Ivy’s shares to Doreen and Julie. However, these discussions did not result in an amicable resolution of the matter – a state of affairs for which Blossom and Ivy blamed Doreen and Julie.

  102. [67] In the later part of these written grounds, I will deal with the issues raised in relation to the discussions about the sale of shares post Blossom’s and Ivy’s commencement of proceedings. I next set out the key aspects of Doreen’s and Julie’s version of events.

  103. Doreen’s and Julie’s version of events

  104. The Companies are not and have never been a “Family Business” or a quasi-partnership

  105. [68] Unsurprisingly, Doreen and Julie refuted the proposition that the Companies were a “Family Business” and/or a quasi-partnership run on the basis of a relationship of mutual trust and confidence between the Sisters. According to Doreen and Julie, the Sisters were never close, even as children; and Blossom and Julie, in particular, never got along. Blossom was the favourite child of their parents, who would “often take her side when there were disagreements among the children”; and since childhood, she had been accustomed to appealing to “a higher power” – usually Father or Mother – to get her way.

  106. [69] The Companies were set up by Father as the corporate vehicles for holding his various investments. As the majority shareholder (with Mother as the only minority shareholder), Father controlled all four Companies and made all the decisions in relation to the running of the Companies. These included decisions as to whom should be appointed as directors in each of the Companies; and those who were appointed by him as directors – such as Mother, Chua and the Sisters themselves – took no part in the management of the Companies, which remained wholly under Father’s purview. Thus for example, although Julie was appointed a director of YP by Father, she never attended any directors’ meeting while Father was alive.

  107. [70] According to Doreen and Julie, therefore, the Companies were not started nor built up by Father on the basis of a relationship of mutual trust and confidence between him and Mother and/or the Sisters. The Sisters acquired the shares in the Companies as part of their inheritance pursuant to Father’s will; and it was critical to note that Father’s will said nothing about each of the Sisters being thereby entitled to participate in the management of the Companies.

  108. The Sisters’ appointment as directors of the Companies

  109. [71] As to why and how the Sisters came to be directors of the Companies, Doreen and Julie testified that this was really a “decision made out of convenience” at a time when the Sisters were “scrambling” to sort out Father’s estate in their capacity as executors of the estate. The preponderance of the Sisters’ interest in his estate derived from the shares in the Companies which they had inherited; and following Father’s passing, the affairs of the Companies were “in disarray”. The then remaining directors – Mother and Chua – were not able to run the Companies; and the auditor had observed that “there was no working director in CCM”, which provided management services to the other three companies. On 17 June 2003, therefore, the Sisters appointed themselves as directors of the Companies (insofar as each was not already a director of one or other of the Companies).

  110. [72] At the time of appointment, none of the Sisters gave much thought to their “entitlements or roles”. In fact, as between them, there were varying levels of involvement in the management of the Companies. At the beginning, only Julie joined CCM fulltime as a working director. Julie’s evidence was that she could not manage things alone and that Alan agreed to “relocate” to CCM’s office to help her with her job. Alan ended up renting a room in the office from 2003 to 2011, and “[lending] his business experience and acumen to CCM’s operations on an ad hoc basis” – a fact which Blossom and Ivy were always aware of and raised no objections to.

  111. [73] In 2004, as Julie was expecting another child, Doreen resigned from her academic position at National University of Singapore (“NUS”) to join CCM fulltime as its second working director. Neither Blossom nor Ivy was interested in becoming a working director at that juncture. Blossom was content to take no part in the management of the Companies and to focus instead on her job at Hewlett-Packard. Ivy was then living in Malaysia; and although she agreed to help oversee CCH’s Malaysian properties, the actual management of these properties was conducted by third party local representatives in Malaysia, with any administrative work being done back in the office in Singapore.

  112. [74] In or around May 2009, Julie had thoughts of resigning her directorships. There was some discussion as to potential options for moving ahead: whether, for example, they should employ a professional manager, or perhaps sell off all the properties and wind up the Companies. In the end, Julie did not resign – but in early 2010, she decided to go on a leave of absence. As the sole working director in CCM at that point, Doreen became concerned that she would be unable to manage things by herself. She therefore invited Blossom to join her in working in CCM. Blossom was initially reluctant to do so but eventually agreed; and Doreen suggested that she look after the administrative and personnel matters in CCM.

  113. Doreen’s and Julie’s perspective on the “strained” relationship between the Sisters

  114. [75] In August 2010, Julie returned from her leave of absence to resume her previous role as a working director in CCM. Doreen and Julie did not dispute that the relationship between them and Blossom – and the relationship between them and Ivy – became increasingly strained from around this time onwards. They attributed the cause to Blossom’s and Ivy’s behaviour. In particular, both of them decried what they perceived as Blossom’s “high-handed approach in relation to the business and staff in CCM”.

  115. [76] Thus for example, whereas Blossom had charged that Julie refused without reason to co-sign cheques, Julie explained that it was Blossom who took it upon herself to “arbitrarily pick and choose which director to pass the cheque(s) to for signing”, even to the extent of getting Mother to co-sign cheques for CCM’s salaries and professional fees when Mother was not involved in CCM’s operations. Blossom would also get the staff to pass Julie cheques to co-sign. According to Julie, there were occasions when as a matter of prudence, she needed to seek clarification about the payments before signing the cheques – and yet when she tried to raise questions about certain cheques at a meeting, Blossom had simply stormed out of the meeting.

  116. [77] Not only did Doreen and Julie take exception to Blossom’s “high-handed approach”, they also objected to the manner in which she sought to drag Mother into the fray. By 2010, Mother was nearly 80 years old and had advanced-stage breast cancer as well as mobility issues – and yet Blossom would insist on getting Mother to come to the office on occasions when the Sisters were due to discuss company matters. Doreen and Julie believed that Blossom was seeking to use Mother as a mean of pressuring them into giving in to her wishes.

  117. [78] One example was the incident arising from Julie’s use of a room in the office. This was the room which Alan had previously rented: when he ceased renting the room in 2011, Julie decided to use it as her working space. This drew the ire of Blossom and Ivy, which in turn led to Mother approaching Julie to ask her to give up the room so that Blossom and Ivy could turn it into a “meeting room for general usage”. Eventually, it was decided that an area in the open office would be partitioned off to create both a meeting room and a room for Julie – but although the matter seemed to have been resolved, tension between the Sisters continued to simmer.

  118. The sale of the JB Properties

  119. [79] As with Blossom and Ivy, so too with Doreen and Julie, the sale of the JB Properties and the abortive sale of the Melaka Properties were two key flashpoints.

  120. [81] In a meeting with Blossom and Ivy on 21 October 2013, Julie sought to remind them that they had previously agreed on selling her the JB Properties for RM 2.3 million. They insisted, however, that they wanted a price in the range of RM 2.5 million to 2.7 million. An angry Ivy even sent an email the following day, complaining that her “authority and capability” in managing the Malaysian property sales had been “questioned and undermined”. Ivy’s email proclaimed that she was “tendering [her] resignation as Director of [CCH] and that her last day would be when the JB Properties and two other KL properties had been sold. Worried that Ivy might drag Mother into the fray, Julie caved in to their demands and agreed to pay RM 2.7 million.

  121. [82] Even then, the drama did not end there. On 22 October 2013, a letter of offer was signed by Julie and Ivy which alluded to the possibility of the option to purchase being granted to Julie and/or Alan. This drew objections from Blossom, who claimed that Julie had deviated from her stated intention of buying the Properties “for sentimental sake, to have something to hold on to that belonged to [Father]”. Blossom refused to co-sign the sale and purchase agreement as CCH’s representative; Doreen was then overseas; and Ivy threatened to “call off the sale” if no second signatory could be found. Eventually, Doreen had to fly back from Australia and rush to Malaysia with Ivy so as to sign the agreement in time before new rules on capital gains tax kicked in.

  122. [83] As far as Doreen and Julie were concerned, therefore, it was Blossom and Ivy who had behaved in an unreasonable and obstructive manner in the sale of the JB Properties.

  123. The abortive sale of the Melaka Properties

  124. [84] As for the sale of the Melaka Properties, it was Doreen’s evidence that she too had experienced the same fickle and unreasonable behaviour on the part of Blossom and Ivy. According to Doreen, Ivy had informed the other Sisters at a meeting in October 2013 that the valuation price of the Melaka Properties was RM 750,000. At that point, Doreen had expressed interest in buying the properties and Ivy had agreed to sell them to her at the valuation price.

  125. [85] On 3 November 2013, Doreen emailed Ivy to confirm her readiness to proceed with the purchase. Being apprehensive about a possible repeat of Julie’s unhappy experience with the purchase of the JB Properties, Doreen requested confirmation of the sale price and other terms and conditions. Her worst fears were realised when in December 2013, Ivy informed her that the sale price had changed to RM 1.025 million, based on the average of two alleged valuations obtained subsequent to October 2013. Doreen was upset – and incredulous, especially since there “were no contemporaneous sale transactions in the vicinity of [the Melaka Properties] to justify the hefty increase in the sale price to RM 1.025 million in the space of about a month”. Doreen told Ivy that she was prepared to pay only 10% more than the RM 750,000 figure – but Ivy was unmoved, claiming that Melaka property prices had risen “by leaps and bounds”.

  126. [86] On 24 December 2013, Ivy and Blossom sent out separate emails. In her email, Ivy lamented that she had been accused of not exercising due diligence and announced that she would seek yet another valuation of the properties. This appeared to be supported by Blossom, who declared in her email that she would co-sign the sale and purchase agreement only if certain conditions set by her were complied with – including a requirement that there be “more than one set of valuations from which the selling price is based and referenced on [to] minimise the risk of being deemed ‘biased’”.

  127. [87] As Doreen did not wish to undergo the same ordeal that Julie had endured in purchasing the JB Properties, she informed them both that she no longer wished to be involved in the sale of the Melaka Properties, whether as a prospective purchaser or a CCH director.

  128. [88] In May 2014, Ivy presented to the other Sisters a proposal to sell the Melaka Properties to one Pastor Francis for RM 1 million. She followed this up with an email on 18 August 2014 declaring that she would “presume” she had the “green light” to start the sale process if she did not receive any reply from the other Sisters. Blossom replied to Ivy the following day saying she had “no issue with this sale transaction”.

  129. [89] Doreen, however, responded to point out to Ivy that proceeding with the sale without a directors’ resolution would be “detrimental to the interests of all directors” and “[expose] the company to unnecessary risks”. According to Doreen, this was simply a reminder to Ivy that the directors’ resolution of 16 August 2013 had given approval for CCH to dispose of the properties subject to the stipulation that a “separate Directors’ Resolution be prepared and approved once the disposal has been agreed”. As far as Doreen was concerned, she had not objected to the sale of the Melaka Properties and found it “baffling” that the subsequent abortion of the sale should have been blamed on her purported “sudden and belated objection”.

  130. Other events that led to unhappiness between the Sisters

  131. [90] In the wake of the events relating to the JB and the Melaka Properties, the tension between Blossom and Ivy on the one hand and Doreen and Julie on the other continued to fester. This unhappy state of affairs, according to Doreen and Julie, was due to Blossom’s and Ivy’s unreasonable behaviour. For example, Julie asserted that the decline in revenue from the RV Building over the years was wholly the doing of Blossom and Ivy. She noted that as the Council members of MCST 325, Blossom and Ivy had ignored her feedback on the deteriorating condition of the RV Building and refused to carry out repairs. This aggravated the already poor condition of the building. There were fewer and fewer units in good condition to be tenanted out – which led in turn to a decline in the revenue generated from the RV Building.

  132. [91] Other matters which riled Doreen and Julie during this period included an incident which involved Blossom apparently removing CCH’s cheque-book from the office without telling anyone; Blossom’s and Ivy’s practice of circulating their own one-sided notes of various discussions in an attempt to pass these off as accurate summaries of the discussions; and Blossom’s “high-handed” practice of passing cheques to Doreen or Julie for signature without explaining the purpose(s) of the payment. Around the same period (2014), Blossom also decided arbitrarily to stop providing Doreen with monthly statements of CCH’s / YP’s / TBL’s rental payments for their units in TBL Building. Doreen was told by Blossom that the CCM staff were busy with “other tasks” and that she should “check the physical book entries” instead for such information. This was a matter of concern to Doreen as she needed these statements to track various leases – and these statements had always been provided in the past.

  133. [92] As for the proposal in late 2015 to re-designate Mother as a consultant, Doreen’s and Julie’s evidence was that they had made this proposal out of concern for Mother. By then Mother was nearing 80 years of age and suffering from advanced-stage cancer. Doreen and Julie denied that they and/or Alan had visited Mother in an attempt to persuade her to step down as director. Indeed, when Mother expressed a desire to continue as director, they respected her wishes, and she remained a director.

  134. [93] In this connection, Doreen and Julie denied that they had wanted to remove Mother as director because of any obstruction she posed to their supposed plans. In respect of her note of 2 October 2015 in which she had proposed having TBL managed “by the company itself” instead of by CCM, Doreen explained that she had made the proposal, inter alia, in the hope of reducing her interaction with Blossom and thus minimising the strain on their relationship. In the event, she had not carried out the proposal. According to Doreen, therefore, she had no reason to resent Mother. In fact, Doreen had not even seen the handwritten notes by Mother (which stated that Mother had not authorised Doreen to make decisions on behalf of her sisters on company matters) until the notes were disclosed by Blossom during these proceedings. She did not know the context in which Mother had come to write these notes, but suspected that a third party might have assisted or guided Mother to do so.

  135. Doreen’s intention to sell her shares to Julie in 2015 – and her extra TBL share

  136. [94] In early 2015, Doreen started thinking about retiring, as she was tired and in ill health. She wanted to sell her shares in the Companies and thought of offering the shares to Julie, as she knew that Julie could afford to pay for them whereas neither Blossom nor Ivy could. Julie, for her part, was open to buying the shares. However, when Doreen announced her intention to sell her shares to Julie at a meeting on 25 May 2015, she realised that Blossom and Ivy were “stunned” – and “probably unhappy”. It was four days later that Doreen received Blossom’s email claiming that she wished to discuss her alleged one-quarter interest in the extra TBL share.

  137. [95] Insofar as the sale of her shares was concerned, Doreen eventually decided to shelf her retirement plans. She did not end up selling her shares to Julie in the year 2015 – or in the ensuing years.

  138. [96] Insofar as the extra TBL share was concerned, Doreen asserted that the Sisters had been advised by their then solicitor – a Mr Cheong – that “the ownership of the Extra TBL shares could not be divided”. According to Doreen, the other three Sisters then agreed unanimously and unconditionally to let her have the extra share, on the ground that she was the eldest sibling. The extra TBL share was registered in Doreen’s name; and she had from the outset been its sole beneficial owner. When TBL paid dividends, she would always receive slightly more than the other three Sisters in terms of dividend pay-out: the other three Sisters were well aware of this; and none of them ever raised any objections. Doreen was shocked, therefore, when she received Blossom’s email asking to discuss her alleged one-quarter interest in the extra TBL share. As she deduced that Blossom’s behaviour was driven by her feeling “threatened by the possibility” of Julie becoming the majority shareholder, she “saw no need to engage Blossom in discussions about the extra TBL share. Unfortunately, the saga of the TBL shares did not end there: nearly a year later, on 4 May 2016, both Blossom and Ivy wrote to Doreen, each demanding the return of her alleged one-quarter interest in the extra share. Although Doreen responded to them on 16 May 2016 to refute their allegations, Blossom’s and Ivy’s allegations regarding the extra TBL added to the acrimony between the Sisters and constituted one of the contentious issues in subsequent negotiations.

  139. The events following Mother’s death

  140. [97] On 27 June 2016, Mother passed away. The date of her sea burial – 30 June 2016 – coincided with the date of the Companies’ AGMs. On that day, following the burial, Doreen informed the other family members that she was exhausted and intended to return to Australia. When Blossom and Ivy inquired about the AGMs, Doreen replied that she would be selling her shares to Julie and that they should discuss the way forward with Julie. This did not go down well with Blossom and Ivy; and “an emotional exchange of words erupted”. Alan then suggested that a separate meeting be held to discuss the matter.

  141. [98] In the meantime, having indicated to her siblings that she did not intend to visit Singapore often after returning to Australia, Doreen decided to give a POA to Alan to conduct company matters on her behalf. To Doreen, Alan was a “natural choice” because she trusted him, and he had previously already been assisting Julie in the office after Father’s death. Accordingly, on 1 July 2016, she went to the CCM office together with Julie and Alan, to explain to the staff that she would be giving her POA to Alan and to reassure them that they need not worry in her absence as Alan would be around to help.

  142. [99] Doreen’s POA to Alan was issued on 8 July 2016. In a private conversation, Doreen also told Alan that if any “major issue” arose concerning the Companies, he “could take care of it for her”.

  143. [100] For his part, Alan met with Blossom and Ivy on 7 July 2016 and 23 July 2016 to discuss options for the Sisters to move forward. Julie attended the first meeting but not the second. Blossom’s husband Vincent attended both meetings. It will be remembered that Blossom and Ivy had alleged that it was Alan who was actively pushing for an en bloc sale of the Properties at the meetings. Alan had a different account of the two meetings. According to Alan, at the first meeting, Blossom had once again put forward the proposal for a share swap among the Sisters, whereas Ivy had proposed the sale of the RV Building. No agreement was reached at this first meeting. Nor was any agreement reached at the second meeting, as Blossom continued to press for a share swap and Ivy for the sale of the RV Building. Vincent suggested that Alan could proceed with the share swap on Doreen’s behalf since he held her POA, and Blossom agreed with his suggestion. When Alan replied that it would not be correct for him to proceed with a share swap without consulting Doreen, Blossom left the meeting in a huff.

  144. [101] On 28 July 2016, less than a week after the second meeting, the company secretary Jenny Tang resigned. On the same day, Blossom tendered her resignation as “an employee” of CCM “with immediate effect”, whilst Ivy too wrote to the other Sisters announcing her “retirement” from “involvement in the Singapore operations”. This spate of resignations, all on the same day, meant that the AGMs could no longer be held on the rescheduled date of 29 July 2016. Doreen and Julie believed that Blossom and Ivy had “engineered” this train of events with the intention of creating “more trouble” and thereby getting their own way. According to Doreen and Julie, it was no coincidence that Jenny Tang was employed by a company called Comwell which was “owned or controlled” by Blossom’s brother-in-law.

  145. [102] Doreen’s and Julie’s belief that the above resignations had been “engineered” so as to pressure them into caving in to Blossom’s and Ivy’s demands was fortified by the latter two’s unreasonable behaviour following their resignations. This included what Doreen and Julie described as their “high-handed” treatment of the staff – including, for example, an ugly incident in August 2016 in which Blossom had gotten the elderly Chua to accept two packages without any explanation and had also procured his signature on “the bottom of a rolled-up document”, but then rejected his request for a copy of whatever he had signed as well as his attempt to return the packages. There were further complaints lodged by other staff of the manner in which they were treated by Blossom and Ivy. It was also around this time (August 2016) that Blossom notified the other Sisters of “multiple conditions” which she wanted complied with if she were asked to co-sign any cheques. These conditions even included a requirement that the co-signatory should sign “respectfully” – a requirement which was revealed at trial to be prompted by Blossom’s anger at Julie having signed on top of her signature on previous occasions.

  146. Blossom’s non-re-election as a director of TBL

  147. [103] In light of the numerous incidents involving Blossom and the irresponsibility she had displayed in abruptly resigning from CCM on 28 July 2016, Doreen and Julie concluded that she had “often overstepped her duties and boundaries as a director”. At the TBL AGM on 27 September 2016, when Blossom as retiring TBL director was up for re-election, Doreen and Julie took the position that it was in the “best interests of TBL” not to re-elect her. As such, they refused to vote for her re-election.

  148. Julie’s salary increase

  149. [104] Among the various examples of Blossom’s and Ivy’s attempts to create “trouble”, the matters which appeared to draw the most antagonism from them were the increase in Julie’s salary from CCM; Alan’s involvement in the Companies; and the question of remedial works and repairs at the RV Building.

  150. [105] As to the former, Doreen and Julie asserted that the increase in Julie’s monthly gross salary from $2,020 to $6,000 was reasonable, given that her salary had not changed since 2011. More importantly, Julie had needed to handle nearly the entire workload in CCM after Blossom’s and Ivy’s abrupt departure in July 2016, as Doreen was then back in Australia. Doreen and Julie were of the view that as the only two working directors in CCM following Blossom’s and Ivy’s departure, they were empowered to decide on matters of salary adjustments without seeking the other two’s permission. When it transpired, however, that Blossom and Ivy were using their opposition to the salary increase as the excuse for refusing to approve CCM’s audited accounts, Doreen proposed in early September 2017 that Blossom could return to CCM as a working director while she and Julie would leave their positions to “pave the way”. The offer was not taken up.

  151. Alan’s involvement in the Companies

  152. [106] As to Alan’s involvement in the Companies, Doreen’s and Julie’s evidence was that Alan had already been assisting Julie with her work in the CCM office for years after Father’s death; and that not only were Blossom and Ivy aware of this, they had never raised any objections. After Blossom’s and Ivy’s sudden departures in July 2016, Alan had stepped in again to help Julie in the office, and he had done so without remuneration for nearly half a year. It was only in February 2017 that Doreen and Julie decided to put things on a formal footing by having CCM enter into a contract with Alan’s company Goodstar for the provision of management consultancy services. Pursuant to this contract, Alan “attended at the office and gave instructions to CCM’s staff in his capacity as a Management Consultant / Advisor”. Goodstar was paid $4,280 monthly for Alan’s services to CCM. Doreen and Julie found Alan’s assistance to be beneficial to the Companies: in their view, Blossom and Ivy were simply raising spurious objections when they insinuated that he could not be trusted with the Companies’ “confidential information”.

  153. The RV Building

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.