Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 5 May 2020

High Court

Borneo Ventures Pte Ltd v Ong Han Nam

Feedback & support

[2020] SGHC 91Case no. Suit No 1268 of 2016

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The claim in Suit No 1268 of 2016 (“this Suit”) is by Borneo Ventures Pte Ltd (“the Plaintiff”) against Ong Han Nam also known as Edward Ong (“the Defendant”) for breach of contract.

  3. [2] The Plaintiff is a company incorporated in Singapore and is a wholly owned subsidiary of GSH Corporation Limited (“GSH”), a public listed company. The executive chairman of GSH is Goi Seng Hui who is also known as Sam Goi (“Goi”).

  4. [3] The Defendant is a Malaysian and is the sole owner of a British Virgin Islands (“BVI”) incorporated company called Eagle Origin Limited (“Eagle”), which in turn owns 22.5% of the shares in a company called The Sutera Harbour Group Sdn Bhd (“SH Group”). Besides Eagle and the SH Group, the Defendant also owns other companies and shares in other companies such as Sutera Harbour Holdings Sdn Bhd (“SH Holdings”).

  5. The facts

  6. [4] The Defendant, through Eagle, had been the sole owner of SH Group (previously known as JV Amazing Sdn Bhd) prior to the acquisition. Pursuant to a Subscription Agreement dated 30 December 2013 (“the SA”), the Plaintiff acquired 77.5% of the share capital in SH Group and thereby became its majority shareholder for a consideration of about RM700m. This acquisition under the SA was completed on 26 March 2014. The SA was preceded by a term sheet dated 18 October 2013 (“the Term Sheet”).

  7. [5] SH Group is the holding company of a fully integrated resort called Sutera Harbour Resort Sdn Bhd (“SH Resort”), covering approximately 384 acres located at Kota Kinabalu, Sabah. The SH Resort consists, inter alia, of two five-star hotels with extensive convention and banquet facilities, which the Defendant developed from the 1990s until July 2000 when SH Resort was completed and officially opened by the then Malaysian Prime Minister.

  8. [6] The SH Resort is in turn the parent company of five companies, namely, (i) Advanced Prestige Sdn Bhd (“Advanced Prestige”); (ii) Eastworth Source Sdn Bhd (“Eastworth Source”); (iii) The Little Shop Sdn Bhd; (iv) Sutera Harbour Travel Sdn Bhd; and (v) Sutera Harbour Golf & Country Club Bhd (“SHGCC”). The Defendant has been a director of SHGCC since 19 December 1991. For ease of reference, the court will refer to all five companies collectively as “the Sutera Target Group”.

  9. [7] The corporate structure of the various companies mentioned above, after the completion of the SA, is best depicted in the chart below:

  10. [8] Besides all the above companies, the Defendant also owns a construction company called Pembinaan OCK (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd (“Pembinaan OCK”) as well as a Singapore company called OCK Investment Pte Ltd (“OCK Investment”). As will become apparent, the Defendant also owned or controlled a number of other companies relevant to the present dispute. These will be discussed where relevant below.

  11. [9] SHGCC owns and has title to a 99-year leasehold estate in state land located at Sembulan District, Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, with an area approximating 95.58 hectares or 238.63 acres (“the Sembulan Land”). In the SA, the Defendant had warranted to the Plaintiff, inter alia, that SHGCC owned the Sembulan Land without encumbrances.

  12. [10] The Plaintiff alleged that by a sale and purchase agreement signed on 21 March 2014 (“the S&P”) but which was apparently back-dated to 1 March 2014, SHGCC agreed to sell to the Defendant’s company, Omega Brilliance Sdn Bhd (“OBSB”), a portion of the Sembulan Land measuring 1.459 acres (“the Subject Land”) for RM1,000 as consideration (“the Transaction”). The S&P was signed by the Defendant on behalf of OBSB which company had been incorporated on 7 February 2013. The Defendant had become its director on 22 March 2013. OBSB is wholly owned by a BVI company called MDS International Limited (“MDS”) which sole shareholder is the Defendant.

  13. [12] I should add that PHSB was itself owned by Vibrant Square Sdn Bhd (“Vibrant”) who had as its shareholder another BVI company called Osterly Holdings Limited (“Osterly”), which held 30% of the shares in Vibrant, while the remaining 70% were owned by one Datuk Zarazilah (“Zarazilah”). Osterly’s shares are owned by the Defendant. Further, the evidence adduced in court from the Defendant was that Zarazilah held the 70% shares in Vibrant in trust for him. As the Defendant owned all the shares in Osterly (which held 30% of the shares in Vibrant) and Zarazilah held the remaining 70% in trust for him, that meant that the Defendant was the ultimate owner of and wholly controlled PHSB.

  14. [13] Since at least 2002 (see [164] below), tenancy agreements had been entered into between SHGCC and PHSB on an annual basis for the rental of the Subject Land. On 1 December 2012, the Liquidators of PHSB entered into a year’s tenancy with SHGCC to rent the Subject Land at RM5,558 per month.

  15. [14] After PHSB was wound up, the Defendant entered into negotiations and reached an agreement with Bank Islam to settle the outstanding debts owed by PHSB. Under the settlement terms, PHSB would make payment of RM33.6m to Bank Islam to discharge the charge which Bank Islam held over PHSB’s plant and machinery and all other securities. The settlement sum of RM33.6m, together with various fees payable under the settlement agreement for a total of RM34.438m, was paid to Bank Islam on or about 28 March 2013 by OBSB and/or the Defendant on behalf of PHSB. As noted below at [157], however, the Defendant admitted that the money came from another of his companies, Investasia Sdn Bhd (“Investasia”).

  16. [15] On 12 July 2013, OBSB (represented by the Defendant) and the Liquidators of PHSB executed an asset sale agreement (“the ASA”) for the sale of PHSB’s plant and machinery to OBSB in consideration for the RM33.6m paid to Bank Islam on PHSB’s behalf in March 2013, as recounted by Recital D of the ASA. Under cl 2.2.4 of the ASA, the Subject Land was expressly excluded from the sale but the Co-Gen Facility was included.

  17. [16] Prior to completion of the SA on 26 March 2014 (see [4] above), the Defendant had issued to the Plaintiff a disclosure letter dated 18 March 2014 (“the Disclosure Letter”) (which was wrongly dated 18 March 2013) where no mention was made of the S&P or the Transaction. The relevant paragraphs from the Disclosure Letter, addressed to both the Plaintiff and TYJ Group Pte Ltd (a company within the GSH Group), read as follows:

  18. The Plaintiff only found out about the S&P more than a year later, when a tax review was conducted on SHGCC’s accounts by its auditors.

  19. The Malaysian Suit

  20. [21] As the Defendant placed great reliance on the favourable outcome to him in the Malaysian Suit (indeed it was the gravamen of his defence that the judgment binds the world), it is necessary for this court to address those proceedings in some detail.

  21. [22] In the Statement of Claim (“the SHGCC SOC”) in the Malaysian Suit, SHGCC alleged that the Defendant was the alter ego as well as the directing mind and will of OBSB. The SHGCC SOC pleaded that PHSB was granted a licence (before its liquidation on 11 January 2012) under the relevant Electricity Act 1990 to generate electricity for sale and distribution.

  22. [23] The SHGCC SOC then referred to the tenancy agreement between SHGCC and PHSB over the Subject Land for which PHSB paid monthly rent to SHGCC. The tenancy agreement was terminated on 30 November 2013 and was not extended or renewed. Pursuant to the ASA, PHSB sold the plant and machinery located on the Subject Land to OBSB. However, the Subject Land itself was expressly excluded from the sale.

  23. [24] By the S&P (which SHGCC contended was actually signed on 24 March 2014 but backdated to 1 March 2014), the Subject Land was purportedly sold by SHGCC to OBSB for a consideration of RM1,000 even though its market value exceeded RM250,000. The S&P was signed by two directors of SHGCC namely, Foo Kia Inn (“Foo”) and Zarazilah on the instructions and direction of the Defendant. The Defendant himself signed the S&P on behalf of OBSB as its director together with Ms Wong Lee Ken (“WLK”), another director of OBSB who was concurrently the Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”) of SHGCC at the material time.

  24. [25] SHGCC alleged it only discovered the S&P and the Transaction in August/September 2015 during a tax review exercise carried out by SHGCC’s tax consultants. On or about 25 September 2015, SHGCC returned to OBSB the sum of RM1,000 paid for the Transaction.

  25. [26] As the SA was only completed on 26 March 2014, SHGCC alleged that the Defendant took expedited steps to cause the sale and disposal of the Subject Land by way of the S&P and the Transaction, given that the S&P was signed on 24 March 2014.

  26. [27] Consequently, SHGCC alleged that the Defendant had breached the fiduciary duties he owed to SHGCC as well as his duties as trustee of the assets of SHGCC. It was alleged that the Defendant owed obligations as a trustee in respect of SHGCC’s assets, in particular the Subject Land. SHGCC further alleged that in causing SHGCC to enter into the S&P and in permitting OBSB to remain in possession of the Subject Land, the Defendant had acted mala fide and against the interests of SHGCC.

  27. [28] The SHGCC SOC claimed, inter alia, against the Defendant and OBSB:

  28. (a) a declaration that the S&P purportedly dated 1 March 2014 was null and void and/or voidable and of no legal effect;

  29. (b) a declaration that SHGCC was entitled absolutely to the Subject Land; and

  30. (c) damages including aggravated and exemplary damages.

  31. [29] In his Defence and Counterclaim in the Malaysian Suit, the Defendant, averred, inter alia, that there was a common expectation or assurance shared between SHGCC and PHSB (and with OBSB after July 2013) ever since the development of the Co-Gen Facility on the Subject Land that the Subject Land was to be a separate parcel of land from the Sembulan Land, and that it would be owned and occupied by the developer of the Co-Gen Facility (“the Common Expectation”).

  32. [32] The Defendant claimed that prior to the execution of the SA, he had informed Goi (who represented the incoming investors including the Plaintiff) on multiple occasions, that the Co-Gen Facility and the Subject Land upon which it was sited was not part of the deal. The Defendant also alleged that representatives from GSH had also conducted a due diligence exercise between October and December 2013.

  33. [33] The Defendant contended that OBSB and PHSB would suffer a detriment should SHGCC renege upon or dishonour the Common Expectation as PHSB would have relied on it to develop the Subject Land thereby incurring the requisite expenditure, expertise, and time over the years without the benefit of a registered leasehold ownership over the Subject Land. The Defendant averred that it was unconscionable for SHGCC to resile from or dishonour the Common Expectation.

  34. [34] Thus, in the Malaysian Suit, the Defendant counterclaimed against SHGCC inter alia, for:

  35. (a) a declaration that SHGCC was estopped from denying OBSB’s proprietary interest in the Subject Land; and

  36. [36] SHGCC then applied to the Federal Court of Appeal for leave to appeal to the Federal Court but its application was dismissed on 17 January 2019.

  37. The pleadings

  38. [37] The basis of the Plaintiff’s Statement of Claim was the SA. The Plaintiff alleged, inter alia, that in view of the Defendant’s interests in both SHGCC and OBSB, and the fact that the consideration of RM1,000 paid by OBSB to SHGCC in the Transaction was significantly less than the market value of the Subject Land, the sale was transacted at a gross undervalue; the Transaction had clearly not been contracted on an arm’s length basis. Consequently, the Defendant breached warranties that he had given to the Plaintiff in the SA, namely paras 4.1(c), 4.1(g), 6.6(b), 11.1, 11.2(a), and 18.2 (read with Schedule 4) of Schedule 2 of the SA and thereby breached cl 6.1 of the SA. For reference, I set out some of the key provisions of the SA.

  39. [38] Paragraphs 4.1(c) and 4.1(g) of Schedule 2 state:

  40. [39] Paragraph 11.1 of Schedule 2 states:

  41. [40] Paragraph 18.2 of Schedule 2 states:

  42. [41] The relevant portion of Schedule 4 states:

  43. [42] By reason of the Defendant’s breach of the above warranties in the SA, the Plaintiff alleged that the Defendant had also breached cl 6.1 of the SA which reads as follows:

  44. [43] Further, under cl 8.1 of the SA, the Defendant was liable to indemnify the Plaintiff for any losses suffered as a result of the Defendant’s breaches of the warranties in the SA. The relevant sections of cl 8.1 state:

  45. [44] The court would point out that there is a limitation of liability clause in cl 8A.1(c)(i) of the SA which the court will return to later (see [267] below). The clause states:

  46. [45] The Plaintiff alleged that despite the expiry of the tenancy agreement between PHSB and SHGCC, and the absence of any novation, OBSB continues to occupy the Subject Land and did not remove the structures and installations erected thereon. Despite demands made to OBSB to enter into a fresh tenancy agreement or to vacate the Subject Land, OBSB did neither. Neither had OBSB paid the monthly rent of RM5,558 for October and November 2013. OBSB was therefore liable to SHGCC for unpaid rent and double rent for holding over the Subject Land. The Plaintiff alleged that, to date, the Transaction has not been completed because the Subject Land has not been subdivided and legal title remains with SHGCC.

  47. [46] The Plaintiff therefore claimed against the Defendant:

  48. (a) a mandatory injunction that the Defendant restrains OBSB from completing the Transaction and/or from enforcing the S&P;

  49. (b) a mandatory injunction that the Defendant procure OBSB to discharge/terminate the S&P forthwith;

  50. (d) further or in the alternative, damages.

  51. [47] In his Defence and Counterclaim (Amendment No 2), the Defendant:

  52. (a) Contended that SHGCC is the registered owner of the Sembulan Land of 95.58 hectares (238.63 acres) which did not include the Subject Land.

  53. (c) Stated that the Malaysian court had accepted and upheld the defence by the Defendant and OBSB of the Common Expectation that was shared by SHGCC and PHSB, the developer and prior owner of the Co-Gen Facility on the Subject Land, and, commencing from July 2013, between SHGCC and OBSB, that the Subject Land would be a separate parcel of land to be occupied and owned by OBSB.

  54. (d) Averred that the Common Expectation was supported inter alia by the following facts/evidence which was not negated by other agreements referred to by SHGCC in the Malaysian Suit:

  55. (i) Pursuant to the development plan (under drawing no. SHR/BLT/2805) dated December 1997 for the development of the Co-Gen Facility on the Subject Land prepared by SHGCC’s and PHSB’s common architect and jointly signed and consented to by SHGCC and PHSB (“the Development Plan”), PHSB had expended the sum of RM155m to develop the Subject Land into the Co-Gen Facility because of the power needs of the SH Resort. This was on the basis of the Common Expectation that the developer would have rights of occupation and ownership as no person would have undertaken the development if it had no rights or occupation or ownership of the Co-Gen Facility.

  56. (ii) From the time of development of the Co-Gen Facility until completion in 1999 and from 1999 until 1 December 2002 when a tenancy agreement was entered into between SHGCC and PHSB (“the 2002 Tenancy”), PHSB had occupied and operated the Subject Land without any written agreement.

  57. (iii) The Common Expectation is not negated by the S&P and/or the 2002 Tenancy which SHGCC alleged were admissions by OBSB and the Defendant that SHGCC is the registered and beneficial owner of the Subject Land.

  58. (iv) The redemption of PHSB’s debt by OBSB and/or the Defendant in the sum of RM33.6m owed to Bank Islam was only for the assets on the Subject Land and not for the Subject Land itself. This did not negate the Common Expectation as no one would pay the redemption sum of RM33.6m unless the redeemer believed that there was an expectation or assurance that the land on which the assets were constructed would be his.

  59. (v) The SA neither affirms nor nullifies the Common Expectation.

  60. (vi) OBSB and the Defendant succeeded on a balance of probabilities in establishing the Common Expectation and the elements necessary to invoke the equitable principle of proprietary estoppel against SHGCC.

  61. (e) Averred he would rely on the Malaysian Judgment at the trial of this Suit.

  62. (f) Asserted that PHSB and OBSB had relied on the Common Expectation and would suffer a detriment should the Common Expectation be dishonoured, denied or reneged upon, as they would have developed the Subject Land, incurring the costs of the requisite expenditure, expertise and time over the years, without the benefit of a leasehold ownership over the Subject Land, for which the subdivision of the Subject Land was intended.

  63. (g) Averred that the Co-Gen Facility and the Subject Land were not part of the acquisition by the Plaintiff under the SA as:

  64. (i) In the course of discussions with Goi when they met to discuss the investment in the SH Resort, the Defendant was asked on about two occasions if the Co-Gen Facility would form part of the SA deal, and the Defendant had informed Goi that the Co-Gen Facility and the Subject Land were not part of the deal for the new investors which included the Plaintiff, and Goi understood this to be the position.

  65. (ii) At a meeting in Singapore (sometime from October 2013 but before the signing of the SA on 30 December 2013) with the new investors represented inter alia by Gilbert Ee Guan Hui (“Gilbert”), Francis Lee Choon Hui (“Francis”) and Kenneth Goi Kok Ming, the Defendant had handed over to the attendees a copy of the report and valuation of SHGCC dated 24 April 2013 (“the Valuation Report”), which valued the net land area on which SHGCC was developed as an area of 94.90 hectares (234.5 acres) and which excluded the Subject Land where the Go-Gen Facility was situated.

  66. (iii) Therefore, the Plaintiff had full knowledge or ought to have knowledge of the Co-Gen Facility and its working relationship with the SH Resort companies since it was the power generated by PHSB (and later OBSB) that supplied electricity to the entire resort. OBSB which occupies and operates the Co-Gen Facility is not part of the SH Group and did not comprise part of the acquisition under the SA.

  67. (iv) Pursuant to a loan facility made available to PHSB by Bank Islam in 1999 of US$24m, ie the US$24m loan, Bank Islam stipulated as a condition that it should have an exclusive charge over the Subject Land. As a result of Bank Islam’s right of security over the Subject Land, other financial institutions that had provided financing to the development of SH Resort in 1999 disclaimed and excluded the Co-Gen Facility and the Subject Land from the ambit of security over the Sembulan Land.

  68. (v) Pursuant to settlement negotiations reached in March 2013 with Bank Islam, PHSB’s outstanding debts to Bank Islam were discharged through the payment of RM33.6m by the Defendant through OBSB on or about 29 March 2013. The settlement also redeemed Bank Islam’s security over the Subject Land.

  69. (h) Averred that the Plaintiff was at all times aware of the subdivision exercise – since the late 1990s, SHGCC had applied to the Lands and Survey Department Sabah (“LSDS”) to subdivide the Sembulan Land so as to facilitate the transfer of the subdivided parcels of land on which the substations and the Co-Gen Facility were sited to Sabah Electricity Sdn Bhd (“SESB”) and to the developer/owner of the Co-Gen Facility respectively. SHGCC was aware that the portion of the Sembulan Land, namely the Subject Land, which was the subject of subdivision was not intended to and did not belong to SHGCC.

  70. [48] The Defendant added that on or about 1 October 2014, SHGCC had accepted the amended offer contained in a letter from the Director of LSDS to revise/reduce the annual rent stated in its previous letter of offer dated 27 July 2007 and to delete the prohibition of transfer to anyone save for SESB and the Sabah state government. The representatives who signed the amended offer on behalf of SHGCC were from the Plaintiff.

  71. [49] The Defendant further averred that pursuant to the due diligence exercise carried out by the Plaintiff’s legal and financial teams in Singapore and Malaysia prior to the execution of the SA, the Plaintiff had knowledge or reasonably ought to have had knowledge of: (i) the extent of SHGCC’s interest in the Sembulan Land, which would include any restrictions or limitations on, the use of the various parcels within that land; (ii) SHGCC’s application for subdivision of the Sembulan Land; (iii) PHSB’s and OBSB’s proprietary interest in the Subject Land; (iv) the discharge of PHSB’s outstanding debt with Bank Islam by the Defendant through OBSB and (v) the extent of any security encumbrance over the Sembulan Land (which excluded the Subject Land) that was being discharged as a result of the new investors (which included the Plaintiff) having discharged the debts of SH Resort with the payment of RM700m.

  72. [50] The Defendant denied he had breached any warranties in the SA or in Schedules 2 and 4 thereof as alleged by the Plaintiff.

  73. [51] The Defendant counterclaimed for a declaration that Schedule 4 of the SA should be rectified to read as follows (proposed rectification emphasised in italics):

  74. [52] It is not necessary to address the Plaintiff’s Reply and Defence to the Defence and Counterclaim as the Plaintiff essentially joined issue with the Defendant’s allegations in his Defence and denied his Counterclaim.

  75. The evidence

  76. [53] Due to the many issues raised by the Defendant in the lengthy Defence that he filed, the Plaintiff called numerous witnesses to rebut the Defendant’s allegations. The Plaintiff’s witnesses comprised of (i) Goi, (ii) Madeline Lee May Ming (“Madeline”), the lawyer from the Kuala Lumpur firm of Mazlan & Associates (“M&A”) who had carried out the due diligence exercise for the Plaintiff before the execution of the SA; (iii) Gilbert, the group Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”) of the GSH; and (iv) Alex Ng Soon Heng (“Alex”) the group Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”) of GSH.

  77. [54] The Defendant on his part had three witnesses, namely himself, WLK and Chong Choong Kim (“Chong”) who was the valuer who had prepared the Valuation Report dated 24 April 2013 for the Defendant on behalf of CH Williams Talhar & Wong (Sabah) Sdn Bhd (“CH Williams”), which the Defendant relied upon in his defence.

  78. The Plaintiff’s case

  79. Goi’s testimony

  80. [55] Goi’s testimony was intended to rebut the Defendant’s claim that the latter had informed Goi in their meetings from October 2013 onwards that the Co-Gen Facility and the Subject Land were a separate development and were not part of the deal for the new investors. Goi testified that in his discussions with the Defendant in October 2013, in relation to the proposed acquisition of a majority stake in the SH Resort, the Defendant did not at any time inform Goi that the plot of land on which the Co-Gen Facility was situated was not part of the acquisition deal. Goi had only inquired of the Defendant whether the power plant business was included in the sale and the Defendant said it was not, because the power plant had many problems and “it wouldn’t make money”.

  81. Gilbert’s testimony

  82. [56] Part of the Defendant’s defence was his assertion that the Plaintiff knew from the Valuation Report of SH Resort, which he had extended to Gilbert and others at a meeting held in Singapore, that the Subject Land on which the Co-Gen Facility was situated was excluded from the sale to the Plaintiff. In his affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”), Gilbert deposed that the Valuation Report (which numbered almost a hundred pages) was simply handed to him and the other representatives of GSH at a meeting around October 2013 in Singapore without explanation or presentation of its contents. It was meant only as a reference point for discussions with the Defendant in their negotiations concerning the pricing for the acquisition of a majority stake in SHGCC by GSH.

  83. [57] Once a broad agreement had been reached with the Defendant, Gilbert deposed that he left the details and documentation to Alex to handle together with the Defendant’s team’s which included WLK. Periodically, Alex would update Gilbert on the progress of the acquisition and would also discuss various decisions to be taken with Gilbert.

  84. [58] Gilbert denied the Defendant’s allegation that GSH had reached an understanding with the Defendant that the Subject Land would be excluded from the acquisition.

  85. [59] Gilbert explained why GSH invested in SHGCC. He disclosed that before the second half of 2013, the Defendant and the Sutera Target Group were facing financial difficulties and significant pressure from various financial institutions. GSH came to know about the situation and decided it would invest in the Sutera Target Group to help the Defendant, although initially Goi was only interested in two parcels of land that the Defendant owned (namely Plots A and B which are dealt with below at [145]–[146]). Gilbert said the negotiations had been conducted on the basis that GSH would acquire the companies in the Sutera Target Group, rather than just the specific assets. GSH would take over the companies on an “as is where is” basis and that would include the assets held in the names of each of the companies to be taken over without any exclusions.

  86. [60] Gilbert confirmed that throughout the discussions with the Defendant, it was understood that the power plant business was not part of the acquisition. However, there were no specific discussions with the Defendant on the ownership of the Subject Land on which the power plant was situated or whether such land was part of the acquisition. In fact, the Defendant did not discuss the ownership of the Subject Land at all. The Defendant certainly did not disclose to anyone from GSH present at the October 2013 meeting referred to at [56] above that PHSB or OBSB or anyone else owned or had an interest in the Subject Land.

  87. [61] On 30 December 2013 when Gilbert signed the SA on behalf of the Plaintiff, neither he nor Alex nor GSH were aware that PHSB or OBSB or any other entity had or was claiming any interest in the Subject Land.

  88. [62] Prior to completion of the SA on 26 March 2014, the Defendant had provided GSH with the Disclosure Letter dated 18 March 2014 (see [16] above). In the Disclosure Letter, however, the Defendant did not state: (i) that SHGCC did not own the Subject Land, (ii) that PHSB or OBSB or any other entity owned or had any interest in the Subject Land, and (iii) that he intended to sign the S&P for the sale of the Subject Land by PHSB to OBSB.

  89. [63] While the Defendant failed to make disclosure of such an important matter as his intended sale of the Subject Land by PHSB to OBSB, he chose to give specific disclosure of such seemingly insignificant matters as a pending case before the Sabah Labour Office by a chef seeking compensation and/or reinstatement after being dismissed from SHGCC. Three days after the Disclosure Letter, the Defendant executed the S&P of the Subject Land to OBSB by PHSB at a consideration of RM1,000 which he then backdated to 1 March 2014. The existence of the S&P was never communicated to GSH prior to or following completion.

  90. [64] In cross-examination, counsel for the Defendant, Mr Andy Lem (“Mr Lem”), placed great emphasis on the Valuation Report that the Defendant had handed over to GSH. Mr Lem pointed out to Gilbert that the Valuation Report clearly stated that the net area of the Sembulan Land was 94.9 hectares after deducting the area of the substations. That meant that the Co-Gen Facility and the Subject Land were excluded. Gilbert disagreed, pointing out that GSH did not rely on the Valuation Report to determine the exact assets of SHGCC or what GSH was buying. GSH would carry out its own due diligence exercise. Gilbert was only interested in the indicative value of SHGCC’s land being RM324m. Moreover, the Valuation Report did not list all the assets owned by SHGCC – these included a large vessel called Columbus that was worth a substantial sum of money. In re-examination, Gilbert added that there were two other vessels belonging to SHGCC which had not been listed as its assets in the valuation.

  91. [65] Gilbert’s attention was drawn to the letters concerning subdivision. The first letter was dated 27 July 2007 (“LSDS’s 2007 Letter of Offer”) which was well before GSH came into the picture. On behalf of SHGCC, the Defendant and its other director Foo had countersigned to accept LSDS’s 2007 Letter of Offer.

  92. [66] Gilbert testified he was neither shown a copy nor was he informed, of the contents of LSDS’s 2007 Letter of Offer when he and Francis countersigned LSDS’s letter dated 1 October 2014 (“LSDS’s 2014 Letter of Offer”) to accept its offer of a reduction in annual rent from RM117,500 (as stated in LSDS’s 2007 Letter of Offer) to RM31,800. LSDS’s 2014 Letter of Offer referred to 95.58 hectares of Land. On the face of the contents of LSDS’s 2014 Letter of Offer, Gilbert said he would not have known of the Defendant’s intention to carve out the Subject Land from the Sembulan Land by way of subdivision.

  93. Madeline’s testimony

  94. [67] As the Defendant’s pleadings had alluded to the due diligence exercise carried out on behalf of the Plaintiff , Madeline was called by the Plaintiff as a witness. In her AEIC, Madeline deposed that M&A’s scope of work was to carry out legal due diligence checks on the Malaysian components for the intended transaction under the SA, including the Sembulan Land. The due diligence exercise commenced officially on 30 November 2013 and M&A issued its due diligence report dated 13 March 2014 (“the DD Report”) at the conclusion of the exercise.

  95. [68] The representatives that Madeline dealt with were Alex from GSH and WLK from the Defendant’s side. In carrying out the work, Madeline deposed that no one from M&A visited the SH Resort in Sabah. What M&A did was to obtain the corporate secretarial records of the Sutera Target Group from the office of its corporate secretary, Jaschin Management Consultants Sdn Bhd based in Kuala Lumpur.

  96. [69] Madeline also viewed documents sent by WLK and her team which were in response to a legal due diligence checklist (“the DD Checklist”) that M&A had prepared.

  97. [70] As for the due diligence exercise conducted on the Sembulan Land, Madeline and M&A had come to know that there was then a pending application with the LSDS office for subdivision and conversion of the Sembulan Land. Her knowledge was sourced from:

  98. (a) being informed that the original title for the Sembulan Land was with the Sabah Land Office when she tried to locate the title deed; and

  99. (b) a directors’ resolution of SHGCC dated 20 September 2012 that authorized the surrender of the title for the purpose of the pending application.

  100. [71] Madeline and M&A were also informed of the following facts:

  101. (a) that the Defendant owned and controlled a company called PHSB which was in liquidation;

  102. (b) that PHSB operated the Co-Gen Facility which supplied electricity to SH Resort and other neighbouring properties; and

  103. (c) that the Co-Gen Facility was located on the Subject Land.

  104. [72] However, Madeline deposed she and M&A were never told by WLK or the Defendant that:

  105. (a) the intention or purpose behind the subdivision and conversion application was to demarcate PHSB’s alleged proprietary interest in the Subject Land and/or for the eventual transfer of the Subject Land to PHSB, OBSB, the Defendant or anyone else; or

  106. (b) that SHGCC was not the legal and beneficial owner of the Subject Land or any part thereof.

  107. Further, WLK did not disclose that PHSB, OBSB or the Defendant had any interest in the Subject Land or that the Defendant intended to execute a sale and purchase agreement to convey the Subject Land to OBSB.

  108. [73] Madeline referred to Section 8 of the DD Checklist which dealt with property records and assets, where:

  109. (a) Item number 2 requested:

  110. (b) Item number 10 requested:

  111. (c) Item number 17 requested parties to:

  112. [74] Under Section 11 of the DD Checklist which referred to “Material Contracts and Commitments”:

  113. (a) Item number 3 requested:

  114. (b) Item number 4 requested:

  115. (c) Item number 8 requested:

  116. (d) Item number 14 requested:

  117. (e) Item number 18 requested:

  118. WLK indicated “N/A” to all the above items.

  119. [75] Under Section 12 (“Directors and Directors’ Interest”), item number 2, M&A requested:

  120. WLK indicated “N/A”.

  121. [76] Madeline pointed out that the resolution of SHGCC dated 20 September 2012 authorising the surrender of the land title for the subdivision and conversion exercise did not go further to explain the purpose of the subdivision and conversion. She added that she and M&A did not find any other resolutions passed by SHGCC that authorised the disposal or transfer of ownership of any part of the Sembulan Land or the Subject Land. She noted from the title deed that the approved purpose of the Sembulan Land was for erecting a “tourist complex” – the construction of the Co-Gen Facility was not part of the approved purpose. Consequently, she deposed that it was reasonably concluded that SHGCC’s application for subdivision and conversion was to regularise the Sembulan Land to accommodate the Co-Gen Facility.

  122. [77] Madeline deposed that she had also looked into the various charges that were found in the records that she checked. Amongst them was a charge from SHGCC in favour of Maybank for a loan of RM118,250,000 extended to PHSB on 15 June 1999, ie the RM118.25m loan. SHGCC had given this charge as a third party charge on behalf of PHSB, as reflected in a directors’ resolution of SHGCC dated 18 November 1998; this was not uncommon practice and did not indicate that PHSB had any proprietary interest in the Subject Land.

  123. [78] Madeline deposed that she was not given and did not have sight of the letter dated 16 June 1999 from Maybank addressed to Bank Islam stating that the former, as the lender to SHGCC and PHSB, recognised the latter’s rights under a lease agreement dated 16 June 1999 between the latter and PHSB in relation to the ownership of the Co-Gen Facility. Maybank stated that it specifically excluded the Co-Gen Facility and the Subject Land from the ambit of Maybank’s charge dated 7 October 1998. Madeline and M&A also did not have sight of a letter dated 16 January 2013 from Bank Islam to SHGCC requesting a copy of LSDS’s Amended Offer to SHGCC pursuant to SHGCC’s application for subdivision and conversion. The request was premised on Bank Islam having an interest in the Subject Land due to a letter of undertaking from SHGCC to execute a charge over the Subject Land in favour of Bank Islam. Having reviewed the letter, however, Madeline deposed that nothing was said about PHSB having any proprietary interest in the Subject Land.

  124. [79] Madeline and M&A were aware at the time the due diligence exercise was being conducted that PHSB was already in liquidation. When they requested from WLK statements of accounts relating to the Maybank and Bank Islam loans, WLK said the documents were with the Liquidators of PHSB. Madeline testified she and M&A never received those statements of accounts. Madeline pointed out that if indeed PHSB had a proprietary interest in the Subject Land as the Defendant asserted, the Liquidators would have known and asserted such an interest on behalf of PHSB as part of their duty to collect and realise all the assets of PHSB. She surmised that since the Liquidators did not at any time assert that PHSB had a proprietary interest in the Sembulan Land or the Subject Land, it must mean that PHSB did not have any such interest.

  125. [80] During cross-examination, Ms Sharmini Selvaratnam (“Ms Selva”) drew Madeline’s attention to the Valuation Report, where it clearly stated that the Sembulan Land is 95.58 hectares after deducting the area of the substations on the Subject Land, indicating that the Subject Land was therefore excluded from the valuation. Madeline’s response was that she did not know the basis of the valuation – she was not looking at the valuation as her focus was on legal due diligence. She had only looked at the Valuation Report to check what encumbrances were on the Sembulan Land, not for the valuation itself. In any case, the Valuation Report was prepared in 2013, well before GSH entered the scene. Neither did the Valuation Report tell her that SHGCC did not own the land on which the substations were built or that the substations did not belong to SHGCC. Further, the Valuation Report valued some, not all, of the assets of SHGCC. Ultimately, Madeline said she relied on land search results rather than the Valuation Report as conclusive evidence of the ownership of the Sembulan Land. Hence, the Valuation Report “doesn’t mean anything” to her. In re-examination, Madeline added that the Valuation Report did not mention there was a caveat on SHGCC’s land by Bank Islam referred to below.

  126. [81] Madeline was referred to a loan restructuring document reflected in a security sharing agreement dated 31 January 2002 (“the SS Agreement”) between Malayan Trustees Bhd (“MTB”) as trustee for the bondholders, the Sutera Target Group, the Defendant, SHGCC, First Time Holdings Ltd, PHSB and scheme creditors whereby SH Resort issued bonds to its lenders. The SS Agreement contained a Letter of Disclaimer clause which states:

  127. The “Excluded Area” was defined as the Subject Land in the SS Agreement. Madeline was told that PHSB’s interest in the Subject Land was clearly spelt out in the SS Agreement, supporting the Defendant’s case. MTB issued the Letter of Disclaimer to PHSB on 29 January 2002 and besides the above extract, the Letter of Disclaimer signed by MTB contained the following paragraph:

  128. Annexure A was a site plan of the Sembulan Land and Subject Land.

  129. [82] Madeline responded, however, that PHSB was stated in the above extract in MTB’s Letter of Undertaking to be “the occupier” and not “the owner” of the “Excluded Area”.

  130. [83] To further substantiate the Defendant’s case, Ms Selva drew Madeline’s attention to the Facility Agreement between PHSB and Maybank dated 15 June 1999 for the RM118.25m loan. In contrast to the SS Agreement, the Subject Land was not excluded from the charge that SHGCC provided as security for the said loan, which Madeline acknowledged.

  131. [84] Madeline’s AEIC had alluded to her having sight of Bank Islam’s caveat over the Subject Land dated 6 December 2010 (“Bank Islam’s caveat”) in the course of her due diligence exercise. The caveat related to the US$24m loan which was extended by Bank Islam to PHSB and for which PHSB executed a debenture dated 16 June 1999 (“Bank Islam’s Debenture”). In Bank Islam’s Debenture, the security provided by PHSB to Bank Islam did not include the Subject Land. Further, Madeline testified that by the time of the due diligence exercise, the US$24m loan had been paid off. Consequently, she did not delve further into Bank Islam’s caveat.

  132. [85] Madeline was also cross-examined on SHGCC’s letter of undertaking dated 16 June 1999 (“Sutera Letter of Undertaking”) wherein SHGCC undertook to execute a charge in favour of Bank Islam over the Sembulan and Subject Lands. She was also questioned on Bank Islam’s letter of release dated 30 January 2002 wherein, in consideration of the Defendant’s entering into a memorandum of charge over his shares, Bank Islam released the Sutera Target Group including SHGCC from their agreements and undertakings (including the Sutera Letter of Undertaking) in relation to the US$24m loan referred to above at [84]. The court will return to the US$24m loan in the course of reviewing the Defendant’s evidence.

  133. [86] Madeline was also questioned on the subdivision application made by SHGCC. As this issue was also raised in the cross-examination of Gilbert and Alex, the court will address this issue below.

  134. [87] Based on the various documents referred to in the foregoing at [80], [81], and [83]–[85], Ms Selva’s questioning of Madeline sought to show that the latter knew or that she ought to have known, that the Subject Land did not belong to SHGCC due to (i) the Valuation Report, (ii) the application for subdivision of the Sembulan Land, and (iii) the numerous banking documents. Madeline consistently disagreed with her.

  135. Alex’s testimony

  136. [88] Alex, the Plaintiff’s last witness and the CFO of GSH, was in overall charge of the due diligence exercise (working together with the financial and legal due diligence teams) as well as the finalization of the terms of the SA.

  137. [89] In his AEIC, Alex pointed out that the Valuation Report (upon which the Defendant placed so much reliance) was not a document that GSH requested and was not a document prepared for the acquisition. He had only glanced at it to get a general idea of the value of SHGCC at the October 2013 meeting when the Defendant’s team handed it over.

  138. [90] Alex deposed that in the days leading up to the signing of the SA, there were heavy negotiations between the Defendant and GSH/the Plaintiff relating to its terms. There were lengthy meetings held at SH Resort attended by the Defendant, WLK, Francis and himself. At these meetings, neither the Defendant nor WLK raised any issues regarding Schedule 4 of the SA (see [41] above).

  139. [91] At the time when the SA was signed, no one in GSH/the Plaintiff was aware that PHSB, OBSB or any other person had or was claiming any interest in the Subject Land. Neither did the Defendant disclose in writing to GSH/the Plaintiff that any person had any beneficial interest in any part of the Sembulan Land apart from SHGCC. On the contrary, the Defendant had specifically warranted that the whole of the Sembulan Land was legally and beneficially owned by SHGCC under para 18.2 of Schedule 2 of the SA (see [40] above) read with Schedule 4. Further, under cl 6.1 of the SA, the representations and warranties in the SA were to hold true and be accurate as at the date of the SA (30 December 2013) and as at completion (26 March 2014). In addition, the Defendant had provided the Plaintiff with the Disclosure Letter, which did not refer to the S&P, the Transaction, or the fact that any party claimed an interest in the Subject Land (see [16] above).

  140. [92] Alex deposed that that the due diligence exercise did not reveal any documents or information that showed the Defendant’s intention to transfer the Subject Land to PHSB or OBSB or any other person following the subdivision of the Sembulan Land. He added that the Plaintiff was unaware of the S&P (see [10] above) which Alex alleged was prepared and executed surreptitiously without the knowledge and consent of GSH or the Plaintiff. Because of the thousands of transactions which took place for the business of SH Resort, Alex deposed that he did not know or notice that SHGCC had not been receiving rent from the Co-Gen Facility for the occupation of the Subject Land since October 2013. This was also because the amount of rent was insignificant in comparison to the revenue received from SH Resort’s business. Further, no one had highlighted to him that rent for the Subject Land had not been received by SHGCC since October 2013.

  141. [93] Alex referred to the valuation report that was prepared after completion of the SA by Azmi & Co dated 2 September 2014 (“the 2014 Valuation Report”). This was prepared at the request of the auditors for the purpose of assessing whether there were any impairments of the book value of SHGCC’s assets. At the request of Azmi & Co, a copy of the Valuation Report was extended to them. Azmi & Co relied on the Valuation Report to prepare the 2014 Valuation Report.

  142. [94] Alex deposed that he discovered the existence of the S&P in mid-2015 during the review by Ernst & Young (“E&Y”) of SHGCC’s accounts. E&Y chanced upon an entry in the said accounts which recorded a gain of RM1,000. E&Y queried Dickson Chong (“Dickson”), the person in charge of the accounts for the SH Group, who said he was unaware of the particular entry. Dickson investigated and traced the entry to the S&P, which copy he found in the files in the office. He then brought the S&P to the attention of E&Y and Alex.

  143. [95] Upon further inquiry, Alex ascertained that WLK had handled the S&P and the Transaction. The S&P was executed on behalf of SHGCC by its former directors while the Defendant and WLK executed it on behalf of OBSB. After execution, WLK bypassed Dickson and handed the S&P directly to one Joanne, the finance manager of SHGCC, to book the entry into the accounts of SHGCC.

  144. [96] E&Y highlighted to Alex that the S&P attracted real property gains tax and advised that a real property gains tax return should have been filed within 60 days of the S&P but it was not. That meant that SHGCC could be liable to a penalty of three times the determined amount of real property gain tax, which could be a significant amount if the market value of the Subject Land was used for computation in the event that it was found not to be a transaction at arm’s length. The directors of SHGCC could also be charged and fined or jailed.

  145. [97] Alex deposed that his immediate focus was to avoid prosecution of the directors of SHGCC and the imposition of tax penalties. Consequently, SHGCC took steps to immediately file the real property gains tax return with the authorities and then seek an indemnity from the Defendant for any tax liability arising thereafter.

  146. [98] After informing Gilbert, Alex then prepared a letter for the Plaintiff (which Gilbert signed) to the Defendant dated 4 September 2015 (“the 4 September letter”) where he narrated the facts stated above in [95]–[97] above. The Plaintiff went on to give notice under cl 8A.2 of the SA and alleged that the Defendant had breached cl 7.2(b) and as well as paras 4.1(c), 6.2(a), 6.3(a)(i), 6.4(b), 6.6(b), 11.1 and 11.2 of Schedule 2 therein, which were to hold true up to completion by virtue of cl 6.1 of the SA. Pursuant to cll 8.1(a), (b), (c) and (d) of the SA, the Plaintiff asserted that the Defendant was liable to fully indemnify the Plaintiff against any loss, and any real property gains tax as well as any tax penalty arising from the S&P and the Transaction.

  147. [99] In his reply to the 4 September letter dated 9 September 2015, the Defendant did not deny the existence of the S&P but merely requested the Plaintiff to instruct E&Y to do the necessary filing and to advise him thereafter.

  148. [100] After the Plaintiff had taken legal advice, it decided to and did return the RM1,000 to OBSB, after giving notice of its intention to do so in its solicitor’s letter to OBSB dated 25 September 2015. E&Y were instructed not to proceed to file the real property gains tax return as the Plaintiff took the stand that the S&P was not an arm’s length transaction and was void. The Plaintiff’s solicitors also gave notice that it would not sell or transfer the Subject Land to OBSB. The Plaintiff’s solicitors wrote a separate letter to the Defendant on the same day which contents were similar to the letter to OBSB.

  149. [101] Alex subsequently discovered from the Malaysian Suit that the S&P had been executed on 21 March 2014 but was backdated to 1 March 2014 on the instructions of WLK to the solicitor, Timothy Soo from the law firm of Jayasuriya Kah & Co (“JK&C”) who had drafted the document. He further ascertained that tenancy agreements had been signed between SHGCC and PHSB since 2001 for occupation by PHSB of the Subject Land where the Co-Gen Facility was located. Under the last tenancy agreement dated 1 December 2012, the monthly rent was RM5,558. SHGCC had charged rent until January 2014 by way of debit notes. However, the debit note for January 2014 was subsequently cancelled and a credit note was raised on or about 24 January 2014 to reverse the effect of the debit notes rendered by SHGCC from October to December 2013. This was done after the SA was signed but before completion.

  150. [102] Alex had also become aware that SHGCC had issued a prospectus dated 27 December 2012 (“the Prospectus”) to the public for the issuance of preference shares in the company. In the Prospectus, SHGCC was clearly stated to be the owner of the Sembulan Land, including the Subject Land. In the subsequent prospectuses issued by SHGCC and dated 29 January and 30 June 2014 respectively, the same statement appeared.

  151. [103] As Alex was questioned on the Valuation Report and 2014 Valuation Report by Mr Lem on the same basis as Gilbert and Madeline, the court deems it unnecessary to review that aspect of his evidence in detail. The nub of Mr Lem’s questions centred on the area of the Sembulan Land stated in the two reports. In the Valuation Report, the net land area was stated to be 94.90 hectares or 234.50 acres after deducting areas for substations. In the 2014 Valuation Report however, the area of the Sembulan Land was stated to be 95.58 hectares or 236.18 acres; the difference was 1.68 hectares. On 8 January 2016, Azmi & Co issued an amended certificate of valuation correcting the area of the Sembulan Land from 95.58 to 94.90 hectares consistent with that stated in the Valuation Report. Mr Lem stated (with which Alex disagreed) that the Plaintiff never took issue with the land area of 94.90 hectares because it knew the Subject Land was never part of SHGCC’s assets. The court notes here that it was in evidence that for both valuation reports, it was the Defendant or the Defendant’s office who informed both CH Williams and Azmi & Co that the area of land for valuation was or should be 94.90 hectares. No independent survey of the Sembulan Land was conducted by either valuer. Given that the stated area was entirely based on the Defendant’s own reporting, the probative value of these reports was minimal.

  152. [104] Mr Lem went further to question Alex on the inclusion of the Valuation Report in the financial statements of SHGCC for 2014 and subsequent years. Alex pointed out that preparation of the financial statements of SHGCC for 2014, which reflected the revaluation exercise in 2013, would have been under the charge of WLK from the previous management. In fact, it is of little or no consequence to the court whether the yearly accounts of SHGCC referred to the Valuation Report or to the 2014 Valuation Report as there were shortcomings in both valuations and this issue was not directly relevant to the dispute at hand.

  153. [105] The court turns to other aspects of Alex’s cross-examination which have a direct bearing on the issues to be decided in this Suit.

  154. [107] Alex’s attention was also drawn to the Defendant’s letter dated 26 March 2013 addressed to the Liquidators. The Defendant informed the Liquidators that he had reached a settlement with Bank Islam, that the settlement sum of RM33.6m would be paid by OBSB and that this sum represented the purchase price of the power plant and machinery of PHSB (collectively “the Assets”) located at the Co-Generation Facility. The Defendant stated he nominated OBSB as the buyer to enter into the sale and purchase agreement with PHSB. This agreement became the ASA executed on 12 July 2013 (see [15] above). The Defendant added that the sale and purchase would exclude the Subject Land for which OBSB would enter into a separate agreement with the landowner, SHGCC.

  155. [108] Mr Lem reminded Alex of the judgment in the Malaysian Suit that upheld the Common Expectation that PHSB (and its successor OBSB) would be entitled to possession and ownership of the Subject Land and the Co-Gen Facility because of money PHSB had expended on the development of the Co-Gen Facility. Mr Lem said the S&P was regarded as a mere formality by the Defendant, as pleaded in the Defence which adopted the language of the judgment in the Malaysian Suit, and, contrary to Alex’s allegation, the Defendant did not deliberately hide the S&P from the Plaintiff; Alex unsurprisingly disagreed.

  156. [109] As for the various prospectuses that SHGCC issued (see [102] above) which were reviewed by M&A, Mr Lem sought to convince Alex (who disagreed) that the purpose of those documents was to determine the reciprocal and affiliation agreements that were entered into by SHGCC for its members to use facilities of 36 other clubs and to make available such agreements for inspection by its members. No evidence in this regard was presented by the Defendant and the court accordingly disregards the Defendant’s explanation.

  157. The Defendant’s case

  158. The Defendant’s testimony

  159. [110] The Defendant was the first witness for his defence. His AEIC was lengthy resulting in his cross-examination taking three days. Most of the facts set out in his AEIC have been canvassed with the Plaintiff’s witnesses and it is not necessary to repeat them.

  160. [111] In his AEIC, the Defendant set out the genesis of the SH Resort which he had started constructing in the early 1990s, with the Co-Gen Facility being built between 1997 and 1999. The Defendant deposed at length as to all the financial institutions and financial instruments that he and/or his companies, including the SH Group, dealt with from the time of or before construction of the SH Resort commenced.

  161. [112] Throughout his AEIC, the Defendant repeatedly referred to the Common Expectation that PHSB had that it would own the Subject Land because it had expended RM155m to develop the Co-Gen Facility situated thereon. This issue will be dealt with in greater detail below (see [135]–[138]).

  162. [113] The Defendant referred to numerous banking and other documentation which were generated before GSH and the Plaintiff came into the picture. Amongst such documents was a letter from Bank Islam to KPMG dated 12 March 2012 (after PHSB had gone into liquidation on 11 January 2012) giving notice that under Bank Islam’s Debenture (see [84] above), Bank Islam as a secured lender had an interest over the assets of PHSB including the Subject Land. Bank Islam had given a similar notice on the same day to MTB. Both these letters were copied to, inter alia, Maybank and SHGCC.

  163. [114] The US$24m loan (referred to in [84] above) to PHSB had been secured by the Defendant’s personal guarantee as well as the pledge of his 51% shares in SH Holdings.

  164. [115] During cross-examination, the Defendant admitted that by 2012, the SH Group was in serious financial difficulties and was owing loan stockholders almost RM2 billion. In some cases, the loans extended to his companies, including PHSB, were secured by the Defendant’s personal guarantees and/or the pledge of his shares in various companies including SH Holdings. In fact, a winding up petition was ultimately filed against SH Holdings. More will be said of the winding up proceedings below (at [134]).

  165. [116] Consequently from early 2013, the Defendant desperately looked for investors to save SH Group as well as himself from financial ruin. He found his white knight in GSH, which then worked through the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff’s investment of RM700m into the Sutera Target Group was used to settle all of the outstanding indebtedness due to the SH Group’s bondholders as well as the loans of Maybank and Bank Islam. As a result of the Plaintiff’s investment, the Defendant not only paid off all the loans owed by him and or his various companies but he also walked away with a windfall of RM127m.

  166. [117] During cross-examination, the Defendant agreed that he did not state in his AEIC that he had told Goi that the land on which the Co-Gen Facility was located, ie the Subject Land, was not for sale. He had only told Goi that the Co-Gen Facility was not for sale. The Defendant felt it was “obvious for anybody as a businessman” that if he was not selling the building, he would not be selling the land, so he assumed when he talked to Goi about the exclusion of the Co-Gen Facility from the sale that the Subject Land was similarly excluded. He admitted it was a mistake on his or his lawyers’ part in not checking that the SA contained an exclusion of the Subject Land from the sale to the Plaintiff.

  167. [118] When questioned by the court, the Defendant said it never occurred to him to tell Goi that the Subject Land was not owned by SHGCC. He denied the suggestion made by counsel for the Plaintiff, Ms Engelin Teh, SC (“Ms Teh”), that he had failed to inform Goi because he knew the Subject Land belonged to SHGCC.

  168. [119] The Defendant was cross-examined on the various warranties he had given under the SA which were set out above at [38] to [42]. He agreed that on 28 December 2013, the day when the SA was signed at SH Resort after last minute amendments were made to the document, neither he nor WLK informed the GSH representatives that PHSB or OBSB owned the proprietary interest in the Subject Land. Further, no amendment was made to the statement that SHGCC was the sole legal and beneficial owner of the whole of the Sembulan Land, stated to be “95.58 hectares”, which included the Subject Land. Again, the Defendant’s excuse for not spotting the omission that morning when the parties were still amending the SA was that he had overlooked the error.

  169. [120] Subsequently, between 28 December 2013 and 2 January 2014, there were emails exchanged between WLK and Alex making further amendments to the SA (notwithstanding that it had been signed) on which the Defendant sought and obtained advice from his Singapore lawyer (“WA”). Even at that stage, the Defendant did not state he wanted the Subject Land to be excluded from the sale. He agreed that on hindsight he should have done so. He repeated his defence that PHSB was the then owner of the Subject Land and the S&P was only a formality. He maintained he made a mistake and it was his oversight in not informing his solicitors of the need to amend Schedule 4 (see [41] above) to exclude the Subject Land.

  170. [121] It is noteworthy that in cross-examination, the Defendant agreed that not only did he not inform the Plaintiff’s representatives or Goi or M&A/Madeline that the Subject Land was not part of the sale or that the Subject Land would be transferred to OBSB, he did not at any time instruct WLK to inform the Plaintiff either. He claimed he did not look at the DD Checklist provided by M&A/Madeline nor the answers that WLK provided to the questions stated herein.

  171. [122] Even more telling was the Defendant’s admission during cross-examination that he even “overlooked” informing his lawyer, WA, of the S&P even though WA had been advising him throughout his negotiations with GSH, before as well as after the signing of the SA.

  172. [123] Despite his above admissions, the Defendant denied the Plaintiff’s suggestion that he had hatched a plan to exclude the Subject Land from the sale only in January 2014 after GSH had committed itself to the investment in the Sutera Target Group by signing the SA on 28 December 2013. He claimed that he had given instructions to JK&C to prepare the S&P a year earlier (in April 2013) but the lawyers had delayed its preparation.

  173. [124] The Defendant denied the Plaintiff’s suggestion that he had instructed WLK to rush through the S&P and then backdate it to just before he was due to provide the Disclosure Letter to the Plaintiff. He further denied hiding the S&P from Goi or the Plaintiff. He presumed they knew about it and that the Subject Land was not part of the deal. It should be noted in this regard that on 24 January 2014, WLK had sent an email to JK&C chasing JK&C for an update on the subdivision exercise as she claimed that the Subject Land was supposed to be transferred to OBSB after the sale of the Co-Gen Facility.

  174. [125] The Defendant further claimed it was WLK not he, who had instructed JK&C to prepare the S&P, although he admitted that she kept him informed by copying him on her correspondence with JK&C commencing from 20 March 2014. He denied the suggestion that the fact that JK&C were rushed to prepare the S&P but that it was signed after the end of the due diligence exercise (on 13 March 2014) and after the Disclosure Letter was sent (on 18 March 2014), revealed that he wanted to avoid disclosing the S&P through either means. However, the Defendant was unable to explain the delay in the signing of the S&P even though JK&C had it ready by 26 February 2014. Neither could he explain the backdating of the S&P to 1 March 2014 when it was actually signed on 21 March 2014, nor why the signing preceded the completion of the SA on 26 March 2014.

  175. [126] The Defendant admitted that he and WLK had prepared Schedule 4 to the SA and yet in his Counterclaim, the relief he prayed for was rectification of Schedule 4 on the basis that SHGCC’s ownership of its property had been incorrectly stated. He denied that his counterclaim was an afterthought.

  176. [127] It was clear from his evidence under cross-examination that the Defendant: (i) did not inform Goi that the Subject Land would not be included in the Plaintiff’s acquisition and (ii) did not inform the Plaintiff’s representatives at the signing of the SA on 28 December 2013 of the same. Neither did he or WLK disclose this to the Plaintiff during the due diligence exercise nor did either of them provide the Plaintiff with any documentation that stated that the Subject Land would be transferred to PHSB or OBSB upon subdivision. The Defendant, however, disagreed that it was deliberate non-disclosure on his part. He explained that the omission from the Disclosure Letter was because it was “irrelevant” and the S&P was “a formalisation of the ownership and doing the housekeeping”, an answer that did not make sense since he also apparently “overlooked” informing his lawyers of the matter at the time he signed the Disclosure Letter, although he now claimed that he wished that WLK had highlighted it to him.

  177. [128] One damning piece of evidence against the Defendant was JK&C’s letter dated 26 March 2014 to him forwarding two original stamped copies of the S&P dated 1 March 2014 and requesting him to forward the document to SHGCC, the vendor. The Defendant did not inform nor pass the document to the Plaintiff’s representatives who were present that same day for completion of the SA. No explanation was given other than his excuse that he believed WLK would follow up, although he admitted that he did not make any arrangements with WLK to do so.

  178. [129] Ms Teh pointed out to the Defendant that instead of a sale and purchase agreement, he could have procured SHGCC to execute a trust deed in favour of OBSB if the former was indeed holding the Subject Land in trust for the latter as he said. The Defendant claimed it was on KPMG’s advice at the time that he had settled the US$24m loan from Bank Islam, and that KPMG had told him that PHSB did not have legal title to the Subject Land at the time the ASA was executed (see [15] above). As the Liquidators therefore could not transfer the Subject Land to OBSB, KPMG recommended to him that a separate sale and purchase agreement should be prepared.

  179. [130] The Defendant agreed that Zarazilah and Foo who signed the S&P as directors on behalf of SHGCC were also appointed by him as directors of OBSB. Ms Teh had described these two directors of SHGCC as the Defendant’s “cronies” who had known him for a long time and who would sign whatever the Defendant wanted. The Defendant disagreed. He denied that the execution of the S&P was done surreptitiously and, even if it were, then WLK and JK&C were responsible. He again described the S&P as a “housekeeping” issue, according to his understanding from WLK.

  180. [131] Ms Teh put to the Defendant that the execution of the S&P and its concealment from the Plaintiff was not his only dishonest action. As part of the acquisition of SH Group, it had been agreed that the non-trade debts owed to the Defendant’s companies amounting to around RM8.78m were to be waived. However, it was discovered that the Defendant had transferred monies from SH Resort to his own companies as repayment of some of those debts. On 13 February 2014, Alex and Gilbert had attended a meeting with the Defendant and WLK where WLK confirmed that such payments had been made.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.