Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 27 Apr 2021

General Division of the High Court

Abdul Mutalib bin Aziman v Public Prosecutor and other appeals

Feedback & support

[2021] SGHC 102Case no. Magistrate’s Appeal No 9438 of 2020

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [2] The present appeals are against sentences imposed under these two provisions, each of which gives rise to novel questions of law on the applicable sentencing principles. We therefore directed that the four appeals be heard together by a three-judge coram pursuant to s 386(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 68, 2012 Rev Ed) (“CPC”). We further appointed Mr Zhuang WenXiong (“Mr Zhuang”) as young amicus curiae to assist us with the legal issues pertaining to the applicable sentencing principles. We are deeply grateful for the considerable effort applied by Mr Zhuang in researching these issues to assist us.

  3. An overview of the legislative framework

  4. [3] Until the Prisons Act was amended by the Prisons (Amendment) Act 2014 (Act 1 of 2014), offenders were released unconditionally after serving two-thirds of a sentence of imprisonment. The Prisons Act was amended on 1 July 2014 to introduce the Conditional Remission System (“CRS”) and the Mandatory Aftercare Scheme (“MAS”). The CRS and the MAS are two separate but related schemes designed to continue the process and enhance the prospects of rehabilitating prison inmates even after their release from prison. Whereas the CRS applies to all inmates upon their release, the MAS applies, in addition, to selected groups of inmates who are ascertained to be at a higher risk of reoffending or who require more help in their quest for rehabilitation and reintegration into society (see Singapore Parliamentary Debates, Official Report (20 January 2014) vol 91 (“the 2014 Parliamentary Debates”)).

  5. [5] Turning to the MAS, that subjects the ex-inmate to various mandatory aftercare conditions. The mandatory aftercare conditions are applicable to certain categories of high-risk ex-inmates who are released under the CRS and concurrently placed on the MAS by virtue of s 50U of the Prisons Act. One such mandatory aftercare condition (“MAC”) is that the ex-inmate shall remain indoors at his place of residence, or at such other place as the Commissioner of Prisons may specify, at certain times of the day (see s 50V(3)(c) of the Prisons Act). In these appeals, the appellants, who had all been released from prison subject to both the CRS and the MAS, were required to reside at Selarang Halfway House (“SHH”) under their respective MACs. The failure to remain indoors as specified constitutes a serious breach of a MAC, which is an offence punishable under s 50Y(1) of the Prisons Act. For convenience, we shall refer to this offence as a “s 50Y offence”, and to a charge in respect of this offence as a “s 50Y charge”.

  6. [6] In these appeals, the appellants had: (a) received enhanced sentences pursuant to s 50T of the Prisons Act for fresh offences committed while they were on remission; and (b) also been sentenced under s 50Y for a serious breach of a MAC. These appeals thus bring to the fore the sentencing approach that should be taken in such circumstances. Before considering the parties’ submissions and the applicable legal principles, we first outline the specific facts pertaining to each appeal.

  7. The facts

  8. MA 9438

  9. [7] The appellant in MA 9438 is Abdul Mutalib bin Aziman (“Abdul”). In 2016, Abdul was convicted of one charge of consuming a specified drug and two charges of failing to present himself for a urine test (“FPUT”), which was an offence punishable under reg 15(3)(f) read with reg 15(6)(a) of the Misuse of Drugs (Approved Institutions and Treatment and Rehabilitation) Regulations (Cap 185, Rg 3, 1999 Rev Ed). He was sentenced to a total of five years and six months’ imprisonment and three strokes of the cane.

  10. MA 9778

  11. [13] On 21 September 2019, Mani failed to return to SHH by the time he was required to. Messages were sent and calls were made by SHH’s staff to Mani, but he did not respond. On 22 September 2019, Mani informed SHH’s staff that he was having some unspecified problems. On 24 September 2019, Mani returned to SHH and was then arrested, having failed to remain indoors at SHH for a total of 58 hours and 30 minutes between 21 September 2019 and 24 September 2019. This was an offence under s 50Y(1) of the Prisons Act.

  12. MA 9780

  13. [18] On 17 July 2019, Norfarah was admitted to Changi General Hospital for vertigo. On 20 July 2019, SHH’s staff were informed that Norfarah had absconded from her ward at about 2.30pm the previous day. Norfarah did not respond to the messages and calls to her from SHH’s staff. Norfarah was subsequently arrested on 22 July 2019, having failed to remain indoors at SHH for a total of 75 hours and 30 minutes between 19 July 2019 and 22 July 2019. This was an offence under s 50Y(1) of the Prisons Act.

  14. MA 9790

  15. [22] On 16 February 2020, Amanshah failed to return to SHH by the time he was required to. SHH’s staff made multiple calls and sent multiple messages to him on 17 February 2020, but he did not respond. On 28 February 2020, Amanshah surrendered himself for drug-related offences and was arrested, having failed to remain indoors at SHH for a total of 279 hours and 25 minutes between 16 February 2020 and 28 February 2020. This was an offence under s 50Y(1) of the Prisons Act.

  16. The relevant provisions of the Prisons Act

  17. [27] The consequences of committing a fresh offence (which, as mentioned at [4] above, does not include a s 50Y offence) in breach of this basic condition are set out in s 50T, the relevant parts of which read as follows:

  18. [30] Turning to the MAS, the various MACs are set out in s 50V(3) of the Prisons Act. The commission of a serious breach of a MAC is itself an offence under s 50Y, which reads as follows:

  19. The purpose of ss 50T and 50Y of the Prisons Act

  20. [33] In short, the CRS and the MAS strive to achieve the twin objectives of incentivising inmates towards good conduct while they are in prison, and promoting their rehabilitation and reintegration into society after their release. Parliament plainly recognised that the process of rehabilitating offenders and reintegrating them back into society necessarily continues even after their release from prison. As the then Senior Minister of State for Home Affairs, Mr Masagos Zulkifli B M M (“the Senior Minister of State”), observed in the 2014 Parliamentary Debates:

  21. [34] The emphasis on rehabilitation and reintegration should be seen in the context of the problem of recidivism. Where an ex-inmate commits an offence after his release from prison, this suggests that the objective of rehabilitation has not been achieved in his case. The importance of reducing recidivism rates was emphasised by the Senior Minister of State in the 2014 Parliamentary Debates as follows:

  22. [35] In short, the project of rehabilitation and reintegration necessarily continues even after an offender has been released from prison. As part of that endeavour, Parliament addressed the need to tackle the issue of recidivism. The CRS and the MAS aim to provide incentives for offenders to maintain good behaviour while they are in prison, stay crime-free upon their release and engage in constructive pursuits thereafter in the hope that over time, they can break free from the cycle of criminal behaviour. To this end, ss 50T and 50Y provide a mechanism to rescind the whole or part of the remission period granted to an offender in respect of his original offence(s) so as to deter him from reoffending after his release from prison, while incentivising him to stay crime-free for as long as possible.

  23. The issues of law raised in the present appeals

  24. The uncertainty in the law

  25. [37] In relation to enhanced sentences meted out pursuant to s 50T of the Prisons Act, the lower courts have adopted two different sentencing approaches in calibrating the appropriate length of the enhanced sentence:

  26. [38] As regards s 50Y(1) of the Prisons Act, the lower courts have likewise applied two different sentencing approaches in determining the appropriate sentence for a s 50Y offence:

  27. (b) In contrast, in Abdul Mutalib (at [49]–[53]), Mani (at [40]–[45]) and Amanshah (at [32]–[34]), the District Court applied a sentencing band approach similar to what had been adopted in relation to s 50T. Under this approach, the starting point in sentencing depends on whether the offender’s culpability is characterised as being “low”, “medium” or “high” by reference to the statutory factors outlined in s 50Y(2).

  28. [39] The courts below have also diverged on three specific points of law:

  29. (a) First, there has been some uncertainty as to whether a guilty plea to a fresh offence is a mitigating factor that should be taken into consideration to diminish the length of the enhanced sentence imposed under s 50T of the Prisons Act. In Mohamad Dom at [70] and Norfarah at [52], the court held that such a guilty plea was irrelevant when determining the appropriate length of the enhanced sentence for the fresh offence because it would already have been considered when deciding on the underlying sentence for that offence; therefore, giving the offender further credit would amount to double-counting the benefit from pleading guilty. In contrast, in Abdul Mutalib (at [46] and [53]), Mani (at [33] and [37]) and Amanshah (at [52], [57] and [61]), the court considered an offender’s guilty plea to a fresh offence to be a mitigating factor when determining the appropriate length of the enhanced sentence for that offence.

  30. (b) Second, it has not been clear whether the totality principle applies to the aggregate of the imprisonment sentences imposed under s 50T and/or s 50Y. The court in Norfarah doubted the applicability of the totality principle in this context (at [44]). In contrast, the court in Mani (at [48]) and Amanshah (at [68]) accepted the Prosecution’s submission that the individual sentences imposed under s 50T and/or s 50Y could and should be calibrated downwards on account of the totality principle in appropriate cases.

  31. [40] Given the relative recency of ss 50T and 50Y of the Prisons Act, it is not surprising that the reasoning applied by the courts below has largely been based on first principles. As a result, there has been a lack of coherence and consistency, which is plainly not satisfactory. This is especially so given the quest for broad parity and consistency in sentencing. Against this backdrop, these appeals present a suitable opportunity for us to clarify and provide guidance on the basic sentencing framework, principles and considerations pertinent to ss 50T and 50Y.

  32. The issues to be determined

  33. [41] A number of issues arise for our determination, which we have broadly framed as follows to incorporate the areas of uncertainty that have been identified above:

  34. (a) Which sentencing approach is best suited to the determination of the appropriate sentences under ss 50T and 50Y of the Prisons Act?

  35. (b) What sentencing factors should the court take into account in calibrating sentences under ss 50T and 50Y? In particular, where s 50T is concerned, should a guilty plea in respect of a fresh offence be considered in calibrating the enhanced sentence for that offence?

  36. (d) How does the totality principle apply in the context of sentences imposed under ss 50T and 50Y?

  37. The appropriate sentencing framework for sentences under ss 50T and 50Y of the Prisons Act

  38. [42] As a preliminary point, we reiterate the unique nature of ss 50T and 50Y of the Prisons Act. As has been noted, although the sentences meted out under ss 50T and 50Y are in respect of fresh offences (in the case of s 50T) and serious breaches of MACs (in the case of s 50Y), the factors that go towards determining the length of such sentences have some reference to the original offence(s) in respect of which the offender was granted remission. This peculiar aspect of ss 50T and 50Y is relevant for the purposes of formulating the appropriate sentencing framework.

  39. The sentencing band approach

  40. [44] As with any sentencing framework, the court’s first task lies in the selection of the appropriate approach. As has been noted, two different sentencing approaches have been applied in relation to s 50T enhanced sentences and sentences for s 50Y offences: the “single starting point” approach and the “sentencing band” approach, to use the terminology adopted by the Court of Appeal in Ng Kean Meng Terence v Public Prosecutor [2017] 2 SLR 449 (“Terence Ng”) at [26] and [36]:

  41. (b) Under the sentencing band approach, the court identifies sentencing bands and determines the applicable sentence by first situating the case at hand within the appropriate sentencing band. In determining the appropriate sentencing band, the court will consider the factors identified in ss 50T(3) and 50Y(2). This approach was applied in Abdul Mutalib, Mani and Amanshah to both s 50T enhanced sentences and sentences for s 50Y offences.

  42. [45] The Prosecution and Mr Zhuang are in agreement that the sentencing band approach should be applied to both s 50T enhanced sentences and sentences for s 50Y offences. We concur. In our judgment, the sentencing band approach is the more appropriate approach in this context. We consider that the single starting point approach is inappropriate for the following reasons:

  43. (a) That approach is best suited for situations “where the offence in question almost invariably manifests itself in a particular way and the range of sentencing considerations is circumscribed” (see Terence Ng at [28]). However, the fresh offences which can trigger the imposition of enhanced sentences under s 50T do not manifest themselves in a particular way, and can be any non-s 50Y offence which results in a sentence of imprisonment (not including a default sentence of imprisonment), corrective training, reformative training or preventive detention (see ss 50S(1)(a) and 50S(1)(b) of the Prisons Act). Similarly, s 50Y offences may manifest themselves as serious breaches of any of the MACs listed in s 50V(3) of the Prisons Act.

  44. [46] We turn to the sentencing band approach, which, in our view, is the more appropriate approach for the following reasons:

  45. (a) The sentencing band approach enables sentencing courts to develop a sentencing framework that covers the entire range of offences in terms of their gravity, and empowers them to choose an indicative starting point out of a band of possible sentences. These features equip sentencing courts with greater flexibility to arrive at sentences that are both proportionate and appropriate in all the circumstances (see Terence Ng at [37(d)]).

  46. (b) The statutory factors to be considered under ss 50T(3) and 50Y(2) are qualitative in nature. This entails that the sentencing band approach is preferable to the “multiple starting points” approach, which is premised on the presence of a single or predominant quantitative metric that acts as a yardstick for the starting point (see Terence Ng at [30]).

  47. (c) The statutory factors to be considered under ss 50T(3) and 50Y(2) are broad, since fresh offences and s 50Y offences may be committed in a myriad of different situations. To that extent, it is difficult to establish a set of “principal factual elements” which can “significantly affect the seriousness of an offence in all cases” (see Terence Ng at [34]). The sentencing band approach is therefore to be preferred as well over the “sentencing matrix” approach given that the latter is predicated on the existence of such a set of principal facts.

  48. [49] We reiterate here a point that we made earlier at [29] above in relation to s 50T specifically, namely, the sentencing court has a discretion whether to impose an enhanced sentence at all for a fresh offence. The factors relevant to the exercise of this discretion are set out in s 50T(3), which reads as follows:

  49. [50] A plain reading of s 50T(3) indicates that the court must decide: (a) whether to impose an enhanced sentence for a fresh offence; and (b) if so, how long the enhanced sentence should be. Two divergent approaches to how this determination should be made were canvassed before us:

  50. (b) The second approach is to adopt an all-encompassing inquiry that considers in tandem both whether to impose an enhanced sentence for the fresh offence in question, and if so, how to calibrate it. Mr Zhuang supports this approach mainly because both steps of the inquiry require consideration of the factors listed in ss 50T(3)(a)–50T(3)(d). The Prosecution broadly agrees with Mr Zhuang, but, in any event, considers that there is unlikely to be any substantive difference between the two approaches.

  51. [51] While we acknowledge that the approach in Mohamad Dom has some advantage in keeping the inquiries distinct, we think that all that is needed is for the sentencing court to pause and consider whether it is necessary to impose an enhanced sentence. So long as the fresh offence committed is more than de minimis, that would suffice in general to justify the imposition of an enhanced sentence. It follows that the questions of whether an enhanced sentence should be imposed, and if so, how long that sentence should be, may be assessed in the round. As Mr Zhuang pointed out, the same factors are to be considered at both stages and we see no need for the same analysis to be undertaken twice. This was also recognised in Mohamad Dom at [55].

  52. [52] For completeness, we reiterate as well our earlier observation (at [31] above) that in contrast to s 50T, it is mandatory to impose an imprisonment sentence in respect of a s 50Y offence. As such, the specific point raised at [50] above does not arise in relation to s 50Y.

  53. The sentencing factors under ss 50T(3) and 50Y(2)

  54. [53] We turn to consider the sentencing factors under ss 50T(3) and 50Y(2), which will be relevant to the sentencing court’s determination of the sentencing band that applies in a given case. In our judgment, these factors can, in broad terms, be classified into three categories: (a) factors going towards the gravity of the offence committed by the offender while on remission (which will be a fresh offence in the case of s 50T, and a serious breach of a MAC in the case of s 50Y); (b) factors going towards the offender’s rehabilitative prospects; and (c) all other relevant circumstances. Without setting down a strict rule, we observe that the first two categories of factors are likely to be the focus of the sentencing court in most cases.

  55. The gravity of the fresh or s 50Y offence committed by the offender

  56. [56] As for the gravity of a serious breach of a MAC under s 50Y of the Prisons Act, both Mr Zhuang and the Prosecution agree that the type of breach (meaning the type of MAC breached) is relevant to the assessment of gravity. However, Mr Zhuang submits that only the type of breach is relevant. In contrast, the Prosecution submits that considerations ancillary to the type of breach – such as the duration of the breach, the consequences of the breach and the motivations behind the breach – are also relevant. On this, we agree with the Prosecution that the word “gravity” in s 50Y(2)(a) extends beyond the type of breach. It is also not practical to assess the gravity of a serious breach of a MAC purely by reference to its type. We further agree with the Prosecution that considerations ancillary to the type of breach, if already taken into account under s 50Y(2)(a), should not be factored in again under s 50Y(2)(c). Finally, we observe that since s 50Y offences consist of serious breaches of MACs, gravity in this context would have to be considered relative to the entire spectrum of breaches of MACs. This is because the harm occasioned by breaches of MACs in and of themselves, being breaches of conditions that go towards monitoring an offender, would ordinarily not be significant.

  57. The offender’s rehabilitative prospects

  58. [57] We next consider the offender’s rehabilitative prospects. The focus here is on the extent to which the offender’s fresh offending behaviour can be said to have undermined the goals enshrined in s 50E of the Prisons Act, which we referred to earlier (see [32] above). This consideration finds expression in the factors of the similarity and timing of the fresh offence under s 50T(3)(b) and s 50T(3)(c) respectively, as well as the factors of the timing of the s 50Y offence and the offender’s lack of commitment to rehabilitation and reintegration under s 50Y(2)(b) and s 50Y(2)(c) respectively. These statutory factors are not exhaustive, and the sentencing court must consider the totality of the circumstances in assessing the offender’s rehabilitative prospects.

  59. (1) The timing of the fresh or s 50Y offence committed by the offender

  60. (2) Similarity between the fresh offence and the original offence

  61. [60] As to the assessment of similarity, we agree with the Prosecution that offences are similar if they share common legal elements or commonalities “in the broad sense understood by laymen”: see Leong Mun Kwai v Public Prosecutor [1996] 1 SLR(R) 719 at [18].

  62. [62] Mr Zhuang disagrees with this approach, and submits that the court need not decide whether to exclude the portion of the suspended sentence attributable to an original offence that is dissimilar to the fresh offence committed. We agree with Mr Zhuang. Where multiple original offences are concerned, the sentencing court should consider the remaining duration of the remission period with reference to all the original offences, regardless of their similarity to the fresh offence committed. This is for the following reasons:

  63. (3) The offender’s lack of commitment to rehabilitation and reintegration

  64. [63] For reasons that are not clear to us, the offender’s lack of commitment to rehabilitation and reintegration is expressly provided for as a relevant consideration in s 50Y(2)(c) but not in s 50T(3). Nevertheless, this does not exclude its consideration in the context of s 50T as the court is statutorily required to have regard to “all other relevant circumstances” under s 50T(3)(d). Self-evidently, the greater the evidence of the offender’s lack of commitment to rehabilitation and reintegration, the greater will be the extent of the rescindment of the remission period. Whether the commission of a fresh or s 50Y offence goes towards establishing a lack of commitment to rehabilitation and reintegration on the offender’s part is a matter for the sentencing court to decide, taking into account all the relevant circumstances of the case. However, it is important to ensure that the identical consideration is not applied multiple times to the prejudice of the offender.

  65. Other relevant circumstances

  66. [64] Finally, the court is required to have regard to “all other relevant circumstances” [emphasis added]. This is embodied in ss 50T(3)(d) and 50Y(2)(d) of the Prisons Act, which are residual catch-all provisions meant to ensure that the court’s sentencing discretion is not fettered.

  67. [65] We turn first to s 50Y, where the position is more straightforward. As s 50Y(1) creates a distinct offence, the specific aggravating or mitigating factors pertinent to the case at hand can be considered without any concerns of double-counting. This would typically include the offender’s guilty plea, although, as a practical matter, this has little weight where the offender has been caught “red-handed” (see Sim Gek Yong v Public Prosecutor [1995] 1 SLR(R) 185 at [6]). Given that s 50Y offences often concern breaches of monitoring conditions, it seems difficult to envisage a situation where an offender would not be caught “red-handed”.

  68. [66] The position under s 50T is more difficult. As we highlighted earlier (at [28] above), s 50T does not create a distinct offence, but only permits the court to impose an enhanced sentence in addition to the underlying sentence imposed for a fresh offence. To that extent, the relevant aggravating or mitigating factors for the purposes of s 50T would necessarily relate to the fresh offence, and there is a real risk of double-counting if aggravating or mitigating circumstances that were considered in calibrating the underlying sentence for the fresh offence are considered again in determining the enhanced sentence for that offence.

  69. [67] In our judgment, while it might theoretically be possible to see the aggravating or mitigating factors to be considered under s 50T as being relevant to a different part of the sentencing analysis (namely, when deciding on the enhanced sentence, as opposed to the underlying sentence, for a fresh offence), this would give rise to unnecessary and excessive complexity for sentencing courts. The better approach is to recognise that once the relevant aggravating or mitigating factors have been considered in arriving at the underlying sentence for a fresh offence, that sentence will itself have a significant influence on the extent of any enhancement in sentence that may be imposed under s 50T (see [55] above). These factors should not then be reconsidered separately in determining any enhanced sentence under s 50T.

  70. Cases involving multiple fresh offences and s 50Y offences

  71. The outer limit to the cumulative sentence under ss 50T and 50Y

  72. [68] Sections 50T and 50Y of the Prisons Act provide that there are certain limits to the sentences that may be imposed thereunder. The relevant provisions of s 50T read as follows:

  73. [69] The relevant provisions of s 50Y read as follows:

  74. The sentencing approach where there are multiple fresh offences and s 50Y offences

  75. [77] We next outline the approach that the sentencing court should take when sentencing for multiple fresh offences and s 50Y offences. We deal first with the situation where none of the offences concerned are s 50Y offences and the sentencing court is faced purely with enhanced sentences under s 50T for multiple fresh offences. We have noticed a tendency by the courts below and also by the Prosecution to consider, first, the enhanced sentence to impose (if any) in respect of each fresh offence and then to reduce each individual enhanced sentence proportionally. In our judgment, the sentencing court need not always analyse separately the appropriate enhanced sentence to impose (if any) for each and every fresh offence.

  76. The totality principle in the context of ss 50T and 50Y

  77. [80] The totality principle is a well-established principle of sentencing which requires the court to take a “last look” at all the facts and circumstances of the case at hand to assess whether the sentence reached at the end of the sentencing process looks wrong. If it does, the court may adjust the aggregate sentence by “re-assessing which of the appropriate sentences ought to run consecutively” and/or “re-calibrating the individual sentences so as to arrive at an appropriate aggregate sentence” (see Mohamed Shouffee bin Adam v Public Prosecutor [2014] 2 SLR 998 (“Mohamed Shouffee”) at [47], [58] and [59]). The underlying rationale of the totality principle is the need to “ensure proportionality in a global sense” (see Mohamed Shouffee at [49], citing Tan Yock Lin, Criminal Procedure vol 3 (LexisNexis, 2010) at para 4101.1).

  78. [81] The totality principle comprises two limbs:

  79. (a) The first limb examines whether the aggregate sentence is substantially above the normal level of sentences for the most serious of the individual offences committed (see Mohamed Shouffee at [54]).

  80. (b) The second limb considers whether the effect of the aggregate sentence on the offender is “crushing and not in keeping with his past record and his future prospects” (see Mohamed Shouffee at [57]).

  81. [82] In respect of enhanced sentences under s 50T and sentences under s 50Y, both the Prosecution and Mr Zhuang agree that the totality principle should apply as a final step at the end of the sentencing process, but they differ as to how it should apply. On the one hand, the Prosecution submits that the first limb of the totality principle should apply to all the sentences except the enhanced sentence(s) imposed under s 50T, while the second limb of the totality principle should apply to all the sentences, including the enhanced sentence(s) imposed under s 50T. On the other hand, Mr Zhuang submits that the court should have regard to all the sentences, including the enhanced sentence(s) imposed under s 50T, when applying the totality principle.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.