General Division of the High Court · Decided 22 June 2021
Public Prosecutor v Muhammad Shafiq bin Shariff
Feedback & support[2021] SGHC 150 · Case no. Criminal Case No 25 of 2019
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The accused person is Muhammad Shafiq bin Shariff (“Shafiq”), who was tried before me on one capital charge of importing five packets of 497.57g of crystalline substance containing not less than 334.67g of methamphetamine, an offence under s 7 of the Misuse of Drugs Act (Cap 185, 2008 Rev Ed) (the “MDA”) (“Capital Charge”).
Circumstances leading to the arrest and charge
- [2]
[2] The following facts are either undisputed or agreed pursuant to an Agreed Statement of Facts. Shafiq is a 29-year-old male Singapore citizen who was 25 years old at the time of the alleged offence. At the time he was arrested on 14 November 2017, he was working as a freelance tattoo artist and part time barber. He stated in his investigative statements that he started consuming methamphetamine, popularly known as “ice”, in early 2017, and he would consume up to 0.2g of methamphetamine a month. However, he explained in his evidence that he was not a regular consumer of methamphetamine. He only consumed it so that he could keep his concentration when doing large tattoo designs, and his consumption depended on whether he had any tattoo customers. He bought methamphetamine from a friend he referred to as “Darul”, and would pay S$80 for a small packet, containing about 1g of the drug.
- [3]
[3] At around noon of 14 November 2017, which is the day of Shafiq’s arrest, Shafiq was returning to Singapore from Malaysia via the Woodlands Checkpoint. He was a passenger in a Malaysian registered car being driven by one Chan Chun Nee (“Chan”), who was a private taxi driver. Shafiq was sitting in the front passenger seat. There was another passenger in the car, who was Muhammad Aidil Nizam bin Muhamad Noh (“Aidil”), a friend of Shafiq’s. At about 12.05pm, the car was randomly stopped for a routine check by Staff Sergeant Hamdan Shah bin Abu Baker (“SSgt Hamdan”), an officer from the Immigration and Checkpoints Authority (“ICA”), who was stationed at the Woodlands Checkpoint.
- [4]
[4] SSgt Hamdan asked Shafiq where he had come from, and what he had been doing in Malaysia. To this, Shafiq replied that he had come from his aunt’s place, but he also said that he had been “hang[ing] out with his friend”. Finding his answers contradictory, SSgt Hamdan decided to carry out a full check on the car and the belongings of the occupants. Thus, SSgt Hamdan directed the car to the “Green Channel” new inspection pit. Once there, Chan, Shafiq and Aidil were instructed to alight from the car. They complied.
- [5]
[5] The ICA Officers then began checking the belongings of Chan, Shafiq and Aidil. Shafiq’s belongings – one luggage bag, one small red plastic bag, and one big red plastic bag – were kept in the boot of the car. The big red plastic bag (exhibit marked “A1”) contained a blue Nestle “Lactogen” baby milk powder box (the “blue milk powder box”) and an orange “Julie’s” packet of biscuits (the “orange biscuit packet”). SSgt Hamdan asked Shafiq who the blue milk powder box belonged to. Shafiq replied that it belonged to his aunt, who he claimed had asked him to bring it home for his nephew or niece.
- [6]
[6] SSgt Hamdan noticed that there were glue stains on the top of the blue milk powder box. Finding this suspicious, he pressed on the box and heard a “crunchy” sound. He asked Shafiq for permission to open the blue milk powder box. Shafiq agreed. The undisputed evidence is that Shafiq did not appear nervous at that time. SSgt Hamdan then cut open the blue milk powder box with a knife and there were two sealed silver foil packets inside (the “silver foil packets”). SSgt Hamdan felt one of the packets and found it to be lumpy, granular and hard, and not powdery like milk powder. He asked for Shafiq’s permission to open one of the silver foil packets. Again, Shafiq did not appear nervous and he agreed to the silver foil packet being opened. SSgt Hamdan cut open the silver foil packet, exhibit “A1B1”, and found crystalline substance within. He asked Shafiq what that substance was. Shafiq appeared surprised and said that he did not know what the substance was. SSgt Hamdan then placed Shafiq under arrest.
- [7]
[7] In total, four plastic packets of methamphetamine were later found in the two silver foil packets. These four plastic packets were eventually marked as exhibits “A1B1A”, “A1B1B”, “A1B1C”, and “A1B2A1”, three in one silver foil packet and one in the other. Later that same day, in the course of investigations, when the various seized exhibits were being photographed, the orange biscuit packet was opened and there were ten smaller individual packets inside. These smaller packets were then opened and, in one of them (exhibit marked “A1A1-A”), there was were two packets – a plastic packet (exhibit marked “A1A1-A2”) containing another packet with 105 grey “ecstacy” tablets (exhibit marked “A1A1-A2A”), and a small plastic packet of methamphetamine (exhibit marked “A1A1-A1”) (“small packet of ice”). Ecstacy is a street name for the controlled drug MDMA. Analysis by the Health Sciences Authority (“HSA”) later revealed that Shafiq’s DNA was found in the interior surface of the plastic packet, exhibit “A1A1-A2”, containing the packet with the ecstacy tablets.
- [8]
[8] The subject of the Capital Charge before me is the four plastic packets of methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box and the small packet of ice in one of the ten individual packets of biscuits that were in the orange biscuit packet. The five plastic packets contained not less than 497.57g of crystalline substance found to contain a total of not less than 334.67g of methamphetamine, which is a Class A controlled drug listed in the First Schedule to the MDA. The specific breakdown of the drug exhibits, as analysed and found by the Health Sciences Authority (“HSA”), is as follows.
Exhibit
HSA analysis
Blue milk powder box (exhibit “A1B”) containing, inter alia:
First silver packet (exhibit “A1B1”) containing, inter alia:
A1B1A
One packet of 62.82g of crystalline substance found to contain not less than 42.44g of methamphetamine
A1B1B
One packet of 62.60g of crystalline substance found to contain not less than 42.18g of methamphetamine
A1B1C
One packet of 122.7g of crystalline substance found to contain not less than 82.58g of methamphetamine
Second silver packet (exhibit “A1B2”) containing, inter alia:
A1B2A1
One packet of 248.0g of crystalline substance found to contain not less than 166.5g of methamphetamine
A1B2B
One packet of 0.64g of powdery substance in which no controlled drug was detected
Orange biscuit packet (exhibit “A1A”) containing, inter alia:
A1A1-A1
One packet of 1.45g of crystalline substance found to contain not less than 0.97g of methamphetamine
One packet (exhibit “A1A1-A2”) containing:
A1A1-A2A
- [105]
[105] grey tablets weighing a total of 29.21g and found to contain not less than 10.88g of MDMA, a Class A controlled drug
- [9]
[9] At this stage, I should, for completeness, highlight that, initially, the investigating officer, ASP Parthiban s/o Mathevanan (“IO Parthiban”), had counted that only 100 ecstacy tablets were in the orange biscuit packet, and this number was lodged in the police report (filed by SSSgt Ritar). In his oral evidence, Shafiq also said that he was told by “Baba”, as explained later in this judgment, that he was delivering 100 ecstacy tablets. However, as is clear from the table above, HSA analysed exhibit “A1A1-A2A” to be 105 tablets. IO Parthiban explained in his testimony that he had miscounted the ecstacy tablets at the Central Narcotics Bureau (“CNB”) Woodlands Office because, when he counted the tablets, he had divided the tablets into batches of five, and then counted the batches, but missed out one batch when adding up the numbers (thus arriving at the figure of 100 instead of 105 tablets). Therefore, Shafiq’s account in his investigative statements and in his testimony that he had only intended to deliver 100 ecstacy tablets must be seen in this light.
The Prosecution’s case
- [10]
[10] The Prosecution’s case, as stated in its opening statement and closing submissions, is that the elements of the offence of importation under s 7 of the MDA have been made out. First, Shafiq knowingly possessed the drugs. Second, he knew the nature of the drugs in his possession, ie, that the drugs in question were methamphetamine. Third, and this element is not in dispute, the methamphetamine has been brought into Singapore without prior authorisation.
- [11]
[11] For the first element of the offence, the Prosecution’s primary case is that the presumption of possession in s 18(1)(a) of the MDA is satisfied in this case, as it is undisputed that Shafiq was in possession of the blue milk powder box and the orange biscuit packet that contain the methamphetamine, and that Shafiq is unable to rebut the presumption. Alternatively, the Prosecution argues that Shafiq was wilfully blind to the existence of the methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box and the orange biscuit packet.
- [12]
[12] For the second element of the offence under s 7 of the MDA, the Prosecution’s case is that Shafiq knew the nature of the drugs in his possession, ie, that the drugs were methamphetamine. The Prosecution relies on the presumption in s 18(2) of the MDA to establish such knowledge because they say that it has been proven or presumed that Shafiq knowingly possessed the four packets of methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box and the packet of methamphetamine in the orange biscuit packet.
The Defence’s case
- [13]
[13] Shafiq admits to having knowingly possessed and imported the small plastic packet of methamphetamine in the orange biscuit packet. However, he denies knowing the existence of the four plastic packets of methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box. His counsel contends that he has rebutted the presumption under s 18(1)(a) of the MDA that he was in possession of the methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box because, for the reasons elaborated below, he has shown that he had no knowledge that those drugs were in the blue milk powder box.
- [14]
[14] As for the Prosecution’s alternative case that he was wilfully blind to the existence of the drugs in the blue milk powder box, Shafiq’s counsel contends that he had no basis to suspect that the blue milk powder box would contain the four plastic packets of methamphetamine.
The applicable law and issues
- [16]
[16] It is equally trite that the Prosecution may either prove the elements of possession and knowledge of the nature of the drugs beyond a reasonable doubt or rely on the statutory presumptions under ss 18(1) and 18(2) of the MDA respectively to presume these two elements, so that the burden of proof shifts to the accused to rebut the statutory presumption on a balance of probabilities: see, eg, Ilechukwu Uchechukwu Chukwudi v Public Prosecutor [2021] 1 SLR 67 (“Ilechukwu”) at [171]; Gobi a/l Avedian v Public Prosecutor [2021] 1 SLR 180 (“Gobi”) at [57] and [98(b)]; Obeng Comfort v Public Prosecutor [2017] 1 SLR 633 (“Obeng Comfort”) at [35]–[37].
- [17]
[17] Sections 18(1) and 18(2) of the MDA provide as follows:
- [19]
[19] The main contest between the Prosecution and the Defence is whether the element of possession is satisfied in this case. In particular, the parties dispute whether Shafiq has successfully rebutted the s 18(1)(a) presumption that he knowingly possessed the methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box and whether he was wilfully blind as to the existence of the methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box. If the element of possession is satisfied, the other issue is whether Shafiq has successfully rebutted the s 18(2) presumption that he knew the nature of the drug, ie whether he knew that the “things” in the blue milk powder box were methamphetamine.
- [20]
[20] I should also add that Shafiq accepts that he knowingly imported the ecstacy tablets into Singapore. But that is the subject of a separate charge of importation under s 7 of the MDA, which has been stood down, pending the trial of the present charge. Shafiq also accepts that he knowingly imported the 0.97g of methamphetamine in exhibit “A1A1-A1” (the small packet of ice) in the orange biscuit packet into Singapore.
Shafiq’s evidence
- [21]
[21] Shafiq elected to give evidence in his own defence. He explained in his evidence that the blue milk powder box, which contained the four packets of methamphetamine, belonged to one Husir Khan bin Fidah Hussein (“Husir”), whom he referred to as “Baba”, someone with whom he had been acquainted for about six months. He had met Husir for the first time sometime in mid-2017 at a mutual friend’s flat.
- [22]
[22] One of Shafiq’s hobbies is playing online jackpot games on his mobile phone. He started with a gaming application called “ACE333”, but then moved on to another one called “SCR888”. It was Husir who introduced Shafiq to “SCR888” and taught him how to use it. Husir told him that SCR888 was easy to “hack”, and that one could win large sums of money from SCR888 regularly.
- [23]
[23] In his evidence, Shafiq described how SCR888 worked. Husir had put Shafiq in contact with a person, described as an “agent”, who then sent Shafiq a link. With that link, Shafiq could download the SCR888 application to his mobile phone. Shafiq then created an account on the SCR888 application, and obtained a user ID and password to log on to the application.
- [24]
[24] The “agent” also added Shafiq to a WhatsApp chat group. To start gambling using SCR888, Shafiq needed credits in his account. He would inform the “agent” via WhatsApp that he wanted to deposit money to obtain credits. Shafiq would then transfer money to a bank account, the details of which had been provided by the “agent” via WhatsApp. Following this, his SCR888 account would be topped up with credits. If he won on his gambling on SCR888, his credits in his account would increase. But, if he lost, his credits would be depleted.
- [25]
[25] To withdraw his winnings from his SCR888 account, Shafiq gave evidence that he would have to inform the “agent” via WhatsApp that he wished to withdraw a specified sum, and he would also provide the “agent” with the receiving bank account details. The credits in his account would be deducted, and correspondingly, the money would then be deposited into his bank account.
- [26]
[26] Shafiq’s evidence is that he played jackpot games on the SCR888 application. This was consistent with his statements to the CNB. But, in his oral evidence, Shafiq claims that it was also possible to play “live casino” games on the application. The significance of this evidence will be elaborated upon later.
- [27]
[27] It is not disputed that Husir had left Singapore on 26 October 2017 and has not returned since then. Husir had informed Shafiq that he was wanted by the CNB, and that was why he decided to live in Malaysia instead. In November 2017, Husir was living with his family in a rented condominium unit in Danga Bay, Johor, Malaysia.
The first trip to Johor
- [28]
[28] On 11 November 2017, Shafiq had travelled to Johor to meet up with Husir. He gave evidence that he had met up with Husir to gamble with him using the SCR888 application, and he wanted to learn from Husir how to win regularly on SCR888. He left Singapore at about 1.08am by car, and met Husir at a coffee shop in Johor.
- [29]
[29] After chatting and eating at the coffee shop for about 2 hours, they then went to Husir’s condominium unit. Husir’s unit was a one-bedroom apartment. It was open-concept in the sense that there was no physical wall between the living room, dining area and the kitchen, but there was a door leading to the bedroom and the toilet. There, Shafiq met Rahilme Khan bin Husir Khan (“Rahilme”), Husir’s oldest son, for the first time. Rahilme was 18 years old at the time of the trial.
- [30]
[30] Husir and Shafiq played the jackpot game on SCR888 until about 10.41am. Shafiq then took his leave to return to Singapore. Before he left, Husir passed him several items – a “Coco Crunch” box, two to three milk tins, a tin of sardines and a packet of “Maggi” instant noodles. Husir asked Shafiq to bring these items back to Singapore and hand them to Husir’s friend. Shafiq agreed to do this.
- [31]
[31] Rahilme also accompanied Shafiq on the return trip back to Singapore because he wanted to meet up with his friends to skateboard. Rahilme would stay with Shafiq at his flat in Bukit Batok while he was in Singapore. As such, Rahilme brought along a luggage bag, which contained, amongst other things, his clothes.
- [32]
[32] Shafiq and Rahilme entered Singapore via the Woodlands Checkpoint in a taxi at about 1.14pm. Rahilme stayed with Shafiq on the nights of 11 and 12 November 2017. That was a weekend. He spent most of his days meeting up with his friends in Singapore and skateboarding.
- [33]
[33] At about 7.50pm of 11 November 2017, Shafiq handed the food items Husir had entrusted with him to one “Roymeo”. This was on the instructions of Husir, with whom Shafiq had been constantly communicating in the afternoon of 11 November 2017. He had exchanged 11 calls with Husir in the space of four hours that afternoon. After handing the items to Roymeo, Shafiq had three further phone calls with Husir that night.
- [34]
[34] Between 11.34pm of 11 November 2017 and 3.04am of 12 November 2017, a total amount of S$14,200 was deposited into the bank account of Mohamad Haikal bin Mohamad Faizal (“Haikal”), who was a friend of Shafiq’s, in five separate transactions. At that time, Haikal was in a reformative training centre. According to Shafiq, Haikal had passed his POSB ATM card and iBanking token to him so that he could use his bank account.
- [35]
[35] From these deposits, Shafiq transferred a total of S$5,200 to the bank accounts of two of his brothers. On his instructions, his two brothers – Akmal and Danial – withdrew the sum in cash from ATMs and handed the cash to Shafiq. This was in the early hours of 12 November 2017. Shafiq took a photo of the cash amount of S$5,200 at about 2.58am and sent it to Husir via WhatsApp on 12 November 2017. He then deleted the WhatsApp message, like all his other WhatsApp messages exchanged with Husir from 11 to 14 November.
- [36]
[36] Later in the day on 12 November 2017, Shafiq took another photo of some cash and an open book with the numbers 5,900, 800, 2,450 and 14,200. He sent this photo to Husir via WhatsApp at about 5.35pm, and then deleted the message. Shafiq then created a note, which was saved on his mobile phone. That note was last modified at 8.56pm at 12 November 2017. It stated:
- [37]
[37] Shafiq also gave evidence that, between 7.07pm and 9.52pm on 12 November 2017, he exchanged calls and messages with one “Alan”, who was a friend of Husir’s. In his messages, Shafiq gave Alan the details of Haikal’s bank account. Alan replies that he has cash and he “confirm take”.
- [38]
[38] From 6.12pm on 12 November to 2.38am on 13 November 2017, there were four further deposits totalling the amount of S$7,190 into Haikal’s bank account. Thus, a total amount of S$21,390 was remitted or deposited into Haikal’s account on 12 and 13 November 2017, if one includes the earlier transfers totalling S$14,200. Shafiq’s evidence was that this total sum of S$21,390 were winnings from gambling on SCR888, and that Husir and him were going to share these winnings equally.
The second trip to Johor
- [39]
[39] On 13 November 2017 at 3.04am, Shafiq left Singapore via the Woodland Checkpoint. This time Shafiq was accompanied by his cousin, and they both travelled on a motorcycle, which belonged to this cousin.
- [40]
[40] Once he arrived in Johor, Shafiq called Husir to arrange to meet him. The purpose of this trip was to pass Husir his share of the jackpot winnings. He was quite vague in his evidence as to exactly how much money he handed over to Husir when they met, even though he had claimed that they had agreed to split the winnings equally.
- [41]
[41] Shafiq spent almost 12 hours in Johor for this second trip. His evidence was that he played jackpot on SCR888 from about 4.20am to 10.39am, and then fell asleep at Husir’s condominium unit.
- [42]
[42] At 2.30pm, Shafiq returned to Singapore via the Woodlands Checkpoint. Under cross-examination, Shafiq admitted that he had brought 100 pills of ecstacy with him into Singapore on 13 November 2017. During the second trip, Husir had given him these pills and asked him to bring them to Singapore to pass them to Alan. Shafiq agreed to do so. He hid the ecstacy pills in his jacket.
- [43]
[43] At about 5.45pm later that day, Alan contacted Shafiq and arranged to meet with him. When they met, Shafiq handed the 100 ecstacy pills to Alan. Shafiq’s evidence is that he was handed cash by Alan, but he could not recall how much. He also could not recall whether the money was for him or whether he had to pass the cash to Husir.
- [44]
[44] Shafiq was in possession of Husir’s ATM card at this time. His evidence was that Husir had passed him the ATM card during his first trip to Johor, but the Prosecution contended that it is more likely that Husir had handed Shafiq the ATM card during the second trip. I do not find it to be material when the ATM card was actually passed by Husir to Shafiq. What is relevant though is that Shafiq withdrew a total of S$21,200 from Husir’s bank account on 13 and 14 November 2017 after the second trip, using a combination of direct cash withdrawals using the ATM card, and via transfers to Shafiq’s brothers’ accounts, from which he then withdrew in cash the amount that had been transferred from Husir’s account.
- [45]
[45] After he had withdrawn and obtained S$18,000 of the S$21,200 in cash, Shafiq took a photo of the cash of S$18,000 and sent it to Husir via WhatsApp. He then deleted that message. Shafiq’s evidence is that the entire amount of S$21,200 were winnings from SCR888, which he would share with Husir.
The third trip to Johor
- [46]
[46] On the night of 13 November 2017, Shafiq was planning to travel to Johor to see Husir so as to pass him his share of the jackpot winnings from SCR888. For this trip, Rahilme was going to accompany Shafiq so that he could return home. Shafiq also asked a friend of his, Aidil, to come along for the trip.
- [47]
[47] Husir arranged for a private taxi to pick Shafiq up from his flat in Singapore. Chan was the driver and he arrived at about 3.30am (on 14 November 2017) to pick them up. Rahilme brought his luggage bag with him on this return trip. The car left Singapore at about 3.58am via the Woodlands Checkpoint, and entered Johor.
- [48]
[48] At about 5.00am, Chan dropped Shafiq, Rahilme and Aidil off at the condominium where Husir stayed. At the condominium, Shafiq met one Muhammad Rohaizat bin Mohamed Ramzan (“Rohaizat”) for the first time. Rohaizat is a male Singapore citizen who was 29 years old at the time of the trial. Rohaizat is Husir’s cousin and was also referred to as “Mambo”. He lived in another unit at the same condominium.
- [49]
[49] There were four other persons at Husir’s condominium unit that morning – Rahilme’s mother, Rahilme’s two younger brothers and an unknown lady. Shafiq handed Husir S$9,200 in cash as the latter’s share of the jackpot winnings from SCR888. His evidence was that he kept the remaining S$12,000, out of the S$21,200 withdrawn from Husir’s bank account, for himself.
- [50]
[50] Rahilme stayed at the unit for a while before being brought by Rohaizat to the latter’s condominium unit to sleep. Thereafter, Shafiq, Aidil and Husir played jackpot and casino games on SCR888, while seated at the living room sofa.
- [51]
[51] Shafiq, Aidil and Husir also consumed methamphetamine in the living room of Husir’s condominium unit. Shafiq’s evidence is that he saw Husir take out a “bong” from under the coffee table in the living room. This is a device that is used to consume methamphetamine. Shafiq saw that there was already methamphetamine in the “bong”, but when it ran out, Husir took out a packet of methamphetamine from under the table and refilled the “bong”.
- [52]
[52] Shafiq’s evidence is that he was surprised to find out that morning that Husir consumed methamphetamine. In his oral testimony, under cross- and re-examination, Shafiq said that he did not think that Husir sold methamphetamine, though he did know by then that Husir sold ecstacy pills.
- [53]
[53] Sometime between 7.00am and 8.00am, Rohaizat came back to Husir’s unit, and both of them wanted to go to the market because Rohaizat wanted to get groceries. Shafiq and Aidil decided to accompany them. As it turned out, the market was closed. Rohaizat then drove them to a convenience store because he wanted to buy milk for his son. When they arrived at the store’s location, Rohaizat and Aidil alighted and went inside to get the milk. Shafiq and Husir remained in the car. Shafiq then saw Rohaizat and Aidil exiting the store with a red plastic bag. When they got into the car, Shafiq saw a blue Nestle “Lactogen” milk powder box in the red plastic bag, which looked like the one he had in his possession when he was later arrested. However, he cannot be sure that it was the very same milk powder box because he was focused on playing jackpot while he was in the car.
- [54]
[54] The four men returned to Husir’s condominium unit at about 9.00am. Aidil placed the plastic bag containing the milk powder box near the kitchen cabinet. All of them continued to play jackpot and casino on SCR888 in the living room. They also consumed methamphetamine again.
- [55]
[55] Then, Husir called Shafiq to the dining table. He asked Shafiq whether he would bring some ecstacy pills to one of his friends in Singapore. Husir said that they should get in touch with each other after Shafiq arrives in Singapore so that Husir can inform Shafiq of where and how Shafiq should pass the ecstacy pills to Husir’s “friend”. Husir did not mention if Shafiq was supposed to collect any money in exchange for the ecstacy pills. Shafiq agreed. Shafiq saw that the ecstacy pills were packed in a small plastic packet, which was placed in another slightly larger plastic packet. Husir then said that he was giving Shafiq 1g of methamphetamine as his “ration” for bringing his share of the SCR888 winnings to Johor, and for helping him bring the ecstacy pills to Singapore. This was in another small plastic packet, which Husir placed within the slightly larger plastic packet, which held the small packet of ecstacy pills. It is not in dispute that these drugs were the ones that were eventually found in exhibit “A1A” that Shafiq had in his possession when he was arrested (see [8] above).
- [56]
[56] Shafiq wanted to conceal the slightly larger packet containing the small packet of ice and the packet of ecstacy pills somewhere in his jacket. However, Husir told him that there might be a “spot check”, and said that he would help Shafiq conceal the small packet of ice and the ecstacy pills. He took the drugs back from Shafiq. At this point, Shafiq then left the dining table and went back to the living room sofa to continue consuming ice and playing on SCR888.
- [57]
[57] According to Shafiq, Rohaizat then left the unit. Shafiq’s evidence is that Husir was at the kitchen, but he did not know or pay attention to what Husir was doing there. He was not involved in, and did not see, the packing of the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice. He also did not see any other drugs in the apartment.
- [58]
[58] At around 10.45am, Chan arrived with his car at the condominium to pick up Shafiq and Aidil. This had been arranged by Shafiq that morning. When Shafiq was leaving the condominium unit with Aidil, Husir took a big red plastic bag from the top of the kitchen cabinet and passed it to Shafiq. This bag contained the blue milk powder box and the orange biscuit packet. Shafiq asked Husir where the ecstacy pills and methamphetamine were, and Husir replied, “the things are already inside”. By this, Shafiq understood that the ecstacy pills and methamphetamine were in the plastic bag.
- [59]
[59] According to Shafiq, he only took a quick look at the contents of the plastic bag. He did not examine or check the blue milk powder box and/or the orange biscuit packet because he was in a rush to get downstairs as Chan was waiting. In his statements to the CNB and in his oral evidence, Shafiq gave inconsistent versions as to whether he believed that the ecstacy pills and methamphetamine were inside or outside the blue milk powder box and/or the orange biscuit packet. The Prosecution describes Shafiq’s evidence on this point as a “key inconsistency”. I will explore this later in the course of this judgment.
- [60]
[60] When he left the condominium unit, Shafiq also took Rahilme’s luggage bag with him. This luggage bag, the red plastic bag handed to him by Husir, and the rest of his and Aidil’s belongings were placed in the boot of Chan’s car. While on the way, he asked Chan to stop at a mini-mart. There, Shafiq bought a packet of instant noodles and a packet of biscuits. These were in another smaller red plastic bag that was also placed in the boot of the car (see [5] above).
- [61]
[61] As already described (at [6] above), Shafiq was arrested at the Woodlands Checkpoint.
Shafiq’s statements to the CNB
- [62]
[62] In the course of investigations, Shafiq gave a total of 14 statements to the CNB. There were three contemporaneous statements, eight long statements and three cautioned statements. The Prosecution relies on these statements to show that Shafiq has changed his version of events along the way, as more and more incriminating evidence was presented to him. As such, the Prosecution says that he has shown himself quite capable of lying to the CNB and is not a person who has credibility.
- [63]
[63] Shafiq does not challenge the voluntariness of all his statements to the CNB, as explicitly stated in the Agreed Statement of Facts. In the Agreed Statement of Facts, Shafiq also agreed that all the statements were recorded accurately. However, when he was cross-examined, Shafiq tried to explain away some of the inconsistencies between his statements and his oral evidence on the basis that the recorder of the statements, who was the investigating officer, IO Parthiban, had misunderstood him.
Contemporaneous statements on 14 November 2017
- [64]
[64] In his contemporaneous statements recorded on 14 November 2017, Shafiq claimed that the blue milk powder box contained “Susu C” (ie, milk powder) and that it belonged to “Helmi” (ie, Rahilme). Shafiq claimed that Rahilme asked him to bring Rahilme’s clothes and a red plastic bag containing “infant powder” into Singapore to pass to Rahilme. Shafiq took the red plastic bag from “Baba”, Helmi’s father (ie, Husir), at Rahilme’s unit in Johor, Malaysia. Husir told Shafiq to bring a luggage (containing Rahilme’s clothes) and the red plastic bag with “baby formula” to Singapore, and that either Rahilme or someone else would collect the red plastic bag. In the contemporaneous statements, Shafiq was not asked about the orange biscuit packet and the ecstacy contained in it.
The first seven long statements from 15 November 2017 to 28 May 2018
- [65]
[65] In gist, the first seven long statements recorded from Shafiq set out the following version of events. Shafiq and Rahilme – who Shafiq referred to as “Abang” in the statements – went to Rahilme’s house in Johor Bahru the night prior to the offence to “slack” and play a jackpot game, and for Shafiq to pass $9,200 cash to Rahilme’s father, Husir. Shafiq and Rahilme went to Rahilme’s house from Shafiq’s flat in Singapore at about 3am (on 14 November 2017) by a “private taxi” – driven by Chan – arranged by Husir. Aidil also came along with Shafiq and Rahilme. After arriving at Rahilme’s house and having some food, Rahilme left with Rahilme’s uncle, Rohaizat, to the latter’s house.
- [66]
[66] Subsequently, at about 7–8am, Shafiq and Aidil accompanied Husir and Rohaizat to a nearby Indian “mama” shop. There, Husir asked Aidil to help buy ‘Lactogen’ milk, which was for Rohaizat’s son. Shafiq and Husir stayed in the car while Aidil and Rohaizat went to buy milk. They came back in about 10 minutes and Aidil was carrying a small red plastic bag with the milk box inside. After arriving back at Rahilme’s house, Aidil put the milk box in the kitchen cabinet, and they continued to play the jackpot game.
- [67]
[67] At about 9am, Aidil and Shafiq wanted to go back home. While Husir tried calling for a “private taxi” again, “no one picked up”, so Shafiq called the number on the name card which Chan had given him. Chan then called Shafiq back to make the transport arrangements. Shafiq then saw Rahilme’s luggage “of dirty clothes” in Rahilme’s home, so Shafiq asked Husir if he could bring Rahilme’s clothes to his house in Singapore to wash. Husir agreed but also asked Shafiq to bring the red plastic bag containing the blue milk powder box and the orange biscuit packet with him to Singapore. Shafiq could tell that the red plastic bag was different from the red plastic bag that Aidil had before, but Shafiq “was rushing” and so “never think so much”. Shafiq could also see the contents of the red plastic bag. Shafiq opened the boot of the car and put the red plastic bag in the boot. Shafiq was not paid by Husir to help him.
- [68]
[68] Shafiq stated that he “never touch” the orange biscuit packet and that he thought that exhibit “A1A1-A1” (the small packet of ice) in the orange biscuit packet contained methamphetamine, though he was “not sure”. He did not know what exhibit “A1A1-A2A” (the plastic packet of ecstacy pills) from the orange biscuit packet was. Shafiq also had “not touched” the blue milk powder box before. He knew that the “white thing” in the packets in the blue milk powder box were methamphetamine, but he claimed they were not his and he did not see them until his arrest. He did not suspect that there were drugs in the orange biscuit packet and blue milk powder box.
- [69]
[69] Shafiq did find it suspicious that Husir asked him, and not Rahilme, to bring the blue milk powder box and orange biscuit packet to Singapore, and Shafiq did question Husir about this. Husir explained to Shafiq that Rahilme “will be coming back late to Singapore”. Shafiq is “not close” to Rahilme and had only known him for “a few months”. Shafiq got to know Rahilme through a mutual friend called “Faris” who plays in the same soccer team as Shafiq. Shafiq does not know if Rahilme is involved in drugs. Shafiq also said he did not know Husir or Rahilme’s family “that well”.
- [70]
[70] Shafiq’s DNA was found inside exhibit “A1A1-A2” (the plastic packet containing the packet of ecstacy pills). Shafiq explained that he thinks it could be because “[he] was holding a[n] empty plastic packet when [he] was smoking ‘Ice’ at Abang’s condo. [He] cannot remember what happened to the plastic packet after that but it looks similar to the ‘A1A1-A2’.” Shafiq denies having packed any of the drugs in Rahilme’s flat in Johor Bahru.
First cautioned statement on 15 November 2017
- [71]
[71] After his first long statement was recorded on 15 November 2017 from 10.36am to 2.45pm, Shafiq was served a charge of jointly importing 6 packets containing approximately 515g of crystalline substance believed to contain methamphetamine into Singapore with Aidil. Shafiq gave his cautioned statement that same day from 5.17pm to 5.30pm. In that statement, he stated that he wanted to “ask for leniency from the judge if [he] was ‘sabo’ by ‘Baba’” (ie, Husir). He is “not the person who will smuggle drugs into Singapore”. He “really thought that it was milk and biscuits in the red plastic bag and did not know there were drugs inside”.
Second cautioned statement on 1 June 2018
- [72]
[72] However, after the first seven long statements were given, in his cautioned statement recorded on 1 June 2018 in response to a charge of importing not less than 10.88g of MDMA, Shafiq admitted that he “kn[e]w about the packet of 105 tablets and the 1 gram of Ice that was inside the orange biscuit packet”. He “was supposed to pass the Ecstacy tablets to someone who will come to [his] house to pick it up … The 1 gram of Ice is for [his] own ration because [he] help Abang father bring the cash from Singapore to Malaysia and also to bring the Ecstacy tablet from Malaysia.” In that cautioned statement, Shafiq also stated that he is “sorry”, regretful, and pleaded for leniency.
Eighth long statement on 2 June 2018
- [73]
[73] Shafiq’s eighth long statement recorded after his admission regarding the drugs in the orange biscuit packet is critical in that it is largely consistent with his oral evidence in court outlined above. In gist, Shafiq stated the following in this eighth long statement.
(a) Husir was the one who asked him to bring the ecstacy tablets into Singapore to pass to “someone” as a “favour”. Husir said that he would call Shafiq and tell him who to pass them to when Shafiq reached his house in Singapore. This was the same as what Husir told Shafiq when Shafiq brought food items for Husir on 11 November 2017. Shafiq did not admit this in his previous investigative statements as he “was shocked” and “was really scared at that time”.
(b) Husir said that he would pack the ecstacy tablets, and Shafiq did not know or see how Husir packed them. Husir simply passed the red plastic bag to Shafiq and informed Shafiq that “the things are already inside”. From this, Shafiq knew that the ecstacy tablets and the 1g of ice were inside but he did not know whether “it was in the [blue] milk powder box or the [orange] biscuit packet”. Shafiq did not open and check the blue milk powder box and orange biscuit packet since they were already packed by Husir.
(c) Shafiq’s DNA was found in the packet because he “h[e]ld the packets to see what it is”. At the time, he did not know what it was as he had never taken ecstacy tablets before. It was Husir who told Shafiq that they were ecstacy tablets before Shafiq passed the packet back to Husir.
(d) Husir also told Shafiq that he would give him a “gift” of 1g of ice as a reward for bringing the ecstacy tablets into Singapore and for helping him to bring his cash from Singapore to Malaysia.
(e) Shafiq helped Husir to bring the ecstacy tablets into Singapore because he helped Shafiq with the jackpot game and taught him how to play and win money with it.
(f) This was “the only time” Shafiq had helped Husir import drugs into Singapore.
(g) Shafiq knew that drug importation is a “serious offence”, but he did it for Husir “as a favour as [Husir] helped [Shafiq] before”.
- [74]
[74] I will deal with the inconsistencies in Shafiq’s statements and his explanations for these inconsistencies when I deal with the contested issues of fact below.
Has the s 18(1)(a) presumption been rebutted?
Requirements of s 18(1)(a)
- [75]
[75] As mentioned at [16] above, the legal burden is on the accused person to adduce sufficient evidence to rebut the s 18(1) presumption on a balance of probabilities. In this regard, it is well established that an accused person’s bare denial is insufficient to rebut the statutory presumptions in the MDA or cause the evidential burden to shift to the Prosecution: see, eg, Beh Chew Boo at [64]. However, the “inherent difficulties of proving a negative” must also be borne in mind so that the burden of rebutting the relevant presumption “should not be made so onerous that it becomes virtually impossible to discharge”: Harven a/l Segar v Public Prosecutor [2017] 1 SLR 771 at [2].
- [76]
[76] It is also well established that, while the legal burden remains on one party throughout, the evidential burden on any specific factual issue can shift to the opposing party once it has been discharged by the proponent. The opposing party must then call evidence or take the consequences, which may or may not be adverse. The Prosecution’s failure to a call a material witness may mean that it had failed to discharge its evidential burden to rebut an accused person’s defence or may justify the court drawing an adverse inference against it under s 116 illustration (g) of the Evidence Act (Cap 97, 1997 Rev Ed) (“EA”): see Muhammad Nabill bin Mohd Fuad v Public Prosecutor [2020] 1 SLR 984 (“Nabill”) at [67]–[72]. Thus, if I find, on an assessment of Shafiq’s evidence, that his contention that he did not know that the blue milk powder box contained methamphetamine is plausible, then the evidential burden would shift to the Prosecution to rebut Shafiq’s evidence.
- [78]
[78] The Prosecution argues that Shafiq’s evidence that he did not know that the drugs were in the blue milk powder box is not believable. It submits that Shafiq is not a credible witness and his explanations should thus be rejected. Also, the Prosecution submits that Shafiq’s admitted lies in his statements to the CNB are on material issues and, as such, are corroborative of his guilt.
- [79]
[79] I will consider these issues in relation to the alleged actual knowledge of Shafiq of the drugs in the blue milk powder box in turn. I shall first consider the Prosecution’s detailed submissions that Shafiq is unable to rebut the ss 18(1) and 18(2) presumptions because he is not a credible and reliable witness.
Shafiq’s credibility as a witness
- [80]
[80] The crux of the Prosecution’s case against Shafiq is that he is an unreliable witness whose inconsistent, belated, and false claims should be dismissed. The Prosecution submits that Shafiq’s denial of his knowledge of the true contents of the blue milk powder box is unbelievable because Shafiq had given materially inconsistent accounts of what he believed the blue milk powder box contained. Shafiq had also lied in his investigative statements and had omitted to tell the truth. The Prosecution submits that these lies and omissions concern material issues and corroborate his guilt. The Prosecution urges me to find that Shafiq’s account in his oral evidence that he was not aware of the blue milk powder box’s contents is incredible.
- [81]
[81] The Defence argues that Shafiq did not know that the blue milk powder box contained the methamphetamine in question. For all the times that Shafiq had visited Husir’s condominium unit, he had never seen large quantities of methamphetamine. It was only in the early hours of the day of his arrest, 14 November 2017, that he discovered that Husir consumed methamphetamine and saw that he kept a small packet of methamphetamine below his coffee table in the living room.
- [82]
[82] Also, Shafiq’s evidence is that he did not see Husir re-pack the blue milk powder box with methamphetamine that morning after the four men had returned from the mini-mart, as submitted by the Prosecution. He was sitting on the sofa for most of the time, playing the SCR888 game on his mobile phone and consuming methamphetamine. The sofa faces away from the dining table and the kitchen. It was only when he was about to leave that Husir handed him the red plastic bag which contained the blue milk powder box and the orange biscuit packet. Shafiq simply took the plastic bag without examining its contents carefully (see [57] to [59] above).
- [83]
[83] As the Prosecution relies heavily on Shafiq’s purported lies and omissions in his investigative statements, it is first important to outline the relevant principles on this issue. Section 261 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 68, 2012 Rev Ed) (“the CPC”), which applies to cautioned statements, provides:
- [84]
[84] Therefore, the effect of s 261 of the CPC is that the accused person’s omission in stating a material fact for his defence in the cautioned statement allows the court to draw an adverse inference, which in turn can be used to corroborate other evidence. Deliberate untruths or lies may equally invite the drawing of adverse inferences: see Ilechukwu at [151]. While there is no equivalent statutory provision in the CPC for long statements, it is trite that a court may also, where appropriate, draw an adverse inference against an accused person for failing to state a fact in his long statement even though this fact will exculpate the accused from an offence: see Ilechukwu at [152].
- [85]
[85] It is well-established that the court’s power to draw adverse inferences is a discretionary one based on the specific facts at hand. In determining whether lies and/or omissions of an accused person might be used to corroborate evidence of guilt, the following requirements set out in Regina v Lucas (Ruth) [1981] QB 720 at 724 must be satisfied: (a) the lie told out of court is deliberate; (b) it relates to a material issue; (c) the motive for the lie is a realisation of guilt and a fear of the truth; and (d) the statement must clearly be shown to be a lie by independent evidence. Whether something is a lie is a question of fact to be determined by the court: see Ilechukwu at [153]–[154].
- [86]
[86] Critically, it is important to bear in mind that lies can only be used to corroborate or strengthen other pieces of evidence relied on by the Prosecution. Lies alone cannot be the basis of a conviction. Lies can only amount to corroboration of evidence of guilt if they are shown to be told out of a motive that can only be linked to his guilt: see Ilechukwu at [156]. An accused person may lie because he is guilty. On the other hand, an accused person who might in fact be innocent may also lie for some reason not linked to guilt. For instance, as observed by V K Rajah J (as he then was) in Public Prosecutor v Chee Cheong Hin Constance [2006] 2 SLR 24 (“Constance Chee”) at [92], lies may be told “in a misguided attempt to support or embellish an explanation, to deflect blame, to minimise embarrassment or to conceal some other behaviour”. Therefore, Shafiq’s lies in his investigative statements, if any, have to be carefully scrutinised with the foregoing principles in mind.
- [87]
[87] At this stage, I should also add that the Prosecution also makes extensive reference to the first two trips that Shafiq made to Husir’s condominium unit in Johor, what Shafiq did in Johor, and what he did on his return to Singapore for each of those two trips. The Prosecution has expressly stated that they are not relying on Shafiq’s evidence as to the first two trips to argue that Shafiq had a “propensity to import drugs into Singapore and the Court should find, on this basis, that he knowingly imported the Drugs on 14 November 2017”. In other words, the Prosecution is not relying on the first two trips to Johor as similar fact evidence to show propensity, which in any event is not permitted: see Muhammad Abdul Hadi bin Haron v Public Prosecutor and another appeal [2021] 1 SLR 537 (“Muhammad Abdul Hadi bin Haron”) at [53].
- [88]
[88] Rather, the Prosecution argues that such evidence is relevant to (a) Shafiq’s state of mind on 14 November 2017 when he brought the blue milk powder box into Singapore, and (b) the nature of Shafiq’s relationship with Husir, what Shafiq was doing in November 2017 and why he had made that fateful third trip to Johor, which eventually led to his arrest and charge. This is permissible, as similar fact evidence may be utilised in the limited manner envisaged within a strict application of ss 14 and 15 of the EA. These provisions permit the admission of similar fact evidence if its probative force outweighs its prejudicial value, taking into account, inter alia, the three factors of cogency, strength of inference and relevance: see Muhammad Abdul Hadi bin Haron at [53] and [55]; Tan Meng Jee v Public Prosecutor [1996] 2 SLR(R) 178 at [48]. Sections 14 and 15 of the EA provide as follows:
- [89]
[89] I will thus assess the evidence of the first two trips to Johor with this important caveat in mind.
Shafiq’s belated admission in his second cautioned statement of 1 June 2018
- [90]
[90] The Prosecution submits that I should reject Shafiq’s denial of knowledge about the methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box because he is not a credible witness as shown by his “shifting” positions in his statements to the CNB and at trial. Primarily, the Prosecution refers to the fact that Shafiq had denied knowledge of having any drugs in his first 11 statements until 1 June 2018 when he first admitted to having knowledge of the packet of ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice in a cautioned statement.
- [91]
[91] Shafiq’s explanation for lying about knowledge of the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice is that, if he admitted to such knowledge, he was afraid that he would be charged for importing the four packets of methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box as well. The Prosecution argues that such an explanation does not hold water because Shafiq had already been charged with importing the methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box on 15 November 2017, the day after he was arrested.
- [92]
[92] In my view, the Prosecution has not fully understood the general thrust of Shafiq’s explanation. His point is that, if he admitted to knowledge of the ecstacy tablets and the small packet of ice, the CNB would be less likely to believe that he did not also know about the four packets of methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box. Eventually, after some probing in re-examination, this was indeed how Shafiq explained why he had not admitted to knowledge of the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice earlier in the investigations. The Prosecution criticises this explanation as being raised in re-examination for the first time, but I find that unwarranted. Shafiq was merely explaining what he intended to convey all along as his reason for initially denying knowledge of any drugs at all.
- [93]
[93] Furthermore, Shafiq had already stated during his examination-in-chief that he only made the admission in his cautioned statement of 1 June 2018 because he was “afraid that if I had admitted to the ecstacy that I would also be charged for the Ice”. This must be understood to mean that he was initially afraid of admitting to knowledge of the ecstacy pills (as explained at [92] above), until he had no real choice but to do so. Thus, it is not accurate that Shafiq only raised this claim belatedly for the first time in re-examination. As explained at [101] below, during the recording of the last long statement (dated 28 May 2018) before the cautioned statement was recorded on 1 June 2018, Shafiq was informed that his DNA had been found on the inside of exhibit “A1A1-A2”, which is the plastic packet that contained the packet with the ecstacy pills. Thus, by 28 May 2018, Shafiq was confronted with objective evidence indicating his handling of the packet containing the ecstacy pills. In that same long statement on 28 May 2018, IO Parthiban showed Shafiq the photos of the orange biscuit packet and the items contained within it, viz, the ten smaller individual biscuit packets (including exhibit “A1A1-A”), and the small packet of ice and the packet of ecstacy pills contained within exhibit “A1A1-A”. In these circumstances, it is not surprising that he then felt it futile to deny his knowledge of the drugs in the orange biscuit packet. This explains his belated admission of his knowledge of these drugs in the second cautioned statement on 1 June 2018.
- [94]
[94] The Prosecution also attacks the Defence’s submission that Shafiq had “come clean” in his cautioned statement recorded on 1 June 2018, when he was served the charge of importing the ecstacy pills, by voluntarily admitting knowledge of those pills. The Prosecution points out that Shafiq had in fact been confronted on 1 June 2018 with the evidence that his DNA was found on the inside of exhibit “A1A1-A2”, the plastic packet containing the packet of ecstacy pills. As such, he must have then realised that it would be difficult to deny knowledge of the ecstacy pills.
- [95]
[95] I accept the Prosecution’s point that, by this point, Shafiq might have felt it futile to deny knowledge of the ecstacy pills any further. However, in my view, the fact that Shafiq felt that there was no point denying knowledge of the ecstacy pills any further only on 1 June 2018, has little bearing on the truth or otherwise of his explanation as to why he did not want to admit earlier to knowledge of the ecstacy pills. To reiterate, Shafiq explained that he was afraid that, if he had admitted to importing the ecstacy pills earlier, the CNB would not believe that he did not also know about the presence of the ice in the blue milk powder box. Furthermore, I would add that the fact that Shafiq’s DNA appeared on the inside of the plastic packet containing the packet of ecstacy pills has no connection to why he would also admit to knowledge of the small packet of ice.
- [96]
[96] I thus accept as credible Shafiq’s explanation that he did not want to admit to knowledge of those drugs (the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice) earlier because he feared the CNB would be less likely to believe that he did not also know about the four packets of methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box.
Shafiq’s inconsistencies regarding the ecstacy pills and small packet of ice
- [97]
[97] The Prosecution relies on the inconsistences in Shafiq’s statements to the CNB. In his first 11 statements, Shafiq had initially denied knowledge of any drugs in the blue milk powder box or the orange biscuit packet. But eventually, in his cautioned statement, recorded on 1 June 2018, in response to a charge for importing the ecstacy pills, Shafiq admitted that he knew that the packet of ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice – exhibits “A1A1-A2A” and “A1A1-A1” respectively – were in the orange biscuit packet and that he was “supposed to pass the Ecstacy tablets to someone who will come to [his] house to pick [them] up” while the 1g of methamphetamine was given to him as a reward for helping Husir to deliver cash to him in Malaysia and for delivering the ecstacy pills.
- [98]
[98] Then, in his eighth long statement recorded on 2 June 2018, Shafiq reiterated that Husir had asked him to bring the ecstacy pills into Singapore, and had given him the small packet of ice as a reward. The Prosecution points out that Shafiq stated in that long statement that he did not know whether those pills and the small packet of ice were in the blue milk powder box or the orange biscuit packet. The Prosecution argues that this was inconsistent with Shafiq’s admission in the cautioned statement taken the day before (ie on 1 June 2018) that he knew that the ecstacy pills and the 1g of methamphetamine were in the orange biscuit packet.
- [99]
[99] In his oral evidence at trial, as already mentioned, Shafiq said that he did not know whether the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice were inside the blue milk powder box or the orange biscuit packet. He said that he believed that these drugs were hidden in the red plastic bag, either between the box and the packet, or beneath them. He also said that he thought that the blue milk powder box and the orange biscuit packet were “dummies”.
- [100]
[100] Having reviewed the evidence carefully, I am unable to agree with the Prosecution that these inconsistences show that Shafiq knew the truth about the blue milk powder box’s contents, and that he was lying to the CNB to hide his knowledge of the box’s contents.
- [101]
[101] It is not disputed that Shafiq’s second cautioned statement referred to at [97] above was recorded three days after he was told that his DNA was found on the inside of the packet, exhibit “A1A1-A2”, which held the packet of ecstacy pills. It can be seen from his statement recorded on 28 May 2018 that IO Parthiban showed Shafiq the photos of the orange biscuit packet and the items contained within it, viz, the ten smaller individual biscuit packets (including exhibit “A1A1-A”), and the small packet of ice and the packet of ecstacy pills contained within exhibit “A1A1-A”. Shafiq was informed when that statement was taken that his DNA had been found on the inside of exhibit “A1A1-A2”, which is the plastic packet that contained the packet with the ecstacy pills. Thus, by 28 May 2018, if not earlier, Shafiq would have known that the small packet of ice and packet of ecstacy pills were found in the orange biscuit packet.
- [102]
[102] Therefore, I agree with defence counsel’s submission that Shafiq’s admission in the cautioned statement (referred to at [97] above) meant that Shafiq knew of the existence of the packet of ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice that were found inside one of the smaller biscuit packets. This is evident from the way his admission was phrased in this cautioned statement: “I want to say that I know about the packet of 105 tablets and the 1 gram of Ice that was inside the orange biscuit packet” [emphasis added]. The important phrase to bear in mind is that Shafiq “kn[e]w about” the ecstacy pills and small packet of ice, not that Shafiq knew that the ecstacy pills and small packet of ice had been hidden in the orange biscuit packet. It does not follow from the way the sentence is phrased in the cautioned statement that Shafiq had admitted that he knew that the pills and the small packet of ice had been concealed in the orange biscuit packet (instead of the blue milk powder box).
- [103]
[103] This reading of Shafiq’s second cautioned statement is also consistent with Shafiq’s evidence at trial that he agreed to import the ecstacy pills into Singapore at the request of Husir, and he had accepted the gift of the small packet of ice, but that he did not know how Husir had concealed them, save that he knew that these drugs were found in the red plastic bag.
- [104]
[104] In Shafiq’s eighth long statement, recorded on 2 June 2018, he elaborated on how it transpired that he agreed to import the ecstacy pills into Singapore. This statement has to be examined carefully. In this statement, he states: “I am now being asked about the orange colour biscuit packet because I said that I know about the 105 Ecstacy tablets and the 1 g of Ice in my charge that was read to my [sic] yesterday”. He then goes on to relate how Husir asked him to bring the ecstacy pills into Singapore to “pass to someone”. Shafiq then explains in the statement: “[a]fter I pass back the packet of 105 Ecstacy tablets, I don’t know how [Husir] packed it and I also never see”. He then also explains how Husir had said he would get “1 gram” of methamphetamine because of his help in bringing the ecstacy pills.
- [105]
[105] In the next paragraph of the statement, it is significant that Shafiq states: “When [Husir] pass me the red plastic bag containing the blue colour milk powder box and orange biscuit packet, he said that the things are already inside. From that, I know that the Ecstacy tablets and 1 gram of ‘Ice’ is inside but I don’t know whether it was in the milk powder box or the biscuit packet” [emphasis added]. And later in the statement, Shafiq stated again: “[Husir] also said that the drugs are inside so I never open and check because I thought it was only the Ecstacy tablets and the 1 g of ‘Ice’”.
- [106]
[106] This statement, which was taken the day after Shafiq was served the charge for importing the ecstacy pills and his second cautioned statement was recorded, is quite critical because it shows several things. It confirms that both Shafiq and the recorder of his statements, IO Parthiban, understood that Shafiq did not mean in his cautioned statement of 1 June 2018 that he knew that the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice were hidden in the orange biscuit packet. All Shafiq meant was that he knew “about” the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice. IO Parthiban must have also understood this. Otherwise, when he recorded Shafiq’s long statement on 2 June 2018, he would have questioned him as to why he was changing his account from the cautioned statement from just the day before, and Shafiq’s explanation for the change would have been recorded in the long statement.
- [107]
[107] Also, this long statement recorded on 2 June 2018 is significant because it records Shafiq’s admission that, while he claimed not to be involved in, or witnessed, any re-packing of the blue milk powder box or orange biscuit packet by Husir, he knew that the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice were packed into either one of these containers, or perhaps even both (see [105] above). In this regard, I reject Shafiq’s explanation in his oral evidence that he believed that the ecstacy pills and small packet of ice were somewhere in the red plastic bag, either beneath or between the blue milk powder box and orange biscuit packet. That evidence is contradicted squarely by his long statement of 2 June 2018.
- [108]
[108] I accept the Prosecution’s submission that this notion that Shafiq would have honestly believed that the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice were somewhere inside the red plastic bag, but outside of the blue milk powder box and orange biscuit packet, is rather incredible. That would be an absurd way for Husir to conceal those drugs. In any event, if that was what Shafiq initially believed when handed the red plastic bag, a cursory glance in the bag would have proven his belief to be wrong.
- [109]
[109] For the foregoing reasons, I do not find that Shafiq had taken an inconsistent position in his statements to the CNB on his knowledge of the contents of the blue milk powder box. I find that his position in his statements, after he admitted to having brought into Singapore the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice, is that he knew of the existence of these drugs and that they were concealed in either the blue milk powder box or the orange biscuit packet, or perhaps both, but that he did not know in which “food item” the drugs were hidden. Further to this, as I have already mentioned, I do not accept Shafiq’s attempt in his oral evidence to distance himself from this position by claiming that he believed that the drugs were hidden in the red plastic bag, but outside of the blue milk powder box and orange biscuit packet.
Recipient of blue milk powder box
- [110]
[110] The Prosecution next submits that there is a set of inconsistencies in relation to Shafiq’s account of the person to whom he should hand the blue milk powder box in Singapore. In this regard, in his statements before he admitted to having agreed to the importation of the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice, Shafiq gave different answers as to whom the blue milk powder box should be handed to. In different statements, he said it was for Rahilme, Rahilme’s aunt, or some other person. In his first contemporaneous statement, Shafiq also said that the blue milk powder box belonged to Rahilme. Then, in his long statement given on 2 June 2018, after his admission in relation to the importation of the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice, Shafiq stated that his instructions were to wait for Husir’s call after he reached Singapore as to whom the blue milk powder box should be handed.
- [111]
[111] Then, at trial, Shafiq said in his evidence that Husir had not told him, when he handed him the red plastic bag, to do anything specifically in relation to the blue milk powder box. Rather, Husir’s instructions were to hand the ecstacy pills to a friend, and Husir would tell Shafiq whom to give it to when Shafiq reached Singapore. Shafiq also claimed that the blue milk powder box and orange biscuit packet were “dummies”, and that he would probably throw them away after crossing the checkpoint.
- [112]
[112] I agree with the Prosecution that Shafiq’s evidence in this respect is most unsatisfactory. However, when one examines (a) the explanation proffered by Shafiq for the changes in his account, and (b) the contents of his long statement taken on 2 June 2018 as compared with his evidence in court, I do not think that these inconsistencies necessarily show that Shafiq knew that the blue milk powder box contained the four packets of methamphetamine that are part of the subject of the Capital Charge.
- [113]
[113] First, before he finally admitted to the importation of the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice, Shafiq gave different versions in his statement as to whether the blue milk powder box was supposed to be passed to Rahilme, Rahilme’s aunt, or someone else (see [110] above). He explained that he was not able to “think properly” when he gave those accounts. In my judgment, when one reads all of Shafiq’s statements in their entirety, together with Shafiq’s conduct upon arrest, it is clear that his lies in the earlier statements, before his admissions regarding the drugs in the orange biscuit packet in the cautioned statement (see [72] and [97] above), were initially because he believed that the ecstacy pills might have been hidden in the blue milk powder box, and later because of (a) surprise that there were large amounts of methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box, and (b) fear of being implicated for importing this capital-amount of methamphetamine when he had thought that he was only carrying 100 ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice.
(a) When Shafiq was first questioned by SSgt Hamdan at the Woodlands Checkpoint, before Shafiq was arrested, Shafiq lied that he had come from his aunt’s place, that the blue milk powder box belonged to his aunt, and that his aunt had asked him to bring it home for his nephew or niece (see [3] to [5] above). It was thus clear that Shafiq was putting up a front and lying at this stage. This, however, does not necessarily show that Shafiq was lying because of an awareness of the capital-amount of methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box. Rather, Shafiq’s lie at this stage is equally consistent with his claim that he was lying so that the ecstacy pills and small packet of ice that he was carrying would not be discovered.
(b) After Shafiq was arrested, he was shown the cut open silver foil packet, exhibit “A1B1”, and the crystalline methamphetamine within it, and even asked what it was (see [6] above). As a consumer of methamphetamine, Shafiq must have recognised the methamphetamine in that silver foil packet, and would have known by the time of arrest that the blue milk powder box contained packets of methamphetamine rather than milk powder, or the ecstacy pills and the small packet of ice that he knew he was bringing into Singapore.
(c) By the next day after his arrest, Shafiq was already served with the capital charge of importing methamphetamine (see [71] above). This would have further confirmed his initial fear that he had been sabotaged by Husir with importing a capital-amount of methamphetamine, as he stated in the cautioned statement for that capital charge.
(d) Therefore, as Shafiq testified and as the Defence submits, that was why he initially sought to distance himself from any possible drug activities – including the ecstacy pills, the small packet of ice, and Husir, who is a known drug dealer who had told Shafiq that he could not return to Singapore as he was wanted by CNB (see [27] above) – as he was worried that any association with these would reduce the credibility of his claim that he did not knowingly import the packets of methamphetamine in the blue milk powder box.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.