General Division of the High Court · Decided 12 July 2021
Lakshmi d/o Kumaravelu v Lazada Singapore Pte Ltd
Feedback & support[2021] SGHC 174 · Case no. Tribunal Appeal No 10 of 2021 · 6 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The plaintiff filed this ex parte originating summons (“OS”) to appeal against decisions which, by law, are unappealable. I dismissed the OS. The plaintiff has indicated that she is dissatisfied with my decision, and will take the matter further.
Background
- [2]
[2] The plaintiff brought a claim before a Small Claims Tribunal against the defendant (“Lazada”), seeking (a) a refund of the amount she had paid for a dishwasher purchased on Lazada’s online platform in July 2020, and (b) damages for her suffering eczema, which she claimed was a result of her dealing with Lazada’s customer service.
- [3]
[3] Lazada was willing to refund the sum which had been paid for the dishwasher (which Lazada said was $472.98, but the plaintiff said was $499); but Lazada disputed the plaintiff’s claim for damages for eczema, which the plaintiff quantified in the sum of $1,124.51 for the period up to mid-October 2020. The plaintiff’s damages claim was denied by the tribunal magistrate. The magistrate found that (a) the plaintiff had not proven that Lazada had in any way caused her eczema, and (b) the nature of the damage was too remote for damages to be claimable. The magistrate only allowed a refund of the sum paid, which the magistrate found was $472.98 (which Lazada had already been willing to provide).
The plaintiff had no right of appeal
- [8]
[8] Section 38 of the Act was highlighted to the plaintiff by Lazada in email correspondence, by an Assistant Registrar at a pre-trial conference, and by me at the hearing of the OS, but the plaintiff maintained that she could still pursue her damages claim. She argued that there was a difference between the District Court dismissing her application for leave to appeal, and the District Court not granting leave to appeal. There is no difference. She applied for leave to appeal, the District Court did not give her leave to appeal, and without such leave she could not appeal against the Small Claims Tribunal’s decision. Further, she could not appeal against the District Court’s decision. She filed this OS nevertheless.
- [9]
[9] The plaintiff also suggested that the OS could be regarded as a fresh claim, for what she had failed to get from the Small Claims Tribunal. That does not work. One cannot get around a final, binding, and unappealable decision by filing the same claim (that had failed) in another court.
- [11]
[11] Finally, I would mention that the plaintiff proceeded ex parte in the absence of Lazada. It was highlighted to her at a pre-trial conference that she should amend the OS to make it inter partes, and serve it, to require Lazada to attend. The court even gave her leave to amend the OS, but she declined to do so. She said that as she was the party dissatisfied with the Small Claims Tribunal’s decision, the court should just hear from her; she expressed concern that if the court also heard from Lazada, that could be “detrimental” to her (as she said the Small Claims Tribunal’s decision was, when the tribunal had heard from both sides). The court could not however overturn the Small Claims Tribunal’s decision without giving Lazada an opportunity to be heard.
Conclusion