General Division of the High Court · Decided 22 March 2021
Public Prosecutor v Ahmed Salim
Feedback & support[2021] SGHC 68 · Case no. Criminal Case No 29 of 2020
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The accused, Ahmed Salim, a 32-year-old male Bangladeshi national, was tried before me for the murder of one Nurhidayati Bt Wartono Surata (“Yati”). At the end of the trial, I found that the Prosecution had proven its case against the accused beyond a reasonable doubt. I convicted the accused on the charge of murder and imposed the mandatory death sentence on him. The accused has appealed against his conviction and I now set out below the grounds of my decision.
- [2]
[2] The charge on which the accused was tried read as follows:
Facts
- [3]
[3] It was not disputed that the accused killed Yati on the evening of 30 December 2018 at the Golden Dragon Hotel located at No. 61 Westerhout Road, Singapore 397662 (“the Hotel”). The facts of the relationship between the accused and Yati were also not contentious for the most part. I will first set out the key elements of the factual narrative, which are primarily based on the Agreed Statement of Facts filed jointly by the parties and, where necessary, supplemented by the evidence adduced at trial.
Background
- [4]
[4] At the material time, the accused was employed as a painter by Ferh International Pte Ltd (“Ferh”) and stayed at a dormitory at 500 Old Choa Chu Kang Road, Sungei Tengah Lodge, Singapore 698924 (“the Dormitory”). Yati, a female Indonesian national, was working as a domestic helper at the material time.
- [5]
[5] The relationship between the accused and Yati began sometime in May 2012. They met on alternate Sundays and had sex about once a month. The accused’s evidence was that he would give Yati about $50–$100 every month; and in addition, he bought her various things and even helped to pay off her debts and loans. In his words, “[t]he clothes she was wearing, all the things she had in her room, everything was given by me, bought with my money … whatever a person gives to his wife, I did the same”.
- [6]
[6] The relationship between the accused and Yati developed and, in November 2017, they agreed to get married in December 2018. Although they had not yet gotten married, the accused testified that he regarded his relationship with Yati as that of “husband and wife” and that they had promised to be faithful to each other.
- [7]
[7] Sometime in May or June 2018, Yati started dating one Shamim Shamizur Rahman (“Shamim”), a Bangladeshi plumber working in Singapore. They would meet about once a month on Sundays. As the accused would call Yati every day, he began to suspect that she was seeing someone else when she became uncontactable one Sunday. He confronted her and she admitted that she was in a relationship with Shamim. Following the confrontation, the accused asked his mother and his friend to help him look for a wife in Bangladesh. His mother found him a potential wife and arranged for his marriage in Bangladesh in February 2019.
- [8]
[8] The accused and Yati reconciled sometime in July or August 2018 and resumed their meetings on alternate Sundays. They continued dating each other even after the accused informed Yati about his upcoming arranged marriage. Both of them continued to argue over Yati’s relationship with Shamim. On one occasion, when they argued over Yati’s relationship with Shamim, the accused pressed a towel over Yati’s mouth. He released the towel when she started to struggle. Frightened, Yati apologised to the accused.
- [9]
[9] Sometime in late October 2018 and early November 2018, Yati got to know one Hanifa Mohammad Abu (“Hanifa”) on Facebook. Hanifa was a Bangladeshi working in Singapore as a general fitter. About a week later, he and Yati started meeting each other every Sunday morning; and they had sex within three weeks of getting to know each other. Yati admitted to Hanifa that she was in a relationship with the accused and told him that the accused had an arranged marriage in Bangladesh. She also sent Hanifa a screenshot of the accused’s WhatsApp profile. Yati promised Hanifa that she would end her relationship with the accused, and she and Hanifa continued dating.
- [10]
[10] On 9 December 2018, the accused once again suspected Yati of seeing someone else when he could not contact her. That night, Yati called the accused. She revealed to him that she had a new boyfriend (ie, Hanifa) and told him to return to Bangladesh for his arranged marriage. The accused asked to meet Yati on 23 December 2018 and she agreed.
- [11]
[11] On 23 December 2018, the accused and Yati checked into a room at the Hotel. Yati told the accused that she did not meet Hanifa in person and that she would continue to meet the accused. However, this was untrue as she had met Hanifa in the morning prior to meeting the accused on 23 December 2018. She also repaid a loan of $500 to the accused. After they parted ways, Yati called the accused that same evening to break up with him. He persuaded her to meet him at the Hotel for a final time on 30 December 2018.
The events on 30 December 2018
- [12]
[12] On the morning of 30 December 2018, the accused withdrew nearly all of his savings from a teller machine near the Dormitory, leaving only $37 in his bank account. He had a rope with him in the pocket of the trousers that he wore to meet Yati, but as will be seen, the Prosecution and the Defence provided sharply differing reasons for this.
- [13]
[13] The accused met Yati at the block where she stayed with her employer at around 4pm. They took a taxi to Paya Lebar for Yati to collect facial cream from her friend. They then took a train from the Paya Lebar Mass Rapid Transit (“MRT”) station to Aljunied MRT station and made their way to the Hotel.
- [14]
[14] After paying $40 for a three-hour stay, the accused and Yati checked into room 307 of the Hotel (“the Room”) at around 5.15pm. They had sex for the first time that night and remained naked thereafter. The accused attempted to convince Yati to break up with Hanifa but to no avail. She also refused to let the accused check her mobile phone. The accused wrapped a bath towel around her neck for the first time that night and threatened to kill her if she continued dating Hanifa and if she did not allow him to check her phone. However, he then released the towel and they had sex again.
- [15]
[15] The accused provided starkly different accounts in his statements and in his oral testimony as to what happened thereafter. According to his statements and his interviews with the psychiatrist from the Institute of Mental Health (“IMH”) Dr Christopher Cheok (“Dr Cheok”), after he and Yati had sex for the second time, Yati told him that it would be the last time that they would meet. He then wrapped the towel around her neck for the second time that night. Yati was not cowed by the accused’s threat to kill her and told him: “If you want to kill me, kill me. With you, this is my last meet. I don’t want to see you again and I will not leave [Hanifa].” Upon hearing this, the accused tightened the towel around her neck.
- [17]
[17] The accused also testified at trial that it was at this juncture that Yati told him: “[Hanifa] is better than you. He is better than you in the hotel … he is better in bed … he is better financially. If you don’t believe … next week I will go with him, will make a video and show you” (“the Humiliating Words”). According to the accused’s testimony at trial, he was provoked by the Humiliating Words and lost his self-control; and this was why he proceeded to strangle Yati.
- [18]
[18] The Prosecution disputed that Yati had uttered these Humiliating Words to the accused on 30 December 2018 and pointed out, inter alia, that these words had never once been mentioned in the accused’s statements.
- [19]
[19] In any event, the accused did not (for the most part) dispute the account he had given in his investigative statements of the acts he had carried out in killing Yati. He wrapped the towel around Yati’s neck and tightened it. He then stepped on one end of the towel and pulled at the other end. Yati became motionless soon after and the accused removed the towel from her neck. The accused then retrieved the rope which had been in his trouser pocket and tied it around Yati’s neck. He tightened the rope and tied “about two or three knots” with it.
- [21]
[21] The accused proceeded to take a shower as he was sweating. He also put Yati’s clothes back on her body as he did not want anyone else to see her naked. He then placed her on her left side, covered her with a blanket and left the Room.
- [22]
[22] At around 8.15pm, the accused went to the Hotel reception to extend the room booking. He haggled with the hotel staff over the price of extending the room booking and eventually paid $30 for a two-hour long extension. Thereafter, he left the Hotel and bought a can of “Red Bull” at a provision shop nearby.
- [23]
[23] The accused then returned to the Room. He observed that Yati was in the same position that he had left her. He took all her cash amounting to around $30, her mobile phone and her ez-link card, switched off the air-conditioner and lights in the Room, and left the Hotel.
- [24]
[24] That night, the accused also spoke to Hanifa on the phone several times. Hanifa testified that he had tried to call both Yati’s and the accused’s phone numbers that night, and that he knew that the accused was holding onto Yati’s phone. In these exchanges, the accused persistently interrogated Hanifa about his relationship with Yati. Hanifa testified that the accused sounded “angry” and that he “talked in a loud voice”.
The arrest of the accused
- [25]
[25] The accused called his colleague and roommate, Khalik Md Abdul (“Khalik”), twice at about 8pm and 8.45pm, to ask for Khalik’s whereabouts. Khalik informed the accused that he was at a provision shop within the Dormitory. Shortly thereafter, the accused returned to the Dormitory and bought some food at the canteen. He then handed $1,000 in cash to Khalik, who agreed to help the accused remit the money to the accused’s father in Bangladesh. The accused told Khalik that he had killed someone.
- [26]
[26] The accused then told his roommates that he would be returning to Bangladesh and offered them the food that he had earlier bought at the canteen. He also offered food to others in the neighbouring room. After talking to his colleagues, the accused took a shower and left the Dormitory. He loitered around Geylang before checking into Kim Tian Hotel (Han) located at 29 Lor 4 Geylang, Singapore 399281, at around 2am the next morning. He checked out of the hotel at around 5am and loitered in a park at Boon Lay.
- [27]
[27] At around 9am, the accused sent a WhatsApp message to one Zoe Lau (“Zoe”), who was in charge of human resource matters at Ferh. He told Zoe that he needed to return to Bangladesh that very day as he had some problems back at home. At Zoe’s direction, the accused called Ferh’s owner, Fadhillah bin Sahamat (“Fadhillah”), and requested to return to Bangladesh that day. Fadhillah told the accused to go to the Ferh office to discuss the matter. Unbeknownst to the accused, the police had already been in touch with Fadhillah by then. When the accused arrived at the Ferh office at around 10.45am, he was arrested by the police officers who were waiting in the office.
The discovery of Yati’s body and the autopsy
- [28]
[28] At about 10.15pm on 30 December 2018, Mr Lee Peng Yuan (“Mr Lee”), the Hotel receptionist, called the Room as the two-hour extension had expired. As nobody answered the call, Mr Lee went to the Room. He knocked on the door but received no response. He then unlocked the door and entered the Room with a duplicate key.
- [29]
[29] Mr Lee saw Yati lying on the bed. He tried waking her up but she remained unresponsive. He then left the Room and called the police at around 10.45pm.
- [30]
[30] Paramedics from Paya Lebar Fire Station were dispatched to the Hotel. At about 10.53pm, the paramedics arrived at the Hotel and went to the Room. One of the paramedics, Paramedic Sergeant Nabilah binte Sadali (“W/Sgt Nabilah”), saw Yati lying on her side on the bed, covered in a blanket up to her shoulders. When the paramedics removed the blanket, they observed Yati to be unresponsive. There was a towel stained with blood next to her. W/Sgt Nabilah checked Yati’s body and observed that there was blood coming out of her nose and left ear, and that her face was swollen. She also felt the rope tied around Yati’s neck. Yati was pronounced dead at 11.02pm.
- [31]
[31] On 31 December 2018, Dr Lee Chin Thye (“Dr Lee”), a Consultant Forensic Pathologist with the Health Sciences Authority, conducted an autopsy on Yati. When conducting an external examination of Yati’s body, he noted that there was a ligature, comprising a grey fabric rope measuring 0.5cm in thickness and approximately 100cm in length, around Yati’s neck. The rope had been wound a total of four times around her neck and a knot had been tied with the rope at the left side of the front of her neck. Dr Lee further noted that the only external injury to the body was a complex ligature mark around Yati’s neck, and that the ligature mark was consistent with the rope that had been found around her neck.
- [32]
[32] Dr Lee found the cause of Yati’s death to be strangulation and cervical spine injury. He also testified that it was possible that Yati had been strangled with a towel before being strangled with the rope, given that strangulation with a towel would not leave much of a mark on the neck. However, whether the cause of Yati’s death was strangulation with a towel or strangulation with a rope, it was undisputed that the accused had caused Yati’s death.
The accused’s statements
- [33]
[33] A total of five police statements were recorded from the accused and comprised:
(a) a cautioned statement recorded on 31 December 2018 by Assistant Superintendent of Police Lee Tien Huat Chris, pursuant to s 23 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 68, 2012 Rev Ed) (“CPC”); and
(b) four long statements recorded by Assistant Superintendent of Police Teo Ko Sing (“ASP Teo”) on 3 January 2019, 4 January 2019, 7 January 2019 and 8 January 2019 respectively, pursuant to s 22 of the CPC.
- [34]
[34] While the Defence did not contest the voluntariness of the accused’s statements, the accuracy of these statements became a bone of contention at trial.
- [35]
[35] The gist of the accused’s statements was that upon learning of Yati’s relationship with Hanifa on 9 December 2018, the accused had decided to kill her, and he had come up with a plan whereby he would kill her if she refused to leave Hanifa and to stay with him (the accused) until his departure for Bangladesh. In this regard, the accused’s statements contained numerous references to his having “decided” to kill Yati even before 30 December 2018, and certainly on 30 December 2018 when she refused to break up with Hanifa. The accused further elaborated in his statements that he had “chose[n]” to kill Yati with a rope because it was illegal to carry sharp weapons in public whereas it would be easy to keep the rope in his pocket; he had deliberately brought the rope along with him to the Hotel on 30 December 2018 for the purpose of killing her. The accused also stated in his cautioned statement that he “admitted to the charge” because “[he] did it out of anger, because [he had] proof that [Yati had] another relationship with another guy”.
The Prosecution’s case
- [38]
[38] While the Prosecution accepted that the accused was suffering from adjustment disorder (“AD”) at the time of the killing, they argued that he could not avail himself of the partial defence of diminished responsibility as his AD did not substantially impair his mental responsibility. As for the partial defence of grave and sudden provocation, the Prosecution’s primary case was that the Humiliating Words – which the Defence relied on as the “provocation - were never uttered and were fabricated by the accused. The Prosecution further contended that, in any event, the Humiliating Words were not objectively grave or sudden and that the accused had not been deprived of self-control at the time of the killing.
The Defence’s case
- [39]
[39] In their closing submissions, the Defence said that the accused “did not intend to kill [Yati]”: according to the Defence, the Prosecution could not prove that the accused “intended to kill [Yati] beyond a reasonable doubt”, and the court was urged to “exercise its powers to convict the accused under section 300(c) of the [Penal Code] instead”.
- [40]
[40] The Defence also relied on the partial defences of diminished responsibility and grave and sudden provocation. As for the former, the Defence cited the opinion of Dr Ung Eng Khean (“Dr Ung”), whom they called as their psychiatric expert. In reliance on Dr Ung’s evidence, the Defence argued that the accused’s AD “significantly contributed to his offence by ‘making his emotions more labile (unstable) especially exacerbating his feelings of anger as well as reducing his self-control and impairing his judgment (leading to his making inappropriate choices’”. As for the latter, the Defence contended that the Humiliating Words had indeed been uttered by Yati to the accused, that these Humiliating Words were objectively grave and sudden, and that they had caused the accused to lose self-control. Additionally, the gravity of the Humiliating Words was amplified by the accused’s AD.
The issues to be determined
- [41]
[41] It was not disputed that the accused had caused Yati’s death. As such, the following issues arose for my determination:
(a) whether the accused had intended to cause Yati’s death;
(b) whether the Defence had proven the partial defence of diminished responsibility on a balance of probabilities; and
(c) whether the Defence had proven the partial defence of grave and sudden provocation on a balance of probabilities.
- [42]
[42] I address each of these issues in turn.
Whether the accused intended to cause Yati’s death
- [43]
[43] At the outset, it should be noted that in putting forward the broad proposition that the accused “did not intend to kill [Yati]”, the Defence was really saying two things. Firstly, it was saying that the Prosecution had failed to prove the mens rea required for an offence under s 300(a) – namely, the intention of causing Yati’s death. This was why the Defence’s submissions concluded with the suggestion that the accused should be convicted of an offence under s 300(c) instead – which would have entailed a finding that the accused’s intention was only to cause bodily injury to Yati. Secondly, in saying that the accused “did not intend to kill [Yati]”, the Defence was also contending that the accused’s killing of Yati was not carried out in accordance with a “premeditated plan”.
- [44]
[44] I will first deal with the argument regarding the absence of any intention to cause death. In considering this argument, it was important to bear in mind the physical acts which were carried out by the accused against Yati in the moments leading up to her death. These were described by the accused in the investigative statements recorded by the police. I noted of course that at trial, the accused disavowed all references in the investigative statements to any “decision” or “plan” on his part to kill Yati. However, even shorn of these references, the accused’s description of the physical acts per se was in my view highly instructive as to his intention in carrying out these acts. In gist, he described two separate acts of strangulation: the strangulation performed with a towel, followed by the strangulation using the rope which had been inside his trouser pocket. In addition to (and subsequent to) the two acts of strangulation, he also described how he had pressed down on Yati’s nose and mouth using a towel, and finally, how he had twisted her head from left to right. He also described the steps he took in carrying out each of these acts and the degree of force he employed. I set out below the passages from his statements in which the various physical acts were described, starting with the strangulation using the towel:
(a) From the accused’s investigative statement of 4 January 2019:
(b) From the accused’s investigative statement of 7 January 2019:
- [45]
[45] Apart from the description given in his investigative statements, during a site visit and “scene re-enactment” at the Hotel on 7 January 2019, the accused also gave a demonstration to ASP Teo of how he had strangled Yati, first with the towel and then with the rope.
- [46]
[46] By and large, the accused’s description of the physical acts carried out against Yati in the moments leading up to her death was borne out by the forensic pathologist’s (ie, Dr Lee’s) findings as to the injuries sustained by Yati and the cause of her death. In the re-enactment he carried out for ASP Teo on 7 January 2019, the accused had demonstrated how he had placed the rope around Yati’s neck, crossed it behind her neck, then “rounded” it around her neck, and finally tied a series of knots in the rope. In examining Yati’s body, Dr Lee noted that a ligature in the form of a grey fabric rope was found around her neck, tied as follows: it was wound a total of four times around her neck, “first wound twice around the entire neck, immediately over the skin and under the hair around the back of the neck”, “then wound twice around the entire neck, going over the hair around the back of the neck”, and “knotted with a granny knot measuring 1.5 x 1.5 x 1 cm at the left side of the front of the neck”. Dr Lee also noted a “complex ligature mark” which was “present circumferentially around [Yati’s] neck, corresponding to the overlying ligature”. A dissection of the neck revealed the following injuries: haemorrhages in the thyrohyoid muscles bilaterally; pre-vertebral haemorrhage around the midline at the level of the C4/5 cervical vertebrae; dislocation of the C4/5 intervertebral joint; and extensive epidural haemorrhage within the cervical spinal canal. Dr Lee concluded that the cause of death was “strangulation and cervical spine injury”. None of Dr Lee’s findings was challenged by the Defence at trial.
- [47]
[47] Indeed, although at trial the accused denied vehemently having said anything about a “decision” or a “plan” to kill Yati, he did not disavow the bulk of the narrative he had provided in his statements about the physical acts carried out against Yati in the moments leading up to her death. What he did dispute in cross-examination was, firstly, the number of times he had placed the towel around Yati’s neck before finally strangling her: in his statements, he described the strangulation as having taken place on the third occasion when he had placed the towel around her neck; in cross-examination, he claimed that he had placed the towel around her neck a total of four times and that he had only tightened the towel on the fourth occasion. In addition, he denied that he had committed the subsequent acts of strangulation with the rope, pressing on Yati’s mouth and nose, and twisting of her head because he thought that she was not yet dead and wanted to ensure that she would not survive: according to his oral testimony, by the time he came to use the rope, he already “thought she had died”.
- [48]
[48] Neither of the above objections went towards refuting the account given in his statements of the physical acts carried out against Yati in the moments leading up to her death. In my view, the number, the nature and the sequence of these physical acts clearly demonstrated an intention to cause Yati’s death. To put it bluntly, the accused visited multiple, successive acts of violence on Yati within a short span of time. This was not, moreover, a case of mere slaps or punches: he strangled her twice using two different implements, pressed down hard on her mouth and nose (“a force of 10, out of the spectrum 10”), and twisted her head from left to right. He could not have intended anything else other than her death.
- [49]
[49] It should also be pointed out that although in his interviews with Dr Ung the accused denied having formed any plan to kill Yati prior to 30 December 2018, Dr Ung’s notes of the interview on 19 May 2020 recorded the accused as having said that he had “decided to kill [Yati] on 3rd time of strangling (on 30th December 2018)”. At trial, the Defence did not challenge the accuracy of this portion of Dr Ung’s notes. That the accused himself had admitted to having “decided to kill [Yati] on 3rd time of strangling (on 30th December 2018)” further supported the inference that his intention at the time of carrying out the physical acts of strangulation was to cause Yati’s death.
- [50]
[50] For the reasons set out in [44]–[49], I was satisfied that the accused’s intention at the material time was to cause death.
Whether the accused’s killing of Yati was carried out in accordance with a “premeditated plan”
- [51]
[51] In submitting that the accused “did not intend to kill [Yati]”, the Defence’s other contention was that the killing was not carried out in accordance with a premeditated plan. According to the accused, he had merely “thought” about killing Yati prior to 30 December 2018 but had not formulated any real plan nor come to a firm decision to do so. Instead, he had simply lost all self-control and acted impulsively on 30 December 2018 upon hearing Yati utter the Humiliating Words to him in the Room. This version of events – as presented to Dr Ung and at trial – turned on two key factual propositions: firstly, that various statements documented in the accused’s police statements and in his interviews with Dr Cheok could not be relied on because he had never made those statements; and secondly, that the Humiliating Words had indeed been spoken by Yati to the accused on 30 December 2018.
Whether the accused told the police in his investigative statements that he had decided to kill Yati
- [52]
[52] I address first the accused’s claims about the statements recorded from him by the police. The accused claimed that he had “never told [ASP Teo] and the Interpreter of his Section 22 CPC Statements that he ‘decided’ to kill [Yati]”. In this connection, the accused came up with a number of allegations against Mohammad Zahurul Hasan (“Hasan”), who had acted as the Bengali interpreter for the recording of all five of his investigative statements. According to the accused, Hasan spoke in a “very literary” and “well-educated” language; and the accused did not understand some of the words used by Hasan. In particular, according to the accused, he had “never heard or used” the Bengali word for “decide” until Hasan used it. In fact, he had not even realised the meaning of the word “decide” until his cell-mate at Changi Prison got hold of his statements. The accused himself had never told Hasan that he had “decided” to kill Yati. What he had said was that he had been “thinking” about whether to kill her after discovering her infidelity and asking himself how he should deal with her: it was Hasan who had used the word “decided” in interpreting what he (the accused) had said.
- [53]
[53] Thus, for example, in paragraph 20 of his investigative statement of 3 January 2019, the accused was recorded as having said this:
According to the accused, the italicised words were never said by him to Hasan or to ASP Teo. Instead, what he had told Hasan was this:
- [54]
[54] I rejected the accused’s assertion that he had “never told [ASP Teo] and [Hasan] that he ‘decided’ to kill [Yati]”. I found the accused’s evidence about what he had purportedly said to Hasan and about Hasan’s alleged errors in interpreting his statements to be entirely unbelievable. My reasons were as follows.
- [55]
[55] Firstly, the evidence from Hasan – which was not disputed – showed that at the end of the recording of each investigative statement, that statement would be read back and interpreted to the accused on the same day, and the accused would be asked if he wished to make any amendments. It was also not disputed that on 3 January 2019, the accused had made various amendments to the investigative statement recorded from him that day. These were the handwritten amendments seen, for example, at paragraph 15 of the statement, wherein the accused had volunteered additional details about Yati’s spare phone and about how he had returned her the phone he had taken from her earlier. Similarly, on 4 January 2019, the accused also made various amendments to the investigative statement recorded from him that day, and these were again handwritten in the body of the said statement. For example, the handwritten amendments at paragraph 67 of the statement of 4 January 2019 showed that the accused had volunteered additional details about the rope which was eventually used to strangle Yati. On 7 January 2019, the accused had also made amendments to the investigative statement recorded from him that day. Thus, for example, the handwritten amendments at paragraph 98 of the statement of 7 January 2019 showed that the accused had volunteered additional details about how he had noticed blood stains on the towel – but not blood coming out from Yati – at the point when he started putting her clothing on her body and positioning her body on the bed.
- [56]
[56] The accused did not deny that the handwritten amendments in his investigative statements were made at his request at the end of the recording of each statement. In addition to being given the opportunity at the end of the recording of each statement to make amendments to that statement, the statement-recording on 4 January 2019 and on 7 January 2019 was preceded by Hasan reading back and interpreting to the accused the statement(s) recorded in the previous session(s), and ASP Teo asking the accused (through Hasan) if he wished to make any amendments to the previous statement(s). This meant that on 4 January 2019, before any statement was recorded from the accused, the statement of 3 January 2019 was read back and interpreted to him; and he was asked if he wished to make any “correction, deletion or addition to it”. Similarly, on 7 January 2019, before any statement was recorded from the accused, the statements of 3 January 2019 and 4 January 2019 were read back and interpreted to him; and he was asked if he wished to make any “correction, deletion or addition” to those statements. This process was documented at the start of the statements of 4 January 2019 and 7 January 2019 respectively. As for 8 January 2019, the accused refused to have his statements of 3 January 2019, 4 January 2019 and 7 January 2019 read back to him, and informed ASP Teo that he did not wish to make any correction, deletion or addition to those statements.
- [57]
[57] On each occasion on 4 January 2019 and 7 January 2019, the accused requested to make various amendments to his previous statements. In particular, on 4 January 2019, when his statement of 3 January 2019 was read back by Hasan and the accused was asked if he wished to make any correction, deletion or addition to that statement, he specifically requested to amend paragraph 20. This was the paragraph with the sentence “I decided that I wanted to kill her”. The accused requested that the following sentences be added at the end of paragraph 20:
- [58]
[58] It should be added that Hasan testified that the accused raised no complaints in the course of the recording of his statements. Certainly he did not complain that he could not understand Hasan or that Hasan had misinterpreted parts of his statements. Hasan’s testimony in this respect was not challenged by the Defence.
- [59]
[59] I found it telling that the accused had his statements read back to him several times, that he was presented with multiple opportunities to amend those statements, and that he did make amendments (including substantive amendments). It raised serious questions as to why the accused did nothing about those parts of the statements in which he was recorded as saying he had “decided” to kill Yati. Even more tellingly, when pressed to clarify exactly what he had said to Hasan and how Hasan had interpreted his statement back to him, the accused’s evidence became increasingly incoherent and unbelievable. I take paragraph 20 of the accused’s statement of 3 January 2019 as an example. In examination-in-chief, although he started by claiming that he had told Hasan he was “thinking” about what to do and whether to kill Yati, he shifted after a while to claiming that “[t]hese words came from … Hasan”. According to him:
- [60]
[60] In cross-examination, when the accused was asked what Bengali word Hasan had used for “decided” when reading the statement back to him, the accused prevaricated, initially claiming that he was “thinking of many things, particularly like [his] family” at the material time and that he “[did] not really remember what [Hasan] said because at that time, [he] did not really pay attention [to] what [Hasan] was saying”. This was despite his having said in examination-in-chief that Hasan had used “the big Bengali word” which he could not understand. When it was pointed out to him that he had managed to make multiple amendments to the statement of 3 January 2019 and even to paragraph 20 itself, the accused’s testimony shifted again: he claimed that “[s]ometimes [he] heard [Hasan], sometimes [he] did not”; that “[s]ometimes [he] felt like talking, sometimes [he] didn’t feel like talking”; and that although he had made some amendments to that statement, “after a while [he] really got irritated” so he had told Hasan there was “[n]o need to read everything” back to him before signing off on the statement.
- [61]
[61] With respect, the above evidence made no sense, since it was clear that despite his avowed lack of interest in the contents of the statement being read back to him, the accused had nevertheless made substantive amendments to various parts of the statement, including paragraph 20. Indeed, in respect of paragraph 20, when this was read back to him on 4 January 2019, not only had he volunteered details of Yati’s failure to call him at night after she started a relationship with Hanifa and of his own anger at her behaviour (as noted at [57]), he had even added details about her trip to collect “two boxes of facial cream” from a friend on 30 December 2018 prior to their going to the Hotel. Given his attention to detail vis-à-vis the contents of paragraph 20, it beggared belief that he should have failed to pay attention to the crucial sentence, “I decided that I wanted to kill her”.
- [62]
[62] It appeared that the accused realised the tenuous quality of the above evidence because when questioned further by the Prosecution, he suddenly asserted that Hasan had used the Bengali word “sirdhanto”, which meant “decide”. Indeed, not only did the accused purport to recall Hasan’s use of the word “sirdhanto”, he was able to contrast this with the court interpreter’s use of the word “thik” (which the latter had explained was an “easier” Bengali word for “decided”) and to assert that he himself had used the Bengali word “bahapchi” (translated by the court interpreter as “thinking” ):
- [63]
[63] Having given the above evidence, when he was asked by me to confirm that Hasan had used the word “sirdhanto”, the accused appeared to baulk at providing such confirmation. On the one hand, he appeared to retreat at one point to his earlier claims about not remembering what Hasan had said. He also claimed that in fact, he did not know the two words “sirdhanto” and “thik” (as in “thik kora ci”), despite having – just moments prior - distinguished these two words from the word “bahapci” which he said he had used. On the other hand, he also subsequently claimed that where he was recorded as having said that he had “decided that [he] wanted to kill Yati” (paragraph 20 of the 3 January 2019 statement) and that he had “decided to kill her” (paragraph 27 of the same statement), “[t]he sentences were formed by [Hasan]”. When asked to clarify what he meant when he said these sentences had been “formed” by Hasan, he claimed – after much stalling and equivocation – that Hasan had asked him, “Have you decided that you wanted to kill her”, to which he had said “yes”. When asked why he had said “yes” if he had never used the word “decided” himself, he claimed that he had said “yes” because he did not know the meaning of the word “decided” and understood Hasan to be simply asking him if he had killed Yati.
- [64]
[64] In further cross-examination, the accused was referred to Question 5 in his statement of 4 January 2019, in which ASP Teo had focused specifically on the sentence in paragraph 20 of his 3 January 2019 statement, “On 9 December 2018, when she (‘Yati’) first told me that she had another boyfriend, I decided that I wanted to kill her”, and asked him to “further elaborate on this”. In response to ASP Teo’s request for further elaboration, the accused gave the following response:
- [65]
[65] Again, the accused’s responses in paragraphs 67–69 of his 4 January 2019 statement were telling, because ASP Teo had specifically drawn his attention to the sentence containing the words “I decided that I wanted to kill her”. That he could have failed to notice at that juncture the use of the word “decided” again beggared belief. Indeed, having had his attention drawn to the said sentence, he responded to the request for elaboration by supplying details of his “plan” – namely, to question Yati to see if she would agree to break up with her new boyfriend, and to kill her if she did not agree. In other words, far from denying any decision to kill Yati, the accused’s response affirmed the earlier statement about his decision to kill her.
- [66]
[66] At trial, of course, the accused did not accept that he had said anything about a decision or a plan to kill Yati. When he was asked how Hasan had interpreted the words “I decided that I wanted to kill her” when interpreting Question 5 to him, his answers became increasingly convoluted and unbelievable. First, he claimed that Hasan had used the Bengali words for both “think” and “decide” when interpreting Question 5. He claimed that he did not remember exactly whether Hasan had used the Bengali word “sirdhanto” or “thik” – but he appeared quite certain that the word “bhabso” was used by Hasan for “think”. He even suggested that there were “many” Bengali words which could be used for the English word “think”. However, when the Prosecution sought to get him to pin down the meaning of the Bengali word “bhabso”, he again shifted position and declared that he had believed all three words – “sirdhanto”, “thik” and “bhabso” – to “[mean] the same thing”. On being questioned further by the Prosecution, his answers became entirely illogical as he vacillated between repeating that Hasan had used the Bengali word “bhabso” and denying any memory of what Hasan had said. I set out below the relevant extract from the trial transcript:
- [68]
[68] Moreover, if in fact all that the accused had told Hasan was that he was “thinking” about whether to kill Yati, there was no reason for Hasan to convey to ASP Teo something entirely different. From the accused’s own evidence at trial, assuming he had said in Bengali that he was “thinking”, he would have used either the word “bahapchi” or the word “bhabso”. It was simply not possible that Hasan – a certified interpreter of 18 years’ standing – would have confused these Bengali words for “think” with the Bengali words for “decide” (“sirdhanto” or “thik”). The Defence did not suggest to Hasan that he had somehow misheard the accused.
- [69]
[69] As for the suggestion that Hasan had used the word “decide” in posing questions to the accused and that the accused had simply said “yes” to his question without knowing what the word meant, I found this suggestion equally unbelievable. I have explained earlier why I found the accused’s evidence in this respect to be riddled with inconsistencies and lacking in credibility. It should also be noted that in cross-examining ASP Teo, Defence counsel had put it to her that every specific question she had asked of the accused during the statement-recording was recorded in the body of the relevant statement; and that if there were any other questions, they would have been merely of a clarificatory nature, along the lines of “You said this. I don’t understand what it means”. According to the Defence’s case, therefore, it would have been Hasan himself (and not ASP Teo) who took the initiative to introduce the word “decide” into the recording process when the accused had never used the word at all and did not even know what it meant. In my view, this was an entirely baseless proposition. The Defence did not suggest why – in the absence of any specific questions from ASP Teo as to whether or when the accused had decided to kill Yati – Hasan should have found it necessary to put such questions of his own to the accused. Certainly I could not see any reason why – as the interpreter – Hasan would have gone on such a frolic of his own and put words in the accused’s mouth.
- [70]
[70] For the reasons set out in [55]–[69], I did not believe the accused’s denial of a premeditated plan to kill Yati. I found that the accused did indeed tell the police that as early as 9 December 2018, he had decided he wanted to kill Yati after learning of her new relationship (paragraph 20 of the 3 January 2019 statement); and further, that his plan was to ask her to break up with her new boyfriend – and to kill her if she did not agree (paragraph 67 of the 4 January 2019 statement).
Why the accused brought the rope along with him on 30 December 2018
- [71]
[71] The existence of such a plan was corroborated by the accused’s own admissions in his investigative statements as to why he had brought a rope along with him on 30 December 2018. In his statement of 3 January 2019, the accused said that the rope “belonged” to one of his old jackets, and that although he had discarded the jacket long ago, he had kept the rope “to be used to tie [his] laundries together before washing”. He said at one point that he “chose to kill ‘Yati’ with a rope with no real reason”. However, he also explained that he “felt that rope was easy to keep in the pocket” and that he had concerns about “sharp weapon[s] like knife” which he knew were “prohibited to carry in public”. As noted earlier, when he was subsequently asked on 4 January 2019 to elaborate on his earlier statement (in paragraph 20 of the 3 January 2019 statement) that he had “decided that [he] wanted to kill [Yati]”, the accused disclosed that on 9 December 2018, when he became “so angry” on hearing of Yati’s new boyfriend and “told [himself] that [he] would kill [her]”, he had looked around and found the rope. It will be recalled that he also explained that this rope was “soft, tough, and easy … to keep … inside [his] pocket”. His plan was to kill Yati if she refused to leave her new boyfriend: he knew that he could strangle her to death, and he “told [himself] that [he] would bring the rope with [him] and kill ‘Yati’ the next time [they] were in the Hotel”. He did in fact bring the rope with him on 23 December 2018 but did not kill Yati that day because she agreed to continue seeing him and assured him that she did not meet with Hanifa. On 30 December 2018, however, she refused to break up with Hanifa, and the accused “strangled her to death”.
- [72]
[72] At trial, contrary to the account he had given in his investigative statements, the accused claimed that the presence of the rope in his pocket on 30 December 2018 was entirely fortuitous. According to the accused, he had used the rope to tie his laundry on 9 December 2018. While doing his laundry that day, he had been talking to Yati on the telephone and had become “very angry” upon hearing about her new boyfriend. It was at that point that it “came to [his] head that [he] will kill her with that rope”. He put the rope in his pocket after finishing his laundry. The next day, he reconciled with Yati, and “everything was okay”. He did not bother to remove the rope from his pocket, because in any event he “always” kept the rope in his pocket. He wore the same pair of trousers (with the pocket containing the rope) when he went to meet Yati on 23 December 2018 and on 30 December 2018, because these were the trousers he “usually” wore: these trousers had “quite a number of pockets”, and he wore them for going out. Since he wore the same pair of trousers on 23 December 2018 and 30 December 2018, the rope “was with [him] as well” inside the pocket, but he “didn’t carry that rope to kill [Yati]” on 30 December 2018: it just so happened that the rope was “[a]lways in [his] pocket”.
- [73]
[73] I did not believe the accused’s narrative at trial about why he had the rope with him on 30 December 2018. My reasons were as follows. Quite apart from the details which the accused himself had volunteered in paragraph 67 of his 4 January 2019 statement, in that same statement-recording session, ASP Teo had drawn his attention to his mention of the rope in paragraph 21 of his 3 January 2019 statement and had specifically asked him to elaborate on why he had taken a rope with him on 30 December 2018. I reproduce below the accused’s response to ASP Teo:
- [74]
[74] Again, I found the above response telling because it was provided by the accused after his attention had been drawn by ASP Teo to the issue of the rope. If the presence of the rope in his pocket on 30 December 2018 was merely fortuitous, one would have expected him to say so to ASP Teo. He did not. Indeed, reading the above response together with his response in the preceding paragraphs 67–69 of the same statement, it was clear that the rope played an integral part in his plan to kill Yati: he chose it because it was tough, yet easy to keep in his pocket; he knew he could strangle Yati with it; he planned to strangle her in a hotel; and he made sure to bring the rope with him whenever he knew he and Yati would be going to a hotel. This was why he had the rope with him on 23 December 2018 and on 30 December 2018. In other words, the fact that he had the rope with him on 30 December 2018 was the result of a considered decision: it was not a coincidence nor an accident of ill fortune.
- [75]
[75] At trial, the accused sought once again to blame Hasan for those portions of his statements which dealt with his possession of the rope. According to the accused, he knew that he had killed Yati with the rope; he “didn’t want to explain everything” and “wanted to cut short the whole thing”:
- [76]
[76] I found the accused’s explanation unbelievable. His assertion that he had “wanted to cut short” the statement-recording – and that he had simply answered “Yes, yes” to whatever Hasan asked about the rope – was refuted by the contents of his investigative statements, which showed that he had taken the trouble to provide various details about the rope: for example, the fact that the rope had been part of an old jacket; the use he had habitually made of it when doing his laundry; the ease with which it could be kept in his pocket, as compared to a prohibited weapon such as a knife; and his decision to bring it with him after 9 December 2018 whenever he knew he and Yati would be going to a hotel. These were details which Hasan could not have known, and which – even if Hasan had asked about the rope – could not have been conveyed via the brief answer “Yes, yes”. They were details which had to have been volunteered by the accused himself. The same reasoning would apply even if it was ASP Teo who had asked the accused (through Hasan) about the rope – although in this connection, I should add that it was never put to ASP Teo that she had asked the accused questions about the rope, nor were any such questions by her recorded in the statements.
- [77]
[77] Finally, the Defence argued that the fact that the accused had used a towel to strangle Yati showed that “the rope was not part of a pre-meditated plan to kill [Yati] with that particular item”. With respect, this argument ignored facts which the accused himself had volunteered. It was not disputed that there were two acts of strangulation – the first involving the use of the towel, the second involving the use of the rope. According to the accused’s narrative, the rope was kept in the pocket of his trousers on 30 December 2018, just as it had been kept there on 23 December 2018. At the point of the first act of strangulation, both the accused and Yati were naked. In other words, the accused did not have the rope close at hand at that point. He did have the towel in his hand at that point, according to his narrative. He had already “rounded” the towel around Yati’s neck twice – and at one point, even around his own neck – while trying to convince her to break up with Hanifa and to stay in a relationship with him (the accused) until his return to Bangladesh. When she refused and when he told her “Today, I will kill you”, he was holding the same towel and he “rounded” her neck with it again. He started to tighten the towel after she “challenged” him to kill her; and this was how he came to strangle her with the towel. In the circumstances, the use of the towel in the first act of strangulation was purely a matter of convenience: the towel was what the accused happened to have in his hands when Yati made the fatal decision to refuse once more his plea that they continue their relationship. Significantly, when he decided to commit the second act of strangulation, he chose to do so with the rope, which he took from his trouser pocket; and from his own narrative, his use of the rope was not some hasty fumbling act but a deliberate one involving, inter alia, the “crossing” of the rope behind Yati’s neck and the tying of several knots.
- [78]
[78] For the reasons set out in [73]–[77], I accepted the Prosecution’s submission that the accused had brought the rope with him on 30 December 2018 as part of a premeditated plan to kill Yati.
Whether the accused’s statements to Dr Cheok should be given any weight
- [79]
[79] In addition to challenging the incriminating portions of his investigative statements in which he had spoken of his decision to kill Yati and his plan to use the rope, the accused also took issue with Dr Cheok’s interview notes. The Defence’s main objections were in respect of certain parts of these interview notes in which Dr Cheok had recorded the accused relating to him a “plan” to kill Yati. According to the Defence, no weight should be given to those parts of Dr Cheok’s interview notes because various defects in the interview process for all three interviews rendered the interview notes unsafe to rely on. In particular, the Defence objected to any weight being given to the following statements and comments recorded by Dr Cheok in his notes:
(a) From the interview notes of 21 January 2019:
(b) From the interview notes of 25 January 2019:
- [80]
[80] The Defence argued that it was unsafe to rely on Dr Cheok’s notes because – according to the accused – Dr Cheok already had the accused’s police statements at the first interview on 21 January 2019; Dr Cheok conducted nearly all of the first interview and at least half of the second interview in English without the Bengali interpreter being present; and Dr Cheok merely asked a few questions about the accused’s sleep while omitting to ask any case-related questions during the third interview.
- [81]
[81] I found the Defence’s objections to Dr Cheok’s interview notes to be without merit. Notably, the accused’s allegations about the Bengali interpreter’s absence for the most part during these interviews were unsupported – indeed, controverted – by the objective evidence. In respect of the first interview by Dr Cheok on 21 January 2019, the CAMS tracking report maintained by the prison authorities showed that Dr Cheok had arrived for the interview at the Changi Medical Complex at 1.57pm on that day, while the Bengali interpreter Md Sirajul Islam (“Sirajul”) had arrived at 2.18pm. Subsequently, Sirajul had left at 3.44pm while Dr Cheok had left at 3.46pm. The CAMS tracking report showed, therefore, that Sirajul had arrived soon after Dr Cheok’s arrival, and not towards the end of the interview as the accused claimed. Dr Cheok’s evidence was that the 21 minutes prior to Sirajul’s arrival would have been used as “some degree of administrative time” (escorting the accused to the interview room, uncuffing him, getting him seated, cuffing him again and so on). The formal interview would have started with his recording the accused’s personal particulars and explaining the purpose of the interview as well as the issue of confidentiality vis-à-vis the contents of the interview: Sirajul would have been present right from the start of the formal interview. Dr Cheok’s evidence on this score was corroborated by Sirajul himself. I should add that given the terminology which would have had to be explained to the accused when he was briefed about the purpose of the interview (“psychiatric assessment”, “Institute of Mental Health”, “confidentiality”, etc), I found it extremely unlikely that Dr Cheok would have attempted to explain the various terms to the accused in English. At the same time, given the accused’s indisputably limited grasp of English, it was also extremely unlikely that Dr Cheok could have elicited all the information recorded in his interview notes without the assistance of an interpreter.
- [82]
[82] It should be pointed out that in making allegations about Sirajul’s absence on 21 January 2019, the Defence appeared to have misunderstood some of the evidence. The Defence claimed that Dr Cheok’s interview notes for 21 January 2019 showed that Sirajul was only present at about 3.30pm. This was a misapprehension of Dr Cheok’s notes. In fact, Dr Cheok had clearly recorded in his notes that the interview commenced at 2pm, with Sirajul present as interpreter; and that at 3.30pm on the same day, he had spoken via telephone with the accused’s mother in Bangladesh, again with Sirajul present as interpreter.
- [83]
[83] As for the second interview on 25 January 2019, the CAMS tracking report showed that Sirajul had arrived at 10.12am, slightly ahead of Dr Cheok who had arrived at 10.18am; and both of them had left at 10.53am. Again, therefore, the CAMS tracking report supported Dr Cheok’s assertion that Sirajul was present for the entire interview. This was confirmed by Sirajul himself.
- [84]
[84] As for the third interview on 28 January 2019, the CAMS tracking report showed that Dr Cheok had arrived at 2.13pm and left at 2.43pm, while Sirajul had arrived at 2.29pm and left at 2.43pm. Dr Cheok testified that the third interview would typically be shorter than the preceding two because by then, most of the information required for the psychiatric assessment would have been obtained. Dr Cheok denied that he had merely asked the accused about his sleep without asking any case-related questions. This was borne out by his interview notes, as these notes documented certain case-related information that Dr Cheok could not have known without asking the accused (for example, the fact that Yati had met Hanifa on Facebook).
- [85]
[85] Dr Cheok further denied having had the accused’s investigative statements during the interviews. He produced in court the only summary of facts he had been provided with by the police prior to interviewing the accused. This was a very brief document which mentioned five things: the discovery of Yati’s corpse in the Room; Yati’s and the accused’s brief personal particulars; the existence of a “romantic relationship” between them; the certified cause of Yati’s death; and the fact that the accused had been charged for the offence of murder. I accepted Dr Cheok’s evidence. If the police had in fact provided him with the accused’s investigative statements, it made no sense for them to give him concurrently the brief summary of facts: such a document would have been superfluous if Dr Cheok already had the investigative statements in hand. In any event, if Dr Cheok really had been given the investigative statements by the police prior to his interviews with the accused, I did not see (and the Defence was unable to suggest) any reason why he should have felt it necessary to lie about it.
- [86]
[86] For the reasons set out in [81]–[85], I rejected the Defence’s submission that it was unsafe to rely on Dr Cheok’s interview notes.
- [87]
[87] Dr Cheok’s interview notes were relevant because, inter alia, they established that the accused had narrated to Dr Cheok a version of events largely similar to the version narrated in his investigative statements. In particular, the accused had told Dr Cheok about his “plan” to bring Yati to the Hotel and to kill her if she refused to remain in the relationship with him until he returned to Bangladesh. As with the accused’s investigative statements, therefore, Dr Cheok’s interview notes supported the Prosecution’s contention that the accused’s killing of Yati was carried out in accordance with a premeditated plan.
- [88]
[88] Dr Cheok’s interview notes were also relevant to the determination of another important issue: namely, whether Yati had in fact spoken the Humiliating Words to the accused in the Room on 30 December 2018. I next address this issue.
Whether the alleged Humiliating Words were in fact spoken by Yati to the accused in the Room on 30 December 2018
- [89]
[89] As I noted earlier at [51], the accused’s contention that he had killed Yati completely on impulse and not in accordance with any premeditated plan rested on two key factual propositions. The first was that he had never told the police – or Dr Cheok – about a decision or a plan to kill Yati. The second was that Yati had spoken the Humiliating Words to him in the Room on 30 December 2018. I have explained why I rejected the first proposition. I will now explain why I also rejected the second proposition.
- [90]
[90] To recap: in its closing submissions, the Defence identified the following as the Humiliating Words:
- [91]
[91] According to the accused, the Humiliating Words were the trigger for his actions in strangling Yati to death: when he heard her say these words, he “went crazy”, he “lost control”, his “mind [was] blank”, “he had the thought to kill her” – and that was precisely what he did.
- [92]
[92] Given the momentous impact which the Humiliating Words had on the accused, one would have expected him to mention Yati’s utterance of these words to the police and/or to Dr Cheok when he was interviewed by them. Yet, as the accused himself admitted, he said nothing at all about the Humiliating Words to the police and to Dr Cheok. It was not disputed that the first time he brought up Yati’s alleged utterance of the Humiliating Words was at his interview with Dr Ung on 19 May 2020 – some 17 months after the killing of Yati. The accused’s failure to make any mention of the Humiliating Words to the police and/or to Dr Cheok in the weeks following the killing struck me as being highly anomalous, and ultimately, fatal to his credibility, particularly since he was unable to provide any coherent explanation for the omissions.
- [93]
[93] In so far as his statements to the police were concerned, the accused came up with a few different answers when asked why he had not mentioned the Humiliating Words in any of these statements. In respect of his cautioned statement, the accused claimed that the recording officer (ASP Lee Tien Huat Chris, “ASP Lee”) had told him that he was “stupid” to have killed “the girl” (ie, Yati), and that now his “life go away”. The accused thought that in saying this, ASP Lee “was feeling bad for [him] because [he] was going to die”; and that since he was “going to die”, he would not mention the Humiliating Words in giving his cautioned statement. Secondly, he thought that ASP Lee “might get annoyed, angry” if he mentioned “all these things”, so he decided to “be precise” and “say whatever [he] wanted to say” in “a shortcut way”.
- [94]
[94] I found the accused’s explanations vis-à-vis his cautioned statement glib and lacking in credibility. The accused himself had described ASP Lee as having spoken to him in a “very kind” and “nice” manner during the statement-recording. It seemed to me quite unbelievable that the “kind” and “nice” ASP Lee should have taken it upon himself to admonish and alarm the accused by telling him that he was “stupid” and that his life would “go away”. Furthermore, there was simply no reason for ASP Lee to admonish and alarm the accused in this manner: he had no connection with the case other than having been requested to record the cautioned statement from the accused, and he was not aware of the details of the case – not even that a rope had been used. Defence counsel himself put it to ASP Lee that it was not his job to elicit more details from the accused during the recording of the cautioned statement: his job was just to record whatever the accused said to him. In the circumstances, it would have made no sense for ASP Lee to make any comments to the accused about his actions.
- [95]
[95] In any event, even assuming that ASP Lee had somehow taken it upon himself to tell the accused that he was “stupid” and that his life would “go away”, there was no logical connection between these comments and the accused’s alleged decision to refrain from mentioning the Humiliating Words in his cautioned statement. When the accused was asked to explain what one had to do with the other, he could not provide any explanation and ended up merely repeating, “I was going to die”. I should add that it did not appear to me the accused meant by this statement that he had fatalistically decided it was futile to say anything of importance in his cautioned statement. Indeed, despite having allegedly concluded that he “was going to die”, he had still found it necessary to state in his cautioned statement that he had proof of Yati having had “another relationship with another guy”, that he had “spent a lot of money on her” and that she had “cheated” on him.
- [96]
[96] As for the accused’s claims about having been afraid to anger ASP Lee by saying too much, this appeared to me to be just as unbelievable as his claim about ASP Lee calling him “stupid”. As noted above, Defence counsel had put it to ASP Lee that his job was simply to record whatever the accused said: it was not put to ASP Lee that he had tried to cut the accused off in the course of his narrative. Not was it put to ASP Lee that he had given the accused the impression he was required to give his cautioned statement in a “shortcut way”. There was no reason, therefore, why the accused should have felt apprehensive about mentioning details such as the Humiliating Words. Indeed the contents of the accused’s cautioned statement disproved his allegations about having been afraid to say too much. As noted above, the accused had sought to explain the killing of Yati by saying that he had done it “out of anger, because [he had] proof that she ha[d] another relationship with another guy” and she had “cheated” on him after he had “spent a lot of money on her”. He had also given details of how he strangled Yati first with a towel and then with a rope. It did not appear to me that he felt in any way constrained in what he could say or how much he could say.
- [97]
[97] For the reasons set out in [94]–[96], I rejected the accused’s explanations for why he omitted to mention the Humiliating Words in his cautioned statement.
- [98]
[98] In respect of his investigative statements, the accused said he had two reasons why he did not mention the Humiliating Words to ASP Teo. First, he claimed that he did not mention the Humiliating Words to ASP Teo “because she was a lady” (to which he subsequently added, “[s]he looked like my girlfriend”); and he felt that it would not be nice to say such things to a lady. Second, the accused claimed that he did not mention the Humiliating Words because he “was going to die”: according to him, although he had thought at one point of telling ASP Teo about the Humiliating Words when she asked him why he had killed Yati, he decided against it because –
- [99]
[99] As with his reasons for not telling ASP Lee about the Humiliating Words, the accused’s stated reasons for not mentioning those words to ASP Teo also rang false. First, I found it unbelievable that he was so fearful of offending a “lady” like ASP Teo that he could not bring himself to repeat the words. After all, in recounting to ASP Teo the events of 30 December 2018, he had already told her about having sex with Yati twice in the Room, about their remaining naked in the Room even as they continued to quarrel over Yati’s relationship with Hanifa, and about Yati telling him after sex that “she was a prostitute” and asking him “how much [he] could pay her”. Given that he had felt able to mention all these things to ASP Teo without worrying about her taking offence, it was highly improbable that he would have suddenly developed concerns about her getting offended at hearing the Humiliating Words.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.