General Division of the High Court · Decided 6 April 2021
Ong Chai Koon and others v Ong Chai Soon
Feedback & support[2021] SGHC 76 · Case no. Suit No 1310 of 2018
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] This is a family dispute among the parties – six siblings of the Ong family – over whether they share a common intention that a Housing and Development Board (“HDB”) two-storey shophouse located in Hougang purchased more than 25 years ago is to be their “retirement fund”, in that the shophouse should be sold and they all have a right to share equally in the sale proceeds. This HDB shophouse is registered in the sole name of the defendant, who is also the oldest son (though not the oldest child) of the family. The facts of the case are not that complicated. The dispute on the facts essentially boils down to whether the parties’ conduct is consistent with the alleged common intention. On account of the dearth of available documentary evidence owing to the passage of time, the inquiry will have to focus on a careful scrutiny of the oral evidence of the siblings to assess their credibility.
- [2]
[2] Legally, the case is less straightforward, and many of the nuances of the legal issues seem to have escaped the attention of the parties’ counsel. The plaintiffs run three alternative claims to support their case: common intention constructive trust, resulting trust, and proprietary estoppel. The analysis is complicated by s 51(10) of the Housing and Development Act (Cap 129, 2004 Rev Ed) (“HDA”), which provides that no person shall “become entitled” to HDB property (or any interest therein) under any resulting or constructive trust. The question thus arises as to whether s 51(10) prevents the plaintiffs from “becom[ing] entitled” to the shophouse under a constructive or resulting trust.
Facts
The parties
- [3]
[3] The plaintiffs and the defendant in this case are siblings of the Ong family. Mr Ong Chen Kiat and Mdm Ang Mong Kwa had six children, four daughters and two sons, who are the parties in this action (collectively, the “Ong siblings”), as follows. The defendant is the oldest son of the family.
Background to the dispute
- [4]
[4] The six siblings grew up in the family home in a kampong at Lorong Gemilap which is located in Yio Chu Kang. This was one of the last surviving kampongs in Singapore, until the kampong land was compulsorily acquired in the late 1980s. While they were living in the kampong, their father carried out several trades on their land: first, pig farming, and then later, poultry slaughtering. He also planted fruit trees throughout the kampong and sold the fruits.
- [5]
[5] The plaintiffs and defendant attended school but also helped in the father’s poultry slaughtering business. Most of them dropped out of school at a young age, with KG being the only one managing to qualify to take the exams at secondary four level. She went on to attend a vocational institute where she learnt hairdressing. She then worked as a hairdresser at a beauty salon in Ang Mo Kio.
- [6]
[6] After dropping out of school, the other plaintiffs also worked. When their father switched from pig farming to poultry slaughtering, the land where the pig sty once stood was converted to a space where SK carried out a hairdressing business of her own, which was named after her, called Sor Kim Unisex Hairdressing & Beauty Salon. SA worked as a live-in domestic helper outside of the kampong, while SM worked as a seamstress. CK was an apprentice to a carpenter before he entered national service. After that, he worked in a furniture upholstery business where he made cushions, while at the same time helping in the father’s poultry slaughtering business.
- [7]
[7] The defendant was the only one who did not pick up a trade of his own but continued to help the father in the poultry slaughtering business. Their uncle was also involved in the business, for which he was paid by the elder Mr Ong. It is disputed whether CK and the defendant were also paid by their father for helping out in the business, with the defendant insisting that he was, but CK denying that the two sons were ever paid.
- [8]
[8] The plaintiffs all gave evidence that they would hand over their earnings to their mother, who would manage the finances of the Ong family from a communal family fund. The defendant, on the other hand, claims that he kept whatever he was paid by his father for helping in the poultry slaughtering business.
- [9]
[9] In 1988, the kampong land was compulsorily acquired by the Government. A significant sum was paid in compensation, which was kept and managed by the mother. It is not disputed that the father did not handle the finances of the family because he was a gambler. Parties were in dispute as to the size of the compensation payment. The defendant’s counsel put to the plaintiffs that it was only S$100,000, but the defendant testified that it was “about” S$110,000. The plaintiffs’ figures ranged from S$100,000 to S$176,000 (the plaintiffs pleaded that it was “over S$100,000.00”, which was also SK’s testimony; KG attested that it was S$150,000 but also testified that it was S$176,000; CK testified that it was S$150,000).
- [10]
[10] However, it is not in dispute that the Ong family was offered the chance to buy two adjoining three-room HDB flats in Yishun to assist in their resettlement, and for which approximately S$60,000 of the compensation moneys was used to pay for one flat (“Unit 172”) and the other flat (“Unit 174”) was completely financed by a loan from the HDB. Unit 172 was registered in the joint names of the parents, while Unit 174 was registered in the joint names of CK and the defendant. The housing loan for Unit 174 was paid over the years, but it is common ground that the defendant did not make any financial contributions to the payment of the loan.
- [11]
[11] In February 1989, a tender for a two-storey HDB shophouse at Block 698 Hougang Street 61 #01-06 (“the Hougang shophouse”) was made in the name of the defendant. That tender was successful and a tenancy agreement dated 31 March 1989 between the HDB and the defendant was executed. Parties are in dispute as to the circumstances leading to the tender for the tenancy of the Hougang shophouse and who made the initial payments for that tenancy, but that will be dealt with later in this judgment.
- [12]
[12] The Hougang shophouse had a commercial space on the ground floor and a residential unit on the second floor. While it contains a residential unit, HDB shophouses are commercial properties, so the eligibility criteria set by HDB for their ownership is different (and less stringent) than HDB flats. I will come back to this point on whether the plaintiffs are eligible to own the Hougang shophouse later. The evidence before me is that the commercial space on the first floor was sub-divided into four separate spaces and let to various sub-tenants. One of those spaces was occupied by a hairdressing salon known as “Red Point Hair Beauty and Trading” (“Red Point”), which was a sole proprietorship registered in the name of the defendant. Again, the circumstances under which Red Point started and how it was managed and run are matters of dispute. However, it is not disputed that SK, SM and KG worked at Red Point from its inception until 2018, when this dispute started between the plaintiffs and the defendant.
- [13]
[13] The HDB offered the Hougang shophouse for sale to the existing tenant, the defendant, in 1995. The offer was taken up, and the purchase price was S$782,000, which was completely financed by a loan from Hong Leong Finance. The defendant was registered as the owner of the Hougang shophouse, and he remains the sole registered owner up to this day.
- [14]
[14] As for the two Yishun flats, they went through changes in the registered owners. In 1994, the elder Mr Ong passed away from an illness and the mother became the sole owner of Unit 172. SM was added as a joint owner of that flat the following year. She became the sole registered owner of Unit 172, when their mother passed away in 2016.
- [15]
[15] In 1999, CK got married and wanted to apply for an HDB flat of his own. To do this, his name was withdrawn as a registered co-owner of Unit 174, and he was replaced by SK. To date, the defendant and SK are the registered joint owners of Unit 174.
- [16]
[16] With the exception of KG, who got married in 1989, most of the Ong family resided in the two Yishun flats after they moved out of the kampong. In the mid-1990s, SA moved out and got a resale flat of her own. CK moved out not long after he got married in 1999. While the defendant maintained a room at Unit 174, he usually stayed at a room on the second floor of the Hougang shophouse.
- [17]
[17] SK and SM, who were unmarried, stayed with their mother at Unit 172. But sometime after the passing of the elder Mr Ong, the three of them moved to live at the second floor of the Hougang shophouse in 2003. The Yishun flats were then rented out and the rental proceeds were used to pay for the Ong family expenses.
- [18]
[18] For the last nine years of her life, their mother became ill, was bedridden and needed medical care. A domestic helper was employed to help care for her and also to handle the household chores. She passed away in 2016, while living at the Hougang shophouse. SK and SM continued to live there until they were forced to move out by the defendant in 2018. They then moved back to Unit 174 and presently reside there. Only Unit 172 is rented out now.
- [19]
[19] The unchallenged evidence before me is that the relationship between the defendant and his siblings had always been quite strained. For some of his siblings, such as SM and CK, their relationship was barely cordial. After their mother’s death in 2016, the defendant started acting in a way which caused the plaintiffs to believe that he would attempt to claim beneficial ownership over the Hougang shophouse. In their view, this was wrong because the property was beneficially owned by all six siblings in equal shares, as it was always the intention of all the members of the Ong family that it would be their “retirement fund” and it was in any event paid for with funds which were family moneys.
- [20]
[20] The differences between them eventually led to a family meeting on 25 June 2017 held at the Hougang shophouse. There is an audio recording of the meeting, which lasted more than two and a half hours. For most of the meeting, things were fractious, and there was plenty of shouting and arguing. Many longstanding family issues were raised. Towards the end of the meeting, the defendant signed a document in English where he acknowledged that the Hougang shophouse and Unit 174 were to be shared equally between all the Ong siblings.
- [22]
[22] The plaintiffs then commenced these proceedings against the defendant on 27 December 2018.
The parties’ cases
The plaintiffs’ case
- [23]
[23] The plaintiffs’ primary claim is that the Hougang shophouse is the subject matter of a common intention constructive trust, under which the defendant, as trustee, holds the property on trust for each of the Ong siblings who are entitled to equal beneficial shares. The other facet of this common intention is that the Hougang shophouse represented a family asset or “retirement fund”, and it would be sold when the siblings got older and the sale proceeds shared equally amongst them. It is contended that the common intention for this trust arrangement is evidenced by the circumstances under which the tenancy for the property was first entered into and later how the property was purchased. The siblings’ conduct throughout the years also demonstrate that all of them knew of and shared this common intention. The plaintiffs also rely on the terms of the document signed by the defendant at the family meeting on 25 June 2017 (“the family meeting document”) as evidence of his acceptance and acknowledgment of the common intention constructive trust over the Hougang shophouse and the proceeds when it is eventually sold.
- [24]
[24] The plaintiffs also submit that the Red Point business, while registered as a sole proprietorship in the name of the defendant, was in truth a “family” business, where all the earnings were used for the expenses of the Ong family, including the payments towards the reduction of the loan on the Hougang shophouse. Put another way, it is argued that the Red Point business’s beneficial owners are all six siblings.
- [25]
[25] The plaintiffs also contend that the Hougang shophouse was paid for through a combination of the following funds: the rent generated by the sub-tenancies of the commercial spaces on the first floor of the Hougang shophouse; the earnings from Red Point; and the personal funds of their mother and of KG. Thus, it is argued that, in the alternative, the defendant holds the Hougang shophouse subject to a resulting trust for the benefit of the Ong siblings in equal shares. This is because all these sources of funds are trust moneys to which all the Ong siblings are entitled in equal shares. This in turn stems from the fact that their mother had pooled the family’s assets and funds, including the two Yishun flats, to be used for the benefit of all her children.
- [26]
[26] Further and alternatively, the plaintiffs also argue that the doctrine of proprietary estoppel precludes the defendant from denying that he holds the Hougang shophouse for the benefit of all the Ong siblings in equal shares. In this regard, the plaintiffs rely on various instances of the defendant’s conduct over the years and contend that this amounted to representations to the plaintiffs that they own an interest in the Hougang shophouse. The plaintiffs submit that this conduct includes the defendant’s acquiescence of SK, SM, CK, and their mother using the Hougang shophouse without having to seek his permission or compensate him; his acquiescence in letting KG receive the lion dance couplet at the opening ceremony for Red Point; and his non-collection of Red Point’s profits. The plaintiffs relied on this representation, for instance, by – in SK, SM, and KG’s case – accepting meagre salaries at Red Point and – in CK’s case – by working for free on the fitting-out of and repairs to the shophouse.
- [27]
[27] Arising from these claims in common intention constructive trust, resulting trust and proprietary estoppel, the plaintiffs seek various remedies, which I shall outline and address at [177] to [191] below.
- [28]
[28] Finally, for completeness, I should add that the plaintiffs had pleaded the existence of an express trust over the Hougang shophouse, viz, that Mdm Ang created an express trust over any sale proceeds of the Hougang shophouse such that the defendant was to hold such proceeds, when realised, for the benefit of the plaintiffs. This claim was maintained at trial, but eventually abandoned in the plaintiffs’ closing submissions because they accept “that the evidence does not support the existence of [such an express trust]”.
The defendant’s case
- [29]
[29] The defendant’s case is a straightforward one. He denies that he holds the Hougang shophouse on trust for anyone. He claims to own the property beneficially in its entirety. He denies that there was any common intention, whether express or inferred, for the property to be held on trust for all the Ong siblings when he first tendered for the tenancy for the property and later when he purchased the property outright.
- [30]
[30] The defendant submits that he left it entirely to KG to manage the Hougang shophouse, the sub-tenants and the Red Point business because she was the most qualified of all the Ong siblings. He claims that the rental paid by the sub-tenants would have been sufficient to pay for the mortgage loan instalments for the Hougang shophouse and he expected KG to have used that rent to make the payments. Even if KG had used the earnings from the Red Point business for herself, it would make no difference because he owned the business entirely as the sole proprietor. In this regard, the defendant argues that SK, SM and KG were his employees and he had set up this hairdressing business for them to make a living by working for him. He thus denies that any resulting trust arose over the Hougang shophouse through the payments towards its purchase price.
- [31]
[31] As for any payments towards the purchase price that allegedly came from the jointly held funds of their mother and KG, the defendant claims that KG should not have utilised those funds to make payments of the mortgage loan instalments given what he believed was the sufficiency of the sub-tenancy rental from the Hougang shophouse to make the payments.
- [32]
[32] I should add that, although the plaintiffs did not specifically plead a case based on resulting trust, the defendant had not, whether in his opening statement or the closing submissions, raised any objection to this deficiency in the pleadings. Instead, the defendant has attempted instead to deal with the arguments on resulting trust on its merits. This is perhaps because the evidence as to the acquisition of the Hougang shophouse and the payments towards its eventual acquisition were all extensively raised and explored in the evidence, and are, in any event, relied upon by both sides on the issue of whether there is a common intention constructive trust over the shophouse.
- [33]
[33] The defendant argues that, in relation to the plaintiffs’ claim on express trust, that is a claim that should be brought by the personal representatives of their mother’s estate, because the mother would be the settlor of the trust. In this regard, the mother’s estate remains unadministered, with none of the siblings having applied for letters of administration to act as the estate’s personal representatives. Thus, the plaintiffs have no locus standi. However, since the plaintiffs are no longer pursuing their claim on the express trust, it is unnecessary for me to deal with this issue.
- [34]
[34] The defendant also pleaded that s 51 of the HDA “provides that no trust shall be created on HDB property without the prior written approval of HDB and any trust which purports to be created shall be void”. However, as I explain further at [140] below, the defendant’s argument on s 51 has morphed significantly from the time of the pleadings until now.
- [35]
[35] As for the family meeting document, the defendant insists that he signed the document under duress because there were threats of physical harm to his person when he was at the meeting. He also relies on the doctrine of non est factum because he claims that he was not told by his siblings that the family meeting document would touch upon the ownership of the Hougang shophouse. Further, the defendant argues that, if the family meeting document amounts to a contract, under which he agreed to share ownership of the Hougang shophouse with his siblings, such a contract is not enforceable because no consideration has been furnished by his siblings.
- [36]
[36] As for the claim in proprietary estoppel, the defendant flatly denies that he had made any representations to the plaintiffs, whether written, verbal or by conduct, that suggested that all the Ong siblings had an equal beneficial interest in the property.
Issues to be determined
- [38]
[38] First, is the Hougang shophouse subject to a common intention constructive trust, under which the defendant holds the beneficial interest in the property on behalf of himself and his siblings, all in equal shares? The determination of this issue requires, as I will explain below, a careful examination of the evidence as to whether a common intention, either express or inferred, existed at the time when the property was acquired that it would be shared among the Ong siblings.
- [39]
[39] Second, in any event, does the defendant hold the Hougang shophouse subject to a resulting trust where the true beneficiaries are himself and his siblings, all in equal shares? To answer this question, as will be obvious, one primarily needs to examine the sources of funds used to pay for the acquisition of this property and whether those sources of funds are the defendant’s moneys and, if not, who owned those moneys.
- [40]
[40] Third, if the Hougang shophouse is subject to a trust, does s 51 of the HDA prevent the trust from arising or having effect and, if so, what are the implications and remedies available to the plaintiffs, if any at all?
- [41]
[41] Fourth, if the Hougang shophouse is not subject to a common intention constructive trust or a resulting trust in favour of all the Ong siblings, can the plaintiffs avail themselves of the doctrine of proprietary estoppel to assert a claim to an equitable interest in the property?
- [42]
[42] In my view, as would be patently clear, the first two of the essential issues listed above actually devolve into a determination of one central question, ie, who beneficially owns the Hougang shophouse in equity? From my analysis of the relevant legal principles (as I set out at [43] to [45] below), the determination of this question requires the Court to take into account the intentions of the parties and their parents, whether these intentions were shared by all the relevant parties, the parties’ conduct, and the payments towards the purchase price of the property. In other words, the entire factual context must be scrutinised. To illustrate, the payments towards the mortgage instalments for the Hougang shophouse, according to the plaintiffs, came not only from the rental generated by the sub-tenants of the property but also the Red Point business, amongst other sources. This in turn requires the Court to delve into the issue of whether the Red Point business was indeed beneficially owned by the Ong siblings as alleged. Otherwise, one would not be able to conclude whether any payments from Red Point’s earnings to reduce the mortgage loan would be considered as a financial contribution by the defendant to the acquisition of the Hougang shophouse. As the issues of whether there exists a common intention constructive trust over the Hougang shophouse or whether the property is held by the defendant on resulting trust for all the Ong siblings are so intimately intertwined, I will deal with the issues together in an overarching analysis of who the beneficial owner or owners of the Hougang shophouse are.
Is there a trust over the Hougang shophouse?
The legal framework
- [43]
[43] Parties are not in dispute as to the law and rely mainly on the same authorities. The legal principles that are applicable when the Court has the task of determining the beneficial ownership of property, when various parties have contributed to the purchase price and where there has been no declaration of trust, were explored and summarised in the Court of Appeal’s decision in Chan Yuen Lan v See Fong Mun [2014] 3 SLR 1048 (“Chan Yuen Lan”) at [160]:
- [44]
[44] The starting point, thus, is for the Court to examine whether there is sufficient evidence of the financial contributions to the purchase price of the Hougang shophouse – what were the sources of funds for the payment of the purchase price and how much was paid? That, as per the Court of Appeal in Chan Yuen Lan, will lead to the presumption that the beneficial interest in the property will be held in proportion to the parties’ respective contributions to the purchase price, which is an application of the presumption of resulting trust.
- [45]
[45] However, in this suit, the plaintiffs’ claim in resulting trust is not their primary case. Indeed, as I pointed out earlier (see [32] above), it is not even pleaded by the plaintiffs, although the defendant has raised no objection in this regard. Furthermore, as noted by the High Court in Ng So Hang v Wong Sang Woo [2018] SGHC 162 at [24]:
- [46]
[46] This was indeed how the plaintiffs structured their arguments in this trial – their primary and foremost case in their closing submissions was based on a common intention constructive trust. As such, I shall consider if a common intention constructive trust exists first. I will begin my analysis of the evidence from around the time when the tender for the tenancy for the Hougang shophouse was submitted and move forward chronologically from that point. Along the way, I will touch upon the evidence as to the mother’s and the siblings’ intentions with respect to the ownership of the property. My findings in that regard will be relevant to the determination of the issue of the common intention constructive trust.
Tender for the tenancy of the Hougang shophouse
- [47]
[47] Due to the long passage of time from when the material events occurred, the evidence of what had happened at this time is based mainly on the oral evidence of the parties. In this regard, the main person who is able to shed the most light on the details in relation to the tender for the tenancy and the later acquisition of the Hougang shophouse was not the defendant, but KG.
- [48]
[48] It is quite clear from all the evidence before me that KG is clearly the most capable and competent of the Ong siblings in terms of being able to manage the finances of the family and handle issues of administration. As already mentioned, of all the Ong siblings, she had achieved the highest standard of academic qualifications, in that she took her “O” Level exams at secondary four and later attended ITE for her hairdressing certificate. I also find that KG has a better command of written and spoken English as compared to her siblings. It is thus no surprise that their mother placed trust and responsibility on KG to help her in managing the finances of the family. She was meticulous and kept records of financial transactions, significant payments and key documents. In fact, it was KG who produced the documentation in relation to the tenancy of the Hougang shophouse, its subsequent acquisition and also the financing of its purchase, and its subsequent refinancing. The defendant, despite being the registered legal owner, did not have in his possession any of these documents.
- [50]
[50] KG’s, SK’s and CK’s evidence is consistent in that they, together with the defendant, discussed and decided to tender for the tenancy of two HDB shophouses – one in Yishun and one in Hougang. The tender for the shophouse in Yishun was in SK’s name, while the other tender was in the name of the defendant. KG was the one who filled up the tender application forms, and she gave evidence that there was no particular reason for having chosen the names of SK and the defendant. After all, it was understood by all of them that the business was going to be a family business. As things turned out, only the tender for the shophouse in Hougang was successful, and a tenancy agreement was then executed with the HDB by the defendant.
- [51]
[51] In contrast, the defendant’s evidence is that his mother never gave any instructions for the tender of an HDB shophouse and he never had any discussions with KG, SK or CK about this. Instead, it was his own decision to do so, after learning from a friend that the HDB put up notices for shophouses available for tender, and after reading from the notices that a tenancy for the Hougang shophouse was up for tender. He then asked KG to help him fill up the tender application form. He denied having any knowledge of any other tender for a shophouse in Yishun.
- [52]
[52] In the absence of any documentary evidence, in assessing the oral evidence of the Ong siblings, I had to consider the inherent probabilities of each side’s version of events against the undisputed facts. It is clear from the evidence that, when they lived at the kampong, the Ong family operated businesses which were treated as family businesses in that the income earned was utilised for the benefit of the family. With the acquisition of the kampong land, the ability of the Ong family to earn a livelihood from their family businesses of poultry slaughtering, planting of fruit trees and hairdressing had been taken away. It is thus entirely logical that the family would have thought about how the children could help start a business to make a living for themselves. It is also sensible that the mother, who was in charge of the moneys paid by the HDB as compensation for the acquisition, would have set aside some portion of those moneys to assist in the setting up of a new family business.
- [53]
[53] I thus found the evidence of SK, KG and CK to be more consistent with the circumstances as they stood at that time. I was not helped, in general, by the poor quality of the evidence given by the defendant. In particular, and in this regard, he never explained why he would tender for a tenancy of an HDB shophouse to run a hairdressing business. The undisputed evidence is that he knew nothing about hairdressing. He gave no evidence that he had discussed with his sisters about them coming to work for him in a hairdressing business that he was planning to set up. Not only that, the evidence before me, which was not challenged by the defendant, is that he got on quite poorly with his siblings, in particular, SM. This is relevant because it makes it quite improbable then that he would have asked SM and that she would have agreed to work for him.
- [54]
[54] Significantly, the defendant also did not state in his affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”) that he asked for KG’s assistance to complete the tender application form. That evidence only came out belatedly in his oral evidence, in what I find to be a rather feeble attempt to explain away the fact that it is KG’s handwriting which appears on the tender application form and it was KG who was able to produce that document in these proceedings and not the defendant. This added to the general poor quality of the defendant’s evidence.
- [55]
[55] I come now to the evidence as to the payments for the tender and the initial rental for the Hougang shophouse.
- [56]
[56] KG’s evidence is that the government had paid the total sum of between S$150,000 to S$176,000 as compensation for the acquisition of their land in the kampong and for the loss of their farming licence (see [9] above). She was candid in admitting that she did not know precisely how much was received because it was their mother who handled the finances for the family at that time and it was their mother who had custody of the compensation moneys. She had heard about these figures from her mother. She also agreed with the defendant’s counsel’s suggestion that some portion of the compensation moneys had to be repaid to the authorities because the elder Mr Ong had overstated the number of fruit trees that the family had cultivated. She estimated the repayment to be in the region of S$4,000 to S$5,000, which is based on what her father had told them.
- [58]
[58] KG’s evidence is that the Red Point business was started with funds which came from their mother, which probably came from the balance of the compensation moneys. Moneys were needed to renovate and fit out the commercial space at the Hougang property from which Red Point was to operate, and also to purchase the necessary equipment for hairdressing. Funds were also needed for the initial payments of rent and conservancy charges to HDB and the stamp fees, and for the deposit of three months’ rental with Far Eastern Bank so that it would issue a guarantee to the HDB as security, which was a requirement of the tenancy. All these funds were provided by their mother.
- [60]
[60] I find that the defendant’s evidence on this factual dispute suffers from a number of problems. Despite his claim that he furnished the sums required for the tenancy of the Hougang shophouse to be granted to him, he was not able to give accurate details as to the tenancy in a number of significant respects.
- [62]
[62] Second, the defendant was not able to even accurately state the rental charged by the HDB for the tenancy. In his oral evidence, he claimed it was S$3,500, which is the accurate figure, but in his AEIC, he referred to a figure of S$3,200.
- [64]
[64] Fourth, in his oral evidence, the defendant also claimed that he leased the Hougang shophouse for about ten years before HDB offered to sell the property to him. Again, this is way off the mark because the property was offered by the HDB for sale to the defendant in 1995, after six years from the start of the tenancy.
- [65]
[65] Fifth, the defendant was not able to furnish any evidence that he had savings of S$15,000 or so in 1989 to be able to start the Red Point business. He was not able to produce any documents at all, eg, in the form of bank statements or pay slips, to show that he had the wherewithal at that time to be able to finance the start up of the business. His evidence that his father paid him for helping in the poultry slaughtering business is contradicted by the evidence of CK, who testified that only their uncle was paid by their father for helping in the business. I find the evidence of CK to be more credible in this regard because it is consistent with the evidence of all the plaintiffs that all the children would hand over their earnings to their mother for her to manage the finances of the family communally.
- [66]
[66] Viewed in its totality, I find the evidence of the defendant in this regard to be rather confusing and unsatisfactory. On the other hand, the plaintiffs gave a coherent and consistent account that the set up of the business and the initial payments for the Hougang shophouse was paid for from their mother’s funds. KG’s evidence is particularly credible because she was able to provide some documentation to show that she was involved in the process of the tender of the tenancy for the Hougang shophouse, and the payments for the issuance of the bank guarantee as security and the initial rental payment to HDB.
- [67]
[67] I should point out that one of the defendant’s main arguments in his closing submissions is that there could not have been enough moneys left over after the expenditure on the purchase of Unit 172 and the renovations to the two Yishun flats for their mother to come up with any other moneys for the tenancy of the Hougang shophouse and the start of Red Point’s business. However, I find that this argument proceeds on the flawed premise that the parents had no savings of their own at all. Even if I were to assume that the elder Mr Ong had frittered away what he earned from the poultry slaughtering business because he was a gambler, it was unchallenged that the mother also did extra jobs at the kampong as a cleaner and washerwoman. KG, who shared a joint account with her mother, gave evidence that her mother had approximately S$40,000 in savings. That being the case, I am not prepared to accept the defendant’s suggestion that his mother had no savings of her own. I thus accept the plaintiffs’ evidence that their mother provided the initial funds for the tenancy of the Hougang shophouse from the HDB and the setting up of the Red Point business.
Purchase of the Hougang property
- [69]
[69] KG testified that she did think, when she was filling up the application form, whether it was necessary to include all the family members as registered owners for the Hougang shophouse, but thought it was probably fine to have the property registered solely in the name of the defendant given that the whole family knew that this was considered a “family property”. The purchase was thus completed with the defendant as the sole registered owner. It was financed by a loan for 100% of the purchase price by Hong Leong Finance, which KG arranged on her own without any involvement of the defendant, save that he was asked to sign the relevant documents in relation to the housing loan and the mortgage.
Payments of the mortgage loan instalments for the Hougang shophouse
- [71]
[71] I now turn to the issue of who paid for the mortgage loan instalments for the Hougang shophouse. I first set out the legal principles on whether mortgage payments may be taken into consideration for the purposes of presuming a resulting trust, which were considered by the Court of Appeal in Su Emmanuel v Emmanuel Priya Ethel Anne and another [2016] 3 SLR 1222 (“Su Emmanuel”) and Lau Siew Kim v Yeo Guan Chye Terence and another [2008] 2 SLR(R) 108 (“Lau Siew Kim”).
- [72]
[72] The resulting trust crystallises at the time the property is acquired. Thus, the extent of the parties’ beneficial interests under a resulting trust must be determined at the time the property is purchased: Lau Siew Kim at [112]–[113] and [117]. To determine the direct contributions to the acquisition of a property when a mortgage is taken out, the crucial consideration is the parties’ intentions, at the time the property was acquired, as to the ultimate source of the funds for the purchase of that property. Actual mortgage payments made at a later time would therefore only count as direct contributions to the purchase price where these were referable to, and in keeping with, a prior agreement between the parties as to who would be liable to repay.
- [73]
[73] Many factors are engaged in the determination of the precise agreement or understanding between the parties as to who would repay the mortgage, and the focus should not lie exclusively on who took on liability for the mortgage as against the bank. In this regard, subsequent conduct may be relevant to the extent that it sheds light on such an agreement (if any) between the co-owners: Su Emmanuel at [87]–[90]. Furthermore, if the objective evidence does not demonstrate that parties reached a clear agreement, a court would not be precluded from determining the parties’ rights based on some common intention or understanding, and the actual loan repayments can be relied on as the manifestation of the parties’ intention as to the extent to which each source of funds was to be used to repay the loan: Tan Yok Koon v Tan Choo Suan and another and other appeals [2017] 1 SLR 654 at [153] and [160].
- [74]
[74] Therefore, I have to assess who the parties agreed, at the time when the mortgage was taken out, would be paying for the mortgage for the Hougang shophouse. Subsequent mortgage instalment payments can only count towards the resulting trust analysis if they are consistent with the parties’ original agreement on who should pay for the mortgage.
- [75]
[75] KG’s account in her evidence is the most helpful in this regard. She gave evidence that the mortgage for the Hougang shophouse was serviced by transfers from her personal UOB bank account, and the monies in this account “mainly” came from income generated by Red Point.
- [76]
[76] In addition, KG also gave evidence that shows that the sub-tenant rental was used to pay for the mortgage payments. She was the sole person in charge of procuring the sub-tenants for the commercial spaces on the first floor of the Hougang shophouse, apart from the space occupied by Red Point. She applied to the HDB for permission to partition the first floor into four commercial spaces, one of which would be retained for use by Red Point. She advertised for sub-tenants. She denied that the defendant played any role in any of these tasks. Also, unlike the defendant, KG was able to identify the sub-tenants that occupied the spaces over the years, the various types of businesses they carried out, and the amount of rental they paid.
- [77]
[77] KG also gave evidence that, right from the start, she was also the one who was in charge of collecting the rent from the sub-tenants. She estimated that the amount of rent collected from the sub-tenants totalled the amount of approximately S$5,300 monthly. This was sufficient to pay for the monthly rental to the HDB at the time when the Hougang shophouse was still leased. I find that the rental collected from the sub-tenants was also generally sufficient to pay the monthly mortgage payments to Hong Leong Finance, which was about S$4,300 per month.
- [78]
[78] I should add that it was KG who produced the receipts for the various mortgage payments in these proceedings, and not the defendant. She was responsible for and made all these payments monthly to Hong Leong Finance. In this regard, she paid the monthly mortgage instalments to Hong Leong Finance from the funds in her personal UOB account. She had regularly deposited cash and other payments due to Red Point into her UOB account. KG also often deposited the amounts she collected from the sub-tenants as rental into her UOB account. That being the case, I can only infer that the sub-tenants must have either often paid in cash or, if by cheque, KG must have told them to make the cheque out to her personal name.
- [79]
[79] KG explained in her evidence that she had this arrangement of making such deposits into her UOB account solely out of convenience because Red Point kept an account with OCBC, but UOB had a branch that was closer to where she lived. Hence, it was more convenient for her to travel to the UOB branch to do her deposits. The payments of the mortgage instalments directly from the funds in KG’s UOB account carried on until 2011.
- [80]
[80] KG approached OCBC in 2010 to seek a refinancing of the housing loan for the Hougang shophouse. It was her personal decision to do so after learning from friends that OCBC provided better interest rates on housing loans. She got the defendant to sign the necessary documents for the refinancing by OCBC to take place. The arrangement where she would make payments of the mortgage loan instalments, now to OCBC, directly from funds in her personal UOB account carried on.
- [81]
[81] In 2012, she arranged for the defendant to open an account with OCBC. She would then regularly transfer moneys from her personal UOB account to the defendant’s OCBC account, and the monthly instalments would be deducted by OCBC from that latter account to service the mortgage instalments. Throughout all this time, KG continued to deposit the cash takings of the Red Point business and the sub-tenant rental for the Hougang shophouse into her personal UOB account. It is a matter of common sense that not all the takings of Red Point nor all the sub-tenant rental received would have been paid into her personal UOB account because some portion would have been kept as cash for the day to day functioning of the Red Point business. I infer that some portion would have also been paid into Red Point’s account with OCBC.
- [83]
[83] It is significant that KG’s evidence as to how she procured the refinancing of the loan and how she arranged for the payments of the monthly mortgage instalments was not seriously challenged in cross-examination. The defendant’s main focus in his case on the issue of payments of the mortgage instalments is that the sub-tenant rental was sufficient to pay for the mortgage payments to Hong Leong Finance and later OCBC. Since he claims to be the sole owner of the Hougang shophouse, these were funds that were entirely his. As such, the defendant submits that this is a situation where the Court should find that he made all the payments for the purchase of the Hougang shophouse.
- [84]
[84] None of the parties gave any evidence as to the arrangements for the payment of the mortgage instalments at the time the Hong Leong Finance mortgage was taken out, and also later when it was replaced by the OCBC mortgage. To my mind, there was no explicit discussion on this issue because it was understood that the earnings of Red Point and the sub-tenancy rental income would be sources of funds for the payment of the mortgage instalments. The defendant must have known that, and hence he left it to KG to handle matters and took no interest in how payments were effected and where precisely each payment came from. I find that this arrangement between the defendant and KG was arrived at when the Hong Leong Finance mortgage was created, and subsequently it was expected to continue when KG refinanced the loan with OCBC and the latter’s mortgage was created. The payments that were made by KG were consistent with this arrangement.
- [85]
[85] Further, from my analysis above, I find that there is sufficient evidence as to how the Hougang shophouse was paid for. It was paid from a mixed fund, which comprised mostly the sub-tenant rental and Red Point’s takings, although it appears not possible on the evidence before me to say what proportion of the payments came from which source of funds. Even if the Court is to proceed on the assumption that the mortgage payments could and should have been paid for entirely by the sub-tenant rental, but for the conduct of KG in mixing the sub-tenant rental with earnings from Red Point, the issue of the legal entitlement to that sub-tenant rental remains unresolved. It ultimately depends on whether there was a common intention, express or inferred, at the time the Hougang shophouse was acquired, that the property would be owned equally by the Ong siblings and thus that the defendant would only hold the property as a trustee. I turn now to that issue.
Was there a common intention that the Hougang property would be owned by the Ong siblings?
- [86]
[86] To determine if there is sufficient evidence of an express or an inferred common intention that the parties should hold the beneficial interest in the property in a different proportion from their respective financial contributions to the property’s purchase price, the evidence must be sufficient and compelling: Su Emmanuel at [83].
- [87]
[87] In my judgment, what is clear from a holistic examination of the evidence before me is that the Ong family treated the compensation moneys paid for the acquisition of their kampong land as a communal or family fund to pay for the expenses of the Ong family and to set up businesses for the benefit of the family. Consequently, I find that, on a balance of probabilities, the Ong siblings always shared a common intention that they shall have equal beneficial shares in the Hougang shophouse and, more importantly, its sale proceeds. I will set out what I consider to be the key considerations which have led me to this conclusion.
- [88]
[88] First, the evidence shows quite clearly that the Ong family treated the two Yishun flats as assets that would ultimately be shared by all the Ong siblings. This is relevant because the two flats were acquired mainly from the proceeds of the compensation given by the authorities, and it appears to me that the parties treated those Yishun flats not much differently from the Hougang shophouse.
- [89]
[89] For Unit 172, the purchase price of approximately S$60,000 was paid outright entirely from the compensation moneys. It was initially in the names of the two parents, but after the father passed away in 1994, SM was added as a registered co-owner with the mother. When their mother passed away in 2016, SM became the sole registered owner (see [14] above). That flat is now rented out and the rental collected by SM is paid into an account held by KG, which holds the Ong “family funds”. There is no dispute between the Ong siblings that Unit 172 is beneficially owned by them in equal shares.
- [90]
[90] For Unit 174, the flat was registered in the name of the defendant and CK. The purchase price of approximately S$60,000 was 100% financed by a loan from the HDB (see [10] above). As was the case for Unit 172, the renovations for Unit 174 were paid for by their mother. KG gave unchallenged evidence that the monthly loan instalments for the flat was paid for by the mother over time from the compensation moneys received. When CK withdrew as a registered owner in 1999, he was replaced by SK. It is not disputed that SK then paid the sum of S$39,267.15 out of her own funds, which was the balance of the outstanding loan owed to HDB. The defendant does not claim to have paid any moneys towards the acquisition of Unit 174. While the unit is today registered in the names of the defendant and SK, the Ong siblings do not dispute that the property is beneficially owned by all of them in equal shares. Even SK, who I find appears to have paid more than 50% of the purchase price from her own savings, does not dispute that Unit 174 is owned by all the siblings in equal shares.
- [91]
[91] Furthermore, and this is significant, it is evident from the siblings’ testimony that it was always intended that the Hougang shophouse was meant as a shared fund meant for their retirement.
(a) As KG explained in her oral evidence:
(b) As KG and the other sisters said at the family meeting on 25 June 2017:
(c) Soh Wei Ling (“Wei Ling”), KG’s daughter, was also present at the family meeting on 25 June 2017. Wei Ling testified that:
- [92]
[92] From my review of the evidence, it is quite clear that the Ong siblings shared a common intention that the Hougang shophouse was to function as an income generating asset for them. They derived income from the rental collected from the sub-tenants and from the Red Point business that carried on its business from the premises. While it was intended that the plaintiffs should own shares in the Hougang shophouse, it was certainly not envisaged that they would all reside at the premises for the long term, given the abysmal state of the relationship between the defendant and some of his siblings. Instead, the common intention was that, at some stage, when the siblings could no longer work and make a living for themselves, the shophouse would be sold and the sale proceeds distributed equally to each of them as a “nest egg” for their retirement.
- [93]
[93] Second, I accept the evidence of the plaintiffs that Red Point was started by using the funds of their mother and the compensation moneys and that Red Point was intended by their mother to be a family business to be operated for the benefit of all the Ong siblings. KG’s evidence is clear and cogent as to the tender of the tenancy of the Hougang shophouse, setting up of the business, the choice of “Red Point” as a name and their mother’s intentions. On the other hand, the defendant’s claim to be the sole owner of Red Point business was so lacking in credibility and substance that I have no hesitation in rejecting it.
- [94]
[94] As I already noted, the defendant could not, in his affidavit made in October 2019, even name the hairdressing business accurately. This lack of knowledge of even basic facts about the business is consistent with the evidence of KG, SK and SM that he was never involved in the business of Red Point at all. KG was the de facto “boss” of the salon. KG set the salaries for herself and for SK and SM, without having to consult or check with the defendant. She managed all the finances and maintained the accounts. She operated Red Point’s bank account with OCBC. Even though the defendant was named as an account signatory because the business was registered in his name, the undisputed evidence is that he never once attempted to operate Red Point’s bank account, or even examined Red Point’s bank statements.
- [95]
[95] The defendant claims in his evidence that the Red Point business belonged to him and he had set it up for his sisters, KG, SK and SM, to work as his employees. I find this to be inherently improbable given the poor relationship he had with them, particularly with SM. I also find that the defendant’s complete unfamiliarity with the details of the business, for instance, the salaries of his sisters, or whether the business was turning a profit or loss over the years, or who prepared the accounts of the business, makes it highly unlikely that he is the true owner of the business. He claims that he left it to his sisters to pay themselves the market rate for employees in a hairdressing salon. But, when cross-examined as to what those market rates would be, the defendant was at a loss for words. Needless to say, I find it very unlikely that an owner of a hairdressing business would not know what the market rate of salaries paid to hairdressers are.
- [96]
[96] I do not accept the defendant’s evidence that he entrusted the business entirely to KG to run but ultimately remained the “boss”. There is no evidence at all that KG reported to him as to how the business was doing. Rather, this was a case that the business was simply registered in his name and thereafter he took no part at all, save to sign documents when he was asked to do so by KG. What I find most telling is the unchallenged evidence that the defendant would approach KG to ask for cash from time to time. KG would then pass cash to the defendant from the earnings of Red Point. In my judgment, this showed that it was not KG who reported to the defendant as the owner of the business. Rather, it was the defendant approaching KG as the “custodian” of the family funds, to ask for some portion of the family funds to be given to him from time to time.
- [97]
[97] In my view, if the defendant were the true owner of Red Point, he would at the very least have examined the finances and the accounts of the business from time to time. However, it is not disputed that he never did so. Instead, this was the domain of KG, who took care of the finances of Red Point and arranged for the accounts to be prepared every year.
- [98]
[98] KG also gave evidence that the earnings from Red Point was used as part of the Ong family funds to pay for family expenses, such as holidays for the siblings and their families, the medical expenses of their parents, and the funeral expenses of their father. I rejected the defendant’s evidence as being untruthful that he was unaware of the use of Red Point’s earnings for these purposes until during the course of these legal proceedings. He claimed in his oral evidence that, had he known of the use of Red Point’s moneys as a family fund, he would have objected to it. But this assertion is an entirely hollow one because the defendant has taken no steps in these legal proceedings or in any other proceedings to get KG to account for the use of Red Point’s moneys. In my judgment, the defendant has shown through his conduct that he knew the earnings of Red Point was treated as family funds and properly utilised as such.
- [99]
[99] In all the circumstances, I find that there is overwhelming evidence to support the plaintiffs’ contention that the parties’ intention was always that the Red Point business was a family business and the profits generated therefrom belonged to the Ong siblings in equal shares.
- [100]
[100] Third, the conduct of the siblings in relation to the Hougang shophouse is also consistent with there being a common intention that it was to be shared beneficially by all the Ong siblings, and that, at some later stage, the shophouse would be sold and the sale proceeds shared equally by them.
- [101]
[101] KG, SK and SM all worked at Red Point for 28 years taking relatively meagre salaries. To illustrate, KG’s last drawn salary before the business shuttered was S$1,200, SK’s was S$1,000 and SM’s was $600. The gist of their evidence is that this was because they regarded Red Point as a family business and they believed that the earnings of Red Point would be pooled with the family funds and used, amongst other things, to service the mortgage loan on the Hougang shophouse. Put simply, they regarded the property as a family asset for which they owned a part, and they were happy to contribute to its payment.
- [103]
[103] As for CK, he helped in the renovations and fitting out of the space which Red Point would occupy. He did the carpentry work, like he did for the Yishun flats. His evidence is that he was happy to contribute because he regarded Red Point and the Hougang property as family assets.
- [104]
[104] As for the defendant, I have already dealt with the evidence (at [70] above) where, in an earlier affidavit filed in October 2019, he could not even state which year the Hougang shophouse was acquired from HDB or accurately set out the purchase price. He did not have in his possession the relevant documents relating to the purchase of the property or its financing. The evidence before me was also quite clear that he did not know how the mortgage instalments were being paid, or the source of funds of each payment. He could not name the sub-tenants of the first floor of the property, or how much rent they paid. He did not collect the rent from these sub-tenants. He only handled the letting out of a room on the second floor of the property, which was illegally tenanted to an employment agency for a period of time. It is common ground that the defendant lived on a room on the second floor of the property. KG’s evidence is that the defendant wanted to rent out one of the other rooms on the second floor to one of his friends.
- [105]
[105] The defendant had his own businesses apart from the family business at Red Point. In this regard, he claims to be involved in some businesses involving the sale of birds’ nests and honey. The plaintiffs also gave evidence that, at some point, the defendant was an illegal bookie for horse racing and ran into trouble with the law because of that and, as a result, needed some financial help from his siblings. The plaintiffs’ evidence in this regard was not disputed. The point here is that the defendant was never involved at all in the affairs concerning the management of the Hougang shophouse or Red Point, and was busy with his own matters. As already stated, he also did not himself make any direct financial contributions to the payment of the mortgage loan for the Hougang shophouse, although he insisted that any payments from the sub-tenant rental or Red Point’s earnings should be regarded as payments from him.
- [106]
[106] What I found rather remarkable was the fact that the defendant did not even know that CK started operating his audio equipment business from a part of the commercial space used by Red Point from sometime in the mid-1990s. CK’s evidence is that KG agreed to let him use some of the space in Red Point’s premises to carry out his audio equipment business. This arrangement carried on until 2017. CK did not pay any rent. According to CK’s evidence, the defendant’s consent was not sought for this arrangement. This is entirely consistent with the fact that the defendant did not know when CK started operating his business at the Hougang shophouse. In my view, this showed how uninvolved and uninterested the defendant was in the dealings involving the Hougang shophouse over the years, and is consistent with the plaintiffs’ contention that he did not act in any manner which showed that he believed that he was the sole owner of the property.
- [107]
[107] In my judgment, an assessment of the totality of the evidence shows that the plaintiffs’ contention is correct. The defendant’s conduct is entirely consistent with his belief that the Hougang shophouse was part of the pool of family assets. I accept that there is no direct evidence that the Ong siblings and their mother had collectively met to discuss and agree that the Hougang property should be held by the defendant on trust for the Ong siblings at the time when the HDB offered the property for sale to the defendant in 1995. However, in my view, there is sufficient evidence as set out above which shows quite clearly that the acquisition of the Hougang shophouse in 1995 was intended for the Ong family as a whole. It was intended to be a family asset, just like the two Yishun flats and Red Point’s business, for the benefit of the second generation of the Ong siblings. It was intended that, at some later time, the shophouse would be sold and the sale proceeds shared equally so that each of the siblings would have a “retirement fund”. This intention was known to and shared by all the Ong siblings, including the defendant, whose conduct throughout the years was consistent with the fact that he did not own the Hougang shophouse beneficially but that it was owned by the family as a whole.
- [108]
[108] I thus find that the plaintiffs have established their case that the Hougang shophouse and its sale proceeds is subject to a common intention constructive trust where the true beneficial owners are the plaintiffs and the defendant in six equal shares.
- [109]
[109] Finally, for completeness, I note that there were a few instances in 2018 when the defendant attempted to start to assert control over the Hougang Shophouse and Red Point. For example, on 25 January 2018, the defendant entered the Hougang shophouse and asked KG, SK, and SM to pay him rent. That same day, the defendant told KG, SK, and SM to move out of the Hougang shophouse, and even called the police that day when KG, SK, and SM did not move out (and no further action has been taken by the police). The defendant also removed KG as the authorised signatory to Red Point’s bank account in or around January 2018. However, in my judgment, it is the defendant’s conduct over the years that is relevant and probative, and not the conduct after the family meeting on 25 June 2017 and when he had already consulted lawyers. Such post meeting conduct, after the dispute had erupted, would obviously be self-serving and unreliable as indicative of the defendant’s true intentions.
Was there a resulting trust?
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.