Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 15 Jul 2022

General Division of the High Court

Public Prosecutor v Tan En Jie Norvan

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHC 166Case no. Criminal Case No 33 of 2019

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The accused in this case faces four charges for various acts of sexual assault against the complainant that are said to have occurred in the early hours of 26 December 2016 at a flat in Block 941 Hougang Street 92 (“the Flat”), where he then resided. These charges are:

  2. I will refer to each of these charges as the first, second, third and fourth charges respectively.

  3. The Prosecution’s case

  4. [2] The complainant was 19 years of age at the time of the alleged offences. She was close friends with one Tan En Ting Julniee (“Julniee”). The two had known each other since primary school and had also been classmates at a school for vocational instruction. Julniee is the younger sister of the accused, who is two years older than her. At the time of the alleged offences, the accused was 21 years of age. Like the accused, Julniee also resided in the Flat at that time, together with their parents. It is not disputed that the complainant is known to Julniee and Julniee’s family (including the accused) by her first name, “[V]”.

  5. [3] On the night of 25 December 2016, the complainant and Julniee went out drinking to celebrate Christmas. They went to a bar where they met some of Julniee’s friends. The complainant had a few glasses of beer. The complainant and Julniee then went to a club where they met another group of Julniee’s friends where more drinking ensued. The complainant consumed several alcoholic drinks. At around 5.00am the next morning, the complainant and Julniee headed back to the Flat, where the complainant had planned to stay over. By this time, the complainant was feeling quite intoxicated. She indicated to Julniee in the car ride back that she felt like vomiting.

  6. [4] They eventually arrived at the Flat at about 5.42am. When Julniee and the complainant got to the Flat, there were in total five other persons present there. Julniee’s parents were asleep in their room. The accused and two of his friends, Tsang Ching Rui, Ruben (“Ruben”) and Alexander Vicknesh Sneesby (“Alex”), were in the accused’s room. The accused, Ruben and Alex had also gone drinking at a club, and had arrived at the Flat shortly before the complainant and Julniee.

  7. [5] Once the complainant and Julniee arrived at the Flat, the complainant immediately went to the toilet located at the Flat’s service balcony, which is next to the kitchen (“the Toilet”). The complainant went to the Toilet to vomit as she was feeling dizzy and nauseous. She had been to the Flat several times before and was familiar with its layout. When vomiting into the toilet bowl, the complainant was kneeling on the floor in front of it with her arms wrapped around it. Julniee then came into the Toilet and helped the complainant change out of her dress, and into a red t-shirt (“the T-shirt”) and a pair of shorts.

  8. [6] Julniee then left the complainant in the Toilet and went to the accused’s bedroom. There, she asked to speak to Ruben in private. The accused then left the bedroom to allow his sister to speak with Ruben. Alex was asleep on the floor of the bedroom throughout all this time.

  9. The complainant’s evidence

  10. [7] The account of events relied upon by the Prosecution thus far is largely undisputed. I come now to the allegations of sexual assault in this case and the testimony given by the complainant.

  11. [8] Her evidence is that, when she was in the Toilet vomiting, in the same kneeling position as before, she heard a male voice coming from someone standing behind her. She testified that she heard the male voice saying “[V], are you okay?” a few times, but she did not reply as she was still trying to vomit while bent over the toilet bowl. The male person then lifted her up by placing his forearms under her armpits. The complainant testified that, as she was being lifted up, she fell and this caused her body to turn to face the front of the male person. At that point, she opened her eyes briefly and saw this male person wearing a dark blue-coloured shirt, although she did not see his face clearly. The male person then supported her from the service balcony area through the kitchen and headed towards the living room of the Flat. Along the way, the complainant fell twice because her legs felt weak. One fall was somewhere in the middle of the kitchen and the other fall was at the exit of the kitchen leading to the living room. During the second fall, she hit her head against the kitchen door frame. The male person helped her up after the second fall and brought her to the sofa in the living room, where he laid her on her back. The man then gave the complainant a short kiss on her lips. In her words, she felt a “peck” on her lips. The complainant’s eyes were closed when she was kissed, and she was not expecting it. This kiss was done without her consent. This kiss forms the basis of the fourth charge against the accused (see [1] above).

  12. [9] Almost immediately after getting kissed, the complainant felt the urge to vomit again. She got up from the sofa and ran back to the Toilet, where she continued to vomit into the toilet bowl. While doing so, she was kneeling on the floor in front of the toilet bowl with her arms wrapped around the toilet bowl, roughly in the same position which she had been earlier (see [5] above). After vomiting, the complainant remained in the Toilet. She then heard the same male voice from behind her, asking “[V], are you okay?”. Again, she did not respond. The male person then lifted her up with his forearms under her armpits (in the same way as he had done so earlier (see [8] above)) and brought her out of the service balcony area, through the kitchen and the living room, and into Julniee’s room. The complainant recognised that she was being brought into Julniee’s room because of the pink-coloured walls in that room, which she saw when she opened her eyes briefly after being brought to the entrance of the room. On the way from the Toilet to Julniee’s bedroom, the complainant had also opened her eyes briefly to see where she was being brought, and she saw that she had passed by the accused’s room, where the room door was shut. The complainant testified that she had wanted to remain in the Toilet to vomit but she did not think of telling him that and also did not have the strength to resist or say anything to the male person at the time when she was brought out of the Toilet.

  13. [10] The male person laid the complainant on Julniee’s bed. The complainant then opened her eyes and saw that the lights of Julniee’s room were switched on and that she was alone in Julniee’s room. She then closed her eyes again. Shortly after, she felt a hand underneath the T-shirt that she was wearing, touching the base of her breasts her briefly. She then felt the hand being removed and being placed under the shorts and panties that she was wearing, and two fingers being inserted into her vagina briefly. Both the touching of her breast and the digital penetration happened suddenly while the complainant’s eyes were closed, and each time it prompted her to open her eyes for a brief moment. The complainant testified that she knew it was the same person who inappropriately touched her on both instances because, after the person (who had touched the base of her breasts) removed his hand from under the T-shirt, the hand was immediately placed under her shorts and panties. The complainant also testified that, when she opened her eyes briefly upon feeling this person inserting two fingers into her vagina, she saw this person wearing the same dark blue-coloured shirt that had been worn by the male person who approached her in the Toilet on the first occasion (see also [8] above). On both occasions when she was inappropriately touched, she did not have the strength to physically resist what the male person was doing, or to say anything to him. She did not consent to the touching of her breast or the digital penetration. These acts form the basis of the second and third charges (see [1] above).

  14. [11] When the complainant opened her eyes again, she found that she was alone in Julniee’s room. She again felt the urge to vomit, and managed to get up and make her way back to the Toilet. There, she continued to vomit. She then heard the same male voice again, asking her, “[V], are you okay?”, to which she did not respond. At that time, she was kneeling on the floor in front of the toilet bowl with her arms over the toilet bowl. She felt that the male person had positioned himself behind her. The complainant then felt the male person pulling down her shorts and panties together at the same time, and trying to insert his penis into her vagina. All this while, the complainant remained kneeling in front of the toilet bowl. She tried to push him away with her left hand, which resulted in her falling to the right side of the toilet bowl. There, she remained in a kneeling position, with her upper body supported by her arms on the floor. The male person then placed his hands on her hips while behind her, lifted her up and inserted his penis into her anus. She cried out loud that she was in pain. Despite this, the male person thrusted his penis in and out several times, before stopping. He then left the Toilet, leaving the complainant there alone. The complainant did not consent to the act of penetration by the male person. This act of penetration forms the basis of the first charge (see [1] above).

  15. [12] Throughout the events described (see [8]-[11] above), the complainant’s evidence is that she did not get a good look at the face of the assailant. However, she was able to say that he was about the same build as the accused, and was wearing a dark blue-coloured shirt. She believed that the accused was her assailant, but could not be sure.

  16. [13] The complainant continued to vomit in the Toilet until Julniee came to the Toilet to check on her. Julniee helped her up and brought her back to her room. According to her evidence, the complainant did not tell Julniee then about what had happened because she did not have the strength to do so. They both fell asleep on Julniee’s bed.

  17. [14] Later that morning, after 8.00am, the complainant woke up and felt pain in her anus. She then called a close friend, “[D]”, and told her that she had been assaulted. More specifically, she told [D] that she had been penetrated in the anus. [D] told the complainant to tell Julniee what happened. The complainant explained in her testimony that she did not dare to do so because she believed that it was the accused who was responsible for the assault and she was afraid of how Julniee would react. [D] told the complainant to pass the phone to Julniee. The complainant woke Julniee up, and passed the phone to her. After speaking with [D] on the phone, Julniee passed the phone back to the complainant and went back to sleep. The complainant was not aware of what Julniee and [D] spoke about over the phone. The complainant could not remember what Julniee had said while on the phone with [D], or what Julniee had told her after speaking with [D] on the phone. She also could not remember if she told Julniee anything after the phone call ended. The complainant then changed out of the T-shirt and shorts into her dress from the night before, and left the Flat at about 9.28am. As she lived within walking distance from the Flat, she then walked home. She did not see anyone in the Flat that morning, except for Julniee.

  18. [15] After reaching her home, the complainant took a shower. While showering, she felt soreness in her anus, which persisted for a few hours. That day, she also spoke to and exchanged messages over WhatsApp with a few close friends. She informed [D] that she was having a panic attack and also about the pain she was feeling from a bruise on her forehead. She also told her then-boyfriend, “[E]”, that she had been penetrated in the anus while at the Flat, and that she suspected that it was the accused who was responsible for that. The complainant also called another friend, “[F]”, and told him about the assault.

  19. [16] On 26 and 27 December 2016, the complainant and Julniee exchanged many WhatsApp messages concerning the details of what had happened during the early hours of 26 December 2016. Among the many things that were said over these messages, Julniee told the complainant that she would find out who was responsible for the assault. Julniee also repeatedly asked whether the complainant intended to make a police report, and expressed the hope that the complainant would not do so. In her reply to one of those messages sent at around 5.16pm, the complainant said “[b]ecause you want [to protect] your brother if it was him that did it?”

  20. [17] Then, at around 6.01pm on 27 December 2016, Julniee told the complainant over WhatsApp messages that she had found out who the assailant was. Julniee said that it was the accused, and that he had admitted to having “fingered” the complainant, but that “[h]e say that he didn’t fuck you”. She also told the complainant that she was ashamed to face the complainant after finding out that her brother was responsible for the assault. Later that evening, at 10.38pm, the complainant made a police report.

  21. The evidence of the complainant’s friends

  22. [18] [D], [E] and [F] were all called by the Prosecution to give evidence. They testified as to their phone conversations and WhatsApp exchanges with the complainant on 26 December 2016. All of them provided consistent accounts that the complainant was emotional, anxious and upset about what had happened to her.

  23. [19] Of particular note is [D]’s evidence. She testified that the complainant had called her at about 8.00am on the morning of 26 December 2016. The complainant told [D] that she felt pain at the area of her anus. The complainant told [D] that she thought that she “was anal[led]”, meaning that she had been sexually penetrated in the anus. The complainant also told [D] that she believed that the accused was responsible for the assault because she recognised his voice. [D] testified that she asked the complainant to pass the phone to Julniee. [D] then told Julniee what had happened to the complainant.

  24. Julniee’s evidence

  25. [20] Julniee was also called as a witness by the Prosecution. As the Deputy Public Prosecutor (“DPP”) said in his oral closing submissions, Julniee’s evidence plays “a very important role” in the Prosecution’s case. Given the WhatsApp messages she had sent to the complainant on 27 December 2016 (see [17] above), this was hardly surprising.

  26. [21] Julniee’s evidence was consistent with that of the complainant’s in describing the events leading up to the alleged assault. She confirmed the complainant’s evidence that the latter was groggy and nauseous by the time they reached the Flat. She described how she was initially with the complainant at the Toilet while the complainant was vomiting. Julniee also helped change the complainant out of her dress, and into the T-shirt and boxer shorts that the complainant came to be wearing when she was sexually assaulted.

  27. [22] Julniee gave evidence that, after she helped the complainant change, the complainant continued vomiting. She then left the complainant in the Toilet to vomit. She went to the accused’s room and asked to speak to Ruben in private. She had a misunderstanding with Ruben concerning their relationship, and wanted to speak to Ruben to clear things up. The accused left the room so that she and Ruben could speak in private. At that time, Alex was asleep on the floor of that room. At this juncture, I should add that Julniee also testified that she was in the accused’s room speaking with Ruben for five minutes. Julniee also testified that when the accused left his room, he had left the room door slightly open. This is consistent with the accused’s evidence. This may suggest that, when Julniee had her private conversation with Ruben in the accused’s room (during which the alleged sexual assault had taken place), the accused’s room door had been open and not shut as the complainant has testified (see [9] above). However, I note that there is evidence to the contrary. In an investigation statement recorded from Julniee on 28 April 2017, Julniee stated that after she had “talked to Ruben for a while”, the accused returned to his room to check if she and Ruben were done. When she informed the accused that they were not done, the accused then closed his room door and left. Thus, according to Julniee’s investigation statement, the accused had initially left his room door ajar but later shut it after he returned to the room and saw that Ruben and Julniee were still talking. When Julniee was cross-examined by the Prosecution on this part of her investigation statement (see [29] below), she testified that she could not recall that the accused had returned to his room to check on her and Ruben and shut the room door. Her oral evidence is that the accused’s room door had been left open throughout the entire duration of her private conversation with Ruben. For reasons that will be explained later in this judgment (see [102] and [131] below), I prefer Julniee’s evidence as set out in her investigation statement and reject her oral testimony as an untruth, and I find that the accused’s room door had in fact been closed during part of Julniee’s private conversation with Ruben.

  28. [23] After their private conversation in the accused’s room, Julinee and Ruben went to the kitchen to smoke. There, they saw the accused standing near the sink area. According to Julniee, the accused said words to the effect that her friend was “damn drunk”. After Ruben finished his cigarette and left the kitchen, Julniee checked on the complainant, and found that the complainant was still vomiting into the toilet bowl while in the same kneeling position as she had left her. Julniee’s evidence is that the complainant appeared to be in a worse state than before as she could not stand up or even respond to Julniee. Julniee then helped the complainant up, cleaned up the complainant’s mouth, and brought the complainant to her bedroom. They then fell asleep on Julniee’s bed.

  29. [24] Julniee also gave evidence that she was woken up a few hours later by the complainant, who told her that [D] wanted to speak to her. [D] told Julniee over the phone that something had happened to the complainant, and that the complainant’s “ass” hurts. Julniee brushed off [D] and said that they would talk later. Julniee said that she reacted that way because she was still sleepy. Julniee’s evidence is that did not ask [D] for the details of what happened to the complainant. Julniee also did not ask the complainant about what happened after she was done speaking with [D]. Julniee told the complainant that they would speak about what happened later. After hearing this, the complainant did not say anything to her, but wanted to leave the Flat and return home. Julniee tried to get the complainant to go back to sleep. However, the complainant was insistent on leaving, and she left the Flat soon thereafter.

  30. [25] After the complainant left the Flat, Julniee tried to go back to sleep but was unable to do so. Julniee said that she remained lying on her bed and eventually only got out of bed sometime before lunch. Julniee also testified that after she got up, she did not follow up with [D] and the complainant about what [D] had told her earlier that morning.

  31. [26] In court, Julniee was showed a WhatsApp message which she sent to the complainant at 9.56am on 26 December 2016, in which she told the complainant, “I’ll get shit settled when everyone’s sober ok?”. She testified that, after having heard what [D] had told her over the phone, she knew that something serious had happened to the complainant.

  32. [27] Julniee sent WhatsApp messages to the complainant later that day (on 26 December 2016), in which she told the complainant that she had tried to speak to her brother, Ruben, and Alex to ascertain who was responsible for assaulting the complainant. According to Julniee’s WhatsApp messages, none of them knew anything about what had happened. However, in her testimony, Julniee claimed that this was all a lie, because she did not actually speak to any of the three of them. She said in court that she had lied because she was hoping that, by telling the complainant that she did not know who was responsible for the assault, the complainant would come to the view that there was “no conclusion” and so would not continue to pursue the matter. Julniee claimed that she did not want to find out what had happened to the complainant because in her view, it was “very hard for something that big to happen … during that few minutes”. In this regard, she was referring to the period of time in which the complainant had been out of her sight and while she was in the accused’s room speaking to Ruben.

  33. [28] As for the WhatsApp message to the complainant sent in the evening of 27 December 2016, where Julniee said that she found out that the accused had been responsible for the assault, but that the accused only admitted to “fingering” the complainant (see [17] above), her evidence in court was that she was lying in this and her other messages to the complainant. She did this so that the complainant would drop the idea of reporting the assault to the police, which the latter had said she wanted to do.

  34. [29] In the light of Julniee’s evidence in court, the Prosecution applied to cross-examine her on two investigation statements that she had given to the police. There is no dispute that these statements were voluntarily given by Julniee.

  35. [30] In Julniee’s investigation statement recorded by Assistant Superintendent Christine Tai (“ASP Tai”) on 28 December 2016 (“the 28 Dec Statement”) , she stated that she was in the accused’s room speaking to Ruben in private for about eight to ten minutes. She recounted that, when she later saw the accused in the kitchen after speaking to Ruben, the accused had told her that the complainant was very drunk and that he had tried to help her up when “he heard her falling down”. While doing so, the accused said that the complainant “hugged” him.

  36. [31] In the 28 Dec Statement, Julniee also stated that she had been woken by the complainant at around 8.00am on 26 December 2016. The complainant passed her mobile phone to Julniee so that she could speak to [D]. The 28 Dec Statement recorded Julniee’s recollection of the conversation with [D] as follows:

  37. [32] Julniee also stated in the 28 Dec Statement that, on the evening of 26 December 2016, she had called Ruben to find out what happened, but the latter said he had no idea. The statement also recorded her as saying that she had spoken to the accused, who said that he could not remember anything. Then, on 27 December 2016, Julniee questioned the accused again. The accused told her that, while he was smoking in the kitchen, he heard the complainant fall, so he went into the Toilet to help her up, and while he was helping her get up from the floor of the Toilet, the complainant had thrown herself at him, and they “make out” [sic]. Julniee also stated that the accused told her that he and the complainant were kissing, but that he could not remember what happened after that. In the statement, Julniee went on to explain that, in the evening of 27 December 2016, she had told the complainant, through a message, that the accused was responsible for what had happened to her, and she also tried to persuade the complainant not to make a police report.

  38. [33] Julniee gave a further investigation statement to ASP Tai on 28 April 2017 (“the 28 Apr Statement”), which I have referred to earlier in this judgment (see [22] above). ASP Tai had shown her the WhatsApp messages which she exchanged with the complainant on 26 and 27 December 2016. These messages had been extracted from the complainant’s mobile phone. ASP Tai then asked Julniee a series of questions and recorded her answers.

  39. [34] After having reviewed the 28 Dec Statement and the 28 Apr Statement, I accepted that there were material inconsistencies between Julniee’s evidence in court and what she had said in her investigation statements. I thus allowed the Prosecution to proceed with their cross-examination of Julniee under s 147(1) of the Evidence Act (Cap 97, 1997 Rev Ed) (“the EA”).

  40. [35] Under cross-examination by both the Prosecution and later the Defence, Julniee kept to her version of events, which can be summarised as follows.

  41. (a) She insisted that she spoke to Ruben in the accused’s room for less than five minutes. She also testified that, when she went to the kitchen after speaking to Ruben, she could not recall that the accused had told her that he tried to help the complainant up from the floor, or that the complainant had hugged him in the process of doing so. She testified that all the accused told her was “your friend damn drunk”.

  42. (b) Julniee also denied that she had been told by [D] over the phone that the complainant had been sexually penetrated in her anus, while the latter was in the Toilet. Julniee claimed that she could only remember that [D] had told her that the complainant had informed [D] that “her [the complainant’s] butt hurts” and that she could not remember anything else that [D] might have told her over the phone.

  43. (c) She testified that she did not believe that the complainant had actually been assaulted, but she had sent messages to the complainant that gave the impression that she was trying to find out who the assailant was only to show the complainant that she was concerned. She insisted that she never spoke to Ruben to ask him whether he knew what happened.

  44. (d) She repeatedly denied that the accused had admitted to her or their parents that he had “fingered” the complainant or that he had kissed the complainant. She claimed that, when she showed the accused the complainant’s message about her (Julniee) wanting to protect the accused if he was indeed responsible for the sexual assaults (see [16] above), the accused brushed her off and told her words to the effect that she should “manage [her] own problems”.

  45. (e) She claimed that she had subsequently identified the accused as the assailant in her WhatsApp messages to the complainant (see [17] above) because the latter had already assumed that it was him and she wanted to assuage the complainant. She claimed that the complainant had assured her that no police report would be made once the assailant was identified.

  46. (f) Julniee also testified that she had lied to ASP Tai in many parts of her two investigation statements, or that she could not recall many of the things she told ASP Tai in those statements.

  47. [36] On the basis of her inconsistent evidence in court, the Prosecution submits that Julniee’s credit should be impeached pursuant to s 157(c) of the EA, and full weight should be given to the 28 Dec Statement and the 28 Apr Statement under s 147(3) of the EA. This is an important issue in this case, which I will return to later in the course of this judgment.

  48. Forensic and medical evidence

  49. [37] Two medical professionals, who had examined the complainant at various times after she had made the police report (see [17] above), were also called by the Prosecution to give evidence. These were Dr Koh Meiling Serena (“Dr Koh”) from KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital, and Dr Zheng Zhimin (“Dr Zheng”) from the Institute of Mental Health. The Prosecution relies on the complainant’s account of the events in relation to the alleged offences given to Dr Koh and Dr Zheng, and as recorded in their medical reports, and submits that the complainant has maintained a consistent version of the events throughout.

  50. [38] The Prosecution also called a senior forensic scientist from the Health Sciences Authority (“HSA”), Mr Ping Shueh Yang (“Mr Ping”), to give evidence. He had examined, amongst other items, the T-shirt and the boxer shorts worn by the complainant at the time of the assault and prepared a report on his findings. Mr Ping’s evidence is that the exterior back of the T-shirt worn by the complainant tested positive for acid phosphatase, prostate-specific antigen, and semenogelin. From this result, Mr Ping could confirm that semen was present at the exterior back of the T-shirt. Further, from an examination of the DNA, the semen found matched the DNA profile of the accused.

  51. [39] At the conclusion of the Prosecution’s case, I called for the Defence.

  52. The Defence’s case

  53. [40] The accused elected to give evidence. He testified that he is the managing director and co-founder of a food and beverage chain, the owner of a retail footwear business, and a partner in a bar and bistro business. He was 21 years-old at the time of the alleged offences.

  54. [41] From 2014 up to sometime in 2017, his girlfriend at that time was living with him at the Flat, where he stayed with his parents and his sister. His girlfriend was a flight attendant, and was referred to by him (and others) as “Pang”. She stayed in the same room as him.

  55. [42] On the night of 25 December 2016, he had gone drinking with his business partner in the retail footwear business, one Kelvin Tan (“Kelvin”), and Ruben and Alex. They went to a club at Jalan Sultan, which he described as a “Thai disco”. They were at the club from around midnight until around 4.00am, chatting and playing drinking games. When the club closed, Ruben and Alex headed back home with the accused as they had decided to stay over with him at the Flat. Pang was working on a flight at that time. She had flown off on a flight to Australia on the night of 25 December 2016.

  56. [43] Once in the accused’s bedroom, Alex fell asleep almost immediately on the floor. The accused and Ruben were planning to share the bed. Before he and Ruben fell asleep, Julniee knocked on the room door to inform the accused that she had just come home. Julniee then shut the door and left.

  57. [44] Not long after, Julniee knocked again on the door. This time she asked to speak to Ruben alone, and for the accused to give them some privacy. The accused testified that he was aware that Julniee and Ruben had an “affair” while Julniee was dating someone else. The accused then came out of his room, and left the door slightly ajar. He decided to go to the kitchen to smoke. He was dressed at this time in a dark blue-coloured shirt, and his boxer briefs.

  58. [45] While he was sitting in the kitchen smoking, the accused claimed that he heard a “thud” coming from the toilet at the service balcony area (ie, the Toilet). He made his way to the area outside the Toilet to take a look, and saw a “girl” there who was sprawled on the floor of the Toilet on the right side of the toilet bowl. She had her limbs and body in contact with the floor, her face facing towards the floor of the Toilet (the accused’s evidence is that her face was near to the floor but he could not see if it was actually touching the floor), and her back facing the entrance of the Toilet. He further testified that she looked disoriented. The impression he had was that she had fallen to the floor. The accused’s evidence is that he remembered her knees leaning towards the floor but that he could not determine if she had been sitting down or kneeling on the floor of the Toilet. He assumed that she was the complainant because Julniee had earlier sent a message to their family’s WhatsApp group chat that the complainant would be staying over at the Flat that night.

  59. [46] According to the accused, he first stood outside the Toilet and called out to the complainant to ask whether she was okay, but there was no response. He then went into the Toilet, tapped on her right shoulder, and asked her again whether she was okay. Again, there was no response.

  60. [47] The accused’s testimony was that he then used the palm of his hands and placed them under the complainant’s armpits to support her into an upright position. In the process of doing so, he said that the complainant’s right arm swung around towards him, and she hugged him for support. When this happened, their faces came very close together, almost into contact. The complainant was using her right arm to hold on to his left shoulder for support, and their bodies were in physical contact. The accused then managed to rest the complainant in a “comfortable” sitting position, next to the toilet bowl, with her back against the wall of the Toilet. He then left the Toilet and went back to the kitchen to carry on smoking.

  61. [48] After a short time, Julniee and Ruben came to the kitchen. The accused’s evidence is that he told Julniee that her friend was “damn drunk”. The accused testified that Julniee did not say anything in response. After that, he finished up smoking his cigarette and went back to his room to sleep. He woke up sometime between 9.00am to 10.00am. He then left the Flat for work at around 10.00am. He did not see anyone at the Flat after he woke up and before he left, other than Ruben and Alex, who were still sleeping in his room. The accused’s evidence is that the rest of the day passed uneventfully with him being at work as was usual.

  62. [49] On 27 December 2016, Pang returned to Singapore in the afternoon. The accused and Pang were in his room at the Flat discussing what happened when she was away. According to the accused, when he told Pang that he had gone drinking with his friends at a “Thai disco”, she flew into a rage. They had a heated argument in his room. While this was happening, Julniee knocked on the door of his room, and asked to speak to him. Julniee told him that someone “fucked” the complainant, and showed him some WhatsApp messages exchanged between her and the complainant. The accused testified that the gist of the WhatsApp message shown to him was the complainant questioning Julniee that “if it was your brother, you want to protect him”. As the accused was preoccupied with his ongoing argument with Pang, his evidence is that he was not bothered or concerned about what Julniee was telling him. He told Julniee that this had nothing to do with him and told Julniee to go and “settle” things with the complainant. In short, he brushed off what Julniee said to him.

  63. [50] Not long after, when he left his room to take a break from his argument with Pang, Julniee told him that she had told the complainant that he was the one who was responsible for the assault on the complainant. The accused’s evidence is that he was a bit “lost” when he heard this. Julniee showed him some WhatsApp messages that she had sent to the complainant, which identified him as the assailant. The accused said that he then shouted at Julniee, “you crazy? Do you know what you are even doing”. He testified that he hurled some vulgarities at Julniee, and told her she was ruining his future. He then returned to his room to get a cigarette so he could calm himself down. After he told Pang about what Julniee had done, he and Pang started having another heated argument. The accused then decided to leave the Flat. The accused also testified that, all this while, his parents were at work and not in the Flat.

  64. [51] The accused testified that he got into his car and drove around aimlessly for a few hours. He had a lot on his mind. He was angry because Julniee had framed him with this serious allegation. He was also upset with Pang, who appeared to believe that he was responsible for something that happened to the complainant. He felt very disappointed and lost.

  65. [52] The accused testified that he eventually stopped his car somewhere in Kallang, and stood by the roadside. During this time, he had received several phone calls and messages on his mobile phone from Pang, his parents and his business partner, Kelvin. He did not answer any of the calls, although it appears that he replied to some of the messages he received. The accused spent a significant portion of his evidence-in-chief explaining the context of some of the WhatsApp messages he had exchanged with his father and Pang during this period after he left the Flat and before he eventually returned to home. I will delve into his explanations and the contents of his WhatsApp message exchanges in more detail later in the course of this judgment.

  66. [53] The accused returned to the Flat past midnight on 28 December 2016, after he was informed by his father that some police officers were at the Flat waiting for him.

  67. [54] There are two other aspects of the accused’s evidence that bears mention.

  68. [55] The first involves his explanation for the presence of his semen on exterior back of the T-shirt (see [38] above). The accused gave evidence that he and Pang lived like “husband and wife” in the Flat. According to him, he and Pang would have sex on a daily basis whenever she was not working on a flight. They would do so at various locations in the flat, including in the Toilet while they were showering together. When he did so, he would ejaculate on the floor or wall of the Toilet. The case for the Defence is that the accused’s semen might have been on the floor or wall of the Toilet, or on some other article of clothing in the laundry basket, and from there, the semen was transferred to the exterior back of the T-shirt. That might have happened when the T-shirt came into contact with the floor or wall of the Toilet or some other article of clothing in the laundry basket. The police had seized the T-shirt from the laundry basket in the service balcony area, when they searched the Flat in the early hours of 28 December 2016.

  69. [56] The other aspect of the accused’s evidence that bears mentioning is that he denied having admitted to Julniee or his parents on 27 December 2016 that he had “fingered” or kissed the complainant. He disputed the account given by Julniee in the 28 Apr Statement that he had admitted to “fingering” the complainant. He insisted that Julniee was trying to frame him. As for her motive for doing so, the accused explained that he often acted in a controlling manner over Julniee by setting curfews for her and limiting how much alcohol she could drink. This was because she was very “mischievous”.

  70. [57] There were two other witnesses called for the Defence. The first was the accused’s and Julniee’s father, Tan Keck Kuan. He is also known as “Alson” and I will refer to him as such in the course of this judgment. His evidence is that he first learnt of the allegations against the accused when he came home from work on 27 December 2016, at about 7.00pm. Julniee told him that the complainant was going to make a police report against the accused for having sexually assaulted her. He tried to find out more details from Julniee and the accused as to what had happened. He denied that the accused had admitted to him about being responsible for the sexual assault. Alson also denied that Julniee had told him that the accused had admitted to being the assailant.

  71. [58] The second other witness for the Defence was Ruben. The gist of his evidence is that he spoke to Julniee in the accused’s room (while the accused had left his room) for about five minutes or less. He could not remember very much else about what had happened that night, but he was certain that he had spoken to Julniee for not more than five minutes.

  72. The law

  73. [59] Section 376(1)(a) of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) then-in-force at the material time and pursuant to which the accused has been charged (“the Penal Code”), reads as follows:

  74. [60] Section 376(2)(a) of the Penal Code reads as follows:

  75. [61] From these provisions, the elements of the first and second charges which the Prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt are: (a) that the accused had sexually penetrated the complainant; and (b) the penetration was not consented to by the complainant. Given the evidence of the accused and the complainant, the only issue in contention in relation to these two charges is whether he had indeed sexually penetrated the complainant as she has alleged. If the accused had indeed done so, it is not the Defence’s case that the complainant had consented to these acts.

  76. [62] Section 354(1) of the Penal Code, pursuant to which the accused been charged in respect of the third and fourth charges, reads as follows:

  77. [63] “Criminal force” is defined in s 350 of the Penal Code as follows:

  78. [64] From these provisions, the elements of the third and fourth charges which the Prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt are: (a) that the accused had used criminal force on the complainant; and (b) the accused intended by the use of such criminal force to outrage the modesty of the complainant. It is not in dispute that the act of kissing the complainant’s lips and the touching of the complainant’s breast, both without her consent, constitute acts of criminal force, and if indeed so perpetrated by the accused, would have been intended by him to outrage the modesty of the complainant (see, eg Teo Keng Pong v Public Prosecutor [1996] 2 SLR(R) 890). Thus, in respect of the third and fourth charges, the only issue before this court is whether the accused had indeed kissed her lips and touched her breast as the complainant has alleged.

  79. [65] An accused person can be convicted solely on a complainant’s testimony alone but only when it is so “unusually convincing” as to overcome any doubts that might arise from the lack of corroboration (see AOF v Public Prosecutor [2012] 3 SLR 34 (“AOF”) at [111]). While the “unusually convincing” standard does not change the rule that the Prosecution must prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt, it does set the threshold for the complainant’s testimony to be preferred over the accused’s evidence where the case is one that boils down to one person’s words against another’s (see XP v Public Prosecutor [2008] 4 SLR(R) 686 (“XP”) at [31]). The emphasis is on the sufficiency of the complainant’s testimony, and the threshold would be met only if the testimony, when weighed against the overall backdrop of the available facts and circumstances, contains that ring of truth which leaves the court satisfied that no reasonable doubt exists in favour of the accused (see Public Prosecutor v Mohammed Liton Mohammed Syeed Mallik [2008] 1 SLR(R) 601 (“Liton”) at [39]).

  80. [66] A witness’s testimony may only be found to be “unusually convincing” by weighing the demeanour of the witness alongside both the internal and external consistencies found in the witness’s testimony (see AOF at [115]). The demeanour of the witness is not invariably determinative, and if the witness fails to recall or satisfactorily explain material facts and assertions, her credible demeanour cannot overcome such deficiencies (see XP at [71]). Finally, even if the witness’s testimony is found to be “unusually convincing”, it does not automatically lead to a guilty verdict and does not dispense with the need for the court to consider the other evidence and the factual circumstances peculiar to each case, as well as the need to assess the complainant’s testimony against that of the accused’s (see AOF at [114(d)]). An “unusually convincing” testimony does not overcome materially or inherently contradictory evidence (see AOF at [114(d)]).

  81. [67] If the complainant’s testimony is not “unusually convincing”, then the accused’s conviction is unsafe unless there is some corroboration of the complainant’s evidence (see AOF at [173]). A liberal approach is adopted in determining whether a particular piece of evidence can amount to corroboration (see Liton at [43]). There is no need for the corroborative evidence to consist of independent evidence implicating the accused in a material particular, and what is important is the substance as well as the relevance of the evidence, and whether it is supportive or confirmative of the weak evidence which it is meant to corroborate (see Liton at [43]). However, it is clear that subsequent repeated complaints by a complainant cannot, in and of themselves, constitute corroborative evidence so as to dispense with the requirement for “unusually convincing” testimony (see AOF at [114(a)]; XP at [29]).

  82. The issues

  83. (a) whether the account of events given by the complainant as to the alleged sexual assaults is “unusually convincing”;

  84. (b) the relevance of Julniee’s evidence and her credibility as a witness; and

  85. (c) whether the accused’s account stands up to scrutiny in the light of the evidence before the court.

  86. [69] It is to these issues that I now turn.

  87. Assessment of the complainant’s evidence

  88. [70] The Prosecution’s case is that the complainant’s testimony is “unusually convincing”, although it also takes the position that the “unusually convincing” standard is not necessarily applicable in this case because the complainant’s evidence does not form the sole basis of their case against accused. As corroboration, the Prosecution has referred to the evidence of the presence of the accused’s semen on the exterior back of the T-shirt, as well as Julniee’s evidence.

  89. [71] The Defence attacks the complainant’s credibility in various respects and argues that her testimony falls short of being “unusually convincing”. First, it points out that the complainant had not been able to positively identify the accused during the time of the alleged assaults. Also, as the complainant had been drinking heavily, her memory of the events that occurred at the material time was affected. This led to her having memory gaps as to who might have been responsible for the assault. The Defence submits that the complainant had filled up her memory gaps with whatever she believed transpired and thus simply assumed that the accused was the one who had assaulted her, and this started with her conversation with [D] on the morning of 26 December 2016, several hours after the alleged assault had taken place. The Defence also points to what it says are inconsistencies in the accounts which the complainant had provided to [D], [F] and later to the court about the identity of her assailant.

  90. [72] Second, the Defence argues that there are several problems with the complainant’s testimony: (a) it is unbelievable that she had been unable to physically resist the assailant or shout for help during each of the sexual assaults, despite having the ability to rush to the Toilet to vomit whenever she had the urge to do so; (b) the complainant’s recounting of the facts relating to each of the four charges in her investigation statement, and in the accounts which she provided to the two medical professionals who had examined her, and later in her testimony in court, had been inconsistent; (c) it is inconceivable that the accused would have been able to carry out the assaults without drawing the attention of the other persons residing in the Flat at the material time. Finally, the Defence also submits that the complainant has been an evasive witness who has, amongst other things, embellished her evidence.

  91. The complainant’s identification of the accused as her assailant during the time of the assaults

  92. [73] I have carefully reviewed the evidence of the complainant (see [8]-[12] above). Having done so, I am unable to agree with the Defence’s submission that the complainant had not been able to positively identify the accused as her assailant during the time of the assaults. Her evidence was candid and direct. She was quite intoxicated at the time of the assaults. As such, she did not get a good look at the face of the male person who had assaulted her. In her memory, she had a blurred image of a face. She agreed that she might not have seen her assailant’s face completely. However, she did think from the voice and the build of the male person in question that the assailant was the accused. In my judgment, it is clear from the complainant’s evidence that she had been able to positively identify the accused as the assailant during the time of the assaults based on what she could perceive of her assailant then.

  93. [74] According to the complainant, when she was first approached by the male person in the Toilet and brought out onto the sofa in the living room (see [8] above), she had “assumed” from the voice of the male person that he was the accused. The complainant explained that this was for a few reasons. First, this male person knew her name. Second, the voice of that male person, who had asked her “[V], are you okay?”, did not sound like Julniee’s father, with whom she had spoken before in an extended conversation. She had also met Julniee’s father in person before. Third, the complainant also explained that, from what she could feel of the build of that male person with whom she had come into contact, she knew that he was not Julniee’s father. At that time, the complainant also knew (from Julniee) that only Julniee’s parents were at home in the Flat that morning. In other words, the only other male person who could have come to the complainant’s mind then would have been the accused because, save for Julniee’s family, she would not have known that anyone else was also staying over in the Flat that morning. The complainant also explained that, as a result of her assuming that the male person was the accused, she did not ask him where he was bringing her to when she was first supported out of the Toilet, because she thought it was the accused helping her to go to the living room to rest. The complainant also noticed, when she opened her eyes briefly, that the male person who brought her out to the living room was wearing a dark blue-coloured shirt. It is not in dispute that the accused was wearing a dark blue-coloured shirt at the material time.

  94. [75] According to the complainant, the male person, whom she assumed to be the accused, gave her a kiss on the lips after placing her on the sofa in the living room. Almost immediately after the kiss, the complainant had the urge to vomit again, and she sat up and ran back to the Toilet to do so. After she finished vomiting, the male person again approached her in the Toilet, asking her “[V], are you okay?” (see [9] above). This male person then brought her out of the Toilet and supported her into Julniee’s bedroom. The complainant recognised from the voice of the male person that it was the same person as before, and therefore she “assumed” it was the accused.

  95. [76] After the complainant was supported into Julniee’s bedroom and placed on Julniee’s bed, she felt someone touching her breast, and a few seconds later, felt two fingers inserted into her vagina (see [10] above). The complainant testified that she knew it was the same person who had touched her breast and digitally penetrated her because, after this person touched her breast, he removed his hands from under her shirt, and inserted his fingers into her vagina almost immediately. The complainant also testified that, when she felt this person insert his fingers into her vagina, she opened her eyes briefly, and saw that he was wearing the same dark blue-coloured shirt which she had noticed earlier being worn by the male person who brought her out of the Toilet on the first occasion to the living room. The complainant therefore “assumed” that the male person who had touched her breast and digitally penetrated her vagina was the accused.

  96. [77] Thereafter, the complainant remained on Julniee’s bed and the next time she opened her eyes, she noticed that she was alone. She felt an urge to vomit, and so she ran back to the Toilet to do so (see [11] above). Again, the male person approached her in the Toilet, asking her “[V], are you okay?”. The complainant felt him pulling down her shorts and panties, and first attempting to insert his penis into her vagina (but failed to do so), and later penetrating her anus with his penis before stopping and leaving the Toilet (see [11] above). Again, the complainant “assumed” that this male person was the accused because his voice was the same as that of the male person who had approached her in the Toilet on the first and second occasions.

  97. [78] From the foregoing, it is clear that the complainant had formed the view that the accused was the assailant during each of those occasions when she had been sexually assaulted, based on the physical features that she could perceive of her assailant. Thus, I find that there is no merit in the Defence’s submission that the complainant had not been able to positively identify the assailant during the assaults and only later came to assume that her assailant was the accused. I also make an observation in respect of this part of the complainant’s testimony. It is significant that, when the complainant was asked during evidence-in-chief whether she knew who her assailant was, her response had been that she “assumed” that her assailant was the accused based on, amongst other things, the fact that she had heard the same voice on all three occasions when she was in the Toilet asking her “[V], are you okay?”. In my view, the complainant could easily have embellished her evidence to say that she saw the accused’s face and remembered it, and thus positively identified the accused as the assailant during those assaults. However, I find that she was honest enough to admit that her eyes were closed for most of the time during the assaults, and she did not get a good look at who her assailant was. She also testified that she had not blacked out, but had been conscious throughout as to what was happening to her, though she did not have the strength to resist the assailant. As such, she could remember the details of the sexual assault and her assailant, and this aided her in identifying the accused as her assailant.

  98. [79] While it is true that, in the first information report (“FIR”) made by the complainant on the night of 27 December 2016 (see [17] above) and in her investigation statement recorded at 3.20am on 28 December 2016, she did not identify the accused as her assailant, that is because these two documents simply set out the facts as they happened. It appears that in neither of these documents was the complainant being asked or required to expressly identify her assailant (see [85] below).

  99. [80] In the investigation statement, the complainant stated that, when she was being brought out of the Toilet for the first time by the male person:

  100. The Defence relies on the above quoted portion of the complainant’s statement as evidence that she could not be sure who her assailant was. In my view, the sentence where the complainant says that she did not know who the male person was must be read in its proper context. I find that the complainant was simply explaining that she did not see who the person was because her eyes were not fully open, and as such, she could not say for sure that she knew that the assailant was the accused. This in no way detracts from the evidence which she had given in court that, from the voice and the build of the male person, and the fact that the male person seemed to know her, she knew that it must have been the accused, even though she did not see his face clearly.

  101. [81] The information which the complainant shared with [D] and [E] on the morning of 26 December 2016 about what had happened to her is also consistent with her having positively identified the accused as the assailant during the time of the assaults. The information which the complainant shared with them is consistent with her testimony in court - namely that she had come to the view, from the physical features of her assailant which she perceived of during the assaults, that it was the accused.

  102. (a) According to [D]’s testimony, when the complainant called her on 26 December 2016 at around 8.00am (see [19] above), it was the complainant who had first told her that the accused had anally penetrated her. This led to [D] asking the complainant how sure she was that it had been the accused given that she had been in a drunken state. The complainant responded to [D] that she could recognise the voice of that male person who assaulted her as the accused’s voice. In a WhatsApp message which the complainant sent to [D] while they were discussing the identity of the complainant’s assailant, the complainant said on her own accord and without any suggestion from [D], “I really keep thinking it’s the brother” [emphasis added], referring to Julniee’s brother, the accused.

  103. (b) On 26 December 2016 at 9.09am, the complainant sent a WhatsApp message to [E] informing him what had happened to her earlier that morning. The complainant said to [E], “I feel … That my friends brother did smth [sic] to me last night” [emphasis added], referring to the accused.

  104. [82] I note that when [F] testified about what he had spoken on the phone with the complainant on 26 December 2016, he said that the complainant had told him that she had been anally penetrated, and that her assailant had called out her name, but other than that, she was not sure as to who that person was. I find that this in no way detracts from what I have said about the complainant’s testimony. Her evidence is not that she knew with certainty who her assailant was, which might well have been the case if she had opened her eyes and saw her assailant’s face. Instead, her evidence is that she had come to the view, as a result of the physical features which she could perceive of her assailant during the time of the assaults, that he was the accused. Thus, the complainant’s identification of the accused as the assailant is based on what she had perceived during the assaults, and not any assumptions which she later made or what others might have told her.

  105. [83] The Defence also submits that the complainant could not have recognised, from the voice of the male person who had approached her in the Toilet, that the male person was the accused. This is because the complainant had testified during evidence-in-chief that she did not recognise the voice of this male person when he first approached her in the Toilet. Also, the Defence argues that, since the complainant had never engaged in any extended conversation with the accused, and only spoke to him prior to 26 December 2016 on a “hi/bye” basis, she would have been unfamiliar with the accused’s voice, and thus could not have recognised it.

  106. [84] I reject this submission, which misses the fundamental point about the complainant’s evidence entirely. It is not the complainant’s evidence that she had identified the accused as the assailant only because of the voice of the male person who had approached her in the Toilet. As the Prosecution correctly puts it, the voice of the male person was simply one of the reasons which contributed to the complainant identifying the accused as her assailant during the time of the assaults (see [74] above). The complainant considered that this male person, who was able to call out her name, must have known her, yet he did not sound like Julniee’s father, nor did the build of this male person fit that of Julniee’s father. The complainant therefore formed the view then that it could only have been the accused. As such, even if I were to accept the Defence’s submission that the complainant was unfamiliar with the accused’s voice and so could not have recognised it, this in no way undermines the fact that there had been a series of reasons that led to the complainant forming the view that her assailant was the accused.

  107. [85] By the time the complainant gave her investigation statement, she had already identified the accused as her assailant. That explains why the FIR stated that she had been “raped by a 22-year-old male”. Also, shortly after the accused returned home in the early hours of 28 December 2016, he was placed under arrest and brought to the Police Cantonment Complex for further investigation under the instructions of ASP Tai. As such, the proper context of the investigation statement is that she was being asked to recount the sexual assaults, and she did not have to specifically identify the accused in her statement, since she had already informed the police who had assaulted her. No significance can therefore be attached to the complainant’s omission to specifically identify the accused as the assailant in the complainant’s investigation statement as identified by the Defence (see [80] above).

  108. [86] On the question of identification, another piece of evidence which has not been satisfactorily dealt with by the Defence is the complainant’s testimony that her assailant was wearing a dark blue-coloured shirt. I reiterate that it is undisputed that the accused was wearing a dark blue-coloured shirt at the material time. This part of the complainant’s testimony is therefore externally consistent. The Defence argues that the complainant had embellished her evidence when she mentioned the dark blue-coloured shirt in her evidence-in-chief because this fact had not been mentioned in her earlier conversations with her friends, including Julniee. However, I am not able to accept this submission because, in her conversations with her friends, it did not appear that she had been asked to describe the details of precisely what had happened, or what she had observed, and none of the complainant’s friends had questioned her claim that she had been sexually assaulted. There was thus no reason for the complainant to point out to her friends that she saw her assailant wearing a dark blue-coloured shirt. In her evidence-in-chief, however, she had to explain in minute detail, step-by-step, what happened, and what she could remember as to what she saw and heard. That was when she mentioned that she saw her assailant was wearing a dark blue-coloured shirt. I also noted that the Defence did not suggest to the complainant that she had embellished her evidence about having seen that her assailant was wearing a dark blue-coloured shirt.

  109. [87] More fundamentally, though, I find that the Defence’s submission as to the identification of the accused does not really assist the court. There were only four other male persons in the Flat at that time, and all of them, save for the accused, have been accounted for. This is accepted by the Defence. The accused’s father, Alson, was asleep in his bedroom with his wife. Alex was asleep on the floor of the accused’s bedroom. Ruben was in the accused’s room speaking to Julniee. As such, the only male person who could have had the opportunity to assault the complainant, while she was out of Julniee’s sight, was the accused. Further, it was the accused’s own evidence that he was the person who had approached the complainant in the Toilet and helped lift her up from the floor.

  110. The internal and external consistency of the complainant’s testimony

  111. [88] The Defence attacks the consistency of the complainant’s account of the sexual assaults (see [72] above), but I find the inconsistencies that have been pointed out to be rather immaterial. Some of these inconsistencies include: (a) the complainant had mentioned to Dr Koh that there might have been a second kiss while she was on the sofa in the living room, contrary to her initial testimony during evidence-in-chief where she said that there had only been one kiss; (b) the complainant was unable to remember during her evidence-in-chief whether one or both her breasts had been touched during the assault, and the fact that her breasts had been touched was not recorded in Dr Koh’s report; and (c) the complainant failed to say until her evidence-in-chief that she had fallen to the side of the toilet bowl when the accused was about to insert his penis in her anus.

  112. [89] I find that these minor inconsistencies do not detract from the fact that, from an overall assessment of the complainant’s evidence, she has been materially consistent when describing the account of the assaults, right down to the details as to what she could not remember. Her account of the sexual assaults, from the time she was first brought out of the Toilet up to the time she was sexually penetrated in the anus after she returned to the Toilet for the second time, was largely unshaken under cross-examination. What she told her friends, [D], [E], [F] and Julniee, a few hours after she was assaulted, was consistent with her evidence in court as to what transpired during the assault, in particular, that she had been sexually penetrated in the anus, and that the accused was the one who was responsible (see [81]-[82] above). The evidence of these four friends confirms that the complainant’s account of the events that occurred never changed.

  113. [90] Further, the omission of these somewhat peripheral facts by the complainant, whether while she was examined by Dr Koh or when her investigation statement was recorded, does not detract from my assessment that the complainant’s testimony has been materially consistent. The proper context in which the complainant had been asked to provide those accounts (whether to Dr Koh or ASP Tai) should be borne in mind (see also [85] above). On those occasions, the complainant was not asked to recount in minute detail what had happened to her, like she was during her evidence-in-chief. The fact that she had omitted particular details did not in and of itself render her account inconsistent.

  114. [91] The Defence also attacks the internal consistency of the complainant’s evidence on two other grounds. First, it submits that it is unbelievable that the complainant did not have the strength to physically resist her assailant despite being able to rush to the Toilet whenever she had the urge to vomit. On this point, I accept the evidence of Dr Zheng that the complainant’s ability to do the latter but not the former can be explained by the fact that the biological urge to vomit was familiar to her and so she was able to maintain control over that urge and react by vomiting only in a socially appropriate place as she was accustomed to doing. On the other hand, the experience of sexual assault would have been foreign to the complainant. The incoordination in motor responses and sensory perceptions from which the complainant suffered as a result of her alcohol consumption the night before might have affected her ability to respond to the sexual assault and call for help. Dr Zheng had come to this assessment by reference to what the complainant had told her about the physical and cognitive symptoms which she had experienced on previous incidents of alcohol intoxication, and in particular, her habit of making sure that she vomited in a socially appropriate place no matter how uncomfortable she felt.

  115. [92] The Defence does not challenge the correctness of Dr Zheng’s assessment but it did, in cross-examination, suggest to Dr Zheng that her assessment would be entirely dependent on the accuracy of the subjective account which the complainant had provided (including what the complainant says is her usual response to her biological urge to vomit). The Defence also appears to make a submission that, given the complainant’s ability to run to the Toilet to vomit, her motor and sensory functions would not have been so seriously affected that she could not physically resist her assailant and as such, her account of what had happened is unbelievable. The Defence relies on: (a) Dr Zheng’s agreement that the complainant would still have been in a position to shout and scream for help even if the complainant had been suffering from a delay in responding to stimuli; and (b) Dr Zheng’s agreement that, if the complainant’s motor coordination had been affected, then it would have hampered her ability to run to the Toilet to vomit.

  116. [93] I do not find any merit in the Defence’s submission. It is not the Defence’s case that the account which the complainant had provided to Dr Zheng, in particular, about her habit of vomiting in a socially appropriate place, even when she was intoxicated, is untrue. Also, Dr Zheng’s evidence was not that the complainant’s sensory and motor functions had been completely incapacitated, but only that there had been some impairment and so her responses would have been delayed. In those circumstances, the complainant would still have been in a position to call out or shout for help, though she would have taken a longer time to perceive the stimuli, comprehend what was going on, and respond. That would explain why the complainant had not been able to physically resist her assailant and shout for help as the stimuli arising from her being sexually assaulted was foreign to her and so she had not been able to respond in time and call for help. On the other hand, the complainant was able to respond more quickly to her biological urge to vomit because that was a sensation that was familiar to her.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.