General Division of the High Court · Decided 12 September 2022
HQH Capital Ltd v Chen Liping
Feedback & support[2022] SGHC 215 · Case no. Suit No 682 of 2014 · 17 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [2]
[2] This case surfaced questions on the nature and effect of Tomlin Orders. I heard the parties on 30 June 2022 and allowed the plaintiff’s application under summons no 1314 of 2022 (“SUM 1314”).
Facts
- [3]
[3] The plaintiff, HQH Capital Limited (“HQH”), is a company providing corporate advisory services and was incorporated under the laws of the British Virgin Islands. The defendant, Ms Chen Liping (“Ms Chen”), is a director of Pavillon Holdings Ltd (“PHL”), a company incorporated under the laws of Singapore.
Suit 682
- [4]
[4] The dispute essentially arose over two agreements which Ms Chen had entered into in 2014. According to Ms Chen, she had required a short-term loan of $2m to pay for placement shares in PHL. It was undisputed that on 15 March 2014, a friend had introduced Ms Chen to Mr Ang Kheng Hui (“Mr Ang”), the chief executive officer of HQH. Mr Ang in turn introduced Ms Chen to Mr Lee Chia Chee (“Mr Lee”), a director and the sole shareholder of HQH. It was also undisputed that the first agreement had been entered into on or about 16 or 17 March 2014 (“the Principal Agreement”), that Mr Lee had given Ms Chen a cheque for $2 m on 17 March 2014 and that the Principal Agreement had been amended by way of a supplementary agreement on or about 7 April 2014 (“the Supplementary Agreement”).
- [5]
[5] Where the parties differed was regarding the purpose and intended effect of the Principal and Supplementary Agreements. HQH’s position was that the Principal and Supplementary Agreements were call option agreements whereby Ms Chen would grant HQH a call option (“the Call Option”) to purchase shares (“the Option Shares”) in PHL and receive a prepaid sum of $2m from HQH as full consideration for the purchase price of the Option Shares. Ms Chen averred, however, that Mr Ang and Mr Lee had agreed to grant her a lump sum loan of $2m. Her position was that the Principal and Supplementary Agreements were designed to disguise this unlicensed and illegal moneylending transaction between the parties, and that Mr Lee had orally represented to her that the Principal and Supplementary Agreements would not be enforced against her.
- [6]
[6] On 17 June 2014, HQH gave notice of its exercise of the Call Option via email. However, Ms Chen did not deliver the Option Shares to HQH.
- [7]
[7] HQH commenced this suit on 25 June 2014. Ms Chen pleaded the defence of illegality as well as the defence of estoppel by convention and/or conduct. On 27 June 2014, HQH obtained an ex parte Mareva injunction against Ms Chen which, inter alia, prohibited her from removing from Singapore or dealing with assets up to the value of $3,999,930 (“the Mareva Injunction”).
The two Tomlin Orders
(a) Ms Chen was to pay $500,000 to HQH by 22 August 2015.
(b) Ms Chen was to pay $2,350,000 to HQH by 28 August 2015.
(c) In the event that Ms Chen failed to make either payment within the stipulated time, HQH was at liberty to enter final judgment against her for the liquidated sum of $3,250,000 (less any payments already paid to HQH), and Ms Chen was to consent to final judgment being entered against her by HQH for this sum.
(a) The total amount payable by Ms Chen to HQH was $3m, of which $498,000 had already been paid by Ms Chen.
(b) Ms Chen was to pay the remaining sum of $2,502,000 in three instalments – 30 days, 60 days and 90 days respectively, after the discharge of the Mareva Injunction.
(c) In the event that Ms Chen failed to make any of these three instalment payments, HQH was entitled to enter judgment against Ms Chen for $3.25m (less any sums already paid) and legal costs of $50,000.
Deed of Agreement and Addendum to Deed of Agreement
- [12]
[12] Subsequently, Ms Chen requested for an extension of time to make payments to HQH as Innovative Corporation Pte Ltd (“Innovative”), a company in which she was a director, was engaged in another High Court suit (“the Innovative lawsuit”). The parties agreed on an extension of time till 31 May 2019 and crystallised their agreement by way of a Deed of Agreement dated 24 October 2018. Clauses 1 and 5 of the Deed of Agreement were especially relevant to this application:
Summons to enter final judgment
- [14]
[14] It is not disputed that Ms Chen had paid a total of S$1,795,725.54 towards her debt.
- [15]
[15] On 25 March 2022, HQH filed a summons to enter judgment under summons no 1314 of 2022 (“SUM 1314”). HQH applied for the following orders:
Parties’ cases in SUM 1314
- [17]
[17] Next, Ms Chen submitted that she was not legally represented when she signed the Deed of Agreement.
- [18]
[18] Lastly, Ms Chen submitted that the Principal and Supplementary Agreements were unenforceable agreements which concealed an illegal money-lending transaction.
Issues in this Suit
- [20]
[20] This application boiled down to three main issues:
- [21]
[21] On a preliminary note, I found that the arguments canvassed with respect to the Principal and Supplementary Agreements were not relevant to the court’s consideration as they concerned issues pertaining to the main dispute in this suit instead. HQH relied on the rule in Henderson v Henderson (1843) 3 Hare 100 (“the Henderson rule”) and its application in Venkatraman Kalyanaraman v Nithya Kalyani and others [2016] 4 SLR 1365 (“Venkatraman”) to argue that Ms Chen could no longer bring forth contentions pertaining to the circumstances under which the Principal and Supplementary Agreements were entered into.
- [22]
[22] As explained in Venkatraman (at [25]), the Henderson rule, also known as the extended doctrine of res judicata, “operates to preclude litigants in later proceedings from raising points not previously decided because they were not raised in the earlier proceedings, even though they could and should have been raised in those proceedings”. Hoo Sheau Peng JC (as she then was) went on to explain (at [33]) that:
Issue 1: Validity of the Revised Tomlin Order
Nature and effect of Tomlin Orders
Sub-issue 1: Whether the first Tomlin Order curtailed the court’s power to lift the stay
Sub-issue 2: Whether the stay had been lifted when parties appeared before Justice Wei to seek the Revised Tomlin Order
Issue 2: Whether subsequent agreements had modified the Revised Tomlin Order
- [41]
[41] Counsel for Ms Chen submitted that the Deed of Agreement and the Addendum were signed by Ms Chen when she was not legally represented, that the contents had not been interpreted or explained to her in her mother tongue and that Ms Chen did not fully understand the legal consequences and the impossibility of securing Innovative to pay HQH proceeds from its ongoing suit. HQH’s position was that Ms Chen had received assistance from her legal advisor, had the opportunity to seek legal advice and had been comfortable negotiating in English.
- [44]
[44] As for the Addendum:
- [50]
[50] In light of the foregoing reasons, it was not necessary for me to make a determination on whether Ms Chen had entered the Addendum and Deed of Agreement without proper legal representation and without mother-tongue interpretation. However, I briefly noted that in any event, there did not appear to be sufficient evidence to establish on a balance of probabilities that she had been unrepresented or had not understood the Deed of Agreement and the Addendum. Clause 8 of the Deed of Agreement in fact stated that the respective parties had been advised to seek independent legal advice on the agreement.
Issue 3: Whether the terms recorded in the Revised Tomlin Order should be set aside
Conclusion