General Division of the High Court · Decided 23 September 2022
Chan Hui Peng v Public Utilities Board
Feedback & support[2022] SGHC 232 · Case no. Suit No 1022 of 2018 · 41 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] In November 2020, the suit between the plaintiff (“Ms Chan”) and the defendant (“PUB”) went to trial. The trial was scheduled for two weeks but only proceeded for four days, when it was settled by Ms Chan accepting an offer to settle that PUB had earlier made.
- [2]
[2] Ms Chan was not only the plaintiff, she also testified over the four trial days. Ms Chan’s husband, Mr Sim Kwang Jui (“Mr Sim”) accompanied her to and from court on the four trial days. Mr Sim had also been subpoenaed by PUB as a witness, but his attendance as a witness was scheduled for the second week, and so he never had to attend court as a witness.
- [3]
[3] After the conclusion of the trial, Mr Sim sought payment from PUB and its lawyers, WhiteFern LLC (“WhiteFern”). Initially, he wanted to be paid for attending court on the first day of trial: for his transport to and from court, lunch, and one day’s worth of his salary. That amounted to $34.59 for transport and meal expenses (for which Mr Sim provided receipts), and $750 for Mr Sim’s time (Mr Sim said he earned $14,700 a month; $750 per day is roughly one day’s pay based on 20 working days a month).
- [4]
[4] PUB’s position was that it was not obliged to pay Mr Sim anything, but WhiteFern said they could advise PUB to pay for Mr Sim’s transport and meal expenses amounting to $34.59. Mr Sim was however not prepared to settle for that.
- [5]
[5] He said that he would be referring to the Law Society the issue of “other subpoena fees on [his] 1st day of attendance in court”. In response, WhiteFern said that the Law Society was not the proper forum for that issue, but that did not deter Mr Sim. He complained to the Law Society that PUB’s lawyers had cheated him out of payment for attending court on the first day. That complaint was dismissed at the review committee stage.
- [6]
[6] Mr Sim then filed a claim in the Small Claims Tribunals against WhiteFern. He raised his claim to $3,815.09 and alleged that he had a contract with WhiteFern for the provision of services for that contract sum – those services being his court attendance as a subpoenaed witness. Mr Sim no longer claimed for one day’s worth of court attendance, but some five days’ worth. The Small Claims Tribunals dismissed Mr Sim’s claim.
- [7]
[7] At that point, PUB offered Mr Sim $1,000 to settle the matter. That was more than what he initially wanted, which was $34.59 for transport and meal expenses, plus $750 for one day’s court attendance, totaling $784.59. But Mr Sim turned down the $1,000 offer. He said he would file a lawsuit if he was not paid $3,932.93 (slightly more than his claim amount before the Small Claims Tribunals); he also complained to the Minister of Sustainability and the Environment.
- [9]
[9] I decided that neither PUB nor its lawyers were obliged to pay Mr Sim anything for having subpoenaed him. This decision was conveyed to both PUB and Mr Sim by way of a letter from the court dated 22 September 2022. These are my full grounds of decision.
Summary of the court’s decision
Issues
- [11]
[11] The main issue may be framed as: what compensation (if any) is a subpoenaed witness entitled to, if the trial ends before he is required to attend court as a witness?
- [12]
[12] More specifically:
(a) Is Mr Sim entitled to any payment for his expenses, for having been subpoenaed?
(b) Is Mr Sim entitled to any payment for his time, for having been subpoenaed?
The applicable rules of court
- [17]
[17] The commentary further stated that Singapore had no equivalent of the provisions under the Australian rules which allow subpoenaed witnesses to be compensated for not only expenses but also loss reasonably incurred in complying with the subpoena.
Why did Mr Sim go to court?
- [21]
[21] Even before the subpoena was served on him, Mr Sim had intended to attend the trial of the suit, which was scheduled to commence on 23 November 2020.
- [22]
[22] Mr Sim mentioned his “original intention to follow [his] wife’s trial proceedings and watch after and take care of [his] wife during her trial”, and complained that he was “deprived of [his] privilege and the satisfaction of using [his] leave to sit in the court hearing to follow the actual proceeding” because he was subpoenaed as a witness and asked to leave the courtroom while other witnesses testified, as he was a material factual witness.
- [23]
[23] On 12 November 2020, Mr Sim applied for leave for the period of 23 to 27 November 2020, ie, the first week of trial. His leave application was approved the day he applied.
- [24]
[24] The subpoena was then served on him on 15 November 2020, by PUB’s lawyers WhiteFern.
- [26]
[26] In his email, Mr Sim said that he was told to appear in court on the first day of the trial, but he was not told which day he was scheduled to attend (as a witness). As such, he asserted that WhiteFern was responsible to pay for his appearance as witness for the whole trial period, ie, 23 November to 7 December 2020. He concluded by saying that if he did not hear further from WhiteFern by 5pm on 21 November, he would assume that WhiteFern had to pay him for the day(s) that he was in court; he said his monthly salary was $14,700.
- [28]
[28] That email (which Mr Sim had read before going to court on 23 November 2020) indicated that Mr Sim was not required to attend as a witness from the start of the trial: WhiteFern had said they could only inform him whether he would be required as a witness, and if so, when, after hearing back from the plaintiff’s solicitors on 23 November 2020 regarding the plaintiff’s witnesses.
- [29]
[29] No agreement was reached between Mr Sim and WhiteFern (or PUB) as to what (if anything) Mr Sim should be paid for attending court. Instead, WhiteFern asked Mr Sim for documentary evidence pertaining to his request for payment:
(a) documents evidencing his monthly income of $14,700;
(b) his company’s confirmation that it would not be paying Mr Sim for his attendance at trial;
(c) his application for leave; and
(d) his leave approval from his company.
- [30]
[30] Mr Sim only responded to WhiteFern on this on 7 December 2020, by which time the trial had already ended with Ms Chan accepting an offer to settle that PUB had made earlier. The last full day of trial was Thursday, 26 November 2020. On Friday, 27 November 2020, the court was informed that the matter had been settled; the remainder of the trial was vacated, and the subpoenas issued (including that to Mr Sim) were discharged. Mr Sim thus never had to attend court as a witness.
- [31]
[31] Indeed, Mr Sim never did attend court as a witness. He accompanied his wife to court for the start of the trial on Monday, 23 November 2020, but this was what he had always intended to do; it was not because he had been subpoenaed as a witness by PUB.
- [32]
[32] When the trial started, WhiteFern raised the issue of Mr Sim’s presence right away:
(a) WhiteFern said that as Mr Sim was a potential witness, he should not remain in the courtroom;
(b) Ms Chan’s lawyers said that they would leave it to the court whether Mr Sim should be sitting in the courtroom or not;
(c) WhiteFern indicated that Mr Sim would not be required to attend until 1 December 2020, and asked that he be excused from attending court until then;
(d) the court then asked Mr Sim to leave the courtroom and wait for WhiteFern to let him know when he was required to come back as a witness – it was explained to him that he was a potential factual witness covering some ground that earlier witnesses would be covering, and so he should not be in the courtroom until it was his turn to testify;
(e) Mr Sim’s attendance as a witness was scheduled for 2.30pm on 1 December 2020, unless he heard otherwise from WhiteFern or the court; his mother’s attendance (likewise on subpoena) was scheduled for 10am on 1 December 2020 and Mr Sim was informed that he could accompany her to court that morning;
(f) Mr Sim was then excused from the trial – it was then around 10.33am, and Mr Sim was thus present at the trial for only around half an hour; and
(g) Mr Sim left the courtroom, but he did not leave the court building – he stayed outside the courtroom while the trial was in session, not only for the rest of 23 November 2020, but also on 24, 25, and 26 November 2020.
Mr Sim’s position
- [33]
[33] Mr Sim now claims the sum of $7,826.28, for which he provides the following breakdown (in his own words, from para 6.10 of his 23 August 2022 submission):
Mr Sim did not spend time or incur expenses complying with the subpoena
- [36]
[36] Although Mr Sim was expressly excused (and, indeed, excluded) from the trial by around 10.33am on the first day of trial (23 November 2020), he stayed at the court building (but outside the courtroom) while the trial was in progress until the end of that day, going home only after 6pm; and he again returned to the court building on 24, 25, and 26 November 2020 although the trial court had told him to return to the trial at 2.30pm on 1 December 2020, and not to sit in while earlier witnesses were testifying.
- [37]
[37] Mr Sim’s latest email of 2 September 2022 reinforces the point that he was just accompanying his wife to and from court. He says he had to chaperone and escort her from home to court, and back, on those four days; they travelled together in the same taxis. He further says he made all the logistical arrangements including the payment of taxi fares, “to ensure that Ms Chan was able to appear and attend the Court as required.” Had Mr Sim never been served with the subpoena, he would have behaved no differently: he would have accompanied his wife, as he did.
- [38]
[38] Indeed, it is clear from what Mr Sim himself says that his complaint is not about having to attend court because he was subpoenaed; it is about not being able to attend the trial because he was subpoenaed. However, what a witness might receive as expenses of attending on a subpoena has nothing to do with compensating him for not being permitted to sit in while earlier witnesses testify.
- [39]
[39] In any event, Mr Sim does not deserve any compensation in that regard. If Mr Sim were aggrieved at the subpoena keeping him out of the trial, he could have applied to set aside the subpoena – or he could have suggested that his wife (who was legally represented) do so – but there was no application to set aside the subpoena. Or Mr Sim could have sought to persuade the court to reconsider its decision to exclude him from the trial while earlier witnesses testified, but he did not do that either, nor did his wife. Instead, his wife’s lawyers simply said, “He will be a witness of fact. I leave it to your Honour’s ruling on whether he should be sitting in the courtroom or not.” The court then asked Mr Sim to leave the courtroom, and not to be present while earlier witnesses testified, and the matter rested there.
Mr Sim’s heads of claim
Actual Time in court for Nov-23 to 26 (4 days) and 1 day cancellation @ 766.67 x 5
Time spent at the court building
- [43]
[43] PUB submitted that if I were minded to fix Mr Sim’s attendance claim, allowing the claim for half a day for the morning of 23 November 2020 at a rate of $750 a day, ie, $375, would be fair and reasonable. $750 is the per day rate Mr Sim had used in his request to PUB and WhiteFern (which he thereafter revised to $766.67).
- [44]
[44] Mr Sim was present at the trial for only half an hour, and if he were entitled to any compensation for that, $375 for half a day as suggested by PUB (or a slightly higher $383.34 using the rate now suggested by Mr Sim) would be ample.
- [47]
[47] Moreover, after the lunch break on 26 November 2022, WhiteFern informed the court that PUB would not require Mr Sim as a witness at all, and Ms Chan’s lawyers agreed to inform Mr Sim of this. However, Ms Chan continued to testify till the end of the day, and Mr Sim continued to wait outside the courtroom; they then travelled home together. This reinforces the conclusion that Mr Sim’s attendance in court in the period of 23–26 November 2022 was unrelated to the subpoena; he was just accompanying his wife, the plaintiff.
Cancellation fees
- [48]
[48] There is no basis for Mr Sim to get anything on his claim for 1-day cancellation fees. The trial effectively ended on 26 November 2020 because Ms Chan accepted PUB’s offer to settle; in the morning of 27 November 2020 (a day on which Mr Sim did not come to court), the court was informed of the settlement, vacated the rest of the trial, discharged the subpoenas, and gave further directions. If Mr Sim truly believed he was obliged to turn up at the court every day until his subpoena was discharged, he should have been there on 27 November 2020, but he was not (and neither was his wife, and so he did not need to accompany her to court).
Transport to and fro cost of @$25 per day with sub-total $109.59 (including receipt of $34.59 on Day 1 for Taxi and lunch meal)
- [50]
[50] Mr Sim provided receipts for taxi fare and lunch on 23 November 2020:
(a) $9 taxi fare for a trip from 9.10am to 9.19am;
(b) $10.30 for a takeaway meal at 1.24pm;
(c) $15.29 taxi fare for a trip from 6.08pm to 6.28pm.
- [51]
[51] Mr Sim’s transport claim of $25 per day for the three subsequent days appears to be based on his taxi fares totalling $24.29 for 23 November 2020 (rounded up to $25).
- [52]
[52] If Mr Sim’s presence in the trial for half an hour were regarded as attendance on the subpoena, he should only be reimbursed for his taxi fares to and from court, ie, $24.29.
- [53]
[53] PUB’s position is that at most Mr Sim should be allowed his transport and meal expenses incurred on 23 November 2020. In my view, however, as Mr Sim was told to leave the trial at around 10.33am, it was not reasonably necessary for him to have stayed till lunchtime (after 1pm), and then to charge his lunch expenses to PUB. Accordingly, the court would not award Mr Sim his lunch expenses, even if he were regarded as having attended court on the subpoena for half an hour that morning. In his email of 2 September 2022, Mr Sim says that he “had not included the claim of [his] entitled meals for the 2nd to 4th day”. Mr Sim however had no entitlement to eat at PUB’s expense on the 2nd to 4th day of trial, and any claim for these meal expenses would have been dismissed.
- [54]
[54] Even awarding Mr Sim his transport expenses would have been problematic, for (as Mr Sim confirmed) he had travelled to and from court together with his wife. His wife would have travelled to and from court in any event, as she was the plaintiff, and testifying as a witness. Mr Sim did not incur any additional travel expenses on account of being served with the subpoena.
Other legal filing fees & costs - filing Complaint to Law Society & SCT $ 73.34
- [56]
[56] Mr Sim sought to be compensated for proceedings he had unsuccessfully commenced. Both the Law Society complaint and the Small Claims Tribunals claim were dismissed. There is no basis to compensate Mr Sim for unsuccessfully pursuing proceedings against WhiteFern for payment that he was not entitled to.
- [58]
[58] WhiteFern was in any event not the party liable to compensate Mr Sim: if Mr Sim ought to be compensated, PUB was the party liable to compensate him. As the court in Lam Hwa put it at [20], it is “[t]he litigant who subpoenas the witness” who is obliged to compensate the witness. That litigant was PUB (the defendant to Ms Chan’s claim), not WhiteFern (PUB’s lawyers).
Disbursement (Transport and Printing costs) $75
Litigant time costs (as the court deems appropriate for 37 hours spent) $ 3,543
- [62]
[62] Moreover, Mr Sim’s rate of $766 per day is questionable. It is based on his previous salary of $14,700 per month with his previous employer, Targo Technology GmbH Singapore branch (“Targo”). It appears that Mr Sim revised his per day rate from $750 per day (which was what he had initially been claiming) to $766 per day because that was the rate Targo used (based on 260 working days a year, ie, around 21 working days a month) in encashing his untaken leave. This was reflected in a document entitled “Resignee salary computation for the month of January 2021” which Mr Sim provided. The same document shows Mr Sim’s resignation date (presumably meaning his last day as a Targo employee) as 31 January 2021.
- [64]
[64] I did not accept Mr Sim’s contention that reasonable compensation to a litigant-in-person is to be computed according to the person’s work income. That would mean that a successful litigant-in-person who has no work income, eg, a homemaker, or a retiree, would get no compensation for the time and work required for the proceedings: this cannot be right. But in so far as work income is a relevant consideration, Mr Sim failed to substantiate what his work income was (if he had any) after his resignation on 31 January 2021.
Conclusion
- [69]
[69] Mr Sim was served with a subpoena, but the trial ended before he was scheduled to attend as a witness. He went to court because he was accompanying his wife, the plaintiff; he did not do so as a subpoenaed witness. Mr Sim did not spend time or incur expenses in complying with the subpoena for which he ought reasonably to be compensated. He is not entitled to any payment from PUB or its lawyers WhiteFern for having been served with the subpoena. Mr Sim’s claims for payment are dismissed.
- [70]
[70] Mr Sim has spent the better part of two years pursuing payment that he is not entitled to. He should stop chasing after the wind.