Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 24 Nov 2022

General Division of the High Court

Public Prosecutor v Mohamed Aliff bin Mohamed Yusoff

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHC 295Case no. Criminal Case No 21 of 2022

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The accused, Mohamed Aliff bin Mohamed Yusoff (“the accused”), claimed trial to a charge of murder under s 300(c) of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) (“PC”). The alleged victim was 9-month-old Izz Fayyaz Zayani bin Ahmad (“Izz”), the son of the accused’s then girlfriend Nadiah bite Abdul Jalil (“Nadiah”).

  3. [2] The Prosecution’s case was that the accused had pushed Izz’s head against the wooden floorboard in the rear cabin of his van twice, thereby inflicting blunt force trauma to Izz’s head which resulted in fatal brain injuries. The Prosecution contended that the accused had done so intentionally. The accused’s defence, on the other hand, was that Izz’s death had been an accident. According to the case for the Defence which was filed on his behalf, at the material time, the accused and Izz had been next to the accused’s van: the accused had been holding Izz in his right arm while holding a plastic bag and a packet of “kitchen tissue” in his left hand. As the accused was trying to close the van door with his left hand, Izz “fidgeted and fell out from [his] right arm”. According to the accused, Izz fell “head down first, hitting the wooden floorboard of the van, then the edge near to the door of the van and finally falling to the ground”.

  4. [3] Following a seven-day trial, I convicted the accused of the charge of murder under s 300(c) of the PC. Having heard submissions on sentencing from both the Prosecution and the Defence, I sentenced the accused to a term of life imprisonment and 15 strokes of the cane.

  5. [4] As the accused has filed an appeal against both his conviction and sentence, I set out below the reasons for my decision.

  6. The charge

  7. [5] The accused was charged as follows:

  8. The agreed facts

  9. Background

  10. [6] The following facts were not disputed. The accused got to know Nadiah through Instagram sometime in 2017 or 2018, and became romantically involved with her in September or October 2019.

  11. [7] Izz was Nadiah’s son from her previous marriage. He was born in January 2019.

  12. Events on 7 November 2019

  13. [8] On the evening of 7 November 2019, the accused drove Nadiah and Izz in his van GBE 4012P (“the van”) to Wisteria Mall, where they had dinner. This was a van purchased by the accused, Nadiah and her brother Ahmad Faris bin Abdul Jalil (“Faris”) for their delivery business.

  14. [9] During the dinner, Izz accidentally spilled Nadiah’s drink. The accused carried Izz away to clean him up while Nadiah continued with her meal. Nadiah subsequently went to the nursing room to clean Izz’s milk bottle. While Nadiah was doing this, the accused left the nursing room with Izz and told her that he would meet her at the van. After washing Izz’s milk bottle, Nadiah found the accused and Izz in the van at the Wisteria Mall carpark.

  15. [10] On leaving the Wisteria Mall carpark, the accused drove to Nadiah’s mother’s flat at Choa Chu Kang (“the Choa Chu Kang flat”). He volunteered to bring Izz to his house in Yishun (“the Yishun home”) and to take care of him for the night. Nadiah agreed to this arrangement as she was due at work the next day and would not be able to look after Izz while at work. She intended to stay over at Faris’s flat in Jurong East (“the Jurong East flat”) as it was closer to the location where she would need to report for work the next day.

  16. [11] The three of them arrived at Choa Chu Kang sometime after 9.00 p.m. Nadiah went upstairs to her mother’s flat to collect her personal belongings and to pack essential items for Izz in a baby bag. She then handed the baby bag to the accused before taking a private hire vehicle to the Jurong East flat.

  17. [12] According to the accused’s statements to the police, after being left alone with Izz, he drove the van to a multistorey carpark in Yishun (“the Yishun MSCP”) and parked there at about 10.08 p.m. Izz was seated in the front passenger seat during the journey. While the accused was still at the MSCP, he exchanged text messages with his father via WhatsApp at about 10.51 p.m. on whether it was convenient for him to bring Izz to his father’s house. After the WhatsApp exchange with his father, the accused left Izz in the rear cabin of the locked van while he made a trip to a nearby Sheng Shiong supermarket. This was at11.02 p.m. At the supermarket, the accused purchased some items before returning to the van.

  18. [13] Sometime after his return to the van, the accused called Nadiah several times. Nadiah did not pick up these calls but subsequently returned his call sometime close to midnight on 8 November 2019. The accused asked Nadiah to meet him, telling her that he had something to tell her. Nadiah agreed and took a private hire vehicle to meet him.

  19. Meeting with the accused on 8 November 2019

  20. [14] Nadiah met the accused at the main road near Strategy Building (which was close to Jurong East MRT station). After driving off with Nadiah in the front passenger seat, the accused held her hand and repeatedly told her that he did not want her to leave him. At some point, he stopped the van and went to the rear cabin of the van with Nadiah. Izz was then lying in a supine position on the floorboard of the rear cabin. Nadiah put on the baby carrier. She then returned to the front passenger seat, carrying Izz in the baby carrier, whereupon the accused drove off.

  21. [15] As he drove, the accused told Nadiah that he had been carrying baby items in one hand and Izz in his other arm whilst trying to close the door of the van. According to him, Izz suddenly fidgeted and fell headfirst onto the floorboard of the van, bounced, and hit his head again on the footrest of the van, before finally falling onto the carpark floor.

  22. [16] The accused eventually agreed to bring Izz to the hospital, but told Nadiah that they should tell the hospital the following: the accused was carrying Izz’s essentials in one hand and Izz on his other hand while trying to close the van door; Izz suddenly fidgeted and fell onto the floorboard of the van, bounced, and hit his head a second time on the footstep of the van before falling onto the floor headfirst; the accused called Nadiah and that was why he did not call for an ambulance; Izz was still warm when Nadiah arrived, and it was when he turned cold that they proceeded to the hospital.

  23. [17] After Nadiah agreed to relate the above-mentioned sequence of events to the hospital, the accused drove to the National University Hospital (“NUH”).

  24. Arrival at National University Hospital (“NUH”)

  25. [18] Upon reaching NUH, the accused parked his van at the NUH basement carpark. As they were walking to the Accident and Emergency Department (“A&E”), he told Nadiah that he wanted to discard one of his mobile phones. Nadiah sat at the NUH Kopitiam while the accused went to look for a place where he could discard the phone, but eventually she started walking towards the AEE. The accused then told her they should make a detour to the bus-stop area outside the A&E; and it was as they were nearing this bus-stop that the accused threw his mobile phone into the bushes. Thereafter, they proceeded to the A&E, where Nadiah fainted and Izz was handed over to medical personnel. By then, it was about 4.20 a.m. on 8 November 2019. Izz was pronounced dead a short while later at 4.30 a.m.

  26. Ensuing police investigations and arrest

  27. [19] Senior Staff Sergeant Lim Kim Huat (“SSSgt Lim Kim Huat”) and his partner were despatched to NUH to attend to the case. They arrived at the A&E at 5.03 a.m. There, SSSgt Lim ascertained that the deceased was Izz, and that he had been pronounced dead at 4.30 a.m. after having been brought to NUH by Nadiah and the accused. SSSgt Lim then interviewed the accused who related to him the following sequence of events: the accused had been holding on to Izz with one hand while packing some items, and Izz had struggled, falling out of his arm onto the floorboard of the van before hitting the ground. The accused told SSSgt Lim that he had met up with Nadiah after Izz’s fall, and that they had decided to bring Izz to NUH after he lost consciousness. The accused also claimed that he had performed CPR on Izz prior to arriving at NUH.

  28. [20] After interviewing the accused, SSSgt Lim reported his findings to Assistant Superintendent Chen Shunli (“ASP Jason”). ASP Jason proceeded to NUH with Senior Staff Sergeant Abu Hamid bin Abu Shama (“SSSgt Abu Hamid”) and met up with SSSgt Lim Kim Huat. ASP Jason then interviewed the accused who gave an account of events similar to the account he had given SSSgt Lim.

  29. [21] At about 12.23 p.m. on 8 November 2019, the accused was escorted back to Woodlands Police Division Headquarters (“Woodlands Police”) to assist with investigations into Izz’s death. From Woodlands Police, he was next escorted to Police Cantonment Complex (“PCC”) and handed over to the Special Investigation Section of the Criminal Investigation Department at about 3.50 p.m. He was subsequently placed under arrest at PCC in connection with Izz’s death.

  30. The Prosecution’s case

  31. [22] As noted at [2], the Prosecution’s case was that the accused had inflicted blunt force trauma on Izz’s head by intentionally pushing or slamming Izz’s head against the floorboard of the van twice. This caused Izz to sustain traumatic intracranial hemorrhage which was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death.

  32. The Defence’s case

  33. [23] As I also noted at the outset (at [2]), the Defence denied that Izz’s death was caused by an intentional act on the accused’s part. According to the case which the Defence ran at trial , the accused had left Izz in the rear cabin of the van – which was then parked in a multi-storey carpark – while he visited a nearby supermarket. On returning to the van, the accused had opened the van door and picked Izz up. He then held Izz in his right arm while holding a plastic bag in his left hand. As he was trying to close the van door, Izz fidgeted, fell out of his arm onto the floorboard of the van, and then onto the footrest of the van, before finally falling on the ground outside the van.

  34. The evidence adduced

  35. [24] I now summarise below the evidence adduced at trial.

  36. Witnesses called by the Prosecution

  37. SSSgt Lim Kim Huat

  38. [25] SSSgt Lim Kim Huat produced the body-worn camera (“BWC”) footage of his interview of the accused at NUH at about 5.27 a.m. In his conditioned statement, SSSgt Lim Kim Huat recalled that during the interview, the accused had said that Izz “struggled and fell onto the floorboard of the motor van”. The accused also told SSSgt Lim Kim Huat that Izz had been responsive following the fall; that he (the accused) had contacted Izz’s mother and met up with her; and that the two of them had “monitored” Izz’s condition before eventually deciding to bring him to NUH when he “lost consciousness”.

  39. [26] In cross-examination at trial, the Defence contended that the accused had used the expression “fidgeted” and not “struggled”. In response, SSSgt Lim Kim Huat clarified that the accused had said that Izz “wriggled and fell off”: SSSgt Lim Kim Huat had written it down as “struggled”, as he felt that the two words had “almost same meaning”. In any event, as SSSgt Lim Kim Huat explained, he had been conducting only a preliminary interview with the accused, not a statement recording.

  40. SSSgt Abu Hamid bin Abu Shama (“SSSgt Abu Hamid”)

  41. [27] SSSgt Abu Hamid accompanied ASP Jason to NUH following a call from SSSgt Lim Kim Huat. After the accused was interviewed by ASP Jason, SSSgt Abu Hamid recorded a statement from the accused from about 6.15 a.m. to about 6.50 a.m. under s 22 of the Criminal Procedure Code 2010 (2020 Rev Ed) (“CPC”). He asked the accused questions in Malay and the accused replied in Malay. SSSgt Abu Hamid then recorded the answers in English.

  42. ASP Chen Shun Li (“ASP Jason”)

  43. [28] In his conditioned statement, ASP Jason stated that as the incident had taken place within the jurisdiction of Woodlands Police Division, the case was referred to Woodlands Police Division. He stated that he had interviewed the accused upon arriving at NUH together with SSSgt Abu Hamid at about 5.50 am on 8 November 2019. The accused told ASP Jason that he had been “packing [Izz’s] items inside his motor van” while "holding onto [Izz] with one arm”. According to the accused, Izz had “struggled and fell onto the floorboard of the motor van”. The accused also stated that Izz had been responsive following the fall; that he (the accused) had contacted Izz’s mother and met up with her; and that they had “observed” Izz’s condition before eventually deciding to bring him to NUH when he “lost consciousness”.

  44. [29] In cross-examination at trial, ASP Jason was questioned on his use of the word “struggled” instead of “fidgeted”. He stated that to the best of his memory, the word “struggled” was what the accused had used at the time.

  45. ASP Ng Liang Jie (“ASP Ng”)

  46. [30] ASP Ng is a Senior Investigation Officer with the Woodlands Police Division. The case of Izz’s death was referred to him on 8 November 2019 at about 6.20 a.m. He contacted SSI Mazlan bin Shariff (“SSI Mazlan”), the Duty Officer from the Special Investigation Section of the Criminal Investigation Department (“CID”) as the case was a “sensitive” one involving “injuries on the baby”. At about 8.35 a.m. on 8 November 2019, ASP Ng arrived at NUH to take over the case from ASP Jason, and he interviewed the accused in the A&E.

  47. [31] At about 12.23 p.m., ASP Ng, together with ASP Tan Teng Hong Colin and Staff Sergeant Lim Wei, left NUH with the accused for Woodlands Police Station. They arrived at Woodlands Police Station at about 12.55 p.m. and brought the accused to Interview Room 2. At about 1.05 p.m., SSI Mazlan commenced his interview with the accused inside the interview room while ASP Ng stood guard. The interview, which was conducted in Malay, concluded at 1.55 p.m.

  48. ASP Ang Ghim Sing (“ASP Ang”)

  49. [32] ASP Ang of CID was the investigating officer (“IO”) in this case. On 8 November 2019, ASP Ang requested that Inspector Daniel Lim Boon Wah (“Insp Daniel Lim”) and Station Inspector Muralidaran s/o Balakrishnan take over custody of the accused from officers at Woodlands Police. The accused had been referred to the CID’s Special Investigation Section as he was a person of interest in Izz’s unnatural death.

  50. [33] On 8 November 2019 at about 7.30 p.m., ASP Ang informed SSI Mazlan that the accused would be placed under arrest for the offence of voluntarily causing grievous hurt and requested that he record a statement from the accused. At about 9.00 p.m., ASP Ang prepared and handed over to Superintendent of Police Koh Yu Shan, Cyndi (“Supt Cyndi Koh”) a typewritten charge of voluntarily causing grievous hurt and requested that she record a cautioned statement from the accused in respect of this charge.

  51. [34] Between 11 November and 21 November 2019, ASP Ang recorded multiple statements from the accused with the assistance of Malay interpreter Mdm Sapiahtun Mohd Ali (“Mdm Sapiahtun”). In addition, on 21 November 2019, he escorted the accused to the basement carpark at PCC where the accused’s van was parked: a re-enactment of the incident was conducted, with ASP Ang also asking the accused questions and Mdm Sapiahtun interpreting.

  52. Nadiah

  53. [35] In Nadiah’s conditioned statement, she provided an account of the events of 7 and 8 November 2019. According to Nadiah, there was a verbal disagreement between her and the accused at Wisteria Mall on 7 November 2019, because inter alia the accused questioned why she had not disciplined Izz for spilling her drink at dinner: according to Nadiah, the accused had been “very pissed off” and “angry” when Izz spilt the drink at dinner; and he had asked her to “scold Izz”, but she had disagreed. Subsequently, however, when the accused volunteered to take care of Izz for the night by bringing him back to his home in Yishun, Nadiah agreed because she was going to work the next day and her mother was unable to look after Izz. At that point, she also believed that the accused’s parents would be able to help take care of Izz since he was staying with his parents in Yishun.

  54. [36] In examination-in-chief, Nadiah was referred to a series of WhatsApp messages which she had exchanged with the accused between 10.36 p.m. and 10.43 p.m. on 7 November 2019 (ie, after he had dropped her off at her parents’ flat); in particular, to a message which she had sent the accused at 10.36 p.m. in which she had said (inter alia), “Sorry about just nw [sic]”, and another message from her at 10.38 p.m. in which she had said (inter alia), “Please don’t give up on me or Izz. I want you not to feel pissed off easily. I want you to be more patience [sic] n gv me time to learn being an independent mum”. Nadiah explained that when she told the accused she was “sorry about just now”, she had been referring to the incident in which Izz had spilt the drink at dinner; and she had apologised to the accused as she did not want to argue further with him. She had asked the accused not to “feel pissed off easily” because she wanted “[her] son to be safe as well”; and moreover, she was having "some problems with [her] marriage” at the time and had “no one else to actually talk to”.

  55. [37] Sometime past midnight on 8 November 2019, the accused called Nadiah on her mobile phone, sounding “panicky”, and told her that he needed to see her urgently. Although she asked him why they needed to meet so urgently, he did not tell her the reason.

  56. [38] When Nadiah met the accused at the main road near Strategy Building and got into the front passenger seat of the van, she found that the accused was behaving strangely: he held her hand and kept repeating that he did not want her to leave him. As they drove off, Nadiah repeatedly asked the accused what had happened, but the only response she received from him was that he would explain later. At this time, Nadiah was under the impression that Izz was still with the accused’s parents at their Yishun flat.

  57. [39] The accused drove aimlessly and did not appear to know where he was going – though he did mention that he wanted to avoid roadblocks. At this point, Nadiah turned her head and saw Izz lying on the floor of the rear cabin. When she asked the accused what had happened, he replied, “Izz tak ada”. Nadiah understood this to mean that Izz had passed away. The accused said that he had been playing with his mobile phone at the rear cabin when Izz “fell off the rear cabin onto the ground”. Nadiah reprimanded him for not pulling Izz to safety when he saw Izz crawling out of the van, but the accused claimed that things had “happened too fast”. When Nadiah asked why he had not called for an ambulance, the accused replied that he had wanted to inform her first.

  58. [40] The accused then stopped the van, whereupon Nadiah went to the rear cabin and saw Izz lying in a supine position on the floorboard. She put on the baby carrier which was spread beneath Izz’s body and strapped Izz into it. When she touched Izz, she could feel that his neck was “not flexible, unlike when [she had] carried him previously when he was sleeping”. While Izz’s body was warm to the touch, it was “not the usual temperature, and was somewhat cooler than usual”.

  59. [41] With Izz strapped in the baby carrier and his face against her chest, Nadiah returned to the front passenger seat, and the accused drove off. Nadiah held Izz’s hands and caressed his neck – but there was no response. At this point, she knew Izz was dead.

  60. [42] Somewhere around Jurong, the accused stopped the van and got out. Nadiah did not know where he went, but she felt that he was “delaying the time to go to the hospital”. When he returned to the van, he asked Nadiah if he should call for an ambulance or bring Izz straight to hospital. Nadiah suggested bringing Izz to hospital, but the accused was undecided. Instead, he continued driving; and as he was driving, he pointed at Izz’s forehead and asked her how long the “wound would take to heal”. It was at this point that Nadiah noticed three bruises on Izz’s forehead, at the center and the left and right sides of his forehead.

  61. [43] Nadiah told the accused that the bruises “would not heal fast”. The accused then told her the following version of events: according to the accused, he had been carrying the baby items in one hand and Izz in his other arm whilst trying to close the van door. Izz “suddenly fidgeted” and “fell headfirst onto the plywood floorboard of the van, bounced, hit his head a second time on the footrest of the van, before finally falling onto the carpark floor”. The accused told Nadiah that “if anyone asked what happened to Izz”, the two of them “should tell them the same story so that he would not get into any trouble”.

  62. [44] By this time, Nadiah was confused and in shock: she just wanted to bring Izz to the hospital. The accused agreed to do so. A short while later, however, he changed his mind. He suggested to her that they should instead pay someone to bury Izz, and that “maybe a year later [they] could report to the Police that Izz was missing”. Nadiah refused and insisted that Izz should be accorded a proper Muslim burial. The accused eventually agreed, and told her the story that he was going to tell the hospital:

  63. (a) The accused was carrying Izz’s essentials in one hand and Izz in his other hand while trying to close the van door;

  64. (b) Izz suddenly fidgeted and fell on the van floorboard. He hit his head, bounced, hit his head a second time on the footstep and finally fell onto the floor headfirst;

  65. (c) Izz’s body was still warm and there was a weak pulse at about 1.00 a.m;

  66. (d) The accused tried to revive Izz by giving him Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (“CPR”);

  67. (e) The accused called Nadiah and that was why he did not call the ambulance;

  68. (f) Izz was still warm when the accused met Nadiah; and

  69. (g) Izz started to turn cold and they proceeded to the hospital.

  70. [45] Nadiah agreed to this and the accused then drove to NUH. In cross-examination at trial, Nadiah explained that at this juncture, her mind had been in a mess and she did not know at the time that the accused was not telling the truth about Izz’s death.

  71. [46] Upon arriving at NUH, the accused told Nadiah that he feared being remanded by the police and wanted to brush his teeth and wipe his body. He then left the van while she waited inside the van. She felt again that he was “delaying time before [they] sought help from a doctor”.

  72. [47] When they finally walked into the A&E department at NUH, the accused told her that he wanted to discard one of his two mobile phones as it contained evidence of him selling vape or vape juice. Nadiah sat at the Kopitiam within NUH while the accused went to look for a suitable spot to discard his phone. When she became impatient and started walking towards the A&E, the accused came up from behind her and suggested making a detour to the bus stop outside so that he could discard his phone. As they approached the bus stop, Nadiah heard the sound of something “heavy” being thrown into the bushes. They proceeded to the A&E after she told him that she was “feeling weak” and “not able to bear it much longer”.

  73. [48] On arriving at the NUH A&E, Nadiah fainted. She did not know what happened next.

  74. Ahmad Faris bin Abdul Jalil

  75. [49] Nadiah’s brother Faris stated that Nadiah had arrived at his Jurong East flat at about 10 p.m. on 7 November 2019. After going to bed himself, Faris woke up at 7.00 a.m. on 8 November 2019 to find six missed calls from Nadiah on his phone and also a text message from Nadiah asking him to call her urgently. When he called her, the accused answered the call. The accused informed Faris that they were at NUH and that Izz had passed away after a fall. Faris was told not to tell anyone and to head to NUH immediately.

  76. Mohamed Yusoff bin Osman (“Yusoff”)

  77. [50] Yusoff is the accused’s father. He received a WhatsApp message from the accused at about 10.51 p.m. on 7 November 2021 in which the accused stated that he was bringing a friend’s son home. Yusoff texted the accused back to tell him that it was not convenient for him to come back at that time as there were people in the living-room of their flat. In cross-examination at trial, Yusoff explained that by sending this response, he did not mean that the accused could not bring Izz back to the flat: what he had in mind was that the accused should not do so at that particular point in time, as he was afraid that if the accused brought the child back at that time, his wife (ie the accused’s mother) and his daughter (ie the accused’s sister) would “not be happy” .

  78. Dr Ian Tan Kai Zhi (“Dr Tan”)

  79. [51] Dr Tan attended to Izz when he was brought to the NUH A&E on 8 November 2019. In his medical report dated 20 November 2019, Dr Tan noted that the accused had described the following sequence of events to him: at “approximately 0000H” on 8 November 2019, Izz “had fallen out of [the accused’s] arms and his forehead collided with the edge of the van before landin prone on the car-park floor”. The accused claimed that following the fall, Izz did not lose consciousness and was “still active and crying”; that he (the accused) had contacted Izz’s mother and met up with her at “approximately 0100H”; that Izz “still had a pulse and was breathing” between 0100H and 0300H, and only “suddenly became unresponsive at 0300H”, at which point he and Izz’s mother had “performed CPR” on Izz “for a few minutes”.

  80. [52] In his medical report, Dr Tan opined that the history and account of the mechanism of Izz’s injuries as provided by the accused were not consistent with the three forehead bruises he found on Izz. He also opined that the shape of the linear horizontal bruises observed on Izz’s lower limb were not typical of accidental injuries sustained by a 9-month-old child. Further, the bruises over his lower back and anterior abdomen were not typical locations of bruises sustained following an accidental fall. In cross-examination at trial, Dr Tan testified that if Izz had indeed fallen on a flat surface as the accused claimed, then such a fall would not have caused the three discrete well-defined bruises he observed on Izz’s forehead: instead, such a fall would usually cause one or two poorly-defined bruises.

  81. [53] Moreover, Dr Tan noted that there was an unexplained delay of approximately one hour in seeking urgent medical help for an unresponsive infant with a recent high risk head injury. Given the delay in seeking treatment as well as the inconsistencies between the alleged history provided by the accused and the physical examination findings at NUH, Dr Tan was of the view that there were grounds for suspecting that Izz’s injuries were non-accidental.

  82. Dr Cheow Enquan (“Dr Cheow”)

  83. [55] Dr Cheow of the Institute of Mental Health (“IMH”) conducted the forensic psychiatric evaluation of the accused, for which purpose he interviewed the accused on three occasions before issuing a report dated 10 December 2019. In gist, Dr Cheow’s opinion was that the accused was fit to stand trial and not of unsound mind at the time of the alleged offence.

  84. [56] The accused’s background and personal history were set out in some detail by Dr Cheow in his report. The accused is divorced, with a 2-year-old daughter who is in the custody of his former wife. He also has a 3-year-old son who lives with his former girlfriend. The accused studied Marine Engineering at a local polytechnic, but dropped out due to financial constraints. In October 2010, he was first seen at IMH when he felt stressed after breaking up with his girlfriend. He was assessed to have no mental illness. He did not complete his National Service, having been medically downgraded and discharged on psychiatric grounds. He was referred to IMH in December 2010, and again in January 2011 by the SAF Medical Officer, for having suicidal and homicidal thoughts: he was diagnosed with an adjustment disorder. During his interviews with Dr Cheow, however, he told the latter that he had “actually lied about being suicidal and having homicidal thoughts towards others during his national service, as he was simply unwilling to serve in the SAF (Singapore Armed Forces)”.

  85. [57] The accused’s next visit to IMH was in December 2015. He was brought there by the police following a quarrel with his fiancée. On that occasion, his father had tried to intervene, which led to his becoming more agitated and allegedly injuring his father’s finger “accidentally”. He was diagnosed with an “acute stress reaction” and with “anger management issues”.

  86. [58] Prior to the 7 November 2019 incident involving Izz, the accused’s last visit to IMH was in July 2017. This was for the purpose of a medical report, as he had been referred to IMH by the Child Protection Services (“CPS”). His then fiancée (whom he later married and then divorced) had reported being physically assaulted by him, and had also reported that he had “pinched and verbally threatened” their son. In the IMH report, the accused was noted to have been sarcastic towards the psychiatrist and to be easily provoked. He was assessed as not meeting the diagnostic criteria for a mental disorder. However, the report noted that he had personality traits such as being prone to anger outbursts and making suicidal/homicidal threats, and that these behaviours were pervasive and causing distress to others”. Psychotherapy for anger management was recommended, but the accused “did not see any problem with his behaviour and did not see the need for intervention”.

  87. [60] Dr Cheow noted that after providing the above version of events, the accused changed his position during his second and third interviews. He claimed that the account he had previously provided “was as per the SOF”, but that he had “said the wrong thing” as he was in a “state of panic”, allegedly as a result of “coercive interrogation techniques” used by the police. The accused’s subsequent, altered account of events ran as follows:

  88. [61] Dr Cheow’s assessment was that the accused had “impulsive personality traits characterised by being prone to anger outbursts with a propensity to react with violent or suicidal threats”. In his report, Dr Cheow stated that despite the accused’s denial of past physical violence, his then-fiancée had reported physical assaults on herself and her son by the accused. In cross-examination at trial, Dr Cheow testified that he did not know whether there was medical evidence or documentary evidence available to support the then-fiancée’s claims: what he had stated in his report was what he had found in the accused’s past IMH records.

  89. Dr Wong Choong Yi Peter (“Dr Wong”)

  90. [62] Dr Wong was asked by the police to provide an expert opinion on Izz’s clavicle report. He was provided the clinical notes and autopsy report for Izz. The following two video recordings were also provided to him:

  91. (a) The first video, dated 3 November 2019 (the “3rd Nov Video”), showed Izz supporting the weight of his torso on both arms in crawling position, while climbing onto a mattress with some hesitation. Dr Wong opined that based on Izz’s vocalisations and facial expressions, he might have been in some discomfort when doing so.

  92. (b) The second video was dated 5 November 2019 (the “5th Nov Video”). It showed Izz crawling on the floor using both outstretched arms and pulling himself into a standing position by holding on to a piece of furniture (sideboard), while using his right hand to reach for and grasp packets of food on the sideboard. Dr Wong opined that Izz did not appear to be in discomfort when doing so.

  93. [63] According to Dr Wong, clavicle fractures are common accidental injuries in young children. Given Nadiah’s account of an earlier injury on 2 November 2019 and photographs showing swelling over Izz’s left clavicle on 3 November 2019, Dr Wong’s view was that the fracture “may have been present” prior to the events in the van on 7 November 2019. In his view, the pathologist was the professional who was best qualified to comment on the age of the fracture. In this connection, Dr Wong noted that the autopsy report had documented an absence of callus formation around the clavicle fracture. This finding was consistent with two possibilities:

  94. (a) The fracture had occurred on 2 November 2019 (5 days before Izz’s demise); or

  95. (b) The fracture had occurred closer to Izz’s demise on 8 November 2019.

  96. [64] At trial, Dr Wong reiterated that it was possible for the clavicle fracture to have occurred on 2 November 2019 (ie, 5 or 6 days before Izz’s death).

  97. Dr Gilbert Lau (“Dr Lau”)

  98. [65] Dr Lau conducted an autopsy on Izz’s corpse on 9 November 2019 and issued an autopsy report dated 18 November 2019.

  99. [66] With regard to the external injuries observed on Izz, the report recorded (inter alia) abrasions and bruising on the scalp, as well as bruising and abrasions on the nose, bruises on the left arm, and bruises on the left thigh and left knee. As for the internal injuries observed by Dr Lau, these included acute subdural hemorrhage and acute subarachnoid hemorrhage, scalp bruises, and a laceration along the frenulum of the upper lip. There was also a fracture of the lateral third of the left clavicle. In Dr Lau’s opinion, the cause of death was traumatic intracranial haemorrhage, which “would be consistent with the infliction of blunt force trauma to the head and face”. Further, a number of the external and internal injuries – namely, the facial abrasions and bruises, the laceration of the frenulum with surrounding mucosal bruising, and the fractured left clavicle – were, in Dr Lau’s opinion, “highly suspicious of non-accident injury”.

  100. [67] At trial, Dr Lau’s evidence was that for fatal traumatic intracranial haemorrhage to have occurred, blunt force trauma would have been applied to the head which would have resulted in internal bruising of the scalp and the left temporalis muscle, and that these forces would have been transmitted through the skull, thereby injuring the brain. The hemorrhage would have caused pressure to build up in the intracranial cavity due to haemorrhage and brain swelling, and vital centres of control (breathing, respiration, heart function etc) in the brain stem would ultimately be compromised. It was uncertain how long it would have taken from the time of injury before the child (Izz) lapsed into unconsciousness. This brain injury would have been sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death.

  101. [68] In response to Defence counsel’s cross-examination, Dr Lee pointed out that he had found Izz’s entire brain to be swollen; and although he had not found evidence of bleeding in the brain substance itself, “the swelling of the brain and the haemorrhages around it would have been very, very significant findings forensically”.

  102. [69] In addition, Dr Lau cautioned that in this instance, it was “important not to be fixated on the presence or absence” of skull fractures because although the skull bones of an infant “are very pliable” and can be subjected to quite a bit of force and yet not break”, the forces applied to the head would have been transmitted through the skull bones into the brain, causing rupture of the blood vessels on the surface of the brain. Dr Lau noted that even for adults, he had seen – when he was in practice – “a huge subdural haematoma in an adult without a fracture of the skull”.

  103. [71] Asked about the fracture of the left clavicle, Dr Lau’s evidence was that the injury looked fresh and that he had not found any evidence of healing at the time of the autopsy. However, he stressed that the healing of bone injuries was very variable; that one had to be “very careful about ageing these injuries”; and that while the fracture seemed to be a fresh injury at the time of the autopsy, he was unable to say categorically that it “could not have been sustained or inflicted a day or two or some day before the fatal injuries were inflicted or sustained”. Nevertheless, even allowing for evidence that the clavicle fracture had occurred “sometime on the 2nd of November 2019”, Dr Lau’s opinion was that that the remaining injuries on Izz were highly suspicious of non-accidental injury.

  104. [72] According to Dr Lau, the injuries on Izz were relatively fresh, and probably inflicted within 24 hours of death as no evidence of healing was shown. Dr Lau stated that insofar as he had documented finding “faint bruises” on Izz, these faint bruises could not be old injuries, as none of the bruises showed the sort of yellowish discoloration that would have suggested they were probably more than 18 hours old. Indeed, the fact that the bruises were faint could suggest that they had not developed fully before the child died.

  105. [73] As to the likely degree of force used in this case, Dr Lau stated that this was a difficult issue to opine on in instances involving fatal non-accidental injuries in young children which had allegedly been caused by a full-grown adult. His evidence was that if the assailant were indeed a full-grown adult, then one had to recognize the existence of “a stark asymmetry…between a defenceless 9.5-month-old infant and a full grown adult”: “what might have been mild or moderate force on the part of the assailant could amount to moderate to severe force as experienced by the child”.

  106. [74] Dr Lau was asked to consider the differing versions of events provided by the accused in respect of what had happened to Izz on the night of 7 November 2019. In gist, these differing versions – which were gleaned from statements made by the accused at various points following the incident itself – posited in turn:

  107. (a) An accidental fall in which Izz had fallen from the van onto the ground;

  108. (b) An accidental fall in which Izz had fallen headfirst onto the floorboard of the van, “bounced” off the floorboard, hit the footstep, and then fallen to the ground;

  109. (c) An accidental fall by Izz onto the van floorboard, followed by the accused accidentally pushing him forward while attempting to soothe him;

  110. (d) The intentional pushing of Izz’s head against the van floorboard, first with his left cheek coming into contact with the floorboard, and a second time with his face down towards the floorboard.

  111. In general, with regard to the versions which recounted an accidental fall of some sort, Dr Lau noted that there was a total lack of the sort of linear abrasions and lacerations that would have been expected from a fall in which the child had allegedly come into contact with the edge of the floorboard or the footstep. Instead, the abrasions found on Izz were all non-linear, and no laceration was found. Dr Lau also expressed doubt about the accused’s claim that Izz had “bounced” off the wooden floorboard of the van, given that the head is a solid non-spherical structure and the floor of the van is a firm unyielding surface. In Dr Lau’s opinion, the version of events in which Izz had fallen headfirst onto the van floorboard before “bouncing” off it would be the least compelling version. In contrast, in Dr Lau's opinion, the version of events in which Izz’s head had been pushed twice against the floorboard was the most compelling version and would explain the occurrence of many of the external and internal injuries to the scalp. Dr Lau testified that taken together, both acts of pushing would have caused the two haemorrhages. In his view, there would have been at least two distinct or discrete blows to the head: one to the front of the head and one to the left side of the head.

  112. Forensic Evidence and Exhibits

  113. [75] Apart from the evidence adduced from witnesses by way of conditioned statements and testimony, forensic evidence was also collected and analysed. Inter alia, under the direction of ASP Ang Ghim Sing, swabs of red stains were collected from the wooden floor of the van. They were submitted to the DNA Profiling Lab at the Health Sciences Authority for analysis. Izz was identified as a matchable contributor for the blood swabs.

  114. [76] Data was extracted from the accused’s two phones (one of which was recovered from some bushes at the bus stop near NUH) and from Nadiah’s phone. CCTV footage of the Yishun MSCP and the Sheng Siong supermarket which the accused had visited was obtained, as well as CCTV footage of NUH and its vicinity which captured the accused’s and Nadiah’s movements from the NUH carpark to the A&E Department.

  115. Statements by the accused

  116. [77] The Prosecution also sought to admit 11 statements given by the accused in the course of investigations. The following four statements were admitted into evidence by agreement:

  117. (a) Statement recorded 8 November 2019 at about 6.15 am by SSSgt Abu Hamid;

  118. (b) Statement recorded on 11 November 2019 at 4.30 pm by ASP Ang;

  119. (c) Statement recorded 12 November 2019 at 5.20 pm by ASP Ang; and

  120. (d) Statement recorded 19 November 2019 at 11.15am by ASP Ang.

  121. [78] The Defence challenged the admissibility of the following seven statements (“the challenged statements”):

  122. (a) Statement recorded on 8 November 2019 at 7.40 pm by SSI Mazlan, in which the accused had admitted to pushing Izz’s head towards the floorboard of the van;

  123. (b) Charge, Notice of Warning and statement dated 8 November 2019 at 9.07 pm by Supt Koh Yu Shan, Cyndi (“Supt Cyndi Koh”), in which the accused had stated he was remorseful upon being served a charge of voluntarily causing grievous hurt to Izz by slamming Izz’s head against the floorboard of the van;

  124. (c) Statement recorded on 12 November 2019 at 10.45 am by ASP Ang, in which the accused admitted to pushing Izz’s head towards the floorboard of the van;

  125. (d) Statement recorded on 13 November 2019 at 9.45 am by ASP Ang Ghim Sing, in which the accused stated that he was “rimas” (or uneasy) when he pushed Izz’s head towards the floorboard;

  126. (e) Charge, Notice of Warning and statement dated 14 November 2019 at 2.25 pm by ASP Ng Choon Siong Desmond (“ASP Desmond Ng”), in which – in response to a charge of murder by causing the death of Izz - the accused stated that he “did it in the moment of frustration after hearing [Izz] crying”.

  127. (f) Statement recorded on 20 November 2019 at 2.05 pm by ASP Ang, in which the accused stated that he and Nadiah had agreed, after discussion, to tell the hospital staff the story of an accidental fall if the staff asked about Izz’s injuries; and

  128. (g) Statement recorded on 21 November 2019 at 4.35 pm with 15 photographs marked as Annex ‘A’ by ASP Ang, depicting the accused’s re-enactment of how he had pushed Izz’s head against the floorboard.

  129. [79] An ancillary hearing was conducted in respect of these seven disputed statements, at the end of which I found all seven statements to have been made voluntarily and admitted them into evidence. I set out below the reasons for this finding.

  130. The ancillary hearing:

  131. The alleged threats

  132. [81] In challenging the voluntariness of these seven statements, the accused sought to rely on two alleged threats, which were first raised in the Case for the Defence dated 31 January 2022 and the Further Case for the Defence dated 6 March 2022. First, the accused claimed that on 8 November 2019, while interviewing him in an interview room at Woodlands Police Division, SSI Mazlan had banged on the table and told him: “If you never change your statement, you go to the gallows” (“the alleged 8 November 2019 threat”). I should add that in cross-examination during the ancillary hearing, this threat was phrased slightly differently, as “If you don’t change your statement, you go to the gallows”.

  133. [82] Second, the accused claimed that on 11 November 2019 at Police Cantonment Complex, after he had voluntarily given a statement at 4.30 p.m., he was brought to a room where there were four to five police officers. According to the accused, one of the police officers threw a Dasani mineral water bottle (which was filled with water) at him, striking his left cheek, before telling him: “You better be remorseful or I buy you a rope” (“the alleged 11 November 2019 threat”).

  134. Witnesses called by the Prosecution in respect of the alleged 8 November 2019 threat

  135. [83] SSI Mazlan was identified by the accused as the officer who made the alleged 8 November 2019 threat to him. SSI Mazlan testified that he had interviewed the accused between 12.55 p.m. and 1.55 p.m. on 8 November 2019, in the presence of ASP Ng in Interview Room 2 at Woodlands Police Station. In cross-examination, it was put to SSI Mazlan that in the course of this interview, the accused had told him “multiple times” about Izz dropping from the accused’s arm “onto the plywood floor of the van, onto the footrest, and onto the ground”; and that “maybe about 1.50 p.m., just before the completion of the interview”, SSI Mazlan had “banged the table before the accused multiple times” before standing up, leaning across the table, going “close to the accused’s right ear”, and saying the words: “If you don’t change your statement, you go to the gallows”. SSI Mazlan denied having done any of these things.

  136. [84] It was also put to SSI Mazlan that when interviewing the accused a second time on 8 November 2019, between 7.05 p.m. to 7.40 p.m. in Interview Room B at PCC (ie, immediately before recording the first of the seven disputed statements), he had asked the accused: “Do you remember what I told you earlier in the afternoon at Woodlands Police Division?” SSI Mazlan denied this. His evidence was that when he entered the interview room, he had started by explaining that he would be interviewing the accused “regarding the case” and ascertaining whether the accused wished to speak in English or Malay. The accused had seemed quiet, and he had “let [the accused] be” for a while, before prompting him by asking if he had anything else to tell the police. During this time, the accused “was looking down and quiet”, so SSI Mazlan decided to wait and to let him think instead. Eventually, the accused stated that he wanted “to tell the truth”, and it was then that SSI Mazlan decided to commence recording his statement.

  137. [85] ASP Ng, who was present in the Woodlands Police interview room the 8 November 2019 threat was allegedly made, testified that during the interview, SSI Mazlan had spoken to the accused in a “professional and courteous” tone, and he had not banged on the table. Evidence was also given by Sergeant Shahrel bin Ali (“Sgt Shahrel”), who arrived at the Woodlands Police interview room while the interview was in progress, for the purpose of escorting the accused to PCC. Sgt Shahrel denied having witnessed SSI Mazlan banging on the table, standing up to lean close to the accused’s right ear, and uttering the words “If you don’t change your statement, you go to the gallows”.

  138. [86] Supt Cyndi Koh, who recorded one of the two disputed cautioned statements from the accused on the night of 8 November 2019, testified that throughout her interaction with the accused, she did not hear from him any complaints about any threats, inducements or promises made by SSI Mazlan. She also had no contact with SSI Mazlan before she recorded the cautioned statement of 8 November 2019. Mohammad Rashikin bin Rajah, who acted as the interpreter during Supt Cyndi Koh’s recording of the 8 November 2019 cautioned statement, testified that he too did not receive any complaints from the accused about SSI Mazlan.

  139. Witnesses called by the Prosecution in respect of the alleged 11 November 2019 threat

  140. [87] Insp Daniel Lim was identified by the accused as the officer who made the alleged 11 November 2019 threat to him. Insp Daniel Lim testified that on 11 November 2019, his team had been preparing for another High Court case, and he had returned to PCC at about 6.15 p.m. after serving the papers for the preliminary inquiry (“PI”) in another case. On his return to PCC, he tidied up some things. As he received no other instructions from his superior ASP Ang Ghim Seng, he left PCC for home at about 6.45 p.m. to 7 p.m.

  141. [88] In cross-examination, it was put to Insp Daniel Lim that he had interviewed the accused earlier on 8 November 2019, at about 3.56 p.m., that he had been “unfriendly” towards the accused, and that he had told the accused he did not believe his version of an accidental fall. Insp Daniel Lim agreed that he had interviewed the accused on the afternoon of 8 November 2019, but clarified that at that stage, the police still did not know much about the case, and he had just been “trying to gather” evidence from the accused about the sequence of events. He denied having been “unfriendly” towards the accused or having stated that he did not believe the accused’s version of an accidental fall. Instead, according to Insp Daniel Lim, he had spent the initial part of the interview trying to build rapport by asking the accused “about his job, et cetera”. At this point, the conversation was in English, as Insp Lim had been told that the accused could speak English. However, as he started going into the “interview proper”, he noticed that the accused was becoming “rather evasive”, especially when asked about things such as timing and sequence which did not seem right – and it was at this point that the accused started asking Insp Lim questions in Malay. As he found it difficult to carry on the conversation, Insp Lim informed the IO ASP Ang that he “might not be the right person to interview [the accused]”; and he was told that another officer would take over the interview. After this, Insp Lim had “more casual” conversation with the accused, which had nothing to do with the case.

  142. [89] It was suggested to Insp Daniel Lim that ASP Ang had called him around 7.15 p.m. on 11 November 2019 to tell him that the accused was “not admitting to his office”. Insp Lim denied this. It was further put to him that he had then brought the accused from the interview room at the regional lock-up of PCC to another interview room “on the 14th or 16th floor of [PCC]” between 7.15pm to 7.28pm on 11 November 2019; and that at this other interview room, he had thrown a “Dasani water bottle” filled with “half a litre of water” at the accused’s cheek before shouting the words: “You better be remorseful or I will buy you a rope”. Insp Lim denied having done any of these things. He testified, moreover, that all floors of the PCC building had to be accessed by officers using their police passes; and he himself did not have access to the 14th and the 16th floors.

  143. [90] ASP Ang Ghim Sing testified that on 11 November 2019, he had started recording a statement from the accused in Interview Room 5 at PCC, with the assistance of Malay interpreter Mdm Sapiahtun Mohd Ali (“Mdm Sapiahtun”). After recording the statement, he printed it out and read it back to the accused in English, with Mdm Sapiahtun interpreting. The accused was invited to make any amendments he wished, and he made several amendments. This statement was one of the four admitted by agreement in this trial (ie, exhibit P92). In cross-examination, ASP Ang agreed that in this statement (P92), the accused had given a version of events involving an accidental fall – which was “entirely different” from the version related in the statement recorded by SSI Mazlan at 7.40 p.m. on 8 November 2019 (ie, the first of the disputed statements). It was suggested to ASP Ang that immediately after completing the recording of P92, he had walked out of the interview room for a short while and had called one of his colleagues “to say that… the accused was not admitting the offence”. It was also put to ASP Ang that subsequent to this, “four police officers came and brought the accused to another interview room”. ASP Ang denied that any of this had happened. Asked about the 13-minute window between the time he recorded the statement-recording and the time the accused was escorted back to his cell by lock-up officers, ASP Ang stated that nothing had happened during those 13 minutes: his evidence was that the 13-minute wait was “very normal” and was in fact “the average waiting time for the escort officer to respond” to a request. ASP Ang asserted that he would not have left the interpreter alone in the interview room with the accused before the escort officers arrived, as he had to guard the accused until someone else could come to take over.

  144. [91] Mdm Sapiahtun testified that she had acted as Malay interpreter for the recording of the statement P92 by ASP Ang on 11 November 2019. She denied that ASP Ang had walked out of the interview room after completing the statement-recording. She also denied that four police officers had come to the interview room thereafter and taken the accused away.

  145. [92] Insp Mohd Shahril bin Ramli (“Insp Shahril”) was called to introduce into evidence a copy of the Electronic Station Diary (ie, exhibit P93). Insp Shahril explained that the interview rooms within the regional lock-up of the PCC were located inside Zone 3, whereas the cells where accused persons were kept were located inside Zone 4. The ESD would show when the accused was brought from his cell to an interview room within the regional lock-up; and it would also show when he was returned from the interview room to his cell. Insp Shahril also testified that the regional lock-up was in the basement of the PCC building. The 14th and 16th floors were thus outside the regional lock-up area. If the accused was brought out of the regional lock-up to another floor of the PCC building, such movement would be reflected in the ESD – as would any movement of the accused from an area outside the regional lock-up back into the regional lock-up.

  146. [93] According to Insp Shahril, any complaint made by anyone remanded in the regional lock-up would be reflected in the ESD as well. In the present case, the ESD did not show any complaints made by the accused for the entire duration of his remand in the regional lockup from 8 November to 22 November 2019. ASP Ang, who recorded further statements from the accused on 12 November 2019 and several subsequent occasions, also testified that he did not receive any complaints from the accused at any of these statement-recording sessions about having been subjected to threats. Mdm Sapiahtun, who acted as the Malay interpreter for the recording of these other statements, testified that she too was not told by the accused of any threats.

  147. The accused’s evidence

  148. [94] The accused claimed that when he was interviewed by SSI Mazlan in the interview room at Woodlands Police Station between 12.55 p.m. and 1.55 p.m on 8 November 2019, ASP Ng and another police officer were present in the room, observing the interview. The accused denied that the other officer present in the interview room was Sgt Shahrel, claiming instead that it was another police officer who “looked like Chinese” and whom he was unable to identify. According to the accused, he had told SSI Mazlan about Izz accidentally falling from his arm, hitting his head on the van floorboard, then hitting his head on the footstep, and finally falling onto the floor. Upon hearing this account of events, SSI Mazlan looked “unhappy” and “banged” the table “multiple times” before standing up, leaning close to the accused’s right ear and saying (in English): “If you don’t change your statement, you will go to the gallows”.

  149. [95] The accused claimed that “SSI Mazlan’s threat [kept] playing on [his] mind” as he was escorted from Woodlands Police Station to PCC. He “got frightened and very worried” that if he “did not change [his] statement, [he] would go to the gallow”. As such, he “decided to create an imaginary story” about having “pushed” Izz’s head “towards the floorboard”. However, he did not initially relate this “imaginary story” to Insp Daniel Lim when he was interviewed by the latter at 3.56 p.m. on 8 November 2019, in the PCC interview room. Instead, he told Insp Daniel Lim the version of events involving an accidental fall. He noticed that Insp Lim looked “unhappy” on hearing this version. He was then handed over to SSI Mazlan, and he persisted in repeating this version of the accidental fall to SSI Mazlan when the latter interviewed him again in the PCC interview room at about 7.05 pm. SSI Mazlan “did not believe [this] version”, and asked him if he remembered what he had been told by SSI Mazlan earlier in the afternoon at Woodlands Police. It was only because of this reminder of the “threat” that he started telling the “imaginary story” about pushing Izz’s head towards the floorboard of the van.

  150. [96] According to the accused, in the three-day period between 8 November 2019 and 11 November 2019, SSI Mazlan’s “threat” continued “playing on [his] mind”. However, when he was interviewed by ASP Ang at 4.30 pm on 11 November 2019, he “decided to come back to [his] original version” of the accidental fall because ASP Ang was “not threatening" him. The accused claimed that when ASP Ang concluded the statement-recording, he walked out of the room, leaving the accused alone with the interpreter Mdm Sapiahtun. When ASP Ang returned to the interview room, he brought the accused out of the room and handed him over to “four to five police officers”. The accused was then taken to another interview room on the 14th or 16th floor, where he was questioned by Insp Daniel Lim “many times”. When he told Insp Daniel Lim that the accused had “accidentally” fallen from his arm, the latter appeared “unhappy”. At this point, the accused and Insp Daniel Lim were seated “facing each other”; and Insp Lim was holding a “Dasani water bottle filled with water”, while “four to five police officers” stood behind Insp Lim “observing” the interview. The accused claimed that Insp Lim threw the bottle of water at his cheek, then came and sat next to him, pointed a finger “on [his] neck”, and said: “You better be remorseful, or I buy you a rope”.

  151. [97] Following the above incident, the accused was brought back to his cell in the lock-up area. By this point, both SSI Mazlan’s threat and Insp Daniel Lim’s threat were “playing on [his] mind”. The following day (12 November 2019), when he was interviewed again by ASP Ang at 10.45 a.m., he “decided to give [the] imaginary story” about pushing Izz’s head towards the van floorboard.

  152. [98] In summarising the accused’s position at the conclusion of the ancillary hearing, his counsel stated that the accused relied specifically on the alleged 8 November 2019 threat to challenge the voluntariness of the statement made on 8 November 2019 to SSSI Mazlan, and the cautioned statement made on 8 November 2019 to Supt Cyndi Koh. Counsel also stated that the accused relied specifically on the alleged 11 November 2019 threat to challenge the voluntariness of the statements made on 12 November 2019 and 13 November 2019 to ASP Ang, as well as the cautioned statement made on 14 November 2019 to ASP Desmond Ng. As for his challenge to the voluntariness of the two statements recorded by ASP Ang on 20 November 2019 and 21 November, the accused relied on both the alleged 8 November 2019 and the 11 November 2019 threats.

  153. [99] The accused admitted that he did not at any time tell his previous counsel, Mr Muzammil, about the alleged 8 November 2019 threat and the alleged 11 November 2019 threat; and that he only brought them up to his new counsel, Mr Nadarajan, sometime in December 2021. When asked by his counsel to explain why he had taken such a long time to bring up the alleged threats, the accused said that it was because these threats “were still playing on [his] mind”; and he also did not know at the time that the words uttered by SSI Mazlan and Insp Daniel Lim constituted threats. He only knew that they were threats when his new counsel told him so.

  154. [100] The accused said that he had understood both SSI Mazlan’s and Insp Lim’s threats to mean that if he stuck to his “true version” of the accidental fall and failed to change his statement, he would “face the death sentence”. According to the accused, it was to avoid the death sentence that he came up with the “imaginary story” about having pushed Izz’s head towards the floorboard of the van. He believed that this “imaginary story” was less serious than his “true version” of the accidental fall because in the true version of events, Izz had fallen three times.

  155. [101] Aside from the accused, no other defence witnesses were called in the ancillary hearing.

  156. The law on voluntariness

  157. [102] I next set out the legal principles applicable to the consideration of the voluntariness of an accused’s statement pursuant to s 258(3) CPC. The determination of voluntariness is a two-stage factual inquiry, comprising an objective and a subjective limb: per the Court of Appeal (“CA”) in Chai Chien Wei Kelvin v Public Prosecutor [1998] 3 SLR(R) 619 (“Chai Chien Wei Kelvin”) at [53]; Sulaiman bin Jumari v Public Prosecutor [2021] 1 SLR 557 (“Sulaiman”) at [39]. The first stage entails an objective consideration of whether there was a threat, inducement or promise having reference to the charge against the accused person. The second stage of the test of voluntariness is a subjective consideration of whether the inducement, threat or promise operates on the mind of the accused person through hope of escape or fear of punishment connected with the charge: in other words, whether the said inducement, threat or promise was such that it would be reasonable for the accused to think that he would gain some advantage or avoid any adverse consequences in relation to the proceedings against him (Chai Chien Wei Kelvin at [53]; Sulaiman at [39]).

  158. [103] Where voluntariness is challenged, the burden of proof lies on the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the confession was made voluntarily: Sulaiman at [36]. That being said, it need not be shown that all doubt of influence or fear had been removed from the accused’s mind before an attempt was made to record his confessions. Rather, the trial judge need only consider whether the evidence of the accused alleging inducements, threats, promises or assaults, taken together with the prosecution’s evidence, has raised a reasonable doubt in his mind that the accused was thus influenced into making the statement (Chai Chien Wei Kelvin at [53], Panya Marmontree and others v Public Prosecutor [1995] 2 SLR(R) 806 at [29]; Mohamed Ansari at [9]).

  159. The submissions made by the Prosecution and the Defence

  160. [104] The Prosecution submitted that the objective limb of the two-stage test was not met for the alleged 8 November 2019 threat and the alleged 11 November 2019 threats as these threats “never took place”. The Prosecution also submitted that even if there had been a threat made by SSI Mazlan on 8 November 2019, the subjective limb of the two-stage test would still not be met because the evidence showed that at 4.30 p.m. on 11 November 2019, the accused was still capable of giving a statement containing his initial story of an accidental fall. Moreover, the accused’s response to the alleged 8 November 2019 threat and the alleged 11 November 2019 threat did not make sense. The accused’s evidence was that he understood both SSI Mazlan and Insp Daniel Lim to have told him that he needed to change his statement from the original (and supposedly true) version of an accidental fall to a version that would allow him to avoid the death penalty. If that were indeed the case, then it made no sense for him to have changed his version of events to a “more serious” version which amounted to a “confession of intentionally pushing” Izz’s head against the van floorboard.

  161. [105] The Defence submitted that the evidence showed SSI Mazlan must have made a threat against the accused between 1.05 p.m. to 1.55 p.m. on 8 November 2019, in the interview room at Woodlands Police, because no statement was recorded during that period of time. According to the Defence, the purpose of this interview must have been to frighten and threaten the accused into giving a different statement from his earlier statement. As for the 11 November 2019 threat, the Defence argued that this must surely have occurred because prior to the accused being threatened by Insp Daniel Lim in the interview room on the 14th or 16th floor of the PCC building, he had been able to tell ASP Ang “the truth” in the statement recorded at 4.30 p.m.; and that must have been because “there was no threat from ASP Ang”.

  162. [106] As to why the accused changed his story from one of an accidental fall to one which “others may consider…more serious”, the Defence argued that the accused, as a layperson, had “his own thinking and his own interpretation”: Defence counsel argued that “we have to accept [the accused’s] interpretation” that a story about his pushing Izz’s head onto the floorboard was somehow less serious than one in which Izz had “dropp[ed] three times”.

  163. [107] The Defence declined to comment on Insp Shahril’s testimony and the evidence of the ESD.

  164. My findings on the voluntariness of the disputed statements

  165. [108] Having considered all the evidence adduced in the ancillary hearing and having heard submissions from both sides, I was satisfied that the Prosecution had proven beyond reasonable doubt the voluntariness of the seven disputed statements.

  166. [109] In respect of the first limb of the two-stage test articulated by the CA in Chai Chien Wei Kelvin and Sulaiman, I was satisfied that the alleged 8 November 2019 threat and the alleged 11 November 2019 threat never occurred.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.