General Division of the High Court · Decided 4 April 2022
Siong Ann Engineering Pte Ltd v Pure Group (Singapore) Pte Ltd
Feedback & support[2022] SGHC 73 · Case no. District Court Appeal No 47 of 2021 · 16 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] The respondent company is in charge of managing a project in Marina Bay Sands (“MBS”) to covert a theatre into a restaurant and nightclub (“the Project”). The respondent’s general manager, Jonathan Peter Coney (“Mr Coney”), led the respondent’s team in managing the Project. Mr Coney was assisted by one Thomas Tan Boon Chin (“Mr Tan”), a senior project manager in the respondent’s Malaysian office who was seconded to Singapore to assist with the Project.
- [2]
[2] The appellant, a company specialising in theatre engineering, bulk-handling systems and steel structural works, is one of the sub-contractors for the Project. Wong Chian Kok (“Mr Wong”) is the business and development manager of the appellant. The respondent and the appellant entered into a number of sub-contracts for various types of works for the Project.
- [3]
[3] The dispute in this action relates only to the design, supply and installation of a temporary ramp to transport materials from the theatre entrance to the stage area (“Ramp Works”). Briefly, the appellant was under the impression that the respondent has accepted its quotation for the Ramp Works and therefore proceeded to fabricate the steel material needed to construct the ramp and delivered them to the worksite. However, the respondent claimed that no agreement for the Ramp Works had been reached, and therefore, rejected the materials and told the appellant not to proceed any further with the Ramp Works.
- [4]
[4] On 16 January, the appellant was asked by the respondent to submit a quote for the Ramp Works. Mr Tan informed Mr Wong that the ramp was needed urgently. On the same day, the appellant, via email, sent the respondent a quotation for the sum of $100,000 (“the 16 January Quotation”).
- [5]
[5] Between 17 January and 1 February 2018, the parties discussed matters concerning the technical designs and specifications of the ramp, and revised requirements were made. The appellant submitted a revised quotation for the sum of $130,180.00 (“the 1 February Quotation”).
- [6]
[6] On 3 February 2018, Mr Tan informed the appellant that the respondent “would like to have the temporary steel ramp completed by 16 February 2018”. Mr Tan also requested for further details of the Ramp Works to be provided by 5 February 2018. Accordingly, the details were provided on 5 February 2018.
- [7]
[7] On 5 February, at 3.57pm, the respondent’s Senior Project Director, Chris Potts (“Mr Potts”) asked for further details such as the description of the works, quantity, unit and unit rates. The further details were provided in the quotation dated 5 February 2018 (“the 5 February Quotation”). The scope of work, price and other terms and conditions in the 5 February Quotation essentially mirrors the 1 February Quotation.
- [9]
[9] On 8 February, at 9.20am, Mr Tan sent an email to Mr Wong, stating “...Pls have the steel materials ready for your fabrication-installed by 23 Feb 2018, thanks.” (“8 February Email”). Wong immediately acknowledged receipt of the 8 February Email, stating that “Ok noted Thomas, we will start to prepare the steelworks materials first ready for site installation”.
- [10]
[10] On 9 February 2018, Mr Wong exchanged WhatsApp messages with Mr Coney (“9 February WhatsApp”). I set them out in full given their importance:
- [11]
[11] On 19 February 2018, there was further WhatsApp correspondence between Mr Wong and Mr Coney, as set out below (“19 February WhatsApp”):
- [12]
[12] However, on 22 February 2021, Mr Coney emailed Mr Wong, stating “[p]lease do not do any further work on this until we discuss these works”. Mr Coney’s request for Mr Wong to stop further work was made after the respondent’s structural engineer, Arup Singapore Pte Ltd (“Arup”), expressed concerns about calculations of the load capacity of the steel ramp.
- [13]
[13] The parties tried to resolve the matter but could not. The appellant then filed Adjudication Application No SOP/AA 435 of 2018 (“AA”) and sought payment for the Ramp Works. The adjudicator determined that a total sum of $123,897.77 was payable to the appellant for the Ramp Works and the respondent paid the adjudicated sum to the appellant (“the Paid Sum”). Thereafter, the respondent commenced Suit No 35 of 2020 in the District Court against the appellant to recover the Paid Sum from the appellant.
- [14]
[14] The District Judge (“DJ”) found that there was no agreement and that the Paid Sum must be returned to the respondent on the basis that the appellant was unjustly enriched. The DJ reasoned, inter alia, that:
- [15]
[15] The appellant appealed against the DJ’s decision. On appeal, the appellant says that the DJ has erred in finding that there was no agreement for the Ramp Works. The appellant says that the respondent has accepted the 5 February Quotation in the 8 February Email, with the agreed price being $130,180.00. The appellant further says that this acceptance is supported by the preceding and subsequent exchange of emails and WhatsApp messages between the parties. The appellant is not pursuing its claims on the basis of unjust enrichment and quantum meruit for this appeal. I am of the view that there was an agreement between the parties and that the respondent did instruct the appellant to proceed with the Ramp Works. My reasons are as follows.
- [16]
[16] First, the respondent, in the 8 February Email, expressly instructed the appellant to have the steel materials ready for fabrication and to have the ramp installed by 23 February 2018. The respondent says that the phrase “have the steel materials ready for fabrication” does not mean the same thing as “fabricate now”. However, the same email instructed the plaintiff to install the metal ramps by 23 February 2018, which I find to be clear instruction for the appellant to commence work to meet the tight deadline.
- [17]
[17] The respondent further argues that the sender of the 8 February Email is Mr Tan and that Mr Tan has no actual, implied or ostensible authority to enter into the contract for the Ramp Works on behalf of the respondent. However, I am of the view that it is immaterial whether Mr Tan has the authority to enter into contracts on behalf of the respondent. The instructions for the appellant to commence the Ramp Works came from the respondent, including Mr Coney.