Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 16 Jan 2023

General Division of the High Court

Public Prosecutor v Yap Pow Foo

Feedback & support

[2023] SGHC 11Case no. Criminal Case No 32 of 2022

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The accused is Yap Pow Foo, a 47-year-old male Singapore citizen (“the Accused”). The victim is a 39-year-old female Chinese national (“the Victim”). On the first day of the trial, the Prosecution made an application for the Court to prohibit the publication of anything that might lead to the identification of the Victim. I granted this application.

  3. [2] The Prosecution alleges that the Accused had entered the Victim’s house without her permission in the early hours of 30 January 2017 and raped the Victim. These offences were allegedly committed shortly after the Accused met the Victim for the first time at a KTV lounge located at Bugis Cube (“the KTV Lounge”) on 29 January 2017.

  4. [3] Two charges were preferred against the Accused under the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) (“the Penal Code”):

  5. That you, YAP POW FOO,

  6. [4] The above two charges were read to the Accused at the beginning of these proceedings, and he elected to plead not guilty. The Accused thus claims trial to these two charges.

  7. [5] The Accused also faces another charge in relation to the harassment of another woman in a separate incident under s 3(1)(b) read with s 3(2) of the Protection from Harassment Act 2014 (Cap 256A, 2015 Rev Ed). For the purposes of the trial, however, the Prosecution applied for the third charge to be stood down.

  8. Background facts

  9. [6] The Victim is currently residing in Singapore on a monthly special pass issued by the Immigration and Checkpoints Authority (“ICA”). She is currently unemployed. At the time of the alleged offences, the Victim was residing at a private apartment (“the Apartment”), unit #05-09 (“the Unit”). The Victim also worked as a beautician at that time.

  10. [7] The Accused was 42 years old at the time of the offence. He was unemployed.

  11. Facts leading up to the Accused’s commission of the alleged offences

  12. [8] The offences were committed in the early hours of 30 January 2017. The Accused had met the Victim for the first time, a few hours before the incident, on the night of 29 January 2017, at the KTV Lounge.

  13. [9] On the afternoon of 29 January 2017, the Victim celebrated Chinese New Year with her friends, namely, Ma Jinzhe (“Ma”), Henry Tan Jun Yuan (“Henry”), Wang Xu Jing (“Wang”), Chen Shuwen (“Angela”) and Heng Kwok Hun (“Heng”) at her Unit. The Victim and her friends drank alcohol and played mahjong and card games while they were at the Unit.

  14. [11] The Accused arrived at the KTV Lounge at about 12.07am. He met the Victim in person for the first time. While the Victim could not remember her interactions with the Accused, the evidence shows that the Accused and the Victim had chatted for a short while at the KTV Lounge.

  15. [12] Shortly after, the Victim had collapsed from heavy intoxication. The Victim lay asleep on the couch at the KTV Lounge, and her friends could not wake her up. Given her incapacitated state, the Accused and Henry carried her out of the KTV Lounge to the ground floor. While Wang took a cab home herself, the Accused offered to drive the rest of the group home. All of them accepted the Accused’s offer and the Accused proceeded to drive them to their respective residences at around 12.45am on 30 January 2017.

  16. [13] The Accused drove first to the Apartment. As the Victim was completely intoxicated and unconscious, Henry and Ma had to carry her to the Unit. The Accused initially remained in the car to clean up the Victim’s vomit. However, as Henry and Ma had not returned for some time, the Accused went up to the Unit to check on them. When the Accused reached the Unit, he helped Henry and Ma put the Victim on the bed. The Accused, Henry and Ma then left the Unit. Henry locked the main door behind them and slipped the key underneath the door. The Accused proceeded to send the rest of the Victim’s friends back home.

  17. The commission of the alleged offences and the arrest of the Accused

  18. [14] Sometime around 3.04am on the same day, the Accused returned to the Unit by himself and entered the Unit. Prior to that, the Accused had called the Victim on her handphone numerous times. There was, however, no response from the Victim. The Accused then entered the Unit and raped the Victim. In the course of the rape, the Victim was awakened. The Accused left the Unit shortly after at around 3.44am. Shortly after the Accused left, he called the Victim’s handphone numerous times. The evidence shows that the Victim answered the handphone a few times, but it was unclear what was said between the both of them. The Victim then called Ma to inform Ma of the alleged rape. The Victim also called the police to lodge a report that the Accused had raped her.

  19. [15] Subsequently, the police and Ma came to the Unit. After the police had questioned the Victim, she was brought to KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital (“KKH”) for a medical examination. She was attended to by Dr Karuna Lional (“Dr Lional”) from the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology. After the medical examination, the Victim returned to the Unit in the afternoon. Shortly after the Victim returned, the Accused called Ma, who was in the Unit, to ask if he could speak to the Victim. There was a short conversation between the Accused and the Victim before the Victim hung up the call. There was also a discussion on monetary compensation. Ma and Angela sought to persuade the Victim to accept the Accused’s compensation. While the Victim had initially considered the Accused’s offer, she ultimately rejected it. Instead, she returned to the police station to provide a statement on the incident.

  20. [16] Shortly after, the Accused was arrested by the investigation officer, SIO Mohamad Noor Aboe Bakar (“SIO Noor”). On the same day of the Accused’s arrest, the police retrieved the denim shorts that the Victim was wearing at the material time. During the Victim’s medical examination by Dr Lional at KKH, samples of the Victim’s blood and urine, as well as swabs from her high vaginal area and urethra were obtained. The Victim’s denim shorts, her blood and urine samples, and the swabs were sent to the Health Sciences Authority (“HSA”) for analysis.

  21. [17] On 4 July 2017, the Accused was examined by Dr Darren Goh Wee Yian (“Dr Goh”) at the Department of Urology at Changi General Hospital. Dr Goh concluded that the Accused was not suffering from erectile dysfunction.

  22. [18] On 25 and 29 September and 2 October 2020, the Accused was examined by Dr Stephen Phang Boon Chye (“Dr Phang”) from the Institute of Mental Health (“IMH”). The Accused was assessed not to be of unsound mind at the time of the alleged offences. However, the Accused was characterised by Dr Phang as having had a past history of fetishistic sexual interest, although Dr Phang acknowledged that nothing turned on this observation on the present offence against the Accused.

  23. The parties’ cases

  24. The Prosecution’s case

  25. [19] The Prosecution’s case is that the Accused committed the following two offences against the Victim at the Unit on the same day:

  26. [20] The Prosecution relies on the evidence of 38 witnesses and more than 80 exhibits to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the Accused committed the offences as charged. The evidence-in-chief of the witnesses are adduced by way of conditioned statements admissible under s 264(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 68, 2012 Rev Ed) (“CPC”), and supplemented, where necessary, with their oral testimonies. Thirteen witnesses testified in court for the Prosecution’s case:

  27. [21] The Prosecution also sought to rely on the evidence of Wang. She was abroad and could not be located to secure her attendance in Court, whether to testify physically in Court or by way of video-link evidence. Wang’s conditioned statement was admitted under s 32(1)(j)(iii) of the Evidence Act 1893 (2020 Rev Ed) (“EA”).

  28. [22] In respect of the House-breaking Charge, the Prosecution submits that the Accused had committed house-breaking by night when, in the early hours of 30 January 2017, he retrieved the key to the Unit from under the main door and used it to enter the Unit without the Victim’s permission. The purpose of the unlawful entry was to rape the Victim. Thus, the Accused had committed house-breaking by night. The Prosecution relies on the Accused’s statements voluntarily recorded under s 22 of the CPC dated 31 January 2017 (“the 31 January Statement”) and 27 October 2017 (“the 27 October Statement”), and the Accused’s pre-polygraph interview which was recorded by SSI Chea Wai Choong (“SSI Chea”) dated 27 July 2021 (“the Pre-Polygraph Interview”) to support the House-breaking Charge. The Prosecution also relies on the Accused’s antecedent conviction of house-breaking and theft by night to support the additional element of the House-breaking Charge under s 458A of the Penal Code

  29. [23] In respect of the Rape Charge, the Prosecution submits that the Accused penetrated the Victim’s vagina with his penis while she was heavily intoxicated and was unable to give her consent. The crux of the Prosecution’s case was two-fold. First, the Accused had in fact penetrated the Victim’s vagina with his penis. Second, the Accused knew that the Victim was intoxicated and was unable to give her consent. In support, the Prosecution relies on two reports produced by the HSA’s DNA Profiling Laboratory and the expert testimony of Ms Tang. Further, the Prosecution relies on the Victim’s testimony, the Close Circuit Television (“CCTV”) footage recorded at the lift lobby of the Apartment showing the Victim’s unconscious state, the expert testimonies of Dr Lee and Dr Guo, the outgoing and incoming calls from the Victim’s handphone at the material time of the rape, and the testimonies of the Prosecution’s witnesses. The Prosecution submits that the Victim could not have given consent to the sexual intercourse given that she was heavily intoxicated. Thus, the Accused had penetrated the Victim’s vagina with his penis without her consent.

  30. The Victim’s evidence

  31. [24] The Prosecution relies on the Victim’s evidence that she had not consented to have sexual intercourse with the Accused. The Victim said that she has poor alcohol tolerance. On the day the offence was committed, the Victim had consumed large quantities of alcoholic drinks, both at the Unit and then at the KTV Lounge. The Prosecution submits that, given the Victim’s level of intoxication, she would have been unconscious throughout the night up until the point she was raped. Indeed, the Victim’s next immediate recollection after her time at the KTV Lounge was waking up to find the Accused on top of her, with his penis in her vagina. As such, the Victim was not in a state to give consent to the Accused’s act of penetrating her vagina with his penis. According to the Prosecution, therefore, the elements of the Rape Charge are made out.

  32. Psychiatric reports

  33. [25] The Prosecution relies on the evidence of Dr Guo and Dr Phang, both of whom are psychiatrists at the IMH.

  34. [26] Dr Guo had interviewed the Victim on 30 May 2019 and 24 July 2019. Following those interviews, Dr Guo prepared a medical report dated 29 October 2019. Dr Guo opined that the Victim had low alcohol tolerance. He was of the view that she was in a state of high alcohol intoxication at the time of the rape. Thus, she would not have had sufficient cognitive abilities or mental capacity to consent or reject the Accused’s request for sexual intercourse given her state of alcohol intoxication.

  35. [27] Dr Phang, on the other hand, had interviewed the Accused on three separate occasions in September and October 2020 (see [18] above). Dr Phang’s assessment was in the medical report dated 8 October 2020. The report states that the Accused was not suffering from any psychiatric disorder at the time of the offences on 30 January 2017. However, Dr Phang opined that the Accused’s increasingly severe sexual conducts, ie, from pilfering lingerie to facilitate masturbation to committing an actual sexual offence, warranted future psychiatric monitoring as they demonstrated an augmented degree of risk of serious sexual offending.

  36. HSA reports and Dr Lee’s expert reports

  37. [28] The Prosecution relies on two sets of evidence from the HSA. The first set of evidence relates to the DNA reports produced by Ms Tang from the HSA’s DNA Profiling Laboratory. The first report was dated 21 June 2017. It indicated a positive finding of semenogelin and prostate-specific antigen located on both the crotch area and the interior of the Victim’s denim shorts which she wore at the time of the offence. Further, a deoxyribonucleic (“DNA”) profile (spermic fraction) corresponding to the Accused’s DNA was also found in the interior of the Victim’s shorts. The second report, also dated 21 June 2017, indicated a positive finding of semenogelin in respect of swabs taken from the Victim’s high vaginal area. Further, the semenogelin contained a DNA profile (spermic fraction) corresponding to the Accused’s DNA.

  38. [29] The second set of evidence relates to the Victim’s blood and urine samples which were sent to the HSA for analysis, the results of which were contained in two reports. The first report dated 13 February 2017 was produced by Ms Fu Baohui, an analyst with the HSA’s Analytical Toxicology Laboratory. That report states that less than 20 mg/100 ml of ethanol was found in the Victim’s blood sample and 99 mg/100 ml of ethanol was found in the Victim’s urine sample. The Victim’s blood and urine samples were obtained from her during her medical examination at KKH on 30 January 2017 after the rape. Those findings, together with the additional information provided by the police, were submitted for analysis by Dr Lee. Dr Lee’s findings were in the second report dated 12 April 2017. That report states that the average blood alcohol content (“BAC”) in the Victim’s body at the material time of the rape was 144 mg/100ml. According to Dr Lee, that amount would be consistent with significant mental and physical impairment. The parties do not dispute the accuracy of Dr Lee’s report.

  39. Text messages and call logs retrieved from the Accused’s handphone and the Victim’s handphone

  40. [30] The Prosecution relies on three reports provided by forensic examiners from the Technology Crime Forensic Branch (“TCFB”) of the CID.

  41. [31] The first two reports contain the findings of the TCFB forensic examiners following a forensic examination conducted on the Victim’s handphone. The outgoing and incoming calls on the Victim’s handphone at the material time of the rape (“the Call Logs”) were retrieved. They also retrieved various messages sent between the Victim and her contacts via WeChat and WhatsApp. The Call Logs showed that on 30 January 2017, between 2.44am and 6.44am, various calls were exchanged between the Victim and the Accused, although not all of the calls went through.

  42. [32] The third report contains the findings of the TCFB forensic examiners on the Accused’s handphone. The call records and various messages sent between the Accused and his contacts via WeChat and WhatsApp were retrieved. Three image files were also retrieved from the Accused’s handphone. The WeChat calls and messages sent between the Accused and Ma revealed that the Accused offered to pay the Victim monetary compensation following the rape.

  43. [33] Based on the totality of the evidence, the Prosecution argues that the Accused had committed the offences for which he stands charged.

  44. The Defence’s case

  45. [34] The Accused denies having entered the Unit without the Victim’s permission. He also denies that he had penetrated the Victim’s vagina with his penis without the Victim’s consent. Apart from the Accused who chose to testify in his defence, the Defence also called his long-time childhood friend, Heng, to be his witness.

  46. The House-breaking Charge

  47. [35] The Accused’s defence in relation to the House-breaking Charge is that he did not use either a satay stick or his Genting membership card to retrieve the key from under the main door of the Unit to gain entry. Instead, he claims that he knocked on the door and rang the doorbell. The Victim then opened the door and invited him into the Unit. Accordingly, the offence of house-breaking by night under s 457 of the Penal Code is not made out.

  48. The Rape Charge

  49. [36] The Accused testified that his penis did not fully penetrate the Victim’s vagina. He said that his penis only penetrated her vagina a little bit, ie, only the head of his penis entered her vagina.

  50. [37] The Accused also vehemently maintained that the sexual intercourse with the Victim was consensual. The Defence submits that the Victim was not so intoxicated that she was unable to consent to the sexual intercourse. Rather, she appeared to be awake and conscious, although slightly intoxicated. Further, the Defence submits that the Victim had, by her words and conduct, implicitly consented to the Accused’s act of penetrating her vagina with his penis. Accordingly, the Defence alleges that the offence of rape under s 375(1)(a) of the Penal Code is not made out as the Victim gave her consent.

  51. The Victim’s ulterior motives in reporting the Accused

  52. [38] The Defence also suggests that the Victim had fabricated the allegations of rape against the Accused as she had two ulterior motives.

  53. [39] The first was for the Victim’s stay in Singapore to be extended by way of a special pass granted by the ICA. Thus, the Victim falsely alleged that the Accused had raped her so that she could continue to stay in Singapore. Prior to the present case, the Victim was a prosecution’s witness involving a sham marriage (“the Sham Marriage Proceedings”). As a result of that case, the Victim’s stay in Singapore was extended by way of a special pass to facilitate investigations and prosecution of the offender involved in the Sham Marriage Proceedings. At the material time when the Accused committed the alleged offences, the Sham Marriage Proceedings she was involved in was about to conclude. Hence, the Victim would have to return to China. The Defence thus argues that the Victim had fabricated the rape allegation, so that her special pass would be extended and she could continue to stay in Singapore.

  54. My decision

  55. The applicable law

  56. House-breaking by night

  57. [41] For the Accused to be guilty under s 457 of the Penal Code, the Prosecution must establish, beyond a reasonable doubt, that he had committed “house-breaking by night”. “House-breaking by night” is defined under s 457 of the Penal Code, and it reads as follows:

  58. [42] Section 446 of the Penal Code defines “house-breaking by night” as the commission of house-breaking “after 7 p.m. and before 7 a.m.”. Section 445(d) of the Penal Code lists the following situation in which a person has committed “house-breaking”:

  59. [43] Section 445 of the Penal Code refers to “house-trespass”, which is defined in s 442 of the Penal Code as follows:

  60. [44] Section 442 of the Penal Code in turn refers to “criminal trespass” which is defined in s 441 of the Penal Code as follows:

  61. [45] To establish the offence of house-breaking by night, the Prosecution must prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that (a) the Accused had committed the act of house-breaking “after 7 p.m. and before 7 a.m.”; (b) the Accused had unlawfully entered the Unit without the Victim’s permission; (c) the Accused entered the Unit with the intent to commit an offence, namely the rape of the Victim.

  62. [46] I note that the Accused has an antecedent conviction for house-breaking and theft by night (see [3] above). Accordingly, it is necessary to consider s 458A of the Penal Code, which reads as follows:

  63. [47] Finally, I note that s 457 of the Penal Code was repealed in 2019 and several types of house-breaking offences, namely s 448 to s 451 were enacted in its place on 1 January 2020 and remain in the present 2020 revised edition of the Penal Code (“the Penal Code (2020 Rev Ed)”). Section 451 of the Penal Code (2020 Rev Ed) is the relevant type of house-breaking offence in this case and it reads as follows:

  64. [48] Despite this amendment, it is correct that the Prosecution proceeds under s 457 of the Penal Code. This is because the applicable law at the time of the house-breaking was s 457 of the Penal Code and not s 451 of the Penal Code (2020 Rev Ed), which was not in the Penal Code in force at that time (see also Public Prosecutor v Lam Leng Hung and other appeals [2017] 4 SLR 474 at [14]). For the avoidance of doubt, however, the Accused’s act of house-breaking, if committed on or after 1 January 2020, would still be an offence today, albeit under s 451 of the Penal Code (2020 Rev Ed).

  65. [49] For the Accused to be guilty of rape, the Prosecution must establish, beyond a reasonable doubt, the elements of rape under s 375(1)(a) of the Penal Code:

  66. [50] To support a charge of rape under s 375(1)(a) of the Penal Code, the Prosecution must establish, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the Accused had: (a) penetrated the Victim’s vagina with his penis; and (b) the said act of penetration was done without the Victim’s consent.

  67. [51] In respect of the element of consent, s 90(b) of the Penal Code is relevant, and reads as follows:

  68. [52] Thus, s 90(b) of the Penal Code invalidates any consent if the Victim was so intoxicated that the law deems such consent to be invalid or vitiated (see Public Prosecutor v Pram Nair [2017] 2 SLR 1015 (“Pram Nair”) at [62]). In Pram Nair, the Court of Appeal at [93] endorsed the following passage from Ratanlal & Dhirajlal’s Law of Crimes: A Commentary on the Indian Penal Code 1860 vol 2 (CK Thakker & M C Thakker eds) (Bharat Law House, 26th Ed, 2007) which elaborated on the concept of consent:

  69. [53] In other words, to demonstrate that an individual had voluntarily consented to sexual intercourse with another person, that individual must have voluntarily and consciously agreed to have sex with the other person.

  70. [54] The Court of Appeal in Pram Nair also prescribed some guiding principles at [96] when dealing with the issue of whether an intoxicated person has the capacity to consent to sexual intercourse:

  71. [55] Where a complainant is so heavily intoxicated that she is unconscious, therefore, she cannot be said to have the capacity to consent to sexual intercourse. That much is self-explanatory. On the other hand, where a complainant is intoxicated, but not unconscious, whether that complainant has the capacity to consent to sexual intercourse is a more fact-sensitive inquiry. The issue of the complainant’s capacity to consent turns on the degree of impairment in the complainant’s understanding or knowledge. The degree of impairment must be such that the court is satisfied that the complainant lacked the ability to make any decisions. Accordingly, where a complainant is so heavily intoxicated to the extent that she suffers from alcohol-induced delirium, that complainant will be incapable to consent to sexual intercourse. To ascertain whether the Victim was capable of consenting to sexual intercourse with the Accused, the Court may have recourse to evidence such as the Victim’s BAC level.

  72. The threshold of proof in the context of mutually exclusive testimonies

  73. [56] I am mindful that no one had witnessed the Accused’s commission of the sexual acts on the Victim in her bedroom at the material time. However, the Prosecution’s case does not rest solely on the Victim’s testimony of the alleged rape, as there is ample corroborative evidence to buttress the Victim’s account of the events and her state of intoxication both before and after the rape. This includes the corroborative scientific evidence in the form of Dr Guo’s and Dr Lee’s reports and testimonies, the testimonies of the other Prosecution’s witnesses present at the festive celebration at the Apartment and the KTV Lounge, and the Accused’s statements to the police. This is, therefore, not a case where there is no other evidence, and the Court must simply weigh the Victim’s word against the Accused’s. Thus, the “unusually convincing” burden of proof may not be necessary in this case (see Public Prosecutor v Ridhaudin Ridhwan bin Bakri and others [2019] SGHC 105 at [114]–[116], affirmed by the Court of Appeal in Asep Ardiansyah v Public Prosecutor [2020] SGCA 74 at [28]). This test was explained by the Court of Appeal in AOF v Public Prosecutor [2012] 3 SLR 34 (“AOF”) at [111]:

  74. [57] I also note the Court of Appeal’s explanation in Haliffie bin Mamat v Public Prosecutor and other appeals [2016] 5 SLR 636 that the “unusually convincing” standard “does not introduce a new burden of proof [and] … ‘does nothing … to change the ultimate rule that the Prosecution must prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt, but it does suggest how the evidential Gordian knot may be untied if proof is to be found solely from the complainant’s testimony against the accused’” (at [29], citing XP v PP [2008] 4 SLR(R) 686 at [31]).

  75. [58] Whether or not this standard applies, the burden of proof remains indisputably on the Prosecution to establish each element of the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. The Court must therefore carefully examine all the evidence placed before it to determine if that burden has been satisfactorily discharged. As I shall explain below, I am satisfied that the Victim’s account that the sexual intercourse was without her consent can withstand the close scrutiny akin to the high standard of the “unusually convincing” test. Her evidence is credible, reliable, internally consistent and externally consistent with the other evidence before the Court.

  76. [59] With these legal principles in mind, I shall set out the issues in the present case.

  77. The issues

  78. [60] The issues that arise for my consideration in respect of the two charges are primarily factual and are as follows:

  79. (a) In respect of the Rape Charge, the key factual issue is whether the Victim had consented to the Accused’s act of performing sexual intercourse, and in particular whether she had consented to the Accused’s penetration of her vagina with his penis. The Accused did not deny that his penis penetrated the Victim’s vagina, albeit a little bit using the head of his penis. This requires the Court to consider:

  80. (i) Whether the Accused’s penetration of the Victim’s vagina with the head of his penis is a viable defence.

  81. (ii) The extent of the Victim’s intoxication, and whether she was so intoxicated that she would not have been able to give consent.

  82. (iii) Whether the Victim had personal motives to fabricate the Rape Charge against the Accused.

  83. (b) As for the House-breaking Charge, the issue is whether the Victim did in fact invite the Accused into the Unit, or had the Accused entered the Unit unlawfully by retrieving the key from underneath the Unit’s main door.

  84. [61] I shall deal with the facts pertaining to the Rape Charge first.

  85. The Rape Charge

  86. The Accused penetrated the Victim with his penis

  87. [62] For there to be rape of the Victim, the Accused’s penis must penetrate her vagina. This is not an issue as the Accused admits that his penis did penetrate the Victim’s vagina. The Accused admitted in his first statement to the police, ie, the 31 January Statement, which was given a day after the rape, that he might have penetrated the Victim’s vagina “a few times”. However, the Accused attempted to mitigate his conduct by testifying in Court that he had penetrated the Victim’s vagina once and it was “[j]ust a bit”, in that only the head of his penis went into her vagina.

  88. [63] I cannot accept the Accused’s explanation. It is not a defence to an offence of rape if the Accused had penetrated the Victim’s vagina “a bit” using the head of his penis. Section 375(1)(a) of the Penal Code does not distinguish between full and partial penetration. An offence of rape would have been made out even if the Accused had penetrated the Victim’s vagina a little bit if the Victim did not consent to the sexual intercourse.

  89. [64] Further, I find that the Accused was not truthful in his testimony when he said he only penetrated “a bit” into the Victim’s vagina. Ms Tang explained to the Court that an analysis of the high vaginal swab which Dr Lional had obtained from the Victim during her medical check-up at KKH tested positive for the Accused’s DNA:

  90. [65] Therefore, even if the Accused did not ejaculate into the Victim’s vagina, Ms Tang accepted the possibility that the Accused’s penis had entered the Victim’s high vaginal area. Dr Lional explained in her oral testimony that the high vaginal swab was “taken from deep into [the Victim’s] vagina at the fornix area”. This is “8 to 12 centimetres deep” from the surface of the vagina. Thus, the DNA evidence shows that the Accused’s penis had in fact penetrated deep into the Victim’s vagina.

  91. [66] The Accused did not dispute the accuracy and reliability of the scientific evidence indicating the presence of his DNA deep in the Victim’s vagina. The irrefutable scientific evidence is inconsistent with his repeated accounts that only a little bit of his penis entered the Victim’s vagina. If the Accused’s version were the truth, his DNA would not have been present deep in the Victim’s vagina.

  92. [67] When confronted with this forensic evidence on the second last day of the trial, the Accused realised the serious inconsistency in his evidence, and that he had to explain the presence of his DNA deep in the Victim’s vagina. He, therefore, claimed, for the first time, to the surprise of everyone in Court, that he had used his finger to penetrate the Victim’s vagina. This, he thought, would have been able to explain satisfactorily the presence of his DNA deep in the Victim’s vagina. I cannot accept the Accused’s very belated explanation. Nowhere in his evidence or throughout the course of his testimony at the trial did the Accused ever claim to have penetrated the Victim’s vagina with his finger. Both the Prosecution and the Defence agreed that it was the first time that the Accused mentioned that he also used his finger to penetrate the Victim’s vagina. These are the unsatisfactory answers of the Accused in Court:

  93. [68] This is one of the many clear examples of the Accused changing and fabricating his evidence on the go when he was on the witness stand. The Accused vacillated in his evidence when he denied that it was not the first time that he had mentioned about using his finger to penetrate the Victim’s vagina. It is clear that the Accused lied about informing Dr Phang that he had used his finger to penetrate the Victim’s vagina. When he was asked to explain, in the same breath, he retracted that claim and admitted he did not tell Dr Phang that he used his finger to penetrate the Victim’s vagina. The Accused also did not deny that he did not inform anyone that he had used his finger to penetrate the Victim’s vagina. When he was beleaguered by the evidence that was against him, he finally admitted that this was the first time he had made such a claim.

  94. [69] Therefore, I am unable to accept the Accused’s explanation that his DNA was found in the Victim’s vagina because he had used his finger to penetrate her vagina. I also disbelieve the Accused’s claim that he penetrated a little bit into the Victim’s vagina. The presence of the Accused’s DNA deep in the Victim’s vagina shows that the Accused had fully and completely inserted his penis into the Victim’s vagina.

  95. The Victim could not have consented to sexual intercourse with the Accused

  96. [70] I shall now consider whether, at the material time of the rape, the Victim had consented to have sexual intercourse with the Accused. This is the central plank of the Accused’s defence on the Rape Charge.

  97. [71] The Accused alleged that the issue of the Victim’s consent to the sexual intercourse started when she allegedly became physically intimate with the Accused at the KTV Lounge. The Victim also allegedly gave the Accused her address to the Unit (“the Address”), the access code to her apartment’s side gate (“the Access Code”), and her handphone number (“the Phone Number”). The Accused claimed that these actions from the Victim suggested to him that she was inviting the Accused to engage in further acts of physical intimacy and sexual acts at her home.

  98. [72] When the Accused returned to the Unit in the early morning of 30 January 2017, he claimed that he rang the doorbell to the Unit numerous times and knocked on the Unit’s main door. After some time, the Victim allegedly opened the door and invited the Accused into the Unit. The Accused described the Victim as appearing slightly intoxicated but was otherwise conscious. The Accused further alleged that the Victim spoke to him before she went to her bedroom. Thereafter, the Accused followed the Victim into her bedroom.

  99. [73] When the Accused entered the Victim’s bedroom, he claimed that the Victim continued to behave intimately towards him in her bedroom. The Accused undressed the Victim and asked the Victim what clothes she wanted to wear. According to the Accused, the Victim just shook her head and stayed silent. The Accused then used a blanket to cover the Victim and lay beside her. The Accused claimed that they kissed and had intimate physical contact with each other. When the Accused observed that the Victim had groaned in pleasure, he removed his pants and rubbed his penis against her vagina. The Victim supposedly did not protest. The Accused thus perceived that the Victim had implicitly consented, and therefore inserted his penis into the Victim’s vagina. When the Victim told him to stop, he immediately withdrew his penis from her vagina. The Defence thus argues that the Victim implicitly consented to all of the intimate physical acts in which both the Accused and the Victim partook, including the Accused’s sexual penetration of the Victim’s vagina with his penis.

  100. [74] In response to the Accused’s version of the events, the Victim said that she had no recollection whatsoever of any of the events. She said that “she had no recollection at all that she went to the [main] door to open the door and … spoken to the [A]ccused”. Responding to the Victim’s claim that she could not recall any of the events as alleged by the Accused, the Defence suggests that it is possible for the Victim to have given her consent to initiate sexual intercourse with the Accused, either by her words or by her conduct, despite her being unable to recall doing so.

  101. [75] The Defence relies on the Victim’s testimony regarding her prior experience of being unable to recall having consumed noodles when she was intoxicated. While she did in fact consume noodles, the Victim could only remember this after someone had reminded her about that event. According to the Defence, this indicated that the Victim suffered from selective recollection whenever she is intoxicated. It is, therefore, possible that the Victim had indulged in consensual sexual activities in her bedroom, but she could not recall as she was intoxicated. Accordingly, the Defence suggests that the Victim’s inability to recall the events that happened at the time surrounding the rape is not a bar to establishing that she did consent to have sexual intercourse with the Accused.

  102. [76] The Defence further submits, in the alternative, that the Victim could have given consent to the Accused because she was under the impression that the Accused was her ex-boyfriend, whom she missed very much. The Defence says that this is a possibility because, prior to the alleged rape, the Victim was reminiscing about her ex-boyfriend and was yearning for his return while at the KTV Lounge. The Defence thus suggests that, given the Victim’s state of intoxication, the Victim could have been operating under the mistaken assumption that the Accused was her ex-boyfriend and, therefore, gave her consent to the Accused while operating under this mistaken assumption. In response, the Victim clarified during her re-examination that she did not have any recollection of having sex with her ex-boyfriend before waking up on the morning of 30 January 2017; neither could she have mistaken the Accused as her ex-boyfriend.

  103. [78] I accept the Victim’s evidence as the true account of what had happened at the time of the sexual encounter, ie, that she was heavily intoxicated and could not have woken up to open the Unit’s main door to invite the Accused into the Unit and to have consensual sex with the Accused. I find that the Victim’s evidence is supported by the objective evidence and the testimonies of the various Prosecution’s witnesses. The evidence points towards the Victim being heavily intoxicated and unconscious at the time of the sexual encounter. Accordingly, I am satisfied that the Prosecution has established the Rape Charge beyond a reasonable doubt.

  104. [79] I shall now deal with each of the pieces of evidence in turn.

  105. (1) The CCTV Footage

  106. [80] The Prosecution relies on the CCTV Footage, which shows the ground floor lift lobby of the Apartment leading up to the Unit. The CCTV Footage shows Henry carrying the Victim to the lift lobby and appearing exhausted. He was seen placing her on the ground waiting for the lift together with Ma. Ma pressed the lift button to call for the lift. Even though Henry had propped the Victim up against a wall, she could not lean against the wall and tipped over onto the floor. When the lift arrived, Ma held the lift door open while Henry tried to carry the Victim into the lift. He could not carry her fully into the lift but instead carried and dragged her into the lift. When she was brought into the lift, her body was unresponsive, and her limbs were lifeless. This shows that the Victim was impervious to external stimuli and was not even able to exert minimum force to support herself. Indeed, Henry described the Victim as a “dead weight”. It is thus clear, from the CCTV Footage, that the Victim was completely unconscious and helpless.

  107. [81] Given the Victim’s state as depicted in the CCTV Footage, it is highly unlikely that the Victim would have been conscious when the Accused returned to the Unit on the morning of 30 January 2017, after sending the rest of the Victim’s friends back home. The Defence did not dispute the accuracy and reliability of the CCTV Footage. Indeed, the Defence recognised that the Victim was so intoxicated to the extent that she “couldn’t even walk” and had to be carried by Ma and Henry up to the Unit.

  108. [82] The CCTV Footage is thus very strong evidence that the Victim was heavily intoxicated and would have been in deep sleep at the material time of the rape which was about two hours later. That explains why the Victim did not respond to any of the Accused’s numerous calls which were made during his journey to the Unit the second time (see [31] above). Further, the Accused’s claim that the Victim had woken up to his ringing of the Unit’s doorbell and knocking on the main door could not have been possible. Indeed, it was inconceivable that the Victim could have brought herself to the main door, opened it, and responded meaningfully and relevantly to the Accused before inviting him in. Instead, it appears that the Victim was and remained completely incapacitated by the heavy intoxication when the Accused returned to the Unit. The CCTV Footage thus supports the Prosecution’s case that the Victim could not have given her consent to have sexual intercourse with the Accused.

  109. [83] I turn next to analyse the medical evidence adduced by the Prosecution to show that the Victim could not have been conscious right up to the time the Accused penetrated her vagina with his penis.

  110. (2) The Medical Evidence

  111. [84] There are two sets of expert evidence that the Prosecution relies on to support its case that the Victim was so intoxicated that she could not have either been conscious or in the right state of mind to give her consent.

  112. (A) Dr Lee’s expert report

  113. [85] Dr Lee opined in his expert report that the Victim’s BAC level, at the time of the rape, ranged from 79mg/100ml to 232mg/100ml, with the average reading of 144mg/100ml.

  114. [86] Dr Lee explained that his findings were based on the report prepared by the HSA’s Analytical Toxicology Laboratory which measured the Victim’s BAC level during her medical examination at KKH on the morning of 30 January 2017. Using those results, Dr Lee explained that he applied a “non-linear mathematical model” and extrapolated the Victim’s BAC level backwards to arrive at the estimated range of BAC at the time of the alleged rape. Dr Lee explained that there were three possible BAC levels which could reflect the approximate BAC level in the Victim’s body at the time of the rape. These results were reached by considering three possible metabolic rates: individuals with very rapid metabolic rates; the average metabolic rate of the population; and individuals with slow metabolic rates. Depending on the Victim’s metabolic rate, ie whether she has a fast, slow or average metabolic rate, her BAC level would also vary, from 232mg/100ml representing the BAC level in the Victim’s body at the time of the rape if she had a slow metabolic rate to 79mg/100ml if she had a fast metabolic rate. This range of BAC levels, according to Dr Lee, “may be associated with effects extending from mild to severe intoxication”.

  115. [87] The Defence submits that Dr Lee’s report alone is insufficient to determine the actual effects of intoxication on the Victim at the time of the rape. Dr Lee acknowledged that the effect of intoxication would still vary between individuals:

  116. [88] Dr Lee’s expert report on the Victim’s BAC level must, therefore, be considered together with the other corroborative evidence available before the Court to ascertain the Victim’s physical and mental state at the time of the rape. The Prosecution thus relies also on Dr Guo’s expert report and testimony to support its case on the extent of the Victim’s intoxication at the time of the rape. Dr Guo opined that the Victim’s physical and mental state at the time of the rape was that she was not capable of giving her consent to have sexual intercourse with the Accused. I shall now consider Dr Guo’s evidence.

  117. (B) Dr Guo’s expert report

  118. [89] Dr Guo’s evidence is that the Victim was in a state of high alcohol intoxication at the time of the rape. Her mental state would have been “fluctuating between deep sleep and partial awake state”, such that “it is unlikely that she would have fully become alert or recovered from the effects of alcohol intoxication”. Accordingly, she “would not have the cognitive abilities or sufficient mental capacity that is required for either consenting or rejecting the request for sexual intercourse”.

  119. [90] In reaching his findings, Dr Guo relied on the HSA toxicology report which indicates the Victim’s estimated BAC level, Dr Lee’s expert report, the CCTV Footage, and the Victim’s recollection of the night’s events which was described to Dr Guo during his interview with the Victim on 30 May 2019 and 24 July 2019. Dr Guo also elaborated on several medical concepts related to intoxication during his testimony, which he then used to explain the Victim’s physical and mental state at the time of the rape.

  120. [91] The first concept is the correlation between the BAC level in an individual’s blood and his or her physical and mental state. Dr Guo explained that as an individual consumes alcohol, the BAC level in his or her bloodstream rises. Even when the individual stops consuming alcohol, the BAC level will continue rising until it reaches a peak, before decreasing again.

  121. [92] As an individual’s BAC level rises, this would lead to the individual first entering a state of disinhibition. Disinhibition refers to an individual’s motivation to do an act or behave in a certain manner that would otherwise not have been the case if they were sober. Persons who have consumed alcohol might experience an elevation in mood and make imprudent or careless decisions as a result of being disinhibited. Disinhibition thus affects a person’s decision-making process.

  122. [93] Once the individual consumes sufficient alcohol, he or she then enters a state of sedation. Dr Guo explained that sedation is the degree of the person’s responsiveness to external stimuli. Sedation occurs in a range. Minimal sedation on the one hand would lead to an individual feeling drowsiness or sleepiness. Heavy sedation, on the other hand, may result in a person experiencing a blackout. Extreme sedation may also result in the person entering a condition of stupor or even coma and may eventually lead to death.

  123. [94] Dr Guo further explained that sedation affects a person’s psychomotor functions. The greater the extent of an individual’s intoxication, the more likely the individual’s psychomotor functions would be impaired. Dr Guo drew a distinction between an individual’s psychomotor function and consciousness. Consciousness relates to the individual’s awareness of his or her surroundings and the ability to respond to his or her surroundings relevantly. It is theoretically possible for an individual to be sedated and for his or her psychomotor functions to be compromised, but yet for him or her to remain conscious. However, the higher the level of intoxication, the less likely that individual will be conscious.

  124. [95] Dr Guo also explained that an individual who is heavily sedated due to alcohol intoxication would enter a state of stupor. In this mental state, the person will have no psychomotor functions, and may also be unconscious. Dr Guo further explained that there is a difference between an individual who is in a state of stupor versus an individual who is asleep. When an individual is asleep, it is possible to wake him or her up by applying external stimuli such as slapping or shaking that individual. An individual who is in a state of stupor, on the other hand, would unlikely be awakened despite the application of these external stimuli.

  125. [96] Finally, Dr Guo also explained the concept of amnesia. According to him, amnesia is a person’s incapability to recollect a certain event, despite being conscious at the time of that event. Amnesia occurs when the part of the brain that is involved in memory coding is impaired by alcohol. Accordingly, the higher the level of intoxication, the greater the likelihood of amnesia. Dr Guo then elaborated on two states of amnesia. In the first state, an individual can suffer from complete amnesia and he or she is unable to recall the events that had occurred. Dr Guo described this as “complete anterograde amnesia”. However, Dr Guo clarified that it is possible for that individual to be able to recall the events that occurred despite suffering from complete anterograde amnesia. This can be done either by his or her own efforts, or that individual is reminded of the incident by someone else. In the second state, the individual may be able to remember fragments of the events that occurred. This may occur where another individual had assisted the person in recollecting the events that occurred, such as by showing images or videos to that person. Dr Guo termed this “partial anterograde amnesia”.

  126. [97] Dr Guo explained that the occurrence of these symptoms is highly specific to each individual’s body. However, generally speaking, a person may experience a blackout when he or she suffers from severe alcohol intoxication. Further, there will be associated symptoms such as stupor, impairment of psychomotor skills, unconsciousness and amnesia. This will happen at around a BAC level range of between 100mg/100ml and 160mg/100ml. It is also possible for a person with a low alcohol tolerance to experience these symptoms.

  127. [98] Dr Guo opined that the Victim would likely have been suffering from amnesia when she was at the KTV Lounge. This is so despite the Victim appearing conscious, as seen from the videos captured on the handphone at the KTV Lounge. Dr Guo noted that the Victim began consuming alcohol in the afternoon on 29 January 2017 while she was celebrating Chinese New Year with her friends at the Unit. The build-up of BAC in her body would thus already have begun by then. Accordingly, the Victim would have experienced the effect of disinhibition caused by the gradual build-up of BAC in her body. When the Victim continued to consume alcohol at the KTV Lounge, there would be a continuous build-up of alcohol in her body. At a certain stage, the BAC level in the Victim would be sufficient to inhibit the memory coding portion of her brain, thereby leading her to suffer from amnesia.

  128. [99] Dr Guo further opined that, based on the Victim’s rate of consumption of alcohol and assuming that her last alcohol intake was at around 12.45am shortly before she left the KTV Lounge, the highest amount of BAC in the Victim’s body would have been around one to two hours after that. Given that the Victim was constantly consuming alcohol at the material time, this would lead to a steady increase in the concentration of BAC in her body. This in turn would lead to her becoming increasingly sedated, and her psychomotor functions would gradually become impaired.

  129. [100] At the point where the Victim was “knocked out and lying prone on the sofa in the KTV lounge” and was unable to wake up, Dr Guo opined that the Victim was already heavily sedated. Accordingly, the Victim would by then have entered a state of stupor, such that she would have been unconscious. In Dr Guo’s view, this explains why she remained unresponsive to external stimuli and was unable to wake up when she left the KTV Lounge.

  130. [101] Dr Guo was then shown the CCTV Footage of Henry and Ma carrying the Victim up to the Unit (see [80] above). The Victim’s unresponsiveness to external stimuli further supports Dr Guo’s finding that she was in a state of stupor. Accordingly, the Victim would have been unconscious and unaware of her surroundings. Dr Guo opined that the Victim’s inability to respond to the numerous calls which the Accused made to her handphone prior to his return to the Unit is consistent with her heavy state of sedation and her being unconscious.

  131. [102] It is important to note that Dr Guo explained that the Victim’s average BAC level was about 144mg/100ml at the time of the rape. Hence, her psychomotor functions would have been impaired as she was likely to be in a state of sedation. Thus, Dr Guo explained that it would not be possible for the Victim to have done all the actions which the Accused had alleged, including responding to the Accused’s knocking on the main door of the Unit or the ringing of the doorbell, waking up from her bed, walking to the door, unlocking the door and also pulling it to open the door.

  132. [103] Further, given the Victim’s state of intoxication and the estimated BAC level in her body, Dr Guo testified that it would have been “almost impossible” for her to have recognised and spoken to the Accused after opening the main door. What the Accused had narrated in respect of the Victim’s actions, in Dr Guo’s view, involved “complex … [and] [v]oluntary” actions and was in essence the Victim responding relevantly to her environment. If indeed these had happened, Dr Guo suggested that the Victim would have been able to form a memory of it, such that she would have been able to recall that series of events. Dr Guo also confirmed that, if the Victim was already experiencing amnesia while she was at the KTV Lounge, it would not have been possible for her to have recognised the Accused when she saw him after opening the main door, as the Accused alleged.

  133. [104] Even on the Accused’s alternate case that the Victim might had mistaken the Accused for her ex-boyfriend (see [76] above), Dr Guo’s evidence is that this would not have been possible. On the Accused’s version, if the Victim could perform various complex actions, such as walking from her bedroom to the main door, unlocking the door, responding and talking to the Accused and walking back to the bedroom to have consensual sex with the Accused, Dr Guo opined that the Victim’s cognitive functions and state would have been functioning at full capacity. Accordingly, it would not have been possible for her, at any point in time, to have mistaken the Accused for her ex-boyfriend.

  134. [105] Dr Guo opined that the Victim’s physical state at the time of the rape was likely to be in a state of sedation, such that her psychomotor functions (and therefore her reaction to external stimuli) would have been impaired. As for her mental state at the time the Accused raped her, Dr Guo explained that the Victim “would have been still fluctuating between deep sleep and partial awake state”. This was likely the case, according to Dr Guo, because of the Victim’s high average BAC level of 144 mg/100m. In other words, at the time the Accused penetrated the Victim, she was likely in a state of “deep sleep” or in a state of “partial awake”. Dr Guo further testified that when the Victim was in a state of “deep sleep”, this meant that she would be unconscious, and would definitely not have the capacity to consent. If the Victim was in the “partial awake” state, she would only have a “little bit of awareness” and would not have been conscious enough to appreciate her surroundings and consent to sex. Under these circumstances, Dr Guo concluded that the Victim would not have the cognitive abilities or sufficient mental capacity to consent to the sexual intercourse.

  135. [106] In an attempt to discredit Dr Guo’s evidence and to cast doubt on the Prosecution’s case, the Defence submits that Dr Guo’s evidence does not negate the possibility that the Victim was operating on a level of consciousness that demonstrates her ability to appreciate and know what she was doing. Thus, the Defence submits that it remains possible for the Victim to be capable of giving the Accused her consent to have sexual intercourse. The Defence relies on the following points.

  136. [107] First, Dr Guo would not have been able to ascertain how long the Victim had taken to recover from the effects of alcohol intoxication. Accordingly, Dr Guo could not rule out the possibility that the Victim would have already been conscious and awake, although slightly intoxicated, when the Accused arrived at the Unit the second time at approximately 3.04am on 30 January 2017.

  137. [108] Second, the Defence relies on Dr Guo’s concession that he would not have been able to conclusively say, simply based on the estimated reading of the Victim’s BAC level at 144 mg/100ml, that she was so intoxicated as to be in a state of unconsciousness and was, therefore, unable to give consent. The Defence submits that Dr Guo acknowledged that he did not have the benefit of any objective evidence at the time of the rape to ascertain whether the Victim had the capacity to consent to the sexual intercourse. The Defence further points out Dr Guo’s concession that it was not possible to know the exact BAC level in the Victim’s body from 3.04am to 3.44am, ie, the time the Accused gained entry to the Unit on the second occasion until the Accused raped the Victim and left the Unit.

  138. [109] Finally, the mere fact of the Victim being unable to recall that she had given consent to the Accused does not necessarily negate this possibility. Instead, this could be attributed simply to the Victim suffering from amnesia. In making this point, the Defence relies on Dr Guo’s evidence that, while she was at the KTV Lounge, the Victim appeared to be conscious and aware of what she was doing, but she was in fact in a state of blackout and could not remember what she was doing at that time. The Defence, therefore, suggests that the Victim could have been in a similar state at the time the Accused reached the Unit at 3.04am. That would explain why the Victim was unable to recall the fact of her opening the main door, inviting the Accused into the Unit, and having consensual sex with him. Accordingly, the Defence submits that the Victim knew what she was doing; she had consensual sexual intercourse with the Accused, albeit she was unable to remember that she had in fact given her consent.

  139. [111] Finally, I do not accept the Defence’s suggestion that the Victim was suffering from amnesia and hence was unable to recall whether she did in fact consent to have sexual intercourse with the Accused and that this does not negate the possibility that she did indeed give consent. This simply goes against the weight of the undisputed scientific medical evidence before the Court. As Dr Guo explained, the Victim was extremely intoxicated at the time of the rape, such that she was fluctuating between a state of “deep sleep” (and was thus unconscious) and “partial awake” (that she had limited awareness of her surroundings). It could simply not have been the case that the Victim was merely suffering from amnesia. Further, Dr Guo also explained that it was not possible for the Victim to be suffering from amnesia at that time, given that her BAC level was descending at the time of the rape.

  140. [112] I accept Dr Guo’s evidence as supporting the Prosecution’s case that the Victim lacked the capacity to consent to have sexual intercourse with the Accused due to her state of heavy intoxication.

  141. (3) Call Logs

  142. [113] I shall now deal with the parties’ submissions on the Call Logs.

  143. [114] When the Accused was on his way to the Apartment after dropping Heng off and prior to the Accused entering the Unit the second time, he made numerous calls to the Victim’s handphone. In this respect, the Call Logs showed that the Accused made the first call on 30 January 2017 at 2.44am, and the last call at 3.04am on the same day. A total of 12 calls were made by the Accused to the Victim’s handphone. The Victim did not answer any of the Accused’s phone calls.

  144. [115] Shortly after the Accused left the Unit after the rape, the Call Logs showed numerous incoming and outgoing calls between the Victim and several numbers. According to the Victim, some of these calls were erroneous calls that she made while she was still intoxicated. The Victim testified that she had received calls from a number which she did not recognise at first as it was not in her handphone’s contact list, but she later recognised that it was the Accused’s handphone number. The Call Logs also showed that some of these calls between the Victim and the Accused went through, and that the Victim had purportedly engaged in conversations with the respective caller at the other end of the line.

  145. [116] Despite this, the Victim explained that she could not recall any conversations which took place between herself and the Accused. She also could not recall a phone call between her and the Accused that lasted three minutes and two seconds long. Instead, all that the Victim could recall from “pieces of [her] recollection” was receiving “a call from an unknown person not in [her] contact list” and hanging up the phone.

  146. (A) The Victim’s physical and mental state

  147. [117] The Defence’s case in respect of the Call Logs after the Accused had left the Unit, is that they constitute evidence that the Victim was sufficiently conscious at or around the material time of the rape. The Defence argues as follows. The Victim was sober enough to call Ma and her ex-boyfriend, that she was sober enough to return her missed calls, and finally, that she was sufficiently sober to remember the sequence of calls which she made. Accordingly, the Defence suggests that the Victim’s mental capacity to make numerous calls from her handphone is indicative of her state of consciousness.

  148. [118] Further, the Call Logs showed that there were several calls which lasted for durations ranging from half a minute to three minutes. This supports the finding that the Victim was conscious enough to communicate with other callers. The Defence thus submits that the Call Logs show that the Victim was in fact conscious shortly after the alleged rape. It follows she would have been sufficiently conscious at the time leading up to the rape, to have performed all the actions which the Accused described at [73] above.

  149. [119] It is true that the Call Logs showed several calls made to and from the Victim’s handphone after the rape. However, I do not accept that this shows that the Victim was sufficiently conscious following the rape, such that she must also have been conscious at the time of the rape. Thus, in her state of confusion and intoxication, I find it entirely probable that the Victim might have unconsciously pressed some buttons on her smartphone and thus made calls to several phone numbers or pressed the wrong numbers in her attempt to call the police or her friends to seek assistance. Moreover, the Victim’s mental state was not only affected by her intoxication but was further aggravated by the traumatic and shocking experience of being raped by the Accused in her own bedroom.

  150. [120] A few of the calls went through with durations ranging from half a minute to three minutes. However, it does not follow from these calls that the Victim necessarily talked to the person on the other end of the line, nor does it suggest that the Victim was fully conscious shortly after the rape. Since the Victim was still recovering from the effects of heavy alcohol intoxication at that time, I find that the Victim would not have been entirely conscious or alert, and might, therefore, not have known that the calls were connected such as to converse with the person on the line.

  151. [121] Indeed, as Dr Guo explained both in his expert report and at the trial, the Victim was recovering from a stupor and was thus fluctuating between a state of deep sleep and being partially awake, ie, between a state of consciousness and unconsciousness. While the Victim might have been able to move around and respond to her environment, she would not yet be sufficiently conscious enough to recall the events that occurred after the rape or to respond meaningfully or relevantly to her surroundings. Thus, I am unable to accept the Defence’s case that the Call Logs support the finding that the Victim was conscious and was able to give her consent to have sexual intercourse with the Accused.

  152. [122] The Defence’s reliance on the Call Logs as evidence that the Victim was sufficiently conscious and hence possessed the capacity to consent to sexual intercourse is also speculative and inconclusive. As Dr Guo pointed out, it is important to ascertain whether there was any dialogue or conversation in these Log Calls. In the absence of any dialogues, the sole fact that the Victim had made or picked up calls for a certain duration is equivocal to the issue of whether she was conscious. This further supports the Prosecution’s case. Even if the Victim was conscious as alleged by the Accused, the evidence does not suggest that she consented to have sex with the Accused.

  153. (B) The Accused’s motive

  154. [123] The Defence also relies on the Accused’s calls to the Victim, which were recorded in the Call Logs while he was on the way to the Unit for the second time, to show that the Accused could not have had the motive to rape the Victim. The Defence submits that the only reason why the Accused had returned to the Unit was because he “was concerned for [the Victim] and because [she] didn’t pick up his calls”. The Defence submits that the fact that the Accused called the Victim multiple times showed that “he was very open and candid about it … [and] had nothing to hide”. The Defence argues that “generally if a person has an ulterior motive … he wouldn’t leave call records behind to have himself identified”. Accordingly, the Defence submits that “this is not a case whereby after dropping [the Victim’s] friends, the [A]ccused quietly and discreetly came up to [the Unit] without making any calls, without asking anyone”. The Accused would not have left trails of incriminating evidence if he, at that time, had known that the calls would be used as evidence against him. Further, the Accused thought that he could get away with the rape as the Victim was completely unconscious when he last saw her, and he never expected the Victim to suddenly wake up in the midst of the rape.

  155. [124] I reject the Defence’s arguments. The Accused testified that after he sent Heng home, he proceeded to drive back to the Apartment as he wanted to check on the Victim. The Accused made the first call to the Victim at 2.44am, after he decided to return to the Apartment. Thus, the Accused had already decided to return to the Apartment even before he made the first call. The Accused’s intention to return to the Unit to have sex with the Victim is evident from the Pre-Polygraph Interview, where the Accused informed SSI Chea that he “went back to look for the Victim to see if there was an opportunity to have sex with her”.

  156. [125] Therefore, the Accused made multiple phone calls to the Victim’s Phone Number, not because the Accused showed concern for her safety, but to satisfy himself that she was still unconscious due to her intoxication. Indeed, when the Accused left the Victim’s Unit together with Henry and Ma, he knew that the Victim was completely intoxicated and was in a stupor. The 12 calls which the Accused made was, therefore, to confirm that the Victim remained intoxicated and unconscious. This would enable him to take advantage of the Victim’s unconsciousness to outrage her modesty with a view to rape her. The Accused’s reliance on the Call Logs does not necessarily indicate that he was “concerned” for the Victim.

  157. [126] Even on the Accused’s account, if the Accused truly showed concern for the Victim, he would have displayed his relief when the Victim opened the main door and spoke to him upon his arrival at the Unit the second time. This showed that she would have been sober and conscious and more importantly, that she was safe. Indeed, the Accused admitted this in Court:

  158. [127] When the Accused was purportedly happy that the Victim was alright, he should have left the Unit thereafter as his supposed “concern” for the Victim’s safety would have been addressed. The whole purpose of his return to the Unit, ie, to ensure the Victim was alright, would have been fulfilled. On his own account, he was “very happy” that the Victim was sober and in good condition. He could have left the Unit after that. There was, therefore, no reason for him to have remained in the Unit for such a long time. In this context, it would have been entirely unnecessary and inappropriate for him to have entered the Victim’s Unit and followed her into her bedroom in the early hours of the morning, let alone to remain in the Unit for about 40 minutes, ie, from 3.04am to 3.44am.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.