General Division of the High Court · Decided 28 April 2023
Hyflux Ltd (in compulsory liquidation) and others v Lum Ooi Lin
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 113 · Case no. Suit No 267 of 2022 (Registrar’s Appeal No 42 of 2023) · 12 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [2]
[2] In essence, the plaintiffs are appealing against the learned SAR’s decision as to the form of the security. More particularly, the plaintiffs would like the form of security to be restricted to the Undertaking only, instead of effectively vesting the eventual form of security on the defendant’s wishes.
The parties’ positions
- [4]
[4] The parties’ positions can be stated briefly. The plaintiffs and the defendant had agreed on the quantum of security, which is $90,000. However, they disagree as to the form of the security.
- [5]
[5] The plaintiffs’ position is that they can provide security by way of an undertaking from their litigation funders, OB, and OBS. In particular, the plaintiffs argue that the Undertaking provides adequate protection and does not impose an unacceptable disadvantage to the defendant. The plaintiffs emphasise, among others, that the Undertaking is an irrevocable and unconditional promise by OB and OBS that is akin to a bank guarantee. This is because the Undertaking is a promise given by entities with the means to pay, who would in all likelihood make payment without the need for enforcement, and in any case, against whom enforcement can be readily obtained.
My decision: the appeal is allowed
The purpose of a security for costs
The relevant considerations in deciding the form of security
Order 23 r 2 of the Rules of Court 2014
- [10]
[10] The starting point is O 23 r 2 of the ROC 2014 (“O 23 r 2”), which provides as follows:
(a) the plaintiff is entitled to propose security in a form least disadvantageous to it;
(b) the plaintiff bears a “practical onus” of establishing that the proposed security is adequate and does not impose an “unacceptable disadvantage” on the defendant;
(d) based on these and any other relevant considerations, the Court will determine how justice is best served in the particular circumstances of the case.
- [13]
[13] With these observations in mind, I turn to examine each of the two principles I outlined above.
The plaintiff is not restricted to any fixed form of security for costs
- [22]
[22] Moreover, while Mr Shankar asked that I treat with caution Hargrave J’s approach in DIF III Global in light of the decisions of the Victoria Court of Appeal in Trailer Trash Franchise Systems Pty Ltd v GM Fascia & Gutter Pty Ltd [2017] VSCA 293 (“Trailer Trash”) and of the English Court of Appeal in AP (UK) Ltd v West Midlands Fire and Civil Defence Authority [2001] EWCA Civ 1917 (“AP (UK)”), I do not think that the reasoning in these decisions justifies a departure from the approach in DIF III Global.
- [24]
[24] In AP (UK), the English Court of Appeal expressed what was in substance the same concern. Longmore LJ (with whom the other Lord Justices agreed) distinguished Rosengrens (where the same court was concerned with the options of payment of money into court, a solicitor’s undertaking, and banker’s guarantee), from the option proposed by the appellant in AP (UK), which was a charge on real property. The learned Lord Justice opined that while the alternatives to payment of money into court in Rosengrens were “simple and straightforward” if enforcement became necessary, the principle in Rosengrens was not so broad as to include “a charge on real property with all the risks that would follow from enforcement of that charge and a forced sale” (at [15]).
The plaintiff bears the burden of showing that the proposed form of security is adequate
- [31]
[31] The same core consideration also applies in Australia. Thus, in DIF III Global, the plaintiffs appealed against a lower court’s decision that security should be provided in the form of “deposit into Court, or by way of [a] guarantee from an agreed Australian bank or other authorised deposit-taking institution” (see the Victoria Supreme Court decision of DIF III Global Co-Investment Fund, LP v BBLP LLC [2015] VCS 484 at [131]). Instead, the plaintiffs wanted to provide security in the form of, among others, a deed of indemnity to be given by a United Kingdom insurance company, AmTrust Europe Ltd (“AmTrust”).
- [33]
[33] With these principles in mind, I come to the facts of the present case.
The form of the Undertaking does not mean it is inadequate
- [35]
[35] In this regard, the defendant cites two cases which she claims support the general proposition being advanced. However, these cases all turned, as they should, on their particular facts. I do not think they can be extrapolated to stand for any broader principle beyond that a security in the form of an undertaking by funders was not adequate on the particular facts of those cases.
As can be seen, the learned judge was convinced by the specific characteristics of the funder in that case in holding that an undertaking by the funder would not be an adequate form of security. Also, while the learned judge did not allude to this fact, it should be kept in mind that Northern Southern Western Supermarkets was decided in 2002, which is about the same time as when Roberts-Smith J in Global Finance Group described litigation funding as a developing area of business. Accordingly, I cannot think that the case stands for any broader proposition that the defendant appears to extrapolate from it.
The Undertaking is an adequate form of security
- [44]
[44] Third, there is little to no risk of OB or OBS not honouring the Undertaking because of the substantial damage that they would suffer in not doing so. This is because OB and OBS are in the business of litigation funding. If they will not honour an undertaking in respect of an ongoing litigation, I can imagine that potential or current clients will not see them in a positive light. Thus, similar to Iddles, there would be little or no risk of satellite litigation surrounding the enforcement of the Undertaking.
Conclusion
- [52]
[52] In closing, I would like to thank Mr Tan and Mr Shankar for their most helpful and clear submissions.