High Court · Decided 3 April 2025
Le Ninh Tien v Rainbow Forest Enterprises Lt d and others
Feedback & support[2025] SGHCR 3 · Case no. Originating Claim No 665 of 2024 (Summons No 158 of 2025) · 17 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Background
- [2]
[2] For context, I first set out some information about the underlying claim, HC/OC 665/2024 (“OC 665”), which is for minority oppression. The 5th defendant is an asset-holding vehicle, whose sole asset is the vessel FPSO Song Doc Pride MV 19 (“vessel”). The registered shareholders of the 5th defendant (and their respective shareholdings) are the 4th defendant (1%), the claimant (40%), and the 1st defendant (59%). One Truong Dinh Hoe (“TDH”) is the ultimate beneficial owner of the 1st defendant. The claimant, the 2nd defendant and 3rd defendant are directors of the 5th defendant. The 2nd and 3rd defendants are TDH’s nominee directors.
- [3]
[3] The primary reliefs sought by the claimant in OC 665 are to buy over the shares in the 5th defendant which are held by the 1st and 4th defendants, or have them buy him out.
- [4]
[4] In August 2024, the claimant made his first application for injunctions against the 1st to 4th defendants, in HC/SUM 2468/2024 (“SUM 2468”). These were primarily to restrain the 1st to 4th defendants from selling, transferring or disposing of the vessel. The injunctions were granted on condition that the claimant provided fortification of S$1 million by 6 September 2024. The claimant was unable to provide the fortification by the stated deadline, and the injunctions expired and terminated.
- [5]
[5] In November 2024, the claimant again sought, and obtained, similar injunctions, in HC/SUM 2695/2024 (“SUM 2695”). The injunctions were again granted on condition that the claimant provided fortification, but the amount was increased to S$1.5 million. The claimant has since provided the fortification.
- [7]
[7] In January 2025, TDH was added as the 6th defendant in OC 665, after which he filed a counterclaim against the claimant.
Present application
- [8]
[8] The application before me, SUM 158, was the 1st to 4th defendants’ application against the claimant for SFC. I will herein refer to the 1st to 4th defendants as “the applicants” collectively where their position in SUM 158 is concerned, but to minimise confusion, I will still refer to the claimant as “claimant”, instead of “respondent”, and to the individual defendants as “1st/2nd/3rd/4th/5th/6th defendant” as necessary. The applicants sought orders for two amounts:
(a) S$90,000 as security for their collective costs for all work done in relation to OC 665 until set down; and
(b) S$30,000 as security for their collective costs for all work done in relation to SUM 2695.
It was not disputed that the claimant holds an Australian passport and is not ordinarily resident in Singapore. The applicants therefore relied on O 9 r 12(1)(a) of the Rules of Court 2021 (“ROC 2021”) to ground their application.
The Law
- [10]
[10] In Creative Elegance (M) Sdn Bhd v Puay Kim Seng [1999] SLR(R) 112 at [18] to [25], the Court of Appeal noted the factors a court would typically consider in such an application:
(a) whether the claimant has a bona fide claim;
(b) the claimant’s financial standing;
(c) the ease of enforcing any judgment for costs against the claimant;
(d) the relative strength of parties’ cases; and
(e) whether the application has been taken out oppressively to stifle the claimant’s action.
Essentially, the court must strike a balance between an outcome that is too oppressive for the claimant, and one that gives the defendant a measure of security (see Singapore Civil Procedure at 9/12/1).
- [11]
[11] The first issue to be determined in this application was whether SFC should be granted. The second issue of the quantum of the SFC to be awarded would arise only if the first issue was answered in the affirmative.
Issue 1: Whether SFC should be granted
Parties’ positions
My decision on the granting of SFC
Ease or difficulty in enforcing a judgment against the claimant
- [15]
[15] In this regard, I noted that in explaining his inability to provide fortification on time for SUM 2468, the claimant had stated in his supporting affidavit for SUM 2695 (filed on 18 September 2024) that this was caused in part by banks being closed in Vietnam due to public holidays, followed by a typhoon which caused significant portions of Vietnam to close. I pointed this out to counsel for the claimant Ms Ong Hui Wen, noting that this suggested that the claimant’s main assets were in Vietnam rather than Australia. In response, Ms Ong did not contend otherwise, and conceded that Vietnam was not gazetted under the Reciprocal Enforcement of Foreign Judgments Act 1959.
Oppressively stifling the claim
- [19]
[19] On balance, I did not find that an application for SFC in and of itself operated to oppressively stifle the claimant’s claim.
Relative strength of parties’ cases
- [20]
[20] The applicants’ third point was that they were very likely to prevail in their defence. This was connected to the question of whether the claimant had a bona fide claim, because answering this question in the negative would likely result in a finding that the applicants were very likely to prevail in their defence. Ms Ong submitted that the claimant’s claim did not lack bona fides, since the courts which granted the injunctions to the claimant in SUM 2468 and SUM 2695 found that there was a serious question to be tried on the merits of the case.
- [21]
[21] A key contention regarding the merits of the parties’ cases was whether the claimant paid valuable consideration for his 40% shareholding in the 5th defendant, which translated to his share in the vessel. The claimant contended that he did pay such valuable consideration (see para 13(a) of the 1st amended Statement of Claim). The applicants contended otherwise, on the basis that the money which was paid to transfer the said 40% share to the claimant came from the 6th defendant (see para 4 of 1st amended Defence and Counterclaim). The applicants thus contended that the claimant could not substantively succeed in OC 665, because even if minority oppression is found, he would be bought out for a nominal sum.
- [22]
[22] It is trite that in an application for SFC, the court generally does not go into a detailed examination of the merits of the case. Based on the information before me, I noted that Justice Aidan Xu, in granting the injunctions in SUM 2695, found that the claimant demonstrated serious issues to be tried. Nevertheless, this did not mean that the claimant had a strong case. This was because the defendants, in their amended Defence, referred to evidence supporting their position that the claimant’s acquisition of shares in the 5th defendant was paid for by the 6th defendant. This has yet to be addressed by the claimant since the Reply has yet to be filed.
- [23]
[23] I pause to observe that if the 6th defendant effectively funded the claimant’s acquisition of a 40% share in a company that essentially belonged to the 6th defendant, then it was an unusual arrangement. Since both the claimant and the 6th defendant appear to be seasoned businessmen, they must have had their reasons for this. The circumstances under which they came to this arrangement would address the issue of whether the claimant provided valuable consideration for his acquisition, and these are matters to be determined at trial. Given the incomplete evidence before me, to make a finding that the applicants are “very likely to prevail” in their defence would be pre-judging the matter, and I declined to do so. In my view, at best, there are triable issues.
- [24]
[24] For the present purposes, my view was that the relative strength of the parties’ cases seemed to be evenly balanced at this time. I therefore found this to be a neutral point.
Whether the balance lay in the applicants’ favour
Whether the 6th defendant was “hiding behind” the applicants
- [26]
[26] On the fifth point, the applicants explained that the 6th defendant was not party to the present application because he had filed a counterclaim against the claimant, which might preclude him from obtaining SFC from the claimant. Since it is settled law that a court would consider any overlap between a claim and a counterclaim in determining whether to grant a defendant SFC, my view was that this was a valid reason for the 6th defendant not being party to this application.
Issue 2: What quantum of SFC should be awarded
Parties’ positions
- [30]
[30] He stated that it had been their “intention all along” for the S$100,000 to include the work done in OC 665 until set down and the work done in relation to SUM 2695. That figure of S$100,000 was discounted as the applicants hoped to obtain the claimant’s agreement to the SFC. However, as the claimant counter-proposed a lower amount and then placed the condition that the 6th defendant furnish SFC as well, such that parties were unable to agree and this application had to be brought, the applicants were now seeking the “full amount” of S$120,000. On the matter of why the 6 December letter did not specify the components of the amount sought, Mr Tan could only say that it was an “oversight”.
My decision on quantum of costs
Costs
Parties’ positions
My decision on costs