General Division of the High Court · Decided 19 July 2023
Razer (Asia-Pacific) Pte Ltd v Capgemini Singapore Pte Ltd
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 195 · Case no. Suit No 1233 of 2020 · 9 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Facts
The parties
- [2]
[2] The plaintiff, Razer (Asia-Pacific) Pte Ltd (“Razer”), is a company incorporated in Singapore. It is in the business of high-performance gaming hardware, software, services and systems, financial technology services, and digital payments.
- [3]
[3] The defendant, Capgemini Singapore Pte Ltd (“Capgemini”), is a professional services company incorporated in Singapore. It provides information technology consultancy services.
Background
- [5]
[5] Razer claimed that Capgemini had breached the express and implied terms of the agreements between them: Razer (Asia-Pacific) at [34]–[35]. Further, Capgemini’s alleged contractual breaches caused the Data Leak between 18 June 2020 and 9 September 2020 and caused Razer to suffer, among other things, reputational damage, which caused its sales revenue to decrease significantly: Razer (Asia-Pacific) at [36]. For context, these agreements referred to the consulting services agreement (“CSA”) and the Data Processing Addendum (“DPA”) which Razer had entered into with White Sky Labs (Singapore) Pte Ltd (“WSL”) on 1 March 2019 and 20 March 2019, respectively. On 1 June 2020, after Capgemini acquired WSL, Capgemini assumed the obligations of WSL under the agreements: Razer (Asia-Pacific) at [4], [15] and [18].
- [6]
[6] In the alternative, Razer claimed that Capgemini was negligent when assisting Razer to resolve its inability to log into and access the Kibana server and/or its application (the “Login Problem”) on 18 June 2020, and/or that Capgemini was vicariously liable for the injury, loss, and damage sustained as a result of Mr Cabalag’s negligence: Razer (Asia-Pacific) at [19] and [39]. The resulting negative press caused Razer to suffer loss of profits and loss of chance to secure potential business opportunities: Razer (Asia-Pacific) at [40].
The parties’ cases
The decision
Relevant legal principles
Contractual entitlement to indemnity costs
Offer to settle
- [16]
[16] What is “favourable” must be determined on the terms of the offer to settle. A more “favourable” sum offered in settlement means “more in terms of dollar value than what has been awarded”: Tan Shwu Leng v Singapore Airlines Limited and another [2001] SGHC 51 (“Tan Shwu Leng”) at [96]. However, “[i]n an offer to settle which contains many terms, the sum offered in settlement is only one factor to be taken into account in determining whether the plaintiff’s judgment is more favourable than the offer to settle”: CCM Industrial Pte Ltd v Uniquetech Pte Ltd [2009] 2 SLR(R) 20 (“CCM Industrial”) at [40]; also see SCP at para 22A/9/3.
Analysis
Contractual entitlement to indemnity costs
- [18]
[18] Clause 12 of the CSA reads:
- [19]
[19] Clause 12 of the DPA reads:
- [20]
[20] It was undisputed that the Indemnity Clauses were engaged, in light of my decision in Razer (Asia-Pacific). Clause 12 of the DPA was engaged as Capgemini had breached cl 7 of the DPA: Razer (Asia-Pacific) at [56]. Clause 12 of the CSA was engaged as cll 3(ii)(a) and 3(ii)(c) had been beached, and these were occasioned by the failure of WSL (which Capgemini acquired in March 2020 and whose obligations Capgemini had assumed) to “[perform] its services to an appropriate standard of proficiency, skill and quality” and the failure to use “reasonable methods and due care” to “protect against harmful code”: Razer (Asia-Pacific) at [4] and [82].
- [23]
[23] I now come to the present facts. The pleading in question was set out in paras 24 and 25 of Razer’s Statement of Claim, which I reproduce below:
Offer to settle
Conclusion