General Division of the High Court · Decided 25 August 2023
Public Prosecutor v Tan Yew Kuan and another
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 235 · Case no. Criminal Case No 5 of 2023
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] This is a joint trial involving two accused persons, Mr Tan Yew Kuan (“Mr Tan”) and Mr Dineshkumar Sambusivam (“Mr Dineshkumar”).
- [2]
[2] The first accused, Mr Tan, faces a charge of having in his possession not less than 37.95g of diamorphine (“the Drugs”) for the purpose of trafficking on 25 February 2020. This is an offence under s 5(1)(a) read with s 5(2) of the Misuse of Drugs Act (Cap 185, 2008 Rev Ed) (“the MDA”).
- [3]
[3] The second accused, Mr Dineshkumar, faces a charge for the trafficking of the Drugs to Mr Tan on 25 February 2020, an offence under s 5(1)(a) of the MDA.
The Prosecution’s case
- [4]
[4] On 25 February 2020, Mr Tan was arrested shortly after he collected the Drugs from Mr Dineshkumar. As against Mr Tan, the Prosecution’s case is that the presumption of possession under s 18(1) of the MDA applies, and Mr Tan was in possession of the entire quantity of the Drugs. Further, the presumption of knowledge under s 18(2) of the MDA (ie, Mr Tan knew the nature of the drugs) applies. Mr Tan is unable to rebut the presumptions. Further, Mr Tan was in possession of the Drugs for the purpose of trafficking. Notably, in the course of investigations, he admitted in his statements that he intended to deliver the Drugs on the instructions of one “Pal”.
- [5]
[5] As regards Mr Dineshkumar, the Prosecution’s case is that Mr Dineshkumar had actual possession of the Drugs before he delivered them to Mr Tan. He was arrested shortly after the delivery. Mr Dineshkumar knew the nature of the Drugs (as he, too, is unable to rebut the presumption of knowledge under s 18(2) of the MDA). By delivering them to Mr Tan, Mr Dineshkumar had trafficked the Drugs.
- [6]
[6] I now set out the evidence, which is largely undisputed.
Arrest of the accused persons and seizure of the exhibits
- [7]
[7] On 25 February 2020, between 5.30pm and 7.45pm, a team of Central Narcotics Bureau (“CNB”) officers arrived at the vicinity of Block 23 Toa Payoh East (“Block 23”) to keep a lookout for Mr Tan.
- [8]
[8] At about 10.25pm, Station Inspector Tay Keng Chye (“SI Sunny”) saw a Malaysian-registered car bearing the registration number JGE8363 (“the Car”) stop along Lorong 7 Toa Payoh (“Lorong 7”) near the entrance to the car park of Block 23. The Car was driven by Mr Dineshkumar. Shortly after, SI Sunny saw Mr Tan walking towards the Car and boarding the Car with a black recycle bag (“the Recycle Bag” – later marked as “E1”).
- [9]
[9] When Mr Tan was in the Car, Mr Dineshkumar drove along Lorong 7 and Lorong 6 Toa Payoh (“Lorong 6”). While Mr Tan was in the Car, a white tied-up plastic bag (marked “E1A”) and a black tied-up plastic bag (marked “E1B”) were placed into the Recycle Bag.
- [10]
[10] At about 10.27pm, Station Inspector Wong Kah Hung Alwin (“SI Alwin”) saw Mr Tan alight from the Car when it stopped at the junction of Lorong 6 and Toa Payoh East. Mr Tan was seen to be carrying the Recycle Bag when he got off from the Car. The Car moved off thereafter.
- [11]
[11] Subsequently, the CNB officers moved in to arrest both Mr Tan and Mr Dineshkumar. At about 10.28pm, Mr Tan was arrested at the sheltered walkway beside Block 23. As for Mr Dineshkumar, at about 10.30pm, he was apprehended after the Car was intercepted along Lorong 6 towards Lorong 2 Toa Payoh.
- [12]
[12] Upon Mr Tan’s arrest, the Recycle Bag was seized by SI Alwin. SI Alwin saw that the Recycle Bag contained, among other things, two tied-up plastic bags, E1A and E1B. SI Alwin then placed the Recycle Bag, along with all its contents, into a tamper-proof bag and duly sealed that bag. Afterwards, Mr Tan was escorted back to his residence at Block 23 (“the Unit”).
- [13]
[13] In the Unit, and in the presence of Mr Tan, a search was conducted on, among other things, the Recycle Bag. The two plastic bags, E1A and E1B, were taken out of the Recycle Bag and opened. Two black-taped bundles (marked “E1A1” and “E1A2” respectively) were recovered from E1A, while another two black-taped bundles (marked “E1B1” and “E1B2” respectively) were recovered from E1B. I shall refer to these as “the Four Bundles”. Out of these, E1A1, E1A2 and E1B1 (“the Three Bundles”) contained the Drugs in question, while the remaining bundle, E1B2, contained not less than 163.75g of methamphetamine and some glass utensils.
- [14]
[14] Separately, after Mr Dineshkumar was arrested, he was brought to a multi-storey car park located at Block 171A Lorong 1 Toa Payoh (“the Multi-storey Car Park”). At the Multi-storey Car Park, the Car was searched, and an envelope containing $11,200 of cash (“the Cash”) was recovered from the centre compartment of the Car, just behind its handbrake. Mr Dineshkumar had received the Cash from Mr Tan.
Analysis of exhibits by the Health Sciences Authority
- [15]
[15] The Three Bundles containing the Drugs were subsequently sent to the Health Sciences Authority (“HSA”) for analysis. HSA’s analysis revealed that the Drugs contained a total of no less than 37.95g of diamorphine, which form the subject matter of this trial. I set out the results below (which are not disputed):
S/N
Description
Marking
HSA Certificate
Results of analysis
1
One packet containing granular/powdery substance
E1A1A1
Lab No ID-2032-00388-006
(Exh P10)
461.3g of substance found to contain not less than 12.99g of diamorphine
2
One packet containing granular/powdery substance
E1A2A1
Lab No ID-2032-00388-007
(Exh P11)
460.7g of substance found to contain not less than 13.75g of diamorphine
3
One packet containing granular/powdery substance
E1B1A1
Lab No ID-2032-00388-008
(Exh P12)
460.4g of substance found to contain not less than 11.21g of diamorphine
Statements made during investigations
- [16]
[16] As part of its case, the Prosecution tendered a number of statements recorded from both Mr Tan and Mr Dineshkumar in the course of investigations, pursuant to s 258(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 68, 2012 Rev Ed) (“CPC”). Neither Mr Tan nor Mr Dineshkumar objected to the admissibility of any of these statements, and they were accordingly admitted into evidence. However, Mr Tan and Mr Dineshkumar contested the accuracy of certain aspects of the statements.
Statements made by Mr Tan
- [17]
[17] Nine statements recorded from Mr Tan were admitted into evidence as follows:
(a) a contemporaneous statement recorded by Inspector Eng Chien Loong Eugene (“Insp Eugene”) under s 22 of the CPC on 25 February 2020 at about 10.45pm in the living room of the Unit;
(b) a contemporaneous statement recorded by Insp Eugene under s 22 of the CPC on 25 February 2020 at about 11.08pm in the living room of the Unit;
(c) a contemporaneous statement recorded by Staff Sergeant Goh Jun Xian (“SSgt Eric”) under s 22 of the CPC on 26 February 2020 from 12.15am to 1.45am in the living room of the Unit;
(d) the cautioned statement recorded by Assistant Superintendent Fernandez Anthony Leo (“ASP Fernandez”) under s 23 of the CPC on 26 February 2020 from 1.58pm to 2.08pm at Police Cantonment Complex (“PCC”);
(e) a long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez under s 22 of the CPC on 3 March 2020 from 11.21am to 3.02pm at PCC;
(f) a long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez under s 22 of the CPC on 3 March 2020 from 6.00pm to 10.46pm at PCC;
(g) a long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez under s 22 of the CPC on 4 March 2020 from 11.30am to 12.05pm at PCC;
(h) a long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez under s 22 of the CPC on 18 August 2020 from 11.05am to 12.15pm at Changi Prison Complex;
(i) a long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez under s 22 of the CPC on 25 August 2020 from 2.10pm to 4.15pm at Changi Prison Complex; and
(j) a long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez under s 22 of the CPC on 24 November 2020 from 10.09am to 10.16am at Changi Prison Complex.
- [18]
[18] Given the importance of the contents of these statements to the case, I shall set out substantial portions of them. In the first contemporaneous statement recorded on 25 February 2020, Mr Tan said that E1A and E1B contained “Heroin and Ice” [emphasis added] and that they belonged to one Malaysian man. Mr Tan “was supposed to drop [E1A and E1B] off as instructed” [emphasis added] by the Malaysian man. In the third contemporaneous statement, Mr Tan identified the Malaysian man as “Sal Poulez”. Once again, he stated that the Four Bundles, E1A1, E1A2, E1B1 and E1B2, contained “Heroin and Ice, but he do [sic] not know which is Heroin, which is Ice” [emphasis added]. The items belonged to Sal Poulez. When asked what he was “supposed to do with the Heroin and Ice” [emphasis added], he said he was to wait for Sal Poulez’s call with instructions “to drop the Heroin and Ice at specified location”. In return for his help, Sal Poulez would “pay [him] SGD$500 for 02 batu heroin, SGD$300 for 01 batu heroin and 125g of Ice for SGD$200”. During his ride in the Car, Mr Dineshkumar put E1A and E1B into the Recycle Bag that Mr Tan had brought. Mr Tan also gave Mr Dineshkumar the Cash which he had collected from “previous drops instructed by Sal Poulez”. He had been working for Sal Poulez for a couple of weeks. When asked, “[D]o you know how much you supposed to collect today?” Mr Tan answered, “No. I do not know”.
- [19]
[19] In the cautioned statement, Mr Tan merely stated, “I did what I did. I am guilty”.
- [20]
[20] In the first long statement recorded on 3 March 2020, the following material details are set out:
(a) In the afternoon of 25 February 2020, Mr Tan received a phone call from Pal. Pal told Mr Tan that he had a package to deliver to Mr Tan at night. While on the way home from work, there was another call between them. Pal told him there was a slight delay in the delivery. According to Mr Tan, Pal did not inform him of the amount of drugs he would be collecting that night. This was the norm. Normally, Mr Tan would collect the drugs, and he would know the amount of drugs he had collected once he reached home. Mr Tan would then confirm with Pal the amount of drugs he had collected was correct. Up to then, there had been no mistakes or discrepancies in the amount of drugs that Mr Tan had collected with the amount he was supposed to collect. For one “batu” of heroin, Mr Tan would receive $300. For 125g of “ice”, he would receive $200. To Mr Tan, one “batu” amounts to about 450g of heroin.
(b) After Mr Tan boarded the Car, he placed the Recycle Bag on the floorboard at his feet area at the front passenger side of the Car. While the Car was moving, Mr Tan felt that Mr Dineshkumar was reaching for the Recycle Bag. Mr Tan believed that, at that point, Mr Dineshkumar took the sealed envelope containing the Cash from the Recycle Bag, although he did not physically see Mr Dineshkumar take it. When the Car stopped at the traffic light junction of Lorong 7 and Lorong 6, Mr Tan saw Mr Dineshkumar “bent down and started throwing some things into the [Recycle Bag]”.
(c) As per his usual practice, Mr Tan did not check the contents of the Recycle Bag while he was inside the Car or after he had alighted from the Car. After Mr Tan alighted from the Car, he felt that the Recycle Bag was heavy. It was more than double the weight he would normally collect. He would normally collect only “01 pound of ‘heroin’ and sometimes 01 or 02 packets of ‘ice’ together.” Despite this, Mr Tan did not check the contents of the Recycle Bag as his “only desire was to quickly get home”. He did not intend to do any “drop offs” that night.
(d) Immediately after Mr Tan was arrested, the Recycle Bag was opened in his presence. Upon seeing its contents, Mr Tan told the CNB officers that “it was ‘heroin’ and ‘ice’” [emphasis added]. Mr Tan cursed and said, “[B]astard, why so much”. He felt that it was a “dirty deed done to [him] and it was not gentleman of ‘Pal’”. Mr Tan thought that Pal should at least have given him the option to “choose whether [he] had wanted to do the collection of this amount of drugs”. He was then escorted up to the Unit.
(e) At the Unit, Mr Tan’s handphone kept ringing, and the CNB officers asked Mr Tan whether he would cooperate with the CNB and answer the phone. Mr Tan agreed. However, as he was feeling very agitated and angry with Pal at that point in time, Mr Tan told the officers that he would “fuck” Pal first before saying what the CNB officers had wanted him to say. However, the officers did not let Mr Tan answer the phone when it rang. When the officers tried calling Pal afterwards, the calls went through, but Pal did not answer.
- [21]
[21] In the second long statement, also recorded on 3 March 2020, Mr Tan said the following:
(a) Although the Recycle Bag felt heavier than usual, Mr Tan did not intend to check it in public. He wanted to check it only at home. Even if he had checked the Recycle Bag after leaving the Car, “the contents were already in [his] hands and so [he] cannot drop it or do anything to it”.
(b) Mr Tan told the CNB officers that the Recycle Bag contained heroin and ice, as he assumed it to be so. Mr Tan held this assumption because he had previously collected drugs from Pal about six to seven times. On those occasions, he would receive “either ‘heroin’ and ‘ice’ or a mixture of both”. Mr Tan knew there must have been ice in the Recycle Bag because Pal told him after lunch on 25 February 2020 that he had packed instruments for Mr Tan to smoke ice together with some ice for that night’s collection. He had told Pal that he needed a new “popeye”, ie, an instrument for consuming “ice”, and had asked Pal for a new one. This is how he knew there would be “ice” in the Recycle Bag. Mr Tan had assumed that heroin would also be involved based on his previous experiences.
(c) Normally, Mr Tan would collect only “01 pound of ‘heroin’ or 125 grams of ‘ice’, or a mixture of both”. From the fourth collection onwards, there were occasions where he would collect a combination of “01 batu of heroin and 125 grams of ‘ice’”.
(d) As regards the receipt of extra drugs on the night when he was arrested, Mr Tan said that he would have told Pal off. If Pal had tried to brush Mr Tan off, Mr Tan would have warned Pal not to “put this amount of drugs without letting [him] know next time”. However, Mr Tan would “still have continued to drop off the drugs from this collection on ‘Pal’s’ instructions”. That said, whether Mr Tan “would continue to do this [was] not confirmed as [he] felt unhappy that ‘Pal’ had passed [him] drugs more than the usual amount collected without informing [him] beforehand”.
(e) Mr Tan clarified the answers in his contemporaneous statement (at [18] above). First, the sums of “SGD$500 for 02 batu heroin, SGD$300 for 01 batu heroin and 125g of Ice for SGD$200” had been agreed between Sal Poulez and Mr Tan since Mr Tan started helping Sal Poulez. Second, Mr Tan had never taken two “batu” of heroin from Sal Poulez. Third, “Pal” refers to “Sal Poulez”.
(f) Initially, Mr Tan started collecting and delivering drugs for Pal to feed his own addiction. Subsequently, Mr Tan realised that, by delivering drugs for Pal, he could afford to smoke heroin and “ice” without tapping into his family’s expenses. That is why Mr Tan continued to collect and deliver drugs for Pal. Mr Tan said that he never repacked Pal’s drugs; he had merely removed the black tapes and wrapped the drugs in newspaper before delivering them.
- [22]
[22] In his third long statement recorded on 4 March 2020, Mr Tan confirmed that he had read back the first and second long statements recorded a day earlier and that he did not wish to make any amendments to them. Mr Tan then went on to say that he did not touch the Four Bundles (marked “E1A1”, “E1A2”, “E1B1” and “E1B2”) that were found in the Recycle Bag at all. He had brought the Recycle Bag into the Car, and it was Mr Dineshkumar who placed the Four Bundles into the Recycle Bag.
- [23]
[23] Finally, Mr Tan reiterated the following in the fourth long statement, recorded some months later on 18 August 2020:
(a) The Drugs were placed into the Recycle Bag by Mr Dineshkumar. While doing so, Mr Dineshkumar did not say anything. Moreover, at no point in time did Mr Tan handle the Drugs. The only conversation Mr Tan had with Mr Dineshkumar was when he asked Mr Dineshkumar where Mr Dineshkumar was heading, to which the latter replied that he was going back to the causeway.
(b) Mr Tan also explained that when he said he would “still have continued to drop off the [D]rugs from this collection despite the larger amount on ‘Pal’s’ instructions” (at [21(d)] above), this was hypothetical. Mr Tan thought that since the Drugs were already in his hands, there was nothing else he could have done with them. However, while it was probable for Mr Tan to have continued to drop the Drugs off for Pal, Mr Tan was not certain if he would have continued to help Pal as he was really upset at Pal at that point in time for giving him more drugs than what he would typically receive without informing him beforehand.
Statements made by Mr Dineshkumar
- [24]
[24] Eight statements recorded from Mr Dineshkumar were admitted into evidence. These were:
(a) a contemporaneous statement recorded by Sergeant Mohammad Nasrulhaq bin Mohd Zainuddin (“Sgt Nasrulhaq”) under s 22 of the CPC from 11.36pm on 25 February 2020 to 1.04am on 26 February 2020 at the Multi-storey Car Park;
(b) a contemporaneous statement recorded by Sgt Nasrulhaq under s 22 of the CPC on 26 February 2020 from 1.05am to 1.08am at the Multi-storey Car Park;
(c) a cautioned statement recorded by Station Inspector Lee Swee Leng (“SI Lee”) under s 23 of the CPC on 26 February 2020 from 2.00pm to 2.10pm at PCC;
(d) a long statement recorded by SI Lee under s 22 of the CPC on 3 March 2020 from 9.24am to 12.16pm at Central Police Division;
(e) a long statement recorded by SI Lee under s 22 of the CPC on 3 March 2020 from 2.24pm to 6.25pm at Central Police Division;
(f) a long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez under s 22 of the CPC on 4 March 2020 from 7.10pm to 10.00pm at PCC;
(g) a long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez under s 22 of the CPC on 18 August 2020 from 2.10pm to 4.21pm at Changi Prison Complex; and
(h) a long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez under s 22 of the CPC on 23 October 2020 from 2.48pm to 4.10pm at Changi Prison Complex.
- [25]
[25] While Sgt Nasrulhaq recorded the contemporaneous statements in the Malay language by conversing with Mr Dineshkumar in Malay, SI Lee and ASP Fernandez recorded the other statements in the English language. To do so, they were assisted by a Tamil interpreter, Mdm Vijaya Thavamary Abraham (“Mdm Vijaya”). Mdm Vijaya interpreted what the recording officers said in English to Mr Dineshkumar in Tamil and then interpreted what Mr Dineshkumar said in Tamil to the recording officers in English.
- [26]
[26] Before I set out the contents of these statements, I should state that it is in his third long statement recorded by ASP Fernandez on 4 March 2020 that Mr Dineshkumar admitted that he was delivering drugs at the material time (and that he knew that the Four Bundles contained drugs). He did so as he hoped to receive a lighter sentence for telling the truth. Prior to that, essentially, Mr Dineshkumar denied any involvement with the Drugs.
- [27]
[27] With that in mind, I go to the first contemporaneous statement. In it, Mr Dineshkumar said that Mr Tan had passed the envelope containing the Cash to him. His friend, one “Kelvin”, had told him to collect the money from Mr Tan and bring it back to Kelvin in Malaysia. After entering the Car, Mr Tan told him to drive. After that, Mr Tan took out the envelope containing the Cash and handed it to Mr Dineshkumar. Mr Dineshkumar denied giving anything to Mr Tan; nor had Kelvin paid him to take money from Mr Tan. Mr Dineshkumar’s account in the cautioned statement dated 26 February 2020 is similar to the account set out above.
- [28]
[28] The first long statement made by Mr Dineshkumar on 3 March 2020 contains, inter alia, the following:
(a) On the evening of 25 February 2020, Mr Dineshkumar received a phone call from Kelvin, who asked Mr Dineshkumar to go to Singapore to collect some money for him. Although Kelvin was his friend, Mr Dineshkumar did not know Kelvin’s real name. He was an Indian who was about 25 years old. Mr Dineshkumar got to know Kelvin from a mutual friend. By 25 February 2020, Mr Dineshkumar had known Kelvin for about three months.
(b) When Kelvin asked Mr Dineshkumar to help him collect money in Singapore, Kelvin told Mr Dineshkumar that his passport was about to expire. However, Kelvin did not tell Mr Dineshkumar how much money he was supposed to collect or what the money was meant for. Mr Dineshkumar thought that the money would amount to S$1,000 to S$2,000. Mr Dineshkumar agreed to help Kelvin collect the money because he wanted to return a favour to Kelvin, as the latter had been sending Mr Dineshkumar to various locations for job interviews.
(c) After Mr Dineshkumar agreed to assist Kelvin, Kelvin arrived at Mr Dineshkumar’s residence with his car (ie, the Car), and left immediately. Thereafter, Mr Dineshkumar left his residence for Singapore at around 6.05pm. Upon his arrival at the Tuas Checkpoint, Mr Dineshkumar was stopped by immigration officers as they wanted to inspect the Car. The inspection took about an hour. According to Mr Dineshkumar, the entire car was checked, “starting from the bonnet to the boot”. Nothing was recovered by the immigration officers from the Car.
(d) Kelvin provided Mr Dineshkumar with three locations consecutively. When Mr Dineshkumar checked with Kelvin, Kelvin told him to proceed to the last location to collect the money. At that location, Mr Tan boarded the Car and asked Mr Dineshkumar to “drive one round”. While Mr Dineshkumar was driving, he saw Mr Tan taking the white envelope out of the Recycle Bag and placing it beside the handbrake. Thereafter, Mr Tan alighted at a traffic junction where the Car had stopped. Mr Dineshkumar further added that: (i) he did not pass anything to Mr Tan; (ii) Mr Dineshkumar only received the white envelope from Mr Tan and did not open it; and (iii) Mr Tan did not take anything from the Car.
(e) This was the second occasion that he helped Kelvin to collect monies in Singapore. The first was just a day before, on 24 February 2020.
- [29]
[29] Mr Dineshkumar gave the second long statement about two hours after his first long statement was recorded. Similar to the contents of earlier statements, the gist of this statement is as follows:
(a) On the two occasions (ie, on 24 February 2020 and 25 February 2020) that Kelvin handed the Car over to Mr Dineshkumar, Mr Dineshkumar did not check the Car. At all material times, no one else apart from Mr Dineshkumar had access to the Car.
(b) On 25 February 2020, when Mr Dineshkumar put the envelope containing the Cash into the armrest compartment of the Car, he felt that it was heavier than the envelope that he had handled the day before.
(c) When shown a photograph depicting the Recycle Bag and the plastic bags E1A and E1B, Mr Dineshkumar identified the Recycle Bag as the one carried by Mr Tan. However, Mr Dineshkumar had never seen nor touched E1A and E1B prior and did not know who they belonged to. Mr Dineshkumar also disavowed any knowledge of, or connection with, E1A1, E1A2, E1B1 and E1B2.
- [30]
[30] In the third long statement recorded from Mr Dineshkumar on 4 March 2020, he admitted for the first time to delivering drugs for Kelvin and stated the following:
(a) When Mr Dineshkumar first entered Singapore to deliver drugs for Kelvin on 24 February 2020, Kelvin had not told him the type or amount of drugs involved. Neither had Mr Dineshkumar asked Kelvin about these because Mr Dineshkumar knew he had to do the job for money, as he had just lost his job at Permal Logistic and was about RM20,000 in debt.
(b) On 24 February 2020, when Mr Dineshkumar took over the Car from Kelvin, he did not know where the drugs were located in the Car. It was only after Mr Dineshkumar entered Singapore that he called Kelvin and was told by the latter that the drugs were kept in the Car’s boot. The 24 February 2020 delivery involved one bundle of drugs. Once Mr Dineshkumar reached the location provided by Kelvin and stopped his car, an Indian man boarded the Car. The Indian man passed Mr Dineshkumar S$2000 in cash (which Mr Dineshkumar did not expect to collect), and Mr Dineshkumar handed him the bundle of drugs. Upon Mr Dineshkumar’s return to Malaysia, Kelvin paid him RM5,000 for the delivery.
(c) The next day, on 25 February 2020, Kelvin called Mr Dineshkumar in the evening to inform him of another delivery task. Mr Dineshkumar took over the Car without inspecting it. Mr Dineshkumar did not bother to check the car boot as he felt that it was a good place to hide drugs. If Kelvin had really hidden the drugs again in the car boot, Mr Dineshkumar was confident that he could “clear [the] checkpoint without the drugs being detected”.
(d) After clearing the checkpoint, Mr Dineshkumar proceeded to “Jurong Hospital”. While waiting there, Kelvin sent him the address of a location to go to (subsequently established and undisputed at trial to be at Jalan Besar). Mr Dineshkumar realised it would take 30 minutes to get there. Having been subjected to heavy checks at the Tuas checkpoint, he was scared. Reluctant to proceed, he expressed his concerns to Kelvin. Then, Kelvin sent another address which was a location about 15 minutes away (later established and undisputed at trial to be at Fishery Port Road). However, when Mr Dineshkumar reached the location, Kelvin told him that the recipient had already left. As such, Kelvin sent him the address of another location which was about 20 minutes away (established and undisputed at trial to be at Lorong 7 near the entrance to the car park of Block 23). Before leaving Fishery Port Road, Mr Dineshkumar located a black plastic bag containing one bundle of drugs wrapped in black tape in the Car’s boot. He also found three more bundles of drugs hidden in the boot.
(e) Mr Dineshkumar decided to place all the drugs on the right rear passenger seat. From within the Car, he then took one of the three bundles and put it inside the black plastic bag (that was already containing a bundle of drugs). Mr Dineshkumar then put the remaining two bundles into a white-coloured plastic bag which was in the Car. Accordingly, the black and white plastic bags each contained two bundles of drugs. Mr Dineshkumar then placed both plastic bags under the driver’s seat.
(f) After proceeding to the last location (ie, Lorong 7), Mr Dineshkumar waited by the side of the road and called Kelvin to inform him that he had arrived. Kelvin informed Mr Dineshkumar to pass the drugs to the recipient and to collect money from him as well. Then, Mr Tan boarded the Car. While Mr Dineshkumar was driving the Car, Mr Dineshkumar “used one hand to take the black and white plastic bag under [his] seat, each containing 02 bundles wrapped in black tape and passed it to [Mr Tan]”. Mr Dineshkumar “passed him one plastic bag after the other”. Mr Tan “took the black and white plastic bag each containing 02 bundles wrapped in black tape and put them inside his black bag …”. Mr Tan then alighted from the Car at a traffic junction with his black bag.
(g) Mr Dineshkumar did not touch the Recycle Bag but had touched the two plastic bags, E1A and E1B, as these were “where the 04 bundles … were kept in”. Mr Dineshkumar identified E1A1, E1A2, E1B1 and E1B2 as the Four Bundles of drugs which he had passed to Mr Tan on 25 February 2020. Mr Dineshkumar knew that the bundles were drugs as “Kelvin had told [him] that the bundles contained drugs”.
(h) Mr Dineshkumar said that he did not tell the truth in his earlier statements as he was afraid of the fact that he was facing a death sentence. Mr Dineshkumar hoped that by being honest, he would receive a lighter sentence. Mr Dineshkumar wished to cooperate with the CNB but did not have any other information to give.
- [31]
[31] Finally, the fourth and fifth long statements recorded on 18 August 2020 and 23 October 2020, respectively, provide, inter alia, the following:
(a) Kelvin told Mr Dineshkumar that the Four Bundles of drugs (ie, E1A1, E1A2, E1B1 and E1B2) contained “ice”. Mr Dineshkumar initially told CNB that he did not know what drugs were in the bundles because he had just been arrested and could not think properly. Mr Dineshkumar did not know the quantity of “ice” in the bundles.
(b) Mr Dineshkumar’s prior delivery on 24 February 2020 involved just one bundle of drugs wrapped in white tape. As the Four Bundles of drugs on 25 February 2020 were instead wrapped in black tape, Mr Dineshkumar asked Kelvin what the bundles contained, and Kelvin told him they contained “ice”.
Close of the Prosecution’s case
- [32]
[32] At the close of the Prosecution’s case, I found that there was sufficient evidence against each of the accused persons to call for their defence. Mr Tan and Mr Dineshkumar each gave evidence. They did not call any witnesses.
Mr Tan’s defence
- [33]
[33] Mr Tan, a 65-year-old Singaporean, has a Bachelor of Arts degree from an Australian university. At the material time, he was working as a technical support officer, earning $1,600 per month. He lived with his wife in the Unit. Mr Tan began abusing drugs in his teens. Since then, he has not been able to overcome his drug addiction. Apart from drug addiction, he had also been previously diagnosed with depression and anxiety.
- [34]
[34] Given the rather nuanced defence Mr Tan raises, I shall now set out his evidence concerning drug deliveries in some detail. According to Mr Tan, a Malaysian called “Boy Tanjong” used to supply him with drugs for his consumption. Then, Boy Tanjong gave Mr Tan’s contact to another Malaysian, one “Segar”. Around end-December 2019, he began delivering drugs for Segar to support his drug consumption. Segar told Mr Tan that at times, he would want Mr Tan to collect heroin, and at other times, he would want Mr Tan to collect “ice”. He told Mr Tan that he would “give [Mr Tan] $300 for each pound of heroin [he] collected. And then [$]200 for each 125 gram of Ice that [he] collected.” Mr Tan said, “Okay, … but [he] wouldn’t want to be taking anything more than that.” This was because as a drug addict, he knew the “threshold for … capital offence”.
- [35]
[35] The arrangement was that Segar would call him the night before to inform him of an intended delivery of drugs which would be left at one of two agreed drop-off points – either at the recycling bin or the ATM machine near Block 23. Mr Tan would collect the drugs, bring them home, clean the packaging, take off the black duct tape, and re-wrap them in some newspaper. Then, he would wait for Segar’s call again, which he would usually receive on the same day. Thereafter, Mr Tan would be instructed to drop the drugs off at one of two specified locations – again either at the recycling bin or the ATM machine near Block 23. Later, Mr Tan started collecting cash left by those who picked up the drugs, with the cash to be passed to Segar thereafter.
- [36]
[36] However, on one occasion around 9 January 2020, Mr Tan discovered that Segar delivered more than one pound of heroin to him. Unlike the previous occasions where he would pick up and drop off without meeting anyone directly, he met an Indian couple for this pick up. When Mr Tan called Segar to confront the latter about the large amount of drugs, saying that “[they] never agreed that [he] would … take more than one---one pound. This was [their] prior agreement”, Segar repeatedly dismissed Mr Tan’s concerns and told Mr Tan that he would be remunerated accordingly. As such, Mr Tan was “quite fed up” with Segar and said that “the Ice and heroin and all, [he would] reject it.” He also said that he did not “want to have anything to do with this one and they should come pick it up”.
- [37]
[37] During a subsequent call, when Mr Tan argued with Segar regarding the amount of heroin to be delivered, Segar told Mr Tan that he would call Mr Tan back. It was Pal, another Malaysian, who returned the call and told Mr Tan that Mr Tan would deal with Pal from then on and “won’t be dealing with Segar anymore”. Pal made contact with Mr Tan through the same Malaysian number used by Segar, which Mr Tan saved on his handphone under the contact “Sal Poulez”. Pal arranged to “take it back”, and assured him that he would personally deal with Mr Tan, and that “he will make sure that [Mr Tan] don’t get anything more than one and one”. After Pal arranged to “take the thing back”, Mr Tan dealt with him for five to seven times before his arrest. The same arrangement reached with Segar carried on in relation to the pick-up and drop-off of the drugs, as well as the collection and delivery of cash. These collections and deliveries usually took place in the morning.
- [38]
[38] On 23 February 2020, Pal said that he wanted cash that Mr Tan had collected previously. Mr Tan told him that he needed some “ice” for consumption, as well as three “popeyes” for consuming “ice”. Pal was meant to arrange for a drop-off and pick-up on 24 February 2020. Mr Tan testified that he did not need to pay for the small sachet of “ice” (about three to five grams) for his consumption. After Pal failed to make the arrangements for 24 February 2020, there was a series of calls between them on 25 February 2020, beginning from 11.38am, to arrange for a drop-off and pick-up on the night of 25 February 2020. In particular, between 7.19pm and 10.17pm, there were nine calls of varying durations between the parties. Mr Tan explained that he had to work late that night, and kept Pal updated as to what time he could be expected to be back home, and when he would be available for the transaction. In the meantime, Pal told him that the “conveyor” had also been delayed.
- [39]
[39] When Mr Tan entered the Car, Mr Dineshkumar was talking on his handphone and rummaging under his seat. Mr Tan put the Recycle Bag on the floorboard of the front passenger seat. Mr Tan does not remember if he told Mr Dineshkumar the Cash was in the Recycle Bag and Mr Dineshkumar took it out or if he handed the Cash to Mr Dineshkumar. The car ride from Lorong 7 back to Lorong 6 lasted about one minute. When Mr Tan carried the Recycle Bag to get out of the Car, he felt that it was quite heavy. Mr Tan was vaguely aware of hearing a “thudding sound” on the floorboard while he was in the Car although he did not exactly see Mr Dineshkumar putting anything into the Recycle Bag.
- [40]
[40] After Mr Tan’s arrest, he was brought back to the Unit. When Mr Tan saw that there were four black bundles in the Recycle Bag, he knew he had been played out by Pal. When Insp Eugene was recording his first contemporaneous statement, there was a call from Pal. Insp Eugene asked if Mr Tan wanted to answer the call, and Mr Tan said he wanted to and that he was going to “fuck him … [he] was going to scold [Pal] actually.” He said, “[B]astard, you know, why so much drugs, you know, why all the drugs.” Mr Tan said this was because he “never agreed to take more than one pound of heroin at the time or 125 gram of Ice or a combination of both [he] agreed to that.” He did not want to “take more than a pound of heroin and more than that amount of Ice because [he] thought that would be the gallows for [him]”.
- [41]
[41] To sum up, in relation to the night of 25 February 2020, Mr Tan’s defence is that he did not know about the Drugs, much less their nature, until after he was arrested by the CNB. Mr Tan was expecting to deliver money to Pal’s “conveyor” (who turned out to be Mr Dineshkumar). He was not expecting to collect the Drugs at all. Instead, as arranged with Pal, he was to collect some “ice” and three “popeyes” for himself. I shall refer to this as “the Nature of Transaction Defence”. Connected to the above, since Mr Tan did not know that he was to receive the Drugs that night, he could not have formed an intention as to what he would do with the Drugs. For this reason, Mr Tan was not in possession of the Drugs for the purposes of trafficking.
- [42]
[42] Further, as argued by his counsel, Mr Andre Jumabhoy (“Mr Jumabhoy”), Mr Tan is “well-versed in the drug laws to know that a certain amount would carry a death sentence and therefore agreed with the supplier that he would only collect one pound of heroin (around 450g) and/or 125g of ice”. There was never any agreement for him to traffic more than one pound of heroin (“the Alleged Agreement”). Intertwined with all the above is the contention that on that night, Mr Tan was not the intended recipient of the Drugs. The Drugs were meant to be delivered to persons other than Mr Tan. Such surrounding circumstances bolster Mr Tan’s claim that he had no knowledge of the nature of the Drugs and fortify his denial of an intention to traffic the Drugs.
- [43]
[43] To explain the contents of the statements made during investigations, including certain admissions, Mr Tan claims, inter alia, that he was depressed, despondent and suicidal, and his intention was to end it all. There are also other allegations concerning the accuracy of some aspects of the statements (which I shall set out in due course).
Mr Dineshkumar’s defence
- [44]
[44] Turning to Mr Dineshkumar, he is a 31-year-old Malaysian living in Johor Bahru. At the material time, he was unemployed. Before that, he worked as a lorry driver, transferring goods for his company between Malaysia and Singapore. Mr Dineshkumar was a drug addict, and Kelvin used to sell him “ice” for his consumption. Another drug supplier introduced Kelvin to him. Prior to his arrest, he had known Kelvin for about three months.
- [45]
[45] Mr Dineshkumar’s fairly straightforward defence is that he did not have any knowledge that he was delivering diamorphine at the material time. Instead, Mr Dineshkumar was under the impression that he was only delivering “ice”. Mr Dineshkumar was made to believe that he would be (and was) carrying only “ice” by the words and assurances of Kelvin, who directed Mr Dineshkumar to bring drugs into Singapore. Separately, Mr Dineshkumar also agreed to collect cash for Kelvin.
- [46]
[46] Turning to the statements made during investigations, Mr Dineshkumar seeks to undermine the accuracy of those recorded with the assistance of Mdm Vijaya by alleging that Mdm Vijaya fell short in carrying out her role as interpreter.
The law
- [47]
[47] I now turn to the law. The relevant provisions within the MDA read:
By s 2 of the MDA, “traffic” is defined to include “give”, “transport”, “send” and “deliver”.
- [48]
[48] In respect of a charge of trafficking under s 5(1) read with s 5(2) of the MDA (as faced by Mr Tan), the elements to be established are: (a) possession of the drugs; (b) knowledge of the nature of the drugs; and (c) proof that possession of the drugs was for the purpose of trafficking which was not authorised (Muhammad Ridzuan bin Md Ali v Public Prosecutor and other matters [2014] 3 SLR 721 at [59]). For a charge of trafficking under s 5(1) of the MDA (as faced by Mr Dineshkumar), the elements which need to be established are: (a) the act of trafficking in the controlled drug which was not authorised; and (b) knowledge of the nature of the drugs.
- [49]
[49] In relation to possession and knowledge, s 18 of the MDA contains these rebuttable presumptions:
- [50]
[50] When dealing with the element of possession, the Prosecution may rely on the presumption in s 18(1) of the MDA or seek to prove that the accused person had actual knowledge that the thing which turns out to be a controlled drug was within his possession, custody or control. If the Prosecution relies on the s 18(1) presumption, the accused person may rebut this presumption by either establishing, on a balance of probabilities, that (i) he was never in possession of or never had custody of or control over the container, keys or document referred to in s 18(1), or (ii) that he was never aware that the thing which was later found to be a drug was in his custody: Adili Chibuike Ejike v Public Prosecutor [2019] 2 SLR 254 (“Adili”) at [40].
- [51]
[51] As regards s 18(2) of the MDA, the presumption will be rebutted where an accused person establishes, on a balance of probabilities, that he did not know the nature of the drugs in his possession. This would be the case where the accused person was able to prove that he believed he was carrying something innocuous (even if he is unable to specify exactly what that was) or where the accused person was able to prove that he believed he was carrying some other illegal item or drug other than the specific drug in his possession: Gobi a/l Avedian v Public Prosecutor (“Gobi”) [2021] 1 SLR 180 at [57] and [59]. That said, an accused person who was merely indifferent to or ignorant of what he was carrying would not be able to rebut the presumption in s 18(2): Gobi at [64].
Decision: Mr Tan
- [52]
[52] I turn to consider the case against Mr Tan.
Knowing possession
- [53]
[53] As set out above at [48], the first element to be established is the possession of the Drugs. However, for the purposes of the MDA, possession has been interpreted to mean not just the fact of physical possession or custody but also to incorporate an element of knowledge. As regards the sort of knowledge required, all that is needed is that the accused person must know of the existence, within his possession, control or custody, of the thing which is later found to be a controlled drug. To be clear, it is not necessary that the accused person also knows that the thing was, in fact, a prohibited drug, much less its specific nature: Adili at [31].
Whether the Prosecution ran a different case at trial
- [54]
[54] Mr Tan does not dispute that he was in physical possession of the Recycle Bag, which contained, inter alia, the Drugs when he alighted from the Car. Accordingly, the Prosecution invokes s 18(1)(a) of the MDA for the presumption that Mr Tan had the Drugs in his knowing possession. However, in his closing submissions, Mr Jumabhoy argues that a line of questioning taken by the Prosecution in the cross-examination of Mr Tan shows that the Prosecution’s case against Mr Tan is one of wilful blindness. Accordingly, it is impermissible for the Prosecution to rely on s 18(1) of the MDA to presume that Mr Tan was wilfully blind to the presence of the Drugs in his possession. In fact, Mr Jumabhoy proceeded on the basis that the Prosecution was running its case based on wilful blindness and focused on how the Prosecution had failed to establish the elements of wilful blindness.
- [55]
[55] In my view, the questions posed to Mr Tan during cross-examination by the Prosecution must be considered in totality and in their context. This requires an examination of the Prosecution’s opening statement, its cross-examination of Mr Tan, and closing submissions. So viewed, it is clear to me that the Prosecution’s case against Mr Tan is not one of wilful blindness, despite that particular line of questioning by the Prosecution, as relied on by Mr Jumabhoy. Nowhere in the Prosecution’s opening statement and closing submissions did it refer to the doctrine of wilful blindness. In fact, the opening statement clearly states:
- [56]
[56] As such, when Mr Tan gave his evidence-in-chief, he was well aware of the Prosecution’s case against him, which relies on the ss 18(1)(a) and (2) presumptions of the MDA. On that premise, he provided his defence to address the allegations against him, setting out his account of the facts and circumstances of the relevant events. Moreover, it is clear that, when read in context, the Prosecution’s questions (as shown in the notes of evidence extracted by Mr Jumabhoy) were targeted at showing that Mr Tan was indifferent to the nature of the drugs he was collecting from Pal through Mr Dineshkumar. To elaborate, these questions concerned whether Mr Tan took any steps to open the plastic bags so as to “verify” their contents. In my view, this line of questioning was primarily aimed at demonstrating that Mr Tan is unable to rebut the presumption of knowledge under s 18(2) of the MDA. For the avoidance of doubt, the element of knowledge is distinct from that of knowing possession. This coheres with established law that an accused person who was merely indifferent to or ignorant of what he was carrying would not be able to rebut the presumption in s 18(2): Gobi at [64].
- [57]
[57] In any event, the Prosecution is only precluded from invoking the presumption under s 18(1) of the MDA if its case proceeds solely on the basis that the accused person had been wilfully blind: Adili at [100]. This is certainly not the case here. Insofar as Mr Jumabhoy has chosen to focus on the issue of wilful blindness in the closing submissions, Mr Tan is in no way prejudiced. The closing submissions deal fully with the evidence at the trial and the substance of Mr Tan’s defence (as outlined above from [33] onwards). Further, Mr Tan filed reply closing submissions and had the opportunity to respond to the Prosecution’s closing submissions which clearly also relied on the presumption under s 18(1) of the MDA.
Whether Mr Tan has rebutted the presumption
- [58]
[58] Returning to the s 18(1)(a) presumption, as mentioned (at [54] above), Mr Tan accepts that, when he alighted from the Car, he was in physical possession of the plastic bags, E1A and E1B, which contained the Drugs. The issue for my determination is whether Mr Tan has successfully rebutted the presumption under s 18(1)(a) of the MDA by proving, on a balance of probabilities, that he was never aware that the Drugs were in his custody.
- [59]
[59] In my judgment, Mr Tan has failed to establish that he was not aware that the Drugs were in his custody. During cross-examination, Mr Tan admitted that he knew that certain things were placed in the Recycle Bag by Mr Dineshkumar while Mr Tan was in the Car. When he exited the Car, Mr Tan felt that the bag was heavy. In his contemporaneous statements, Mr Tan said that E1A and E1B contained “heroin and ‘ice’” [emphasis added] belonging to Sal Poulez (ie, Pal) and that Mr Tan was supposed to drop them off at a specified location as instructed by Sal Poulez. I note that Mr Tan alleges that he did not use the conjunctive “and” (but that he used the conjunctive “or”). As explained later at [92]–[96], I reject this allegation.
- [60]
[60] For present purposes, what is important is that Mr Tan does not dispute that he knew he was carrying drugs at the material time. In fact, this was Mr Tan’s consistent position during investigations and at trial. By the Nature of Transaction Defence, raised only at trial, Mr Tan claims that he was expecting small quantities of “ice” and three “popeyes” to be delivered to him (albeit for his personal use). I shall deal with the Nature of Transaction Defence from [67] below. In any event, by the time Mr Tan exited the Car with the Recycle Bag, however, he knew it was heavy and must have contained things other than some “ice” and three “popeyes”. Therefore, I am not satisfied that Mr Tan has established that he was not aware that the Drugs were in his possession so as to rebut the s 18(1)(a) presumption.
Whether Mr Tan or Mr Dineshkumar placed the Drugs into the Recycle Bag
- [61]
[61] For completeness, in relation to this issue, I should mention that Mr Tan takes objection to the fact that the contradictory positions taken by Mr Tan and Mr Dineshkumar during investigations as to who placed the Drugs into the Recycle Bag were never clarified by the investigation officers. As such, a factual ambiguity has arisen and, so says Mr Tan, the court must resolve the ambiguity in his favour.
- [62]
[62] In his long statement recorded on 18 August 2020, Mr Tan said that he did not handle the Drugs at all; they were placed into the Recycle Bag by Mr Dineshkumar. In contrast, in Mr Dineshkumar’s long statement recorded on 4 March 2020, he stated that he passed the two plastic bags, E1A and E1B, to Mr Tan during the car ride. It was Mr Tan who then placed the plastic bags into the Recycle Bag. Notwithstanding this, during cross-examination, Mr Dineshkumar disavowed his earlier narrative and admitted that Mr Tan had no role in placing E1A and E1B into the Recycle Bag.
- [63]
[63] According to Mr Tan, as Mr Dineshkumar would gain nothing by lying about this, he must have been telling the truth while he was on the stand. In any event, if there is any doubt as to who is telling the truth, the benefit must be given to Mr Tan. Moreover, this apparent contradiction in the statements was never clarified by the CNB officers during investigations, despite it being a material aspect in the Prosecution’s case (the Prosecution had put to Mr Tan during cross-examination that he was the one who placed E1A and E1B into the Recycle Bag).
- [64]
[64] In finding that Mr Tan has failed to rebut the presumption under s 18(1)(a) of the MDA, I have proceeded on the basis that Mr Tan knew that Mr Dineshkumar placed certain things into the Recycle Bag (see [59] above). Effectively, I have resolved any ambiguity or discrepancy in favour of Mr Tan. For clarity, I state that I accept that Mr Dineshkumar placed the plastic bags, E1A and E1B, into the Recycle Bag.
Knowledge
- [65]
[65] With that, I turn to the element of knowledge. As Mr Tan is presumed to have had the Drugs in his possession pursuant to s 18(1)(a) of the MDA, the presumption of knowledge (that Mr Tan knew the nature of the Drugs) under s 18(2) of the MDA applies. The main issue I have to consider is whether Mr Tan has successfully rebutted this presumption.
Whether the Prosecution ran a different case at trial
- [66]
[66] Similar to the element of knowing possession above, Mr Tan takes issue with the Prosecution for purportedly running a different case at trial. While the Prosecution suggested in its opening that it was relying on the presumption under section 18(2) of the MDA, the questions put by the Prosecution to Mr Tan during cross-examination suggest that its case is based on actual knowledge or wilful blindness. As such, Mr Jumabhoy urges me to decide Mr Tan’s state of mind on the basis of wilful blindness. For the same reasons which I stated (at [55]–[57] above), there is no merit in this argument. Accordingly, I decline to decide Mr Tan’s state of mind on the basis of wilful blindness. Instead, I shall direct my mind to the question of whether Mr Tan has successfully rebutted the presumption of knowledge.
The Nature of Transaction Defence
- [67]
[67] As set out at [38] above, Mr Tan’s main defence is that he was only expecting to deliver money to Pal’s “conveyor” and collect some “ice” and three “popeyes” for himself on the night of 25 February 2020 ie, the Nature of Transaction Defence. On the other hand, the Prosecution argues that the Nature of Transaction Defence is a fabricated afterthought that ought to be rejected. In my judgment, Mr Tan’s Nature of Transaction Defence should be rejected for the following reasons.
(1) Mr Tan’s purported reactions after the arrest
- [68]
[68] In support of the defence, Mr Tan highlights his reactions after the Recycle Bag was opened in his presence in the Unit to reveal the Four Bundles.
- [69]
[69] As set out above at [20(d)], in his first long statement, Mr Tan said that upon his arrest while on the way home, the Recycle Bag was opened, and he was shown the contents of the Recycle Bag by the CNB officers. He cursed Pal for doing “a dirty deed” to him. Thereafter, he was brought up to the Unit.
- [70]
[70] However, in his evidence at trial, consistent with the evidence of the CNB officers, Mr Tan testified that the Recycle Bag was opened and its contents revealed to him in the Unit. Mr Tan said that he felt “played out”. However, he did not mention that he cursed aloud (see [40] above). I shall refer to the opening of the Recycle Bag in the Unit as “the first point in time”.
- [71]
[71] A little later, as set out in his first long statement (see [20(e)] above), Mr Tan said that when his handphone rang while he was in the Unit, he felt very agitated and told the officers that he wanted to “fuck” Pal for delivering the amount of drugs in question without informing Mr Tan beforehand. He would do so before saying what the CNB had wanted him to say. In his evidence (as set out at [40] above), he said this happened while Insp Eugene was recording his first contemporaneous statement. I shall refer to this as “the second point in time”.
- [72]
[72] For context, in the living room of the Unit, SI Alwin handed a tamper-proof bag containing the Recycle Bag to Staff Sergeant Phang Yee Leong James (“SSgt James”). At about 10.41pm, SSgt James cut open the tamper-proof bag and conducted a search of the Recycle Bag. This was when its contents were revealed. Staff Sergeant Low Yi Xun (“SSgt Low”) was there to assist. In the conditioned statements of SSgt James, SI Alwin and SSgt Low, nothing was mentioned of Mr Tan’s reaction. In cross-examining these officers, Mr Tan did not ask about this purported reaction of his. For completeness, I should add that SI Alwin and SSgt Low were the arresting officers. They said that Mr Tan was arrested standing and was not pushed to the ground, contrary to Mr Tan’s assertion (that he was tackled onto the ground). According to SI Alwin, it was a normal arrest. Neither was asked about a reaction by Mr Tan to the contents of the Recycle Bag at the point of arrest.
- [73]
[73] Turning to the second point in time, Insp Eugene testified that from 10.45pm onwards, he instructed SSgt James to pause the search of the Recycle Bag, after which Insp Eugene commenced the recording of the contemporaneous statements in the living room. When Mr Tan’s handphone rang, and during his discussion with Mr Tan about answering the calls, Mr Tan did not express his frustration regarding Pal’s actions, contradicting Mr Tan’s evidence. It was put to Insp Eugene that when Mr Tan was asked if he would like to answer a call from Pal’s number, Mr Tan said yes, but that “first, [he wants] to fuck him for sending [him] so much drugs”. Insp Eugene disagreed. When cross-examined, SSgt James, SI Alwin and SSgt Low were unable to shed light on the conversation between Insp Eugene and Mr Tan. They were not paying attention to the statement recording process as they were occupied with other matters in the Unit.
- [74]
[74] To sum up, the three officers, ie, SSgt James, SI Alwin James and SSgt Low, were not asked about the purported reaction at the first point in time – when the contents of the Recycle Bag were revealed. They were only asked about what happened at the second point in time. Furthermore, Mr Tan did not mention this aspect in his testimony. Nor did he raise this in his closing submissions. It would seem that Mr Tan no longer relies on this aspect raised in the first long statement. For the avoidance of doubt, I find that there was no such reaction upon seeing the contents of the Recycle Bag.
- [75]
[75] SSgt James, SI Alwin James and SSgt Low did not know what was said between Insp Eugene and Mr Tan when Insp Eugene was interviewing Mr Tan. As these officers had other duties at the time, I do not treat their failure to notice any strong reaction by Mr Tan against Mr Tan’s defence. To me, this would have been a neutral point. However, Insp Eugene’s evidence clearly contradicts that of Mr Tan. I see no reason to doubt Insp Eugene’s account. At the material time, Insp Eugene’s focus would have been on Mr Tan. It is unlikely that he would have missed the strong reaction (if any). I pause to observe that the sentiment underlying the purported reaction ie, that Mr Tan had been deceived, was not reflected in either the first or the second contemporaneous statement. In these statements, Insp Eugene had duly recorded Mr Tan’s other responses, which included those that implicated Pal in the transaction. If Mr Tan said to Insp Eugene that he had been deceived by Pal, I do not see any reason for Insp Eugene to deliberately leave out this important detail, contrary to what Mr Tan seems to suggest. This is because even if Pal had deceived Mr Tan concerning the quantity of drugs involved, it does not necessarily mean that Mr Tan would be exculpated. In light of the discussion above, as well as what I shall discuss below, I do not accept Mr Tan’s account of his purported reaction at the second point in time.
- [76]
[76] Presumably, Mr Tan claims to have reacted as such because he was to collect only some “íce” and three “popeyes” that night ie, the Nature of Transaction Defence, and that, in any case, the agreement was that he would not take more than one pound of heroin and 125g of “ice”, ie, the Alleged Agreement. Taking his account of the purported reaction at the second point in time at the highest, they do not go far to support the Nature of Transaction Defence. Essentially, Mr Tan’s concern seemed to be that he was deceived into taking delivery of a large quantity of drugs per se. His reaction was not in relation to being deceived into taking delivery of any drugs at all, other than some “ice” for his own consumption. In fact, Mr Tan’s account seriously detracts from the Nature of Transaction Defence. The fact that I disbelieve his account of the purported reaction at the second point in time also undermines, albeit perhaps to a lesser extent, his claim in relation to the Alleged Agreement.
(2) Mr Tan’s failure to mention the Nature of Transaction Defence in the investigation statements
- [77]
[77] Next, while the Nature of Transaction Defence forms the core of Mr Tan’s defence, it is conspicuously absent in all the investigation statements.
(A) The contemporaneous statements
- [78]
[78] As discussed above, the Nature of Transaction Defence is absent from the first and second contemporaneous statements recorded by Insp Eugene after Mr Tan’s arrest. In particular, there is no mention at all about how Mr Tan was deceived by Pal. As discussed above at [75], I accept that Insp Eugene had no reason not to record such an important detail in the contemporaneous statements, especially the second one, if Mr Tan had told him about his predicament.
- [79]
[79] The third contemporaneous statement was recorded by SSgt Eric from about 12.15am, about two hours after Mr Tan’s arrest. When Mr Tan was asked specifically whether he knew how much drugs he was supposed to collect ie, Question 26, Mr Tan answered, “No. I do not know”. At trial, Mr Tan explained that he did not raise the Nature of Transaction Defence in response to Question 26 because he wanted to implicate himself so that he could receive the death penalty. Mr Tan was feeling despondent at the time and wanted to “get it done with”. However, in my view, it is difficult to see how Mr Tan’s answer of “No. I do not know” bears out his alleged state of mind when the answer is essentially a denial. If Mr Tan had truly wanted to implicate himself to receive the death penalty, he would have provided an inculpatory answer to Question 26 rather than claiming that he was ignorant of how much drugs he was supposed to collect that night.
- [80]
[80] Further, at trial, Mr Tan also provided inconsistent accounts as to what he told SSgt Eric in response to Question 26. During the cross-examination of SSgt Eric, Mr Tan’s case was that the answer was a shortened form of what he was telling SSgt Eric. In fact, Mr Tan had meant to say that he had no expectation of collecting anything on that day. However, this account, as put to SSgt Eric, is at odds with Mr Tan’s alleged state of mind, ie, that he wanted to implicate himself, as well as the Nature of Transaction Defence, ie, that he was expecting only some “ice” and “popeyes”.
- [81]
[81] Immediately after his answer to Question 26, Mr Tan was asked if he had anything else to tell or if he wanted to help CNB, ie, Question 27. Mr Tan answered that he wished to cooperate but did not know who to incriminate. It is incongruous for Mr Tan to offer to cooperate with the CNB if he had wanted to implicate himself and be sentenced to suffer death at that time. Mr Tan also did not provide any satisfactory explanation for the inconsistency of the answer with his alleged state of mind. When asked about the inconsistency, Mr Tan could only say that he did not know why, and his mind was muddled at that point in time.
- [82]
[82] In my view, the absence of the Nature of Transaction Defence in all three contemporaneous statements, and its absence from the third contemporaneous statement, despite Mr Tan expressing a wish to cooperate with the CNB and his preparedness to implicate someone else, suggest that the Nature of Transaction Defence is an afterthought. For completeness, I note that there is medical evidence regarding Mr Tan’s state of mind at the relevant time, which I shall deal with from [84] below.
(B) The cautioned statement
- [83]
[83] Similarly, Mr Tan also failed to raise the Nature of Transaction Defence in his cautioned statement that was recorded a day following his arrest. The cautioned statement is brief as Mr Tan merely stated, “I did what I did. I am guilty”. The key issue for me to decide is what exactly Mr Tan’s state of mind was at the material time. In this regard, Mr Jumabhoy argues that there is “a real risk of taking things too literally” as Mr Tan was “really resigned and despondent” and was trying to kill himself. As such, Mr Tan wanted to implicate himself at that point in time. Unsurprisingly, the Prosecution’s position is that Mr Tan did not labour suicidal thoughts at the material time, and his expression of a desire to implicate himself is a mere afterthought.
- [84]
[84] I reject Mr Tan’s claim that he was suicidal mainly because it is discredited by the evidence of the psychiatrist from the Institute of Mental Health (“IMH”), Dr Christopher Cheok (“Dr Cheok”). Dr Cheok examined Mr Tan on three occasions on 6, 9 and 11 March 2020 after Mr Tan’s arrest on 25 February 2020. In his psychiatric report dated 17 March 2020, Dr Cheok observed that Mr Tan’s “mood was euthymic”, and there were “no psychotic symptoms and no thought disorder”. There were no “feelings of passivity”, and “there were no thoughts of suicide or violence”. Dr Cheok concluded that Mr Tan suffered from “severe substance use disorder”. He also had “a past history of depression (which was in remission)”. In his testimony, Dr Cheok was clear that Mr Tan was not suicidal prior to the offence. This opinion was based on Mr Tan’s narrative when interviewed by Dr Cheok and Dr Cheok’s professional assessment.
- [85]
[85] Mr Tan also says that on 9 March 2020, he had remarked to Dr Cheok that (i) prior to the offence, he made no attempt at suicide but “did think of it” and (ii) Mr Tan knew it would “be the gallows” for him and wanted a “quick way to go”. These were recorded in Dr Cheok’s medical notes. I agree with the Prosecution that Mr Tan’s purported claim on 9 March 2020 that he had suicidal ideations must be viewed with circumspection considering Mr Tan’s indication to Dr Cheok just three days before ie, 6 March 2020, that he was not suicidal prior to the offence. In any event, Dr Cheok’s considered opinion, based on a holistic psychiatric assessment of Mr Tan, is that he was not suicidal prior to the offence. For completeness, as regards Mr Tan’s remark that he wanted a “quick way to go”, Dr Cheok testified that it did not necessarily point to “a certain darkness in terms of [Mr Tan’s] mindset” at the material time because it could simply be a “very logical, straightforward” response.
- [86]
[86] During his examination-in-chief, Mr Tan stated that during Dr Cheok’s medical examination, Mr Tan asked Dr Cheok if the latter was familiar with the terms “suicide by cops” or “suicide by police”. He told Dr Cheok that he had wanted to commit “suicide by cops”, but Dr Cheok failed to record this material fact in his notes and consider it in assessing Mr Tan’s state of mind. In my view, apart from Mr Tan’s bare assertion, which was categorically denied by Dr Cheok, there is no credible reason why Dr Cheok would deliberately lie and omit this crucial piece of evidence if it existed. Nothing suggests that Dr Cheok is not an independent and objective witness.
- [87]
[87] By the above, I reject Mr Tan’s claim regarding his suicidal ideations. For completeness, I note that Mr Tan argues that, in any event, his cautioned statement is no more than an expression of despondency in the situation he had found himself in rather than an admission of guilt. As he was not thinking rationally, no weight should be attached to the cautioned statement. I first observe that Mr Tan has conceded during cross-examination that he had failed to furnish any credible reason for failing to raise his Nature of Transaction Defence in his cautioned statement. Even if I give Mr Tan the benefit of the doubt, by giving no weight to the cautioned statement, the fact remains that Mr Tan’s Nature of Transaction Defence is absent in his contemporaneous statements (see [78]–[82] above) and long statements (see below).
(C) The long statements
- [88]
[88] Lastly, the Prosecution also contends that Mr Tan’s Nature of Transaction Defence does not feature in any of his long statements. In contrast, Mr Tan points to paragraph 19 of his second long statement, as recorded on 3 March 2020 by ASP Fernandez, to argue that he had raised the Nature of Transaction Defence during investigations. The material sentence reads:
- [89]
[89] In my view, the sentence does not assist Mr Tan very much. All it states is that the collection for the night would include some “ice” and an instrument to smoke the “ice”. It does not state that the package would only contain three “popeyes” and a small amount of “ice” (ie, the Nature of Transaction Defence). Indeed, the sentence must be read in context. Right before that sentence, Mr Tan said the following in paragraph 19:
- [90]
[90] Therefore, I fail to see how the sentence in paragraph 19 is supposed to assist Mr Tan because that very paragraph reveals Mr Tan’s expectation of what he would be carrying as it says Mr Tan had assumed that there would heroin and “ice”. At best, Mr Tan could be said to be merely indifferent to the presence of heroin, in addition to “ice”. However, an accused person who was merely indifferent to what he was carrying would not be able to rebut the presumption of knowledge in s 18(2): Gobi at [64].
- [91]
[91] By the above, I reject Mr Tan’s explanations for his failure to state the Nature of Transaction Defence in the investigation statements. This hampers his attempt to rebut the presumption in s 18(2) of the MDA.
(3) The contemporaneous statements contradict the Nature of Transaction Defence
- [92]
[92] Apart from the fact that the Nature of Transaction Defence is absent in the investigation statements, in my view, it is also contradicted by the contents of Mr Tan’s contemporaneous statements. The plain words of the first contemporaneous statements are that the Four Bundles ie, E1A1, E1A2, E1B1 and E1B2 contained heroin and “ice”.
- [93]
[93] At trial, when confronted with the first contemporaneous statement recorded by Insp Eugene, Mr Tan initially accepted that he had probably told Insp Eugene that E1A and E1B contained heroin and “ice” but later asserted that what he said was “heroin or ice” as he had no idea what the contents of the bundles were and was just speculating. According to Mr Tan, he could have overlooked the mistake and just signed. However, this was flatly denied by Insp Eugene who firmly testified that Mr Tan had said that the bundles contained “heroin and ice”.
- [94]
[94] In my view, Mr Tan’s position is unbelievable. In the first place, this claim that he said “heroin or ice” was not raised in Mr Tan’s examination-in-chief. Mr Tan appended his signature at the bottom of the two pages of the first contemporaneous statement. It is also incredible that Mr Tan would have “overlooked” the mistake on two occasions because, in the third contemporaneous statement, recorded by another officer, ie, SSgt Eric, it was also stated that the four bundles contained “heroin and ice” [emphasis added]. There is no reason why two different officers would have recorded the same conjunctive “and” if Mr Tan had indeed verbalised the word “or” to them. I shall deal with the allegations against SSgt Eric shortly. More detrimental to Mr Tan’s position is the fact that in the third contemporaneous statement, Mr Tan was recorded as saying that he “[did] not know which is Heroin, which is Ice” immediately after identifying the Four Bundles as “Heroin and Ice”. This clearly indicates that Mr Tan knew that he was carrying both heroin and “ice”.
- [95]
[95] At trial, Mr Tan sought to cast doubt on the veracity of the third contemporaneous statement by claiming that he did not bother to read it and had simply signed where SSgt Eric had told him to sign because he was very resigned and despondent and had wanted to “just get it done with”. Mr Tan had an altercation with SSgt Eric and was not “in a very good frame of mind at that time”. According to Mr Tan, he had an altercation with SSgt Eric because the latter was insisting that Mr Tan was guilty and hurrying the recording process.
- [96]
[96] I am unable to accept the allegations made by Mr Tan. For a start, I note that SSgt Eric denied that he failed to record what Mr Tan said, ie, “heroin or ice”, but recorded “heroin and ice” instead. SSgt Eric also denied that he refused to reflect what Mr Tan was telling him. SSgt Eric explained that the recording process took quite long because he had to clarify Mr Tan’s answers. More importantly, as explained above at [94], taken in context, it was clear that Mr Tan meant “heroin and ice”. As for the allegation of the altercation, pertinently, Mr Tan made no complaints against SSgt Eric despite the improper conduct alleged against SSgt Eric. While Mr Tan allegedly complained about SSgt Eric’s unreasonable behaviour to ASP Fernandez, this is contradicted by ASP Fernandez’s unchallenged account that Mr Tan did not make any complaints regarding the statement recorded by SSgt Eric.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.