General Division of the High Court · Decided 31 October 2023
Public Prosecutor v Jeffrey Pe
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 313 · Case no. Criminal Case No 52 of 2022
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The accused, Jeffrey Pe (“the Accused”), claimed trial to the following two (2) charges of sexual assault by penetration under s 376(1)(b) of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) (“PC”), and one (1) charge of sexual assault by penetration under s 376(2)(a) of the PC.
1st charge
That you, JEFFREY PE, on 9 August 2017, sometime between 4.02 a.m. and 5.43 a.m. (on the first occasion), at 27 Jalan Jintan #07-29, Singapore, did cause [the Complainant], a male then aged 20 years old, to penetrate your mouth with his penis without his consent and you have thereby committed an offence under section 376(1)(b) punishable under section 376(3) of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed).
2nd charge
That you, JEFFREY PE, on 9 August 2017, sometime between 4.02 a.m. and 5.43 a.m., at 27 Jalan Jintan #07-29, Singapore, did penetrate with your finger the anus of [the Complainant], a male then aged 20 years old, without his consent and you have thereby committed an offence under section 376(2)(a) punishable under section 376(3) of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed). (“2nd Charge”)
3rd charge
That you, JEFFREY PE, on 9 August 2017, sometime between 4.02 a.m. and 5.43 a.m. (on the second occasion), at 27 Jalan Jintan #07-29, Singapore, did cause [the Complainant], a male then aged 20 years old, to penetrate your mouth with his penis without his consent and you have thereby committed an offence under section 376(1)(b) punishable under section 376(3) of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed). (“3rd Charge”)
- [2]
[2] In respect of all three charges, the alleged victim was “S” (“the Complainant”), a male youth who was 20 years of age at the time of the alleged offences.
- [3]
[3] The Prosecution’s case was that the Complainant had never consented to any sexual activity with the Accused; and that in any event, any purported consent would have been vitiated, pursuant to s 90(b) of the PC, by reason of the Complainant’s state of intoxication at the material time. Further, contrary to the Accused’s contention, the Complainant had never represented to the Accused that he was interested in “exploring his sexuality” or that he was sexually interested in the Accused; and there was therefore also no room for the Accused to make any claim of mistake as to the Complainant’s consent under s 79 of the PC.
- [4]
[4] The Accused’s case, on the other hand, was that the Complainant had spoken about wishing to “explore his sexuality”; that the Complainant had shown romantic – or at least sexual – interest in him (the Accused); that he had reciprocated the Complainant’s interest; and that the sexual acts referred to in the three charges had all been performed by him on the Complainant with the latter’s consent.
- [5]
[5] Following a nine-day trial, I convicted the Accused of the two charges of sexual assault by penetration under s 376(1)(b) of the PC and one charge of sexual assault by penetration under s 376(2)(a) of the PC. The Accused was sentenced to a global sentence of ten years’ imprisonment and 12 strokes of the cane. As he has appealed against both the conviction and the sentence, I set out below the reasons for my decision.
The undisputed facts
- [6]
[6] The following facts were not in dispute.
The parties
- [7]
[7] The Accused is Jeffrey Pe, a 45-year-old man. He was born in the Philippines and moved to Singapore sometime in 2008. He has been living and working in Singapore since then.
- [8]
[8] The Complainant, “S”, is a citizen of the United Kingdom (“UK”) and a permanent resident of Singapore. He was living with his father in Singapore and had just completed his National Service at the time of the alleged offences.
Background
- [10]
[10] The Accused’s birthday party was held at three separate, successive locations: first, at a restaurant called The Mustard Incident on the evening of 29 July 2017; second, at a bar called Drinks & Co later in the evening of 29 July 2017; and finally at a different bar called the Skyline Club in the early hours of 30 July 2017. On 29 July 2017, the Complainant attended the party then taking place at Drinks & Co before leaving to meet his own friends . Shortly after midnight on 30 July 2017, the Complainant texted the Accused to ask if he could bring two or three friends along with him to the Skyline Club. Upon the Accused agreeing to his request, the Complainant turned up at the Skyline Club with three of his friends. The Complainant bought the Accused a drink at the Skyline Club and wished him a happy birthday.
- [11]
[11] Between 30 July 2017 and 5 August 2017, the Accused and the Complainant chatted about their social activities via WhatsApp and Snapchat from time to time.
- [12]
[12] On 6 August 2017, the Complainant accepted the Accused’s invitation to have drinks at his home. However, no meeting materialised that night as the Accused fell asleep before the Complainant’s arrival. The Complainant and the Accused later agreed to catch up for drinks on 8 August 2017.
Night of the incident
- [13]
[13] On 8 August 2017, the Complainant met up with the Accused at about 10.00pm at Chinatown MRT station, after which they proceeded to have alcoholic drinks at various pubs and bars. On 9 August 2017, at around 3.00am, the Complainant and the Accused took a taxi to the Condominium. On arrival, they went up to the Accused’s apartment within the Condominium (the “Accused’s Apartment”). The Accused made the Complainant an alcoholic drink consisting of Whiskey and Coke, which the Complainant consumed while sitting down on the floor in the Accused’s room.
The sexual acts
- [14]
[14] At trial, the precise content of the sexual activity which subsequently occurred, as well as the Complainant’s state of consciousness at the material time, were matters of dispute between the Prosecution and the Defence. What was not disputed was that sometime between 4.02am and 5.43am, the Accused fellated the Complainant. While the Accused was fellating the Complainant, the Complainant got up and went to the toilet next to the Accused’s room. The Complainant then left the Accused’s Apartment and used his mobile phone to call his friend Tan Sian Sou Zen (“Zen”). The Complainant subsequently called the Police.
First Information Report and the Accused’s arrest
- [15]
[15] The Complainant’s phone call to the Police on 9 August 2017 at about 5.47am constituted the first information report. In that phone call, the Complainant stated inter alia: “A guy just tried to rape me. I have known him for a few weeks, he was very intoxicated. He is at home right now”. He stated at first that he was on “Nutmeg Road” but eventually gave the Police the address as 27 Jalan Jintan, Kim Sia Court.
- [16]
[16] On 9 August 2017 at about 10.30am, the Accused was arrested in the Accused’s Apartment for the offence of Sexual Assault by Penetration.
The evidence adduced
- [17]
[17] I outline below the major pieces of evidence adduced at trial by both sides.
Key witnesses called by the Prosecution
S (“Complainant”)
(1) First meeting with Accused on 23 July 2017 (“First Meeting”)
- [18]
[18] The Complainant testified that he first met the Accused at Hero’s pub on 23 July 2017. On that night, the Complainant had been chatting and dancing with Francesca, whom he had just met and whom he was interested in getting to know better. Francesca was subsequently approached by a group of three men, including the Accused who invited both the Complainant and Francesca to his birthday party after chatting with them.
- [19]
[19] The Complainant recalled having a conversation with the Accused at Hero’s Pub which lasted for about 15 minutes . The Complainant and the Accused both got Francesca’s telephone number that night and also exchanged telephone numbers with each other. While the Complainant could not remember the details of his conversation with the Accused, he was able to say that they had talked about how it was “nice connecting to new people and how it’s nice to meet people on a night out”. He also recalled telling the Accused that it was “quite refreshing to meet these new connections and interact with new people as this is a good way to get to know people and potentially get a job one day with these connections”. At that point in time, the Complainant was about to complete his National Service and intended to take up a course of study at a university in the UK.
(2) WhatsApp messages between the Complainant and the Accused between the First Meeting and the second meeting at the Accused’s birthday party (“Second Meeting”)
- [20]
[20] Evidence was led from the Complainant as to the contents of his subsequent communications with the Accused via WhatsApp. By way of explanation, the Complainant testified that he had used an iOS software called “Amazing” to obtain a record of his WhatsApp conversation history with the Accused. Although the Complainant no longer had an iPhone, he still retained his iPhone backups and was able to view them on the “Amazing” software. The Complainant obtained the screenshots of the messages a “couple of weeks” before the trial.
- [21]
[21] A perusal of the WhatsApp conversation history between 23 July 2017 and 29 July 2017 showed that the Complainant and the Accused had a total of five WhatsApp conversations during this period. These conversations generally related to their respective social activities, the Accused’s plans for his birthday celebrations on 29 July 2017, and the Complainant’s efforts to try to get to know Francesca better. On 23 July 2017, the Accused shared a photo of himself embracing a female “friend of a friend” and talked about how he had been “so smashed” the night before, among other things. On 29 July 2017, the Accused reminded the Complainant about his birthday party; the Complainant replied that he would stop by Drinks & Co, but did not think he would be able to make it to the third stop for the birthday party (ie, Skyline Bar).
(3) Second Meeting
- [22]
[22] On the night of 29 July 2017, the Complainant attended the Accused’s birthday celebrations at Drinks & Co where he stayed for about half an hour before leaving to meet his own friends at Hero’s pub for more drinks.
(4) Interaction between the Complainant and the Accused between the Second Meeting and the night of 8 August 2017 (“Third Meeting”)
- [24]
[24] Between 30 July 2017 and 8 August 2017, the Complainant and the Accused continued to chat from time to time via both WhatsApp and Snapchat, about topics such as the Accused’s birthday party and their respective social activities. The Complainant explained that the Snapchat application allowed the taking and sending of photos and videos which would subsequently disappear. The Snapchat messages themselves had remained in the chat because the Complainant saved all his messages and communications on Snapchat. According to the Complainant, the images of his Snapchat conversations with the Accused were taken from a backup copy that he had retrieved: the photos of these Snapchat conversations which were exhibited in court had been taken by him using another phone.
- [25]
[25] In respect of the events of 6 August 2017, the Complainant testified that prior to messaging the Accused, he had been out drinking with some friends. As he wanted to continue drinking when his friends went home, he texted the Accused to ask if the latter was out. The Accused replied saying that he had just gotten home, and invited the Complainant to come over to his home for drinks. The Accused, who was then staying at 27 Jalan Jintan (the “Condominium”), sent the Complainant the address via WhatsApp. The Complainant also clarified that shortly after accepting the invitation, he had messaged the Accused to say he was feeling “down” and did not want to go to the Accused’s house to drink – but as he managed to get a taxi at the same time, he deleted those messages and instead sent a message to say he was coming over.
- [26]
[26] The Complainant went to the Condominium sometime after 2.00am on 6 August 2017, but did not manage to meet the Accused, who had fallen asleep before his arrival. Shortly thereafter, the Accused texted the Complainant on the early morning of 6 August 2017 to apologise. Sometime later in the same WhatsApp thread on 6 August 2017, the Accused also stated that he wanted to “make it up to” the Complainant and sought to invite the latter to drinks at his place that day. The Complainant declined the invitation, and they chatted about their sporting activities before making tentative plans to catch up for drinks on 8 August 2017. In a Snapchat message sent to the Complainant on 7 August 2017, the Accused suggested that they should “do clubbing” first, “then… finish off getting wasted [ie drunk] at [his] place”.
(5) Third Meeting
- [27]
[27] On 8 August 2017, the Complainant met up with the Accused at Chinatown MRT at about 10.00pm, following which they visited a number of pubs and bars – Lime Bar, HQ, 1-Altitude, Café Iguana and Sticky Fingers – to imbibe alcoholic drinks. The Complainant testified that along the way, they chatted about various topics such as their respective families; he himself also talked about his former girlfriend. At Sticky Fingers, they met up with his friends from school, and he chatted with these friends about the army as they were two years younger than him and had not yet completed National Service.
- [28]
[28] The last nightspot which the Complainant and the Accused visited in the early hours of 9 August 2017 was Hero’s pub. After leaving Hero’s pub, the Complainant and the Accused took a Grab taxi back to the Accused’s home at the Condominium, to continue drinking. According to the Complainant, he was “very drunk” by then; and he only realised later that they had taken a Grab taxi when he found the Grab receipt on his phone. He did recall that it was in the taxi on the way to the Condominium that they spoke about him “crashing” at the Accused’s home “because the plan was to continue drinking and it was quite far away” from his own home.
- [29]
[29] At the Condominium, the Complainant did not remember how he got to the Accused’s apartment: he could only remember following the latter into the lift. The next thing he then remembered was going into the Accused’s “very small, very compact” room and sitting on the floor.
- [30]
[30] While they were in the room, the Accused gave the Complainant an alcoholic drink which he had made. The Complainant found the drink “quite strong”, “stronger than what [he was] used to”, and thought that it “might have been whiskey or something similar”. Thereafter, the Complainant remembered lying flat on his back on the floor and saying that he was going to sleep there. According to the Complainant, this was in line with the initial plan for him to sleep over, since his home in Upper Bukit Timah was “quite far away”, and he often stayed over at the homes of friends who lived closer to town.
- [31]
[31] The Complainant remembered that the Accused kept asking him if he wanted to change into some pyjamas. The Complainant declined and remarked that he was going to “just wear [his] own clothes” and “just going to sleep… just going to sleep here”. He remembered “just feeling quite tired and then eventually falling asleep”. At this point in time, he was wearing a shirt and “skinny” jeans with a belt and a pair of briefs beneath his jeans.
- [32]
[32] The next thing the Complainant remembered was being woken up by “some movement”. In his own words, this was what happened :
I just remember being woken up by some movement. JP [the Accused] was sucking my penis and I was shocked… I was just like paralysed, similar to like when you are dreaming and you have like sleep paralysis and you feel like you want to move, you want to get out but you can’t. I was just paralysed with fear. I just – I remember falling in and out of consciousness. I don’t remember chronologically the acts that happened but I know that he – I woke up by him sucking my penis and he also tried to stick his fingers in my anus. And he tried to put his tongue in my mouth and yah, I was really shocked. I also remember him trying to put my hand on his penis and then it would just drop. I just felt floppy. I just -- I couldn’t move and then – so like I said, I don’t remember sequentially how did that happen but I was woken up by him sucking my penis and I just eventually managed to do something, managed to gain the strength to get up and I pushed him away and not violently, just brushed him away. And then I just wanted to get out… I just wanted to get out. So I tried to leave as soon as possible…
- [33]
[33] In his evidence-in-chief, the Complainant clarified that the “movement” which he had been woken up by involved his “legs being moved”. At the point he was woken up, his legs “would have been spread out with [his] knees pointing outwards; and the Accused was in front of him and “kneeling between [his] legs”, “sort of kneeling, just crouching over” him. He was able to recollect that the Accused “was in more than one position” in the course of the alleged sexual assault.
- [34]
[34] In respect of the sequence of events, the Complainant testified that he recalled two instances of fellatio by the Accused: once when he first woke up and again just before he left. He could also recall three other acts by the Accused in between the two instances of fellatio. He could not recall strictly the sequence in which these three other acts were committed as he was at that juncture “falling in and out of consciousness”, but he could recall that one of the acts involved the Accused sticking his fingers into his (the Complainant’s) anus. He knew it was more than one finger because he “felt fingers” and “it felt painful”. Another act involved the Accused lifting his hand and putting it on the Accused’s penis. He recalled that the Accused was on his left side by then and “kept lifting…up” his left hand to put it on the Accused’s penis. At that point, the Accused was wearing “something on top but nothing on the bottom”. The third act involved the Accused “trying to put his tongue in [the Complainant’s] mouth, trying to kiss [him]”: he could remember “feeling [the Accused’s] tongue in [his] mouth as [he] was sleeping” as well as “opening [his] eyes and seeing [the Accused’s] face there” and then closing his eyes again because he “was scared” of what the latter was doing. There was no conversation between the Accused and the Complainant from the time when the Complainant saw the Accused sucking his penis to the time he pushed the Accused off.
- [35]
[35] The Complainant also testified that it was only when he managed to “gain the strength” to get up that he realised that his trousers and belt were around his ankles. He had a “vague recollection” of going to wash himself in the toilet next to the Accused’s room because he was “feeling quite disgusted” and also “scared of STDs”. He then tried to get out of the apartment as soon as possible. He recalled that he had some difficulty (“struggle”) trying to get out of the door and vaguely recalled that the Accused might have helped him, but could not be sure. He remembered getting into the lift but could not recall the floor he was on. At this juncture he felt “quite emotional” and “very upset”: he was crying, but because there was a lady in the lift who started laughing at him, he tried to hide the fact that he was crying.
- [36]
[36] After exiting the lift, he could not remember how to get out of the Condominium and was unable to find the main road. Eventually, he “calmed down a bit” when he managed to get “away from the situation”. He then called his friend Zen. He was feeling “really upset, really ashamed” about the incident and found it “really hard” to “talk about it", but he told Zen what had happened and asked Zen for his advice as the latter was then doing his national service in the police force. As Zen told him to call the police, he called “995” and then “999”. In all, he called the police three or four times, as the police took some time to arrive. By this point, he was “next to the road, just on the pavement”.
- [37]
[37] At trial, the audio recording of the Complainant’s “999” call was played back in court during his evidence-in-chief. The Complainant identified his own voice on the audio recording voice. He testified that he had been crying and feeling “emotionally exhausted” at the time of the call, which was why his voice had sounded very nasal. It took an hour or so after his phone calls for the police to arrive. The Complainant recalled having to speak to “a few people” and then being taken to Singapore General Hospital (“SGH”) for assessment, blood tests and urine tests. He called his former girlfriend and his father to tell them what had happened. He was initially reluctant to tell his father as he felt “ashamed”, “embarrassed” and “upset”, but was told by the investigating officer (“IO”) that he needed to have his guardian or parent with him as he was below 21 years of age. His father came to meet him at SGH, and later, so did Zen.
- [38]
[38] The Complainant testified that at no time had he given the Accused any consent to perform the various sexual acts on him. In cross-examination, he agreed that he was generally a “very open” person, and that in chatting with the Accused at Hero’s pub on 23 July 2017, he had mentioned his “toxic” relationship with his former girlfriend. However, he denied that he had told the Accused in the same conversation that he was “exploring [his] sexuality”. He also denied having told the Accused several times during the birthday celebrations on 30 July 2017 that he “really likes him [the Accused]”.
Tan Tian Sou Zen (“Zen”)
- [39]
[39] Zen gave evidence that on 9 August 2017, he was woken up between 4.00am and 5.00am by a telephone call from the Complainant. When he answered the phone, the Complainant was “mumbling” and “sounded like he was panicking and really scared”. The first thing the Complainant said to Zen was that “J.P. raped me”. Zen did not understand the Complainant and had to ask him to repeat himself. The Complainant was “mumbling little bits of words and breathing heavily”, sounding “drunk but scared at the same time”. Through talking with the Complainant, Zen “understood from him that J.P. had touched his penis”.
- [40]
[40] After calming the Complainant down, Zen advised him to call the police. Zen again received a call from the Complainant about 10 minutes after the first call, with the Complainant stating that the police had not yet arrived, and that he did not know what to do. The Complainant then called Zen a third time to inform him that the police were already at the scene and to ask Zen to “go down and see him”. Zen subsequently went to SGH to meet the Complainant.
- [41]
[41] At SGH, the Complainant related to Zen the events of 9 August 2017. According to the Complainant, he had been invited by the Accused (referred to as “J.P.”) to “chill” at the latter’s house after clubbing; and while at the house, the Accused had given the Complainant an alcoholic beverage, which was very strong and which “hit [the Complainant] really hard”. The Accused had then “touched [the Complainant] inappropriately… around [his] penis”. The Complainant told Zen that he had “managed to push J.P. away, zipped up his own pants, and ran out of J.P.’s house to the ground floor of the block”.
Dr Irfan Abdulrahman Sheth (“Dr Irfan”)
- [42]
[42] Dr Irfan of the Department of Emergency Medicine at SGH gave evidence that he conducted an examination of the Complainant on 9 August 2017 at about 11.18am. Upon learning that the Complainant was an alleged victim of sexual assault, he referred the case to Dr Lew Pei Shi (“Dr Lew”), the Doctor-On-Call, for a sexual assault medical examination. The examination by Dr Lew included “a penile swab, low anal and high anal swabs” being taken “with routine bloods for full blood count, renal and liver panels”. On 10 August 2017, Dr Irfan again examined the Complainant regarding his blood test results. Dr Irfan subsequently prepared and produced a medical report dated 17 August 2021. It should be noted that in preparing this medical report, Dr Irfan incorporated observations recorded in his own notes as well as observations recorded in Dr Lew’s notes.
- [43]
[43] In the report dated 17 August 2021, Dr Irfan set out the history taken by him from the Complainant at the Department of Emergency Medicine on 9 August 2017, at 11.18am. Per Dr Irfan’s report, the Complainant had recounted that “he was out drinking with the [A]ccused the night before, and then decided to stay overnight at the [A]ccused house”. According to the Complainant, “the [A]ccused made him a drink which made him very giddy, after which he fell asleep”. The Complainant said that when he “woke up at around 0530 hours on 09 Aug 2017”, he claimed that “the Accused was performing oral sex on him and penetrating his anus with his fingers”. The Complainant also said that he “subsequently pushed the [A]ccused away, walked out and called the police”.
- [44]
[44] Dr Irfan also gave some evidence explaining the Complainant’s blood test results and the reasons why a repeat blood test was conducted. It is not necessary to reproduce this part of Dr Irfan’s evidence in these written grounds, as the evidence was not germane to either side’s case in respect of the alleged offences.
Dr Lew Pei Shi (“Dr Lew”)
- [45]
[45] Dr Lew of the Department of General Surgery at SGH conducted a sexual assault medical examination of the Complainant on 9 August 2017, at about 12.25pm. As part of the examination, Dr Lew took a sample of blood from the Complainant, along with anal and penile swabs. Dr Lew concluded her medical examination at about 1.00pm. Dr Lew subsequently reviewed the medical report prepared by Dr Irfan (P42) and confirmed that the contents of the said report were consistent with her findings in the assessment of the Complainant.
- [46]
[46] In cross-examination, Dr Lew testified that during her examination of the Complainant, he had given her an account of events similar to the account set out in the opening paragraph of Dr Irfan’s report.
Dr Lambert Low (“Dr Low”)
- [47]
[47] Dr Low of the National Addictions Management Service at the Institute of Mental Health (“IMH”) was called as an expert witness. He was asked by the Prosecution to address three questions in his expert report of 7 August 2018:
(a) the Complainant’s blood alcohol concentration (“BAC”) between 4.15am and 5.30am on 9 August 2017;
(b) the Complainant’s mental state at that time and whether his judgment was impaired;
(c) the Complainant’s ability to consent to sexual acts committed against him at that time.
- [48]
[48] Prior to preparing his report, Dr Low interviewed the Complainant on 24 July 2018 and 7 August 2018. He also read the summary of facts provided to him by the police and spoke to the Complainant’s father on 7 August 2018 for corroborative history.
- [49]
[49] In his report, Dr Low noted the history provided to him by the Complainant. In gist, the Complainant reported having been “quite intoxicated” by the time he reached the Accused’s home on 9 August 2017, and then having “completely lost consciousness” after a “subsequent drink offered to him by the [A]ccused at his home”. According to the Complainant, upon awakening, he had still been “drifting in and out of consciousness” and “couldn’t recognise his surroundings”. He “noticed that the [A]ccused was performing fellatio on him”; that the Accused had used “his limp hand to touch the [A]ccused’s penis” ; and that “the [A]ccused had also performed digital penetration of his anus”. After “some struggle”, the Complainant “managed to push off the [A]ccused and staggered to the bathroom outside to wash himself”, following which “he staggered out of the flat and headed for the lift outside”. The Complainant reported having felt disoriented and having to ask “a Chinese lady whom he met in the lift what floor he gotten on [sic] as he was too disoriented to even notice”. He also reported having been “too disoriented to figure out how to exit the premises of the condominium”: “[a]fter some trying, he managed to leave the compound briefly for twenty metres but thereafter proceeded to walk back in after failing to find the main road and waited for the police to arrive after calling them”.
- [50]
[50] Dr Low also noted the Complainant’s drinking pattern. The Complainant “tended to drink once per week, each time drinking 3 pints of beer on average”, with beer being “his preferred beverage”. According to the Complainant, at these levels of alcohol consumption, he would “not get intoxicated”, “but would feel tipsy and somewhat ‘happy’”, and “thereafter he would stop drinking”. The Complainant also informed Dr Low that “on the day of the alleged sexual assault, he estimated that he had drunk 2 times his usual amount” and had not consumed “more food to go along with his alcohol at night” after having had “dinner at around 6-7pm”. In his evidence-in-chief at trial, Dr Low explained that he had recorded this piece of information because food tended to “slow down the absorption of alcohol”, and “the presence of additional food in the stomach would therefore delay gastric emptying and possibly slow down the absorption if he had had any food to go along with the alcohol”.
- [51]
[51] In arriving at the conclusions stated in the final paragraph of his report, Dr Low first highlighted that it would be “difficult to quantify the exact amount” that the Complainant had drunk on the night of the alleged offences, “due to issues of alcohol dilution with mixers and difficulties with recall”. However, “based on the pattern of [the Complainant’s] drinking”, Dr Low opined that he was “a moderate drinker with an estimated alcohol clearance rate of 15mg/100ml to 20mg/100ml of blood per hour”. Dr Low also noted that the Complainant’s blood ethanol concentration – taken at 1.00pm on 9 August 2017 – was 40mg/100ml. Based on Dr Low’s calculations, “this would imply that at 4.15am, [the Complainant’s] BAC level was between 171.25mg/100ml and 215mg/100ml.” At 5.30am, “[the Complainant’s] BAC level was between 152.5mg/100ml and 190mg/100ml”.
- [52]
[52] Based on such BAC levels and on the Complainant’s description of the events surrounding his awakening, Dr Low opined that it was “not hard to conclude that [the Complainant] was likely to still be intoxicated between 4.15am and 5.30am and therefore unable to consent to the sexual acts committed against him”.
- [54]
[54] Dr Low also explained the different stages of alcohol intoxication based on BAC levels as follows. Generally speaking, a person would first experience the effects of alcohol on the system at “levels above 50 milligrams per decilitre”: at BAC levels above 50mg/100ml, such a person would “start experiencing effects of alcohol on his psychomotor functions, so he could be a bit clumsy, a bit more…impaired in his coordination”. At BAC levels above 100mg/100ml, “more cognitive effects start to come in, in which the person becomes a little bit more dizzy, more elated, more talkative”. Thereafter, at BAC levels above 150mg/100ml, the cognition or mental state of the person would “start to become even more affected”, in terms of his “awareness of the surroundings…his responses to his surroundings, his ability to take in information and process information, his ability to understand and weigh decisions, his ability to…make sense of things around him”: “his conscious level drops”. In Dr Low’s opinion, generally, at BAC levels above 150mg/100ml, “a person’s mental state becomes impaired, he tends to make reckless behaviour, tends to be…less aware of his surroundings…more and more confused”. At the even higher BAC levels of 250 to 300mg/100ml, the person would experience stupor and be unable to move very much; his muscles would become very weak; he would become “very lethargic and very much unable to respond to the external circumstances”. Finally, at above 300mg/100ml, the person would become comatose.
- [55]
[55] As for the physical state of the intoxicated person, Dr Low opined that “the physical state would depend very much…on his surroundings”: for example, an intoxicated person who was in a familiar environment would be more likely to be able to find his way around and to move more effortlessly, compared to someone who was in a “foreign environment” where he might “end up tripping, falling over or…having a bit of a staggered gait…because he’s not familiar with the environment”.
- [56]
[56] As to his opinion that the Complainant was likely to still have been “intoxicated between 4.15am and 5.30am [on 9 August 2017] and therefore unable to consent to the sexual acts committed against him”. Dr Low provided the following explanation:
[U]sing a threshold of about 150 milligrams per decilitre to reach a confused state and taking into account the…gravity of the act which is a sexual act which is something very intimate, and ability to weigh the information with regards to consent to a sexual act which is something that is very personal, something that you’re giving away…your own personal body, being able to reach such a difficult decision at a blood alcohol level of 150 when you are…confused is going to be very hard…to explain, yah. So…if proper consent was to be taken at that blood alcohol level, it is very hard to say that the person is being able to give that consent in such a confused state for something [so] personal and important…
- [57]
[57] In his evidence-in-chief, Dr Low also testified that he had been informed of the account given by the Complainant of the events which had taken place inside the Accused’s room from the time he was woken up until the time he left the apartment. In respect of the first instance of fellatio and the three other acts following it (the Accused using his fingers to penetrate the Complainant’s anus, the Accused using the Complainant’s limp left hand to touch his penis, the Accused trying to insert his tongue into the Complainant’s mouth), Dr Low was asked whether he could explain why the Complainant had “seemed to be registering what was happening to him, but he was unable to move”. Dr Low opined that the “most likely case” was that the Complainant had been in “a state of shock”, “a dreamlike state in which he was kind of drifting in and out of consciousness”, had a “partial awareness” of what was going on around him”, and was “trying to make sense of what [was] going on around him, and possibly…then falling back to sleep thereafter and waking up again”. In Dr Low’s opinion, in this state, the Complainant would not have really reacted because he would still have been “really trying to appreciate the nature and the circumstances” of what was happening around him. By the time of the second instance of fellatio, however, the Complainant would probably have “gained a better understanding and awareness of his scenario, realising that it’s actually happening and it’s no longer a dream that he’s experiencing”. At this stage, the Complainant, “being a big-sized individual, would then summon…the rest of his faculties to then push off” the Accused.
- [58]
[58] At trial, Dr Low was also shown the CCTV video footage of the Accused and the Complainant arriving at the lobby of the Condominium, as well as the video footage of the Complainant later exiting the lift and leaving the lobby. Asked to explain why the video footage appeared to show the Complainant having been able to walk unsupported instead of staggering, Dr Low testified that an intoxicated person could “potentially still do an act properly if it’s a simple one, as long as [such person] focus[ed] all [his] mental faculties on doing it properly”: in his words, “you may be just walking and talking nonsense. That’s okay, because your primary focus at that point in time is to walk… to make sure you don’t fall down”. Dr Low also caveated that the distances which the Complainant was shown walking in the video footage were “very short” distances; and it would be “very hard to conclude” whether the Complainant would have been able to continue walking straight without staggering over a “more protracted, more prolonged” distance.
- [59]
[59] In cross-examination, Dr Low stated that he could not comment much on the Complainant’s cognitive abilities at the times shown in the video footage because the distances involved were short, and he could not hear what the Complainant might have been saying: all that he could say was that the Complainant appeared not to be staggering, which could have been due to his “just focusing squarely on” walking. As for the audio-recording of the Complainant’s first phone call to the police, which the defence claimed showed the Complainant to have had “his cognitive abilities about him”, Dr Low’s evidence was that it showed that the Complainant had “limited mental faculties, in the sense that he’s able to recall certain information about himself, for instance, his own phone number, his name”; and that he had “limited awareness of surroundings. He knows he’s on Nutmeg Road”. Dr Low caveated that the Complainant’s phone call to the police was a “very simple conversation”; and while he was able to say that the Complainant had been able to provide the information required by the operator who answered his call, he was unable to tell very much more.
- [60]
[60] Overall, Dr Low disagreed with the assertion by the Defence that the Complainant’s “cognitive abilities were not impaired”. Dr Low also stated that he highly doubted the assertion by the Defence that the Complainant’s BAC level could have been below 150mg/100ml at 4.01am, “[g]iven the fact that he [was walking straight into the lift and… an experienced drinker”. Dr Low further explained the opinion expressed in his report as to the Complainant’s BAC levels at 4.15am and at 5.30am on 9 August 2017:
[A]t 4.15, I give a range of values, 171.25 to 215 milligrams per 100ml. In fact, if [the Complainant] had been a very experienced drinker, his blood alcohol levels would have been even higher… [T]he more experienced you are, the faster – the faster you metabolise alcohol and therefore the reference values would then creep up and not creep down. So if anything, the 171.25 would probably be an underestimate. I’ve given you a range of values which I’m more or less sure that that is where his blood alcohol level is at that point in time, but it's probably closer towards the 215 at 4.15. It’s probably closer towards there because [the Complainant] being an experienced drinker would push towards the higher value because he metabolises alcohol faster.
Dr Cornelia Chee (“Dr Chee”)
- [61]
[61] Dr Chee of the Department of Psychological Medicine of National University Hospital (“NUH”) conducted a psychiatric assessment of the Complainant on 30 July 2018 and 6 August 2018. At the time of the psychiatric assessment, the Complainant was a first-year undergraduate student in London who had returned to Singapore during his holiday to assist with police investigations in his case. In her report dated 22 January 2019, Dr Chee noted that the Complainant had recounted to her the following events: on 8 August 2017, he “had finished his last day of National Service”, “had gone drinking, and had gone to a friend’s house to sleep”. However, he woke up to find that this friend (an older man) was “performing oral sex on him, and was attempting to digitally penetrate him”. He “managed to break free and run out of the house”.
- [62]
[62] The Complainant reported that after the above incident, he had experienced “shame, anger, hyperarousal symptoms such as being easily startled i[f] anyone touched him, poor sleep, intrusive memories of the incident and avoidance of reminders of the incident”; and that while “these symptoms had reduced by the time he went to London to further his studies”, he was “re-experiencing some of the unwanted memories and symptoms again” after undergoing questioning at CID in July and August 2018. Dr Chee noted that this was not uncommon.
- [63]
[63] In her report, Dr Chee noted that the Complainant had given “a history of brief episodes of low mood lasting a few days, starting from before he was 18-years old”, and that these episodes did not seem to be connected to the above symptoms. She diagnosed the Complainant as suffering “Generalized Anxiety Disorder with possible Post-traumatic stress symptoms”. He was started on antidepressant medications for anxiety disorders (Venlafaxine with a dosage of 75mg/d). On his follow-up visit on 6 August 2018, prior to his return to London, the dosage of Venlafaxine was increased to 150mg/d. Another follow-up visit was planned for the period of his December 2018 holidays, but he defaulted on this follow-up appointment and subsequently informed that he was “not keen for further follow-up”.
Thermizi Tho (“Mr Tho”)
- [64]
[64] Mr Tho was the original investigating officer (“IO”) for this case. At the time of the investigations in 2017, he was an Assistant Superintendent of Police (“ASP”), attached to the Serious Sexual Crime Branch (“SSCB”) of the Criminal Investigation Department (“CID”). He resigned from the Singapore Police Force on 7 May 2018.
- [65]
[65] Mr Tho was part of the arresting team that arrived at the Accused’s residence at about 10.20am on 9 August 2017. He recalled that when he first knocked at the door of the Accused’s apartment, there was no response; the police proceeded to activate a locksmith to come down to the apartment. However, before the locksmith could actually try to open the door, it was opened by the Accused himself.
- [66]
[66] Mr Tho testified that he asked the Accused questions in relation to the Complainant’s allegation of sexual assault, and that the Accused “mentioned something about they were having drinks in his room” and “claimed that the sexual thing was consensual”. At about 10.30am, together with ASP Tai Yian Peng Christine, Mr Toh arrested the Accused on suspicion of committing an offence of sexual assault by penetration under s 376(1)(b) punishable under s 376(3) of the PC.
Dr Arnab Kumar Ghosh (“Dr Ghosh”)
- [67]
[67] Dr Ghosh of the South Region of the IMH conducted a forensic psychiatric assessment of the Accused on 18 September 2017 and 20 September 2017, for the purposes of his psychiatric report dated 26 September 2017. Before issuing his report, Dr Ghosh also perused the statement of facts. In gist, Dr Ghosh was of the opinion that the Accused did not suffer from any mental illness, he was not of unsound mind at the time of the alleged offence, he “had alcohol intoxication before the alleged offence”, and he was fit to stand trial.
- [68]
[68] In his report, Dr Ghosh also set out the Accused’s background as well as his account of the events of 8 August and 9 August 2017. Inter alia, Dr Ghosh recorded the Accused’s account of the clubs and bars he and the Complainant had visited that night and the drinks they had consumed.
- [69]
[69] In respect of the events in the Accused’s room in the early hours of 9 August 2017, Dr Ghosh noted that the Accused’s version was as follows. According to the Accused, upon reaching his place, the “[C]omplainant had taken out his ring and sat comfortably in his room”. The Accused changed his clothes in front of the Complainant before “they started sipping whisky and coke, which the [Accused] had prepared there, while sitting beside each other”. The Accused claimed that the Complainant had “started playing guitar” and that “their arms were rubbing against each other”. As to the sexual acts, the Accused claimed that “the Complainant was awake when he started touching his thigh”; and that “when he tried to open the [C]omplainant’s pant[s] the Complainant cooperated”: according to the Accused, “after finding the [C]omplainant’s penis erect, [he] tried to pull down his pant[s] to fully expose the penis”, whereupon the Complainant had “raised his body to allow the [Accused] to pull down his pant[s]”. The Accused then started performing fellatio on the Complainant and also kissed his mouth and nipples. He claimed that he did so for about 10 minutes. However, he denied “putting his fingers into the Complainant’s anus even though he admitted to having touched his buttocks”.
- [70]
[70] Dr Ghosh further documented that per the Accused’s version of events, the Complainant “had not protested or resisted [his] actions at any point of time despite being awake and aware of what was going on”. Subsequently, “the [C]omplainant had then stood up and gone to toilet for few minutes”. The Accused was “waiting in the room but then the [C]omplainant left the house without informing him”. The Accused “assumed that the [C]omplainant was done with the one-night stand and did not attempt to stop him”.
Close of the Prosecution’s case
- [71]
[71] At the close of the Prosecution’s case, the Defence did not make a submission of no case to answer. As I was satisfied that the Prosecution had made out a prima facie case against the Accused on the two charges of penile-oral penetration under s 376(1)(b) PC and the charge of digital-anal penetration under s 376(2)(a) PC, I called on the Accused for his defence to these charges. The Accused elected to give evidence.
- [72]
[72] I outline below the Accused’s version of events and the key evidence he relied on.
The evidence led by the Defence
The Accused’s evidence
- [73]
[73] The Accused described himself as a friendly person. According to him, he was bisexual and had realised that he was bisexual since 2015.
(1) First Meeting
- [74]
[74] The Accused agreed with the Prosecution that he first met the Complainant at Hero’s pub on the night of 23 July 2017, when the latter was together with Francesca. His version of the first meeting at Hero’s pub differed from the Prosecution’s chiefly in terms of the contents of his conversation with the Complainant on that night. The Accused claimed that while he was chatting with the Complainant that night, the latter revealed that he had “gone through a toxic relationship with his ex-girlfriend and [that] he was exploring his sexuality”. Upon hearing this, the Accused replied that “it’s okay because I’m bisexual”. This was because he wanted the Complainant to be “comfortable” and “just to be authentic”.
- [75]
[75] Although the conversation between the Accused and the Complainant lasted only about 20 to 30 minutes, the Accused asserted that he was able to feel a “connection” and “chemistry” with the Complainant even when they spoke for the first time. He ended up inviting the Complainant to his birthday celebrations on 29 July 2017. This invitation was sent to the Complainant via WhatsApp on the mobile phone number that the Accused obtained from him. The Accused also invited Francesca to his birthday celebrations.
- [76]
[76] Following the First Meeting, the Accused and the Complainant exchanged some messages on the WhatsApp and Snapchat platforms. These were the same messages which the Complainant had referred to in his testimony (Exhibits 45 and 46). For his part, the Accused sought to highlight that the Complainant had signed off on one of his messages using the “xo” emoji. According to the Accused, “xo” was “universal slang” for “hugs and kisses”. The Accused also claimed that his remark in one of his messages to the Complainant – “it’s going to be refreshing for you” – was a reference to the Complainant’s statement at Hero’s pub about wanting to explore his sexuality: by using the word “refreshing”, the Accused meant that the Complainant would get to meet “new people”, “new guys”.
- [77]
[77] At trial, the Accused alleged that there were Snapchat messages between 25 July 2017 and 31 July 2017 which were missing from the messages exhibited in court by the Prosecution. He said that these would have been daily conversations about “family and friends”, although he was “not 100% certain”. When asked if these missing messages could be found on his own phone, he said that he could not find them .
(2) Second Meeting
- [78]
[78] As per the Complainant’s account, the second meeting between him and the Accused took place on the occasion of the latter’s birthday celebrations on 29 and 30 July 2017. The Complainant attended the celebrations at Drinks & Co. and later at the Skyline Bar. The Accused, for his part, sought to emphasise in his testimony that when the Complainant came to Drinks & Co., he gave the Accused a “tight hug” when wishing him a happy birthday, and another “tight hug” before leaving.
- [79]
[79] Subsequently, when the Complainant turned up at the Skyline Bar with his friends, he again gave the Accused a “tight hug” when offering him birthday greetings a second time. According to the Accused, in the course of the night, the Complainant bought him a drink as a birthday present, placed his arms around the Accused’s shoulders, and stated that he “really likes” the Accused. The Accused claimed that he reciprocated by telling the Complainant “I do like you”, and that before the Complainant left the Skyline Bar, he gave the Accused another “tight hug”.
(3) Third meeting
- [81]
[81] As to the events of 8 August 2017, the Accused did not dispute the Complainant’s testimony about the clubs and bars they visited that night. The Accused claimed, however, that he had specifically informed the Complainant that the event at the 1-Altitude bar was “a gay night” and that the Complainant had replied that he was “okay with that”. The Accused also claimed that when told 1-Altitude was “quite strict on their age limit”, the Complainant had said “he was 25 years old”.
- [82]
[82] According to the Accused, in the course of the night, he and the Complainant chatted about personal matters such as “family matters” and the MBA degree programme which the Accused was pursuing. The Accused also gave evidence about various alleged instances of physical contact between the two of them over the course of the night. According to the Accused, at “HQ” bar, their “arms actually brushed each other” when they went to the toilet, and they “felt comfortable with each other”. At Hero’s pub, they danced while standing next to each other, with their arms around each other’s shoulders.
- [83]
[83] The Accused further testified that in the course of the night, he had “asked [the Complainant] three times” to “sleep over” at his (the Accused’s) place: first, when they were on their way to Lime Bar at the start of the evening; a second time when they were making their way to Café Iguana; and finally, while they were at Hero’s pub. Each time he was asked if he wanted to “sleep over”, the Complainant agreed to the suggestion. In cross-examination, the Accused claimed that per his own understanding, the term “sleep over” could refer either to “sleeping” or to “actually having sex”. He claimed that this understanding was based on his own “experience”, because an invitation from someone to “go home to their place after a club night” would “usually” lead to sex; and that he therefore understood the Complainant to be communicating that they could end up having sex at his apartment, although the Complainant did not actually state expressly that they might have sex.
- [84]
[84] To get to the Accused’s apartment from Hero’s pub, the Accused and the Complainant took a Grab taxi. The Accused testified that the Complainant was the one who booked the taxi; that the Complainant “definitely knows what’s going on around him” and was “fully in control of himself”; and that he was “not intoxicated at that time”.
(4) Events upon reaching the Condominium
- [85]
[85] The Accused further testified that upon reaching the Condominium, the Complainant was able to walk steadily on his own without any signs of staggering. Once inside the apartment, the Accused made drinks for both of them. He recalled the Complainant sitting on the floor next to the wall in his room. He also recalled changing his clothes in front of the Complainant and offering the latter a change of clothes (which was refused). While consuming their drinks, they continued chatting; at some point, the Complainant also sang while strumming on a guitar which the Accused had in his room. The Accused alleged that in the course of their conversation, the Complainant said that the Accused was “really cool” and that he “really likes” the Accused. The Accused then reciprocated by telling the Complainant: “Cool, as I really like you”.
- [86]
[86] Subsequently, the Complainant said that “he wanted to sleep”. The Accused responded by telling the Complainant “no, let’s chat more” because they were “having a good conversation”. The Complainant replied “no, let’s chat tomorrow morning over breakfast” to which the Accused replied “okay. But then let’s chat more. Let’s have breakfast, but then let’s chat more”. At this point, the Complainant “leaned his arm against the wall because he was already seated next to the wall”.
- [87]
[87] According to the Accused, the following sequence of events then took place. First, he touched the Complainant’s left thigh using his right hand. He claimed that this was done with consent because the Complainant “did not push [him] away or brush [him] away”: the Complainant’s eyes were “still opened that time” and he maintained “eye contact” with the Accused. Thereafter, the Accused tried “to insert [his] hand inside [the Complainant’s] pants”; and when he found that he could not do so “because it was really tight”, the Complainant “shifted his body towards the ceiling” “so that [the Accused] could actually reach and unbutton his pants, unbuckle his belt and unzip him”. In fact, according to the Accused, the Complainant shifted his buttocks so that the Accused “could pull down his pants and underwear towards his mid-thigh”. The Accused claimed that all this while, the Complainant remained “conscious” and “awake”, and he “did not push away [the Accused’s] hands”. Thereafter, as the Accused noticed that the Complainant was slowly getting an erection, he started to masturbate the Complainant; and then, when the latter’s penis “was hard”, he proceeded to suck his penis.
- [88]
[88] At this point, per the Accused’s testimony, the Complainant “was still awake, conscious and he did not push [the Accused’s] hands away or brush [the Accused’s] hands away”. The Accused also claimed that while he was sucking on the Complainant’s penis, the expression on the Complainant’s face showed that “he was actually having an arousal because of his eyes [sic] were half-closed”. The Accused looked at the Complainant while fellating him and then kissed him before continuing to fellate him. He also unbuttoned the Complainant’s shirt while fellating him. In his evidence-in-chief, the Accused tendered a sketch plan to show his and the Complainant’s alleged positions at the material time : according to the Accused, he remained on the Complainant’s left side as the room was “really tiny” and there was “no space to manoeuvre anything at all”.
- [89]
[89] In the second half of his evidence-in-chief, the Accused added a number of other details in relation to his account of the alleged sexual encounter. According to the Accused, it was during this second round of oral sex that the Complainant touched the Accused’s penis (from outside his shorts); and the Accused responded to the touch by removing his shorts while continuing to fellate the Complainant. The Accused also testified that while he was pulling the Complainant’s jeans and briefs down to mid-thigh, his hands “brushed” the cheeks of the Complainant’s buttocks.
- [90]
[90] After about 10 minutes, while the Accused was still fellating the Complainant, the latter “suddenly” stood up “out of the blue”, pulled on his pants and underwear (which were then at mid-thigh), and left the room. The Accused heard the sliding door of the toilet next to his room being opened and closed. He believed that the Complainant was masturbating in the toilet because he “was fully erected when he actually stood up”; he stayed in the toilet “for some time, without “any water spraying or anything like that in the toilet”. Thereafter, the Accused heard the main door of the apartment shut with “a bang”; and he assumed that it meant the Complainant had left. The Accused said he believed that the Complainant left because he knew he would otherwise “need” to “have sex” with the Accused, and “he changed his mind”.
- [91]
[91] Following the Complainant’s departure, the Accused went back to sleep. He was woken up sometime later in the morning of 9 August 2017 by the police calling him on his mobile phone and telling him that the Complainant had made a police report against him. He then opened the main door, whereupon “a battalion” of police officers – who included Mr Tho – entered the apartment. The Accused recalled feeling “really, really frightened” because in the Philippines where he had grown up, the police “is not really on the good side” and did “bad things to people” such as torturing them, beating them and subjecting them to verbal abuse. The Accused claimed that he was so frightened that he “was really shivering”, and this led Mr Tho to remark that he “must have done something wrong”.
- [92]
[92] The Accused was subsequently escorted to Police Cantonment Complex; and on 10 August 2017 at about 3.25 PM, Mr Tho recorded a statement from the Accused. This was tendered as a defence exhibit at trial. It should be noted that although it was the Accused who adduced this statement in support of his defence and although he agreed in evidence-in-chief that the statement was “voluntarily given”, he also claimed that it was “not recorded accurately”. In the course of his testimony, it also transpired that what he was seeking to do was to disavow certain portions of the statement on the ground that he had not actually said the things recorded in those portions and/or that he had phrased certain things in a different manner from that recorded; further, that the IO Mr Tho had either told him “[i]t’s ok” or had declined to amend the alleged inaccuracies when the Accused tried to point them out; and that he had acquiesced to these inaccuracies remaining in his statement out of fear.
- [93]
[93] In their reply submissions, the Defence produced a table summarising the Accused’s evidence on the inaccuracies in the statement of 10 August 2017. This table is substantially reproduced below:
What was recorded in D2
What the Accused meant
What Mr Tho said to the Accused
“I was almost gone by then…”
I was a little bit tipsy, a little bit drunk.
“It’s okay”.
“I was drunk and high”.
I was drunk and tipsy.
“It’s okay. Just leave it.”
“He was almost lying flat…”
He was, like, sitting.
“Impossible”.
“I think he was conscious…”
I know he was conscious that time because we were just talking.
“Leave it”.
“However, I did use my left fingers to touch his anus…”
“ănus” with a short ‘a’ which in the Philippines, refers to the butt cheek.
“Leave it, it’s okay. I understand what you mean.”
“I could not recall whether I inserted my fingers into his anus”.
I did not actually insert my fingers in the anus.
“It’s okay, I understand what you mean.”
“…and I was arrested”.
I was taken by the police.
-
“We were both quite high on alcohol.”
We were both moderately high on alcohol.
-
“…and touched his anus”.
“ănus” with a short ‘a’, which in the Philippines refers to the butt cheek.
-
“I really don’t know whether I put my fingers into his anus or not”.
The Accused wanted to remove this from his statement.
“Leave it. It’s okay”.
- [94]
[94] The Accused gave evidence that the fear which led him to acquiesce to the alleged inaccuracies remaining in his statement came about because of the following reasons. First, according to the Accused, prior to Mr Tho recording his statement, he was verbally “interrogated” by another officer (later identified as one ASP Vimala Raj (“ASP Raj”) without anyone else being present in the interview room. The Accused claimed that ASP Raj questioned him about how he had pulled down the Complainant’s pants as well as the Complainant’s position at the relevant time. The Accused also claimed that ASP Raj told him that the Complainant’s family was “wealthy”, and that the Complainant’s father was “loaded, super loaded”. This made the Accused “really more scared” because police officers “back in [his] hometown” were “really corrupt”; and he had the thought “that this police officer…might do something to [him] and because of the power of the wealth, then [he] can’t do anything anymore to protect [himself]”.
- [95]
[95] In cross-examination, the Accused added two other allegations against ASP Raj. He said that ASP Raj had also told him he “likes President Duterte”, and that he felt “more scared” upon hearing this, because “at that time, President Duterte was killing people”, and “a lot of things were going inside [his] mind” about who would take care of his parents if he “was going to die here”. Further, the Accused claimed that when he told ASP Raj “I thought he was willing” (referring to the Complainant being willing to engage in sexual activity), ASP Raj “was angry” and repeated the words “you thought” several times in a “raised” voice. This again made the Accused “scared” and caused the words “I thought he was willing” to be “stuck in [his] mind”, such that he subsequently repeated the words “I thought he was willing” to Mr Tho when he had actually intended only to say “He was willing”.
- [96]
[96] According to the Accused, after the “interrogation” by ASP Raj, he was so “scared that he “could not really focus anymore” during the recording of his statement, and he “was just almost agreeing to everything that [Mr Tho] was telling [him]”. Additionally, the Accused said he was “really, really scared” during the recording of his statement because Mr Tho spoke to him in a raised voice and an “angry tone”. He felt that Mr Tho was “trying to coach [him], trying to tell [him] the words to say and [he] just said ‘Yes, okay’” because he was “really, really scared”; he “had nobody”; he was “just thinking that [he did] not want to be beaten up”; and he was “shivering” with fear “whenever [Mr Tho] was in front of [him]”. Thus, for example, although he had initially told Mr Tho that the Complainant was in a “sitting” position when he took off the Complainant’s pants, he did not try to correct Mr Tho when the latter first remarked that this was “impossible” and then told him that the Complainant had said he was “lying down flat”.
- [97]
[97] In respect of paragraph 15 of his statement, where he had stated that he “could not recall whether [he] inserted [his] fingers into [the Complainant’s] anus” but that he “did use [his] left fingers to touch [the Complainant’s] anus while sucking his penis”, the Accused asserted that as far as he was concerned, the word “anus” – as used in his statement – bore two different meanings. According to the Accused, when he was “growing up”, the word “anus” was used to refer to the “whole butt”. When he told Mr Tho that he “could not recall whether [he] inserted [his] fingers into [the Complainant’s] anus”, he had used the word “anus” to mean “the hole, the anus with the hole”. However, when he told Mr Tho that he “did use [his] left fingers to touch [the Complainant’s] anus while sucking his penis”, he had used the word “anus” to mean the cheeks of the buttocks. The Accused claimed that after having told Mr Tho that he “did use [his] left fingers to touch [the Complainant’s] anus while sucking his penis”, he asked Mr Tho to change the word “anus” in that sentence to “cheeks of the buttocks”, but his request was denied by the latter who said “Leave it, it’s okay, I understand what you mean”. In cross-examination, the Accused agreed that he had not explained to Mr Tho that as far as he was concerned, there were two different meanings which could be ascribed to the word “anus”. He said this was because at that moment, he had been “really, really scared, and....was not really thinking straight anymore”.
- [98]
[98] In cross-examination, the Accused also alleged that before he signed his statement on 10 August 2017, Mr Tho had informed him that if he did not sign the statement, he “won’t be released from the lock-up”.
- [99]
[99] As the Accused’s allegations against Mr Tho and ASP Raj were disclosed only during his testimony, the Prosecution applied for leave to recall Mr Tho and to call ASP Raj as rebuttal witnesses. The Defence did not object; and I granted the application. I summarise these two witnesses’ rebuttal evidence below at [111] to [117].
Dr Lim Yun Chin (“Dr Lim”)
- [100]
[100] Dr Lim of Raffles Hospital Psychiatric Department was disclosed as a defence witness only on 27 September 2022. The Defence informed that they were calling Dr Lim as an expert witness; and his report dated 4 October 2022 was served shortly before the second tranche of the trial.
- [101]
[101] Although in his report Dr Lim stated that he had conducted a mental state evaluation of the Accused on four separate occasions and although he set out the Accused’s personal history and version of events, defence counsel’s examination-in-chief of Dr Lim revealed that the real purpose of calling Dr Lim was to adduce his opinion on Dr Lambert Low’s report about the Complainant’s state of intoxication between 4.15am and 5.30am on 9 August 2017. It is this evidence that I outline below. In this connection, in preparing his report, Dr Lim had regard to the following (inter alia):
(a) A screenshot of the Grab receipt for the ride from Hero’s pub to the Accused’s home, dated 9 August 2017;
(b) CCTV video footage of the Accused’s lift lobby on the ground floor timestamped as 04:01:44 on 9 August 2017;
(c) Video footage of the Accused’s lift lobby on ground floor timestamped as 05:39:46 on 9 August 2017;
(d) An audio recording of telephone call made by Complainant to the police and the transcript of the recording;
(e) Dr Lambert Low’s report dated 7 August 2018; and
(f) Dr Cornelia Chee’s report dated 22 January 2019.
- [102]
[102] In his evidence-in-chief, Dr Lim confirmed he had “no difficulty in accepting” Dr Low’s calculation of the Complainant’s estimated BAC level at the time of the incident, because there was “only one formula” that would be used by “all” experts. In Dr Lim’s report, he referred to a table which set out nine different levels of “BAC percent” and stated that based on the BAC level calculated by Dr Low (between 171.25mg/100ml and 215mg/100ml at 4.15am and between 152.5mg/100ml and 190mg/100ml at 5.30am), the Complainant would have been within the range of 0.16 to 0.20 BAC percent shown in the table. This table also purported to describe the “[e]ffects of increased BAC levels on a typical person” for each level of “BAC percent”. According to this table, the effects of 0.16 to 0.20 BAC percent on a “typical person” would include the following: “Dysphoria predominates, nausea may appear, drinker has the appearance of ‘sloppy drunk’.
- [103]
[103] When asked to clarify the source of the table in his report, Dr Lim said that he had downloaded it from the Internet – apparently from the website of an “educational institution” in the United States. However, he was unable to say which particular educational institution it was.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.