Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 24 Feb 2023

General Division of the High Court

Ng Hong Khiang v Wu Cuiyun

Feedback & support

[2023] SGHC 45Case no. Originating Application No 221 of 202213 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. The facts

  3. The parties’ relationship

  4. [4] The Applicant and the Respondent first became acquainted in 2010. At that time, the Respondent was working for the Applicant at a KTV Lounge. They entered into a romantic relationship in or about 2011. The Applicant was married at that time and the Respondent knew that the Applicant was married. The Respondent was also married at that time. Later, she and her husband divorced.

  5. The purchase of the Property in 2014

  6. [5] In 2014, the Applicant and the Respondent agreed to purchase the Property. The purchase price was S$838,888.00. The Respondent exercised the Option to Purchase in respect of the Property in September 2014 and instructed M/s PKWA Law Practice LLC (“PKWA”) to act for her in the purchase.

  7. The parties’ cases

  8. The Applicant’s case

  9. [8] The Applicant claims that the parties had entered into an oral agreement before the purchase of the Property. According to the Applicant, the terms of the purported oral agreement are as follows:

  10. (a) The Applicant and Respondent would each contribute monies to invest in the Property.

  11. (b) The Respondent would obtain a loan to fund her contribution towards the purchase of the Property by way of a mortgage in her name secured on the Property.

  12. (c) The Applicant would fund the cash component of the purchase price of the Property and pay all applicable stamp duties and legal costs associated with the purchase of the Property. The Applicant would also pay the maintenance fees in respect of the Property after the completion of the purchase of the Property.

  13. (d) The Property would be sold upon either party’s request, with the sale proceeds divided in the proportion of each party’s contributions towards the purchase price and costs of the Property.

  14. The Respondent’s case

  15. (a) First, the Respondent claims that she gave S$130,000.00 to the Applicant on 4 November 2014 by way of a cheque for S$50,000.00 and another cheque for S$80,000.00. The Respondent asserts that these amounts which she gave to the Applicant were used towards the purchase price and costs of the Property.

  16. (b) Second, the Respondent claims that she made two other payments totalling S$4,000.00 towards the purchase price and costs of the Property to PKWA. These payments were made by way of a cheque for S$3,000.00 and another cheque for S$1,000.00.

  17. Issues to be determined

  18. [14] The Court has to consider the following issues:

  19. (a) First, whether the Applicant’s contribution towards the purchase price and costs of the Property was part of an oral agreement between the parties that each party would be entitled to the sale proceeds according to the parties’ contributions should the Property be sold or whether the Applicant’s contribution towards the purchase of the Property was a gift to the Respondent.

  20. (b) Second, if the Applicant’s contribution towards the purchase price and costs of the Property was part of an oral agreement between the parties, what were the respective contributions of the parties towards the purchase price and costs of the Property.

  21. My decision

  22. Whether the Applicant’s contribution towards the purchase price and costs of the Property was pursuant to an oral agreement as described by the Applicant or was the Applicant’s contribution a gift to the Respondent

  23. [16] The Applicant played an active role in the purchase of the Property. He engaged a property agent to facilitate the viewing of different condominiums. The Applicant shortlisted the properties to be viewed. He assisted the Respondent to obtain the loan of S$630,000.00 under her name through a banker whom he knew at Standard Chartered Bank. In the Respondent’s words, the Applicant “handled all the matters because [the Respondent] did not know how to handle them”.

  24. [18] First, the Respondent said the Applicant’s contribution was a gift in her affidavit. However, when the Respondent was questioned by the counsel for the Applicant, the Respondent also referred to the Applicant’s contribution as a “dowry”:

  25. [20] Second, I refer to the WeChat messages between the Applicant and the Respondent in February 2022. When the Applicant first suggested to the Respondent to sell the Property after the breakdown of their relationship, her responses focused on: (a) the length of time she had been staying in the Property, (b) the fact that the Applicant had supposedly told her that the Property would be treated as her “dowry” if the Respondent were to really marry someone one day, and (c) that the Respondent had spent the prime years of her life with the Applicant.

  26. What were the respective contributions of the parties towards the purchase price and costs of the Property?

  27. (a) Whether the amount of S$130,000.00 given by the Respondent to the Applicant by way of two cheques should be taken as the Respondent’s contribution towards the purchase price and costs of the Property.

  28. (b) Whether the cheque payments totalling S$4,000.00 made by the Respondent to PKWA, the lawyers who did the conveyance, should be considered in favour of the Respondent in assessing the parties’ contributions towards the purchase price and costs of the Property.

  29. [28] The Applicant alleges that the S$130,000.00 given to him by the Respondent was actually his money that he gave to the Respondent for safekeeping in the course of their relationship. The Applicant claims that sometime from the early or middle of 2012 to the end of 2013, the Applicant had given the Respondent about S$5,000.00 in cash each month for safekeeping. This was done to conceal his income from his wife and to set aside money for himself in the event he wished to make large purchases or investments. Thus, when the Respondent issued two cheques totalling S$130,000.00 to the Applicant, she was just returning his money which she had been safekeeping for the Applicant.

  30. [29] However, as was pointed out to the Applicant during his cross-examination, even by his account that he gave the Respondent S$5,000.00 each month from early 2012 to December 2013 for safekeeping, this did not add up to the amount of S$130,000.00 which was given back by the Respondent to the Applicant. Based on the Applicant’s account, the amount of money he would have given the Respondent for safekeeping from early 2012 to December 2013 would have only been in the range of S$90,000.00 to S$110,000.00, ie, S$5,000.00 per month x 18 to 22 months (depending on the timeframe during which the Applicant gave the Respondent his money for safekeeping). Further, the Applicant’s account at the hearing is inconsistent with his account in his affidavit dated 14 October 2022. In his affidavit dated 14 October 2022, the Applicant alleged that he gave the Respondent S$5,000.00 each month from the middle of 2012 to October 2014, ie, a period of about 29 months. Based on his account, the Applicant would have given the Respondent a sum of about S$145,000.00, ie, S$5,000.00 per month x 29 months. Therefore, there is a serious material discrepancy in the Applicant’s evidence regarding the S$5,000.00 which he allegedly gave to the Respondent every month for safekeeping. Hence, I find it difficult to believe this aspect of the Applicant’s evidence.

  31. [31] The Respondent denied that the Applicant had given her S$5,000.00 per month for safekeeping. Why did the Applicant give the S$5,000.00 per month to the Respondent for safekeeping? He could have put this monthly payment in a bank account for safekeeping without his wife’s knowledge. Why did he give this monthly sum of S$5,000.00 to the Respondent for safekeeping, as alleged, for a short period of time only? This allegation of giving the Respondent S$5,000.00 per month for safekeeping is unbelievable.

  32. [35] I shall now consider the analytical framework set out by the Court of Appeal in Chan Yuen Lan v See Fong Mun [2014] 3 SLR 1048 (“Chan Yuen Lan”).

  33. Analysing the present case under the analytical framework in Chan Yuen Lan

  34. [36] In Chan Yuen Lan (at [160]), the Court of Appeal set out an analytical framework to be applied in a property dispute involving parties who have contributed unequal amounts towards the purchase price of a property and who have not executed a declaration of trust as to how the beneficial interests in the property are to be apportioned. As set out in Chan Yuen Lan (at [160]), the steps under this framework are as follows:

  35. [41] Finally, at step (f), there was no express or inferred common intention that the Applicant and the Respondent should hold the beneficial interests differently from the proportions in which the beneficial interests were held at the time of acquisition of the Property.

  36. Conclusion