General Division of the High Court · Decided 31 March 2023
Liang Xihong v Loong Soo Min and another and another suit
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC 80 · Case no. Suit No 275 of 2020
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [2]
[2] The division of matrimonial assets in the divorce proceedings left Sandy’s and Sam’s respective 50% shareholdings in a company known as Yangbum Engineering Pte Ltd (“Yangbum”) intact. It also did not deal with Sandy’s shares in three other companies: Ace Class Precision Engineering Pte Ltd (“Ace Class”), Apex Precision Engineering Pte Ltd (“Apex Precision”) and Qing Lian Precision Pte Ltd (“QL Precision”). In this judgment, I shall refer to these three companies collectively as the “Three Companies”. The Three Companies were subcontractors to Yangbum exclusively. Yangbum and the Three Companies are the subject-matter of these proceedings.
- [4]
[4] HC/S 345 of 2020 (“S 345”) is Sam’s claim against Sandy, her current husband, Mr Zhang Shengqiang (“Zhang”), and the Three Companies. Sam claims that Sandy holds her shares in the Three Companies on trust for him and that Sandy has acted in breach of trust. Sam also claims that Zhang dishonestly assisted Sandy in her breaches of trust and that both Sandy and Zhang conspired to injure him. Finally, Sam claims that Sandy wrongfully withdrew S$188,000 from their joint account. The Three Companies are nominal defendants in S 345.
- [5]
[5] S 275 and S 345 were heard together.
Background facts
- [6]
[6] Prior to 1992, Sam worked for two different companies that were involved in precision metal machining and machine tools. In July 1992, Sam started a partnership known as Yangbum Industrial Services (“YIS”) with another partner. YIS’ core business was in precision metal machining component manufacturing.
- [7]
[7] Sandy was a Chinese national who had come to Singapore as a student in 1992. In 1993, Sam met Sandy and started dating her. In September/October 1993, Sandy returned to China. Sam continued to court her.
- [8]
[8] In May 1994, YIS was dissolved. On 21 June 1994, Sam registered a sole proprietorship known as Yangbum Engineering (“YE”). YE was in the business of manufacturing fabricated metal products, excluding machinery and equipment.
- [9]
[9] In June 1994, Sandy returned to Singapore on a social visit pass sponsored by Sam and on 27 July 1994, Sam and Sandy were married. About three months later, Sandy became a Singapore permanent resident.
- [10]
[10] On 19 June 1997, Sam incorporated Yangbum, with Sandy and him as equal shareholders, and directors. Yangbum obtained banking facilities from Focal Finance Ltd and Oversea-Chinese Banking Corporation Limited and used these facilities to purchase machines for production. Sam was the sole guarantor for the banking facilities.
- [11]
[11] On 15 September 2005, Sandy resigned as a director of Yangbum. Sam has been the sole director of Yangbum ever since. The reason for Sandy’s resignation is in dispute.
- [12]
[12] In 2008, Sam incorporated four companies. Ace Class and Apex Precision were incorporated on the same day. Ken Precision Pte Ltd (“Ken Precision”) was incorporated some four weeks later, followed by QL Precision a little over two months after that.
(a) Ace Class and Apex Precision were incorporated on 1 July 2008. Sandy was and remains the sole shareholder in these companies. An employee of Yangbum, Mr Tan Boon Hwa, was appointed as the sole director of Ace Class. Another employee of Yangbum, Mr Hay Chiak Buang, was appointed as the sole director of Apex Precision.
(b) Ken Precision was incorporated on 28 July 2008, with Sandy’s brother, Mr Liang Jian, as the sole shareholder and sole director.
(c) QL Precision was incorporated on 8 October 2008, with Sandy’s cousin, Ms Liang Qing Lian (“LQL”), as the sole shareholder. Sandy and LQL were appointed as directors of QL Precision.
All four companies acted as subcontractors to Yangbum. The circumstances leading to the incorporation of these companies are in dispute.
- [13]
[13] On 5 October 2009, LQL resigned as director of QL Precision and transferred her shares in the company to Sandy. An employee of Yangbum, Mr Toh Thian Hock (“Clarence Toh”), replaced LQL as director of QL Precision.
- [14]
[14] In July 2009, Sandy brought the children to Beijing and enrolled them in an international school. Whilst in China, Sandy met Zhang (a traditional Chinese medicine practitioner) in late 2009 when she went to see him for treatment.
- [15]
[15] On 9 November 2009, Sandy ceased to be a director of QL Precision, leaving Clarence Toh as the sole director.
- [16]
[16] On 7 January 2010, Art 87 of Yangbum’s Articles of Association was amended to authorise a sole director to sign cheques (among other things). Before the amendment, Art 87 required the signatures of two directors.
- [17]
[17] On 19 February 2010, one Ms Ooi Tin (“Ooi”) was appointed as a second director of Ken Precision, the other director being Liang Jian (see [12(b)] above).
- [18]
[18] Sandy returned to Singapore in 2013. After her return, Sandy was sick and Zhang visited her in Singapore frequently to take care of her and also because one of her two sons had “some form of [attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder]”.
- [19]
[19] Sandy and Zhang started having an affair in 2013 although it is not clear when exactly the affair started. In late 2013, Sandy asked Sam for a divorce.
- [20]
[20] On 3 April 2014, Sam and Sandy entered into a Deed of Settlement relating to their divorce, division of assets and maintenance. With respect to the division of matrimonial assets, Sam agreed (a) to pay Sandy S$9.3m as her share of the matrimonial assets, (b) that they would retain their respective shareholdings in Yangbum, (c) that they would retain their respective shares in a company called “Walton”, and (d) that Sandy could retain all assets in her name that were held in China. Sandy acknowledged that she had received S$1.9m as at the date of the Deed of Settlement. The Deed of Settlement did not deal with the shares in the Three Companies and Ken Precision.
- [21]
[21] On 15 May 2014, Sandy commenced divorce proceedings against Sam in FC/D 2222 of 2014 (“D 2222”) on the ground of unreasonable behaviour (as agreed in the Deed of Settlement). The Statement of Particulars cited constant quarrels caused by Sam’s behaviour in neglecting Sandy and stated that Sam was mostly absorbed in his work, returned home late, kept to himself and ignored her.
- [22]
[22] On 10 July 2014, interim judgment was entered in D 2222 (the “IJ”). Paragraph 3 of the IJ set out the orders made by consent, which were mostly in line with the terms of the Deed of Settlement. With respect to Sam’s obligation to pay Sandy S$9.3m, the IJ acknowledged that S$3.7m “has already been paid” and the balance sum of S$5.6m will be paid within two years from 3 April 2014.
- [23]
[23] Like the Deed of Settlement, the IJ did not deal with the shares in the Three Companies and Ken Precision. The decision to leave the shareholdings in Yangbum intact and the omission to deal with the shares in the Three Companies and Ken Precision became the seeds from which the present disputes sprouted.
- [24]
[24] On 28 October 2014, the IJ was made final. Sandy denied that she asked Sam for a divorce because she was having an affair with Zhang and wanted to marry him. However, the fact remains that she married Zhang on 1 April 2015, some five months after the IJ was made final.
- [25]
[25] On 7 December 2016, Sam incorporated two more companies – TL Precision Pte Ltd (“TL Precision”) and SH Precision Pte Ltd (“SH Precision”). TL Precision was named after Mr Lim Thiam Leong who was appointed as the sole director whilst SH Precision was named after Mr Tan Soo Huat who was also appointed as the sole director; both were employees of Yangbum. Both companies also acted as subcontractors to Yangbum. Sandy was the sole shareholder in both companies. Sandy does not claim beneficial ownership of the shares in TL Precision and SH Precision.
- [26]
[26] On 14 April 2018, Sandy sent a text message to Sam requesting a loan of S$1m from Yangbum to purchase a property. Sam procured Yangbum and Ken Precision to make loans of S$800,000 (the “Yangbum Loan”) and S$200,000 (the “Ken Precision Loan”) respectively to Sandy; both loans were disbursed on 7 May 2018.
- [27]
[27] On 31 October 2018, Sandy asked Sam to have the shares in “the few small companies held in [her] name” transferred to another shareholder; alternatively, Sandy suggested closing them down. At this time, Sandy was the sole shareholder of the Three Companies, TL Precision and SH Precision. Sandy also asked Sam to “close [Ken Precision] first”; Liang Jian was still the sole shareholder of Ken Precision. Sam did not object to Sandy’s requests. The reasons for Sandy’s requests are in dispute.
- [28]
[28] On the same day, 31 October 2018, Liang Jian transferred his shares in Ken Precision to Sam. Liang Jian also resigned as director, leaving Ooi (see [17] above) as the remaining sole director.
- [29]
[29] On 1 November 2018, Sandy transferred her shares in TL Precision and SH Precision to Sam. That left Sandy holding the shares in the Three Companies. The shares in the Three Companies were not transferred because these companies would lose certain benefits that they had under the Productivity and Innovation Credit Scheme (“PIC Scheme”) in the event of a transfer of more than 50% of the share capital.
- [30]
[30] Between 20 February and 13 March 2019, Sandy corresponded with Mr Lai Fatt (“Lai”), who was in charge of managing Yangbum’s store. Sandy wanted to retrieve financial and accounting records of Yangbum, the Three Companies and Ken Precision.
- [31]
[31] On 19 March 2019, Lai sent Sandy a photo of 11 boxes of documents. On 21 March 2019, Sandy informed one of Yangbum’s finance staff, Ms Yang Xiaoman (“Xiaoman”), that she had collected “3 files”.
- [32]
[32] On 22 March 2019 (which was a Friday), Sandy went to Yangbum’s store to take documents belonging to Yangbum, the Three Companies and Ken Precision. Xiaoman informed Sam that Sandy was removing documents from Yangbum. On Monday, 25 March 2019, Sam told Xiaoman that documents should not be removed from Yangbum’s premises. Sandy was asked to return the boxes of documents taken by her and she did so between 26 and 27 March 2019.
- [33]
[33] Before October 2019, the mandates for the bank accounts operated by Yangbum, the Three Companies, Ken Precision, TL Precision and SH Precision were not consistent. Sandy was not an authorised signatory for all the accounts and where she was an authorised signatory, the threshold levels beyond which her signature would be required were also not consistent. Between mid-October 2019 and January 2020, changes were made to the mandates at Sandy’s request. The effect of the changes was that Sandy became an authorised signatory for all the accounts and her signature/approval was required for all transactions involving S$20,000 or more (in the currency of each of the accounts).
- [34]
[34] In November 2019, Sandy sought advice from her tarot master on the strategy for the legal campaign that she was about to commence against Sam; her objective was to sell her shares in Yangbum or force Sam to buy her out at between S$25m and S$35m.
- [35]
[35] In 2020, both Sandy and Sam began firing salvoes at each other, which escalated and led inevitably to the present proceedings.
- [36]
[36] On 24 February 2020, Sandy withdrew S$188,000 (the “S$188,000 Withdrawal”) from a joint account with Overseas-Chinese Banking Corporation Limited in the names of Sam and herself (the “OCBC Joint Account”), leaving a balance of just a little over S$550.
- [38]
[38] On 25 February 2020, on Sam’s instructions, Yangbum’s accounts executive, Ms Long Soo Hsien (“Soo Hsien”), prepared the following cheques and payment vouchers:
(a) UOB 136068 for S$1m payable to Sam; the corresponding payment voucher described this as dividends payable to Sam;
(b) UOB 136069 for S$500,000 payable to Sam; the corresponding payment voucher described this as dividends payable to Sam;
(c) UOB 136071 for S$476,000 payable to Sam; the corresponding payment voucher described this as dividends payable to Sam; and
(d) a payment voucher which stated that dividends of S$1m and S$188,000 were payable to Sandy but were to be set-off against the loans from Yangbum and Ken Precision and the S$188,000 Withdrawal.
Sam signed the cheques and payment vouchers.
- [39]
[39] On the same day (25 February 2020), Sandy issued a Statutory Demand against Sam for purported non-payment of the sum of S$5.6m under the IJ plus interest. Sam subsequently succeeded in setting aside the Statutory Demand on the ground that the debt was disputed on substantial grounds.
- [40]
[40] On 26 February 2020, Soo Hsien asked Sandy to go to Yangbum’s office to sign the cheques and payment vouchers relating to the dividends and set-offs mentioned in [38] above. On Sandy’s request, Soo Hsien sent copies of the cheques and payment vouchers to Sandy. Sandy refused to sign the cheques or to acknowledge the proposed set-offs.
- [41]
[41] Between 27 February and 8 March 2020, Sam (as the sole director of Yangbum) removed Sandy as an alternate or joint signatory to Yangbum’s bank accounts.
- [42]
[42] On 2 March 2020, Sandy filed MSS 719/2020 (“MSS 719”) to enforce payment of S$1,693,276 being alleged arrears of maintenance for the children under the IJ. MSS 719 was subsequently struck off.
- [43]
[43] On the same day (2 March 2020), Sandy’s lawyers issued letters to UOB, CIMB, SCB and OCBC alleging that Sam had forged Sandy’s signatures on cheques drawn on Yangbum’s accounts with the banks, and that Sam may have diverted dividends (issued to Sandy) to himself or caused Yangbum’s records to be falsified to create the impression that the dividends were paid to Sandy.
- [44]
[44] On 12 March 2020, Sandy appointed Zhang and herself as directors of the Three Companies. It is not disputed that this was done without the knowledge of Sam or the other directors of the companies.
- [45]
[45] On 18 March 2020, Sandy turned up at Yangbum’s office, accompanied by four men, and demanded the financial records of the Three Companies. Sam told her that she was not entitled to the documents and asked her to leave. Sandy and the men left without the documents.
- [46]
[46] On 20 March 2020, Sandy issued notices of directors’ meetings of the Three Companies to be held on 27 March 2020 to (among other things) convene Extraordinary General Meetings (“EGMs”) for each of the companies for the purpose of passing special resolutions to wind up the companies.
- [47]
[47] On 25 March 2020, Sandy commenced S 275.
- [48]
[48] On 27 March 2020, the directors’ meetings of the Three Companies were held with Sandy and Zhang in attendance; the resolutions to convene EGMs to wind up the companies were passed.
- [49]
[49] On 30 March 2020, the EGMs of the Three Companies were held (with Sandy consenting to the holding of the EGMs without full notice) and the requisite resolutions to wind up the companies were passed.
- [50]
[50] On 13 April 2020, Sam commenced S 345.
- [51]
[51] On 2 June 2020, Yangbum demanded repayment of the Yangbum Loan and Ken Precision demanded repayment of the Ken Precision Loan. Sandy did not make any repayment.
- [52]
[52] On 26 June 2020, Yangbum commenced HC/S 567/2020 (“S 567”) against Sandy for repayment of the Yangbum Loan. On the same day, Ken Precision commenced DC/DC 1500/2020 (“DC 1500”) against Sandy for repayment of the Ken Precision Loan.
- [53]
[53] In S 567, Sandy’s defence pleaded that in mid-April 2018, Sam and Sandy agreed that she would repay the Yangbum Loan by applying a portion of her share of future shareholder dividends disbursed to her until the loan was fully repaid (the “Repayment Agreement”).
- [54]
[54] On 30 June 2020, Sam filed FC/SUM 1731/2020 (amended on 24 May 2021) (“FC/SUM 1731”) in D 2222, seeking, among other things, to set aside the entire para 3 of the IJ.
- [56]
[56] On 17 September 2020, Yangbum applied for summary judgment in respect of the Yangbum Loan in S 567. On 10 November 2020, the Assistant Registrar granted Yangbum’s application and entered judgment against Sandy (the “O 14 Judgment”). On 8 January 2021, the High Court dismissed Sandy’s appeal against the O 14 Judgment. On 16 February 2021, Sandy paid the Yangbum Loan.
- [57]
[57] On 3 December 2021, the Family Court:
(a) set aside para 3 of the IJ in its entirety on the grounds that Sandy had failed to disclose a material fact to Sam; and
(b) made no orders on FC/SUM 550 since it was predicated upon the continued existence of para 3 of the IJ.
Sandy has appealed against the decision and the appeal is pending. For present purposes, the Family Court’s reasons for setting aside para 3 of the IJ are not relevant.
Parties’ cases in S 275
- [58]
[58] In her closing submissions, Sandy alleges that Sam engaged in the following acts of oppression and/or unfair discrimination and/or unfair prejudice:
(a) Sam diverted to himself dividends issued by Yangbum to her by way of eight cheques amounting to a total of US$922,052.47, and falsified Yangbum’s payment vouchers to create the impression that the dividends were paid to Sandy.
(b) Sam forged her signature on at least 49 cheques issued by Yangbum to various payees; the total amount of these cheques was S$3,044,863.80.
(c) Sam caused Yangbum to attempt to issue more dividends to himself than to her in 2020 and to apply improper set-offs against her declared dividends.
(d) Sam removed her as a joint signatory of Yangbum’s bank accounts in breach of her legitimate expectations as a quasi-partner.
- [59]
[59] Sam’s case is as follows:
(a) He did not divert Sandy’s dividends to himself. Sandy’s dividends in seven of the cheques were deposited into their OCBC Joint Account, which Sandy had access to. The eighth cheque was payment towards Sam’s agreed fees for management and expenses (“M&E Fees”).
(b) He is unable to recall whether he signed all of the 49 cheques on Sandy’s behalf and thus does not admit to having done so. In any event, Sandy had agreed that Sam could sign cheques on her behalf after she moved to China with the children (the “Cheque Signing Agreement”).
(c) There was no attempt to issue unequal dividends. The difference between the amounts to be paid to Sam and Sandy reflected (i) sums that were payable to Sam as his M&E Fees and (ii) a sum equal to the S$188,000 Withdrawal. In addition, the proposed set-offs were proper.
(d) Yangbum is not a quasi-partnership and Sandy has no legitimate expectation to have joint oversight of the use of Yangbum’s funds.
Parties’ cases in S 345
- [60]
[60] In his closing submissions, Sam states his case as follows:
(a) Sandy held the shares in the Three Companies on trust for him.
(b) Sandy acted in breach of trust by:
(i) appointing Zhang and herself as directors of the Three Companies on 12 March 2020 without Sam’s consent;
(ii) calling for directors’ meetings of the Three Companies via notices issued on 19 and 20 March 2020 without Sam’s consent;
(iii) passing directors’ resolutions at the directors’ meetings of the Three Companies without Sam’s consent; and
(iv) passing special resolutions at the EGMs of the Three Companies on 30 March 2020 to put them into member’s voluntary liquidation without Sam’s consent.
(c) Zhang dishonestly assisted Sandy in her breaches of trust.
(d) Sandy and Zhang conspired to injure Sam by liquidating the Three Companies. These acts constituted breaches of trust by Sandy and were therefore unlawful. Alternatively, they were carried out with the predominant purpose to cause harm to Sam as the beneficial owner of the Three Companies.
(e) The S$188,000 Withdrawal was in breach of the IJ.
- [61]
[61] Sandy’s case is as follows:
(a) She owned the shares in the Three Companies absolutely.
(b) Even if she held the shares on trust for Sam, the trusts are illegal or tainted with illegality and hence unenforceable.
(c) Even if Sandy had committed breaches of trust, there was no dishonest assistance by Zhang.
(d) Even if the liquidations of the Three Companies were unlawful, Sandy and Zhang did not act in concert. There was also no intention to injure. In any event, there is no evidence of loss.
(e) The S$188,000 Withdrawal was not in breach of the IJ because Sam had not paid Sandy the sum of S$9.3m as required under the IJ. Further, para 3 of the IJ has been set aside and Sandy’s appeal is pending.
The issues
- [62]
[62] The issues before me are as follows:
S 275
(a) Whether Sam diverted Sandy’s dividends amounting to US$922,052.47 to himself and falsified Yangbum’s payment vouchers to create the impression that the dividends were paid to Sandy?
(b) Whether Sam forged Sandy’s signatures on at least 49 cheques issued by Yangbum to various payees in the total sum of S$3,044,863.80?
(c) Whether Sam caused Yangbum to attempt to issue disproportionate dividends in 2020 and to apply improper set-offs against Sandy’s declared dividends?
(d) Whether Yangbum is a quasi-partnership and whether Sam’s removal of Sandy as a joint signatory of Yangbum’s bank accounts was in breach of her legitimate expectations as a quasi-partner?
(e) Whether Sandy is entitled to relief under s 216 CA?
S 345
(f) Whether Sandy holds the shares in the Three Companies on trust for Sam?
(g) Whether Sandy’s actions leading to the liquidation of the Three Companies were in breach of trust?
(h) Whether Zhang dishonestly assisted Sandy in her breaches of trust?
(i) Whether Sandy and Zhang conspired to injure Sam by liquidating the Three Companies?
(j) Whether the S$188,000 Withdrawal was wrongful?
Whether Sam diverted Sandy’s dividends to himself and falsified Yangbum’s payment vouchers
- [63]
[63] Between August 2014 and March 2018, Yangbum issued the following eight cheques:
- [64]
[64] The sum of US$922,052.47, which Sandy claims Sam diverted to himself, comprises the following:
(a) US$618,196 being Sandy’s half share of the total amount of the first seven cheques; and
(b) US$303,856.47 being the amount of the eighth cheque.
The first seven cheques
- [65]
[65] It is not disputed that the first seven cheques were drawn payable to Sam and signed by Sam. The authorised signatories then were Sam and Sandy; either one was authorised to sign cheques without any limit.
- [66]
[66] It is also not disputed that the seven cheques were payments of dividends (in the total amount of US$1,236,392.00) to Sam and Sandy. This is also supported by the payment vouchers in respect of these cheques.
- [67]
[67] Sandy claims that she did not receive her half-share (US$618,196) of the dividends. Consequently, she claims that (a) Sam diverted her share of the dividends to himself, and (b) Sam falsified Yangbum’s payment vouchers to create the impression that her share of the dividends had been paid to her.
- [68]
[68] Sam’s case is that:
(a) There was no wrongful diversion of Sandy’s share of the dividends because Sandy had received the benefit of the dividends. The moneys from the seven cheques were deposited into the OCBC Joint Account and Sandy knew this. It is not disputed that Sandy had unrestricted access to the OCBC Joint Account.
(b) It follows that he did not falsify the payment vouchers.
Whether the seven cheques were deposited into the OCBC Joint Account
- [69]
[69] Sandy’s affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”) is silent as to whether she accepts that the proceeds of the first seven cheques had been deposited into the OCBC Joint Account. However, the evidence is clear that that the proceeds of the seven cheques were deposited into the OCBC Joint Account. The OCBC Joint Account statements show deposits by way of transfers from Sam which correspond to the seven cheques. The cheques, which were in US dollars and drawn payable to Sam, were paid into a US dollar joint account in Sam’s and Sandy’s names (the specific account depending on the exchange rates offered) after which Sam deposited (by way of transfers) the equivalent amounts in Singapore dollars into the OCBC Joint Account.
- [70]
[70] Under cross-examination, Sandy accepted that the moneys from the first to seventh cheques were deposited into the OCBC Joint Account.
Whether Sandy knew that the seven deposits were payments of dividends
- [71]
[71] It is not disputed that Sandy received the monthly bank statements for the OCBC Joint Account. It is also not disputed that she was aware of the seven deposits into the account. However, she claims that she did not know that the amounts deposited were payments of dividends. According to her, after her divorce from Sam, dividends were to be paid to her directly instead of being paid into the OCBC Joint Account. Sandy claims that she therefore thought that the amounts deposited into the OCBC Joint Account were not dividends but payments by Sam for maintenance for her and the children.
- [72]
[72] In my view, whether Sandy knew that the amounts deposited into the OCBC Joint Account were dividends, or whether she truly thought that they were payments for maintenance, is in fact irrelevant. It does not change the fact that her share of the dividends was deposited into the OCBC Joint Account. It is also not disputed that she had unrestricted access to the moneys in the OCBC Joint Account. In the circumstances, Sam cannot be said to have diverted Sandy’s share of the dividends to himself. It follows that Sam also did not falsify Yangbum’s payment vouchers with respect to the payments to Sandy of her share of the dividends.
- [73]
[73] I also note that based on Sandy’s own evidence, she would have used her share of the seven deposits into the OCBC Joint Account. Sandy testified that she took care to use only the portion of the funds in the OCBC Joint Account that was intended for maintenance. This would mean that she had used her share of the seven deposits since, according to her, she thought that the seven deposits were payments by Sam for maintenance.
- [74]
[74] In any event, I find that Sandy did know about the payment of dividends by way of the seven cheques and that the dividends were deposited into the OCBC Joint Account.
- [75]
[75] First, it is not disputed that Yangbum’s finance staff kept a journal that recorded dividends paid to Sam and Sandy (the “Dividends Journal”). Sandy had signed against the entries relating to the second to sixth cheques in the Dividends Journal on the same day as the date of the entries or a day later.
- [76]
[76] Sandy did not sign against the entry relating to the first cheque in the Dividends Journal. However, I find it inconceivable that she was not aware of the same. The entry was just above the entry relating to the second cheque; she could not have failed to notice it. Further, two members of Yangbum’s finance team at the material time, Xiaoman and Ms Chin Shuling (“Shuling”), testified that they would inform Sandy whenever a dividend was being issued. Xiaoman also testified that Sandy would always flip through the Dividends Journal to look at the records of past dividend payments. Shuling testified that Sandy would always look at the payment vouchers and flip through the Dividends Journal but would generally not bother signing these documents to acknowledge her receipt. Xiaoman and Shuling were objective witnesses; they were no longer working for Yangbum when they gave evidence. I find no reason to disbelieve their testimonies.
- [77]
[77] Sandy also did not sign the entry relating to the seventh cheque. Nevertheless, I find that on the totality of the evidence (including the evidence of Xiaoman and Shuling), it is more probable than not that she knew that the corresponding deposit of S$300,000 into the OCBC Joint Account on 6 January 2016 was payment of dividends for Sam and herself.
- [78]
[78] By the time she received the relevant bank statements, Sandy was clearly aware that the seven cheques had been issued as payments of dividends to Sam and herself. There was no reason for her to think that the corresponding amounts deposited into the OCBC Joint Accounts were anything other than the payments of dividends.
- [79]
[79] Second, as Sam points out, the first time that Sandy raised these issues was in S 275, which she commenced on 23 March 2020. Sandy’s case is that she discovered the diversion of dividends in 2017. Even so, that does not explain why she did not raise these issues until March 2020.
- [80]
[80] In any event, in my view, Sandy’s alleged discovery of the diversion of dividends in November 2017 is a fabrication. Sandy’s evidence about her alleged discovery was both internally and externally inconsistent.
(a) In her oral evidence, Sandy confirmed that she discovered the diversion of dividends in November 2017. However, in her AEIC, Sandy said that in March 2018, Xiaoman requested her to review Yangbum’s accounting records to investigate suspected misappropriation of funds by three Yangbum employees, and it was upon reviewing these records that she discovered the diversion of dividends by Sam. When questioned about the inconsistency as to the date that she discovered the alleged diversion of dividends, Sandy explained that the relevant paragraphs in her AEIC were referring to two different issues and were unconnected. I do not accept Sandy’s explanation. Her AEIC is patently clear: she claimed to have discovered the diversion of dividends in March 2018.
(b) Sandy also testified that the “accounting records” that she reviewed in November 2017 was a table prepared by Shuling showing the dividends paid to Sam and Sandy between April 2013 and June 2017 (the “November 2017 Dividends Table”). However, the November 2017 Dividends Table has nothing to do with the alleged misappropriation of funds that Xiaoman allegedly requested Sandy to investigate.
(c) Xiaoman denied having requested Sandy in March 2018 to review the accounts to investigate suspected misappropriation of funds by three employees. Xiaoman testified that in 2018 she had merely shared an incident regarding high tooling costs, which Sam had resolved. Xiaoman further testified that it was Sandy who, in March 2019, spread an untrue rumour that Xiaoman believed three important Yangbum employees were guilty of corruption. Xiaoman’s evidence was not challenged. I also have no reason to disbelieve her evidence.
(d) Sandy confirmed that she checked the payment of dividends in the November 2017 Dividends Table against her personal bank statements but not against the OCBC Joint Account. She claimed that she did not check against the OCBC Joint Account because the moneys in that account were for the children’s university education, and she had “enough money for daily use”. Sandy’s explanations were non-responsive. In my view, even if Sandy did not check against the OCBC Joint Account, the inference to be drawn from Sandy’s inability to explain why she did not do so is that she knew that the dividends had been paid into the OCBC Joint Account and that her alleged discovery of the diversion in 2017 is a fabrication.
- [81]
[81] Third, I agree with Sam that Sandy’s conduct showed that she knew about the payment of the dividends into the OCBC Joint Account at all material times. On 6 March 2018, Sandy told Sam that there was a discrepancy between the November 2017 Dividends Table and the Deed of Settlement. Sandy also suggested clearing up the matter before distributing the dividends for 2018. Despite having allegedly discovered the diversion of dividends in November 2017, Sandy said nothing about the alleged diversion. Instead, the next day, Sandy signed the eighth cheque (see [63] above); according to Sandy, she signed the cheque without knowing the purpose of the payment. Separately, on 14 April 2018, Sandy asked Sam for Yangbum to lend her S$1m. Although she needed money, she did not ask for payment of the dividends allegedly diverted by Sam and again made no mention of the same.
- [82]
[82] Fourth, it is unbelievable that Sandy could have thought that the amounts deposited in 2015 were for maintenance. Under the IJ, Sam was to pay S$500,000 a year as maintenance for Sandy and the children. The total amount deposited into the OCBC Joint Account in 2015 (from the third to sixth cheques) was S$850,000, which is S$350,000 more than what Sam had to pay as maintenance.
- [83]
[83] Fifth, Sandy does not dispute that she had an arrangement with Sam whereby dividends issued by Yangbum to them would be paid to Sam to be deposited into one of their joint accounts. However, she alleges that she did not think that the seven deposits into the OCBC Joint Account were payments of dividends because the arrangement had ended and her share of dividends were to be paid to her directly. Sandy alleges that the arrangement ended when her divorce became final on 30 October 2014.
- [84]
[84] Sandy’s allegation that she did not think that the seven deposits were payment of dividends because the arrangement of paying dividends into the OCBC Joint Account ended on 30 October 2014 cannot be true.
(a) It is inconsistent with her own evidence that she did not think about what the purpose of the deposit from the first cheque was. Further, the amount from the first cheque was deposited into the OCBC Joint Account on 6 August 2014, well before the arrangement allegedly ended. There was no reason for her to doubt that that deposit was a payment of dividends.
(b) Her claim that the arrangement ended on 30 October 2014 is contradicted by Sam’s evidence that the arrangement stopped after December 2015 because Sandy asked the finance team not to pay dividends into the joint account. Sam’s evidence was not challenged. It is not disputed that after 2015, dividends were paid to Sam and Sandy individually.
- [85]
[85] In any event, even if the arrangement of paying dividends into the OCBC Joint Account ended on 30 October 2014 (as Sandy alleges), it does not change the fact that the monies from the seven cheques were deposited into the account, and that Sandy knew this.
Conclusion on the first seven cheques
- [86]
[86] I find that Sandy knew at all material times that the first seven cheques were payments of dividends to Sam and herself and that the Singapore dollar equivalents of the seven cheques were deposited into the OCBC Joint Account. She also had unrestricted access to the moneys in the OCBC Joint Account. Indeed, it appears that she had access to even Sam’s share of the dividends deposited into the OCBC Joint Account.
- [87]
[87] Accordingly, I find that Sam did not divert Sandy’s share of the dividends (paid by way of the seven cheques) to himself. It follows as well that Sam did not falsify the payment vouchers or cause the payment vouchers to be falsified. In my judgment, Sandy’s allegations of diversion of dividends and falsification of payment vouchers were fabrications.
The eighth cheque
- [88]
[88] Sandy claims that Sam diverted the eighth cheque to himself because the cheque was drawn payable to Sam but the payment voucher for the cheque described the payment of US$303,856.47 as dividends payable to Sandy. It is not disputed that Sandy did not receive any part of this amount. Sandy also claims that she discovered this diversion by Sam at the same time that she discovered the diversions relating to the seven cheques discussed above.
- [89]
[89] The circumstances leading to the issuance of the eighth cheque are as follows. At an EGM held on 7 March 2018, Yangbum declared US$2.8m as dividends for FY 2017. The dividends were paid by way of four cheques, all dated 7 March 2017:
(a) Two cheques, SCB 002665 and SCB 002666, were drawn for the same amount of US$759,631.32 each; the cheques were drawn payable to Sandy and Sam respectively and the corresponding payment vouchers state that the cheques were for dividends payable to Sandy and Sam respectively.
(b) Two cheques, SCB 002668 and SCB 002669, were drawn for the same amount of US$303,856.47 each; both cheques were drawn payable to Sam but the corresponding payment vouchers state that the cheques were for dividends payable to Sandy and Sam respectively.
All four cheques were signed by Sam and Sandy. It should also be noted that three of the four payment vouchers are dated “7 March 2017”; the fourth payment voucher is dated “7 March 2018”. However, it is not disputed that the references to “2017” were in error and should refer to “2018”.
- [90]
[90] The eighth cheque, which Sandy claims was diverted by Sam, refers to SCB 022668 (see [89(b)] above). Sandy’s AEIC does not set out the circumstances leading to the issuance of the eighth cheque. She claims that she signed the eighth cheque at Sam’s request without knowing the purpose of the payment. In her closing submissions, Sandy submits that she did not agree that Sam could pay his M&E Fees by way of dividends.
- [91]
[91] Sam’s case is that:
(a) the two cheques (SCB 002668 and SCB 002669) for US$303,856.47 each were payments of his M&E Fees; and
(b) Sandy agreed to the arrangement of paying his M&E Fees by way of dividends issued to both of them.
- [92]
[92] I find that Sam has proved his case.
- [93]
[93] First, I find that the two cheques (SCB 002668 and SCB 002669) were used to pay Sam’s M&E Fees. The entries in the Dividends Journal confirm that of the four cheques issued on 7 March 2018:
(a) two cheques (SCB 022665 and SCB 022666) for US$759,631.32 each were payments of dividends to Sandy and Sam respectively; and
(b) the other two cheques (SCB 022668 and SCB 022669) for US$303,856.47 each were paid to Sam as his M&E Fees.
- [94]
[94] Sam’s case is also consistent with the payment vouchers, which show that the Singapore dollar equivalent for each cheque was S$400,000. It is not disputed that as part of their divorce settlement, Sandy agreed that Sam was entitled to payment of S$800,000 per year as his M&E Fees; this comprised a management fee of S$500,000 and entertainment expenses of S$300,000.
- [95]
[95] Second, I find that Sandy knew that the two cheques (SCB 022668 and SCB 022669) were paid to Sam as his M&E Fees and that she had accepted and agreed to the arrangement of using dividends to pay Sam’s M&E Fees. Sandy’s claim that she did not know the purpose of the eighth cheque (SCB 022668) is simply unbelievable. She signed against the entries in the Dividends Journal for all four cheques that were issued on 7 March 2018.
- [96]
[96] Quite apart from the Dividends Journal, Sandy had to have known that the eighth cheque was one of the four cheques issued pursuant to the declaration of dividends at the EGM on 7 March 2018. Sandy was present at the EGM. She also signed all the four cheques all of which were also dated 7 March 2018.
- [97]
[97] Under cross-examination, Sandy explained that the two cheques for US$303,856.47 each were not signed at the same time and that she could not recall the specific times. When questioned further, Sandy also claimed that all four cheques were signed separately. She claimed that she could not remember the sequence in which the cheques were signed except that Shuling brought the second cheque for US$303,856.47 to her house for her to sign. I do not accept Sandy’s explanation. Her explanation was not in her AEIC. Further, all four cheques were for payment of the dividends of US$2.8m that were declared at the EGM on 7 March 2018. There was no reason why the four cheques would have been signed separately and Sandy offered none.
- [98]
[98] Even if Sandy did sign the cheques separately, that still does not mean that she therefore did not know that the four cheques were issued pursuant to the declaration of dividends at the EGM.
- [99]
[99] The evidence also shows that in December 2015, Sandy had already agreed to the arrangement of using dividends to pay Sam’s M&E Fees. Back then, Yangbum had issued two cheques (SCB 933682 and SCB 933683) that were payable to Sam. The corresponding payment vouchers described SCB 933682 as payment of dividends to Sam and Sandy, and SCB 933683 as payment of dividends to Sam. In the Dividends Journal, Shuling wrote “(entertainment)” against the entry for SCB 933682, and “(director fee)” against the entry for SCB 933683. Shuling testified that this was based on what Sandy told her and that Sandy also told her that it was pursuant to her “divorce agreement” with Sam. Shuling’s evidence was not challenged.
- [100]
[100] As for Sandy’s claim that she discovered the diversion of the eighth cheque at the same time that she discovered the diversion of the first seven cheques, I have rejected that claim (see [80] above).
- [101]
[101] It is clear from the above that although the two cheques in question (SCB 002668 and SCB 002669) were issued pursuant to the declaration of dividends at the EGM on 7 March 2018, they were never intended to be paid to Sandy and Sam as dividends. Instead, they were intended to be and were paid to Sam as his M&E Fees. Sandy knew and agreed to this arrangement. Accordingly, I find that Sam did not divert the proceeds of the eighth cheque to himself.
Whether Sam forged Sandy’s signature on 49 cheques
- [102]
[102] Sandy claims that in 2018, she discovered that Sam had forged her signature on at least 49 cheques issued by Yangbum against Yangbum’s OCBC account between 2012 and 2013 (the “49 Cheques”). During this period, cheques issued against Yangbum’s OCBC account for amounts of S$20,000 or more required Sam’s and Sandy’s signatures. The cheques were issued to various business counterparties of Yangbum; Sandy accepts that the payments were made in the ordinary course of business.
- [103]
[103] Sam admitted that there were a few instances when he signed cheques (issued by Yangbum) on behalf of Sandy; however, he was unable to recollect those instances specifically and thus did not admit that all of the 49 Cheques were signed by him on Sandy’s behalf.
- [104]
[104] Sandy did not adduce any expert evidence to prove that her signatures on the 49 Cheques were forged. Nevertheless, given Sam’s admission, I proceed on the basis that Sandy’s signatures on some of the 49 Cheques (without any indication as to how many) were signed by Sam.
- [105]
[105] Sam’s case is that during the period from 2009 to 2013, when Sandy was living in China with the children, there was an understanding that he would sign cheques on behalf of Sandy if it was inconvenient for Sandy to do so. Sandy denies any such understanding.
- [106]
[106] I find that there was an understanding between Sam and Sandy that he could sign cheques on behalf of Sandy if it was inconvenient for her to do so. This understanding is consistent with the following facts:
(a) Sam held Sandy’s bank token for Yangbum’s OCBC account (against which the 49 Cheques were issued) so that he could approve payments that required the use of both tokens. In other words, he approved transactions through internet banking on Sandy’s behalf, using her bank token. Sam’s evidence to this effect was not challenged. Xiaoman confirmed that Sandy had passed her bank token to Sam and Sam could approve transactions through internet banking on behalf of Sandy and himself. Her evidence was not challenged either.
(b) Sandy signed cheques without question. Xiaoman testified that Sandy would usually sign cheques upon seeing that Sam had signed them, and she never rejected signing any cheque or asked to see any supporting documents. Xiaoman’s evidence was not challenged. Shuling testified that Sandy did not ask any questions about the cheques that she was asked to sign; she would simply sign after seeing that Sam had signed the cheque. Shuling’s evidence was also not challenged.
Whether Sam caused Yangbum to attempt to issue disproportionate dividends to himself and to apply improper set-offs
- [107]
[107] As stated in [36] above, on 24 February 2020, Sandy withdrew S$188,000 from the OCBC Joint Account, leaving a balance of just a little over S$550. Sam claims that this withdrawal was wrongful because he had made full payment of S$9.3m to Sandy as required under the IJ and Sandy was to relinquish her interests in all joint bank accounts held with him.
- [108]
[108] The next day, 25 February 2020, Sam decided that Yangbum should issue the following dividends:
(a) S$2,000,000 to be paid to Sam and Sandy equally; however, Sandy’s share of S$1m would be set-off against the Yangbum Loan (S$800,000) and the Ken Precision Loan (S$200,000) (see [26] above);
(b) S$376,000 to be paid to Sam and Sandy equally; however, Sandy’s share of S$188,000 would be set-off against the S$188,000 Withdrawal;
(c) S$100,000 to be paid to Sam as partial payment of his expenses; and
(d) S$500,000 to be paid to Sam as his management fee for 2018.
The set-offs in (a) and (b) above meant that Sandy would not receive any part of her share of dividends amounting to S$1,188,000.
- [109]
[109] On Sam’s instructions, Yangbum’s accounts executive, Ms Long Soo Hsien (“Soo Hsien”), prepared the following cheques and payment vouchers:
(a) UOB 136068 for S$1m payable to Sam; the corresponding payment voucher described this as dividends payable to Sam;
(b) UOB 136069 for S$500,000 payable to Sam; the corresponding payment voucher described this as dividends payable to Sam;
(c) UOB 136071 for S$476,000 payable to Sam; the corresponding payment voucher described this as dividends payable to Sam; and
(d) a payment voucher which stated that dividends of S$1m and S$188,000 were payable to Sandy but were to be set-off against the Yangbum Loan, the Ken Precision Loan and the S$188,000 Withdrawal.
- [110]
[110] The payment of S$476,000 comprised the amounts of S$376,000 and S$100,000 referred to in [108(b)] and [108(c)] above. The amount of S$376,000 included $188,000 payable to Sandy as dividends but which Sam wanted to set off against the S$188,000 Withdrawal. As that withdrawal was from the OCBC Joint Account, it was owed to Sam. In effect, Sam was trying to set off dividends payable by Yangbum to Sandy against a debt that he claimed Sandy owed to him.
- [111]
[111] Sam signed the payment vouchers and the cheques. On 26 February 2020, Soo Hsien asked Sandy to go to Yangbum’s office to sign the cheques and payment vouchers. On Sandy’s request, Soo Hsien sent copies of the cheques and payment vouchers to Sandy. Sandy refused to sign the cheques or to acknowledge the proposed set-offs on the grounds that the dividends were disproportionate and Yangbum was not entitled to apply the set-offs.
- [112]
[112] Sandy’s case is that Sam abused his position as sole director of Yangbum by causing Yangbum to attempt to issue more dividends to himself and to apply improper set-offs against Sandy’s declared dividends.
Whether Sam abused his position as sole director
- [113]
[113] The proposed dividends were not paid and the proposed set-offs were not effected since Sandy refused to sign the three cheques. Sam submits that he did not abuse his position as sole director because the proposed dividends and set-offs were subject to Sandy’s agreement. I agree. In substance, Sam’s actions amounted to nothing more than a request for Sandy’s agreement to the proposal. It was entirely up to Sandy whether to agree or disagree. There is no suggestion that Sam misrepresented any fact to Sandy.
- [114]
[114] I also agree with Sam that in any event, the proposed dividends and set-offs have no continuing oppressive effect that merits any relief under s 216 CA. I agree with the following view expressed by the learned author in Margaret Chew, Minority Shareholders’ Rights and Remedies (LexisNexis, 3rd Ed, 2017) at 4.231:
- [115]
[115] For completeness, I proceed to deal with whether the proposed dividends were disproportionate and whether the proposed set-offs were improper.
Alleged disproportionate dividends
- [116]
[116] Sandy alleges that the proposed payments of dividends were disproportionate because Sam was to be paid a total amount of S$1,976,000 whereas Sandy was to be paid a total of S$1,188,000. In my view, Sandy’s allegation is erroneous, and the proposed dividends were not disproportionate.
- [117]
[117] As stated in [108] above, of the total amount of dividends to be issued,
(a) Sam and Sandy were to receive only S$1,188,000 each as dividends but an amount of S$188,000 from Sandy’s dividends was to be paid to Sam to set off against the S$188,000 Withdrawal; and
(b) the additional amounts of S$100,000 and S$500,000 were to be paid to Sam towards his M&E Fees.
Clearly, the proposed payment of dividends of S$1,188,000 each was not disproportionate since Sam and Sandy would have received equal amounts.
- [118]
[118] The additional amounts (a total of S$600,000) were not intended to be paid to Sam as dividends but as payment towards his M&E Fees. I have found that Sandy had agreed to the arrangement of using dividends to pay Sam’s M&E Fees (see [99] above). Sandy is therefore wrong to claim an entitlement to be paid a similar amount of S$600,000 as dividends. Indeed, payment of this amount to Sandy as dividends would have resulted in a disproportionate payment of dividends in favour of Sandy.
Alleged improper set-offs
- [119]
[119] Sandy claims that the proposed set-offs (see [108] above) were improper for the following reasons:
(a) Yangbum had not demanded repayment of the Yangbum Loan;
(b) the Ken Precision Loan was not a debt owing to Yangbum; and
(c) Sandy was entitled to make the S$188,000 Withdrawal.
Set-off against the Yangbum Loan
- [120]
[120] Sandy’s pleaded case is that Yangbum was not entitled to set-off her dividends against the Yangbum Loan because (a) Yangbum had not demanded repayment of the loan, and (b) in mid-April 2018, Sam agreed to Sandy repaying the Yangbum Loan by applying a portion of her share of future shareholder dividends disbursed to her, until the loan was fully repaid (the “Repayment Agreement”).
- [121]
[121] In my view, the fact that Yangbum had not demanded repayment of the Yangbum Loan is neither here nor there. If the Repayment Agreement exists, whether Yangbum had demanded repayment would be irrelevant. If the Repayment Agreement does not exist, Yangbum would have been entitled to set-off Sandy’s dividends against the Yangbum Loan even if Yangbum had not demanded repayment.
- [122]
[122] As for the alleged Repayment Agreement, I note that Sandy’s closing submissions do not refer to this. Nevertheless, in my view, the Repayment Agreement is yet another fabrication by Sandy.
- [123]
[123] First, Sandy’s position as to the terms of the Repayment Agreement has not been consistent.
(a) In her Statement of Claim in S 275 and her affidavit filed in opposition to Yangbum’s application for summary judgment in S 567, Sandy asserted that the agreement was that she would repay the Yangbum Loan by applying “a portion” of her share of future shareholder dividends. This is different from her response on 29 June 2020 (through her lawyers) to the demands made by Yangbum and Ken Precision for repayment of the Yangbum Loan and Ken Precision Loan respectively. In that response, Sandy alleged that there was an agreement that the Yangbum Loan would be “fully repaid from or set-off against [Sandy’s] share of the future dividends issued by Yangbum”. There was no mention of Sandy using “a portion” of her future dividends to repay the Yangbum Loan.
(b) In her oral testimony, Sandy said that it was for Sam, not her, to decide how much of any future dividends would be used to pay off the Yangbum Loan. This was different from her case in S 275 and S 567, which was that she would repay the Yangbum Loan by applying a portion of her future dividends. When Sam’s counsel pointed out to her that her case in S 567 was that she had the right to decide how much of her future dividends would be used to repay the Yangbum Loan, Sandy immediately abandoned what she said in her oral testimony. No attempt was made to explain her position in her oral testimony.
- [124]
[124] Second, Sandy’s case is that the Repayment Agreement applied only to the Yangbum Loan. Sandy had requested a S$1m loan from Yangbum on 14 April 2018. Subsequently, Sam arranged for the loan to be given by way of the Yangbum Loan and the Ken Precision Loan. It is illogical that the Repayment Agreement (which was allegedly made in mid-April 2018) would have applied only to the Yangbum Loan. It seems to me that Sandy very likely did not include the Ken Precision Loan in the alleged Repayment Agreement because she did not need to. She was able to argue that the proposed set-off against the Ken Precision Loan was improper because that loan was not owed to Yangbum. However, Sandy needed a reason to challenge the proposed set-off against the Yangbum Loan and she came up with the Repayment Agreement for that purpose.
- [125]
[125] Third, the Repayment Agreement is a bare assertion by Sandy. There is no other evidence supporting the alleged agreement. In fact, Sandy’s request for the S$1m loan was made by way of a text message, to which Sam simply replied “Ok”. There is no evidence that supports Sandy’s bare allegation that she had a meeting with Sam in mid-April 2018, during which they entered into the Repayment Agreement. In dismissing the appeal against the summary judgment entered against Sandy in S 567, the learned High Court Judge had expressed the view that the Repayment Agreement was uncertain and that there was “no evidence reasonably capable of belief that the loan would only be repayable from dividends” (emphasis in original). I fully agree.
- [126]
[126] In my view, the proposed set-off against the Yangbum Loan was not improper.
Set-off against the Ken Precision Loan
- [127]
[127] Ordinarily, Yangbum would not have been entitled to set-off Sandy’s dividends against the Ken Precision Loan since the Ken Precision Loan was not a debt owing to Yangbum. However, as discussed earlier, all that Sam had done was to propose the set-off for Sandy’s agreement.
Set-off against the S$188,000 Withdrawal
- [128]
[128] As will be seen later in this judgment, I find that Sandy was entitled to make the S$188,000 Withdrawal. However, as discussed earlier, the proposed set-off against the S$188,000 Withdrawal was just a proposal that Sandy could agree or disagree with.
Yangbum’s claim against Sandy in HC/S 567/2020
- [129]
[129] Sandy’s pleaded case includes an allegation that Sam’s action in causing Yangbum to commence S 567 despite the Repayment Agreement was oppressive. Sandy has not pursued this in her closing submissions. In any event, I have found that the Repayment Agreement is a fabrication. Yangbum was fully entitled to commence S 567 against Sandy. I note as well that S 567 was commenced only after Sandy failed to respond to Yangbum’s demand for payment made on 2 June 2020.
Whether the removal of Sandy as a joint signatory breached her legitimate expectations
- [130]
[130] Between 27 February and 8 March 2020, Sam (acting as the sole director of Yangbum) removed Sandy as a joint signatory of Yangbum’s bank accounts. Sandy’s case is as follows:
(a) Yangbum is a quasi-partnership between Sam and her.
(b) Even though she resigned as a director of Yangbum on 15 September 2005, it was the intention, understanding and/or agreement that she had with Sam that:
(i) both of them would continue to have joint authority and oversight of the use of Yangbum’s funds, and
(ii) withdrawal of substantial funds from Yangbum would require the consent of both of them,
(the “Understanding”).
(c) Her removal as a joint signatory was in breach of the Understanding.
- [131]
[131] A quasi-partnership may be defined as an association formed or continued on the basis of a personal relationship, involving mutual confidence. While legal rights and expectations are usually enshrined in the company’s constitution in the majority of cases, a special class of quasi-partnership companies form an exception to this rule. The finding of a quasi-partnership allows the court to take into account informal understandings and assumptions in determining whether the minority shareholders have been unfairly treated. See, Ting Shwu Ping v Scanone Pte Ltd and another appeal [2017] 1 SLR 95 at [85].
- [132]
[132] In the present case, proving that Yangbum is a quasi-partnership would allow this Court to take into account the Understanding in determining whether Sandy has been unfairly treated. However, Sandy must still prove the Understanding.
Whether Yangbum is a quasi-partnership
- [133]
[133] Sandy makes the following allegations in support of her claim that Yangbum is a quasi-partnership:
(a) In 1994, Sandy and Sam set up YE (the sole proprietorship in Sam’s name). Sam was primarily in charge of sales and marketing whilst she was primarily in charge of production and book-keeping. Sandy’s contributions to YE since 1994 formed the foundations which led to the incorporation of Yangbum.
(b) As YE’s business became successful and required further financing to grow, Sandy and Sam decided to incorporate Yangbum to limit their personal liability; Sandy and Sam were appointed as directors to manage Yangbum. Yangbum was incorporated with the parties’ shared efforts; Sandy and her family provided labour and financing.
(c) Yangbum was a closely held family-owned company formed and managed on the basis of mutual trust and confidence; Yangbum’s affairs were conducted on an informal basis.
(d) The understanding and/or agreement was that Sandy and Sam would be jointly involved in the key decision-making in YE and Yangbum.
(e) Sam continued to be in charge of sales and marketing while Sandy continued to be in charge of production and book-keeping in Yangbum, and they jointly made decisions in relation to the financing and manpower needs of Yangbum.
- [134]
[134] I am not persuaded that Yangbum is a quasi-partnership.
Sandy had no material involvement in YE
- [135]
[135] I find that Sandy did not have any substantial or material involvement in the setting up of YE or in YE’s business.
- [136]
[136] First, I reject Sandy’s claim that she set up YE (the sole proprietorship in Sam’s name) together with Sam.
(a) Sam formed a partnership (YIS) in July 1992 before he even met Sandy. Sam managed YIS; the other partner was a sleeping partner. In May 1994, Sam dissolved the partnership and registered YE on 21 June 1994, using moneys he received from the dissolution of YIS to start YE. YE operated out of the premises of a subcontractor who was Sam’s contact.
(b) Sandy came to Singapore as a student in 1992. Sam started dating Sandy only in 1993. Sandy returned to China in September/October 1993 and came back to Singapore in June 1994, which was around the same time that YE was set up. Sandy had no experience or knowledge of the business that YE was in. Sandy became a permanent resident of Singapore about three months after she married Sam. After that, she worked in a child-care centre but resigned in less than a month. YE was registered as a sole proprietorship in Sam’s name instead of as a partnership in both Sam’s and Sandy’s names.
(c) Based on the above facts, I find it unbelievable that Sandy would have been involved in any meaningful way in the setting up of YE. The fact that Sam married Sandy in July 1994 does not mean that Sandy was therefore involved as a business partner in the formation of YE.
- [137]
[137] Second, I reject Sandy’s claim that she was primarily in charge of production and book-keeping in YE. Sandy’s claim that she was in charge of production is a blatant exaggeration. Under cross-examination, Sandy admitted that in fact YE had no production work; Sam outsourced the production work and what Sandy did was to smooth the edges of the products and check the dimensions, and to type the delivery orders and invoices. It is not surprising that as Sam’s partner in marriage, she would have helped him with such tasks. As for her claim that she was in charge of book-keeping, Sam’s evidence that he (not Sandy) managed YE’s book-keeping was not challenged. In short, the evidence does not show that Sandy played any substantial role in YE.
Sandy had no material involvement in Yangbum
- [138]
[138] I find that Sandy did not have a substantial or material involvement in the decision to incorporate Yangbum or in Yangbum’s business.
- [139]
[139] First, Sandy claims that she and Sam decided to incorporate Yangbum to limit their liability. I agree with Sam that this makes no sense. Sam was the sole proprietor of YE. Sandy had no personal liability for YE’s debts. When asked to explain, Sandy first said that she was a partner of YE but she subsequently conceded that she was not registered as a partner and therefore had no personal liability. She then changed her evidence and said that Yangbum had to take loans to buy machinery and start the factory and as a private limited company, liability would be limited. However, that still does not explain what liability she had that would be limited by incorporating Yangbum. Incorporating Yangbum to carry on YE’s business had no impact on Sandy’s liability since she was not liable for YE’s debts in any event. In my view, Sandy was making up her evidence.
- [140]
[140] I accept Sam’s evidence that he incorporated Yangbum because YE’s business had expanded and he wanted to carry out production on his own. It is more cogent and, in any event, was not challenged.
- [141]
[141] Second, Sam obtained banking facilities of approximately S$624,000 from Focal Finance Ltd and OCBC for Yangbum to purchase machines for production. Sam was the sole guarantor for the loans. Further, Sandy was not involved in obtaining these loans. In her AEIC and during cross-examination, Sandy said she was not aware Sam had secured financing for Yangbum in 1997. Subsequently, during re-examination, Sandy changed her evidence and said that she knew Sam had obtained bank loans to purchase machinery. I do not place much weight on Sandy’s evidence during re-examination. When asked to explain her earlier evidence that she did not know about the loans, her answers were not responsive. In any event, Sandy also admitted that she did not know how much the loans were. Sandy’s lack of involvement in and knowledge about the loans show that she was not as involved in the setting up of Yangbum as she claims.
- [142]
[142] Third, Shuling testified that she referred to Sandy as “lady boss” as a term of respect; it did not mean that Sandy was one of the bosses at Yangbum. Shuling also confirmed that she reported to Sam directly, Sandy did not “guide her” when she joined Yangbum, the finance team did not report to Sandy, Sandy rarely went to the office and was not involved in Yangbum’s business and operations, she (Shuling) consulted Sam on financial decisions for Yangbum, and she had not seen Sam discussing finance issues with Sandy. I accept Shuling’s evidence; she was an objective witness and her evidence was unshaken during cross-examination.
- [143]
[143] Fourth, Sandy submits that she and her family provided labour and financing to Yangbum at a time when both Sam and Sandy were financially impoverished. In my view, whatever help that Sandy or her mother may have provided is consistent with her relationship to Sam and is insufficient to prove that Yangbum is a quasi-partnership.
- [144]
[144] Fifth, regarding the loan of RMB200,000, it is not disputed that such a loan was made to Yangbum. Sandy claims that her family (including her mother) and family friends made the loan to Yangbum as working capital during its incorporation and that it was interest-free. Sam, however, says that the loan was made in mid-1999 and that it was Sandy who had insisted on Yangbum taking the loan so that she “could show off and do her relatives a favour by offering them a high [interest] rate” of 15%.
- [145]
[145] I reject Sandy’s claim that the RMB200,000 loan was made to Yangbum as working capital during its incorporation.
(a) Sandy’s evidence about the loan is inconsistent in material respects.
(i) In her reply in S 275, Sandy pleaded that her mother contributed “almost her entire life savings of [RMB]200,000 as working capital for [Yangbum] during its incorporation”. However, in her third affidavit filed in these proceedings (dated 9 June 2020), she said that her mother contributed the RMB200,000 after the incorporation of Yangbum. When questioned, Sandy could not give any credible explanation and merely kept repeating that the loan was given in 1997.
(ii) As stated above, in her reply in S 275 and in her affidavit dated 9 June 2020, Sandy said that her mother contributed the RMB200,000. In her reply, she even described the amount as “almost [her mother’s] entire life savings”. In her AEIC, Sandy changed her evidence and said the RMB200,000 came from her family (including her mother) and family friends. Sandy was not responsive when asked to explain the different versions of her evidence and simply repeated that her mother “approached relatives and friends to get the loan”.
(b) Sandy’s claim that the loan was interest-free is unbelievable. RMB200,000 was a substantial amount in China in 1997. The lenders included not just Sandy’s mother but also her family and even family friends. There was no reason why they would give Yangbum an interest-free loan of RMB200,000. When questioned about this, Sandy explained that in 1997, people in China were very helpful and were willing to give out loans to help others prosper. I find Sandy’s explanation unbelievable.
(c) Yangbum did not need the loan as YE’s assets were transferred to Yangbum and Sam had also obtained financing from the banks. It is also not disputed that Sam did not ask for the loan.
(d) There is no evidence as to when the loan was made to Yangbum. Sandy relied on a copy of handwritten notes that she claimed were her records of the amounts borrowed for the loan. I find that these notes are not helpful in determining when the loan of RMB200,000 was made.
(i) Only a copy was produced in evidence.
(ii) It is also not clear that the entries were in respect of the loan of RMB200,000. The figures in the notes do not tally with the loan amount of RMB200,000. Sandy’s explanation that “we just call it 200,000” is not believable. Sandy’s explanation as to how all the figures show the loan of RMB200,000 is muddled and illogical.
(iii) The dates shown in these notes do not indicate the year and the dates ranged from 16 March to 11 June. Yangbum was incorporated only on 19 June 1997. Sandy at first claimed that the dates referred to 1997. However, when asked if she was saying that she was borrowing moneys from her mother and family from March 1997, she changed her evidence and said that the 16 March date referred to 1998.
(e) During her oral testimony, Sandy said that she started borrowing moneys before Yangbum was incorporated because “[w]e wanted to buy a car ... and … an HDB flat” and that the moneys were to be used wherever needed. Sandy’s testimony contradicted her own case that the loan of RMB200,000 was made to Yangbum as working capital during its incorporation.
- [146]
[146] I find that it was more probable than not that (a) it was Sandy who insisted on Yangbum taking the loan and (b) the loan was made in 1999.
- [147]
[147] Sixth, Sandy’s resignation as a director of Yangbum on 15 September 2005, of her own free will, shows that she had no material involvement in the management of Yangbum. Sandy claims that she resigned as director due to differences with Sam regarding the management of Yangbum, including Yangbum’s alleged use of “phantom workers” to enable Yangbum to employ more foreign workers and the employment of foreigners without work permits.
- [148]
[148] I reject the reasons given by Sandy for her resignation as director. In 2008, Sandy became the sole shareholder of Ace Class and Apex Precision, and a director of QL Precision. In 2009, she became the sole shareholder of QL Precision. In 2016, she became the sole shareholder of TL Precision and SH Precision. Sandy’s claim that she resigned in 2005 due to disagreement with Sam over the management of Yangbum (in particular, the alleged use of phantom workers) is inconsistent with the roles that she subsequently assumed in the above companies. After all, for all intents and purposes, these companies were part of the Yangbum group and remained under Sam’s management.
- [150]
[150] I also accept Sam’s evidence that Sandy resigned as a director in 2005 because there was no longer a legal requirement for at least two directors and Sandy did not want the responsibilities of a director. The CA was amended in 2004 to permit a company to have a single director who was ordinarily resident in Singapore. Sandy’s resignation as director in 2005 shows that she had no material involvement in the management of Yangbum.
- [151]
[151] Seventh, in or about October 2019, Sandy requested to be reappointed as a director of Yangbum. Her request was rejected by Sam. Sandy simply accepted Sam’s decision. Sandy’s conduct is also consistent with the fact that she had no material involvement in the management of Yangbum.
No understanding that Sandy would be jointly involved in key decision-making
- [152]
[152] A part of Sandy’s pleaded case is that when YE was set up and Yangbum was incorporated, there was an understanding that she would be jointly involved with Sam in key decision-making in YE and Yangbum. In her further and better particulars filed in S 275, Sandy stated that such decisions included decisions relating to financing, office needs and manpower needs. In my judgment, there was no such understanding.
(a) As discussed in [141] above, Sandy was neither aware of nor involved in Sam’s efforts in obtaining bank loans to purchase machinery for Yangbum’s business.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.