General Division of the High Court · Decided 18 January 2024
Shree Ramkrishna Exports Pvt Ltd v JG Jewelry Pte Ltd and another suit
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC 10 · Case no. Suit No 418 of 2018
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] These proceedings involve two related actions – HC/S 418/2018 (“S 418”) and HC/S 475/2018 (“S 475”). The company at the heart of the disputes is incorporated in Singapore but the other parties to the disputes hail from India, the United States and Hong Kong.
- [2]
[2] S 418 involves a claim for the price of diamonds and diamond jewellery sold and delivered to the Singapore company, and a counterclaim alleging that the Singapore company was incorporated pursuant to a joint venture agreement and that the diamonds and diamond jewellery represented contributions towards capital pursuant to the agreement. The joint venture agreement is disputed.
- [3]
[3] S 475 involves an oppression claim by a shareholder (and director) of the Singapore company and a counterclaim for breach of director’s duties. One of the issues is whether the plaintiff in S 475 is a nominee shareholder and director for the plaintiff in S 418, and if so, how that affects the oppression claim.
- [4]
[4] It is alleged that the joint venture agreement was concluded by a handshake and the utterance of the word “mazal”, which is a recognised practice of entering into contracts in the diamond industry. The traditional phrase used is “mazal and bracha” but “mazal” or “mazel” is used for short. Sealing a deal with an uttered “mazal” may have the appealing ring of a time-honoured practice. However, it is no substitute for a properly drafted agreement, all the more so when the transaction is a complex one (as it was in this case). Ignoring the need for proper legal documentation in this case was just poor management of the legal risks.
Parties in S 418 and S 475
- [5]
[5] The parties in S 418 are as follows:
(a) Shree Ramkrishna Exports Pvt Ltd (“SRK”) is the plaintiff, and the first defendant in counterclaim. SRK is a company incorporated in India. It is in the business of manufacturing and trading in jewellery and precious stones including cut and polished diamonds and/or polished natural diamonds and/or diamond studded jewellery and/or diamond and coloured stone studded jewellery.
(b) JG Jewelry Pte Ltd (“JGJ”) is the defendant, and the plaintiff in counterclaim. It is a company incorporated in Singapore and is in the business of trading jewellery and precious stones.
(c) The Jewelry Company (“TJCI”) is the second defendant in counterclaim and the plaintiff in its own counterclaim against JGJ. It is a partnership registered in India and is in the business of manufacturing, sales and marketing of diamond studded jewellery.
(d) TJC Jewelry, Inc (“TJCNY”) is the third defendant in counterclaim. It is a company incorporated in the US and is in the business of sales and marketing of jewellery, including diamonds.
(e) Mr Govind Dholakia (“Govind”) is the fourth defendant in counterclaim. He is an Indian national and is the founder, Chairman and a director of SRK.
(f) Mr Rahul Dholakia (“Rahul”) is the fifth defendant in counterclaim. He is an Indian national and is a Managing Director of SRK and a partner of TJCI. Rahul is Govind’s nephew.
(g) Mr Nirav Narola (“Nirav”) is the sixth defendant in counterclaim. He is an Indian national and is an employee of SRK and a partner of TJCI. Nirav is Govind’s grandson and Rahul’s nephew.
(h) Mr Amit Shah (“Amit”) is the seventh defendant in counterclaim. He is an Indian national and is the Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”) and a partner of TJCI.
(i) Mr Ashish Shah (“Ashish”) is the eighth defendant in counterclaim. Ashish is a US national and is the sole shareholder and President of TJCNY.
- [6]
[6] The parties in S 475 are as follows:
(a) Mr Shaileshkumar Manubhai Khunt (“Shailesh”) is the plaintiff and also the defendant in counterclaim. He is an Indian national who is resident in Hong Kong and is a shareholder and director of JGJ.
(b) Mr Michael Bernard Kriss (“Michael”) is the first defendant. He is a US national and is a shareholder and director of JGJ.
(c) Mr David Miles Kriss (“David”) is the second defendant. He is a US national and is a shareholder and director of JGJ. David is Michael’s younger brother.
(d) JGJ is the third defendant and the plaintiff in counterclaim.
Background facts
- [7]
[7] SRK operates, among other things, a sales office for its loose diamonds business at the Bharat Diamond Bourse in Mumbai (“SRK-BDB”) and a jewellery manufacturing factory in Sachin, which is near Surat, India (“SRK-Sachin”).
- [8]
[8] TJCI operates a jewellery manufacturing factory in the Santacruz Electronic Export Processing Zone (“SEEPZ”) in Mumbai, India. SEEPZ is a special economic zone with tax incentives for factory sales. TJCI is the jewellery arm of SRK and is known in the market as a company within the SRK group.
- [9]
[9] TJCNY is the marketing affiliate of TJCI and helps to market the latter’s products in the US.
- [10]
[10] In this judgment, I shall refer to SRK-Sachin, TJCI and TJCNY as the “SRK Entities”. It is worth emphasising that although SRK-Sachin and SRK-BDB are just different businesses of the same entity (SRK), for present purposes, SRK-BDB is not part of the SRK Entities.
- [11]
[11] Michael and David (together, the “Kriss Brothers”) own and control the following entities in the US (the “JDM Entities”):
(a) JDM Import Co Inc (“JDM”);
(b) MG Worldwide LLC (“MG Worldwide”);
(c) Miles Bernard, Inc (“Miles Bernard”); and
(d) Asia Pacific Jewelry, LLC (“AP Jewelry”).
The JDM Entities operate a New York family-owned jewellery business, selling jewellery wholesale to major retailers in New York and elsewhere in the US, Canada, United Kingdom and Australia. The business was established by Michael’s and David’s father. Michael and David are Co-Presidents of the JDM Entities.
- [12]
[12] The JDM Entities operate under the trade name “Instock Programs” (or “Instock” for short) and sell to major jewellery retailers in New York and around the US; their clients include Macy’s, Zales and Sterling Jewelers (which owns Kay Jewelers).
- [13]
[13] Shailesh worked for SRK from 2005 to 2007. He is now a director of S Goldi (Asia) Limited (“S Goldi”), a company incorporated in Hong Kong. S Goldi is the marketing arm of SRK. The other director is one Mr Mansukhbhai Bhikhabhai Budheliya (“Mansukhbhai”), who is also the sole shareholder of the company.
- [14]
[14] Since around 2000, the Kriss Brothers had been purchasing diamonds, diamond studded jewellery and diamond and coloured stone jewellery from SRK.
- [15]
[15] In December 2014, the Kriss Brothers met with Rahul. The details of what was discussed are in dispute. Michael claims that Rahul proposed a joint venture between the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities (the “JV”) in which the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities would contribute selected assets, liabilities and activities to the JV. Michael also claims that during one of the meetings, Rahul shook hands with David and him, uttering “mazel”. Rahul claims that the Kriss Brothers proposed a closer partnership in which SRK would benefit from the Kriss Brothers’ experience and marketing network in the US, and the JDM Entities would have a more stable production line. Rahul denies uttering “mazal” and says that they merely decided to explore the opportunity.
- [16]
[16] In early January 2015, Nirav, Amit and Ashish met up with the Kriss Brothers for further discussions in New York. Michael claims that it was agreed pursuant to these discussions that the operation of the JV would commence on 1 April 2015.
- [17]
[17] On 13 January 2015, Amit sent an email to the Kriss Brothers, attaching a document dated the same day and titled “Joint Venutre [sic] Between JDM Group and The Jewelry Co. (SRK Group)” (the “13 January Memo”). The effect of this document is in dispute.
- [18]
[18] The Kriss Brothers made a trip to Mumbai, India on 27–28 January 2015 and met with, among others, Govind. Michael claims that the purpose of the trip was to visit Govind to obtain his “blessings” for the joint venture. However, Govind claims that he was only introduced to the Kriss Brothers as a matter of courtesy.
- [19]
[19] On 31 March 2015, JGJ was incorporated in Singapore with an issued share capital of US$100 comprising 100 ordinary shares.
(a) Shailesh holds 50 shares; Michael and David hold 25 shares each.
(b) Mr Ng Chee Wooi Michael (“Ng”) was appointed as a director of JGJ on 31 March 2015.
(c) Shailesh, Michael and David were appointed as directors on 15 April 2015.
- [20]
[20] Ng is a nominee resident director of JGJ. A Resident Director Indemnity Agreement dated 1 April 2015 (the “RDI Agreement”) states that Shailesh and the Kriss Brothers requested Ng to act as the resident director. The RDI Agreement also provides that Ng is to act upon the instructions of Mr Jim Goldsborough (“Jim”) as the Authorized Person designated by Shailesh and the Kriss Brothers. Jim was the Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”) of JDM.
- [21]
[21] In April 2015,
(a) SRK purchased a 26% stake in TJCI through its subsidiary, Ramkrishna Goldi Pvt Ltd;
(b) TJCNY moved to the JDM Entities’ office in New York and operated from there until 8 October 2017; and
(c) the bookkeeping, accounting and other back-office functions of JGJ and the JDM Entities (to the extent the functions could be carried out in India) were transferred to and undertaken by a team employed by TJCI; whether this team reported to Amit or to the Kriss Brothers is in dispute.
- [22]
[22] In May 2015, JGJ opened a bank account with the Israel Discount Bank in New York (“JGJ’s IDBNY Account”). The signatories of this account were Amit, Ashish, Jim, David and Michael; any one of them could authorise payments to be made from the account. At all material times, JGJ did not have a bank account in Singapore.
- [23]
[23] It is not disputed that with effect from 1 April 2015, there was some form of business collaboration between the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities. However, the parties dispute the nature of the collaboration. JGJ and the Kriss Brothers say that the collaboration was pursuant to a joint venture agreement entered into on 13 January 2015 (the “JVA”) under which, among other things, the diamonds and jewellery supplied by the SRK Entities to JGJ were to be treated as capital in the JV. The SRK Entities say that the collaboration was a business arrangement (“BA”) under which, among other things, SRK sold diamonds and jewellery to JGJ while they concurrently negotiated with the Kriss Brothers on the terms of the JV.
- [24]
[24] On 11 May 2016, S Goldi transferred US$500,000 to Shailesh. In turn, Shailesh transferred US$200,000 and US$300,000 to JGJ on 11 May 2016 and 13 May 2016 respectively. On 19 May 2016, S Goldi transferred another US$200,000 to Shailesh. On the same day, Shailesh transferred US$200,000 to JGJ. In the remittance forms, the moneys transferred by Shailesh to JGJ were described as “Capital Introduction”. Whether the total sum of US$700,000 was an injection of funds into JGJ by Shailesh or SRK is in dispute.
- [25]
[25] Issues arose from an accounting exercise in 2016. The reason for the accounting exercise is in dispute. JGJ’s case is that the accounting exercise was an accounting reconciliation conducted pursuant to the JVA. However, SRK’s case is that the accounting exercise was to test and determine whether the BA was a success, and if so, whether it could be replicated in a potential joint venture as envisaged by the Kriss Brothers.
- [26]
[26] In September 2016, JGJ engaged KPMG (an Indian partnership and member of the KPMG international network) to carry out the accounting exercise. KPMG started work on its engagement in November 2016 and eventually withdrew in October 2017, citing difficulties in getting “the required support / data from the [finance] team.”
- [27]
[27] By August 2017, the collaboration between the SRK Entities and the JDM Entities had lost whatever sparkle it may have had. During a meeting in August 2017, Rahul, Amit and Nirav informed the Kriss Brothers of SRK’s decision to terminate the collaboration. The collaboration was terminated on 31 August 2017.
- [28]
[28] By then, SRK had supplied diamonds and diamond jewellery to JGJ in respect of which the invoiced amounts totalled US$66,394,768.91. SRK issued the invoices to JGJ but the goods were shipped by SRK directly to the JDM Entities or other entities directed by them. Of the invoices:
(a) between October 2015 and August 2017, JGJ paid a total amount of US$42,994,312.66 on invoices issued between 15 September 2015 and 14 April 2017 (the “42M Invoices”); and
(b) a total amount of US$23,400,456.25 remains unpaid on invoices issued between 2 September 2016 and 2 August 2017 (the “23M Invoices”).
- [29]
[29] SRK’s claim in S 418 is for the amount unpaid on the 23M Invoices. It is not disputed that all of the diamonds and diamond jewellery in the 42M Invoices and the 23M Invoices were received by the JDM Entities. There is also no dispute over the quality of the goods.
- [30]
[30] Separately, TJCI had supplied diamond jewellery and associated services to JGJ and a total amount of US$2,211,077.91 remains unpaid on invoices issued between 8 October 2016 and 1 August 2017 (the “2.2M Invoices”). TJCI claims this amount against JGJ in TJCI’s counterclaim in S 418. Again, it is not disputed that the goods and services were delivered; there is also no dispute over the quality of the goods and services.
Events after the collaboration was terminated
- [31]
[31] After the collaboration was terminated, Ashish’s access to the JDM Entities’ office was terminated.
- [32]
[32] On 28 December 2017, TJCNY commenced action in New York against the JDM Entities to, among other things, recover loose diamonds and fine jewellery that were stored in the JDM Entities’ vault at their office (the “2017 US Proceedings”). Ashish claimed the goods belong to TJCNY whilst the JDM Entities claimed that the goods were subject to the claims of the JV.
- [33]
[33] On 12 January 2018, Michael sent to JGJ’s auditors, M/s AT Adler (“AT Adler”), a copy of JGJ’s revised financial statements for FY 2016 (the “2016 FS”). Michael explained that the initial copy of the financial statements did not correctly reflect the financial position of the company. Jim sent a copy of the letter to Shailesh via email on the same day. Shailesh claims that he did not see Jim’s email until sometime in or around April 2018.
- [34]
[34] On 22 January 2018, the Kriss Brothers signed a JGJ directors’ resolution (the “First Resolution”) authorising them to commence and manage legal proceedings against TJCNY on behalf of JGJ to recover an amount of US$3,733,503.43 owing by TJCNY (the “TJCNY Debt”).
- [35]
[35] Shailesh did not sign the First Resolution. By way of a letter dated 6 February 2018 from his solicitors to the Kriss Brothers, Shailesh objected to the First Resolution because, among other things, it was not supported by relevant background documents or information.
- [36]
[36] On 15 February 2018, the Kriss Brothers and Ng signed a JGJ directors’ resolution authorising the Kriss Brothers to commence and manage legal proceedings against SRK and TJCI to recover excessive charges that the Kriss Brothers believed were the responsibility of SRK or one of its affiliates (the “Second Resolution”). The preamble in the Second Resolution referred to Shailesh as SRK’s nominee director in JGJ, holding his shares in JGJ on behalf of SRK and alleged SRK and TJCI of manipulating the pricing of goods billed to JGJ.
- [37]
[37] Shailesh did not sign the Second Resolution. By way of a letter dated 21 February 2018 from his solicitors to the Kriss Brothers, Shailesh objected to the Second Resolution. Shailesh alleged that the allegations that he was SRK’s nominee and that SRK/TJCI had manipulated the prices were baseless.
- [38]
[38] Thereafter, the Kriss Brothers’ solicitors (M/s Wong Tan & Molly Lim LLC) responded to Shailesh’s solicitors (M/s Collyer Law LLC) in relation to Shailesh’s objections to the First and Second Resolutions. Shailesh’s solicitors also traded barbs with Ng’s solicitors, M/s David Ong and Partners.
- [39]
[39] On 1 March 2018, SRK’s lawyers in India, M/s K Ashar & Co (“K Ashar”), wrote to JGJ to demand payment of the outstanding invoices plus interest. On 8 March 2018, JGJ’s US solicitors, M/s Moses & Singer LLP (“Moses & Singer”), replied to K Ashar, setting out JGJ’s case based on the JV; an identical letter dated 11 March 2018, with a Notary’s stamp, was also sent.
- [40]
[40] On 5 March 2018, Shailesh received an email from AT Adler enclosing the draft 2016 FS, an earlier email dated 1 March 2018, and directors’ resolutions approving the 2016 FS and the calling of an Annual General Meeting (“AGM”). The email dated 1 March 2018 pointed out the “Disclaimer of Opinion” and the “Basis of Disclaimer of Opinion” in the 2016 FS. In brief, the auditors did not express an opinion on the 2016 FS as they had not been able to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence to provide a basis for an audit opinion. The auditors also noted the disagreements between the directors and shareholders.
- [41]
[41] The Kriss Brothers and Ng signed a JGJ directors’ resolution dated 6 March 2018 (the “Third Resolution”) approving JGJ’s audited accounts for FY 2016 and resolving that the Second AGM be convened.
- [42]
[42] On 8 March 2018, K Ashar issued a letter of demand on behalf of TJCI for US$2,211,079.91 (see [30] above).
- [43]
[43] On 27 March 2018, JGJ and the JDM Entities commenced action in New York against the SRK Entities for, among other things, damages in excess of US$40 million arising from their failure to transfer assets and profits to JGJ in breach of the JVA, the TJCNY Debt (US$3,733,503), and damages in excess of US$20 million arising from the SRK Entities’ failure to contribute equally to the JV (the “2018 US Proceedings”).
- [44]
[44] On 4 April 2018, notice was given that an AGM of JGJ would be held on 19 April 2018 to adopt the 2016 FS. Shailesh objected to the 2016 FS.
- [45]
[45] On 11 April 2018, Shailesh received a copy of the Third Resolution. Shailesh did not sign the Third Resolution.
- [46]
[46] The AGM was held on 19 April 2018 and the 2016 FS was adopted. Shailesh did not attend the AGM, whether by himself or by proxy.
- [47]
[47] On 23 April 2018, SRK filed S 418.
- [48]
[48] On 30 April 2018, Jim sent a JGJ Board resolution to Shailesh for his signature (the “Fourth Resolution”). The Fourth Resolution sought, among other things, to appoint solicitors to act for JGJ and to authorise the Kriss Brothers to act on behalf of JGJ in relation to S 418. Shailesh did not sign the Fourth Resolution. In an email dated 3 May 2018 to the Kriss Brothers and Ng, Shailesh protested against the Fourth Resolution, giving various reasons.
- [49]
[49] On 4 May 2018, Shailesh filed S 475.
Parties’ cases in S 418
SRK’s claim
- [50]
[50] SRK’s case is that:
(a) The diamonds and diamond jewellery set out in the 23M Invoices were sold to JGJ at the prices stated in the invoices and JGJ had agreed to these prices. Therefore, JGJ is liable to pay the sum of US$23,400,456.25 that is still outstanding on the 23M Invoices.
(b) Alternatively, SRK is entitled to a restitutionary claim for payment of reasonable compensation.
- [51]
[51] JGJ’s pleaded defence is that the JDM Entities, the SRK Entities and JGJ entered into the JVA on 13 January 2015. The alleged agreed terms of the JVA were as follows:
(a) The shares in JGJ would be held equally between the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities.
(b) All income and expenses generated by each of the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities pursuant to the JV were to be for the account of the JV.
(c) Any and all jewellery and/or other goods supplied by the SRK Entities and/or the JDM Entities pursuant to the JV would be treated as capital in the JV. The supplying party would issue an invoice to JGJ with the goods priced at cost plus a specified mark-up to cover other related costs (eg, marketing, duties and taxes) and some profit (the “Cost-Plus Pricing”). The Cost-Plus Pricing was for the purposes of complying with any applicable tax requirements (including transfer pricing treatment) as well as to enable the parties to maintain proper records of the goods supplied. The invoices were not intended to create any liability on the part of JGJ to pay on the invoices. The invoices were also necessary to enable SRK to export and ship the goods out of India.
(d) The SRK Entities would carry out a full accounting reconciliation at the end of each year (the “Accounting Reconciliation”). This would involve:
(i) adjustments being made where necessary to the aggregate values of the goods supplied as between the parties to reflect the Cost-Plus Pricing;
(ii) the net profits or losses being determined and apportioned equally between the SRK Entities and the JDM Entities; and
(iii) valuing the goods supplied to the JV at cost for the purposes of determining the net profits or losses under the JV.
(e) The JDM Entities and the SRK Entities would each maintain a capital account with the JV. The contributions by the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities to the JV, including cash injections and goods supplied to the JV (valued at cost) would go into their respective capital accounts. The JDM Entities and the SRK Entities may make cash withdrawals from the JV with the knowledge and/or consent of the other party. Such cash withdrawals would reduce the balance in the relevant capital account.
(f) From the second year of the JV (ie, from 1 April 2016), if either of the SRK Entities’ or the JDM Entities’ equity in their respective capital accounts is more than 50% of the combined sum in the capital accounts, the party that contributed more than 50% would be entitled to payment of a monthly interest of 1% of the equity surplus, from the other party.
(g) The backroom and accounting responsibilities of JGJ would be undertaken by the SRK Entities at their back-office in India. To this end, SRK’s representatives, Amit and Ashish, were appointed as authorised signatories to JGJ’s IDBNY Account and were authorised to review and approve transactions and to release payments under the IDBNY Account.
- [52]
[52] According to JGJ, it was incorporated pursuant to the JV.
- [53]
[53] JGJ’s case is that the SRK Entities failed to conduct the Accounting Reconciliation during the course of the JV. Alternatively, JGJ says that following the termination of the JV and JVA, it was understood between the parties that there was to be a final reconciliation and settlement of accounts to be carried out (the “Termination Settlement Exercise”). JGJ says that it is not liable to pay on the 23M Invoices until either the Termination Settlement Exercise or the Accounting Reconciliation has been conducted.
- [54]
[54] JGJ further claims that even if there is no JV or the terms of the JVA do not address how the goods under the 23M Invoices are to be dealt with, SRK is not entitled to claim reasonable compensation in respect of the 23M Invoices because (a) SRK is estopped from doing so, (b) JGJ has changed its position, (c) JGJ is entitled to counter-restitution and/or (d) SRK has come to court with unclean hands.
- [55]
[55] SRK denies the JV/JVA. SRK’s case is that the parties entered into negotiations on the terms of the JV which did not materialise. Concurrently, the parties agreed to enter into the BA, the key features of which were as follows:
(a) The book-keeping and accounting for the sale of diamonds and diamond jewellery pursuant to the BA would be kept in India and administered by persons reporting to and taking instructions from the Kriss Brothers and their representatives.
(b) SRK would sell diamonds and diamond jewellery to JGJ and JGJ would in turn sell the same to companies controlled and/or owned by the Kriss Brothers.
(c) A two-step process would be implemented to ensure timely payment of invoices issued by SRK/TJCI to JGJ (the “Two-Step Payment Process”). The Two-Step Payment process involved:
(i) the Kriss Brothers’ representative setting up payment requests on IDBNY’s web portal for payments to be made to SRK; and
(ii) one of the parties holding the security tokens issued by IDBNY, ie, Amit, Ashish, Jim, David and Michael (see [22] above), would subsequently release the payments.
(d) TJCI’s marketing affiliate, TJCNY, would operate out of the JDM Entities’ office in New York.
- [56]
[56] SRK claims that JGJ was incorporated pursuant to the BA and was for the Kriss Brothers’ personal tax benefit as well as to consolidate purchases from SRK/TJCI.
JGJ’s counterclaim
- [57]
[57] JGJ claims as follows:
(a) The SRK Entities acted wrongfully and in breach of the JVA by:
(i) issuing the 23M Invoices and the 42M Invoices at prices that were not based on Cost-Plus Pricing;
(ii) procuring JGJ to pay the 42M Invoices; and
(iii) demanding payment of the 23M Invoices.
(b) One or more of TJCNY, TCJI, Govind, Rahul, Nirav, Amit and/or Ashish (the “S 418 Counterclaim Defendants”) induced the breaches of the JVA set out in (a) above.
(c) One or more of the S 418 Counterclaim Defendants conspired, through lawful or unlawful means, to injure JGJ and procured:
(i) SRK to issue the 23M Invoices and the 42M Invoices at prices that were not based on Cost-Plus Pricing (see [51(c)] above); and
(ii) JGJ to pay the 42M Invoices and SRK to demand payment of the 23M Invoices, despite knowing that JGJ was not liable to make payment on the 42M Invoices and 23M Invoices.
- [58]
[58] The S 418 Counterclaim Defendants deny JGJ’s counterclaim. The case for the S 418 Counterclaim Defendants (other than TJCNY and Ashish) is as set out in [55]–[56] above. In addition, they argue that in any event, JGJ has no standing to make a counterclaim based on the JVA because JGJ is not a party to the JVA, and JGJ cannot rely on the Contracts (Rights of third Parties) Act 2001 (2020 Rev Ed).
- [59]
[59] The case for TJCNY and Ashish is that TJCNY was not a party to the alleged JV and that their roles were to facilitate and assist administratively in the commercial arrangement between SRK/TJCI and the JDM Entities.
TJCI’s counterclaim
- [60]
[60] TJCI’s counterclaim is similar to SRK’s claim. TJCI claims the amount of US$2,211,077.91 based on the 2.2M Invoices. Further or in the alternative, TJCI claims that it is entitled to a restitutionary claim for payment of a reasonable compensation.
- [61]
[61] JGJ’s defence relies on the JV/JVA and is similar to its defence against SRK’s claim on the 23M Invoices.
Issues in S 418
- [62]
[62] The issues in S 418 are as follows:
(a) Whether the SRK Entities and the JDM Entities entered into the JVA or the BA, and if a JVA, whether
(i) TJCNY was a party to the JVA; and
(ii) there was a concluded and legally enforceable JVA?
(b) Whether JGJ has standing to enforce the JVA?
(c) What is JGJ’s liability and/or claim in respect of the 23M Invoices, 42M Invoices and 2.2M Invoices?
(d) Whether the S 418 Counterclaim Defendants are liable to JGJ for inducing breaches of the JVA?
(e) Whether the S 418 Counterclaim Defendants are liable to JGJ for conspiracy to injure JGJ?
Whether the SRK Entities and the JDM Entities entered into the JV or the BA
- [63]
[63] In my judgment, the evidence overwhelmingly proves that the collaboration between the SRK Entities and the JDM Entities was based on the JV and that the BA was a concoction by Amit, Nirav and Rahul.
The 13 January Memo was all about a joint venture
- [64]
[64] In December 2014, the Kriss Brothers and Rahul met and discussed a collaboration. This led to Nirav, Amit and Ashish meeting up with the Kriss Brothers in New York in early January 2015 for further discussions. Subsequently, Amit sent the 13 January Memo to the Kriss Brothers. The 13 January Memo is clear evidence that the parties had agreed to enter into a joint venture:
(a) The title of the 13 January Memo was “Joint Venutre [sic] Between JDM Group and the Jewelry Co. (SRK Group)”.
(b) The 13 January Memo stated the following:
(c) The 13 January Memo contained “General Terms” and “Partnership Terms” as well as matters to be discussed, all of which could only refer to a joint venture, and not the alleged BA. In particular, it contained the following “General Terms” and “Partnership Terms”:
- [65]
[65] In his oral testimony, Amit claimed that he used the term “JV” without knowing what it meant. However, this is inconsistent with his evidence in his affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”) that the 13 January Memo was prepared in anticipation of the contemplated JV. I have no doubt that Amit knew what the term “JV” meant. He was an experienced businessman involved in a business that was international. Further, the contents of the 13 January Memo are self-explanatory and show that Amit must have known what the term “JV” meant.
- [66]
[66] Amit also claimed that:
(a) only points 2, 3, 4 and 7 of the “General Terms” in the 13 January Memo were implemented as part of the BA; and
(b) key terms of the JV, including those set out under “Partnership Terms), eg, the term “50% TJC & 50% JDM partnership with 50-50% investment”, were not implemented.
- [67]
[67] I reject Amit’s claims. I find that the BA is a concoction (see [155] below). Further, points 2 and 4 of the “General Terms” deal with the transfer of JGJ’s and the JDM Entities’ back-office functions to India. I find that the transfer of the back-office functions to India was consistent with the JV but not the BA (see [102]–[106] below). Finally, the balance sheet template and balance sheets that were prepared in 2016 and 2017 are consistent with the equal partnership between the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities (see [134]–[147] below).
Correspondence between the parties show that the parties proceeded on the basis of a joint venture
- [68]
[68] There are numerous contemporaneous emails that show that the parties intended and proceeded on the basis of a joint venture. Nothing in these emails support the alleged BA.
- [69]
[69] On 15 January 2015 (two days after sending the 13 January Memo), Amit wrote to the Kriss Brothers, raising questions including how to “announce the JV to customers”. Amit first explained that this was a reference to a potential JV in the future, and subsequently said that his use of the term “JV” referred to a “close business relationship”. As stated earlier, I find that Amit understood what a “JV” was.
- [70]
[70] On 23 January 2015, Amit sent an email to the Kriss Brothers, attaching a document titled “Agenda in Mumbai” for the Kriss Brothers’ visit to Mumbai on 27–28 January 2015. The items in the Agenda included the following:
- [71]
[71] On the same day, Mr Divyesh Patel (“Divyesh”), an employee of TJCI, sent an email to the Kriss Brothers, copied to Amit. The email attached a proposed itinerary of the Kriss Brothers’ schedule in Mumbai on 27–28 January 2015. The itinerary included a two-hour slot on 27 January 2015 for a meeting with Govind and a tour of SRK’s diamond factory. Seen in the light of the agenda referred to above and Govind’s status, it is more likely that the meeting with Govind was to obtain his blessings for the JV (as Michael claimed) rather than just a matter of courtesy (as Govind claimed).
- [72]
[72] On 29 January 2015, Michael sent an email to Amit and David in which he wanted to begin the discussion about “capital investment needed to finance the JV.” On 30 January 2015, Amit sent Michael an email setting out his estimates of the capital investment needed. Amit noted that his estimates were very similar to Michael’s. These emails could not have been referring to the BA since the BA did not involve any capital investment.
- [73]
[73] On 30 March 2015, Michael sent an email to Amit and David, attaching a list of points relating to sales, “memos” (ie, consignments), repairs, credit rebill, returns, expenses and capital. These issues were relevant to the JV but not the BA. It is telling that even on 30 March 2015, the email made no reference to the BA.
- [74]
[74] On 30 June 2015, Jim emailed Michael and Amit about the billing procedure between JGJ and the JDM Entities. The inclusion of Amit is consistent with the JV. Under the purported BA, SRK was simply selling to JGJ; there would be no reason for Amit to be involved in the billing procedure between JGJ and the JDM Entities.
- [75]
[75] On 6 July 2015, Ashish sent an organisation chart of SRK’s and TJCI’s teams that handled the operational aspects of the business to several Instock (ie, JDM) personnel. The organisation chart was relevant to JDM’s personnel under the JV but not under the purported BA.
- [76]
[76] On 14 July 2015, one of the TJCI employees assigned to handle JDM’s back-office functions in India, Mr Vikas Ashokkumar Padhya (“Vikas”), sent Amit the “JDM work schedule”. The JDM work schedule was relevant to Amit under the JV but not under the purported BA.
- [77]
[77] On 4 August 2015, Amit sent Ashish an email (copying David) in which he instructed Ashish to streamline a list of work/processes in New York. Neither Amit nor Ashish had any reason to streamline the work processes in New York under the purported BA.
- [78]
[78] In August 2015, Amit discussed the roles and responsibilities of all the key individuals of the JV with Michael and David. On 25 August 2015, Amit sent Michael and David a draft paper setting out the roles and responsibilities of Amit, Nirav, David and Michael; Amit expressed the view that “this clarity will help all of us run the company more efficiently and smoothly”. It is clear that the parties were already operating on the basis of a joint venture.
- [79]
[79] On the same day, Amit sent an email to Jim and David, saying that “we need to have meetings with all our NY staff” and “[w]e need to re align everyone’s roles and responsibilities”. But for the JV, Amit would not have referred to JDM’s staff in New York as “our NY staff” or had any need to meet them to realign the roles and responsibilities.
- [80]
[80] On 9 March 2016, Amit sent the Kriss Brothers and Nirav a document entitled “JV Sales Apr to Feb”. The document set out the sales made to each customer by each of the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities. The reference to “JV sales” is self-explanatory. This document had nothing to do with the purported BA.
- [81]
[81] On 11 March 2016, Amit asked Jim for a provisional balance sheet as he wanted to “go over the financials of each company to see the profit/loss for the year.” There was no necessity for this under the purported BA. The tone of Amit’s email also shows that he was not asking for the financials simply for purposes of considering whether to enter into a joint venture with the JDM Entities.
- [82]
[82] On 17 May 2016, Rahul wrote to the Kriss Brothers and said:
The contents of Rahul’s email are self-explanatory.
- [83]
[83] On 16 June 2016, Mr Vibhor Jain (“Vibhor”) emailed various persons from TJCI, SRK and Instock, complaining that he had not “received any data for 31st March 2016 for any of the JV entity till date”. Amit and Nirav were also copied on this email. It appears that Vibhor was formally employed by SRK as its CFO but was known to the JDM Entities as TJCI’s CFO. Vibhor introduced himself to the JDM employees as the new CFO for TJCI. It is not disputed that Vibhor handled mainly JGJ’s and the JDM Entities’ accounts. The fact that Vibhor was asking for financial information of not just the JDM Entities, but of TJCI and SRK as well, showed that the parties were operating on the basis of a joint venture and not the purported BA.
- [84]
[84] In an email dated 5 July 2016:
(a) Michael referred to the “new joint venture” being in place; and
(b) Michael told Nirav, Amit and David that “[o]ur [b]ank line at [IDBNY] has expired” and that the bank wanted them to sign a letter to extend the line with David and Michael guaranteeing the line; Michael asked to “have a conversation and decide” what needed to be done.
- [85]
[85] On 6 July 2016, Amit replied as follows:
Amit’s reply is clear evidence that the parties were operating on the basis of the JV. Under the purported BA, there would be no reason why the JDM Entities’ banking facilities should be shared with the SRK Entities.
- [86]
[86] On 8 July 2016, one Vinay Vaghani (from TJCI) reported to the Kriss Brothers, Nirav and Amit, the “per gram labour for the month of June” . Amit’s reply complimenting the factory’s performance was also copied to the Kriss Brothers. The fact that the Kriss Brothers were copied on the emails is consistent with the JV; there was no reason to copy the Kriss Brothers about the performance of TJCI’s factory if the parties’ relationship was merely that of partners under the BA.
- [88]
[88] On 7 September 2016, Vikas informed Jim and Ajay Matta (the Financial Controller of JDM) that SRK required US$500,000 to buy gold. Ajay Matta then asked Michael if it was “ok to borrow” if the funds requested were not available. At Michael’s request, Ajay Matta sent him the projected dates of payments from customers. In his reply (which was copied to Amit and Nirav), Michael asked for an explanation for the shortfall in funding. Michael also said that they needed to make a joint decision as they had decided it should not be necessary to obtain financing from the bank, and pointed out that it had been agreed that “Amit would manage all the day to day credit in accordance with [their] joint meetings, and if things change significantly he would bring it to the table with our partners/board”. These exchanges regarding the financing arrangements between SRK and JDM show that the parties were operating on the basis of the JV.
- [89]
[89] On 13 September 2016, Vibhor sent minutes of a meeting earlier that morning to Michael and Amit. The minutes referred to “Diamond Bank of JDM Group which has been taken earlier into balance sheet” and to “SRK/TJC old goods [having] been taken into JV”. These references evidenced the parties’ contributions to the capital of the JV. The minutes also stated that 50% of the “[s]everance pay to terminated employees in JDM after 01 Apr 2015” was to “be debited to JDM Capital as prior period expenses” and the remaining 50% was to “be treated as JV Expenses”. The fact that 50% of the severance (paid to JDM employees who were terminated as a result of the back-office functions being transferred to India) was to be treated as “JV expenses” is clear evidence that the parties were operating on the basis of the JV.
Amit’s, Nirav’s and Rahul’s explanations for the use of the term “JV”
- [90]
[90] Amit claimed that he used the terms “joint venture” or “JV” loosely and that he used these terms to refer to either the BA or the potential JV. I find Amit’s claim that the term “JV” could refer to the BA to be unbelievable. Amit was, and is, an experienced businessman. He must have understood what a joint venture meant. The BA was clearly not a joint venture.
- [91]
[91] Rahul claimed that he understood a “little bit” of English and that he spoke to his assistant in Gujarati and his assistant translated and typed his messages in his emails in English. In my view, Rahul understated his ability to understand English. Although he chose to give his oral testimony through a Gujarati interpreter, I noticed that he was nodding in response to some of the questions before they were translated. He was also able to give an answer – “business associate” – in English. I have no doubt that Rahul understood the term “JV”.
Credibility of Amit, Nirav and Rahul as witnesses
- [92]
[92] Amit, Nirav and Rahul claimed that they were not aware of the significance of the word “mazal”. I find this very hard to believe given their experience in the diamond industry. It is not disputed that the use of the word “mazal” to conclude a deal is an established and well-recognised practice in the diamond industry. Govind himself testified that this word is used in practice in the diamond business when agreement is reached on a deal. Govind also testified that “this is what we do, we shake hands and say ‘mazal’” and that Rahul should know about this practice.
- [93]
[93] Amit’s, Nirav’s and Rahul’s claim that they were not aware of the significance of the word “mazal” served only to tarnish their credibility as witnesses.
JGJ was incorporated pursuant to the JV
- [94]
[94] On 31 March 2015, JGJ was incorporated in Singapore. The evidence shows that JGJ was incorporated pursuant to the JV.
- [95]
[95] According to Michael, JGJ was incorporated as a tax efficient vehicle through which capital flow and eventual profit distribution could be effected to the joint venture partners; in addition, it was a convenient vehicle to handle joint venture purchases from non-joint venture parties. Michael explained that JGJ would be tax-free because all of the business was being done offshore.
- [96]
[96] Rahul and Nirav alleged that the Kriss Brothers incorporated JGJ for their personal tax reasons and to consolidate purchases from SRK/TJCI.
- [97]
[97] I accept Michael’s evidence that JGJ was incorporated as a tax efficient vehicle for the JV for several reasons. First, Michael’s evidence is supported by Amit’s email to the Kriss Brothers dated 2 February 2015, attaching a summary of decisions made during the Kriss Brothers’ visit to Mumbai. One of the decisions made in Mumbai was to “set up a JV” in Hong Kong; Michael was to check with his friend in Hong Kong on the legal composition of the JV. Michael’s unchallenged testimony was that, eventually, they could not set up the JV vehicle in Hong Kong because Amit said that SRK’s nominee was in Hong Kong.
- [98]
[98] Second, Amit was concerned about the tax status of JGJ. The exchange of emails in February 2016 between Vikas and AT Adler (JGJ’s auditors) regarding JGJ’s tax liabilities were copied not only to Jim but also to Amit. Amit was not just a passive participant either. He expressly asked AT Adler to “send a recap confirmed our tax liability in Singapore” [emphasis added]. Amit’s interest in JGJ’s tax liabilities shows that JGJ was set up pursuant to the JV. There would be no reason for Amit to be concerned about JGJ’s tax liabilities if JGJ was simply a buyer of diamonds and diamond jewellery from SRK/TJCI or if JGJ was incorporated solely for the Kriss Brothers’ own purposes.
- [99]
[99] Third, I accept Michael’s testimony that the letters “J” and “G” in JGJ’s name stand for “JDM” and “Jewel Goldi” respectively, to reflect the association between both the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities. This is supported by an email dated 27 March 2015 between Michael and Ms Juliana Ng (who was assisting with setting up JGJ). An article by the Diamond World News Service dated 11 January 2012 described Jewel Goldi as SRK’s dedicated manufacturing arm. I also note that the name of SRK’s subsidiary (which bought a stake in TJCI) is Ramkrishna Goldi Pvt Ltd (see [21(a)] above). Michael explained that the Goldi Group of companies (the “Goldi Group”) is part of the SRK Group’s global network of companies. The explanation for JGJ’s name is consistent with the JV. There would have been no reason for the name “Goldi” to feature in JGJ’s name if the basis for the collaboration was merely the BA.
- [100]
[100] Fourth, in his email dated 5 July 2017, Jim asked Amit to comment on matters relating to what to tell AT Adler (JGJ’s auditors) in relation to JGJ’s accounts for FY2016, and on whether JGJ could be classified as a procurement company rather than a trading company. On 6 July 2017, Jim told a tax consultant, Jeffrey Sacks (“Sacks”) that he had spoken to Amit and that Amit had no problems with control being located in Bangkok and JGJ being classified as a procurement company. Amit’s involvement in the decisions relating to JGJ supports the fact that JGJ was asset up pursuant to the JV.
- [101]
[101] Fifth, in August 2017, Rahul told the Kriss Brothers that he was terminating the JV (see [27] above). Himanshu S. Mehta (“Himanshu”), a consultant to the JDM Entities, attended the meeting as a translator for the Kriss Brothers. Himanshu testified that there was a heated discussion and Rahul said “we can just bankrupt [JGJ]”. I accept Himanshu’s evidence. His evidence was not shaken during cross-examination. Rahul’s statement showed that he treated JGJ as a company under the JV; there was no reason for him to make that statement if JGJ were merely a company set up by the Kriss Brothers for their own purposes.
Transfer of back-office functions of JDM Entities and JGJ to India
- [102]
[102] In April 2015, the bookkeeping, accounting and other back-office functions (collectively, the “back-office functions”) of JGJ and the JDM Entities (to the extent the functions could be carried out in India) were transferred to and undertaken by a team employed in India by TJCI. The team was based in TJCI’s premises. Approximately 40% of the employees of the JDM Entities in New York, with accounting and/or managerial responsibilities, were terminated in connection with this move.
- [103]
[103] I reject the SRK Entities’ claim that the transfer of JGJ’s and the JDM Entities’ back-office functions to a team employed by TJCI was done pursuant to the BA. Under the purported BA, SRK was simply a seller of diamonds and diamond jewellery to JGJ. TJCI was (and remains) a company within the SRK group. It is illogical that, in the context of the purported BA, the Kriss Brothers would have agreed to the back-office functions (which included the accounts) of not only JGJ, but the JDM Entities as well, being undertaken by a team employed by TJCI in India.
- [105]
[105] Whether the team handling the back-office functions in India reported to and took instructions from the Kriss Brothers or Amit was disputed. I find that the team reported to and took instructions from Amit for the following reasons:
(a) Vikas was employed by TJCI as an accountant for the JV after being interviewed by Amit and Rahul; he confirmed that he took instructions from Amit and Nirav, and subsequently from Vibhor (after Vibhor was appointed as CFO).
(b) In an email dated 30 January 2017, Vikas sought Amit’s approval for the payment of a bill from KPMG. The fact that Vikas sought Amit’s approval is all the more significant because the bill was sent to Vikas by a JDM employee.
(c) When Amit instructed one Mr Tetsu Takahashi (a JDM employee) to add JGJ to the JDM system so that orders could be processed and goods could be shipped to JGJ, he also instructed Vikas to provide the address.
- [106]
[106] In any event, it still does not make commercial sense for the Kriss Brothers to have agreed to the back-office functions being handled by TJCI employees in India even if they took instructions from the Kriss Brothers, unless the parties were operating on the basis of the JV.
JDM’s and JGJ’s accounts in IDBNY were controlled by representatives from JDM and SRK
- [107]
[107] The setting up of JGJ’s IDBNY Account and the persons who were authorised to operate JDM’s and JGJ’s IDBNY accounts point to the existence of the JV rather than the BA.
- [108]
[108] It is common ground that the collaboration between the parties started on 1 April 2015. On 14 May 2015, Jim sent documents to the Israel Discount Bank in New York for the opening of JGJ’s IDBNY Account. His email said “J.G. Jewelry, Inc. is a 50/50 venture between Michael & David Kriss and SRK Diamonds”. Although the email referred to “J.G. Jewelry, Inc.”, it is clear that Jim was referring to JGJ; the email attached corporate resolutions of JGJ. It is also clear that the reference to a venture between the Kriss Brothers and SRK was a reference to the JV.
- [109]
[109] In May 2015, JGJ’s IDBNY Account was set up. The authorised signatories comprised representatives of the SRK Entities and the JDM Entities. They were Amit, Ashish, Jim, David and Michael; any one of them could authorise payments to be made from the account. The Kriss Brothers could not have agreed to Amit and Ashish being given the authority to make payments from the account to the SRK Entities unless the parties were operating on the basis of the JV. Under the purported BA, JGJ was just a buyer of diamonds and diamond jewellery from SRK. It is unthinkable that in the context of the purported BA, the buyer (JGJ) would have authorised representatives of the seller (SRK) to make payments from the buyer’s account to the seller.
- [110]
[110] Nirav’s explanation was that one of the key features of the purported BA was a two-step process for the payment of the invoices issued by SRK/TJCI to JGJ (the “Two-Step Payment Process”). According to him, the Two-Step Payment Process worked as follows:
(a) Vikas would review invoices from SRK/TJCI. Upon his approval, Vikas would set up a payment request for payment of the invoices to be made from JGJ’s IDBNY Account.
(b) After the payment request was set up, the payment could be released by any one of the holders of the security tokens issued by IDBNY. The holders of the tokens were Amit, Ashish, the Kriss Brothers, Jim, Ajay Matta, Vikas and Brady D’Elia (“Brady”). Brady was the manager of MG Worldwide.
- [111]
[111] Nirav claimed that the purpose of the Two-Step Payment Process was twofold – first, to ensure timely payments of SRK’s and/or TJCI’s invoices, and second, to ensure that the Kriss Brothers or their representatives had their desired degree of control over the payments to be made by JGJ to SRK/TJCI.
- [112]
[112] Amit adopted Nirav’s evidence relating to the Two-Step Payment process. Rahul disclaimed any involvement in or knowledge of the details of the payment mechanism concerning the purported BA.
- [113]
[113] I reject Nirav’s and Amit’s claims relating to the Two-Step Payment Process. In my view, the claims are contrived.
(a) First, Vikas testified that generally, he would prepare the payment instructions under the direction of Amit and/or Nirav. Vikas’ testimony contradicted Nirav’s claim that Vikas would set up the payment instruction after reviewing and approving the invoices from SRK/TJCI. I have no reason to doubt Vikas’ testimony.
(b) Second, the persons who held the tokens for JGJ’s IDBNY Account were Amit, Ashish, the Kriss Brothers and Jim. Contrary to Nirav’s assertion, Ajay Matta, Vikas and Brady did not hold tokens for JGJ’s IDBNY Account.
(c) Third, Nirav’s assertion that the Two-Step Payment Process was to ensure timely payment is illogical. Under the alleged Two-Step Payment Process, Vikas had to review and approve the invoices. This meant that the timeliness of payment on SRK’s and TJCI’s invoices was dependent on Vikas. Timely payment could not be ensured since, according to Amit, Vikas was a representative of the Kriss Brothers and/or the JDM Entities.
(d) Fourth, there was no reason for JGJ (as the buyer) to authorise representatives of the seller to release payments from JGJ’s account to the seller.
- [114]
[114] Vikas also testified that when he received a request from Amit for funds, he had to first initiate a payment from JDM’s account in IDBNY to JGJ’s IDBNY Account; the payment from JDM’s account to JGJ’s IDBNY Account would be approved by Ashish. Ashish also approved payments to be made from JGJ’s IDBNY Account.
- [115]
[115] The fact that Vikas took instructions from Amit/Nirav to prepare payment instructions and that Ashish could approve payments from JDM’s and JGJ’s accounts can only be explained if the parties were operating on the basis of the JV instead of the BA.
The JV was announced or made known to third parties
- [116]
[116] On 15 January 2015, Amit sent the Kriss Brothers an email (copied to Nirav and Ashish), saying that they should start having a conversation on, among other things, how to “announce the JV to customers”.
- [117]
[117] On 30 January 2015, Amit sent an email to the Kriss Brothers, attaching draft announcements to customers and the industry. The draft announcements referred to JDM having “tied up with … SRK in a Joint Venture”, and to TJCI/SRK having “tied up with … Instock Programs and entered into a Joint Venture with them.”
- [118]
[118] In his AEIC, Amit asserted that while he used the term “joint venture”, this was in fact a reference to the BA. I do not believe Amit’s assertion. His assertion is inconsistent with his own description of the draft announcement as one of the documents that was prepared in anticipation of the potential JV. Further, the contents of the draft announcement clearly did not reflect the terms of the BA (see [55] above).
- [119]
[119] On 18 February 2015, Amit sent an email to one Ms Stephanie Lawler informing her that “TJC and SRK group have recently entered into a joint venture with Instock programs”. Ms Lawler was from Zales, a major jewellery retailer that was also a client of the JDM Entities.
- [120]
[120] On 8 June 2015, one Julius Kassar from TJCNY wrote to Ms Rachel B Leinwand and Ms Jelena Stojanovic, stating that Instock and TJCNY “now are a merged company”. Ms Leinwand and Ms Stojanovic represented buyers who were customers of TJCNY. Subsequently, Amit was copied in the chain of emails. On 9 June 2015, Amit wrote to Ms Leinwand and Ms Stojanovic stating that “we have just recently entered into a joint venture with Instock”.
- [121]
[121] On 22 July 2015, Ashish sent an email to one George DeAngelis of “gilbertdisplays” stating: “In-stock & TJC Jewelry are now one entity – we will have a joint booth space next year” [emphasis added]. Amit was also copied on the email and he did not correct Ashish’s email.
- [122]
[122] On 12 October 2016, a team comprising representatives from the JDM and SRK Entities (including Amit and Nirav) made a joint presentation to Signet Jewelers, which is one of the world’s largest retailers of diamond jewellery. The PowerPoint presentation showed the logos of SRK, Instock Programs, MG Worldwide, and TJCI on the very first slide, and showcased these entities. In addition, one of the topics covered was “Corporate Organization / JV”.
- [123]
[123] Amit, Nirav and Rahul claimed that they had used the term “joint venture” or “JV” in their emails and documents loosely and that they meant to refer to the BA. I find these claims too incredible to be believed. Further, as will be seen later, I find that the BA is a concoction (see [155] below).
Insurance policies were combined
- [124]
[124] On 19 April 2016, Jim emailed Amit stating that JDM’s insurance policy (“JDM’s Jeweler’s Block Policy”) would now also cover routine consignment shipments from SRK to TJCNY; Amit confirmed the coverage value of US$10m. Jim also liaised with the JDM Entities’ insurers for credit insurance to add certain SRK and/or TJCI sales onto the portfolio from 2016 onwards.
- [125]
[125] Credit insurance was obtained on a combined policy basis for the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities, after Amit gave his approval on 8 January 2017, after having run it by Rahul.
- [126]
[126] There was no reason for the combined policies or for Amit/Rahul to approve the same unless the parties were operating on the basis of the JV. Certainly, there was no reason for the combined policies under the purported BA.
Parties engaged Advaita Legal to draft a joint venture agreement
- [127]
[127] The parties engaged a law firm in India, Advaita Legal, to prepare a joint venture agreement. On 30 June 2016, Advaita Legal sent an engagement letter to JGJ in which it stated that JGJ “ha[d] approached [Advaita Legal] for assistance in drafting a Joint Venture Agreement or a Shareholders’ Agreement”.
- [128]
[128] On 19 July 2016, Advaita Legal sent the “first draft of the JV agreement” to Amit and Michael. The draft agreement listed the Kriss Brothers, Amit, Nirav as “JV Parties” and JGJ as “the Company”. It is not clear why Advaita Legal listed the individuals but it is not disputed that the intention was for the entities (rather than the individuals) to be the parties to the JV.
The Volume Rebate Agreements are consistent with the JV
- [129]
[129] On 22 February 2017, Jim informed Vibhor, Amit and the Kriss Brothers that the then practice of “billing the NY entities at 90% of the sale price” was not sufficient to cover the expenses of the New York companies, and that they needed to “decide on how to recoup a significant amount of funds from [JGJ]” before JGJ’s financials were presented to the accountant. Jim also said that he had spoken to Sacks, who saw no problem in JGJ reporting a loss. As an interim measure, Jim proposed volume rebate agreements between the parties that would reduce the amounts that the JDM Entities had to pay JGJ.
- [130]
[130] By 27 February 2017, Volume Rebate Agreements had been signed between JGJ and JDM, MG Worldwide, AP Jewelry and TJCNY.
- [131]
[131] On 1 March 2017, Vibhor sent an email to Jim; one of the points that he raised was his belief that the adjustment “will only be for the purpose of statutory filings in NY for accounting books and no effect will be given in the system inventory valuation, otherwise it may impact to our MIS profitability also”. “MIS” referred to the management information system.
- [132]
[132] There was no reason for Jim to involve Vibhor and Amit on the intercompany billings between JGJ and the JDM Entities or the proposal to improve the bottom lines of the New York companies by charging operating expenses to JGJ, unless the parties were operating on the basis of the JV.
- [133]
[133] Further, if SRK and TJCI were merely selling diamonds and diamond jewellery to JGJ, the Volume Rebate Agreements would surely have caused Amit concern since they negatively impacted JGJ’s financial position and ability to make payment. Yet, Amit raised no objections to the Volume Rebate Agreements. In his oral testimony, Amit claimed not to be aware that the Volume Rebate Agreements resulted in credit notes being given to the JDM Entities and TJCNY. I do not believe Amit’s denial of knowledge. Jim’s email dated 22 February 2017 (see [129] above) was addressed to Amit as well and Amit remained copied in the subsequent email chain. Further, a Volume Rebate Agreement was also entered into with, and a credit note issued to, TJCNY. Amit must have been aware of this.
Balance sheets were prepared on the basis of the JV
- [134]
[134] On 2 May 2016, Vibhor sent Michael (copying Amit and Nirav) the following documents:
(a) An “Accounting Manual/Understanding description for JV Accounting As on 30-4-2015” (the “Accounting Manual”).
(b) A balance sheet template showing, among other things, capital balances of the parties. The explanatory note in the Accounting Manual for the capital balances stated as follows:
- [135]
[135] The Accounting Manual recognised that contributions to capital could be in cash or by way of contributions in kind, eg, “assets/inventory”. The balance sheet template was intended to contain information relating to (among other things) capital balances. This template was used for various balance sheets that were circulated subsequently.
- [136]
[136] On 6 July 2016, Vibhor sent Jim the balance sheets for “the JV entities” for his review. The balance sheets included:
(a) A “Consolidated Joint Venture Balance Sheet” as of 31 March 2016, which showed the capital balances of the “SRK Group” and the “JDM Group” at US$10,609,207.38 and US$22,908,945.38 respectively.
(b) Balance sheets as of 31 March 2016 for entities within the “SRK Group” and the “JDM Group”.
- [137]
[137] On 1 August 2016, Vibhor sent to Jim and Michael, copying Nirav and Vikas, the “Draft Consolidated MIS Balance Sheet as on 31 Mar 2016” and the balance sheets for the various entities, for Michael’s and Jim’s review. The consolidated balance sheet shows the capital balances of the “SRK Group” and the “JDM Group” at USD2,416,091.30 and USD21,785,920.93 respectively.
- [138]
[138] On 12 May 2017, Vibhor sent updated estimated balance sheets of various entities as of 14 October 2016 to Vikas and Jim, copying Amit, Nirav and Michael. Jim used these balance sheets to prepare a document titled “Equity Input to JV by Michael & David Kriss”. The document recorded the sum of US$7,744,446.60 being due to each of Michael and David.
- [139]
[139] On 11 September 2017, Vikas sent SRK’s financial data (which he received from Amit/Nirav) to Michael for his review. Nirav confirmed that the data was prepared by Mr Rajiv Shah (“Rajiv”)) on his instructions. Rajiv was SRK’s CFO. The attachments sent by Vikas comprised the following:
(a) The opening balance sheet as of 1 April 2015 for TJCNY, TJCI and SRK, and transactions for the capital account during the period from 1 April 2015 to 21 August 2017.
(b) The balance sheet as of 31 August 2017 for TJCNY, TJCI, SRK and JGJ, and the transactions for the capital account during the period from 31 May 2017 to 21 August 2017.
The balance sheets show the “capital balances” for each of the entities in both their regular accounts as well as their “B” books. Ajay Matta explained that the “B” books were in respect of cash trades that did not appear in the regular accounts. Transactions for the capital accounts included capital injections and withdrawals/transfers. In particular, the capital injections confirm that the SRK Entities were injecting capital into the JV.
- [140]
[140] On 27 September 2017, Ajay Matta sent an email to Mr Anish Mehta (“Anish”). Anish was from BSR & Associates LLP (“BSR”), an external consultant firm engaged to provide tax and regulatory services (see [151] below). The subject of the email was “JV Summary Sheet”. The documents attached to the email (the “JV Computations”) included the following table:
- [141]
[141] The fact that “SRK Group Profits” were to be paid to JGJ is proof that the parties were operating on the basis of the JV since the SRK Group was sharing its profits with JGJ. Also attached to the email was a computation of SRK’s profits in its “A” and “B” books, of which a total amount of about US$20.5m was described as “JV Profit[s]”. This supported the amount of US$20.5m to be paid to JGJ from “SRK Group Profits” in the table above.
- [142]
[142] The deduction of US$25.62m attributed to “SRK Group A/P” meant that SRK Group’s accounts payable were credited to the SRK Group as its contribution to the JV. I agree with JGJ’s submission that this shows that SRK’s goods were supplied as capital.
- [143]
[143] The table above shows that (according to the JDM Entities) a net balance of US$16.35m was due to the Kriss Brothers. Rajiv (SRK’s CFO) made various adjustments to the computations and on 5 October 2017, Rajiv sent to Anish and Nirav the “final working along with reconciliation of profit claimed by JGJ group” and asked Anish to forward it “for their review”.
- [144]
[144] Rajiv’s computations show a net balance amount of US$5.91m as “Balance belongs (sic) to SRK Group towards capital introduced”. Nirav confirmed that he added the words “Balance belongs to SRK Group towards capital introduced” and that this was the “capital balance for SRK”. Rajiv did not dispute the inclusion of “SRK Group Profits” or “SRK Group A/P” in the JV Computations. In fact, Rajiv reduced the amount of “SRK Group Profits” (payable to JGJ) from US$20.51m to US$17.19m. As discussed earlier, the fact that SRK Group profits were payable to JGJ is proof that the parties were operating on the basis of the JV, and the inclusion of SRK Group’s accounts payable in the computations shows that SRK’s goods were supplied as capital.
- [145]
[145] As requested by Rajiv, Anish forwarded Rajiv’s computations to Ajay Matta, describing the computations as a “re-working of profit of JV”. Anish also explained that Rajiv’s computations included (among other things) TJCI’s losses, differences in exchange rates used, addition of closing stock, change in valuation of closing stock form book value to market value and “[c]apital introduction by Singapore JV Partner …”.
- [146]
[146] Ajay Matta replied, enclosing his calculations which stated that the net amount payable to SRK was US$0.58m.
- [147]
[147] The balance sheets and the JV Computations prove that the parties were operating on the basis of the JV. Nirav also confirmed that the JV Computations showed the amount that JDM had to pay to SRK “[f]or goods we supplied”. Nirav’s evidence confirms that the goods supplied by SRK to JGJ were not meant to be paid as invoiced. Although Nirav claimed that the goods were supplied under the purported BA, he eventually conceded that the computations were not consistent with the purported BA.
Parties engaged KPMG’s and BSR’s services with respect to the JV
- [148]
[148] On 20 January 2016, Amit sent an email to KPMG stating that he had discussed with Michael and David and they needed “help in inventory management process”. Amit asked KPMG for a proposal for inventory flow and management, including “[h]ow to separate old co inventory with new co” and processes to “easily identify and reconcile the inventory separately”. As JGJ submits, this shows that the parties had merged their inventory and were seeking KPMG’s help to properly account for the inventory that had been injected into the JV.
- [149]
[149] On 16 March 2016, Vibhor sent KPMG the names of the entities to be incorporated in the engagement letter. These entities include the JDM Entities, the SRK Entities and JGJ (which the Kriss Brothers claim to be the parties to the JV) and Jewel-Lux Mfg. Group Co. Ltd (“Jewel-Lux”). Jewel-Lux was a factory in Bangkok that Michael used for research and development. According to Michael, Jewel-Lux was a contractor to the JV and was not a party to the JV.
- [151]
[151] Amit and Michael asked BSR to (among other things) undertake a “jurisdiction evaluation of Hong Kong vis a vis Dubai in comparison to Singapore” and an “evaluation of shareholder structure of such proposed HK/Dubai Company”. The evaluation of the shareholder structure was to include an evaluation as to whether the shareholder of the HK/Dubai company “should be US Shareholder directly or through existing Singapore/UK Company.”
- [152]
[152] On 25 October 2016, BSR sent to JGJ an engagement letter for tax and regulatory services. Paragraph 2.1.2 of the letter described part of BSR’s work as “undertaking jurisdiction analysis of the preferred jurisdiction (i.e. UAE and HK) considering the commercial and business aspect, in compare [sic] to Singapore JV structure”. Michael’s unchallenged explanation was that this was about a restructuring of the JV because SRK had a tax problem.
Amit appointed a CFO for the JV
- [153]
[153] On 26 February 2016, Vibhor sent an email to various Instock personnel and Ashish to introduce himself. In his email, Vibhor said he joined “TJC SEEPZ Mumbai” on 15 February 2016 as CFO. Amit testified that Vibhor was part of the team handling the back-office functions of JGJ and the JDM Entities.
- [154]
[154] Amit claimed that it was Michael who hired Vibhor. Michael testified that Vibhor was hired by Amit as CFO for the JV. I accept Michael’s version. It is more probable that Amit was the one who hired Vibhor. After all, although he handled the back-office functions, Vibhor was formally employed as CFO of SRK and he was paid by SRK. Further, in his email to the Kriss Brothers dated 25 August 2015, Amit had attached a draft of the roles and responsibilities of “KEY individuals of the JV”. In that draft, one of Amit’s roles was to appoint a CFO for the JV.
The BA is a concoction
- [155]
[155] I find that the BA is nothing more than a concoction by the SRK Entities.
- [156]
[156] First, SRK has adduced no evidence of when the negotiations for the BA took place. There is also no discussion of the BA or its terms in the correspondence between the parties. Amit tried to explain that he only started using the expression “business arrangement” after learning, as a result of S 418, that the expression “joint venture” could have legal implications. However, Amit’s evidence does not explain why the correspondence between the parties referred to or were consistent with terms of the JV rather than terms of the purported BA.
- [157]
[157] Second, Rahul confirmed that the invoices issued by the SRK Entities were issued pursuant to the purported BA. Yet, the demand letter dated 1 March 2018 from SRK’s lawyers, K Ashar and Co, to JGJ for payment of the invoices made no mention whatsoever of the BA.
- [158]
[158] Third, under the purported BA, SRK was to sell diamonds and diamond jewellery to JGJ and JGJ would in turn sell the same to companies controlled and/or owned by the Kriss Brothers (see [55(b)] above). Yet, in SRK’s invoices, SRK was charging JGJ based on prices that were discounted against the end customer’s selling prices. In other words, SRK invoiced JGJ at prices discounted against the JDM Entities’ selling price to their customers (“Sell-Minus Pricing”). This pricing approach is completely incompatible with the alleged BA, which involved a straightforward sale by SRK to JGJ. It is illogical that in a straightforward sale, SRK sell its goods to JGJ at prices that are discounted against the JDM Entities’ selling price to their customers.
- [159]
[159] Fourth, the balance sheets show capital balances for the SRK Entities and the JDM Entities (see [134], [137], [139] above). There would have been no contributions to capital under the purported BA. The JV Computations show that SRK’s and TJCI’s profits were to be shared with the JDM Entities (see [140]–[144] above). The purported BA would not have involved any such sharing of profits as Nirav also confirmed.
- [160]
[160] Fifth, moving the back-office functions of JGJ and the JDM Entities to India to be handled by persons employed by TJCI did not make sense if the parties’ relationship was just that of partners in the purported BA (see [102]–[106] above).
Whether TJCNY was party to the JV
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.