General Division of the High Court · Decided 30 April 2024
Public Prosecutor v CEO
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC 109 · Case no. Criminal Case No 26 of 2023
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The accused is a 45-year-old married man. One night sometime between 2010 and 2011, he found himself in an apartment belonging to a 42-year-old married man (who I will refer to as “T”). The accused had previously met T online on a website known as the Sammyboy Forum (“SBF”), where the accused had started a thread in April 2010 named “Wife Fantasy”. It was not disputed that on the night in question, prior to arriving at T’s apartment, the accused had received a text message from T. The message stated that T’s wife (whom I will refer to as “V”) was drugged, and asked the accused to come over to the apartment. In response, the accused drove over to T’s apartment. T let the accused into the apartment and led him into the master bedroom. There, the accused saw V, who had earlier been drugged by T, lying motionless on the bed. After some time, the accused left T’s apartment.
- [2]
[2] Per the Prosecution’s case, T gave the accused access to his apartment on the night of the alleged offence because there was an agreement between them for the accused to rape V while she was unconscious from being drugged. Pursuant to this agreement, the accused engaged in non-consensual penile-vaginal intercourse with the unconscious V in the master bedroom before he left the apartment.
- [3]
[3] The accused, on the other hand, claimed that there was never at any time a conspiracy between him and T to rape V: instead, he had gone to T’s apartment out of concern for V after being told that she had been drugged. According to the accused, he was at that time already in a consensual sexual relationship with V and thus had no reason to rape her. No sexual intercourse occurred at T’s apartment that night; and the accused did not so much as even touch V. Instead, according to the accused, the following series of events took place while he was in the master bedroom of T’s apartment:
(a) The accused sat down on the side of the bed where V was lying and had a conversation with T;
(b) T suggested that the accused touch V, but the accused rejected this suggestion;
(c) The accused then pretended to stimulate himself by stroking his private parts over his shorts, before signalling to T that he could not get an erection;
(d) T and the accused proceeded to the toilet of the master bedroom where they chatted before the accused left T’s apartment without further incident.
- [4]
[4] The Prosecution charged the accused with one count of abetment by conspiracy with the co-accused T to commit rape under s 375(1)(a) (punishable under s 375(2)), read with s 109 of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) (“the Penal Code”) (“the Charge”). The accused also faced a further eight charges, seven of which related to offences under s 292(1)(a) of the Penal Code, with the remaining charge being an offence under s 30(2)(a) of the Films Act (Cap 107, 1998 Rev Ed). These last eight charges were stood down pending the trial of the Charge.
- [5]
[5] The Charge read:
- [6]
[6] Given the facts admitted by the accused in the agreed statement of facts, the following two issues were central to the determination of the accused’s guilt:
(a) Why did the accused go to T’s apartment on the night in question?
(b) What happened while the accused was at T’s apartment?
- [7]
[7] At the end of the trial, I found that the Prosecution was able to prove its case against the accused beyond a reasonable doubt. On the evidence before me, I was satisfied that the accused went to T’s apartment pursuant to an agreement between them to rape an unconscious V, and this agreement was carried to fruition by the accused engaging in non-consensual penile-vaginal penetration of V. I therefore convicted the accused of the Charge and sentenced him to 13 years’ imprisonment and 12 strokes of the cane.
- [8]
[8] The accused having filed an appeal against both conviction and sentence, I now set out the reasons for my decision.
Background facts
- [9]
[9] The Prosecution and the Defence agreed on the following facts pursuant to s 267(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code 2010 (2020 Rev Ed).
The accused’s online activity
- [10]
[10] On or about 16 April 2010, the accused created an online public message thread titled “Wife Fantasy” on SBF under the forum section “The Asian Commercial Sex Scene”. He used the monikers “Sorros” and “UMIST” to post in this thread. Under the moniker “Sorros”, he posted the following message:
- [11]
[11] Sometime in the year 2010, the accused also communicated privately with T over Skype. T used the monikers “Sick Fark” and “tomwin25”, while the accused used the names “Brad Chan”, “Brad Chan Chan”, and “Bradchan77”. In the course of their communications, T asked the accused to approach V and to ask her out. The precise details of this invitation were a matter of dispute as between the Prosecution and the Defence. However, it was not disputed that the accused agreed to approach V and that T gave him V’s contact details.
The accused’s relationship with V
- [12]
[12] About a month after the accused started communicating with V online, they met in person for the first time for dinner at “Bliss Restaurant” at Punggol Park. After dinner, the accused sent V home. He dropped her off at the base of her block of flats and did not go up to the apartment where T and V were staying.
- [13]
[13] On or about 2 September 2010, the accused met V again, this time at Sushi Tei restaurant at East Coast Parkway. They had lunch there in the afternoon before heading to Goldkist Beach Resort (“Goldkist”) at East Coast Parkway. The accused booked a room at Goldkist, where he and V engaged in consensual penile-vaginal intercourse. Afterwards, the accused sent V home, again dropping her off at the base of her block of flats. The accused continued to chat with V online for some time after this consensual sexual encounter , but did not inform T of his sexual activity with V.
The night of the alleged rape
- [14]
[14] On a date in 2010 or 2011, T sent the accused a message saying that V had been drugged and asking if the accused wanted to come over to T’s apartment. The accused proceeded to T’s apartment.
V’s police report
- [15]
[15] On 2 January 2020, V lodged a police report after finding explicit photos of herself on T’s handphone, including one which showed her lying unconscious with two penises over her face.
- [16]
[16] On 3 January 2020, the police arrested T and seized, among other items, digital storage media containing photographs and videos of T and other men (“the co-accused”) sexually assaulting V, as well as evidence of other offences. On 17 January 2020, the accused was arrested.
- [17]
[17] The accused was examined by a psychiatrist who certified that he was not of unsound mind at the time of the alleged rape, and that he was fit to plead in a court of law. At trial, the accused did not claim to have been suffering from any mental disorder at the time of the alleged rape. The accused was also medically assessed not to be suffering from erectile dysfunction.
The Prosecution’s case
- [18]
[18] Per the Prosecution’s case, the accused engaged in non-consensual penile-vaginal sex with an unconscious V in T’s presence at T’s apartment sometime on or about 14 March 2011. The Prosecution contended that (a) there was an agreement between the accused and T for the former to rape V, and (b) that pursuant to this agreement the accused did have non-consensual penile-vaginal intercourse with V while she was unconscious from being drugged. Further, the Prosecution submitted that no reasonable doubt had been raised by the Defence, and that on the contrary, the accused’s credit should be impeached, and an adverse inference drawn against him for omitting to mention certain aspects of his defence in his Case for the Defence (“CFD”) and in the cautioned statement recorded from him under s 23(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 68, 2012 Rev Ed).
- [19]
[19] Nine witnesses were called by the Prosecution to give evidence in support of its case. I briefly outline below the pertinent evidence.
V’s evidence
- [20]
[20] V testified that she had previously chatted online over Skype with a user whose username included the word “Brad”. V identified the accused as the person behind that username. This was sometime in 2010. At that time, V’s relationship with her husband T was not stable, as she had found out about T having an affair. In response to T’s affair, she had an affair with the accused and met up with him on two occasions.
- [21]
[21] On the first occasion, V and the accused met for dinner at a café at Punggol Park. On that night, V arrived home from dinner at the same time that T returned from work. T asked V whether she had allowed anyone else apart from T to hold her hand. V had the impression that a friend of T’s must have seen her together with the accused. V testified that she could have told the accused about T asking her whether anyone else had held her hand.
- [22]
[22] On the second occasion, V met the accused for lunch at a Japanese restaurant at East Coast Parkway. After lunch , the accused drove V to Goldkist where they engaged in consensual sex. V confirmed that two photographs produced by the Prosecution were photographs of her which had been taken at Goldkist. She remembered that on that day, the accused had taken a photograph of her without her permission after they had sex. She had asked the accused to delete the photograph but did not know if he had in fact done so.
- [23]
[23] V also testified that at one point, she had sent the accused a message saying that during sex with T, she would close her eyes and imagine that she was having sex with the accused instead. According to V, T had never confronted her about this message.
- [24]
[24] Sometime in October 2010, T and V went for a staycation at Marina Bay Sands (“MBS”). T did not confront V about her affair with the accused either during or after the staycation. According to V, aside from having asked her whether anyone else had held her hand, T had never questioned her at any point about an alleged affair. As for her communications with the accused, V did not recall having any conversation with the accused during the staycation about her menstrual cycle and/or plans to have sex for a second time.
- [25]
[25] V testified that there was no second consensual sexual encounter between her and the accused. At the end of 2010, she blocked the accused as a Skype contact because the accused had tried on several occasions to convince her to engage in a “threesome” with him and T, which she understood to mean the three of them having sex together at the same time. V stated that she was “not into” such things, and that a threesome would be the “last thing that [she could] ever think of”. She was able to remember that she blocked the accused in 2010 specifically because by 2011, her relationship with T had improved, and in the later part of 2011, she became pregnant with their third child. V denied that she had met up with the accused on a third occasion and/or that he had driven her to Hougang Mall and then to Fragrance Hotel at Lavender.
- [26]
[26] As for what happened on the night of her third wedding anniversary on 14 March 2011, V testified that she had no recollection of that night.
- [27]
[27] V stated that she only told T about her affair with the accused sometime in 2020, by which time T was already in prison. According to V, she would have told him either by writing him a letter or while visiting him in prison.
T’s evidence
- [28]
[28] T testified as a Prosecution witness. Prior to testifying at the trial, T had pleaded guilty on 4 May 2023 to six charges, including one under s 375(1)(a) p/u s 375(2) r/w s 109 of the Penal Code for abetment by conspiracy with the accused to rape V. Another 11 charges were taken into consideration. He filed an appeal against sentence, which was pending at the time of the present trial (and which has since been heard and dismissed).
T’s initial communications with the accused
- [29]
[29] T recalled getting to know the accused during the period from 2009 to 2010. At that time, T had two accounts on SBF under the names “Newbie2alltis” and “SGJuicyhotMILF”, although the former eventually fell into disuse. He knew the accused by the latter’s online username “Brad”. The two of them first started chatting in SBF under the subject thread “Adult Discussion about Sex”: the accused had approached T after T posted an online thread about “test[ing] out [his] wife” (V) because he (T) suspected her of being unfaithful to him. To show his eligibility as a candidate for “testing” V, the accused messaged T privately on SBF to volunteer information about his car, his job, and his marital status. Based on this information, T selected the accused from amongst a pool of various individuals, for the purpose of “testing” V.
- [30]
[30] The accused and T chatted on SBF about “hot wifeing” and “threesome sex”. According to T, the term “hot wifeing” (which was used on SBF interchangeably with “hot-wifing”) referred to a spouse being romantically involved with another person outside the marriage, with the other spouse’s knowledge, while the term “threesome sex” meant having sex with multiple sex partners at the same time. T came to know that the accused was married, as the accused talked about having a wife whom he referred to as “tua neh neh” – T understood this to mean “big breasts” in Hokkien dialect.
- [31]
[31] From SBF, the accused and T migrated to communicating on MSN Messenger and Skype. T recalled the accused asking him on Skype for photographs and videos of V so that the accused could masturbate. The accused would also send T pictures of a woman’s breasts or of a woman engaging in oral sex, claiming that the woman shown in these images was his wife. The accused would ask T to print out these pictures and to photograph himself masturbating to these pictures.
The accused’s relationship with V
- [32]
[32] Some months after T started chatting with the accused, T chose the accused to “test” V. According to T, the arrangement was that the accused would update T on what happened between him and V, and if at any point T felt uncomfortable, he reserved the right to stop this “testing”. T also insisted that at no point was the accused to influence V into breaking up the family. T provided the accused with details of V’s Facebook account and handphone number, as well as additional details such as her former school, her preferred alcoholic drinks, and other preferences. T did not set any boundaries for what the accused could or could not do with V in terms of sexual intimacy.
- [33]
[33] The accused subsequently informed T that he and V had met up on at least one occasion in Punggol Park, where they had drunk wine, held hands, kissed and hugged. This occurred sometime between February and October 2010. When T heard that the accused had hugged and kissed V, he felt angry, hurt and sad: his “world collapsed”. However, T did not communicate any of this to the accused. During the same period between February and October 2010, T had also consulted friends before suggesting to the accused that he should bring V to Goldkist Resort at East Coast.
- [34]
[34] T was certain that any affair between the accused and V had already ended by 14 March 2011, the date of T’s third wedding anniversary with V and the day of the alleged rape. First, T had logged in to V’s MSN Messenger account before that date and found that V had deleted and blocked the accused’s contact. Second, T recalled having a “confrontation” with V sometime after October 2010, during which he had told V that “somebody in the neighbourhood” had seen her being intimate with another person. This was in fact untrue. T recalled that this confrontation took place a few days after V’s meeting with the accused at Punggol Park, as he had still been on guard duty in camp on the evening when V met up with the accused, and he would only have left camp the morning after. Third, T recalled that the accused had asked him sometime between October 2010 and March 2011 why V had stopped contacting the accused.
- [35]
[35] T also testified that when he logged in to V’s MSN Messenger account, he saw two conversations between V and the accused which were “burned” into his memory. The first conversation involved V and the accused making fun of T’s reaction to seeing a BMW car on an occasion when he was out with V. T testified that he had a reaction to seeing the BMW car because his wife had slept with an ex-boyfriend who also drove a BMW car. The second conversation involved V telling the accused that when T asked her for intimacy, she had initially been reluctant to respond but that she had subsequently had an orgasm after imagining T to be the accused while having sex with T.
- [36]
[36] T also recounted seeing a third conversation between the accused and V in which the two of them talked about whether V’s menstrual cycle had affected her ability to wear a bikini during her staycation with T at MBS. The second and the third conversations led to T forming the suspicion that the accused and V had been sexually intimate: T was especially incredulous that V could have discussed her menstrual cycle with another man whom she was not intimate with.
- [37]
[37] Up to this point, T had not planned with the accused to drug V so that the accused could have sex with her. According to T, somewhere “along the way”, he had actually told the accused that he was not comfortable and was going to “call off everything”. He felt betrayed by the accused and tried to ask the accused whether he had been sexually intimate with V, but the accused did not reply. After T “confronted” V, partial communications resumed between the accused and T: the accused continued to keep mum on the subject of whether he had engaged in any sexual activity with V, but would appear online randomly to ask T what he was doing, what he was planning with other co-accused persons, and what V was doing.
The night of the alleged rape
- [39]
[39] T’s evidence was that he could not remember the specifics of the communications between him and the accused prior to the latter coming to the apartment. However, T affirmed that the two of them had talked online, and that he had likely told the accused about V having been drugged with Dormicum. T believed that there would have been coordination between him and the accused on the night in question, although he could not recall the specific details of that coordination. T also affirmed that the purpose of the accused coming to his apartment was to help T with “what [T] wanted to do to [his] wife” V, which was for her to be raped in retaliation for her having dishonoured him with her infidelity. T explained that this was part of the agenda in his “operation”, as he was inspired by the lyrics of the military song “Purple Light”. According to T, this was a song which included references to the protagonist’s girlfriend being raped “with my buddy and my rifle and myself”: in T’s view, the accused was the “buddy” referred to in the song. T’s evidence was that the accused would have known of his purpose, because T had previously disclosed to the accused his discussions with his other co-accused about using drugs to sedate V. The accused would also have known that V was unconscious on the night when he came over to T’s apartment on 14 March 2011, because there was no other reason why the accused would have appeared at T’s apartment that night.
- [40]
[40] When the accused arrived at T’s apartment, it was around midnight, and the flat was dark when T opened the door to the accused. The accused and T went straight away to the master bedroom, which was illuminated. T’s children and helper were at home at that point in time, but in a separate bedroom. Inside the master bedroom, V was lying naked and blindfolded on the bed. She was unconscious throughout the time that the accused was in the apartment.
- [41]
[41] T testified that he had several distinct memories of the events of that night, from the time when the accused was inside the master bedroom with T and V.
- [42]
[42] First, T remembered being inside the toilet in the master bedroom, looking out from the toilet while smoking , and seeing the accused on top of V in the “missionary position”. This led him to believe that they were having sex. T experienced multiple emotions watching this. He felt anger at his wife for her affair, thrill, and arousal. This feeling of arousal, according to T, was not sexual: rather, it was a sense of “relief of [his] pent-up frustration” against V as a result of having achieved “retaliation” against her. At the end of the night, he also felt guilt for what he had done.
- [43]
[43] Second, T remembered the accused asking him where to dispose of a condom and his telling the accused to flush it down the toilet. This was a condom which the accused had brought along with him to the apartment. It was T who had told the accused that a condom would be needed to “carry out the operation” because V was a hepatitis B carrier and also “very fertile”. In other words, T believed he had told the accused to use a condom when having sex with V that night.
- [44]
[44] Third, after the accused left T’s apartment, T recalled holding the unconscious V, cleaning her up so as to remove any trace of lubricant on her and crying as he did so.
T’s communications with the accused after the night of the alleged rape
- [45]
[45] T testified that he and the accused continued to discuss the above events after 14 March 2011, with the accused continuing to ask T to show him pictures of V. The accused would also “usually” ask T when he would be getting a “resupply” of Dormicum and other drugs such as clonazepam. The latter was understood by T to be a sleeping medication used to drug women so that other men could have sex with them.
- [46]
[46] T was brought through the contents of his conversations with the accused over Skype. Where relevant, I set out below at [138]–[158] and [189]–[195] the details of these conversations.
T’s meetings with the accused after the night of the alleged rape
- [47]
[47] T also testified that following the night of the alleged rape, he and the accused had met up near his workplace at Marina South Pier as the accused had asked T to pass him some sleeping pills. The last time T saw the accused again was when they were both in prison.
T’s communications with V after his arrest
- [48]
[48] As for his communications with V, T testified that sometime in 2020, while he was in prison, V had written him a letter telling him about her previous consensual sexual encounter with the accused.
T’s statements to the police
- [49]
[49] The Prosecution applied under s 161 of the Evidence Act 1893 (2020 Rev Ed) (“EA”) to refresh T’s memory by showing him the recording of his video-recorded interview (“VRI”) with the police on 14 January 2020. Following this, T affirmed the following in court:
(a) After the accused revealed that V had stopped contacting him, T said that he would find a time for the accused to meet V; specifically, by “the drugging drugging way”. The purpose of such a meeting would be for the accused to have sex with V. T believed that this purpose would have been discussed with the accused.
(b) Before the accused’s arrival at T’s apartment on the night of the alleged offence, T had told him about drugging V and had said to him that V was “out” (by which T meant that she was unconscious) and that she was “ready” (by which T meant that the accused could start having sex with her).
- [50]
[50] The Prosecution also refreshed T’s memory by showing T his VRI dated 8 January 2020.
The Prosecution’s cross-examination of T as to his previous statements
- [51]
[51] The Prosecution applied to cross-examine T under s 147(1) of the EA and to substitute part of his previous police statements as evidence under s 147(3) of the EA, on the basis that his testimony in court was inconsistent with the content of those statements. In gist, the areas on which T was cross-examined were as follows:
(b) According to T in his evidence-in-chief, he had administered Dormicum to V by crushing it and putting it inside her wine. In his statements to the police, on the other hand, he had mentioned drugging V by giving her Dormicum in the form of a pill without her knowing what the pill contained, under the guise of administering medicine to her. When confronted with this inconsistency, T maintained the account given in court, as he said he had no recollection of having given V any medication on the night of the alleged offence.
(c) In court, T’s evidence was that he had taken off V’s clothes after drugging her, whereas in his statements to the police he had said that it was the accused who had undressed V. When confronted with this inconsistency, T maintained the account given in court as he could remember taking a picture of V in an undressed state prior to the accused’s arrival at the apartment. This memory was triggered by his recollection of a message sent by him to the accused during one of their online conversations, in which he had shown the accused this particular picture and asked the latter whether he could see it.
- [52]
[52] In relation to (b) and (c), T’s attention was also drawn to the Statement of Facts (“SOF”) which he had admitted to in pleading guilty. This SOF stated that (a) on the night of the alleged rape, T had caused V to consume a sedative drug on the pretext of feeding her medication, and (b) that it was the accused who had undressed V when he came to the apartment. Although T acknowledged the SOF was inconsistent with his account in court, he maintained that his account in court was the correct one. T explained that the version of events stated in the SOF had been based on his statements to the police; and it was only after giving these statements to the police that he recalled the picture he had sent to the accused during their online conversation and thereby realised that the version given in his police statements was incorrect.
- [53]
[53] After hearing T’s explanation, the Prosecution decided not to apply to substitute as evidence those portions of his VRI statements which concerned the issues of how he had given V Dormicum and who had undressed V. The Prosecution initially stated during the trial that it intended to substitute those portions of T’s VRI statements relating to his discussions with the accused on SBF for his oral testimony. Subsequently, however, in their closing submissions, they took the position that T’s evidence on this issue did not involve any material discrepancy. I deal with this issue at [92] below.
The Defence’s impeachment of T
- [54]
[54] In cross-examination, the Defence applied to impeach T’s credit in relation to his oral testimony about (a) how V was drugged, and (b) who undressed V. T agreed that his testimony in relation to these two matters was inconsistent with his VRI statements but offered explanations for the inconsistencies. I deal with this issue at [176]–[188] below.
The accused’s online activity
- [55]
[55] In addition to calling witnesses, the Prosecution adduced screenshots of the accused’s various posts on SBF under the usernames “Sorros” and “UMIST”, dating from 2010 to 2019. The Prosecution also produced records of the accused’s internet search history from 2018 and 2019 which featured numerous pornographic websites. The Defence did not object to the admission of this evidence.
The accused’s communications with T
- [56]
[56] The Prosecution also adduced evidence of the Skype messaging history between the accused and T, between the accused and V, and between T and other co-accused persons. The Defence did not object to the admission of this evidence.
The accused’s statements
- [57]
[57] The Prosecution tendered transcripts of several of the VRI statements given by the accused to the police. The accused was cross-examined on the contents of these statements, and the Prosecution applied to impeach the accused’s credit on the basis of inconsistencies between his testimony in court and his VRI statements.
Other witnesses
- [58]
[58] In addition to the witnesses highlighted above, the Prosecution also called seven other witnesses in support of its case. Where relevant, I highlight their evidence below.
- [59]
[59] I next summarise the case put forward by the Defence at trial.
The Defence’s case
- [60]
[60] The accused did not dispute having gone to T’s apartment on the night of the alleged offence, although he insisted that this had happened in 2010 and not in 2011. He denied having been party to a conspiracy with T to rape V, claiming that he had gone to the apartment on the night in question out of concern for V after being informed by T that she had been drugged.
- [61]
[61] The accused did not call any other witnesses.
The accused’s evidence
The accused’s posts on SBF
T’s invitation for the accused to date V
- [63]
[63] Soon after the accused started the “Wife Fantasy” thread, T privately messaged him, following which the two of them engaged in “some banter talk” and “talking nonsense”. Out of the blue, T asked the accused whether he wanted to try to date T’s wife, V. The accused, thinking that T had a “fetish” for people dating his wife, agreed. T did not tell the accused of any conditions he would be subject to in dating V, nor did T say anything about “testing” V.
The accused’s relationship with V
- [64]
[64] T provided the accused with V’s Facebook account details, after which the accused started chatting to V on Facebook Messenger. A week or two after they started chatting, they met up for a dinner date at a café near Punggol Park. The accused informed T that he was meeting V, and told him about the meeting time and place. The accused claimed that during the date, he and V had “clicked quite well”, and they had kissed in the car before he sent her home.
- [65]
[65] The evening after their date at Punggol Park, V messaged the accused to say that T’s friend had seen V and the accused together, holding hands. Around the same time, T also messaged the accused saying that his friend had seen V and the accused together, holding hands. The accused testified that he replied to T to ask T what he was thinking, because he found it odd that T would confront him about the very thing T had invited him to do. T responded that he had no choice but to confront the accused since his friend had already seen V and the accused together. The accused could not recall whether, in the course of this exchange, he had told T about having hugged and kissed V during their date at Ponggol Park.
- [66]
[66] According to the accused, he and V continued to chat over SMS, and on 2 September 2010, they went on a second date at Sushi Tei East Coast. The accused claimed that after lunch at Sushi Tei, he and V had gone to Goldkist, where they again engaged in consensual sex. The accused did not tell T about this second meeting with V.
- [67]
[67] The accused’s evidence was that after this second consensual sexual encounter, he and V continued to engage in “some romantic talk”, with V confiding in the accused about her family issues. The accused distinctly remembered receiving a message from V in which she told him that she had just had sex with T, that she had been unsure about whether she really wanted sex with T, and that she had closed her eyes and pretended she was having sex with the accused instead.
- [68]
[68] Several days or weeks after the above message, the accused received a Skype message from T asking, “[d]id you have sex with my wife?”, which the accused responded to with a denial. T then sent the accused a screenshot of the above message from V (at [67] above), to which the accused responded by assuring T, “[t]here’s nothing. It’s just romantic talk”. Both T and the accused did not refer to the message from V again and instead continued to “talk nonsense”.
- [69]
[69] A few days later, T sent another message to the accused asking “[a]re you going to break up my family?”. The accused could not recall exactly how he responded to this message. However, he testified that he and T did not get into any argument, as T seemed to accept his assertion that he would not break up T’s family. The accused subsequently stopped communicating with T.
The night of the alleged rape
- [70]
[70] In respect of the night of the alleged rape, the accused maintained that his visit to T’s apartment took place sometime in 2010 and not on 14 March 2011. According to the accused, T’s messages to him (“[d]id you have sex with my wife?” and “[a]re you going to break up my family?”) should have been sent at the end of September 2010 at the latest; and he would have visited T’s apartment within two months of these two messages.
- [71]
[71] The accused testified that on the night in question, he had been home watching television when T – whom the accused had not met in person up till then – suddenly messaged him on Skype something along the lines of “[V] is drugged. Want to come over?”. T also texted the accused his address. At that point, the accused was wondering whether V was high on drugs – and whether she had even been drugged. The accused thought that given the previous messages from T (see [67]–[68] above), there was a good possibility that T wanted to confront both the accused and V about their affair. According to the accused, he did not think there was anything sexual at all about the invitation.
- [72]
[72] Within five minutes of receiving T’s invitation and without asking T any further questions, the accused told his wife he had to attend to business matters and left his house for T’s apartment. The accused’s evidence was that he accepted T’s invitation to go over to his apartment out of “curiosity and concern” for V. He was curious because he did not know what was going to happen out of “so many permutation [sic] that could be happening”. He was concerned because he knew that T was from “the military”, and “if [T] really were to go crazy” over V’s affair with the accused, T could “inflict damage” on V if he was not “controlled”. The accused therefore thought that he should go to T’s apartment to “settle it” through a “conversational” and “amicable” resolution.
- [73]
[73] When the accused reached T’s apartment, T greeted him and opened the door for him. The apartment was dark. T wordlessly led the accused into a room with an attached toilet, which the accused presumed was the master bedroom. In this room, he saw “a body” lying on the bed covered with a duvet or some other object. He assumed that this was V’s body. The accused was “freaking out” at this point. He then sat on the side of the bed sizing up the situation and focusing his attention on T, whom he chatted to about “normal things” in an attempt to “diffuse [sic] the situation”. Both of them spoke softly because – in the accused’s words – “maybe [V] is sleeping or what”.
- [74]
[74] T next suggested to the accused, “you want to touch [V]?”. The accused did not reply. At this juncture, the accused was thinking that he ought not to touch V. At the same time, however, he felt that he could not show that he was indifferent or disinterested towards V because in his view, this would have confirmed T’s suspicion that he was having an affair with V. According to the accused, he had to “try to get out of this situation” by “show[ing] [T] through body language [sic]”, which he did by trying to “stroke” his “private parts” over his clothes , and then giving a “hand signal” (which he demonstrated in court by shaking both hands) to indicate that he could not get an erection. The accused said he was unsure whether T actually saw these actions.
- [75]
[75] Thereafter, T suggested that the two of them go for a “smoke break”. Both T and the accused proceeded to the toilet of the master bedroom, where T smoked and the accused continued to talk with him about “normal stuff”. The accused subsequently went home after telling T he had to leave.
The accused’s communications with T after the night of the alleged rape
- [76]
[76] Following the night of his visit to T’s apartment, the accused continued to stay in touch with T, albeit infrequently, because he was concerned about V and wanted to “make sure everything is okay”. At trial, the accused was brought through his Skype messages with T after the night of the alleged rape: I deal with this evidence in more detail below at [138]–[158] and [189]–[195].
The accused’s relationship with V after the night of the alleged rape
- [77]
[77] As for V, the accused claimed that he and V had re-established communications around the end of 2011 to early 2012, but that they had decided to “stay low” about their relationship because they knew that T was emotionally unstable. The accused also claimed that during this period, he and V had a second consensual sexual encounter which took place at Lavender Fragrance Hotel after a lunch at Hougang Mall. The following day, the accused and V were messaging each other when the accused sent V a message stating “Thanks for the great time yesterday, it was great to have raw sex with you”. Following this, V stopped replying to the accused’s messages. The accused maintained that he did not at any point ask V to join him and T in a sexual threesome.
Screenshots from the accused’s phone
- [78]
[78] The Defence sought to rely on three screenshots of T’s profile page on Facebook which the accused had taken on his mobile phone but which were tendered only midway through the trial. The Prosecution consented to these screenshots being admitted, while noting that these screenshots had been deleted from the accused’s own mobile phone such that it was impossible to determine the date on which they had been taken. These screenshots showed, respectively, T’s Facebook profile picture, a post made by T on 15 March 2011, and a photograph of T and V at the Marina Bay Sands resort (“MBS”) posted by T on 12 October 2010.
The applicable law
- [79]
[79] Having outlined the evidence adduced at trial, I next summarise the relevant legal principles.
The law on conspiracy
- [81]
[81] Proof of conspiracy may be founded on the surrounding circumstances and the conduct of parties before and after the alleged commission of the crime. This is generally a matter of inference, which would be drawn only if it is inexorable and irresistible, and accounts for all the facts of the case (Er Joo Nguang and another v Public Prosecutor [2000] 1 SLR(R) 756 (“Er Joo Nguang”) at [35], Nomura Taiji v Public Prosecutor [1998] 1 SLR(R) 259 (“Nomura Taiji”) at [106]).
- [82]
[82] The mens rea for abetment by conspiracy is that the accused must have “(a) intended to be a party to an agreement to do an unlawful act, and (b) known the general purpose of the common design, and the fact that the act agreed to be committed is unlawful” (Ali bin Mohamad Bahashwan v Public Prosecutor [2018] 1 SLR 610 (“Bahashwan”) at [34], citing Nomura Taiji at [107]–[110]).
- [83]
[83] Although it is not necessary that all the conspirators are equally informed as to the details of the conspiracy, it is essential that there must be a “meeting of minds” so that they are all aware of the general purpose of the plot (Er Joo Nguang at [34]). It is not necessary, however, that the abettor and the person abetted share the same mens rea (Bahashwan at [34]).
The applicability of the unusually convincing standard
- [84]
[84] Insofar as the evaluation of the evidence in this case was concerned, it was not disputed that leaving aside the accused and the unconscious V, T was the only eyewitness to the alleged rape. As such, one of the key questions which I had to consider was whether T’s evidence was uncorroborated and formed the sole basis for a conviction (Public Prosecutor v GCK [2020] 1 SLR 486 (“GCK”) at [89]) – in other words, whether no other evidence was available (Public Prosecutor v Ridhaudin Ridhwan bin Bakri and others [2019] SGHC 105 (“Ridhaudin”) at [113]). In the absence of corroborative evidence, a conviction based solely on an T’s evidence would be unsafe if his evidence were not unusually convincing (AOF v Public Prosecutor [2012] 3 SLR 34 at [173]; GCK at [87]).
- [85]
[85] The “overwhelming consideration” that triggers the application of the “unusually convincing” standard is the amount and availability of evidence (GCK at [90], citing Kwan Peng Hong v Public Prosecutor [2000] 2 SLR(R) 824 at [29]). This standard is a cognitive aid and does not change the ultimate standard of proof required of the Prosecution (Ridhaudin at [112], XP v Public Prosecutor [2008] 4 SLR(R) 686 at [31]; Haliffie bin Mamat v Public Prosecutor and other appeals [2016] 5 SLR 636 at [29]).
- [86]
[86] The corollary of the above principle is that where there is other evidence against an accused person which corroborates an eyewitness’s testimony, this can obviate the need for the application of the “unusually convincing” standard. This evidence can take the form, inter alia, of an accused’s own statements (Public Prosecutor v Yue Roger Jr [2019] 3 SLR 749 (“Yue Roger Jr”) at [74], Ridhaudin at [115] and [116], Public Prosecutor v Yap Pow Foo [2023] SGHC 11 (“Yap Pow Foo”) at [56]), medical reports (Public Prosecutor v Tan En Jie Norvan [2022] SGHC 166 (“Norvan Tan”) at [37]), psychiatric reports (Yue Roger Jr at [75]), other documentary evidence such as emails (Xu Yuanchen v Public Prosecutor and another appeal [2023] SGHC 123 at [108]), expert opinions (Ridhaudin at [115] and [116]), forensic evidence (Norvan Tan at [71], Yap Pow Foo at [56]), and CCTV footage (Ng Kum Weng v Public Prosecutor [2021] SGHC 100 at [44]).
Issues to be determined
- [87]
[87] On the evidence before me, while the Defence disagreed on the precise date, it was not disputed that there was an occasion on which the accused had gone to T’s apartment at night. It was also not disputed that on that occasion T had brought the accused into the master bedroom of the apartment. Further, the accused did not dispute being aware that non-consensual penile-vaginal penetration of V in the manner alleged by the Prosecution would be unlawful if carried out. For the purposes of his defence at trial, however, the accused denied having gone to T’s apartment for a sexual purpose, and he also denied having carried out penile-vaginal penetration of V in the master bedroom on the night in question.
- [88]
[88] The following issues thus had to be determined by the court:
(a) Was there a conspiracy between the accused and T for the accused to rape V?
(b) Pursuant to the conspiracy, did the accused penetrate V’s vagina with his penis without V’s consent?
Whether the accused was party to an agreement with T to rape V
The accused and T discussed “wife sharing” and “drugging” prior to the night of the alleged rape
- [89]
[89] In respect of the issue at (a) above (ie, the existence of a conspiracy between the accused and T for the former to rape V), I first considered evidence which showed that prior to the night of the alleged rape, the accused and T had discussed “wife-sharing” and “drugging”. I should make it clear that the evidence of these discussions did not per se constitute direct evidence of an agreement between the accused and T for the former to rape V. Rather, I found that the evidence shed light on the understanding which the accused and T had when they talked about “wife sharing”, and on the accused’s understanding of what T meant when he messaged the accused on the night in question to say that V was “out” and that “it’s ready”. In other words, the evidence of these prior discussions was relevant pursuant to the following provisions in the EA: s 8 (previous conduct), s 9 (facts necessary to explain or introduce a fact in issue – in this case, the existence of an agreement for the accused to have sex with a drugged V in her husband’s presence), and s 14 (knowledge).
- [90]
[90] The evidence of these discussions emanated from the following sources: T’s testimony, T’s VRI statement, the accused’s VRI statements, and the accused’s posts on the SBF forum.
T’s testimony
- [91]
[91] T’s initial account was that he and the accused had not spoken about “wife sharing” and “drugging” while chatting on SBF, and that they had only started talking about these topics when they shifted to communicating on MSN Messenger. After being cross-examined under s 147(1) of the EA (see [51(a)] above), T clarified that it was possible that he and the accused had discussed “wife sharing” (in the sense of a husband sharing his wife with another man for sexual purposes), albeit via the private messaging function on the SBF site rather than in the public forum of SBF. T also testified that he would have discussed the topic of “drugging” and “hot-wifing” with the accused on SBF as well. “Drugging” would refer to a husband rendering his wife unconscious with sedatives so that another man could have sex with her, while “hot-wifing” would refer to a wife getting romantically and sexually involved with another man while being watched by her husband.
T’s VRI statements
- [92]
[92] I agree with the Prosecution that T’s testimony in court (ie, that he had discussed “wife sharing”, “drugging”, and “hot-wifing” with the accused via private messages on SBF) was not materially inconsistent with his VRI statements of 14 January 2020 and 26 May 2020, wherein he had stated that he was “chatting” on SBF with the accused about wife sharing and hot-wifing “initially”, and that subsequently the conversation became “more and more suggestive towards…drugging”. Although in his VRI statement of 26 May 2020 T had mentioned talking with the accused “inside.. a thread” of SBF, rather than via private messaging on SBF, I did not find this potential discrepancy to be material. I should also point out that the Defence failed to suggest any reason why the above evidence in T’s VRI statements should not be believed.
The accused’s VRI statements
- [93]
[93] T’s evidence that he and the accused had discussed “wife sharing”, “hot wifing” and “drugging” prior to the night of the alleged rape was corroborated by evidence provided by the accused himself in his VRI statements.
- [94]
[94] In his VRI statement dated 17 January 2020, the accused stated that he and T had talked about “sexual stuff” and “fetish” “like wife sharing”, when they first met on SBF. Wife sharing, as explained by the accused, was the “sharing of wife and things like that, which…is usually see, see in the porn, porn movies”. It was a “concept”, about which he and T would “just talk la but…execution might not be able to execute”. In fact, as the accused elaborated in his VRI statement dated 20 January 2020, wife sharing was the main topic that led to the accused and T becoming interested in engaging in private conversation with each other on SBF.
- [95]
[95] It should be noted that despite having admitted in his VRI statement that he and T had talked about “wife sharing” on SBF, the accused sought in his later statement dated 20 January 2020 – and subsequently in court – to explain away this admission by claiming that “wife sharing” to him meant merely the sharing of pictures of wives, and that these “could be normal picture[s]” of the wives. This explanation was plainly untenable. In his VRI statement of 17 January 2020, the accused had already described wife-sharing as the sort of “things…usually see [sic] in…porn movies”: “normal” pictures would certainly not be the kind of material “usually” seen in “porn movies”. Further, if wife sharing meant only the sharing of “normal” pictures of one’s wife, there was no reason at all for the accused to have stated that the “execution” of this concept of wife sharing would be difficult for him and T to carry out. It should also be noted that even in his VRI statement of 20 January 2020, the accused described wife sharing as the sharing of pictures “at the initial stage” – which indicated that the concept of wife sharing encompassed more than just the sharing of photographs.
- [96]
[96] In his VRI statements, the accused also volunteered the information that in addition to discussing wife sharing, he and T had talked about the use of drugs ; specifically, the use of sleeping pills. Although the accused initially denied at trial that this portion of his VRI statement was true, he was unable to offer any explanation for why he would have told the police such an untruth in his statement. Tellingly, the fact that the drugs in question were in the form of sleeping pills was disclosed by the accused himself without any prompting from the police officer recording his VRI statement. In cross-examination, the accused eventually conceded that he had indeed talked with T about the use of sleeping pills. I found it significant that the identity of the sedative drug was a fact volunteered by the accused independent of any question from the police officer recording his VRI statements; and I saw no reason why the accused’s account in his VRI statements should not be accepted.
- [97]
[97] The accused’s admission that he and T had talked about the use of sleeping pills in the context of their chats about wife sharing was relevant in establishing the context for his understanding of T’s message inviting him to come over to T’s apartment on the night of the alleged rape.
The accused’s posts on SBF
- [98]
[98] I next considered the accused’s posts on SBF. At the outset, I should make it clear that I accepted the Defence’s submission that the accused’s posts on SBF could not amount per se to evidence of the existence of an agreement or understanding between the accused and T for the former to rape V. However, this did not mean that the accused’s posts on SBF should be entirely ignored. Given the accused’s insistence on explaining the references to “wife sharing” in his VRI statement as being merely references to the sharing by men of “normal” pictures of their wives, his posts on SBF – insofar as they spoke about wife sharing – were useful in elucidating his own understanding of the term. Having considered this evidence, I found the accused’s attempt to describe “wife sharing” as being merely the sharing of “normal” pictures of wives to be highly disingenuous, given the nature of the discussions he himself had engaged in with other users on the SBF thread “Wife Fantasy”.
- [99]
[99] As I noted earlier, “Wife Fantasy” was a thread started by the accused himself on SBF on 13 April 2010. Within this thread, the accused identified himself as being part of a group of “folks” where “a lot of us have fantasies about other’s wife and of their wife being fantasize by others”. He elaborated on this in subsequent posts in response to comments posted by other users in the thread.
- [100]
[100] For example, user “aston68” responded to the accused’s post (“a lot of us have fantasies…”) on 12 April 2010 to say: “Hi Sorros [the accused’s username], I share the same likings for the past many years. One of my fantasies is being in the same room watching 2 to 3 bros doing it with wifey.” User “aston68” then went on to describe in sexually-explicit terms how he would visualise his wife engaged in various sexual acts with different “bros” at the same time. Another user, one “whitebull”, responded to “aston68” on the same day stating that he would be “glad” to turn the latter’s “fantasy into reality” provided the latter’s wife agreed. Other users then chimed in as well, with “geniusme28” stating: “I do fantasise about wife swapping, if she agrees”. The following day (13 April 2010), the accused responded to these comments with a post stating :
I guess most will be just in the fantasy mode as when it comes to the real thing, it takes a big move, so I am thinking of just getting like minded ppl to chat perhaps on a pm and discreet basis and see how we can explore our fantasy further.
[emphasis added]
- [101]
[101] In another user’s reply to the accused’s post, the user stated they were looking for “other couples to soft swing” as they “have hotwife fantasies also and would like to see my current steady gf getting fucked”. On 4 October 2010, the accused also put up a post in the Wife Fantasy thread stating: “So any out there into hotwifing, perhaps we can share pics and videos for a start”.
- [102]
[102] From the accused’s posts, therefore, it was clear that he considered himself part of a group of men who were interested in exploring the sharing of their wives – sexually – with other men. From the accused’s posts, it was also clear that his conception of “wife sharing” involved sharing pictures at the initial stage (“for a start”), before progressing to other ways to “explore [his] fantasy further”. I noted, moreover, that as a matter of linguistics, the accused and other users in the “Wife Fantasy” thread used the term “hot-wifing” interchangeably with the term “wife sharing”. It appeared to me highly implausible that the former term “hot-wifing” would have been used by the accused and the other users in the “Wife Fantasy” thread purely in the sense of sharing “normal” photographs of each other’s wife. In court, the accused was unable to provide any evidence or to point to any portion of the SBF posts to substantiate his assertion that his comments about wife sharing on SBF were restricted to sharing “normal pictures”.
- [103]
[103] I pause here to reiterate that I referred to the evidence of the accused’s posts on SBF for context, in terms of how the concept of “wife sharing” would have been understood by the accused. I did not consider these posts to be proof per se either of the existence of a conspiracy between the accused and T, or of the actual commission of rape in furtherance of that conspiracy. The accused’s posts on SBF did not specifically refer to V and did not expressly articulate how the “exploration” of “wife sharing” fantasies would be taken “further”: as I noted above, the accused himself suggested to “like minded” users that to “explore [their] fantasy further”, they should chat with him “on a pm and discreet basis”.
- [104]
[104] The Prosecution also sought to rely on certain comments about “drugging” which were posted by the accused on SBF subsequent to the night of the alleged rape. On 16 February 2012, the accused posted on the Wife Fantasy thread on SBF:
- [105]
[105] The accused also asked others in a thread titled “Mi Jian Drugged Rape” asking “Any have such fantasy? PM me to chat more” in 2015, and started a separate thread on SBF with the title “Drugged Fantasy” in 2018.
- [106]
[106] While it might be argued that such posts demonstrated familiarity on the accused’s part with the modus operandi of rape alleged by the Prosecution, having regard to their content, I did not think that they carried any substantive probative weight in respect of the Charge against the accused. These posts could not be said to be probative of the accused’s familiarity with the modus operandi of V’s rape at the time of the alleged offence.
- [107]
[107] In sum, I found that the accused and T did in fact talk about “wife sharing” during their initial private communications on SBF; further, that the accused understood “wife sharing” to mean a husband arranging for another man to “share” his wife in the sense of carrying out sexual acts with her. Per the accused’s own account of his discussions with T, the two of them also talked about the use of sleeping pills in the context of “wife sharing”. Against the backdrop of their communications on SBF, T’s message to the accused on the night in question, stating that V was drugged (which message the accused did not dispute receiving), could only have been understood by the accused as referring to the drugging of V in the context of wife sharing.
The accused had an interest in wife sharing which involved V and T specifically
- [108]
[108] Next, I considered evidence which showed that the accused had an interest in wife sharing which involved T and his wife V specifically.
- [109]
[109] As a preliminary point, I noted that the accused had acknowledged in his VRI statements and at certain points in cross-examination that he had a wife sharing “fetish” in general. It appeared to me, however, that the Prosecution, the police and the accused himself were using the label “fetish” in a rather loose sense, to mean something along the lines of a strong interest. I did not understand them to be using the term in the sense of a fetishistic disorder amounting to a recognised mental disorder. To avoid unnecessary confusion, for the purposes of the present grounds, I have not used the label “fetish” to describe a strong interest in wife sharing.
- [110]
[110] I should make it clear as well that while in his VRI statements and in cross-examination, the accused did appear to acknowledge having a strong interest in wife sharing in general, this evidence was not per se probative of the existence of an agreement between the accused and T for the former to rape the latter’s wife. All that such evidence showed at best was that the accused had certain sexual tastes which were not in accordance with conventional social norms and mores – which could not be relevant to proving the charge that he had conspired with T to rape V.
- [111]
[111] On the other hand, evidence that the accused had an interest in wife sharing specifically involving T and his wife would be relevant under s 8 and/or s 9 and/or s 11 EA, as such evidence would shed light on the accused’s understanding of T’s communications with him on the night of the alleged rape and his reason for making his way to T’s apartment that night.
V’s evidence
- [112]
[112] In this connection, V’s evidence pointed to the accused displaying an interest in not just having sex with V, but in having sex with her in the presence of her husband T. V testified that she had blocked the accused on social media in 2010 because he had tried several times to ask her whether she could ask T to join in a sexual threesome with her and the accused.
- [113]
[113] Having had the opportunity to observe V in the witness stand, I found V’s evidence to be cogent and reliable. V was able to signpost the date on which she had blocked the accused by reference to events in her relationship with T, and significantly, the (undisputed) dates of birth of her children. The Defence did not raise any objections to the internal consistency of V’s account of events; and overall, I was satisfied that her account was internally consistent. There was no suggestion by the Defence either that she had any motive to lie.
- [114]
[114] As to the external consistency of V’s evidence, the only argument put forward by the Defence concerned the question of a second consensual sexual encounter between V and the accused. I did not find this argument to be of any assistance to the Defence’s case. First, and in any event, I did not find the accused’s assertion of a second consensual sexual encounter to be credible. His assertion was unsupported by any documentary evidence: as he himself conceded, the 2012 Citibank credit card statement he sought to rely on did not prove that there had been a second consensual sexual encounter at Fragrance Hotel in Lavender Street, because on his own evidence, he had used cash to pay for the hotel room. Based on his own evidence, all that the 2012 Citibank credit card statement showed was that he had used his Citibank credit card to pay for a meal at a Japanese restaurant in Hougang Mall: it did not support his assertion that V too had attended this lunch, much less that she had accompanied him to Fragrance Hotel thereafter for a sexual tryst. I also did not believe the accused’s claim that he was only able to request the statements from Citibank at a late stage of the proceedings, after filing his Case for the Defence, because it only occurred to him to request these particular statements after he saw the 2011 Citibank statements produced by the Prosecution in the Agreed Bundle. As the Prosecution pointed out in cross-examination, he alone would have been in a position to know if he had used his Citibank credit card at all in the course of the alleged second consensual sexual encounter: there was no reason why he would have needed his memory jolted by the sight of the 2011 Citibank card statements in the Agreed Bundle.
- [115]
[115] Second, and more fundamentally, on the Defence’s own case, the accused’s claim about the second consensual sexual encounter was only of consequence in showing (purportedly) that V was wrong about the exact point in time when she cut off contact with the accused – the accused’s position being that she had cut off contact with him at a later point in time than the date she gave in court. However, this point was ultimately irrelevant to the Charge against the accused. In attempting to discredit V’s testimony as to when she cut off contact with the accused, the Defence appeared to have misapprehended the Prosecution’s position. The Prosecution’s case was not that the accused was incentivised to commit the alleged rape because he could not get V to consent to a threesome with T. Instead, per the Prosecution’s case, the accused’s suggestion to V of a threesome constituted evidence that he harboured a specific sexual fantasy involving sex with V in the presence of her husband T. The real relevance of V’s testimony about cutting off contact with the accused thus lay in the reason she gave for cutting off contact: namely, the accused’s attempts to persuade her to agree to a threesome with him and T. In this connection, even if V might have been mistaken about the exact date on which she blocked the accused, there could be no dispute that she did in fact block the accused. Although the accused denied that V blocked him because of his attempts to get her to agree to a threesome with him and T, he was unable to suggest any plausible alternative reason for why she would have blocked him.
- [116]
[116] For completeness, I would add that I did not give any weight to the email notifications of the Facebook message put forward by the Defence during the trial. Although the Defence tried to suggest that this email notification showed that V could only have blocked the accused on Facebook on 26 December 2014, they elected not to pursue this point in their closing and reply submissions. In any event, this evidence was not put to V when she was in the witness stand, despite her having denied knowing the email identities referred to in the email notification. The accused conceded, moreover, that the name used in the email address shown in this Facebook notification was not one which he had ever used to communicate with V.
- [117]
[117] In sum, therefore, I accepted that there was evidence to show the accused had a specific sexual interest, not just in having sex with V, but specifically in doing so in the presence of her husband T.
T communicated to the accused that V was drugged
- [118]
[118] As the next building block in its case on the existence of a conspiracy, the Prosecution relied on the evidence that T had, on the night of the alleged rape, informed the accused about V having been drugged. The Defence did not dispute that on the night in question, the accused did in fact receive a message from T stating that V had been drugged and inviting the accused to come over to T’s apartment.
T’s evidence
- [119]
[119] In relation to what he told the accused on the night of the alleged rape, T affirmed the following after having his memory refreshed by reference to his VRI statement dated 14 January 2020:
(a) After the accused stopped meeting up with V, T told the accused that he would arrange for the latter to meet up with her by “the drugging, drugging way”.
(b) T told the accused that he was “testing out” the use of sedative drugs on V.
(c) The purpose of arranging for the accused to meet V was so that the accused could rape her while she was drugged and unconscious; and this purpose was discussed with the accused.
(d) On the night in question, the accused was aware that T had drugged V.
(e) Upon reaching the location of T’s block of flats on the night in question, the accused texted T, whereupon T told the accused that he could come up to T’s apartment.
- [120]
[120] In court, T testified that on the night of the alleged rape, after V became unconscious, he told the accused that “she was out and it’s ready”: by “out”, T meant that V was unconscious; and by “ready”, he meant that the accused could start having sex with her. T also told the accused about his discussions with other co-accused persons in which they had spoken about using drugs to sedate V.
- [121]
[121] The Defence argued that T’s testimony could not be relied on as evidence of a “pre-arrangement” between him and T prior to the alleged rape. For one, according to the Defence, the above testimony was inconsistent with certain portions of T’s VRI statements to the police. I found this argument misconceived because those portions of the statements relied on by the Defence for this argument were taken out of context. T’s statement that he did not plan to drug V so that the accused could have sex with her actually related to the point in time when T first found out about the accused’s consensual sexual encounter with V from reading the chats between the two of them : this was obviously at a point of time prior to the night of the alleged rape. The Defence conceded as much in court.
- [122]
[122] The Defence also argued that the portions of T’s statements relied on by the Prosecution should be “discounted” because they were based on leading questions by the recording officer; T’s responses were by way of non-verbal cues (nodding), and T was not subjected to cross-examination during the VRI statement-recording. I did not find any merit in this argument. Clearly, T was willing to affirm the relevant portions of the statements in court during examination-in-chief (see [49] above): he elaborated on the answers given in his VRI statement, including the non-verbal responses, and his evidence in court was subjected to cross-examination by the Defence.
- [123]
[123] I also rejected the Defence’s argument that T’s inability to remember the exact details of his invitation to the accused on the night of the alleged rape rendered his evidence unreliable. For the Prosecution to prove the charge of conspiracy against the accused, it was not necessary that they be able to prove every single detail of the communications between the accused and T on the night in question: it sufficed for the Prosecution to establish that the communications from T to the accused contained enough information to enable the latter to know the “general purpose of the plot” (Nomura Taiji at [110]) and to form the intention to be party to an agreement with T to have sex with V while she was unconscious. In this connection, as seen at [49], [51], [91] and [119], T gave evidence that prior to the night of the alleged offence, he and the accused had discussed wife-sharing and the use of sleeping pills; he had told the accused that he would be “testing out” the use of these sedative drugs on V; and he had also told the accused that he would arrange for the latter to meet with V by the “drugging way”. T also testified that on the night in question, he told the accused that V was “out”, meaning that she was unconscious, and that “it’s ready”, meaning that the accused could start having sex with her.
The accused’s VRI statements
- [124]
[124] T’s testimony was corroborated by evidence provided by the accused himself in his own VRI statements. In his VRI statements, the accused admitted on multiple occasions that he thought T had invited him to his apartment because he wanted the accused “to have a sexual relationship with [V]”, specifically to have sex with V in T’s presence. He also knew at the time he went to T’s apartment that T had used some kind of sleeping pill to drug V.
- [125]
[125] In court, the accused initially affirmed these statements, but later disavowed them. He claimed that at the point when T invited him to come over to the apartment, he did not know “whether it’s for something sexual”; and it was only after he arrived at the apartment that he realised that “maybe” T expected “sexual things” to happen, because T asked him if he wanted to touch V. He also claimed that he did not actually remember if T had told him about using sleeping pills.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.