Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 30 Apr 2024
Contents

General Division of the High Court

Wong Ben and others v The WatchFund Ltd and another

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHC 110Case no. Suit No 532 of 2021

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] For the horology enthusiast, watches are more than timekeeping devices or fashion accessories. They represent the intricate craftsmanship and art of watchmakers who have trained for years to perfect their craft. There are others, however, who consider watches as a lucrative investment.

  3. [2] Central to the present dispute is an investment scheme involving high-end luxury watches. The plaintiffs are parties associated with a Hong Kong-registered company, Innovest Financial Group Limited (“Innovest”), which provides financial advisory, asset management and succession planning services. The plaintiffs had entered into investment agreements with the first defendant, a Hong Kong-registered investment vehicle. The first defendant is operated by a Singaporean director, who is the second defendant. Pursuant to those agreements, the plaintiffs were to purchase a number of luxury watches from the first defendant, on the condition that after a period of time, the first defendant would offer to re-purchase those watches from the plaintiffs at a markup. The plaintiffs have now brought claims for fraudulent and negligent misrepresentation as well as breach of contract. There is also a further issue of whether the corporate veil should be lifted to hold the second defendant responsible for the liabilities that may be imposed on the first defendant in this suit.

  4. [3] After considering the evidence and the parties’ submissions, I dismiss the plaintiffs’ claims for fraudulent and/or negligent misrepresentation but find the first defendant liable to the plaintiffs for breach of contract. I decline to lift the corporate veil of the first defendant to hold the second defendant personally responsible for the first defendant’s liabilities.

  5. Facts

  6. The parties

  7. [4] The first to fourth plaintiffs – Mr Wong Ben, Dr Liew Edmund Ket Vui (“Dr Edmund Liew”), Mr Wong Tim Fuk Gary (“Mr Gary Wong”) and Mr Wong Nga Kok respectively – are Hong Kong citizens. Mr Wong Ben, Dr Edmund Liew and Mr Wong Nga Kok were clients of Innovest. Mr Gary Wong was not a client of Innovest, as far as the present dispute is concerned, though he was the one who had introduced the second defendant to Mr Fung Ka Lok Adams (“Mr Jowin Fung”), the chief executive officer (“CEO”) and vice-chairman of Innovest, in mid-2016. The fifth plaintiff, MCA Limited, is a company registered in Hong Kong, and a wholly-owned subsidiary of Innovest. Mr Jowin Fung is also the CEO of MCA Limited.

  8. [5] The first defendant – The WatchFund Limited (“WatchFund HK”) – is a Hong Kong-incorporated private company. The second defendant – Mr Dominic Khoo Kong Weng (“Mr Dominic Khoo”) – is a Singapore citizen who is the sole director and sole shareholder of WatchFund HK. Mr Dominic Khoo is also associated with The WatchFund Pte Ltd (“WatchFund SG”), a Singapore-registered company.

  9. [6] Mr Wong Ben and Mr Gary Wong had previously invested with WatchFund SG, with Mr Dominic Khoo signing the investment agreements for and on behalf of WatchFund SG. WatchFund SG is not a party to the present suit. References in this judgment to “WatchFund investment scheme” are to be taken as references to the WatchFund investment vehicles in general, without limitation as to which particular WatchFund vehicle (WatchFund HK or WatchFund SG) is involved.

  10. Background

  11. Introduction of the WatchFund investment scheme to Innovest

  12. [7] The first of the plaintiffs to encounter Mr Dominic Khoo was Mr Gary Wong. Mr Gary Wong was introduced to Mr Dominic Khoo in mid-2015 by a mutual friend, and the parties had discussed the WatchFund investment scheme.

  13. [8] Thereafter, according to Mr Jowin Fung, Mr Gary Wong introduced Mr Dominic Khoo to officers from Innovest and MCA Limited sometime in mid-2016. These officers were Mr Jowin Fung, Mr Kenneth Li (then the executive vice-president of business development of Innovest) and Mr Yu Lok Man (“Mr Leon Yu”) (then the vice-president of Innovest). Following these introductions, Innovest and Mr Dominic Khoo had further discussions to explore the possibility of providing the WatchFund investment scheme to Innovest’s clients. Separately, Innovest also conducted due diligence on WatchFund HK and Mr Dominic Khoo, which included web searches and reference checks.

  14. [9] Sometime in 2016, Innovest and Mr Dominic Khoo struck a deal for Innovest’s clients to invest in the WatchFund investment scheme. At this time, WatchFund SG was the adopted investment vehicle. For the purpose of helping Innovest to refer its clients to the WatchFund investment scheme, Mr Dominic Khoo sent a deck of marketing slides, referred to by the parties as the “2016 Investment Proposal”, to Innovest. In 2018, Mr Dominic Khoo further sent an updated copy of the marketing slides (the “2018 Investment Proposal”) to Innovest. These 2016 and 2018 marketing slides will be collectively referred to as the “2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals”. Relatedly, Mr Dominic Khoo had also sent his curriculum vitae (“CV”) to Innovest.

  15. Pre-dispute investment agreements

  16. [10] Innovest introduced Mr Wong Ben to the WatchFund investment scheme in 2016. According to Mr Wong Ben, he attended a presentation on the WatchFund investment scheme at Innovest’s office, where he was shown the 2016 Investment Proposal and Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV. Mr Gary Wong gave evidence that in 2016, he separately met up with Mr Dominic Khoo and Mr Dominic Khoo promoted the WatchFund investment scheme to him. Mr Gary Wong deposed that Mr Dominic Khoo had orally explained the WatchFund investment scheme and also provided the 2016 Investment Proposal to him. Mr Gary Wong clarified that he liaised with Mr Dominic Khoo personally, and was not a client of Innovest in relation to the WatchFund investment scheme.

  17. [11] Mr Wong Ben and Mr Gary Wong thereafter entered into multiple investment agreements with WatchFund SG. These investments are not the subject of the present suit, and these pre-dispute investment agreements will be referred to as the “Pre-Dispute IAs”. The broad structure of these investment agreements was as follows:

  18. (a) The investor would invest moneys in WatchFund SG.

  19. (b) The investor had to pay an investment fee to WatchFund SG for the investment services provided.

  20. (c) Using the invested moneys, Mr Dominic Khoo, as director of WatchFund SG, would use his connections to purchase luxury watches for the investor, at prices allegedly much lower than their recommended retail prices (“RRPs”).

  21. (d) The watches would be held by the investor for an investment period of up to a year (the “Investment Period”).

  22. (e) WatchFund SG, before the expiry of the Investment Period, would provide a re-purchase offer to the investor to allow the investor to sell the watches back to WatchFund SG at a profit.

  23. [12] Mr Wong Ben entered into four Pre-Dispute IAs between 9 November 2016 and 31 May 2018. He paid amounts ranging from HKD$1,144,500 to HKD$4,279,800 per investment agreement, totalling HKD$10,021,137, to WatchFund SG. As for Mr Gary Wong, he entered into five Pre-Dispute IAs between 31 October 2016 and 22 January 2018. He paid amounts ranging from HKD$1,141,623.20 to HKD$3,258,987.20 per investment agreement, totalling HKD$9,734,620.40, to WatchFund SG.

  24. [13] Within the Investment Period, Mr Wong Ben and Mr Gary Wong received notices (referred to by the parties as “recall confirmations”) from WatchFund SG to re-purchase the watches, and the watches were delivered by them to WatchFund SG. Mr Wong Ben and Mr Gary Wong testified that these Pre-Dispute IAs were performed and completed.

  25. Disputed investment agreements

  26. [14] The investment agreements in dispute in the present suit were entered into from September 2018 to August 2019.

  27. [15] According to the plaintiffs, at various times in 2018, Mr Wong Ben, Mr Wong Nga Kok and Dr Edmund Liew attended investment presentations in Innovest’s office concerning the WatchFund investment scheme, conducted by Innovest personnel. They allege that the 2018 Investment Proposal and Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV were shown at these investment presentations. Mr Gary Wong deposed that he continued to meet with Mr Dominic Khoo separately in late 2018, and that Mr Dominic Khoo gave him the 2018 Investment Proposal and Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV. Separately, there is a further investor in the WatchFund investment scheme, Ms Yung Choi Ha (“Ms Yung”), who claims that she was introduced to the WatchFund investment scheme by a company related to Innovest, and that she had dealt through this related company. Ms Yung gave evidence that Mr Jowin Fung and another Innovest employee attended at her office sometime in 2019 to give her a presentation on the WatchFund investment scheme. According to her, the 2018 Investment Proposal and WatchFund HK’s website were shown to her at this meeting.

  28. [16] The plaintiffs and Ms Yung entered into investment agreements with WatchFund HK. The broad structure of these disputed investment agreements (“Disputed IAs”), which form the subject of this suit, was similar to that of the Pre-Dispute IAs outlined at [11] above.

  29. [17] The plaintiffs assert that after the various Disputed IAs were entered into, Mr Dominic Khoo personally delivered the watches to the respective investors for them to hold for the Investment Period. This is not denied by Mr Dominic Khoo, save that he denies ever meeting Ms Yung.

  30. Closure of WatchFund HK’s bank accounts

  31. [18] Mr Dominic Khoo gave evidence that on 30 August 2019, WatchFund HK received a letter from its Hong Kong bank (“DBS HK”) informing them of the bank’s decision to close WatchFund HK’s bank accounts on 30 September 2019.

  32. [19] According to Mr Jowin Fung, between August and September 2019, cash of approximately S$2m held in WatchFund HK’s DBS HK accounts were transferred by Mr Dominic Khoo into his personal bank account.

  33. Re-purchase offers and cancellations

  34. [20] The plaintiffs gave evidence that near the end of the Investment Period for the Disputed IAs, either they or Innovest had sent chasers to Mr Dominic Khoo by e-mail and WhatsApp asking for re-purchase offers to be made. Between September 2019 and March 2020, Mr Dominic Khoo e-mailed Innovest and Mr Gary Wong with re-purchase offers. Re-purchase offers were made in relation to all the Disputed IAs except for the Disputed IA with Ms Yung. Innovest (on behalf of their clients and MCA Limited) and Mr Gary Wong stated their acceptance of the re-purchase offers.

  35. [21] However, Innovest, Mr Gary Wong and Mr Dominic Khoo then got into an apparent dispute as to: (a) whether the respective investors had to pay a sale fee (the “Sale Fee”) to WatchFund HK before the re-purchase was processed; (b) whether Mr Dominic Khoo was entitled to insist that the Sale Fee be paid to his personal bank account instead of WatchFund HK’s corporate bank account without providing an accompanying board resolution from WatchFund HK authorising this mode of payment; and (c) whether WatchFund HK or the investors were responsible for making arrangements to return the watches to WatchFund HK. The dispute was not resolved, and between October 2019 and February 2020, Mr Dominic Khoo e-mailed Innovest and Mr Gary Wong purporting to cancel the re-purchase offers that were made.

  36. [22] The details of the Disputed IAs and the re-purchase offers made are summarised as follows:

  37. This has been left intentionally blank.

  38. Preparing for the present suit

  39. [23] Mr Wong Ben, Mr Wong Nga Kok and Dr Edmund Liew authorised Innovest to deal with the defendants on their behalf in resolving this dispute. As for Ms Yung, she assigned her rights and interests under her Disputed IA dated 22 August 2019 to MCA Limited, and handed over the watches under that investment agreement to MCA Limited. She was paid RMB2,200,000 by MCA Limited in consideration for the assignment.

  40. Issues

  41. [24] The plaintiffs have brought three broad claims, giving rise to the following issues:

  42. (a) Firstly, are the defendants liable for fraudulent and/or negligent misrepresentation in relation to the Disputed IAs?

  43. (b) Secondly, are the defendants liable for breach of contract in relation to the Disputed IAs?

  44. (c) Thirdly, in the event that liability is found on the part of WatchFund HK for either, or both, of the claims in (a) and (b) above, should the corporate veil be lifted to render Mr Dominic Khoo liable for the liabilities of WatchFund HK?

  45. Claims for fraudulent and/or negligent misrepresentation

  46. Parties’ cases

  47. Plaintiffs’ case

  48. [25] The plaintiffs claim that the defendants had made a series of representations to the plaintiffs fraudulently and/or negligently, and have thereby committed the torts of fraudulent and/or negligent misrepresentation. In this regard, they assert two main sets of alleged misrepresentations.

  49. [26] The first set of alleged misrepresentations is referred to as the “Documentary Representations”. These comprise representations made in the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals, online interviews given by Mr Dominic Khoo to news outlets, WatchFund HK’s website and Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV. The contents of these representations are summarised below at [45].

  50. [27] The plaintiffs submit that the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals were prepared by Mr Dominic Khoo, who then provided them to Innovest, Mr Gary Wong and MCA Limited’s representatives. Mr Dominic Khoo had also provided his CV to Innovest via e-mail. It is the plaintiffs’ submission that Mr Dominic Khoo had sent copies of the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals and his CV to Innovest with the intention that Innovest would share these documents with its clients for the purpose of inducing them to invest in the WatchFund investment scheme. Thereafter, Innovest had shared the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals, Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV and WatchFund HK’s website with Mr Wong Ben, Dr Edmund Liew, Mr Wong Nga Kok and Ms Yung to market the WatchFund investment scheme.

  51. [28] The second set of alleged misrepresentations are referred to as “Oral Representations”. The contents of these representations are set out below at [46]. The plaintiffs claim that these Oral Representations were made by Mr Dominic Khoo when he met the plaintiffs and Ms Yung to deliver their watches to them after they had executed their Disputed IAs with WatchFund HK. In addition, for Mr Gary Wong and MCA Limited, the plaintiffs pleaded that the Oral Representations were also made by Mr Dominic Khoo before they executed their Disputed IAs, when Mr Dominic Khoo met Mr Gary Wong and MCA Limited’s representatives. I note that in the plaintiffs’ closing and reply submissions, they attempted to shift away from their pleaded case by submitting that the Oral Representations were also made to Mr Wong Ben and Dr Edmund Liew before they entered into their Disputed IA. This account is not pleaded. In the interest of fairness, I hold the plaintiffs to the case that they have pleaded.

  52. Defendants’ case

  53. [29] The defendants argue that the plaintiffs have failed to prove that the defendants made the Documentary and Oral Representations to the plaintiffs and Ms Yung, or that these representations were fraudulent or negligent.

  54. [30] The defendants argue that the Documentary Representations were not made by the defendants to the plaintiffs or Ms Yung. This is because the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals and Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV were never sent directly to the plaintiffs or Ms Yung by the defendants. The defendants also assert that there is no proof that the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals were prepared by the defendants, and that Innovest or its affiliates may have created their own presentation decks on the WatchFund investment scheme.

  55. [31] Moreover, the defendants contend that the plaintiffs have not proven that they had relied on or were induced by the Documentary Representations to enter into the Disputed IAs.

  56. [32] In relation to the content on WatchFund HK’s website, the defendants contend that there is no evidence that the defendants showed the plaintiffs or Ms Yung the said website to induce them to execute the Disputed IAs. The plaintiffs and Ms Yung had either searched and found the website on their own accord or received the link from Innovest’s representatives. As for the online interviews given by Mr Dominic Khoo to media organisations, the defendants submit that the plaintiffs’ evidence in this regard was bereft of details.

  57. [33] Specifically concerning the Oral Representations, the defendants contend that these could not be relevant for the claim of misrepresentation mounted by Mr Wong Ben, Mr Wong Nga Kok and MCA Limited (as Ms Yung’s assignee), as Mr Dominic Khoo only met Mr Wong Ben and Mr Wong Nga Kok after they had executed their Disputed IAs. Ms Yung had also confirmed that she had never met Mr Dominic Khoo prior to the execution of her Disputed IA. The defendants argue that Mr Wong Ben and Mr Gary Wong could not have relied on the Oral Representations, as they had decided to invest with WatchFund HK on their own accord due to the successful investments they previously had with WatchFund entities.

  58. [34] The defendants also argue that the plaintiffs and Ms Yung conducted their own due diligence on the WatchFund investment scheme, and that if the plaintiffs and/or Innovest as their investment manager had failed to appreciate certain information, there would be a break in the chain of causation which absolved the defendants of liability.

  59. [35] Even if the Oral and Documentary Representations were made, the defendants submit that the plaintiffs have failed to demonstrate how the representations were fraudulent and/or negligent misrepresentations. In particular, the defendants point out that Mr Wong Ben’s own evidence was that Mr Dominic Khoo had made similar oral representations to him in relation to the Pre-Dispute IAs. Hence, Mr Wong Ben’s decision to invest with WatchFund HK after successfully reaping the benefits of his previous investments means that the “similar” Oral Representations which were made to Mr Wong Ben are not fraudulent and/or negligent.

  60. [36] The defendants object to the plaintiffs’ submission that the defendants failed to provide brand new watches, as this was not pleaded by the plaintiffs.

  61. [37] The defendants further contend that the plaintiffs and Ms Yung failed to prove the falsity of the representations regarding the RRPs of the watches, and that the plaintiffs have failed to prove that they suffered loss from the defendants’ alleged wrongdoing. They emphasised that the plaintiffs have tendered only two Excel sheets and unverified WhatsApp messages as proof of their alleged loss. In this regard, the defendants highlighted that on 23 November 2022, they had filed a Notice of Non-Admission to the first Excel sheet presented by the plaintiffs as evidence of their loss, on the basis that the maker of the Excel sheet would not be testifying. The defendants hence argue that the plaintiffs had ample opportunity to rectify this deficiency but chose not to do so.

  62. The law

  63. [39] The elements of the tort of fraudulent misrepresentation are undisputed, and were restated in IM Skaugen SE and another v MAN Diesel & Turbo SE and another [2018] SGHC 123 (“IM Skaugen SE”) at [121], citing IM Skaugen SE and another v MAN Diesel & Turbo SE and another [2016] SGHCR 6 (“IM Skaugen SE (SGHCR)”) at [65], which in turn referred to the Court of Appeal decision in Panatron Pte Ltd and another v Lee Cheow Lee and another [2001] 2 SLR(R) 435 at [14], as follows:

  64. [40] Given the gravity of the allegation of fraud, a relatively high standard of proof is required for the court to be satisfied that fraudulent misrepresentation is established. Hence, “cogent evidence” is required (Fuji Xerox Singapore Pte Ltd v Mazzy Creations Pte Ltd and others [2021] SGHC 193 (“Fuji Xerox”) at [50]).

  65. [41] The elements of the tort of negligent misrepresentation are also undisputed. These elements were restated in IM Skaugen SE at [121], citing IM Skaugen SE (SGHCR) at [66], which in turn referred to the Court of Appeal decisions of Fong Maun Yee and another v Yoong Weng Ho Robert [1997] 1 SLR(R) 751 at [52] and Spandeck Engineering (S) Pte Ltd v Defence Science & Technology Agency [2007] 4 SLR(R) 100, as follows:

  66. [42] For a statement to constitute an actionable misrepresentation, it must be a statement of a present fact. This would exclude statements as to future intention, predictions, statements of opinion or belief, sales puffs, exaggerations and statements of law (Deutsche Bank AG v Chang Tse Wen [2013] 1 SLR 1310 (“Deutsche Bank AG”) at [93]).

  67. Analysis

  68. [43] In my judgment, the plaintiffs’ claims for fraudulent and/or negligent misrepresentation must fail. The torts of fraudulent misrepresentation and negligent misrepresentation share these common elements: (a) a false representation of fact; (b) inducement and reliance; and (c) damage to the plaintiff (see IM Skaugen SE at [122]–[123] and [127]). In this case, the plaintiffs have failed to prove elements (a) and (c), in that the plaintiffs have not established on the balance of probabilities that the defendants had made false representations of fact or that the plaintiffs had suffered damage. This leaves the plaintiffs’ claims for misrepresentation dead in the water.

  69. What are the alleged representations put in issue?

  70. [44] Before I examine the merits of the plaintiffs’ case on the alleged representations, I first consider which alleged representations were put in issue by the plaintiffs. It is trite that pleadings “delineate the parameters of the case” and “define the issues before the court and inform the parties of the case that they have to meet”. Parties are, therefore, “bound by their pleadings and the court is precluded from deciding on a matter that the parties themselves have decided not to put into issue” (V Nithia (co-administratrix of the estate of Ponnusamy Sivapakiam, deceased) v Buthmanaban s/o Vaithilingam and another [2015] 5 SLR 1422 at [36] and [38]).

  71. [45] In their closing submissions, the plaintiffs submit that they and Ms Yung had relied on all the Documentary Representations, and in particular, the following:

  72. (a) Mr Dominic Khoo had close connections with luxury watch manufacturers, brands, retailers and distributors, such that he could purchase watches from them when others could not (the “Documentary Close Connections Representation”).

  73. (b) With these close connections, Mr Dominic Khoo could buy high-end luxury watches retailing at twice the Investment Cost, such that the watches were held by investors as double-collateral (the “Documentary Double-Collateral Representation”).

  74. (c) WatchFund HK “would purchase the investors’ watches at more than 50% discount off the current published recommended retail price” (the “50% Discount Representation”).

  75. (d) Investors “will receive” an e-mail from WatchFund HK within one year of entering into the investment agreements to sell the watches at a net profit (the “One Year Sale Representation”).

  76. [46] In addition, the plaintiffs submit that Mr Dominic Khoo had made the following Oral Representations to them and Ms Yung:

  77. (a) Mr Dominic Khoo was a luxury watch expert; he was only one of four qualified luxury watch experts in Asia, a shareholder of four Swiss watchmakers and had previously worked for the renowned Antiquorum auction house (the “Luxury Watch Expert Representation”).

  78. (b) Due to the connections from Mr Dominic Khoo’s aforesaid positions, he was able to obtain luxury watches at lower prices for his investors to profit when the watches were later sold to buyers under the WatchFund investment scheme run by him (the “Oral Close Connections Representation”).

  79. (c) The watches which were purchased by Mr Dominic Khoo using the investors’ money and delivered to each of the investors for them to hold had RRPs of at least double the amount of money invested by each of the investors with WatchFund HK (the “Oral Double-Collateral Representation”).

  80. (d) Mr Dominic Khoo had a network and connections, and a long waiting list of buyers to purchase the watches obtained by the investors under his WatchFund investment scheme (the “Many Buyers Representation”).

  81. (e) If Mr Dominic Khoo did not have a buyer for a watch, he would not use the investors’ money to buy the watch for the investors to hold first (the “Ready Buyer Representation”).

  82. [47] In the plaintiffs’ closing submissions, they further allege that the defendants had represented that the watches would be purchased brand-new (the “Brand-New Watches Representation”) and that the watches would be bought from the actual watch manufacturers, brands, distributors or retailers (the “Source Representation”).

  83. [48] The Brand-New Watches Representation and the Source Representation are, however, not pleaded by the plaintiffs. As regards the former, simply reproducing the terms of the Disputed IAs does not suffice. Paragraph 42 of the plaintiffs’ Statement of Claim is the only paragraph mentioning the delivery of the watches in “brand-new condition” via a reproduction of clause 4.1 of the Disputed IAs. Clause 4.1 states that WatchFund HK “warrant[ed] that the timepieces are genuine products of the corresponding manufacturer, and delivered in a brand-new condition”. However, paragraph 81 of the Statement of Claim makes it clear that the plaintiffs’ pleaded representations do not include paragraph 42 of the Statement of Claim. Similarly, the Source Representation is not pleaded. In fact, there is no mention at all in the Statement of Claim that the watches would be purchased from “manufacturers, brands, distributors or retailers”. As the plaintiffs have not pleaded either representation as part of their case, they are precluded from relying on them.

  84. [49] I turn to consider the alleged representations pleaded by the plaintiffs.

  85. Were the pleaded representations made by the defendants and relied upon by the plaintiffs?

  86. (1) Documentary Representations

  87. [50] I first consider the Documentary Representations. The defendants do not dispute that the contents of the Documentary Representations were contained in the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals and Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV. It is helpful at this juncture to set out where precisely each representation is found.

  88. [51] The Documentary Close Connections Representation can be found in the following statements in the following documents:

  89. (a) 2016 Investment Proposal:

  90. (b) 2018 Investment Proposal:

  91. (c) Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV:

  92. [52] The Documentary Double-Collateral Representation and the 50% Discount Representation can be found in the following statements in the following documents:

  93. (a) 2016 Investment Proposal:

  94. (b) 2018 Investment Proposal:

  95. (c) Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV:

  96. [53] The One Year Sale Representation can be found in the following statements in the 2018 Investment Proposal:

  97. [54] Based on the evidence before me, I am persuaded that the pleaded representations were made by the defendants and relied upon by the plaintiffs and Ms Yung. The plaintiffs and Ms Yung have all given evidence that they had seen and relied on the Documentary Representations when entering into the Disputed IAs. Mr Wong Ben, Dr Edmund Liew and Mr Wong Nga Kok gave evidence that they had relied on the written representations found in, inter alia, the 2018 Investment Proposal, Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV, online interviews and WatchFund HK’s website in entering into the Disputed IAs. Mr Gary Wong and Mr Jowin Fung (who was one of MCA Limited’s representatives for entering into MCA Limited’s Disputed IA) gave evidence that they had relied on, inter alia, the written representations found in the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals, online interviews and WatchFund HK’s website when entering into the Disputed IAs. Ms Yung gave evidence that she relied on, inter alia, the written representations found in the 2018 Investment Proposal, online interviews and WatchFund HK’s website when entering into her Disputed IA. The plaintiffs and Ms Yung further affirm that WatchFund HK’s website repeated the written representations found in WatchFund HK’s 2018 Investment Proposal. Mr Wong Ben and Mr Gary Wong, who had seen the 2016 Investment Proposal, also gave evidence that WatchFund HK’s website repeated the written representations found in WatchFund HK’s 2016 Investment Proposal.

  98. [55] Further, I note that the contents of the Documentary Representations were from sources emanating from the defendants, such as the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals, the WatchFund HK website, Mr Dominic Khoo’s CV and online interviews that the plaintiffs assert they had seen. I note further that the contents of the Documentary Representations are in the same nature as the Oral Representations, and consistent with the sales pitch for WatchFund HK. I also have no reason to doubt the broadly consistent stance taken by the plaintiffs’ witnesses in relation to the representations that were made to them as part of the promotion of the WatchFund investment scheme. Accordingly, I find that the defendants had made the Documentary Representations to the plaintiffs and Ms Yung, and that the plaintiffs and Ms Yung had relied on them when entering into the Disputed IAs.

  99. (A) Whether direct transmission of representations to representee is required

  100. [56] The defendants’ rebuttal is that the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals were “given to Innovest as marketing materials for Innovest to refer clients to The WatchFund” and were not sent directly by WatchFund HK or Mr Dominic Khoo himself to the plaintiffs or Ms Yung. This argument of the defendants is misconceived. As noted by the court in United Overseas Bank Ltd v Lippo Marina Collection Pte Ltd and others [2023] 4 SLR 202 at [109], citing Gary Chan Kok Yew & Lee Pey Woan, The Law of Torts in Singapore (Academy Publishing, 2nd Ed, 2016) at para 14.016, the false representation need not be made directly to the plaintiff “[as] long as the defendant intended the misrepresentation to be communicated to the plaintiff, through a third party”. This conclusion was not disturbed on appeal.

  101. [57] In this present matter, it is Mr Dominic Khoo’s own evidence that the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals were given to Innovest “as marketing materials for Innovest to refer clients to The WatchFund”. He also confirmed on the stand that his CV and WatchFund HK’s website were provided to Innovest for a similar purpose. The necessary inference is that WatchFund HK and Mr Dominic Khoo had intended for Innovest to convey the Documentary Representations to Innovest’s clients, such as the plaintiffs and Ms Yung, so that they could be persuaded and induced to enter into the Disputed IAs. As for the representations found on WatchFund HK’s website, whether the website was accessed by the plaintiffs and Ms Yung themselves, or shown to them by Innovest or by the defendants, the outcome is no different since those representations were made to the world at large, including the plaintiffs and Ms Yung.

  102. (B) Whether Innovest made their own marketing materials for the WatchFund investment scheme

  103. [58] The defendants pleaded that Innovest had created their own separate set of presentation slides concerning the WatchFund investment scheme, which Innovest used when marketing the scheme to its investors. On the defendants’ case, this meant that it was Innovest, and not the defendants, that made the representations regarding the WatchFund investment scheme to the investors. The defendants adduced in evidence two sets of slides after the commencement of the trial. The first set of “WClub slides” were slides that were provided by the defendants to their counsel. The plaintiffs did not object to their authenticity and contents. The second set – known as the “Chinese slides” – were slides that had been disclosed by the claimant in HC/OC 184/2022 Tse Siu Hang v The WatchFund Limited & Anor. The defendants rely on the Chinese slides only for context, to show that Innovest had prepared its own marketing materials in relation to the WatchFund investment scheme beyond what the defendants had supplied to Innovest, and not for their content. The plaintiffs did not object to the Chinese slides being used for cross-examination on that basis. However, the plaintiffs assert, in rebuttal, that Innovest did not create a separate version of WatchFund HK’s slides for distribution or presentation to their clients. The plaintiffs gave evidence that the WClub slides never went beyond the draft stage and were never shown to Innovest’s clients.

  104. [59] There is no evidence before me that the WClub slides or the Chinese slides were used to market the WatchFund investment scheme to the plaintiffs or Ms Yung. According to Mr Jowin Fung, the WClub slides were never shown to anyone except Innovest’s internal staff, as these were draft slides that were not yet ready for presentation to clients. As for the Chinese slides, he testified that these were the mandarin translations of the WClub slides, which were also not yet ready for use. During cross-examination, the first to fourth plaintiffs denied seeing the WClub slides prior to trial, Mr Wong Ben and Dr Edmund Liew further testified that they had not seen the Chinese slides prior to trial, while Ms Yung stated that she could not remember if the Chinese slides were the slides used when Innovest representatives gave the presentation on the WatchFund investment scheme to her.

  105. [60] Even taking the defendants’ case at its highest and assuming that the slides were used, the defendants have not shown how the contents of those slides were different from the contents of the 2016 and 2018 Investment Proposals. The defendants’ claim that Innovest, and not the defendants, made the representations to the plaintiffs and Ms Yung, is therefore without merit.

  106. (2) Oral Representations

  107. [61] The Oral Representations can be dealt with quite swiftly. Based on the plaintiffs’ pleaded case, Mr Wong Ben, Dr Edmund Liew, Mr Wong Nga Kok and Ms Yung could not have relied on Mr Dominic Khoo’s Oral Representations because Mr Dominic Khoo had only met them after they executed their Disputed IAs with WatchFund HK. Hence, the plaintiffs’ claims in fraudulent and/or negligent misrepresentation cannot succeed on this basis as there could not have been any reliance on the Oral Representations.

  108. [62] As for Mr Gary Wong and Mr Jowin Fung (a representative of MCA Limited), the evidence, when viewed as a whole, suggests that it is likely true on a balance of probabilities that the Oral Representations were made to them as part of Mr Dominic Khoo’s spiels about the WatchFund investment scheme, and that they had relied on these Oral Representations in entering into the Disputed IAs. While Mr Dominic Khoo denies having made the Oral Representations to any of the plaintiffs, his denial is unconvincing.

  109. [63] For one thing, Mr Dominic Khoo admits to having known Mr Gary Wong and Mr Jowin Fung since 2015, long before the Disputed IAs were entered into. Both Mr Gary Wong and Mr Jowin Fung gave evidence that Mr Dominic Khoo had made the Oral Representations to Mr Gary Wong and to MCA Limited’s representatives before their Disputed IAs were entered into. Mr Gary Wong further gave evidence that representations with similar content to the Oral Representations were made to him by Mr Dominic Khoo sometime in 2016, prior to Mr Gary Wong entering into his Pre-Dispute IAs.

  110. Were the pleaded representations false representations of fact?

  111. [65] The burden lies on the plaintiffs to establish misrepresentation (Fuji Xerox at [50], citing Trans-World (Aluminium) Ltd v Cornelder China (Singapore) [2003] 3 SLR(R) 501 at [29]). It is incumbent on the plaintiffs to adduce proof that the defendants have made false representations of fact. The plaintiffs have, however, produced no evidence to demonstrate the falsity of the representations that underlie their case.

  112. [66] In their closing submissions, the plaintiffs specifically submit that the representations made by the defendants were false in that:

  113. [67] As stated above at [48150], the plaintiffs have failed to plead the Brand-New Watches Representation and the Source Representation as part of their misrepresentation claims, and are therefore precluded from relying on them. It will be highly prejudicial to the defendants if the plaintiffs are allowed to belatedly bring items (b), (c) and (d) in their closing submissions as the defendants would be deprived of the opportunity to lead evidence in their defence to address these allegations. Items (a), (e) and (f) relate to the Documentary Double-Collateral Representation, Oral Double-Collateral Representation and 50% Discount Representation, and these will be considered below. Item (g) relates to the One Year Sale Representation, which will also be considered below.

  114. (1) Documentary Close Connections Representation and Oral Close Connections Representation

  115. [69] In relation to the Documentary Close Connections Representation and Oral Close Connections Representation, the plaintiffs have presented no evidence to demonstrate their falsity. I note that the plaintiffs did not submit that these two representations were false in their closing submissions (see [66] above). On the contrary, Mr Jowin Fung had deposed that Mr Dominic Khoo had, pursuant to Mr Jowin Fung’s due diligence request, shown Mr Jowin Fung a discount purchase agreement with the watch manufacturer Roger Dubuis. I am therefore unable to conclude that the Documentary Close Connections Representation and Oral Close Connections Representation are false.

  116. (2) Luxury Watch Expert Representation

  117. [70] In relation to the Luxury Watch Expert Representation, the plaintiffs again led no evidence to show that it was not true. I note that the plaintiffs also did not submit that this representation was false or how it was false in their closing submissions (see [66] above). I further note that the plaintiffs’ counsel, in cross-examining Mr Dominic Khoo, put questions to Mr Dominic Khoo on the footing that Mr Dominic Khoo (a) was “a former employee and watch expert at Antiquorum” and (b) had credentials including being “one of only four, or the only Southeast Asian watch expert with all these deep relationships or connections with watch CEOs, watch brands, et cetera”. It therefore appears that the plaintiffs themselves may not fully believe that the Luxury Watch Expert Representation is false. I am therefore also unable to conclude that the Luxury Watch Expert Representation is false.

  118. (3) Many Buyers Representation and Ready Buyer Representation

  119. [71] In relation to the Many Buyers Representation and Ready Buyer Representation, the plaintiffs similarly presented no evidence to show that these representations were false. Neither did they argue, in their closing submissions, that these representations were false (see [66] above). All that the plaintiffs advanced in their closing submissions was the suggestion that if there were waiting buyers, the defendants would not have made and reneged on the re-purchase offers in a short span of time. That argument, however, is premised on the flawed assumption that there could be only one reason for reneging on the re-purchase offers, and that reason was that there were no ready buyers. But it is entirely possible that the defendants had other reasons for not fulfilling their contractual obligations under the Disputed IAs. As the plaintiffs have failed to prove that there were no waiting and ready buyers, I am unable to conclude that these two representations are false.

  120. [72] As for the defendants’ submission that the plaintiffs’ watches were not re-purchased because the conditions for re-purchase were not satisfied, this will be considered below under the claim for breach of contract.

  121. (4) One Year Sale Representation

  122. [73] I turn to the One Year Sale Representation. The plaintiffs submitted in closing that the One Year Sale Representation is false as the defendants’ offers to re-purchase the plaintiffs’ watches were illusory and intended to evade legal obligations (see [66] above).

  123. [74] I am unable to see how this constitutes a misrepresentation. The One Year Sale Representation is, in essence, a promise by the defendants to do an act (ie, send by e-mail a re-purchase offer within one year of entering into the Disputed IAs) in the future. In Deutsche Bank AG at [94], the court, citing The Law of Contract in Singapore (Andrew Phang Boon Leong gen ed) (Academy Publishing, 2012) at paras 11.029–11.030, noted that a “statement by one party that he ‘would’ do something for the other party in the future is in essence a promise, which becomes actionable only if such promise was subsequently incorporated into the contract as a term”. At [92] and [98] of Deutsche Bank AG, the court found that statements such as “DB would provide a team of competent and responsible bankers, relationship managers and resources …” [emphasis in original] were “at best statements of future intention” and not statements of fact. Similarly, as noted in Tonny Permana v One Tree Capital Management Pte Ltd and another [2021] 5 SLR 477 at [183], for claims involving “future promises or statements of intention”, the more proper cause of action would be breach of contract as opposed to misrepresentation.

  124. [75] The court in Deutsche Bank AG noted (at [96]) that statements as to future facts may be re-characterised as statements implying that the maker of the statement honestly believed that the event would happen in the future or that the statement-maker had reasonable grounds for making such an assertion. To the extent that the plaintiffs may be taken to have pleaded that the defendants never intended to make binding offers to re-purchase the watches under the Disputed IAs with an intention to be bound by the offers, the plaintiffs did not manage to prove the defendants’ state of mind at the time the One Year Sale Representation was made. There is insufficient evidence to show that the defendants did not honestly believe that the re-purchase offers would be made or honoured, or that the defendants did not have reasonable grounds for making the promise to re-purchase the watches, particularly when the undisputed evidence in relation to the Pre-Dispute IAs is that Mr Wong Ben and Mr Gary Wong had received re-purchase offers for their watches (see [13] above). As far as the defendants’ intentions are concerned, there is no evidence to suggest that at the time the One Year Sale Representation was made, the promise was made with no intention of honouring it.

  125. [76] For completeness, I note the plaintiffs’ submission that due to the defendants’ failure to plead that the alleged representations were not of facts but of future intentions, this is not an issue which has been defined for the court to deal with. I am unable to agree with the plaintiffs. The issue of whether the One Year Representation or any other representation pleaded by the plaintiffs is actionable as a false statement as to a fact, or is not actionable as it is a statement as to future intention, is a matter of the legal result that emerges from an analysis of the material facts as pleaded by the parties. In this case, the plaintiffs have not been deprived of fair notice of any material facts pertinent to the determination of the issue.

  126. [77] Accordingly, the plaintiffs have not proven the One Year Sale Representation to be actionable or false. I will deal with WatchFund HK’s offers to re-purchase below, under the plaintiffs’ claim for breach of contract.

  127. (5) Documentary Double-Collateral Representation, Oral Double-Collateral Representation and 50% Discount Representation

  128. [78] I turn then to the Documentary Double-Collateral Representation, Oral Double-Collateral Representation and 50% Discount Representation. These alleged misrepresentations are the meat of the present dispute. Unfortunately, the plaintiffs’ reliance on them is not without problems.

  129. [80] The Excel sheets suffer from interlinked problems that are fatal to the plaintiffs’ claims for misrepresentation.

  130. [81] Most fundamentally, as the defendants rightly submit, the Excel sheets constitute hearsay and are inadmissible as evidence of the RRPs or the valuation of the watches contained in them. The person who allegedly provided these figures – Ms Connie Siu – was not called as a witness in this suit to testify that the information in the Excel sheets was provided by her and to be cross-examined on the contents thereof.

  131. [82] The rule against the admissibility of hearsay evidence is well-established. As the Court of Appeal in Soon Peck Wah v Woon Che Chye [1997] 3 SLR(R) 430 (“Soon Peck Wah”) noted, citing Jeffrey Pinsler, Evidence, Advocacy and the Litigation Process (Butterworths, 1992) at p 64, assertions made out of court which are tendered to prove any facts in issue or relevant facts are inadmissible as hearsay, unless they fall within an established exception (Soon Peck Wah at [26]). This is because a witness who does not have personal knowledge of what occurred “cannot verify the truth of the facts”. As “the person who does have personal knowledge of the facts is not in court, the accuracy of his perception and his veracity cannot be assessed and tested in cross-examination”. Such evidence is therefore unreliable and should be excluded from consideration (Soon Peck Wah at [27]).

  132. [83] The plaintiffs are asserting that the contents of the Excel sheets are true and that the court should rely on the data in the Excel sheets to make a finding on what the RRPs and valuation of the watches are. But the highest that the plaintiffs have been able to pitch their case is that Mr Jowin Fung and Mr Gary Wong had communicated directly with a person known to them as “Ms Connie Siu” and had provided her with photographs of the watches in this suit. Even if it is accepted that Mr Jowin Fung and Mr Gary Wong did receive the Original Excel Sheet from someone who claims to be “Ms Connie Siu”, all that it proves is that Mr Jowin Fung and Mr Gary Wong had received the Excel sheet from a “Ms Connie Siu”. Mr Jowin Fung and Mr Gary Wong have no first-hand knowledge of the contents of the Excel sheets or how the data was derived, and “cannot verify the truth of the facts” asserted in these Excel sheets. What was allegedly said by someone who claims to be Ms Connie Siu are statements made by her out of court and have not been tested in cross-examination. Therefore, the statements allegedly made by her are not reliable and are inadmissible as proof of the contents of those statements. Ultimately, the Excel sheets are a classic example of hearsay evidence that is inadmissible unless the plaintiffs can bring the Excel sheets under one of the exceptions to the hearsay rule in s 32(1) of the Evidence Act 1893 (2020 Rev Ed). This, the plaintiffs did not attempt to do. Neither did they attempt to remedy the deficiency in their evidence even though the defendants had, as early as 23 November 2022, filed a notice of non-admission to the Edited Excel Sheet. As the Excel sheets are hearsay, they will be excluded from consideration.

  133. [84] Even if the Excel sheets were admitted, the figures contained within would not have taken the plaintiffs’ case very far. As the defendants have rightly submitted, in the absence of the testimony of the person who provided these figures, this court is left unable to confirm what the figures represent, how the figures were arrived at, what sort of examination, study, or research went into deriving the figures, and who examined the watches. The two Excel sheets purportedly show Antiquorum’s estimate of the “Reserve Price”, “Low estimate” and “High estimate” for the watches under the Disputed IAs. The defendants have noted that there is no reference to “valuation” and “recommended retail price” in the Excel sheets. Mr Dominic Khoo testified that the “Reserve Price” refers to a price decided as between the seller of an item and the auction house, and this is the minimum price that must be reached at the auction before the item would be sold. As for the “Low estimate” and “High estimate”, these refer to attractive estimated prices provided by the auction house for the item being auctioned to entice potential buyers to bid in the auction, and these estimates may be significantly lower than the price at which the item is eventually sold. I do not have before me any expert evidence concerning the watch auctioning process or the process of pricing watches. It appears, however, that Mr Dominic Khoo’s explanation of the terms “Reserve Price”, “Low estimate” and “High estimate” is not incredible. Indeed, these values appear to be distinct from the RRP or the valuation of the watches, and if it was Ms Connie Siu who provided those values in the Original Excel Sheet, she was not called to testify what the “Reserve Price”, “Low estimate” and “High estimate” refer to, how they relate, if at all, to the RRP or the valuation of the watches, and how these estimates were arrived at.

  134. [85] Ultimately, the fact that has to be proven is the RRPs or value of the watches under the Disputed IAs, but the plaintiffs have failed to adduce any evidence showing that the RRPs or value of the watches they hold were not what they should have been. The plaintiffs’ action in misrepresentation based on the Documentary Double-Collateral Representation, Oral Double-Collateral Representation and 50% Discount Representation must therefore fail because they have failed to prove that these are falsehoods.

  135. [86] There is a further problem with the plaintiffs’ reliance on the Documentary Double-Collateral Representation and Oral Double-Collateral Representation, and this concerns actionability. In this regard, my observations above (at [42] and [74]–[75]) that a promise to do something in the future, not being a statement of fact, cannot ground an action in misrepresentation, apply equally here. In my view, the Documentary Double-Collateral Representation and Oral Double-Collateral Representation are also future promises.

  136. [87] In relation to the 50% Discount Representation, I similarly fail to see how it is a statement of fact with respect to the watches of potential investors like the plaintiffs and Ms Yung at the time the representation was made. Here again, the plaintiffs have themselves regarded the 50% Discount Representation as a future promise, as is evident from their submission that WatchFund HK “would purchase the [plaintiffs’] watches at more than 50% discount off the current published recommended retail price” [emphasis added].

  137. [88] All said, not only have the plaintiffs failed to prove that the Documentary Double-Collateral Representation, Oral Double-Collateral Representation and 50% Discount Representation are false, in so far as they relate to the RRP or value of the watches of potential investors such as the plaintiffs and Ms Yung at the point in time when the representations were made, the plaintiffs have also failed to show that the representations are actionable as statements of fact in claims for fraudulent and/or negligent misrepresentation.

  138. Disclaimer and Due Diligence

  139. [89] As the plaintiffs have not proven that the representations which were made by the defendants are misrepresentations, there is no need for me to deal with the defendants’ submissions on the disclaimer and on due diligence. For completeness, I would only state briefly that the disclaimer on WatchFund HK’s website cannot absolve the defendants of liability in misrepresentation if they are found to have made misrepresentations to the plaintiffs. Firstly, the screenshot of the disclaimer shows “© 2021 Watchfund. All Rights Reserved”. This means that the disclaimer was present in 2021, but says nothing about whether the disclaimer could have been seen by the plaintiffs and Ms Yung in 2018 and 2019 before they entered into the Disputed IAs. Mr Dominic Khoo claimed that he had evidence that the disclaimer was already on WatchFund HK’s website in 2018 or 2019, but he did not provide any evidence in the end to substantiate his bare assertion. Secondly, the disclaimer, in essence, warns prospective investors that the website serves “information purposes only” and that investing under the WatchFund investment scheme is generally risky. It says nothing about the specific claims made in the Documentary Representations and the Oral Representations, or reliance on those representations.

  140. [90] In relation to the defendants’ argument that the plaintiffs and Ms Yung conducted their own due diligence, which should exonerate the defendants of liability for misrepresentation, it is without merit because the defendants have adduced no evidence that the plaintiffs and Ms Yung, through their due diligence, had come to learn of any misrepresentations before entering into the Disputed IAs, or that they did not rely on the defendants’ representations when entering into the Disputed IAs: Jurong Town Corp v Wishing Star Ltd [2005] 3 SLR(R) 283 at [114].

  141. Was there damage?

  142. [91] For completeness, I deal also with the issue of damage. As the plaintiffs have failed to tender proper evidence on the value of the watches, there is no basis for their contention that they have suffered damage due to the alleged misrepresentations. Further, it is telling that the plaintiffs’ closing submissions devoted only a single sentence to the issue of damage. In their reply submissions, they cited the cases of Zim Integrated Shipping Services Ltd and others v Dafni Igal and others [2011] 1 SLR 862 (“Zim Integrated (CA)”) and Asia Hotel Investments Ltd v Starwood Asia Pacific Management Pte Ltd and another [2005] 1 SLR(R) 661 (“Asia Hotel”) in support of their submission that the evidential burden has shifted to the defendants to prove that the plaintiffs have not suffered damage and/or disprove that the plaintiffs have suffered damage. I am unable to agree with the plaintiffs’ submissions.

  143. [92] The operation of the concept of the evidential burden was summarised by the Court of Appeal in Britestone Pte Ltd v Smith & Associates Far East, Ltd [2007] 4 SLR(R) 855 (“Britestone”). In sum, at the start of the plaintiff’s case, the plaintiff bears both the legal burden of proving “the existence of any relevant fact that the plaintiff must prove”, and the evidential burden of adducing some “not inherently incredible” evidence of such relevant facts (Britestone at [60]). After that, the evidential burden shifts to the defendant to adduce some evidence to rebut the plaintiff’s evidence (Britestone at [60]). However, in this case, the plaintiffs have completely failed to discharge their burden, given that the Excel sheets, which formed the basis of their submissions, are plainly inadmissible and unreliable (see above at [81]). Unlike the cases of Zim Integrated (CA) and Asia Hotel, the plaintiffs in this case have not adduced any evidence, in so far as the issue of damages is concerned, to shift the evidential burden onto the defendants. The plaintiffs have not adduced admissible evidence that the watches given to them were worth less than what they say the defendants had promised those watches would be worth. Accordingly, their contention that the evidential burden of proving damage has shifted to the defendants is devoid of merit.

  144. [93] The plaintiffs have also argued that it is for the defendants to provide the RRPs of the watches. The plaintiffs argue that under clause 2.7 or 2.8 of the various Disputed IAs, WatchFund HK “warrant[ed] that the [watches] are purchased for the investor at below 50% of the current or published recommended retail price”. According to the plaintiffs, it is consistent with logic, commercial reality and principle that the defendants owe disclosure obligations in respect of the RRPs of the watches because of the asymmetry in knowledge between, on the one hand, the plaintiffs and Ms Yung, and, on the other hand, the defendants. I am not persuaded by these arguments for two reasons.

  145. [94] First, applying the principles in Britestone, there is no basis for the plaintiffs to contend that the evidential burden has shifted to the defendants given, as I have explained, the plaintiffs’ abject lack of evidence to discharge their initial evidential burden in the first place. Hence, it is also not necessary for me to examine the material tendered by the defendants as evidence of the value of the watches, namely, the website screenshots of online search results tendered by Mr Dominic Khoo allegedly stating the RRPs of the watches under the Disputed IAs. Second, as a matter of contractual interpretation, the warranty found at clause 2.7 or 2.8 of the various Disputed IAs does not give rise to an obligation for WatchFund HK to provide the RRPs of the watches in this suit.

  146. [95] The plaintiffs have not shown how this contractual warranty could be interpreted as imposing an obligation on the defendants to provide the RRPs. Further, if the plaintiffs’ case is that there has been a breach of the warranty, the plaintiffs must still first prove the breach, and thereafter, it is for the defendants to establish any defences under the contract. Shorn of its adornments, the plaintiffs’ argument is a desperate attempt to avoid the natural consequence of their failure to adduce evidence of the damage that they had allegedly suffered due to the defendants’ representations.

  147. [96] In sum, the plaintiffs’ claims for fraudulent and/or negligent misrepresentation cannot succeed because they have failed to establish on the balance of probabilities that the defendants had made false representations of fact and that the plaintiffs had suffered damage.

  148. Breach of contract

  149. Parties’ cases

  150. Plaintiffs’ case

  151. [97] The plaintiffs next bring claims against WatchFund HK for breach of the Disputed IAs.

  152. [98] The plaintiffs argue that clause 3.1 of the Disputed IAs obliged WatchFund HK to make at least one offer to re-purchase the watches from the plaintiffs within the Investment Period of one year. As re-purchase offers were not made in respect of Ms Yung’s Disputed IA, the plaintiffs argue that the defendants had repudiated Ms Yung’s Disputed IA.

  153. [99] As for the rest of the plaintiffs’ Disputed IAs for which re-purchase offers were made, the plaintiffs argue that all these re-purchase offers were accepted without qualification by the plaintiffs, and that the defendants thereafter wrongfully cancelled the re-purchase offers.

  154. [100] The plaintiffs further contend that a warranty found in the Disputed IAs was breached. According to the plaintiffs, the watches were not purchased for the plaintiffs and Ms Yung at below 50% of current/published RRPs, and this constituted a breach of the warranty found in clauses 3.1, 3.2(a) and 9 of the Disputed IAs for all the plaintiffs, clause 2.8 of the Disputed IAs entered into by Mr Wong Ben, Dr Edmund Liew, MCA Limited and Ms Yung, and clause 2.7 of Mr Gary Wong’s and Mr Wong Nga Kok’s Disputed IAs. In this regard, the plaintiffs rely on the Original Excel Sheet and the Edited Excel Sheet for what they assert to be the “price estimates” or value of the watches (see above at [79]). The plaintiffs also assert that under the said warranty in the Disputed IAs, WatchFund HK had agreed to provide the RRPs to the plaintiffs. As no RRPs of the watches was ever provided to the plaintiffs, the defendants have allegedly breached the warranty clause.

  155. [101] The plaintiffs also argue that the loss caused to them by the defendants’ repudiatory breach of the Disputed IAs is quantifiable without reference to the valuation allegedly provided by Antiquorum. This is because the Disputed IAs contain clauses that either (a) specify a minimum price at which WatchFund HK was obliged to re-purchase the watches under the Disputed IAs, or (b) provide for a guaranteed return on the investment for the plaintiffs.

  156. [102] The plaintiffs also submit that the defendants breached clause 4.1 of the Disputed IAs (see above at [48]) because the watches were not in brand-new condition.

  157. [103] In addition, the plaintiffs pleaded that the defendants breached clauses 3.1, 3.2(a) and 9 of the Disputed IAs (without specifying which particular agreement(s) was breached), by failing, refusing and/or neglecting to make at least one offer to re-purchase the plaintiffs’ watches during the Investment Period, with time being of the essence.

  158. Defendants’ case

  159. [104] In relation to the plaintiffs’ claim that the watches were not purchased at below 50% of current/published RRPs, in breach of a contractual warranty, the defendants allege that this issue was belatedly raised and was not pleaded, and hence, should be disregarded. Relatedly, the defendants argue that this warranty does not import any obligation for WatchFund HK to provide the plaintiffs and Ms Yung with the RRPs of the watches.

  160. [105] In relation to the claims for breach of contract, the defendants state that only the re-purchase offers made to Mr Wong Ben, Dr Edmund Liew and Mr Wong Nga Kok under the Disputed IAs were made late. In that regard, they contend that the plaintiffs had waived WatchFund HK’s alleged breach of the Disputed IAs in terms of the timing of the re-purchase offers, when the plaintiffs communicated their intention to accept WatchFund HK’s re-purchase offers.

  161. [106] The defendants contend that there was no wrongful cancellation of re-purchase offers as WatchFund HK’s re-purchase offers were never validly accepted by the plaintiffs in the first place because the plaintiffs had failed to pay the Sale Fee and to return the watches to WatchFund HK.

  162. [107] The defendants also argue that even if the court finds a repudiatory breach of the Disputed IAs on the part of WatchFund HK, the plaintiffs have not proven loss. The defendants repeat the criticisms concerning the plaintiffs’ inadequate proof of loss via the two Excel sheets allegedly containing valuations of the watches by Ms Connie Siu.

  163. The law

  164. [108] The law on repudiatory breaches of contract is well-settled. In iVenture Card Ltd and others v Big Bus Singapore City Sightseeing Pte Ltd and others [2022] 1 SLR 302 (“iVenture”) at [63], the Court of Appeal summarised the applicable legal framework as follows:

  165. [109] A repudiatory breach, narrowly defined, refers to the renunciation of a contract. This is encompassed by Scenario 1 above. In contrast, a repudiatory breach in the broader sense includes situations where there has been a breach of a condition (Liu Shu Ming and another v Koh Chew Chee and another matter [2023] 1 SLR 1477 at [106], citing The Law of Contract in Singapore (Andrew Phang Boon Leong gen ed) (Academy Publishing, 2nd Ed, 2022) at paras 17.006–17.007).

  166. [110] The Court of Appeal in iVenture, in analysing Scenario 1, held that where a party refuses to perform a contract unless the other party complied with an invalid condition, this may not necessarily amount to a repudiation. Instead, the key inquiry is whether such refusal “would lead a reasonable person to conclude that it no longer intended to be bound by the [contract]” (iVenture at [65]). This approach was applied in the earlier case of RBC Properties Pte Ltd v Defu Furniture Pte Ltd [2015] 1 SLR 997 (“RBC”). The Court of Appeal was faced with a situation where the appellant had entered into a lease with the respondent to make certain premises available for the respondent’s use as a showroom. The Singapore Land Authority then purportedly exercised its right under the State Lease to charge a differential premium, which the appellant wanted to pass on to the respondent by still leasing the premises to the respondent, but at a higher rent (RBC at [134]–[135]). The Court of Appeal noted that the appellant could not pass that differential premium on to the respondent under the terms of the lease (RBC at [134]). The Court of Appeal held at [135] that the appellant had evinced an intention not to be bound by the terms of the lease through a series of communications that indicated that it would pass the differential premium on to the respondent as a supplement to the monthly rent under the lease, and was therefore in repudiatory breach.

  167. Analysis

  168. [111] The material terms of the Disputed IAs entered into by the plaintiffs and Ms Yung are similar. For the purposes of this present judgment, extracts from Mr Wong Ben’s investment agreement dated 30 November 2018 will be quoted. These extracts are applicable (unless stated otherwise) to the rest of the Disputed IAs as well.

  169. Re-purchase and closing out of investment

  170. [112] The broad structure of the Disputed IAs is similar to that which pertained to the Pre-Dispute IAs as outlined above at [11]. The clauses governing the Investment Period and the re-purchase offer read as follows:

  171. [113] All the plaintiffs selected Re-purchase scheme A, while Ms Yung selected Re-purchase scheme B.

  172. Timing of the re-purchase offers

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.