General Division of the High Court · Decided 30 May 2024
Shieh Liang H v Google Singapore Pte Ltd and others
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC 142 · Case no. Suit No 635 of 2010 (Summonses Nos 1924 and 1925 of 2023) · 12 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] The two applications by the plaintiff, Mr Shieh Liang H, before me are as follows:
(a) HC/SUM 1924/2023 (“SUM 1924”), in which the substantive prayer is for leave to serve the Writ of Summons (the “Writ”) as well as all other documents in HC/S 635/2010 (this “Suit”) “upon (i) all Singapore Defendants (SD) who/which have only one single address in [Singapore], and (ii) SD who/which also have foreign addresses”; and
(b) HC/SUM 1925/2023 (“SUM 1925”), in which the substantive application is for leave to extend the validity of the Writ, and to file an amended Writ of Summons and an amended Statement of Claim.
- [2]
[2] The hearings for both summonses were conducted on 5 September 2023 and 12 January 2024. At the end of the second hearing, the plaintiff requested permission to file a further affidavit as well as an amended Writ of Summons and an amended Statement of Claim by 1 March 2024. The plaintiff stated that there was no need for further submissions as the documents to be filed (ie, the further affidavit, the amended Writ of Summons and the amended Statement of Claim) were for formal compliance. I granted his request and adjourned the hearing to await the receipt of those documents before considering the matter.
- [3]
[3] On 29 February and 1 March 2024, the plaintiff submitted some of the abovementioned documents and also sought an extension of time to 18 March 2024 to submit his documents. I granted this request. On 14 March 2024, the plaintiff submitted more documents along with a further request for an extension of time to 23 March 2024. I once again granted this request. This sequence of events repeated once more a week later: on 21 March 2024, the plaintiff submitted more documents along with a further request for an extension of time to 31 March 2024. I granted this request and indicated that this would be the final extension. The extensions of time were granted due to the exceptional circumstances of the present case which is not likely to be replicated.
- [4]
[4] Notwithstanding the final extension of 31 March 2024, the plaintiff continued submitting further documents across the period of March–May 2024.
- [5]
[5] Having considered the plaintiff’s submissions along with all the affidavits and documents that he had submitted prior to 12 January 2024, as well as the new documents that he submitted in February–May 2024, this is my decision on his applications in SUM 1924 and SUM 1925.
Procedural history
- [6]
[6] As this suit has a long history and was dealt with by four other judges over its 13-year odyssey, it would be useful to set out the significant events in this litigation.
The Writ of Summons
- [7]
[7] On 11 August 2010, the plaintiff filed the Writ in this Suit. He is the sole plaintiff, and he named a total of 149 defendants. The first six defendants are corporate entities based in Singapore and they are as follows:
The remaining defendants are corporations, partnerships and individuals which/who appear to be based in Taiwan.
The various interlocutory applications before the present applications
- [8]
[8] On 8 October 2010, the plaintiff filed HC/SUM 4752/2010 to apply for leave to serve the Writ outside of Singapore in respect of the seventh to 149th defendants, who were ostensibly based overseas. This was heard on 27 October 2010 by Assistant Registrar (“AR”) Nathaniel Khng, who dismissed the application on the ground that the case was not a proper one for service out of jurisdiction. The plaintiff’s appeal against this decision in HC/RA 442/2010 came before me on 17 August 2011. During that hearing, the plaintiff notified me that he was withdrawing the appeal. The result of this is that the decision of AR Nathaniel Khng on 27 October 2010 denying the plaintiff leave to serve the Writ on the seventh to 149th defendants out of jurisdiction is final.
- [12]
[12] Prior to the present applications, the plaintiff had made various other interlocutory applications, all of which were either unsuccessful or withdrawn. The following are the other applications not already mentioned and its respective outcomes:
(a) On 12 April 2013, I heard and dismissed the plaintiff’s application in HC/SUM 4840/2011 for judgment in default of appearance against the seventh to 149th defendants.
(b) On 26 June 2013, the plaintiff’s application in HC/SUM 5716/2012 was heard by Lai Siu Chiu J (as she then was), who held that the application was substantively an application to rehear HC/SUM 4271/2011, HC/RA 320/2011 and HC/RA 147/2011, all of which had already concluded. Lai J dismissed the application on the ground that she had no jurisdiction to grant the orders prayed for.
(c) On 25 July 2018, the plaintiff applied ex parte before Lai Siu Chiu SJ for injunctions against various defendants. This was dismissed by the judge.
- [13]
[13] On 27 June 2023, the plaintiff filed the applications now before me, SUM 1924 and SUM 1925.
The plaintiff’s claims
- [14]
[14] In the plaintiff’s Statement of Claim filed on 11 August 2010, the plaintiff seeks damages for the harm caused to his reputation and business resulting from the deprivation of his rights, privileges and opportunities by the defendants. He also seeks damages suffered by his clients, potential clients, relatives and friends arising from the acts of the defendants. The Statement of Claim also prays for quashing orders of resolutions passed by various Taiwanese bar associations and legal entities of which he was formerly a member. The plaintiff alleges that the members of a group known as the “Wen-Lien Group” run an organised crime operation which had caused him to be disbarred in Taiwan and procured his removal from various associations which he was a member of. Additionally, the plaintiff alleges that the defendants were engaged in various conspiracies against him. It is notable that, aside from the fact that the first to sixth defendants are Singaporean entities, the remaining defendants and events do not appear to have any connection with Singapore, although there is a bare allegation that those defendants have assets in Singapore.
- [15]
[15] In terms of quantum, the plaintiff is seeking damages in excess of US$1 trillion, plus special, exemplary and aggravated damages of not less than US$10bn.
My decision