General Division of the High Court · Decided 19 January 2024
Golden Pacific Shipping & Holdings Pte Ltd v Arc Marine Engineering Pte Ltd
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC 15 · Case no. Suit No 1041 of 2020
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] In the present suit, the plaintiff is a ship owner that chartered its vessel to a bareboat charterer. During the charter period, the main engine of the vessel suffered damage. The manager of the vessel contracted with the defendant repairer to repair the main engine. Upon redelivery of the vessel to the plaintiff, the plaintiff was of the view that the repair works were deficient. As there is no contractual relationship between the plaintiff and defendant, the plaintiff brought this action in tort and bailment against the defendant.
Facts
The parties
- [2]
[2] The plaintiff is a Singapore-incorporated company in the business of shipowning and chartering. It is undisputed that the plaintiff was the registered owner of the motor tanker vessel, the “Bravely Loyalty”, at all material times (the “Vessel”). The Vessel is registered in Singapore, classed with Bureau Veritas (“BV”) and carries IMO No 9582726. The defendant is a company incorporated in Singapore and in the business of, inter alia, marine offshore engineering repairs and ship engine repairs.
Background to the dispute
- [3]
[3] On 9 June 2017, the plaintiff chartered the Vessel to Bravely International Pte Ltd (“Bravely”) under a bareboat charter (the “GP-BI Charterparty”). The terms of the GP-BI Charterparty comprise of a modified version of the BIMCO Standard Bareboat Charter “BARECON 2001” as well as various rider clauses (the “Charterparty Contract”). The GP-BI Charterparty was for a term of 24 months plus an additional six months at Bravely’s election. The Vessel was delivered into Bravely’s service on or about 19 September 2017. MSI Ship Management Service Pte Ltd (“MSI”) contracted with Bravely to act as the ship managers of the Vessel.
- [4]
[4] On 15 April 2019, when the Vessel was en route from Tabangao, Philippines to Singapore, she suffered damage to her main engine (the “Main Engine”). For context, the Main Engine utilises a nine-cylinder SXD MAN B&W 9L 32/40 4-stroke medium speed trunk diesel engine which was built under licence from MAN by Shaanxi Diesel Heavy Industry Co Ltd. MSI approached the defendant to quote for repair works, and on 22 April 2019, MSI confirmed the appointment of the defendant for the scope of repair works quoted.
- [5]
[5] On 23 April 2019 the Vessel arrived at the Singapore Anchorage for the repairs to be executed. That same day, two of the defendant’s service engineers boarded the Vessel to carry out an inspection of the Main Engine. The inspections were completed on 25 April 2019. Thereafter, from 26 April 2019, the defendant commenced repairs on the Vessel and its Main Engine. On 13 July 2019, the Vessel was shifted to the Offshore Marine Centre Repair Berth of ST Marine Tuas Shipyard, where the repairs continued. Chief of the repair works was the replacement of the existing crankshaft with a new crankshaft (the “Replacement Crankshaft”). This replacement process is also known as “crankshaft renewal” and was executed by the defendants between 10 and 12 July 2019. The Replacement Crankshaft had been procured by MSI and was then installed by the defendant. Another significant aspect of the repair works was the fitting of the torsional vibration damper (the “TVD”) to the Replacement Crankshaft on 16 July 2019. Based on the various service reports provided by the defendant, the other items of repair carried out by the defendant were as follows:
(a) The cylinder heads of the Main Engine (a total of nine units) were removed from the Vessel for repairs and subsequently reinstalled.
(b) The pistons and connecting rods (a total of nine units) were removed from the Vessel for repairs and subsequently reinstalled.
(c) All the liners from the engine block were removed from the Vessel for repairs and subsequently reinstalled.
(d) The liner top landing rings (a total of nine units) were removed and repaired.
(e) The air starting valves (a total of nine units) were dismantled, cleaned, inspected, and some units were renewed.
(f) The safety valves (a total of nine units) were removed and sent for standard overhauling, and subsequently reassembled to their respective cylinder heads.
(g) The indicator cocks (a total of nine units) were dismantled, cleaned, inspected and subsequently renewed.
(h) The fuel injectors (a total of nine units) were sent to the defendant’s workshop for overhauling, and some units were renewed.
(i) The fuel pumps (a total of nine units) were removed, cleaned and reinstalled with new gasket and O-rings.
(j) The air-cooler and lube-oil cooler were dismantled from the Main Engine and sent to the defendant’s workshop for standard overhauling before being reinstalled.
- [6]
[6] Between 9 and 17 August 2019, the Vessel underwent various sea trials to test its seaworthiness. It is undisputed that a sea trial was conducted on both 10 August 2019 and on 16 August 2019 (respectively, the “Second Sea Trial” and “Third Sea Trial”). However, while the plaintiff considers the attempted sea trial on 9 August 2019 to be a sea trial, the defendant merely considered it as “testing”. For ease of reference, this will simply be described as the “First Sea Trial”. I shall describe the First Sea Trial, Second Sea Trial and Third Sea Trial as the “Sea Trials” collectively. During the First Sea Trial, the exhaust temperature of the Main Engine cylinder #6 was very high, and subsequently, the turbocharger insulation of the Main Engine caught fire. The Main Engine was stopped to put out the fire and the ship subsequently returned to the Offshore Marine Centre for inspection and repair. At the Second Sea Trial, among other things, the Main Engine was run on idle and subsequently tested on increasing loads, up to full speed. When the Main Engine load hit 80% of the capacity, it had to temporarily stop as the turbocharger insulation caught fire. However, the test run continued thereafter, and eventually, the load was increased to 100% again. During the Third Sea Trial, the Main Engine was once again run at various loads, including at a load of 100% for an hour.
- [7]
[7] By 20 August 2019, the defendant and its subcontractors had completed the repair works, and on the following day, MSI acknowledged that all relevant repairs had been completed. On 31 August 2019, Bravely redelivered the Vessel to the plaintiff. At the time of redelivery, the plaintiff found the Vessel to be in an allegedly unsatisfactory state. Therefore, the plaintiff arranged for Metalock Engineering (Qingdao) Ltd (“Metalock”), to inspect the Main Engine crankpin bearings. These inspections were conducted from 12 to 16 September 2019, following which Metalock produced a service report dated 17 September 2019 (the “Metalock Report”). In particular, the Metalock Report stated that they “found scratches on most main journals which is abnormal phenomena, especially for new crankshaft”. The Vessel continued to remain in Singapore to undergo repairs to its generators.
- [9]
[9] On 27 November 2019, the Vessel commenced its voyage to Vietnam, and then to Yuanye Shipyard in China for the rectification works. Crucially, on 9 December 2019, it was discovered that the engine-driven lubricating oil pump (the “lube oil pump”) had failed. It is not clear when exactly the lube oil pump failed, but according to a report prepared by Aqualis Braemar, the hull insurer’s appointed surveyor, dated 20 January 2020 (“AB’s 20 January Report”), “[t]he pump was reported damaged on the fourth day after the vessel’s departure”, ie, 1 December 2019.
- [11]
[11] On 29 October 2020, the plaintiff commenced the present suit against the defendant in negligence for allegedly defective repair work. It is undisputed that there is no contract between the plaintiff and defendant.
Expert witnesses
- [12]
[12] The plaintiff relies on the expert evidence of Mr Bindra Jaskirat Singh (“Mr Singh”). Mr Singh is the sole proprietor of Eco Marine Services, a marine consultancy services firm. He has undertaken damage and repair inspection of various main engines, including those manufactured by MAN (ie, the maker of the Main Engine), and has carried out damage and repair inspections of more than 200 ships. The defendant called Mr Thomas Douglas Wilson (“Mr Wilson”) as its expert witness. Mr Wilson is employed as a marine consultant at ABL Energy & Marine Consultants Pte Ltd, a company which provides technical engineering and consultancy services to the marine and offshore energy industries. He is a chartered marine engineer with over 30 years’ experience as a surveyor and consultant.
- [13]
[13] On 2 March 2023, Mr Singh and Mr Wilson held an experts’ caucus to discuss the various technical factual issues that are in dispute. This resulted in a joint memorandum dated 11 March 2023 setting out areas of agreement and disagreement for each of the issues (the “Joint Memorandum”).
The parties’ cases
- [14]
[14] The plaintiff claims that the defendant owes the plaintiff a duty of care in negligence to exercise all reasonable skill and care in carrying out the repair works on the Vessel and Main Engine. In the alternative, the plaintiff alleges that it bailed the Vessel to Bravely, and Bravely sub-bailed the Vessel to the defendant. As sub-bailee, the defendant owes a duty of bailment to the plaintiff to take reasonable care of the Vessel during the time that the Vessel was in the defendant’s physical possession. In its Statement of Claim, the plaintiff asserted that the repair of the Main Engine was deficient in various respects, which can be divided into five factual issues (the “Defective Works”):
(a) Issue 1:
(i) The defendant failed to ensure that the correct orifice plug (with 10mm diameter bore) was placed into the free-end side of the crankshaft and/or failed to remove this plug. This resulted in lubricating oil starvation of and the consequent complete destruction of the TVD.
(ii) The defendant failed to ensure that sufficient lube oil was supplied to the TVD.
(b) Issue 2: The Main Engine was incapable of operating satisfactorily or stably (sandpaper was used in the Main Engine control during the Sea Trials).
(c) Issue 3: The majority of the main journals suffered from severe scratches.
(d) Issue 4:
(i) The crankshaft was misaligned.
(ii) The defendant erroneously observed and/or recorded the crankshaft deflection measures.
(iii) The defendant failed to ensure that the crankshaft deflection was within allowable limits.
(iv) There had been improper and incomplete installation of the crankshaft with deflection of -0.16 mm, which exceeded the maximum allowable limits of +/- 0.14 mm set by the Main Engine maker. This caused excessive wear to the bearings of the Vessel.
(e) Issue 5: The lube oil filter and sump of the Main Engine were replete with a substantial number of metal particles.
- [16]
[16] Based on the foregoing, the plaintiff claims:
(a) the sum of US$3,144,785.21 and/or such sum as the court deems fit;
(b) or, in the alternative, for damages to be assessed;
(c) a declaration that the plaintiff is entitled to be indemnified and to be kept fully indemnified from and against, and/or a contribution from the defendant for any and all liabilities (present or contingent), claims, demands, losses, expenses or damages of whatsoever nature incurred by and/or to be incurred by the plaintiff and/or asserted against the plaintiff arising out of or in connection with the repairs, and/or in consequence of claims made and/or to be made against the plaintiff arising out and/or in connection with the repairs;
(d) an indemnity against all liabilities (present or contingent), claims, demands, losses, expenses or damages of whatsoever nature incurred by and/or to be incurred by the plaintiff and/or asserted against the plaintiff arising out of or in connection with the Incident, and/or in consequence of claims made and/or to be made against the plaintiff arising out and/or in connection with the repairs;
(e) interest pursuant to s 12 of the Civil Law Act;
(f) costs; and
(g) such further or other relief as the court deems just.
- [17]
[17] Conversely, the defendant avers that it does not owe a duty of care to the plaintiff either in negligence or in bailment. The defendant claims that it is not responsible for the alleged Defective Works as they pertain to matters outside its overall scope of works. Further or in the alternative, the alleged Defective Works were not caused by the defendant. In addition, the defendant acted reasonably in carrying out its repair works. In particular, at the trial, it became clear that the main factual dispute centres on whether the defendant had left an orifice plug or blank plug inside the free-end of the Replacement crankshaft. The defendant avers that the Replacement Crankshaft was equipped with the correct plug, ie, an orifice plug. In the alternative, even if the incorrect blank plug was fitted, the defendant avers that it is entitled to rely on third parties, such as MSI, to ensure that the Replacement Crankshaft was free of defects, as well as the classification society of the Vessel, BV, which endorsed a “Certificate of Product Conformity for Crankshaft” (the “Certificate of Conformity”) which declared that the product was “manufactured, tested and examined in conformity with the approved documentation”.
Issues to be determined
- [19]
[19] The following issues arise for my determination.
(a) Firstly, whether the defendant owes a duty of care in tort to the plaintiff.
(b) Secondly, whether the defendant owes a duty of care in bailment to the plaintiff.
(c) Thirdly, whether the defendant has breached its duty by effecting any of the Defective Works, and if so, whether the breach(es) caused damage to the plaintiff.
(d) Fourthly, whether the plaintiff had mitigated its losses by conducting the rectification works economically and expediently.
(e) Fifthly, if the defendant is liable to the plaintiff in negligence, the extent of damages that the plaintiff is entitled to.
Duty of care in negligence
Relevant legal principles
- [20]
[20] The legal requirements for establishing an action in the tort of negligence are trite. First, the defendant must owe a duty of care to the plaintiff. Second, the defendant must have breached this duty of care. Third, the defendant’s breach must have caused the damage suffered by the plaintiff; and in addition, the resulting damage should not be too remote (The Law of Torts in Singapore (Academy Publishing, 2016) (“The Law of Torts in Singapore”) at para 03.006).
- [21]
[21] The test for the imposition of a duty of care in negligence is set out in the seminal case of Spandeck Engineering (S) Pte Ltd v Defence Science & Technology Agency [2007] 4 SLR(R) 100 (“Spandeck”). It is a two-stage test comprising of, first, proximity and, second, policy considerations, which are together preceded by the preliminary requirement of factual foreseeability (Spandeck at [73]). Factual foreseeability refers to reasonable foreseeability and “will almost always be satisfied, simply because of its very nature and the very wide nature of the ‘net’ it necessarily casts” (Spandeck at [75] citing Sunny Metal & Engineering Pte Ltd v Ng Khim Ming Eric [2007] 1 SLR(R) 853 at [55]). The first stage requires sufficient legal proximity, which is determined by the closeness of the parties’ relationship, including physical, circumstantial and causal proximity, supported by the twin criteria of the defendant’s voluntary assumption of responsibility and the plaintiff’s actual reliance upon the defendant (Spandeck at [77]–[81]). Where there is factual foreseeability and legal proximity, a prima facie duty of care arises. The second stage entails weighing policy considerations to determine whether the prima facie duty should be negated or limited (Spandeck at [83]).
- [22]
[22] Crucially, the Court of Appeal in Spandeck stressed that the test was to be applied incrementally, “in the sense that when applying the test in each stage, it would be desirable to refer to decided cases in analogous situations to see how the courts have reached their conclusions in terms of proximity and/or policy” (Spandeck at [73]). Analogous precedents, which determine the current limits of liability, make it easier for the later court to determine whether to extend its limits. However, in a novel situation, the court may extend liability where it is just and fair to do so, taking into account the relevant policy consideration against indeterminate liability against a tortfeasor (Spandeck at [73]).
The decision
- [23]
[23] The first issue for my determination is whether the defendant owes the plaintiff a duty of care in tort in its repair of the Vessel. The plaintiff argues that there is a duty of care and that the present case is “on all fours” with the decision in Jet Holding Ltd and others v Cooper Cameron (Singapore) Pte Ltd and another [2005] 4 SLR(R) 417 (“Jet Holding (HC)”), which was affirmed by the Court of Appeal in Jet Holding Ltd and others v Cooper Cameron (Singapore) Pte Ltd and another and other appeals [2006] 3 SLR(R) 769 (“Jet Holding (CA)”). Conversely, the defendant submits that the present case is analogous to Man B&W Diesel S E Asia Pte Ltd and another v PT Bumi International Tankers and another appeal [2004] 2 SLR(R) 300 (“PT Bumi (CA)”), where the Court of Appeal declined to find a duty of care in negligence.
- [24]
[24] I set out the salient facts of PT Bumi (CA) and Jet Holding (HC).
- [26]
[26] In Jet Holding (HC), the first plaintiff (“JHL”) became the owner of a drill ship, the Energy Searcher, in July 1999. Prior to that, the second plaintiff (“JSL”) was the registered owner. Upon JHL becoming the owner, JHL chartered the Energy Searcher to JSL under a bareboat charter. The third plaintiff (“JDL”) was at all material times the manager of the Energy Searcher (Jet Holding (HC) at [2]). The first defendant (“Cameron”) was looked upon as the original equipment manufacturer. The second defendant (“Stork”) was a Cameron-approved contractor (Jet Holding (HC) at [3]). Earlier on, in 1997, an inspection revealed that two slip joints on the Energy Searcher were unfit for use. They were then sent to Cameron’s approved contractor (“VDH”) to be dissembled and refurbished. Cameron subcontracted the refurbishment of a spare slip joint to Stork, which was fabricated from “discarded” components from the original two slip joints. Thereafter, the spare slip joint was returned to the Energy Searcher in November 1998 (Jet Holding (HC) at [9]). Subsequently, in November 2000, the Energy Searcher was time chartered to an oil exploration company (Jet Holding (HC) at [4]). In March 2001, a decision was made to replace the primary slip joint with the spare slip joint. In the course of installation, the spare slip joint fractured and broke into two, which resulted in the loss of other drilling equipment. It was later discovered that the wall thickness of riser box of the spare slip joint (which connects the upper end of the slip joint to the ship) had been inadequate (Jet Holding (HC) at [6] and [12]). Among other things, the plaintiffs sued the defendants in negligence. The High Court held that Cameron owed a duty of care to the owner, JHL (Jet Holding (HC) at [60]), and stated the following:
In particular, the High Court held that the existence of the contract between JSL and Cameron did not have the effect of negativing a duty of care owed by Cameron to JHL, the owner.
- [27]
[27] The High Court also held that Stork owed the defendants a duty of care (Jet Holding (HC) at [129]). I reproduce the relevant part of the judgment:
- [28]
[28] On appeal, the Court of Appeal in Jet Holding (CA) affirmed the High Court’s finding of duty of care. The Court of Appeal stated that it was “clear, on the facts, that Cameron owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs and had breached it. The Judge’s analysis and reasoning in this regard was thorough and persuasive and we have nothing useful to add” (Jet Holding (CA) at [129] and [131]).
- [29]
[29] Before I proceed with my analysis, I make a preliminary observation. As parties sought to argue whether the present case is more akin to Jet Holding (HC) or PT Bumi (CA), they dedicated extensive submissions characterising the nature of the plaintiff’s loss, ie, whether the loss was physical damage or pure economic loss. This was because Belinda Ang J (as she then was) distinguished the case in Jet Holding (HC) from that of PT Bumi (CA) on the basis that the latter concerned a claim for pure economic loss, whereas the former involved a claim for direct physical damage to property (Jet Holding (HC) at [128]). Further, in the case of The “Sunrise Crane” [2004] 4 SLR(R) 715 (“The “Sunrise Crane””), the Court of Appeal similarly distinguished PT Bumi (CA) on the basis that that case concerned pure economic loss, emphasising that this was a “fundamental difference” (The “Sunrise Crane” at [35]). However, it must be stressed that this series of cases was decided prior to the decision in Spandeck, where the Court of Appeal laid down a single test for the establishment of a duty of care in tort. In doing so, the Court of Appeal eschewed the approach taken in some earlier Singapore cases, where a different test for a duty of care was applied depending on the nature of the loss suffered by the plaintiff (NTUC Foodfare Co-operative Ltd v SIA Engineering Co Ltd and another [2018] 2 SLR 588 (“NTUC Foodfare”) at [1], citing Spandeck at [58] and [69]). In this regard, the exhortation of the Court of Appeal is instructive (NTUC Foodfare at [4]):
- [30]
[30] Similarly, in ACB, the Court of Appeal stressed that the nature of the loss claimed is, at most, only a “very rough” proxy for whether a duty of care in tort ought ordinarily to arise in a given context (ACB at [82]). Instead, the focus should be on the facts of each case, and whether the twin requirements of proximity and policy are satisfied. Therefore, in my view, the nature of the loss ought not to be a significant factor when parties seek to analogise the present case to PT Bumi (CA) or Jet Holding (CA).
- [34]
[34] At this juncture, the Court of Appeal’s observations in The “Sunrise Crane” at [34] must be borne in mind:
Duty in bailment
The law
- [36]
[36] It is trite law that a bailee owes a duty to the bailor to take proper care of the goods in his possession. A sub-bailee is generally in the same position as a bailee with respect to caring for the original bailor’s goods (Techking Enterprise Ltd and another v JFE Consolidators Pte Ltd and another [2005] 2 SLR(R) 744 (“Techking”) at [10]). Where goods that are on bailment are injured or lost, the burden of proof rests on the bailee to show, on a balance of probabilities, that he discharged his duty of care (Techking at [9]). The justification is that, since the bailee is in possession of the relevant goods, he is best able to provide an explanation of the misadventure and he is most likely to have been at fault if such an explanation is not forthcoming: Palmer on Bailment (Sweet & Maxwell, 3rd Ed, 2009) (“Palmer on Bailment”) at para 1.053. These principles apply to the sub-bailee as well, who must prove that he has discharged his duties to the original bailor (Techking at [12]).
- [37]
[37] To establish bailment, the bailee must have exclusive possession over the chattel. In Yearworth and others v North Bristol NHS Trust [2010] QB 1 at [48], the English Court of Appeal set out the relevant principles of the law of bailment, one of which being:
- [38]
[38] In Midland Silicones Ltd v Scruttons Ltd [1961] 1 QB 106 at 119, the English Court of Appeal found that there was no exclusive possession on the part of the defendants in that case as would support a bailment, thereby implying that exclusive possession is a necessary requirement to establish bailment.
- [39]
[39] The Canadian courts have taken a similar position on the requirement of exclusive possession. In The Queen v Halifax Shipyards Ltd (1956) 4 DLR (2d) 566 (“Halifax Shipyards”) at 571, Thorson P stated that:
Thereafter, in the case of Coast Crane Co Ltd v Dominion Bridge Co Ltd et al British Columbia Power Com’n v E.B. Investmenets Ltd et al (1961) 28 DLR (2d) 295 at [20], the pronouncement of Thorson P in Halifax Shipyards as quoted above was adopted as a statement of the law on bailment:
- [40]
[40] These authorities are consistent with the position taken under Singapore law. In Zweite Ms “Philippa Schulte” Shipping GmbH & Co KG & another v PSA Corp Ltd [2012] SGHC 135 (“Zweite”) at [147], Tan Lee Meng J held that:
- [41]
[41] In Zweite, an accident occurred when the plaintiff shipowner’s vessel was berthed at the defendant’s container terminal. The shipowner and the demise charterer claimed that the defendant negligently lifted and dropped one of the vessel’s hatch covers during cargo discharging operations, causing damage to the hatch cover and vessels (Zweite at [1]). The plaintiffs further asserted that they were entitled to rely on bailment to demand that the defendant prove that the accident was not caused by its negligence, thereby reversing the burden of proof (Zweite at [145]). The court held that there was no bailment as the unloading of cargo was, without more, a joint operation conducted by the plaintiff and defendant. The defendant did not work independently of the vessel’s crew during the lifting operation (Zweite at [148]).
- [42]
[42] Palmer on Bailment also considers that possession can be alternating and/or divided geographically upon the subject chattel and that possession (Palmer on Bailment at paras 1.137 and 1.138):
The decision
- [43]
[43] To recapitulate, the plaintiff pleaded that the defendant, as sub-bailee, owes a duty of bailment to take reasonable care of the Vessel for the period of time when the Vessel was in the defendant’s physical possession. I find that no such duty is owed.
- [44]
[44] It is clear that a relationship of bailment existed between the plaintiff and Bravely. Under the bareboat charter, the plaintiff transferred possession and control of the Vessel to Bravely. In The “Chem Orchid” [2015] 2 SLR 1020 at [66], the High Court expounded on the nature of a bareboat charter:
- [45]
[45] The authors of Howard Bennett et al, Carver on Charterparties (Sweet & Maxwell, 2nd Ed, 2021) at para 1.031 take a similar view:
- [46]
[46] However, a relationship of sub-bailment cannot be established between Bravely and the defendant. According to the plaintiff, the defendant was the sub-bailee of the Main Engine. Yet, the evidence before me does not disclose such a relationship – the defendant did not have exclusive possession of the Main Engine. First, the Vessel was never delivered to the defendant’s premises. The Vessel was berthed at various third-party locations throughout the course of the defendant’s repair work, such as the Singapore Anchorage and the Offshore Marine Centre Repair Berth of ST Marine Tuas Shipyard. Second, the three service reports for the Main Engine prepared by the defendant during the period of repair and dated 23 May 2019, 11 July 2019 and 8 August 2019 state that all works done were witnessed by the superintendent and chief engineer or captain of the vessel. These service reports also state that the defendant’s job scope was “confirmed with attending Superintendent and Chief Engineer before work commencement on-board vessel”. In addition, the reports are also affixed with the stamp and signature of the chief engineer, one Nan Wen Long. Neither the superintendent nor the chief engineer are employees of the defendant. In fact, the reports indicate that the chief engineer and/or the superintendent were present at various points of the Main Engine repairs. For example, the service report dated 23 May 2019 states that:
The relationship between the superintendent, the chief engineer and the defendant disclosed by these documents shows that the defendant did not have exclusive possession of the Main Engine.
- [47]
[47] Third, the plaintiff’s asserts that defendant’s timesheets during the repair period do not “state that the crew was in the engine room or near the [Main Engine]”. This is not a convincing argument. As the timesheets are internal documents to the defendant, it is reasonable that they only record the attendance of the defendant’s personnel.
- [48]
[48] The plaintiff also attempts to rely on Halifax Shipyards, The “Wilson Ruby” and another action [1998] 1 SLR(R) 932, and The “Ruapehu” (1925) 21 Ll L Rep 310 to argue that “a repairer may still be found to have possession for the purposes of founding bailment, even though the crew remained onboard”. However, the defendant rightly points out that these authorities are distinguishable from the present case. In those cases, the vessel was delivered to the repairer’s premises, but the vessel’s crew remained on board the vessel during the repair works. The fact that the vessel was in the ship repairers’ premises would have been a significant factor for the finding of bailment. Here, the Vessel was not in the defendant’s shipyard. Further, the Vessel’s crew was also on board the Vessel and the Main Engine during the course of the repair works. The plaintiff in Zweite had sought to make a similar argument as the plaintiff in this case. In this regard, Tan Lee Meng J’s observations are instructive (Zweite at [153]):
- [49]
[49] Therefore, the aforementioned cases are not relevant to the facts of the present case. To conclude, the defendant does not owe a duty in bailment to the plaintiff.
Whether there were Defective Works such that the defendant breached its duty of care
Blank plug or orifice plug
- [50]
[50] The main factual dispute for my determination is whether the plug left by the defendant inside the free-end of the Replacement Crankshaft was a blank plug or an orifice plug.
- [51]
[51] The plaintiff pleaded that the defendant had breached its duty of care by “failing to ensure that the correct orifice plug … was placed into the free-end side of the [Replacement Crankshaft] and/or [failing] to remove the incorrect plug. This resulted in lubricating oil starvation of and the consequent complete destruction of the [TVD]”. The plaintiff contends that the blank plug was, in all likelihood, present in the Replacement Crankshaft when it was purchased. The purpose of having a blank plug in a new crankshaft was to prevent dirt or water from entering the lube oil channel of the crankshaft during storage and transportation. However, when the Vessel was repaired, the defendant failed to ensure that the correct orifice plug was installed in the free-end of the Replacement Crankshaft, and left the blank plug there instead. The defendant denies this claim. Its case is that the crankshaft had been pre-fitted with an orifice plug.
- [52]
[52] Before I proceed with my analysis, I first explain the significance of these two plugs being fitted in the Replacement Crankshaft.
- [53]
[53] A crankshaft is a component of an engine. Essentially, the crankshaft rotates within the engine while being held in place by bearings. The crankshaft is connected to the pistons via connecting rods. The reciprocating motion of the pistons causes the crankshaft to rotate. When the engine of a vessel is running, the crankshaft vibrates due to the flexing of the crankshaft in response to the impulses created as the connecting rods push on the crankshaft. At certain revolutions, the torsional vibrations occurring within the crankshaft align with the natural frequency of the engine and cause severe vibrations. The engine revolutions at which this occurs is called the engine’s “critical speed”. If left unchecked, the vibrations will quickly destroy the crankshaft and main bearings, and in severe cases, other components of the main engine. The TVD was designed to significantly limit the amplitudes of these vibrations. It protects the crankshaft by mitigating the impact of opposing torsional forces experienced during a vessel’s operation. In particular, the spring packs within the TVD utilise the high elasticity of its leaf springs, as well as the hydrodynamic damping of the lubricating oil, to shift the major critical speeds out of the engine’s operating speed range. This process absorbs the vibrations and changes them to heat. The lubricating oil also serves as a cooling medium to remove the heat generated. It is undisputed that the TVD required a supply of lubricating oil to operate. The oil would flow from the oil pump through the passages of the Main Engine, and then into the TVD, before flowing out through two nozzles into the engine sump to be pumped back into the system.
- [54]
[54] Importantly, both experts agree that if a blank plug, as opposed to an orifice plug, had been fitted into the Replacement Crankshaft, the TVD would not work. An orifice plug has a 10mm diameter hole drilled into it that allows lubricating oil to pass through it and be supplied to the TVD. On the other hand, a blank plug has no such hole or opening. Therefore, if a blank plug had been fitted into the free-end of the Replacement Crankshaft, no lubricating oil would be supplied to the TVD, resulting in “lube oil starvation”. The TVD would be unable to reduce the torsional vibrations by hydraulic dumping and eventually, the attached leaf springs and intermediate pieces would lose elasticity and crack from fatigue and thermal stresses. In essence, the TVD would mechanically self-destroy. Further, the absence of lubricating oil causes extensive vibrations during the extensive running of the Main Engine. These vibrations would then result in the break down and damage of the Main Engine. In addition, the vibrations would be accompanied by a lot of noise, as the unlubricated springs would “[rub] against each other”.
- [55]
[55] To be clear, the plaintiff has only put forward one theory to explain the allegedly inadequate supply of lubricating oil in the TVD – that being the presence of the blank plug in the Replacement Crankshaft. Therefore, if an orifice plug was, in fact, fitted into the Replacement Crankshaft, the plaintiff has no other basis to claim that the defendant had failed to ensure that sufficient lubricating oil was supplied to the TVD.
- [56]
[56] I make a finding of fact that the defendant left an orifice plug in the free-end of the Replacement Crankshaft. This is for the following reasons.
Absence of excessive vibrations and noise on the Vessel during the Sea Trials
- [57]
[57] In my judgment, I place significant weight on the absence of excessive vibrations experienced on the Vessel during the Sea Trials.
- [58]
[58] It is undisputed that if a blank plug had been fitted to the Replacement Crankshaft, severe vibrations would be experienced on the Vessel. Therefore, the presence of excessive vibrations would strongly indicate the presence of a blank plug in the Replacement Crankshaft. The plaintiff takes the position that there were strong vibrations and noise were experienced on the Vessel during the Sea Trials. However, the plaintiff principally relies on the testimony of Mr Lee Sai Kit (“Mr Lee”), a director of the plaintiff, for this assertion. Under cross-examination, Mr Lee testified that he had personally experienced strong vibrations and noise during the Sea Trials.
- [59]
[59] As a preliminary point, I note that there is some ambiguity as to whether Mr Lee was, in fact, on board the Vessel during the three Sea Trials. In his Affidavit of Evidence-in-Chief (“AEIC”), Mr Lee stated that “[the plaintiff’s] representatives, Zhang Long and Zhang Yunchen, were present” at the First Sea Trial. Further, “Zhang Long … reported to [Mr Lee] that the Main Engine had strong vibration and noise. He also reported the same to [Mr Lee] in respect of the [Second Sea Trial]”. This gives the impression that Mr Lee had merely received feedback about the First Sea Trial and Second Sea Trial from the plaintiff’s representatives who were physically present on the Vessel. Nowhere in his AEIC does Mr Lee explicitly mention that he was physically present at the First Sea Trial and Second Sea Trial. Further in his AEIC, Mr Lee laments that “[g]iven the issues faced during the failed sea trials prior, I was very concerned and so I attended on board for this [Third Sea Trial]”. This statement suggests that Mr Lee was not on board the Vessel on the First Sea Trial and the Second Sea Trial. However, at trial, Mr Lee testified that he was physically present at the Sea Trials (ie all three sea trials). He also produced photographs from his mobile phone which had been taken on the Vessel. The metadata showed that these pictures were taken on 9 August 2019, the date of the First Sea Trial. There is no indication that these photographs had been transferred from another device and downloaded to his mobile phone. Counsel for the defendant also conceded that there was no evidence to prove that Mr Lee was absent from the First Sea Trial. On balance, I find that Mr Lee was present on the Vessel during the Sea Trials.
- [60]
[60] However, Mr Lee’s assertions about the strong vibrations and loud noise that he experienced on the Vessel are met with deafening silence in the contemporaneous records. Firstly, in the timesheets/services reports produced by the defendant for 9, 10 and 16 August 2019, ie, the days on which the Sea Trials were conducted, there were no records of any excessive vibrations on the Vessel. However, during the Sea Trials, the Main Engine was run at varying loads, including up to 100% load. In fact, during the Third Sea Trial, the Main Engine was run at 100% power at constant revolutions for an hour. Under cross examination, Mr Singh agreed that the Main Engine would have hit critical speed at some point during the Sea Trials, as it was put through the entire range of revolutions. He also agreed that if the TVD was not working, there would be severe vibrations on the Vessel. But there is no record of severe vibration in the timesheets/service reports. In contrast, the timesheet for the Third Sea Trial recorded that “the engine performance test … [was] found satisfactory”. Similarly, the Survey Report produced by BV reported that “[o]operating parameters of main engine [were] observed to be normal” during the Third Sea Trial, based on the engine testing data record of the defendant. Secondly, around the time of the Sea Trials, Mr Lee was in correspondence with BV. He sent two emails to BV on 19 August 2019. Mr Lee explained in his AEIC that he “had informed BV of the deficient repairs by [the defendant] and the state of the Main Engine, knowing full well that the true and complete picture may not be available to BV”. However, notwithstanding the fact that Mr Lee sought to provide a “true and complete picture” to BV, he failed to mention the abnormal and excessive vibrations he had testified in court that he had experienced on the Vessel. Thirdly, in the morning of 19 August 2019, Mr Lee had a meeting in person with representatives of BV about the repairs conducted by the defendant and the damages sustained by the Vessel. The plaintiff has provided a transcription of the audio file of said meeting. However, in the course of the meeting lasting more than 30 minutes, the transcript is silent on the issue of excessive vibrations on the Vessel. On 17 and 20 August 2019, Mr Lee also sent two emails to Bravely. In each email, he described certain problems with the Vessel. Again, there is no mention of any excessive vibrations. At trial, Mr Lee alleged that he had written to Bravely on 9 and/or 10 August 2019 about the vibrations. However, he subsequently recanted this statement and no such emails were produced by the plaintiff. Thirdly, the plaintiff’s representative, Zhang Long, who attended the First Sea Trial and Second Sea Trial, prepared a report dated 10 August 2019 in respect of those sea trials. However, the report makes no reference to any excessive vibrations. It is odd that the report would make such a material omission, given that, according to Mr Lee, Zhang Long had specifically reported to him that “the Main Engine had strong vibration and noise”, meaning that this was an issue of significance. Finally, Mr Singh, the plaintiff’s expert, conceded that there was no written record of vibrations at the Sea Trials.
- [61]
[61] During the trial, Mr Lee submitted a video that he had taken on the Vessel during the First Sea Trial. He claimed that he had recorded this video as he realised that there were problems when the Main Engine was running. He asserted that the video would prove that there were excessive vibrations on the Vessel. However, no vibration could be seen from the video, and Mr Lee concedes as much. The plaintiff submits that the loud noise that could be heard in the video show that there was excessive vibration. The plaintiff cites Mr Wilson’s evidence that there would be a lot of noise if the TVD suffered lube oil starvation, because the springs will not be dampened by the oil and will rub against each other. In my view, this piece of evidence is neither here nor there. There is no evidence before me to prove that it was the excessive vibrations that had caused the noise heard in the video. Further, it is unclear whether the noise was attributable to a normal level of noise associated with the operation of the Vessel.
- [62]
[62] In fact, the first written record of any vibrations on the Vessel was an entry on the logbook of the Vessel dated 4 December 2019, when the Vessel was en route from Singapore to Zhoushan, China:
This entry was recorded by the crew of the Vessel. However, no other entry in the logbook makes reference to any vibration on the Vessel. Further, this entry was recorded more than three months after the Vessel had been redelivered to the plaintiff, and six days after the Vessel had departed Singapore. Mr Wilson provided an alternative explanation for the sudden vibrations. According to the logbook of the Vessel, the turbocharger was surging on 3 and 4 December 2019 at speeds of 530–570rpm. Mr Wilson explained that this was likely to have been caused by the heavy weather that the Vessel had been encountering at the time and may have resulted in the vibration and noise to the Main Engine. Further, the checks conducted on that day showed that the Main Engine was operating within the normal parameters.
- [63]
[63] In its written submissions, the plaintiff, in the alternative, tries to explain the absence of strong vibrations during the Sea Trials. The plaintiff contends that during the Sea Trials, the springs of the TVD were still in operation. The plaintiff cites Mr Wilson’s observation that the springs would only be “progressively” destroyed, which was why the springs within the TVD were found to be cracked when the Vessel arrived in Zhoushan. However, earlier on in the cross-examination, Mr Wilson had explained that “the springs alone are only a minor player [emphasis added]” in giving the damping effect. Instead, “[t]he main player is … the lube oil. The main purpose of the lube oil going to the damper is to dampen these vibrations”. In Mr Wilson’s First Expert Report dated 21 February 2023, he also explained that “without a supply of lubricating oil, the internal leaf springs of the [TVD] … would quickly start to destroy themselves and this would have caused extensive vibrations during the extensive running of the Main Engine at varying loads, including up to 100% load, during the [Sea Trials]” [emphasis added]. Further, Mr Singh did not testify that the vibrations would gradually intensify over time. Instead, during cross-examination, Mr Singh agreed that it would be puzzling that no excessive vibration was recorded during the Sea Trials if the blank plug was fitted in the Replacement Crankshaft.
- [64]
[64] For completeness, I recognise that Mr Dante Mendoza De Villa ("Mr Dante”), an engineer of the defendant, gave evidence that there were vibrations on the Main Engine during the Third Sea Trial. However, Mr Dante caveated that these vibrations were not excessive. As explained by Mr Wilson, vibrations would be experienced when any engine is running. Even when the TVD operates, vibrations are experienced, albeit that they are reduced. Therefore, the vibrations experienced by Mr Dante were likely to be within the normal parameters and his testimony does not contradict my finding.
Checks on the TVD
- [65]
[65] According to the Main Engine logbooks maintained by the Vessel’s crew, the crew conducted three internal checks on the TVD after the Vessel was redelivered to the plaintiff. These inspections took place on 9 November 2019, 19 December 2019 and 7 January 2020. On each occasion, the crew concluded that the TVD was operating normally. During the trial, Mr Wilson explained that these checks would involve the crew accessing the TVD by removing the door of the crankshaft, activating the priming pump, and verifying whether the lubrication oil was being discharged from the discharge hole of the TVD. Mr Singh agreed that this was the standard practice for a TVD check. However, he expressed doubt as to whether these steps were actually carried out by the crew. On balance, I find that the crew conducted the standard procedure. The plaintiff has tendered no evidence to suggest why this would not be the case. I also note Mr Wilson’s observation that “[t]his is a standard practice you would do especially if the vessel had been laid up … for approximately three months”. In relation to the first inspection, conducted two weeks before the Vessel set off to China, it is reasonable to expect that these procedures are carried out, given that the Vessel had been lying idle in Singapore for a sustained period of time.
- [66]
[66] Notably, Mr Singh acknowledged that if the standard practice was executed, and the crew concluded that the TVD was operating normally, meaning that there was oil flowing through the TVD, that would confirm that the Replacement Crankshaft was fitted with an orifice plug:
- [67]
[67] Therefore, given that the Main Engine logbooks reported that the TVD was functioning normally, this supports the defendant’s position that it was an orifice plug that was in the free-end of the Replacement Crankshaft.
- [68]
[68] Another relevant piece of evidence is the oil residue located in the dismantled TVD. When the Main Engine was being repaired by the defendant in Singapore, the defendant serviced the TVD. In particular, the defendant cleaned the internal components of the TVD before fitting it to the Replacement Crankshaft. However, when the TVD was dismantled by Dalian Shunzhou in China, it displayed an oily interior. This was a markedly different appearance from the images taken of the TVD after it was serviced in Singapore, which depicted its clean interior. This indicates that the TVD continued to receive a flow of lubricating oil after the defendant conducted repairs on the Vessel. Mr Singh suggested that the oily interior was a result of oil being splashed and circulated from the Main Engine, which would gradually leak into the TVD through the two nozzles on the side of the TVD over the course of the eight months. Mr Singh further contended that this could have been a result of the oil mist which entered the TVD. Mr Wilson rejected these suggestions. I am not convinced by Mr Singh’s alternative explanations. Mr Singh only raised these examinations on the stand. Notably, the oily interior of the TVD was one of the issues canvassed in the Joint Report. Mr Singh stated that he would address this point in his Reply Expert Report. However, in Mr Singh’s Reply Expert Report dated 20 March 2023, he failed to address the point, let alone provide a viable explanation for it. Mr Wilson also refuted Mr Singh’s claim about the oil mist, explaining that oil mist could not have been present as that would have caused danger of an explosion and would have been picked up by the oil mist detectors of the Main Engine, which was not the case on the evidence. Therefore, on balance, I accept that the oily interiors of the TVD evidence that the TVD had received lubricating oil.
Video of removal of blank plug
- [69]
[69] The second arrow that the plaintiff carries in its quiver is a video that allegedly showing the discovery of the blank plug in the Replacement Crankshaft. According to Mr Lee, “[o]n 3 April 2020, the vessel crew together with the repairers from Dalian Shunzhou while inspecting the [Replacement Crankshaft], discovered that a blank plug had been installed by [the defendant] at the free-end of the [Replacement Crankshaft]”. The plaintiff exhibited a video of this alleged discovery, which was recorded by the plaintiff’s engineer, Mr Huang Chao (the “Video”). The Video was played during the trial and showed an individual removing a plug from the free-end of a crankshaft. The two persons filmed in the Video are repairers from Dalian Shunzhou. Upon viewing the video during the trial, Mr Dante confirmed that the Video was of the Replacement Crankshaft of the Vessel.
- [70]
[70] As a preliminary point, I accept that direct video recordings of facts in issue are admissible as evidence of those facts. They do not constitute hearsay evidence because they directly communicate the occurrence of what was seen, to the court: Jeffrey Pinsler, Evidence and the Litigation Process (2017, 6th Ed, Lexis Nexis) at para 4.057.
- [71]
[71] However, in my judgment, the evidence of the Video carries little weight. The alleged discovery of the blank plug took place more than seven months after the defendant redelivered the Vessel to the plaintiff, which is not an insignificant duration. Furthermore, the maker of the video, Mr Huang Chao, was not called as a witness in the proceedings. Therefore, he could not give evidence on the circumstances in which the Video arose, including how the alleged blank plug was discovered. He was also not present to testify on the nature of the plug that was discovered in the Replacement Crankshaft. Furthermore, the chain of evidence is not satisfactory. During the trial, Mr Lee exhibited WeChat messages dated 3 April 2020, where an employee of Eversea Shipping had sent to him photographs of a crankshaft, purportedly with a blank plug fitted in the free-end. However, there is no evidence of how Mr Lee came to receive the Video. Further, even if Mr Lee received the Video from Eversea Shipping, the chain of evidence from the maker of the Video, Mr Huang Chao, is not established.
- [72]
[72] I note that the Trade-wind Report mentions that “[d]uring the rectification works in Zhoushan Yuanye Shipyard”, “[a] nut was found blocking the lube oil supply channel in the crankshaft”. However, the maker of this report, Trade-wind, would not have direct knowledge of the alleged discovery of the blank plug. This is because Trade-wind’s surveyor only attended on board the Vessel between 14 and 15 March 2020, ie, prior to the alleged discovery of the blank plug on 3 April 2020. On the other hand, the Dalian Shunzhou Diesel Engine Inspection Report dated 13 May 2020 is silent on the issue. This report relates to the Main Engine repairs that were undertaken in Dalian Shunzhou and includes a series of photographs depicting an “[i]nspection of issues of original parts”. However, no mention is made of the alleged discovery of the blank plug fitted to the free-end of the Replacement Crankshaft This is curious, especially given Mr Lee’s claim that it was a “significant and crucial” discovery.
- [73]
[73] The defendant points to an inconsistency pertaining to the discrepancy in appearance between the plug featured in the Video (the “Video Plug”) and the physical exhibit presented by Mr Lee during the trial, which he claimed to be the actual blank plug that had been removed from the Vessel (“PE-1”). Firstly, the Video Plug contained a distinct ring-shape machining mark on its centre, whereas PE-1 does not. The plaintiff sought to argue that the reflected light in the Video gave the appearance of a ring on the Video plug. Further, the threads on the Video Plug appear to have some tape or material on it, which Mr Wilson suggests being “PTFE tape, plumber’s tape”. Again, however, this does not appear on PE-1. However, I am of the view that it is not possible to tell from the Video whether PE-1 is or is not the plug in the Video.
Mr Dante’s testimony
- [74]
[74] Additionally, the plaintiff relies on Mr Dante’s testimony on the stand to argue that the defendant had left a blank plug in the Replacement Crankshaft. To recapitulate, Mr Dante is a service engineer employed by the defendant. He was part of the defendant’s team which conducted repairs on the Main Engine from on or about 23 April 2019 to 20 August 2019. His role was to supervise and assist the team onboard the Vessel with the repair works conducted by the defendant. Under cross-examination, Mr Dante was asked whether his eight workers had forgotten to remove the blank plug. He answered in the affirmative. The plaintiff argues that this admission is “fatal” to the defendant’s case. According to the plaintiff, Mr Dante was the team leader and would have known if the blank plug had been left inside the Replacement Crankshaft by his workers. He would be capable of stating the defendant’s position on the state of affairs in respect of the blank plug.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.