Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 7 Oct 2024

General Division of the High Court

The defendant held shares as a nominee, and her claim of being misled into it failed

Xia Zheng v Lee King Anne

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHC 253Case no. Suit No 242 of 2021

The decision, in one line

Not legal advice

The defendant held shares as a nominee, and her claim of being misled into it failed

Summary by laws.sgParagraphs [3], [188]

There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] This case concerns two ostensible contractual agreements signed by the plaintiff and the defendant, being the parties to the plaintiff’s suit in HC/S 242/2021 (the “Claim”) that, on their face, created (or purported to create) an interest-free loan agreement (the “Loan Agreement”) between them, and under which moneys were said to have been loaned by the plaintiff to the defendant. Those moneys were then used to purchase shares in a listed company, thereby forming the subject-matter of the present dispute.

  3. [3] For the reasons which follow, I dismiss the Counterclaim in full and I dismiss the primary relief sought in the Claim – ie, for repayment of the moneys allegedly loaned to the defendant by the plaintiff or the return of the shares purchased therewith, pursuant to the terms of their putative Loan Agreement. However, I allow an alternative prayer sought in the plaintiff’s Claim – viz, a declaration that the defendant holds the shares on trust for the plaintiff. This is because I find, on the totality of the evidence before me, that the true arrangement between the parties was for the defendant to hold the shares on a bare trust as only a nominee shareholder, and not for moneys to be loaned to the defendant to purchase shares for her own benefit and as an absolute owner thereof. I elaborate further on how I arrive at that finding of fact below.

  4. Factual background

  5. Relevant persons

  6. [4] The plaintiff and first defendant in the Counterclaim is Ms Xia Zheng (“Xia”) while the defendant and plaintiff in the Counterclaim is Ms Lee King Anne (“Lee”) (collectively, “Xia and Lee”).

  7. [5] The second defendant in the Counterclaim and former husband of Xia is Mr Li Hua (alias Tony) (“Tony”). Furthermore, the contracts (or purported contracts) were said by the plaintiff in the Claim to have been entered into between Xia and Lee following communications between three other persons – first, Xia’s former husband, Tony; second, Lee’s husband to date, Mr Huang Zhi Rong (alias Billy) (“Billy”); and lastly, Mr Tanoto Sau Ian (alias Eric) (“Eric”), who was also the Chief Executive Officer, Managing Director, and Executive Director of USP Group Limited (the “Company” or “USP”).

  8. [6] Although Tony is a party to the proceedings as a second defendant to the Counterclaim, by the time that the trial commenced before me, he was absent and unrepresented throughout. Hence, I shall use the abbreviation the “parties” to refer to Xia and Lee specifically, and to the exclusion of Tony.

  9. Subject-matter of dispute between the parties

  10. [7] At present, Lee is the legal owner of 9,100,817 ordinary shares (the “Shares”) in USP, a Singapore-listed company. Lee acquired the legal title to the Shares in two different transactions by purchasing them from two vendors, namely, Bestway Investments Asia Pte Ltd (“Bestway”) and Mr Zeng Fuzu (“Zeng”) (collectively, the “Vendors”), in or around January–February 2020 for a total consideration sum of $1,856,150.64 (the “Advanced Sum”). However, during the trial, it was discovered that the Advanced Sum had in fact been furnished not by any Chinese investors but by Xia in the form of cashier’s orders obtained by her and then issued in favour of the Vendors.

  11. [8] The crux of the dispute centres on the nature by which Lee holds the Shares. On Xia’s case, Lee holds the Shares absolutely and for her own benefit because Lee had borrowed the Advanced Sum from Xia and the Advanced Sum was paid out as a loan to Lee, to be repaid by Lee to Xia under their contractual agreements with the terms having been set out in the documents signed by the parties. On Lee’s case, she holds the Shares as a trustee for the benefit of Xia qua payor, who never loaned the Advanced Sum to her, and to the extent that any purported contractual documents state otherwise, they were mere shams not intended to have any real legal effect.

  12. Disputed Documents executed between the parties

  13. [9] The true nature by which the Advanced Sum was extended by Xia to Lee turns on the import behind the parties’ execution of two documents purporting, on their face, to be contractual agreements. The fact that the parties signed them is not disputed.

  14. [10] The two documents are self-styled “Interest Free Loan Agreement[s]”, both dated 3 February 2020, and are in pari materia (collectively, the “Disputed Documents”). They state as follows:

  15. INTEREST FREE LOAN AGREEMENT

  16. I, [Lee], hereby agree [sic] this loan agreement and acknowledge receipt of a loan of Singapore dollars $ [particulars of the loan amount stated herein together with the details of the respective cashier’s orders for Bestway/Zeng], from [Xia], on [date of loan], without any interests [sic] whatsoever, to purchase [the Shares in the Company] from [the Vendors], according [sic] the S&P between [Lee] and [the Vendors] [in/on] [the dates of the sale and purchase agreements with the Vendors].

  17. I, [Lee], will give one original copy of S&P to [Xia] once it has been signed.

  18. I also sign the Charge, Form 9 of SGX, and Request for Transfer of Securities.

  19. The loan will last for 3 months from the date of this agreement, unless extended by the mutual agreement of both parties.

  20. [Xia] has the right to sell the shares or take over the Shares from [Lee] after 3 months.

  21. Commercial background behind the signing of the Disputed Documents by the parties

  22. [11] As the genuineness of the Disputed Documents is disputed between the parties, it is relevant to note the commercial background behind them which can shed light on the parties’ object and purpose behind their execution in 2020.

  23. [12] Based on the relevant affidavits filed or referred to by Tony and Eric – and the areas in which they are corroborated by the affidavits of Xia and Billy – the following facts emerge therefrom.

  24. [14] In January 2020, a series of WhatsApp messages were sent in a group chat (called “USP EGM”) consisting of Tony and Eric and two lawyers from Lee & Lee. Tony sought Lee & Lee’s assistance for the sale and purchase transactions with two then-shareholders in the Company (one of those two was Bestway, being one of the Vendors that sold the Shares to Lee). On 2 January 2020, in response to Tony’s query as to whether Lee & Lee could be the lawyer for the purchaser in the sales and purchase transactions, one of the Lee & Lee lawyers replied with: “As long as parties are separate and not acting in concert”.

  25. [15] On 3 January 2020, one of the Lee & Lee lawyers sent a WhatsApp message to that same group, reading as follows:

  26. [16] On 14 January 2020, a forwarded WhatsApp message originally from Tony stated as follows:

  27. [17] Lee concluded her deeds of share purchases with Bestway on 4 February 2020, and with Zeng on 31 January 2020. Xia then had her cashier’s orders issued not to Lee as the payee but directly to the two Vendors as payees vis-à-vis the Advanced Sum on 29 January (for Zeng) and 3 February 2020 (for Bestway). Zeng acknowledged receipt of the purchase moneys on 3 February 2020.

  28. [18] Soon thereafter, on 20 February 2020, an EGM was held by the Company, whereat most of its then-directors were voted out of office and inter alia Eric was voted in as a director.

  29. [19] After the EGM, Eric, Billy, and Tony were made part of a WhatsApp group (called “Shares”), wherein they had exchanged messages with respect to inter alia the EGM and acquisition of shares in the Company therefor. These included a message sent by Tony on 5 November 2020 to that WhatsApp group which reads as follows:

  30. [20] Moreover, on 8 November 2020, Billy sent a WhatsApp message to Tony as follows:

  31. [21] That same day, Tony replied to that message with the following:

  32. [22] On 30 December 2020, Xia signed and executed a self-styled “Letter of Waiver and Release”, pursuant to which she confirmed that Lee’s transfer of the Shares into the securities account of Xia “shall be in full and final settlement of the Obligations for the purchase of the aforesaid shares”. On the same day, Lee signed and executed a self-styled “Acknowledgement” letter, in which she acknowledged receipt of the “Letter of Waiver and Release” and confirmed that she would take steps to transfer the Shares to Xia’s securities account “within three (3) business days”. On 31 December 2020, she signed on a Singapore Exchange (SGX) form for “Request for Transfer of Securities”, for the Shares to be transferred from her to Xia. The Shares however still remain with Lee to date, although, at that time, Lee wanted to have the Shares transferred to Xia’s securities account. Apparently, there were some administrative problems that blocked the finalisation of the transfers.

  33. Procedural history

  34. History of Claim and Counterclaim

  35. [24] Lee filed her Defence on 7 April 2021, averring inter alia that the Disputed Documents were a sham as the true arrangement between the parties was for Lee to hold the Shares as a nominee shareholder for Tony’s “purported Chinese investors”. She also filed her Counterclaim for, primarily, compensation and indemnification on the basis of an alleged oral agreement to compensate and indemnify her for standing as the nominee shareholder for Tony’s “purported Chinese investors”.

  36. [25] At first, Lee’s Counterclaim was instituted solely against Xia. On 27 December 2021, Lee filed a third-party notice against Tony notifying him that she was filing a claim against him for inter alia compensation and indemnification for reasons that were similar to that in the Counterclaim filed against Xia. This was filed pursuant to her summons in HC/SUM 5796/2021 for leave to issue a third-party notice, which was filed on 20 December 2021 and then granted on 27 December 2021.

  37. [26] Hence, at first, Tony was actively participating in the proceedings. He filed his memorandum of appearance on 14 February 2022 and his defence against the third-party claim on 26 April 2022. He was represented at the time.

  38. Applications for summary judgment and striking out

  39. [28] On 4 May 2021, Xia filed two interlocutory applications. The first was HC/SUM 2109/2021 for Lee’s defence and counterclaim to be struck out (the “Striking Out Application”). The second was HC/SUM 2112/2021 for summary judgment to be entered in her favour ordering Lee to transfer the Shares to her (the “Summary Judgment Application”).

  40. [30] On the same day of 6 August 2021, Lee filed two registrar’s appeals (see HC/RAs 215/2021 and 216/2021) against the AR’s decision to grant the Striking Out Application and the Summary Judgment Application. Both appeals came up for hearing on 24 August 2021 before Tan Siong Thye J (as he then was), who allowed both appeals and gave written grounds in his ex tempore judgment: see Xia Zheng v Lee King Anne [2021] SGHC 199 (“Xia Zheng (Civil Procedure)”). Lee was granted unconditional leave to defend against Xia’s Claim. Lee was also allowed to prosecute her Counterclaim against Xia. It is of note that the triable issues raised by Lee at that interlocutory stage cohere with her pleaded case at trial. Particularly, she argued that the Disputed Documents were only signed to show Tony’s purported Chinese investors that their moneys had been used to acquire the Shares, which Lee would hold on to on their behalf. Their execution was not intended to create any legal relations (see Xia Zheng (Civil Procedure) at [11]–[12]).

  41. Application to set aside interim ex parte injunction

  42. [31] On 21 June 2021, Xia filed a summons in HC/SUM 2911/2021 for an interim injunction to be rendered on an ex parte basis restraining Lee from selling or dealing in the Shares or from exercising any of the rights inhered therein. The interim injunction was granted against Lee on an ex parte basis on 23 June 2021 (see HC/ORC 3481/2021 dated 23 June 2021 and filed on 24 June 2021 in Xia’s HC/SUM 2911/2021) (the “Interim Injunction”).

  43. [32] Lee then filed an application to discharge the Interim Injunction in HC/SUM 3044/2021 on 30 June 2021 (the “Setting Aside Application”). She, Billy, and Eric all filed affidavits in support of the Setting Aside Application (collectively, the “Setting Aside Affidavits”).

  44. [33] The Setting Aside Affidavits averred inter alia that the acquisition of the Shares by Lee took place against the backdrop of a takeover attempt to vote out the Company’s board of directors at the EGM on 20 February 2020, involving inter alia Billy, Eric, and Tony (see [18] above).

  45. [34] In response to the Setting Aside Affidavits, both Xia and Tony filed affidavits–in–reply (“Xia’s Reply Affidavit” and “Tony’s Reply Affidavit”, respectively; collectively, the “Reply Affidavits”) on 22 July 2021. In Xia’s Reply Affidavit, she averred as follows:

  46. B. Requisitioning and voting in the Extraordinary General Meeting (“EGM”)

  47. [paragraph 14 omitted]

  48. 15. It was around this time that I was approached to support Eric’s intention to ascend to the Director of USP. Since I was already fairly interested in acquiring USP’s shares in my own right Tony asked me whether I would be agreeable to purchasing the shares and parking it in the name of the Defendant until the EGM was over, whereupon the shares would be returned to me. I agreed to do so.

  49. C. First Interest Free Loan Agreement (“IFLA”) between myself and the Defendant

  50. 16. To formalise the relationship between the Defendant and myself, we entered into the first IFLA dated 3 February 2020. I shall detail the salient terms for ease of reference:

  51. [terms omitted]

  52. 17. From the terms of the IFLA above, it is clear that the Defendant was only allowed to hold the Shares in her name for only three (3) months. The reason behind the time period is significant – three months was the estimated time period for Eric to table resolutions and replace the 2nd BOD in the EGM, and elect another Board of Directors in their stead. Thereafter and at the end of the three months, the Shares ought to have be [sic] transferred back to me. I provided the purchase monies of $1,460,291 to the Defendant on 30 January 2020.

  53. [emphasis in original in bold and italics] [emphasis added in underline]

  54. [35] Likewise, Tony’s Reply Affidavit averred as follows:

  55. 9. On or around December 2019 / January 2020, Eric, Billy, and I discussed about whether it was possible or feasible to oust the 2nd Board of Directors of USP as we felt that the 2nd Board was not doing a proper job. I accept that I actively participated in these discussions. While these discussions were largely verbal, I confirm that I participated in the Whatsapp communications in a groupchat formed between Billy, Eric and me. …

  56. 10. Sometime in January 2020, I spoke to my ex-wife, the Plaintiff (“Xia Zheng”). If I recall correctly, it was an occasion that I was updating her on what I was doing at that time. I believe I mentioned to her that I was in discussions with Eric and Billy to fulfil Eric’s intention to ascend to the Board of USP so that he could turn his fortunes around as he appeared to have good business ideas and a number of contacts. If this plan succeeded then USP could look to better days ahead. I understood from the Plaintiff that if there was a prospect of a decent investment return, she may be willing to invest in USP shares. Sometime in late January, an opportunity for the Plaintiff to acquire shares from Bestway and Zeng Fuzu materialised. As such, the Plaintiff and I spoke about it and the Plaintiff agreed to purchase those shares. I asked the Plaintiff whether she would be agreeable to purchasing the shares and parking it in the name of the Defendant until an EGM to appoint Eric onto the Board was held and after that the shares would be returned to her. She agreed to do so.

  57. 11. Accordingly, the Plaintiff agreed to provide the money for the Defendant to buy over Bestway and Zeng Fuzu shares at in [sic] January 2020 and February 2020 (i.e. a total sum of $1,856,150.64 (“Loan Sum”) for the purchase of T shares (“the Shares”) in USP). Before providing the Loan Sum, the Plaintiff reiterated to me that she wanted for the Shares to be returned to her, within 3 months (i.e. after Eric has successfully replaced the 2nd BOD). This was reflected in the Interest Free Loan Agreements (“IFLAs”): [terms omitted]

  58. 12. The real reason for having the loan agreement without interest is so that the Defendant can acquire the Shares and vote in favour of Eric’s resolution. Once that is done, the Defendant can then transfer the Shares back to the provider of the purchase monies, the Plaintiff. …

  59. [emphasis in original in bold] [emphasis added in underline]

  60. Civil trial proceedings

  61. [37] The civil trial of the Claim and Counterclaim was heard over the course of seven days from 19–22 and 26–27 December 2023 and 15 February 2024. While Xia and Lee were present and represented throughout, Tony (the second defendant in the Counterclaim) was absent and unrepresented for all seven days of the trial. Quahe Woo & Palmer LLC appeared on a watching brief on behalf of the liquidator of Sunmax Global Capital Fund 1 Pte Ltd.

  62. Parties’ arguments

  63. Plaintiff’s submissions

  64. Claim

  65. [40] In the alternative, if the Disputed Documents are found to be a sham, then Xia seeks the payment of the Advanced Sum from Lee on the basis that Lee has been unjustly enriched owing to Xia paying the Advanced Sum to the Vendors under an invalid contract where there has been total failure of consideration.

  66. [41] Finally, Xia pleads, in the further alternative, for a declaration that Lee holds the Shares on a resulting trust for Xia, on the basis that she paid out the Advanced Sum without a corresponding intention to benefit Lee. For these reasons, Xia is entitled to succeed in her Claim for enforcement of the Disputed Documents and the transfer of the Advanced Sum (primarily) and the Shares (in the alternative) from Lee.

  67. Counterclaim

  68. [42] On Lee’s Counterclaim, Xia argues that it should be dismissed. First, she argues that Lee has failed to prove the existence of an oral agreement that Xia or Tony ever agreed to compensate or indemnify Lee for agreeing to be a nominee shareholder of the Shares. There is no objective evidence of such a promise having been made by Tony to Billy to compensate and indemnify Lee, such as that recorded in documentary evidence. In any event, even if it were assumed that Tony made that promise, it is not attributable to Xia as he was never her agent.

  69. [43] Next, Xia argues that Lee is not entitled to an indemnity on the basis of a fiduciary relationship between the parties because (a) Lee was never the fiduciary of Xia as their relationship was one of creditor and debtor; and (b) even if Lee held the Shares on trust, to the extent that it is based on either a constructive or resulting trust (as opposed to an express trust), no fiduciary duty is owed by Lee to Xia such as to give rise to an implied equitable obligation to indemnify Lee.

  70. Defendant’s submissions

  71. Claim

  72. [45] Lee submits that Xia’s Claim should be dismissed on the basis that the Disputed Documents do not disclose a true contractual agreement but are sham documents, in which the parties lacked any intention to create any legal relations thereon. The true arrangement between the parties all along, based on communications between Tony and Billy, was for Lee to hold the Shares as nominee shareholder for the payor(s) of the Advanced Sum, whether they be Tony’s “Chinese investors” as Lee originally believed at the time, or Xia as she has now come to understand. The context behind their execution was that Tony told Billy that Lee had to sign the Disputed Documents so as to assuage the “Chinese investors” that the Advanced Sum had, in fact, been used to purchase the Shares on their behalf. As such, Xia is not entitled to seek enforcement of the Disputed Documents.

  73. [46] Moreover, Lee argues that Xia’s alternative claim under unjust enrichment should be dismissed. Lee has not been unjustly enriched from the Advanced Sum because she presently holds the Shares on trust for Xia’s benefit now that she understands that Xia (and not Tony’s “Chinese Investors”) had in fact provided the Advanced Sum to purchase the Shares. Lee has also not been enriched at the expense of Xia either as she does not hold the Shares absolutely for her own benefit.

  74. [47] Lee concedes that, on her own case, Xia is the beneficial owner of the Shares. However, she highlights that her pleaded position remains that, while she is willing to return the Shares to Xia, this is subject to Xia giving her a comprehensive and irrevocable indemnity in relation to her holding the Shares as nominee shareholder for Xia. For all of these reasons, Lee submits that Xia’s Claim should be dismissed.

  75. Counterclaim

  76. [48] Lee seeks compensation in the amount of $100,000.00 from Xia and/or Tony for her holding the Shares as nominee shareholder for Xia. Her claim for $100,000.00 is premised on an oral agreement arising out of statements made by Tony to the effect that Lee would be compensated for acting as a nominee shareholder, thereby forming an agreement to that effect with him and/or Xia (with Tony acting as Xia’s agent) (the “Oral Agreement”). While the exact sum was not agreed, there was an agreement to the effect that Lee would receive reasonable remuneration for her services as a nominee shareholder on a quantum meruit basis, be it an express or implied term of the Oral Agreement.

  77. [49] In the alternative, Lee invokes the doctrine of promissory estoppel to argue that she is entitled to remuneration for holding the Shares as a nominee shareholder for Xia based on the representations of Tony (acting as the agent of Xia), which she has acted in reliance on.

  78. [50] In addition, Lee is entitled to be indemnified for any and all losses flowing from, or which may flow from, her acting as a nominee shareholder for Xia, based primarily on the Oral Agreement contracted with Tony (acting as Xia’s agent), who had promised that Lee would be indemnified in her capacity as a nominee shareholder. Alternatively, it arises out of an implied equitable obligation to indemnify Lee as the trustee of Xia holding the Shares for Xia’s benefit, as a facet of their fiduciary trustee-beneficiary relationship.

  79. [51] Finally, Lee seeks compensation from Xia for misrepresentation, both for fraudulent misrepresentation and under the Misrepresentation Act 1967 (2020 Rev Ed) (“MA 1967”). The false statement of fact was that the moneys in the Advanced Sum came from Tony’s “Chinese investors” when, in truth, they came from Xia instead. In reliance on that false representation, Lee agreed to hold the Shares as a nominee shareholder only. Lee was induced by the false representations of Tony that the Disputed Documents were only being signed to inform the supposed “Chinese investors” that their moneys were being used to purchase the Shares to be held on trust for them.

  80. [52] And as a result of Lee holding the Shares as Xia’s nominee, she was sued in the Conspiracy Lawsuit for acting in an alleged tortious conspiracy with inter alia Xia, Billy, Eric, and Tony, for allegedly acting in concert with them as a nominee shareholder in the Company, incurring legal expenses in the process and having to pay out a settlement sum to the plaintiff of that action. These are the consequential economic losses flowing from, and caused by, the actionable misrepresentations of Xia and Tony, for which they are liable.

  81. Issues to be decided

  82. [53] It follows that these are the issues which I have to decide –

  83. [54] I shall address each of these issues in turn.

  84. Issue 1: Parties did not intend to create a contract whereby the plaintiff provided an interest-free loan to the defendant to be repaid at a later date on the terms of the Disputed Documents

  85. [55] I find, on the totality of the evidence before me, that Xia and Lee never intended to create any legal relations between them based on their signing the Disputed Documents. The true arrangement between them was for Lee to hold the Shares, not for her own benefit, but as a nominee shareholder for the person or persons paying the Advanced Sum – which, based on the statements of Tony, she had understood to be the undisclosed “Chinese investors” known to Tony.

  86. [56] As such, it follows that Xia is not entitled to seek enforcement of the Disputed Documents, which were never intended to create any true contractual relationship between the parties. It also follows that Xia is entitled to the grant of her alternative remedy prayed for in her pleadings, viz, “Alternatively, a declaration that the Defendant holds the Shares on trust for the Plaintiff”.

  87. [57] I arrive at these factual findings upon the totality of the evidence before me, which I analyse as follows.

  88. Admissions of Xia and Tony in their Reply Affidavits

  89. [58] First, the admissions of Xia and Tony in their Reply Affidavits clearly demonstrate that the true intention behind the Disputed Documents was not – as the documents suggest, on their face – to extend an interest-free loan to Lee, but rather to have Lee hold the Shares as a nominee shareholder only, for the purposes of the EGM on 20 February 2020, whereat the Company’s board was to be replaced (see [34]–[35] above).

  90. [59] The contents of the Reply Affidavits clearly contradict Xia’s case that the Disputed Documents were intended to extend an interest-free loan to Lee. If the Advanced Sum was extended to Lee as a genuine loan, then Lee would own beneficially the Advanced Sum and would be under an obligation to repay Lee an equivalent amount (without interest) within three months. It would follow that Lee would own the Shares absolutely for her own benefit as she would have bought the Shares for herself using the Advanced Sum that she owned beneficially, and she would be entitled to exercise the rights therein – including voting rights – independently and howsoever she wished.

  91. [62] Many crucial aspects of the Reply Affidavits contradict Xia’s pleaded case that the Disputed Documents reflected a genuine contractual intent of the parties to create an interest-free loan arrangement between them. Far from Lee desiring to purchase the Shares for her own benefit or in furtherance of the plans of her husband Billy, the Reply Affidavits are clear that it was actually Xia who wanted to purchase the Shares for herself to further the plans of Tony and Eric to replace the board of the Company. Xia’s Reply Affidavit states that “Eric’s plans to inject more business through his contacts appeared promising. If Eric [sic] plans came to fruition, the value of USP Shares would increase. As such, I considered it to be a potentially viable investment opportunity for myself” [emphasis added], ie, the purchase of the Shares was for Xia’s own benefit and not for Lee’s. Xia’s Reply Affidavit makes clear that she “was already fairly interested in acquiring USP’s shares in [her] own right”.

  92. [63] Likewise, this evidence is corroborated by Tony’s Reply Affidavit, which states (at para 10) that:

  93. [64] Moreover, Tony’s Reply Affidavit explicitly states: “I categorically state that the beneficial and absolute owner of the Shares is the Plaintiff”. Hence, the Reply Affidavits make clear that it was Xia who wanted to buy the Shares and not Lee. It was therefore Xia who acquired the beneficial ownership and not Lee. That is inconsistent with a loan whereby Lee would become the beneficial owner of the Advanced Sum and the Shares that were purchased therewith.

  94. [66] In her cross-examination, Xia attempted to belatedly distance herself from the evidence in the Reply Affidavits. First, she contradicted her affidavit evidence in her Reply Affidavit when she disagreed with the question put to her that “[t]he true reason why you, Xia Zheng, wanted to buy the shares was because you wanted to help Tony use the shares to vote in an EGM to appoint Eric onto the board. Agree or disagree?”

  95. [67] When confronted with the contents of her Reply Affidavit, Xia tried to distance herself from what she had affirmed in her own affidavit evidence by suggesting that she did not know its contents when she swore on it and filed it in opposition to Lee’s Setting Aside Application. In her own words: “The lawyer asked me to ask so---sorry, asked me to sign and I signed” and “Sorry, at the time I was---I just started suing Lee King Anne and I didn’t know English, I didn’t understand the procedures. And that time, the lawyer asked me to sign and I just signed. And this is the first time I am seeing it and I am not very sure about it. And I don’t even recognise the names here”.

  96. [68] I do not accept Xia’s attempts to distance herself from the contents of her Reply Affidavit. Xia’s Reply Affidavit was filed in opposition to the Setting Aside Application and to preserve the Interim Injunction. It is not believable or credible that Xia swore to an affidavit in these proceedings, in support of her own position at the interlocutory stage, and filed it through her legal counsel without having any awareness of its contents. More likely, Xia swore to and filed the Reply Affidavit because it was the truth and, at the time, supported her interlocutory position to maintain the Interim Injunction against Lee on the basis that Lee had no rights over the Shares. Now, she makes a belated attempt to distance herself from her own Reply Affidavit because it is inconvenient to her pleaded case on the merits – viz, that she had loaned the Advanced Sum to Lee to purchase the Shares for Lee’s own benefit and Lee was therefore not a bare trustee of the Shares for her.

  97. [69] Moreover, Xia’s attempt to downplay her English proficiency by suggesting that she was unable to read the contents of her Reply Affidavit which were in English (as opposed to it having been interpreted to her prior to her affirming its contents), was also not believable. Having had the benefit of observing Xia in the witness box, I note that she was able to proficiently read and pronounce the words in the Disputed Documents – which were entirely in English – without any difficulty, and she herself admitted to having been able to comprehend its contents. That, too, contradicted Xia’s earlier evidence that she had trouble understanding the Disputed Documents because its contents were in English. I find, therefore, that these were self-interested and belated attempts by Xia to give evidence tailored to disown her position in her Reply Affidavit which, as I have found, contradicts her pleaded case. Hence, I accord little weight to Xia’s explanations for disavowing the contents of that Reply Affidavit. I totally reject her evidence that she did not know its contents at the time she affirmed her Reply Affidavit which was subsequently filed in court on her behalf in the Setting Aside Application. I find that she was fully aware of the contents that she had affirmed in her Reply Affidavit.

  98. [70] As for Tony’s Reply Affidavit, Xia also tried to distance herself from his affidavit evidence when confronted with its contents during her cross-examination. Her evidence in response to a series of put questions was that she had never seen that affidavit and disagreed with its contents. The weight and credibility of her evidence on this front stands to be appraised in light of the fact that I have found that she tried to give self-serving evidence on the stand tailored to distance herself from her own prior averments in her Reply Affidavit (see [67]–[69] above), and the contents of which cohere with that of Tony’s Reply Affidavit. Hence, as a matter of common-sense, that would afford a strong reason to accord little weight to Xia’s similar explanations to distance herself from the evidence in Tony’s Reply Affidavit.

  99. [71] At no point did Xia refute any of the averments in Tony’s Reply Affidavit or seek permission of the court to file an affidavit to rebut the claims he made therein, such as when the Setting Aside Application came up for a hearing on 26 July and 10 August 2021. That fact is not without significance. Given that the contents of Tony’s Reply Affidavit concerned Xia’s own alleged actions and squarely contradicted her pleaded case, if they were indeed all untrue, then it is curious that Xia made no attempts to disavow or refute Tony’s evidence back then. In fact, as I have found, the contents of Tony’s Reply Affidavit actually materially corroborate the contents of Xia’s Reply Affidavit instead (see [62]–[63] above).

  100. Contemporaneous communications between Tony, Eric, and Billy

  101. [73] The inference of fact that Xia extended the Advanced Sum to purchase the Shares for her own benefit but then placed it under the legal name of Lee as a mere nominee shareholder is further bolstered by the contents of the various messages exchanged between Tony, Eric, and Billy.

  102. [74] On 5 November 2020, Tony sent a WhatsApp message to a group consisting of him, Eric and Billy (see [19] above), which stated that “Ann [sic] need to pay the money to Chinese investors. There is no delay. Chinese investors gave me the buyer name yesterday. We will start to transfer the shares tomorrow”.

  103. [75] This message must be interpreted in tandem with Billy’s WhatsApp message to Tony on 8 November 2020 (see [20] above), which stated that: “Regarding the shares you put with Anne, pls let me know when you are ready to trf. Anne has held the shares for your investors since Feb 2020., [sic] and was potentially exposed to litigation in relation to USP, Eric and you” [emphasis added].

  104. [76] Several facts emerge from the messages of 5 and 8 November 2020. First, it is clear that they support the inference of fact that Lee (referred to as “Ann” in the first message and “Anne” in the second message) was never regarded as the absolute beneficial owner of the Shares in her own right. She held the Shares “for” Tony’s Chinese investors only. This bolsters the inference of fact that Lee was only a nominee shareholder throughout.

  105. [77] Second, the words “the shares you put with Anne” further supports the inference of fact that the Shares were only ‘parked’ under the legal name of Lee as a nominee shareholder without her ever having true ownership thereof, based on the evidence in the Reply Affidavits that the Shares were meant to be ‘parked’ in the name of Lee for the purposes of the upcoming EGM of 20 February 2020 to vote to change the board composition of the Company.

  106. [78] Third, both messages speak of Lee having to transfer the Shares to a “buyer” whose name would be provided by Tony’s “Chinese investors”. Lee had no discretion to sell to anyone as she pleased at the highest price (which a true beneficial owner would have). Instead, Lee had to transfer those Shares only at the instance of the “Chinese investors” and only to a named “buyer” selected by the “Chinese investors” and at a time unilaterally decided by the “Chinese investors”.

  107. [80] These WhatsApp messages between Tony and Billy make sense only when understood in the following factual context: (a) as far as Lee knew at the time, the “Chinese investors” had provided the moneys to Lee to buy the Shares on their behalf; (b) the mechanism for the transfer of moneys to Lee from the “Chinese investors” was to have Xia act as the conduit for the flow of funds amalgamated from various Chinese investors; (c) Xia would, after collecting the moneys from these various Chinese investors, transfer the moneys to Lee as part of that mechanism or Xia could bypass Lee and transfer/pay the moneys directly to the two Vendors of the Shares (which would be more convenient, and also safer, for the Chinese investors, as Lee would not have the chance to handle any of the moneys originating from the Chinese investors); (d) Lee was to purchase the Shares in her own name on behalf of the Chinese investors and become the nominee shareholder for the Chinese investors; (e) the Chinese investors as the true beneficial owners would have the right to sell (and therefore transfer) the Shares at any time to any “buyer” of their choice and at a price to be determined by them; (f) the Chinese investors therefore provided the name of the “buyer” to whom they had ostensibly sold the Shares registered in Lee’s name as the nominee shareholder for these Chinese investors; and (g) the named “buyer” would therefore have to pay Lee as the registered shareholder the purchase and sale consideration, and Lee would, in turn, obviously have to transfer to the Chinese investors the sale proceeds that she would subsequently receive after she had transferred the Shares held nominally in her name to the named “buyer”. This was how the sale of the Shares by the Chinese investors to the “buyer” was intended to be done and how the flow of the sale proceeds was contemplated to take place, based on the information known to Lee and Billy at that time.

  108. [81] As such, these WhatsApp messages support the inference of fact that Lee acquired the Shares in her legal name as a mere nominee. That would clearly contradict Xia’s pleaded case that the Disputed Documents were intended to create an interest-free loan arrangement between the parties, giving rise to the Loan Agreement between them. If that were the case, Lee would have become the absolute owner of the Advanced Sum, to be used to purchase the Shares, which she too would own outright, in exchange for her taking on a corresponding obligation to repay the Advanced Sum to Xia by a given deadline. That clearly was not the intended or agreed arrangement, given that these WhatsApp messages speak of Lee not as the Shares’ true owner but a mere nominee thereof.

  109. [82] For completeness, I note the possible argument that the wording of “Ann [sic] need to pay the money to Chinese investors” could be said to support the pleaded case of Xia that Lee took on an obligation to subsequently pay Xia back the moneys that Xia had lent pursuant to a Loan Agreement, whereby Lee had used the Advanced Sum to buy the Shares for herself. The first difficulty with this argument is that the message did not say that “Ann” (ie, Lee) needed to pay the money to Xia (ie, to repay the loan that “Ann” had allegedly taken from Xia to purchase the Shares for herself). Instead, the message stated that Lee had to pay (or repay) the money to the “Chinese investors”, which would not make any sense, unless “Chinese investors” (referred to in the first sentence of Tony’s WhatsApp message) had all along been meant to be a reference to Xia herself, which obviously was not the case in the whole series of WhatsApp messages. The second difficulty is that, even if it were to be assumed that the phrase “pay the money” within Tony’s message was a reference to Lee’s repayment obligations to Xia under the Loan Agreement, as per the Disputed Documents, it is not clear why Tony was also instructing that Lee must transfer the Shares to a new buyer because his “Chinese investors” (referred to in the second sentence of the WhatsApp message) have apparently found a “buyer”, unless the plural phrase “Chinese investors” is again to be taken to mean Xia alone. I do not believe that this is a double typographical error occurring in both sentences made by Tony. Instead, the message is in substance about Lee having to pay the “Chinese investors” as the beneficial owner of the Shares after transferring (and selling) the Shares the next day to the new “buyer” found by the “Chinese investors” and as instructed by the “Chinese investors” through Tony to Billy. All of this is neither consistent with the Disputed Documents nor the Loan Agreement said to be constituted thereunder. The Disputed Documents, on their face, do not state that Lee was to pay any moneys within any given deadline. They only state that, after three months, Xia is then entitled to “sell the shares or take over the Shares from [Lee]”, but not before the three months have passed. Even if one were to interpret the Disputed Documents to mean that Lee is given a fixed term loan of three months and, failing repayment at the expiry of the period of the loan, Xia is entitled to possess the Shares and to sell them if Xia wished to do so, that would still be irreconcilable with Tony’s message, which speaks of both the need for Lee to “pay the money” and “to transfer the shares tomorrow”.

  110. [83] As such, the WhatsApp messages of 5 and 8 November 2020 do not lend any support to the pleaded case of Xia of an arrangement to loan moneys or to lend the Advanced Sum with no interest to Lee for a fixed period of three months, pursuant to the written terms of the Disputed Documents, for her to purchase the Shares for herself. Rather, they lend support for Lee’s pleaded case that she was only a mere nominee of the Shares throughout.

  111. Corroborative evidence of Eric

  112. [84] Next, I consider that the evidence of Eric further supports the pleaded case of Lee that she was never the absolute owner of the Shares but a mere nominee shareholder of the same.

  113. [85] First, I consider the contents of Eric’s Affidavit of Evidence-in-Chief (“AEIC”) filed in the Conspiracy Lawsuit, which he craved leave to refer to in his supplementary AEIC for these proceedings. Eric’s evidence there was clear that he wanted to acquire control over the board of directors of the Company. As part of his plans, he had to acquire control over more shares in the Company or get the other shareholders to agree to support his plans and help him to take control of the board of directors of the Company when it was time to vote at an EGM. Tony then informed Eric that he was in contact with “the Chinese Investors” who were willing to acquire the Shares from the two Vendors in support of his plans for the Company. According to Eric, “[t]hese shares were held by Lee King Anne, the 6th Defendant, as Trustee” [emphasis added].

  114. [86] Eric reiterates that evidence in his AEIC for these proceedings. He avers there that Tony arranged a meeting with “the Chinese Investors” who were willing to purchase shares in the Company, with Tony as their liaison for their investments. Then, “Tony informed me that he had asked Billy and his wife, the Defendant and Plaintiff in Counterclaim (“Anne”) for their help to hold shares for the Chinese Investors” [emphasis in original in bold; emphasis added in italics].

  115. [87] I accept Eric’s evidence and give weight to it as credible and reliable. He withstood cross-examination and made clear in his evidence that the person chosen to hold the Shares for Tony’s “Chinese investors”, who came to be aligned with Eric’s plans for the Company, had to be someone who would vote the way that the Chinese investors wanted them to vote, “take directions from the Chinese investors”, and would not “have a controlling mind of her own, you know, to vote in whatever way she wants, you see”. As such, the chosen person to hold the Shares would play the role of being “just a proxy”. The person chosen to act as that “proxy” became Lee, Billy’s wife. She could be trusted to play the role of that “proxy” because, at least at that point in time, Eric, Tony, and Billy were all aligned in their common aim and design to effect a change in the board composition of the Company at the next EGM.

  116. [88] In considering the weight to be attributed to Eric’s evidence in these proceedings, two important factors have to be taken into account. First, Eric was a neutral, non-partisan witness with no personal incentive or motive to tailor his evidence in favour of either Xia or Lee. Whatever Eric’s past dealings with Billy and Tony, and his interest in the Conspiracy Lawsuit, for the purposes of this action, Eric has no direct stake or interest in the outcome of the Claim and Counterclaim. He neither gains nor loses in any personal capacity if Xia fails or succeeds in recovering moneys from Lee or if Lee fails or succeeds in receiving compensation and indemnification from Xia. As an unaligned party with no interest in these proceedings, the weight to be attributed to his evidence is accordingly greater than if it were otherwise.

  117. [89] More importantly, Eric’s evidence on this area is bolstered by the external consistency with the other evidence – particularly, the evidence in the Reply Affidavits and the WhatsApp messages of November 2020, which, as I have found (see [72] and [83] above), all support the inference of fact that Lee was meant to be a nominee shareholder of the Shares all along and not the absolute owner thereof. That necessarily bolsters the weight to be attributed to Eric’s evidence that Lee was chosen to be the “proxy” holding the Shares for Tony’s “Chinese investors” who were backing Eric’s plans to take control of the board of directors of the Company.

  118. [90] As such, I accept Eric’s evidence that Lee was chosen to be a nominee shareholder to own the Shares in furtherance of his plan – supported at the time by Billy and Tony – to replace the then-board of directors at the Company’s next EGM. That necessarily means that Lee was never intended to be an absolute owner of the Shares with complete freedom to exercise the rights therein, including the voting rights, howsoever she pleased. Her being a bare trustee of the Shares for concert parties who would back up Eric’s plans to replace the then-board of directors of the Company is irreconcilable with the pleaded case of Xia that Lee borrowed moneys from Xia to purchase the Shares for herself because she lacked sufficient funds for the acquisition. Lee being a mere nominee of the Shares is also inconsistent with her borrowing the moneys in the Advanced Sum from Xia, which would have involved her acquiring the beneficial ownership of the Advanced Sum, and then the Shares that were purchased therewith, whilst coming under a legal obligation to repay that sum as a result of having borrowed the Advanced Sum for herself from Xia, with the consequence that Lee could not simply “repay” the loan to Xia by returning the Shares (whose total value, based on its traded market price, if not suspended, could well be significantly below the amount of the Advanced Sum at the time of such return) without making up for the shortfall in cash.

  119. Surrounding commercial circumstances involving the change in the board composition of the Company at the EGM of 20 February 2020

  120. [91] Next, I find that the inference of fact that Lee was intended to be a mere nominee of the Shares and not an absolute owner thereof receives further support when one examines the surrounding commercial circumstances at the time, namely, the upcoming EGM of 20 February 2020 and Eric’s plans to take over the Company’s board of directors, which were supported, in varying capacities, by Tony and Billy at the time (see [13] and [18] above).

  121. [92] It is clear that Eric was motivated, at the time, to ensure that the total number of ordinary shares in the Company under his legal name did not exceed the requisite threshold such as to trigger an obligation to make a general offer to all members of the Company. That much is clear from the messages sent by Lee & Lee’s lawyers in the WhatsApp group called “USP Shares” in January 2020 (see [14]–[15] above). I note, in particular, the 3 January 2020 message from one of the Lee & Lee lawyers, which specifically states that: “i thought eric is not entering into the [B]estway contract? If he does he may cross 30% with the deemed interest based on his existing transactions? So a completely separate party shd be the transacting party” [emphasis added]. This was a reference to the (then) prospective share purchase agreement to purchase 12.8 million ordinary shares in the Company from the vendor Bestway. At that time, Eric was searching for an appropriate counterparty to buy the Shares from Bestway – one who, in the words of the Lee & Lee lawyer, would be “a completely separate party”, and who would not cause Eric to exceed the stated 30% threshold for a mandatory general offer to be triggered pursuant to Rule 14 of the Takeover Code. That was why, as of 3 January 2020, the draft sales and purchase contract with Bestway still had a placeholder for the purchaser thereof, under “[Name of Purchaser]”, in the email sent from Lee & Lee to Eric and Tony. They were still searching for an appropriate counterparty who would be “completely separate” and would not appear to be a concert party to avoid hitting the 30% threshold to trigger a mandatory general offer under the Takeover Code.

  122. [93] Hence, as Eric stated in his evidence, he did not want to hold the Shares in the Company because “I had already committed myself to about 25.4%, you know, of USP shares and my lawyers advised me that it is not prudent, you know, because, you know, we’re coming really close to the 30%, you know, and … I didn’t want to get myself in that kind of situation, so I rejected Tony Li Hua and I told him that he had to look for someone else” [emphasis added]. The legal advice referenced here is the advice given by the Lee & Lee lawyer in the 3 January 2020 WhatsApp message quoted at both [15] and [92] above, as stated in Eric’s evidence.

  123. [94] The fact that Eric, Billy, and Tony were attempting to find a way to procure the acquisition of the Shares without hitting the 30% threshold such as to trigger the mandatory general offer under Rule 14 of the Takeover Code receives additional support from the Setting Aside Affidavits of Billy, Eric, and Lee, all of which also make mention of this consideration. The affidavit of Lee states that when “Eric attempted to enter into a sale and purchase agreement with Bestway, Eric’s lawyers then … advised him, that he could not do so without triggering a General Offer to the rest of shareholders of USP as he would have crossed the 30% threshold”. Billy’s affidavit states that: “Tony approached me and told me that Eric needed to buy the Bestway Shares to beef up his shares to defeat Ricky. Tony further explained that Eric could not do it as it would cause Eric to cross the 30% threshold and cause a G.O.”

  124. [95] Moreover, Eric’s affidavit states that “at that point in time, as I had already acquired 25.14% of USP shares, I was advised by my then solicitors that I would not be able to buy any more shares. Therefore, I rejected the shareholders’ offers to sell to me and offered instead to explore working together instead in the interest of USP”. Hence, the Setting Aside Affidavits demonstrate that, at the time, the relevant players had, in their minds as a material consideration, the need to ensure Eric did not hit the minimum 30% threshold to trigger a mandatory general offer, pursuant to the Takeover Code.

  125. [96] The fact that Eric was motivated to avoid triggering a mandatory general offer in his acquisition of sufficient shares in the Company to take over its board at the next EGM is relevant in shedding light on why the parties likely arranged the affairs between them in the way that they did. Tony’s “Chinese investors” would provide the Advanced Sum to purchase the Shares and they would have to appear as non-concert parties, although they would use these Shares to vote on the side of Tony and Eric at the upcoming EGM of 20 February 2020. The Shares would, however, be held in the name of Lee to make it appear that she was both the legal and beneficial owner, voting in her own right, and hence, her votes at the EGM would not be linked to either Tony or Eric as concert parties voting the same way at the EGM. However, Lee being in fact a mere nominee holding the Shares on a bare trust was obligated to vote in accordance with the wishes of the true owner, ie, the payor of the Advanced Sum (be it Xia, in truth, or Tony’s “Chinese investors”, as Lee and Billy believed at the time). As Eric put it in his evidence, because Lee was never the true owner of the Shares, it followed that, in terms of voting at the EGM, she was “only performing an administrative role” and “in this particular instance, [she] is just playing an administrative role”. In other words, she was never an absolute owner who could decide, independently, whether she would vote in favour of or against that resolution at the EGM, which right a beneficial owner would have.

  126. [97] Since Lee was in fact a nominee shareholder, she could not have borrowed the Advanced Sum from Xia to acquire the Shares from the Vendors for herself beneficially. If she had been intended to be a debtor of the Advanced Sum, she would have acquired beneficial ownership of the Advanced Sum and, by extension, the Shares purchased by Lee with the borrowed moneys. The result would have been that Lee would have had complete freedom to vote howsoever she pleased at the EGM and she would not be a nominee shareholder having no such freedom. I find, therefore, that these surrounding commercial circumstances lend further support for the factual inference that Lee was only intended to be a bare trustee of the Shares. That is factually incompatible with an inference that the parties intended for Lee to borrow the Advanced Sum from Xia to purchase the Shares for herself.

  127. Wording of the Disputed Documents themselves

  128. [98] Finally, the fact that the parties never intended to create an interest-free loan, with a creditor-debtor relationship between them, giving rise to the Loan Agreement alleged by Xia, receives further support when one considers the curious wording employed in the Disputed Documents themselves. Certain parts of that wording contradict Xia’s pleaded case that the parties had intended to contract an interest-free loan based on a creditor-debtor relationship.

  129. [100] For one, in a typical loan arrangement, the debtor who borrows moneys becomes the absolute owner with freedom to apply those sums to the purposes he or she deems fit, with a personal obligation to repay the sum to the creditor. The creditor does not generally control the moneys themselves once they have been extended to the debtor. Here, however, the Disputed Documents specify the destination of the Advanced Sum, viz, to “pay to ‘Zeng [sic] Fuzu …to purchase … USP Group Limited shares (the Shares) from Zeng Fuzu”, and likewise for the purchase of the Bestway shares in USP.

  130. [101] To be clear, this factor, in itself, is not definitive. Parties are free to tailor and customise their own loan arrangements however they deem fit, in exercise of their freedom of contract. They may add the terms and conditions they desire even if they differ from the usual form of a creditor-debtor relationship. I note, however, that it is unusual for Lee, as the borrower of the Advanced Sum, to be limited or constrained in how she may use the moneys borrowed for a particular purpose of purchasing the Shares from Zeng and Bestway. Even if the wording at [100] above is viewed as purely prefatory, it must be considered against the fact that the Advanced Sum was never paid to Lee directly for Lee to purchase the Shares for herself (see [17] above). Instead, Xia ensured that the cashier’s orders were issued in favour of the Vendors instead of in Lee’s favour. This is also not definitive, in itself. It could mean that Lee, as the borrower of the Advanced Sum, gave instructions to the creditor to apply the sum directly to the Vendors, to facilitate the acquisition of the Shares. However, it is a relevant factor within the factual matrix that I take into consideration. It was an unusual means of structuring a creditor-debtor relationship, since normally a debtor has the complete freedom, as beneficial owner of the borrowed moneys, to apply the sum howsoever he or she wishes, and is at liberty to change his or her mind about where the moneys would go to. Here, however, the Disputed Documents not only specify what the Advanced Sum was to be applied to, viz, as “a loan … to purchase … USP Group Limited shares”, but the supposed borrower, Lee, never came into direct possession of the moneys which she ostensibly came to own beneficially in exchange for a corresponding personal liability to repay her supposed creditor, Xia. Rather, these words in the Disputed Documents, coupled with how the acquisition of the Shares was effected, are more naturally congruent with a nominee arrangement in which Xia retained control over the Advanced Sum throughout – including its destination and the object and purpose to which it would be applied – and Lee was but a bare trustee of the same.

  131. [102] More significantly, however, the Disputed Documents do not describe the date when Lee is required to repay the Advanced Sum to Xia. Instead, the dispositive parts of the Disputed Documents state that:

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.