General Division of the High Court · Decided 21 October 2024
Outrage of modesty and rape of the same victim were treated as one transaction
Public Prosecutor v Raj Kumar s/o Bala
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC 265 · Case no. Criminal Case No 25 of 2023
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
Outrage of modesty and rape of the same victim were treated as one transaction
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraphs [197], [198]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The accused faced a total of 25 charges. He was tried before me on two of these charges. The first was for one count of outrage of modesty under s 354(1) of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) (“the Penal Code”) (“the First Charge”). The second was for one count of rape under s 375(1)(a) p/u s 375(2) of the Penal Code (“the Second Charge”). Both charges concerned the same alleged victim, whom I will refer to as the complainant. She was 17 years old at the time of the alleged offences in February 2020.
- [2]
[2] The First and the Second Charges read as follows:
- [3]
[3] There was a third charge which the Prosecution proceeded on (“the Third Charge”) and which concerned an offence under s 78(c) of the Children and Young Persons Act (Cap 38, 2001 Rev Ed) (“CYPA”). The Third Charge was stood down for the duration of the trial, as the Defence communicated that the accused would be pleading guilty to it.
Background facts
- [4]
[4] The following facts were undisputed.
- [5]
[5] In February 2020, the accused was the owner of Don Bar & Bistro (“Don Bar”), which was located at 82 Dunlop Street.
- [6]
[6] The complainant and two other girls, whom I will refer to as A and B, were all abscondees from the Singapore Girls’ Home. A was then 20 years old, while B was then 18 years old. B was the first of the three girls to find work at Don Bar on 15 February 2021. She subsequently introduced both the complainant and A to the accused. The accused hired the complainant to work at the bar. As for A, she alleged that she too was hired by the accused to work at the bar – although the accused denied that she worked for him there. What was not disputed was that all three girls – the complainant, A and B – were at some point permitted by the accused to stay at the bar. This arrangement came to an end when the police raided Don Bar.
- [7]
[7] The raid on Don Bar took place on 21 February 2020, after the police received a report that A and B had absconded from the Singapore Girls’ Home and were working at the bar. Following the raid and on that same night, the accused brought the three girls to his rental apartment in Southbank Condominium at North Bridge Road (“the Unit”).
- [8]
[8] At the Unit, the accused and the three girls sat at the first level of the apartment, chatting and drinking alcohol. The accused then had sexual intercourse with A and the complainant at the second level of the Unit.
- [9]
[9] On 14 August 2020, A lodged a police report stating that between February and March 2020, the complainant had been raped by her ex-employer (ie the accused).
The Prosecution’s case
- [10]
[10] The Prosecution’s case was that the accused had forced the complainant to drink alcohol before having non-consensual penile-vaginal sex with her when she was in a drunk and weak state. According to the Prosecution, the complainant’s testimony was internally and externally consistent; and her late reporting of the alleged rape did not tarnish her credibility. Her testimony was also corroborated by other witnesses. In respect of the material aspects of the Prosecution’s narrative, the testimony of the complainant, A and B was consistent. There was no motive for any of them to fabricate allegations against the accused or to collude with each other to do so. Conversely, the accused’s evidence was riddled with numerous inconsistencies; and his version of events simply could not be believed.
The Defence’s case
- [11]
[11] The accused, for his part, did not dispute having committed the sexual acts described in the two Charges, but claimed that they had taken place with the complainant’s consent. The accused also alleged that the complainant had willingly consumed alcohol, and that far from having become drunk or weak as a result, she had been “normal”. Further, the accused claimed that it was not only the complainant who could not be believed: according to him, A and B were also not credible witnesses.
The evidence led by the Prosecution
- [12]
[12] To prove its case, the Prosecution called ten witnesses to testify at trial, with an additional four witnesses providing evidence through conditioned statements to the court. I summarise below the evidence of the material witnesses.
The complainant’s evidence
- [13]
[13] The complainant testified that between 2016 and 2020, she was residing at the Singapore Girls’ Home, and that she absconded from the home on 12 February 2020. In an attempt to find work, she messaged “B” on Instagram, having been acquainted with B when the latter was also residing at the Singapore Girls’ Home. B, who was then working at Don Bar , invited the complainant to come down to the bar to talk to the accused about getting a job there.
- [14]
[14] When the complainant met the accused at Don Bar, he told her that B and another girl A (whom the complainant had been quite close to in the Singapore Girls’ Home) were both staying at the bar. The complainant agreed to work at the bar, and to stay there too.
- [15]
[15] Following the above meeting with the accused, the complainant stayed at Don Bar that night and started working there. On the third day of her employment at Don Bar, she spotted a police car outside the bar. After informing the other Don Bar staff about this, the complainant and B left the bar, because as abscondees from the Singapore Girls’ Home, they were worried about being “wanted” by the police. B called the accused, who then arrived to pick both of them up in his car. At this point, A was already with the accused in his car. The accused persuaded the complainant to follow him, A, and B to his “second house”, ie, the Unit.
- [16]
[16] Upon arrival at the Unit, the accused and the three girls sat inside the apartment and “chilled” before going to a nearby coffeeshop where they bought food to bring back to the Unit. The complainant recalled that on the way back to the apartment, she had mentioned wanting to drink alcohol, and the accused had said that he could get some alcohol.
- [17]
[17] At this juncture, the complainant did not intend to stay overnight at the Unit, and she mentioned that she was still messaging her friends to see if there was anyone she could stay with. When the accused heard this, he brought the complainant out of the Unit and spoke to her at the condominium carpark to persuade her to stay with him. He told the complainant that if she stayed with her friends, she would have to “fork out money” for rent and groceries, whereas if she stayed with him and the other two girls at the Unit, she would not need to pay rent and would moreover be given a job by him. While telling the complainant this, the accused also showed her the money in his wallet as well as two cars in the car park which he claimed were his. Although the complainant initially told the accused she did not want to stay at the Unit, she eventually said that she would “see about it” because he “ke[pt] on persuading” her.
- [18]
[18] At some point that night, the accused produced alcohol in the form of vodka, which he and the three girls consumed along with the food they had bought. After finishing their dinner, they continued to chat at the first level of the Unit while drinking vodka mixed with Coca-Cola. The complainant drank three or four cups of alcohol before deciding that she should stop drinking. She was starting to feel tipsy, and she knew that she had very low alcohol tolerance.
- [19]
[19] At this juncture, A, B, and the accused were all drinking; and the conversation had turned to stories about lesbian activity in the Singapore Girls’ Home. The accused asked the complainant to “just drink some more”, but she knew that if she did drink more, she would be “gone already”. When she replied that she did not want to drink more, the accused opened her mouth by holding her chin, and proceeded to pour alcohol into her mouth. It was “quite a lot” of alcohol, which caused the complainant to vomit onto the floor and onto the accused’s shirt. By this stage, the complainant could feel her eyes starting to close: although she was “still conscious”, she was “very weak, worse than drunk”.
- [21]
[21] Next, the complainant remembered A lying down beside her, and both of them lying on their backs. The accused, who had removed all his clothes, started to kiss the complainant before moving on to kiss A. He then moved back to the complainant and licked her vagina. The next thing the complainant remembered was the accused inserting his penis into her vagina. At this point, she felt pain in her chest area as she was experiencing drug withdrawal symptoms from the drug “Ice”. She cried out in Malay to A that her “dada” (meaning her chest) was hurting. She did not hear any reply from A. At this time, she could feel the accused “below [her] waist area”: she tried to push the accused away by pushing against his shoulders, while crying and telling the accused to “stop”. The accused did not “stop”. Instead, he tried to turn her around to move her into a “doggy position”, but she lacked the strength to stay in that position and fell back onto the floor. The accused then moved on to having sex with A, while the complainant fell asleep.
- [22]
[22] The following morning, when the complainant woke up at the second level of the Unit, there was no one else on that floor. She went down to the toilet on the first level to shower. After showering and managing to get dressed, she went to the balcony of the first level of the Unit, where A and B were seated.
- [23]
[23] At the balcony, the complainant asked B “Why you never help me?”, referring to the events of the previous night. B’s response was, “… you know, it’s not that I don’t want to help. I’m your friend. Of course I will help you. But then [the accused] told me to sit down here and listen to music, and you know I cannot fight [the accused]”. The complainant lay down, placing her head on B’s lap, and cried. She also asked A sarcastically, “You, like, okay…yesterday?” A responded in the negative. The complainant then fell asleep.
- [24]
[24] After the complainant woke up again, she learnt from A and B that the accused would be returning to the Unit around 7.00pm that day. The complainant reacted by telling A and B that she was going to leave the Unit before the accused came back, as she did not want to see him again. Subsequently, the three of them left the Unit, first to buy groceries, and then to go swimming at the condominium swimming pool. The complainant also spoke to B again, as she could not accept that B had failed to help her the previous night and wanted to know exactly what the accused had said to B. In response to the complainant’s questions, B reiterated that she could not do anything because the accused was “big-sized” and a “guy”.
- [25]
[25] After this, the complainant left to meet up with an acquaintance whom she was hoping would assist her with accommodation (and whom I will refer to as “R” – see [52(a)] and [136] below). Some time later, when R had become the complainant’s boyfriend, the complainant told him what the accused had done to her. This came about because on one occasion, R had started to lick the complainant’s vagina in the middle of sexual intercourse, which had caused her to be “in shock” and to tear up. It was then that she explained to R what the accused had done to her.
- [26]
[26] In her testimony, the complainant explained that she did not think of reporting the matter to the police because she felt “embarrassed”, and also because she knew “it’s going to take very long time”. After she surrendered to the Singapore Girls’ Home in July 2020, she met A and B again, as they too had also surrendered to the home by then. A and B suggested to the complainant that they should make a report about her experience of rape – but at this juncture, she still felt that it would be “very troublesome” to do so, and she also knew that “rape case will take very long to process”.
- [27]
[27] Eventually, in August 2020, the complainant disclosed the rape to her case worker – “Ms Joe” – during an interview that the latter conducted with her. Even after Ms Joe contacted the police and informed the complainant that the police would be coming to take her statement, she was reluctant to speak to them because she remained of the view that “rape case will very long to process”.
- [28]
[28] The complainant also testified that she had returned to Don Bar on two occasions after the incident of rape. Both visits took place prior to her surrender to the Singapore Girls’ Home. On the second occasion, when she went back to the bar to collect her pay, she ended up in an argument with the accused, during which he claimed to have heard from B that she (the complainant) had brought drugs to the bar to sell. On hearing this, the complainant asked the accused to call B over, whereupon B claimed that she had never told the accused anything about the complainant selling drugs.
A’s evidence
- [29]
[29] Like the complainant, A too absconded from the Singapore Girls’ Home. She did so in November 2019, when she was 20 years old. Post-abscondment, she stayed with her then-boyfriend for two months, during which period she became pregnant with their child. After those two months, she stayed with another friend before coming into contact with B. She asked B for a job and a place to stay; and B said that she would talk to the accused. A had not previously met the accused, but she knew him to be the “boss” of Don Bar, and was aware that B was staying with him at that time.
- [30]
[30] A next met with the accused and was shown around Don Bar. Later that same day, the accused drove her to Southbank Condominium, where they went to the Unit (which the accused referred to as “his office”).
- [31]
[31] According to A, the accused knew by this time about her pregnancy because B had told him about it. At the Unit, he spoke to A about her pregnancy and suggested that she undergo an abortion. A rejected this suggestion. They then proceeded to have sexual intercourse, which A described as being non-consensual on her part. Following this first sexual encounter, the accused drove A back to Don Bar after telling her, “Whatever happened, don’t tell others. It’s just between us.” A did not report this incident of non-consensual sexual intercourse because she feared that she would be forced to return to the Singapore Girls’ Home if she made a police report.
- [32]
[32] A stayed at the second level of Don Bar after the above incident. The day after, the complainant – who was at that point a good friend of A’s – arrived at Don Bar, also intending to work and to stay there. It was shortly after the complainant’s arrival that the accused brought A back to the Unit, where he had sex with her again. According to A, she had not expected this second sexual encounter, but she proceeded to engage in sexual intercourse with the accused because she “[did] not want anything to happen” to her unborn child and was afraid that the accused might injure her if she pushed him away. The accused drove A back to Don Bar after this second sexual encounter.
- [33]
[33] Upon returning to Don Bar, A was told by B that the three girls would not be able to stay at the bar any longer because there were police officers around, and all three girls – being abscondees from the girls’ home – were “wanted” by the police. The accused then drove all three girls to the Unit.
- [34]
[34] A recalled that while they were at the Unit, B and the complainant expressed a wish to drink alcohol, which led to the accused arranging for one of the Don Bar staff to deliver alcohol to the Unit. The complainant and B started drinking. The accused himself did not drink. As for A, she did not want to drink because of her pregnancy, but she was forced to drink by the accused who pulled her and tried to pour a cup of alcohol into her mouth.
- [35]
[35] A also recalled that at one point, while they were all chatting, B and the complainant started talking about “threesomes” or “lesbian sex in girls’ home”. This led the accused to ask the complainant whether she would “love to have a threesome” with him and A. The complainant replied that she did not want to.
- [36]
[36] The next thing A recalled was the accused and the complainant going up to the second level of the Unit. She did not see how the two of them made their way up to the second level because she was “busy taking [her] phone” at that point in time. She could recall that B was then at the balcony (which was located on the first floor of the Unit). The accused subsequently called out to A to go up to the second level.
- [37]
[37] When she went up to the second level, A saw that the accused was having sex with the complainant in a missionary position on a mattress. Both of them were naked. A could see that the complainant was “in pain”, “struggling”, and “didn’t wanted [sic] to have…sex”. It appeared to A that the complainant was struggling to push the accused away but that she was too weak or drunk to do so. The accused told A to “get naked”, and A complied. A then had sex with the accused.
- [38]
[38] At this point, according to A, the complainant was “still out”, and A heard her asking in Malay, “What is going on?”. A replied, “I don’t know”. A also heard the complainant saying that her stomach hurt. She wanted to help the complainant but could not do so, as she was “scared” that the accused would “put force on [her]”.
- [39]
[39] A next recalled the complainant going down to the first level of the Unit while A was still having sex with the accused. A herself went down to the first floor after she had finished having sex with the accused, whereupon she heard the complainant vomiting in the toilet. The complainant, who appeared very weak, asked A to help bring her clothes to her. After washing up and getting dressed, the complainant went to the balcony where B was sitting. When A went to join them at the balcony, she noticed that the complainant was lying down on B’s lap with an “expression of pain” on her face. Soon thereafter, the accused left the Unit, leaving A with the condominium access card and some money for food. A and B then helped the complainant up to the second level of the Unit so that they could rest there. The complainant was “on her feet walking” by then, but A and B had to support her by placing her hands on their shoulders.
- [40]
[40] The next morning, the complainant asked A and B “What actually happened last night?” Upon being reminded by A about having had sex with the accused, the complainant asked angrily why B had not helped them. B replied that she had been sitting at the balcony the entire time and had not known what was happening at the second level. Later that day, the three of them went for a swim at the condominium pool, after which the complainant left the Unit. As for A, she too left the Unit the following day to surrender to the Singapore Girls’ Home. A’s evidence was that she did so because of her disagreement with the accused, who had been insisting that she should abort her baby and who had even made an appointment for her to see a doctor for this purpose.
- [41]
[41] At trial, A testified that she felt the accused had done something wrong that night when he engaged in sex with the complainant, but that she had not made a police report because she did not want anyone to know about a matter which concerned the complainant’s dignity. Subsequently, on 14 August 2020, A did lodge a police report stating that the complainant had been raped by her ex-employer (referring to the accused). A explained that she did not go to a police station to lodge the report: instead, the report came about because a police officer came to the girls’ home to look for her.
B’s evidence
- [42]
[42] In respect of B, she absconded from the Singapore Girls’ Home on 13 February 2020. In need of a job and a place to stay, she obtained the accused’s phone number from a friend. B started work at Don Bar on 15 February 2020. Initially tasked with ushering people into the bar, her role subsequently evolved beyond waitressing to include helping the accused to hire girls to work in the bar. While working at Don Bar, she also lived on the premises of the bar.
- [43]
[43] B recalled that some time after starting work at Don Bar, she was contacted by A, whom she knew as an acquaintance from the girls’ home. As A wanted to find a job and accommodation, B gave A the accused’s phone number. Soon, A too was working at Don Bar and staying at the bar. Around this time, the complainant and another girl from the girls’ home (“C”) started working at Don Bar as well, although C quit the job after her first day.
- [44]
[44] On a day sometime later, B became suspicious that there were undercover police outside the bar. As she and the complainant were on the run from the girls’ home, they needed to leave the bar. B contacted the accused, who arrived in his car – together with A – to pick B and the complainant up from Sim Lim Tower. All four of them proceeded to the Unit before going out to have supper. Upon their return to the Unit, the accused left for a while and returned with some vodka.
- [45]
[45] At first, the group was drinking “for fun”. However, things became “tense” when A and the complainant refused to drink, the former on account of her pregnancy and the latter on account of her “low tolerance of alcohol”. According to B, the accused forced both A and the complainant to drink by gripping their jaws and forcing them to drink from a cup. The complainant “became weak” and vomited into a plastic bag, before going to the toilet: B could not remember if anyone helped the complainant to the toilet. After this, the accused told B to bring the complainant up to the second level of the Unit “because she was not in a good state”. The complainant was drunk, weak and walking unsteadily by this point: she had to be supported by having her arm placed over B’s shoulder. When they reached the second floor, B placed the complainant on a mattress before proceeding to the balcony at the first level, where she then sat listening to music and playing with her phone.
- [46]
[46] At some point, B noticed the accused heading up to the second level, after which she saw him coming downstairs again to bring A up with him to the second level. At this juncture, the accused was not wearing any clothes. B became worried for the complainant after noticing that the accused was naked. However, she did not ask the accused any question because he was “the boss”, and she was “normally…not allowed to ask” about what he was doing.
- [47]
[47] B next recalled the accused and the other two girls coming back downstairs, and the complainant going to take a shower. After her shower, the complainant came to the balcony to join B. B’s evidence was that at this point, the complainant was lying on B’s lap, shivering, crying and muttering something incomprehensible.
- [48]
[48] B also remembered a conversation with the accused and A sometime between midnight and 1.00am that night, during which the accused tried to get A and B to persuade the complainant to continue staying at the Unit. The accused left the Unit after this conversation and after giving A and B some money for their “allowance”. The three girls then went to sleep on the second level of the Unit.
- [49]
[49] The following morning, the complainant told B that she had been raped by the accused. B was “stunned” to hear this: according to her, this was because she knew that the complainant and A had “slept with a lot of men”. B asked the complainant if she was telling the truth. In response, the complainant reiterated that she “didn’t give her consent to [the accused]” and asked why B had not helped her. B could not recall the rest of the conversation. After going for a swim, the three girls went out for lunch; and in the course of lunch, B asked the complainant again whether what she had alleged was true, because “rape is a big allegation”. The complainant affirmed that she was telling the truth. When they returned to the Unit, the complainant packed her belongings and left as she did not want to stay at the Unit anymore.
- [50]
[50] B recalled that at some point after the complainant had left the Unit, she had a conversation with A in which A stated that she was the accused’s mistress and that she too had been raped by the accused. B replied that she did not believe A. Soon thereafter A also left the Unit, telling B that she had been “chased out” by the accused as a result of rejecting his demand that she have an abortion.
- [51]
[51] B continued to work at Don Bar, stopping work only in March 2020 because of continued police raids. Sometime in May 2020, she did some pest control work for the accused for one day. She ceased contact with the accused when he was arrested in June 2020.
Other witnesses
- [52]
[52] In addition to the three girls whose evidence has been summarised above, the Prosecution called a number of other witnesses. These included the following:
(a) R met with the complainant the day following the alleged rape as she was hoping to stay in a room in his family’s flat. At that point in time, R and the complainant were acquaintances, having met at Don Bar the previous day through a mutual friend. According to R, when he met with the complainant the following day to assist her with her request for accommodation, she appeared “very tired”, “weak”, “lethargic” and “very quiet”. This was the “complete opposite” of the “cheerful” demeanour she had presented when he saw her at the bar the previous day. R also testified that after he entered into a relationship with the complainant, she told him about her non-consensual sexual encounter with the accused. R also testified that on an occasion between February and July 2020, the complainant had become angry when he attempted to lick her vagina while they were having sex, and she had told him that she did not want him to do it.
(b) “Ms Joe”, the case worker from the Ministry of Social and Family Development assigned to the complainant, gave evidence about a “case recording” she had made of an interview with the complainant on 5 August 2020. It was during this interview that the complainant told Ms Joe about having been raped by the accused. Ms Joe recalled that before the complainant started speaking about the rape, she had been cautioned that the police would have to be involved if it was a “crime-related” matter, and this had made her initially “a bit hesitant” to recount the rape. According to Ms Joe, this was because the complainant “generally doesn’t like authority to be involved, especially the police”. Ms Joe also recalled that the complainant was quite “matter-of-fact” when she began recounting the rape, but that she later became “more emotional” and “a bit teary in her eyes”.
(c) C, a close friend of the complainant at the material time, testified that at some point in time after 22 February 2020 (the night of the alleged rape), the complainant told C that she had been raped by the accused.
The evidence led by the Defence
- [53]
[53] I next summarise the evidence led by the Defence, In respect of the Defence’s case, the accused was the sole witness.
The accused’s evidence
- [54]
[54] By way of background, the accused testified that he ran the pub known as Don Bar, then located at Dunlop Street. He also rented (through other persons) the Unit at Southbank Condominium. The accused confirmed that A and the complainant were introduced to him by B. The complainant was hired by him as a waitress at Don Bar, while A became his “sex partner”. According to the accused, A had told him that she was pregnant; and he had offered to let her stay at Don Bar for free, without needing to work, so long as she became his sex partner.
- [55]
[55] On the day of the alleged rape, the accused was in his car with A when he received a call from B, saying that she had seen the police at Don Bar. The accused proceeded to pick B and the complainant up in his car. B informed the accused that because she and the complainant were “wanted” for absconding from the girls’ home, the police presence at the bar made it unsafe for them to continue staying there. The accused – who knew by this time that B and the complainant were abscondees – replied that they could stay at the Unit.
- [56]
[56] After the accused and the three girls arrived at the Unit, they went out to buy food to eat back at the Unit. One of the workers from Don Bar also brought the girls’ belongings over to the Unit. At some point, either B or the complainant said that they wanted to drink, so the accused had vodka brought over to the Unit. He was able to remember that there were two bottles of vodka, one of which was less than half full. All four of them drank the vodka. The accused recalled that he himself drank one to two cups; B drank about four to five cups; A drank half a cup or one cup; and the complainant drank one to two cups. As they drank, they talked about the girls’ relationships with other girls in the Singapore Girls’ Home, and the accused talked about life in prison. The discussion then moved to sex, and the accused brought up the topic of threesomes. A and the complainant both said that they had never had sex in a threesome. The complainant said that she had not had sex “for some time”, and teasingly added that she should have sex with the accused. In response, the accused suggested that they have sex – whereupon A and the complainant, turning shy, laughed. The accused then said “Come on, let’s go up”, following which he, A and the complainant went up to the second level of the Unit together. As for B, she decided to sit at the balcony at the first level.
- [57]
[57] According to the accused, the complainant was able to walk up to the second level “as per normal”, without anyone assisting her. She also appeared “normal” despite having drunk alcohol. At the second level, A and the complainant undressed and lay down on the mattress, while the accused removed his jewellery and undressed himself. He then started kissing both A and the complainant, both of whom kissed him back. He also touched and sucked their breasts. After sucking A’s breast, he licked A’s vagina, and A moaned loudly in response. While the accused was licking A’s vagina, the complainant and A were touching and kissing each other. At some point, the accused heard the complainant utter the words “apa itu” (meaning “what’s this” in Malay); and both she and A started laughing. After licking A’s vagina, the accused had penile-vaginal sex with A in the missionary position, while continuing to touch the complainant.
- [58]
[58] At this point, the complainant – who was lying next to the accused – stated that it was her “turn”. The accused responded by kissing the complainant, touching and sucking her breasts, and licking her vagina. As he started to insert his penis into the complainant’s vagina, she remarked that his penis was “big”, which caused all three of them to laugh. The accused assured the complainant that he would “put in slowly”. He then proceeded to have sexual intercourse with the complainant . According to the accused, at no time during the sexual intercourse did the complainant push him away or tell him to stop. While he was having sex with the complainant, he was also touching A, but after A remarked that her stomach was “painful”, he stopped touching her, and she sat down at his side to watch him having sex with the complainant. At some point, the complainant said “Enough lah, free show”, after which A left the second level while the accused continued to have sex with the complainant.
- [59]
[59] When they had finished having sex, the accused and the complainant lay down side by side, talking with each other. They subsequently went down to the first level of the Unit to shower, taking turns to do so. The accused then spoke to A, B, and the complainant and gave them some money before leaving the Unit.
- [60]
[60] The next day, the accused returned to the Unit in the late afternoon or evening. While outside the door of the Unit, he noticed the complainant dressed as if to leave the Unit and asked her where she was going. The complainant replied that she was delivering something to a friend; and in answer to his further query, she explained that she was delivering “Ice”. On hearing this, the accused – who knew “Ice” to be a drug – informed the complainant that she could not continue staying at the Unit if she was involved with drugs, and asked her to leave. According to the accused, he later received a message from either A or B, stating that the complainant had left the Unit.
- [61]
[61] The accused claimed that subsequent to this incident, he met the complainant again on at least two occasions . The first occasion was one or two days after the night of their sexual encounter, when the complainant came to Don Bar to ask him if she could stay at the Unit “with the girls”. He refused her request. On the second occasion, he saw the complainant outside Don Bar about a month or two later, looking “high”. After asking whether she was “okay” and advising her to “be careful”, he told B to ask the complainant to leave the bar.
The ancillary hearing
- [62]
[62] In the course of his testimony, the accused disputed the voluntariness of various portions of his Video Recorded Interview (“VRI”) statements. As such, an ancillary hearing became necessary, in which the Prosecution bore the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the disputed portions of these VRI statements were in fact provided voluntarily by the accused (Muhammad bin Kadar and another v Public Prosecutor [2011] 3 SLR 1205 at [177]). This meant that the Prosecution had to prove that there was no threat, inducement or promise made to the accused which operated on his mind through hope of escape or fear of punishment connected with the charge (Chai Chien Wei Kelvin v Public Prosecutor [1998] 3 SLR(R) 619 at [53]).
The accused
- [63]
[63] For the purposes of the ancillary hearing, the Defence clarified that it was challenging only certain portions of the VRI statement of 3 September 2020 (specifically, the portions which it highlighted at pages 55–56, 139–141 and 169).
- [65]
[65] Second, according to the accused, at his VRI on 3 September 2020, he was told by either ASP Joyce Lau (“ASP Joyce”) or ASP Gan Mei Huey (“ASP Gan”): “If you do not tell the truth, you’ll be put behind bars for 20 years”. This happened at some point in time either before the commencement of the VRI or during a toilet break in the middle of the VRI. The accused’s evidence was that the threat to put him “behind bars for 20 years” caused him to become “worried” and “scared” that if he gave answers that offended the police or failed to show cooperation, his bail would be revoked and he would “be charged for something which [he] never do”. The accused’s position was that he had this understanding of what the police were telling him in part because of ASP Joyce’s remark in June 2020 that he would be given bail if he cooperated. Further, the accused clarified that only certain portions of the VRI statement he gave that day were affected by what was told to him. He claimed that in respect of these portions of his statement, the IO would keep repeating “the same questions”, which led him to become “worried” about whether the answers he was giving were answers which she “[did] not want to hear”, or whether she “want[ed] to hear something from [him], differently”.
ASP Joyce Lau
- [66]
[66] ASP Joyce testified that she recalled the police having conducted six or seven VRIs sessions with the accused during the period of his remand at Police Cantonment Complex (“PCC”) in June and July 2020. She was present at all these VRIs bar one. During these VRIs, she acted as the assistant to the officer conducting the interviews, whom she recalled would have been either Supt Burhan or Deputy Superintendent Liao Chengyu (“Supt Liao”). She did not tell the accused during the interview sessions at which she was present that he would be given bail if he cooperated. She also did not witness Supt Burhan telling the accused that he would be given bail if he cooperated.
- [67]
[67] ASP Joyce subsequently conducted a VRI with the accused on 3 September 2020 at PCC. ASP Gan was her assistant on that occasion; and the interview lasted for 114 minutes. According to ASP Joyce, neither she nor ASP Gan told the accused that he must tell the truth or he would be “put behind bars for 20 years”. Nor did they tell him that he must tell the truth or that he would be charged with something he had not done. In fact, neither ASP Joyce nor ASP Gan made any mention of imprisonment during the interview. During the accused’s toilet break, it was ASP Joyce who escorted him to the toilet and then back to the interview room; and there was no conversation between them during this short interlude.
- [69]
[69] ASP Joyce also testified that after 3 September 2020, she conducted three further VRIs with the accused after 3 September 2020, and that at these further interviews, no issues were raised by the accused in respect of the 3 September 2020 VRI.
ASP Gan Mei Huey
- [70]
[70] ASP Gan testified that she acted as ASP Joyce’s assistant for the VRI on 3 September 2020. She affirmed that neither she nor ASP Joyce told the accused he would be “put behind bars for 20 years” if he did not tell the truth. The two of them also did not make any mention of imprisonment to the accused either before the VRI or during the toilet break.
Supt Burhanudeen
- [71]
[71] Supt Burhan testified that he was involved in the recording of four long statements from the accused between 22 June and 30 June 2020. During these interviews, he was assisted by ASP Joyce. Supt Burhan denied that either he or ASP Joyce had told the accused that he would be given bail if he cooperated. Towards the end of the VRI on 23 June 2020, the accused had asked, “What about bail?” – to which Supt Burhan had replied, “We will talk about it later”, and the accused had asked, “…after this, ah, Sir?”. Supt Burhan testified that he did not in fact discuss the issue of bail with the accused after the VRI was concluded. In cross-examination, Supt Burhan agreed that at that point in time, the police had decided not to offer the accused bail. However, he explained that this decision had not been firmed up at that point because bail matters had to be discussed with the Attorney-General’s Chambers (“AGC”) and their confirmation sought. In any event, it was not his practice to discuss bail matters with any accused person.
My decision
- [72]
[72] At the conclusion of the ancillary hearing, having considered the evidence given by the accused and the various police officers, I rejected the accused’s allegations about having been subjected to threats, inducements and / or promises by the police. I accepted the police officers’ evidence that they did not make any of the remarks alleged by the accused.
- [74]
[74] For the reasons stated above, contrary to the accused’s allegation, there would have been no reason for him to harbour the belief on 3 September 2020 that the IO was “in charge” of his bail. Further and in any event, I found that neither ASP Joyce nor ASP Gan could have made any remark to him about his being “put behind bars for 20 years” if he failed to cooperate. In the first place, I found it quite unbelievable that the accused could claim to remember clearly such a remark having been made – but could not remember which of the two police officers present had made it.
- [75]
[75] Second, and more importantly, even if such a remark had been made by ASP Joyce or ASP Gan, I found that it would not have operated on the accused’s mind. This was because the accused himself affirmed in cross-examination that despite repeated questioning by the IO, he persisted in telling the truth: he made sure that he only spoke about things which he had in fact done, and if he had not in fact done anything, he also made sure to say so.
- [76]
[76] Finally, the accused himself testified in re-examination that when he went to PCC on 3 September 2020, ASP Joyce had told him about another report being made against him; and this had led him to become “worried that this charge now come up that [his] bail will be revoked”. In short, therefore, the reason why the accused became worried about his bail being revoked on 3 September 2020 was not because of any remark made by ASP Joyce or ASP Lau: on his own evidence, it was because he realised there could be further charges brought against him, which might in turn affect his bail status.
- [77]
[77] For the reasons given above, I found that the disputed portions of the 3 September 2020 VRI statement were in fact given voluntarily by the accused.
Issues to be determined
- [78]
[78] As I noted earlier, the accused did not dispute the commission of the sexual acts described in the First and the Second Charges (ie licking the complainant’s vagina and penetrating her vagina with his penis) but alleged that these were carried out with the complainant’s consent.
- [79]
[79] For the record, it should be noted that although the Prosecution did in its closing submissions allude to the complainant having been “extremely inebriated” and “too weak to resist”, it did not take the position that the complainant had – per s 90(b) of the Penal Code – lacked the capacity to give consent to sexual activity at the material time. Nor did the complainant’s evidence indicate that she had lacked the capacity to give consent: eg, the complainant stated in her testimony that up until the point when the accused inserted his penis into her vagina, she “know what’s happening”, although “everything was just not so clear”, and she “already know he going to have, like, have sex” with her and A.
- [80]
[80] The only issue in contention between the Prosecution and the Defence thus concerned whether the complainant had consented to the sexual acts described in the two charges. The Prosecution had the burden of establishing, beyond a reasonable doubt, the lack of consent from the complainant.
The unusually convincing standard did not apply to the complainant’s testimony
- [81]
[81] At the outset, the Prosecution submitted that the “unusually convincing” standard did not apply to the complainant’s evidence in the present case.
- [82]
[82] The relevant general principles were clearly established by the Court of Appeal in Public Prosecutor v GCK and another matter [2020] 1 SLR 486 (“GCK”), at [104]). In GCK, the accused was a male employee at a nursing home who was charged with an offence of outrage of modesty under s 354(1) of the Penal Code. The victim was an elderly female resident of the nursing home who was found unfit to testify due to severe physical and cognitive disabilities. The accused denied the charge. At trial, the prosecution’s case rested substantially on the testimony of a female nurse who had seen the accused straddling the victim with his trousers pulled down and his groin on the victim’s groin. The trial judge in the district court found the female nurse’s evidence “unusually convincing” and convicted the accused. On appeal, the accused was acquitted by the High Court; and in its judgment, the High Court appeared to suggest inter alia that the “unusually convincing” standard applied to an alleged victim’s testimony but that a different standard applied to an eyewitness’ testimony. In the criminal reference subsequently filed by the prosecution, the Court of Appeal reframed the questions referred. One of the reframed questions related to the standard to be applied when evaluating the evidence of an eyewitness to a crime, where such evidence was uncorroborated and formed the sole evidence for a conviction. On this question, the Court of Appeal held (at [104]) that the “unusually convincing” standard would apply to the uncorroborated evidence of a witness in any offences, where such evidence formed the sole basis for a conviction; and that in principle, this standard would apply regardless of whether the witness was an alleged victim or an eyewitness. Delivering the judgment of the Court of Appeal, Sundaresh Menon CJ explained the court’s reasoning as follows (at [89]-[90]):
- [89]
[89] …(T)he basis for the “unusually convincing” standard has nothing to do with the status of the witness concerned (namely, whether he or she is an alleged victim or an eyewitness), and instead has everything to do with “the ultimate rule that the Prosecution must prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt”… In the absence of any other corroborative evidence, the testimony of a witness, whether an eyewitness or an alleged victim, becomes the keystone upon which the Prosecution’s entire case will rest. Such evidence can sustain a conviction only if it is “unusually convincing” and thereby capable of overcoming any concerns arising from the lack of corroboration and the fact that such evidence will typically be controverted by that of the accused person: see the decision of this court in AOF v Public Prosecutor [2012] 3 SLR 34 (“AOF”) at [111].
- [90]
[90] Put simply, the “unusually convincing” standard entails that the witness’s testimony alone is sufficient to prove the Prosecution’s case beyond a reasonable doubt: see Teo Keng Pong v Public Prosecutor [1996] 2 SLR(R) 890 at [73]. The overwhelming consideration that triggers the application of the standard is the amount and availability of evidence…
- [83]
[83] In the present case, the complainant’s evidence did not form the sole basis for convicting the accused: in the course of the trial, the Prosecution pointed to other evidence which it relied on for corroboration; in particular, the testimony of A (who was an eyewitness to the alleged rape) and of B (who observed the complainant’s demeanour and conduct shortly before and after the alleged rape). In the circumstances, I accepted the Prosecution’s submission that the “unusually convincing” standard did not apply to the complainant’s testimony.
The credibility of the complainant’s evidence
- [85]
[85] In evaluating the complainant’s credibility, I weighed her demeanour in testifying and being cross-examined on the stand alongside the internal and external consistencies in her testimony (see AOF v Public Prosecutor [2012] 3 SLR 34 at [115]).
- [86]
[86] I address first the issue of internal consistency.
Internal consistency
- [87]
[87] The Prosecution submitted that the complainant’s account was one “characterised by clarity and coherence”, and that there was an “internal logic” to the behaviours she described. The Prosecution highlighted that she was a candid witness whose testimony showed that she had retained sufficient presence of mind to deduce what was happening despite having been physically affected by the alcohol consumed that night.
- [88]
[88] The Defence, on the other hand, argued that there were multiple areas of inconsistency between the account of events given by the complainant at trial and the account given in her previous statements. The previous statements relied on by the Defence for this argument consisted of a statement given by the complainant to the police on 20 July 2022, and notes recorded by Ms Joe of an interview she conducted with the complainant on 5 August 2020 (which notes Ms Joe referred to as a “case recording”). According to the Defence, the areas of inconsistency were as follows:
(a) In court, the complainant testified that she was the one who had suggested the idea of drinking alcohol on the night of the alleged rape. However, in her statement to the police, she stated that it had been the accused’s idea to drink. When cross-examined about this discrepancy, the complainant affirmed the version of events given in court. The complainant asserted that the version given in court was what she had told the IO during the statement-recording but that the IO had not recorded it.
(b) In court, the complainant testified that after she vomited, the accused took off his “shirt” and “showered her”. However, in her statement to the police, she said that the accused took off his “clothes” and showered in the toilet. When asked about this, the complainant stated that the accused had showered both himself and her, that she could only remember him removing his shirt, and that she could not remember whether he removed the bottom half of his clothing as well.
(c) In court, the complainant testified that it was the accused who had brought her up to the second level of the Unit. However, in her statement to the police, she stated that the accused and “possibly one other person” had brought her up to the second level. When asked about this, the complainant affirmed that it was only the accused who had brought her up to the second level.
(d) In court, the complainant did not mention that prior to licking her vagina, the accused had “tried to insert his penis into [her] vagina” but that it had been “too tight”. This particular detail was, however, mentioned in her previous statement to the police. When asked about this, the complainant stated that that she had not mentioned it in court because she felt “shy” and “hesitant” about saying it in court.
(e) In her evidence in court, the complainant testified that the sequence of events which took place after she woke up was as follows: she went to shower, saw A and B at the balcony, went to look for her clothes at the second level, and then went back to the balcony to talk to A and B. This account was inconsistent with the sequence provided in her statement to police, where she had said that after waking up and showering, she had gone back to sleep before waking up again and joining A and B at the balcony. When asked about this, the complainant affirmed the account given in court. She also asserted that it was the IO who had wrongly recorded what she said.
(f) In court, the complainant’s evidence was that the accused was able to rape her because at the time, she was weak from intoxication and drug withdrawal. However, in Ms Joe’s case recording, Ms Joe had recorded the complainant saying that she was “scared” to disobey the accused because he was very “big-sized”. When asked about this, the complainant explained that in her interview with Ms Joe, she had been referring to B being scared to disobey the accused because of his big size.
(g) In her case recording, Ms Joe had recorded the complainant as saying that after she told the accused she did not know how a threesome worked, the accused told her that she did not need to do anything and just had to lie there. In court, however, this piece of information was not mentioned by the complainant; and when asked about it, the complainant denied giving this information to Ms Joe.
(h) In her case recording, Ms Joe had recorded the complainant as saying that she “screamed and cried” when she was raped, whereas in court the complainant did not at any point say that she had screamed when she was raped. When asked about this, the complainant stated that she had told Ms Joe about crying when the accused raped her, but that she had not mentioned screaming.
(i) In her case recording, Ms Joe had recorded the complainant as saying that after the rape, she “could not take it”; that she had run to the toilet and turned on the shower; and that she had sat there naked and half-awake the entire night. These details were missing from the account she gave in court. When asked about this, the complainant denied having recounted the series of events recorded by Ms Joe.
- [89]
[89] The Defence’s position was that these alleged discrepancies related to the credibility of the account given by the complainant of events preceding, during and after the alleged rape. Per the Defence’s case, whilst the complainant had tried to come across as a victim whom the accused had gotten drunk and then taken advantage of when she was physically incapacitated, the discrepancies in her evidence showed that her story could not be believed.
- [90]
[90] I address in turn the alleged areas of inconsistency highlighted by the Defence.
Who suggested the idea of drinking alcohol
- [91]
[91] As to (a), while the complainant’s evidence as to who initiated the idea of drinking was inconsistent as between her testimony and her 22 July 2022 statement, I noted that the version of events provided in court was in fact more unfavourable to her position than the version given in her statement: in the version given in court, the complainant admitted to having asked for the alcohol which subsequently led to her inebriated state – as opposed to the accused having offered her alcohol from the outset. As such, while the inconsistency in her evidence suggested that her recollection of the details of events leading up to the alleged rape was not entirely faultless, I found that she was scrupulous about telling the truth in court, even if the truth did not cast her in the best light. I agreed with the Prosecution, therefore, that this was not a case of the complainant intentionally changing her evidence to gain some sort of benefit or advantage. Rather, it appeared to me that this was an innocuous discrepancy stemming from inaccurate recall. The impact on the complainant’s credibility was, in my view, minimal.
Whether the accused showered himself after the complainant vomited
- [92]
[92] As to (b), I did not consider the complainant’s evidence to be materially inconsistent. While the complainant did testify during her examination-in-chief to the accused showering her, she never actually denied that the accused had also showered himself. Further, when shown her 22 July 2022 statement, she was able to give a cogent explanation: according to the complainant, while showering her, the accused had also “put the water on him[self]… (l)ike he was showering himself also” because “there was vomit on him too”. In the circumstances, even if it could be said that there was some sort of inconsistency between the complainant’s testimony on this point and her previous statement, I did not find her credibility to be adversely affected by the alleged discrepancy.
Who brought the complainant to the second level of the Unit
- [93]
[93] As to (c), I did not find any inconsistency between the complainant’s testimony and her 20 July 2022 statement. In her previous statement, the complainant had simply stated the possibility of there having been one other person who helped the accused to bring her up to the second level of the Unit. In court, the complainant stated that at the point in time when she was brought up to the second level, her eyes were closed because when she attempted to open her eyes, “everything [was] very blurry”. Her testimony that it was the accused who brought her up and who was “holding on to [her]” was not inconsistent with her previous statement.
Whether the accused initially tried to insert his penis into the complainant’s vagina but “it was too tight”
- [95]
[95] Having regard to the above reasons, while I accepted that there was a discrepancy between the complainant’s evidence in court and in her previous statement, I found that the existence of this discrepancy was not fatal to her credibility: she had a cogent explanation for the discrepancy; and it did not suggest any mendacity on her part.
The sequence of events after the complainant woke up
- [96]
[96] As to (e), the only potential discrepancy between the complainant’s account in court and in her previous statement lay in whether she went back to sleep in between taking a shower and talking to A and B. I did not consider this discrepancy to be material. Both the accused’s and B’s accounts of events also alluded to the complainant showering after sex; and both A and B attested to the complainant joining them at the balcony after showering. Whether the complainant slept at some point between having a shower and talking to A and B at the balcony was a minor detail which did not go towards the credibility of her evidence of the sexual assaults.
The other alleged discrepancies highlighted by the defence at (f) to (i)
- [97]
[97] In respect of the remaining items at (f) to (i), I found that these did reveal discrepancies between the complainant’s testimony and her previous statement to Ms Joe (as documented by the latter in the “case recording”). To recap, these were as follows.
- [98]
[98] In respect of (f), the complainant’s evidence was that the accused was able to rape her because intoxication and drug withdrawal had rendered her too weak to put up effective physical resistance. In the case recording, however, she was recorded as having told Ms Joe that she had been too scared to disobey the accused due to his big size. When shown the discrepancy, the complainant’s evidence was that in her interview with Ms Joe, she had been talking about B being scared of the accused due to his big size – and not about her own response during the rape.
- [99]
[99] In respect of (g), the complainant was recorded by Ms Joe to have said that after she told the accused she did not know how a threesome worked, the accused told her she did not need to do anything and just had to lie there. Conversely, the complainant did not mention any such exchange with the accused in her testimony. When shown the discrepancy, the complainant’s evidence was that she had never provided Ms Joe with details of any such exchange.
- [100]
[100] In respect of (h), the complainant was recorded by Ms Joe to have said that she “screamed and cried” when she was raped, but in her testimony, the complainant said nothing about screaming when raped. When shown the discrepancy, the complainant’s evidence was that she had never told Ms Joe about screaming when raped.
- [101]
[101] In respect of (i), the complainant was recorded by Ms Joe to have said that after being raped, she “could not take it and ran” to the toilet, where she turned on the shower and sat there naked and half-awake the entire night. Conversely, the complainant did not mention these details in her testimony. When shown the discrepancy, the complainant’s evidence was that she had never given such details to Ms Joe.
My evaluation of the weight to be given to the above discrepancies
- [102]
[102] After careful consideration, I decided to give only very limited weight to the above discrepancies. To put it another way, I found that these discrepancies did not ultimately have a material bearing on the complainant’s credibility. My reasons were as follows.
- [104]
[104] The circuitous manner in which the Defence chose to go about using the case recording to discredit the complainant’s testimony meant that at the end of the day, her explanations that she had not said certain things to Ms Joe, and/or that she had meant something else, could not be tested and verified with Ms Joe. This was unfortunate, all the more because Ms Joe’s testimony revealed, firstly, that she had paraphrased or summarised certain things said by the complainant (eg paraphrasing the complainant’s statement about feeling “weird” when the accused touched her as a statement that the accused had “touched her inappropriately”); and secondly, that she had not shown her notes to the complainant prior to typing them up and destroying the original document. In other words, the manner and sequence in which the complainant’s explanations as to specific passages in the case recording were elicited meant that I could not discount the possibility of some degree of misunderstanding and/or inaccurate paraphrasing on Ms Joe’s part. In my view, this regrettable situation made it less than fair to rely on the discrepancies at (f) to (i) to discredit the complainant.
- [105]
[105] Second, and in any event, given the nature of the discrepancies at (f) to (i), they did not suggest to me that the complainant was changing her evidence at trial in an effort to cast herself in a better light – or to cast the accused in a worse light. To put it another way, this was not a case where the complainant appeared to be deliberately embellishing or exaggerating her evidence at trial so as to frame the accused. After all, if she had wanted to do so, there would have been no reason for her to omit details such as their exchange about what a sexual threesome involved or her screaming when he raped her. The highest at which the Defence’s case could be pitched was that the complainant’s recollection of certain details was imperfect and potentially unreliable. The question, then, would be whether the defects in her recollection of these details were such as to undermine or damage in some consequential way the internal consistency of her evidence about the rape. I was of the view that they did not. My reasons were as follows.
- [106]
[106] The only issue in contention throughout the trial was whether the complainant had consented to the sexual acts described in the First and Second Charges. On this issue, the complainant’s account at trial remained firmly the same as the accounts given to Ms Joe on 5 August 2020 and to the police on 20 July 2022. In gist, in both her previous statements and in her testimony at trial, the complainant’s evidence was that the accused had poured or forced alcohol down her throat until she vomited; that she had needed to be brought up to the second level of the Unit by the accused; that she had not consented to sexual intercourse with the accused but had not been able to resist; and that she had cried when he carried out the sexual acts. On the central issue of consent, therefore, I concluded that the defects in the complainant’s recollection of the details highlighted by the Defence at (f) to (i) did not damage in any material way the internal consistency of her evidence and / or her overall credibility as a witness.
- [107]
[107] Not only did the complainant maintain a consistent account of her lack of consent in both her previous statements and in her testimony, her evidence on this central issue was corroborated by evidence from other witnesses – notably, from A and B. In the next section of these written grounds, I address the issue of the external consistency of the complainant’s account of events.
External consistency
The Defence’s arguments
- [108]
[108] In respect of the issue of external consistency, the Defence argued that there were numerous areas of inconsistency between the complainant’s evidence and that of A and B. According to the Defence, these were as follows:
(a) The complainant testified that it was the accused who brought her up to the second level of the Unit, and that when she was brought to the second level, she heard him telling B to “go and move the bedframe”. However, B testified that she (B) was the one who brought the complainant up to the second level after being instructed by the accused to do so.
(b) The complainant testified that in the course of the sexual encounter with the accused, she had told A that her chest, or “dada”, hurt. However, A’s recollection was that the complainant had said her stomach hurt.
(c) The complainant claimed to have been suffering drug withdrawal symptoms on the night of the alleged rape, but neither A nor B gave evidence as to having noticed any drug withdrawal symptoms.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.