General Division of the High Court · Decided 16 December 2024
Both accused were convicted of the trafficking charges over diamorphine and cannabis
Public Prosecutor v Muhammad Hanafi bin Abdul Talip and another
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC 319 · Case no. Criminal Case No 24 of 2023
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
Both accused were convicted of the trafficking charges over diamorphine and cannabis
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraphs [2], [3], [212]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] This is a joint trial involving two accused persons, Mr Muhammad Hanafi bin Abdul Talip (“Hanafi”) and Mr Mohamed Nagib bin Awang (“Nagib”).
- [2]
[2] Hanafi claimed trial to two charges under s 5(1)(a) read with s 5(2) of the Misuse of Drugs Act (Cap 185, 2008 Rev Ed) (the “MDA”), for having in his possession for the purpose of trafficking, on 27 April 2021, five packets containing not less than 58.86g of diamorphine (the “Bundles”), and four blocks containing not less than 499.99g of vegetable matter which was analysed and found to be cannabis (the “Blocks”).
- [3]
[3] Nagib claimed trial to two charges of trafficking under s 5(1)(a) of the MDA, for delivering the Bundles and Blocks to Hanafi.
- [4]
[4] For the charges in relation to the Bundles (but not the Blocks), the death penalty is prescribed as punishment. In addition, the Prosecution chose to proceed with other non-capital charges, four against Hanafi, and three against Nagib. Although Hanafi and Nagib claimed trial to these other non-capital charges, from the outset, they indicated that they would provide no substantive defence to them. I shall return to these charges at [213]–[214] below.
The Prosecution’s evidence
- [5]
[5] Broadly speaking, the Prosecution’s case is that on 27 April 2021, pursuant to an existing arrangement between them, Hanafi and Nagib met up to collect a consignment of drugs. Specifically, Nagib had alighted from the car they were travelling in, bearing the registration number SJA1446S (the “Car”), along Riverside Road to collect the consignment of drugs, comprising of the Bundles and the Blocks. Upon returning to the Car, Nagib passed the drugs to Hanafi. In turn, Hanafi placed the Bundles and the Blocks into different compartments of his black “Superdry” backpack (the “Superdry Bag”). He had the intention to supply the drugs to others. Shortly thereafter, they were arrested. I now set out the main strands of the Prosecution’s evidence.
Arrest of the accused persons and seizure of exhibits
- [6]
[6] At around 7.28pm on 27 April 2021, officers from the Central Narcotics Bureau (“CNB”) intercepted the Car at the traffic junction of Woodlands Industrial Park E7 and Woodlands Avenue 8, Singapore. The driver of the Car was Muhamad Nur Zaihidir bin Abdul Kadir (“Zaihidir”). Hanafi was seated at the front passenger seat of the Car, while Nagib was seated at the rear passenger seat. Hanafi, Nagib and Zaihidir were placed under arrest.
- [7]
[7] During the arrest, Hanafi put up a struggle, and force was used to place him under arrest. Upon his arrest, Hanafi was brought to the side of the road, where he subsequently became unresponsive. An ambulance arrived at the scene at 7.50pm. At about 8pm, Hanafi was conveyed to Changi General Hospital (“CGH”).
- [8]
[8] At about 8.02pm, Zaihidir and Nagib were escorted to the multi-storey carpark at Block 780 Woodlands Crescent (the “MSCP”).
- [9]
[9] At around 8.18pm, the CNB officers conducted a search and seizure of the Car in the presence of Zaihidir and Nagib at the MSCP. In challenging the chain of custody of the drug exhibits, the location of the search and seizure – specifically, the relevant block of the multi-storey carpark – is heavily contested by both Hanafi and Nagib. The relevant evidence is detailed at [63]–[74] below. In particular, from the front passenger floorboard of the Car, the CNB officers recovered the Superdry Bag which was subsequently marked as Exhibit Al.
- [10]
[10] The Superdry Bag contained five packets of granular/powdery substance bound together with a red tape, which were subsequently separately marked as Exhibits A1A1A, A1A2A, A1A3A, A1A4A and A1A5A respectively (collectively, the “Bundles”). The Superdry Bag also contained four blocks which were subsequently marked as Exhibits A1B1, A1E1A, A1E2A and A1F1 (collectively, the “Blocks”). The Bundles and the Blocks each form the subject of the two charges against Hanafi and Nagib (see [2]–[3] above).
- [11]
[11] The five packets comprising the Bundles, as well as one of the Blocks (ie, A1B1), were retrieved from the main compartment of the Superdry Bag. Two of the Blocks (ie, A1E1A and A1E2A), were found in the right compartment of the Superdry Bag. The last of the Blocks (ie, A1F1) was recovered from the left compartment of the Superdry Bag. At the point of seizure, the Superdry Bag was zipped.
- [12]
[12] From the front compartment of the Superdry Bag, a black pouch marked as Exhibit A1H was retrieved. This black pouch contained various drug exhibits forming the subject matter of the four additional charges against Hanafi (see [4] above). I deal with the charges at [213]–[214] below.
- [13]
[13] In addition, a black YONEX bag was recovered from the main compartment of the Superdry Bag, and this was marked as Exhibit A1C (the “YONEX bag”). During the process, a brown sling bag belonging to Nagib was also seized (the “sling bag”). A torn black plastic wrapper marked as Exhibit A1D was also retrieved from the main compartment of the Superdry Bag.
- [14]
[14] Further, three mobile phones were seized by the CNB. Two mobile phones marked as B1 and B2 belonged to Hanafi, while the mobile phone marked MN-HP1 belonged to Nagib.
Analysis of drug exhibits by the Health Sciences Authority
- [15]
[15] After the drug exhibits were handed over by the CNB to the Health Sciences Authorities (the “HSA”), the analysts analysed the contents of the Bundles and the Blocks and found the quantity of drugs in each of the exhibits to be as follows:
Zaihidir’s evidence
- [16]
[16] According to Zaihidir, who was the driver of the Car, Hanafi was his friend at the time of the arrests. They met in prison in 2015 and stayed in contact thereafter via social media. Zaihidir and Nagib did not know each other.
- [17]
[17] On the afternoon of 27 April 2021, at 4.08pm, Hanafi messaged Zaihidir asking Zaihidir if he was free, and at 4.09pm, Hanafi messaged Zaihidir that he needed urgent transport. Zaihidir did not respond. At 5.56pm, Hanafi messaged Zaihidir again, asking Zaihidir to pick him up from “Woodlands 183”. Zaihidir ascertained where Hanafi was, before driving the Car to Woodlands Block 183 to meet Hanafi. Upon his arrival, Hanafi got into the front passenger seat, while Nagib sat at the rear passenger seat.
- [18]
[18] To search for food, Zaihidir drove the Car to a restaurant called “Al-Ameen”, and subsequently to “Rasa Rasa” at Waterfront Woodlands. However, as both places were crowded, they did not eat at either eatery.
- [19]
[19] Nagib subsequently mentioned that a friend needed his help as his lorry had broken down. Zaihidir agreed to help, and therefore followed Nagib’s directions to drive to the location. However, on the way there, Nagib said that his friend was fine. Later, as Zaihidir was driving off to drop Hanafi at Yishun, Nagib said that he needed to urinate. As directed by Nagib, Zaihidir stopped the Car along Riverside Road for Nagib to alight. Five minutes later, Nagib returned to the Car.
- [20]
[20] When Nagib returned to the Car, Zaihidir resumed driving. Zaihidir testified that he “saw like movement, [Nagib] give Hanafi bag”. Specifically, Zaihidir was checking his left blind spot when he saw the bag move “from back to front” through the centre gap between the front passenger seat and the driver seat. This happened before the arrest. Zaihidir claimed that he had nothing to do with the drugs.
Statements made during investigations
Statements made by Hanafi
- [21]
[21] During the course of the investigations, Hanafi gave the following statements to the CNB:
- [22]
[22] Hanafi does not challenge the admissibility of these statements on the grounds of threat, inducement or promise. I now set out key extracts from five of these statements which the Prosecution relies on against both Hanafi and Nagib.
- [23]
[23] I begin with the long statement recorded on 4 May 2021, and should point out that this is a statement handwritten by Investigation Officer Inspector Muhammed Ridlwan bin Mohamed Raffi (“IO Ridlwan”) into his investigation diary. IO Ridlwan’s evidence is that he initially intended to record a formal statement from Hanafi. However, when he saw Hanafi at the lock-up that day, Hanafi indicated to IO Ridlwan that he required an asthma pump. IO Ridlwan therefore made a call to the in-house doctor. Despite this, Hanafi told IO Ridlwan that he wished to share some brief accounts of what had happened. In those circumstances, IO Ridlwan decided to record a brief investigation statement from Hanafi in his investigation diary. However, the interview ended up lasting longer than he expected, and the statement was a detailed one. Hanafi eventually saw a doctor and obtained an asthma pump. In my view, nothing really turns on this background, as Hanafi does not seriously raise any challenges based on the recording process.
- [24]
[24] Turning to the contents of the statement recorded on 4 May 2021, Hanafi detailed the following:
(a) Sometime at 4pm on 27 April 2021, Hanafi was supposed to meet his girlfriend at her workplace. However, he received a video call from Nagib asking him “about [Block] 183 Woodlands or something”. Nagib said that this was “urgent” and very important.
(b) Hanafi therefore booked a Grab car to fetch Nagib from his home in Serangoon. Hanafi brought along his Superdry Bag.
(c) When Hanafi arrived at Serangoon, Nagib was alone and carrying a sling bag. From Serangoon, the pair headed to “Blk 183 Woodlands or 183 Marsiling”. When they arrived at their destination, Nagib wanted to locate a specific spot in Block 183. Hanafi decided to help him as Nagib was “old”.
(d) After spending some time trying to locate Block 183 of Woodlands, Hanafi contacted Zaihidir to pick them up. Nagib was unable to find anything at Block 183.
(e) The three of them drove to two restaurants in Woodlands (ie, “Al-Amin” and a restaurant at Woodlands Waterfront), but both places were full. Zaihidir thus began the journey to Yishun.
(f) Along the way to Yishun, Nagib said that he needed “to pee”. Zaihidir stopped the Car along Riverside Road for Nagib to alight. When Nagib was heading out of the Car, Hanafi saw Nagib unzipping the sling bag and pulling out another bag from within it. Hanafi could not recall how long Nagib had left as Hanafi had consumed Epam tablets. When Nagib came back to the Car, he was hugging “a big black bag”. He asked Zaihidir to proceed to Yishun.
(g) In the Car, Hanafi heard Nagib talking on the mobile phone in Malay with an Indian man through a video call. Hanafi could not remember what they had talked about. Hanafi saw a flash, and he turned back to see Nagib taking pictures. He asked Nagib why he was taking pictures, but Nagib did not answer him. He also saw Nagib “tearing some plastic bag”, but he could not recall the colour of the plastic bag. Later, Nagib asked Hanafi to keep the black bag into the Superdry Bag. Hanafi did not ask Nagib for the reason behind this request as he was hungry, and asked Nagib to pass him the bag. Less than a minute later, Nagib asked Hanafi to return him the bag so as to take pictures again. Hanafi became frustrated and opened the bag. He tore a black plastic bag and saw “ubat”. He then confronted Nagib. Hanafi did not pass the bag back to Nagib as Hanafi was angry.
- [25]
[25] In the long statement made on 8 May 2021 at 1.30pm, Nagib provided an account largely similar to that set out in the long statement on 4 May 2021. While Hanafi initially claimed that IO Ridlwan simply “transfer[red]” the details in the 4 May 2021 statement over to the 8 May 2021 statement recorded at 1.30pm, Hanafi subsequently confirmed that “every single aspect” of the 4 May 2021 statement had been read out to him to “clarify and confirm” its contents. The material portions of the long statement made on 8 May 2021 at 1.30pm are as follows:
(a) Hanafi reiterated, as in the statement of 4 May 2021, that when Nagib left the Car, Hanafi saw Nagib unzipping the sling bag, and pulling out another bag from within it. When Nagib came back to the Car, he was hugging “a big black bag”, and had told Zaihidir to drive. In the Car, Hanafi heard Nagib talking on the mobile phone in Malay, and Hanafi “saw flashes of light from the back like [Nagib] was taking pictures”. When Hanafi looked to the back, he saw Nagib tearing some plastic bags. Again, he could not remember the colour of these plastic bags.
(b) Departing from the long statement of 4 May 2021, Hanafi said that he was the one who asked Nagib to pass the bag to the front, which Nagib did. Going into more detail, Hanafi said that when he opened the bag, there was a big parcel. He tore the plastic wrapper of the parcel and saw the drugs which he recognised as heroin. He believed that Nagib did not know about the contents of the bag as the drugs had been concealed. Hanafi kept the bag into the Superdry Bag. Nagib did not say anything as he “looked very lost”. Less than a minute later, the CNB intercepted the Car.
(c) When shown the photographs of the exhibits seized by the CNB, Hanafi admitted that he knew that the Bundles contained heroin, and that the Blocks looked like either “Mushroom or Cannabis”. Hanafi “admitted ownership” of both the Bundles and the Blocks, but claimed that they were for his consumption. He exonerated Nagib and Zaihidir of any involvement in the Blocks, claiming that “neither [Zaihidir] nor [Nagib] knew about them”. He also identified the YONEX bag as the “bag which carried the parcel which contained the drugs”. Further, he identified a black plastic bag, Exhibit A1D, as the “plastic wrapper” he tore from the parcel.
- [26]
[26] In the cautioned statement to the first charge recorded on 10 May 2021, Hanafi stated that he “took ownership of the drugs” for his own consumption:
- [27]
[27] As for the cautioned statement to the second charge recorded on 10 November 2021, Hanafi explained why he “took ownership” of the drugs:
- [28]
[28] Finally, in the long statement recorded on 7 January 2022, Hanafi stated that the drugs were not in the Superdry Bag before he met with Nagib.
Statements made by Nagib
- [29]
[29] Similarly, Nagib gave 15 statements to the CNB as follows:
- [30]
[30] Nagib does not challenge the admissibility of these statements on the grounds of threat, inducement or promise. The gist of these statements is that Nagib denied delivering the Bundles and Blocks to Hanafi. He claimed that he only had his sling bag both when he left the Car “to pee”, and when he returned to the Car. He denied any knowledge of the YONEX bag found in the Superdry Bag. He also denied knowledge of the Bundles and the Blocks and what they contained. Nagib also gave various reasons to account for his presence in Woodlands that day. In brief, he claimed that he wanted to go to Woodlands to “find food” as well as meet his old friends, that it was one “Baiya” who had told him to go to Woodlands to look for a white lorry, and that he was going to meet one “Das”. These shall be dealt with in due course (see [195]–[199] below).
WhatsApp messages, and expert evidence on the communications
- [31]
[31] From the mobile devices recovered, WhatsApp messages between Hanafi and Nagib, as well as between Hanafi and various third parties, including Zaihidir, “Arab Jujul”, “Ace A.A Msl”, “Adek Don Grab”, “Boy Steam”, “Ali Jepun”, and “Kidl”, were recovered. Communications were also extracted between Nagib and Das (saved as “Chef Dosrty Long” on Nagib’s phone), and Baiya.
- [32]
[32] Inspector Mohamad Khairul bin Mohamed (“Insp Khairul”) was called as an expert witness on drug matters. Based on the contents of the WhatsApp messages, he testified that Hanafi and Nagib were involved in drug trafficking activities, and were supplying drugs to each other’s customers. I shall go to the evidence later (see [98]–[103] below).
- [33]
[33] More importantly, pointing to WhatsApp messages between Hanafi and Nagib, the Prosecution argues that they had made arrangements to meet on 27 April 2021 to carry out a drug transaction. As for communications involving Hanafi, Zaihidir and “Boy Steam”, they show that Hanafi had been searching for heroin purchasers on 27 April 2021. Further, the messages between Nagib and Baiya show that Nagib was a “go-between” between the drug source (ie, Baiya) and the recipient (ie, Hanafi).
Hanafi’s evidence
- [34]
[34] Having considered that the Prosecution has established a prima facie case, I called for Hanafi’s defence. Hanafi testified in his defence. At the time of the arrest, Hanafi was a deliveryman for GrabFood and Deliveroo, using a personal mobility device (“PMD”) or a power assisted bicycle (“PAB”). He also had other part-time jobs such as delivering parcels and helping to repair PMDs.
- [35]
[35] Hanafi claimed to consume a wide range of drugs. He would share information over WhatsApp on drug suppliers, as well as the prices of drugs, with his friends, including Arab Jujul, Abu Alok (also saved as “Ace A.A Msl” on his mobile phone), Adek Don Grab, Ali Jepun, Kidl, Boy Steam, Zaihidir (also saved as “Didie Airmata” on his mobile phone) and Nagib (also saved as “Nagib Ace” on his mobile phone).
- [36]
[36] Turning to the events on 27 April 2021, at 3.44pm, Hanafi received a WhatsApp message from Nagib asking Hanafi to call Nagib back urgently. At 4.08pm, Hanafi responded that he would do so as soon as possible. Shortly after, a call took place between Hanafi and Nagib. According to Hanafi, during the call, Nagib informed Hanafi that he needed to go to Block 183 of Woodlands to look for his friends. At the time, Hanafi was at a rented room in Orchard Towers with his girlfriend. As it was the first time Nagib had ever asked for his help, and Nagib’s speech was slurred, as if he had taken a tablet such as Epam, Hanafi decided to help. Hanafi left Orchard with the Superdry Bag, and took a Grab car to fetch Nagib from Serangoon to go to Woodlands together.
- [37]
[37] At around 5.15pm, Hanafi arrived at Nagib’s place of residence in Serangoon. Nagib was carrying the sling bag. The pair made their way to Woodlands in a Grab car.
- [38]
[38] When Hanafi and Nagib reached their destination, they alighted from the Grab car. They were, however, unable to locate Block 183. During their search for Block 183, Hanafi became hungry and bought a cake from a bakery. He also consumed Epam pills. They were ultimately unable to find Block 183. Hanafi therefore called Zaihidir to ask for a ride to Yishun.
- [39]
[39] After getting into the Car, Zaihidir drove them to look for restaurants to eat at in the vicinity. As the places were full, they decided to proceed to Yishun instead. However, as Nagib wanted “to pee”, Zaihidir stopped at the side of the road. When Nagib left the Car, he had the sling bag with him. When he came back, he also only had the sling bag. After Nagib returned to the Car, Hanafi saw Nagib “playing with his phone, taking picture”, and “fondling with … a bag or something”. Nagib was also talking in Malay. Hanafi asked Nagib to “pass it to the front, to pass the bag”. Although Hanafi could not remember clearly, he thought that there was a bag “being passed to the front”. The next thing Hanafi remembered was tearing up plastic, and finding “the bundle” with “drugs inside” on his lap. The Car was subsequently intercepted. Hanafi was “so shocked” that he placed the “whole thing inside [his] bag”. Hanafi was dizzy at that point as he had consumed Epam.
- [40]
[40] Even then, Hanafi said that at first glance, the drugs in the bundle looked like heroin. He put the drugs into the Superdry Bag because he thought he would be able to consume them. During cross-examination, Hanafi claimed that while he recognised the drugs in the Bundles as heroin, he did not know what the Blocks contained, ie, cannabis. Having set out the main of his evidence in examination-in-chief, which I observe to be fairly consistent with the accounts in his statements as set out in [23] to [28] above, I should highlight that on various aspects, Hanafi shifted his stance, especially during cross-examination and re-examination. These shall be dealt with below.
Nagib’s evidence
- [41]
[41] Similarly, having called for his defence, Nagib testified. Consistent with his position in the statements as set out at [30] above, Nagib denied delivering the drugs to Hanafi. On 27 April 2021, Nagib intended to go to Woodlands to meet his friends to “carry out some good deeds”, to meet Das to pass him monies, and to obtain a mobile phone from Das. He got a lift from Hanafi, thinking that Hanafi would return to Yishun. Along the way, Nagib helped Baiya look for a white lorry.
- [42]
[42] For context, Nagib claimed that Das was a friend whom he treated “like family”. Nagib claimed that they spoke at least two to three times every week and were close enough that Das could ask for money from Nagib. However, Nagib did not know Das’s full name, nor his address. As for Baiya, Nagib claimed that Baiya, whose real name is pronounced as “Thivan”, was someone he knew through another individual he called “Boy”. Nagib claimed that Baiya called him frequently, that Baiya lives in Malaysia, and that they “understand each other”. Save for these general and rather vague details, Nagib could provide no further information on Das and Baiya.
- [43]
[43] Nagib subsequently alighted along Riverside Road to urinate. In relation to various photographs he sent to Baiya when he alighted to urinate, Nagib explained that these were to inform Baiya that he could not locate the white lorry. At the time, Nagib was “high”, as he had consumed “Erimin”, “Epam” and “mushroom”. However, he denied having anything to do with the Bundles and the Blocks, and claimed that he never passed a bag to Hanafi in the Car.
The Prosecution’s case
Chain of custody
- [44]
[44] The Prosecution argues that there was no break in the chain of custody of the drug exhibits. The CNB officers’ documentation and identification of the seized exhibits was unchallenged at trial, and the evidence shows that the movement of the drug exhibits from the point of seizure to the point that they were submitted to the HSA is properly accounted for. Hence, the chain of custody has been established beyond a reasonable doubt.
Case against Hanafi
Bundles of diamorphine
- [45]
[45] In relation to the Bundles, the Prosecution argues that based on the evidence, Hanafi had possession of and actual knowledge of the nature of the drugs in the Bundles, ie, diamorphine. As Hanafi was proved to have in his possession 58.86g of diamorphine (within the Bundles), the presumption of trafficking under s 17(c) of the MDA applies.
- [46]
[46] The presumption under s 17(c) is unrebutted by Hanafi’s claim that the diamorphine in the Bundles was intended for his consumption. First, Hanafi’s account at the trial implied that the drugs did not belong to him and that he had chanced upon the drugs. Hence, Hanafi’s consumption defence is somewhat inconsistent with his version of events, as it would mean that he intended to consume drugs belonging to someone else. Second, Hanafi was not an abuser of heroin at the relevant time. He did not report his heroin consumption to the CGH doctor after his arrest, and had informed his reporting doctor at the Institute of Mental Health (“IMH”), Dr Cheow Enquan (“Dr Cheow”) that he tried to quit drugs one week prior to his arrest. Third, Hanafi conceded at the trial that he was not a heavy heroin abuser at the relevant time. Fourth, Hanafi’s claims were deficient as he failed to adduce any credible evidence on his rate of consumption. Given these factors, Hanafi would not have stockpiled heroin weighing approximately five pounds with a substantial value for his consumption.
- [47]
[47] Indeed, the objective evidence shows that Hanafi possessed the Bundles for the purposes of trafficking. Based on text messages between Hanafi and Zaihidir as well as Boy Steam, Hanafi had been searching for heroin purchasers on 27 April 2021, the same day that he received the Bundles. Hanafi’s claim that these messages were confined to information-sharing and did not concern drug sales ran contrary to the content of the messages. Additionally, text messages between Hanafi and, amongst others, Kidl, Ali Jepun and Arab Jajul, show that Hanafi was operating a drug trafficking business. These further point towards the Bundles being for trafficking purposes and not for Hanafi’s personal consumption.
Blocks of cannabis
- [48]
[48] In relation to the Blocks, the Prosecution argues that Hanafi had possession of the Blocks and relies on the presumption in s 18(2) of the MDA that he had knowledge of the nature of the drugs. Hanafi has failed to rebut this presumption.
- [49]
[49] As regards whether Hanafi possessed the Blocks for the purpose of trafficking, the Prosecution argues that because the amount of cannabis involved (ie, 499.9g) is “more than 30 times the statutory threshold that triggers the presumption of trafficking” under s 17 of the MDA, there is an irresistible inference that the Blocks were for the purpose of trafficking. The Prosecution emphasises that although it is not relying on the statutory presumption under s 17 of the MDA, the statutory threshold “remains useful” to highlight the substantial quantity of cannabis in the present case.
- [50]
[50] Next, Hanafi’s claim that he intended to consume the cannabis is not convincing. Hanafi did not report his cannabis consumption habits to the CNB or to Dr Cheow. Neither did he raise this in his cautioned statement in respect of the second charge. On the contrary, again, the messages show that Hanafi was engaged in drug trafficking activities, which strengthens the inference that he possessed the Blocks for the purpose of trafficking.
- [51]
[51] Thus, the evidence leads to the irresistible inference that Hanafi was in possession of the Blocks for the purpose of trafficking.
Case against Nagib
- [52]
[52] To establish the case against Nagib, the Prosecution relies on both Hanafi’s confession in the statements, where Hanafi admitted that it was Nagib who passed him the drugs, as well as the objective evidence and circumstances. The Prosecution argues that full weight should be given to Hanafi’s account which implicates Nagib as it was internally and externally consistent. Further, Hanafi had incidentally incriminated Nagib while incriminating himself, which lends credibility to his account.
- [53]
[53] The objective evidence bolsters the inference that the drugs were delivered by Nagib to Hanafi. According to the Prosecution, Nagib’s drug-centred relationship with Hanafi provides the context to their meeting on 27 April 2021. Additionally, based on text messages between Nagib and Baiya, Nagib had arranged to collect a drug consignment on the day of his arrest. Text messages between Nagib and Baiya were deleted soon after they were sent, and from around 4.30pm to 7.21pm, Nagib had provided multiple updates to Baiya of his whereabouts, such as by sending pictures of his surroundings. This included a picture of a plastic bag sent at 7.21pm.
- [54]
[54] In comparison, Nagib’s defence of denial should be rejected as it lacks veracity and credibility, and is unbelievable. Nagib was also an evasive and dishonest witness, prepared to conjure accounts whenever it suited his purposes. Accordingly, the Prosecution argues that Nagib has failed to rebut the presumption of knowledge under s 18(2) of the MDA. The charges against him are therefore established.
The Defence’s cases
Location of the search and seizure and the chain of custody
- [55]
[55] Hanafi and Nagib submit that the location of the search of and seizure from the Car is uncertain, and that the Prosecution has not discharged its burden of proving an unbroken chain of custody.
- [56]
[56] In this regard, the electronic Global Positioning System (“GPS”) records for the movement of the Car on 27 and 28 April 2021 were extracted by Mr Kelvin Kum Tuck Leong (“Mr Kum”), the director of Karz Automobile & Leasing Pte Ltd, the company Zaihidir rented the Car from. The GPS records indicate that the Car had been at Block 782C Woodlands Crescent from 8.06pm, at the very earliest, to 11.27pm on 27 April 2021.
- [57]
[57] While the Prosecution’s witnesses testified that the search and seizure of the Car took place at the MSCP (located at Block 780 of Woodlands Crescent), this location did not appear in the GPS records of the Car. Instead, the Car was only recorded as being at Block 782C of Woodlands Crescent. No satisfactory explanation was provided by the Prosecution’s witnesses on this discrepancy. The location of the seizure was uncertain. Hence, a reasonable doubt has arisen from the point of interception to the point of seizure.
Hanafi’s case
Nagib’s case
- [59]
[59] Nagib’s primary case is that he did not have possession of the Bundles and Blocks, and was not aware of their existence at any point in time. Nagib points to the fact that at the time of the arrest, he was not in physical control over the bag which contained the Bundles and Blocks – specifically, this refers to the YONEX bag, which Hanafi claimed contained the drugs (see [25(c)] above).
- [60]
[60] Nagib submits that the bag which contained the drugs and which had been passed from Nagib to Hanafi, as alleged by the Prosecution and Hanafi, does not exist and was fabricated to implicate Nagib. This is supported by the following points. There were only three bags seized by the CNB: Nagib’s sling bag, the Superdry Bag, and the YONEX bag. However, neither Nagib’s sling bag nor the YONEX bag were large enough to fit the drugs. Only the Superdry Bag was large enough to fit the drugs. In turn, Nagib’s DNA was not found on the Superdry Bag or the YONEX bag, which shows that he never had contact with them. The fibre test between Nagib’s sling bag and the YONEX bag also showed that there was no connection between them.
- [61]
[61] Instead, Nagib claims that Hanafi had possession of the drugs at all times. Nagib relies on photographs of Hanafi at Orchard Towers on the morning of 27 April 2021 as evidence that the Superdry Bag was not empty at the time. Hanafi’s testimony was also not reliable, as it is odd that Hanafi would have opened a bag belonging to Nagib without his permission. Moreover, Hanafi had time to pack the Bundles and the Blocks into the Superdry Bag, as shown by how they were found in separate compartments. Hanafi’s evidence is unreliable.
- [62]
[62] As regards Insp Khairul’s evidence on the messages between Nagib and his friends, Nagib argues that Insp Khairul’s evidence is not accurate. Accordingly, Nagib argues that the element of possession has not been established, and that the presumption in s 18(2) of the MDA cannot be invoked.
Decision: Location of the search and seizure, and chain of custody
- [63]
[63] Having set out the parties’ cases, I turn to the common issue concerning the location of the search and seizure, and the chain of custody of the drug exhibits. It is well-established that the burden of establishing the chain of custody lies on the Prosecution. This requires the Prosecution to account for the movement of the exhibits from the point of seizure to the point of analysis. Where the defence suggests that there has been a break in the chain of custody, it may show that at one or more stages, a reasonable doubt has arisen as to whether the chain of custody has been broken. Where this is shown to be the case and a reasonable doubt arises as to the identity of the drug exhibits, the Prosecution would have failed to discharge its burden (Mohamed Affandi bin Rosli v Public Prosecutor and another appeal [2019] 1 SLR 440 (“Affandi”) at [39]).
- [64]
[64] I make two preliminary points. First, contrary to Hanafi’s submission, it seems wrong to me to characterise a concern which arises “from the point of interception to the point of seizure” as a chain of custody issue. Any difficulty which arises from the GPS records concerns a point in time before (and not after) the formal seizure of the drug exhibits. Strictly speaking, this does not give rise to a chain of custody issue. Notwithstanding this, I recognise that following the interception and arrests, the CNB officers had control of the Car until the time of the search and seizure. Therefore, it falls for the Prosecution to prove that the contents within the Car remained intact until the point of seizure of the drugs.
- [65]
[65] Second, as pointed out by the Prosecution, the parties have agreed in the Statement of Agreed Facts (“SOAF”) that the search and seizure of the Car took place at the MSCP located at Block 780 of Woodlands Crescent. The SOAF was admitted pursuant to s 267(1) of the CPC. Section 267 of the CPC provides that:
- [66]
[66] Section 267(1) of the CPC makes it clear that any fact in the SOAF is “conclusive evidence” of a fact being admitted in the proceedings. Counsel for Hanafi and Nagib have not sought to withdraw their admission under s 267(4) of the CPC, in relation to this fact. I therefore invited further submissions from them on the significance of their departure from the SOAF. Neither counsel, however, provided a meaningful response, save to assert that the burden was on the Prosecution to establish an unbroken chain of custody.
- [67]
[67] That said, given the extent to which both counsel have advanced certain arguments in their written submissions about the uncertainty regarding the location of the search and seizure, and the credibility of the CNB officers who testified on the matter, I turn to deal with the issue in more detail.
- [68]
[68] According to the Prosecution’s witnesses, at around 8.02pm, Zaihidir and Nagib were escorted to the MSCP for the search and seizure. While making their way to the MSCP, Zaihidir was in the custody of Staff Sergeant Goh Bai Lin (“SSgt Goh”) and Sergeant (3) Muhammad Hidayat Bin Jasni (“Sgt Hidayat”) in the Car, while Nagib was with Inspector Eng Chien Loong Eugene (“Insp Eugene”) and Staff Sergeant Au Yong Hong Mian (“SSgt Au Yong”) in an operational CNB car. Station Inspector Tay Keng Chye Sunny (“SI Sunny”) rode a bike and trailed after them to the MSCP. At around 8.12pm, they arrived at the MSCP. At around 8.18pm, at the MSCP, SI Sunny conducted a search of the Car in the presence of both Zaihidir and Nagib. The Superdry Bag was seized from the front passenger floorboard, and the drugs were seized from the Superdry Bag. The search concluded at about 9.32pm.
- [69]
[69] With regards to the location of the search and seizure, Sgt Hidayat explained that it was the typical practice of CNB officers, following an interception, to “rendezvous” at the nearest multi-storey car park. Similarly, SSgt Goh testified that the usual practice was to commence a search of the vehicle involved at the “rendezvous” location. He also added that it was the CNB’s prevailing practice not to touch any items in the vehicle. The “rendezvous” location is typically determined by the ground commanding officer, who was Insp Eugene at the time. In turn, Insp Eugene confirmed that he had directed for the search to be at Block 780, and that location was where the officers had proceeded to. This is consistent with the evidence of SSgt Goh, who testified that he had personally checked and seen the block number – ie, Block 780 – when he drove into the MSCP. I accept the evidence of Sgt Hidayat, SSgt Goh and Insp Eugene, whose accounts are corroborative in material aspects and which, together, paint a cogent picture of the CNB officers commencing and conducting the search at the MSCP.
- [70]
[70] The Prosecution also relies on the evidence of Mr Kum, who testified that based on his own experience, it was “quite possible” for the GPS entries to have wrongly registered Block 782C as the relevant location. This was because the MSCP, being comprised of multi-layers of concrete and brick, could interfere with the passing of GPS signals. In his two years of using the GPS system, he had experienced this around five to eight times. I am cognisant that Mr Kum does not have scientific expertise in GPS systems. Nevertheless, his evidence is relevant for the limited purpose of showing that the GPS system is not completely infallible, and that there is a possibility of such GPS systems inaccurately registering the location of a vehicle.
- [71]
[71] In addition, the gantry records of the carparks near Blocks 780 and 782C of Woodlands support the Prosecution’s case. Mr Au Leong Heng David (“Mr Au”), a representative of ST Engineering Urban Solutions Ltd, the company which manages the carpark gantries at Woodlands Crescent, helped retrieve the gantry records for the carpark at Block 780 on 27 April 2021. The gantry records show that the Car had entered the carpark at Block 780 – ie, the MSCP – at 8.05pm. The CNB had also asked Mr Au to check the gantry records of the carpark at Block 782C of Woodlands Crescent. However, as Block 782C of Woodlands Crescent is a residential block and not a multi-storey carpark, Mr Au instead checked the gantry records of the carpark at Block 782, where there was a multi-storey carpark. In this regard, he found no records of the Car on 27 April 2021. The Prosecution relies on these gantry records to argue that the Car was at Block 780 for the search and seizure, and that there is no discrepancy as regards the location of the search and seizure. I agree with the Prosecution, and find that the gantry records are consistent with the CNB officers’ evidence that the search took place at Block 780, and not Block 782C. While Hanafi suggests that the Car’s entry into Block 782C may not have been captured on the gantry records due to tailgating, no evidence has been adduced in support of this. Such “speculative arguments that seek to raise a theoretical possibility of a break in the chain of custody” [emphasis in original] do not suffice in proving a break in the chain of custody (Affandi at [56]). In addition, I also find Mr Au’s evidence, namely, that Block 782C of Woodlands Crescent was a residential block instead of a multi-storey carpark, to be useful to support Mr Kum’s point, as it illustrates that the GPS records of the Car may not pinpoint its location with absolute accuracy.
- [72]
[72] To sum up, based on the evidence of the CNB officers as well as the gantry records, I find that the location of the search and seizure was at the MSCP at Block 780 of Woodlands Crescent. More importantly, neither Hanafi nor Nagib have put forth any evidence suggesting any form of tampering with the contents in the Car prior to the point of seizure of the drugs. As mentioned above at [68], during the drive to the MSCP, Nagib was in the custody of Insp Eugene and SSgt Au Yong in an operational CNB car, while Zaihidir was in the custody SSgt Goh and Sgt Hidayat in the Car. None of these witnesses were questioned on any alleged tampering during this journey.
- [73]
[73] With that, I turn to the rest of the Prosecution’s evidence, showing the chain of custody from the point of seizure to the point of analysis as follows:
(a) After the search was concluded at 9.32pm, SI Sunny passed the seized exhibits to SSgt Au Yong, who packed and sealed the drug exhibits into separate tamper proof bags. Nagib and Zaihidir signed on each tamper-proof bag. From 9.32pm onwards, SSgt Au Yong took custody of the exhibits.
(b) Separately, at 10.21pm, IO Ridlwan arrived at the MSCP. At 10.30pm, SSgt Au Yong showed all the seized exhibits, which had been placed in a black duffel bag, to IO Ridlwan, for him to conduct the relevant checks and documentation. IO Ridlwan checked the tamper-proof bags to ensure that there had been no tampering, and that the bags had been sealed and signed. At 11.42pm, the drug exhibits were returned to the same black duffel bag, and IO Ridlwan placed this duffel bag containing the drugs into the boot of his operational car. He then left for the CNB Headquarters (“HQ”).
(c) At 12.19am on 28 April 2021, IO Ridlwan arrived at the CNB HQ. SSgt Au Yong, who had also returned by then, took custody of the duffel bag containing the exhibits. At 12.21am, he kept them locked inside a metal cabinet which had previously been empty. He was the only one who possessed the key to the locked metal cabinet.
(d) At 9.05am, SSgt Au Yong handed the duffel bag containing the drugs to Inspector Tay Cher Yeen Jason (“Insp Jason”). From 9.05am to 10.41am, the duffel bag was in Insp Jason’s custody. As he went about his duties related to the case, he brought the duffel bag with him and had sight of the duffel bag at all times.
(e) At 10.41am, Insp Jason brought the duffel bag, and its contents, to the Exhibit Management Room. Exhibit processing commenced at 10.41am. Nagib was present to observe the exhibit processing, save when he left the room from 10.59am to 11.01am to urinate. The exhibit processing concluded at about 2.27pm.
(f) At 2.36pm, the weighing of the exhibits commenced. This concluded at 2.45pm. Nagib witnessed the weighing of the drug exhibits, acknowledged the recorded weights, and signed on the investigation diary.
(g) At 3.40pm, IO Ridlwan placed the exhibits in Women Inspector Tan Lye Cheng Michelle’s (“OC Michelle”) office. OC Michelle was the only one who could access her office. There were no exhibits in her room prior to her receiving the 90 exhibits from IO Ridlwan.
(h) From 3.40pm to 4.05pm, OC Michelle had custody of the exhibits. At 4.05pm, OC Michelle submitted all 90 exhibits to Sergeant Kovalan s/o Gopala Krishna (“Sgt Kovalan”) at the CNB Exhibit Management Team office (“EMT office”).
(i) Upon receiving the exhibits at 4.05pm, Sgt Kovalan placed them inside a locked metal cabinet inside the EMT office. He was the only one who had access to the locked metal cabinet at the material time. He also ensured that there were no exhibits from other cases in the cabinet at the time.
(j) On 29 April 2021:
(i) At around 2.48pm, Sgt Kovalan retrieved 21 exhibits and handed them to Sergeant 3 Muhammad Norjansher Shah Bin Misnan for delivery to the Illicit Drugs Laboratory of the HSA.
(ii) At around 2.45pm, Sgt Kovalan retrieved 45 exhibits and handed them to Staff Sergeant Mohammed Rafi s/o Anwar Badcha for delivery to the DNA Profiling Laboratory of the HSA.
(k) According to Sgt Kovalan, none of the exhibits, including the drug exhibits, were rejected by the HSA. This was confirmed by HSA analyst Sylvia Tan.
- [74]
[74] For completeness, Hanafi could not be present during the events as he was recuperating in CGH. He was only discharged on 3 May 2021. However, an accused person’s inability to observe the processing and/or sealing of a drug exhibit does not automatically break the chain of custody during that period of non-observation. What is important is the actual chain of custody of the material drug exhibits, and not any accused person’s observation of that chain of custody (Public Prosecutor v Yogesswaran C Manogaran and another [2023] SGHC 170 at [45]). Based on all of the above, I find that the Prosecution has established that there was no break in the chain of custody of the drug exhibits.
Decision: Hanafi
The law
- [75]
[75] I now turn to consider the specific issues in relation to the two charges against Hanafi, beginning with the law.
- [76]
[76] The elements in respect of a charge of trafficking under s 5(1) read with s 5(2) of the MDA are well-established. It must be proven that the accused person had: (a) possession of a controlled drug; (b) knowledge of the nature of the drug; and (c) possession of the drug for the purpose of trafficking, which was not authorised.
- [77]
[77] The last element may be proved by the Prosecution or presumed under s 17 of the MDA (Chong Hoon Cheong v Public Prosecutor [2022] 2 SLR 778 at [4]; Zainal bin Hamad v Public Prosecutor and another appeal [2018] 2 SLR 1119 at [49]). In this connection, s 17(c) of the MDA reads:
Bundles of diamorphine
Possession and knowledge
- [78]
[78] Dealing first with the Bundles of diamorphine, Hanafi has not seriously disputed that he was in possession of the Bundles at the time of his arrest. During his examination-in-chief, he admitted that he had placed Exhibit A1A (ie, comprising of the five packets of heroin which form the subject of his first charge) in the Superdry Bag prior to the arrest. When this element of the charge was put to him by the Prosecution during cross-examination, he accepted that he had possession of the Bundles. In his written submissions, Hanafi also accepts that should the court find that the chain of custody of the drug exhibits has not been broken, that the element of possession is satisfied. Hence, the first element of possession has been established beyond reasonable doubt.
- [79]
[79] Similarly, Hanafi’s knowledge of the nature of the drugs contained in the Bundles, ie, diamorphine, does not appear to be disputed. In his investigation statements, he consistently stated that he saw heroin or “ubat” (the street name for heroin) when he opened the “black plastic” enclosing the Bundles. In his testimony, Hanafi said that he could tell that the drugs in the Bundles were heroin. During cross-examination, Hanafi testified that at the time of his arrest, he was familiar with how heroin looked like. He further admitted that when he tore open the Bundles, he recognised that they contained heroin. More notably, in his written submissions, he has not disputed his knowledge of the drugs, and has only sought to rebut the presumption of trafficking. Hence, I find that Hanafi had actual knowledge of the nature of the drugs in the Bundles.
Possession for the purposes of trafficking
- [80]
[80] Having proven that Hanafi had in his possession and knew of the nature of the drugs in the Bundles, and given that the amount of diamorphine in the Bundles exceeds 2g, the presumption under s 17(c) of the MDA is properly invoked by the Prosecution. The burden is on Hanafi to rebut the presumption of trafficking on a balance of probabilities (Muhammad bin Abdullah v Public Prosecutor and another appeal [2017] 1 SLR 427 at [26]).
- [81]
[81] As noted above at [58], Hanafi’s defence is that he chanced upon the Bundles while in the Car and formed the intention to consume them on the spot. Having considered the evidence, I find that Hanafi has not rebutted the presumption of trafficking under s 17(c) of the MDA on a balance of probabilities. My reasons are these.
(1) The reason for meeting Nagib
- [82]
[82] Given that a key plank of Hanafi’s defence is that he had chanced upon the drugs fortuitously, the reason why Hanafi and Nagib met up on 27 April 2021 is an important aspect of his defence. In court, Hanafi’s account of why he met with Nagib spontaneously that day is set out at [36] above. Essentially, he denied that there was any prior arrangement to carry out a drug transaction. However, the WhatsApp messages between Hanafi, and Nagib, Zaihidir and Abu Alok are telling, and contradict his position.
- [83]
[83] At 3.44pm, Hanafi received a message from Nagib asking Hanafi to call Nagib back urgently. At 4.08pm, Hanafi responded that he would do so shortly. A call took place between them after. According to Hanafi, it was only during this call that he knew that Nagib needed to go to Woodlands. Yet, at 4.08pm, Hanafi had also sent a message to Zaihidir asking Zaihidir if he was free, and followed up at 4.09pm indicating that this was “[v]ery urgent. i need transporter”. Given the proximity in time of the two messages, as well as the apparent urgency of both matters, a possible inference is that the urgent need for transport referred to by Hanafi in his message to Zaihidir, and the urgent matter referred to in Nagib’s message, relate to the same matter. This would suggest that Hanafi had already known that Nagib had an urgent matter prior to their call. (While it is plausible that the call between Hanafi and Nagib lasted less than a minute, this was not Hanafi’s case at trial.) As I will show in the paragraphs which follow, this inference is supported by the evidence as a whole.
- [84]
[84] When Hanafi was questioned on his texts to Zaihidir at 4.08pm and 4.09pm, he claimed that his text to Nagib about Nagib’s urgent matter, and his text to Zaihidir on urgent transport, related to different matters. He claimed that he had told Zaihidir that he needed to go to Yishun urgently because he needed to fix PMDs. This was a claim that only surfaced during the trial itself. In his statements, he made no mention of any plans to fix PMDs. Instead, he had claimed that he was going to meet his girlfriend. Hanafi also acknowledged that the Superdry Bag did not contain PMD tools, even though he typically had them in his bag to carry out repair jobs. The WhatsApp messages therefore do not square well with Hanafi’s claim that he had no prior arrangement to meet Nagib on 27 April 2021.
- [85]
[85] Moreover, earlier that day at 2.27pm, Hanafi had received a WhatsApp message from one Abu Alok, a mutual friend of both Nagib and Hanafi, telling Hanafi that Nagib “had an appointment” with Hanafi. Hanafi replied to Abu Alok at 4.08pm saying “Ok”, confirming that he knew Nagib had an appointment with him. If the meeting between Hanafi and Nagib was indeed spontaneous, it is difficult to see how a third party would have known of their meeting so early on. As the Prosecution pointed out, Hanafi showed no sense of surprise that Abu Alok knew of their meeting. When questioned on this, Hanafi’s only response was that he did not think much of this.
- [86]
[86] As for Hanafi’s claim that out of concern for Nagib, he went from Orchard to Serangoon to meet Nagib to proceed to Woodlands, I note that both men conceded that they had only known each other for around one month at the relevant time. While I can accept that one would want to help a friend, Hanafi’s claim is illogical when I take into account that he had apparently been rushing to Yishun for PMD repairs or to meet his girlfriend, both or either of which were sufficiently urgent to him that he would ask Zaihidir for urgent transport. His explanation plainly does not square with his existing WhatsApp messages with Nagib, Zaihidir and Abu Alok, which all converged at 4.08pm. To claim that all three messages related to different matters, in light of the content of these messages, would require an incredibly strained reading of the texts.
- [87]
[87] Taking the above together, Hanafi’s conduct was inconsistent with that of a person who had spontaneously decided to meet up with a friend. He was aware that he needed to meet Nagib that day.
(2) The explanation for obtaining and keeping the Bundles
- [88]
[88] The circumstances leading up to Hanafi’s purported collection of the Bundles (and Blocks) from Nagib in the Car are also of central importance. Yet, his testimony in this regard is riddled with material inconsistencies:
(a) First, as regards why Hanafi took the bag containing the Bundles and Blocks from Nagib and intentionally opened the bag unprompted, there are inconsistencies between his statements and his testimony. In his statement on 4 May 2021, Hanafi claimed that he had opened the bag out of frustration at Nagib (see [24(g)] above). During cross-examination, Hanafi claimed that he had unwrapped the parcel containing the Bundles because he was “curious”. When confronted on this inconsistency, Hanafi claimed that he could not remember. I stress that his act of opening a bag that did not belong to him is inherently bizarre, and requires a reasonably plausible explanation. His inability to provide a consistent and believable explanation for doing so is therefore troubling.
(b) Second, as regards why he chose to retain possession of the bag despite finding out that there were drugs in the bag, I am not persuaded that it was due to his spontaneous intention to consume the drugs.
(i) In his statement recorded on 4 May 2021, Hanafi claimed that when he opened the black plastic surrounding the Bundles and saw diamorphine, he “confronted Nagib”, and did not pass Nagib back the bag as he was “angry” (see [24(g)] above).
(ii) In his statement recorded on 8 May 2021 at 1.30pm, Hanafi claimed that he kept the drugs and did not say anything to Nagib because he believed that Nagib did not know of the drugs, as Nagib looked “lost” (see [25] above). This is materially at odds with his claim that he “confronted” Nagib once he found out about the drugs.
- [89]
[89] Hanafi argues that his conduct must be assessed in light of the circumstances that when the drugs came into his possession, he was “dizzy” and “unable to fully appreciate the situation that he was in”. In his intoxicated state and “in the spur of the moment… [Hanafi] only saw some heroin and decided to retain possession” of the Bundles (and Blocks) for consumption. This argument is inconsistent with the contemporaneous evidence.
- [91]
[91] Accordingly, I find that Hanafi’s evidence lacks credibility in these material aspects of his defence. These point away from his claim that he had come into possession of the drugs by chance and formed the intention to consume the diamorphine on the spot.
(3) The drugs were found in different compartments
- [92]
[92] Perhaps the most striking indication that Hanafi did not chance upon the drugs, was the fact that the drugs had been recovered by the CNB from different compartments of the Superdry Bag.
- [93]
[93] In his statement recorded on 8 May 2021 at 1.30pm, Hanafi claimed to have put the drugs into the Superdry Bag prior to the CNB’s interception (see [25(b)] above). Subsequently, in his IMH report, Hanafi was recorded as having “panicked and stuffed the black bundle into his own bag” during the interception. At trial, Hanafi asserted that when the CNB intercepted the Car, he “chucked” the drugs, which were on his lap, into the Superdry Bag. However, the objective evidence points against these subsequent assertions.
- [94]
[94] When the CNB seized the drugs, the drugs were found in different compartments of the Superdry Bag. As set out above at [11], two of the Blocks, ie, Exhibits A1E1A and A1E2A, were found in the right and left compartments of the Superdry Bag respectively, while the Bundles and one of the Blocks, ie, A1B1, were found in the main compartment. The Superdry Bag was also zipped at the point of seizure. Hanafi’s shift in position to claim that he hurriedly packed the drugs at the point of interception, and that he was high on Epam, is unbelievable. The latter has been dealt with at [90] above. As for the former, I find it to be contradicted by the objective evidence. The fact that the drugs were recovered in different compartments shows that Hanafi had ample time, and had made the purposeful decision, to separate the Bundles and the Blocks, before zipping the Superdry Bag.
- [95]
[95] Notably, when Hanafi was questioned on this, he did not challenge the correctness of this fact, and could provide no explanation of this finding:
- [96]
[96] Further, consistent testimony was provided by SI Muhammad Fardlie Bin Ramli, SSgt Goh, and Insp Eugene, that less than a minute passed between the point of interception and the point of opening the passenger door of the Car to effect the arrest. It would have been difficult for Hanafi to have separated the drugs and zip the Superdry Bag within this short period of time. If Hanafi had indeed “chucked” everything into his Superdry Bag as he subsequently claimed, one would imagine that the drugs would have been found in a more haphazard state, forcibly shoved into a single compartment. This is especially given his insistence that he had been intoxicated on Epam tablets at the time.
- [97]
[97] Moreover, when I invited further submissions on this point, Hanafi did not dispute that from the time a photograph of a plastic bag was sent by Nagib to Baiya in the Car at 7.21pm (see [202] below), to the time of interception by the CNB at 7.28pm, approximately seven minutes passed. It seems to me that after Nagib returned to the Car, there was ample time for Hanafi to take hold of the drugs, and to pack the Bundles and the Blocks into the Superdry Bag. In short, the state in which the drugs were seized undermines Hanafi’s claim that he had come into ownership of the drugs by chance, and casts further doubt on the reliability of his narrative.
(4) WhatsApp messages from Hanafi sourcing for potential buyers of heroin
- [98]
[98] Specifically, in relation to the Bundles, I address the Prosecution’s argument that Hanafi possessed the drugs for the purposes of trafficking as he had been searching for heroin purchasers on 27 April 2021, the same day that he received the Bundles. In response, Hanafi argues that he was not looking for potential buyers of heroin, but simply following up on previous queries on the price of heroin.
- [99]
[99] In particular, the Prosecution relies on Hanafi’s conversations with one Boy Steam. Hanafi claims that Boy Steam is a friend whom he met in prison, who is “also an addict”. On 27 April 2021, Hanafi texted Boy Steam the following:
- [101]
[101] Hence, I disbelieve Hanafi that he was simply following up on an inquiry of the prices of heroin.
- [102]
[102] Likewise, at 5.48pm on 27 April 2021, Hanafi had texted Zaihidir as follows: “See who wants, half tablet is 2.7k”. In his statement recorded on 8 May 2021 at 1.30pm, Hanafi confirmed that he was asking if Zaihidir knew anyone who wanted half a packet of heroin for $2,700. He claimed that he was asking on behalf of a friend, whose identity he did not wish to reveal. During cross-examination, Hanafi shifted in his position and stated that he was asking Zaihidir if Zaihidir himself wanted half a pound of heroin, and that it was someone else who was enquiring about the price of heroin. He could not remember who this was. Hanafi’s assertion that he was simply following up on a price inquiry requires a strained reading of his message to Zaihidir, where he expressly asked Zaihidir to “[s]ee who wants” heroin. I therefore do not accept his explanation of the messages. His inability to remember any further details as regards the messages renders his account unsatisfactory.
- [103]
[103] Taken in the round, I accept that Hanafi had been looking for heroin purchasers on 27 April 2021 and was not simply following up on price inquiries. This is consistent with an intention to traffic the diamorphine in the Bundles. As the Prosecution pointed out during Hanafi’s cross-examination, it would have been an incredible coincidence for Hanafi to have been asking for heroin buyers on 27 April 2021, only to chance upon a large consignment of heroin that very evening.
(5) Hanafi’s defence of consumption
- [104]
[104] Based on all of the above, I reject Hanafi’s claim that he fortuitously came into possession of the drugs. Even if I were to accept this claim, on analysis, Hanafi’s consumption defence fails as Hanafi has not provided any credible evidence of his rate of consumption of diamorphine.
- [105]
[105] In A Steven s/o Paul Raj v Public Prosecutor [2022] 2 SLR 538 (“A Steven”) at [25], the Court of Appeal emphasised that the “key pillar and essential foundation” of the consumption defence is an accused person’s rate of consumption. The court further expounded on the relevant considerations when determining if the presumption under s 17 of the MDA has been rebutted:
- [108]
[108] Before I go to Hanafi’s rate of consumption of heroin, however, I should point out that it is not altogether clear whether prior to the arrest, Hanafi was consuming heroin at all. From 27 April to 3 May 2021, when Hanafi was monitored at CGH, he did not inform the CGH doctor that he was consuming heroin, despite the fact that he admitted to abusing methamphetamine, benzodiazepine, and alcohol. Although Hanafi did inform Dr Cheow, his IMH examining doctor who saw him on 21 and 27 May 2021, that he had previous use of “almost every type of illicit drug available” and “recent use of … heroin”, Hanafi had also informed Dr Cheow that he tried to quit drugs one week prior to his arrest. During the trial, Hanafi clarified that this was “not to the extent of going cold turkey”, but that he did “cut down” on his consumption.
- [109]
[109] More importantly, even if Hanafi was abusing heroin at the relevant time, Hanafi has provided no credible evidence of his daily rate of heroin consumption. According to Hanafi’s statement recorded on 7 January 2022, he began smoking heroin in 2020. He would consume heroin together with “ice”, and would only consume drugs before and after clubbing. His frequency of consuming heroin in a week was thus the same as that for ice. As to his frequency of clubbing, he claimed that he went either three or four times a week, or sometimes not at all.
- [110]
[110] In his testimony, however, he claimed that the frequency of consumption was mood dependent, and that he consumed drugs when he “[felt] like it”. He was unable to estimate how frequently he consumed ice, as this depended on what he had available. He also accepted that he was unable to provide a consistent rate of heroin consumption. Yet, he also claimed that he would consume heroin about two to three times a week, and that there were no weeks where he did not consume heroin. When pressed, Hanafi admitted that his claim that he consumed heroin at least once a week was untrue:
- [111]
[111] Given Hanafi’s evolving position and his unequivocal admission that he had lied about consuming heroin once a week, I find that Hanafi has failed to provide credible evidence on his daily rate of consumption.
- [113]
[113] As such, Hanafi has failed to provide credible evidence on his daily rate of consumption, and the number of days his supply could last for. This is a serious shortfall in his case, given that he claims that the heroin, which weighed 2307.5g in its unprocessed form, which is approximately five pounds, was for his personal consumption.
- [114]
[114] On the contrary, based on the objective evidence, I accept the Prosecution’s argument that Hanafi was not a heavy abuser of heroin. In particular, Hanafi was able to carefully apportion and restrain his intake depending on his financial circumstances:
- [115]
[115] Before leaving this point, I address Hanafi’s claim that he has been consistent from the start of investigations in claiming that the drugs were for his personal consumption. However, as can be seen from the analysis above, Hanafi’s claim that the drugs were for his personal consumption is internally inconsistent with his own evidence on his rate of heroin consumption. Moreover, while an accused person’s internally consistent account would lend credibility to his case, there is a further inquiry of whether his account coheres with the other aspects of his evidence, as well as the external objective evidence. As I have explained above, there are further reasons pointing to the lack of veracity of his evidence, as well as the inconsistency of his account with the external objective evidence.
Conclusion
- [116]
[116] Given all of the above, I reject Hanafi’s defence, and I find that Hanafi has not rebutted the presumption of trafficking under s 17(c) of the MDA. I therefore convict him of the first charge.
Blocks of cannabis
Possession
- [117]
[117] Turning next to the Blocks, following Adili Chibuike Ejike v Public Prosecutor [2019] 2 SLR 254 (at [31] and [35]), to prove possession, the Prosecution need only prove that the accused person knew of “the existence, within his possession, control or custody, of the thing which is later found to be a controlled drug”. The accused need not know that “the thing was in fact a controlled drug” [emphasis in original].
- [118]
[118] In this case, Hanafi claimed in his cross-examination that while he had noticed the presence of the Bundles, he did not notice the Blocks, or what they contained (see [40] above). This suggests that he had no knowledge of the presence of the Blocks. This is unconvincing. In the statement recorded on 8 May 2021 at 1.30pm, Hanafi had unequivocally claimed ownership over the Blocks and claimed that they were for his consumption. He also asserted that the drugs looked like “Mushroom or Cannabis”. Even in cross-examination, he did not dispute that he should have touched the Blocks, as he needed to put everything, including the Blocks, into the Superdry Bag. This first element is only concerned with knowledge of a thing that turns out to be drugs, and not knowledge of the specific nature of the drug. By his own position at the trial, possession is thus established.
- [119]
[119] More importantly, when the Prosecution put this element of the charge to him, Hanafi admitted to possession of the Blocks:
- [120]
[120] Further, in his written and reply submissions, Hanafi dealt with the Blocks and Bundles in the round, and made no submission disputing that the Blocks were in his possession. I therefore find that Hanafi had possession of the Blocks.
Knowledge
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.