Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 6 Feb 2024
Contents

General Division of the High Court

Lim Jen Lin v Energy Market Company Pte Ltd and others

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHC 35Case no. Registrar’s Appeal from the State Courts No 11 of 20235 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [2] Ms Lim had resisted SUM 221 on the ground that her Offer to Settle had lapsed or withdrawn, but I found that the offer had been accepted and gave judgment on the terms of her offer to settle. Ms Lim appealed against my decision to the Court of Appeal in CA/CA 104 of 2015, but having failed on numerous occasions to meet the deadlines given to her to file the papers for the appeal, the Court of Appeal declared that her appeal was deemed withdrawn. Ms Lim made further attempts to reinstate her appeal but without success.

  2. [5] At the hearing on 2 February, Mr Ong made an application that I should recuse myself from hearing this appeal because there are reasonable grounds to believe that there may be an appearance of bias by reason of the fact that I had ruled against Ms Lim in the 2011 action. Mr Ong submitted that DR Kaur and PDJ Toh both held that the action in DC/DC 459 of 2022 was an abuse of the process of court, and thus I would reasonably be thought to be biased were I to hear this appeal against their decisions.

  3. [6] Listening to counsel, it became immediately apparent to me what the problem was, and what the solution ought to be — and that does not include filing this new action.

  4. [8] Ms Chiang said that neither Energy nor Rodyk & Davidson LLP knew that Ang & Partners had not given the $200,000 cheque to Ms Lim. She said that they only found out about this recently, after the action commenced.

  5. [10] I now return the matter of my recusal. Having heard the submissions of counsel, suit DC/DC 459 of 2022 is virtually akin to asking the court for further directions regarding orders that were unfulfilled. In my view, not only would that not justify my recusal, but I would, in fact, be the most appropriate judge to hear appeals arising from it. However, having now identified the problem and pronounced on what the solution is, I should not hear the appeal on its merits. If the parties are not amenable to the solution as I suggested, then another judge has to hear the appeal. It is for this reason alone, and not that suggested by Mr Ong, that I recuse myself.