General Division of the High Court · Decided 6 June 2025
Without good faith, defendants could not rely on a change of position defence
Petrotech Marine Services Sdn Bhd v Wong Wai Leng (trading as Win Services & Agency) and another and another matter
Feedback & support[2025] SGHC 105 · Case no. Originating Claim No 485 of 2022
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
Without good faith, defendants could not rely on a change of position defence
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraph [303]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] In HC/OC 485/2022 (“OC 485”) and HC/OC 486/2022 (“OC 486”), Petrotech Marine Services Sdn Bhd (“Petrotech”) brought claims alleging that it had been defrauded or misled into paying various invoices, and that those payments were caused or enabled by one of its directors acting in breach of his fiduciary duties and in conspiracy with the other defendants.
Parties
- [2]
[2] Petrotech was incorporated in Malaysia in 2013. It was involved in the business of providing ship-to-ship (“STS”) transfer services – providing equipment for, and facilitating, the transfer of cargo between vessels. It conducted operations at the Malaysian port at Batu Pahat until early 2019, when it moved to the Malaysian ports at Port Dickson and Linggi (in Malacca).
- [3]
[3] The defendants in OC 485 and OC 486 were:
(a) Mr Low Chong Peng (“Mr Low”), a director of Petrotech from its incorporation until he was removed on 10 August 2023.
(b) Ms Wong Wai Leng (“Ms Wong”), sued in her capacity as the sole proprietor of two businesses in Singapore, Win Services & Agency (“Win”) and Winx Linen Enterprises (“Winx”);
(c) Mr Wong Yau Kan (“Mr Wong”), the nephew of Ms Wong, and sued in his capacity as the sole proprietor of Mozer’s Enterprises (“Mozer’s”); and
(d) “Zhu Pang”, who was not served and did not participate in the proceedings.
Background
- [4]
[4] Petrotech’s first shareholders and directors were Captain Mustafa Bin Saibon (“Capt Mustafa”), Captain Mohd Hariff Bin Abdul Hamid (“Capt Hariff”) (both Malaysians), Mr Yeo Peng Hay (“Mr Yeo”) and Mr Low (both Singaporeans).
- [5]
[5] Capt Mustafa was the chairman of Petrotech but did not play an active role in its day-to-day business. He passed away in December 2019. Thereafter, Capt Hariff – who oversaw Petrotech’s operations and who gave evidence – took over as chairman.
- [6]
[6] Mr Yeo, who did not give evidence, lived in Singapore and largely played a business development role.
- [7]
[7] Mr Low was made the director in charge of Petrotech’s finance and administration department. He worked with one Mr Soo Kay Lee (“Mr Soo”), the finance and accounts manager of Petrotech. In November 2018, Petrotech employed Ms Gui Kuy Jin (“Ms Jin”) and Mr Ong Liu Kian (“Mr Ong”) to replace Mr Soo, who was in poor health and eventually retired in December 2018. Ms Jin and Mr Ong played critical roles in this dispute, and gave evidence. Mr Soo did not give evidence.
- [8]
[8] For a brief period from 2 May 2017 to 27 November 2017, one Captain Mohamed Kamal Bin Ismail (“Capt Kamal”) also served as a director of Petrotech. He did not give evidence.
Kunlun
- [9]
[9] From the time of its incorporation in 2013 to 2016, Petrotech did not have significant business. Its fortunes changed when it was introduced to Kunlun Trading Co. Limited (“Kunlun”), a shipping company incorporated in the People’s Republic of China. This introduction was made by one Mr Simon s/o Chandrahason (“Mr Simon”) of SC Marine Consultancy & Services (“SC Marine”).
- [10]
[10] In or around late 2016 or early 2017, there were meetings between Captain Li Ming (“Capt Li”) of COSCO Shipping Tanker (Dalian) Seaman & Ship Management Co. Ltd., Captain Xu Rongbao (“Capt Xu”) and Captain Han Jiude (“Capt Han”) (representatives of Kunlun), Mr Simon, Capt Kamal and all the directors of Petrotech.
- [11]
[11] These meetings culminated in Petrotech and Kunlun entering an agreement dated 7 March 2017 for Petrotech to provide Kunlun STS services at Batu Pahat (“1st STS Agreement”). In essence, Kunlun would deploy a “mother vessel” – a vessel anchored at the port and used for the temporary storage of cargo – and Petrotech would provide equipment and other services to facilitate the transfer of the cargo between the mother vessel and other ships (collectively “Kunlun ships”).
- [12]
[12] On 15 November 2018, the parties entered a new agreement (“2nd STS Agreement”) on essentially the same terms as the 1st STS Agreement, save that the services would be performed at three different ports in Malaysia (Batu Pahat, Linggi and Port Dickson) and with changes to the fees chargeable by Petrotech.
- [13]
[13] Under Clause 7 of the 1st STS Agreement, Kunlun and Petrotech were each to appoint authorised representatives. Capt Hariff testified that he was Petrotech’s representative, while Kunlun’s representatives were Capt Han and Capt Xu (who were stationed in Malaysia) and one Ms Yolande (who was based in China).
- [14]
[14] Ms Yolande would instruct Petrotech on the entity to be invoiced for each operation. These entities were Kunlun and six other companies: CCCC International Shipping Corporation, Fair General Trading Co Ltd, P&G Consulting Pte Ltd, China Concord Petroleum Co Limited, Summit Resources Limited and Swiss Oil Trading SA. The references below to “Kunlun” include, where appropriate, all these companies.
- [15]
[15] Petrotech’s business model enabled it to obtain revenues in two ways:
(a) Petrotech would provide services to Kunlun as described under the 1st STS Agreement and 2nd STS Agreement (collectively, “STS Agreements”), or specifically agreed with Kunlun, and charge Kunlun for the same; and
(b) Petrotech would engage third parties to provide services related to the STS operations for Kunlun, which it would pay for and on-charge to Kunlun with a mark-up or fee.
- [16]
[16] Capt Hariff’s evidence was that all third-party service providers were engaged by, and worked directly with, Petrotech. Mr Low’s evidence was that there were several service providers which Kunlun instructed directly, but whose invoices were sent to Petrotech for payment, which Petrotech would pay and then charge to Kunlun. Win and Mozer’s were two such service providers.
Zhu Pang and the Win Agreement
- [17]
[17] According to Mr Low, sometime in May 2017, he was contacted by, and met with, one Zhu Pang (“Zhu Pang”) who claimed to be “responsible for managing Kunlun ships operating in both open seas and Malaysian territorial waters” and that his duties “included sourcing spare parts, machinery, and maintaining the Kunlun ships”. Zhu Pang asked Mr Low to introduce him to “someone with good connections in Malaysia, as Kunlun was planning to increase its business by introducing more service providers to the ongoing venture” of Petrotech and Kunlun. Mr Low introduced Zhu Pang to Ms Wong that same day but claimed he left the meeting immediately afterwards.
- [18]
[18] Ms Wong was at the time in the business of selling linen goods and other related household products through Winx, a business she had established in 2008. She testified that she received a call from Mr Low who informed her that there was a business opportunity “for [them] to work together”. Zhu Pang was introduced to her as an “authorised representative of Kunlun”.
- [20]
[20] Ms Wong established Win to carry out this business.
- [21]
[21] By a written agreement dated 15 May 2017, Petrotech entered an Exclusive Agency Agreement with Win (“Win Agreement”). The Win Agreement was drafted by Mr Low and signed by Capt Kamal (on behalf of Petrotech) and Ms Wong. Its terms are discussed below (at [96]–[113]).
- [22]
[22] Ms Wong claimed that she started performing services for Kunlun from August 2017. In addition to supplying Groceries, on Zhu Pang’s instructions, Win paid SC Marine for oil survey services it (allegedly) provided to Kunlun from the payments Win received from Petrotech.
- [23]
[23] From August 2017 to December 2021, Win issued 111 invoices to Petrotech for a total sum of US$2,853,250 (“Win Invoices”) and received payment in full. From the amount received, Ms Wong claimed that she:
(a) deducted the costs of the Groceries – she was, however, unable to say how much these were;
(b) paid SC Marine a total sum of S$459,800;
(c) made cash payments to Zhu Pang – she was also unable to say how much there amounted to; and
(d) kept the balance which, again, she was unable to quantify, save that this included her fees totalling US$570,650 (based on 20% of the sums invoiced to Petrotech).
- [24]
[24] In short, other than the sums paid to SC Marine, Ms Wong was not able to produce any documentary or other evidence to show or account for what she did with the sum of US$2,853,250 she received from Petrotech.
The Mozer’s Agreement
- [25]
[25] According to Ms Wong, sometime in November 2017, Zhu Pang asked if she knew of any service providers willing to provide “similar agency services as that which Win had been providing to Kunlun and the Kunlun Ships”. She introduced him to Mr Wong.
- [26]
[26] Mr Wong claimed Ms Wong asked if he was interested in a business opportunity, where “the work would involve helping to coordinate with suppliers and vendors in Malaysia for some representatives from a Chinese company. [He] would need to drive them around Malaysia and help to liaise and translate with locals there”. Mr Wong said he met with Zhu Pang, who informed him that Petrotech would pay him on Kunlun’s behalf. Zhu Pang also informed him that he would have to sign an agreement with Petrotech and one of Petrotech’s directors would call him to arrange the signing. That director was Mr Low.
- [27]
[27] According to Mr Low, sometime in December 2017, Capt Mustafa informed him that Zhu Pang had requested Mozer’s to be a service provider for Kunlun, and that Mr Low was to prepare an agreement like the Win Agreement to be entered by Petrotech and Mozer’s (“Mozer’s Agreement”).
- [28]
[28] The Mozer’s Agreement was dated 20 December 2017 and signed by Capt Hariff on behalf of Petrotech. There is a dispute over when it was actually signed, which is dealt with below (at [237]–[252]).
- [29]
[29] Mr Wong claimed that he began providing services to Kunlun in September 2018. This involved driving a Kunlun representative, one “Mr Chow” around in Malaysia to attend meetings with Kunlun’s suppliers and providing interpretation at these meetings. When he could not travel to Malaysia (including during the COVID-19 lock-down), he would interpret over the phone.
- [30]
[30] According to Ms Wong, sometime in July 2019, Zhu Pang approached her to discuss a different business opportunity – for Winx to supply Kunlun ships with linen goods such as bedsheets, pillowcases, towels and blankets (“Linen Goods”). Zhu Pang said that he would arrange for Mozer’s to pay Winx for the Linen Goods. Winx began supplying the Linen Goods in September 2019. In the period September 2019 to September 2021, Winx issued 41 invoices (“Winx Invoices”) and received payment in full from Mozer’s.
- [31]
[31] In turn, Mozer’s invoiced Petrotech. In the period September 2018 and July 2021, Mozer’s issued 223 invoices for a total sum of S$4,695,201 (“Mozer’s Invoices”), which were paid in full. Of that amount, Mr Wong:
(a) paid Winx S$1,671,980 for the Linen Goods;
(b) paid cash totalling S$2,404,540 to Zhu Pang;
(c) retained a sum of $276,000 which he claimed to be Mozer’s fees based on 6% of the sums invoiced to Petrotech (although 6% of the sums invoiced would in fact be S$281,712); and
(d) kept the balance which comprised a monthly allowance which he claimed to be around S$4,000 to S$6,000 – this would amount to about S$270,000 (taking the upper limit of S$6,000 per month for 45 months).
However, this left at least S$72,000 unaccounted for.
- [32]
[32] Kunlun terminated the STS Agreements in early 2022. However, Petrotech continued to make payments on some Win and Mozer’s Invoices. This led Capt Hariff and Mr Yeo to launch an internal investigation in the middle of 2022 (“Internal Audit”), which resulted in these proceedings.
The claims
- [33]
[33] Petrotech commenced: (a) OC 485 against Mr Low and Ms Wong (trading as Win); and (b) OC 486 against Mr Low, Mr Wong (trading as Mozer’s) and Ms Wong (trading as Winx). Petrotech named Zhu Pang as a defendant in OC 486, but he was not served as Petrotech did not know his whereabouts.
- [34]
[34] It was Petrotech’s case that the Win Agreement and the Mozer’s Agreement (collectively, “Win and Mozer’s Agreements”) were procured by Mr Low to defraud or mislead Petrotech into making payments to Win and Mozer’s. The causes of action in both proceedings were similar. In essence, Petrotech’s claims were:
(a) as against Mr Low, for breach of fiduciary duties for causing Petrotech to make payments which were not in its best interests nor for its benefit;
(b) as against Mr Low, for deceit or negligent misrepresentation, inter alia, for causing Capt Hariff to sign the Mozer’s Agreement and approve the payments to Win and Mozer’s and failing to inform Petrotech that it would not be receiving any services under the Win and Mozer’s Agreements;
(c) as against Ms Wong and Mr Wong, for deceit, negligent or innocent misrepresentation in that, inter alia, Win and Mozer’s did not inform Petrotech that it would not be providing Petrotech services and/or the contents of the Win Invoices and Mozer’s Invoices were false or incorrect;
(d) as against Ms Wong and Mr Wong, for dishonest assistance in Mr Low’s breach of his fiduciary duties;
(e) as against Ms Wong and Mr Wong, for knowing receipt of the payments received by them on account of the Win Invoices and Winx Invoices and Mozer’s Invoices respectively;
(f) as against Ms Wong and Mr Wong, in respect of the payments received by them, for unjust enrichment, as constructive trustees or for payments made under a mistake; and
(g) as against Mr Low, Ms Wong and Mr Wong, for conspiracy by unlawful or lawful means.
- [35]
[35] The defendants denied all the claims.
- [36]
[36] Mr Low pleaded that:
(a) Zhu Pang informed Capt Mustafa and him that Kunlun wanted to have Petrotech contract with Kunlun’s various service providers (such as Win and Mozer’s) when in fact the services would be provided directly to Kunlun – Petrotech would act as an intermediary and pay these service providers and Kunlun would in turn pay Petrotech (what was then) an unfixed commission (“Payment Arrangement”);
(b) the commission was only fixed in September 2018 at a meeting between Kunlun and Petrotech, at which Capt Mustafa held a discussion with Kunlun’s “big boss” and secured a fixed commission fee of 15%;
(c) when the Win Invoices and Mozer’s Invoices were received by Petrotech, the amounts invoiced by Petrotech to Kunlun“[would] include costs to be incurred by [Petrotech] and an additional commission fee of 15%”;
(d) Petrotech did not suffer any loss but made profits from the Payment Arrangement; and
(e) Capt Hariff made independent decisions to pay the Win and Mozer’s Invoices without checking with Mr Low.
- [37]
[37] In their pleadings, Ms Wong and Mr Wong adopted the Payment Arrangement, also claiming that Petrotech did not suffer any loss as the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were charged to Kunlun.
- [38]
[38] In addition, Ms Wong and Mr Wong also pleaded defences of laches, acquiescence, ministerial receipt, change of position and estoppel.
- [40]
[40] On 4 October 2024, the parties jointly appointed KPMG Advisory Services (“KPMG”) as their joint expert. KPMG issued its report on 10 March 2025 (“KPMG Report”), which was admitted into evidence. For the reasons explained below, KPMG’s findings were ultimately of little value. KPMG did not take the stand as parties confirmed that they had no questions on the KPMG Report.
My findings
Zhu Pang
- [41]
[41] Before dealing with the principal issues, I first deal with Zhu Pang. On the defendants’ case, he played a central role in the dispute and even received a substantial portion of the monies paid by Petrotech to Win and Mozer’s.
- [42]
[42] It was Petrotech’s pleaded position that Zhu Pang was not an authorised representative of Kunlun. It joined Zhu Pang as a defendant to OC 486 but did not serve proceedings on him as they did not know who he was or where he could be found. The Kunlun employees they asked did not know him. In their evidence, Petrotech’s witnesses stated that they had never met Zhu Pang or even heard of him prior to these proceedings and expressed doubts that he even existed.
- [43]
[43] I find that the defendants have failed to prove that there was an authorised representative of Kunlun named Zhu Pang. The evidence strongly suggested that Zhu Pang did not exist.
- [44]
[44] First, despite claiming to have known and worked with Zhu Pang from 2017 to 2022, none of Mr Low, Ms Wong or Mr Wong could offer his contact details, messages exchanged with him or even a photograph of him. They all claimed that they communicated with Zhu Pang via WeChat, but:
(a) Mr Low claimed that, sometime in June 2022, he discovered that he was “unable to locate Zhu Pang’s WeChat contact on [his] handphone”;
(b) Ms Wong claimed that she “no longer [had] Zhu Pang’s number and Zhu Pang [had] deleted [their] WeChat chat history”, and
(c) Mr Wong claimed that he lost his phone sometime in or around October 2022 and, along with it, his WeChat call logs, chat histories and contacts.
As will be seen, the defendants also failed to produce other material documents, claiming that they were lost, deleted or destroyed.
- [45]
[45] Second, it is incredible that Mr Low simply accepted Zhu Pang’s claim of his (alleged) role within Kunlun. On his own evidence, he took no steps to verify Zhu Pang’s identity or even ask for his name card or his contact details within Kunlun. He did not even mention Zhu Pang to the Kunlun representatives stationed in Malaysia. He claimed that he was satisfied that Zhu Pang was employed by Kunlun because Zhu Pang was aware of information which only someone in Kunlun would know, namely that Kunlun had a joint venture with a company known as “CCCC” and would be setting up a company in Singapore. But Mr Low did not explain why only someone in Kunlun would know this, or how this was sufficient to confirm Zhu Pang’s position or authority.
- [46]
[46] Third, Mr Low did not introduce Zhu Pang to Captain Hariff, Mr Mohamad Azmi bin Selamat (“Mr Azmi”) (who was involved in Petrotech’s operations at the Malaysian ports) or Capt Kamal, who Mr Low described as being “responsible for coordinating between Kunlun and [Petrotech]”. This is especially curious given that (a) Kunlun was Petrotech’s only customer and “most of [Petrotech’s] income from 2017 to 2022 originated from the business that [Petrotech] did with Kunlun”; and (b) Zhu Pang was, according to Mr Low, “responsible for managing Kunlun ships in both open seas and Malaysian territorial waters” and therefore played an important role for Kunlun in Malaysia.
- [47]
[47] In fact, the first time Zhu Pang’s name appeared in any document was in the Defences. Prior to this, Mr Low did not inform Capt Hariff of Zhu Pang’s involvement, despite having ample opportunities to do so:
(a) Capt Hariff testified that in July 2022, he and Mr Yeo confronted Mr Low about the Mozer’s Invoices, and Mr Low was unable to give any satisfactory explanation. This evidence was not challenged by Mr Low.
(b) On 12 December 2022, Capt Hariff, Mr Yeo and Mr Low convened a board of directors meeting to discuss commencing legal proceedings against four companies, including Win and Mozer’s. At the meeting, Mr Low was asked why these companies had been paid by Petrotech. Mr Low did not mention Zhu Pang and insisted on speaking to the lawyers engaged by Petrotech, BR Law Corporation (“BR Law”).
(c) BR Law wrote to Mr Low on 19 December 2022, informing him of his fiduciary duty to assist Petrotech in pursuing its claims against Win and Mozer’s by providing information regarding the payments to them. Mr Low’s lawyers responded on 6 January 2023 to complain that BR Law’s appointment was without Mr Low’s consent, without responding to BR Law’s queries or mentioning Zhu Pang.
If Zhu Pang existed, was an authorised representative of Kunlun and the Win and Mozer’s Agreements were legitimate, there would have been no reason for Mr Low to keep silent. To the contrary, it would have been to his benefit (and consistent with his fiduciary duties to Petrotech) to explain what he knew about the payments to Win and Mozer’s.
- [48]
[48] Significantly, although it was pleaded by Mr Low that Capt Hariff, being the chairman and the director in charge of Petrotech’s operations, would have known of Zhu Pang’s involvement in the business of Petrotech, this allegation was not put to Capt Hariff. Mr Low’s failure to do so was consistent with him knowing that Zhu Pang did not exist.
- [49]
[49] Mr Low claimed that he had introduced Zhu Pang to Capt Mustafa over the phone and Capt Mustafa thereafter instructed him to draft the Win Agreement. This could not be corroborated as Capt Mustafa had passed away in 2019. For reasons I elaborate on below, I reject this evidence. It would be a constant theme of Mr Low’s evidence to allege Capt Mustafa’s knowledge or involvement to explain his own conduct and downplay his culpability.
- [50]
[50] Fourth, despite Zhu Pang’s (alleged) important role for Kunlun in Malaysia, it was not Mr Low’s evidence that he ever visited Petrotech’s offices in Johor Jaya, or their operations at Batu Pahat, Port Dickson or Linggi. In this regard, Ms Wong also claimed that Zhu Pang was involved in arranging the delivery of Groceries to the Kunlun ships, but Mr Azmi, who oversaw the delivery of material and personnel from the jetties to the Kunlun ships, never encountered him. Ms Wong’s response was that Zhu Pang had made his own arrangements to deliver the Groceries, without explaining how she knew this or what those arrangements were.
- [51]
[51] Fifth, Petrotech’s directors met with Kunlun’s senior management and officers at least twice in March 2017 and September 2018 to negotiate and ultimately execute the STS Agreements. Despite the importance of the STS Agreements, and Zhu Pang’s allege role and responsibilities in Malaysia, he was not present at any of these meetings – there was no evidence that his name was even mentioned. Mr Low’s explanation was that Zhu Pang was involved in ship management and not STS operations. This did not make sense and was contradicted by his own evidence in respect of the invoices issued by Petrotech to Kunlun (see [84] below).
- [52]
[52] Sixth, other than the defendants, no one else met or dealt with Zhu Pang. Significantly, despite Ms Wong claiming that Zhu Pang dealt with Mr Simon of SC Marine, none of the defendants called him to give evidence. Likewise, Ms Wong claimed to have introduced Zhu Pang to her friends Mr Henry Tan (“Mr Tan”) and Ms Carol Yap (“Ms Yap”) in connection with the delivery of Groceries but did not call either to give evidence as well. Ms Wong’s failure to do so is dealt with in detail below (at [206]).
- [53]
[53] Seventh, the defendants did not produce any document which mentioned Zhu Pang’s name or even hinted at his existence. This included all the emails produced between the parties and Kunlun personnel.
- [54]
[54] Eighth, none of the defendants took any meaningful steps to contact Kunlun to confirm the existence of Zhu Pang or the Payment Arrangement. Mr Low and Mr Wong did not even attempt to do so. Ms Wong’s efforts were perfunctory. She wrote to Kunlun’s Hong Kong office although there was no evidence that Zhu Pang ever worked there. Further, her letter was addressed to Zhu Pang – the very person whose authority was in question. Tellingly, when she failed to receive a response, she did not follow up by writing to anyone else at Kunlun’s Hong Kong or other offices. This half-hearted attempt suggested that she knew that Zhu Pang either did not exist or was not an authorised representative of Kunlun. Petrotech’s efforts were better – Capt Hariff instructed Ms Syahidah Binti Ahmad (“Ms Syahidah”), Petrotech’s employee, to send text messages to Kunlun representatives familiar with the Malaysian operations such as Capt Xu, Capt Han and Capt Mai, who responded to say that they had checked with Kunlun’s offices and no one knew of Zhu Pang. The defendant’s criticisms that Petrotech’s efforts were not thorough were misplaced as it was the defendants’ burden to prove Zhu Pang’s existence and authority.
- [55]
[55] The evidence that Zhu Pang existed was therefore entirely the say so of the defendants and nothing else. All the objective evidence pointed to him not existing. In addition, I find the defendants, particularly Mr Low, dishonest in several material aspects of their evidence, which I elaborate on. I therefore reject the defendants’ evidence that they had reached an agreement or understanding with an authorised representative of Kunlun with respect to Win and Mozer’s Agreements or the Payment Arrangement. The Payment Arrangement was exposed as a lie when Mr Low was cross-examined on the invoicing arrangements between Petrotech and Kunlun (see [75]–[87] below).
Whether Petrotech on-charged the Win and Mozer’s Invoices to Kunlun
- [56]
[56] Under the Payment Arrangement, Kunlun would ultimately bear the amounts charged by Win and Mozer’s to Petrotech (see [34] above). There was no dispute that Kunlun paid in full all the invoices issued by Petrotech (“Petrotech Invoices”). In the circumstances, the central issue is whether the amounts in the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were included in the Petrotech Invoices or otherwise charged to, and paid by, Kunlun.
- [57]
[57] In this regard, Mr Low’s pleaded that:
(a) The Win and Mozer’s Invoices were handed to Ms Jin for her to process and generate the Petrotech Invoices, which would include the amounts charged in the Win and Mozer’s Invoices and the additional commission fee.
(b) Kunlun would sometimes transfer sums of money even prior to receiving Petrotech Invoices or delay payment on the Petrotech Invoices. Win or Mozer’s would also delay sending invoices even after the work for Kunlun had been completed. But it was not his case that such delays affected the process of on-charging the Win and Mozer’s Invoices to Kunlun.
- [58]
[58] In the same vein, Ms Wong and Mr Wong pleaded that (a) Zhu Pang informed them of the Payment Arrangement; and (b) it was on this basis that they entered the Win and Mozer’s Agreements.
- [59]
[59] I find that the defendants have failed to prove that the amounts charged in the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were included in the Petrotech Invoices, or otherwise charged to Petrotech, and that Kunlun paid or reimbursed Petrotech for the same. In fact, the evidence was overwhelming that Mr Low deliberately caused the amounts invoiced by Win and Mozer’s not to be charged to Kunlun and that the Payment Arrangement was entirely contrived.
Petrotech’s procedure for dealing with invoices
- [60]
[60] I first describe how Petrotech dealt with invoices it received from third parties and its invoicing of Kunlun.
- [61]
[61] Ms Jin and Mr Ong joined Petrotech in November 2018. Prior to their joining, their roles were performed by Mr Soo. Mr Soo resided in Malaysia. While Mr Low had applied for him to give evidence via video conference, his solicitors wrote to the court on 14 October 2024 to say that they were no longer calling Mr Soo as he was not well. No medical report was produced to support this claim. In any event, his absence was immaterial as it was not suggested that matters relating to invoicing and payments were dealt with differently during Mr Soo’s tenure.
- [62]
[62] Ms Jin and Mr Ong explained as follows:
(a) Invoices issued by service providers and suppliers to Petrotech (“Third Party Invoices”) were processed by Mr Ong. It was part of his duties to request for supporting documents for the Third Party Invoices, and he would inform Mr Low if there were none. He then handed over copies of the Third Party Invoices, with supporting documents, to Ms Jin.
(b) Ms Jin would consult the operations team, including Ms Syahidah (the designated human resources manager, but also an administrative assistant) or Mr Azmi to confirm that the goods or services reflected in the Third Party Invoices had been provided.
(c) After Ms Jin received confirmation, she would return the Third Party Invoices to Mr Ong. He would record them in a spreadsheet he called a “payment chart”, which he submitted to Mr Low for instructions on which to pay.
(d) For those which Mr Low instructed to pay, either Mr Low or Mr Ong would prepare a payment request using their respective internet banking tokens linked to Petrotech’s OCBC (Malaysia) Berhad (“OCBC”) account. This was managed through OCBC’s Velocity application, an online banking platform. Mr Ong only prepared payment requests from November 2019 when he was granted access to the account.
(e) Either Mr Low or Mr Ong would call Capt Hariff (who was usually out of the office dealing with Petrotech’s operations) to authorise the payment request through his mobile banking application. Payments could only be made if Capt Hariff authorised them. Capt Hariff would not have sight of the Third Party Invoices but would see some details in the payment request, including the name of the supplier and the amount.
(f) Mr Ong would then record the Third Party Invoices in Petrotech’s accounting ledger (“Ledger”).
(g) Concurrently, Ms Jin would prepare the Petrotech Invoices. In that regard, the amounts charged to Kunlun could be classified into two broad categories: (i) fees for goods and/or services provided to Kunlun by Petrotech as prescribed in the STS Agreements, which provided fixed rates (including monthly fees) for different services; and (ii) the amounts charged in the Third Party Invoices as well as an agency fee for processing and making payments on the Third Party Invoices. Ms Jin would attach to the Petrotech Invoices brief descriptions of the services provided (“Summaries”).
(h) Ms Jin would receive instructions from Ms Yolande on which Kunlun entity to bill and Mr Low would approve the Petrotech Invoice before Ms Jin signed and issued them.
- [63]
[63] With respect to step (g) above, Ms Jin testified that when she first joined, Mr Low would instruct her on what items to include in the Petrotech Invoices. Once she became more familiar with Petrotech’s operations, she would prepare the Petrotech Invoices by referencing the fees prescribed in the 2nd STS Agreement or any separate fee agreement with Kunlun. Where items did not fall within either of these categories, Mr Low would instruct her on what to bill. This was borne out by several WhatsApp messages between them.
- [64]
[64] Mr Low did not challenge the process detailed above but asserted that he would first consult Capt Mustafa and Capt Hariff before giving instructions on which Third Party Invoices to pay. But this assertion was not put to Capt Hariff.
Treatment of Win and Mozer’s Invoices
- [65]
[65] The Win and Mozer’s Invoices would, by definition, be Third Party Invoices. However, according to Ms Jin and Mr Ong, they were dealt with differently.
- [66]
[66] According to Mr Ong, he first saw Win Invoices in or about end November 2018 when Mr Soo handed him some copies. These invoices, dated 2017, were already included in the payment chart. He therefore did not hand these to Ms Jin.
- [67]
[67] Subsequently, he recalled an instance where he received a Win Invoice and handed it to Ms Jin in accordance with the usual procedure. Ms Jin spoke with Mr Low about this Win Invoice, and Mr Low then instructed Mr Ong not to hand over any Win Invoices to Ms Jin. Ms Jin confirmed this incident and testified that Mr Low instructed her not to charge the Win Invoice to Kunlun.
- [68]
[68] Mr Ong also testified that the Win Invoices he received did not have any supporting documents.
- [69]
[69] The same happened with respect to the Mozer’s Invoices.
- [70]
[70] Mr Ong testified that sometime between 18 and 20 July 2019, Mr Low handed him a stack of Mozer’s Invoices which were dated September 2018 to December 2018 (“2018 Mozer’s Invoices”) and instructed him to record these in the Ledger. None of the 2018 Mozer’s Invoices had any supporting documentation. Mr Ong produced in evidence a payment chart for the period November 2018 to June 2019 he had earlier prepared which did not record any Mozer’s Invoices. This supported his evidence that no Mozer’s Invoices had been received by him prior to June 2019. As per Mr Low’s instructions, Mr Ong included Mozer’s as a creditor in the Ledger around 22 July 2019 and updated his payment chart accordingly.
- [71]
[71] Subsequently, all Mozer’s Invoices dated 2019 and after were sent to Mr Ong via e-mail from Mozer’s. He received the first e-mail from Mozer’s on 22 August 2019, which enclosed Mozer’s Invoices for January and February 2019. As per the usual procedure, Mr Ong handed these invoices to Ms Jin. However, shortly after, Mr Low instructed him not to submit any Mozer’s Invoices to Ms Jin. Mr Ong forgot those instructions and handed Ms Jin copies of Mozer’s Invoices for the months of March and April 2019 after receiving them, only to be reminded by Mr Low of his earlier instructions.
- [72]
[72] Ms Jin corroborated Mr Ong’s evidence. She confirmed that she never received any invoices from Mozer’s except on two occasions when Mr Ong handed her copies – but she could not remember when that happened. When she asked Mr Low, he instructed her not to include the Mozer’s Invoices in the Petrotech Invoices and took them away from her.
- [73]
[73] Mr Low denied giving such instructions and insisted that the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were handed to Ms Jin for processing and on-charging to Kunlun.
- [74]
[74] I accept Ms Jin and Mr Ong’s evidence. They gave clear and consistent testimonies, which were unshaken under cross-examination. Their evidence was also consistent with the documentary evidence, including the Petrotech Invoices and the Summaries, which contained no references to the Win and Mozer’s Invoices or the services allegedly provided by them.
- [75]
[75] In contrast, Mr Low’s evidence was vague, contradictory and dishonest. Importantly, given Mr Low’s pleaded case on the Payment Arrangement and his role as the director in charge of finance, it was for him to explain how the amounts charged by Win and Mozer’s were on-charged to Kunlun. He could not do so.
- [76]
[76] Mr Low pleaded that the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were handed to Ms Jin to process and generate the Petrotech Invoices and that the amounts invoiced to Kunlun by Petrotech would include the amounts charged in the Win and Mozer’s Invoices with a commission fee of 15%. But this was not supported by his own evidence, which changed constantly and to a point where it became incomprehensible.
- [77]
[77] The first version of Mr Low’s evidence was set out in his affidavit, where he testified that the amounts charged by Win and Mozer’s were not “explicitly” stated in the Petrotech Invoices. Mr Low cited the following example:
That evidence was plainly false.
- [78]
[78] First, although Mr Low claimed that all the Petrotech directors were aware of the Payment Arrangement, this allegation was not put to Capt Hariff.
- [79]
[79] Second, the 1st STS Agreement was signed in March 2017. Zhu Pang allegedly only surfaced in May 2017 and the Win Agreement was signed on 15 May 2017. On Mr Low’s own evidence, he did not know what services Zhu Pang wanted Win to perform and certainly could not have known that in March 2017.
- [80]
[80] In that regard, the example cited by Mr Low in his affidavit exposed his lie. The first Petrotech Invoice of US$97,000 to Kunlun was specifically provided for in Clause 6.1.2 of the 1st STS Agreement:
- [81]
[81] In other words, Kunlun agreed in March 2017 to pay Petrotech a fixed monthly fee of US$97,000 for services to Kunlun’s “mother vessel”. Importantly, Mr Low accepted that the breakdown of services for that fee was set out in Schedule 4 of the 1st STS Agreement. Those services did not include anything Win allegedly did or agreed to do for Kunlun. The amount payable to Win therefore could not have been “pre-determined” before, or included in, the 1st STS Agreement. Nor could the monthly fee of US$97,000 have included the amount claimed in the first Win Invoice, which was only issued in August 2017.
- [82]
[82] When confronted with this, Mr Low disavowed the plain text of his affidavit and claimed that what he meant was that the Win Invoice of US$38,250 was paid out of the US$97,000 received from Kunlun. That “clarification” was plainly contrived in the context of what he was trying to explain in his affidavit.
- [83]
[83] Mr Low accepted that the Petrotech Invoice for US$97,000 did not include the Win Invoice for US$38,250, and that applied to all Petrotech Invoices issued in respect of the fixed monthly fee of US$97,000. Mr Low had effectively abandoned the evidence in his affidavit.
- [84]
[84] Mr Low then changed his evidence, this time claiming that when the fees in Schedule 4 of the 1st STS Agreement was negotiated and agreed, Kunlun had already incorporated what it anticipated it would have to pay service providers such as Win. He claimed to have been informed of this by Capt Mustafa, who reached such an understanding with Kunlun. Over and above contradicting his earlier evidence, this version was also incredible:
(a) Although Mr Low claimed that all the Petrotech directors was aware of this arrangement, this was again not put to Capt Hariff.
(b) There was no reason, and Mr Low did not offer any, as to why Petrotech and Kunlun would agree to the fees in Schedule 4 in this manner. In fact, there was no reason for Petrotech to agree to their fixed fees in Schedule 4 being significantly reduced to pay for future services Kunlun engaged from third parties.
(c) According to Mr Low (see [51] above), the STS services and ship management services were entirely different – and that explained Zhu Pang’s absence from Petrotech’s meetings with, and operations for, Kunlun. If so, he did not explain why Kunlun would be anticipating and incorporating fees for ship management services in the 1st STS Agreement.
(d) Mr Low could not explain how the fees in Schedule 4 were determined, simply asserting that Kunlun had its own way of doing things.
- [85]
[85] Mr Low then advanced a third version. He accepted that, on the face of the Petrotech Invoices, the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were not included in them. However, he claimed that Capt Mustafa and Kunlun had agreed that Petrotech would earn a profit margin of 15% in respect of services carried out by third party service providers, including Win and Mozer’s, and that margin would only be determined at the end of the year, taking into account all the charges incurred, and revenue earned, by Petrotech. Therefore, so long as Petrotech achieved a 15% profit margin, it would follow that all the Win and Mozer’s Invoices had been charged to and paid by Kunlun. Not only was this not pleaded or in Mr Low’s affidavit, it was not supported by the evidence:
(a) Mr Low again testified that all the other directors were aware of this arrangement, but that assertion was not put to Capt Hariff;
(b) Mr Low did not offer any evidence that Petrotech in fact achieved a profit margin of 15% for any year of its operations;
(c) Mr Low accepted that the profit margins for different third party suppliers varied from 5% to 50%. In the circumstances, unless the amounts charged by Win and Mozer’s were specified in the Petrotech Invoices, neither Petrotech nor Kunlun could know whether they were charging or paying a margin of 15%. Mr Low claimed that Kunlun would know how much Win or Mozer’s had charged or how Petrotech added the 15%, but when asked how Kunlun would know, he could not answer.
- [86]
[86] Mr Low was plainly making up his evidence as he went along. In fact, he continued to take different and contradictory positions during cross-examination, including that the Win Invoices were charged to Kunlun, but the Mozer’s Invoices were not as they were often received late. . He then walked back that evidence by claiming that the Mozer’s Invoices were subsequently charged to Kunlun, but he was unable to explain how.
- [87]
[87] In his closing submissions, Mr Low was left with asserting that (a) Petrotech’s invoicing and Kunlun’s payments were “messy” as the on-charging to Kunlun was not done on an invoice-to-invoice basis; and (b) the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were charged to Kunlun, but that he did not know how.
- [88]
[88] But Mr Low’s evidence failed to deal with a fundamental flaw in his case. While he insisted that all the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were handed to Ms Jin to be processed and charged to Kunlun, it was not put to Ms Jin how she went about doing so. Mr Low conceded that he did not give Ms Jin any instructions on how to incorporate the Win and Mozer’s Invoices. It was also not his case that Ms Jin included the charges on her own initiative. In other words, there was no explanation as to how the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were dealt with by Ms Jin. This completely undermined Mr Low’s case that the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were charged to Kunlun, never mind his pleaded case that Ms Jin included the amounts in the Petrotech Invoices and added a fee of 15%.
- [89]
[89] I therefore have no hesitation rejecting Mr Low’s evidence. He was reduced to giving contradictory and illogical evidence because he knew that the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were not given to Ms Jin to process and the amounts therein were not charged to Kunlun. His case on the Payment Arrangement was entirely fabricated and dishonest. I find that it was entirely concocted to explain why Petrotech paid the Win and Mozer’s Invoices.
- [90]
[90] That raised questions about the Win and Mozer’s Agreements. According to the defendants, the Win and Mozer’s Agreements were legitimate agreements entered into by Petrotech at the request of Kunlun (through Zhu Pang) and Ms Wong and Mr Wong testified that Kunlun received the services they provided. If so, there would be no reason for Petrotech not to on-charge the Win and Mozer’s Invoices to Kunlun. As I explain below, the Win and Mozer’s Agreements were plainly shams.
KPMG’s findings
- [91]
[91] For completeness, I deal with the KPMG Report. The parties engaged KPMG to review Petrotech’s accounts and documents to determine whether the Win and Mozer’s Invoices could be matched to the Petrotech Invoices.
- [92]
[92] KPMG carried out the exercise by analysing and matching the details in the Win and Mozer’s Invoices to that in the Petrotech Invoices such as the operation dates, operation location, vessel name, description and amount. This resulted in a list of preliminary matches, which it then narrowed by the process of elimination by applying other criteria such as the difference in vessel names and operation dates.
- [93]
[93] In the circumstances, just because some of the Win and Mozer’s Invoices may have met the criteria used by KPMG did not mean that they had been included in the Petrotech Invoices. Indeed, KPMG highlighted that “in light of the many uncertainties, assumptions, limitations and contradicting statements made by all parties”, it was unable to confirm the accuracy of its findings. More importantly, KPMG’s findings did not consider how the Petrotech Invoices were prepared and, of course, the evidence and my findings above. In fact, after hearing the evidence of the factual witnesses, all the parties agreed that it was not necessary to ask questions on the KPMG Report.
- [94]
[94] In the circumstances, I find that:
(a) there was no agreement between Petrotech and Kunlun that Petrotech would pay the Win and Mozer’s Invoices and charge them to Kunlun and the Payment Arrangement as pleaded by the defendants did not exist;
(b) the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were not charged to Kunlun on Mr Low’s instructions, and Kunlun did not reimburse Petrotech its payments to Win and Mozer’s;
(c) Petrotech processed and paid the Win and Mozer’s Invoices on Mr Low’s instructions; and
(d) Petrotech suffered losses by paying the Win and Mozer’s Invoices as Win and Mozer’s did not provide it with any services.
- [95]
[95] Before I turn to whether the defendants, or any of them, are liable for those losses, I first deal with the Win and Mozer’s Agreements and the circumstances leading to their executions. In this regard, I highlight that it is the respective pleaded positions of Ms Wong and Mr Wong that the Win and Mozer’s Agreements were executed to put in effect the Payment Arrangement, and the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were issued pursuant to them. I have found that the Payment Arrangement did not exist.
The Win Agreement
- [96]
[96] Mr Low claimed that he and Capt Kamal drafted the Win Agreement on Capt Mustafa’s instructions.
- [97]
[97] There were several features of the Win Agreement which are suspicious.
- [98]
[98] First, Recital (2) stated that:
This was not true. According to Ms Wong, she established Win in May 2017 to carry out the business of supplying Groceries to the Kunlun ships. Mr Low agreed that he knew Recital (2) was false, but claimed that he drafted it on Capt Mustafa’s instructions. I do not believe him – it was another instance of him conveniently pointing the finger at Capt Mustafa. It was Mr Low and not Capt Mustafa who knew Ms Wong and that Ms Wong was not, and had no experience, in the business of providing marine services. Likewise, Mr Low knew that Clause 7.1.2 of the Win Agreement, which provided that Win “has the qualification to perform the transaction contemplated hereunder and such transaction is covered under its scope of business” was false. Mr Low was content to have Petrotech sign an agreement which he knew contained false terms. If the Win Agreement was a legitimate agreement (as Mr Low claimed), there would be no reason for such subterfuge.
- [99]
[99] Second, Recital (3) of the Win Agreement provided that:
Clauses 1.1 and 1.2 explained:
According to Mr Low, “exclusive agent for all marine services” included the STS services Petrotech was providing Kunlun. It made no sense for Petrotech to appoint Win (a) to play such an important role in the service of its only customer when Win had no experience providing such services; and (b) as its exclusive agent when it was capable of engaging, and had in fact engaged, other service providers itself.
- [100]
[100] Third, if Kunlun genuinely required oil survey services, there was no reason for it to engage Win, which had no such expertise in such matters. In fact, SC Marine which provided such services was known to both Kunlun and Petrotech (see [9] above). Capt Hariff also testified that oil survey services required by Kunlun ships were directly arranged between the Kunlun ship captains and Mr Simon of SC Marine, and he produced an agreement between Kunlun and SC Marine dated 31 January 2019 for SC Marine to provide services to Kunlun ships. In other words, Kunlun had directly engaged SC Marine and there was no reason for it to go through Win.
- [101]
[101] Significantly, Ms Wong testified she did not even deal with SC Marine. According to her, Zhu Pang (allegedly) dealt with SC Marine and made all the arrangements, and she did not even know if such oil survey services were provided. All she had to do was to pay invoices (allegedly) issued by SC Marine which she received via e-mail.
- [102]
[102] Fourth, Clause 2.2 of the Win Agreement provided that if Win could not provide any service required, such service would be “conducted by an appropriate third party solely appointed by [Petrotech]”. This only raised the question of why either Kunlun or Petrotech needed to engage or deal with Win in the first place.
- [103]
[103] Fifth, Clause 4 of the Win Agreement stated that Win was entitled to charge a fee of US$2,000 per ship. But this was not what it charged. According to Ms Wong’s affidavit, in or around August 2017, Zhu Pang proposed, and she agreed, that the Win Agreement be amended to reflect an agency fee of 20% on each invoice that Win charged to Petrotech. This “amendment” was not evidenced in writing. I deal with this in detail later.
- [104]
[104] Sixth, and most importantly, Win did not provide any of the services listed in the Win Agreement. The supply of Groceries – which was the only substantive task Win was asked to perform – was not included in the Win Agreement. Counsel for Ms Wong referred to “replenish ships” in Recital (3) – but, when read in context, that clearly referred to the type of ships and not replenishing ships. Win was also supposed to liaise with oil surveyors, which, as discussed above, it did not do.
- [105]
[105] This in turn raised several questions which cast further doubt on the legitimacy of the Win Agreement:
(a) Why could Kunlun not have engaged Petrotech directly to arrange for Groceries? Over and above the STS services, Petrotech had provided other services related to the welfare of the Kunlun ships’ crews, such as arranging meals, transport and air flights.
(b) What was the commercial rationale for Kunlun wanting to appoint a middleman who had no experience at all in the marine industry and paying it substantial fees? When asked about this, all Mr Low could say was that this was what Kunlun wanted to do.
(c) Why did the Win Agreement not simply state what Win was tasked to do? In fact, the Win Agreement did not mention Kunlun at all, much less provide that Win would provide services to Kunlun but be paid by Petrotech. Instead, the Win Agreement was replete with falsehoods and inaccuracies. Mr Low could not explain this other than insisting that it was all done on Capt Mustafa’s instructions.
- [106]
[106] How the Win Agreement came to be drafted and executed is also suspicious. Mr Low claimed that after Zhu Pang accepted his recommendation to appoint Ms Wong, he discussed the arrangement with Capt Mustafa over the phone and handed his phone to Zhu Pang so that he could speak directly with Capt Mustafa. After Capt Mustafa agreed with Zhu Pang’s proposal, Mr Low claimed that (a) he and Capt Kamal drafted the Win Agreement based on a template Mr Low downloaded from the internet; and (b) Capt Kamal signed it on behalf of Petrotech at the direction of Mr Yeo. I disbelieve that evidence.
- [107]
[107] First, Capt Mustafa resided in Seremban and was not involved in Petrotech’s day-to-day operations. Capt Hariff explained that (a) Capt Mustafa was in poor health and hard of hearing; (b) he and Capt Mustafa were close and Capt Mustafa would speak to him if he wanted to find out about matters relating to Petrotech and would only discuss matters concerning Petrotech if he was with him; and (c) Capt Mustafa would have mentioned the Win Agreement to him but never did so. I accept this evidence. Mr Low agreed that Capt Mustafa and Capt Hariff were close and even testified that he did not inform Capt Hariff of the Mozer’s Agreement as he assumed Capt Mustafa would have done so. It was also put to Capt Hariff by Mr Low’s counsel that he and Capt Mustafa were close and would have discussed the Win Agreement.
- [108]
[108] In that regard, it did not make sense that Capt Mustafa would agree to appoint Win as Petrotech’s “exclusive agent” for all marine services and oil surveying services without at least discussing with Capt Hariff who was in charge of Petrotech’s operations and dealt with its service providers.
- [109]
[109] Further, despite claiming that Capt Kamal was in charge of coordinating matters between Kunlun and Petrotech, Mr Low did not inform Capt Kamal of Zhu Pang’s approach or ask him to attend any meeting with Zhu Pang despite (a) Zhu Pang’s (apparently) important role in Kunlun’s operations in Malaysia ; and (b) Mr Low’s admission that he was the least experienced of all the Petrotech directors in the marine services industry. Mr Low could not give a good reason for not involving Capt Kamal other than insisting that he was handling the matter.
- [110]
[110] It is unknown what Capt Kamal knew or understood of the Win Agreement or why he signed it. Neither Petrotech nor Mr Low called Capt Kamal to give evidence – both claimed to have lost touch with him and not to have his contact details. Importantly, Mr Low’s evidence on his and Capt Kamal’s involvement in the signing of the Win Agreement was inconsistent. In his affidavit, he claimed that he “drafted the Win Agreement together with [Capt] Kamal” and that he “was not physically present to witness the signing of the [Win Agreement] by [Capt] Kamal”. Yet, in the same affidavit, he claimed that “[Capt] Kamal was informed of the [Win Agreement] when he signed the [Win Agreement]”.
- [111]
[111] Second, Mr Low falsely tried to distance himself from the discussions between Zhu Pang and Ms Wong by claiming that he left the meeting immediately after making the introduction as he “did not want to be involved any further and wanted to focus [his] work with [Petrotech].” In the stand, he said he was concerned about “conflicts of interests” and that he did not want Petrotech to be prejudiced should Kunlun’s relationship with Win sour. I find his evidence contrived:
(a) Given Kunlun’s importance to Petrotech, Mr Low should have been even more concerned that the discussions between Kunlun and Ms Wong (who was his recommendation) should progress smoothly and that any issues be resolved. Further, the discussions involved Petrotech, as it was Petrotech which was to enter into an agreement with Win. It therefore did not make sense for Mr Low not to be present during the discussions.
(b) If Mr Low was genuinely concerned about conflicts of interests, he ought not to have recommended Ms Wong given his close relationship with her – which I will deal with later – or should have at least consulted his fellow directors before making that recommendation.
(c) I also note that:
(i) Mr Low’s evidence that he was not involved in the actual signing of the Win Agreement was contradicted by Ms Wong, who said that he was the one who handed it to her and was present when she signed.
(ii) Mr Low was copied on all of Win’s e-mails to Mr Ong attaching the Win Invoices and, prior to Mr Ong joining Petrotech, the Win Invoices were received by Mr Low; and
(iii) It was Mr Ong’s unchallenged evidence that he had asked Mr Low about the Win Invoices and was told that there were no supporting documents – Mr Low clearly knew more about the Win Agreement and the Win Invoices than he let on in his evidence.
- [112]
[112] Third, Mr Low was actively giving or maintaining the false impression that Win was providing marine services for Petrotech’s operations. When Mr Ong sent him a message on 20 August 2019 saying that Petrotech’s auditors had asked about the kind of services that Win provided to Petrotech, Mr Low instructed Mr Ong to inform the auditors that Win did the following: (a) coordinating with ship management on supply of ship crews; (b) liaising and coordinating of supplying ship stores and equipment; (c) coordinating repair work for CCPC Vanguard (a mother vessel); and (d) coordinating and supplying oil surveyors and bunkering for CCPC Vanguard. That was plainly false. Ms Wong confirmed in her evidence that she did not provide any of these services.
- [113]
[113] Fourth, Mr Low claimed that (a) he informed the Petrotech directors that Win was owned by Ms Wong; and (b) all directors were informed of the Payment Arrangement by Capt Mustafa sometime in July or early August 2017. But these assertions were not in his affidavit nor were they put to Capt Hariff.
The Mozer’s Agreement
- [114]
[114] The Mozer’s Agreement was also drafted by Mr Low. It was simply a copy of the Win Agreement, with some modifications. It was equally suspicious.
- [115]
[115] First, Ms Wong’s evidence as to the involvement of Mozer’s made no sense. When Zhu Pang asked if she knew of any service provider who could provide “similar agency services” as Win, Mozer’s was plainly not such an entity. There was also no explanation as to why Zhu Pang needed a second service provider to provide similar services. In the event, the services (allegedly) provided by Mozer’s bore no similarity to that provided by Win (other than handing substantial cash to Zhu Pang).
- [116]
[116] Second, Recital (2) of the Mozer’s Agreement stated:
This was false. Further, in Clause 7.1.2 of the Mozer’s Agreement, Mozer’s undertook and warranted to Petrotech that “it has the qualification to perform the transaction contemplated hereunder and such transaction is covered under its scope of business”, which was also false.
- [117]
[117] Third, Recital (3) of the Mozer’s Agreement stated:
But these were services that Mozer’s had no experience providing.
- [118]
[118] Fourth, Mozer’s was not asked to, and did not, carry out any of the services described in the Mozer’s Agreement. It also did not state that Mozer’s would provide services to Kunlun but be paid by Petrotech. Like the Win Agreement, Kunlun was not even mentioned in the Mozer’s Agreement.
- [119]
[119] Fifth, Clause 4 of the Mozer’s Agreement expressly provided that Mozer’s was to charge an agency fee of S$1,500 per ship, which was not what Mozer’s in fact charged. According to Mr Wong’s affidavit, Zhu Pang agreed that he could charge (a) a coordinating fee amounting to 6% of the sums invoiced by Mozer’s to Petrotech; and (b) a monthly allowance of about S$6,000 a month. But this change was not evidenced in writing.
- [121]
[121] When confronted with these issues, Mr Low’s response was (again) that he had simply followed Capt Mustafa’s instructions. For the same reasons as with the Win Agreement, I do not find this evidence credible. I also note that Capt Mustafa’s involvement was not pleaded by Mr Low.
- [122]
[122] In fact, Mr Low’s falsely downplayed his involvement with Mozer’s and the Mozer’s Agreement. According to his affidavit:
(a) in December 2017, Capt Mustafa called him and informed him that Zhu Pang had requested Mozer’s to be a service provider to Kunlun on terms similar to the Win Agreement;
(b) Mr Low was not privy to the details of Capt Mustafa’s discussions between Zhu Pang; and
(c) Capt Mustafa instructed Mr Low to draft the Mozer’s Agreement and gave him instructions on what to include – Mr Low claimed that was the extent of his involvement in the Mozer’s Agreement.
- [123]
[123] However, Mr Wong’s evidence suggested a greater involvement on the part of Mr Low. According to Mr Wong, sometime in mid-December 2017, Mr Low called him to arrange the signing of “an agreement with Petrotech”, and informed him that this was so that Petrotech could pay him pursuant to his arrangement with Zhu Pang. Mr Wong therefore went to Petrotech’s office in Malaysia sometime in mid-December 2017 to sign the Mozer’s Agreement in the presence of Mr Low. He did not meet anyone else in Petrotech and claimed that the Mozer’s Agreement had already been signed by Capt Hariff. Further, as discussed below (at [242]–[243]), Mr Low clearly dealt with Mr Wong on the issuance of the 2018 Mozer’s Invoices to Petrotech.
- [124]
[124] I reject Mr Low’s evidence that Capt Mustafa was responsible for the terms of the Win and Mozer’s Agreements and find that their drafting and execution were entirely orchestrated by Mr Low. I also find that Mr Low deliberately drafted them to give the false impression that Win and Mozer’s were experienced service providers in the marine industry and providing services to support Petrotech’s STS operations. That the Win Agreement template was modified for the Mozer’s Agreement to reflect specific and different services (which Mozer’s was not qualified to do, and did not perform) only evidenced the deliberateness with which Mr Low set about that task. The Win And Mozer’s Agreements were necessary as Petrotech or its auditors would likely ask about them in reviewing the Win and Mozer’s Invoices, which was in fact what happened (see above at [112] and below at [130] and [244]).
Breach of fiduciary duties
- [125]
[125] I first deal with the claim against Mr Low for breach of fiduciary duties.
- [126]
[126] It is trite that directors owe fiduciary duties to their companies, which include duties (a) to act honestly and in good faith in the best interests of their company; (b) not to exercise their powers for an improper purpose; and (c) not to place themselves in a position in which there is a conflict between their duties to the company and their personal interests or duties to others: Concorde Services Pte Ltd (in liquidation) v Ong Kim Hock and another [2024] SGHC 324 (“Concorde Services”) at [61], citing DM Divers Technics Pte Ltd v Tee Chin Hock [2004] 4 SLR(R) 424 at [80].
- [127]
[127] It is clear from the evidence and my findings above that Mr Low had acted in breach of his fiduciary duties to Petrotech:
(a) on his own evidence, he knew that Win and Mozer’s were not providing any services to Petrotech;
(b) he caused Petrotech to pay the Win and Mozer’s Invoices, by preparing or instructing Mr Ong to prepare the payment instructions to the banks and for Capt Hariff to approve the same;
(c) on his own case, the amounts charged in the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were to be charged to and borne by Kunlun;
(d) he nonetheless caused Petrotech to pay the Win and Mozer’s Invoices knowing and intending that the amounts charged therein would not be charged to Kunlun and that Kunlun would not reimburse Petrotech for the same; and
(e) by doing so, he knew that he would cause Petrotech to suffer loss and Petrotech did suffer such loss.
- [128]
[128] The above is sufficient to establish Mr Low’s breach. But the evidence against him goes much further – it is evident that he was the mastermind behind a scheme to wrongfully misappropriate monies from Petrotech by using the Win and Mozer’s Agreements and the Win and Mozer’s Invoices.
- [129]
[129] First, Mr Low orchestrated the preparation and execution of the Win and Mozer’s Agreements:
(a) I did not accept his evidence that he dealt with Zhu Pang, much less that Zhu Pang was authorised by Kunlun, or that it was Zhu Pang who was behind the Win and Mozer’s Agreements;
(b) he alone from Petrotech met and dealt with Ms Wong and Mr Wong, and according to him, Zhu Pang (see [17] and [123] above);
(c) on his own evidence, he roped in Ms Wong to be the counterparty to the Win Agreement (see [17] above);
(d) it was likely that he brought Mr Wong into his scheme as well, or at least, supported Ms Wong’s proposal to do so, given that I do not accept Mr Low’s evidence with respect to Zhu Pang or that he was acting on Capt Mustafa’s instructions (see [41]–[45] above);
(e) he drafted the Win and Mozer’s Agreements (see [96] and [114] above);
(f) he caused the Win and Mozer’s Agreements to (i) contain false statements calculated to give the appearance that these were legitimate agreements with entities experienced in the marine industry and could provide services to support Petrotech in their STS operations (see above at [98], [116] and [117]) and (ii) falsely reflect services which Win and Mozer’s had no experience in providing and did not in fact provide (see [104] and [118] above);
(g) he arranged for and witnessed the signing of the Win and Mozer’s Agreements by Ms Wong and Mr Wong respectively (see [96] and [123] above); and
(h) he arranged for Capt Kamal and Capt Hariff to sign the Win and Mozer’s Agreements respectively on behalf of Petrotech (see [21] and [28] above).
- [130]
[130] Mr Low’s evidence that his role was limited to getting the Win and Mozer’s Agreements drafted and signed was clearly untrue. To cover up his conduct, Mr Low went as far as to claim that he was unaware of the services provided by Win and Mozer’s, and that he did not care whether they provided any services at all because they would be charged to Kunlun. That evidence was dishonest and contrived to distance himself from Win and Mozer’s. Over and above the matters set out above, it was contradicted by:
(a) WhatsApp messages between Mr Ong and Mr Low, where Mr Low instructed Mr Ong to provide the auditors with false information about the services that Win provided (see above at [112]); and
(b) Mr Ong’s (unchallenged) evidence that when the auditors queried what services Mozer’s provided, he asked Mr Low, who said that he would deal with the auditors.
- [131]
[131] That lie was also exposed by the fact that Mr Low knew the amounts charged by Win and Mozer’s would not be paid by Kunlun (see above [89]).
- [132]
[132] Second, and crucially, the scheme would only work if Petrotech paid the Win and Mozer’s Invoices without question or verification. It was Mr Low who ensured that happened (see [94] above). Mr Low instructed Mr Ong to make the payments to Win and Mozer’s and caused Capt Hariff (either personally or through Mr Ong) to approve the payments. He also specifically instructed Mr Ong not to hand the Win and Mozer’s Invoices to Ms Jin, and Ms Jin not to act on the Win and Mozer’s Invoices. It was his intention that they would not be charged to Kunlun. Contrary to the suggestion of counsel for Mr Low that there was no reason for Mr Low not to charge the Win and Mozer’s Invoices Kunlun, Mr Low knew he could not do that because Ms Yolande (as conceded by Mr Low) would carefully review the Petrotech Invoices to ensure that they were consistent with the STS Agreements.
- [133]
[133] Third, Mr Low knew that the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were shams in that they did not reflect services performed by Win and Mozer’s as a substantial part of Petrotech’s payments were (according to Ms Wong and Mr Wong) handed to Zhu Pang in cash. Mr Low claimed that he was unaware of this, but that evidence contradicted his own affidavit, where he stated that “Kunlun will use [Win and Mozer’s] to claw back from the amount they paid monthly to [Petrotech]”. When confronted with this, Mr Low bizarrely claimed that he did not know what the term “claw back” meant, although they were his own words. Even that canard was exposed because he had stated, in another paragraph in his affidavit, that “[Kunlun] sought to recover a portion of the monthly payments made to [Petrotech] for their operations through [Win and Mozer’s]” (emphasis added). Mr Low could not pretend that he did not know what “recover” meant. Unsurprisingly, he fell back to claiming that he was merely recounting what Capt Mustafa told him at the meeting with Kunlun in September 2018. But this was not stated in his affidavit, where he testified that this was “based on [his] understanding” (emphasis added). Further, it was Ms Wong’s evidence that the cash payments to Zhu Pang began in 2017. Mr Low could not explain why Zhu Pang was collecting cash payments before Kunlun had (allegedly) agreed to such an arrangement. When further questioned, Mr Low changed his evidence and conceded that he knew that Kunlun was recovering monies from Win and Mozer’s. Clearly, Mr Low had no regard for the truth. I find that he mentioned the “claw back” of monies by Kunlun in his affidavit to support Ms Wong and Mr Wong’s position that it was proper of them to hand cash to Zhu Pang, only to resile from it when he realised that it exposed his own position.
- [134]
[134] The defendants argued that all payments to Win and Mozer’s could only have been made with Capt Hariff’s approval. That does not absolve Mr Low of his breaches. In any event, I accept Capt Hariff’s evidence that he relied on Mr Low that the payments were appropriate before approving the same. Capt Hariff oversaw Petrotech’s operations and left the financial and accounting matters to Mr Low, who was the director in charge of the Finance Department and an equal shareholder. He had no reason to doubt that Mr Low was acting properly and approved the payments without raising queries.
- [135]
[135] Mr Low also argued that there was no reason for him to cause Petrotech loss given that he held just over a third of its shares and would have benefitted from higher profits through dividends. The fact that there may be no apparent motive for Mr Low’s breach is not a defence; nor does it displace the overwhelming evidence against him. In any event, there was a clear motive. At a minimum, the Win and Mozer’s Agreements benefitted Ms Wong, whom (as will be explained below at [153]–[154]) Mr Low had a close relationship with, and Mr Wong, who was related to Ms Wong and who Mr Low knew personally as well. Further, a large proportion of the monies paid by Petrotech to Win and Mozer’s (including cash allegedly given to Zhu Pang) remained unaccounted for. This is significant given my findings that Mr Low orchestrated the scheme and Zhu Pang was likely a character he contrived – this suggested that Mr Low benefitted personally as well.
- [136]
[136] Mr Low’s evidence that he was acting on Capt Mustafa’s instructions and that Capt Mustafa had, while he was alive, instructed him to pay all the Win and Mozer’s Invoices also does not assist him. I do not believe that evidence. In any event, Mr Low conceded that Capt Mustafa’s instructions to pay the Win and Mozer’s Invoices were on the premise that they would be charged to, and paid by, Kunlun, which Mr Low knew they would not be.
- [137]
[137] Mr Low sought relief under ss 157C and 391 of the Companies Act 1967 (2020 Rev Ed) (“Companies Act”). Parties agreed that, for the purposes of the present proceedings, the law governing a director’s duties under Malaysian law was the same as under Singapore law. In any event, similar relief is available under the Malaysian Companies Act. However, s 157C(2)(a) specifies that relief is only available if the director had acted in good faith and made proper inquiries where the circumstances necessitated it. In interpreting s 391, the Court of Appeal highlighted that “relief from liability must be underpinned by the presence of the three elements of honesty, reasonableness and fairness”: JSI Shipping (S) Pte Ltd v Teofoongwonglcloong (a firm) [2007] 4 SLR 460 at [167].
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.