General Division of the High Court · Decided 6 June 2025
The accused was sentenced for rape and outrage of modesty offences
Public Prosecutor v CFE
Feedback & support[2025] SGHC 106 · Case no. Criminal Case No 37 of 2024
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
The accused was sentenced for rape and outrage of modesty offences
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraphs [287], [288], [305]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The Accused in this case claimed trial to the following five charges (the “Five Charges”) involving various sexual offences under the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) (“Penal Code”):
1st charge
That you, [CFE], sometime between 11.50pm on 5 January 2020 and 12.20am on 6 January 2020, in [address redacted], being a member of the employer's household of a domestic worker, namely, [the Complainant] (female/then 35 years old), did penetrate [the Complainant]’s vagina with your penis, without her consent, and you have thereby committed an offence under section 375(1)(a) of the [Penal Code], punishable under section 375(2) read with section 73(1) of the said Act.
2nd charge
That you, [CFE], sometime between 11.50pm on 5 January 2020 and 12.20am on 6 January 2020, in [address redacted], being a member of the employer's household of a domestic worker, namely [the Complainant] (female/then 35 years old), did sexually penetrate, with at least one finger, the vagina of [the Complainant], without her consent, and you have thereby committed an offence under section 376(2)(a) of the [Penal Code], punishable under section 376(3) read with section 73(1) of the said Act.
3rd charge
That you, [CFE], sometime between 11.50pm on 5 January 2020 and 12.20am on 6 January 2020, in [address redacted], being a member of the employer's household of a domestic worker, namely, [the Complainant] (female/then 35 years old), did use criminal force on [the Complainant], to wit, sucking her right breast (skin-on-skin) and touching her vagina (skin-on-skin), intending to outrage her modesty, and you have thereby committed an offence punishable under section 354(1) of the [Penal Code], read with section 73(1) of the said Act.
4th charge
That you, [CFE], sometime between 11.50pm on 5 January 2020 and 12.15am on 6 January 2020, in [address redacted], being a member of the employer's household of a domestic worker, namely, [the Complainant] (female/then 35 years old), did penetrate, with your penis, the mouth of [the Complainant], without her consent, and you have thereby committed an offence under section 375(1A)(a) of the [Penal Code], punishable under section 375(2) read with section 73(1) of the said Act.
5th charge
That you, [CFE], sometime between 11.50pm on 5 January 2020 and 12.20am on 6 January 2020, in [address redacted], being a member of the employer's household of a domestic worker, namely, [the Complainant] (female/then 35 years old), did use criminal force on [the Complainant], to wit, by licking her vagina (skin-on-skin), intending to outrage her modesty, and you have thereby committed an offence punishable under section 354(1) of the [Penal Code], read with section 73(1) of the said Act.
- [2]
[2] In respect of all Five Charges, the alleged victim (the “Complainant”) was a female domestic helper. The Complainant was employed by one of the Accused’s daughters (“[D2]”) at the time of the alleged offences. All the alleged offences occurred between 11.50pm on 5 January 2020 and 12.20am on 6 January 2020, in the living-room of the flat (“the Flat”) where [D2] was then living with her husband, their two children, [D2]’s sister (“[D1]”), the Accused and the Complainant. At the material time, a closed-circuit television (“CCTV”) camera was installed in the living-room; and as such, there was CCTV footage which captured a series of sexual acts carried out by the Accused on the Complainant during the periods specified in the Five Charges.
- [3]
[3] The Prosecution’s case was that the CCTV footage from the living-room corroborated the Complainant’s evidence about the sexual acts carried out by the Accused and about the fact that she had not consented to any of these sexual acts. The Prosecution contended that from the CCTV Footage, it was obvious that the Complainant was in a weak and unresponsive state at the material time and could not have given her consent to any of the sexual acts.
- [4]
[4] The Accused, on the other hand, claimed that he did not commit the sexual acts alleged in the Five Charges. Insofar as he admitted to carrying out certain sexual acts on the Complainant, the Accused claimed that this was done with the Complainant’s consent.
- [5]
[5] I first set out the undisputed facts in this case.
The undisputed facts
The parties
- [6]
[6] The Accused is a 69-year-old male Singaporean. He divorced his former wife (referred to by the Complainant as “Ah Ma” during the trial) some 20 years ago but has referred to her as his “late wife” in his testimony during the trial. He has four children; and at the time of the alleged offences, he lived with two of his daughters – [D1] and [D2] – in the Flat which was owned by [D1]. At trial, the Accused’s evidence was that he had been living in China and Hong Kong prior to the alleged offences, and that he would stay with [D1], [D2] and her family in the Flat on his trips back to Singapore.
- [7]
[7] In his evidence-in-chief, the Accused described himself as a “researcher” in the field of health and health supplements. He also gave evidence that he kept stocks of various health supplements, injections, and Traditional Chinese Medicine (“TCM”) products at the Flat because he had previously been in the business of distributing such supplements.
- [8]
[8] The Complainant is a Filipino national. She is currently 40 years old and was 35 years old at the time of the alleged offences. She first came to Singapore to work as a domestic helper in 2016 and started working for [D2] in August 2018. She has four children (aged 19, 16, 15, and 14) in the Philippines. Some of the children stay with her partner, while the others are taken care of by her mother.
- [9]
[9] The Complainant is the youngest of three children. Her eldest sister, [S], has been working in Singapore as a domestic helper since 2007. The Complainant and [S] are very close; and they talk on the telephone or via messaging applications almost every day – including on the day of the alleged offences.
Background
- [11]
[11] When the Complainant was first employed by [D2] in August 2018, she worked in [D2]’s flat in Dawson, tending to [D2], her husband, and their two sons. About a year after the birth of [D2]’s second son, [D2] and her family moved into [D1]’s flat at Tampines (the “Flat”) as it was a larger two-storey apartment.
- [12]
[12] In October 2019, due to her deteriorating health, Ah Ma (the mother of [D1] and [D2]) moved from Taiwan to Singapore, to stay in the Flat with her daughters. Ah Ma stayed in the Flat until her death on 26 November 2019, sharing a room with the Complainant during this period. Around the same time, the Accused (whom the Complainant referred to as “Kong Kong”) also began staying in the Flat, sleeping on the second floor in the children’s room.
- [13]
[13] On 1 January 2020, [D1] and [D2] flew back to Taiwan with [D2]’s husband and children to settle the affairs of their deceased mother. This left the Accused alone with the Complainant in the Flat from 1 to 8 January 2020. From 1 to 4 January 2020, nothing unusual happened between the Accused and the Complainant. The Complainant described her interactions with the Accused during this period as being “normal”: as far as she was concerned, he was “the father of [her] employer”.
The CCTV Cameras
- [14]
[14] There were two CCTV cameras installed on the first floor of the Flat:
(a) one in the living room (the “Living Room CCTV”); and
(b) one in the Complainant’s bedroom (the “Bedroom CCTV”).
- [15]
[15] Both cameras had audio and video recording capabilities but would only start recording when they detected motion within their frame of view. The recorded footage would then be uploaded to a cloud drive which [D2] had access to. For the purposes of the trial, the Prosecution tendered in evidence the footage retrieved from both cameras for the period 5 January to 6 January 2020. Due to the motion-activated nature of the cameras, there are intermittent gaps in the footage. Indisputably, however, the footage from the Living Room CCTV Camera did capture a number of sexual acts carried out by the Accused from the Complainant. I will refer to the sexual acts shown in the CCTV footage as the “Incident”.
- [16]
[16] The relevant video clips from this footage were played in court. The Prosecution also produced two transcripts of the audio recordings from the CCTV footage – one for 5 January 2020 and another for 6 January 2020 – which were prepared by the investigation officer Ms Gan Mei Huey (“IO Gan”).
Events leading up to the Incident
- [17]
[17] The Incident took place on the night of Sunday, 5 January 2020. This was the Complainant’s designated day off. As noted above (at [15]), the CCTV cameras captured a substantial portion of the day’s events, notwithstanding intermittent gaps in the footage. The following account of the events leading up to the Incident is derived from the audio and video recordings obtained from the CCTV footage.
Morning of 5 January 2020
- [18]
[18] On 5 January 2020, the Complainant woke up at around 6.30am to shower and do some household chores before leaving for her day off. The Accused came downstairs at about 7.50am, at which point he spoke briefly to the Complainant about her menstrual cramps and passed her some medication, purportedly to help her manage her menstrual pain. The Accused also suggested to the Complainant that she could try providing oral sex to her boyfriend in Singapore as a means of alleviating her menstrual discomfort. The Complainant laughed in response to this remark without saying anything. At trial, the Accused relied on this conversation (amongst other things) to support his claim that the Complainant had on various occasions shown interest in having “intimacy” with him. Shortly after, the Complainant left the Flat and was out the entire day.
The Complainant returning home and the Accused’s instructions for her to prepare fruits
- [19]
[19] The Complainant returned to the Flat at about 7.30pm and greeted the Accused before going to take a shower. At this time, the Accused was still dressed in a white tee shirt and khaki pants. About 15 minutes later, the Accused was seen in the living room still in his khaki pants but no longer wearing his tee shirt. He then went upstairs while the Complainant was having her dinner at the dining table, but was seen coming downstairs again at about 8.14pm. By this point in time, the Accused appeared to have removed his khaki pants as well and was wearing only a pair of white boxers. He remained wearing only his white boxers until the eventual sexual acts.
- [20]
[20] At about 8.15pm, the Accused gave the Complainant instructions to prepare some fruits for them both to eat. At 8.20pm, the Accused switched on the TV and picked out a few snacks from a shelf in the living-room, which he told the Complainant they should eat with the fruits.
The Accused’s invitation to the Complainant to watch TV with him
- [21]
[21] At around 8.28pm, the Accused sat down on the floor of the living room to watch TV. He got up after a few minutes and went into the Complainant’s room to ask her for q-tips. It was at this point that he told the Complainant to “come out and sit and watch TV”, “if [she] want[ed]”. The Complainant then came out of her room to the living-room where she and the Accused sat on the floor watching a horror movie on TV.
The Accused’s offer of wine to the Complainant
- [22]
[22] At 11.10pm, the Accused was seen getting up from the living room floor and walking to the kitchen. There was a gap of approximately 4 minutes in the CCTV footage after 11.10pm. When the CCTV recording resumed at about 11.14pm, the Accused was seen coming back to the living room with a bottle of red wine and two glasses. He passed one of the glasses to the Complainant and said “come” – inviting her to drink with him. When the Complainant accepted the glass, the Accused poured wine for her and also for himself, while remarking to her that “this is grape juice… this is actually holy water according to the Christians”. The Complainant replied that she had previously drunk some wine given to her by [D2]. The Accused and the Complainant then continued to watch TV as they drank the wine and ate some snacks. As I will elaborate below, the Accused claimed that at the time she accepted his offer of wine, the Complainant knew she was not allowed to drink alcohol in the house and had nonetheless given him the false impression that it was alright for her to drink with him.
Refilling of the wine glasses and the Complainant’s complaint of pain in her abdomen
- [23]
[23] At about 11.32pm, the Accused was seen getting up and apparently refilling both their glasses with more wine. At the same time, the Complainant could be heard telling the Accused that she had been having trouble sleeping. The Accused responded by asking the Complainant some questions, including questions about her last menstrual period. The Complainant replied that she was in the “second week” of her cycle. There then followed a gap in the CCTV footage.
- [24]
[24] On the recording which resumed at 11.34pm, the Complainant could be seen telling the Accused about pain in her stomach and her breast. When asked by the Accused how long she had been feeling pain, the Complainant stated that it had been “two days already”. The CCTV recording then stopped again at this point.
The events leading up to the injections
- [25]
[25] It was not disputed that after the above exchange, the Accused and the Complainant spoke about his giving her injections of some health supplements.
- [26]
[26] When the CCTV recording resumed at about 11.43pm, the Accused was seen heading upstairs, apparently to retrieve the materials he needed to prepare the injections. He came back carrying a box which he placed at the dining table; and from 11.44pm to 11.46pm, he could be seen preparing the injections at the dining table while the Complainant went to the toilet.
- [27]
[27] When the Complainant returned from the toilet and sat back down in the living room, the Accused switched the TV back on for her, after which he was seen walking to her room. It was at this juncture – at 11.49pm – that the footage from the Bedroom CCTV showed the Accused shifting the Bedroom CCTV camera, such that the Complainant’s bed could no longer be seen from the CCTV camera’s field of view.
- [28]
[28] Having moved the position of the Bedroom CCTV camera, the Accused returned to the living-room where he was subsequently seen chatting with Complainant about the TV show she was watching. He was then seen reaching for his wine glass and clinking it against the Complainant’s glass before saying to her, “Ok! We go and give you the injection and then you can sleep”.
- [29]
[29] As the Accused switched off the TV, the Complainant got up from the living-room floor. At this point, she could be heard remarking, “I feel dizzy now” – to which the Accused responded by remarking, “Oh, it’s good! Easy to sleep”. The Accused next retrieved the injections he had prepared and proceeded to switch off the lights in the living room, prompting the Complainant to exclaim aloud, “Eh”. This led to the Accused switching the lights back on. The Complainant then gestured to the sofa bed in the living room and said “I open ah? Open here”. To this, the Accused initially replied “no la, on the bed”, as he switched the living-room lights off again and gestured towards the Complainant’s room. A moment later, he paused and asked the Complainant, “you want to open here?” – to which the Complainant replied, “ya la”. After the Accused said “ok la” and switched on the living-room lights again, the Complainant proceeded to pull out the sofa bed in the living room. It was at this point, however, that the Accused switched off the living-room lights yet again and walked to the kitchen to switch the kitchen lights on. It was also at this point that the Complainant could be seen stumbling a little while unfolding the sofa bed.
The injections
- [31]
[31] At about 11.57pm, the Complainant lay down on the sofa bed and unbuttoned her shorts before assuming a prone position on the sofa bed, with her arms beside her head. While doing so, the Complainant could be heard remarking that the Accused’s daughters had also previously received injections on the sofa bed. I should point out that it was not disputed that the Accused would typically administer injections of various supplements to his family members on their buttocks and that the Complainant was aware of this practice.
- [32]
[32] Next, the Complainant assisted the Accused in pulling down her shorts halfway, just enough to expose the top half of her buttocks. The Accused then applied pressure onto her buttocks and told her “Ok, I will inject here ah – these two sides”. The Complainant appeared to inquire “ar painful?”, to which the Accused replied “this medicine is not painful” before proceeding to pat her buttocks. He also told the Complainant to breathe and relax, to which she responded by mumbling “ok” and adjusting the position of her arms. Up until this point, therefore, it appeared that the Complainant was still able to move her limbs and to converse with the Accused without difficulty.
- [33]
[33] The CCTV footage next showed the Accused applying what appeared to be a sanitising wipe to the Complainant’s right buttock. However, the actual administering of the injections to the Complainant’s right buttock was not captured on the footage as the CCTV camera appeared to stop recording at this point. When the recording resumed at 12.01am on 6 January 2020, the Accused could be seen getting up from the Complainant’s right side and walking around the sofa to position himself on her left. As he did so, he said “ok ah?” – but there was no audible response from the Complainant. The Accused proceeded to pat her left buttock in the same manner in which he had patted her right buttock. He then appeared to administer an injection into her left buttock, at which point there was again a break in the CCTV recording. It should be noted that throughout this 37-second video clip, there was no visible or audible response from the Complainant to what the Accused was doing and saying: her body appeared motionless.
- [34]
[34] Following this 37-second video clip, there was a gap of approximately four minutes before the CCTV recording resumed at 12.06am.
The Incident
- [35]
[35] In the resumed recording, a number of sexual acts were captured across four video clips with gaps of varying lengths between them. While I address in some detail the precise contents of the footage in the later part of these written grounds, for present purposes, I summarise below what is shown in each clip.
(a) First clip (12.06am to 12.07am): The first clip showed the Accused moving the Complainant’s apparently limp body, lifting her shirt up to expose her breasts, and placing his mouth over her right nipple for at least 19 seconds, until the end of this first clip. While his mouth was over the Complainant’s nipple, he also placed his right hand over her crotch.
(b) Second clip (12.09am to 12.10am): The second clip began with the Accused crouching near the Complainant’s crotch with his mouth placed over her vaginal area. The Accused then removed his boxers, and moved into what is referred to colloquially as the “69” position; ie, with his crotch over the Complainant’s face and with his face over her vaginal area.
(c) Third clip (12.10am): The third clip resumed just seven seconds after the end of the second clip. The Accused could be heard asking the Complainant if she wanted to return to her bed. There was no visible or audible response from the Complainant. As she lay unmoving on the sofa bed, the Accused proceeded to kiss her.
(d) Fourth clip (12.13am to 12.15am): The fourth clip resumed three minutes later. In this clip, the Accused could be seen lying on top of the Complainant in the missionary position, apparently thrusting in and out of her. Towards the end of the clip, the Accused was seen withdrawing himself from the Complainant and walking away.
The aftermath of the Incident
- [36]
[36] The Accused was out of the CCTV frame for about 30 seconds. When he reappeared, he was seen wiping his hands with some tissue paper. He then put his boxers back on, and walked off again towards the toilet. On the audio recording from the CCTV footage, a door could be heard closing, followed by the sound of running water before the recording was cut off.
- [37]
[37] When the recording resumed 10 seconds later, the Accused was seen coming back towards the sofa bed. He was then out of the CCTV frame for the rest of the clip (which lasted about 29 more seconds). It should be noted that throughout this time, the Complainant could be seen lying motionless and silent on the sofa bed. She appeared to be in the same position she was last seen in during the video clip for the period from 12.13am to 12.15am.
- [38]
[38] After a gap of roughly two minutes, the CCTV recording resumed, with the Complainant now fully clothed but still lying motionless in the same position on the sofa bed. The Accused grabbed her right arm with both his hands and pulled her body into a seated position. The Accused could be heard saying “go back to bed” before attempting to lift her up from the sofa by placing his hands underneath her armpits. However, she dropped back down onto the sofa bed without any discernible physical or verbal response. The Accused reiterated “go back to bed” before attempting to lift her up again. This time he was successful, but there was still no response from the Complainant. The Accused was then seen manoeuvring the Complainant from the living-room back to her bedroom by supporting her from under her armpits and pushing her along as he walked behind her. As he was doing so, the Complainant’s body appeared to flop listlessly, and the Accused could be heard panting.
- [39]
[39] Next, the footage from the Bedroom CCTV camera showed the Accused placing the Complainant back on her bed before shifting the angle of the Bedroom CCTV back to its original position, such that the Complainant’s bed was now back in the camera frame. The Accused was then shown returning to the living-room where he could be seen cleaning up for a few minutes before heading upstairs at about 12.33am.
- [40]
[40] The Bedroom CCTV footage showed that the Complainant woke up at about 3.36am on 6 January 2020. She was seen walking to the toilet. On her return to her bedroom, she closed the curtain surrounding her bed such that she could no longer be seen on the Bedroom CCTV camera.
- [41]
[41] At about 3.43am, the Complainant called her sister, [S]. The call logs adduced at trial showed that this call lasted for about one and a half hours. While the contents of this extended telephone call were not audible from the Bedroom CCTV footage, [S] testified at trial that at the Complainant was crying when she called [S].
- [42]
[42] For the rest of the day on 6 January 2020, there was nothing unusual about the interactions between the Complainant and the Accused, insofar as these interactions were captured on the CCTV cameras. At about 1.30pm, the Complainant sent two photographs to [S]: one of an empty wine bottle and another of an empty plastic bottle containing material which had apparently been used for injections. According to the Complainant, she noticed these bottles in the rubbish bin and took a photograph of them to retain as evidence.
- [43]
[43] The Complainant continued to confide in [S] over the next three days, before [D1] and [D2] returned to Singapore. However, the messages exchanged between them were mostly in Filipino dialects (Ilonggo and Cebuano) . No certified translations of these messages were adduced at trial, as the translator engaged by the Prosecution was not proficient in these dialects.
- [44]
[44] Between 6 and 8 January 2020, the Complainant confided in several other individuals:
(a) The Complainant confided in [N], a Filipino domestic helper in a neighbouring flat, on 6 January 2020.
(b) The Complainant spoke to “Bing”, a volunteer from Humanitarian Organisation for Migration Economics (“HOME”), on 7 January 2020.
(c) The Complainant also confided in [S]’s friend [GF], who was a nurse based in the Philippines. Sometime in the morning of 8 January 2020, [GF] sent a long text to the Complainant, telling her that [GF] and [S] would always be there to support her. Thereafter, they continued exchanging messages, with [GF] advising the Complainant on how to protect herself.
- [45]
[45] [D1] and [D2] returned to Singapore on the night of 8 January 2020. After they got home, the Complainant messaged them in a common group chat, stating that she needed to speak to them both. [D1] and [D2] then spoke to the Complainant at the dining table from 11.38pm to 12.04am. The entire conversation was audio-recorded by the Complainant; and at trial, the Prosecution adduced the audio file in evidence, together with a transcript of the audio-recording prepared by IO Gan.
- [46]
[46] In gist, the Complainant told [D1] and [D2] that she had accepted wine and injections from the Accused. She alluded to having felt “dizzy”, waking up “in the morning 4 o’clock” and noticing that “something” had happened, and suggested that she was sexually assaulted by him without going into explicit details. [D1] and [D2] initially reprimanded the Complainant for accepting the wine in contravention of “house rules”, before asking her for details of what had happened. When pressed for more specific details, the Complainant stated that the Accused had given her “injection” on her buttocks and that he had “put his finger inside [her]”. She then became audibly distressed and could be heard crying. At this juncture, [D1] and [D2] told the Complainant that they would review the CCTV footage to “find out if anything wrong”. They also told the Complainant to think about what she wanted to do, adding that they would not “cover” up for the Accused just because he was “family”, and that any wrongdoing must be set right.
- [47]
[47] The next morning (ie, 9 January 2020), [D1] and [D2] spoke to the Complainant again at about 10.43am. Again, their conversation was recorded by the Complainant on her handphone; and the audio-recording was tendered in evidence.
- [48]
[48] During this conversation, [D1] and [D2] told the Complainant that they wanted to go to the police, so as to be fair to her. They stated that they “don’t cover up bad things” or “protect anybody”. [D2] added that they should not “drag it anymore” because it had already been four days since the alleged Incident, and any further delay could arouse suspicion. The Complainant’s initial response was that she did not want “this problem bigger”, and that she also wanted to protect her own family and to go home. She expressed fear that the matter could “be in the newspaper”. [D1] and [D2] then assured the Complainant that the police “won’t call newspaper reporter” and that “[t]his kind of thing is handled quietly”. They also assured her that she would definitely get to go home, and that they would buy the air ticket for her.
First Information Report and the Accused’s arrest
- [49]
[49] Sometime between 11am and 11.30am on 9 January 2020, [D1], [D2], and the Complainant arrived at Tampines NPC. The first information report was made at 12.26pm. In that report, the Complainant stated: “On 06.01.2020 at about 0030hrs, I was raped”. On the same day, the police also interviewed the Accused briefly at Tampines NPC. He was eventually arrested at 6.20pm for the offence of rape.
The parties’ cases
- [50]
[50] I next summarise the parties’ respective positions vis-à-vis the Five Charges.
The Prosecution’s case
- [51]
[51] The Prosecution’s case was that the Complainant did not consent to any of the sexual acts alleged in the Five Charges, as she was in a weak and unresponsive state throughout the Incident.
- [52]
[52] The Prosecution submitted that the Complainant was a consistent and credible witness whose account revealed no material inconsistencies. Further, according to the Prosecution, there was other evidence which corroborated her version of events, including evidence of her complaints about the sexual assaults to various individuals, as well as the CCTV footage and the Accused’s admissions in the statements recorded from him during a number of video recorded interviews (“VRI”).
The Accused’s case
- [54]
[54] Additionally, the Accused attempted to explain away the admissions in his VRI statements by claiming that these admissions were the result of erroneous assumptions he had made while in a distraught frame of mind.
The issues in dispute
- [55]
[55] In the course of the trial, the Accused denied the voluntariness and admissibility of his VRI statements. An ancillary hearing was therefore conducted. I explain my findings on this issue at [79]–[90] below.
- [56]
[56] At the conclusion of the trial, I had to decide whether the Prosecution had successfully proven the physical elements of the Five Charges and the alleged lack of consent from the Complainant. I explain my findings on these issues at [96]–[231] below.
Voluntariness and admissibility of the Accused’s VRI statements
- [57]
[57] The Prosecution sought to admit the following VRI statements given by the Accused during investigations:
(a) Statement recorded on 10 January 2020 at 10.49pm by IO Gan;
(b) Statement recorded on 14 January 2020 at 4.30pm by IO Gan; and
(c) Statement recorded on 15 January 2020 at 4.31pm by IO Gan.
- [58]
[58] The Accused initially challenged the voluntariness of all three statements. However, during the ancillary hearing, he clarified that he was only challenging the voluntariness of the statements recorded on 10 January 2020 and 15 January 2020.
- [59]
[59] Since the Accused did not challenge the voluntariness of the 14 January 2020 statement, I admitted it into evidence. As for the statements of 10 January 2020 and 15 January 2020, I found at the conclusion of the ancillary hearing that both were made voluntarily.
The alleged threat and inducement
- [60]
[60] At the outset, it should be noted that the Accused initially cited an alleged threat by Deputy Superintendent Liao Chengyu (“DSP Liao”) as his basis for challenging the voluntariness of the two statements. The Accused claimed that on 9 January 2020, while the Accused was alone with DSP Liao in an interview room at Tampines NPC, DSP Liao had said to him, “You are in serious trouble, and you will be in there for the rest of your life.”
- [61]
[61] Subsequently, the Accused retracted his allegations against DSP Liao. Instead, he claimed that it was Deputy Superintendent Ryan Yue Rui Sheng (“DSP Yue”) who had made certain threats and/or inducements to him. According to the Accused, while he was alone with DSP Yue in a waiting room at Tampines NPC on 9 January 2020, DSP Yue had told him, “What you have done is a very serious offence, and based on your age, you will be in there for the rest of your life.” A short while later, DSP Yue had also allegedly said to him, “If you cooperate…” The Accused’s evidence in the ancillary hearing was that he could not remember if DSP Yue had said anything else after uttering the words “If you cooperate…”. Nevertheless, he understood DSP Yue to have meant that if he “cooperated”, he might get a “lesser” sentence.
Witnesses called by the Prosecution in the ancillary hearing
DSP Ryan Yue Rui Sheng
- [62]
[62] DSP Yue testified that on 9 January 2020, he was the duty officer at the Serious Sexual Crime Branch (“SSCB”). As the duty officer, his role was to be SSCB’s first point of contact for case referrals from the police land divisions: he would gather facts about the cases referred and check with the head of SSCB to confirm whether the cases fell within SSCB’s purview. If they did, he would notify SSCB officers to attend to these cases.
- [63]
[63] On 9 January 2020, after being informed of a report of rape made at Tampines NPC, DSP Yue went to Tampines NPC to gather some facts about the case. At Tampines NPC, DSP Yue conducted a short interview with the Accused in an interview room. In gist, he asked the Accused to confirm his name and place of residence, and whether he was working at the time. DSP Yue recalled the Accused stating that he was retired but had previously practised medicine. The Accused also requested to use the toilet, which he was permitted to do. Apart from this short interview, DSP Yue did not have any other interactions with the Accused.
- [64]
[64] In cross-examining DSP Yue, the Accused said nothing about any threat, inducement, or promise he was alleged to have made. The Accused merely put it to DSP Yue that he had never told DSP Yue anything about previously practising medicine. DSP Yue disagreed.
IO Gan Mei Huey
- [65]
[65] IO Gan testified that she conducted the VRIs with the Accused on 10 January 2020, 14 January 2020, and 15 January 2020. In all three interviews, only IO Gan, Deputy Superintendent Sarah Ann Lee (“DSP Lee”), and the Accused were present in the room.
- [66]
[66] IO Gan testified that, at the start of each interview, she would ask the Accused whether he was able to proceed with the interview and if he had any issues to raise. In all three interviews, the Accused did not raise any issues, nor did he tell IO Gan that he had been threatened by another police officer. IO Gan recalled that the Accused’s demeanour was calm and collected during all three interviews. He also appeared confident in giving his answers and did not appear to be acting under threat or duress.
DSP Sarah-Ann Lee
- [67]
[67] DSP Lee testified that she assisted IO Gan in recording the three statements given by the Accused on 10 January 2020, 14 January 2020, and 15 January 2020. For the statements of 10 January and 15 January 2020, DSP Lee testified that the Accused did not appear to be operating under any threat, inducement, or promise during the interviews. On both occasions, he did not say anything about having been threatened by another police officer.
DSP Liao Chengyu
- [68]
[68] DSP Liao testified that he was a member of the team assigned to the Accused’s case. The team was led by IO Gan. He went to Tampines NPC on 9 January 2020 together with IO Gan and Deputy Superintendent Muhammad Fadzridin (“DSP Fadzridin”, then an Assistant Superintendent). He recalled that he and DSP Fadzridin had spoken with the Accused in an interview room. The Accused was calm and cooperative when speaking to them and showed no signs of anxiety or stress. Later that day, the Accused was escorted to the scene of the alleged offence for a scene visit, and DSP Liao spoke briefly with him during this visit. The Accused did not tell him about having been subjected to threats by another police officer
- [69]
[69] On 16 January 2020, DSP Liao was assigned to escort the Accused from Police Cantonment Complex, where he was being held, for another scene visit. DSP Liao recalled speaking to the Accused during this visit. On this occasion, the Accused also did not say anything about having been subjected to threats by another police officer.
- [70]
[70] In cross-examining DSP Liao, the Accused put it to DSP Liao that during the interview at Tampines NPC on 9 January 2020, it was DSP Liao who had told him, “You are in serious trouble, and you will be there for the rest of your life.” DSP Liao denied this allegation and asserted that in fact, DSP Fadzridin had also been present in the room when he spoke to the Accused.
- [71]
[71] As I noted earlier, the Accused subsequently retracted his allegation against DSP Liao.
DSP Muhammad Fadzridin
- [72]
[72] DSP Fadzridin testified that on 9 January 2020, he and DSP Liao had briefly interviewed the Accused at Tampines NPC. He recalled entering the interview room when DSP Liao was already speaking to the Accused. The Accused was coherent and did not appear upset at the time. He also recalled that the Accused had remained calm and cooperative when brought for a scene visit later that day.
The Accused’s evidence
- [73]
[73] In his testimony in the ancillary hearing, the Accused claimed that on 9 January 2020, he was alone in a waiting room at Tampines NPC when DSP Yue entered the room. DSP Yue said to him, “What you have done is a very serious offence, and based on your age, you will be in there for the rest of your life.” Shortly after saying this, DSP Yue also uttered the words, “If you cooperate…” The Accused did not remember if DSP Yue said anything else after uttering the words, “If you cooperate…”.
- [74]
[74] Both in his evidence-in-chief and in cross-examination during the ancillary hearing, the Accused asserted that he was unable to recognise DSP Yue when the latter was in the witness stand, and that this had led to his “wrongly” identifying DSP Liao as the officer responsible for making the threats and/or inducements.
- [75]
[75] According to the Accused, the words spoken to him by DSP Yue at Tampines NPC kept “flash[ing]” through his mind during the subsequent VRIs conducted by IO Gan. As a result, he felt “very torment[ed]” and confused as he was giving his statements; and he also experienced “bad thoughts” about going to prison for the rest of his life.
- [76]
[76] When asked to explain what he understood by the term “cooperate”, the Accused said that to “cooperate” meant to tell the truth. At the same time, he also understood the word “cooperate” to mean cooperating “with the police” and “with the investigation”. His “perception” was that he would “get a lesser sentence” if he showed the police that he was not giving them any “trouble”. He added that he wanted the investigators to “feel better” so that they would finish the interviews “sooner”, because he was handcuffed during the interviews, and this gave him a “very very bad feeling, a very sad feeling”. The Accused claimed that it was this belief which led him to give IO Gan “dressed-up statements” in an attempt to make her “happy” – “like…when you are in the army camp, your instructors – or your superiors, if you please them more, they tend to go easier on you”. However, he conceded that it was an assumption on his part that the investigators would shorten the interviews or consider his requests more favourably if they were “pleased” with his answers.
The law on voluntariness
- [77]
[77] In assessing the voluntariness of the 10 January and 15 January 2020 statements, I bore in mind the principles articulated by the Court of Appeal in Chai Chien Wei Kelvin v PP [1998] 3 SLR(R) 619 (“Chai Chien Wei Kelvin”) at [53] and in Sulaiman bin Jumari v PP [2021] 1 SLR 557 (“Sulaiman”) at [39]: namely, that the determination of voluntariness is a two-stage, factual inquiry comprising an objective and a subjective limb. The first stage entails an objective consideration of whether there was a threat, inducement, or promise, having reference to the charge against the Accused. The second stage is a subjective consideration of whether the threat, inducement, or promise operated on the mind of the Accused, through hope of escape or fear of punishment connected with the charge: in other words, whether the threat, inducement, or promise was such that it would be reasonable for the Accused to think that he would gain some advantage or avoid any adverse consequences in relation to the proceedings against him (Chai Chien Wei Kelvin at [53]).
- [78]
[78] Where voluntariness is challenged, the burden of proof lies on the Prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the statement was made voluntarily. It is “only necessary for the Prosecution to remove a reasonable doubt of the existence of the threat, inducement or promise, and not every lurking shadow of influence or remnants of fear” (Chai Chien Wei Kelvin at [53], citing Panya Martmontree and others v PP [1995] 2 SLR(R) 806 (“Panya Martmontree”) at [29]).
My findings on the voluntariness of the challenged statements
The objective limb
- [79]
[79] In respect of the first limb of the two-stage test articulated in Chai Chien Wei Kelvin, I rejected the Accused’s allegations about DSP Yue having told him that what he had done was “a very serious offence” and that he would “be in there for the rest of [his] life”. I also rejected the Accused’s allegation about DSP Yue having said to him the words, “If you co-operate…”.
- [80]
[80] At the ancillary hearing, the Accused gave two contradictory accounts: he first alleged that it was DSP Liao who had threatened him, but later retracted this allegation and claimed instead that it was DSP Yue who had made the threats. I found the Accused’s explanation for this volte-face to be wholly unbelievable. When DSP Liao took the witness stand, the Accused had confidently asserted that he recognised DSP Liao. The Accused even stated in his evidence-in-chief that he recognised DSP Liao because the latter had escorted him on several occasions and had been friendly towards him. In other words, the Accused could recall the context in which he had interacted with DSP Liao. It was in this context that the Accused had put it to DSP Liao in cross-examination that he was the officer responsible for making the threatening statements. This version of event contradicted the Accused’s subsequent claim that his interaction with the officer responsible for the threats was very short, and that he could not remember or recognise this officer until DSP Yue took the witness stand. In short, therefore, the Accused’s evidence as to who made the threatening remarks to him was riddled with inconsistencies. The fact that he was unable to maintain a consistent account of who was responsible for the threats suggested that he was making up his story on the fly. It should be pointed out, moreover, that the Accused’s retraction of his allegations against DSP Liao came after DSP Fadzridin gave evidence that he too had been in the interview room with DSP Liao and had not witnessed the latter making any threats, inducements, or promises to the Accused.
- [81]
[81] More fundamentally, the Accused’s evidence about what was actually said to him was simply unbelievable. In cross-examining the Prosecution’s witnesses, the Accused had asserted that the words said to him were along the lines of, “You are in serious trouble, and you will be in there for the rest of your life.” The Accused did not mention anything else being said. Even in his evidence-in-chief, he had started by testifying that DSP Yue’s words to him were, “What you have done is a very serious offence, and based on your age, you will be in there for the rest of your life.” Again, he did not mention anything else being said. Subsequently, however, when asked to confirm if anything else was said, the Accused purported to remember that DSP Yue had also said the words, “If you cooperate…” These additional words “If you cooperate” were never put to any of the prosecution witnesses during the ancillary hearing. If these additional words had in fact been spoken to the Accused, then it was unbelievable that he should have failed to remember them until midway through his evidence-in-chief and long after the prosecution witnesses had completed their testimony. After all, the Accused claimed that DSP Yue’s words had a “huge impact” on him. In particular, it was his evidence that the words “If you cooperate” had “repeatedly” flashed through his mind during his period of remand and when his statements were recorded. As seen from the summary of his evidence (at [73]–[76]), it was after hearing these words that he had decided to try to “please” the investigating officers by showing them “cooperation”. Given his evidence as to the “huge impact” that the words “If you cooperate” had on him, it was illogical and quite incredible that he should have been incapable of recalling these words until after all the prosecution witnesses had completed their testimony.
- [82]
[82] In short, therefore, the Accused’s allegations about what was said to him were self-contradictory and inherently improbable. In contrast, I found DSP Yue’s evidence to be cogent and credible. I was satisfied that DSP Yue had no reason to make the alleged threats or inducements to the Accused. It was not disputed that DSP Yue went to Tampines NPC on 9 January 2020 in his capacity as the SSCB duty officer for that day. His inquiries of the Accused were meant to be brief and of a purely preliminary nature, since he was not tasked with investigating the report of rape: his role was to gather enough facts to allow the Head of SSCB to determine whether the case fell within SSCB’s purview. Indeed, the Accused himself testified that DSP Yue’s interaction with him was “very short”.
- [83]
[83] For the reasons set out above, I was satisfied that the two statements which were alleged to constitute the threats and/or inducements to the Accused were never made by DSP Yue (or indeed, by any police officer).
- [84]
[84] Even assuming for the sake of argument that the alleged statements were made by DSP Yue, I agreed with the Prosecution that they were in any event insufficient to amount to a threat, inducement, or promise. Critically, the Accused himself conceded that he could not actually remember DSP Yue saying “you will get a lighter sentence if found guilty” after saying the words “If you cooperate”: these further words were the Accused’s own “perception” and “interpretation”. In this connection, it is useful to have regard to the case of Roshdi bin Abdullah Altway v PP and another matter [2022] 1 SLR 535 (“Roshdi”). In that case, the appellant Roshdi – who claimed trial to a capital charge of drug trafficking – had challenged the voluntariness of his statements. According to Roshdi, prior to the recording of the impugned statements, the officers from the Central Narcotics Bureau had told him, firstly, “Now Singapore has a new law. If this thing is not yours, you will not be hanged. You don’t be afraid”; and secondly, “Those things are not yours, so you don’t have to be afraid” (at [19] of Roshdi). The Court of Appeal held that as an objective matter, these statements did not constitute a threat. As the Court of Appeal pointed out (at [68]):
- [85]
[85] In similar vein, in the present case, I found that the alleged statements – “What you have done is a very serious offence, and based on your age, you will be in there for the rest of your life” and “If you co-operate” – were, as an objective matter, too vague to amount to a threat or an inducement of any sort. It was unclear from these alleged statements what the Accused was (supposedly) being threatened or induced into doing. To borrow the words of the Court of Appeal in Sulaiman, the alleged statements gave the Accused no reasonable grounds for supposing that an advantage could be gained or an evil of a temporal nature could be avoided by taking a particular course.
The subjective limb
- [86]
[86] Further and in any event, even assuming for the sake of argument that the two alleged statements were made and that they were sufficient to constitute threats, inducements, or promises, the subjective limb of the two-stage test for voluntariness was not made out. This was because the Accused’s own evidence did not show that the words allegedly spoken by DSP Yue “operate[d] on [his] mind … through hope of escape or fear of punishment connected with the charge” (Chai Chien Wei Kelvin at [53]).
- [87]
[87] In Panya Martmontree, the Court of Appeal framed the subjective stage of the inquiry in the following terms:
- [88]
[88] In the present case, the Accused claimed that the words “If you cooperate” kept “flash[ing]” through his mind when he was giving the VRI statements. When asked to explain the effect which these words had on his state of mind during the VRI process, the Accused said that he had tried to “dress up” the statements and to “say something that would be pleasant to the interviewers”. When he was then asked to explain what he meant by “dressing up” the statements, it transpired that he meant only that he had made minor adjustments to some of the phraseology in the statements. Thus, for example, instead of saying “I wasn’t very sensible”, he had said “I wasn’t sensible”. As another example, instead of saying “it is stupid and maybe unforgivable”, he had said “it is stupid and it is unforgivable”.
- [89]
[89] When asked to explain why he had made these minor adjustments to phraseology, the Accused claimed that it was “to make the interviewer happy” and to “reinforce the feeling” that he was “very co-operative”. Importantly, the Accused also testified that he wanted to “make the interviewer happy” so that they would ask him “[e]asier questions” and end the interview session “sooner”. According to him, he wanted the interviews to end “as soon as possible” because he was then handcuffed to a bench, and his “cervical pinched nerve was not good”.
- [90]
[90] In sum, therefore, even if I were to accept the Accused’s evidence, nothing in his evidence suggested that the words allegedly spoken by DSP Yue had “operated on his mind…through hope of escape or fear of punishment connected with the charge”.
Conclusion at the end of the ancillary hearing
- [91]
[91] For the reasons explained above, I found that the statements of 10 January and 15 January 2020 were voluntarily given by the Accused; and I admitted them into evidence.
Evaluation of the Five Charges
- [92]
[92] I turn next to my findings in respect of each of the Five Charges. To recapitulate, the Accused denied having carried out any of the sexual acts described in these charges; and insofar as he did admit to certain sexual acts, he claimed that they were carried out with the Complainant’s consent. In evaluating the evidence adduced in respect of the Five Charges, I noted that in this case, in addition to the Complainant’s testimony, the Prosecution also sought to rely on other evidence which was said to be corroborative of the Complainant’s testimony: namely, the Accused’s VRI statements of 10 January 2020, 14 January 2020 and 15 January 2020; CCTV footage of the Incident; and evidence of the Complainant having confided in others about the sexual assaults shortly after their occurrence.
The applicable standard
- [93]
[93] By way of general principle, it is trite that in a criminal trial, the burden lies on the Prosecution to prove the elements of the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. In particular, in cases where “[the] conviction turns solely on the bare words of the complainant, the complainant’s testimony must be weighed against that of the accused, and the court should not convict unless it finds on a close scrutiny that the evidence of the complainant is unusually convincing” (per the High Court in PP v Ridhaudin Ridhwan bin Bakri and others [2019] SGHC 105 (“Ridhaudin”) at [111], citing the judgment of the Court of Appeal in AOF v PP [2012] 3 SLR 34 at [111]).
- [94]
[94] The “overwhelming consideration” that triggers the application of the “unusually convincing” standard is the amount and availability of evidence (PP v GCK [2020] 1 SLR 486 (“GCK”) at [90], citing Kwan Peng Hong v PP [2000] 2 SLR(R) 824 at [29]). This standard is a cognitive aid and does not change the ultimate standard of proof required of the Prosecution (Ridhaudin at [112]; XP v PP [2008] 4 SLR(R) 686 at [31]; Haliffie bin Mamat v PP and other appeals [2016] 5 SLR 636 (“Haliffie”) at [29]). The corollary of this principle is that where there exists other evidence which corroborates the complainant’s testimony, the need for the application of the “unusually convincing” standard may be obviated. Examples can be found in caselaw of such corroborative evidence in the form, inter alia, of an accused’s own statements (PP v Yue Roger Jr [2019] 3 SLR 749 at [74], Ridhaudin at [115]–[116], PP v Yap Pow Foo [2023] SGHC 11 (“Yap Pow Foo”) at [56]), as well as CCTV footage (Ng Kum Weng v PP [2021] SGHC 100 at [44]).
The evidence in respect of the physical elements of the Five Charges
- [96]
[96] I next set out my evaluation of the evidence adduced in respect of the physical elements of the Five Charges.
- [97]
[97] In gist, according to the Prosecution’s case, the sequence of the physical acts carried out by the Accused was as follows. First, the Accused inserted at least one finger into the Complainant’s vagina while she was lying face-down on the sofa bed (2nd Charge). This took place right after he had administered the injection to her buttocks. He then flipped her body over such that she was lying face-up, licked her breast and touched her vagina. Both these acts involved skin-on-skin contact (3rd Charge). Next, he licked her vagina in another instance of skin-on-skin contact (5th Charge), before proceeding to climb on top of her and inserting his penis into her mouth (4th Charge). As he was doing this, he continued to lick her vagina, in what is colloquially referred to as a “69” position. After this, he climbed off her, positioned himself between her legs and pulled her body to the edge of the sofa. He then inserted his penis into her vagina (1st Charge).
1st Charge: penile-vaginal penetration
- [99]
[99] In respect of the 1st Charge (ie, the charge of penile-vaginal penetration), the Prosecution relied on the Complainant’s testimony and other evidence which was said to constitute corroboration of her testimony.
(1) The Complainant’s evidence
- [100]
[100] I found the Complainant’s testimony on the act of penile-vaginal penetration to be credible, being both internally and externally consistent. It was also corroborated by CCTV footage and the Accused’s admissions in his VRI statements.
- [101]
[101] In her evidence-in-chief, the Complainant gave a detailed account of the act of penile-vaginal penetration. According to her account, the Accused had positioned himself between her legs and pulled her towards the edge of the sofa bed before inserting his penis into her vagina. The Complainant testified that at the time of the incident, she was feeling “so dizzy… like everything [was] spinning around [her]”. Because of this feeling of dizziness, she “could barely open [her] eyes”. Despite this, she was certain that it was the Accused’s penis which penetrated her vagina because she “know[s] the feeling” and could tell the difference between a penis entering her vagina and a finger doing so. She could not confirm whether the Accused’s penis was erect, if he used a condom during the penile-vaginal penetration, or whether he ejaculated. However, she was aware that as he was penetrating her vagina with his penis, he was also kissing her on her lips and breast: she felt him inserting his tongue into her mouth and licking her tongue. She felt “disgusted and helpless” as the Accused “abused her like an animal”. She tried to raise her hand “to prevent” the Accused “from what he [was] doing to [her]” but was too weak to “even defend [herself]”.
- [102]
[102] I also found that the Complainant’s post-Incident behaviour was consistent with her evidence that penile-vaginal penetration did occur. While the Complainant did not explicitly describe the penile-vaginal penetration to [D1] and [D2] during their conversation on the night of 8 January 2020, she explained her reasons for this to her sister [S] and her friend [GF] the following morning. In the group chat with [S] and [GF], the Complainant explained that she had been afraid when she was speaking to [D1] and [D2], as she could not bring herself to tell them that “grandfather” (ie, the Accused) had “penetrated [her] with his penis”. I noted that following reassurance from [S] and [GF] that she should disclose everything as she had done nothing wrong, when the Complainant was brought by the police for a medical examination on 9 January 2020, she did report to the examining doctor that the Accused had “inserted his penis into her vagina” after “pull[ing] her to the edge of the sofa”. While she could not remember if the Accused had ejaculated, she was able to recall that he had gone to the toilet before returning to carry her back to her room.
- [103]
[103] Having considered the evidence, I accepted that the Complainant had a cogent explanation for her initial reluctance to provide an explicit account of the penile-vaginal penetration to [D1] and [D2]. The angst and stress associated with having to recount such a sensitive matter would have been exacerbated by her awareness of the Accused’s position as a senior member of the household – as demonstrated by her reference to him as “grandfather” during the group chat with [S] and [GF]. It should also be pointed out that in describing what the Accused had done, the Complainant was scrupulously honest in admitting that there were details she could not remember; in particular, whether the Accused’s penis had been erect and whether he had ejaculated after penetrating her. This showed that she was concerned with telling the truth and was not inclined to embellish or exaggerate her account of events. Overall, I was satisfied as to the internal consistency of her evidence on the physical act of penile-vaginal penetration.
- [104]
[104] The Complainant’s account was also externally consistent, in that her account of events was borne out by the CCTV footage and the Accused’s own admissions in his VRI statement. I address below these two pieces of corroborative evidence.
(2) The CCTV footage
- [105]
[105] The relevant portion of the CCTV footage consisted of a roughly two-minute clip from 12.13am to 12.15am.
- [106]
[106] At the start of this clip, the Accused could be seen lying on top of the Complainant, who was then lying on her back, such that his groin area was positioned over hers. It was clear from the CCTV footage that the Accused was thrusting his hips vigorously towards the Complainant; and that he made minor adjustments in the positioning of his body throughout the two minutes of footage while the Complainant lay, apparently motionless, on the sofa bed. The only discernible movement from the Complainant throughout the two-minute footage occurred when she appeared to raise her right hand briefly towards the Accused before dropping the hand back onto the sofa. This brief movement on her part did not appear to have any effect on the Accused. At one point, the Accused was seen moving his upper body into a more upright position such that his torso was perpendicular to the Complainant’s body. At this point, both the Accused’s and the Complainant’s crotches could be seen as the Accused continued the thrusting motion of his hips and buttocks. Significantly, although both their crotches could be seen, the Accused’s penis could not be seen – which strongly suggested that his penis was inside the Complainant’s vagina. Further, as he was thrusting his hips and buttocks towards the Complainant, he placed his right hand onto her crotch and appeared to fondle her genitals while continuing his thrusting movements. When his thrusting movements eventually ceased, he could be seen kissing the Complainant before lowering his body and pulling his crotch away from the general area of the Complainant’s genitals – in what appeared to be an act of withdrawing his penis from her vagina. As he moved away from the Complainant, her legs fell limply to the floor over the edge of the sofa, making an audible “thud” sound. The Accused was then shown walking towards the kitchen. He could be heard breathing heavily on the CCTV audio recording.
- [107]
[107] The Complainant was next shown remaining motionless on the sofa bed for about four minutes, until the Accused returned to bring her back to her room.
- [108]
[108] This detailed sequence of events, as captured on CCTV, provided strong corroborative evidence for the Complainant’s account of penile-vaginal penetration. While the CCTV recording did not provide explicit visual confirmation of the Accused’s penis entering the Complainant’s vagina, what could be seen from the footage – in particular, the positioning of the Accused’s body over the Complainant’s and the thrusting motion of his hips and buttocks towards her – corroborated her evidence that there was penile-vaginal penetration.
(3) The Accused’s admissions in his VRI statements
- [109]
[109] The Complainant’s account of events was also corroborated by the admission by the Accused in his VRI statements to having penetrated the Complainant’s vagina with his penis.
- [110]
[110] In his VRI statement of 10 January 2020, in recounting the Incident, the Accused admitted that he had been able to penetrate the Complainant:
- [111]
[111] In responding to the follow-up questions posed by DSP Lee, the Accused elaborated upon the above account by volunteering various details such as the condition of his penis and his state of mind during the act of penetration:
- [112]
[112] Further on in the VRI statement, the Accused went on to explain in greater detail the thoughts which had passed through his mind when he penetrated the Complainant:
- [113]
[113] While the Accused attempted at trial to explain away the admissions in his VRI statement, for the reasons I explain below (at [120]–[125]), I rejected these attempts.
(4) Alleged inconsistencies relied on by the Accused: The medical and forensic evidence
- [114]
[114] I next address the medical and forensic evidence which – according to the Accused – was inconsistent with the Complainant’s account of there having been penile-vaginal penetration. In gist, the Accused relied on the following:
(a) Dr Lee and Dr Wong’s medical report, which appeared to show that the Accused suffered from erectile dysfunction;
(b) the fact that there were no traces of his DNA or semen found in the Complainant’s vaginal swabs; and
(c) the fact that although the Complainant tested positive for two strains of sexually transmitted diseases (“STDs”), (viz. chlamydia and trichomonas), these were not detected in the Accused.
In my view, the above evidence did not assist the Accused. I explain.
- [115]
[115] First, the Accused’s claim about suffering from erectile dysfunction did not negate the possibility of penetration. Both Dr Lee (the urologist) and Dr Wong (the radiologist) were clear in testifying that it was still possible for the Accused to have achieved an erection in a non-clinical setting:
(b) Dr Lee noted that the findings from the test conducted by Dr Wong showed a “peak systolic velocity of less than 35 cm/s associated with a low erection hardness score”: a “normal value should be more than 35” cm/s. Persistent raised end diastolic flow was also noted. In simplified terms, this indicated that there was insufficient blood flow into the penis, coupled with persistent blood flow out of the penis. Both these factors “would… contribute to erectile dysfunction”. According to Dr Lee, the venous leak would generally be a permanent condition. However, Dr Lee also testified that patients with erectile dysfunction could still be capable of achieving an erection, albeit a “lesser degree of an erection”, “depending on the situation” – such as, for example, the patient’s level of sexual arousal and whether there was manual stimulation.
- [116]
[116] Second, the absence of the Accused’s DNA or semen in the Complainant’s vaginal swabs did not negate the possibility of penetration. Dr Judith Ong, the doctor who examined the Complainant upon referral by the police on 9 January 2020, testified that in sexual assault cases, DNA collection would generally be done within “3 days, or 72 hours” from the alleged incident, as “most of the forensics would remain at the areas that they are in for, roughly, about 72 hours or less”. In the present case, the Incident was alleged to have occurred between 11.50 pm on 5 January 2020 and 12.20 am on 6 January 2020 – a time-frame gleaned from the CCTV footage. Dr Ong examined the Complainant at about 10.10 pm on 9 January 2020 and took the vaginal swabs in the course of that examination. In other words, the swabs were taken more than 72 hours after the Incident. Dr Ong pointed out, moreover, that forensic evidence was likely to be eroded by everyday activities such as showering, defecating, changing clothes, or eating – all of which the Complainant had done between the time of the Incident and the time when the swabs were taken. In short, therefore, the absence of the Accused’s DNA and/or semen in the Complainant’s vaginal swabs did not negate the possibility of penile-vaginal penetration having occurred.
- [117]
[117] Third, while the Accused asserted that he had not been shown to have contracted either chlamydia or trichomonas (which were both detected in the Complainant), there was actually no evidence of the Accused having tested negative for these infections. More precisely, there was no evidence of his having been tested for these infections to begin with. Even assuming such test results existed, their probative value would have been limited since there was no evidence to show that transmission of these infections was inevitable during sexual intercourse. Indeed, in his closing submissions, the Accused himself appeared to acknowledge that transmission of the infections during intercourse was not inevitable, as he purported to estimate (without the benefit of any expert evidence) that the “transmission rate” of chlamydia through “vaginal intercourse” was “around 25-50%” and that the “transmission rate” of trichomonas was “about 70%”.
- [118]
[118] For the reasons explained above, I rejected the Accused’s argument that the medical and forensic evidence in this case contradicted the Complainant’s evidence about penile-vaginal penetration having taken place.
(5) The Accused failed to raise a reasonable doubt in respect of the physical elements of the 1st Charge
- [119]
[119] Having examined the evidence, I was further satisfied at the conclusion of the trial that the Accused was unable to raise a reasonable doubt in respect of the physical elements of the 1st Charge. As I alluded to earlier, the Accused’s defence at trial was that no penile-vaginal penetration had occurred and that he could not have committed any penile-vaginal penetration because he suffered from erectile dysfunction. I found this defence entirely untenable, because it was contradicted by an abundance of other evidence; in particular, the Accused’s own admissions in his VRI statements and the CCTV footage of the Incident. While the Accused did attempt at trial to explain away these admissions and to align his narrative with the CCTV footage, I found his testimony to be contrived and disingenuous. I explain.
(A) The Accused’s failure to explain the admissions in his VRI statements
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.