Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 3 Apr 2025

General Division of the High Court

Heavy prison terms were imposed for abusing a child and disposing of her body

Public Prosecutor v Foo Li Ping and another matter

Feedback & support

[2025] SGHC 60Case no. Criminal Case No 8 of 2025

The decision, in one line

Not legal advice

Heavy prison terms were imposed for abusing a child and disposing of her body

Summary by laws.sgParagraphs [1], [170], [171]

There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] After enduring 13 months of abuse at the hands of the accused persons, Megan Khung Yu Wai (“Megan”), then four years old, died from a punch to her stomach area. After Megan’s death, the accused persons callously disposed of her body.

  3. [2] For the cruel acts perpetrated, serious charges are brought in these two cases against the accused persons, Megan’s biological mother, Foo Li Ping (“Foo”), and Foo’s then boyfriend, Wong Shi Xiang (“Wong”).

  4. [3] Specifically, in Criminal Case No 8 of 2025 (“CC8”), Foo pleaded guilty to the following three charges:

  5. [4] I shall refer to these charges as the “Child Abuse Charge”, the “Allowing Death of Child Charge”, and the “Disposal of Corpse Charge against Foo” respectively. For simplicity, I shall, unless I am referencing a provision in a specific version of the statute which is materially different, also refer generally to the Children and Young Persons Act (Cap 38, 2001 Rev Ed) as the “CYPA”, the Criminal Procedure Code 2010 as the “CPC”, and the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) as the “PC”, respectively.

  6. [5] As for Wong, he pleaded guilty to four charges in Criminal Case No 9 of 2025 (“CC9”). Two of the charges correspond to the charges faced by Foo, and they read as follows:

  7. [6] The other two charges pertain to drug offences, and state as follows:

  8. [7] I shall refer to these four charges as the “Culpable Homicide Charge”, the “Disposal of Corpse Charge against Wong”, the “Drug Trafficking Charge”, and the “Drug Consumption Charge” respectively. I shall also refer generally to the Misuse of Drugs Act (Cap 185, 2008 Rev Ed) as the “MDA”, since the relevant provisions contained therein do not differ materially in the versions of the MDA which are relevant to the present case.

  9. Facts in relation to the offences involving Megan

  10. [8] I now set out the material facts for the offences involving Megan, reproducing extensively the common facts in the Statement of Facts in CC8 (“SOF in CC8”) and the Statement of Facts in CC9 (“SOF in CC9”). Certain facts set out at [24], [30] and [32] below are only found in the SOF in CC8, while certain additional facts in the SOF in CC9 are set out (at [34]−[36]) below.

  11. Background

  12. [9] In 2015, Foo got married to Khung Wei Nan (“Khung”), and Megan was born to the couple on 4 October 2015.

  13. [10] Following a breakdown in the marital relationship, Foo, together with Megan, shifted to live with Foo’s mother Chua Ah Kim (“Mdm Chua”). In 2017, Megan was enrolled in a preschool (the “Preschool”).

  14. [11] In November 2018, the accused persons began their romantic relationship. In January 2019, Foo moved out of Mdm Chua’s residence to live with Wong in a rented unit at Suites @ Guillemard Condominium (the “Flat”). Megan continued to stay with Mdm Chua, but would stay over at the Flat on some weekends.

  15. [12] Sometime in 2019, Nouvelle Chua Ruoshi (“Nouvelle”), who was Wong’s friend, got to know Foo. They became close friends. Nouvelle would stay over with her daughter at the Flat.

  16. Start of the abuse

  17. [13] Between late February 2019 and early March 2019, during Megan’s stay at the Flat, the accused persons caned Megan when she urinated on the bed and sofa, causing bruises over various parts of Megan’s body. On 19 March 2019, one of the staff members at the Preschool noticed bruises on Megan’s face, arms and feet, and asked Foo about them. Foo lied that Megan had fallen while cycling, even though the injuries were caused by Wong. Foo admitted to inflicting the other injuries but claimed that she had been disciplining Megan. The staff member informed Foo that this manner of discipline was excessive.

  18. [14] On 22 March 2019, another staff member further reiterated to the accused persons that they should stop physically punishing Megan, or a referral to the Ministry of Social and Family Development would be made. The accused persons understood and accepted this.

  19. [15] On 17 September 2019, Foo withdrew Megan from the Preschool.

  20. The escalation of the abuse

  21. [16] From September 2019, Megan resided in the Flat with the accused persons. As described below, their physical abuse of Megan escalated:

  22. (a) On average, Wong caned Megan at least once a week. On one occasion, he hit Megan with a water hose. Foo did nothing to stop Wong. She also joined him to cane Megan on some occasions.

  23. (b) On occasions, Wong slapped, pushed, and/or punched Megan. Foo was aware of these actions.

  24. (c) Wong taught Foo how to inflict pain on Megan without leaving visible marks or injuries, by pressing forcefully against Megan’s ribcage closer to her waist and side of the body using her thumb. Foo hurt Megan this way on various occasions, when she was upset with Megan.

  25. [17] In addition to the physical abuse, the accused persons subjected Megan to humiliation and emotional injury:

  26. (a) On 9 November 2019, Foo hit Megan with a tissue packet. Foo also forced Megan to wear her soiled diaper over her head. Foo was angry that Megan did not inform Foo that her diaper was full, and that her urine leaked out as a result. Megan resisted, but Foo grabbed Megan by her hair and slapped her face. As Megan was crying, Foo forced the soiled diaper over her head, covering her eyes and nose. When Megan resisted, Foo forcibly pulled the diaper back in place. Nouvelle was present and recorded this incident. The recorded footages show that Megan fell over from the force of Foo’s slap.

  27. (b) Sometime in late 2019, Wong forced Megan to eat food from the dustbin and video-recorded this. Separately, Wong shaved Megan’s hair to humiliate her. Foo was aware of Wong’s actions.

  28. (c) Sometime in late 2019, Wong drew all over on Megan’s face. He wanted to humiliate her because she had used Foo’s make-up products without permission. Foo and Nouvelle were present at the time. Wong and Nouvelle then humiliated her by parading her in public. Megan cried from the humiliation. Again, Nouvelle recorded this incident. Foo was also aware of Wong’s actions.

  29. [18] The above facts form the background and basis for a separate amalgamated charge of child abuse against Foo, which is to be taken into consideration for the purpose of sentencing (see [64] below).

  30. Facts relating to the Child Abuse Charge against Foo

  31. [19] From January 2020, the accused persons began starving Megan to prevent her from defecating around the house. Megan often told Foo that she was hungry, but Foo would deny Megan’s requests for food. Whether Megan was allowed to eat depended on Wong’s mood. If Wong was in a bad mood, Megan would be denied food for the whole day.

  32. [20] Also from January 2020, on multiple occasions, the accused persons did not allow Megan to wear her clothes. This was because Megan developed a habit of peeling on the scabs from her wounds and her blood stained her shirts. Unnecessary physical suffering was caused to Megan, who had no protection from the environment. Having to walk around naked, Megan also suffered humiliation. On one occasion on 3 February 2020, Megan repeatedly asked Foo for permission to wear a shirt, but Foo denied her requests. The episode, which lasted at least 5 minutes and 57 seconds, was recorded by Nouvelle.

  33. [21] Initially, Megan slept in a bedroom of the Flat. Around the start of 2020, to further prevent her from dirtying the Flat, the accused persons made her sleep in the planter box outside the master bedroom. The planter box measured about 3 metres by 1 metre, and faced the afternoon sun. Regardless of the weather, the accused persons made Megan sleep there. On one occasion, Megan suffered from a heat stroke. Wong placed ice on Megan’s body but did not send her to the doctor. On various occasions, Megan was forced to sleep in the planter box without pillows or blankets.

  34. [22] On 5 January 2020, Foo and Nouvelle were unhappy with Megan when her nose mucus splashed on them while she was crying. Foo slapped Megan’s face, before blowing out mucus onto a handkerchief and wiping it onto Megan’s face. Nouvelle told Foo to feed Megan her mucus since she was hungry. Foo then blew out mucus onto the handkerchief again, and instructed Megan to open her mouth and stick out her tongue. She then wiped the mucus-stained handkerchief forcefully over Megan’s tongue, ignoring Megan’s discomfort. Nouvelle recorded the incident, which lasted at least 5 minutes and 11 seconds. The video footage also showed that Megan’s eyebrows had been drawn using make-up in a humiliating manner.

  35. [23] On 4 February 2020, Foo was consuming food near the planter box where Megan was made to sleep in. Standing in the planter box, Megan begged Foo for some food as she was hungry. Foo repeatedly refused her requests, and recorded the incident. In this video footage, which lasted 6 minutes and 7 seconds, Foo repeatedly taunted Megan, turning vulgar at times:

  36. [24] As set out above, Foo, as a person who had care of Megan, ill-treated Megan on several occasions, which taken together amount to a course of conduct. Foo has thus committed the offence stated in the Child Abuse Charge.

  37. Facts relating to the Allowing Death of Child Charge against Foo

  38. Significant risk of suffering grievous hurt due to Wong’s unlawful actions

  39. [25] Between January to February 2020, Wong became more violent and cruel in his treatment of Megan, as described below:

  40. (a) Knowing that Megan was afraid of having water splashed on her face, Wong would spray water on her face using the water bidet inside the toilet, whenever he felt that Megan had misbehaved. On one occasion, this caused Megan to jump and fall. Her face hit the ground, leaving a big bruise on her left cheek.

  41. (b) On another occasion, Wong discovered that Megan had placed a toy pony in the toilet bowl. He hit Megan on her back area multiple times using a hose, leaving multiple bruise marks with bleeding.

  42. (c) On a separate occasion, Wong injured Megan’s jaw by hitting her. Foo saw Megan’s crooked jaw and asked Wong about it. However, she did not bring Megan to see a doctor as she did not want the doctor to be alerted to the abuse of Megan. Instead, she searched up the Internet on fixing dislocated jaws and informed Wong about it. Wong then attempted to fix Megan’s jaw. However, Megan’s jaw remained crooked.

  43. [26] By mid-February 2020, video footages captured an emaciated, naked Megan, with injuries and scars covering both the front and back of her body, and with a poorly shaven head.

  44. Act of punching Megan in the stomach

  45. [27] On 21 February 2020, Megan was deprived of food for the entire day. Sometime that night, the accused persons made Megan stand in front of them. They were sitting on the bed in the bedroom, while Megan stood about 10cm from the wall, with her back facing the wall. Wong scolded Megan and punched her in her stomach. The force of the punch caused Megan’s back to hit against the wall with a loud thud. Megan then appeared unusually weak. Foo told Wong in Mandarin that Megan looked like she “cannot make it”, and Wong stopped hitting Megan.

  46. [28] On 22 February 2020, sometime after midnight, Nouvelle arrived at the Flat. Wong informed Nouvelle that he had hit Megan very badly earlier. Subsequently, Nouvelle saw Megan lying on the bedroom floor. Megan was holding on to her stomach, and said that she was in pain. However, when Nouvelle informed the accused persons of this, they dismissed the matter, and claimed that Megan was merely trying to get attention. Nouvelle therefore ignored Megan, and joined the accused persons in the living room to consume controlled drugs.

  47. [29] Several hours later, Nouvelle saw that Megan remained in the same position. She informed the accused persons about this. Upon entering the bedroom, Foo noticed some vomit with “clear membrane and black contents” beside Megan, who had become unresponsive. They separately attempted to perform cardiopulmonary resuscitation on Megan. Wong later obtained a 30 cm tube and the three of them took turns to blow air into Megan’s mouth using the tube.

  48. [30] Foo knew that she should call for an ambulance, but did not do so for fear that her drug use and the abuse of Megan would be discovered.

  49. [31] While Wong continued performing cardiopulmonary resuscitation on Megan, Nouvelle left the Flat to search for a defibrillator. She returned empty-handed. Wong then left the Flat to do the same. He found one nearby, but did not bring it back for fear that removing it would trigger alarms and lead the authorities to Megan. Around this time, Foo sent a message in a WhatsApp group chat between the three of them, stating “Megan is gone”. After returning to the Flat, Wong decided to improvise. He took two wires and taped a metal chopstick to each end, which he then inserted into a three-pin power source. Wong then tried to resuscitate Megan by placing one wire on Megan’s chest and the other wire below her chest. After Megan remained unresponsive, Wong instructed Foo and Nouvelle to smoke drugs and blow the smoke into Megan’s mouth through a tube, to see if she would respond. They did so, but Megan remained unresponsive.

  50. [32] Wong’s unlawful act of punching Megan in her stomach led to her death on 22 February 2020. The pathologist’s findings are set out at [37] below. The accused persons were members of the same household as Megan, and had frequent contact with her. Foo was aware of the significant risk of grievous hurt being caused to Megan by Wong, and she failed to take such steps as she could reasonably have been expected to take to protect Megan from the significant risk of grievous hurt. Wong’s unlawful act of punching Megan in her stomach occurred in circumstances that Foo ought to have foreseen. Therefore, on or about 21 February 2020, Foo committed the offence stated in the Allowing Death of Child Charge.

  51. Facts relating to the Culpable Homicide Charge against Wong

  52. [33] As explained at [8] above, the matters set out above (save for those in [24], [30] and [32] which only concern Foo), are also found in the SOF in CC9 and apply in relation to the Culpable Homicide Charge against Wong.

  53. Other particulars of Wong’s abuse

  54. [34] In addition, the SOF in CC9 sets out these further particulars in relation to Wong’s abuse of Megan:

  55. (a) In relation to the incident in late 2019 where Wong drew all over Megan’s face (described at [17(c)] above), Wong had done so to embarrass Megan. Wong and Nouvelle also taunted Megan during this incident. For example, Wong asked Megan if she was embarrassed and repeatedly told her to say hello to strangers in passing vehicles.

  56. (b) Connected to the incidents in the toilet (set out at [25(a)] above), from January to February 2020, Wong, at times, restrained Megan in the toilet with a blue cotton rope. Wong secured one end of the rope to Megan’s hand while the other end was threaded beneath her armpit and around her neck, subsequently wrapping around the armpit of her other hand before being secured to her other hand. This manner of restraining Megan caused bruising on her body.

  57. (c) On an occasion between January and February 2020, Wong presented a cane and a baton to Megan and asked her to choose an instrument. Megan chose the cane, but Wong hit her on the arms and legs using the baton.

  58. (d) A few days before 21 February 2020, Wong confined Megan in the toilet and left the Flat with Foo and Nouvelle. When he returned, Wong found that Megan had escaped from the toilet. He also stepped on a yellow stain on the floor, which he understood to be urine. Angry with Megan, he grabbed Megan and dragged her into the toilet. He then gave a hard slap or punch to her chest, before pulling her arm and giving a hard slap on her back. Megan started crying. Wong then dragged Megan out of the toilet and placed her back at the balcony.

  59. Act of punching Megan in the stomach

  60. [35] In relation to the matters set out in [27], the SOF in CC9 also elaborated that it was past 9pm on 21 February 2020 when Wong brought Megan into the Flat from the balcony. When Megan stood in front of the accused persons, Wong warned her not to urinate or defecate in the Flat if he was to allow her to sleep in it. However, Wong felt that Megan was not looking at him as he was talking to her. Angry at this, Wong scolded her and punched her in the stomach, leading to the events narrated from [28] to [31] above.

  61. [36] The pathologist’s opinion is set out below at [37]. Wong’s act of punching Megan in her stomach led to her death on 22 February 2020, and was done with the intention of causing such bodily injury as was likely to cause death. Wong thus committed the offence stated in the Culpable Homicide Charge.

  62. The pathologist’s opinion

  63. [37] In relation to Megan’s death, on 26 October 2021, Dr George Paul, a forensic pathologist with the Health Sciences Authority (“HSA”), reported that based on the available information, such as what Megan was complaining of after the blow to the stomach, and her subsequent behaviour of lying on the ground clutching her stomach and complaining of pain, the possible cause(s) of Megan’s death – in the absence of a body – was “septicaemia - due to either”:

  64. (a) peritonitis from ruptured intestine(s);

  65. (b) peritonitis from ruptured pancreas;

  66. (c) peritonitis from abdominal haemorrhage due to liver lacerations;

  67. (d) peritonitis from abdominal haemorrhage from splenic lacerations;

  68. (e) peritonitis from abdominal and retroperitoneal haemorrhage from ruptured kidney(s);

  69. (f) peritonitis and/or haemorrhage from ruptured liver and diaphragm;

  70. (g) empyema with/or intrathoracic haemorrhage from rupture of lungs and/or diaphragm; or

  71. (h) a combination of a few or many of the above different events in the same body.

  72. Facts relating to the Disposal of Corpse Charges

  73. [38] On 23 February 2020, the accused persons and Nouvelle left the Flat, where Megan’s body remained. From 23 February 2020 to June 2020, they stayed in hotels and serviced apartments. The accused persons also discussed how to dispose of Megan’s body to hide her death and Wong’s unlawful actions that caused it. Nouvelle was aware of the discussions. The accused persons discussed incinerating Megan’s corpse. Wong suggested using a smokeless burn barrel, referring to a burn barrel with a blower attached to introduce oxygen into the barrel to feed the fire. This would ensure complete combustion of Megan’s corpse.

  74. [39] The accused persons researched online on how to go about this. They also experimented with different barrel designs using empty drink cans. Nouvelle was aware of the experiments. Following a few experiments, the accused persons decided to proceed with the plan of disposing Megan’s corpse by incinerating it in a smokeless burn barrel.

  75. [40] During this period, on two occasions, Wong returned to the Flat to do the following:

  76. (a) To prevent Megan’s corpse from being discovered, Wong wrapped the corpse using a blanket followed by layers of cling wrap and brown tape, before placing the wrapped corpse into a Toyogo box. Further, Wong kept the air-conditioning in the Flat switched on to slow the decomposition of Megan’s corpse and minimise the foul smell of decomposition. On this occasion, Nouvelle drove Wong to the Flat.

  77. (b) On a later date, Wong returned to the Flat with Foo. They wrapped the Toyogo box with layers of cling wrap before sealing the lid with cement. Wong also boiled vinegar to mask the smell of decomposition.

  78. [41] Sometime between April and May 2020, Wong bought a leaf blower. He also asked a signboard manufacturer (“Ooi”) to construct an “incense burning container”. Wong provided Ooi the dimensions of the Toyogo box, and shared his design with Ooi. Foo was aware of this. She had accompanied Wong on a few occasions when Wong discussed the design of the container with Ooi. Ooi then constructed the container (the “metal barrel”) in accordance with Wong’s instructions. Wong then tested the metal barrel, and instructed Ooi to make further modifications for improved combustion. Foo was present during the testing.

  79. [42] On 8 May 2020, together with Nouvelle, the accused persons proceeded to Ooi’s workshop. Wong collected the metal barrel, as well as two boxes of charcoal, which Wong had asked Ooi to obtain.

  80. [43] At about 5.25am, the trio returned to the Flat. Wong drove a separate vehicle from Nouvelle and Foo. Nouvelle knew that the accused persons intended to dispose of Megan’s corpse that day. She drove Foo to the Flat. Foo helped Wong load the Toyogo box into the car which Wong drove. Wong then drove to his godfather’s workshop. At about 6.10am, Wong set up the metal barrel at an open area adjacent to the workshop (the “burning site”). He then used the leaf blower to supply a continuous flow of air into the metal barrel’s valve to intensify the fire, before placing the Toyogo box into the metal barrel.

  81. [44] Meanwhile, Foo and Nouvelle returned to the Flat to collect some Indian incense on Wong’s request. When they arrived at the burning site, they saw that the Toyogo box containing Megan’s corpse was already in the metal barrel. The accused persons intended to dispose of Megan’s corpse by incineration to prevent the detection of an offence. Further, according to the SOF in CC8, the accused persons and Nouvelle burned incense paper in the metal barrel for several hours.

  82. [45] At about 10.40am, Nouvelle left the burning site. After the fire stopped, Wong swept the ashes inside the metal barrel into a trash bag and put it in his car. He then drove to East Coast Park by himself and scattered Megan’s ashes into the sea. He threw the trash bag away and returned to meet Foo at the burning site. He cleaned up the area, and together with Foo, wrapped the metal barrel with shrink wrap and trash bags. They left thereafter.

  83. [46] On 15 May 2020, on Wong’s instructions, and accompanied by Wong and Nouvelle, Ooi discarded the metal barrel. Neither the metal barrel, nor Megan’s remains, were ever recovered.

  84. [47] By the above, the accused persons, together with Nouvelle, in furtherance of the common intention of the three of them, intentionally disposed of Megan’s corpse and, by such act, impeded the investigation of an offence under the PC. The accused persons have thus committed the offence in the respective Disposal of Corpse Charges against them.

  85. Discovery of the offences

  86. [48] On 20 July 2020, Khung, Megan’s biological father, lodged a police report concerning the whereabouts of Megan. The police traced the accused persons and Nouvelle, and brought them to the Criminal Investigation Department on 23 July 2020 for interviews. The trio were arrested in connection with Megan’s disappearance, and subsequently charged for their respective acts.

  87. Facts in relation to Wong’s drug offences

  88. The Drug Trafficking Charge

  89. [49] With that, I turn to the facts in relation to Wong’s drug offences, beginning with the Drug Trafficking Charge. On 22 November 2018, at about 9.08pm, a party of officers from the Central Narcotics Bureau (the “CNB”) conducted a raid at a unit in a block at Pine Close (the “Pine Close unit”), during which Wong and his then-fiancé (“Chua”), were arrested for drug-related activities.

  90. [50] The CNB officers searched Chua’s bedroom, and seized the following exhibits:

  91. [51] In addition to the above, CNB officers also recovered other related exhibits:

  92. [52] Wong was subsequently escorted to his residence where CNB officers found drug paraphernalia belonging to him.

  93. [53] On 26 November 2018, amongst others, the exhibits marked “SXA1A”, “SX-A1A1A”, “SX-A1A2A”, “SX-A1B1” and “SX-A1C” were submitted to the HSA for analysis.

  94. [54] On 7 January 2019, HSA issued five certificates under s 16 of the MDA bearing the following Lab No and descriptions:

  95. [55] The 13 packets containing not less than 36.29g of crystalline substance were analysed and found to contain not less than 24.51g of methamphetamine.

  96. [56] Methamphetamine is a Class A Controlled Drug listed in the First Schedule of the MDA. On 22 November 2018, Wong drove to the Pine Close unit and brought along the brown pouch (marked “SX-A”) to the unit. Wong had ownership of the exhibits, and the 13 packets of methamphetamine found in his possession were meant for selling to acquaintances. At the material time, Wong knew that the said 13 packets contained methamphetamine.

  97. [57] Since early November 2018, Wong had been selling methamphetamine to his acquaintances. The last transaction he made was about three days prior to his arrest by CNB officers. Wong was not authorized under the MDA, or the regulations made thereunder, to have in his possession a Class A Controlled Drug for the purpose of trafficking. He has thereby committed the offence under the Drug Trafficking Charge.

  98. [58] In relation to the Drug Trafficking Charge, Wong was arrested on 22 November 2018, produced in court on 24 November 2018, and released on court bail the same day. He remained on bail from 24 November 2018 to 23 July 2020.

  99. The Drug Consumption Charge

  100. [59] Finally, I turn to the facts in relation to the Drug Consumption Charge. On 23 July 2020 at about 7.35pm, in connection with Megan’s disappearance, the police found Wong at the Flat. Drugs and drug paraphernalia were found and seized from the Flat, including:

  101. (a) one packet of crystalline substance;

  102. (b) two improvised utensils; and

  103. (c) one weighing scale.

  104. [60] Following his arrest, Wong provided two bottles of his urine samples. Both urine samples were later submitted to HSA for analysis. HSA issued two certificates under s 16 of the MDA stating that on analysis, the urine samples were found to contain methamphetamine.

  105. [61] Methamphetamine is a Specified Drug listed in the Fourth Schedule of the MDA. Investigations revealed that on 23 July 2020, sometime in the morning, Wong knowingly smoked methamphetamine.

  106. [62] Wong is not authorised under the MDA, or the regulations made thereunder, to consume methamphetamine. He has thereby committed an offence under s 8(b)(ii) of the MDA. Prior to the commission of the said offence, on 2 September 2017, Wong was admitted to the Drug Rehabilitation Centre (“DRC”), for consumption of methamphetamine. He is thus liable to be punished under s 33(4AA) of the MDA.

  107. Conviction

  108. [63] Based on the SOF in CC8 and SOF in CC9, which Foo and Wong admitted to respectively without qualification, I am of the view that all the proceeded charges have been made out, and accordingly, I convicted them of the respective charges on 28 February 2025.

  109. Charges taken into consideration

  110. [64] In relation to Foo, another amalgamated charge of child abuse pursuant to s 5(1) of the Children and Young Persons Act (Cap 38, 2001 Rev Ed) (the “Pre-2020 CYPA”) read with s 124(4) of the CPC is taken into consideration for the purpose of sentencing (the “TIC child abuse charge”). This charge relates to the earlier acts of abuse committed from January 2019 to December 2019 as set out at [16] and [17] above. As will be explained below (at [82]), the Pre-2020 CYPA is materially different from the CYPA, which came into operation in January 2020.

  111. [65] As for Wong, 11 other charges are taken into consideration for the purpose of sentencing (the “TIC charges”), being:

  112. (a) 2nd charge – Possession of 10 tablets containing Nimetazepam on 22 November 2018 under s 8(a) of the MDA;

  113. (b) 3rd charge – Possession of not less than 0.13g of MDMA under s 8(a) of the MDA on 22 November 2018;

  114. (c) 4th charge – Consumption of methamphetamine under s 8(b)(ii) of the MDA on or about 22 November 2018;

  115. (d) 5th charge – Possession of utensils for the consumption of drugs under s 9 of the MDA on 22 November 2018;

  116. (e) 6th charge – Voluntarily causing hurt to his brother by punching and kicking him on 24 November 2018 under s 323 of the PC;

  117. (f) 7th charge – Consumption of methamphetamine under s 8(b)(ii) of the MDA on or about 8 March 2019;

  118. (g) 10th, 11th and 12th charges – Failure to report for urine testing on 18 June 2020, 2 July 2020 and 6 July 2020 under reg 15(6)(a) of the Misuse of Drugs (Approved Institutions, Medical Observation and Treatment and Rehabilitation) Regulations (1999 Rev Ed);

  119. (h) 13th charge – Possession of 0.46g of methamphetamine on 23 July 2020 under s 8(a) of the MDA; and

  120. (i) 15th charge – Possession of utensils for the consumption of drugs on 23 July 2020 under s 9 of the MDA.

  121. Antecedents

  122. [66] Foo is untraced. Wong, however, has a string of antecedents, including drug-related antecedents, spanning the years 2002 to 2018. The relevant ones will be mentioned below where appropriate.

  123. Overview of decision

  124. [67] In relation to the offences involving Megan, I have taken pains to recite the facts in considerable detail. I do so to underscore the heinous, deplorable and violent conduct of the accused persons, which resulted in the tragic death of Megan, a young and vulnerable victim who was helplessly reliant on the accused persons for her daily care.

  125. [68] As alluded to above, Megan’s helplessness was clearly evidenced in the video recordings, in which she pleaded with Foo for food, clothing and to be able to leave the compartment of the planter box. Her pitiful pleas fell on deaf ears, and a hardened heart; Foo’s reaction was to taunt, mock, and berate Megan. Similarly, despite noticing Megan’s obvious discomfort in being paraded around the condominium with her face painted, the video recording showed Wong persisting in his efforts to humiliate her. By February 2020, as I observed above, Megan had injuries covering her frail body. In an emaciated state, she was a mere shadow of her previous self.

  126. [69] The deliberate recording of Megan’s pain and suffering further demonstrated the absolute depravity of the accused persons. These records of Megan captured her in the most distressing of situations, eg, being naked, crying, eating food from the dustbin, and having diapers put over her head. For their own sadistic ends, they robbed Megan of her basic dignity. Ironically, it is these very chilling recordings which shed light on Megan’s plight during that period.

  127. [70] After Megan’s passing, the accused persons did not repent at all. Instead, they continued to display utter callousness and cruelty. Immediately after her death, in a vain attempt to revive her, they resorted to unorthodox and harmful methods, including blowing drug fumes into her mouth. Over months, they prioritised their interests of self-preservation, to cold-heartedly plan for and then deviously execute the disposal of Megan’s body. At the end of her life, they denied Megan of the dignity of a proper laying to rest. Nothing of Megan, not even her ashes, remained.

  128. [71] Against this background, I make a few general points. In these two cases, the sentencing considerations of general deterrence and retribution must predominate: Public Prosecutor v AFR [2011] 3 SLR 833 (“AFR”) at [30]; Public Prosecutor v DAN [2024] SGHC 250 (“DAN”) at [41].

  129. [72] General deterrence is premised on the need to deter like-minded individuals from mimicking similar criminal behaviour through the imposition of severe sanctions, for the protection of the public: DAN at [42]. Indeed, society has a special interest in protecting the young from physical abuse, particularly by those whose duty it is to care for the young under their charge. The court must send a clear signal to those entrusted with such a duty that any unwarranted infliction of violence on young children would not be tolerated and would be met with the full force of the law: AFR at [12] and [20]; Public Prosecutor v Law Aik Meng [2007] 2 SLR(R) 814 at [24(b)].

  130. [73] As for the retributive principle, its essence is to ensure that an offender must pay for what he or she has done: DAN at [41]. Society, through the courts, must show its abhorrence of certain crimes: Public Prosecutor v Tan Fook Sum [1999] 1 SLR(R) 1022 at [16].

  131. [74] Given the sheer cruelty of the accused persons’ conduct, and the unimaginable pain and suffering inflicted upon Megan, it is critical to deter other potentially like-minded individuals who might be similarly situated as the accused persons from ever entertaining the thought of engaging in similar wrongdoing. It is also critical that the accused persons are appropriately punished for their misdeeds.

  132. [75] In this light, while the accused persons have pleaded guilty at the earliest possible stage, which demonstrates some remorse on their part, I am of the view that they should not be accorded the full 30% sentencing discount in relation to their offences against Megan, notwithstanding the Sentencing Advisory Panel’s Guidelines on Reduction in Sentences for Guilty Pleas (“PG Guidelines”). In especially grave cases such as the present cases, the sentencing considerations of general deterrence and retribution are not to be significantly displaced merely because of an offender’s plea of guilt: DAN at [51], citing Ng Kean Meng Terence v Public Prosecutor [2017] 2 SLR 449 (“Terence Ng”) at [66] and [71].

  133. [76] With these broad considerations in mind, I turn to consider the sentences for Foo and Wong respectively.

  134. Sentencing of Foo in CC8

  135. The Prosecution’s submissions

  136. [77] The Prosecution points out that there has been a “gross abnegation of parental duties” on Foo’s part, and submits that the following individual sentences are warranted:

  137. (a) the Child Abuse Charge − five to seven years’ imprisonment;

  138. (b) the Allowing Death of Child Charge – ten to 13 years’ imprisonment; and

  139. (c) the Disposal of Corpse Charge against Foo – five to seven years’ imprisonment.

  140. [78] The Prosecution submits for the sentence for the Allowing Death of Child Charge to run consecutively with the sentence for either of the other charges, so as to give rise to a global sentence of 15 to 20 years’ imprisonment.

  141. Foo’s mitigation plea

  142. [79] As part of her mitigation plea, Foo submitted two handwritten letters for consideration (collectively, the “Letters”). In the Letters, Foo explains that she suffered badly from childhood abuse by her father, from an abusive marriage with Khung, and from an abusive relationship with Wong. The latter two relationships caused her to suffer from her “own self-perceived crippling fear”. Foo also expresses her deep love for Megan and regret over her actions.

  143. [80] In the mitigation plea, Defence Counsel for Foo (“Mr Wong”) highlights that in a report by Dr Cheow Enquan from the Institute of Mental Health (“IMH”) dated 1 September 2020, Dr Cheow opined that Foo “was probably having an adjustment disorder with depressed mood at and around the time of the alleged offences as she was trapped in an abusive relationship”. While Mr Wong concedes that Dr Cheow found “no direct contributory link due to her adjustment disorder” to the offences, he asks that Foo’s plight be considered. He submits that Foo was also “a victim in all of this, and had suffered at the hands of [Wong]”. There were “insidious downstream effects” to her being “trapped in an abusive relationship”.

  144. [81] In summary, Mr Wong asks for a global sentence of ten and a half to 11 years’ imprisonment, broken down as follows:

  145. The Child Abuse Charge

  146. [82] I turn to the Child Abuse Charge. Since 1 January 2020, pursuant to ss 171(d) and 171(e) of the Criminal Law Reform Act 2019 (Act 15 of 2019), the punishment for an offence under s 5(5)(b) of the CYPA has doubled (from that under the Pre-2020 CYPA) to a fine not exceeding $8,000, or imprisonment for a term not exceeding eight years or both. Further, due to the operation of s 124(8)(a)(ii) of the CPC, the maximum sentence for a charge amalgamated under s 124(4) of the CPC has doubled, to a fine not exceeding $16,000 or 16 years’ imprisonment or both.

  147. [83] It is clear that the custodial threshold is crossed, and Mr Wong does not dispute this. In terms of the length of imprisonment term, I consider seven years’ imprisonment to be warranted. My reasons are as follows.

  148. [84] In Public Prosecutor v BDB [2018] 1 SLR 127 (“BDB”) at [85] and [132], the Court of Appeal observed that similar to the sentencing for child abuse offences prosecuted under s 325 of the PC, in the sentencing for child abuse offences prosecuted under s 5 of the CYPA, the sentencing considerations of deterrence and retribution apply. The sentences imposed should reflect a proper appreciation of all the circumstances of the case, including the nature of the harm caused and the seriousness and permanence of the injuries inflicted.

  149. [85] More specifically, the Court of Appeal held that the following factors relating to culpability are to be considered (see BDB at [62]):

  150. (a) the extent of deliberation or premeditation;

  151. (b) the manner and duration of the attack;

  152. (c) the victim’s vulnerability;

  153. (d) the use of any weapon;

  154. (e) whether the attack was undertaken by a group;

  155. (f) any relevant antecedents on the offender’s part; and

  156. (g) any prior intervention by the authorities.

  157. [86] As for mitigating factors, the Court of Appeal acknowledged that mitigating value may be attributed to an offender’s mental condition in certain situations, and that generally, circumstances demonstrating an offender’s genuine remorse may be accorded mitigating weight (see [72] and [74]). However, the Court of Appeal warned that the often-cited factor of an offender’s difficult personal circumstances at the time of the offences will rarely, if ever, have mitigating value (see [75]).

  158. [87] Returning to the facts, in terms of harm, it is plain by the narrative set out in [19]–[24] above, and supported by the relevant video recordings of the period of the Child Abuse Charge, that Megan suffered significant and prolonged physical, emotional and mental harm. This will also become evident in my analysis of Foo’s culpability (especially at [87(b)]):

  159. (a) Deliberation and premeditation: There was deliberation and premeditation in the different forms of abuse:

  160. (i) Foo deliberately deprived Megan of food to prevent her from defecating around the house, including the occasion on 4 February 2020 (see [19] and [23] above).

  161. (ii) Foo deliberately deprived Megan of clothes to prevent her from staining her clothes with blood from injuries inflicted by the accused persons. Her deliberation is further evidenced by her adamant refusal to give Megan any clothes despite Megan’s repeated pleas on 3 February 2020 (see [20] above).

  162. (iii) Foo deliberately made Megan sleep in the planter box to prevent her from dirtying the Flat. It is also clear from Foo’s conversation with Megan on 4 February 2020 (see [23] above) that Foo was deliberately confining Megan in the planter box as a form of punishment.

  163. (iv) On 5 January 2020, Foo made Megan eat her mucus in response to Nouvelle’s suggestion to do so since Megan was hungry (see [22] above). This manner of abuse was designed to offer Foo and Nouvelle sadistic amusement.

  164. (b) Manner and duration of abuse: The abuse in the Child Abuse Charge spanned two months (ie, January 2020 to February 2020). The TIC child abuse charge also accounts for additional instances of abuse spanning one year, from January 2019 to December 2019. Through the abuse in the Child Abuse Charge, Foo had inflicted different forms of harm onto Megan:

  165. (i) By depriving Megan of food and clothing, forcing her to sleep in the planter box at the balcony (regardless of the weather and despite Megan’s injuries), slapping her face, and forcing her to eat Foo’s mucus, Foo caused Megan significant physical harm.

  166. (ii) By depriving Megan of her clothes and forcing her to eat Foo’s mucus, Foo caused Megan emotional and psychological harm by humiliating her.

  167. I also observe that while the Child Abuse Charge was amalgamated by listing four occasions of the four forms of abuse, each form of abuse (save for the slapping of Megan’s face and making her eat Foo’s mucus, which specifically occurred on 5 January 2020) were not one-off incidents. Put another way, Foo had, for two months, repeatedly deprived Megan of food and clothing, while making her sleep in the planter box. Similar observations can be made in relation to the TIC child abuse charge.

  168. (c) The victim’s vulnerability: Megan was a particularly vulnerable victim, as she was but four years of age.

  169. (d) Group attack: Foo carried out the abuse with others, mainly with Wong and in the last instance, with Nouvelle.

  170. (e) Relevant antecedents: While Foo is untraced, she cannot be considered a first-time offender, considering that the Child Abuse Charge is an amalgamated charge which takes into account instances of abuse spanning around two months. The TIC child abuse charge concerns prior instances of abuse spanning one year. The only reason Foo has no prior convictions is because the law had not yet caught up with her for her misdeeds: Chen Weixiong Jerriek v Public Prosecutor [2003] 2 SLR(R) 334 at [15]. This is a neutral factor.

  171. (f) Prior intervention: There was prior intervention by the Preschool, the staff of which had, on more than one occasion, warned Foo not to punish Megan physically. Foo acknowledged this. Yet, she proceeded to withdraw Megan from the Preschool, and escalated the abuse.

  172. [88] Considering these offence-specific factors, a starting point of eight years’ imprisonment – at the midpoint of the prescribed punishment – for the Child Abuse Charge would be appropriate. In arriving at this starting point, I also draw some comparison with BDB and Public Prosecutor v Azlin bte Arujunah and two appeals [2022] 2 SLR 825 (“Azlin (CA)”). These cases involve Pre-2020 CYPA offences – for which the prescribed punishment is half of that prescribed for the offence post-2020, ie, a fine not exceeding $4,000, or an imprisonment term not exceeding four years or both. These cases were also raised by parties in their arguments.

  173. [89] In BDB, the offender repeatedly abused her four-year-old son over more than two years. She pleaded guilty to two charges under s 325 of the PC (for voluntarily causing grievous hurt) and two charges under s 5(5)(b) of the Pre-2020 CYPA, with two other s 5 Pre-2020 CYPA charges taken into consideration for sentencing (BDB at [1] and [5]). The Court of Appeal upheld the following sentences for the two s 5 Pre-2020 CYPA charges (BDB at [132]):

  174. (a) six months’ imprisonment for the act of using both hands to push the victim between his shoulder and chest area which resulted in him falling backwards and hitting the back of his head against the television console table (BDB at [5], [30] and [132]); and

  175. (b) one year’s imprisonment for the act of kicking the victim at the waist area and stepping on his stomach for a few seconds after he fell (BDB at [5], [30] and [132]).

  176. [90] In Azlin (CA), the two offenders repeatedly abused their five-year-old son over three months. The five-year-old died after the offenders scalded him with hot water in four incidents over a week (Public Prosecutor v Azlin bte Arujunah and another [2020] SGHC 168 (“Azlin (HC)”) at [206]; Azlin (CA) at [1]). Sentences of six months to one year’s imprisonment were imposed on the two offenders for their respective charges under s 5 of the Pre-2020 CYPA, as detailed below:

  177. [91] As the Prosecution highlights, there are two important differences between these cases and the present case. First, as earlier alluded to (at [82]), the prescribed punishment for s 5(5)(b) CYPA offences has doubled since BDB and Azlin (CA).

  178. [92] Second, BDB and Azlin (CA) concerned charges involving single instances of abuse. In contrast, as previously explained (at [87(b)]), Foo faces an amalgamated charge comprising different methods of continuous ill-treatment over a period of time. I note that the first three forms of abuse by Foo (detailed at [19]–[21] and [23] above) might not have targeted any particular part of Megan’s body. However, I am unable to accept Mr Wong’s suggestion that Foo’s offence is less serious because “the level of physical violence [in the present case] cannot be said to be high”. Instead, Foo’s acts of abuse are comparable to, if not more egregious in nature than, the acts in BDB and Azlin (CA). The deprivation of food, proper clothing and place of rest, would have caused harm to Megan’s health, safety and well-being, both physically and emotionally. By February 2020, Megan was an emaciated child. The last act of abuse (detailed at [22] above) comprised not only of the physical act of the slap, but also an act which causes harm to health, ie, swallowing Foo’s mucus. This act also served to humiliate Megan. Had separate charges been brought for each type of abuse within the charge, I would have considered a starting point of about two years’ imprisonment for each charge to be warranted.

  179. [93] Indeed, in Public Prosecutor v DAM [2023] SGHC 265 (“DAM”), where the offender pleaded guilty to an amalgamated charge under s 5(5)(b) of the Pre-2020 CYPA for ill-treating his six-year-old stepchild by hitting him with a belt, a hanger, and his hand, and slapping and punching him over a year, the High Court imposed a sentence of three years’ imprisonment (DAM at [15] and [17]).

  180. [94] While Foo’s acts of abuse against Megan did not involve any implements (unlike in DAM), they constituted offences committed under the Post-2020 CYPA, with doubled maximum punishment. I have also explained above (at [92]) that while some of Foo’s acts of abuse against Megan might not have targeted specific parts of her body, they are no less egregious than abuse directly inflicted on a victim’s body. Further, Foo’s case involved several forms of deliberate group abuse spanning around two months more than that in DAM (see DAM at [15]), taking into account the TIC child abuse charge (see [87(b)] above). It also involved a younger victim.

  181. [95] Given these, if Foo had claimed trial, I would have imposed around eight years’ imprisonment. I, however, give accord to her plea of guilt, which demonstrates some remorse, and provide broadly a 10% reduction (see [75] above; see also DAN at [64]), and round down the sentence to seven years of imprisonment.

  182. [97] On these points raised in mitigation, I close with the observations made by the Court of Appeal in BDB (at [75]), that the difficult personal circumstances of a parent or caregiver can never justify or excuse the abuse of young victims, and in AFR (at [12]), that for mitigation purposes, a parent or caregiver will not be allowed to exclaim with regret that he or she did not intend to inflict violence on the victim who he or she professes to love.

  183. The Allowing Death of Child Charge

  184. [98] I turn to the Allowing Death of Child Charge. Section 304C(1) of the PC reads as follows:

  185. 304C.—(1) A person (A) shall be guilty of an offence if —

  186. [99] As the Prosecution highlights, s 304C of the PC was enacted following the Penal Code Review Committee’s recommendation that a new offence of “causing or allowing death or serious injury of child or vulnerable person” be introduced, as part of proposed criminal law reforms to deal with the abuse of vulnerable victims leading to death or other forms of grievous hurt: Ministry for Home Affairs, Penal Code Review Committee Report (August 2018) at pp 148−149 (Chairman: Indranee Rajah SC and Amrin Amin) (“Review Committee Report”). In enacting s 304C of the PC, Parliament emphasised that a “strong stance” has to be taken against serious cases of abuse which lead to the death of a vulnerable victim: Singapore Parl Debates; Vol 94; Sitting No 103; [6 May 2019] (K Shanmugam, Minister for Law and Minister for Home Affairs). Under s 304C(4) of the PC, the prescribed punishment is imprisonment for a term which may extend to 20 years, and liability to fine or to caning.

  187. [100] At the outset, I note that there are various permutations within s 304C of the PC, with the main two permutations being that of causing the death of or allowing the death of certain vulnerable persons in the same household. As parties highlight, this appears to be one of the first few cases involving the specific permutation – of allowing the death of a child. The first is the unreported case of Public Prosecutor v Roslinda Binte Jamil HC/CC 10/2023 (15 February 2024) (“Roslinda”), which the parties rely on. Building on Roslinda, it would be helpful to set out some guidance for the sentencing of such an offence.

  188. [101] In this regard, I agree with the Prosecution that s 304C of the PC contemplates a single form of harm – death. When determining the appropriate starting sentence, the focus would be on assessing an offender’s culpability. To this end, I also agree generally with the culpability related factors which the Prosecution submits to be relevant for consideration. These include:

  189. (a) The victim’s vulnerability: The younger the victim, the more vulnerable the victim. Where a victim was particularly vulnerable for reasons in addition to his or her age (such as physical disability, mental disability, or ill-health), an offender who allows his or her death would also be more culpable.

  190. (b) Relationship between victim and offender: The closer the relationship between the victim and offender, the greater the onus would be on the offender to protect the victim. This is especially so when there is a relationship of trust and dependence between the victim and the offender (BDB at [119]), which is abused by the offender’s failure to act. As held in BDB (at [119], citing Public Prosecutor v UI [2008] 4 SLR(R) 500 at [33]), a parent who betrays that relationship and harms his or her child will generally stand at “the furthest end of the spectrum of guilt” [emphasis in original].

  191. (c) Mental state of the offender: Section 304C(1)(d)(i) of the PC contemplates two types of offenders: one who was aware and one who ought to have been aware of the significant risk of grievous hurt being caused to the victim by the main perpetrator’s unlawful act, as set out at s 304C(1)(c). The former would generally be more culpable than the latter. Relatedly, it would be relevant to consider the offender’s level of awareness of the significant risk, ie, how much and for how long the offender was aware or ought to have been aware of the significant risk.

  192. (d) Degree of significant risk of grievous hurt: Connected to the above, an offender’s level of awareness would, among other things, be informed by the degree of significant risk of grievous hurt suffered by the victim (beyond that needed to establish a s 304C offence). In this regard, I draw from the recent decision of Rex v ATT and another [2025] 2 WLR 89 (“ATT”), where the English Court of Appeal discussed the interpretation of s 5(1)(c) of the Domestic Violence, Crime and Victims Act 2004 (c 28) (UK), which s 304C(1)(c) of the PC is modelled after (see Review Committee Report at p 148 para 35). In ATT, it was held (at [37]−[45]) that the element of significant risk of grievous hurt should be assessed by considering the previous history of abuse. More specifically, I am of the view that, in the context of sentencing, it would be relevant to consider the following:

  193. (i) Degree of harm caused by prior abuse: The greater the severity of harm already caused to the victim by prior abuse, the higher the degree of significant risk of grievous hurt being caused by the fatal unlawful act (beyond that needed to establish a s 304C offence), and, in turn, the higher an offender’s level of culpability.

  194. (ii) Duration and number of incidents: The greater the duration and number of incidents over which the victim was subject to prior abuse, the higher the degree of significant risk of grievous hurt being caused by the fatal unlawful act (beyond that needed to establish a s 304C offence), and, in turn, the higher an offender’s level of culpability.

  195. (e) Steps which offender failed to take to protect victim: The more flagrant an offender’s failure to protect the victim, the higher his or her culpability. This factor applies in relation to three points in time, where applicable (a point in time might not be applicable if the offender was absent from the scene and had no contemporaneous knowledge of the main perpetrator’s actions, while they were being carried out):

  196. (i) in the lead up to the main perpetrator’s fatal unlawful act;

  197. (ii) during the main perpetrator’s fatal unlawful act; and

  198. (iii) in the aftermath of the main perpetrator’s fatal unlawful act.

  199. (f) Offender’s role in unlawful act and prior abuse: Offenders who are themselves accomplices of the main perpetrator’s unlawful acts and prior abuse would generally have a higher level of culpability. Such offenders not only failed to protect the vulnerable victim, they also actively participated in harming the victim.

  200. [102] As for offender-specific factors, the usual aggravating and mitigating factors would apply. The former includes the presence of related outstanding charges taken into consideration for the purpose of sentencing, antecedents, and the commission of the offence while on bail. The latter includes any mental condition of the offender, or any genuine remorse shown.

  201. [103] Considering the relevant factors, I am of the view that Foo’s level of culpability is moderate to high, and that a starting point of 15 years’ imprisonment is warranted. I explain, making reference to the case of Roslinda, where the offender received a sentence of seven years’ imprisonment for the s 304C PC charge.

  202. [104] In Roslinda, the High Court found, after adopting a similar approach and considering similar factors as what I had earlier set out (see [100]−[102] above), that the offender’s culpability was in the moderate range. The offender received seven years’ imprisonment for her s 304C PC charge, after the High Court applied a downward calibration from a starting point of nine years’ imprisonment, on account of her plea of guilt, expression of remorse, and cooperation with the authorities.

  203. [105] I turn to compare the culpability-related factors in Roslinda with Foo’s case. In Roslinda, the offender was the 11-year-old victim’s biological mother, and the main perpetrator who fatally attacked the victim was the victim’s stepfather. For nine months prior to the victim’s death, the victim had already been repeatedly subject to the stepfather’s abuse, which was often inflicted using an exercise bar. The offender was aware of the abuse, and like Foo, had herself also repeatedly abused the victim. The victim eventually died after being fatally hit by the stepfather with the exercise bar.

  204. [106] In my view, Foo’s case warrants a higher starting point than that in Roslinda for three main reasons. First, as the Prosecution argues, Megan was much younger than the victim in Roslinda, who was 11 at the time of death. At merely four years old, Megan would have been much more dependent on Foo for protection. Foo’s corresponding duty to protect Megan (which Foo had failed in discharging) was therefore much higher.

  205. [107] Second, turning to the history of abuse, the abuse of Megan had persisted for a much longer time than that of the victim in Roslinda, and from September 2019, escalated and intensified. While the abuse in Roslinda lasted nine months, Megan suffered under the hands of Foo and Wong for 13 months. This indicated a greater degree of prior harm caused by Wong, and a higher level of “significant risk of grievous hurt” being caused to Megan which Foo was aware of for a prolonged period. Despite this, she did nothing to protect Megan. It is also no excuse to say, as Mr Wong sought to argue during the hearing, that unlike in Roslinda, no “deadly implements” were used against Megan. This is because the fact remains that Megan had already suffered a high degree of harm prior to Wong’s fatal punch. As the Prosecution highlighted during the hearing, Wong had dislocated Megan’s jaw in the process of abusing her, and Foo knew about this. She even carried out research on how to fix Megan’s jaw.

  206. [108] Third, as the Prosecution alludes to, Foo’s failure to take steps to protect Megan was more egregious than the offender’s in Roslinda. There, prior to the victim’s death, the offender had, on some occasions, tried to stop the stepfather. On one occasion, she confronted him for beating the victim. During the stepfather’s fatal unlawful act of hitting the victim with the exercise bar, the offender did not intervene. However, following that, the offender tended to the victim over the next four days, although the abuse continued (with the offender biting the victim’s arm thrice in a bid to stop the victim from crying in pain when the offender was giving the victim a massage to soothe the victim’s pain from the injuries). The offender did not however send the victim to the hospital, for fear that their abuse would be discovered, until four days later when the victim’s heart stopped beating.

  207. [109] In a word, the offender in Roslinda had, at the very least, attempted to tend to the victim, and did eventually send the victim to the hospital (although this was too late). Foo, however, did none of that. There is nothing in the SOF in CC8 which suggests that Foo tended to Megan following Wong’s fatal punch. Instead, she had proceeded to consume controlled drugs with Wong in the living room of the Flat. Even when Nouvelle subsequently raised concerns to her that Megan was in pain, Foo callously dismissed Megan’s complaints as attempts to seek attention. Even when Megan passed on, Foo did not call the ambulance or seek any medical attention. There is not even a semblance of humanity in Foo’s conduct.

  208. [110] For these reasons, Foo’s level of culpability is moderate to high, and a starting point of 15 years’ imprisonment is warranted. In arriving at this decision, I would also respectfully observe that the sentence in Roslinda might have been on the low side. Moreover, for the same reasons which I have explained above (at [75] and [95]−[97]), broadly, a 10% reduction would be appropriate given Foo’s plea of guilt, bringing her sentence for the Allowing Death of Child Charge to 13 and a half years’ imprisonment. As I also explained at [96], I do not see any mitigating effect arising from Foo’s personal circumstances, and she was, at the material time, not suffering from any mental condition that would ameliorate her culpability.

  209. The Disposal of Corpse Charge against Foo

  210. [111] For the Disposal of Corpse Charge against Foo, s 308B of the PC provides for the offence and its punishment as follows:

  211. [112] As parties highlight, this is the first offence of its kind since its introduction in 2019. Mr Wong urges the court to “err on the side of caution for sentencing herein because [Foo’s] case would most certainly set the tone for subsequent [s 308B PC] cases down the road” given that there is “no known yardstick” to measure the factors presented in the present case against.

  212. [113] I disagree. Instead, I am of the view that the relevant factors for sentencing s 308B PC offences can readily be formulated, and that it would be important to provide guidance on the matter as this is the first case concerning the provision.

  213. [114] I first address the offence-specific factors, going towards culpability and harm. Based on the elements forming s 308B PC offences, in assessing culpability, these are the relevant factors:

  214. (a) Manner and extent of concealment, desecration or disposal. The provision criminalises three distinct acts, being that of concealment, desecration, or disposal of a human corpse. The ordering of the words is important, and in my view, generally reflects an increasing level of culpability. Broadly speaking, an offender who wholly disposes of a human corpse will be more culpable than one who desecrates a human corpse, who is in turn more culpable than one who conceals a human corpse. That said, the manner and extent of concealing, desecrating, or disposing of the human corpse would be more significant. Where sophistication is displayed in an offender’s modus operandi, his or her culpability would be enhanced.

  215. (b) Mental state: The provision contemplates an offender who acts, either intentionally or knowingly. In general, a person who intentionally commits an offence will be more culpable than one who does so knowingly. That said, in relation to this provision, the distinction may be more apparent than real.

  216. (c) Degree of premeditation and planning: The greater the degree of premeditation and planning, the more culpable the offender.

  217. (d) Number of, nature and seriousness of predicate offence(s): The number of predicate offences, and the nature and seriousness of these predicate offences are relevant factors.

  218. (e) Motivation: The motivation behind an offender’s act would also shed light on his or her culpability. For instance, an offender who tries to hide his or her own predicate offence would generally be more culpable than one who does so in a misguided attempt to cover someone else’s wrongdoing without any financial or other benefit.

  219. (f) Presence of collusion: Where an offender acts with others, each offender’s culpability would be higher.

  220. [115] Turning to harm, s 308B of the PC envisages two broad forms of harm, either impeding or preventing (a) the discovery or identification of the corpse; or (b) the detection, investigation or prosecution of an offence. In my view, the former is generally a lesser form of harm compared to the latter. In relation to both types of harm, the duration and extent of impediment is also an important factor to consider.

  221. [116] Apart from these considerations in relation to culpability and harm, the offender-specific aggravating and mitigating factors are broadly the same as those discussed at [102] above.

  222. [117] Applying the offence-specific factors, it can hardly be doubted that the present case should fall on the highest end of the punishment prescribed by s 308B of the PC. I explain below.

  223. [118] Foo’s culpability is very high, for the following reasons:

  224. (a) Manner and extent of disposal: Foo had intentionally disposed of Megan’s corpse in a highly sophisticated manner. Megan’s corpse was completely disposed of by incineration in a custom-made metal barrel, and her ashes were subsequently disposed of completely in the sea. The metal barrel was also disposed of, leaving no trace of Megan whatsoever. Foo was present at the incineration, and even arranged for incense to be burned to mask the incineration of Megan’s corpse.

  225. (b) Degree of premeditation and planning: The accused persons meticulously planned and executed the disposal of Megan’s body. Collectively, they conducted research, experimented with the design of the metal barrel, and arranged for the construction of the same. The actual disposal was conducted only on 8 May 2020, more than two months after Megan’s death.

  226. (c) Seriousness of predicate offences: Foo had disposed of Megan’s corpse to hide serious offences, ie, more than 13 months of child abuse involving an especially vulnerable victim, and causing and allowing the death of a child.

  227. (d) Motivation: Foo committed the offence to cover up her own serious misdeeds over the past year, as well as wrongs done by Wong. In particular, she did so to cover up how Megan died at their hands.

  228. (e) Presence of collusion: Foo had colluded with Wong and Nouvelle in the disposal of Megan’s corpse.

  229. [119] Similarly, the harm caused by Foo’s offence is very high, if not the absolute highest. I am unable to agree with Mr Wong that “the impediment caused to the discovery/investigations of [Megan’s] death was a period of about 5 months”. As the Prosecution highlights, there was “complete destruction of a corpse such that not even Megan’s ashes were recovered” [emphasis in original omitted]. Foo’s offence therefore severely impeded the detection, investigation and prosecution of serious offences. Indeed, the pathologist had difficulty with the determination of Megan’s cause of death owing to the absence of her remains, and only provided the possible causes on a speculative basis.

  230. [120] Given the extremely high culpability and harm present in the Disposal of Corpse Charge against Foo, this must be one of the worst cases contemplated under s 308B of the PC. A starting point of six years’ imprisonment, which is close to the prescribed maximum of seven years’ imprisonment, would thus be appropriate.

  231. [121] Such a starting point also coheres with related precedents involving s 201 of the PC, which criminalises the causing of the disappearance of evidence of an offence committed, or giving false information touching it, to screen an offender. Like a s 308B PC offence, the maximum imprisonment term for a s 201 PC offence is seven years’ imprisonment in cases where the predicate offence sought to be screened is punishable with imprisonment for life or with imprisonment which may extend to 20 years. Given these similarities between s 308B and s 201 of the PC, a comparison of Foo’s case with precedents involving s 201 of the PC would be apt.

  232. [122] I turn to consider the cases of Public Prosecutor v McCrea Michael [2006] 3 SLR(R) 677 (“McCrea”) and Public Prosecutor v Ong Pei Ling Audrey [2003] SGDC 337 (“Audrey Ong”). The offenders were McCrea and his lover, Audrey, and the victims were McCrea’s chauffeur (“Guan”) and his lover (“Suzie”). McCrea, Audrey, Guan, and Suzie lived in the same flat (McCrea at [2]). In the course of a fight with Guan, McCrea killed Guan (McCrea at [3]). McCrea also killed Suzie to silence her since she had witnessed the incident (McCrea at [7]). Following Guan and Suzie’s deaths, McCrea masterminded the commission of a s 201 PC offence, gathering a team consisting of himself and Audrey, as well as two other persons, “Gemma” and “Augustine”, to conceal the two corpses (McCrea at [17]):

  233. [123] McCrea was later charged for two counts of culpable homicide under s 304(b) of the PC for killing Guan and Suzie. He also faced a s 201 PC charge for causing evidence of his culpable homicide of Guan to disappear, with the intention of screening himself from legal punishment (McCrea at [1]). McCrea pleaded guilty to all three offences, and was sentenced to four years’ imprisonment for his s 201 PC offence (McCrea at [17]). On the other hand, Audrey pleaded guilty to two s 201 PC offences, and was sentenced to six years’ imprisonment for each offence, with the sentences running consecutively (Audrey Ong at [2] and [52]−[53]).

  234. [124] While these precedents similarly involved collusion, Foo’s case is much more serious, for at least five reasons:

  235. (a) Manner and extent of concealment or disposal: In McCrea and Audrey Ong, the corpses were concealed in a relatively unsophisticated manner. In contrast, Foo had disposed of Megan’s corpse and ashes in a highly sophisticated manner.

  236. (b) Degree of premeditation and planning: In McCrea and Audrey Ong, there was minimal premeditation and planning. Indeed, the offenders in those cases had difficulty finding a suitable location to conceal the corpses. In contrast, and as earlier explained, Foo’s offence was highly premeditated and thoroughly planned.

  237. (c) Seriousness of predicate offence: In McCrea and Audrey Ong, the offences by McCrea involved s 304(b) of the PC (knowingly causing death), committed against two adults. No further offences were concealed. In contrast, Foo was attempting to hide what was ultimately a more serious offence under s 304(a) of the PC (intentionally causing death) committed by Wong, her own offence of allowing Megan’s death, as well as a prolonged period of prior child abuse, committed against an especially vulnerable victim.

  238. (d) Motivation: Foo was more culpable than Audrey, since the former had sought to cover her own offending, while the latter was attempting to cover McCrea’s predicate offences.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.