Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 20 Feb 2026

General Division of the High Court

A contractor whose renovation work was flawed but largely complete was still paid

33Club Pte Ltd v Design Cliniq Pte Ltd

Feedback & support

[2026] SGHC 39Case no. Originating Claim No 552 of 2023

The decision, in one line

Not legal advice

A contractor whose renovation work was flawed but largely complete was still paid

Summary by laws.sgParagraph [155]

There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The present case underscores the hazards of embarking on a renovation project on the strength of a broad and informal understanding of the works to be done without properly discussing and fleshing out a carefully articulated agreement. In this particular instance, both parties appeared to be content to proceed without fastidious attention to detail, leaving critical matters of scope, standard and expectation largely undefined. Such initial looseness, however, carries consequences. When the essential particulars of a renovation project are not clearly discussed or recorded, the apparent flexibility of what had been “agreed” can later be pressed into service by all sides in ways that bear little to no resemblance to what may have been actually contemplated by either party at the time. This is therefore a case where the court must look beyond the parties’ ex post facto characterisations of their positions and examine the objective reality of how the arrangement was entered into and performed against the rather unfortunate backdrop of a shared failure to strive for clarity and clear expectations at the beginning.

  3. Facts

  4. [2] The claimant, 33Club Pte Ltd (“Claimant”), is a Singapore-incorporated company in the business of running or operating recreation clubs. Its managing director is Mr Tan Cheng Siong (“Mr Tan”). The defendant, Design Cliniq Pte Ltd (“Defendant”), is a Singapore-incorporated company in the business of building construction works. It has two directors, viz, Ms Tee Mei Huan (“Ms Tee”) and Mr Kee Chai Leong (“Mr Kee”), who are married to each other.

  5. [3] The Claimant operates a private members’ club under the name “33Club” (“Club”) at 22 Malacca Street #01-02 (“Premises”) that spans 3,800 sq ft across two floors. The present originating claim finds its genesis in the Claimant’s engagement of the Defendant to carry out renovation works at the Premises (“Renovation Works”) in or around May 2022. The Renovation Works included the installation of travertine fluted tiles on the walls primarily around a staircase, as well as a myriad of other works. The Claimant’s design consultant was Syrenka Studio GmbH (“Syrenka”), whose representative was one Ms Podbielski Joanna Mifsud (“Ms Podbielski”). A WhatsApp chat group was created where the various parties had discussions relating to the Renovation Works (“Renovation Chat Group”).

  6. The commencement of the Renovation Works

  7. [4] On 20 May 2022, the Defendant sent the Claimant a bill of quantities document titled “BQ for Club 33: RB Building 22 Malacca Street” (“20 May BQ”) via a WhatsApp message, explaining that “this is a rough BQ of how the work is suppose [sic] to flow, break down Phase 1, Phase 2, Phase 3 and Phase 4 / please read through and help me sign back would be good for documentation and taking note”. In this document, the following works were listed:

  8. (a) for Phase 1 – preliminary works, hoarding works, scaffolding works, hacking works, miscellaneous works, professional engineer (“PE”) and authorities;

  9. (b) for Phase 2 – plastering works, mezzanine works, ceiling/cladding/roofing works, air-conditioning works, plumbing works, tiling works;

  10. (c) for Phase 3 – mechanical and electrical works, glass works, carpentry works, worktop works, fluted panel cladding, painting works; and

  11. (d) for Phase 4 – fixtures, furniture and other equipment works, wallpaper works, feature wall painting.

  12. In response to the Defendant’s message, Mr Tan replied: “[j]ust proceed as stated rough BQ …”.

  13. [5] The landlord of the Premises required the Defendant to procure public liability insurance coverage for the Renovation Works. The Defendant sought such insurance from NTUC Income Insurance Co-operative Ltd (“NTUC”). On 20 May 2022, while discussing the issue of insurance in a separate WhatsApp chat group, Ms Tee indicated the “Start date” as “21/5”, the “End date” as “1/8 to be launched but Incase [sic] defects periods” and the “Contract value” as “$300k”. She then sent those details to the Renovation Chat Group at 9.13pm, for the Claimant’s confirmation. In this message, Ms Tee indicated the “Start date” as “21/5” and the “End date” as “1/8” but left the “Contract value” empty for the Claimant’s input. At 9.58pm, Mr Tan sent a message in the Renovation Chat Group indicating the “Contract value” to be “$500k” (“20 May WhatsApp Message”). Ms Tee then forwarded Mr Tan’s 20 May WhatsApp Message to her separate WhatsApp chat group where she was initially discussing the issue of insurance. The insurance policy from NTUC (“Insurance Policy”) was issued on 23 May 2022, with a period of insurance from 24 May 2022 to 1 September 2023 (inclusive of a 12-month defects liability period). A copy of the Insurance Policy was sent to the Renovation Chat Group that evening.

  14. [6] On 23 May 2022, the Defendant commenced hacking works at the Premises.

  15. [7] On 2 June 2022, the Claimant paid the Defendant $50,000. This was apparently payment for Phase 1 of the Renovation Works as set out in the 20 May BQ, including hacking, scaffolding and ceiling partition works.

  16. [8] On 9 June 2022, Syrenka sent the parties the first set of 30% schematic drawings. On 17 June 2022, Syrenka sent the parties the second set of 50% schematic drawings.

  17. [9] On 18 June 2022, Ms Tee sent to the Renovation Chat Group pictures of a handwritten note (“Handwritten Note”). Ms Tee claims that the Handwritten Note sets out the Defendant’s unit rates for the Renovation Works. In these proceedings, the Defendant has also provided a transcription of the Handwritten Note (“Transcribed Handwritten Note”). Mr Tan accepts that the pictures of the Handwritten Note were sent (to him and others) in the Renovation Chat Group, but what the contents of the Handwritten Note are, and the Defendant’s interpretation in the Transcribed Handwritten Note, is disputed by the Claimant.

  18. [10] On 30 June 2022, Syrenka sent the parties the third set of 100% schematic and 80% construction drawings.

  19. The travertine fluted tiles

  20. [11] Initially, the travertine fluted tiles for the Renovation Works were to be obtained from a supplier in Singapore. However, on 1 July 2022, Mr Tan sent a message in the Renovation Chat Group indicating that he wanted to “change to special tiles or something else as i dont want to pay for $60k+ for fluted and paint over velvet paint… nothing special and that kind of crazy price”.

  21. [12] Subsequently, on 10 July 2022, Mr Tan sent pictures of travertine fluted tiles from a supplier in China in the Renovation Chat Group. The following messages were then exchanged:

  22. [13] On 14 July 2022, Mr Tan sent a picture of a cross-sectional drawing of the travertine fluted tiles in the Renovation Chat Group. The picture indicated that each tile had an overall thickness of 18mm and a hump thickness of 7mm, thereby implying a base thickness of 11mm.

  23. [14] On 16 July 2022, Ms Tee and Mr Tan discussed the installation method of such travertine fluted tiles in the Renovation Chat Group. In these discussions, Mr Tan asserted the travertine fluted tiles to have a thickness of 18mm. The following messages were then exchanged:

  24. As alluded to in the extract above, Mr Tan sent Ms Tee a link to a YouTube video regarding “stone clip installation”, which appears to be in relation to the use of a mechanical anchorage system.

  25. [15] On 16 September 2022, the travertine fluted tiles arrived on-site. According to the Defendant, the tiles in question had an overall thickness of 16mm and a base thickness of 6mm or less.

  26. [16] On 17 September 2022, the Defendant began installing the travertine fluted tiles on the walls with an adhesive. The installation was completed in about two weeks.

  27. The events after the Renovation Works

  28. [17] On 28 September 2022, Mr Tan sent a message in the Renovation Chat Group stating: “Pls clear up all work and retreat all reno work by this week / My furnitures [sic] will be in next week and no more work can be done”.

  29. [18] On or around 28 September 2022, a new WhatsApp chat group was created including the various parties to discuss the identification and rectification of any defects (“Defects Chat Group”). On 10 October 2022, Mr Tan sent a message in the Defects Chat Group stating: “Lijun will do the renovation quality checks on 33. He have [sic] a checklist to check through all areas. Joanne pls work with Lijun to touch on all the highlighted areas until satisfactory condition for handover”. In this context, “Lijun” was Mr Lai Lijun (“Mr Lai”), a friend of Mr Tan who had agreed to assist him in inspecting the Renovation Works, whilst “Joanne” was Ms Tee.

  30. [19] On 13 October 2022, the Claimant paid the Defendant a further $50,000.

  31. The accidents in December 2022

  32. [20] On 6 December 2022, several pieces of the travertine fluted tiles dislodged and fell off the wall. Mr Lai suffered an injury in the process.

  33. [21] Ms Tee went to the Premises that evening. She sent messages and a video captioned “Marble walk through Solution methods” (“Proposed Rectification Video”) on the Defects Chat Group to explain her proposed rectification of the dislodged tiles, which was essentially to drill the tiles into the walls using screws, to conceal the screws with a sealer, and to fill the gaps between the tiles with some kind of material. Mr Tan replied stating “[y]ou better get it certify by your QS”. The Defendant completed the rectification works on 8 December 2022.

  34. [22] Thereafter, the Claimant raised concerns that the screws on the travertine fluted tiles were unesthetic. On 3 January 2023, Ms Tee prepared a mock-up tile with screws concealed by putty of matching colour. According to Ms Tee, the mock-up was reviewed by Mr Lai and one Mr Shah (the Claimant’s manager), and the latter informed Ms Tee that it was acceptable. The Defendant then carried out the finishing works on the tiles. Subsequent discussions took place between the Claimant, the Defendant and Syrenka via WhatsApp and e-mail to ensure that the touch ups were adequately done.

  35. [23] On 18 January 2023, Mr Ling Lee Teck (“Mr Ling”), a PE, certified the following regarding the travertine fluted tiles:

  36. [24] On 17 and 19 January 2023, Mr Ling endorsed photographs of the method of installation of the travertine fluted tiles.

  37. [25] Sometime in early February 2022, the Defendant submitted the travertine fluted tiles to Setsco Services Pte Ltd (“Setsco”) to determine their mineral composition. On 20 February 2023, the report (“Setsco Report”) was issued and it found that the tiles were made of travertine limestone.

  38. [26] Separately, the Defendant had also installed several door closers in the Premises. On 17 December 2022, one of the door closers came loose and injured one of the Claimant’s employees, Mr Jordan Ooi Boon Lee, as he attempted to open the door. According to the Defendant, it attended to the rectification of the door closer that day.

  39. The events after the accidents in December 2022

  40. [27] On 31 January 2023, the Club had its official opening.

  41. [28] From 31 March 2023 to 26 April 2023, the Defendant issued 14 invoices to the Claimant for various aspects of the Renovation Works, with a total invoiced amount of $609,719.50. On 8 May 2023, the Defendant issued Invoice 0820 to the Claimant for the sum of $609,789.50, which consolidated the 14 earlier invoices, and from which $100,000 would be deducted to take into account the Claimant’s previous payments. According to Ms Tee, the $70 discrepancy between the total invoiced amount across the 14 original invoices and the invoiced amount in Invoice 0820 was the result of a clerical error, and the correct figure should be that found in the former, ie, $609,719.50.

  42. [29] On 8 May 2023, the Defendant also issued Invoice 0821 to the Claimant for the sum of $751.01. According to Ms Tee, this sum represents the difference between the sum of $6,000 which the Defendant paid to another contractor on the Claimant’s behalf, and a credit note of $5,248.99 which the Defendant issued to the Claimant.

  43. [30] Subsequent attempts by the Defendant to seek payment from the Claimant were unsuccessful. On 12 June 2023, the Defendant’s lawyers sent a letter of demand to the Claimant for the sum of $509,789.50. Further correspondence took place between the Claimant’s lawyers and the Defendant’s lawyers to clarify the scope of the Defendant’s claim.

  44. [31] On 20 June 2023, the Defendant issued Invoice 0847 to the Claimant for the sum of $92,888.31. This invoice comprised: (a) professional fees of $28,669.50 for professional services such as Mr Ling’s certification, licensed plumbers and the Setsco Report, with a further 15% project management fee layered on top; (b) 41 additional drawings worth $10,650 which the Defendant allegedly had to produce on-site as they were not provided by Syrenka; and (c) project management fees of $53,568.81 at 10% of the invoices of the Claimant’s other contractors.

  45. [33] From 6 July 2023 to 23 August 2023, further correspondence took place between the Claimant’s lawyers and the Defendant’s lawyers. The following points are salient:

  46. (a) Two payment claims and a payment response were exchanged pursuant to the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2004 (2020 Rev Ed) (“SOPA”). The payment claims were eventually withdrawn by the Defendant.

  47. (b) On 21 August 2023, the Claimant’s lawyers sent a letter to the Defendant’s lawyers giving notice of the Claimant’s intention to carry out rectification works in respect of the travertine fluted tiles. The proposed rectification works was said to span over two months, and the Claimant demanded that the Defendant pay it $778,000, representing the additional losses, costs and expenses incurred due to the further rectification works.

  48. [34] On 26 August 2023, the Claimant filed HC/OC 552/2023 in these proceedings.

  49. [35] On 29 September 2023, the Defendant sent the Claimant its Payment Claim No 1 (Revised) for the sum of $605,408.82. This payment claim included Invoices 0820, 0821 and 0847. However, the quantum of Invoice 0820 was indicated as $611,769.50. On 1 October 2023, the Claimant filed its original Statement of Claim in these proceedings. On 13 October 2023, the Claimant’s lawyers sent the Defendant’s lawyers the Claimant’s Payment Response No 1 (Revised) which alleged that the Defendant owed the Claimant $236,579.49.

  50. The Adjudication Application

  51. [36] On 23 October 2023, the Defendant lodged Adjudication Application No SOP A236 of 2023 (“AA 236”) with the Singapore Mediation Centre pursuant to the SOPA. Dr Evert Christopher Vickery was appointed as the adjudicator (“Adjudicator”). AA 236 was heard on 4 November 2023. The Adjudicator issued his determination on 30 November 2023 (“Adjudication Determination”) and awarded the Defendant $86,281.40 (“Adjudicated Amount”). The Claimant has since paid the Adjudicated Amount to the Defendant.

  52. [37] In the course of the AA 236 proceedings, the following matters transpired:

  53. (a) The Adjudicator accepted the Defendant’s explanation that the discrepancy between the quantum for Invoice 0820 as originally issued to the Claimant (viz, $609,789.50) and as filed in the Payment Claim No 1 (Revised) (viz, $611,769.50) was due to clerical errors. In gist, the correct figure was said to be that of the latter, ie, $611,769.50, save that the Claimant should be further credited $5,600.

  54. (b) The Claimant submitted a set of alternative rates for the Renovation Works provided by Mr Teo Fook Keong (“Mr Teo”) of Hong Giap Construction and Trading Co Pte Ltd (“Hong Giap Quotation”) for the Adjudicator’s consideration if he was minded to make an award to the Defendant on a quantum meruit basis. Pursuant to the Hong Giap Quotation, the total price of the Renovation Works would be $411,786.90. The Claimant objected to paying for hacking, carpentry, tiling and masonry, and painting works, and if those items were excluded, the total price of the Renovation Works would be (on the back of the applicable portions of the Hong Giap Quotation) about $157,581.90.

  55. [38] The key findings made in the Adjudication Determination were as follows:

  56. (a) The $500,000 stated in the 20 May WhatsApp Message was clearly rooted in the context of obtaining insurance coverage. It would defy logic for Mr Tan to have not accepted Ms Tee’s proposal of $300,000 if the stipulated figure was meant to be the price of the Renovation Works. Conversely, it made sense for Mr Tan to request an insurance policy based on a contract value of $500,000, as it would provide an enhanced level of coverage. The reality was that the parties had not agreed on the contract price.

  57. (b) It was impossible to correlate the contents of the Handwritten Note with the heads of claim set out in the Payment Claim No 1 (Revised). Any such correlation relied heavily on guess work. The descriptions in the Handwritten Note were abbreviated and insufficiently precise to indicate the scope of the work item, and were accompanied by lump sums instead of unit rates, leaving the reader to infer the relevant unit rate. The Handwritten Note was thus not a viable tool for establishing valuations of works executed by the Defendant.

  58. (c) The Defendant did not refer to any market rates, supplier invoices or other reliable sources to justify the rates used in its invoices. The Defendant did not provide any documentary evidence to support its claim for 41 additional drawings and project management fees under Invoice 0847. The whole framework on which the Defendant’s payment claim was founded was fundamentally deficient.

  59. (d) Since the completion of the Renovation Works, the Claimant did not raise any objections with the invoices issued. It was only after the Defendant issued its payment claims that the Claimant raised objections in its payment responses. The Claimant’s failure to take any meaningful action to make payment to the Defendant was signally unreasonable, and there was considerable merit in requiring the Claimant to make payment to the Defendant on a quantum meruit basis.

  60. (e) The Adjudication Award of $86,281.40 was computed by adding the Hong Giap Quotation of $157,581.90 with the sum of $28,699.50 in Invoice 0847 which the Claimant did not dispute in its Payment Response No 1 (Revised) and subtracting the $100,000 which the Claimant had already paid the Defendant.

  61. The Claimant’s claim

  62. [39] The Claimant pleads that the Defendant owed a duty of care to the Claimant and other third-party users of the Premises.

  63. [40] In relation to the travertine fluted tiles, the Claimant pleads that the Defendant’s installation of the tiles with the use of adhesive was defective, unsatisfactory and/or negligent. By drilling the tiles into the wall with screws, the Defendant had damaged the aesthetic value of the tiles and compromised the safety and structural integrity of the tiles.

  64. [41] In relation to the door closers, the Claimant pleads that, had the door closer been installed with reasonable care, skill and diligence, it would not have come loose shortly after the Renovation Works were completed.

  65. [42] In relation to the rest of the Renovation Works, it would be unnecessary for me to set out in full detail the Claimant’s myriad claims. Broadly speaking, the Claimant pleads that the Defendant had also caused other defects, including among others: (a) failing to carry out works in accordance with the design drawings provided by Syrenka; (b) failing to deliver satisfactory carpentry pieces; (c) failing to properly cut various tiles so as to achieve a smooth running edge; and (d) failing to construct a staircase with handrails. The Claimant pleads that the Defendant was negligent in carrying out these other works.

  66. [43] The Claimant seeks damages to rectify these defective works. In the alternative, the Claimant seeks a reduction in the price to be paid for the Renovation Works to account for the diminution in value caused by the defects.

  67. The Defendant’s counterclaim

  68. [44] The Defendant pleads that it has suffered loss and damage arising from the Claimant’s failure to make payment for Invoices 0820 (for $611,769.50), 0821 (for $751.01) and 0847 (for $92,888.31). The Defendant gives the Claimant credit for $50,000 paid on 2 June 2022, $50,000 paid on 13 October 2022, $5,600 which the Defendant conceded should be deducted in AA 236, and $86,281.40 which was the Adjudicated Amount. Thus, the Defendant counterclaims for $513,527.42. In the alternative, the Defendant seeks damages calculated on a quantum meruit basis.

  69. Issues to be determined

  70. [45] In evaluating the Claimant’s claim, I will have to determine whether the Renovation Works were truly defective, and if so, whether the Claimant had suffered any loss in that regard. In evaluating the Defendant’s counterclaim, I will have to determine the terms of the contract between the parties, in particular the scope and the price of the Renovation Works, as well as the effect (if any) of the Adjudication Determination on these proceedings. I deal with each of these in turn.

  71. Whether the Claimant’s claim should succeed

  72. [46] To succeed in a claim in negligence, a claimant must prove that: (a) the defendant owed the claimant a duty of care; (b) the defendant’s conduct breached its duty of care by falling below the requisite standard of care; (c) the claimant suffered loss; and (d) the defendant’s breach of duty was the cause of the loss (Chen Qiangshi v Hong Fey CDY Construction Pte Ltd [2014] SGHC 177 at [125]).

  73. [47] Generally, a contractor owes a duty of care to those employing its services (Management Corporation Strata Title Plan No 3556 v Orion-One Development Pte Ltd [2020] 3 SLR 373 at [147]). The Defendant does not argue otherwise. Therefore, the key question in the present case is whether the Defendant’s conduct in carrying out the Renovation Works fell below the requisite standard of care, or put simply, whether the Renovation Works were defective.

  74. The Renovation Works

  75. Travertine fluted tiles

  76. [48] At the heart of the present dispute lies the dislodgment of the travertine fluted tiles on 6 December 2022. The circumstances of that incident, together with the manner in which rectification was undertaken, are at the very core of this case. They frame both the factual matrix against which the competing claims ought to be assessed, as well as the legal principles that ought to guide this court’s decision.

  77. (1) The initial installation and dislodgment of the travertine fluted tiles

  78. [49] I will first discuss the matter of how the travertine fluted tiles were initially installed, for that, in many ways, is the origin of the dispute. In saying this, I should stress that although both parties devoted considerable court time to whose fault it was that the tiles initially dislodged, it was in my view, not a central consideration in determining whether the Claimant’s claim ought to succeed. This is because broadly speaking, the claim does not seek damages by virtue of the (ostensibly less than satisfactory) modus of the initial affixion, but rather by virtue of what followed – in particular, the circumstances of the rectification – which assume far greater importance in the resolution of the issues before me. Indeed, it would be entirely artificial to consider what remedies the Claimant should be entitled to (if any) from the point of view from when the tiles first fell, when the reality is that the tiles have since been refixed onto the wall, albeit in a manner which is disputed.

  79. [50] In any event, the evidence before me, on balance, suggests that both parties share some blame for the travertine fluted tiles dislodging and falling on 6 December 2022. I deal first with why the Claimant, notwithstanding his position qua employer of the Defendant’s services, bore some of the blame.

  80. [52] For completeness, I note that Mr Tan in cross-examination suggested for the first time that he did in fact ask his supplier for a method of statement and had sent it to Ms Tee. To the extent Mr Tan claims this to be the case, I disbelieve his testimony. Not only was it not mentioned in his Affidavit of Evidence-in-Chief (“AEIC”), but his testimony was also inconsistent, at one time suggesting that he sent the method of statement to Ms Tee via a message on WhatsApp, and at another time suggesting that he communicated it to her verbally over the phone. There is, in any event, no evidence before me to corroborate such a belated and self-interested claim.

  81. [53] Second, Mr Tan’s instructions on the exact specifications of the travertine fluted tiles in the lead-up to their delivery were, at times, completely wrong. The initial estimate of 11mm given by Mr Tan for the base thickness of the tiles proved materially inaccurate; the actual base thickness of the tiles eventually delivered was only 6mm (see [13] and [15] above). This is corroborated by the fact that when Mr Ling was given a physical sample of the tile during cross-examination and asked to measure the thickness of the tile, he measured the base thickness to be 6mm. According to Ms Tee, the Defendant had originally prepared anchoring hooks based on the specifications initially provided by Mr Tan, but those anchoring hooks could not be used for tiles with a base thickness of 6mm. To be fair, Ms Tee did not adduce any evidence to support her assertion that the Defendant had originally prepared such anchoring hooks, but neither did counsel for the Claimant (“Mr Chung”) put to Ms Tee that she was lying on this point, and I have no reason to doubt Ms Tee’s evidence in this regard. Given the substantial variance between the numbers initially provided by Mr Tan and the actual numbers on-site, it is also entirely understandable why the Defendant was unable to utilise the anchoring hooks it had originally prepared.

  82. [54] The two points above, of course, do not detract from the fact that the standard of care expected of the Defendant, as the contractor who held itself out as capable of installing the travertine fluted tiles, would reasonably include the taking of necessary steps to mitigate the above problems. The evidence suggests that there were straightforward means to verify the safety of the initial installation of the tiles, including the conduct of a simple pull-out test – an exercise that, as I later note, could be done relatively inexpensively (see [70] below). Yet, despite the sparse, and indeed, sometimes, clearly erroneous information from Mr Tan, the Defendant did not avail itself of such a verification measure. A contractor cannot on the one hand profess competence to do the work, but on the other disclaim responsibility when the method of affixation it elected from experience ultimately proves unsafe and incongruent with site conditions. Indeed, in its written submissions, the Defendant conceded that one of the causes of initial dislodgment of the tiles was arguably its poor choice of bonding material and its poor workmanship in the installation process.

  83. [55] For the above reasons, I am of the view that both parties share blame for the improper initial affixation that ultimately resulted in the dislodgment of the travertine fluted tiles. Nonetheless, this point is something of a storm in a teacup. As I observed earlier, the focus of this court’s inquiry lies largely not in any negligence in the initial affixation, but in the sufficiency of the subsequent rectification works. I thus turn to this latter issue.

  84. (2) The drilling of screws into the travertine fluted tiles

  85. [56] Putting aside whether the rectification works for the travertine fluted tiles were aesthetically pleasing, a matter which I will discuss later on, I have little reason to doubt the propriety of the rectification works carried out by the Defendant. In this regard, I find the Claimant’s various criticisms regarding the drilling of screws into the tiles to be without merit.

  86. [57] Mr Tan contends that the Claimant was never given notice of, and never agreed to, the screwing of the travertine fluted tiles into the walls. In cross-examination, Mr Tan conceded that he was informed about the rectification method but insisted he never accepted it. Putting aside this apparent retreat, I have little hesitation in rejecting the contention for there is evidence of extensive discussions between Ms Tee, Mr Tan and the Claimant’s staff regarding the rectification method of using screws and the necessary touch ups thereafter. In fact, on 6 December 2022 at 10.15pm (ie, the evening Ms Tee attended to the Premises after the tiles fell), Ms Tee sent the Proposed Rectification Video to the Defects Chat Group, seemingly to obtain in-principle approval for the proposed rectification method, to which Mr Tan replied stating: “[y]ou better get it certify by your QS”. There is also evidence of subsequent discussions between the Defendant, the Claimant and Syrenka on the need to do touch ups with a view to minimising its unsightly nature (see [21]–[22] above). Seen against the backdrop of such evidence, Mr Tan’s point appears to be that he never approved the rectification method in unambiguous and specific terms, such as by explicitly stating something along the lines of: “I confirm I approve the use of screws for rectification purposes”. But on such points, the court is concerned with substance over form. For the same reason, it is disingenuous for Mr Tan to take issue with how the method of rectification endorsed by Mr Ling was proposed by the Defendant as opposed to Mr Ling, when the WhatsApp correspondence shows that Mr Tan was well aware that the use of screws was proposed by Ms Tee, and he then asked Ms Tee to get the method certified.

  87. [58] Mr Tan also contended in trial for the first time that he understood the use of screws to be only a temporary measure as he would never have agreed to such a rectification method as a permanent solution because it was “so ugly”. I do not accept this. Such a belief stands in stark contrast with the fact that no express representation that the rectification works were only temporary was ever made, as Mr Tan eventually conceded in cross-examination, and there was therefore no basis upon which such a belief could reasonably have formed.

  88. [59] Mr Tan’s attempt to justify his belief that the rectification works were merely temporary on the ground that they were unesthetic does not assist him. If that was a genuine concern, one would have expected him to have raised the need for a more permanent (and more aesthetically pleasing) solution in the lead-up to the official opening of the Club on 31 January 2023. Yet, conspicuously, no such request was made at the time, and instead the Claimant was more concerned with the use of putty to cover up the screws. What is, in my mind, also telling is that, if Mr Tan genuinely believed that the use of screws was nothing more than a temporary fix, then it is surprising how, for many months after December 2022, he never once posed the obvious question to the Defendant: what is the timeline for when the screws would be replaced with a permanent and more-aesthetically pleasing method of installation?

  89. [60] I might add that this conclusion is further reinforced by the fact that Mr Tan replied to Ms Tee’s Proposed Rectification Video sent on the Defects Chat Group stating: “[y]ou better get it certify by your QS” (see [21] above). Such a demand sits oddly with his characterisation of the rectification works as temporary. I say this because a temporary measure, by nature, would not ordinarily attract the need for certification, which would generally be reserved for works intended to constitute a permanent solution. Even as recently as the Claimant’s letter of demand dated 4 July 2023, the Claimant did not demand that the Defendant replace the screws with a permanent solution, but rather demanded reports certifying that the method of installation was safe (see [32] above). Quite clearly, in my view, this notion of a temporary measure was a mere after-thought, as there is no evidence of Mr Tan ever expressing this “understanding” (as he so asserts) until these proceedings.

  90. [61] In any event, one cannot in the same breath contend that the rectification works involving screws were not approved by the Claimant, and yet at the same time contend that the Claimant only approved its use on a temporary basis. Those two propositions, in my view, are mutually incompatible.

  91. (3) The safety of the rectification works and Mr Ling’s certification

  92. [62] Mr Tan also contends that he harboured real concerns about the safety and structural integrity of the rectification works. Mr Tan claims in his AEIC that he had, at the time, demanded that the Defendant do the following: (a) seek the Claimant’s approval before commencing any rectification works; (b) obtain and implement a method of installation proposed by a PE or qualified person before commencing rectification works; (c) obtain a report from the PE or qualified person giving assurances as to the safety of the rectification works, including the load and stress calculations for their proposed method of installation; (d) obtain a failure analysis test report from Setsco for the cause of the defects; and (e) procure sufficient insurance coverage for the rectification works. Mr Tan claims that the Defendant did not comply with any of these requests.

  93. [63] With respect, while there is some evidence of discussions in the Defects Chat Group regarding certification of the rectification works, the Setsco Report and insurance coverage, there is, contrary to Mr Tan’s suggestion, no evidence in the WhatsApp messages that he had listed all these as demands to the Defendant at the material time. Even in the Claimant’s 4 July 2023 letter of demand, the requests made were, contrary to Mr Tan’s suggestion, of a different nature (see [32] above). It is thus clear to me that the demands listed by Mr Tan in his AEIC were retrospective assertions. In my view, they should be accorded little to no evidential weight. One can, of course, unilaterally assert after the event that further tests ought to have been conducted. But such self-serving assertions say little about what was in fact reasonably required (or indeed expected) at the time.

  94. [64] To be fair, in court, Mr Tan appeared to take a much more restrained stance and focused primarily on his request for certification from a PE. To the extent his point was simply that he wanted sufficient assurance that the rectification works were safe, this was not unfair. On this point, there was simply no basis for me to reject the evidence of Mr Ling, in particular his certification of the safety of the rectification of the travertine fluted tiles and his endorsement of the method of installation used (see [23]–[24] above). From his evidence, it is clear to me that the use of screws was an extremely safe, even if less than aesthetically elegant, method to install the tiles. As Mr Ling testified, screws in this specific context provide significant shear force that would prevent the tiles from falling. According to Mr Ling, each screw on its own was capable of bearing many times the weight of a single tile used here. The method of installation endorsed by Mr Ling involved two screws being drilled in the top-middle and bottom-middle of each tile. In the present case, the undisputed evidence is that at least two screws were drilled into each tile, and some tiles even had three or four screws. It follows that many tiles had even more fastening points than had been needed under the plans approved by Mr Ling. This would have rendered the tiles so firmly affixed that it would be unfathomable, at least from a technical standpoint, to conclude that the installation was unsafe.

  95. [65] In order to discredit Mr Ling’s evidence, the Claimant has attempted a root-and-branch attack of his certification and endorsements. I deal with the main points raised by the Claimant and explain why, in my view, they do not go any way to advancing the case against the Defendant. I emphasise that there was a whole swathe of challenges (none of which were meritorious) and I only deal with the more pertinent ones here:

  96. (a) Mr Tan takes the position that Mr Ling’s evidence was not credible as what he needed was certification by a “third-party PE”, but Mr Ling was not such an individual since Mr Ling was the Defendant’s “own PE”. This is presumably an allusion to the fact that Mr Ling had issued his certification on the Defendant’s letterhead. It was put to Mr Ling in cross-examination that this was done because what Mr Ling had issued was not an independent certification and Mr Ling wanted the Defendant to take responsibility for it as well. That assertion was as speculative as it was baseless. If that was truly Mr Ling’s intention, why would he then defend the very certification in court? It would be wholly incoherent to take especial pains to disown the certification in form, only to stand by it on oath. The argument, with respect, unravels under the weight of its own contradictions. It is obvious that a much simpler explanation belies the certification being issued under the Defendant’s letterhead – Ms Tee has attested that she arranged for this, and Mr Ling was in all likelihood agnostic as to what letterhead was used, as the substance of the certification was what was relevant, and not the letterhead it was issued on. For completeness, I note that this argument was also rejected by the Adjudicator in his Adjudication Determination. As he rightly pointed out, it is irrelevant on what letterhead Mr Ling made his certification, as his statutory duties and liabilities as a PE are held by him personally.

  97. (b) The Claimant also takes issue with the fact that there were annotations on the documents that accompany Mr Ling’s certification which suggested that amendments were made to the documents after the date of the certification. These include, pertinently, a seeming clarification dated 25 January 2023 that the thickness of the travertine fluted tile on-site was not 17mm but 18mm. In cross-examination, Mr Chung put to Mr Ling that there were “various inconsistencies or errors” that were “inexplicable” as the annotations were not consistently made to all references to the tiles being 17mm thick. I would only point out that, in my view, the inconsistencies in question were minor and did not detract from Mr Ling’s certification. As Mr Ling pointed out, and I tend to agree, whether the tiles were 17mm or 18mm thick had “[z]ero significance” to his assessment, even if he accepted it would have been ideal for him to have ensured full consistency in the annotations.

  98. (c) Mr Ling’s testimony was that he inspected the Premises on a particular occasion one to three days before he issued his certification (ie, sometime between 15 January 2023 to 17 January 2023). In cross-examination, Mr Chung put to Mr Ling that he did not actually carry out any site inspections for the purposes of his certification. Mr Chung postulated that, because the invoice issued by Mr Ling to the Defendant was dated 21 December 2022 and included the phrase “3 NOS” in the item description, that means the Defendant had sent three travertine fluted tiles and the method of statement to Mr Ling on 21 December 2022, and any inspection made by Mr Ling was in relation to those three tiles. I would merely observe that such speculation had little factual basis underlying it; suffice it to say that I saw no reason for Mr Ling to lie on the stand that he did in fact inspect the Premises.

  99. (d) During trial, Mr Chung also took especial pains to express concerns that while the method of installation endorsed by Mr Ling involved two screws being drilled in the top-middle and bottom-middle of each travertine fluted tile, the screws were affixed on-site in a random manner and some tiles had not two screws but three to four screws. However, the fact that the screws were not affixed exactly in the manner set out in the drawings was in fact noted in those very drawings, which included an express disclaimer that “screw installation varies on actual site condition”. On the issue of some tiles having more than two screws, as I explained at [64] above, it should be rather obvious that the use of more screws would, generally make the installation more secure, not less. As to the supposedly random manner in which the screws were drilled, Ms Tee explained that the screws could not be drilled into the tiles uniformly due to the wave-like nature of the tiles and the varying surface materials behind the tiles (including calcium silicate, concrete walls and metal cladding). Although there was no corroborative evidence for this explanation, I did not find it unbelievable, and more importantly, the Claimant did not adduce any evidence to disprove it.

  100. [66] All in all, the attack on Mr Ling’s evidence was unpersuasive and did little to detract from its general credibility. I make two further points in this regard.

  101. [67] First, Mr Chung, in his cross-examination, embedded in his questions a variety of suppositions about how Mr Ling ought to have assessed the rectification works, including suggesting: (a) that Mr Ling’s omission to mention in his certification that the Defendant was still carrying touch up works on the tiles at the time rendered the certification unreliable; (b) that Mr Ling’s omission to discuss in the certification the cause for the initial dislodgment of the tiles rendered the certification of the subsequent method of installation unreliable; (c) that Mr Ling did not do “mathematical calibrations” before issuing his certification, (d) that Mr Ling’s omission to discuss in the certification the calcium silicate backing of the wall behind the tiles rendered the certification unreliable; and (e) that Mr Ling failed to consider, from a safety perspective, whether the tiles would crack due to the drilling of the screws.

  102. [68] With respect, Mr Chung’s views were not, despite how they were couched, evidence, and no PE was called by the Claimant to contradict anything that Mr Ling said. It would be quite untenable for the court to prefer counsel’s assertions on technical matters over the evidence of a qualified professional. In the course of cross-examination, Mr Chung appeared to operate on the footing that, by framing questions in a way that seemingly authoritatively asserted how these technical matters work, he might thereby erode the credibility of Mr Ling. However, Mr Ling quite pointedly observed, at one point, that one should be cautious of relying on laymen intuitions in determining issues such as structural safety, and as a PE, his role was not to conform to such lay perceptions but to apply objective technical parameters of tolerance and safety when judging such matters. I agree. At its core, the court’s conclusion on such technical matters must ultimately remain anchored in assessing the most probative evidence. It is for this reason that the court should generally accept unopposed expert evidence unless it is obviously lacking in defensibility (Saeng-Un Udom v Public Prosecutor [2001] 2 SLR(R) 1 at [25]–[26]); whilst I am cognisant that Mr Ling was technically called by the Defendant as a factual rather than expert witness, the same principles ought to apply in so far as the evidence led from him was in relation to his professional expertise. I might add that the court should be especially wary of substituting the views of a professional with counsel’s suppositions couched as technical insight, however confidently counsel articulated such beliefs as being conventional wisdom in questioning.

  103. [69] Second, the evidence suggests that Mr Tan did not in fact harbour any of the safety concerns he claims to have had at the material time. After the travertine fluted tiles were drilled into the walls with screws by 8 December 2022, the Claimant did not take any substantive actions until its 4 July 2023 letter of demand, where it eventually alleged that the rectification works were still defective, even when the Club had officially opened on 31 January 2023 and had continued operating since. If the Claimant was genuinely troubled about the safety of the rectification works, Mr Tan would have raised the alarm much earlier or pressured the Defendant to provide a solution. Mr Tan’s explanation in trial, that he was waiting for the Defendant to come back to him about further rectifications, was unbelievable. Why would a club owner, genuinely concerned about the safety of his “high net worth client[s]” (as he contends the Club services) take such a passive approach? Indeed, Mr Tan himself conceded in trial that, since the completion of the rectification works for the tiles by 8 December 2022, there have been no further incidents of the tiles falling, which suggests to me that the safety concerns were more speculative than genuine.

  104. [71] There is perhaps one further point that would be useful to make about how Mr Ling’s involvement potentially impacts the liability of the Defendant for any alleged defects. At least to the extent that the issue before me pertains to safety, a defendant is generally allowed to rely on a third-party to discharge his due diligence obligations or otherwise insulate himself from negligence liability (Tradewaves Ltd v Standard Chartered Bank [2017] SGHC 93 (“Tradewaves”) at [251]). The fact that the third-party’s input could have been, on hindsight, inaccurate or incorrect does not prejudice or impugn a defendant’s reliance on it in so far as the defendant had no reason to doubt the third-party’s competence and good faith (see, in a somewhat distinct context, the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in Fullowka v Pinkerton’s of Canada Ltd [2010] 1 SCR 132 (“Fullowka”) at [89]). In the present case, there is no evidence to suggest that the Defendant failed to assess the identity, capacity and credibility of Mr Ling as a PE, and failed to satisfy itself as to Mr Ling’s experience and competence (Tradewaves at [251]), or that the Defendant relied on Mr Ling’s certification in bad faith (Fullowka at [89]). In that sense, even if Mr Ling was negligent or otherwise shoddy in how he had certified the rectification of the travertine fluted tiles, and that it remained unsafe in spite of his certification, the Defendant could still be said to have fulfilled its standard of care in relying on Mr Ling’s certification. To be clear, this is not to suggest that Mr Ling was in any way negligent, but only to make the point that even if he were, relying on Mr Ling to certify the safety of the tiles post-rectification on these set of facts would have potentially been an effective defence by the Defendant to insulate itself from liability in relation to any enduring safety issues.

  105. (4) The expert evidence

  106. [72] In coming to my conclusion on the safety of the rectification works on the travertine fluted tiles, I place some weight on the expert evidence adduced by both parties. In the course of these proceedings, the Claimant called one Mr Chin Cheong (“Mr Chin”), a director of Building Appraisal Pte Ltd and an appraisal consultant, as its expert witness, while the Defendant called one Mr George Willi Wall (“Mr Wall”), a director of Asgard Services Pte Ltd and a building construction expert, as its expert witness. Both expert witnesses prepared their respective expert reports.

  107. [73] There was no dispute that both Mr Chin and Mr Wall are properly qualified to be experts, and that they have considerable expertise in these areas and in giving expert evidence. Nonetheless, on the matter of the rectification works involving the travertine fluted tiles, their evidence differed in material respects. I will deal with their evidence on the rest of the alleged defects in the Renovation Works later.

  108. [74] In gist, Mr Chin’s expert evidence on the travertine fluted tiles was that: (a) some of the tiles were not aligned; (b) the screws were haphazardly drilled; and (c) the putty used to conceal the screws had turned yellow-ish and was very unsightly. Mr Chin’s view was that the screws used were not a suitable replacement for a proper anchorage system as they may be inadequate to support the weight of the tiles and the height at which they were installed. As Mr Ling’s certification was subject to a caveat that the site should be reinspected in three-years’ time, the long-term durability of the screws was in question. Mr Chin said it was “extremely crucial” that all the tiles be reinstalled using a “proper anchorage system”. Conversely, Mr Wall’s expert evidence was that the Defendant had adopted a rectification method using screws which had been certified by a PE, and the matter was now closed.

  109. [75] The law on how the court should weigh such conflicting expert evidence is well-established. As noted by V K Rajah JA in Sakthivel Punithavanthi v Public Prosecutor [2007] 2 SLR(R) 983 at [75]–[76], it is “the consistency and logic of the preferred evidence that is paramount”. Ultimately, “[c]ontent credibility, evidence of partiality, coherence and a need to analyse the evidence in the context of established facts” are vital considerations in assessing such evidence. In my view, at least in relation to the travertine fluted tiles, I would prefer the expert evidence of Mr Wall to that of Mr Chin.

  110. [76] To commence analysis, the proposition that the weight of the travertine fluted tiles was an important consideration in determining the manner of affixation was a matter of plain logic and a point consistently affirmed by both experts (and Mr Ling) in their testimony. On this front, it is clear to me that the tiles, weighing about 5kg each, were not especially weighty, relatively speaking, and this was in part because travertine was not a particularly heavy material to begin with. Even Mr Chin conceded in trial that “travertine is not heavy” and is lighter than marble although heavier than other types of tiles, and that he would define (on a “rough and ready” basis) a heavy tile as one above 7kg. I have already noted Mr Ling’s observations on this front earlier that this meant that the use of screws, even if not drilled in a uniform manner, would be self-evidently more than sufficient to secure the tiles (see [64] above). Mr Wall’s testimony reinforces this, having noted in trial that “these tiles … are not very heavy”. Accordingly, as Mr Ling noted (see [65(d)] above), the discussion about whether the screws were placed exactly in the manner set out in the drawings he endorsed was beside the point, given the relatively small load each screw effectively had to bear.

  111. [77] I note Mr Chin himself, in his report, took the position that a proper anchorage system was necessary in this specific context in large part because he “estimated [each tile] to weigh approximately 30kg (calculated using typical marble tiles density)”. Simply put, weight was a key consideration in his mind for why a mechanical anchorage system was necessary. However, as can be seen above, that assessment was based on an erroneous underlying factual assumption of the tiles weighing 30kg each, as each tile was about a sixth of the weight he had suggested. When I first sought his clarification on this apparently flawed assumption at trial, Mr Chin initially suggested that the reference to the tiles being 30kg (and being of a material akin to marble) was an allusion to tiles used for a different part of the Renovation Works, and he was not in fact talking about the travertine fluted tiles. With respect, that made little sense as the reference in the report was under a section titled “Commentary on the Defects on the Debonded Fluted Marble Stone Claddings”, and the surrounding paragraphs make it clear that the reference was in relation to the travertine fluted tiles that had dislodged. This was later clarified in cross-examination where counsel for the Defendant (“Mr De Cruz”) highlighted that there were no travertine fluted tiles weighing 30kg, and Mr Chin conceded that his report should not have mentioned 30kg to begin with. Strangely enough, even before I highlighted this discrepancy in Mr Chin’s report, Mr Chin had himself observed in trial that the travertine fluted tiles weighed around 5kg each.

  112. [78] In any event, it seems to me that, having proceeded on an erroneous assumption as to the weight of the tiles, Mr Chin nonetheless sought to maintain that the same conclusion should follow even after the assumption was fundamentally revised. When the underlying assumption departs so markedly from reality, and the expert resists engaging with the implications of such a departure, it becomes difficult to accord much legitimacy to a conclusion said to remain unchanged.

  113. [80] Mr Chin had also contended in his report that there were certain good practices which, in his view, called for a mechanical anchorage system to be used. However, upon closer scrutiny, it is clear that these were tortured analogies with limited or no relevance to the present context. For instance, Mr Chin quoted the “Building Control Act (Chapter 29) Rg 5 Clause 40.-(1)” for the following proposition:

  114. [81] It is unclear to me what legislative provision Mr Chin was referring to because no such provision presently exists to my knowledge. In any event, the quotation above clearly does not prescribe that a mechanical anchorage system of fixing must be used. Mr Chin also explained that the above provision is a “mandatory item in term [sic] of Building Regulations for claddings installed on the external wall”, but it is quite clear that the travertine fluted tiles were installed in the interior of the Premises, and so the relevance of this provision is further in doubt. As noted by Mr Wall during trial, the standards for external claddings are obviously different because they are subject to harsher conditions than internal claddings.

  115. [82] Mr Chin also quoted s 2.7 of the Building and Construction Authority (“BCA”)’s Construction Quality Assessment System (“CONQUAS”) Good Industry Practices guide for Natural Stone Finishes (“Natural Stone Finishes Guide”) as follows:

  116. [83] Having perused the available Natural Stone Finishes Guide on BCA’s website (as hyperlinked in Mr Chin’s report), s 2.7 actually states:

  117. [84] It is once again clear that s 2.7 does not prescribe that a mechanical anchorage system must be used, it merely sets out relevant considerations and a general guide after it has been determined that an anchorage system will be used. Even if I referred to s 2.7 as quoted by Mr Chin, the references to claddings of “significant size and weight” does not even appear to describe the travertine fluted tiles in the present case.

  118. [85] Mr Chin also referred to BCA’s CONQUAS 2022, a quality assessment system for new building projects, and while he did not indicate what portion of the document he was referring to, it seems to me that he was referring to Appendix 1 which deals with quality standards for “internal finishes works”. In this regard, Mr Chin appeared to be alluding to how the standard set for cladding on internal walls is “proper anchorage for panels”. Mr Chin himself admitted that the CONQUAS is primarily meant to assess the quality standards in new buildings, which is not the case here. In any event, Appendix 1 of CONQUAS clearly does not prescribe that a mechanical anchorage system should be used in every scenario, let alone in one like the present case, it merely sets a standard that the anchorage system must be proper.

  119. [86] In my view, the need to reach for such inapposite guidelines and to draw strained parallels serves to detract from, rather than support, Mr Chin’s thesis. It demonstrates that the matter of rectification works is, in truth, governed by discretion and judgment rather than by prescriptive rule. In the absence of any fixed standards directly applicable, the real question reduces to one of good practical sense, and what, on the evidence, made reasonable sense on-site.

  120. [87] In his oral testimony, Mr Chin also took especial pains to make the point that consideration had to be given to the possibility that the travertine tiles might fracture from the drilling. These, however, appeared to me to be largely theoretical concerns, once more untethered to the practical realities on-site. While it is true that, in theory, a tile might crack from drilling, Mr Chin also accepted in cross-examination that such a hypothesis had not materialised in the present instance, having observed no such breakage when he inspected the premises over two years after the screws were drilled into the tiles. As Mr Wall noted in trial, if the tiles were at risk of cracking because of the drilling, this would likely happen immediately as it was not the case that the tiles were subject to cyclic loading, and thus any such cracking would have been readily apparent, and yet none of the experts who inspected the site saw any evidence of cracking. For completeness, I note that Mr Ling’s evidence on the stand was also that the tiles would not crack because it was made of a composite material. I therefore attach little weight to Mr Chin’s apparent apprehension, particularly as the point was conspicuously absent from his report, suggesting that it was not, and was never, viewed as a central or material concern.

  121. [88] I would add, for completeness, that the factual evidence in this case regarding the travertine fluted tiles aligned more closely with the testimony of Mr Wall than it did with that of Mr Chin. As I have already explained earlier (see [69] and [87] above), there has been no evidence whatsoever of any further defects, whether in the form of dislodgment or cracking, in any of the tiles over the past few years of the Club’s operations. Taken together with my analysis above, these factors corroborate Mr Wall’s assessment and undermine any suggestion that the use of screws to affix the tiles to the wall was in any way deficient from a safety perspective.

  122. [89] On balance, therefore, I was of the view that the better evidence was that of Mr Wall’s on this specific point. Again, at the risk of reiteration, I should make clear that I accept that a mechanical anchorage system could potentially have been a preferable option. Nonetheless, that is not the question before me. The question for my determination is whether the drilling of the travertine fluted tiles into the walls with screws was safe or otherwise. On this point, I accept the evidence of Mr Wall and Mr Ling, both of whom were clear and consistent in their evidence that the use of screws was safe based on the facts of the present case.

  123. (5) Conclusion on the travertine fluted tiles

  124. [91] In sum, I find that the rectification works carried out by the Defendant on the travertine fluted tiles were adequately safe, even if the works were not as pleasing to the eye as one might have hoped. In my view, the rectification works cannot meaningfully be described as defective, and the Defendant cannot be said to have conducted itself below its standard of care.

  125. Door closers

  126. [92] As far as the door closers are concerned, the evidence before me is unfortunately sparse. On the one hand, Mr Tan and Mr Lai assert that all the Defendant did was physically examine the door closers. On the other hand, Ms Tee asserts that the Defendant had arranged for additional reinforcement for the door closers at the Claimant’s request. It is undisputed that one door closer did come loose on 17 December 2022 and injured one of the Claimant’s employees (see [26] above), but it is also undisputed that the one door closer has been reinstalled and there have been no repeat incidents since then.

  127. [93] On balance, I find that there is insufficient evidence to show that all the door closers installed by the Defendant are presently defective. In any event, I note that, much like the other alleged defects which I address below, the issue of the door closers is a lot more minor than the issue of the travertine fluted tiles, and it seems clear that the damages that could conceivably flow from them would have been relatively minimal. Indeed, I note that the Claimant did not (unlike in the case of the travertine fluted tiles) even plead any specific losses in relation to the door closers, and in the parties’ Scott Schedule, the sum claimed by the Claimant in relation to the door closers was a rather modest $747.

  128. Other alleged defects

  129. [94] I next turn to the other alleged defects. These are, by any measure, of a far smaller magnitude than the issues pertaining to the travertine fluted tiles, and, in truth, occupy only a relatively small place in the overall question of liability. The damages that could conceivably flow from them are, relatively speaking, not significant, and therefore I will only briefly touch on them.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.