Appellate Division of the High Court · Decided 26 March 2021
Ser Kim Koi v GTMS Construction Pte Ltd and others
Feedback & support[2021] SGHC(A) 2 · Case no. Originating Summons No 7 of 2021 · 5 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Background
- [3]
[3] We first set out the parties to the dispute:
(a) Ser Kim Koi (“Ser”) was the owner of a plot of land on which three Good Class Bungalows were to be built (“the Project”).
(b) Ser engaged GTMS Construction Pte Ltd (“GTMS”) as the main contractor for the Project.
(c) Ser engaged Chan Sau Yan (formerly trading as Chan Sau Yan Associates) (“Chan”) as the architect for the Project.
(d) CSYA Pte Ltd (“CSYA”) is a company incorporated by Chan to carry out his architecture business.
The arguments and our decision
- [11]
[11] We were of the view that Ser and GTMS had proceeded on the basis of their solicitors’ incorrect understanding of the law as we elaborate below. The two pertinent provisions are s 29A(1)(c) read with para 3(f) of the Fifth Schedule of the SCJA (“the Fifth Schedule 3(f) provision”):
The relevant portion of paragraph 3 of the Fifth Schedule reads:
- [20]
[20] Accordingly, we granted Ser’s leave application and gave the following directions:
(a) Ser was to file and serve the Notice of Appeal in respect of the Costs Judgment within three days from the date of our decision. That appeal was to be fixed for hearing together with the appeal in respect of the Main Judgment. This would obviate the need for Ser to take a further step to consolidate both appeals.
(b) The parties were to proceed with the filing of any subsequent papers as though there were a single appeal.
(c) If any further directions were required, such directions might be given at a case management conference.
(a) The leave application was unnecessary in the circumstances. Ser could have and should have filed a single Notice of Appeal against both the Main Judgment and the Costs Judgment.
(b) That said, GTMS should not have opposed the leave application since it was quite clear that Ser was agreeable to having both appeals heard together. Perhaps that was why the other respondents in the Main Appeal did not resist the leave application.
- [23]
[23] We take this opportunity to make some further observations.
- [26]
[26] Finally, we note that after the written submissions from Ser and GTMS were filed, their solicitors proceeded to send further submissions to the court by way of correspondence. This should not have been done without leave of the court and we hope such conduct will not be repeated in future.