Appellate Division of the High Court · Decided 25 June 2024
Darsan Jitendra Jhaveri and others v Lakshmi Anil Salgaocar (suing as the administratrix of the estate of Anil Vassudeva Salgaocar) and another
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC(A) 20 · Case no. Civil Appeal No 88 of 2023 (Summonses Nos 2, 12 and 16 of 2024) · 28 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] These grounds of decision pertain to three applications which were filed in relation to AD/CA 88/2023 (“AD 88”). For context, AD 88 is the appeal of Mr Darsan Jitendra Jhaveri (“Mr Darsan”) and eleven Singapore-incorporated special purpose vehicles (“SPVs”) (collectively, the “Appellants”) against the decision of a judge of the General Division of the High Court (the “Judge”) on 28 February 2023 in Lakshmi Anil Salgaocar (suing as the Administratrix of the Estate of Anil Vassudeva Salgaocar) & Anor v Darsan Jitendra Jhaveri & Ors [2023] SGHC 47. The Judge held that Mr Darsan had committed breaches of trust in respect of the equity and assets of SPVs which he allegedly held on trust for Mr Anil Vassudeva Salgaocar (“Mr Salgaocar”), who had commenced a claim in HC/S 821/2015 (“Suit 821”). Mr Salgaocar passed away on 1 January 2016. His claim in Suit 821 was continued by his estate (the “Estate”), the administratrix of which is Mr Salgaocar’s wife, Mdm Lakshmi Anil Salgaocar (“Mdm Lakshmi”). The Estate and a British Virgin Islands-incorporated company, Winter Meadow Capital Inc, were the plaintiffs in Suit 821 and the respondents in AD 88 (collectively, the “Respondents”).
- [2]
[2] The three applications were as follows.
- [3]
[3] First, AD/SUM 2/2024 (“SUM 2”) was the Respondents’ application for permission to adduce further evidence at the hearing of AD 88. This application, which was filed on 5 January 2024, pertained primarily to the documents relating to the various applications brought by the parties before the Singapore and Indian courts and the relevant orders made.
- [4]
[4] Second, AD/SUM 12/2024 (“SUM 12”) was brought by the Respondents on 21 February 2024 to strike out AD 88 and for an extension of time to be granted for the filing of this summons.
- [5]
[5] Third, AD/SUM 16/2024 (“SUM 16”) was the Respondents’ application for permission to adduce further evidence at the hearing of AD 88. SUM 16 sought to introduce, inter alia, documents pertaining to further developments before the Indian courts which were filed between January and March 2024. The application was filed on 20 March 2024.
SUM 2 and SUM 16
- [8]
[8] To begin with, we observed that these summonses were poorly worded as they gave the misleading impression that these documents which were sought to be adduced at the hearing of AD 88 were to be employed in respect of the merits of AD 88. This was, however, not the case.
- [9]
[9] Mdm Lakshmi stated at para 5(a) of her supporting affidavit in SUM 2 that the further evidence sought to be adduced in that application “concern[ed] the question whether a Court should hear a party who is in contempt or whose conduct is part of a campaign to intimidate or harass the other party or impedes the delivery of justice or where there is an element of challenge to the Court’s authority”. In the Respondents’ written submissions for SUM 16, they referred to this same paragraph in Mdm Lakshmi’s affidavit to explain the materiality of the documents sought to be adduced in SUM 16.
- [10]
[10] It was therefore clear that the documents which SUM 2 and SUM 16 sought to adduce were to be relied on by the Respondents only in relation to their argument that the court should not hear the Appellants in AD 88 on the basis of the Hadkinson principle (which originates from the case of Hadkinson v Hadkinson [1952] P. 285). This principle, according to the Respondents, states that the court may exercise its discretion to refuse to hear a party in contempt unless and until he has purged his contempt. Counsel for the Respondents confirmed at a case management conference (“CMC”) on 31 January 2024 that the documents mentioned in SUM 2 (SUM 16 had yet to be filed) were to be relied on only in relation to the point on the Hadkinson principle.
- [11]
[11] In addition to the poor wording of the summonses, para 5(c) of Mdm Lakshmi’s supporting affidavit in SUM 2 added to the confusion. This paragraph stated that the further evidence in SUM 2 was “therefore relevant and material to the [issue on the Hadkinson principle], [was] credible and would have a perceptible impact on the Appellate Division’s decision in [AD 88]”. The wording of para 5(c) appeared to be an attempt to meet the requirements in Ladd v Marshall [1954] 3 All ER 745 (“Ladd v Marshall”). However, these requirements are only relevant if the additional evidence is to be admitted for the purposes of determining the merits of an appeal, which was not the case with SUM 2 or, for that matter, SUM 16.
- [12]
[12] Generally speaking, no leave is required to rely on documents for the purpose of persuading the court not to hear an appeal. This was borne out, firstly, by the context in which Ladd v Marshall was decided. In that case, the plaintiff and the defendant entered into a contract for the sale and purchase of a bungalow and two plots of land for £2,500. The parties’ wives were present when the contract was signed. When the defendant subsequently decided not to proceed with the sale, the plaintiff brought an action for the return of £1,000 which he had allegedly paid the defendant when they signed the agreement. The defendant’s wife was called as a witness but testified that she did not remember any money being passed between the parties. The judge at first instance dismissed the action as he was not persuaded that this sum was paid to the defendant. After the judge’s decision, the defendant’s wife divorced the defendant and told her solicitors that she had lied at the hearing. The plaintiff then applied for leave to adduce further evidence on appeal to show that the judge had erred in making a finding of fact. It was therefore clear that the Ladd v Marshall requirements relate to the admission of evidence which goes toward the determination of the substantive issues on appeal.
- [13]
[13] This conclusion was also apparent from a perusal of the Ladd v Marshall requirements themselves. For example, the fresh evidence must not have been obtainable with reasonable diligence for use at the trial and it must have an important influence on the result of the case. These requirements suggest that the evidence sought to be adduced on appeal must pertain to the substantive issues of contention between the parties at trial which have subsequently been taken up on appeal.
- [14]
[14] It also bore noting that the underlying rationale behind these requirements was that of finality in litigation, where parties are incentivised to advance their full case at trial and not resort to strategic ploys to gain unfair advantages (Anan Group (Singapore) Pte Ltd v VTB Bank (Public Joint Stock Co) [2019] 2 SLR 341 at [23]–[24]). This is the reason why the Ladd v Marshall requirements are not applied to new points or claims raised on appeal, where such interests are engaged to a lesser degree (see Yee Heng Khay (alias Roger) v Angliss Singapore Pte Ltd and another matter [2022] 2 SLR 521 at [13]). Accordingly, and a fortiori, evidence pertaining to a matter which was neither an issue at trial nor a substantive issue on appeal against the Judge’s decision will not attract the application of these requirements.
- [15]
[15] As such, while the relevance and credibility of the documents listed in SUM 2 and SUM 16 would have a perceptible impact on the Respondents’ argument on the Hadkinson principle, no leave was required to use them for this purpose as this argument simply did not relate to the substantive issues in AD 88. Instead, this argument pertained only to the issue of whether the court should exercise its discretion not to hear the Appellants until Mr Darsan’s alleged acts of contempt, intimidation or harassment had ceased.
SUM 12
- [17]
[17] We now turn to SUM 12. In this summons, the Respondents sought to strike out AD 88 and for an extension of time to do so. As the issue on the extension of time was logically anterior to the striking out application, we dealt with that issue first.
- [18]
[18] Under O 19 r 35(14) of the Rules of Court 2021, an application to strike out a notice of appeal must be filed and served by the applicant on the parties to the application within 14 days after service of the notice of the appeal on the applicant. In this case, the notice of appeal was served on 14 August 2023 and the application to strike out AD 88 should have therefore been filed by 28 August 2023. Instead, SUM 12 was only filed on 21 February 2024, about six months later.
- [19]
[19] In deciding if an extension of time should be granted for the filing of a striking out application, the court must have “some material” upon which it can exercise its discretion. This encompasses an assessment of: (a) the length of the delay, (b) the reason for the delay, (c) the merits of the “proceeding” in question, and (d) the question of prejudice: see Aathar Ah Kong Andrew v OUE Lippo Healthcare Ltd [2021] SGCA 48 at [24].
- [20]
[20] The Respondents, in their bid to provide an explanation for the delay, argued that the grounds for SUM 12 included matters which occurred after 28 August 2023. In particular, SUM 12 was precipitated by Mr Darsan’s filing of a Writ Petition (Civil) No 14567 (“No 14567”) in the High Court of Delhi on 6 November 2023 and his conduct thereafter.
- [21]
[21] On 28 November 2023, the Respondents filed HC/OA 1197/2023 (“OA 1197”) for an anti-suit injunction (“ASI”) to restrain Mr Darsan from pursuing prayer (iii) of No 14567 and any variation of it or any reliefs which have similar or like effect. This prayer was for “the court [to] direct [the Estate] to not proceed with the execution proceedings before the Singapore Court in view of the present proceedings”. HC/SUM 3643/2023 (“SUM 3643”) was also filed by the Respondents on the same day, which sought an ex parte interim ASI pending the final disposal of OA 1197. The interim ASI was granted on 28 November 2023.
- [24]
[24] In the light of Mr Darsan’s conduct, the Estate’s Singapore solicitors, on 1 December and 17 December 2023, wrote to ask the Singapore court not to hear AD/SUM 41/2023 (“SUM 41”) filed by the Appellants for a stay of execution of the Judge’s orders based on Mr Darsan’s alleged misconduct and the Hadkinson principle. In any event, the court dismissed SUM 41 on 11 January 2024 but did not rely on the Hadkinson principle in doing so.
- [25]
[25] In the meantime, SUM 2 was filed on 5 January 2024. Although its terms were poorly drafted, it was, as mentioned above at [9]–[10], in fact an application to use documents to persuade the court not to hear AD 88. This was the first formal application by the Respondents in support of their reliance on the Hadkinson principle. That said, Mdm Lakshmi’s written submissions dated 5 February 2024 for SUM 2 stated (at para 15) that Mdm Lakshmi had already relied on the Hadkinson principle in her Respondent’s Case in AD 88 on 1 December 2023 to argue that the court should not hear AD 88 as Mr Darsan’s conduct amounted to an abuse of process.
- [26]
[26] In these circumstances, Mdm Lakshmi argued that there was no delay in filing SUM 2. She had already mentioned the Hadkinson principle in her Respondent’s Case on 1 December 2023 where she mentioned that an application would be filed for permission to adduce evidence to the court to pursue this point. However, there was no explanation as to why SUM 2 was filed more than one month later on 5 January 2024. SUM 12 was filed even later on 21 February 2024. This may have been in response to an observation made by the court at the CMC on 31 January 2024 that there was no formal application seeking to persuade the court not to hear AD 88. SUM 16 was filed on 20 March 2024 to adduce more documents in support of the Respondents’ case on the Hadkinson principle.
- [27]
[27] On the other hand, Mr Darsan argued that the Estate had ample opportunity to file SUM 12 since No 14567 was filed on 7 November 2023 and had failed to provide any explanation for the delay in filing SUM 12. He also maintained that his actions were simply in accordance with his desire to comply with the orders of the Singapore courts as well as the Indian tax authorities. Specifically, the tax notices issued by the Indian tax authorities against Mr Darsan indicated that compliance with the Judge’s orders would result in various penalties on Mr Darsan’s part. He was therefore “compelled” to commence No 14567 before the High Court of Delhi as the Indian authorities would only be bound by orders of the Indian courts.
- [28]
[28] Against this backdrop, we took the view that no extension of time should be granted for the filing of SUM 12.
- [30]
[30] There were also no good reasons which were provided for the delay. As observed in the preceding paragraphs, it was open to the Respondents to have filed an application at any time following 1 December 2023.
- [31]
[31] That said, the striking out application was not entirely without merit. To this end, we mention the following matters.
- [37]
[37] All things considered, we were of the view that the application for an extension of time for the filing of SUM 12 should be dismissed and we exercised our discretion accordingly. There was therefore no need for us to deal with the Respondents’ striking out application as it had been filed out of time.
- [38]
[38] In any event, and for completeness, we were not persuaded that even if the alleged conduct of Mr Darsan constituted contempt of court and/or intimidation or harassment of Mdm Lakshmi, it reached the high threshold which warranted a striking out of AD 88.
- [40]
[40] For the avoidance of doubt, we stressed that our dismissal of SUM 12 did not mean that we were of the view that Mr Darsan had not acted in contempt of court or that he had not intimidated or harassed Mdm Lakshmi. The point was simply that even if he had done so, we took the view that, in the circumstances, AD 88 should be heard and should not be struck out peremptorily. Neither should the court decline to hear AD 88 pursuant to the Hadkinson principle. Whether Mr Darsan should suffer other consequences as a result of his conduct was a separate matter.
Conclusion