Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 26 Sep 2024

Appellate Division of the High Court

Marchmont Pte Ltd v Campbell Hospitality Pte Ltd and others

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHC(A) 30Case no. Appellate Division / Civil Appeal No 46 of 2024 (Summons No 34 of 2024)13 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Background

  3. [2] First, we start with the background. Marchmont Pte Ltd (“Marchmont”), the appellant in AD 46 and respondent to SUM 34, is the registered proprietor of a property at 51 Joo Chiat Road. It leased parts of the property (the “Demised Premises”) to Campbell Hospitality Pte Ltd (“Campbell”) under a tenancy agreement (the “Tenancy Agreement”). The liability of Campbell was guaranteed by its directors, Ms Fu Yao (“Ms Fu”) and Mdm Wang Cuirong (“Mdm Wang”), under a deed of guarantee (the “Deed”).

  4. [3] On 28 December 2022, Marchmont commenced HC/OC 492/2022 (“OC 492”) in the General Division of the High Court against Campbell as the first Defendant, Ms Fu as the second Defendant and Mdm Wang as the third Defendant (collectively, the “Defendants”). Marchmont sought various reliefs, including:

  5. (a) against Campbell – possession of the Demised Premises;

  6. (b) against the Defendants:

  7. (i) damages to be assessed for various breaches;

  8. (ii) “double the value” for a period of holding over or alternatively, double rent pursuant to s 28(4) of the Civil Law Act 1909 (2020 Rev Ed) or a provision in the Tenancy Agreement;

  9. (iii) damages to be assessed for loss of rent;

  10. (iv) in the alternative to (ii) and (iii), damages for repudiatory breach;

  11. (v) interest at 18% per annum on all sums due and payable pursuant to cl 9 of the Tenancy Agreement; and

  12. (vi) costs on an indemnity basis pursuant to cl 17(2) of the Tenancy Agreement and cl 9(b) of the Deed.

  13. [4] On 5 June 2023, the Defendants amended their Defence to include a counterclaim by Campbell for various reliefs, including:

  14. (a) a declaration that Marchmont’s notice of breach dated 14 December 2020 (“NOB 1”) was invalid for the purposes of s 18(1) of the Conveyancing and Law of Property Act 1886 (2020 Rev Ed) (“CLPA”);

  15. (b) a declaration that Marchmont’s notice of breach dated 18 April 2022 (“NOB 2”) was invalid for the purposes of s 18(1) of the CLPA;

  16. (c) a declaration that Marchmont’s notice of breach dated 23 June 2022 (“NOB 3”) was invalid for the purposes of s 18(1) of the CLPA;

  17. (d) a declaration that Marchmont had waived its right to forfeit the Demised Premises pursuant to Marchmont’s notices of breach;

  18. (e) in the alternative, a declaration that Marchmont was estopped from forfeiting the Demised Premises pursuant to Marchmont’s notices of breach;

  19. (f) a declaration that the part of cl 4(20)(a) of the Tenancy Agreement, which refers to the need for public liability insurance to cover “all the indemnities” referred to in the Tenancy Agreement, is unenforceable;

  20. (g) a declaration that the whole or part of cl 4(20)(b) of the Tenancy Agreement is unenforceable;

  21. (h) a declaration that, having regard to Marchmont’s conduct, the Court should refuse Marchmont’s claim for possession under s 18(3) of the CLPA;

  22. (i) a declaration that Marchmont was not entitled to double rent; and

  23. (j) costs.

  24. [5] The trial for OC 492 was bifurcated by consent. The first tranche on liability was heard over nine days.

  25. [6] On 2 May 2024, the judge below (the “Judge”) issued his judgment on liability for the first tranche in Marchmont Pte Ltd v Campbell Hospitality Pte Ltd and others [2024] SGHC 108 (the “2 May Judgment”). The Judge found that NOB 2 was valid for the purposes of s 18(1) of the CLPA, but not NOB 1 or NOB 3. As the Judge held that Marchmont had validly exercised the termination clause contained in the Tenancy Agreement based on NOB 2 (2 May Judgment at [66]), the Judge did not make a finding of repudiatory breach by Campbell (2 May Judgment at [138]). The material parts of the 2 May Judgment are [160]-–[161] and [163]–[164] which we set out below:

  26. [10] Thereafter, on 4 July 2024, the Defendants filed SUM 34 to strike out AD 46 on the two grounds mentioned in [1] above.

  27. The relevant statutory provisions

  28. [11] The relevant statutory provisions are O 19 r 4(1), (1A) and (2) of the Rules of Court 2021 (“ROC 2021”):

  29. [12] Under O 19 r 25 of the ROC 2021, a notice of appeal must be filed within 28 days after the date of the lower Court’s judgment.

  30. The arguments and the court’s reasons

  31. [18] In support of their position, the Defendants argue that when Marchmont’s solicitors initially wrote to the Defendants’ solicitors on 7 May 2024, the letter stated:

  32. [21] First, we can dispose of the Defendants’ arguments in so far as they rely on what Marchmont did. The letter from Marchmont’s solicitors dated 7 May 2024 merely reiterated what the 2 May Judgment had said without elaboration. This is not inconsistent with Marchmont’s position on the Threshold Question.

  33. [27] While how the Defendants and Marchmont had interpreted the 2 May Judgment in the lead up to the 23 May Judgment is not binding on any court, the positions taken by the parties could assist a court in determining what the 2 May Judgment meant. It would also assist the court in deciding whether to grant any relief to Marchmont should the Defendants be correct on the Threshold Question, if such relief were sought.

  34. [29] Next, we come to the decision of the Judge on 23 May 2024. His brief grounds state (23 May Judgment at [1]):

  35. [39] First, solicitors should be alert to check when time to appeal begins to run, and seek clarification from the lower court at the earliest opportunity if there is reason for different views on the point, or when disagreement on this first arises (if it is not too late to seek such clarification).