Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 12 Sep 2025

Appellate Division of the High Court

Only one notice of appeal should be filed against the judgments from a single trial

Shipworks Engineering Pte Ltd and another v Sembcorp Marine Integrated Yard Pte Ltd and another and other appeals

Feedback & support

[2025] SGHC(A) 19Case no. Civil Appeal No 36 of 2025 (Summons No 26 of 2025)30 paragraphs

The decision, in one line

Not legal advice

Only one notice of appeal should be filed against the judgments from a single trial

Summary by laws.sgParagraphs [47], [51]

There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [2] The five summonses were considered in the following three groups before the court:

  3. (a) The defendants’ application in AD/SUM 26/2025 (“SUM 26”) to strike out the plaintiffs’ notice of appeal (“NOA”) in AD/CA 36/2025 (“AD 36”), as only one NOA had been filed against both the Liability Judgment and the Quantum Judgment;

  4. (b) The plaintiffs’ applications in AD/SUM 28/2025 (“SUM 28”) and AD/SUM 29/2025 (“SUM 29”) to strike out the defendants’ appeals in AD/CA 42/2025 (“AD 42”) and AD/CA 43/2025 (“AD 43”) for being filed out of time; and

  5. (c) If their appeals were indeed filed out of time, the defendants’ applications for an extension of time to file their appeals in AD 42 and AD 43, by way of AD/SUM 30/2025 (“SUM 30”) and AD/SUM 31/2025 (“SUM 31”) respectively.

  6. [3] On 27 August 2025, we made the following decisions:

  7. (a) We dismissed the defendants’ striking out application in SUM 26 as the plaintiffs were not required to file more than one NOA to appeal against the Judge’s decisions on both liability and quantum.

  8. (b) We dismissed SUM 28 and SUM 29 as the defendants’ appeals were not filed out of time.

  9. (c) Accordingly, we made no order on SUM 30 and SUM 31 as the extension of time sought by the defendants to file their NOAs was not necessary.

  10. (a) for SUM 26, the defendants were to pay the plaintiffs costs fixed at $3,500 (all in);

  11. (b) for SUM 28 and SUM 29, the plaintiffs were to pay the defendants costs fixed at $4,500 (all in) for each summons;

  12. (c) for SUM 30 and SUM 31, each party was to bear its own costs for these summonses, as these applications were necessitated by the plaintiffs’ stance that the defendants’ appeals were filed out of time; and

  13. (d) the usual consequential orders apply.

  14. [5] In addition, we gave the following directions:

  15. (a) As only one NOA had to be filed to appeal against the decision of the lower court, and as part of case management, we directed the defendants to withdraw one of their two appeals and amend the other to include the matter covered by the withdrawn appeal. The amended NOA was to be filed and served within seven days of the court’s decision.

  16. (b) The Registrar was to fix a case management conference as soon as possible to fix the time for the parties’ cases to be filed in the remaining appeals and, if necessary, for combined cases and/or Records of Appeal to be filed and/or the date for hearing of the appeals to be fixed.

  17. (c) Liberty was granted to the parties to apply.

  18. Facts

  19. Background to the dispute

  20. [6] The plaintiffs were contracted to perform work for the defendants, which included supplying manpower, performing “sub-tasks” (such as spray-painting and high pressure washing) and miscellaneous services (such as cleaning toilets and supplying lorry cranes to transport equipment and materials). The plaintiffs claimed against the defendants for unpaid invoices in relation to works and services rendered and on quantum meruit for completed works for which invoices were not yet rendered. The defendants counterclaimed, alleging that the plaintiffs could not have performed the disputed works and services, and further that the plaintiffs overcharged the defendants: Liability Judgment at [1]–[2].

  21. Procedural history

  22. [7] On 20 December 2024, the Judge partially allowed both the plaintiffs’ claims and the defendants’ counterclaim in the Liability Judgment. The Judge ordered the parties to jointly calculate the quantum of damages that each party owed to the other based on the Liability Judgment, with liberty to apply in case of disagreement: Liability Judgment at [82].

  23. [9] On 18 March 2025, the plaintiffs’ solicitors wrote to the court to seek pre-judgment interest. The court rejected this request on 20 March 2025.

  24. [10] On 28 March 2025, the defendants’ solicitors wrote to the court to seek pre-judgment interest. The court partially allowed this request on 2 April 2025.

  25. [14] In the meantime, on 5 May 2025, the parties reached an agreement on the Disputed Sums.

  26. [19] In the light of a dispute as to whether these two appeals were filed in time, a case management conference was convened on 11 June 2025. Thereafter, the filing of these two appeals was accepted by the Registry of the Supreme Court with the caveat that the acceptance of the appeals did not constitute a determination that they were filed in time.

  27. [20] On 13 June 2025, the defendants filed SUM 26 to strike out AD 36.

  28. [21] On 25 June 2025, the plaintiffs filed SUM 28 and SUM 29 to strike out AD 42 and AD 43.

  29. [22] On 9 July 2025, the defendants filed SUM 30 and SUM 31 for an extension of time to file and serve AD 42 and AD 43, if necessary.

  30. The parties’ submissions

  31. The plaintiffs’ striking out applications in SUM 28 and SUM 29

  32. [23] The sole basis of the plaintiffs’ striking out applications in SUM 28 and SUM 29 was that the defendants’ appeals were filed out of time.

  33. [27] The plaintiffs also submitted that they did not waive any right to object to the defendants’ NOAs, and the onus was on the defendants to have clarified with the court when the time to appeal had begun to run.

  34. [29] The defendants also submitted that in SUM 1396 where the defendants applied for a stay of execution, the plaintiffs were put on notice that the defendants intended to appeal and had taken the position that the appeal timeline had not started running. As such, they submitted that when the plaintiffs did not object to this assertion, the plaintiffs had waived their right to object to the defendants’ position on the timeline for appeal.

  35. The defendants’ extension of time applications in SUM 30 and SUM 31

  36. The defendants’ striking out application in SUM 26

  37. [33] The plaintiffs disagreed. They submitted that separate NOAs were not required for appeals against orders made in the same proceedings at the same trial or hearing. The word “judgment”, as used in O 19 r 3 and O 19 r 25(1)(a) of the ROC 2021, should have been understood in the “composite” sense, in that it encompassed all decisions made by the Judge in Suit 1040, which was not bifurcated. In that regard, the defendants’ reading would have eroded the distinction between bifurcated and non-bifurcated suits; bifurcated suits were governed by O 19 r 4(2)(b) of the ROC 2021, which required separate NOAs to be filed for distinct bifurcated portions of the bifurcated trial. In any case, it submitted that this was not a clear and obvious case for striking out, and that the court had the discretion to allow amendments to remedy the irregularity.

  38. Issues to be determined

  39. [34] The disposal of the five summonses turned on the following issues:

  40. (a) when the time to file an appeal against the decisions of the Judge expired;

  41. (b) if the plaintiffs were correct that the deadline for filing any appeal against the Judge’s decisions was 30 May 2025, whether an extension of time should be granted to the defendants to file and serve their two NOAs in AD 42 and AD 43; and

  42. (c) whether more than one NOA needed to be filed to appeal against the orders in both the Liability Judgment and the Quantum Judgment.

  43. The plaintiffs’ striking out applications in SUM 28 and SUM 29

  44. [36] First, the final sum under the 13 Work Orders needed to be known and would have to be endorsed by the Judge. Where the trial is not bifurcated, a party should only be required to file an appeal after the final sum is known.

  45. [40] We also considered that the plaintiffs’ argument, that the defendants could “indefinitely delay” the commencement of the appeal timeline by disputing or withholding agreement and/or returning to court on matters relating to the appointment of the independent accountant, did not assist the plaintiffs’ position. The situation was no different if the Judge had decided to resolve the Disputed Sums himself. If either side was delaying matters, the aggrieved side could seek directions from the court.

  46. [42] As regards the waiver argument of the defendants, it is questionable whether a timeline prescribed by law may be waived by a party. In any event, although the plaintiffs knew that the defendants had thought that the timeline to appeal had not begun to run, the plaintiffs were under no duty to correct that perception.

  47. The defendants’ extension of time applications in SUM 30 and SUM 31

  48. [43] As we found that the defendants’ appeals were not filed out of time, it was not necessary for us to consider their applications for an extension of time to file their appeals in AD 42 and AD 43. However, we note for completeness that we would have granted the defendants an extension of time to file and serve their appeals if this was necessary.

  49. [44] As mentioned at [30], the defendants argued that the length of delay was five and six days for the filing and service of their appeals. This was based on the assumption that the deadline to do so was 30 May 2025 (as contended by the plaintiffs) and the date of 4 June 2025 when they attempted to file their appeals, which would have been served on 5 June 2025. Although the plaintiffs argued that the length of delay should be computed instead from the date when the defendants filed their applications for extension of time (ie, on 9 July 2025), we were of the view that the date of 4 June 2025 was appropriate, because that was the first time the defendants sought to resolve the matter. In any event, even if the date of the filing of the applications for extension of time should be the correct date to determine the length of the delay, that would not have made a material difference as we explain below.

  50. [46] We wish to remind parties that in the context of an application for an extension of time to file and serve an NOA, the question of prejudice to the opponent means undue prejudice, ie, one that is something more than what an extension of time would ordinarily entail (see Tan Heng Khoon (trading as 360 VR Cars) v Wang Shing He [2024] SGHC 243 at [10], citing Aberdeen Asset Management Asia Ltd and another v Fraser & Neave Ltd and others [2001] 3 SLR(R) 355 at [44] and S3 Building Services Pte Ltd v Sky Technology Pte Ltd [2001] SGHC 87 at [67]–[69]). Thus, for example, the fact that the appeal may then succeed or the hearing of the appeal is delayed because an extension of time is granted does not constitute undue prejudice and should not be relied upon to oppose the application. Otherwise, there would be prejudice in every application for such an extension of time.

  51. The defendants’ striking out application in SUM 26

  52. [47] Turning to the defendants’ application to strike out the plaintiffs’ appeal in AD 36, it was clear to us that there should only be one NOA filed to appeal against the Judge’s decisions in Suit 1040. That was because the word “judgment”, as used in O 19 r 25(1)(a) of the ROC 2021, refers to a judgment given by the lower court in a trial (see the definition of “judgment” under O 19 r 3(a) of the ROC 2021). Both the Liability Judgment and the Quantum Judgment were issued in respect of the same trial. As the trial for Suit 1040 was not bifurcated, the trial was not over until the Liability Judgment and Quantum Judgment were issued. Therefore, it was appropriate for the plaintiffs to file only one NOA to appeal against both the Liability Judgment and the Quantum Judgment.

  53. [51] Although the facts before us involved two separate judgments on substantive issues, this did not make a difference. Since the trial was not bifurcated, only one NOA should have been filed.

  54. [52] In fact, it was the defendants who acted incorrectly in filing two NOAs. Although the plaintiffs did not apply to strike one out on the ground that the defendants should only have filed one NOA, we directed, for case management purposes, that the defendant withdraws one NOA and amend the other to include the matter covered by the withdrawn appeal. The amended NOA was to be filed and served within seven days of our decision. This avoided the filing of multiple documents for two appeals.

  55. Observation

  56. [53] There is one other matter we should mention. The Judge had directed that if the parties could not agree on the Disputed Sums, they were to appoint an independent accountant to determine the dispute and that decision would be final and binding on the parties.

  57. [55] The case before us did not involve the appointment of an assessor as such and neither side disputed the jurisdiction of the Judge to direct that the independent accountant’s determination would be final and binding on the parties. In any event, the parties did not appoint an independent accountant. Hence, this is not an issue for us to decide, but we mention it so that it may be fully addressed in an appropriate case in the future.

  58. Conclusion

  59. [56] In the circumstances, we made the orders mentioned above at [3]–[5].

  60. [57] The usual consequential orders were to apply.