Appellate Division of the High Court · Decided 7 March 2025
A shareholder's oppression claim failed: the wrongs were the company's, not personal
J. G. Jewelry Pte Ltd v Shree Ramkrishna Exports Pvt Ltd and others and other appeals
Feedback & support[2025] SGHC(A) 5 · Case no. Appellate Division / Civil Appeal No 21 of 2024
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
A shareholder's oppression claim failed: the wrongs were the company's, not personal
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraphs [228], [229]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] This dispute centres around a business collaboration between Shree Ramkrishna Exports Pvt Ltd (“SRK”) and JDM Import Co Inc (“JDM”), as well as various companies associated with each of them. Pursuant to this arrangement, SRK and its related companies supplied tens of millions of dollars’ worth of diamonds and various kinds of jewellery (collectively, the “Goods”) to the US-based affiliated companies of SRK and JDM. The Goods were however invoiced to J. G. Jewelry Pte Ltd (“JGJ”), a company which was incorporated in Singapore by the parties as a vehicle for their collaboration. Half of the shareholding in JGJ is held by Mr Michael Kriss (“Michael”) and Mr David Kriss (“David”) (collectively, the “Kriss Brothers”), who own and control JDM and its related companies. The other half is held by one Mr Shaileshkumar Manubhai Khunt (“Shailesh”). As we elaborate later, we affirm the finding of the learned judge below (the “Judge”) that Shailesh held his shares in JGJ as SRK’s nominee.
- [2]
[2] The business collaboration between the parties broke down in August 2017 after a period of only about two years (see Shree Ramkrishna Exports Pvt Ltd v JG Jewelry Pte Ltd [2024] SGHC 10 (hereafter, the “Judgment”) at [27]).
- [3]
[3] SRK then commenced HC/S 418/2018 (“Suit 418”) on 23 April 2018, claiming that it was entitled to be paid sums of moneys totalling US$23,400,456.25 on invoices which it had issued to JGJ between 2 September 2016 and 2 August 2017 (the “23M Invoices”). JGJ’s response was that the parties never intended that JGJ would have to pay for the Goods. Instead, the supply of the Goods by SRK to JGJ under the invoices represented SRK’s contributions toward capital pursuant to a joint venture (“JV”) between the parties.
- [5]
[5] One of SRK’s related entities, The Jewelry Company (“TJCI”), then brought its own counterclaim against JGJ for payment of moneys under unpaid invoices totalling US$2,211,077.91 allegedly owed to TJCI for the Goods it had supplied to JGJ. The invoices were issued to JGJ between 8 October 2016 and 1 August 2017 (the “2.2M Invoices”).
- [6]
[6] We will refer to the amount claimed under the 23M Invoices as the “SRK Unpaid Sum” and the amount claimed under the 2.2M Invoices as the “TJCI Unpaid Sum”.
- [7]
[7] Separately, Shailesh commenced a minority oppression claim in HC/S 475/2018 (“Suit 475”) on 4 May 2018 pursuant to s 216 of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed) (the “CA”) against the Kriss Brothers and JGJ. He complained that after the parties’ business collaboration was terminated, the Kriss Brothers sought to pass resolutions authorising themselves to, inter alia, commence legal proceedings on behalf of JGJ against TJCI and SRK in the US on JGJ’s behalf for moneys which TJCI and SRK allegedly owed to JGJ. No efforts were made, however, to recover moneys owed by JDM and its related companies to JGJ. Other resolutions were also passed to make four allegedly unjustified adjustments to JGJ’s financial statements for 2016 (the “2016 Revised FS”). These adjustments were reflected in JGJ’s financial statements for 2017 and 2018 (the “2017 FS” and “2018 FS” respectively). We elaborate later on the adjustments. JGJ counterclaimed in Suit 475, alleging that Shailesh had breached his duties as a director of JGJ by refusing or failing to sign three resolutions relating to the commencement of legal proceedings against SRK and its related entities, the approving of the 2016 Revised FS and the calling of an Annual General Meeting (“AGM”). We will refer to these resolutions collectively as the “Three Resolutions”.
- [8]
[8] The Judge issued the Judgment on 18 January 2024 in respect of both suits. The Judge found that the Goods which were the subject of the claims in Suit 418 were supplied as equity contributions in the parties’ joint venture and that the invoices were never intended to attract payment liability. Nonetheless, he allowed SRK’s and TJCI’s claims in unjust enrichment against JGJ and dismissed JGJ’s counterclaim in Suit 418. As for Suit 475, the Judge allowed Shailesh’s claim in part and dismissed JGJ’s counterclaim.
- [9]
[9] There are now four appeals before us which may be categorised into two sets. The first set comprises AD/CA 21/2024 (“AD 21”) and AD/CA 22/2024 (“AD 22”), which are appeals against the Judge’s decision in Suit 418 by JGJ and by SRK and TJCI respectively. The second set comprises AD/CA 23/2024 (“AD 23”) and AD/CA 24/2024 (“AD 24”), which were brought by the Kriss Brothers and JGJ respectively against the Judge’s decision in Suit 475.
Background facts
The parties in Suit 418 and Suit 475
- [10]
[10] We provide some background to the suits, much of which is already set out in the Judgment. We begin with the parties to Suit 418.
- [11]
[11] The plaintiff, SRK, is an India-incorporated company which is in the business of manufacturing and trading in jewellery and precious stones, including diamonds. SRK’s business includes a sales office in Mumbai and a jewellery manufacturing factory in Sachin in India (Judgment at [7]). JGJ, the defendant, is a Singapore-incorporated company in the business of trading jewellery and precious stones.
- [12]
[12] JGJ’s counterclaim in Suit 418 was brought against the following parties (collectively, the “Suit 418 Counterclaim Defendants”):
(a) SRK;
(b) TJCI, a partnership registered in India and in the business of manufacturing, sales and marketing of diamond studded jewellery. SRK owns a minority stake in TJCI through its subsidiary, Ramkrishna Goldi Pvt Ltd. TJCI is the jewellery arm of SRK and is known in the market as a company affiliated with SRK;
(c) TJC Jewelry, Inc (“TJCNY”), a US-incorporated company in the business of sales and marketing of jewellery. TJCNY is the marketing affiliate of TJCI and helps to market TJCI’s products in the US;
(d) Mr Govind Dholakia (“Govind”), an Indian national and the founder, chairman and director of SRK;
(e) Mr Rahul Dholakia (“Rahul”), an Indian national and the Managing Director of SRK and a partner of TJCI. Rahul is Govind’s nephew;
(f) Mr Nirav Narola (“Nirav”), an Indian national who is an employee of SRK and a partner of TJCI. Nirav is Govind’s grandson and Rahul’s nephew;
(g) Mr Amit Shah (“Amit”), an Indian national and the Chief Executive Officer and a partner of TJCI; and
(h) Mr Ashish Shah (“Ashish”), a US national and the sole shareholder and president of TJCNY.
Of the Suit 418 Counterclaim Defendants, only TJCI brought a counterclaim against JGJ in Suit 418.
- [13]
[13] In respect of Suit 475, the plaintiff, Shailesh, is an Indian national resident in Hong Kong and is a director and a 50% shareholder of JGJ. He worked for SRK from 2005 to 2007 and is a director of S Goldi (Asia) Limited (“S Goldi”), a Hong Kong-incorporated company which serves as the marketing arm of SRK (Judgment at [13]). The first and second defendants in Suit 475 are the Kriss Brothers, who are US nationals and directors of JGJ. The third defendant in Suit 475 is JGJ. Apart from the Kriss Brothers each holding 25% of the shares in JGJ, they also own and control the following entities in the US. Collectively, these US entities are referred to as the “JDM Entities” (Judgment at [11]):
The JDM Entities, which operate under the trade name “Instock” or “Instock Programs”, run a New York family-owned jewellery business selling jewellery wholesale to major retailers in the US and abroad. The counterclaim in Suit 475 was brought by JGJ against Shailesh for alleged breaches of his fiduciary duties owed to JGJ.
The parties’ dealings from 2015 to 2017
- [14]
[14] For approximately 15 years leading up to 2015, SRK supplied diamonds to the Kriss Brothers. In December 2014, the Kriss Brothers met with Rahul in Mumbai. According to Michael, Rahul proposed the JV between the JDM Entities on the one hand and SRK, TJCI and TJCNY (collectively, the “SRK Entities”), in which both sides would contribute selected assets, liabilities and activities. Michael claimed that both sides shook hands on this agreement and uttered the word “mazal” (or “mazel”), which is a recognised practice of entering into contracts in the diamond industry. In contrast, Rahul, claimed that the parties to the collaboration were only exploring the opportunity of working together in a closer partnership.
- [15]
[15] In early January 2015, Nirav, Amit and Ashish met up with the Kriss Brothers for further discussions in New York. Michael claimed that they agreed at this meeting that the JV would commence operations on 1 April 2015. On 13 January 2015, Amit sent an e-mail to the Kriss Brothers, attaching a document titled “Joint Venutre [sic] Between JDM Group and The Jewelry Co. (SRK Group)” (the “13 January Memo”). The Kriss Brothers then made a trip to Mumbai at the end of January 2015, purportedly to obtain Govind’s “blessings” for the JV.
- [16]
[16] JGJ was then incorporated in Singapore on 31 March 2015 with an issued share capital of US$100 comprising 100 ordinary shares. One issue was whether JGJ was incorporated as a party to the putative JV, or whether JGJ was merely the subject of such a JV. We address that later. At the very least, JGJ was incorporated as a vehicle for the parties’ collaboration, although counsel for JGJ stressed at the hearing before us that JGJ was not to be equated to the putative JV itself. In any event, Shailesh was issued 50 shares in JGJ and Michael and David 25 each. The number of shares issued by JGJ has not changed since the time of its incorporation. A nominee resident director, Mr Ng Chee Wooi Michael (“Ng”), was also appointed. According to a Resident Director Indemnity Agreement, Ng was to act on the instructions of Mr Jim Goldsborough (“Jim”) – the Chief Financial Officer (“CFO”) of JDM – as the “Authorized Person” designated by Shailesh and the Kriss Brothers. Shailesh and the Kriss Brothers were appointed as directors of JGJ on 15 April 2015 (Judgment at [19(c)]).
- [17]
[17] In April 2015, TJCNY moved to the JDM Entities’ office in New York and operated from there until 8 October 2017. The bookkeeping, accounting and other back-office functions of JGJ and the JDM Entities were, to the extent possible, transferred to and undertaken by a team employed by TJCI in India. In May 2015, JGJ opened a bank account with the Israel Discount Bank in New York (the “IDBNY”). The signatories of this account were Amit, Ashish, Jim and the Kriss Brothers; any one of them could authorise payments to be made from the account (Judgment at [22]).
- [18]
[18] Given these events and more, there was evidently some close collaboration between the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities. However, the precise nature of this collaboration between the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities from 1 April 2015 was (and continues to be) heavily disputed. On one hand, JGJ pleaded that the collaboration was based upon a JVA entered into among the SRK Entities, the JDM Entities and JGJ itself on 13 January 2015. We have referred to the alleged JV agreement as the “JVA”, but this description does not necessarily mean that we accept that JGJ has established all the alleged terms of the JVA. According to JGJ, under the JVA, the Goods supplied by the SRK Entities to JGJ would be treated as capital. In other words, the invoices issued by SRK and TJCI to JGJ were not intended to attract any payment liability on JGJ’s part. On the other hand, SRK pleaded that the collaboration was based on a non-committal business arrangement (the “BA”) under which SRK sold the Goods to JGJ while the parties negotiated concurrently on the terms of a potential JV.
- [19]
[19] This disagreement on the nature of the collaboration aside, the parties acknowledge that their broad arrangement was for SRK and TJCI to supply the Goods directly to the JDM Entities and TJCNY in the US and to invoice JGJ for these Goods. The JDM Entities and TJCNY would then sell the Goods to third party retailers (such as Macy’s, Zales and JCPenney) on a consignment basis; payment would only be received by the JDM Entities or TJCNY when these Goods were sold to the end-consumer by the retailers. The Goods were therefore never physically transported to or from JGJ in Singapore. Hence, when we refer to the supply of Goods to JGJ, we mean that the supply was for the account of JGJ and not that JGJ physically received them.
- [20]
[20] Sometime in May 2016, a total sum of US$700,000 was injected into JGJ and described in the remittance forms as “Capital Introduction”. The background to the injection of US$700,000 was that on 11 May 2016, S Goldi had transferred US$500,000 to Shailesh. In turn, Shailesh transferred US$200,000 and US$300,000 to JGJ on 11 May 2016 and 13 May 2016 respectively. On 19 May 2016, S Goldi transferred another US$200,000 to Shailesh. On the same day, Shailesh transferred US$200,000 to JGJ (Judgment at [24]). We will return to the significance of this US$700,000 injection later (see [206] below).
- [21]
[21] The parties also embarked on an accounting exercise in 2016. The reason for this exercise is however disputed by them. JGJ, on one hand, claimed that it was intended as an accounting reconciliation exercise conducted pursuant to the JVA to adjust the value of the Goods supplied and to determine and apportion the JV’s profits and/or losses. SRK, on the other hand, claimed that the exercise was intended to determine if the BA was a success and, if so, whether the arrangement could be replicated in a potential future joint venture. KPMG, an Indian partnership and member of the KPMG international network, was engaged by JGJ in September 2016 to carry out this exercise. However, it eventually withdrew in October 2017, citing difficulties in obtaining the required support and data (Judgment at [26]). According to JGJ, the exercise failed because SRK had failed to cooperate with KPMG in providing the relevant information. SRK, however, attributed this failure to the unavailability of data from the JDM Entities and the parties’ disagreement over the methodology and approach for accounting.
Termination of the parties’ collaboration in August 2017
- [22]
[22] In August 2017, Rahul, Amit and Nirav informed the Kriss Brothers of SRK’s decision to terminate the collaboration (Judgment at [27]). The parties agree that the collaboration was officially terminated on 31 August 2017. By this time, SRK had supplied the Goods to JGJ in respect of which the invoiced amounts totalled US$66,394,768.91 comprising the Goods supplied under the 42M Invoices and the 23M Invoices.
Litigation in the US
- [23]
[23] Following the termination of the collaboration but prior to the commencement of Suit 418 in Singapore, TJCNY commenced action against the JDM Entities in New York (Case Index No. 657583/2017) on 28 December 2017 to, among other matters, recover diamonds and jewellery inventory which were allegedly stored in the JDM Entities’ vault at their New York office (the “2017 US Proceedings”). TJCNY claimed that the goods belonged to them while the JDM Entities claimed that they were subject to the claims of the JV.
- [24]
[24] On 27 March 2018, the JDM Entities and JGJ commenced action in New York against the SRK Entities and Ashish (Case Index No. 651469/2018) (the “2018 US Proceedings”). This action included claims for the recovery of the JDM Entities’ alleged excess contributions of capital and payment of expenses, together with half of JGJ’s profits earned during the term of the JV.
- [25]
[25] We understand that at the time of the hearing of the four appeals before us, the 2017 and 2018 US Proceedings were still ongoing.
The First, Second, Third and Fourth Resolutions and the Singapore actions
- [26]
[26] We now elaborate on the conduct of the Kriss Brothers following the termination of the parties’ collaboration and the Singapore actions.
- [27]
[27] On 12 January 2018, Michael sent to JGJ’s auditors, M/s AT Adler (“AT Adler”), a copy of JGJ’s 2016 Revised FS and explained that the initial copy of the financial statements did not correctly reflect the financial position of JGJ. Jim claimed to have sent a copy of the letter to Shailesh on the same day via e-mail, but Shailesh stated that he did not see this e-mail until April 2018 (Judgment at [33]).
- [28]
[28] On 22 January 2018, the Kriss Brothers and Ng signed a directors’ resolution (the “First Resolution”) authorising them to commence and manage legal proceedings against TJCNY on behalf of JGJ to recover an amount of US$3,733,503.43 owing by TJCNY (the “TJCNY Debt”). This resolution was not signed by Shailesh on the purported basis that it was, inter alia, not supported by relevant background documents or information (Judgment at [34]–[35]).
- [29]
[29] On 15 February 2018, the Kriss Brothers and Ng signed a directors’ resolution authorising the Kriss Brothers to commence and manage legal proceedings against SRK and TJCI to recover excessive charges that the Kriss Brothers believed were the responsibility of SRK or its affiliates (the “Second Resolution”). This resolution was not signed by Shailesh as he considered the allegations that he was SRK’s nominee and that SRK and/or TJCI had manipulated the prices to be baseless (Judgment at [36]–[37]).
- [30]
[30] On 6 March 2018, the Kriss Brothers and Ng signed a directors’ resolution approving JGJ’s 2016 Revised FS and resolving that the second AGM of JGJ be convened (the “Third Resolution”). Shailesh did not sign this resolution, which he received from Jim on 11 April 2018 (Judgment at [41] and [45]) as he alleged that he had not been provided with the relevant documents and information pertaining to the 2016 Revised FS.
- [31]
[31] On 4 April 2018, notice was given that an AGM of JGJ would be held on 19 April 2018 to adopt the 2016 Revised FS. Shailesh objected to the 2016 Revised FS. However, the AGM took place on 19 April 2018 and the 2016 Revised FS were adopted. Shailesh did not attend the AGM personally or by proxy (Judgment at [44] and [46]).
- [32]
[32] SRK filed Suit 418 against JGJ on 23 April 2018 for the SRK Unpaid Sum. JGJ filed its defence and counterclaim in Suit 418 on 5 February 2020. This was subsequently amended on 20 December 2021. TJCI’s counterclaim against JGJ in Suit 418, which was brought on 6 November 2020 was for the TJCI Unpaid Sum. It is not disputed that all of the Goods under the 42M Invoices, the 23M Invoices and the 2.2M Invoices were delivered and received; there is also no dispute over the quality of the Goods (Judgment at [29] and [30]).
- [33]
[33] Jim sent another resolution to Shailesh for his signature on 30 April 2018, which sought to appoint solicitors to act for JGJ and to authorise the Kriss Brothers to act on behalf of JGJ in relation to Suit 418 (the “Fourth Resolution”). This resolution was not signed by Shailesh (Judgment at [48]).
- [34]
[34] Shailesh proceeded to file Suit 475 on 4 May 2018. JGJ filed its defence and counterclaim in Suit 475 on 30 May 2018, alleging that Shailesh had breached his fiduciary duties to the company in relation to the Three Resolutions. JGJ sought declarations, an injunction and damages in respect of the legal fees incurred in responding to Shailesh’s solicitors’ letters on the Three Resolutions.
- [35]
[35] It is useful to mention at this juncture that following the breakdown of the collaboration in late 2017, the persons behind the litigation – in so far as JGJ is concerned – are the Kriss Brothers. This was confirmed by counsel for JGJ at the hearing before us.
The parties’ cases
- [36]
[36] We now outline the parties’ cases in the court below.
Suit 418
- [37]
[37] SRK’s primary case in Suit 418 was that it had sold the Goods to JGJ from September 2016 to August 2017. To this end, it issued 958 invoices for these Goods and was consistently paid on these invoices up until 2 August 2017. JGJ, however, stopped payments in August 2017. A total of 205 invoices were left unpaid, comprising the SRK Unpaid Sum (ie, the 23M Invoices). SRK therefore argued that it was entitled to this sum of money from JGJ.
- [38]
[38] In the alternative, SRK pleaded that JGJ was unjustly enriched at SRK’s expense as it received the benefit of the Goods without providing payment for those Goods. It was therefore unjust and/or unconscionable for JGJ to retain such a benefit.
- [39]
[39] Pertinently, SRK denied JGJ’s assertion that the JVA was concluded. SRK instead explained that the parties were simply working together in a non-binding arrangement which it termed the BA. This arrangement was intended as a way for the parties to evaluate whether there was potential to enter into a joint venture subsequently. According to SRK, the key features of this purported BA were as follows:
(a) The parties would incorporate an entity in Singapore for tax benefit purposes (ie, JGJ). SRK would sell the Goods to JGJ, which would then sell it to companies controlled and/or owned by the Kriss Brothers.
(b) The book-keeping and accounting for the sale of the diamonds and jewellery pertaining to the BA would be kept in India and administered by persons reporting to and taking instructions from the Kriss Brothers.
(c) JGJ would operate a bank account with the IDBNY from which payment for the Goods would be made to SRK immediately after the credit period. To ensure timely payment, the parties established a two-step process: (i) the Kriss Brothers or their representatives would set up the payment requests on IDBNY’s web portal for payments to be made to SRK; and (ii) these payments could then be released by any of the persons holding a security token issued by IDBNY (ie, Amit, Ashish, Jim and the Kriss Brothers).
- [40]
[40] In sum, SRK’s case in Suit 418 was that SRK and JGJ were operating on a supplier-customer basis whilst SRK and the Kriss Brothers concurrently carried on negotiations on the terms of a potential joint venture which did not eventually materialise.
- [41]
[41] JGJ’s pleaded defence to SRK’s claim in Suit 418 was that the JDM Entities, the SRK Entities and JGJ entered into a binding JVA in the first quarter of 2015. The alleged terms of the JVA were as follows:
(a) The shares of JGJ would be held equally between the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities.
(b) All income and expenses generated by each of the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities pursuant to the JV were to be for the account of the JV.
(c) Any Goods supplied by the SRK Entities or the JDM Entities pursuant to the JV would be treated as the respective parties’ capital in the JV. The supplying party would issue an “invoice” to JGJ for the Goods priced at cost plus a specified mark-up to cover other related costs (eg, marketing, duties and taxes) and some profit (the “Cost-Plus Pricing”). The Cost-Plus Pricing was for the purposes of complying with any applicable tax requirements (including transfer pricing treatment) as well as to enable the parties to maintain proper records of the Goods supplied. Pertinently, the invoices were not intended to create any payment liability on the part of JGJ. The invoices were also necessary to enable SRK to export and ship the Goods out of India.
(d) At the end of each year, the SRK Entities would carry out a full accounting reconciliation of the JV which would involve, inter alia, adjusting the aggregate values of the Goods supplied as between the parties to correctly reflect the Cost-Plus Pricing (the “Accounting Reconciliation”). Separately, the net profits or losses generated under the JV were to be determined and apportioned equally between the SRK Entities and the JDM Entities. This would be done by valuing the Goods supplied to the JV at cost. In other words, the net profits or losses would be determined by deducting the cost of the Goods (as reflected on the SRK Entities’ end) as well as any other relevant expenses from the revenue obtained by the JDM Entities from selling the Goods to the eventual consumer.
(e) The JDM Entities and SRK Entities would each maintain a capital account with the JV. The contributions of the parties to the JV, including all cash injections and the Goods supplied to the JV (valued at cost) would go into these capital accounts and would represent each of the parties’ equity contributions to the JV. Both the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities were permitted to make cash withdrawals from the JV with the knowledge and/or consent of the other side – such withdrawals would reduce the balance of the capital account of the party making the withdrawals.
(f) From the second year of the JV, if either of the SRK Entities’ or the JDM Entities’ equity in their respective capital accounts was more than 50% of the combined sum in both the capital accounts, the party who contributed more than 50% of the total equity sum would be entitled to receive a monthly interest payment of a sum equivalent to 1% of the equity surplus from the other party.
(g) JGJ’s backroom and accounting matters would be undertaken by the SRK Entities at their back-office in India. To this end, SRK’s representatives, Amit and Ashish, were appointed as authorised signatories to JGJ’s IDBNY account and were authorised to review and approve transactions and to release payments under the account.
- [43]
[43] In the alternative, JGJ pleaded that it was understood between the parties to the JV, following the termination of the JV or the JVA in August 2017, that there was to be a final reconciliation and settlement of accounts to be carried out (the “Termination Settlement Exercise”). This would involve determining and quantifying the capital contributions to be returned and any other payments and/or set-offs to be made by/to each of the parties to the JV. Until the Accounting Reconciliation and the Termination Settlement Exercise were carried out, JGJ was not liable to make payment in relation to the 23M Invoices. We shall refer to this argument as JGJ’s “alternative pleaded defences”.
- [44]
[44] JGJ also pleaded that SRK was not entitled to its claim in unjust enrichment because SRK was estopped from doing so. SRK had come to court with unclean hands. Also, JGJ had changed its position. Further, and alternatively, JGJ was entitled to counter-restitution in respect of (a) the benefits received by SRK under the 42M Invoices, (b) the benefits received by the SRK Entities pursuant to their withdrawals from the JV capital accounts and (c) any other payments and/or set-offs to be made by each party to the JV.
- [45]
[45] We need only say that JGJ’s counterclaim for the last two benefits were rejected by the Judge (Judgment at [223] and [224]) and as they are not the subject of the appeals before us, we need not say any more about them.
- [46]
[46] In its counterclaim in Suit 418, JGJ claimed that Amit and/or Ashish had fraudulently misused their access to JGJ’s IDBNY account to cause JGJ to pay out US$42,994,312.66 to SRK in purported settlement of JGJ’s alleged liability under the 42M Invoices. These payments were initiated at the instructions of Govind, Rahul, Nirav, Amit or Ashish, and the majority of these payments were approved for release by Ashish. SRK had therefore breached the JVA as it had (a) issued the 23M Invoices and the 42M Invoices at manipulated and erroneous prices; and (b) demanded payment of invoices which were not intended to give rise to any liability. JGJ also alleged that any one or more of the Suit 418 Counterclaim Defendants, excluding SRK, had induced these breaches of the JVA or conspired to procure such breaches. JGJ alleged that SRK had been unjustly enriched and that JGJ was entitled to the return of the moneys paid under the 42M Invoices, ie, US$42,994,312.66.
- [47]
[47] TJCI counterclaimed against JGJ for the payment of the TJCI Unpaid Sum and, in the alternative, for fair value of the Goods supplied under these invoices. TJCI’s pleadings mirror those of SRK’s above. JGJ’s defence to TJCI’s counterclaim relied on the JV and/or JVA and was similar to its defence against SRK’s claim on the 23M Invoices.
- [48]
[48] As for TJCNY and Ashish, who are two of the Suit 418 Counterclaim Defendants, their case was that TJCNY was not a party to the alleged JV, and that their roles were merely to facilitate and assist administratively in the commercial arrangement between SRK/TJCI and the JDM Entities. They also denied that JGJ was incorporated pursuant to the JV or JVA and their pleadings mirror SRK’s in that the parties were simply operating on the basis of a “possible commercial arrangement” (ie, the BA). TJCNY and Ashish took the position that they had not induced SRK to issue the 23M Invoices and the 42M Invoices at prices that were manipulated or erroneous. The parties’ inability to carry out the Accounting Reconciliation was also not due to the fault of TJCNY or Ashish. Finally, TJCNY and Ashish denied that they had breached the JVA or conspired to procure breaches of the JVA or to otherwise injure JGJ and put JGJ to strict proof of its alleged loss and damage. The position of the other Suit 418 Counterclaim Defendants is similar to that of TJCNY and Ashish.
Suit 475
- [49]
[49] Shailesh’s pleaded case in Suit 475 was as follows. As a shareholder of JGJ, he possessed legitimate expectations pursuant to s 157 of the CA that the Kriss Brothers – as directors of JGJ – would, inter alia, act honestly and diligently in the interests of JGJ, avoid being in positions of conflict of interests and ensure that JGJ’s financial statements gave a true and fair view of JGJ’s financial position. However, the Kriss Brothers had instead exercised their powers as directors and/or shareholders in a manner oppressive to Shailesh and/or prejudicial to his interests as a shareholder of JGJ.
- [50]
[50] Shailesh’s pleaded case took issue with several acts by the Kriss Brothers. In his closing submissions for Suit 475, however, Shailesh pursued only his complaints against the following acts of the Kriss Brothers, which he alleged demonstrated commercial unfairness:
(a) passing the First Resolution (which authorised the commencement of legal proceedings against TJCNY to recover the TJCNY Debt) and the Second Resolution (which authorised the commencement of legal proceedings against SRK and TJCI for overcharging JGJ). Shailesh asserted that he was not provided sufficient information and that these resolutions sought to accord preferential treatment to the JDM Entities as debtors of JGJ, given that JGJ had only sought to recover the debts owed by the SRK Entities and not the US$23,051,737 owed by the JDM Entities. Shailesh also asserted that there was no basis for the Second Resolution as SRK and TJCI did not overcharge JGJ; and
(b) manipulating JGJ’s accounts by making four unjustified adjustments to JGJ’s financial statements for 2016 and failing to provide documentary evidence and explanations to JGJ’s auditors, thereby resulting in a disclaimer of opinion for JGJ’s 2016 Revised FS and adverse opinions for JGJ’s 2017 FS and 2018 FS. These four adjustments comprised:
The Kriss Brothers also refused to provide further information to Shailesh and/or engage Shailesh regarding the adoption of JGJ’s 2016 Revised FS. By failing to ensure that JGJ’s accounts presented a true and fair view of the company’s financial position, the Kriss Brothers failed to act in JGJ’s interests and breached their fiduciary duties.
- [51]
[51] While Shailesh sought various remedies in his pleadings, he pursued only the following reliefs in his closing submissions below:
- [52]
[52] In response, the Kriss Brothers’ pleaded case was as follows:
(a) Shailesh was the SRK Entities’ nominee shareholder and nominee director in JGJ and was not involved in the management of JGJ at any material time.
(b) The First and Second Resolutions were validly passed in accordance with JGJ’s Articles of Association.
(c) Shailesh himself does not dispute the TJCNY Debt, the recovery of which was authorised by the First Resolution. It was in the interests of JGJ to recover the TJCNY Debt from TJCNY and to take action against SRK and TJCI for overcharging JGJ in respect of the Goods sold to JGJ.
(d) In the 2018 US Proceedings, JGJ together with the JDM Entities are seeking, among other things, their share of the profits owed by the SRK Entities under the JVA. Accordingly, the issues to be determined in the 2018 US Proceedings would also include the veracity of any alleged debts due and owing as between JGJ, the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities. They had therefore not preferred the JDM Entities’ interests in commencing the US Proceedings.
(e) The four adjustments in the 2016 Revised FS were made to address inaccuracies that the Kriss Brothers discovered in the 2015 financial statements (“2015 FS”). The Kriss Brothers’ inability to produce sufficient documentary evidence to the auditors was solely the result of the SRK Entities having wrongfully and improperly retained JGJ’s and the JV’s accounting books and records upon the termination of the JV.
(f) The resolutions pertaining to JGJ’s 2016 Revised FS were validly passed in accordance with JGJ’s Articles of Association.
- [53]
[53] JGJ also brought a counterclaim in Suit 475 that Shailesh had breached his fiduciary duties by:
(a) refusing and/or failing to sign the First, Second and/or Third Resolutions and, in the alternative, refusing and/or failing to abstain from voting on these resolutions; and
(b) requesting the following information and documents for collateral and/or ulterior purposes:
(i) documents in relation to the TJCNY Debt and any other claims;
(ii) details of the then-current signatories of JGJ’s IDBNY account, details of the transactions pertaining to the account, monthly bank statements and details of any other bank accounts in JGJ’s name; and
(iii) a copy of the legal opinion that Ng (JGJ’s nominee resident director) should have obtained on the validity and strength of the claim to recover the TJCNY Debt and other claims, purchase orders or other similar documents and invoices in relation to transactions among JGJ, SRK and TJCI.
Decision below
Suit 418
- [55]
[55] The Judge made the following findings and conclusions in relation to Suit 418:
(a) The parties operated on the basis of the JV/JVA and the alleged BA was a concoction by the SRK Entities and/or their representatives (Judgment at [63], [155] and [242(a)]). Under the terms of the JV/JVA (Judgment at [194]):
We shall refer to these two terms collectively as the “Equity Terms”. On the other hand, we note that JGJ refers to the terms that the Goods supplied should be treated as “capital” in the JV and that the invoices were not payable as, collectively, “the Capital Term”.
(b) JGJ was incorporated as a tax-efficient vehicle for the JV through which capital flow and eventual profit distribution could be effected to the JV partners; in addition, it was a convenient vehicle to handle purchases by the JV from non-JV parties (Judgment at [95] and [97]).
(c) TJCNY was a party to the JV. The Judge rejected Ashish’s claim that his role in the JV was purely to provide administrative assistance (Judgment at [161]).
(d) However, the Judge found that the JVA was not legally enforceable because (Judgment at [172] and [242(b)]):
(i) JGJ had failed to prove that the JV/JVA was entered into on 13 January 2015 as pleaded (Judgment at [174]). In addition, the Judge had dismissed JGJ’s application – that was made after the commencement of the trial – to amend its pleadings in relation to the date of the JV (Judgment at [181]);
(ii) regardless of the date that the JV was entered into, JGJ also failed to prove material terms of the JVA as pleaded (Judgment at [183]); and
(iii) no agreement had been reached on the manner in which the profits made by the JV were to be distributed to the alleged parties to the JV (Judgment at [188]).
(e) It therefore followed that the question of JGJ’s standing to enforce the JVA did not arise (Judgment at [193] and [242(b)]). In any event, following JGJ’s pleaded case that the JVA was entered into on 13 January 2015, JGJ could not enforce the JVA because JGJ was incorporated after 13 January 2015 and was thus not a party to the JVA (Judgment at [193]).
(f) There was no agreement for JGJ to pay for the Goods supplied by SRK and TJCI based on the amounts stated in the 23M Invoices, 42M Invoices and 2.2M Invoices. The amounts on the invoices were to comply with tax and regulatory requirements (including transfer pricing) (Judgment at [194]–[195] and [242(c)]).
(g) Nonetheless, SRK and TJCI were entitled to reasonable compensation for the Goods supplied by them, subject to JGJ’s claim for counter-restitution (Judgment at [204] and [242(c)]). JGJ was enriched at the expense of SRK and TJCI (Judgment at [209]–[210]). There was a total failure of consideration as the basis for the supply of the Goods had failed, ie, the JVA was unenforceable (Judgment at [212]). The defences of estoppel and change of position failed (Judgment at [216] and [219]). The Judge declined to make a finding that SRK and TJCI had come to court with unclean hands (Judgment at [225]). JGJ’s claim for counter-restitution in respect of the 42M Invoices succeeded in principle but was restricted to an amount that exceeded the reasonable compensation for the Goods supplied under those invoices (Judgment at [242(c)(i)]).
(h) As to what the reasonable amounts payable under the 23M Invoices, the 42M Invoices and the 2.2M Invoices were, the Judge held that the best proxy for the market value of the Goods supplied was the Cost-Plus Pricing (Judgment at [228]). The Judge adopted the calculations of JGJ’s expert, Mr Robert Golden, which were based on the total cost-plus amounts, and held (Judgment at [229]–[233]):
(i) The reasonable compensation under the 42M Invoices was US$40,526,969.99. As US$42,994,312.66 had been paid to SRK, JGJ was entitled to a counter-restitutionary claim of US$2,467,350.67 in respect of the 42M Invoices (Judgment at [229(a)], [231] and [242(c)(i)]).
(ii) The reasonable compensation under the 23M Invoices was US$20,210,267.04. Taking into account JGJ’s counter-restitutionary claim (ie, recovery of the excess paid on the 42M Invoices), JGJ was liable to pay SRK US$17,538,999.49 in respect of SRK’s restitutionary claim under the 23M Invoices (Judgment at [230], [233(a)] and [242(c)(ii)]).
(iii) The reasonable compensation under the 2.2M Invoices was US$2,027,846.91. JGJ was liable to pay this amount in respect of TJCI’s restitutionary claim under the 2.2M Invoices (Judgment at [233(b)] and [242(c)(iii)]).
(i) As the JVA was not legally enforceable, JGJ failed in its counterclaims in Suit 418 for the inducement of breaches of the JVA (Judgment at [237] and [242(d)]). Presumably, the Judge also intended to find that JGJ failed in its counterclaim against SRK for breach of the JVA.
(j) JGJ also failed in its counterclaim for conspiracy to injure (Judgment at [240] and [242(e)]).
- [56]
[56] In summary:
Suit 475
- [57]
[57] As for Suit 475, the Judge made the following findings and conclusions (see, generally, Judgment at [328]):
(a) Shailesh was SRK’s nominee shareholder and director in JGJ. That said, he had the necessary standing to bring a claim under s 216 of the CA (Judgment at [251], [267] and [328(a)]).
(b) Although the Kriss Brothers were aware of and had accepted the nominee arrangement, Shailesh had failed to plead his s 216 claim on the basis that he was a nominee shareholder for SRK (Judgment at [270] and [271]). Accordingly, in deciding whether the acts complained of were commercially unfair to Shailesh, the interests of SRK (as the beneficial owner of Shailesh’s shares in JGJ) could not be considered by the court (Judgment at [271]).
(c) Shailesh could not claim a legitimate expectation that the Kriss Brothers would fulfil their duties as directors (Judgment at [275], [276] and [328(b)]).
(d) Shailesh’s claim based on the First Resolution failed. The complained-of conduct in relation to the First Resolution affected Shailesh primarily in his capacity as a director of JGJ. It did not affect his interest qua shareholder as he did not plead any legitimate expectation to be involved in the management of JGJ as a director and the evidence did not support such a legitimate expectation (Judgment at [279]). The complaint that the Kriss Brothers decided to go after the TJCNY Debt but not the other debts (ie, the debts owed by the JDM Entities) related to a corporate wrong, not a personal wrong (Judgment at [282]).
(e) Shailesh’s claim based on the Second Resolution failed. The allegation that SRK and TJCI manipulated the prices of the Goods sold to JGJ related to a corporate wrong and Shailesh did not show how he had suffered an injury as a shareholder (Judgment at [289]). The complaint that Shailesh did not have access to or information about JGJ’s IDBNY account affected Shailesh in his capacity as a director, and thus fell outside the scope of s 216 (Judgment at [290]).
(f) With respect to Shailesh’s claim pertaining to the four adjustments made by the Kriss Brothers in the 2016 Revised FS:
(i) The Commission Rebate Adjustment was not commercially unfair because it was made pursuant to volume rebate agreements that had been discussed and agreed upon (Judgment at [297] and [328(d)(i)]). However, the other three adjustments, ie, the Accounts Payable Adjustment, SRK Payable Adjustment and Capital Repayment Adjustment were commercially unfair (Judgment at [299], [301], [302], [304] and [328(d)(i)]). We will refer to these adjustments as the “Three Adjustments”.
(ii) Shailesh’s complaint that the Kriss Brothers had failed to provide documents and/or explanations to JGJ’s auditors was based on the Kriss Brothers’ duties to JGJ as directors to ensure that JGJ’s financial affairs were properly managed. It thus fell outside the scope of s 216 of the CA (Judgment at [309] and [328(d)(ii)]).
(iii) Shailesh’s complaint that the Kriss Brothers had failed to provide him with documents or to engage him with respect to the four adjustments in the 2016 Revised FS was not substantiated and therefore failed (Judgment at [312] to [315]). Furthermore, in so far as Shailesh’s complaint related to the resolution to approve the 2016 Revised FS, that affected him in his capacity as a director and thus fell outside the scope of s 216 of the CA (Judgment at [311]).
(g) Shailesh therefore succeeded in his s 216 claim only to the extent that it was based on the Three Adjustments (Judgment at [328(e)]).
(h) JGJ’s counterclaim against Shailesh was dismissed (Judgment at [328(f)]). With respect to the First Resolution, the facts did not support JGJ’s claim that Shailesh acted in breach of his director’s duties (Judgment at [319]). With respect to the Second Resolution, there was no price manipulation because the parties had agreed for the Goods to be invoiced based on Sell-Minus Pricing (Judgment at [323]). With respect to the Third Resolution, as the Judge found that the Three Adjustments made by the Kriss Brothers in the 2016 Revised FS were unjustified, Shailesh had not acted in breach of his director’s duties in connection with the Third Resolution (Judgment at [324]). With respect to JGJ’s counterclaim that Shailesh had acted in breach of his fiduciary duties by requesting certain information and documents, JGJ had failed to prove that the purpose of Shailesh’s requests was to defeat, frustrate and/or stymie JGJ’s claims against one or more of the SRK Entities (Judgment at [327]).
- [58]
[58] In summary, with respect to Suit 475:
(b) JGJ failed in its counterclaim.
Costs and interest
(a) SRK interest on the sum of US$17,538,999.49 at the rate of 5.33% per annum from the date of the Writ of Summons (23 April 2018) until the date of the Judgment (18 January 2024); and
(b) TJCI interest on the sum of US$2,027,846.91 at the rate of 5.33% per annum from the date of TJCI’s counterclaim (6 November 2020) until the date of the Judgment (18 January 2024).
The appeals arising from Suit 418 (namely, AD 21 and AD 22)
The parties’ cases
JGJ’s case
- [63]
[63] JGJ is the appellant in AD 21 and the respondent in AD 22.
- [65]
[65] JGJ was also able to enforce the JVA as it became a party to the JVA after it was incorporated on the basis of the doctrine of implied contracts. JGJ also argues that SRK is estopped from denying that JGJ is a party to the JVA and that, in any event, JGJ can enforce the terms of the JVA pursuant to the Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 2001 (Cap 53B, 2002 Rev Ed) (the “CRTPA”).
- [66]
[66] Even if the Court finds that the JVA is unenforceable, SRK’s claim in unjust enrichment should nevertheless be dismissed. JGJ was not the party enriched as it neither received the Goods nor earned a profit from them. The Judge also erred in dismissing JGJ’s defences of change of position and estoppel.
- [69]
[69] In AD 22, JGJ’s case as the respondent is that SRK has wrongly contended that the Judge was not entitled on the pleadings to find that the parties had conducted themselves on the basis of the JV. According to JGJ, the Judge had impliedly found that the parties began operating on the basis of the JV on or around 13 January 2015. The Judge found that the terms by which the JV operated included the Capital Term. The evidence also supported the finding that the parties were operating on the basis of a JV.
SRK Parties’ case
- [70]
[70] SRK and TJCI are the first and second appellants in AD 22 respectively. SRK, TJCI, Govind, Rahul, Nirav and Amit (which we will refer to collectively as the “SRK Parties”) are the first, second and fourth to seventh respondents in AD 21 respectively.
- [71]
[71] In AD 22, SRK and TJCI appeal against:
(a) the Judge’s decision to dismiss SRK’s primary claim for the SRK Unpaid Sum;
(b) the Judge’s decision that SRK is liable to JGJ for counter-restitution of US$2,467,350.67;
(c) the Judge’s decision to dismiss TJCI’s primary claim for the TJCI Unpaid Sum; and
(d) the Judge’s decision on costs and interest in so far as affected by the findings in (a) to (c) above.
In the event that this Court dismisses the appeal in AD 22, SRK and TJCI do not appeal against the Judge’s finding on their alternative claim (ie, the restitutionary claim), which they contend should be allowed to stand.
- [72]
[72] In summary, the SRK Parties contend in AD 21 and AD 22 that the Judge was correct in (a) rejecting JGJ’s case on the purported JVA entered into on 13 January 2015 with the terms set out at para 10 of JGJ’s Defence and Counterclaim (Amendment No. 1); and (b) finding that even if JGJ had successfully amended its pleaded case to change the date of the JVA, JGJ would still have failed in its case. However, the Judge erred in making a finding on an unpleaded case involving the unenforceable JVA that the parties were purportedly collaborating on, and consequently in finding that this somehow meant that the invoices did not create any payment liability. The evidence does not support the Judge’s finding of a JV. In any event, JGJ has no standing to enforce the JV that the Judge found to exist.
TJCNY’s and Ashish’s case
- [74]
[74] TJCNY and Ashish are the third and eighth respondents in AD 21 respectively; they are not parties to AD 22. They argue that Ashish did not act wrongfully in releasing payments from JGJ’s account as, even on JGJ’s case, the release of payments against the invoices was the agreed-upon mechanism for capital to flow within the JV. JGJ’s case also failed to show any wrongdoing by TJCNY or Ashish in relation to SRK’s demand for payment on the 23M Invoices. Indeed, TJCNY and Ashish were not involved in seeking any payment on the invoices.
- [75]
[75] TJCNY and Ashish also echo the SRK Parties’ position that the Judge had erred in finding that the collaboration between the SRK Entities and the JDM Entities was based on a JV and that TJCNY was a party to this JV. While the Judge found that there was an unenforceable JV in respect of certain matters, none of those matters involved TJCNY.
- [76]
[76] In any event, TJCNY and Ashish submit that the Judge did not err in dismissing JGJ’s counterclaim in Suit 418 in its entirety on the basis that there was no legally enforceable JVA and that in any event, JGJ had no standing to enforce the JVA. It follows that JGJ’s counterclaim for inducing breaches of the JVA must fail. Even if the Court finds that there was a legally enforceable JVA and JGJ had standing to enforce it, TJCNY and Ashish submit that JGJ’s counterclaim against them would have been dismissed. JGJ's case in AD 21 against the Judge’s dismissal of its counterclaim is focused on its counterclaim on conspiracy to injure JGJ, which is a clearly unmeritorious claim.
Issues to be determined
- [78]
[78] At the outset, we observe that much time was spent by the parties and, consequently, the Judge on the distinction between the BA and the JV/JVA and on which label ought to be properly accorded to the nature of the parties’ business collaboration. Both the parties and the Judge proceeded on the assumption that this was a material distinction and, specifically, that if the Judge agreed that the parties had operated on the basis of the JV/JVA, the Goods must have been supplied as “capital” and there would be no liability on JGJ’s part to pay for these Goods. As we will elaborate later in this judgment, that is not necessarily the case. In our view, the main issues which require determination in AD 21 and AD 22 are instead as follows:
Issue 1: Whether JGJ is prima facie liable to pay SRK and to pay TJCI for the Goods supplied under the 23M Invoices and the 2.2M Invoices respectively
- [79]
[79] The parties’ arguments pertaining to SRK’s primary claim on the 23M Invoices, TJCI’s claim on the 2.2M Invoices and JGJ’s counterclaim on the 42M Invoices, are ultimately concerned with the issue of whether JGJ is contractually liable to pay for the Goods supplied. If so, the question then arises whether JGJ is liable to pay the sums reflected in the invoices. If JGJ is so liable, there would be no basis for JGJ’s counterclaim on the 42M Invoices given that SRK would have rightly received the full sums stated therein.
- [80]
[80] As alluded to above, the bulk of the parties’ arguments on this issue is premised on their respective characterisations of the nature of their business collaboration. SRK’s case, simply put, is that the invoices, which reflect the sale of goods to JGJ, have yet to be paid. These sales were made in the context of the BA, which by SRK’s pleaded case was a non-committal commercial arrangement serving as a “trial” period for a potential joint venture that never materialised. This BA was terminated on 31 August 2017. TJCI’s case on the 2.2M Invoices proceeds on the same basis.
- [82]
[82] Further and/or in the alternative, JGJ pleaded that it is not liable to make payment on the 23M Invoices and the 2.2M Invoices because the Accounting Reconciliation was not conducted. Still further and/or in the alternative, JGJ also contends that following the termination of the JV/JVA on 31 August 2017, it was understood between the parties to the JV that the Termination Settlement Exercise would take place. JGJ’s alternative case is that unless and until this exercise is conducted, JGJ is not liable to make payment of the 23M Invoices. JGJ adopts the same position in respect of the 2.2M Invoices. We deal with JGJ’s alternative pleaded defences on the Accounting Reconciliation and the Termination Settlement Exercise later.
- [84]
[84] Nonetheless, the Judge proceeded to find that “[u]nder the terms of the JV/JVA”, the parties had agreed on the Equity Terms. The Judge concluded that it “follow[ed] from the [Equity Terms] that there was no agreement by JGJ to pay for the goods supplied by SRK and TJCI based on the amounts stated in the 23M Invoices, 42M Invoices or 2.2M Invoices” and found that the amounts on the invoices were only “to comply with tax and regulatory requirements” (Judgment at [194] and [195]).
- [85]
[85] In our view, the key question underlying the parties’ lengthy arguments as to whether they had collaborated on the basis of the BA or the JV/JVA is whether the Goods were supplied by SRK/TJCI to JGJ as sales. As a starting point, the existence of the invoices suggests, on a prima facie basis, that the Goods were sold to JGJ and, accordingly, that contractual liability arose on JGJ’s part to pay for the Goods supplied by SRK and TJCI. This is for the simple reason that an invoice is often considered as evidence that goods have been delivered pursuant to a contract of sale and consequently there is an underlying obligation to pay for them. It is important to bear in mind that JGJ did not question the issuance of the invoices addressed to JGJ. Accordingly, the evidential burden shifts to JGJ to prove that the parties never intended for JGJ to be contractually liable for the Goods, ie, the transactions were not in fact sales.
- [86]
[86] We agree with the Judge that the evidence does not support the SRK Entities’ narrative that the parties were only cooperating on the basis of a non-committal arrangement like the BA, in which they were merely “exploring” the possibility of a future joint venture. This narrative sits uncomfortably with, among other things, (a) the parties’ access to JGJ’s IDBNY account (see [17] above), (b) the combining of insurance policies between the JDM Entities and the SRK Entities, (c) the parties’ joint participation at business events and (d) the streamlining of back-office functions, which would inevitably have involved the sharing of highly confidential information. For these reasons, and for the other reasons given by the Judge in finding that there was a JV (Judgment at [63]–[160]), we accept that there was some sort of JV between the parties and that they had entered into a JVA.
- [87]
[87] While it is not clear what all the terms of the JVA were, and even who all the parties thereto were, we agree that some, if not all, of the SRK Entities and of the JDM Entities were parties to the JVA. Steps were taken pursuant to the JVA which gave rise to rights and obligations, although it is not clear what all the rights and obligations under the JVA were. It is apparent, for example, that JGJ was incorporated as a 50-50 set-up and the Goods were to be, and were in fact, supplied by SRK and/or TJCI. However, we take the view that it is not necessary for us to decide on all the terms of the JVA and all the parties thereto as the present dispute only concerns the question of whether JGJ is liable to pay SRK and TJCI for the Goods and the quantum of such liability. For present purposes, we need only say that the existence of a JVA does not necessarily mean that JGJ had no liability to pay for the Goods. Indeed, even if the Goods were supplied as “capital”, that too is not determinative of the key question as we proceed to explain.
Deficiencies in JGJ’s case regarding the Capital Term
- [88]
[88] To start off, we are of the view that the Judge erred in concluding that because there was a JVA (albeit unenforceable for the reasons provided at [172]–[192] of the Judgment), the Goods were necessarily supplied as equity contributions and hence did not need to be paid for by JGJ. As mentioned, JGJ defines “the Capital Term”, which it claims forms part of the terms in the JVA, as “the term that the Goods supplied shall be treated as capital in the JV and the invoices were not payable” [emphasis added]. The two parts to JGJ’s definition are not necessarily causally related. In other words, even if the Goods were supplied as “capital”, whether JGJ is liable to make payment for them will ultimately depend on the meaning of the term “capital”. JGJ will therefore need to show that the Goods were supplied as equity contributions (ie, share capital) or were otherwise supplied as “capital” which it did not need to repay. We add that the invoices themselves do not create a cause of action. They are, at most, evidence of a contract of sale, who the parties thereto were, the relevant goods and/or services and the prices they were supplied at. The real question is whether the Goods were supplied as sales and thus whether JGJ is liable to pay for the Goods.
- [89]
[89] We now turn to JGJ’s case that the Goods supplied by each party were to be treated as its respective “capital” injections into the JV. In short, we do not find this narrative to be a coherent one.
- [90]
[90] Although the Judge concluded that the Goods were supplied as “equity contributions” (Judgment at [194(a)]), JGJ is unclear in its pleadings on what the term “capital” is intended to refer to. In its Defence and Counterclaim (Amendment No. 1) dated 20 December 2021 in Suit 418 (“Suit 418 DCC”), JGJ states at para 10(2)(c) that any goods supplied pursuant to the JV would represent and be treated “as capital in the Joint Venture”. On the other hand, at para 10(2)(e), JGJ then states that the goods supplied, including those under the 23M Invoices and 42M Invoices, represented and were to be treated as each party’s “equity contributions to the [JV]” [emphasis added]. The use of the term “equity” suggests that “capital” as pleaded refers to share capital. Moreover, the implication is that any share capital would be share capital in JGJ, as that was the vehicle for the JV and no share capital of any other corporate entity was suggested to be relevant.
- [91]
[91] On the other hand, counsel for JGJ confirmed at the hearing before us that “capital” did not refer to JGJ’s share capital. Mr Joseph Lee (“Mr Lee”), who appeared with Mr Lok Vi Ming SC (“Mr Lok”) for JGJ, clarified that JGJ’s share capital never increased to reflect what was, on JGJ’s case, “the capital in the terms of goods that were being injected into the JV” for FY 2015. Specifically, in JGJ’s audited financial statements for 2015, only the initial US$100 issued share capital and JGJ’s retained earnings for 2015 comprised JGJ’s equity for FY 2015. In JGJ’s audited financial statements for 2016 (ie, the 2016 Revised FS), JGJ’s issued share capital of 100 shares was reflected at a total value of US$100 plus the US$700,000 injection in May 2016 (see [20] above). Both financial statements were authorised for issue by JGJ’s board, which would have included the Kriss Brothers. This means that the Kriss Brothers, who are now giving instructions to counsel on JGJ’s behalf, were aware all along that these “capital” contributions were not injections into JGJ’s share capital.
- [92]
[92] Instead, Mr Lee sought to explain that the parties’ injections of “capital” were recorded entirely independently of JGJ’s share capital, and that this “capital” need not have been held by JGJ and was capital in the JV. However, this explanation was nebulous and he stopped short of suggesting that it was equity in any other entity. His oral explanation was therefore inconsistent with the Judge’s conclusion that the Goods were to be treated as “equity contributions” to the JV. On the contrary, Mr Lee’s explanation suggested that the contribution of such “capital” was in essence working capital or loans made by the respective parties to the JV. We find this explanation problematic for JGJ for three reasons.
- [93]
[93] First, even if the Goods were supplied by SRK/TJCI to JGJ as working capital, there must be a party who has to be liable for these Goods. If this were not so, that means that SRK/TJCI would in essence have provided these Goods to JGJ for free without obtaining anything (be it shares or money) in return. In our view, the party who is liable must be JGJ. This is because the invoices were addressed to and sent to JGJ without protest and, in turn, JGJ invoiced the JDM Entities and TJCNY. The analysis in this regard may be made clearer by way of a hypothetical illustration. Suppose SRK had supplied a sum of US$23m (ie, cash) to JGJ to buy the Goods and JGJ had used the sum to buy the Goods which were then supplied to the JDM Entities and TJCNY. JGJ would still be liable to SRK for that sum of money even though it was supplied as working capital for JGJ to buy the Goods. In this hypothetical scenario, the sum of US$23m would be a loan from SRK which JGJ would need to repay unless the sum was tendered in exchange for shares issued by some entity.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.