Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 7 Jan 2026

Appellate Division of the High Court

Serious claims of dishonesty by a director needed a full trial, not affidavits alone

Yit Chee Wah (as private trustee of the estate of Chan Siew Lee Jannie, a bankrupt) v Fulcrum Distressed Partners Ltd

Feedback & support

[2026] SGHC(A) 1Case no. Appellate Division / Civil Appeal No 11 of 2025

The decision, in one line

Not legal advice

Serious claims of dishonesty by a director needed a full trial, not affidavits alone

Summary by laws.sgParagraphs [140], [144]

There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] This is an appeal against the decision by the Judge below (the “Judge”) in SME Care Pte Ltd v Chan Siew Lee Jannie and another matter [2025] SGHC 27 (the “Judgment”). The Judgment addressed three main applications involving the same bankrupt, Jannie Chan Siew Lee (“Ms Chan”), and her private trustee in bankruptcy (“PTIB”), Mr Yit Chee Wah (“Mr Yit”).

  3. [2] The first main application, HC/SUM 4315/2022 (“SUM 4315”), was Ms Chan’s application to set aside Mr Yit’s partial admission of a proof of debt filed by SME Care Pte Ltd. The Judge dismissed the application. Since this appeal does not involve SUM 4315, we say no more about it.

  4. [3] The second and third main applications were in respect of a proof of debt filed by the liquidators of Timor Global Pte Ltd (“TGPL”), a Singapore-incorporated company, and pursued by the assignee of TGPL’s debt, Fulcrum Distressed Partners Ltd (“FDPL”), a company incorporated in the British Virgin Islands (“BVI”). The second main application comprised HC/SUM 4314/2022 (“SUM 4314”) and HC/OA 797/2022 (“OA 797”) filed by FDPL, where it sought to reverse Mr Yit’s rejection of two sums of the proof filed. At the same time, for the third main application in HC/SUM 4316/2022 (“SUM 4316”) filed by Ms Chan, she argued that two other parts of the proof should not have been accepted by Mr Yit. The Judge allowed the second main application and dismissed the third main application.

  5. [4] Mr Yit brings this appeal against the Judge’s decision relating to the second main application, ie, SUM 4314 and OA 797, which was decided in favour of FDPL. Mr Yit contends that two sums, referred to by the parties and the Judge as the “TL Sum” and the “Finished Goods Sum”, should not be admitted under the proof of debt regime, or alternatively, that the Judge ought to have conducted a trial or at least ordered cross-examination of witnesses, before deciding whether those sums should be admitted.

  6. [5] Having considered the parties’ written and oral submissions, we are of the view that the proper course of action is for us to order a trial before the Judge to determine the admissibility of the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum. The allegations against Ms Chan are that she had breached her duty to act honestly and in good faith in the interests of TGPL. Those are serious accusations, and the available evidence before us does not appear sufficient to establish such dishonesty and lack of good faith. As we shall elaborate, the evidence pertaining to the elements of breach of fiduciary duty is contradictory and incomplete, leaving gaps which ought to be further explored through the processes available in proceedings for an originating claim such as discovery, orders for persons to attend court as witnesses, and the oral examination of witnesses.

  7. [6] We also take this opportunity to reiterate that the proof of debt regime is designed for the relevant adjudicator (eg, a PTIB) to decide straightforward claims efficiently, such as where the written and/or documentary evidence clearly establish liability. In claims which involve complex disputes of fact, and where examination of witnesses is necessary to resolve the disputes, the adjudicator can reject the claim and explain that the claim is not amenable to be determined summarily. Alternatively, the adjudicator can seek directions from the court as to how the claim should be determined. Often, in such cases, the court may direct that there be a trial of the claim or at least some limited cross-examination of witnesses to resolve the material disputes of fact. In the present case, given the nature of the issues, it would have been appropriate for Mr Yit to have sought directions from the court on how those issues should be best resolved in the present circumstances. Alternatively, Mr Yit and FDPL should have attempted to agree on the modalities for resolving those issues and obtain directions from the court on whether their approach was acceptable. However, neither course of action was taken by the parties. Instead, each party proceeded independently on the basis that the issues in dispute could be resolved simply based on the affidavits and documentary evidence. This was an erroneous approach. The Judge ought not to have permitted the parties to proceed on this basis. Instead, a trial of the disputed claims ought to have been ordered.

  8. Facts

  9. Background

  10. [7] TGPL was incorporated in Singapore on 16 February 2005. Its sole shareholder at all material times was Ms Chan. From the time of incorporation until the company was ordered to be wound up in 2018, Ms Chan and a Mr Lay Ni Suig Bobby (“Mr Lay”) were directors of TGPL. In addition, a Mr Tan Tjo Tek (“Mr Tan”) was a director of TGPL from 2005 to August 2016. TGPL was placed in compulsory liquidation on 2 March 2018. Timor Global (TL) Pte Ltd (“TL”), a Timor-Leste company registered in 2005, is another company that features in these proceedings. Ms Chan held between 60 to 70% of the shares in TL at all material times. Mr Lay was the sole director of TL: Judgment at [26]–[27].

  11. [8] TGPL and TL were in the business of agricultural trading, such as coffee beans. From 2006 to 2008, TGPL and TL were involved in a joint venture arrangement with Intraco Trading Pte Ltd (“Intraco”) for the processing and trading of coffee beans, and for the profits to be shared between TGPL and Intraco. To that end, TGPL, TL and Intraco entered into a joint venture agreement on 1 July 2007 (“2007 JVA”). Notably, the recitals of the 2007 JVA referred to an earlier agreement dated 27 March 2006 (“2006 JVA”), but only the 2007 JVA was produced as part of the documentary evidence before the court below. According to the recitals of the 2007 JVA, the latter covered substantially the same subject matter as the 2006 JVA, but there were some changes to Intraco’s trading commitment and the way profits were to be shared.

  12. [9] Under the terms of the 2007 JVA:

  13. (a) TGPL would place orders for processed coffee beans from Intraco, and Intraco would in turn order an equivalent amount from TL. Intraco was required to make advance payment to TL of the purchase price for the coffee beans.

  14. (b) TL would purchase raw materials from third parties and then process them into coffee beans. The advance payment by Intraco was intended to enable TL to purchase the raw materials and process them into coffee beans.

  15. (c) The coffee beans Intraco purchased from TL would be on-sold by Intraco to TGPL at cost.

  16. (d) TGPL would then market and sell the coffee beans to third-party buyers, with gross profits of such sales being split according to a pre-arranged formula of either (a) 60:40 (TGPL:Intraco) where Intraco’s share of the profits were up to US$770,040; or (b) 70:30 for profits above that threshold. Any losses would be borne entirely by TGPL.

  17. [10] It is not in dispute that the parties did not adhere strictly to the terms of the 2007 JVA. For example, for reasons that were not explained, the invoices issued by TL to Intraco for the advance payments directed the latter to make payment to TGPL’s bank accounts instead of TL’s bank accounts. That was what Intraco did. It is undisputed that, from 31 July 2007 to 17 October 2007, S$8,638,389.92 was paid by Intraco to TGPL, who then paid S$8,142,398.70 to TL (from 3 August 2007 to 18 October 2007). Whether those payments to TGPL and their onward transfer to TL were pursuant to the joint venture arrangements between Intraco, TGPL and TL is one of the contentious issues in dispute in this case, as we will explain below.

  18. [11] In 2008, disputes arose in relation to the joint venture agreement. In September 2009, Intraco commenced arbitration proceedings against both TGPL and TL. While Intraco settled its claim against TL in September 2010, it continued pursuing its claim against TGPL. Eventually, Intraco obtained arbitration awards in its favour of S$6,635,566.93 and S$3,630,001 on 10 March 2015 and 26 November 2015 respectively against TGPL. In April 2015, Intraco obtained leave to enforce one of the awards as an order of court and took out examination of judgment debtor proceedings against TGPL (the “Intraco EJD Proceedings”). Ms Chan filed three affidavits in those proceedings (the “Intraco EJD Affidavits”), and was also examined in court. Intraco subsequently brought winding up proceedings against TGPL and it was ordered to be wound up on 2 March 2018.

  19. [12] TGPL’s liquidators found discrepancies in the records of TGPL as to the amounts due from TL. For example, the latest management accounts of TGPL reflected the TL Sum as being the amount of receivables due from TL, whereas the amount of receivables recorded as due from TL to TGPL in TGPL’s last audited financial statements (for the financial year ending 31 December 2008) was substantially less than the amount shown in TGPL’s management accounts for the same year. The books and records of TGPL were also found to be incomplete.

  20. [13] On 17 May 2019, TGPL’s liquidators applied to examine Ms Chan and Mr Lay, the two directors of TGPL at the time it was placed in liquidation. However, on 27 May 2019, Ms Chan was adjudged bankrupt on an application made by SME Care Pte Ltd in relation to an unrelated debt. Proceedings against Ms Chan were then stayed and she was never examined by TGPL’s liquidators. For reasons which are unclear, the liquidators also did not proceed with the examination of Mr Lay.

  21. [14] On 14 October 2019, TGPL’s liquidators filed a proof of debt against Ms Chan’s estate in bankruptcy for four sums, including the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum. The quantum of the four sums totalled S$18,413,260 and US$2,301,767: Judgment at [30]. The proof of debt was revised on 1 April 2022. Among other changes, the TL Sum was adjusted from S$15,400,000 to S$15,766,460. This sum referred to the receivables allegedly owed by TL to TGPL as at 31 December 2014. The Finished Goods Sum referred to a sum of US$2,301,767.43, which, according to FDPL, converted to S$3,161,247.39 using the Monetary Authority of Singapore’s exchange rate for 27 May 2019 (the date of Ms Chan’s bankruptcy order) of S$1.3734 = US$1. This sum represented sales proceeds from coffee beans sold by TGPL in 2008, which were allegedly paid directly by TGPL’s customers to TL between 19 June 2008 and 14 November 2008: Judgment at [32]. The basis of the claim against Ms Chan for both sums was that she had breached her fiduciary duties as a director of TGPL.

  22. [15] Mr Yit was subsequently appointed as the PTIB of Ms Chan’s estate in bankruptcy on 9 June 2020 and he proceeded to adjudicate the proof of debt. Mr Yit met with Ms Chan on nine occasions and also wrote to TGPL’s liquidators to ask for further information and documents about the two sums. Ms Chan objected to the claims for the two sums, as well as other sums which are not the subject of this appeal.

  23. [16] On 21 October 2022, FDPL and TGPL entered into a Sale and Assignment of Claim agreement. Through this agreement, TGPL assigned to FDPL “any and all of TGPL’s right, title, and interest in, to and under the claims of TGPL against [Ms Chan] and [her] bankruptcy estate”, including the claims set out in the original and revised proof of debt lodged by TGPL. Mr Yit was given due notice of this assignment. In this judgment, we will refer to the claims for the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum as “FDPL’s claims”, though it should be understood that FDPL is the assignee of TGPL’s claims against Ms Chan for breach of her fiduciary duties owed to TGPL.

  24. [17] Eventually, on 3 November 2022, Mr Yit issued an adjudication notice, in which he, among other things, rejected the claims for both the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum:

  25. (a) Mr Yit rejected the claim for the TL Sum for two main reasons. First, he found that the documents did not provide satisfactory evidence that Ms Chan had breached her custodial fiduciary duties to TGPL. In particular, the evidence did not show that Ms Chan had misapplied the TL Sum by authorising the transfers of funds from TGPL to TL without any commercial purpose or had personally taken the benefit of such funds. Second, Mr Yit found that FDPL’s claim for the TL Sum was time-barred, as the bulk of the transactions making up the TL Sum occurred more than six years before the winding up order on 2 March 2018.

  26. (b) Mr Yit rejected FDPL’s claim for the Finished Goods Sum because (i) there was insufficient evidence that Ms Chan instructed the customers to make these payments directly to TL or even knew about these payments; and (ii) there was no evidence that Ms Chan directly benefited from TL’s receipt of the Finished Goods Sum.

  27. The proceedings below

  28. [18] On 24 November 2022, FDPL filed OA 797 to appeal against Mr Yit’s decision to reject the claims for the TL Sum and the Finished Good Sum. Shortly after that, FDPL filed SUM 4314 under HC/B 2648/2018 (“B 2648”), which was the bankruptcy application pursuant to which Ms Chan was adjudicated a bankrupt. SUM 4314 sought the same orders as OA 797. The reason for the two applications was uncertainty as to whether the regime governing the appeal against Mr Yit’s adjudication was the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 (2020 Rev Ed) (“IRDA”) or the now-repealed Bankruptcy Act (Cap 20, 2009 Rev Ed) (“BA”). If it was the former, the application would be made by an originating application but if it was the latter, the application would be made by a summons. This apparent lack of clarity stemmed from s 525(1)(b) of the IRDA, a transitional provision, which provides that the bankruptcy provisions in the IRDA do not apply “to or in relation to … any bankruptcy application made before 30 July 2020”, but that the BA as in force immediately before 30 July 2020 will continue to apply. The issue is whether these words in s 525(1)(b) of the IRDA mean that the bankruptcy provisions in the IRDA do not apply in relation to proceedings consequential to and arising from an order of bankruptcy based on a bankruptcy application made before 30 July 2020. The Judge did not express a view on this issue.

  29. [20] In our view, the regime under the BA applies to this case. Although the term “bankruptcy application” under s 525(1)(b) of the IRDA is not explicitly defined, that term for Parts 13 to 21 of the IRDA refers to an application to the Court for a bankruptcy order, which in turn means an order adjudging a debtor bankrupt – see s 273(1) of the IRDA. The term “bankruptcy application” has the same meaning under s 2(1) of the BA. We think that the applications made below to appeal against Mr Yit’s adjudication on the admission of certain sums as debts in the bankruptcy estate of Ms Chan were made “in relation to” a bankruptcy application made before 30 July 2020. That the applications were made ultimately arises from the bankruptcy application made against Ms Chan in B 2648 which was filed on 2 November 2018 before the cut-off date of 30 July 2020.

  30. [21] We turn now to the conduct of the proceedings below. Counsel for Mr Yit and FDPL appeared before the Judge and made oral and written submissions. Ms Chan acted in person and filed SUM 4316 to appeal against Mr Yit’s decision to admit certain sums as due from her to TGPL (and thus FDPL as assignee): Judgment at [3]. These sums did not include the TL Sum and Finished Goods Sum as Mr Yit did not admit them. In her affidavit in support of SUM 4316, she stated, among other things, that:

  31. [22] During the hearing before the Judge, Ms Chan also appeared in person and made arguments. She claimed that, amongst other things, she was “just an investor … [t]o finance equipment” for TGPL, and “was not involved in that company” or in its operations.

  32. [23] There was no oral examination of any witnesses in the proceedings below. Mr Lay and Mr Tan did not file any affidavits for the proceedings. The Judge had raised the possibility of converting the matter to a civil suit, but neither party took up the suggestion.

  33. Decision below

  34. The TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum were provable debts

  35. [24] Mr Yit initially argued that breaches of fiduciary duty must be custodial for claims for damages arising from such breaches to be provable in bankruptcy. Mr Yit argued that FDPL’s claims for the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum were claims for non-custodial breaches and thus did not give rise to debts provable in bankruptcy. On the other hand, FDPL contended that claims for damages arising from non-custodial breaches of fiduciary duty were also provable in bankruptcy.

  36. [25] However, after the Judge invited both parties to consider his decision in Re Medora Xerxes Jamshid (in his capacity as the private trustee in bankruptcy of Tan Han Meng) (Planar One & Associates Pte Ltd (in liquidation), non-party) [2024] 5 SLR 1006 (“Re Medora Xerxes”) and file further submissions, the parties then took the common position that a claim for damages for breach of fiduciary duty, regardless of whether the breach was of a custodial or non-custodial nature, was provable as an unliquidated claim arising by breach of trust. On this basis, and applying the principles in Re Medora Xerxes, the Judge held that the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum were capable of being provable debts, if established by the evidence: Judgment at [36]–[37].

  37. [26] The parties did not appeal against this part of the Judge’s decision.

  38. The TL Sum should be admitted

  39. [27] The Judge held that the TL Sum should be admitted in full.

  40. The composition of the TL Sum

  41. [28] The Judge analysed the TL Sum as comprising three components (Judgment at [31]):

  42. (a) the sum of S$8,142,398.70, which arises from transfers made by TGPL to TL in 2007 (the “2007 Payments”) (see [10] above).

  43. (b) the sum of S$6,662,009.44, which is the amount recorded in the accounts as being due from TL to TGPL as at 31 December 2006 (the “Opening Balance”); and

  44. (c) the sum of S$962,051.84, which relates to payments made by TGPL purportedly for TL’s operating expenses (“Sum 3”).

  45. [29] The Judge adopted the TL Sum figure from TGPL’s management accounts for the year 2014 (the “2014 MA”): Judgment at [31]. He also accepted that Sum 3 related to payments by TGPL for TL’s operating expenses, by labelling that sum as “Operating Expenses”. As we shall explain below at [91]–[93], it is not clear that this is indeed what Sum 3 relates to. All that can really be said is that Sum 3 is simply the result of subtracting the 2007 Payments and the Opening Balance from the TL Sum.

  46. The 2007 Payments

  47. [30] Mr Yit contended that the 2007 Payments were legitimate transactions under the 2007 JVA. TL had directed Intraco to make advance payments to TGPL instead of directly to TL as provided for in the joint venture arrangements, and TGPL then passed on these funds to TL. Hence, TL was legally entitled to receive these payments – the transactions were not loans extended by TGPL to TL such that TL would have to repay these amounts. On this footing, Mr Yit argued that Ms Chan did not breach her fiduciary duties in authorising TGPL to make these payments or in subsequently failing to seek repayment and instead approving the writing-off of this “debt” due from TL.

  48. [31] FDPL submitted that the entire TL Sum, including the 2007 Payments, were loans extended by TGPL to TL with little or no commercial benefit to TGPL. These amounts were recorded as “receivables” owed by TL in TGPL's accounts. Ms Chan had also admitted during the Intraco EJD proceedings that these were genuine debts owed by TL to TGPL. As she had caused TGPL to make these loans to TL with little or no benefit to TGPL and failed to recover these amounts whilst TGPL faced insolvency, she was in breach of her fiduciary duties to the TGPL.

  49. [32] The Judge found sufficient evidence that the 2007 Payments were genuine debts owed by TL to TGPL.

  50. [33] First, the 2007 Payments were recorded as “related party receivables” or “amounts due from related parties” in TGPL’s management accounts and financial statements. Although Mr Yit argued that this was inconclusive as “[f]rom an accounting perspective, transfers by TGPL to TL could be recorded as ‘receivables’ even if the payments were not actually loans”, the Judge held that the very definition of a receivable necessarily connotes a debt due and owing to the company: Judgment at [43].

  51. [34] Second, during the Intraco EJD Proceedings, Ms Chan had stated in the Intraco EJD Affidavits that the TGPL had lent money to TL and the total amount owed by TL in 2013 was S$15,343,006.93. This amount corresponded to the receivables recorded in TGPL’s books as of 2013, which includes the 2007 Payments. She further described the loans as a “cash loan” that was secured by a director, interest-free and repayable on demand: Judgment at [44].

  52. [35] Third, the 2007 JVA could not satisfactorily explain the payments (Judgment at [46]):

  53. (a) While most of the incoming payments from Intraco and the outgoing payments to TL occurred close in time, not all of them were temporally proximate.

  54. (b) None of the incoming sums and outgoing sums were identical. For most of the transactions, there was a shortfall in the outgoing sums paid to TL, save for a notable excess of outgoing payments for the month of August 2007.

  55. (c) Some incoming payments from Intraco lacked any onward payments to TL – eg, Intraco's payment of S$1,522,400 to TGPL on 30 August 2007 for raw materials had no recorded corresponding payment from TGPL to TL.

  56. [36] Although TL may have instructed Intraco to pay TGPL for raw materials, the evidence did not establish that TGPL’s subsequent payments to TL were made under the 2007 JVA. Also, while TL may have used US$6,680,435 received from TGPL to purchase the raw materials for the processing of coffee beans, that did not conclusively show that TGPL disbursed the 2007 Payments to TL for the purpose of fulfilling the 2007 JVA. Since TGPL’s records labelled the sums as a “receivable”, and Ms Chan described them as loans, this supported the conclusion that the 2007 Payments could not be linked to the 2007 JVA: Judgment at [47]–[48].

  57. [37] The question then was whether Ms Chan had breached her fiduciary duties to TGPL in respect of the 2007 Payments. The Judge focused on whether Ms Chan had breached her duty to act honestly and bona fide in the interests of TGPL. He found that the disbursement of the 2007 Payments to TL was a breach of Ms Chan’s fiduciary duty to act honestly and bona fide in the interests of TGPL. Ms Chan could not claim ignorance of these payments given her role as director and her signing of TGPL’s financial statements from 2005 to 2017, in which the TL receivables consistently appeared as the largest asset. She had acknowledged the TL Sum during the Intraco EJD Proceedings and had not claimed the payments were made bona fide in TGPL’s interests. Therefore, she could not reasonably have believed the 2007 Payments were in TGPL’s interests: Judgment at [59].

  58. [38] The Judge found that Ms Chan’s failure to pursue repayment from 2007 to 2014 was a further breach of her duty to act bona fide in TGPL’s interests, as this only served to deprive TGPL of its assets and worsen its financial situation. For the same reasons set out in the paragraph above, Ms Chan could not claim to be ignorant of TGPL’s failure to pursue repayment from TL – she herself testified during the Intraco EJD Proceedings that there was “no repayment schedule” for the debts due from TL, and that TGPL had never made a demand for TL to repay the debts owed: Judgment at [60]–[61].

  59. [39] Finally, Ms Chan breached the duty to act honestly and bona fide in the interests of the company by approving the writing down of the TL receivables (including the 2007 Payments) in 2015. By 2014, TGPL had a net deficit of around S$6,512,000, making it clear that insolvency proceedings were inevitable. Despite this, Ms Chan instructed the write-off of S$15,343,005.93 in TL receivables, purportedly to prepare the company for winding up. This was a breach of fiduciary duty: Judgment at [62].

  60. The Opening Balance

  61. [40] The Opening Balance of approximately S$6,662,009.44 was the amount of receivables allegedly due from TL to TGPL as at 31 December 2006. The Judge rejected Mr Yit’s argument that this could be explained by the 2006 JVA. Although the 2007 JVA made reference to the earlier 2006 JVA, there was no direct evidence of its existence or the terms thereof since the agreement was not produced in evidence before the court. Even if one was to consider the 2006 JVA, the Judge found it difficult to conclude the Opening Balance was paid in performance of it for similar reasons to those regarding the 2007 Payments (see [33]–[36] above). Mr Yit’s speculation regarding the 2006 JVA contradicted other evidence showing that TL receivables had accrued since 2006 (ie, S$3,111,000 as of 2005), meaning the 2006 JVA could not fully explain how the TL receivables had accrued. Mr Yit’s assertion that “it is probable that the parties performed the [2006 JVA] in a similar manner to the [2007 JVA] i.e. that … in reality TGPL served as the conduit for payments” was found to be purely Mr Yit’s conjecture and wholly unsubstantiated: Judgment at [66]–[67].

  62. [41] The Judge held that Ms Chan had similarly breached her fiduciary duties regarding the Opening Balance by allowing the loans to be made to TL for no commercial benefit, failing to pursue repayment, and approving the writing down of the TL Sum: Judgment at [68].

  63. Sum 3

  64. [42] Sum 3 purportedly constituted certain business-related expenses paid by TGPL on behalf of TL to TL’s directors, employees, auditors and trade creditors, amounting to S$962,051.84. Mr Yit initially argued that Sum 3 had a commercial purpose as TL was TGPL’s wholly owned subsidiary. However, once FDPL provided evidence that TL was not in fact a wholly owned subsidiary of TGPL, Mr Yit no longer seriously disputed that Sum 3 lacked commercial purpose; instead, he argued that the claim for Sum 3 was time-barred: Judgment at [69].

  65. The claim for the TL Sum was not time-barred

  66. [43] Mr Yit argued that the claims regarding the breaches of fiduciary duties relating to the TL Sum were time-barred under the six-year limitation period prescribed by s 6 of the Limitation Act 1959 (2020 Rev Ed) (the “LA”). Mr Yit took the position that none of the exceptions in s 22(1) of the LA applied.

  67. [44] The Judge held that a six-year limitation period generally applies to claims for breach of directors’ fiduciary duties (Judgment at [74]–[75]), with the cause of action accruing from the point when the breach occurs: Judgment at [71]. However, contrary to Mr Yit’s submissions, the Judge held that s 22(1) of the LA applied. That provision provides:

  68. [45] The Judge endorsed the following propositions (Judgment at [73]–[75]):

  69. (a) A breach of trust is fraudulent if it is dishonest. Such dishonesty “connotes at the minimum an intention on the part of the trustee to pursue a particular course of action, either knowing that it is contrary to the interests of the company or being recklessly indifferent whether it is contrary to their interests or not”. Further, if a trustee “acts in a way which he does not honestly believe is in the interests of the beneficiaries then he is acting dishonestly” (Yong Kheng Leong and another v Panweld Trading Pte Ltd and another [2013] 1 SLR 173 (“Panweld”) at [52]–[53], citing Gwembe Valley Development Co Ltd (in receivership) v Koshy and others (No 3) [2004] 1 BCLC 131 (“Gwembe Valley”) at [131]).

  70. (b) In determining whether there is dishonesty, the court considers whether “the defendant’s conduct was dishonest by the ordinary standards of reasonable and honest people and that he himself realised that by those standards his conduct was dishonest” (Panweld at [52]–[53], citing Gwembe Valley at [132]).

  71. (c) The statutory provisions on limitation regarding a breach of trust apply to claims for a director’s breach of fiduciary duty (Re Medora Xerxes at [45]; Panweld at [44], [48]–[49] and [53]; Dynasty Line Ltd (in liquidation) v Sukamto Sia and another and another appeal [2014] 3 SLR 277 (“Dynasty Line (CA)”) at [55]–[56]).

  72. [46] Applying these principles, the Judge concluded that Ms Chan could not be said to have acted honestly in extending the TL Sum to TL for no commercial benefit, making no effort to seek repayment, and writing down the receivables despite TGPL’s imminent or inevitable insolvency. Therefore, s 22(1)(a) of the LA applied, and FDPL's claim for the TL Sum was not time-barred: Judgment at [76].

  73. The Finished Goods Sum should be admitted

  74. [47] Mr Yit rejected the claim for the Finished Goods Sum primarily because there was no evidence that Ms Chan instructed or knew about these payments from the end-buyers to TL, which Mr Yit contended was required for a director to be in breach.

  75. [48] FDPL argued that Ms Chan’s knowledge should be inferred from the circumstances, especially given that this sum was clearly recorded in TL's management accounts since at least 13 May 2009, making it unbelievable that Ms Chan would not have enquired about it. Mr Yit, in turn, relied on Dynasty Line (CA) and argued that directors can only be held liable for breach of duties if there is evidence they were aware of the impugned transaction, such as evidence that she signed off on and thus had direct knowledge of the transaction.

  76. [49] The Judge rejected Mr Yit’s interpretation of Dynasty Line (CA). The Judge instead ascertained, more broadly, whether there was evidence that Ms Chan knew or should have known of the Finished Goods Sum. He found that there was such evidence for these reasons (Judgment at [82]):

  77. (a) Ms Chan had management and control of TGPL from incorporation until winding up, as TGPL’s liquidators had observed.

  78. (b) Ms Chan signed off on TGPL's financial statements annually from FY 2005 to FY 2017 and was an authorised bank signatory of TGPL. She therefore would have known that TGPL was not recovering all its receivables from third-party buyers.

  79. (c) The Finished Goods Sum of S$3,161,247.39 was substantial, and particularly significant in 2008 when TGPL had a net deficit of S$667,000 on its balance sheet. The Finished Goods Sum was approximately 32% of TGPL's total revenue that year.

  80. (d) As Ms Chan was both director and sole shareholder of TGPL, it was implausible that she would be ignorant of such a significant diversion of funds and would not have made inquiries as to the presence of the funds.

  81. Hence, Ms Chan either knew or should have known of the diversion of funds: Judgment at [77]–[82].

  82. [50] The Judge concluded that Ms Chan’s failure to seek repayment of the Finished Goods Sum from TL was a breach of her duty to act honestly and bona fide in the company's interests: Judgment at [83].

  83. [51] As for limitation, the Finished Goods Sum was paid to TL in 2008. The Judge did not determine whether Ms Chan’s breach was a continuing one (ie, up until TGPL’s liquidation in 2018) or crystallised in 2008. Nonetheless, he held that s 22(1)(a) of the LA applied, making the six-year limitation period inapplicable. According to the Judge, Ms Chan could not honestly have believed that allowing payments rightfully due to TGPL to be paid to TL and/or failing to seek repayment was in the company's best interests. This constituted a “fraudulent breach of trust” under s 22(1)(a) of the LA: Judgment at [84].

  84. Parties’ arguments on appeal

  85. [52] Mr Yit argues that the Judge erred in finding that the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum should be admitted.

  86. [53] For the TL Sum, Mr Yit argues that the Judge erred in finding that:

  87. (a) the TL Sum was due and owing as a genuine debt;

  88. (b) Ms Chan breached her duties in respect of the payments of the TL Sum to TL;

  89. (c) Ms Chan breached her duties in respect of the failure to cause TGPL to collect the TL Sum from TL; and

  90. (d) Ms Chan breached her duties by causing TGPL to write off the TL Sum.

  91. [54] For the Finished Goods Sum, Mr Yit argues that:

  92. (a) part of the Finished Goods Sum should not be admitted as it overlaps with the TL Sum; and

  93. (b) the Judge erred in finding that Ms Chan had breached her duties in respect of the transfer of the Finished Goods Sum, without evidence that she knew or authorised such transfer.

  94. [55] As for limitation, Mr Yit argues that the Judge erred in holding that s 22(1) of the LA applies to the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum.

  95. [56] Alternatively, Mr Yit argues that the Judge erred in summarily determining that the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum should be admitted based simply on affidavit evidence, as the claims are factually complex and substantially disputed.

  96. [57] FDPL argues that the Judge did not err in the above aspects, and that there is no overlap between the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum.

  97. [58] Before we set out the issues before us in this appeal, it will be apposite to set out several legal principles that govern the proof of debt regime.

  98. The law on the proof of debt regime

  99. [59] In the context of corporate insolvency, it has been explained that the proof of debt regime is not meant to be used to adjudicate matters involving controversial disputes of fact. This is because of the policy of efficiency underlying the proof of debt process: ERPIMA SA v Chee Yoh Chuang [1997] 1 SLR(R) 923 (“ERPIMA”) at [5], Feima International (Hongkong Ltd (in liquidation) v Kyen Resources Pte Ltd (in liquidation) and others [2024] 4 SLR 101 (“Feima”) at [57]. Hence, when faced with a claim in a proof of debt that involves disputes of fact that cannot be easily resolved on the affidavit and documentary evidence, a liquidator or judicial manager (as the case may be) is not expected to determine whether the claim has been proven, and is perfectly entitled to reject the proof of debt (see ERPIMA at [5]).

  100. [60] In addition, where the allegations made against a creditor are grave in nature (such as those of misfeasance and fraud), that is a factor which suggests that the cross-examination of witnesses is necessary and that it is inappropriate for the disputed claim to be resolved under the proof of debt regime: Feima at [58], referring to Re Bank of Credit and Commerce international SA (No 6); Mahfouz v Morris [1994] 1 BCLC 450 (“Re BCCI (No 6)”) at 454. Of course, this factor would be less relevant where the allegation is clearly made out on the affidavit or documentary evidence, or where there is no serious dispute regarding the existence of such misconduct.

  101. [61] In Yit Chee Wah and another v Inner Mongolia Huomei-Hongjun Aluminium Electricity Co, Ltd and another appeal [2025] 1 SLR 1110 (“Inner Mongolia”), the Court of Appeal provided guidance on the appropriate recourse for a liquidator when faced with factually complex cases that are disputed. The court held that a liquidator may: (a) reject the proof of debt, providing the reasons for his rejection; or (b) seek directions from the court on the manner or mode by which the adjudication of the proof of debt should be resolved, pursuant to s 145(3) of the IRDA (Inner Mongolia at [55]). Where the liquidator has rejected the proof of debt, the creditor may appeal (ERPIMA at [5]). Where the liquidator has applied to the court for directions for the resolution of adjudication of the proof of debt, the court may find that a trial or a limited cross-examination is necessary for the resolution of the issues.

  102. [62] The law and guidelines set out above were made in the context of corporate insolvency. As a matter of principle, we see no reason why these guidelines should not apply with equal force in personal insolvency proceedings. As such, when faced with a factually or legally complex case, a PTIB may (a) reject the proof of debt and provide reasons for the same; or (b) seek directions from the court on the manner or mode by which the adjudication of the proof of debt ought to be resolved. Depending on the applicable bankruptcy regime, the PTIB has the power to seek directions under s 40(2) of the BA, which provides that a PTIB “may apply to the court for directions in relation to any particular matter arising under the bankruptcy”, or under s 43(2) of the IRDA, which provides the same power using wording similar to s 40(2) of the BA. In deciding what to do, the PTIB ought to consider the same factors listed at [59]–[60] above, namely the ease of which the dispute may be resolved on the documents and/or affidavits, as well as the gravity of the allegation against the defendant.

  103. [63] If the matter comes before the court on appeal after the PTIB has rejected the claim on the basis that it is not amenable to summary determination or where the PTIB seeks directions from the court in relation to a factually complex claim, the next question is what the court should consider in deciding whether to order a trial of the disputed claim or, at the least, cross-examination of the key witnesses. The paramount consideration here is whether oral examination of witnesses and/or discovery is “necessary for fairly disposing of the particular issue”: Re BCCI (No 6) at 453. Whether this necessity exists would depend on the facts of each case. The court will not exercise its discretion to order the oral examination of witnesses where such an order would be needless or oppressive: ERPIMA at [7]; Re BCCI (No 6) at 453.

  104. [64] The other factors which the court ought to consider would be much the same as those to be considered by the PTIB. They include the presence of complex disputes of fact, gaps in the documentary or affidavit evidence, conflicting documentary or affidavit evidence, as well as the gravity of the allegations against the bankrupt: see ERPIMA at [25] and Feima at [58]; see also Re BCCI (No 6) at 454.

  105. Issues to be determined

  106. [66] In this appeal, the overarching substantive issue is whether Ms Chan is liable to TGPL for the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum because of her breach of fiduciary duties as a director of TGPL.

  107. [67] However, as already alluded to, there is an anterior issue to be determined, which is whether FDPL’s claims for the TL Sum and Finished Goods Sum ought to have been determined simply by way of affidavits, documents and submissions by the parties, without the need for a trial, or at least cross-examination of witnesses. As we shall explain, our view is that the evidence before the Judge does not clearly establish that Ms Chan was in breach of her duty to act honestly and bona fide in TGPL’s interests in respect of the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum. The material disputes of fact in relation to FDPL’s two claims render them unsuitable to be decided without a trial. We are of the view that simply ordering cross-examination of the deponents of the affidavits filed in the proceedings would not be sufficient in this case because (a) it does not appear to us that the points in contention between the parties have been clearly defined, (b) there are numerous gaps in the affidavit and documentary evidence and (c) certain individuals who would have knowledge of material facts will have to be ordered to attend court to give evidence and be examined. Also, as it seems to us that all documentary evidence that would shed light on the issues may not be before the court, the more involved process of a trial does appear to be appropriate.

  108. [68] Having considered the parties’ submissions, we think that the following key issues cannot be satisfactorily resolved on the available affidavit and documentary evidence:

  109. (a) The first issue is whether the TL Sum represents a genuine debt owed by TL to TGPL. In particular, for the 2007 Payments and the 2006 Opening Balance, the question is whether these sums were simply payments to TL pursuant to the joint venture arrangements involving Intraco, or whether they were loans from TGPL to TL that had to be repaid.

  110. (b) The second issue pertains to the quanta of the TL Sum, in particular, Sum 3, and the Finished Goods Sum.

  111. (c) The third issue is whether Ms Chan had authorised or otherwise caused TGPL to make the payments comprising the TL Sum and gave instructions to TGPL’s customers to pay the Finished Goods Sum to TL.

  112. (d) The fourth issue is whether Ms Chan has breached her fiduciary duties by failing to cause TGPL to recover the TL Sum and Finished Goods Sum from TL, assuming that both of these sums are genuine debts owed by TL to TGPL.

  113. (e) If the answer to either the third or fourth issues is in the affirmative, the fifth issue is whether FDPL’s claims against Ms Chan are barred by the LA.

  114. [69] For the reasons elaborated below, we are unable to come to a firm determination on each of the key issues (at [68] above) based on the available evidence, and in our view, a trial of the disputed claims is necessary.

  115. Issue 1: Whether the TL Sum was a genuine debt owed to TGPL by TL

  116. [70] We consider each component of the TL Sum separately.

  117. The 2007 Payments

  118. [71] On appeal, Mr Yit argues that the Judge erred by relying on the 2014 MA as evidence that the TL Sum was owing from TL to TGPL. This is because the 2014 MA was unaudited. In fact, TGPL’s management accounts for 2009 to 2013 were also unaudited. Mr Yit also argues that the large differences between the audited accounts and the management accounts for the years up to 2008 in relation to the amount of receivables purportedly due from TL shows that the management accounts of the TGPL are unreliable. For example, in 2008, the management accounts of TGPL recorded a figure of S$16,862,489 as the total amount of receivables due from TL, but the audited figure for that year was S$7,114,375. This amounted to a difference of S$9,784,114 that the auditors had disregarded. After 2008, TGPL ceased preparing audited financial statements but the receivable figures of approximately S$16m was carried over each successive year in the management accounts from 2009 to 2014 and became part of the TL Sum.

  119. [72] In response, FDPL argues that it is not always the case that audited accounts should be regarded as more reliable than the management accounts. In this case, the liquidators of FDPL found that the management accounts were more reliable. Also, Ms Chan had never rectified the management accounts to reconcile them with the audited statements, which gives rise to an inference that Ms Chan knew and accepted that the management accounts were correct.

  120. [73] FDPL also points out that Ms Chan had given various confirmations of the amounts owing by TL to TGPL, for example, in a letter of undertaking dated 15 October 2010 to provide financial support to TL. She (together with Mr Lay and Mr Tan) also gave a personal guarantee to Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (“ANZ”) in 2012 for TL’s liabilities, though the document does not state the amount owed by TL to TGPL. In addition, Ms Chan stated in the Intraco EJD Affidavits that the total amount owing from TL to TGPL was S$15,343,006.

  121. [74] After considering the submissions of parties and reviewing the affidavit and documentary evidence, we are unable to conclude that the 2007 Payments were indeed debts due and owing from TL to TGPL. The undisputed fact is that the period in which TGPL paid the 2007 Payments to TL (between 3 August 2007 and 18 October 2007) roughly coincided with the period in which TGPL received around the same amount from Intraco (between 31 July 2007 and 17 October 2007). This suggests that those inflows and outflows were connected in some way. Indeed, in the invoices issued by TL to Intraco, TL indicated that Intraco should make the advance payments due to TL under the 2007 JVA to TGPL’s bank accounts.

  122. [75] The central question therefore is whether the 2007 Payments were in fact the advance payments that were to be made by Intraco directly to TL pursuant to the 2007 JVA but were instead paid to TL by being channelled through TGPL. If the answer to this question is in the affirmative, absent a credible explanation, those payments would legitimately be for TL’s account and not TGPL’s, per the terms of the 2007 JVA. It would then be questionable to conclude that the 2007 Payments constituted a debt owed by TL to TGPL. It is evident from the 2007 JVA that the advance payments were to enable to TL to purchase the necessary raw materials and turn the same into finished products which would then be sold to TGPL for on-sale to the market. As the advance payments were paid to TGPL, the question of how TL was able to procure the necessary raw material arises. There was no evidence that TL had any independent means to purchase the raw materials to enable it to perform its obligations under the 2007 JVA. The only source of funding that TL received on the record was the 2007 Payments.

  123. [76] Thus, it appears to us likely that TGPL had made the 2007 Payments to TL for the 2007 JVA, ie, TGPL had transmitted to TL the sums, provided by Intraco, for TL to purchase raw materials and process them into coffee beans. If so, that would be critical. As counsel for FDPL accepted at the hearing before us, if Intraco was merely using TGPL as a conduit to make the 2007 Payments to TL, then there can be no issue of any breach of fiduciary duty in respect of these payments by TGPL to TL. The route of payment from Intraco to TGPL and then to TL would not make TL a debtor of TGPL. After all, these were payments to which TL would be contractually entitled under the 2007 JVA and TGPL would not have any basis to retain those sums for itself.

  124. [77] We would add that if Ms Chan, Mr Lay and Mr Tan, or a staff who had knowledge of the reasons for these 2007 Payments, had given evidence and been cross-examined, they might have been able to shed some light on some of the issues regarding these transfers of funds, such as (a) why payments from Intraco were directed to TGPL instead of being paid directly to TL, (b) why the subsequent payments from TGPL to TL were recorded as loans in TGPL’s books, (c) how these purported loans were treated in TL’s accounts, and (d) if the payments to TL were genuinely loans and TGPL had received from Intraco the advance payments intended for TL, how TGPL and TL accounted for these moneys between themselves.

  125. [78] We think the Judge placed too much weight on the fact that the TL Sum appeared as a receivable recorded in the management accounts of TGPL. In our view, there is some force in Mr Yit’s argument that the reliability of the management accounts must be called into question given that TGPL’s auditors, L W Ong & Associates LLP (“L W Ong”), had disregarded more than S$9.7m of the receivables from TL recorded in the management accounts of TGPL in 2008, as can be seen in TGPL’s audited accounts that year. We do not think it is a sufficient response for FDPL to simply assert that the liquidators assessed the management accounts to be more reliable. This is especially as FDPL has been unable to show why L W Ong’s actions of writing down the receivables from TL were not justifiable. The point remains that there were significant unexplained variances between what was stated as the receivables due from TL in TGPL’s management accounts as compared to its audited financial statements during the period of 2005 to 2008, which was the period when its accounts were being audited. The inference must be that the receivables figure in TGPL’s management accounts are questionable. Without further evidence, we are of the view that the management accounts alone cannot form the basis of a finding that the 2007 Payments were correctly recorded as a loan due from TL.

  126. [79] At the hearing before us, we were informed by counsel that L W Ong no longer has TGPL’s books and records in its possession. It is thus not entirely clear whether the auditors will be able to give any meaningful evidence on why they wrote down the receivables recorded in the management accounts as being due from TL. Nonetheless, even if the auditors are ultimately unable to assist, we think that Ms Chan, Mr Lay and Mr Tan, as directors of TGPL, or some staff who had been handling the accounts for TGPL, ought to be in a position to clarify why they decided to maintain that amount of receivables in TGPL’s management accounts from 2009 to 2014 despite the auditors writing the amount down significantly in 2008. But, as we have noted, at the hearing before the Judge, Mr Lay and Mr Tan did not file any affidavits in the proceedings. As for Ms Chan, neither party sought to adduce any evidence from her on this issue.

  127. [80] Although Ms Chan had admitted at various junctures to the amount of the debt owing from TL to TGPL by citing figures similar in range to those recorded in the management accounts, we do not think that that this alone suffices to show that these were indeed amounts due and owing from TL to TGPL. Mr Yit argues that Ms Chan was merely relying on the figures stated in the management accounts when she made these statements. Conversely, FDPL argues that, even if Ms Chan was referring to the figures in the management accounts, that would justify an inference that she accepts that those figures are accurate.

  128. [81] In our view, the evidence as to Ms Chan’s admissions that there were loans due from TL to TGPL should have been explored further at the hearing below. Although Ms Chan admitted the existence of the loans under oath in the Intraco EJD Affidavits, she later made statements contrary to those admissions under oath too. In Ms Chan’s affidavit for SUM 4316, she claimed that, while she was one of the three directors of TGPL and its sole shareholder, she was only a “financial investor” in the company. As she was involved in about 80 companies worldwide, she left all the affairs of TGPL to Mr Lay and Mr Tan, the other two directors. She claimed that Mr Lay could confirm that she had no knowledge of and control over the operations of TGPL. In this regard, she referred to an affidavit of one of the liquidators who confirmed that Mr Lay had informed the liquidators that Ms Chan had no “working knowledge of TGPL”. Ms Chan asserted that the liquidators of TGPL were aware that the company had operated under the management and control of Mr Lay from its incorporation to the date it was ordered to be wound up. On the other hand, TGPL’s liquidators dispute that Ms Chan had no knowledge or control over TGPL. They claim that “the books and records available to the Liquidators show that [TGPL] had operated under the management and control of [Ms Chan] from the date of incorporation of [TGPL], up until the winding up of [TGPL]”.

  129. [82] Ms Chan’s statements on affidavit, where she disclaimed that she oversaw the operations of TGPL or any management control over TGPL, might suggest that she would not be able to explain why the 2007 Payments were made to TL. If that were the case, then the veracity of her assertions in the Intraco EJD Affidavits that these payments were loans to TL must be called into question. We thus find it surprising that neither Mr Yit nor FDPL chose to apply for Ms Chan to be examined as a witness, or apply for orders for Mr Lay and Mr Tan (or any staff of TGPL with knowledge of its management and operations) to attend court as witnesses in the proceedings. There are clear material disputes of fact that ought to be resolved by way of examination of witnesses. Indeed, during the hearing of the appeal, counsel for Mr Yit conceded that Ms Chan’s degree of involvement in TGPL was not clear.

  130. [83] In our view, Ms Chan should have been orally examined on the difference between her statements made under oath and given a chance to explain. If Ms Chan’s statements in her affidavit for SUM 4316 were true, it would add weight to Mr Yit’s submission that Ms Chan had probably repeated in the Intraco EJD Affidavits what was stated in the management accounts of TGPL, ie that there were receivables owing from TL in the amount of more than S$15.3m, without knowing whether this was in fact accurate. Needless to say, that point could have been clarified with Ms Chan if she had been examined as a witness.

  131. [84] In the same vein, the fact that Ms Chan’s signature appeared on the management accounts including the 2014 MA does not establish that those management accounts are reliable or that she acknowledged the existence of the receivables owing from TL. Ms Chan had stated in her affidavit for SUM 4316 that, because she was travelling 90% of the time, her staff had her digital signature which they used when necessary. This assertion is rejected by FDPL. This is another dispute of fact that calls for witnesses, including Ms Chan, Mr Lay and Mr Tan, and possibly the accounting staff at TGPL during the material period, to be examined.

  132. [85] Hence, in our view, the evidence that was adduced in the proceedings does not unequivocally show that the 2007 Payments were debts due and owing from TL to TGPL.

  133. The Opening Balance

  134. [86] The Judge found that the Opening Balance of approximately S$6,662,009.44 is the amount recorded in the management accounts of TGPL as being due from TL as at 31 December 2006 (Judgment at [66]). It is thus the “opening balance” for the receivables due from TL starting on 1 January 2007. However, at the hearing of the appeal, counsel for FDPL clarified that the Opening Balance refers to the quantum of receivables owing from TL as at 1 December 2006, as recorded in TGPL’s general ledger.

  135. [87] Mr Yit argued below, and continues to argue on appeal, that this amount could relate to arrangements similar to the 2007 Payments, that is, Intraco had made payments to TGPL for onward transmission to TL, and TGPL had recorded these outflows as receivables due from TL. Mr Yit suggests that this could have been made pursuant to the 2006 JVA. Mr Yit claims that the 2006 JVA had substantially the same terms as the 2007 JVA, a point that does not appear to be seriously disputed by FDPL.

  136. [88] The Judge found that the Opening Balance was part of the loans extended by TGPL to TL. This was for the same reasons as the 2007 Payments, namely that the amount was recorded as a receivable in the management accounts of TGPL, and that Ms Chan admitted in the Intraco EJD Affidavits that the amount due from TL to TGPL was over S$15.3m, with this sum including the Opening Balance amount. The Judge also found that the 2006 JVA could not explain how the 2006 Opening Balance as the “related party receivables” due from TL had accrued since 2006 (ie, S$3,111,000 as of 2005): Judgment at [67].

  137. [89] In our view, it is difficult for us to conclude, without the examination of witnesses such as Ms Chan, Mr Lay, Mr Tan, staff from TGPL who handled its accounts, and perhaps even someone from Intraco, that the Opening Balance was a genuine debt owing to TGPL. They would be the persons who would be able to shed light on the reasons for the Opening Balance. If, as Mr Yit submits, Intraco had made advance payments to TL under the 2006 JVA, by routing the moneys through TGPL, then the analysis here would be the same as for the 2007 Payments. There would have been no basis to even begin to allege that Ms Chan had breached her fiduciary duties in respect of the Opening Balance if that sum comprised legitimate payments that were due to TL under the 2006 JVA. Regrettably, parties decided not to apply to have aforementioned persons called to be orally examined on this issue.

  138. [90] Our views on the reliability of Ms Chan’s admissions in the Intraco EJD Proceedings and the management accounts including the 2014 MA are the same as for the 2007 Payments for the reasons given earlier (see [74]–[84] above). In addition, at the hearing of the appeal, counsel for FDPL confirmed that the TGPL’s audited financial statements for 2006 did not show that S$6.62m was due and owing from TL to TGPL. To the contrary, those audited financial statements showed that there were no amounts due and owing from TL to TGPL, or in fact from any other related parties. That throws into doubt the reliability of the general ledger relied on by FDPL to show that the Opening Balance was a receivable due from TL as at 1 December 2006. We therefore do not think it possible to conclude, based on the current state of the evidence, that the Opening Balance was a genuine debt due from TL to TGPL.

  139. Sum 3

  140. [91] The Judge found that Sum 3, amounting to S$962,051.84, pertained to certain business-related expenses paid by TGPL on behalf of TL to TL’s directors, employees, auditors and trade creditors (Judgment at [69]). In our view, there is no objective evidence that supports this finding. Rather, it appears to us that the Sum 3 is simply the result of subtracting the 2007 Payments and the Opening Balance from the TL Sum. This was in fact acknowledged by FDPL in its closing submissions below, and by TGPL’s liquidators in one of their affidavits.

  141. [92] TGPL’s liquidators claimed that the amount of S$962,052.84 owed by TL is attested in TGPL’s internal balance sheets from 2009-2015, the 2010-2013 ledgers and the Statement of Financial Position as of December 2014. However, TGPL’s liquidators did not indicate the specific entries they were relying on. Indeed, as mentioned in the preceding paragraph, FDPL did not even describe the sum of S$962,052.84 as payment for TL’s operating expenses – it was Mr Yit who did so. In response, FDPL described Mr Yit’s position as “doubtful” as “many of the Sum 3 payments have no recorded purpose or even payee”. It is only in this appeal before us that FDPL, following the Judge’s adoption of the characterisation of Sum 3 as being payment for TL’s operating expenses, similarly adopted such a characterisation.

  142. [93] Indeed, the characterisation of Sum 3 as Operating Expenses is also not fully explained by Mr Yit. In his decision for the Proof of Debt adjudication, Mr Yit’s quantum for Sum 3 was “SGD 23,737.87 and USD 148,419.22 (equivalent to SGD 227,576.83 converted at forex rate of USD 1 to SGD 1.3734 as at the date of Bankruptcy Order) i.e. from 2010 to 2013, items for which the available information indicate related to operating purposes”. Later on, in his third affidavit, he merely stated that there was a “balance of less than S$1,000,000 which appeared to be amounts paid by TGPL to or on behalf of TL for TL’s operating expenses”, and that his understanding was that “this included business-related expenses which TGPL paid on behalf of TL, such as payments for employee’s salaries or electronics”.

  143. [94] It appears that Mr Yit relied on the finding in TGPL’s liquidators’ report (“TGPL’s Liquidators’ Report”) at para 67 that TGPL’s and TL’s general ledgers include entries which record TGPL paying TL’s operating expenses. However, this finding by TGPL’s liquidators does not support Mr Yit’s conclusion, as the liquidators were simply noting the existence of such payments and they did not state that the amount of TL’s operating expenses paid by TGPL was S$962,051.84, ie, the quantum of Sum 3. Also, those entries in TGPL’s Liquidators’ Report were dated 2007, whereas TGPL’s liquidators took the position that the bulk of Sum 3 was incurred by TGPL from 2010 onwards – more specifically, the years 2010 to 2013 (see [92] above) in which Sum 3 was supposedly attested in TGPL’s ledgers.

  144. [95] It thus appears that TGPL’s liquidators merely placed broad reliance on entries from TGPL’s internal balance sheets from 2009–2015, the 2010–2013 ledgers and the Statement of Financial Position, without actually investigating the specific entries which purportedly supported the “Operating Expenses”. This means that the purpose of Sum 3 (ie, why payment was made) is far from clear, and this would obviously affect any finding of a breach of fiduciary duty by Ms Chan in relation to Sum 3. In our judgment, this too calls for an examination of witnesses such as Ms Chan, Mr Lay, Mr Tan, staff from TGPL and TGPL’s liquidators before the court can make the necessary findings in relation to this Sum 3.

  145. [96] Counsel for Mr Yit appears to have accepted at the hearing before us that Sum 3 was for the operating expenses for TL. However, this acceptance was a qualified one, as counsel also said that Mr Yit did not “have more of the details of what was going on” at the time Sum 3 was paid. In this light, and given that counsel seemed merely to be repeating Mr Yit’s own position of what Sum 3 represented (see [91]–[93] above) – a description we consider unsupported by the evidence and inconclusive – we think that an examination of witnesses is warranted to clarify whether TGPL did in fact pay the operating expenses of TL, and if so, why this was done, and the actual quantum of such operating expenses. We stress that it is FDPL who will have the burden of proving that TGPL had paid for TL’s operating expenses and the precise amounts that were paid. Simply relying on Mr Yit’s “concession”, as we have explained, will not suffice to discharge that burden.

  146. Issue 2: What is the quantum of the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum

  147. [97] There are questions pertaining to the quanta of various components of the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum. The first, as just explained, concerns the existence of Sum 3 as a debt and its quantum. The second question is whether the Opening Balance was even a true receivable due from TL because, as noted above, the audited financial statements of 2006 show that there are no amounts owing from TL to TGPL. The third concerns the possibly erroneous inclusion of amounts in the management accounts of TGPL, which had been excluded in the audited financial statements. The fourth concerns a possible overlap between the TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum. In our view, these questions cannot be resolved on the available affidavit and documentary evidence. An examination of witnesses is called for. We have explained why this is the case for the first and second questions and will now do the same for the third and fourth questions.

  148. The Excluded Amount

  149. [98] On appeal, Mr Yit makes the new argument that, in TGPL’s audited financial statements of the year 2008, some S$9.7m recorded as receivables in the management accounts had been excluded, ie, there are no such amount of receivables owed by TL to TGPL (the “Excluded Amount”). In the subsequent years, “the inflated and unverified receivables figure of some S$16.86 million in the 2008 management accounts (as contrasted with the audited financial statements) was simply carried forward to each successive year, i.e. the [Excluded Amount] was also carried over as an outstanding receivable in the management accounts of subsequent years and ultimately made its way as part of the TL Sum”. In other words, although the Excluded Amount was not reflected in TGPL’s audited accounts, they were still included in the management accounts. Counsel did not identify any document where the auditors had explained the S$9.7m discrepancy, nor did TGPL’s liquidators manage to obtain an explanation from the management of the company or from the auditors.

  150. [99] Notwithstanding that the accuracy of certain entries in the audited financial statements may require further investigation, our view is that these statements cannot be dismissed outright (see [78] above). It follows that the Excluded Amount would raise questions as to the quantum of the TL Sum – questions which would be best answered by witnesses, such as Mr Lay, Mr Tan, Ms Chan and staff from TGPL who handled its accounts.

  151. The overlap between the TL Sum and Finished Goods Sum

  152. [100] According to FDPL, the transfers of the Finished Goods Sum from TGPL’s customers to TL were recorded in nine entries in TL’s general ledger for the year 2008. These were the nine entries, totalling the amount of US$2,301,767.43:

  153. [101] However, Mr Yit submits on appeal that the first eight entries in the above table correspond with receivables recorded in TGPL’s general ledger for 2008, in the sense that:

  154. [102] Mr Yit provides a table showing the corresponding entries:

  155. [103] The eight entries in relation to the Finished Goods Sum as recorded in TL’s general ledger correspond so precisely with the entries in TGPL’s general ledger as set out in the table in the preceding paragraph that it suggests that FDPL is in fact double claiming a significant sum of US$2,002,292.93 (the total of the eight entries) as part of the TL Sum as well as part of the Finished Goods Sum.

  156. [104] FDPL contends that the above argument should be rejected as none of the components of the TL Sum are attested to by TGPL’s general ledger for 2008. Hence, even if the entries in TL’s general ledger for 2008 correspond to TGPL’s general ledger for 2008, FDPL argues that this does not show a claim for the same sum. Moreover, temporal proximity and identical quanta alone do not establish a sufficient basis for concluding that the entries correspond to the same transaction. FDPL claims that Mr Yit’s position amounts to no more than conjecture, unsupported by any documentary evidence or explanation of accounting practices that would justify drawing such a connection.

  157. [105] We are unable to agree with FDPL. We think that the above arguments raise the possibility that there was indeed an overlap in the claimed amounts for TL Sum and the Finished Goods Sum. This should be explored by an examination of witnesses such as Mr Lay, Mr Tan, Ms Chan and staff of TGPL who handled its accounts. As explained at [91]–[95] above, there is a lack of clarity on the composition of Sum 3 and the dates on which Sum 3 accrued as a debt to TGPL, given that TGPL’s liquidators did not identify the exact entries in support of Sum 3. It is not even clear that Sum 3 consisted solely of TL’s operating expenses paid by TGPL. It is thus difficult to determine whether the receivables in TGPL’s general ledger for 2008 could have been factored into Sum 3.

  158. [106] More generally, according to TGPL’s management accounts, the receivables owed by TL to TGPL peaked in 2008 (presumably after the 2007 Payments) and then fluctuated (below the 2008 amount) from 2009 to 2014. There is thus no clarity as to whether any portion of the Finished Goods Sum was reduced by TL transferring some portion of the amount received from TGPL’s customers to TGPL.

  159. [107] In this regard, we are unable to accept FDPL’s submission that the temporal proximity and identical amounts alone do not establish a sufficient basis for a prima facie conclusion that the entries correspond to the same transaction. As for the difference in quantum between the eight entries highlighted by TGPL (S$2,002,292.93) and Sum 3 (S$962,051.84), this could well be related to the decrease in receivables owed by TL after 2008 (see [105] above). The point here is simply that the evidence raises questions that can only be resolved by the examination of witnesses such as Mr Lay, Mr Tan, Ms Chan and staff from TGPL who handled its accounts.

  160. [108] Just like the argument concerning the Excluded Amount, this argument on the overlap of sums is a new argument raised by Mr Yit on appeal. It is well established that the following factors are relevant in considering whether to allow a new point to be raised on appeal: (a) the nature of the parties’ arguments below; (b) whether the court had considered and provided any findings and reasoning in relation to the new point; (c) whether further submissions, evidence, or findings would have been necessitated had the new points been raised below; and (d) any prejudice that might result to the counterparty in the appeal if the new point is allowed to be raised: Grace Electrical Engineering Pte Ltd v Te Deum Engineering Pte Ltd [2018] 1 SLR 76 at [38], referred to in TG Master Pte Ltd v Tung Kee Development (Singapore) Pte Ltd and another [2024] 1 SLR 690 at [59].

  161. [109] We are prepared to consider Mr Yit’s new arguments. For factors (a) to (c), Mr Yit is simply referring to documents that are already part of the evidential record before the court and asking that we draw the reasonable inferences from them. There was no examination of witnesses before the Judge on these entries in these accounting documents. Parties simply made submissions on the documentary evidence. As such, we are in a similar position as the Judge in being able to draw the necessary inferences from the documents. Finally, for factor (d), FDPL did not suffer any prejudice because it could and did respond to these new arguments raised on appeal.

  162. Issue 3: Whether Ms Chan had authorised or caused TGPL to grant the TL Sum and instruct customers to transfer the Finished Goods Sum to TL and whether that was a breach of her fiduciary duties to TGPL

  163. [110] The Judge found that Ms Chan had extended the TL Sum to TL for no commercial benefit (Judgment at [76]) and applied this same analysis to the Finished Goods Sum (Judgment at [82]). These findings suggest that Ms Chan had authorised or caused TGPL to make these payments in the case of the 2007 Payments, Opening Balance, and Sum 3, and that she had instructed the customers of TGPL to make payments to TL in the case of the Finished Goods Sum. The Judge’s conclusion seems to be based on his finding that Ms Chan had management and control over TGPL, which were in turn based on the following (see Judgment at [82]):

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.