Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 21 February 2020
Hai Jiao 1306 Ltd and others v Yaw Chee Siew
Feedback & support[2020] SGHC(I) 03 · Case no. Suit Nos 7 to 9 of 2018 (Summons No 49 of 2019) · 22 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [5]
[5] I now set out the reasons for my decision in Sum 49/2019.
Background facts
- [6]
[6] The defendant is the majority shareholder, sole director and executive chairman of Otto Marine Limited (“OML”), as well as the Executive Chairman of Perdana. The Chief Executive Officer of Perdana, Joseph Lau, is the defendant’s cousin. Perdana’s ultimate holding company is Yaw Holding Sdn Bhd (“Yaw Holding”), which is substantially owned by the defendant’s father and brother.
- [7]
[7] The first to third plaintiffs are the registered owners of three vessels: “GO PERSEUS”, “GO PHOENIX” and “GO PEGASUS” respectively. Each of these vessels was chartered under a bareboat charter agreement (collectively, “the Agreements”). “GO PHOENIX” and “GO PEGASUS” were chartered by Otto Fleet Pte Ltd (“OFPL”). “GO PERSEUS” was chartered by Go Offshore (L) Pte Ltd (“GOPL”). OML is the ultimate holding company of OFPL and GOPL (collectively, “the Charterers”).
- [8]
[8] A corporate guarantee was issued by OML in favour of the second and third plaintiffs, guaranteeing as primary obligor the due and punctual performance by OFPL of all its obligations under the two bareboat charterparties, including the payment of charter hire. OML and GOPL’s immediate parent, Go Marine Group Pty Ltd (“GOML”), issued guarantees in favour of the first plaintiff similarly guaranteeing, as primary obligors, the due and punctual performance by GOPL of all its obligations under its bareboat charterparty.
- [10]
[10] OML delisted but the Letters of Support were not issued despite the fact that the defendant claimed to have executed them. It is common ground, however, that the Letters of Support are binding on the defendant. Post-delisting, the Charterers and OML continued to default on their payment obligations under the Agreements and the related guarantees respectively.
- [11]
[11] This resulted in further negotiations between the plaintiffs and the defendant. The result was two-fold. First, on 26 September 2017, a second set of Letters of Support between the defendant and each of the plaintiffs was agreed and executed as deeds. These deeds each contained terms that were materially identical to those excerpted at [9] above, except that Clause 3 of the second set of Letters of Support reads:
- [12]
[12] Second, also in September 2017, various addenda were entered into in respect of each of the Agreements by the relevant parties. These addenda, which were similar in material respects between the different Agreements, were intended to, amongst other things, modify the charter hire rate and instalment payment scheme under the Agreements in light of the financial situation of the Charterers and OML. Of particular relevance to Sum 49/2019 are the addenda that were entered into on 29 September 2017 (the “Addendum”) between each of the plaintiffs and the relevant Charterer in respect of the relevant Agreement. Each Addendum provided that the Charterers were to deliver to the relevant plaintiff documents satisfactory to the latter evidencing compliance with Schedule 1A of the Addendum:
- [13]
[13] Schedule 1A therefore required, inter alia, that the Charterers provide as a condition subsequent satisfactory evidence of a mortgage over the Hotel registered in the plaintiffs’ favour to secure due performance of the Agreements and the related guarantees. The plaintiffs’ case was that the Hotel was indirectly owned by the Perdana Group of companies and Yaw Holding, and counsel for the defendant did not challenge this at the hearings for Sum 49/2019. The Addenda further provided that the failure to satisfy Schedule 1A on or before 31 October 2017 would render the amendments to the Agreements introduced by the Addenda null and void.
- [14]
[14] OML and its related companies, including the Charterers, were not able to extricate themselves from their financial malaise. OML was placed under judicial management on 21 March 2018 and subsequently placed in liquidation on 5 October 2018. GOPL was placed in liquidation on 11 May 2018, and OFPL went into creditors’ voluntary winding up on 10 July 2019.
- [15]
[15] The present suits rest, inter alia, on the “best endeavours” obligation found in the first and second sets of Letters of Support. They were brought against the defendant on the basis that he had breached the “best endeavours” obligation in both sets of Letters of Support and/or various undertakings, and/or had misrepresented certain facts which the plaintiffs had relied upon, suffering loss as a consequence. Specifically, relevant to Sum 49/2019 is the plaintiffs’ claim that the defendant failed to take any steps, or alternatively to exercise best endeavours, to ensure that the Charterers provided them with satisfactory evidence that a mortgage over the Hotel had been registered in the plaintiffs’ favour, contrary to the obligation under the Addendum excerpted at [12] above. This, it was alleged, constituted a failure by the defendant to comply with his obligations under both sets of Letters of Support to use best endeavours to support the Charterers and OML in meeting their obligations under the Agreements and the related guarantees respectively. In contrast, the defendant asserted that he had exercised his best endeavours to persuade the owner of the Hotel to effect a mortgage over the Hotel in favour of the plaintiffs, but was unsuccessful in doing so.
Procedural history
(a) the type, make and serial number of each electronic device that had been secured by PwC along with the time period for which the device was utilised by the defendant;
(c) if the defendant was not able to provide the confirmation in (b), a list of the electronic devices that remained to be secured by PwC and either the steps that were taken to secure them or, if the defendant was unable to so secure, an explanation as to what had become of them.
- [21]
[21] On 6 May 2019, the defendant’s request for an extension of time was denied by the court. The directions sought by the plaintiffs on 3 May 2019 were not made. However, the defendant’s solicitors notified the plaintiffs’ solicitors by a letter dated 7 May 2019 (“the 7 May letter”) that all relevant electronic devices utilised by him during the relevant period had been provided to and secured by PwC on 30 April 2019. The letter identified the three devices secured by PwC to be: (a) an iPhone 6; (b) an iPhone XS; and (c) an iPad Air.
- [26]
[26] In the supporting affidavit to Sum 34/2019, the plaintiffs alleged that not only had the defendant’s affidavit (see [23] above) been filed after the deadline imposed by the court, it also failed to comply with the requirements of the 8 May 2019 directions. In particular, while the defendant claimed to have misplaced a Samsung mobile phone, he did not explain how, when and where this had occurred. Moreover, he also did not identify the model, serial number and the period in which the phone had been used. Similar arguments were made regarding the “laptop” that had been disclosed (see [23] above). Finally, the plaintiffs alleged that the affidavit showed that there was at least one other unidentified mobile device, an Apple iPhone, which had not been provided to PwC.
- [29]
[29] The defendant did not comply with ORC 38/2019 by the stipulated deadline. On 6 August 2019, after the expiry of the deadline that had been set, the defendant’s solicitors wrote to court requesting that he be given until the close of business that day to comply. The request was allowed. However, according to the plaintiffs, the letter was not served on their solicitors until around 6.26pm, after the court had granted the extension sought at around 6.16pm. By the time the plaintiffs received the defendant’s solicitor’s letter, they had already filed Sum 49/2019 at around 4.38pm. In any event, the defendant did not comply with ORC 38/2019 by the extended deadline he had sought.
Asset Discovery Order
My decision
- [36]
[36] In Mitora Pte Ltd v Agritrade International (Pte) Ltd [2013] 3 SLR 1179 (“Mitora”) at [45], the Court of Appeal set out the following guidelines in relation to peremptory orders:
(a) “unless orders” stipulating the consequence of dismissal should not be given as a matter of course but as a last resort when the defaulter’s conduct is inexcusable;
(b) the conditions appended to “unless orders” should as far as possible be tailored to the prejudice which would be suffered should there be non-compliance; and
(c) other means of penalising contumelious or persistent breaches are available, including but not limited to, raising adverse inferences against the defaulting party at trial.
Whether Sum 49/2019 was premature
- [39]
[39] I begin first with the defendant’s submission that Sum 49/2019 was premature. The defendant argued that at the time the application was filed, the court had granted the defendant’s request for an extension of time and the defendant was therefore not in breach of ORC 38/2019. There was no merit in this submission. Before the plaintiffs filed Sum 49/2019, the defendant had written to the court seeking an extension of time to comply with ORC 38/2019 (see [29] above). However, the court’s records indicate that Sum 49/2019 was filed before the court had granted an extension of time. The defendant was therefore in breach at that point in time. Further, the defendant’s letter to the court was only served on the plaintiffs after Sum 49/2019 was filed. In any event, given that the defendant proceeded to breach the extended deadline of 6 August 2019, any prematurity in the plaintiffs’ application was irrelevant.
The defendant’s non-compliance
- [42]
[42] At the hearing on 30 September 2019, the plaintiffs relied on seven breaches of the defendant’s discovery obligations. With the exception of the plaintiffs’ contention that the emails from csyaw@ppcity.com.my were not provided in their native formats, it is my view that these allegations by the plaintiffs were correctly made. I provide a few examples:
(d) As noted earlier (see [28] above), ORC 38/2019 also required the defendant to provide disclosure of documents in two computers: an “Apple Mac Desktop” in the defendant’s office and a computer in the defendant’s home. The defendant, however, did not do so, alleging instead that, with regard to the “Apple Mac Desktop in [his] office”, he had no recollection of this computer, which was not in his possession. This was a position that changed at the hearing on 10 October 2019 (see [52] below). The defendant’s response was unsatisfactory as it was incumbent on him to take reasonable steps to locate this device. There were messages exchanged between the defendant and his secretary referring to this computer, and he could very well have asked her about its whereabouts at the very least. His bare assertion that he had no recollection of the computer was insufficient. With regard to the computer in his home, the defendant simply stated that it was his wife’s and that he did not have possession or use of it. This seemed unlikely from the correspondence exhibited by the plaintiffs. In any event, given that he did not dispute at the hearing of Sum 34/2019 on 18 July 2019 that these devices were not in his possession, this point was not open to him any longer (see [28] above).
- [43]
[43] Significantly, for the first time, the defendant advanced the argument that the information in the email accounts at Perdana - csyaw@ppcity.com.my and csyaw.om@ppcity.com.my - were not within his power and as such, he could not give discovery. The defendant contended that these repositories were in the control of Perdana, whose permission would be required before discovery of the information there could be provided. The defendant’s affidavit indicated that his solicitors had written to the Perdana Group’s Chief Executive Officer, his cousin Joseph Lau, on 26 July 2019 and 3 August 2019 requesting approval for csyaw@ppcity.com.my to be subject to an e-discovery search. He stated that his solicitors had not received any response.
- [45]
[45] If the email account csyaw@ppcity.com.my was to be regarded as in the possession, custody or power of the defendant, it is axiomatic that the defendant’s other email account at Perdana, csyaw.om@ppcity.com.my, would be similarly regarded.
- [47]
[47] The reasoning from Dirak Asia applies with particular force in the present case given that the defendant was the Executive Chairman of a family-owned business. He clearly had an unfettered right to access the email accounts at Perdana and the practical ability to do so. From the affidavits which had been filed up to this point, there was no basis to conclude that Perdana’s permission was necessary or would be refused. As I have said at [43], his position on affidavit when Sum 49/2019 was heard on 30 September 2019 was that his solicitors had not received any response from Perdana regarding their requests to give discovery of the Perdana email accounts. I found it difficult to believe that the defendant, as Executive Chairman, would have difficulty in even obtaining a response. Further, the various discovery orders were made against him personally, and it was for him to procure any approvals that might be necessary as a matter of corporate policy. The purported need for approval seemed very much like a convenient ruse for not providing discovery particularly when seen in light of the fact that the defendant had been allowed to use one of the email accounts to communicate with the liquidators of OML. While the suggestion was that he did not have the authority in Perdana to procure such access, this was not believable. It was at odds with the defendant’s willingness to agree to the term that required a mortgage be obtained over the Hotel as a condition subsequent to the validity of the Addendum (see [13] above). This spoke clearly to the defendant’s confidence that he would be able to exert the necessary control over Perdana, which, on the plaintiffs’ case, indirectly owned the Hotel. Assessed as a whole, I was satisfied that the defendant’s failure to disclose the documents contained in the email accounts at Perdana was a breach of his discovery obligations. This was a point that was re-visited at the 10 October hearing, as I explain below at [55].
- [50]
[50] In balancing the prejudice to the plaintiffs, taking into account the fact that trial had been fixed for 11 November 2019, I gave the defendant until 7 October 2019 to comply with ORC 51/2019. I stood down for subsequent consideration the plaintiffs’ prayer on the consequences of non-compliance. That was dealt with at the 10 October hearing to which I now turn.
The 10 October hearing
- [52]
[52] Under ORC 51/2019, the defendant was to state, inter alia, the steps he had taken to locate or obtain the “Apple Mac Desktop in [his] office” and “Apple-Mac computer using the operating system OS X 10.10” (see [49] above). The defendant stated for the first time that these were the same device (the “Apple Mac Desktop” computer) and that the device was located in his Perdana office in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. This was contrary to his earlier assertions that he was unaware of the “Apple Mac Desktop” computer’s whereabouts (see [42(d)] above). No indication was given in his affidavit as to the steps that had been taken to provide discovery of the documents therein. In particular, the letter dated 1 October 2019 sent by his solicitors to the Group CEO of Perdana, Joseph Lau, only asked for the latter’s approval to provide discovery of his email accounts at Perdana, but not of the “Apple Mac Desktop” computer. The defendant was therefore clearly in breach of ORC 51/2019. In any event, as noted earlier, the analysis with regard to the two email accounts at Perdana would also apply to this device given that it was apparently located in Perdana’s Kuala Lumpur office.
- [53]
[53] The plaintiffs accepted at the 10 October hearing that, with the exception of the email accounts at Perdana, the “Apple Mac Desktop” computer referred to at [52] above, a Dropbox account registered under the email csyaw@ottomarine.com and the email account csyaw123@gmail.com, the remainder of the repositories and documents I directed the defendant to provide disclosure of in ORC 51/2019 had been provided to PwC Malaysia. The defendant’s position with regards to the Dropbox account and the email account csyaw123@gmail.com was that he had forgotten the passwords necessary to access these repositories. Recovering the password required access to csyaw@ottomarine.com, which was under the control of OML’s liquidators. He further said that he had not yet been able to arrange with OML’s liquidators for the password to be recovered. The defendant produced correspondence between his solicitors and the solicitors of OML’s liquidators, but the last email produced was dated 5 October 2019. It appeared that nothing had been done since then. The defendant did not argue that discovery could not or need not be provided, and it therefore seemed as though it was a matter of time before the documents would be produced.
Conclusion