Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 24 November 2020
Larpin, Christian Alfred and another v Kaikhushru Shiavax Nargolwala and another
Feedback & support[2020] SGHC(I) 24 · Case no. Suit No 3 of 2020 (Summons No 59 of 2020) · 14 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] Through their holding of the shares in Querencia Ltd (“Querencia”), a British Virgin Islands (“BVI”) company, the Defendants held rights to Villa 29 in the Andara Resort in Phuket, Thailand (“the Villa”): sufficiently for present purposes, a form of ownership. In late 2017, the Defendants sold the Villa to the First Plaintiff (“Mr Larpin”), by the sale and transfer of the shares in Querencia to his beneficially owned company, the Second Plaintiff, Quo Vadis Investments Limited (“Quo Vadis”). In these proceedings, the Plaintiffs claim orders for rescission of the sale, return of the purchase price of US$7.9m, and damages.
- [3]
[3] For the reasons which follow, the application should be dismissed.
These Proceedings
- [4]
[4] For the submissions in the application, a brief summary of the claim and the defence to it is desirable. The pleadings are quite extensive, and the summary necessarily does not capture their detail.
- [5]
[5] Mr Larpin attended a viewing of the Villa on 25 or 26 October 2017, conducted by the Defendants’ selling agent Mr Martin Phillips. He expressed interest, and on 8 November 2017 a Reservation Agreement between Quo Vadis and the Defendants was executed. On 14 November 2017 a Share Purchase Agreement between the same parties was executed. Completion of the Share Purchase Agreement took place on 16 November 2017.
- [6]
[6] The Plaintiffs allege that by executing the Agreements, and orally by a telephone conversation between Mr Larpin and the First Defendant (“Mr Nargolwala”) on 15 November 2017, the Defendants made a number of representations concerning the sale of the Villa via the Querencia shares. The representations include that all information which would materially affect the sale of the Villa had been disclosed. The Plaintiffs allege that the representations were false, and that they were made fraudulently or recklessly or, if not, in circumstances attracting relief under the Misrepresentation Act (Cap 390, 1994 Rev Ed). They allege that they relied on the representations in entering into the Agreements and completing the Share Purchase Agreement; that they would not have entered into the Agreements or purchased the Villa had they known the undisclosed information; and that they were prevented by the representations and by concealment of the undisclosed information from electing not to do so.
- [7]
[7] At the heart of the alleged falsity and nondisclosure are dealings in October 2017 between a Mr Solomon Lew and Mr Daniel Meury of the Andara Resort, in so far as they were communicated by Mr Meury to the Defendants. The dealings culminated in an offer by Mr Lew to purchase the Villa for US$5.25m and, on the Plaintiffs’ case, a possible agreement for sale at that price. The Plaintiffs allege that on 14 November 2017 the Defendants were made aware that Mr Lew claimed to have an agreement for the sale of the Villa and threatened legal action to enforce it; but, they say, in the telephone conversation on 15 November 2017 Mr Nargolwala said that the claim was unsustainable. In broad terms, on the Plaintiffs’ case the undisclosed information is the dealings between Mr Lew and Mr Meury as known to the Defendants and the details of Mr Lew’s claim and threat; and the possible adverse claim to the Villa and the threat of legal action by Mr Lew, and the failure to disclose the information to the Plaintiffs falsified the representations made in the Agreements and orally.
- [8]
[8] For present purposes, it is sufficient that the Defendants deny making any false representations to the Plaintiffs, and in particular that their Defence includes that in the telephone conversation on 15 November 2017 and a subsequent email, Mr Nargolwala told Mr Larpin that although the Defendants considered Mr Lew’s claim unsustainable, the Plaintiffs could “abort and unwind the transaction” or wait to see what Mr Lew was going to do, rather than proceed to completion, but Mr Larpin said that he was not concerned and would go ahead and complete.
- [9]
[9] In the Plaintiffs’ Reply, it is said that the options given to Mr Larpin were illusory when the Plaintiffs were labouring under the misrepresentations and nondisclosure. In oral submissions, the Plaintiffs said that Mr Larpin would have been able to make a considered and better decision had all material facts been disclosed.
The Lew Proceedings
- [10]
[10] Mr Lew did bring legal action, although not until early 2019. He named as defendants the Defendants, the Plaintiffs and Querencia. He claimed that he had an oral agreement to purchase the Villa, made through Mr Meury (as the Defendants’ agent) on 11 October 2017; that the Defendants acted in breach of their duties thereby owed to him in transferring the Querencia shares to Quo Vadis; that the Plaintiffs had actual or constructive knowledge of the oral agreement, whereby Quo Vadis was liable in equity to transfer the shares to him and the Plaintiffs were liable for inducing the Defendants’ breach; and that Querencia was liable for dishonestly assisting the Defendants in their breach.
- [11]
[11] Mr Lew’s proceedings went to trial over ten days in late 2019 to early 2020. The judgment of Simon Thorley IJ was published on 5 February 2020: see Lew, Solomon v Kaikhushru Shiavax Nargolwala and others [2020] 3 SLR 61 (“Solomon Lew”). It was held that a binding oral contract had not been entered into, nor were fall-back arguments of ratification and estoppel accepted. It was further held that, on the hypothesis of a concluded oral contract, Mr Larpin did not have the necessary knowledge of it and so no relief would have been granted against the Plaintiffs.
- [12]
[12] Mr Lew has appealed from the decision of Simon Thorley IJ. The appeal is to be heard later this month. At a Case Management Conference (“CMC”) in July 2020, counsel for the Plaintiffs foreshadowed that if the appeal was successful, their claim would be expanded to a claim in unjust enrichment. In this application, however, neither side suggested that my decision should take account of or is affected by the prospect of a successful appeal.
The Amount of Security
Whether security should be ordered
The “foreign plaintiff” ground
- [16]
[16] It was also common ground that the threshold condition of ordinary residence out of the jurisdiction in O 23 r 1(1)(a) was satisfied. Mr Larpin is a Swiss citizen who is resident in Hong Kong. Quo Vadis is a Hong Kong company.
The Plaintiffs’ Means
- [18]
[18] Mr Larpin said that he is a “person of means”. The Defendants said that he is “a very wealthy man who does business in various countries”. There was no further detail of his means. Mr Nargolwala said in his first affidavit that so far as he was aware, Mr Larpin does not carry on any business in Singapore or hold any assets in Singapore, and that he had reason to believe that Mr Larpin often held assets through special purpose vehicles (as with Quo Vadis), and that he understood that the shares in Querencia were Quo Vadis’ only asset. In his affidavit filed in response, Mr Larpin did not controvert these beliefs. I consider that I can proceed on the basis that, although he is wealthy, Mr Larpin does not have any assets in Singapore, and that the shares in Querencia are Quo Vadis’ only asset.
Relative Strengths
- [20]
[20] The Defendants submitted that there was a low likelihood of the Plaintiffs succeeding, describing the Plaintiffs’ case as one they would have great difficulty in establishing and even as untenable. They said that the alleged misrepresentations were premised on an oral agreement for the sale of the Villa having been concluded as asserted by Mr Lew, but that Simon Thorley IJ had found otherwise in the Lew proceedings (this was said to be directed to the representations by the Agreements). They said that any purported misrepresentations were only the Defendants’ opinion and not actionable as misrepresentations of fact (this appears to have been directed towards the 15 November 2017 telephone conversation) and in particular that Mr Larpin’s rejection of the Defendants’ offer to allow the transaction to be aborted and unwound meant that the Plaintiffs did not rely on any actionable misrepresentation. In their oral submissions, the Defendants invited me to come to an “impressionistic view”, without detailed consideration, that the Plaintiffs’ claim was weak.
Other Factors
Decision